Try Free

Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons

FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul November 21, 2026 59m 8,297 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons from FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul, published November 21, 2026. The transcript contains 8,297 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"please stand by while the recording is started and the time is now 10 34 a.m our next case will be case 34 susan smith case 34 susan smith and she'll be represented by attorney thomas please stand by while they both are brought into the room and i have a letter i need to put on the record okay and..."

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: please stand by while the recording is started and the time is now 10 34 a.m our next case will be case 34 susan smith case 34 susan smith and she'll be represented by attorney thomas please stand by while they both are brought into the room and i have a letter i need to put on the record okay and she also has supporters please stand by all right may i put the letter on the [00:00:29] Speaker 2: record now yes ma'am go right here all right and this is a letter addressed to the board please be advised that i will recuse myself in the hearing of susan smith number two two one four eight seven i was acting warden at camille graham correctional center in 1999 where inmate smith was housed and subsequently transferred to leave correctional institution i have determined that it is appropriate to recuse to eliminate any appearance of affecting her opportunity for parole respectfully geraldine pete mirro miss mirro thank you for the letter and if you will please leave the room and for the record miss mirro has left the room thank you and please stand by while all parties [00:01:17] Speaker 1: good morning good morning good morning at our support site are you all here in support of susan smith we are thank you and attorney thomas are you able to see and hear us yes ma'am i am thank you and at leaf ma'am are you miss susan smith yes ma'am thank you you all before the board please wait for the chance to address you [00:01:47] Speaker 2: good morning miss smith and good morning attorney thomas good morning to the supporters there at watkins we thank all of you for appearing before us this morning and miss smith i wanted you to know that your attorney submitted a very extensive packet of information for us to review prior to this hearing and uh we also received this morning as a matter of fact um a report from psychiatrist uh jessica hill um we received the letters that you sent in from michael achie and mattella jacobs and sherry week so we reviewed all of that information prior to this hearing attorney thomas did you want to proceed first sir [00:02:26] Speaker 3: uh yes ma'am if i could and also um just housekeeping um dr hill is here with me and um i'm going to go first and then dr hill and i just wanted to let the board know what i'm going to do is just move my computer uh so she'll be on the screen all right thank you sir and as i [00:02:45] Speaker 4: stated before we have read her report yes ma'am thank you go ahead um good morning um i'm representing susan smith susan of course was convicted of murder uh she has served approximately 32 years and she was [00:03:00] Speaker 3: sentenced to life imprisonment with possibility of parole and that's kind of why we're here today i think it's extremely important and i'll apologize um just to get through the information it will not be extremely lengthy but it will take just a a little bit longer than my normal presentation um one of the goals that i've spent quite a bit of time with susan talking about this is she is she of course would like for the board to consider her for for release on parole um one of the other main factors is to help other mothers who may be struggling with depression and some of the things that was going on in her life at the time and she said if i can make a difference then um this hearing and everything has been well worthwhile because she certainly doesn't want anyone to uh get involved in a crime such as hers um this whole situation in the uh is all about mental health uh the damages um the lack of treatment uh old stigmas about someone who would reach out for mental health counseling and um since she's been in the department of corrections she has worked hard to kind of distinguish herself and to help herself in regards to uh eventually prepare for parole and prepare for release she has no prior record um she would be staying at sotera house um they have um an opportunity or they have a program which is 24 um or 12 months inpatient program for folks who are being uh released uh and going back in the communities in south carolina they do a wonderful job and that's where she would be uh housed she'd be in their program and she would also um they would find employment for her we have uh through dr hill uh established uh outpatient uh services for her and dr hill can speak more about that but um that is the plan for her release she is um been in all of the programs that have been available for her and um they include seven habits uh beyond abuse um self-harmer's group jump start uh endovo and uh cipherworks uh loss and grief uh self-esteem anger management and it just kind of goes on and on and on um the thing that i think that's important to susan and and one of the things that has been kind of a uh misperception in regards to this crime is that um it's not really not about um the love of another man i know that's um been in the media for for years and i think she feels very