Try Free

Politicians tell us green energy is cheaper. These are the facts — Bjorn Lomborg

The Andrew Neil Report November 19, 2026 10m 1,851 words 3 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Politicians tell us green energy is cheaper. These are the facts — Bjorn Lomborg from The Andrew Neil Report, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 1,851 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"people constantly will tell you is the cheapest source of energy solar and wind but they never tell you if you disregard all the other costs we've seen the way america now leaves europe behind in the dust because it's got cheap energy and european energy is very expensive and yet we're constantly..."

[00:00:00] Andrew: people constantly will tell you is the cheapest source of energy solar and wind but they never tell you if you disregard all the other costs we've seen the way america now leaves europe [00:00:19] Speaker 2: behind in the dust because it's got cheap energy and european energy is very expensive and yet we're constantly told by politicians and it happened again in britain this week that the more we move to renewables the cheaper energy becomes as a government minister appeared on british broadcasting this week they're talking about there's a new there was a they tried to make it a new announcement but actually it was announced in january of this year is yet another offshore wind farm uh north of east and west uh is being built by rwe financed by kkr so it's big green and big uh commercialism uh together they got a guaranteed strike price as they do to do this so there's a massive subsidy in it that even that wasn't enough and what the government was really announcing this week was another billion from the so-called national wealth fund which isn't a national wealth fund but that's for another day uh to sweeten the deal uh another billion essentially of taxpayers uh money so it strikes me that if if renewables were going to lead lead to cheaper energy if they could produce more cheaply why does it keep on needing subsidies and taxpayers money and that's the very good [00:01:36] Andrew: question of course it shows you that this is to a very large extent a mirage so the idea is to say solar and wind and you hear this all the time is the cheapest energy you can possibly get but of course what they never tell you is when the sun is shining or when the wind is blowing that's potentially true it's not true everywhere but it's true in a lot of places when the sun is shining it's incredibly cheap when the wind is blowing it's incredibly cheap but remember when it's not it's incredibly expensive it's actually infinitely expensive and people you will sort of uh blindly say oh we should just have batteries or something remember the uk have batteries for less than half an hour of its electricity grid right now you need batteries for about a month or three months depending a little bit on how much you uh you think you're going to run out uh and and the honest answer is that will cost the uk every year because remember you have to replace these batteries every 10 15 years that will cost you between 10 and 15 15 of gdp every year this is just not affordable so i've i've made another graph that i think you'll love and i'll send it to you then maybe you can also share that but it's one that nobody's done but i and i kind of know why uh but it's very very interesting so if you take the official numbers from the international energy agency we can find numbers for about a hundred countries around the world of how much do their electricity cost so this is both for households and for industry and then we weigh them so it's the you know the way that if you use for a lot for industry uh the industry uh counts more more so it's essentially how much did the country pay per kilowatt hour and then out of the x-axis i show how much of your energy do you get from solar and wind and up the y-axis you see how much do your electricity cost and what you see is as you get more and more solar and wind you get more and more expensive energy and this is true for a hundred countries what is phenomenal is there's not one country in the world that has a lot of solar and wind and cheap electricity so again there's a lot of conversations that you can have oh it could both get cheaper it could get more expensive but the empirical facts and this is data from 2025 but we also have it from back before is that no when you get more in solar and wind you end up with more expensive energy because you have to pay for those extra backups remember it's a little bit like you know if if you think about it if if i told you andrew you could have this incredibly cheap electric solar powered car you'd be sort of like oh maybe i'll buy that until i tell you oh but here's one thing it'll only drive when the sun is out so you know if there's a cloud or if it's dark or something you won't have so what you suddenly realize is oh i have to have two cars of course i'll save the fuel in the daytime when the sun is shining but suddenly i have to invest in two full cars and that almost inevitably ends up being a lot more expensive outfit and that's the problem that we're in right now we both have to pay for the unreliable main grid that we're now having and the reliable backup that we don't use very often but we still have to pay for all of it you see i just feel we're [00:05:09] Speaker 2: now just gaslighted or on an industrial scale by by politicians who who are the net zero zealots and and supporters because when they say that renewable power is cheap and the wind power could be the cheapest of all but though sometimes they're out of solar but taking the wind power particularly offshore wind what they're talking about is is the marginal cost of of wind when the when when the wind is blowing and the and the the turbines are turning the marginal cost of that electricity is very slight but that that's not the cost that's just the marginal cost that is doesn't include the capital cost of building these windmills and the last time i looked rwde and siemens and so on they're not charities they put billions in they expect a return on their capital in investment it doesn't include the cost of having to upgrade the grid which as i explained at the beginning we don't have a grid that's fit for purpose for renewables that's another multi-billion pound investment then we have to build the grid to where that energy is coming on shore because we don't have a grid in a lot of these remote parts in the north of scotland or even on the on the norfolk coast and then the point you've alluded to there is then the cost at the moment it's it's backup gas we keep gas-fired electricity stations ticking over to click in when we get what do you call their dunkel flaut or so the germany yeah yeah that's the i knew you would know the proper words uh and or even when the wind just or actually funny enough when the wind is blowing too much and they have to close the wind power down and we fire up the gas power station so we're actually paying the wind people uh not to generate electricity and then we pay the gas people to fire up their generating stations to provide us with electricity to make the gap that's a cost as well so and so all that should be taken into account should it not and when you take all that into account there is no way that the first of all the marginal cost exercise is irrelevant and there's no way that renewables are the cheapest no and you're absolutely right we're [00:07:23] Andrew: being gaslighted because people constantly will tell you is the cheapest source of energy solar and wind but they never tell you if you disregard all the other costs but that of course is irresponsible in any reasonable set setting of uh of of the world and now when we look at the world when you look at almost a hundred nations if you can't find a single one that has lots of solar and wind and lower electricity prices but you can find plenty of ones that have lots of solar and wind and very high electricity prices the evidence seems to suggest that they're wrong and and and you know look at 20 years ago i guess people could sort of be forgiven for just being enthusiastic but by now yes it feels more like we're just simply well we want you to keep paying for this because we think climate change is such an existential threat that yes you would never have said yes had we told you the real cost but we kind of had to delude you into this because it's a really important issue and that of course touches on a really important point if climate change was this end of the world which a lot of people will tell you it is then all of the calculations i just showed you would also be wrong if this was you know if if climate change was this meteor hurtling towards earth and we'd all die unless we you know basically went net zero by 2050 of course we should do it because that's the only rational decision you know we would get rid of the meteor of course for whatever cost it is but it's not we know from three decades of research climate change is a problem but it's not the end of the world in many ways if you look at some of the most important indicators how many people die from climate related disasters like floods droughts storms and wildfires it's dropped by more than 99 percent in in uh per person risk why because when you get richer you don't die as much from anything it has virtually nothing to do with climate and everything to do with economics and this is true in a lot of different cases yes we get more heat deaths we get fewer cold deaths also and of course as you get richer you both reduce heat and cold deaths because we have really good technologies to avoid this so the simple point here is to say it's a problem it's not the end of the world and that's why we need to stop gaslighting everyone with these fake prognoses and be honest about it netser is going to be fantastically expensive and unfortunately [00:10:01] Speaker 2: it doesn't deliver even for the world i'm taken by what you said there that the renewables are the cheapest as long as you don't count the costs um i'm i'm speaking to you from washington dc at the moment where many years ago the the mayor once told me that he said this is a really safe city andrew if you don't count the murder rate well there you go but this would seem to be the washington approach to to to to to climate

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →