About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of State Closing Arguments: TN v Robin Howington, Mother Daughter Murder Trial from COURT TV, published November 18, 2026. The transcript contains 12,065 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"September 14th, 2019. Destiny Oliver is five years old, 56 pounds, 88 inches. She was shot and killed by her mother's gun. In this case, ladies and gentlemen, it's about this thing. That's what this case is about. It's about what happened to this thing. On Bolson Drive on September 14th of 2019...."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: September 14th, 2019. Destiny Oliver is five years old, 56 pounds, 88 inches. She was shot and killed
[00:00:34] Speaker 2: by her mother's gun.
[00:00:43] Speaker 1: In this case, ladies and gentlemen, it's about this thing. That's what this case is about. It's about what happened to this thing. On Bolson Drive on September 14th of 2019. You all heard all of the testimony in this case. You've heard all the witnesses. I submit to you the proof in this case has shown that robbing Howington's negligence. Her negligence. As tragic as this is,
[00:01:26] Speaker 3: but this isn't realistic. Her negligence is the reason that this child is no longer is.
[00:01:39] Speaker 4: I want to talk about the night
[00:01:47] Speaker 1: of September 14th, 2019. What was Jesuit doing? You all heard testimony in this case about what she was doing. She was at a park according to Ms. Howerton. It was her, and it was her mother, and her two-year-old little brother. She was at a park that night, and you're making fun. You heard whenever she got home that she was hungry. She hadn't eaten that night. And so what Destiny was doing at her home on Wall Street Drive right before this incident happened is she is sitting on her couch. She is watching TV with a remote to pull in her head. And this little girl is waiting for her ear. And she has no idea about what's getting ready to happen. As she sat there on the couch with the remote in her hand, a gun was fired. And that bullet came out of the gun, went into her hand, out of her hand, into the remote, into her chest, out the back of her body, and into that room. We heard from the testimony in this case what else came out of that gun besides that bullet that went through Destiny's blood. We heard that there was gunshot rescue workers. You know, the testimony of Kyle Osborne, the TBI agent, he testified about how gunshots work. How when that trigger hits the back of the car there's a projectile that's expanded and then there's fire and gunpowder and then out of that gun through the cracks in the gun as you heard that officer testified. comes these tiny microscopic particles. He testified that when a gun is fired those particles go about five or six feet from the gun where the gun is found and then they settle down. And we heard there's two different ways that gunshot, less than a gunshot particles can get on a person's bullet that you heard that you can get there and you can fire a weapon. if you are in close proximity five to six feet of a weapon when it's fired and then he also testified that you can get gunshot particles on you if you touch somebody that has gunshot particles on you. So what do we know in this case that happened? We know that Gavin, the two-year-old, has gunshot particles on him on his clothing on the front of his building like a t-shirt that he lost on. and we know the defendant has gunshot residue gunshot particles on him and so we know those three things have to be what happened in this case. Fire the weapon or in close proximity to the weapon or touch someone who did one of those two things. So that's the proof that you all heard and that's what we know from that particular article in this case. So I want to shift for a second and I want to talk about the other things that we absolutely know in this case because I submit to you that the defendant has told so many stories so many stories so many different stories that you're not available to rely on what she says happened that night. He can't. He's told too many stories for it to be reasonable for you all to believe what she's saying. So let's start with what we absolutely know in this case. You all watched the video in this case the video from the neighbor's camera and it was grainy and it was kind of boring and we watched it for a long time. I'm sure it wasn't the most dynamic or interesting for this case but that video raised to him is very important. Very important. And the reason the video is moving because it establishes that there are people there and there are people going in and out of that house and it also establishes how long the people are in the house and how many times they can go. So that's why we're going to start with that. So the video that you watched if you'll recall there is a car that arrives at the beginning
[00:06:31] Speaker ?: at the beginning
[00:06:31] Speaker 1: of that video and I'm not going to make you watch it watch the whole thing here again because you guys have already done that you will have that video back in the journal you may watch it at your pleasure as many times as you want during the operation that you need to. But what we saw in that video was that there was a car that arrived at 829.38 that leads at 830.108 and then you can see that there's a car that arrives at 841.04 and that's going to be this car the one with the green arrow in it on the screen and that car we don't know if it's the same car as this one or if it's a different car but we know that that person that was in the car sat there with their lights on from 841.04 until later on and we'll get to that. So the next thing that happens the next part of the video that's important is this part that I have up on the screen. This portion of the video is whenever the defendant Robin Hallington gets to the house and she gets there at 842.43 so when she's there that vehicle is waiting for her. That's uncontroverted. That's what happens and we know that because a neighbor happens to have a video that shows these things. The next thing that you see on that video is that Destiny then walks inside the house. She goes first. She walks in at 842 excuse me 843.28 she walks inside her home. It's kind of the last time that this little girl goes into her home and she's solidly thereafter by Ms. Hallington who was carrying it. So Destiny goes in Ms. Hallington goes in and then there are several minutes that this person who is in this car is sitting outside is sitting outside. It's not a situation where that person comes and helps her with the kids or helps her in and just gives her money real quick because they owe her for a car attention to the window and they wait several minutes or get in
[00:08:47] Speaker 2: with her children.
[00:08:53] Speaker 1: 846.05 you might have to watch the video more than one time. A little bit called for you. You will see right before 846.05 that the door is closed right here and at 846.05 there's activity and that door is opened and I submit to you what's happening there since Hallington is calling that person okay it's okay now to come into my house. And then the person in the car walks up to the house and goes in. You all will see in that video you've already seen the individual goes in at 846.43 and remains in that house until 847.47 which is 63 seconds. 63 seconds.
[00:09:43] Speaker 2: And the reason that's at court
[00:09:44] Speaker 1: is because the defendant doesn't know about this video when she's talking to the police and the shooting. The defendant doesn't know that the comings and goings of the people at the house has been reported.
[00:10:02] Speaker 4: but I don't believe there was any testimony about that and Ms. Hallington knew that video. Is this just why I'm worried about it? Ms. Hallington has got to do a little record.
[00:10:10] Speaker 1: Okay, your reaction's not? Ms. Hallington has got to do that video until the second interview and the police come in with their laptop and show her portions of that video. When she makes her initial statements she has no idea that what happened at that house has been recorded and that there's only 63 seconds that this person is sitting there and that's important. That's important because it shows that her stories about what's happening inside the house
[00:10:42] Speaker 3: are not true.
[00:10:46] Speaker 1: Are not true. She can't come into this courtroom and say oh there's this fight with Anton and there's this big struggle with the gun and all these things that are happening. She can't say that at any time. it's not true first of all but it's not backed up by the video that you all were able to see because the neighbor happened to have the video camera next door to 502 Polson Drive. You all saw in that video that that person comes in calling walks away calling and what's the next thing that happens? The defendant exits her home She does that at 848.52. She leaves her home. She leaves her two children inside her house unattended
[00:11:37] Speaker 2: which is fun to do
[00:11:39] Speaker 1: unless you have a loaded file alarm in a place
[00:11:46] Speaker 3: and she wants you to think and we'll get to this in a minute she wants you to think
[00:12:01] Speaker 1: she wants you to think oh that gun's up in the top of the closet or that gun's somewhere else the child had to have gotten on a stool and reached up to the closet and gotten from the top of the closet but that's not where that gun was going to go think about what's just happened I submit to you that what's just happened consistent with what we heard about Ms. Howington is that there is a drug transaction that happens that person waits outside for three minutes so that she can get her kids into the house and out of the way so that he can come in buy some pills she has that gun there when this transaction happens you'll have heard investigator Pete you'll have heard him testify in his numerous numerous years of law enforcement experience about how drug transactions happen quickly and that often there are firearms there for the protection of the person that found the drugs or the person that's found and I submit to you that's why the gun was about it and the person responsible for that gun where it was it's not destiny it's not Gavin it's not these law enforcement officers that just wants to blame for everything that happened the person responsible for where her gun is that night this night
[00:13:49] Speaker 5: this happened
[00:13:51] Speaker 1: this happened leaves her home 848-52 returns after she moves her car you all saw that on the video she moves her car takes a couple minutes to do that and then she goes back and said after she gets in the home there's about three minutes before she calls 911 here is the portion of the video where she is calling 911 and this is important it's important because when she calls 911 what is she doing what are her actions first of all it's important to know that when she calls 911 her reaction to her child that has just been shot and who is mortally wounded her reaction to that is not to get on the phone and tell the 911 operator exactly what's happened her choice her decisions her actions her words to the 911 operator are lies she decides this detective doesn't make her say anything to 911 Ms. Howington is responsible for her actions and her words and her immediate response to her child being shot in the chest her immediate response is to get on the phone and call 911 and start spinning a story start blaming it on someone else and why why ask yourself why would she do that why would she do that Ms. Howington lies to 911 and spins this web of lies because she's trying to protect again she does these things because she's trying to protect herself she's trying to protect Robin Howington and she knows right away when she's on the phone with 911 right away that leaving her gun out and allowing her children access to her gun is her fault and it's tragic ladies and gentlemen you will not hear the state say that she purposely shot her child or she wanted this to happen that's not what we're saying to you what we are saying to you and what the proof shows in this case is that Destiny died because of her negligence this was an avoidable death and Ms. Howington is responsible for the death of this child as sad as it is so let's talk about this 911 call what I'm going to show you is the clip of the house outside synced with the 911 call
[00:17:25] Speaker 6: on Saturday September 14 2019 at age 53 PM with a GMT offset of negative 200 boiliness aging extension to 202
[00:17:39] Speaker 4: I apologize I have not been shown this demonstrative piece that is linking two separate incidents so that I can test myself whether or not it's currently linked up this final argument
[00:17:52] Speaker 7: both of these pieces of evidence are in the record
[00:17:54] Speaker 6: on Saturday September 14 29 at age 53 PM with a GMT offset of negative 240 minutes aging I D extension is 202 thank you
[00:18:20] Speaker 7: my county 911 yes
[00:18:22] Speaker ?: I don't know how to see
[00:18:24] Speaker 8: this dude was just at my house and
[00:18:26] Speaker ?: my fucking daughter just got shot man please please hurry I'm just following to walk and drive she just got shot right down ma'am yes yes who did it the guy that just walked
[00:18:38] Speaker 7: up to your door yes okay what's your name ma'am Robin Robin okay where's your daughter at now she's on the couch she's on the couch where did where did you shoot her at in my honor it's in
[00:18:54] Speaker ?: my hand okay
[00:18:56] Speaker 7: we're on our way
[00:18:58] Speaker ?: up I understand the problem we're on our way now she's laying on the couch what do I need to do what do I need to do let me let
[00:19:05] Speaker 7: you see the guy who did that the wife left her friend
[00:19:09] Speaker ?: he was black okay what was he wearing he had a right shut off okay did he say anything when he opened the door she goes in no okay and she can hear it she's over my baby he's just waiting you're doing oh my god please come down please come we're talking we're on our way just let me let me let me speak to the table we're trying to hear this oh one minute for him oh my god
[00:19:37] Speaker 8: yes he was in the car he was in the black black car he opened up the door okay hey mark in your emergency 5-0-2 awesome job you can't help whenever 9-0-1-8-0-9-6 yes ma'am okay i already have an email that's on the way there tell me exactly what's going on i had a man that just changed the fucking door man and he fucking i don't know what the hell that was the door was unlocked and he came in here and he fucking shot my daughter in the room and she's waiting here and she's not fucking breathing so please come she's not breathing no okay do you want to try to get to your arm please just come like she is breathing she is breathing she is breathing yes yes how old is she
[00:20:34] Speaker ?: she's five how old five five yes okay all right i've got help on the way
[00:20:45] Speaker 8: they've been on the way since you very first call okay is that her out of your crying no that's my side because she's that's your son okay yes okay you're going to do as fast as they can i'm calling that's okay you said she is breathing is she able to speak to you at all is she conscious at all no no that's me that's me oh my god i can't believe this shit right and you have no idea who it was that shot her no i did no okay they're here they're here they're here now okay all right go talk to the end
[00:21:23] Speaker ?: okay okay bye bye
[00:21:27] Speaker 2: this is a small point
[00:21:38] Speaker 1: something that i want you all to consider as well now when the defendant was on the stand she testified that when the officer came into the house which he's not left his car yet more thought his car is pulled up he's not gotten out yet he's not walking she testified on the stand yesterday that she's on the phone with that one when the officer comes in that's not true okay small point she's on the phone at this point when the officer comes in so let's go back and let's talk about this normal long call so in the normal long call as i said her first
[00:22:28] Speaker 3: reaction immediately after this happens is to blame this
[00:22:37] Speaker 1: on someone else to blame it on an unknown black male that came into the house and shot her drunk and she says on the stand yesterday that the reason that all these lies came out is that she wants to protect gavin let's talk about that for a second she wants to protect gavin but what does that mean she doesn't want gavin to know she says that he shot his sister does that really make sense does that really make sense first of all gavin's two years old there's one of two things that are going to happen he's either going to remember this or he's not if gavin remembers what happened there's nothing she can say or do it's going to change that if gavin doesn't remember he gets older and he doesn't remember she can talk to him about what she can decide big family secret we're not going to talk about it he never knows about it or she can decide tell him the truth about what happened i'm going to say i'm going to say to him gavin you were two years old and there was a gun that was not secured in the house that you got
[00:24:00] Speaker 3: and this is not she can say that
[00:24:04] Speaker 1: that's not what she chooses to do she doesn't want to take responsibility for her actions she absolutely doesn't and her course of conduct from the nominal roll call forward blatantly shows blatantly shows that miss howington does not want to take any responsibility for anything that happened any responsibility instead not only does she lie to the 911 operator
[00:24:45] Speaker 2: she gets rid of the phone she hides this gun this gun that was used she takes it outside
[00:24:57] Speaker 1: while on the phone with 911 while her daughter is in the house having the truck
[00:25:04] Speaker 3: it's more important to leave that house
[00:25:09] Speaker 1: and to put that gun outside in the dark you can see the gun in this picture remember the officer justified because he has a really bright light on his hand those first set of pictures when it was coming around that corner you can see just how dark it is just how dark it is back in that corner of the house the side of the house she takes this gun that was used to shoot this door her first reaction is to take this gun and take it outside and hide it under a brush
[00:25:42] Speaker 2: dark what does she do she's conscious of her she knows that she is the one that has any other children
[00:25:55] Speaker 1: officer Cummings gets there 856-15 you all recall from his testimony that he approached cautiously because there was a shooting and he didn't really know very many more details about what was happening you all remember he was in our second witness that he had the tent officer Cummings testified that he got to the house approached the door cautiously and that he went inside he says that when he went inside that he sees the defendant sitting on the couch and he says has anybody been shot what's going on and that's when officer Cummings sees destiny
[00:26:54] Speaker 4: he sees his little girl
[00:27:09] Speaker 1: he grabs her he takes her outside immediately gets her to the ambulance and that's that's his testimony about what happened it's there he asks is anyone hurt she points to destiny and remember he also said that it was eerily quiet so typically when he arrives to a scene like this there's people there
[00:27:31] Speaker 2: come this way or this is where she is and the defendant's not doing it she's sitting there she's pointing to her about this
[00:27:39] Speaker 3: she's thinking holy crap I left my right Rachel she starts to get on this self-preservation
[00:27:57] Speaker 1: so let's talk about our next set of actions because they say again a lot about her mindset a lot about what she's thinking her deception her lies dare not as the defense attorney wants you to believe something that is caused by these officers they happen before anybody even gets there and they continue from the point where she calls 911 the whole way up to the end of the last interview she is not truthful about what happened why why is she not truthful again it's because she knows that she's responsible she was negligible she speaks to officers as they around the scene this is one of the officers videos that you heard on the playlist portion where she's describing
[00:28:54] Speaker ?: describing
[00:28:54] Speaker 1: the scene
[00:28:56] Speaker ?: what about you? we get officers out
[00:29:03] Speaker 4: right now is it?
[00:29:18] Speaker 7: she says there was a black car there
[00:29:29] Speaker 1: with dark tinted windows so she begins this weave of trying to look for this other person who killed her child this unknown person that's coming to the house and they have a black car that has tinted windows he said you know what when she told that to detective riddle and she talked about how she's sitting on the couch and she's looking the whole way down and she can see through the dark the whole way to the car and she can describe that it's a black Chrysler and it has dark tinted windows he thinks you know what that doesn't make sense that doesn't make sense he believes at this point in time that he has a grieving mother but he also is aware that what she's saying doesn't make sense
[00:30:18] Speaker 2: doesn't make sense
[00:30:20] Speaker 1: and he gives her the benefit of the doubt he asks her tell me more information about this unknown individual that's coming to your house and she does she provides additional details about this person but this detective obviously went in this house and faced with this statement that this woman has seen through the first room through the second room out the door out through the dark to a car that she says is out there and she can describe it as a black Chrysler with dark tinted windows because it doesn't make any sense and it's not true it's not true we know that it's not true what does she say to detective we're like to see
[00:31:08] Speaker ?: I was in there okay we're not all in there we're just all coming up here and we don't want to have a rock
[00:31:13] Speaker 9: but when you say you all it's you
[00:31:16] Speaker 5: you're all in your dog
[00:31:17] Speaker 9: yes okay you're in here
[00:31:19] Speaker 5: and we don't want to go and we want to do that
[00:31:21] Speaker 9: okay and what happened
[00:31:22] Speaker 5: and he just came in here and we're all sitting right there where's he I don't know who he is you don't know who this guy is I don't have the flu I've never seen him in my life
[00:31:30] Speaker 9: and he walks in here and will you show me just start no
[00:31:37] Speaker 5: yes she's lying on the couch I was sitting by the side over he was sitting right here I was sitting right here she was over right here and he just shot and then it was like she was surprised I don't know if he was trying to shoot me or what but he shot me
[00:31:52] Speaker 9: where were you sitting well I was right here and she's right here right here right here
[00:31:59] Speaker 5: she was lying down right here
[00:32:01] Speaker 9: and you were sitting down a little time he comes in yes
[00:32:04] Speaker 5: I didn't even realize he was in here until it was already
[00:32:07] Speaker 9: what happened how many times did you hear him shoot
[00:32:11] Speaker 5: just one time
[00:32:12] Speaker 9: one time and when he shot what happened did he say anything nothing
[00:32:17] Speaker 5: he looked like he was surprised because she just went later
[00:32:21] Speaker 1: so again her statement there to detective Brown gives details about this event that happened that absolutely didn't happen she provides and then later on she tells him I looked down the hallway and I can see it because of black car he turned into this and more importantly more importantly what else did she say to detective Brown I think it was meant for me I think it was meant for me so the fact that these officers are investigating this case as if it's a homicide it's not just because they want to do that it's because of her and what she said that's why they're investigating this case like a homicide she's transported to UT hospital what's she doing on the way to UT hospital she's texting Cali I need you to get that gun Cali for real ASAP it's on the side by the air conditioner in the bush my phone is about to die they are taking me to UT she's texting her boyfriend saying go get that gun that is what is most important for her at this period of time when she's on the way to hospital because again self-preservation she knows she's done something she texts Joe Key go to my house the back way and get my gun out of the bush under the air conditioner Gavin shot Destiny then come to UT and I got you for free she's going to give him some pills for free for doing this the police are there but if you park in the alley and walk up you're good because they are in the house and she's calling you can see in the she's calling a bunch of other people but her main goal there is to make sure somebody goes and gets that gun and she knows that these text messages are in her phone and then she also makes a phone call and you're going to hear her say can you do that please can you do what I just text you
[00:34:43] Speaker 3: can you do that please
[00:34:48] Speaker ?: can you do that please
[00:34:52] Speaker 1: what she's just texting him what she's just texting him is to go get the gun and avoid the police while you're dealing we get to UT hospital now and again the state is not saying that this is something that's not true but what we are saying is that her actions her actions that day are very clearly showing that she is conscious of her wrongdoing she knows that she has been negative and she is desperate at this point in time for the police not to figure out what's going on she's so desperate ladies and gentlemen that when she's in the bathroom she tries to give her phone to a complete stranger to Marty Sands she tries to give her her phone she stands outside the hall the stall you all remember Marty Sands had that she stands outside the stall and waits for her to come out and says take my phone take my phone and Sands is like I'm not going to do that so what does the defendant do after that she runs her phone under water she breaks her phone she wants to say oh my phone is broken before and that's fine even taking her at her word at a minimum she took her phone tried to give it to a stranger and then ran it under water because she knows what's on these text messages ladies and gentlemen she doesn't want the police to know that she's tried to hide the gun she's done this and messed it up so much that Officer Pate who had to come and testify had to reconstruct it let it dry out for hours put a new screen on the phone before he could look into the phone and see it was there she continues with this next thing that we know that happened is that Ms. Howington is taken to the police station she is in an interview room and she is now going to explain what's going on there at the house so I want to go
[00:37:47] Speaker 2: through her stories because I submit to you her stories change constantly constantly let's start
[00:37:56] Speaker 1: with who shot destiny let's talk about her different stories about who shot destiny and remember the reason this is important is because the reason she has all these different stories is because she wants to deflect anything from showing that she is responsible that is her goal when talking to the police that day is to deflect from what she has done and so she blames
[00:38:24] Speaker 2: multiple people
[00:38:25] Speaker 1: multiple people for this shooting in fact on that one call I'm not going to play again but you heard she said this dude was just at my house and her words and my fucking daughter just got shot he was black he's in a black Chrysler I had a man that just came to the fucking door he came in here and he shot my daughter that's her first story we're stating to detective riddle which we've just played he just came in here and we were all sitting right there I don't know who he is I don't have a clue I've never seen him in my life she was laying on the couch I was sitting right beside her he meaning Gavin was sitting right here I don't know if he was trying to shoot me or what but he shot her I didn't realize he was in here until it was already too late those are her two stories the two things that she says before the investigators speak to her and then she comes into the interview room she comes into the interview room and she talks to the detectives in this case and this is what she says
[00:39:25] Speaker 10: we can get that donated you can tell us the truth and be helpful with us right
[00:39:30] Speaker 5: I told you we just came home from the park and I thought somebody was following me and so I went down the alley there's an alley between the neighbors where you sit Gavin or whoever sit Gavin and nobody followed me and then I didn't think nothing about it she was laying on the couch I turned Netflix on before and Gavin was sitting right beside me I have a roast still cooking right now in the crock pot I was getting ready to make the plates and somebody came to the door and I was sitting on the whatever you want to call it the foot roast and she was like this far away from me laying there because I was asking her what else do you want because the only thing I had in the crock pot was the roast and carrots and I let them choose what they want to eat because her dad is a vegan and so she's somewhat picky about what she eats and I didn't even hear the door open because it was just a screen door and the other door was still open because my purse was in the car still because I had to carry Gavin in because he didn't have shoes on so whoever all the thing I seen was a black dude come in and I heard a gunshot and then I looked at my baby and then I looked at him and his eyes got big and I don't know what like I feel like it was good for me
[00:40:48] Speaker 9: what kind of car did it in
[00:40:55] Speaker 5: it was a black Chrysler I'm about how sure it was I'm about 100% sure but I could see like outdoor from where the foot thing was
[00:41:05] Speaker 10: so you never went outside to see the car
[00:41:09] Speaker 5: no I got a towel put it on that's
[00:41:15] Speaker 1: her first story next she starts talking about these kids at the park and her words this may be something let's see what she said this may be something she tells the detectives
[00:41:27] Speaker 5: yes
[00:41:28] Speaker ?: yes
[00:41:28] Speaker 10: well actually
[00:41:32] Speaker 5: I'll be honest with you these three boys there's like a this may be something I don't know but these three Mexican boys there's like a fence or whatever and there's like a bench right beside the fence and they kept on crawling over it going to this building that's right beside of the park I don't know what it is I have no idea so the boys were making comments about my press so I said you guys aren't old enough to be talking to me like this especially in front of my kids I was like you're already teaching my son bad things because he's trying to crawl over the fence too so I went and pulled away because when I walked back up to them they bring me and crossed the fence again and when they crossed the fence I drove up there to see if their parents were there well their parents were there and it was two Mexican men and I said you need to teach your sons to be more respectful because they were being very disrespectful and talking to me in ways that I appreciate especially in front of my daughter
[00:42:47] Speaker 10: and so did you drop off after that yes sir so she tells
[00:42:53] Speaker 1: the police when she's talking to them that it may be something there's a thing going on at the park that involves these green Mexican courts
[00:43:02] Speaker 2: she knows that hasn't been nothing she knows that nothing but instead
[00:43:11] Speaker 1: she starts talking about these other people that it could be there's an extra thing
[00:43:17] Speaker 10: through the attic
[00:43:19] Speaker 5: yeah because I felt somebody like somebody was following me
[00:43:21] Speaker 10: so you thought somebody was following you from the park
[00:43:24] Speaker 5: no I don't know from the park I wasn't paying that much attention because everyone was complaining that they were thirsty and they were hungry and all this so I was just consoling them telling them we're going to be home you know the rose is done basically destiny was the one that was talking so when did you first think that somebody was following you when I turned left off Oak Ridge Highway onto Shock Road so what kind
[00:43:53] Speaker 10: of vehicle was that
[00:43:54] Speaker 5: I'm not sure it was a dark colored car I'm not sure so you think a dark colored car was following you at that time yes sir
[00:44:00] Speaker 10: but you just you still you go straight on
[00:44:02] Speaker 5: yeah but I went through the alley and when I went through the alley nobody was behind me so I didn't think of nothing so when
[00:44:09] Speaker 10: did you so this dark colored car that you thought was following you when did you not see it following you
[00:44:14] Speaker 5: when we stopped at the red light on Callahan they were behind me
[00:44:21] Speaker 10: Callahan Central yeah Central
[00:44:24] Speaker 5: Callahan Central by the Wilder's
[00:44:26] Speaker 10: so right by the Wilder's and I guess a couple restaurants and stuff that you didn't see anymore at that point
[00:44:32] Speaker 5: we're Asian cafe so you didn't see your car anymore at that point
[00:44:36] Speaker 10: correct and then you go on to your house correct
[00:44:38] Speaker 1: and again here she is telling these police officers who she has made them think that there is a common sight of this child about maybe they need to be looking into this other car that I believe to follow you but she knows she knows this has nothing to do with anything that happened to this child her next statement she's going to start talking about Anton now the defense wants you to think Paul the only reason that she said it was Anton is because these police officers overbore her will and made her second and that is just not true they were looking at a story that wasn't making sense wasn't making sense to them that some unknown person would just come and get this child and now they have her saying that she can see this black Chrysler from a place they know she can't do it and then they have her trying to get rid of her phone and putting it under water and so they look at what's available the police reports and they say there is a domestic history with this Anton
[00:45:56] Speaker ?: guy
[00:45:56] Speaker 1: so to them is this what this is about and they ask for that now does she have to say oh yeah I was Anton does she have to do that no no Miss Howington is responsible for the things she does and the things she says she could have told these officers no Anton has nothing to do with this but she chose not to do that this is what she says
[00:46:22] Speaker 10: so why didn't you tell us that early
[00:46:23] Speaker 5: because I mean this is his daughter too I know that he killed her but I don't feel like he did it on purpose I feel like he was trying to kill me
[00:46:30] Speaker 10: so he was already there what happens
[00:46:37] Speaker 5: he tried to talk he came to the house and when he came to the house I told him I didn't talk to him and he went back outside the house he brought
[00:46:58] Speaker 10: me back in living yes so this girl in Cali gave you how long you had it
[00:47:07] Speaker 5: not very long
[00:47:09] Speaker 10: and that was in the house tonight
[00:47:12] Speaker 5: no
[00:47:14] Speaker 10: I think I never was in the house tonight so with that being said if we told you there was a gun found outside and we want to make sure that it's not the gun you say Cali gave you she might give us DNA so we can make sure it's not
[00:47:32] Speaker 5: I don't understand what you're saying
[00:47:34] Speaker 10: so there's a gun found outside right you say Cali gave you a gun at some point right we want to make sure that that's not the gun that Cali gave you why we do that it's DNA you might give us your DNA so we can make sure that's not the gun
[00:47:49] Speaker 5: I'm saying Cali did give me that gun I know that
[00:47:55] Speaker 10: and you're saying you don't know where that gun is at now
[00:47:57] Speaker 5: correct
[00:47:58] Speaker 10: but there was a gun outside your house correct so to make sure that that's not the same gun that Cali gave you we'll run your DNA against the DNA found on that gun do you mind if we get DNA
[00:48:11] Speaker 5: I guess it is the gun that Cali gave me yeah he told me he cleared out something he was supposed to be at the storage
[00:48:18] Speaker 1: so now first of all she throws Anton completely under the bus he came in and he murdered this child in cold blood that's what she tells the officer she goes so far as to circle him in a lineup circle his face and say this is the person is she doing that to protect that or is she doing that to protect herself and then when the police confront her because they found out from the officers on the scene that there's a gun that's outside the house she doesn't say okay I put it out there she says oh there was a gun in my house is it the one outside I don't know and then she says oh Cali put the gun outside which absolutely is the reason we love that so this story is Anton brings the gun inside he leaves comes back excuse me Anton came into the house leaves comes back in with the gun and then shoots Destiny and we know that's not true because we've seen the video nobody comes in the house and leaves and comes back in that just didn't happen this is a complete lie and then she changes her story yet again
[00:49:36] Speaker 5: it's down
[00:49:38] Speaker 1: and not over again
[00:49:39] Speaker 5: it's dark it's not true but it's one what is there
[00:49:50] Speaker 10: how is what's leaving
[00:49:57] Speaker 5: why would you not
[00:50:03] Speaker ?: saying that initially because it's my baby I don't know we will talk to you're amazing we will talk to you because we will charge a two-year-old no
[00:50:12] Speaker 1: so now she's saying that's the honest to God truth she's swearing this is what happens and more importantly she's saying Anton is still there why is it so important for Miss Howington to say that someone else is there why does she say Anton is still there for using Jopper why does she say that she knows that if Anton was there that's somebody she can blame that's somebody she can blame for how that gun is out for a child care and she is so desperate at this point in time to not be in trouble for her actions that she is willing to circle Anton's picture in a lineup and say that this person murdered her child that's what she does and when they say to her after she changes her story that this you know after she changes it and says to Gavin hey you almost had us arrest this guy for first degree murder what does she say about that she doesn't say oh yeah you're right that's crazy she doesn't show any remorse she doubles down and talks about how much she doesn't like it that's the mindset of this individual
[00:51:44] Speaker 3: who's involved in this case
[00:51:46] Speaker 1: so here we have a story Gavin got to hold the gun Antoine is there that's going to change now we're on the following day
[00:51:57] Speaker 5: I didn't actually turn it off but it was honestly it was done it was to do it like that and Antoine came to the door and he was screaming and hollering about Cali yet again like I don't know what the hell he has against Cali but he got to screaming and hollering about Cali and we got to arguing and we kind of tussled a little bit and I asked him to please leave and he was like oh I don't know what you're going to do if you're a police calling me if you're going to call the police go up until he left and then when I went in the kitchen Gavin went into my room and tested his name on the couch watching Netflix and I came back and sat down and had to come shop we'll see it
[00:52:55] Speaker 1: so now in this story Antoine had been there they had been a couple they had been a tussle he leaves and in this story Gavin goes in the bedroom while she's in the kitchen he gets a gun and then comes back in and she was tested and then here's her final story this is the last thing that she tells the police on September 17th of 2019 okay
[00:53:23] Speaker 10: was X-1 already there we got home
[00:53:26] Speaker 5: the neighbors said he interviewed
[00:53:28] Speaker 10: you remember when I said I want you I want you to tell me stuff that you hadn't told me before you need to tell me that
[00:53:35] Speaker 5: you need to have a car on our rent
[00:53:37] Speaker 10: okay that's good and cool
[00:53:40] Speaker 5: and I asked Destiny what she wanted to eat and he kept trying to interfere and he don't want her to eat me so that was a problem right there anything that I do that he could find a problem with it's a problem so he didn't want her to eat me first off so he started on that shit too and he just continued to scream and hollering and raise his voice and he went I thought he was leaving so I was like please leave but he didn't leave and I don't know I felt frightened because I didn't know what the hell he was capable of I mean he's beat me to the point where I was unconscious and I laid off again and my daughter he came from me what was he doing she was in a black bag on the back of the door
[00:54:31] Speaker 10: she was in a black bag on the back door you got it out
[00:54:33] Speaker 5: on the back of my bedroom yes
[00:54:35] Speaker 1: so now we still have this is Anton this is Anton's fault what does she admit what does she finally admit after blaming everybody else in this version she admits that she went and got the gun out of a black bag and took
[00:55:02] Speaker ?: to the house
[00:55:03] Speaker 1: now she still wants to throw in that it's Anton's fault and all this understatement what did we hear yesterday Anton's not even there he's not even there he doesn't have anything to do with this here in this version she finally admits that she's the one that went into the bedroom and got the gun not from the top of the closet but from her purse that's on the back of me so I want to talk about not just this changing story of who did this but I want to talk about some other things and the reason these things are important is what you are going to see and what you've heard in this case is a pattern of blaming other people and not taking any responsibility whatsoever until Miss Halliday gets confronted with things that she cannot get away from and then she finally says that she has some responsibility just like she did here she has all these stories and it's not until the last story when again she's not telling the full truth but in the last story she finally says I'm the one that went and begged the gun to them so now we're going to talk about where did the gun come from and so it's important for her because again she knows she's an average it's important for her to tell the police that this gun is secure and put away and somewhere where a child shouldn't have access so her story to the police is that this gun is on the top of the closet and she gives many versions about how it comes out on the top of the closet that are inconsistent with each other but she wants them to believe that the gun in her home is at the top of the closet because again she doesn't want there to be any responsibility on her part so let's go through her statements about how the gun came into the room we heard her last statement about her going to get it but let's walk through kind of the different statements she gives about this first
[00:57:08] Speaker 10: we'll go back to your story because you said he knew where the gun was so where were you going from there he knew
[00:57:19] Speaker 5: where the gun was because he came in my room one day when he just showed up and he seen it in the closet when I was getting my clothes out to get dressed
[00:57:30] Speaker 10: okay so how does that factor into tonight that's where he went so you told me he went and got that gun and that's the gun he used and he
[00:57:41] Speaker 9: threw it down after he shot his child and you picked it up and you took it out to the bush and you've done something possibly with the showcasing so it's probably somewhere in your house
[00:57:53] Speaker 1: so in that statement she's saying that Anton gets the gun on the top of the closet she keeps all these details about what's happening surrounding her and then she changes that the next thing she's going to say is that her two year old gets a stool from inside of the living room drags it the whole way through the room to her bedroom climbs up on the stool and gets the gun from the top of the closet because again she wants the police to think that she has responsibly secured this gun that she's put it on top of the closet where kids shouldn't have access to it that's not true here she's saying Gavin gets the gun out of the closet and that she saw him take the stool across the room and do that
[00:58:42] Speaker 9: I'll just put these slides on in here. Okay. You went through to tell us what happened prior to what happened when you encountered your Lord's work, or Destiny's daddy?
[00:59:04] Speaker 5: Destiny was laying here. She was watching Netflix. I was sitting here. And Daniel was sitting beside me. And he was already outside. He came here. He started screwing me down. And then he got that stool. And he hit my bedroom.
[00:59:31] Speaker 9: This stool right here? Yes. Okay, do you leave the windshield? Okay. Before we leave, we'll get a picture. Yes, sir. Did you see him moving the stool? Yes.
[01:00:04] Speaker 1: Did you see him moving the stool? Yes.
[01:00:20] Speaker 9: No way.
[01:00:21] Speaker 1: So in this version, she is saying that she saw Gavin hit the stool, take the stool to the closet, climb up. I don't suppose she said she saw him climb up in the stool. What he would have had to do is climb up in the stool and get the gun from the top of the closet. That's the walkthrough that's the walkthrough that happened in September 4th or early of September 15th. And so then we have her come in just a couple days later, September 17th of 2019. And here's what she says. The officer is going to ask her, did you see him get the gun out of the closet?
[01:00:54] Speaker 10: You saw him get the stool. You saw him get the stool. So, there's, there's-
[01:01:00] Speaker 5: I can't make a mistake, correct?
[01:01:02] Speaker 10: You can make a mistake, but I would think that that wouldn't be, you know, a mistake you made right there, right?
[01:01:08] Speaker 1: And so he, Detective Wardlaw says to her, you told us before that you saw him get the gun, excuse me, saw him get the stool and now you're saying that you didn't. She says, oh, I made a mistake. Well, that's not a mistake that you made. She is lying. And the reason it's important, as I've said before, for her to lie about this is because she knows that the police need to be thinking that that gun is in the top of the closet. And because of what she says, Gavin has to get measured. Officer Tonkin there, they've got a gummy bear who's reaching up. He's 45 inches. He's not tall enough to reach a purse in the top of the closet. And then what does she say, finally? Her last statement to the police. After she's blamed it on Anton, after she's blamed it on Gavin going in the top of the closet, what does she say? I got the gun. That's what she says there, I got the gun. Where did the gun come from? I should probably mention, too, September 12th, a couple days before this, this is part of her story that she's telling. She starts with saying there's this tussle and all this other stuff that's happening with Callie and with Anton and her. And finally, this is her final version, she had said before different things, but this is the last thing she says about September 12th. And so Callie never pulled a gun on Anton. It was her that pulled the gun at that time. She finally admitted that and went to this interview on September 17th. How does the gun end up outside? We've heard some of her explanations. I'm going to walk through the litany of things she says about this. First, she's like, what gun? I don't have a gun. I don't have a gun in the house. Watch it.
[01:03:25] Speaker 10: Um, did you want a gun? Have I had a gun? Who was surprised if he told you that gun was thrown outside the house? That would surprise you? Why not?
[01:03:45] Speaker 5: Yes, it was. I mean, it was the first one.
[01:03:50] Speaker 1: First, she says, no, I don't have a gun. I don't have a gun. That would surprise me. Then she says...
[01:03:57] Speaker 5: No. No. Where's it at? Where were you putting? Callie had a gun.
[01:04:04] Speaker 1: I guess that's where you put it. Callie's the one that put the gun outside the house. That's what she's saying. She comes up here on the stand yesterday and wants to say, Callie's the one. Callie's the one with connection. Callie's the one that took the gun in the house. And she didn't bother to move for it. Here she is playing Callie. What's next?
[01:04:25] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:29] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:38] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:41] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:45] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:46] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:50] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:54] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:04:58] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:00] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:05] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:08] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:11] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:37] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:41] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:44] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:45] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:05:47] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:08] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:19] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:27] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:36] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:39] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that's that Callie gave you. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:47] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:48] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:53] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:54] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:55] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:58] Speaker 3: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:06:59] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:01] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:03] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:05] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:07] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:12] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:13] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:21] Speaker 4: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:22] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:28] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:29] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:38] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:40] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:45] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:46] Speaker 9: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:07:55] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:02] Speaker 9: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:05] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:09] Speaker 10: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:10] Speaker 5: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:12] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:13] Speaker 1: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:41] Speaker ?: Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun. Callie's the one that took the gun.
[01:08:47] Speaker 1: The last thing I want to do, ladies and gentlemen, is I want to go through the elements of this offense. You all heard in Ward-Dyer that what the state of Tennessee has to prove in this case. We have the burden of proving this case beyond the risk of death. We talked in Ward-Dyer about what that is. If you all recall, we talked about how the state has to prove the elements of the offense beyond the risk of death. And so I want to walk through briefly the elements of the charged offenses in this case. The first offense that the defendant is charged with is felony murder. I anticipate you will hear from the court, and you all will have these instructions back in the jury room. So if you want to take notes, obviously you can, but you will have this information back in the jury room. Is the defendant or one for whom the defendant is currently responsible unlawfully killed Justin and Oliver? And two, that the killing was committed in the perpetration of, or the attempt to perpetrate, the alleged aggravated child neglect. That is, that the killing was closely connected to the alleged aggravated child neglect and was not a separate and distinct and independent event. And then finally what the defendant intended to commit, the alleged aggravated child neglect. So those are the elements that the state has to prove in this case beyond the losing of the element of the criminal to find the defendant guilty of felony murder. And I'll come back to that in just a second, because basically what this is, is that the state has to show the defendant or someone she's criminally responsible for unlawfully killed Destiny and Oliver. And we know that that is the case here. And then also we have to prove the defendant intended to commit aggravated child neglect. And we have to prove the aggravated child neglect. And these are the elements for aggravated child neglect. First, that the defendant knowingly neglected a child, Destiny and Oliver, so as to adversely affect her health and welfare. And ladies and gentlemen, the death of this child is an adverse effect on her health and welfare. It could be less. You can have aggravated child neglect where a child is seriously, seriously, seriously injured and not dead. And obviously, the ultimate adverse effect on your health and welfare is when somebody is diseased. And so clearly that element has been met in this case. That the act of neglect resulted in serious bodily injury to the child. Again, serious bodily injury is defined under the law to include death. As undisputed in this case, the destiny of Oliver is dead. We have shown you beyond reasonable doubt that second element. And that the child in this case was eight years of age or less. And we've heard testimony in this case that destiny is five years old. And so the state has proved, in this case, all of these elements. And we're going to ask you to find her guilty of aggravated child neglect. That's the second count. The third count is similar to the second count. She's not going to be punished twice for the same thing. But it's another theory of what happened. Under the law, the first element is exactly the same. The third element is exactly the same. But this time because there's a deadly weapon involved. We're going to ask you to find her guilty. Because there is a deadly weapon that was used to accomplish this act. The firearm in this case. The defendant is also guilty of false reports. She initiated a report or a statement to law enforcement concerning an offense or an incident within the officer's concern. And so there are many false reports in this case. But we are required to elect for you which specific false report that we're talking about so that we can have a glance for it. And so in this particular case, we're going to ask for you all to focus on her report to Detective Criddle, that an unknown male shot her daughter. And we submit to you that that is something that is absolutely false. And the defendant knew the information relating to the offense reported was false. We ask you to find her guilty of that offense. She is also charged with tampering with evidence. Count four has to deal with the firearm in this case. So she tampered with the bone, she tampered with the firearm. So count four, we're dealing with the firearm. Count five. Count five. Count five, excuse me, thank you. Count five, the firearm. The defendant knew an investigation was pending and was in progress. And the defendant concealed a firearm with the intent to impair its availability as evidence in this investigation. She took that firearm. She took it outside, into the dark, walled the phone with 911, put that firearm under the bush, and then called her friends and asked them to come in it. And then finally attempted tampering with evidence, we're talking about here the cellular phone. The defendant knew an investigation was pending and was in progress. And the defendant, there's going to be a definition of attempt and then you're going to have this definition. So basically what we're doing here is we're talking about an attempt. So we're saying the defendant attempted to alter a cellular phone with the intent to impair its availability as evidence in the investigation. What did we hear that she gave in the phone? Even, even if we give her the defendant and say, okay, that phone's face was closing before this happened. She still ran it under the water and tried to give it away to a lady in the back row. And that is very clearly, meets the definition of attempted tampering with evidence. We ask you to find her good people. So I want to go back really quick and talk for just a minute about felony murder. Because I think sometimes when people hear the word felony murder, they think, oh, murder. When we hear the word murder, most people think an intentional act. Somebody did something on purpose. Somebody did something premeditated. That's not what we're talking about here in this case. These are the elements. It doesn't have to be premeditated. It doesn't have to be on purpose, intentional. What we have to show is that there was an aggravated childhood left and the child died. And that those things were not separate in the state. She died because of the neglect in this case. That gun in their place where her child had access to it. So the last thing I want to say to you all before I sit down is that the defendant has gotten up on the stand and she has now been her version, her newest version. After five years of this case pending, she has now come up on the stand and given her version of what happened. And I submit to you that even if you take every single thing that she said as the gospel truth, which I don't think it would be unreasonable for you not to do that. But even if you did, if you took everything that she said on this stand as the truth, she has admitted on this stand that there was a gun in her house. And in her version of that she has no idea where it is. And it is left in her house for two days in a place that her two year old child could find it in two minutes, three minutes while she's outside. That's her version that she's telling now. And so again, even if you take everything she says as the gospel truth in this case, she has committed this offense. She is guilty of these crimes. And we're going to ask you all that whenever you go back, look at the evidence, think about how she was acting throughout the course of this investigation.
[01:16:59] Speaker 3: And that you hold her responsible, you hold her responsible for her hand which is that day and I agree with you.
[01:17:11] Speaker ?: Thank you. Thank you.