strongly about that was not what was going on david brock who represented her he and i have talked about that at length and he said that that was came up at trial but it was never approved and um the um some of the things that you know that were going on are all mental health related you know multiple stress points uh converged i think all at the same time and that night um suicidal or father at age six um lack of recognition and treatment of mental health issues she was hospitalized um as a young child and you know just the stigma that existed back then that i think hopefully doesn't exist today um was said oh well you know she's in the hospital for um strep infection or something like that it just never was spoken about in public and um a lot of these things just converse in a perfect storm and this is not an excuse this is just mainly an attempt to kind of identify um as to what was going on if i may i've got a very short thing that that she um sent to me that i think is important to read um and it's not very long she said that i believe um this is what happened to me on october 25th of 94. i lost touch with reality my thoughts were not uh rational uh neurologic i didn't uh think i understood that i allowed this car to go into the lake um that she didn't understand that there was she would never see her children again she didn't understand the finality of what was uh going on she said my thoughts were so screwed up at the time in my mind i thought it was doing um what was best for my children because i believed that jesus could take better care of them than i could um and then she says you know what happened and looking back and was that it was all senseless the whole thought process was just senseless and i think i have represented her for four plus years and what i have seen um with susan smith is a struggle an ongoing struggle um to basically try to get away from the guilt um i think she is extremely remorseful um i think that um she never would have done this had the things that were going on in her life not been present and um it is something that she will bear that burden forever uh with her but um a lot of times you know i've seen clients who maybe their uh remorse was was was doubtful but it's not with susan uh she is extremely remorseful and and works hard to try to maybe obtain some sort of degree of forgiveness um i don't know if she thinks that she can ever get there um but um but she certainly does try um she has uh done everything that she can in the department corrections as we're talking about she's uh a lot of programs uh she's been very uh involved and she says it's very important with prison fellowship she's stronger in her faith uh jumpstart um she um gives back through arts and crafts uh hobby craft and that um she donates a lot of those items to charity uh again she's trying to maybe make things better for some folks other than her situation she said that if she was parole she would like to stand on her own two feet um she has learned not to be influenced by others she has to be her own person um she'd like to live a better life um think before acting um other people are affected by her decisions and what she does and um especially the importance of mental health um the um she said that her goals and we talked about that what would she like to do uh with the rest of her life as she was um released and she said she'd like to give back uh and try to help others of course um that um help others to understand the importance of mental health and just how um not to be ashamed and it's not something that should be uh kept hidden it's something that you need to have to reach out and address live a quiet life she welcomes supervision if granted parole um she is very active uh with uh dogs and cats and some of those programs that she's been able to do within the department of corrections um she um i think that she is in a in a good situation in regards to her preparedness for release um she said that she'd like to she'd like to make the decision that her life maybe means something and um she would really would ask that if you would please consider her for parole uh at this point i'd like to turn this over to dr jessica hill she's a forensic psychiatrist i think she has done an excellent job one of the things that i have always talked to susan about that she and i have discussed is how could something like this happen you know what's going on um and the pain that's been involved in this and the pain for everyone that's been involved um i think dr hill has done a wonderful job and that uh for me uh i think she comes the closest to explaining uh how this could happen uh and not uh as an excuse by any means but just as an understanding so maybe um as susan wishes that this doesn't happen to somebody else i know i've been lengthy and i really appreciate the time and i'm going to turn it over on to dr hill thank you attorney thomas dr hill hi good morning my name is dr jesse hill and as attorney thomas said i'm a forensic psychiatrist [00:12:22] Speaker 5: i had the opportunity to sit with susan on three occasions over the past three months for about a cumulative six hours the focus of that really was a lot of focus on her childhood experiences that shaped her foundation and how she went on navigate life and experiences and navigate relationships and we also spent quite a bit of time focusing on how some of those patterns continued into her incarceration uh some of the struggles that she experienced early on and then why we think things have gotten much better for her over the last 10 years and what some of the reasons are behind her her shift in trajectory um for the past 10 years regarding her childhood the most i think the most critical thing to highlight um is the what started with the loss of her father by suicide at age six uh they were very had she described a very close loving relationship her brother described that when they saw each other their eyes would light up losing her dad to suicide was devastating it left a tremendous void um and a feeling of abandonment a longing for paternal love affection and connection and really set the stage for her to be preyed upon by her stepfather when her mother remarried two years later uh the abuse started uh first quietly kind of as susan has a statue a little bit but it eventually progressed and by early adolescence 12 13 it became a sexualized engaged relationship with her stepfather who was also a prominent political figure it turned into what i would best describe as a love triangle between her stepfather her mother and her and i use the term love triangle because it that is the most accurate representation of how she described how her mother would speak to her kind of accuse her of going after her husband but then at times would be very maternal and really had two separate roles in her life she navigated this triangulation for the better part of a decade day in and day out in her home during what is definitively the most critical years for interpersonal development learning learning um learning boundaries learning what healthy connections are um learning how to interact uh through complex char emotionally charged situations this was her reality and how she came to understand love relationships intimacy and motherhood uh so no surprise she went on to develop borderline personality disorder which is a common sequelae of childhood abuse and trauma borderline personality disorder is hallmarked by extreme emotional ability uh feelings of um emptiness and trying to fill that emptiness often with with uh intimacy um poor boundaries sexually and personally and then a lot of times just extreme internal chaos uh that people will try to dispel through self-harm and often suicidality and in combination with the borderline personality disorder was some extreme depression bouts of depression um particularly in the wake of her children's birth um in the years that followed and um i there is definitively a hormonal component to her depression which was reflected in the jail record prison records um worsening depression around her cycle um or her most severe suicide most potentially lethal suicide attempt came in the throes of perimenopause so there was a hormonal component for susan uh depression got worse after the birth of her children a stronger pull towards suicide and a really fundamental belief that the world was not safe and it was not safe for her children and that was really the foundation of her existence in early adulthood after her arrest she had 20 years of difficulty with numerous infractions poor boundaries within relationships continued all of those hallmarks of borderline personality disorder continued for 20 the first 20 years and that's reflected in multiple medication changes bouncing between jobs dozens of infractions none were criminal none were assaulted but all just reflected poor boundaries poor judgment impulsivity uh poor decision making um and then really something changed around 2015 um there was a definite change and and i really wanted to understand i really wanted to try to understand what the factors were that prompted that change and i identified many first um was that um i think age is a part of it uh we understand just in longitudinally following individuals with borderline personality disorder that into after really after 45 there's a pretty big drop off in symptoms of the of the disorder um so into the late 40s and 50s borderline personality disorder gets better a lot of individuals mature out of these behaviors and ways of functioning and that parallels susan's improvement as well also 2014 was the first time she was ever put on a mood stabilizer class of medications that can be helpful in borderline personality disorder and they can help with treatment resistant depression depression that it persists beyond our bread and butter antidepressants and this is the first time that she said to my knowledge that she was ever put on it she was put on topamax and she's been on topamax ever since um so i think it was an effect has been an effective medication for her that was started in 2014. and then we had the death of her stepfather which she grieved um the the poor sexual boundaries and intimacy between them continued into her incarceration years into her incarceration so his death allowed her to start to move on from that very toxic um relationship that had a hold on her and then the death of her mother also allowed her to start to put things to rest that continued to swirl within that triangulation um 2023 she went through menopause um which this is something that actually kind of occurred to me late in my assessment uh was the hormonal the apparent hormonal component that was popping up in the records um surrounding her menstrual cycle and this uh suicide attempt in february of 2023 i i reached out to her you know when when did you go through menopause september of 2023 so there is clearly a trajectory of improvement um a peak around perimenopause and menopause and then some improvement in overall um stability reduced mood mood lability that often comes after menopause is officially complete and then finally um she would say the thing that has resulted in the the strongest the best reason for her improvement and her brother would say as well is um a real a shift in her relationship with with god and her faith from one of anger and resentment towards um towards forgiveness and unconditional love and that would be what she would identify and that really has been prevalent for her and her actions and her words and her choices over the last about 18 months [00:20:12] Speaker 2: thank you miss smith we've been given a lot of information here but prior to the hearing that we reviewed and also from your attorney and dr hill what would you like to add ma'am [00:20:27] Speaker 6: um well first of all um i know that what i did to michael house was horrible and i have a lot of i have a lot of remorse and um i want to say that i'm very very sorry i want to say i'm sorry to michael napkins they were innocent children they did not deserve to die and i've dropped to my lowest when um i let that car go into that lake and i want to say that david and all the people that love michael napkins knew them that i'm sorry i know i caused them in unbearable pain and i know that david didn't get to see michael napkins grow up he didn't get to see him ride a bike go to school and i'm really really sorry for that and i would go back and change all of that if i could i would but i can't um i'm not the same person i was 32 years ago i have changed i have grown up i have matured and i really do want to go out there and change and help people and and make a difference and help this to keep it from happening to other people and i do want to say like tommy said that um this is this did not happen because of a man that is just not true i don't know i know people believe that for a long time but it's not true i would never have hurt michael and alice for that reason um i want to live if released i want to live my life to please god and to honor the memory of michael and alice i just want to do good and i just want to give back and help other people [00:22:50] Speaker 2: and give them a chance well thank you for that miss me and we do want to commend you it appears you've been disciplining debris since uh your last hearing we want to commend you for that is there anything further before i speak to your supporters yeah ma'am okay thank you again to the supporters there at potkins i need for you to state your name for the record and tell us your relationship to miss [00:23:13] Speaker 7: smith ma'am we'll start with you on the end okay my name is cindy stone i was actually a sergeant at leave correctional institution and i knew susan from 2001 of march of 2001 until i retired in june of 2016. 2016. we continue to be in touch i consider sue to be somebody that is a friend of mine and i want the opportunity if i may to let y'all know about the real person and not just what the media and the rumors want to portray we'll go ahead you let me know when i'll go ahead okay thank you all right um like i said i met her uh in march of 2001 i had just come back from maternity lease and had had had my son so he was two months old i came back and soon lived on my building uh my initial response was uh this isn't gonna work she's gonna have to go i did not want to know her i did not want to have to deal with her because all i knew was what had been in the media and on the news but the time that i 15 years that i spent um working there five days a week she lived on my unit multiple times uh she worked for me as a dorm worker multiple times um i got to know her very well she spoke to me she had a deep trust in me and trusted me with her life stories and as an encourager and a type of a mentor i believe sue has just helped so many of the women out there that leave and people talk about that she's you know it's just selfish and just in there having a good time and that's just not true sue has made it a point to direct people that she's met um to these women who are indigent who don't have family support um she has directed people to become friends with these other women and to help them to give them some support that they never had while they were incarcerated um i have known sue through her struggles there. She is absolutely remorseful, guilt-ridden, and regardless of where Sue is, and she will carry a sort of a prison with her because she is trying very hard to forgive herself and for the pain that she caused everybody, and she loves those boys, and it was not because she didn't love them that this happened. I know that Sue has spent all these years just creating pain, inflicting pain on herself in an attempt to atone for the pain that she's caused, through her suicide attempts and, you know, just self-harming and things. A lot of things that I was going to say the doctors already said, but, you know, she is a lot more than the rumors and the lies and the stories that are told about her, the, you know, from the, oh, she had a baby in prison, which is not true, to, you know, she's just having a big time and partying it up in prison, and that's not true either. She has really worked hard to become a better person, and there are many women in there who are in better positions because of her and because of her friendship and her caring and stuff. Um, I really hope that y'all can see her as a three dimensional person instead of the one dimensional person that the media portrays. Thank you, Mr. Thank you so much. Thank you. We thank you [00:27:49] Speaker 2: for your service at the Department of Corrections. And the gentleman in the middle, sir, your name in [00:27:55] Speaker 8: relationship. Scottie Vaughn and I'm her brother. Yes, sir. Mr. Vaughn, would you like to make a statement? Well, most of what I was going to say has already been said, but I would like to make a couple of points. Um, I think the loss of our father when Susan was six years old had a profound and lasting effect on her. Um, don't know how our mother may have explained to her that she would never see him again. I don't I wasn't a part of that. Um, I know how devastated I was when our father took his life. Um, he and Susan were very close. Uh, their eyes would just light up when they saw each other when he had come to pick her up on the weekend. So I think that loss had a major and lasting effect. Uh, and as it's, as, um, been said before, Susan has matured a lot. Her faith has strengthened and I think she has a true desire to help others avoid the situation that she found herself in. Um, and I'll close by saying this. Her brother and I, uh, our brother Michael. He doesn't talk much. He'll tell you his name, but he, uh, we could sure use her helping home too. Uh, she will definitely. We will provide a home in whatever she needs. Uh, and she'll be able to help us as well. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Vaughan and thank you for being here to support [00:29:56] Speaker 2: your sister. And, uh, uh, your sister. Yes, ma'am. And did you want to make a statement? No. Okay. Well, thank you for being here to support your sister. Um, all of you. Um, attorney Thomas, says anything in closing, sir. Mr. Thomas, you're muted. [00:30:27] Speaker 3: All right. One thing that I have forgotten to mention, Susan sent me a letter which we provided for the parole board and it's called Dear Suicide. Very difficult to read. I agonized over it as to whether to send it to the board or not and decided to send it. It's painful. The reason I said it is that it takes us through a journey from the past to her growth and changes in where she is today. So I thought it was important. I just wanted to bring that to the attention of the board. I do think it gives a good kind of indication of where she is as far as parole ability and I just again want to thank you for your time. [00:31:13] Speaker 2: Okay. Yes, sir. We did review that letter. Well, again, thank you. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Again, thank all of you for appearing before us today. This hearing is concluded. [00:31:24] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you. Please stand by. Waterfront clears. And the room is clear. There'll be additional testimony facilitated by the Office of Victim Services. And the room is clear. There'll be additional testimony facilitated by the Office of Victim Services. [00:31:59] Speaker 9: Board members. We had 10,845 petition statements from concerned citizen opposing the parole. And also we have victims at central office. Thank you. [00:32:29] Speaker 1: Board members. Good morning. [00:32:44] Speaker 2: We want to first thank all of you for appearing before us this morning. It's important to this board to see the faces and hear the voices of victims. They're really no words. We can only imagine how extremely difficult this is. But again, we appreciate so much all of you being here today. What I need you to do is state your name for the record as you did two years ago and tell us your relationship to this case. And if you have a brief statement to make, we will entertain that too. Mr. Smith, may we start with you, sir? [00:33:23] Speaker 10: Can I stand up? [00:33:24] Speaker 2: No, you just stay seated if you're more comfortable with whatever you're more comfortable with. [00:33:29] Speaker 10: I'd rather stand. Mr. Smith, I'm David Smith, Michael and Alex's dad. I realize it's been 32 years since I hadn't buried Michael and Alex. And I know to some of you that 32 years is a long time. But for me, it's yesterday. It's been a hard road. Very difficult road. But I'm here to advocate for Michael and Alex, not for me. So even though it's been 32 years, that doesn't take away what she did to Michael and Alex. She took away one of the greatest gifts that God gives us in this life. She did that deliberately. It wasn't an accident. It wasn't a bad mistake. She did it deliberately. And I know in my heart, granting her parole would be a huge injustice to Michael and Alex. So I'm just here to ask you all to look in your heart and see their father's pain and his still broken heart. and ask your heart is 32 years enough for what she did to Michael and Alex. And I said, you please don't grab her parole. [00:35:54] Speaker 2: Thank you, Mr. Smith. Ms. Smith. [00:36:03] Speaker 11: Good morning. My name is Tiffany Smith. I have been married to David for 23 years. We've been together for 32. So I got to know Michael and Alex for a brief moment. I may not have had as many years with Michael and Alex as I wish I had. But I have spent more than three decades witnessing the impact their loss has had on their father and our family. When I spoke to you previously in 2024, I talked about all the things Michael and Alex would never get to experience. The birthdays, graduations, growing up, and the milestones that most of us take for granted. Today, I want to talk about the passage of time that has not changed. It has been more than 32 years, but the loss of Michael and Alex has never gone away. I have watched David live with the loss of his sons for all these years. And one of the hardest things for me has been knowing that there will always be a part of him missing. He can laugh, he can enjoy life, and he can have a good time, have good days. But there is an emptiness that never goes away. There are two sons who should still be here. Two sons he should have had the opportunity to watch grow into young men. No amount of time can give him that back. For David, this isn't something that happened 32 years ago and is now in the past. He is still their father. He still misses his boys, and nothing will ever change that. So every time we must come before this board, it forces us to reopen wounds that never really healed. We must revisit the worst tragedy of our lives, and once again ask that the person responsible remain in prison. I understand that Susan has spent many years incarcerated, but I ask you to remember that Michael and Alex were sentenced to a lifetime they never got to live. They didn't get a second chance. They didn't get to grow older. They didn't get to make their own choices or decide what their futures would look like. She chose their faith the night of October 25, 1994. So why should she be given the opportunity to walk free when her sons were never given the opportunity to live? The years that have passed do not lessen the severity of what she did, and they certainly do not lessen the impact it continues to have on the people who love this voice. We must live each day of our lives without them, a decision Susan made for us, too. I am asking you to think about Michael and Alex. Think about the lives they should have had. Think about their father who has had to carry that loss every single day. So please deny Susan Smith parole. Michael and Alex deserved a lifetime. They never got one. Please don't give the person responsible for taking their lives the freedom they were never given. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Smith. [00:39:20] Speaker 12: I'm Savannah Smith. I am David and Tiffany's daughter. I'm 25 years old, and as all of us here today know, Michael and Alex were taken 32 years ago. And while I never met them, I've always felt their presence with me. I have spent my whole life seeing how the loss of Michael and Alex has affected everyone in my family. And as a little girl, I knew I had two brothers that were no longer with us. And my parents would tell me just enough [00:40:13] Speaker ?: just enough [00:40:13] Speaker 12: to satiate my curiosity at the time until I was old enough to understand the depth of the tragedy. Since we were last here in 2024, my life has changed so much. And all of these changes make me realize that Michael and Alex should be able to experience [00:40:37] Speaker ?: to experience [00:40:37] Speaker 12: these for themselves. They never got the chance to grow into the amazing men that I know they would have been. And as I get older, the same curiosity remains. How could someone harm become a child and especially their own? I ask that Susan remain incarcerated. While the pain she caused has been felt by so many, Michael and Alex are not here to receive a second chance. I do believe that they watch over my family and I, but that does not ease the pain that they should be here alongside us for birthdays, holidays, and every life event in between, no matter how big or how small. Susan decided Michael and Alex's fate as well as part of my daddy's and as well as part of mine and part of my family's that night in October, 32 years ago, I do not believe that she should be able to walk freely after affecting so many lives and creating a void in so many hearts that cannot be filled. I ask one final time please deny any requests for parole from Susan Smith. Thank you. my name is [00:42:22] Speaker 13: Rebecca Smith French and I'm the aunt of Michael and Alex. It's been two years since we came for the parole board and asked that Susan's request for parole be denied and in that two years it was I can't tell you the sense of peace we had or I had I know that she was going to stay behind bars paying for what she did to Michael and Alex. It was just such a sense of peace because I can't even fathom the thought of her not being there and being walking free because they don't get to do that. Those boys will never get to live their lives they'll never get to experience growing up and being able to sorry to be children to be young adults to have their own children David they just they will never she took that from all of us and while when you grinned denied her her role I for once felt such peace I can't imagine what David felt [00:43:55] Speaker 10: then we [00:43:58] Speaker 13: come up and it's time again and it's like that band-aid gets ripped off and the thought of seeing her walking free and knowing they're not they're not there she was sentenced to life and that's all I'm asking is that she serve her sentence she said she's sorry if she's sorry then serve your life sentence that's how you show you're sorry don't ask for parole serve your life sentence thank you [00:44:41] Speaker 2: thanks [00:44:45] Speaker 14: sir my name is Tommy Pope I was a solicitor of the 16th circuit back when this occurred and I will share with you one thing David Smith was my rock during trying this case in my office trying this case and one thing I've seen and it's the nature of our law but in some ways I think today is harder than the trial was as I look at this family and you know we were here two years ago and what I see and so I just want to echo a few things I said to you before one in 1995 when I tried the case was the last year that life did not mean life in a circumstance like this as you guys well know 96 the legislature changed it but the jury thought that it was life they actually asked the question and came back and back then you had to tell them take life and death and it's plain and usual meaning so I heard some jurors speak afterwards and they said basically that they thought this was a greater punishment because Susan would go to prison and be remorseful and think about Michael and Alex well I want to bring side by side with the crime that was committed here there's really a second crime and it's based as David said Susan made the choice out of selfishness she really thought she could start her life over with someone else by getting rid of these children and so there's a selfish component there too that's almost a separate crime if any of you recall nine days begging for the return of the children putting him through what she put him through what she put the country through the deception in some sad is almost as horrible as a crime so it brings us to now and Susan getting paroled Susan has always been focused on Susan if you look at her conduct and I'm not saying I've had cases where the inmate had killed somebody in prison and I know we're not dealing with that but what we are dealing with is she is not focused on Michael and Alex she is focused on herself and my biggest fear and I have not shared this with them I remember one time David told me he said you know she got out and I saw her in the grocery store I just don't believe I can handle it well he's probably not going to see her in the grocery store she gets out you know where he's going to see her on his phone on his media Susan relished if you remember back then she relished the media attention and I submit nothing's changed in that regard and my biggest fear much like you saw a couple years ago with Casey Anthony who was not convicted but wants to now be an influencer if you think his family's been through hell now imagine every day if you pick up your phone or you turn on your computer and there's Susan talking about that because you know the letters have been written there are people out there that idolize Susan there are people that want to be with Susan that's how upside down this country has become and so I remember last time David said look at Michael and Alex and think it's 15 years enough I say life is not enough but I can promise you 16 years per child is not enough and I am just as afraid of Susan's conduct and how it's going to affect this family if she ever got out you know she tried an opportunity to have social media over the years you know from the prison having friends and she just needs as you just heard she needs to stay where she's at and I'm in the legislature I don't know if this is possible but if there's a chance that we don't have to come in two years that we can come in three or four or five you remember it used to be one I'm gonna do everything possible to do that because the hell they live through now is just an amplification you heard tearing the band-aid off it's opening a wound and at some point I look at David today and no disrespect he Kevin and Celestia Brackett and I were talking this is weighing on David more than two years ago even I see it I see it and every year it's gonna be worse and so I respect the job you have to do I thank you for your time she needs to remain there for the rest of her life and try to give this family some peace and Michael and Alex some justice thank [00:49:11] Speaker 2: you thank [00:49:11] Speaker 14: you and next [00:49:13] Speaker 2: sir good [00:49:16] Speaker 15: morning Kevin Brackett I'm the current solicitor for the sixteenth circuit and prior to the job I'm in now I was this man's deputy solicitor for many years and I worked on this case with him I was on the side of the lake when they pulled the car out I was in the preparation and talking to witnesses including David I was in the courtroom and listened as he testified in some of the most gut-wrenching testimony I have heard in my 35 years and I will tell you that sitting back there now with him before this hearing has been just as devastating it has not changed one bit 32 years later this man is still a ball of grief and it's horrible that he should have to go through this it's not your fault I'm just making an observation and I hope the law can be changed I have a few points I want to make in no particular order first to dovetail on what Speaker Pro Temp Pope just said I want to remind the board that prior to the last parole hearing she was in communication with somebody from the media who was putting money into her Cooper Trust account in anticipation and specifically said do not do anything until after my parole hearing in anticipation of hopefully getting released she was in discussions with media people to sell her story already and talking to them about maybe I can tell you the things that nobody else knows about what happened that day so Mr. Pope is absolutely right she will monetize this crime if she's released she will attempt to capitalize on her fame as you know people do now using Facebook and social media and she will be out there selling the story of Susan Smith and trying to capitalize on the terrible terrible things she did and that must never ever be allowed to happen that is absolutely it would be an appalling appalling affront to this man and what he's been through it must never be allowed to happen Michael and Alex you've heard and I will not try to improve on their eloquence but I do want to call to your minds today to the other people who were victimized all the people in union the men and women who worked so hard for that eight days beating the bushes looking for these children trying to find them police officers all over the country following up on countless reports they had an FBI task force set up there were reports coming in from as far away as Washington state about where this car could be found all of those people who exhausted themselves trying desperately to find these two little boys they were victims the divers who had to go into the lake and swim down to that car after the truth was revealed and had to peer in there with their flashlights and see the horror they were victims all the men the black men who were pulled because of the story she made up about who took these boys every single one of those men they were victims David asked me a really good question while we were waiting and I never really thought about it he said why Michael and Alex so many children are killed by their parents why is this story capture the imagination even 32 years later why is it gathering so much attention and I thought about it and it occurred to me because I hadn't thought about it before but really that's Susan's fault because the lie she told gave eight days for this country to fall in love with Michael Alex they saw pictures videos of them in life and America felt love and then when the truth was repeated it was so horrifying and so shocking because they weren't just his kids anymore they were powerful kids she inflicted grief and damage on everybody who followed this case and fell in love with their case and for their sake too she must never be allowed out of prison thank [00:53:55] Speaker 2: you so Mr Brackett Miss Hudson [00:53:58] Speaker 16: hello I'm Jeff Bailey I'm sheriff of Union County and I'm here today to offer support to the Smith family in 1994 Union County and the Smith family experienced heartbreak and that's exactly what it was and for nine days you know we searched we prayed we had hope we had our hope that we could find those boys I was a probation agent at the time and so we were doing everything we could to find them but just to find out later on that the person who's supposed to be protecting their children actually took their lives and that's a sad thing and so I just I really opposed her receiving parole because like I said she's gonna do what she needs to do to make her life better and her life is just fine where she's at and I hope she can continue to stay there so I just want the board to know we should give her the same consideration that she gave Michael and Alex that night and that was little to none and so that's what that's what consideration she deserves thank you thank you thank you for your service [00:55:05] Speaker 2: next do we have someone allowed to go next [00:55:10] Speaker 17: my name is Scott Coe I'm Chief Devin Sheriff's Office I'm just gonna re-enter a few things so on October 25th 1994 Susan Smith put her two young sons Michael and Alex into their car seats and allowed them to roll into John D. Lone Lake and Union County rather than immediately tell the truth Smith claimed that a black man had carjacked the vehicle and kidnapped her children for nine days law enforcement officers investigators concerned citizens searched for the boys while the nation followed the story in July of 95 Smith was convicted of two counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years I firmly believe Susan Smith should remain in prison for the rest of her life it's not about revenge it's about accountability justice remembering two children that never have opportunity to grow up Michael and Alex depended on their mother to protect them love them and keep them safe instead the person entrusted with their lives became responsible for taking them I recognize people can change and the passes of time can bring opportunities for reflection a life sentence must carry meaning an opportunity to seek parole does not mean that the release is deserved our presence matters when we attend these hearings we demonstrate that Michael and Alex have not been forgotten we remind the parole board that these were not simply names in a criminal case or headlines in the newspaper they were two little boys with futures personalities families and lives that were taken from them we cannot bring Michael and Alex back we cannot undo what happened in October of 94 but I believe that we continue to speak for them when they didn't have a chance to speak for themselves Michael and Alex deserve a lifetime of love protection and opportunity they were denied that lifetime the least we can do is ensure that their lives and memory were never forgotten our stance for the Union County Sheriff's Office Sheriff Bailey is key very good thank you [00:57:12] Speaker 2: thank you for your statement and thank you for your service would anyone else like to make a statement this morning we do need to put your names on the record sir with the bowtie your name please sir [00:57:27] Speaker 14: I'm Thomas Jefferson the war with the third thank you sir I'm Mark [00:57:33] Speaker 16: Reynolds I'm a friend of the family and I'm Rebecca's partner Michael [00:57:38] Speaker 8: Cogdall I'm a friend of the family [00:57:39] Speaker 17: Laura Hudson and I'm with the South Carolina Victims Assistance Network thank you [00:57:44] Speaker 2: for all the work that you do again we thank all of you for being here today and I just have to say on behalf of the board that we're so very sorry that the law is such that you have to endure this every two years they're just no words we're so very sorry that this family and friends and the whole nation experienced this tragedy but again we thank you so much for being here as difficult as it is thank you so much this hearing has concluded [00:58:20] Speaker 11: thank you [00:58:35] Speaker 5: the room is clear [00:58:52] Speaker 2: Susan Smith will be denied parole the vote is unanimous one two [00:59:13] Speaker 1: thank you and with that we will go ahead and pause the recording for our 30 minute lunch break please stand by as the recording has been paused

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →