‘The Five’ on birthright BRAWL...

[0:00] For the first time in U.S. history, a sitting president attended arguments in person. [0:05] It was all about the legality of his day one executive order ending birthright citizenship [0:10] for the children of illegal immigrants. [0:12] The president says the goal is stopping Americans from getting ripped off. [0:17] The reason was it had to do with the babies of slaves and the protection of the babies [0:23] of slaves. [0:24] It didn't have to do with the protection of multimillionaires and billionaires wanting [0:30] to have their children get an American citizenship. [0:34] It is the craziest thing I've ever seen. [0:36] If people are making a living, a big living, getting hundreds of thousands and even millions [0:41] of dollars from bringing people in and saying, congratulations, your whole family is going [0:47] to be a citizen of the United States of America. [0:50] That's not what it was for. [0:51] And the numbers back up the president. [0:54] Nearly one in 10 babies born in the United States in 2023 were born to unauthorized or [1:00] temporary status. [1:01] But that fact is lost on liberal freaks like this guy in a pink frog costume. [1:08] And check out this Democrat's foul mouth meltdown. [1:10] You ready? [1:11] Rep Susie Lee posting and then deleting. [1:14] It's a whole lot of F-bombs. [1:16] She's defending her comments, saying that Trump's attack on the Constitution struck [1:20] a nerve. [1:21] Dana, do you want to take on the birthright citizenship or you want to talk about Susie? [1:29] Susie, I didn't even know who she was. [1:32] Susie Lee. [1:33] No, I will. [1:34] I'll let her. [1:35] Go. [1:36] Sounds like you after a few drinks. [1:38] She's just totally irrelevant. [1:40] What is relevant is a few things here. [1:44] So for a long time leading up to this, people have been saying, people as in legal scholars, [1:50] that President Trump was likely to lose on this. [1:54] It's not that the issue isn't an important one. [1:57] It's that going about it through an executive order might be the wrong way to try to achieve [2:02] a policy goal. [2:04] Over and over again, what do we face? [2:06] Congress does just. [2:08] It communicates its responsibility, walks away, and presidents get frustrated. [2:12] And they said, we want to solve something. [2:14] So on day one, President Trump, who has thought about this issue for many years, he's run [2:18] on immigration. [2:19] He says this stops today. [2:21] And it's interesting because all of a sudden the Democrats are strict constitutionalists [2:27] and they love the originalism argument of which they have hated from Thomas and Alito, [2:34] Barrett, Kavanaugh and Roberts. [2:36] But now all of a sudden they're like, that's not what the Constitution is. [2:38] And so as somebody who I have always believed that let's stick with the Constitution, however, [2:44] I also think if there's nothing wrong with the Supreme Court saying to the Congress, [2:49] this issue should be fixed, but it's not going to work with just this executive order. [2:54] Now, maybe it'll turn out that the president wins on this one. [2:57] But this is the last point I'll make on this that I thought was so disturbing because I [3:01] don't really understand it. [3:03] Maybe somebody here is going to explain it to me. [3:05] In 2006, I was deputy press secretary. [3:08] And the average poll of how people felt about this issue was that 45 percent of Americans [3:14] thought that everyone who was born in America automatically became a U.S. citizen. [3:18] Forty five percent today, it's 69 percent think that anyone who was born in America, [3:25] even after all of these things, all these stories, people come in here just to have [3:28] their babies. [3:30] And I'm not sure where public opinion changed on this. [3:35] I could maybe take a guess, but it's gone up steadily since 2006. [3:40] If Congress were to take it on, I'm not sure how it would turn out. [3:43] Well, if you're a green card holder, Jessica, you come here, you have a baby. [3:48] That baby's an American citizen and that's fine. [3:49] What you're saying is if you're a legal alien whose allegiance is to Guatemala and he crosses [3:54] over and dumps a baby out, then all of a sudden they're a citizen and so is the mother or [3:59] a tourist from China to come in, have a baby in like American Samoa and then go back to [4:05] Beijing. [4:06] It's being abused. [4:07] You'd agree with that? [4:09] No, not completely. [4:10] I think. [4:11] I think that's abuse. [4:13] Some degree of it, yes, but the numbers and Justice Roberts, Chief Justice Roberts was [4:19] batting the government back on that particular issue, saying that you are picking a few isolated [4:24] incidents for then a sweeping judicial theory and that he wouldn't go along with it. [4:29] That's nine percent of the births are from people that aren't really American citizens. [4:36] That's not. [4:37] That's not. [4:38] But I'm saying which I'm not on the Supreme Court. [4:40] All I can do. [4:41] I'm just what I saw the exchanges were and then report them and the evidence that the [4:47] government was using, talking about birth tourism, talking about how kids of diplomats [4:52] don't get citizenship. [4:53] So why should this be different, et cetera? [4:55] Justice Roberts was poo pooing it. [4:57] That's what was happening. [4:58] Dana's are totally right about the close 70 percent of people who approve of birthright [5:03] citizenship right now. [5:05] I think you get into very sticky territory if you're talking about people who are on [5:09] even temporary visas. [5:10] If someone overstays it. [5:11] By. [5:12] A week or two. [5:13] You have people in the U.S. government right now, Marco Rubio, Cash Patel, Usha Vance. [5:17] These are people who have their citizenship because of birthright citizenship. [5:21] And you know that today didn't go well because Donald Trump's true social post once he left [5:26] was we are the only country in the world stupid enough to allow birthright citizenship. [5:30] He didn't say the government kicked butt. [5:33] He didn't say we're going to win this thing. [5:35] He said, basically, I'm throwing a temper tantrum. [5:38] And a couple. [5:39] That was a fact. [5:40] Is that not a fact? [5:41] It doesn't. [5:42] You know, it actually doesn't matter because you know how he behaves when he's excited [5:46] about something. [5:47] You know, you're focusing on emotion and not the government, the absolute second. [5:50] The government did not seem in certain exchanges to be prepared to come and talk to these justices [5:56] like Neil Gorsuch is going to ask you about Native Americans. [6:00] He always talks about Native Americans. [6:02] No response about what was going to happen there. [6:05] Justice Barrett talking about it's already been educated Native Americans. [6:08] Oh, I don't think so. [6:09] No. [6:10] Did you hear him? [6:11] No. [6:12] He responded. [6:13] I don't know. [6:14] I don't think so. [6:15] Justice Barrett. [6:16] Another time that happened. [6:17] You're ignoring some of the facts that were laid out today. [6:20] You say this is a small sliver. [6:21] False. [6:22] Go check out the data from the Government Accountability Institute, which they made [6:25] reference to today. [6:27] One million people they believe went to the Northern Mariana Islands from China and became [6:33] U.S. citizens. [6:34] There are 500 firms. [6:35] This was listed today in China that make this a cottage industry. [6:39] And. [6:40] The Chinese Communist Party into our country. [6:43] Now, what this could translate to, according to Eric Eggers, is one million new voters [6:48] by 2030. [6:49] I think we can all agree that that is a perilous state. [6:52] If you have people from China coming over, giving birth, one million new voters by 2030, [6:57] that is a big problem. [6:58] And it is inconceivable to think that the framers of the 1868 14th Amendment, that's [7:03] the year it was ratified, had an idea that 4 billion women in the world could come here, [7:08] give birth, take a plane ride. [7:09] And boom, you're a U.S. citizen. [7:11] It's inconceivable on its face. [7:13] Greg. [7:14] Yeah, you're an illegal and you come here and you have a baby that is not a citizen. [7:22] And it amazes me that by saying that you are somehow portrayed as harsh by saying something [7:31] that is so obviously sensible, that like if you it makes it as Donald Trump says and it's [7:40] so mean. [7:41] I'm going to get to that. [7:43] No other country does this. [7:45] No other country does this. [7:46] And why? [7:47] Because nobody wants to do it in those countries. [7:49] There's nobody clamoring in to try to gain the system to have babies in Haiti. [7:55] All right. [7:56] So you're saying they're all coming here. [7:59] What does that tell you? [8:00] The system is being gained. [8:02] So how did this happen when you're talking about these polls? [8:04] I don't think the polls are real, but I do think that there has been a shift due to redefining [8:09] in the last, I would say, 15 or 20 years. [8:10] Redefining the system. [8:11] Redefining common sense, patriotism as intolerant, xenophobic, but most important, mean. [8:18] If you think about every segment that we do or every position we're on, we are always [8:24] portrayed as mean. [8:26] So when you say men cannot be women, men cannot be in women's sports, you are intolerant and [8:33] you are mean. [8:34] If you say illegals need to be deported, all illegals, I think the worst first. [8:38] But in the long run, you never know who the worst is first because you let them all in. [8:41] Yes. [8:41] That is so mean. [8:44] You think this guy should go to prison? [8:46] I mean, he had a terrible upbringing. [8:48] Yes, he should go away for 25 years. [8:51] That is so mean. [8:52] Every single policy that the Democrats try to shove down your throats is based on the [8:57] fact that somehow when you take a stand to protect your country or your family, it's [9:03] somehow mean. [9:04] This is like, I really do think this is a dangerous culture. [9:07] Now, I keep thinking to myself. [9:09] What if? [9:12] What if white citizenship were gung-ho patriotic Americans who said, we need to do this and [9:18] we align it with a dedicated citizenship assimilation path? [9:24] So we have the American ideal protected, valued, cherished. [9:29] I'd be like, wow, that's pretty amazing that these people feel that way. [9:33] But the problem is the people that are pushing birthright are the people who reject American [9:38] culture, who reject assimilation. [9:41] Who embrace. [9:42] The so-called tenants of diversity and identity politics who believe that America as an idea [9:48] is not just flawed, but evil and in need of radical change. [9:53] So I don't trust. [9:54] This is why all the arguments about birthright citizens are what ifs analogies, Kenjin Jackson [10:01] Brown, my favorite artist was comparing it to getting your wallet stolen in Japan. [10:06] They cannot live in the real world where you see the incentives and you see the actual [10:11] data. [10:12] So instead they live in analogies and then they look at you and they go, you're just [10:18] mean. [10:19] And everybody said, so we have this poll that says you're just really mean for believing [10:23] this way. [10:24] I don't care. [10:25] We're right on this. [10:26] Anybody's an illegal has a baby in your country and that makes that, that baby, it's no dog. [10:34] Does justice Roberts then fall into the category? [10:36] I don't know. [10:37] He's got, I just think that also not right about everything and Supreme courts have made [10:40] decisions and so politicians that have been wrong. [10:42] Okay. [10:43] And we're left that way for a century. [10:46] I can think of a couple of them, Jessica, that were then overturned, but we let Congress [10:50] off the hook over and over again. [10:52] Britain did have birthright citizenship in the late 1800s. [10:55] They changed it by law. [10:57] You can do something without an executive order. [11:00] That's going to fail in the Supreme court. [11:02] It just takes a little gumption. [11:04] Gumption. [11:05] Watch your mouth. [11:06] You and Susie. [11:07] Wow. [11:08] Gumption. [11:10] Be sure to like, and subscribe for all the Fox news latest on YouTube and catch up with [11:11] us. [11:12] We'll see you next time. [11:13] Bye. [11:14] Bye. [11:15] Bye. [11:16] Bye. [11:17] Bye.