Try Free

Full video of tense cross-examination of crash expert in Karen Read trial Day 23

CBS Boston November 22, 2026 1h 11m 9,260 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Full video of tense cross-examination of crash expert in Karen Read trial Day 23 from CBS Boston, published November 22, 2026. The transcript contains 9,260 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"Remind, you're still in the room. Thank you. Good morning, Your Honor. Dr. Welch, we're going to ask you to not turn on your computer yet. Okie dokie. Thank you. And, Your Honor, if I could, smartwatches that are receiving text messages during his direct, if we can make sure that that does not..."

[00:00:00] Dr. Welch: Remind, you're still in the room. Thank you. Good morning, Your Honor. [00:00:13] Speaker 2: Dr. Welch, we're going to ask you to not turn on your computer yet. Okie dokie. Thank you. [00:00:18] Speaker 3: And, Your Honor, if I could, smartwatches that are receiving text messages during his direct, if we can make sure that that does not occur. I'll get my email. [00:00:28] Speaker 2: Okay, or just don't look at your watch. [00:00:32] Speaker 3: That's good, okay? [00:00:33] Speaker 2: Okay. [00:00:34] Speaker 3: Thank you, Your Honor. Good morning, Dr. Welcher. [00:00:39] Dr. Welch: Good morning. [00:00:41] Speaker 3: Do you know whether there was glass found on the bumper of Ms. Reed's Lexus SUV? That's my understanding there was, yes. Did you reach a conclusion on whether the glass on the bumper came from the drinking glass that you assert Mr. O'Keefe was holding at the time of the alleged impact? [00:00:59] Dr. Welch: I didn't have an opportunity to inspect the glass, but the glass was broken and there was glass on the bumper. That's all I know. [00:01:05] Speaker 3: So, you, as you sit here today, you have no basis to conclude that the glass on the bumper came from the glass that you depict as having been held by Mr. O'Keefe at the time of the alleged impact. Is that correct? Well, you're mixing a couple of things. No, Dr. Welcher, if you can just answer my question, if I need to rephrase it, I will. I'll ask it a different way. Please. You have no basis as you sit here today to conclude that the glass on the bumper came from a drinking glass connected to Mr. O'Keefe, do you? [00:01:52] Dr. Welch: Well, we have a picture of a broken glass at the scene, so I wouldn't say we have no basis. We don't necessarily have enough to conclude it's from it, though. [00:02:07] Speaker 3: Do you, you had depictions in your test with Mr. O'Keefe holding a glass, correct? Correct. My question is, you have no evidence to show at all other than, and I'm talking evidence, testing information. You're saying you have no evidence that shows that the glass on the bumper is not the same glass as you showed on your slides as being found supposedly at the scene. You have no test evidence that that's the same glass, do you? [00:02:52] Dr. Welch: So, again, the one I have at my testing obviously was not the same glass. We have pictures of a broken bar glass in the snow near where Mr. O'Keefe's body was. We have glass fragments on the rear of the bumper. That's the extent of my knowledge on the correlation between those two. [00:03:12] Speaker 3: So, do you, you said you reviewed the reports and testimonies of various Commonwealth representatives, correct? That's in your report. Correct. In the initial. In the initial, right, correct. And some of those reports included forensic scientists who work for the Massachusetts State Police, correct? I believe that's correct. And you put those in your report as documents that you reviewed, correct? Correct. And as you sit here today, it's your testimony. You don't know whether in any of the reports of the Massachusetts State Police, there is an answer to the question of whether there's any connection at all between the glass found in the snow and the glass on the bumper. [00:04:07] Dr. Welch: I recall it being inconclusive. [00:04:10] Speaker 3: Oh, so you recall that the testing was inconclusive? [00:04:13] Dr. Welch: I don't remember what testing they did. But, for example, when they put the taillight fragments back together, they were able to deduce that the fragments were from the taillight. I don't think they attempted to do that with the glass. [00:04:26] Speaker 3: Assume that there has been testing of the glass on the bumper and assume that that testing conclusively determines that the glass on the bumper is not the glass that was found in the snow. Okay. Assume that. Okay. How would that affect your analysis? [00:04:50] Dr. Welch: I'd want to know where the glass came from, but we still have a whole bunch of other elements. So I don't think it would affect the end results. [00:05:00] Speaker 3: So would it have any part in your analysis with my assumption that the glass on the bumper is not the glass that's associated with the broken glass that was supposedly found in the snow? [00:05:14] Dr. Welch: Yes. I mean, we always want to have as much answers or as many answers as possible. So I would want to know if we could figure out where it came from. [00:05:21] Speaker 3: And wouldn't the fact, assuming that the test results show there's no connection, meaning the glass on the bumper is different from the glass in the snow, wouldn't that be contrary to your theory of what happened in some way? [00:05:40] Dr. Welch: It depends on when the glass was actually broken. The glass was in his hand. At least that's the testimonial evidence I have seen. So it depends on whether it's broken from contact with the rear of the vehicle or broken with contact on the ground. [00:05:58] Speaker 3: Assume that the glass on the bumper is not the glass that was found in the snowbank. Doesn't that, at least in part, contradict your hypothesis as to whether there was contact by the Lexus with Mr. O'Keefe at 34 Fairview? [00:06:26] Dr. Welch: So if you recall my slides, nowhere did we discuss that in my slides. So no, it wouldn't contradict it. I would want to know where that glass came from. [00:06:38] Speaker 3: But you didn't seek that information, did you, sir, in your analysis to determine where the glass came from? Of course I did. I read the reports about it. But you sit here and you say you don't know the answer. There's steps you could have taken to get that answer quite easily. Couldn't you have, sir? [00:06:57] Dr. Welch: Not me. That's a material science expert. [00:07:00] Speaker 3: You've been communicating with Lieutenant Tully, haven't you? Correct. You couldn't have asked Lieutenant Tully that question? To my knowledge, he's not a material science expert. But could he have told you the result of testing on that glass on the bumper and whether it was any way associated with the glass found in the snow? Wouldn't that have been an easy question to ask him? Just has there been testing? And if so, what's the results? [00:07:32] Dr. Welch: Yes, but my knowledge from reading the reports was it was inconclusive. [00:07:37] Speaker 3: But you didn't read all of the reports, did you, sir? [00:07:40] Dr. Welch: Apparently not. [00:07:42] Speaker 3: Let's turn to another topic. Laser scans. Part of your analysis involved conducting laser scans of portions of One Meadows Avenue, the house of Mr. O'Keefe, correct? Correct. Those laser scans were used at least in part to answer the question of whether the collision between Ms. Reed's SUV and Mr. O'Keefe's Chevy Traverse at One Meadows at approximately 5.07 a.m. on January 29, 2022, caused the right rear taillight of the Lexus to break, correct? Correct. And in that analysis, inches literally matter, correct? [00:08:32] Dr. Welch: You want to get it as accurate as possible. [00:08:34] Speaker 3: And the reason why inches matter is because, and we're going to get to this, you try, and you did it in your slide presentation on direct, you tried to see whether the Lexus lined up with the Traverse such that there could be a break of the taillight. That was part of your analysis, correct? [00:08:53] Dr. Welch: So the main part of the photogrammetry was to determine the speeds and the angles and the degree of overlap on the vehicles. And then we also looked at the damage from the video, or actually it's just where the snow was knocked off, the rear of the Chevy Traverse, and document the height of that. [00:09:13] Speaker 3: You said the main part. I don't want to engage in semantics. I want to go to my question of, isn't part of the laser scan analysis to determine whether or not those two vehicles align sufficiently such that the Lexus could break, the taillight of the Lexus could break, coming into contact with the Chevy Traverse. Wasn't that part of your analysis, at least in par? Yes. Okay. And in that analysis, inches literally matter, correct? [00:09:51] Dr. Welch: It can, depending on which way you're going inches. [00:09:54] Speaker 3: So the ring camera at One Meadows, you're familiar with that ring camera, right? Correct. At One Meadows? That ring camera at One Meadows was used as part of the laser scan process that you and your firm, Aperture, performed at One Meadows on October 2nd, 2024. Do I have the date correct? [00:10:19] Dr. Welch: I believe so, but the videos were not literally used during the laser scans. We took the laser scans, the video, combined them together in a process called photogrammetry. [00:10:32] Speaker 3: Okay. Let's get this down to the fundamentals. You used, and that was my question, Your Honor, if we could publish the exhibit with regard to the ring camera. [00:10:45] Speaker 2: Sure. [00:10:45] Speaker 3: What exhibit is it? Yeah, I've got my, yeah. Dr. Welcher, you recognize that ring camera as being at One Meadows. You discussed it. As a matter of fact, I need direct testimony, correct? Yes. Now, that ring camera was utilized as part of your laser scan process, correct? It was used. [00:11:20] Dr. Welch: So, confusing laser scan and photogrammetry. The video, the laser scanners are together used in the photogrammetry. The camera and the laser scans are not used necessarily with each other. [00:11:36] Speaker 3: Was that ring camera used for any part of your work? [00:11:44] Dr. Welch: Absolutely. The photogrammetry. [00:11:47] Speaker 3: I just need to be able to finish my question, sir. Was that ring camera used for any part of your work at One Meadows on October 2nd, 2024? [00:11:59] Dr. Welch: Yes. [00:11:59] Speaker 3: And it was used for what purpose? [00:12:02] Dr. Welch: To, in the photogrammetry process, to establish the position and dimensions of various things in the video, so then we could go back and overlay the vehicles and track the tracks in the snow as well as look at the damage to the vehicles. [00:12:20] Speaker 3: Right. So, this was used to, as a basis, not the only one, to establish dimensions of the other work that was done in analysis at One Meadows, correct? Correct. You can take that down, Mr. Wolk. You know that the ring camera at One Meadows in existence when Aperture did the work on October 2nd, 2024, was different than the ring camera that was in existence on January 29th of 2022, the date where you went through to see if those two vehicles aligned. Is that correct? The cameras are different. That is correct. And you know that, that the cameras are different, and you knew that as part of your analysis, correct? Correct. Did you document the differences between the two cameras as part of any work performed at One Meadows? Yes. And did you measure any differences there might have been between the location of the new ring camera from the older one that was in existence on January 29th of 2022? [00:13:51] Dr. Welch: No. What we did is use the current ring camera in conjunction with the old ring camera, and with the laser scans, we're able to, again, map the points onto the scene. That's why I showed you the report from the photogrammetry software that reported our error. [00:14:10] Speaker 3: Sir, my question was just measurement, not your process. Did you measure the difference between where the old camera was and where the new camera was? [00:14:21] Dr. Welch: No. It was angled slightly more to the right, though. [00:14:25] Speaker 3: How would you know that if you were not retained on January 29th of 2022? How would you know where the original angles were? [00:14:38] Dr. Welch: Because when you look at the first camera, the one on January 22nd, it's here. The new one is slightly over to the right. [00:14:50] Speaker 3: That's an eyeball approximation analysis. That's not a measurement, correct? [00:14:57] Dr. Welch: Well, I don't know that we actually measured it, but we accounted for it and corrected for it. But you can see, for example, what the original one shows, for example, to the left-hand side, compared to what the new one shows to the left-hand side, and it's angled more to the right. [00:15:14] Speaker 3: Sir, you have experience with ring cameras, correct? I do. And I think a lot of members of the public have experience with ring cameras. You can move just the camera portion ever so slightly and change significantly the angle of the camera, can't you, what it captures? Just a small turn. Potentially. Right. Even a millimeter turn can make a change. A two millimeter, a one inch, can make a significant change with regard to what the camera captures, correct? [00:15:46] Dr. Welch: Could, sure. [00:15:46] Speaker 3: So, did you measure whether the newer camera that was present on October 2nd, 2024, was installed to the left? And I'm talking measure, to the right, to the top, or the bottom, relative to the camera that was there on January 29th of 2022. [00:16:10] Dr. Welch: So, we solve for the camera? [00:16:15] Speaker 3: I'm asking if you measured, sir. [00:16:17] Dr. Welch: No, we didn't measure. [00:16:19] Speaker 3: So, let's talk about some other differences with regard to cameras and ring cameras. Different ring cameras can have different levels of distortion, correct? [00:16:35] Dr. Welch: Potentially. [00:16:37] Speaker 3: Cameras, well, are you saying that all ring cameras have the same level of distortion? [00:16:43] Dr. Welch: No, but, again, they're mass produced, so you could have some that have the same exact distortion. You could have some that have different. [00:16:51] Speaker 3: And you don't know the comparative distortion between what I'm just going to now refer to as the old ring camera that was there January 29th, 2022, and the camera that you saw on October 2024, which I'll refer to the new camera. You don't know the difference in the distortion between those cameras as you sit here today, do you? [00:17:12] Dr. Welch: So, we know enough information that if the distortions had been different, our errors would have been too high. And so, the fact that our errors are with an acceptable, what's called an RMS error, we know that the distortions are similar enough to give us accurate measurements. [00:17:27] Speaker 3: Sir, that is speculation. That is not data. That is not a measurement. You didn't measure the distortion, sir, did you? If the cameras, you didn't have the old camera to do it. [00:17:37] Dr. Welch: We didn't, but we had images from the old camera, and then when we get images from the new camera, and solve those camera properties, and then overlay data from the old images to the new images with the point clouds, if that distortion is too great, we will have too high of errors in our project, which is why I showed the error report from the photogrammetry process, to show that we have checked for that, and documented that our errors are in an acceptable range, so that we have confidence in our results. [00:18:13] Speaker 3: You do not have information from the manufacturer of Ring. You didn't present it, and you don't have it, as to what is the acceptable level of distortion for the analysis that you did. Do you, sir? The photogrammetry. Do you have that from Ring? [00:18:30] Dr. Welch: I don't have it from Ring, but I don't need it from Ring. [00:18:31] Speaker 3: So, now let's go to, if cameras have different levels of distortion, that would change the analysis in reconciling the difference between their angles. That's a pretty straightforward proposition, sir, wouldn't it? [00:18:48] Dr. Welch: So, it depends on how much difference it is, but we have accounted for that. [00:18:53] Speaker 3: Which model of the Ring camera was present at One Meadows on January 29, 2022? Which model? I don't know. I'd have to go look through the data. Do you believe you, I'm not going to take up the time to have you look, but do you really believe you've got the model of the Ring camera that was in existence on January 29, 2022? I don't know. You didn't present it in your direct testimony, did you, sir? I did not. So, do you have the model of the Ring camera that was present at One Meadows on October 2, 2024? No. So, you don't have even the model for either one of them? [00:19:35] Dr. Welch: Nope, but we have videos from both of them and scans of the scene. [00:19:38] Speaker 3: So, now let's talk about another aspect of Ring cameras. They have mechanisms, as I was talking about earlier, that allow the user to adjust the camera angle, correct? Correct. And do you know whether there was a difference in the camera angle between the two cameras? [00:19:58] Dr. Welch: Yes, as we already discussed, there was a slight difference in the angle. [00:20:01] Speaker 3: But you don't have a measurement of that, right, sir? Correct. Okay. But we accounted for it. So, wouldn't a difference in models of Ring cameras be relevant at all to your analysis of trying to reconcile any differences between them? [00:20:27] Dr. Welch: So, if you have video from both of them and you have laser scans with three-dimensional geometry of the scene, you can go in, and it's called a reverse camera analysis, and solve for the distortion properties. So, once you know the real-world dimensions, you can go in, you can go in and then solve for the camera lens properties based upon the real-world distortions. So, for example, if there's a little bit of bending at the end, the laser scan data will show that, and you can correct for that knowing information about the laser scanner or the laser scan data. [00:21:09] Speaker 3: I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I thought you finished, sir. I'm going to ask the question again because it's a narrow question. Wouldn't knowing the difference in the models be relevant? That's all I'm asking. Wouldn't it be relevant to your analysis of reconciling the differences to them? No. Wouldn't it be relevant? [00:21:26] Speaker ?: No. [00:21:26] Speaker 3: So, you think the different models are irrelevant to any process you occasioned at one? It's irrelevant. [00:21:36] Dr. Welch: So, the analysis of the video itself is more important than the models? I'm not asking if it's more important. [00:21:42] Speaker 3: I'm just asking, would it be relevant? No. I don't believe it would be relevant. Now, let's go to another aspect of the cameras. Are key parameters in a camera that the software needs to know focal length? It is. Is imaging size something that is an important parameter in a camera? [00:22:06] Dr. Welch: Yes. [00:22:07] Speaker 3: Is our sampling characteristics an important parameter in cameras? Can be. Is the principal point, you understand that concept, sir? Is that an important parameter in a camera? Define how you're using principal point. Sure. A principal point of an image is the point where a camera's direct line of sight called, as you may know, the optical axis, intersects the image plane. Does that sound familiar? So, isn't that the image's mathematical center, the principal point? [00:22:43] Dr. Welch: More or less, yes. [00:22:44] Speaker 3: And for high-accuracy photogrammetric work, it's important to know if the lens is mounted centered over the image sensor due to the small manufacturing variances, correct? Could be important. And if the principal point is the center of the image. Okay. That's relevant. So, doesn't that affect the mathematical calculation of the light ray geometry? It could. So, the variance in manufacturing between cameras is a known issue. Do you agree? I do. There are small manufacturing variances that affect one of the key components of the fundamental parameters of the camera, namely the principal point, right? Correct. Did you perform the camera calibration of the camera in place in October of 2024? [00:23:49] Dr. Welch: Yes. So, in photogrammetry, we calibrated the photogrammetric analysis to the camera. [00:23:57] Speaker 3: Did you address the principal point in that calibration? Do you have documentation that you address that important factor, the principal point? [00:24:04] Dr. Welch: So, the checking of the RMS error in the software takes into account, sums up all the potential errors in the measurement, which would include that. [00:24:17] Speaker ?: Okay. [00:24:18] Speaker 3: Sir, you know the importance of all of these topics, because the output of all the work Aperture did at One Meadows, almost all of it, springs from that camera, correct? It starts there. Okay. It starts there. And if the starting point is wrong, then where you go from the starting point is going to be at least potentially wrong, correct? [00:24:53] Dr. Welch: Potentially. [00:24:57] Speaker 3: Would you agree that ring cameras have a swiveling mechanism so that the user can adjust the camera angle? Some do. Do you know whether the camera that was in existence on January 29, 2022, had a swiveling mechanism? [00:25:18] Dr. Welch: I believe it did. Believe? Do you know? I do not know for a fact. But those style of ring cameras on the surveillance have adjustability that includes angle. [00:25:28] Speaker 3: But you don't know whether the camera that was there, the specific camera on January 29, 2022, had a swiveling mechanism or not, correct? Correct. And do you know whether the camera that you saw in October of 2024 had a swiveling mechanism on it? It did. And where did you document the fact that it had a swiveling mechanism? [00:25:50] Dr. Welch: I think we have photos of the camera. [00:25:52] Speaker 3: Did you document it in writing and did you document the tolerance of the swiveling mechanism? No. Okay. Let's go to, and again, all of the camera, this camera that you use, is the starting point for your laser scan and photogrammetry process, correct? Correct. All right. All right. Let's go to another topic. On your direct testimony, as I recall, you stated essentially from various information that you lined up in the video, and we're talking about the lining up of the Lexus with the Traverse. And this is at 1 Meadows, and so as I understand what you did, sir, is you took what are called point clouds, 3D images, created them for the Lexus, you created 3D images, synonym point clouds of the Traverse, and then you attempted to line them up to determine, among other things, whether they would align sufficient. So that the Lexus could line up and potentially hit the Traverse such that the tail light of the Lexus could be broken. Was that at least part of your analysis? That was part. There was more. So, you showed a slide, a few slides, and with Your Honor's permission, what I'd like to do is to start with slide 9-0. [00:27:33] Speaker 2: All right, do you have any problem with Dr. Welchuk keeping his printed copy that he was using? [00:27:38] Speaker 3: I have no problem with the printed copy, Your Honor. [00:27:42] Speaker 2: So, I'm sorry, would slide again? [00:27:44] Speaker 3: 9-0. [00:27:48] Dr. Welch: Your Honor, my printed copy, tiny. Okay. Can you see the... Yes. Yeah, yeah. [00:27:54] Speaker 3: Does that slide, that's part of your presentation, depict a view from the top of the Lexus on the right and the Chevy Traverse on the left? Correct. And is that depicting contact between the two vehicles? It is. Now, let's zero in a closer look, and that is a contact point, am I correct? Correct. [00:28:33] Dr. Welch: I mean, there's multiple points. There's more than one. [00:28:36] Speaker 3: There are two points, but it shows more clearly the contact between the two vehicles. Now, if we could... The next, and that is number 91, Mr. Welch. So, Your Honor, 91. I think these are just going to go in order for a few, and I'll keep announcing them. So, this is 91, same vehicles, just a different viewpoint. Is that correct, Dr. Welcher? [00:29:20] Dr. Welch: Correct. This and the next slide... [00:29:22] Speaker 3: I just want to stay with this one. I just asked the question, does it show the contact? [00:29:27] Speaker 2: Right. So, go ahead and answer now. [00:29:30] Dr. Welch: This slide, and all the other slides, we're trying to show the angle of contact. But because it's a two-dimensional image, you're losing some perspective. For example, here, you're seeing the chrome piece on Mr. O'Keefe's Chevrolet, which is on the right. You're seeing it, obviously, behind where the Lexus is. So, we were trying to show it at a whole bunch of different angles to try and illustrate the degree of closeness or lack thereof. [00:29:58] Speaker 3: All right. So... Thank you. Is it correct that on your direct examination, you said, in sum and substance, we looked at the degree of overlap, and there's only about a two to three millimeters of overlap between the vehicles. Is that what you recall saying on direct? That is correct. And that you stated that that two supposed two to three millimeters of overlap was insufficient to cause the taillight of the Lexus to contact the rear of the Chevrolet. Do you recall saying that? That's correct. Now, I would like you to look at that. This is from your slide presentation. Is that not showing contact between the two vehicles? [00:30:44] Dr. Welch: Oh, it absolutely is not. What you're seeing is a portion of the vehicle that is behind the area. Keep in mind the angle. The Lexus is angled off to the left. So the area that you see here is actually, in this case, in front of where the taillight is. This is why we tried showing it from a whole bunch of different angles, because when you try and take a two-dimensional image and look at it, you see stuff in the background. So it, and again, this is why in the computer, we overlaid them, looked at the measurements, you know, in the computer, where you don't have this, we have the three-dimensional measurements, and it does not hit. [00:31:24] Speaker 3: Okay. Where did you show in your slide presentation what you just said that it doesn't show in overlap? So it. [00:31:34] Dr. Welch: Where? It shows a contact. It definitely contacted, I'm sorry, Mr. Porter, down below here. It does not show a contact here. So to answer your question, all the next slides were our attempt to do that. So all the next slides is your answer. [00:31:51] Speaker 3: We're, we're going to go to those next slides. So you're, just to be clear, you're saying that that depiction does not show any contact between the taillight of the Lexus and the Chevy Traverse? [00:32:06] Dr. Welch: So the upper taillight, just to be clear, because the lower taillight is much closer. [00:32:12] Speaker 3: Well, it's not only much closer, it's in contact, isn't it, sir? [00:32:17] Dr. Welch: It's very close. It's probably within an inch being in contact. [00:32:20] Speaker 3: Oh, so you're, you, you state that even the lower part of the taillight is not making contact? [00:32:24] Dr. Welch: So, if, again, maybe there's a photo we could show or a scan, that is on the rear of the vehicle, and it contacts on the corner, which is just around, so maybe like an inch or so in front of it on the corner. [00:32:39] Speaker 3: I'm just going with what you presented in your slide presentation. [00:32:42] Dr. Welch: Well, let's go to the next slides. [00:32:43] Speaker 3: Sir, I will determine which slides we go to on my questioning. So, now let's go to Mr. Wolfe, the next slide. [00:32:51] Speaker ?: There we go. [00:32:51] Speaker 3: In your presentation, my question is, zeroing in, are you saying that that slide does not show contact between the taillight of Ms. Reed's Lexus and any part of the Chevy Traverse? Yeah, absolutely. [00:33:10] Dr. Welch: That's exactly what it shows. You can, you can see a little better here. Again, we tried all these different angles, which is why all these slides are in there, but you can see some of the geometry of the light. The geometry of the light, this structure, and again, remember I said the Chevy kind of curves in as it goes up a little bit? [00:33:29] Speaker 3: Let's go to the next slide. Forty, yes, please. [00:33:37] Dr. Welch: Is it working? [00:33:50] Speaker 3: Forty-one. Forty-one, Your Honor. [00:33:53] Speaker ?: Right. [00:33:54] Speaker 2: One more, Your Honor. [00:33:57] Dr. Welch: That's exhibit 41? No, I have a question, because that's not my slides. [00:34:05] Speaker 2: So, Mr. Alessi, is this exhibit number 41, or is this from the PowerPoint? Because-- [00:34:19] Speaker 3: Yeah, what do you want? Slide. [00:34:21] Speaker ?: Okay. Yes. [00:34:22] Speaker 3: So, I'm putting this up because I want to show an actual photograph of that taillight, and I would like you, sir, to focus on the quarter panel taillight, do you see a jutting out of the quarter panel taillight in each, do you see a jutting out of the quarter panel taillight in that photo? Do you see it jut out? [00:34:59] Dr. Welch: So, I don't know if you and I are talking the same thing, there are little fins here? [00:35:08] Speaker ?: Correct. [00:35:09] Speaker 3: Now, what I'd like to do is to go back to the depiction we were just looking at, and that depiction doesn't show the jutting out, does it? [00:35:26] Dr. Welch: No, it does. Those are actually more on the side of the vehicle. You can't see them in this image. Correct. You can't see them. Hold on a second. I wasn't finished. They are 100% there. We actually did special hand scans with a hand scanner of the taillight to put it back on to the vehicle. [00:35:47] Speaker 3: You say they're 100% there, but you can't see it in that depiction, can you? The jutting out that you could see in the two-dimensional one we just saw. You can't see it. [00:35:56] Dr. Welch: I can't see who's behind that wall because it's being blocked by something. I can't see on the side of the taillight because it's on the side I can't see. It's being blocked. [00:36:04] Speaker 3: Sir, my question is simple. You cannot see the jutting out of the taillight in this depiction, can you? Correct. Okay. Now let's go on to the next question in this topic. You could have easily, easily solved what you consider to be the issues you had with trying to show it lining up. Couldn't you, sir? You had an easy solution for that. I took the best solution. [00:36:37] Dr. Welch: I'm not sure what you're referring to. [00:36:39] Speaker 3: You had 3D images, correct? I did. You could have shown and measured 3D images to get almost the exact contact point and almost the exact dimensions if you had just used the 3D images that you had available to you. Isn't that correct? [00:37:05] Dr. Welch: That's exactly what we did. When I went through the video analysis, I showed you how we overlaid the point clouds, the 3D scans, on top of each vehicle. So we took the, I'm sorry, let me, we took the vehicles. Sir, please don't interrupt. Hold on. [00:37:19] Speaker ?: Hold on. [00:37:19] Speaker 3: Your Honor, he keeps referencing my hand and saying I'm doing something when I'm not. And I think that's distracting to the jury. I'm not interrupting him. Hold on. [00:37:27] Speaker 2: Hold on. Let the witness answer the question. [00:37:30] Speaker 3: I am. I am. I'm just holding my hand like this, your Honor. He keeps saying that I'm doing something. [00:37:35] Speaker 2: Mr. Lessee, please. [00:37:36] Speaker 3: All right. [00:37:37] Speaker 2: Go ahead. Finish the answer, Dr. Walker. [00:37:39] Dr. Welch: Again, in the photogrammetric analysis, I showed the video. I showed how we overlaid the point cloud on top of the video. That proves that the way we solved it, correct camera characteristics matches. Otherwise, that would be distorted. We overlaid the scans of the Lexus into the photogrammetric analysis. We overlaid the scans of the scene into the photogrammetric analysis. We overlaid all that stuff into the analysis. We did exactly what you're suggesting. [00:38:08] Speaker 3: You could have easily addressed this issue by the following. If you really believe there was no contact or not sufficient contact, you could have produced a graphic that shows a gap between the two vehicles. A graphic, couldn't you? That's not a graphic. What is that? Sir, I get to ask the questions and you are to answer them subject to the judge's ruling. So, my question is, couldn't you have created a graphic that would have better shown the issue that you are creating or talking about today? That's my question. Couldn't you have created a graphic? We did. [00:38:57] Dr. Welch: We created a whole bunch of graphics. [00:38:59] Speaker 3: You called what we just saw a graphic? Yes. Well, if there's a gap, why isn't there then something that shows a clear gap? [00:39:10] Dr. Welch: Because when you have the angulation of the vehicles, you have perspective. When you're looking at it, even if you do a top down, you see everything projected onto a single flat plane. So, you can't tell the height of things. So, when you see things in this dimension, you can't necessarily see depth of things. So, you lose in two dimensional images, you lose one dimension depending on which way you're looking. That's why I showed it from all these different angles to try and show exactly what you're saying. We had graphics to do that. [00:39:42] Speaker 3: 3D images allow you to show perspectives for 360 degrees, correct? [00:39:50] Speaker ?: Is that correct? [00:39:51] Speaker 3: That is correct. So, none of what you presented in your slideshow shows the contact points from 360 degrees, does it? [00:40:05] Dr. Welch: I don't understand your question. Are you asking if I showed it at every single, I went through 360 slides that showed it at every single degree? [00:40:14] Speaker 3: Sir, let's move on. I think I've made the point. [00:40:18] Speaker 2: So, I'm going to strike the comment, Mr. Ellis. [00:40:21] Speaker 3: Dr. Welcher, let's go to the next topic and keep with these two depictions. Are these two images point clouds or 3D images? Those are one and the same thing. Yes. I would use them as synonym. Which term of the two do you want to use? Point cloud or 3D images? [00:40:57] Dr. Welch: Both are fine. It's a 3D image composed of points. Okay. [00:41:01] Speaker 3: So, let's just call them 3D images. Okay. So, we can do this more quickly. The Lexus and the Chevy Traverse that are depicted there are both 3D images of those vehicles, correct? Correct. And Aperture created the 3D images, correct? Correct. Sir, did you do these scans and did you personally create these images? No. [00:41:24] Dr. Welch: One of the assistants at Aperture did. [00:41:26] Speaker 3: So, you're speaking about what somebody else did at Aperture, correct? [00:41:31] Dr. Welch: They were doing it at my direction and for example, the Lexus scan, I showed the photographs. You can see the gentleman that works at Aperture, Mike Morelli, was scanning them for me while I was doing the rest of the inspection. And then the hand scanning of the rear tail light was done by another engineer. I was out there with him doing it, taking measurements. And then same thing with the Chevy Traverse. [00:41:58] Speaker 3: My question is, you didn't do the creation of these 3D images, did you? [00:42:05] Dr. Welch: The individual images, no. [00:42:09] Speaker 3: All right. So, let's go to these individual images. These are 3D images. Is that your testimony? Yes. Let's look at the tail light. Okay. That's not a 3D image. That's a Photoshop, isn't it? Nope. So, it's your testimony that that tail light is a 3D image? [00:42:32] Dr. Welch: That absolutely is a 3D image. The way you can tell is, when you get up near the chrome, because lasers don't like shiny objects, you start to get a scatter. So, see all these dots here? If that was a photo, you wouldn't have these dots. [00:42:47] Speaker 3: Let's go to the Chevy Traverse. Is there... Is there... Is there... Let's... Mr. Wolk zero in on the... Yeah. There's green on that tail light, in the tail light. That's a 3D image of the tail light, isn't it, sir? They're both 3D images. Well, I just want to stay with one. That tail light is a 3D image, and one of the ways you can tell is, it's got all that grainy material on it, correct? Correct. Now, let's go back, Mr. Wolk, to the Lexus. Let's now go to the bumper. [00:43:26] Dr. Welch: Do you want me to explain the difference? [00:43:28] Speaker 3: No. Okay. Thank you. I would like to go to the bumper. Do you see any grainy... The predominance of any grainy image on the bumper? [00:43:40] Dr. Welch: There's a little bit. So, for example, when you get near edges, it has a hard time with edges. I'm sorry, the bumper cover. Right. See the bumper cover up above? This whole thing is... This whole thing is the bumper cover. That's the step pad. Right. That's the rear body panel, or the rear deck lid. I'm talking about the step pad, sir. [00:43:59] Speaker 3: Just the step pad of the bumper. [00:44:01] Dr. Welch: You asked about just from here to here. Correct. The bumper step pad. Can we zoom in on it? Pardon me? Can we zoom in on it? Sure. Do you see any? Yeah. I see grainy nice. Let's go over to... Right in here. You can see it all through here. You see it through here. [00:44:23] Speaker 3: Well, I'm talking about the step pad, not the entire bumper. I'm just talking about the step pad. [00:44:28] Dr. Welch: Right. So, you're zooming in on the bumper. Right. The step pad is this structure up here. We're going to move up. [00:44:34] Speaker 3: It just takes a while. So, your testimony is that is a... Can you zoom in more? That's... You would like it zoomed in? Yes, sir. Sure. Your testimony is that that is a 3D image, not a Photoshop step bumper cover. Is that correct? [00:44:59] Dr. Welch: So, we have mapped the color over the 3D scans. We used two separate scanners. If you recall, when I got out to Ms. Reed's vehicle, that tail light was gone. So, we had to replace the tail light. [00:45:14] Speaker 3: Talking about the bumper cover, not the tail light. Okay. I'm explaining the process. I'm just asking about the bumper cover, not the process. [00:45:22] Speaker 2: So, focus your answer on the bumper cover. [00:45:24] Dr. Welch: That is a laser scan. [00:45:26] Speaker 3: Okay. So, you... That's a 3D model. Your testimony is the step part of the bumper cover is a 3D image from a laser scan, and it's not a Photoshop. That's your testimony. Absolutely. And you didn't perform the work for the 3D that you claim the bumper step up is. You didn't do that work to produce that depiction, did you, sir? Somebody else in your firm did it. [00:45:50] Dr. Welch: So, this is all done at my direction. The engineers that work for me, so I'm telling them what to do. I'm not the one punching the keys. That's my question. I'm saying, I need you to do this, this, this, this, and this. Use the hand scanner. Go scan the light. I need to put this back in because it was missing when we got to it. So, no. I'm not punching the keys. Okay. It's over. Free food. [00:46:13] Speaker 2: Okay. Word over, please. [00:46:41] Speaker ?: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. [00:48:11] Speaker 3: With regard to, no, we don't need him back up, Mr. Wolk. Isn't it correct that 3D images allow for proper and most accurate measurements as opposed to 2D images? Is that a correct general statement? I mean, generally, yeah. Okay. That's my question. So let's go to the next topic. Let's talk about hydraulics on the Lexus SUV. What type of hydraulic system does the Lexus SUV have? [00:48:58] Dr. Welch: So it has a mechanism. I believe it's actually pneumatic. It's air-based system that raises it up and down. [00:49:05] Speaker 3: Do you know what the name of that system is, sir? [00:49:08] Dr. Welch: No, not thought in my head. Do you know how it works, specifically? Well, I mean, I know generally that there's a button on the interior where you can raise and lower the ride height. [00:49:17] Speaker 3: And is that the extent of your knowledge of that system on the Lexus? [00:49:21] Dr. Welch: No. Again, I know when you park it, it'll drop down the ride height. When you adjust it for different roadway conditions, it'll change the ride height. [00:49:28] Speaker 3: Do you know what the height tolerances are? In other words, the lowest to the highest? [00:49:33] Dr. Welch: I believe it's around an inch and a quarter. At one point in time, I measured it. I don't remember off the top of my head. [00:49:39] Speaker 3: So you believe it's an inch and a quarter up and an inch and a quarter down? How do you apply the inch and a quarter? [00:49:46] Dr. Welch: I recall the total being like an inch and a quarter, but I measured it at one point in time. I just don't remember off the top of my head. [00:49:51] Speaker 3: Would you be surprised to hear that the tolerance is five inches on that vehicle? [00:49:57] Dr. Welch: I would be surprised. I don't recall it being that much, but I would need to double check. [00:50:01] Speaker 3: Assume that the manual, as well as other informations, support that the tolerance is five inches and that specifically the vehicle can be raised three inches high and it can be lowered two inches. That's the basis for the five. What was the suspension height of Ms. Reed's Lexus that you used for your accident reconstruction? You used for the suspension height of the suspension. We used for the suspension height of the Lexus to make contact with the eye of Mr. O'Keefe. If it was even possible, what did you use for a measurement of the suspension? We matched the measurements from when the vehicle was tested, I believe on February 1st, at the Canton Police Department. [00:50:55] Dr. Welch: So we aligned the bottom of the tail light, actually the sheet metal right below the tail light. So we adjusted the height of the Lexus to match that. [00:51:19] Speaker 3: Did you in any place document what level the Lexus was at at the time of any testing, meaning the suspension? Did you document it at all? Yes. Where? Slide 107. Can we have slide 107, Mr. Wolfe? [00:51:43] Dr. Welch: And then if you could zoom in on the lower photograph, the gentleman with the blue shirt. Zoom in a little more, please. So if I may, we matched the bottom of the sheet metal here to photographs when it was at the Canton Police Department. [00:52:15] Speaker 3: Sir, my question is, where did you document whether the suspension was at zero, whether it was plus three or minus two, where did you document that? [00:52:30] Dr. Welch: Right here. [00:52:33] Speaker 3: And what are the numbers of the documentation of that? [00:52:42] Dr. Welch: I don't know, we were matching the photos, so I don't care what the numbers are, I care that the height is the same. [00:52:47] Speaker 3: Okay, so I just heard you say, if I heard correctly, you don't care what the suspension is at. Is that your testimony? [00:52:55] Dr. Welch: No, I don't care what the suspension number is, as long as the heights match. [00:53:01] Speaker 3: I understand, I understand. So, what was the suspension height of Ms. Reed's Lexus at 5.07 a.m. on January 29, 2022, while at One Meadows and colliding with the Chevy Traverse? What was the suspension height then? [00:53:26] Dr. Welch: We assumed it was the same as when it was at the Canton Police Department. [00:53:30] Speaker 3: Exactly, you assumed, but there's no measurement, like was just on that depiction. There was no note that said, okay, we're doing this very important and inches sensitive measurements to see whether the tail light on the Lexus makes contact with the Traverse. But there's no measurement and no documentation of what the suspension height was at One Meadows, correct? [00:54:01] Dr. Welch: So, we took the closest measurement in time to the One Meadows event, which is when it was at the Canton Police Department. That was the best information we had. [00:54:11] Speaker 3: Well, that information isn't very good because the vehicle had to go from Canton to One Meadows, and when the vehicle drives, the way the suspension system works, it's automatic. When you go above 20 miles an hour, the suspension comes up, and when you turn off the vehicle, it goes down so you can get out easier. So, it would be improper to assume that the suspension at One Meadows would be the same at another location. [00:54:42] Dr. Welch: That's the only – sorry. [00:54:44] Speaker 2: Was there an objection? [00:54:46] Speaker ?: Yeah. [00:54:46] Speaker 2: Go ahead and answer, please. [00:54:48] Dr. Welch: That's the extent of the information we had. We had it when it was at the Canton Police Department. We matched that height. Sorry, Sergeant. [00:54:53] Speaker 3: I understand. [00:54:56] Dr. Welch: But, actually, you brought up a good point. It's going so slow when it's backing up that it wouldn't raise up. So, the static position when it's backing up would be the static position. [00:55:08] Speaker 3: But it wouldn't be going in back up from the Canton Police Department to One Meadows. It wouldn't be going back up when it's going in other locations, sir, right? It would be driving forward. It had to get from point A to point B. [00:55:22] Dr. Welch: Right. But, as you pointed out, when you turn it off, it drops down. And then you turn it on. And then once you go above 20, as you indicated, it goes up. But when she's backing up, she never goes more than a couple miles an hour. So, it's going to be at the same position as when you start, which is approximately the same position when it's off at the Canton Police Department a couple days later. [00:55:46] Speaker 3: Do you know whether the suspension system locks when there is testing of the infotainment system? [00:55:58] Dr. Welch: Whether the suspensions? I don't know. [00:56:02] Speaker 3: Okay. Let's go on to the next topic. You're aware of the vehicle control – excuse me, Your Honor. I want to go – I'm changing topics to go back now to Fairview, 34 Fairview. You don't know what the suspension ride height at 34 Fairview was on January 29th of 2022, do you? Correct. So, therefore, if you don't know what the suspension height was – because, of course, you weren't there on January 29th, 2022 – there, therefore, was there no measuring stick. As you say, you assert that you would have accounted for it in your methodology. So, you don't have the suspension height for that key day, do you, sir? I only have it two days later. All right. So, when you talk about key measurements, such as the spoiler on the top of the Lexus and the inches that are important as to whether things such as, is there a contact with the front eye? You don't have some data that would be relevant to that calculation to some data being the suspension height of the Lexus at that time, do you? [00:57:52] Dr. Welch: So, we have some data – so, we have some data, we have photos of the vehicle two days later, we don't know the exact height outside because, as you alluded to, we don't have a measurement on January 29th of it, but we do have it two days later. [00:58:08] Speaker 3: You don't have the suspension height or the setting of the Lexus that existed on January 29th, 2022, do you? Correct. Now, let's go on to another topic. So, within the 34 Fairview on January 29th of 2022, I'm not going to go over them, but you asserted various measurements, height, width, with regard to the Lexus, correct? In fact, it wasn't just for the spoiler at the top, correct? Correct. And for all those other measurements that you talked about, you did not have the suspension height and the suspension setting of the hydraulic system of the Lexus on January 29th, 2022, did you? [00:59:13] Dr. Welch: So, the hydraulic is only going to affect the vertical dimensions. It doesn't change anything left or right, and it doesn't change anything down the side of the car. [00:59:22] Speaker 3: Understood. But for the measurements that are affected by vertical, you didn't have the suspension height of the Lexus system on January 29th, 2022. Again, I only know what it is two days later. So, now let's go on to vehicle control history. Sir, you understand what I mean by vehicle control history? You do? [00:59:44] Dr. Welch: This is tech stream information? [00:59:47] Speaker 3: Are you aware of what is called the Bosch crash data retrieval system in Lexus vehicles? Of course. [00:59:56] Dr. Welch: We showed it on my slides. [00:59:58] Speaker 3: And the Bosch crash data retrieval system in Lexus vehicles is sometimes referred to as the black box? [01:00:07] Dr. Welch: No, you're mixing up two things. So, the Bosch is like the tools. It's a question, sir. [01:00:14] Speaker 2: So, can you answer that with a yes or no? [01:00:17] Speaker 3: Is the Bosch crash data retrieval system the black box on Lexus vehicles? I just wanted to repeat it so we can... [01:00:26] Speaker 2: I didn't hear with the objection. You objected? I'd like you to go to finish his answers. So, the question was just asked. Can you answer that question? [01:00:33] Dr. Welch: No. It doesn't make sense. [01:00:35] Speaker 2: Okay, next question, Mr. Lewis. [01:00:37] Speaker 3: I'm going to ask the question, sir. The Bosch crash data retrieval system in Lexus vehicles. You're familiar with that? Are you familiar? [01:00:54] Speaker ?: No. [01:00:55] Speaker 3: Have you read the report of Schubert Fall? [01:00:59] Speaker ?: Yes. [01:00:59] Speaker 3: The May 2023. Does that report not use the exact words POSCH? Let me ask objections. Do you recall? The objection sustained. The objection sustained. Let's go to the VCH system in Lexus. Is the VCH system intended by Lexus as a diagnostic tool for their technicians to assist in vehicle repair and maintenance? Is that what that is created for? That's their stated purpose. Right. And is a synonym for VCH, TechStream? [01:01:42] Dr. Welch: Sort of. TechStream, similar. Like, Bosch is the hardware and software to access the black box data. TechStream is the software to access, for example, the pre-collision system, the PCS system, and the VCH, which is the vehicle control history. So, TechStream is, which does a lot of other stuff, but does access that information. You just mentioned Bosch. Didn't you, sir? So, Bosch is not in the Lexus. You use Bosch stuff sold by Bosch, Bosch software and hardware, and you walk up to the Lexus with all the Bosch stuff and plug it in and download the event data recorder, the EDR, the black box. That was my problem. There is no Bosch stuff in Lexus. [01:02:29] Speaker 3: I understand, sir. That was going to be the question that I was trying to get to, but you've explained it, so I don't have to answer the question. Let's go to the VCH database. That you say the stated purpose is to assist technicians at Lexus in vehicle repair and maintenance. [01:02:47] Dr. Welch: So, I didn't say that was a stated purpose. I'm saying that's what Lexus or Toyota says is a stated purpose. It's being used in litigation all the time. All I know is that's what Lexus and Toyota says, but, again, it came about right when we started seeing all the sudden accelerations in the Toyota vehicles. [01:03:05] Speaker 3: So, my question is, is the VCH database specific to Toyota and Lexus vehicles? [01:03:13] Dr. Welch: So, it's not a database. It's software. [01:03:16] Speaker 3: Is the software specific to Lexus and Toyota? [01:03:20] Dr. Welch: Those particular acronyms are, yes. [01:03:33] Speaker 3: I want to move to another topic, and we are almost finished. We have just two more topics, sir. How common were VCH events when Ms. Reed owned the Lexus? In 2022? From, do you know the ownership period of Ms. Reed with respect to the Lexus? Do you know how long she owned it? [01:04:02] Dr. Welch: I have that documentation. I'm doing it off the top of my head. [01:04:06] Speaker 3: Do you have an approximate? [01:04:09] Dr. Welch: No. I mean, it was a 2021 vehicle. Our accident is January 29, 2022. But I did get that information. [01:04:18] Speaker 3: Do you know how many VCH events were associated with the Lexus of Ms. Reed? [01:04:31] Dr. Welch: I did not count them, no. I have them all. I was only focused on the ones around our time period. Exactly. [01:04:40] Speaker 3: But do you have the number of events? Do you know how many there were? I can get it for you. How long would it take, sir? Three minutes. Why don't we come back to it? Okay. And we'll see if it's done. [01:04:54] Dr. Welch: How about I start this so that we don't have to wait for it to boot up? And then when we come back to it, it's ready to go. You okay with that? [01:05:00] Speaker 3: That's all you're looking at, sir. Yep. Thank you. And then pick your head up, please, so I can finish these two toughs. Go ahead. So how often were VCH events recorded on the Lexus before January 29, 2022? [01:05:23] Dr. Welch: Man, I have to pull this data up. Fair enough. Fair enough. [01:05:25] Speaker 3: I assume that's going to be in what you're also pulling up. [01:05:29] Dr. Welch: That's the goal here. [01:05:36] Speaker 3: Would the number be about 1515? Does that sound right to you? [01:05:45] Dr. Welch: Let's see. One. Two. There's 18. 18. [01:06:23] Speaker 3: So your records show that there were 18 VCH events recorded on Ms. Reed's Lexus, correct? Before the subject one. Right. Did you conclude that any of those events other than the 11-62-2 were a collision? No. Now let's go to reverse recorded events. Can you tell how many of those 18 events were reverse recorded events? Do you know what I mean by reverse recorded events? Yes. The vehicle going in reverse? How many of those events were the vehicle going in reverse? And this is before? Four. Other than that. He asked you, is this before? Yes. I'm sorry. [01:07:19] Dr. Welch: Oh. I would have to pull up the PCS file. [01:07:24] Speaker 3: Could you start that and I can continue on with the questioning? I got to. [01:07:30] Dr. Welch: So the PCS file is a. I have a second laptop. [01:07:33] Speaker 3: Here's what I'm going to do. That's not important for me to keep going and get through it. Okay. So let's just stay on the events, okay? Only one of all of those events, those 18, are you concluding that there was a collision associated with them, correct? Just one. [01:07:57] Dr. Welch: No. All those 18 are before. The collision is number 19. [01:08:01] Speaker 3: No, no. I'm saying, I understand what you're saying, but for all the other events that are recorded, you're not, other than the January 29, 1162-2, you're not concluding that any of those were collisions, correct? [01:08:16] Dr. Welch: I didn't look at them. They were so far mileage away from everything. [01:08:22] Speaker 3: But you're not concluding, even though they were so far away and you didn't look at them, you don't conclude from the information you have that any of them were a collision, correct? Yes. [01:08:32] Speaker 2: Sustained. [01:08:33] Speaker 3: Let's go to 5.07 a.m. on January 29, 2022, at One Meadows, the home of Mr. O'Keefe. Okay. There was a collision between Ms. Reed's 6,000-pound Lexus and Mr. O'Keefe's approximately 4,500 Chevy Traverse. That's undisputed, correct? They collided. They made contact. They touched. Right. But the actual collision at One Meadows did not register the recording of an event on the Lexus VCH system, did it? Correct. It's too minor. So, however, you want this jury, sir, to conclude that the glancing blow that you contend occurred at 34 Fairview Road by the same 6,000-pound Lexus in contact with a mere 216-pound man did register an event on the Lexus, correct? [01:09:50] Dr. Welch: No. Now, the impact didn't register the event. As I pointed out, the T, the trigger, the trigger was from when the accelerator pedal went to 30%. The tech stream does not register crashes at all. It registers excessive acceleration, excessive steering, excessive braking, things like that, things that would be part of the maintenance system. So the tech stream will never register an event, even if you hit a wall at 100 miles an hour, necessarily. It will cause thought codes and things like that, but that's not what it does. The trigger here was transitioning into reverse and then gunning the accelerator pedal in reverse. And so when it went from 30% up to 74% throttle, once it went over 30% in that transition, that's what triggered the tech stream. It had nothing to do with, and that's why I'm telling you, I don't know when in that event the impact occurred, because the tech stream doesn't tell you that. [01:10:48] Speaker 3: Thank you. You're welcome. That's exactly my point. The tech stream information doesn't tell you when a collision occurs, does it? [01:10:59] Dr. Welch: Correct. [01:11:09] Speaker 3: That's all the questions I have at this time, Your Honor. [01:11:11] Speaker 2: All right, why don't we take our morning recess, James? [01:11:14] Speaker ?: Thank you.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →