Try Free

What it takes to scale lower-carbon energy technology — The Energy Podcast

Shell November 20, 2026 24m 4,046 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of What it takes to scale lower-carbon energy technology — The Energy Podcast from Shell, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 4,046 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"If you look at the hydrant industry today, many projects remain on PowerPoint. And I think the key thing is being able to manage the whole system, to match demand with supply, to make sure the infrastructure is there, to make sure the technology works, and to have the right supportive policy..."

[00:00:00] Andy Beard: If you look at the hydrant industry today, many projects remain on PowerPoint. And I think the key thing is being able to manage the whole system, to match demand with supply, to make sure the infrastructure is there, to make sure the technology works, and to have the right supportive policy environment as well. Hydrant is often described as a Swiss army knife. You know, it can do many different things. It's used in refineries, it's used in chemical manufacturing, it's used in producing ammonia as well, which is critical for our food supply chains. So it's a really important energy carrier. [00:00:35] Speaker 2: The Energy Podcast from Shell, the home of conversation about the energy that powers our world. Developing a new energy technology is one thing. Building the infrastructure, securing customer demand, and making the economics work at scale is another. [00:00:54] Speaker 3: So how does a low-carbon solution make the journey from promised to a practical reality? What are the challenges? And what can we learn from those actually helping develop it? [00:01:04] Speaker 2: In this episode, we're exploring those questions with Andy Beard, who's Shell's Vice President of Hydrogen. I'm Bryony. [00:01:13] Speaker 3: And I'm Nitin. [00:01:13] Speaker 2: And this is the Energy Podcast from Shell. Andy, thanks so much for joining us on the Energy Podcast. It's really good to have you with us today. Thank you for having me. Kick us off by explaining the role that low-carbon solutions play, of which hydrogen is one. How are they playing the energy system today, and where can they make the biggest difference? [00:01:34] Andy Beard: The world continues to use a mix of energy sources and carriers, and low-carbon energy sources just help reduce the emission profile of the overall energy mix. However, some of those energy carriers and energy sources have different maturities. Some require new technologies for them to reach their fuel potential. Others actually are easy to use today and fit nicely into the energy supply chains we have. And different customers will pick a mix of energy sources based on cost, emission profiles, and availability. At Shell, you know, we are one of the world's leading providers of conventional and low-carbon fuels. And our portfolio includes biofuels, renewable natural gas, CCS, and hydrogen. [00:02:22] Speaker 3: So, Andy, you touched on hydrogen there. And hydrogen is often described as an energy solution for the future, right? But, in fact, it's widely used today. So, where does hydrogen actually fit into the energy system of now? [00:02:38] Andy Beard: So, hydrogen is often described as a Swiss army knife. You know, it can do many different things. But, realistically, some applications are much more useful than others, especially given the technical maturity of converting hydrogen into a useful energy source. So, if you look at where we have it today, 100 million tons of hydrogen is used globally. Around 1 million, or 1% of that, is low-carbon. And it's used in various applications. It's used in refineries. It's used in chemical manufacturing. It's used in producing ammonia as well, which is critical for our food supply chains as well. So, it's a really important energy carrier. And it's very important as a feedstock into industrial processes, too. [00:03:23] Speaker 2: I really like that analogy of the Swiss army knife. But I think we definitely need to kind of quickly clear up the hydrogen terminology. This is my kind of chemistry corner bit. So, you can tell me if I've got this right, Andy. So, when we say renewable hydrogen, we mean hydrogen produced using electrolysis powered by renewable energy, so wind, solar. And electrolysis, for those people who don't know, is basically using electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. [00:03:54] Andy Beard: That's correct. [00:03:54] Speaker 2: Great. Okay. Decarbonised hydrogen. So, decarbonised hydrogen is produced from natural gas or industrial waste gases with carbon capture and storage, CCS. Both decarbonised and renewable hydrogen can be referred to as low-carbon hydrogen. [00:04:09] Andy Beard: That's right. [00:04:10] Speaker 2: And finally, fossil-based hydrogen, of course, describes hydrogen using fossil fuels. So, that's, in this sense, natural gas and coal or coal without any CCS. [00:04:22] Andy Beard: That's correct. Okay. Yes. The hydrogen molecule looks pretty much the same from each of those processes. It's really the emission profile that differs across those different pathways. [00:04:33] Speaker 2: I'm quite pleased with myself, actually. Yeah. I haven't paid that much attention in my lectures. I only read it, obviously. Andy's the expert. Yeah. Basically, yeah. [00:04:39] Speaker 3: Well, you did well, though. I mean, I learned something new there, Andy, as well. So, thank you for that, Bryony. So, Andy, tell us, why does low-carbon hydrogen matter and where could it make a real difference from where we're at today? [00:04:51] Andy Beard: Today, we already have a large market for hydrogen use. As I mentioned, you know, we use it in industrial processes. We use it. It's a critical feedstock into fuels that we use today, into ammonia, which is critical for our food value chains. It's also used as a fuel, but to a much lesser degree at this point in time. In the future, it will be a building block to produce synthetic fuels as well. And I think that's really important that we focus on where it matters today to help scale, to allow it to reach its full potential. And where it is used today is really in these industrial applications around ammonia and fuel producers. Here, we have an infrastructure ready to go where we can help scale the business. [00:05:35] Speaker 2: So, I suppose the question is not simply whether hydrogen has potential, it's how you turn that potential into a working project. Because sitting here today, we know that Shell is progressing to big hydrogen projects, which are expected to start up next year. But before we come on to those, we talked at the start about the range of technologies that can contribute to a lower carbon energy system. What I'm interested to know is how does Shell choose where to put its money? [00:06:00] Andy Beard: So, Shell has a very large investment. We've invested multiple billions into low-carbon platforms that include renewable electricity, biofuels, renewable natural gas, CCS, and hydrogen. And our focus is really on where we have a competitive advantage, where we have access to customers, and we have a strong policy environment allow us to build a credible investment case to make these projects real. [00:06:29] Speaker 3: And so then, when you apply that test to hydrogen, what makes the case for it? [00:06:33] Andy Beard: So, I think at Shell, we have refineries. And this is a great use case to develop a low-carbon hydrogen business case. So, if we look at the refineries we have, we have one refinery in the Netherlands, and we have another one in Cologne. They use fossil-based hydrogen today. We can replace some of that fossil-based hydrogen with renewable hydrogen, which is in support of reducing the emissions of our assets. And the beauty of us being able to do this is we have the full integration across the value chain. We can source the power. We can produce the hydrogen on-site or nearby, and we can then act as our own customer to use that hydrogen. This allows us to deploy the technology, get proof, learn how these assets actually operate, and how they work in real-world conditions. And through that platform, it allows us to position ourselves, as emerging infrastructure develops around these assets, to be able to target new customers and provide low-carbon or renewable-based hydrogen to customers, which actually add value and not just necessarily pursuing scale for the sake of scale. [00:07:44] Speaker 2: Should we talk about Refine 2? So tell us what it is, how it's going to work, and what it does or what it will do, and how does it build on the experience of Refine 1? [00:07:57] Andy Beard: Maybe let me just start with what is an electrolyzer. So an electrolyzer, as you mentioned earlier, is really taking water and splitting out hydrogen and oxygen. To make that happen, you first have to take high-voltage electricity from the grid and gradually reduce the voltage of that. and then switch the power from an alternate current to a direct current. Use that electricity in the electrolyzer, which then separates out the hydrogen and oxygen. You take the hydrogen, you then clean it, dry it, and then compress it, and ship it out to where you're going to use it within the refinery. So Refine is a great example of this setup within our German refinery in Cologne. So we have two projects. We have Refine 1, which is a 10-megawatt electrolyzer, which started in 2021, and we've now taken FID on 100 megawatts. It's in construction and is going through commissioning now and will be in operation next year. [00:09:01] Speaker 2: Refine 2. [00:09:02] Andy Beard: And that's Refine 2. So what we have here is we have the same technology, a PEM electrolyzer. A PEM electrolyzer is a technology that's relatively well known. It's based off similar technology to what NASA used when it was developing fuel cells for space travel. We have experience with Refine 1, multiple years in operation. We work closely with our technology provider to de-risk and actually get real-world experience of operating this electrolyzer. And then with Refine 2, this will produce up to 44 tons of renewable hydrogen each day, and that will displace some of that fossil-based hydrogen that is currently used within the system. So acting as our own customer, it's allowed us to de-risk the project for now, but it is also now allowing us to provide a foundation as infrastructure and the wider network connects to these facilities to then be able to offer low-carbon hydrogen to customers. [00:10:03] Speaker 3: What have you learned by effectively developing these projects in such stages? [00:10:08] Andy Beard: I mean, to start with, we get real-world experience deploying the technology, but what really makes the difference is we're seeing how it works as a system. It's not just the electrolyzer. It's how does the electrolyzer operate within the refinery system? Because ultimately, refineries don't like intermittent supply of key feedstocks. So we have to understand how does it operate, how reliable is it, how quickly can we scale things up and down in terms of production to make sure we are a reliable supplier for ourselves as the customer? [00:10:40] Speaker 2: Let's talk about Holland Hydrogen 1 or HH1 as well. That's in the Netherlands, but obviously tell us what it is, how it's going to work, and what that is intended to provide as well, because that's kind of an important part of this story, obviously. [00:10:53] Andy Beard: So Holland Hydrogen 1 or HH1, it's a slightly different project. Firstly, it is a greenfield site, so we are building this on a brand new site, and we are then still supplying our own refinery, but it is connected with a 35-kilometer pipeline. So it's not based in the refinery itself, like refineries, but it is producing renewable-based hydrogen, again, displacing fossil-based hydrogen from the refinery. It is double the size, so it is 200 megawatts, and it is also a different technology. So we're making sure we get experience of different technologies so we can understand and learn what will it take to scale, and where do different technologies actually work better under which conditions as well. So HH1, it's a large site. It's about the size of 27 football pitchers. There's enough steel to produce half an Eiffel Tower. Admittedly, not quite as pretty as a full one, but these are sizable investments, and you require a lot of electrical infrastructure as well. So when we started actually building HH1, we didn't have a grid connection that would be available in time. So we actually stepped forward and built our own grid connection to help make sure that we could actually deliver the project on time. So there's a lot of complexity, there's a lot of scale to a site like HH1. So very exciting projects, and it'll be one of the largest coming on stream within Europe next year. [00:12:23] Speaker 2: As you said there, Holland Hydrogen One is expected to replace a small portion of fossil-based hydrogen used in the refining process at Shell's Perniss site. Earlier on, I spoke with Daniela Ebentrech, who's a manager at Perniss, to hear more. Daniela, good to talk to you. Briefly tell us what Perniss does. [00:12:43] Speaker 4: Yes, thank you for having me. Perniss is the largest refinery in Europe, and what we do is use crude oil to produce products that people use on a day-to-day basis, like fuel for airplanes, fuels for your car, but also cleaning products that you use in the household on a daily basis, and that we do for Europe predominantly. [00:13:03] Speaker 2: Hydrogen is already used at Perniss. Tell us what role it plays at the site. [00:13:09] Speaker 4: Hydrogen plays a critical role at the refinery. It is used to produce our products, and it has two main roles. One is to actually clean some of the products that we produce here in interim steps, and it actually allows us to have a higher quality end product that we then are able to sell to our customers. [00:13:26] Speaker 2: When Holland Hydrogen One comes online, talk us through how it will work in relation to Perniss and what it will change there. [00:13:34] Speaker 4: It will change quite a bit. So we currently take in already and produce a lot of hydrogen, and this will actually displace some of the fossil hydrogen that we are currently using in our processes with the renewable hydrogen that will come from Holland Hydrogen One. And it is incredibly interesting because Holland Hydrogen One is also connected to a wind park in the North Sea. So what we're actually going to be seeing is that Holland Hydrogen One will produce renewable hydrogen when the wind is blowing, which in the Netherlands is a lot, and we will get that renewable energy into our refinery at Perniss and use that for producing those products where in the past or in the moment we will actually use fossil hydrogen or fossil-based hydrogen. And we will need a lot of flexibility to ensure that we can match the wind that we see in the Netherlands and ensure that we can ramp up and ramp down our fossil hydrogen use to allow as much renewable hydrogen as we possibly can, depending on the wind. So what does it take [00:14:35] Speaker 2: to integrate this new source of hydrogen into an operating site like Perniss? [00:14:40] Speaker 4: Yeah, it does take quite a bit and the teams are incredibly busy making sure that we do this well and that we can start up safely and reliably. We need to make sure that the hydrogen, the renewable hydrogen from Holland Hydrogen One that comes in is connected to all of our units where it is required. And that is not an easy task because we've got 60 units at this refinery so it's quite complex to make sure that this renewable hydrogen is going to be able to get to the right units at the right moment in time. So there's a lot of work going on but everybody's very motivated to make sure that we can do this in the best possible way. And finally, in that context, give us a sense of what's happening there right now. Yeah, there's still a lot happening. Obviously, we're very close to startup and at the same time, especially with everything going on in the world, we need to make sure that Pernice continues to operate safely and reliably and that we continue to produce the products that our customers need. And we are doing that then in parallel to making sure that we start up Holland Hydrogen One safely and reliably. So currently, they're working on making sure that the pipeline ingress is done properly, that the connection to the process units is there from a technical perspective as well as from an operational and a process perspective to make sure that the quality of hydrogen that comes in and the flow can be used immediately in our process units at the moment that Holland Hydrogen One starts up in 2027. Daniela, thanks so much for joining us. Thanks, Bryony. It was great to talk to you. [00:16:12] Speaker 3: As we've heard from Daniela there, Andy, clearly the scale of HH1 is huge. What does it involve in practical terms to build renewable hydrogen at this scale? [00:16:23] Andy Beard: The key thing is integration. We produce the power for the electrolyzer, we produce the hydrogen, and then we consume the hydrogen. By being able to operate across that full value chain, it's given us the flexibility, it's given us the ability to bank this project as well, and actually to make sure that the steel in the ground really transforms into a live, valuable project that is delivered with capital discipline. [00:16:49] Speaker 2: So what has to come together for projects like these two to move from an idea to a final investment decision? [00:16:56] Andy Beard: I think if you look at the hydrogen industry today, many projects remain on PowerPoint, and I think the key thing is being able to manage the whole system. So to move it forward, to match demand with supply, to make sure the infrastructure is there, to make sure the technology works, and to have the right supportive policy environment as well. You need all five of those things to be able to move forward with confidence. And by us being an integrated player, we've managed to de-risk a lot of the supply, demand, and infrastructure by targeting existing use. And the technology, we have a world-class R&D division that has helped us de-risk and get comfort with the technology as well. [00:17:37] Speaker 3: So those projects show that the production is possible, but two new plants do not by themselves at least create an established market. So what has to happen next for that to become, you know, viable? [00:17:50] Andy Beard: So the industry itself is growing. So as I mentioned, it's 1 million tons of low-carbon hydrogen today. The Hydrogen Council expect that to grow to say 9 to 14 million tons of production per annum by around 2030. And HH1 is 0.02 million tons per annum. So you can see you need a lot of projects like this to get to that scale. The European Union wanted 10 million tons by 2030. You would need 500 HH1s to reach that. So the market is moving and the industry is moving, but we've got quite a way to go to reach the aspirations. And that takes time because we're building out the infrastructure, we're building out the learning, and we're building out the supply chain as an industry. and Shell is really contributing towards that by having these projects which is helping understand what it takes to work, it's helping build supply chains, and it's acting as a proof point for others to follow. [00:18:50] Speaker 2: You mentioned before that some projects just stay on the PowerPoint. There's clearly an interest in low-carbon hydrogen, but many announced projects have struggled to reach the point where a decision is made to invest. So what do you think is holding the market back? [00:19:05] Andy Beard: So I think at the moment where the technology is and where the cost of hydrogen is, that is often higher than a lot of our customers' willingness to pay. So we see a value gap. At this point, policy certainty is one of the most important things to allow the industry to progress, allow us to scale, allow us to close that value gap. At the moment, there is not sufficient policy certainty for the long term. These are large-scale investments that are going to take decades to pay, well, not to pay back, but to be in operation. So it is critical, there is line of sight that that policy certainty will remain. [00:19:46] Speaker 3: So to replay what I'm hearing then, Andy, so what you're saying essentially is that we're at a point now where the demand is now the bigger challenge than the technology? [00:19:56] Andy Beard: So the technology, I would say, is proven. We've seen it work. However, it's more of a systemic issue. We need to make sure that supply can meet the demand, so we need infrastructure in place. We still see there is a value gap, so we need policy to stimulate demand for the industry as a whole. [00:20:15] Speaker 2: And that's going to bring costs down? [00:20:17] Andy Beard: Yes, through scale. A key part will be synchronizing the efforts to make sure that the supply and the demand can actually meet in the middle. And that will be physically, which means infrastructure needs to be put in place. At the moment, a lot of hydrogen production is what we call over the fence. So it's basically produced very close to where it's consumed. If we want to scale this industry, we actually need to probably produce at a much larger scale and move hydrogen larger distances to a much more distributed and wider set of customers. so that infrastructure is going to be critical. At the same point, we've got that price gap or value gap that needs to be closed by policy. So infrastructure and policy certainty are going to be critical to make sure that that is targeted in a synchronized way to start stimulating a new value chain. And that value chain will build scale and that scale will then be more self-fulfilling and help generate new demand as well. [00:21:18] Speaker 2: So, I mean, you've touched upon this, but if we talk about sort of confidence and caution, where are you confident hydrogen can grow from here and where do you perhaps remain a bit more cautious? [00:21:32] Andy Beard: So, I think the industrial applications where hydrogen is used today, that is a demand pool of 100 million tons already available today. And decarbonizing that 100 million tons will have a significant impact on the emission profile. And that is demand that exists, is often supported by infrastructure that exists. So, this is where I think the effort should be focused on. Rather than trying to create new technologies and deploy those, they will be important in the future, but today, that's going to create additional hurdles and slow down the rollout and scale up. So, if we can focus on applications where we build scale today, that will immediately help then future applications become more affordable and easier to switch from one to the other. Certain applications, there may be better technologies. Take light duty vehicles as an example. Battery electric vehicles are proven today, quite cost effective. We don't see there's Shell such a strong need for fuel cell vehicles in passenger fleets. However, heavy duty, that could be a different proposition because battery electric vehicles may not fulfill the operating needs of all vehicles that could be satisfied by that. [00:22:52] Speaker 3: Given everything that you've learned with developing these projects at Shell, what would be one of the biggest misunderstanding that people have about bringing a low-carbon solution to the market? [00:23:05] Andy Beard: I think the typical mistake I've seen is just assuming scale will solve everything. So, often we've seen very, very large-scale projects proposed as a solution. but with scale comes more barriers, more complexity that needs to be overcome. And at the same time, you still need to make this industry move at a system level. So, it's going to be smaller projects building scale and building that concentration that allows things to become lower cost, more available and more reliable. So, I think focus on where you can make a difference today, focus where there is demand and through that prove that this is a viable energy source and carrier for multiple uses. [00:23:52] Speaker 2: Andy, thank you so much for joining us today. Thanks for coming in. Great to talk to you. [00:23:55] Andy Beard: Thank you very much. [00:23:58] Speaker 2: That's it for today but you can find Shell's cautionary note and references from today's show in the show notes. [00:24:04] Speaker 3: And if you enjoyed today's conversation, make sure to follow, like and subscribe to the Energy Podcast wherever you get your podcasts or watch us on YouTube. [00:24:13] Speaker 2: Next time, we'll be sitting down with Shell's CEO, Wai Al-Sawun. So, you'll want to join us for that. See you then. [00:24:20] Speaker 3: Bye-bye. [00:24:29] Speaker ?: Bye-bye.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →