About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of 'Industrial-scale gaslighting!' — This data destroys net zero myths — Bjorn Lomborg x Andrew Neil from The Andrew Neil Report, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 8,499 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"How much is net zero costing us and is it really worth it? This is the Andrew Neal report. Britons will be paying more every year in lost GDP than the net benefit of this climate impact every year. That will cost you between 10 and 15 percent of GDP every year. This is just not affordable. When you"
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: How much is net zero costing us and is it really worth it? This is the Andrew Neal report.
[00:00:06] Bjorn Lomberg: Britons will be paying more every year in lost GDP than the net benefit of this climate impact every year. That will cost you between 10 and 15 percent of GDP every year. This is just not
[00:00:22] Speaker 1: affordable. When you take all that into account, there is no way that, first of all, the marginal cost exercise is irrelevant and there's no way that renewables are the cheapest. It's a problem.
[00:00:33] Bjorn Lomberg: It's not the end of the world and that's why we need to stop gaslighting everyone with these fake prognoses and be honest about it. Net zero is going to be fantastically expensive and unfortunately it doesn't deliver even for the world. Welcome to the show. If you're watching us on YouTube,
[00:00:57] Speaker 1: remember to like and subscribe to our channel. If you're listening, make sure to follow the show in your podcast apps where you get episodes twice a week, every week. Now, net zero, the drive to eliminate carbon emissions, first from the electricity grid generation and then from everywhere. It's been in UK government policy from the latter stages of the Blair-Brown years through 14 Tory years when Theresa May made it legally binding to hit total net zero by 2050. It was her sort of farewell present to the country after a disastrous premiership to the current Labour government, which has been zealous under Ed Miliband when he was at energy, in its pursuit, alms to the dismissal of any other element of energy policy, such as price or security of supply. Now, recently it seemed as if the UK government was mitigating its zeal for net zero. It gave the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea the go-ahead. Still don't know whether it plans the same with Rosebank, the oil field off Shetland. And in the budget, the Chancellor said that cheaper energy was now the priority of British energy policy. Cheaper energy, not hitting net zero because the two don't necessarily go hand in hand. But that hasn't stopped Prime Minister Andy Burnham jetting off this week to the annual global climate January known as COP, C-O-P. This year is in Turkey and it's designated COP 31, which means there have been 30 of them beforehand. And when he got there, Mr. Burnham reaffirmed the commitment to net zero, pledging, quote, a new era of British leadership on the issue. Now, the Brits pride themselves in being net zero leaders, Ed Miliband. You say, that's why we're doing it. We're setting the example to the rest of the world, though I have to say nobody else much notices, least of all the Chinese, as they open another coal-fired power station. But there we are. Joining me in a moment will be Bjorn Lomberg, he's a political scientist, fellow at the Hoover Institute. He's going to discuss a fascinating new free tool he's created to work out exactly what every country's cost benefit is, costs and benefits for net zero is. Just before we get there, a few words from me. It is remarkable how net zero until very recently has been the consensus in British politics. It started when Ed Miliband was first energy secretary in the last years of the Blair Brown governments. The Tories picked it up and to show assiduously how good they were no longer the nasty party. They kept going with net zero with their Lib Dem allies and coalition for the first five years, pushing it. Theresa May wanted to make the performative statement that she was so in favour of it she was going to make it legally binding, which she did. And of course, Ed Miliband came back as energy secretary in 2024 when Labour won, and he picked up the baton from the Tories and ran with it even faster. So that is why we've had this incredible enormous rollout of renewables, particularly wind power, especially offshore wind power at enormous expense and requiring enormous subsidies to make our electricity generation less dependent on fossil fuels. Of course, we no longer use coal, we stopped using oil a long while ago, but we still need some gas because surprise, surprise, the wind doesn't always blow. But we had this huge rollout so that renewables, solar, onshore wind, offshore wind, but particularly offshore wind, started to supply a bigger, bigger share of the electricity being generated. That was done with huge subsidies. Otherwise, the wind farm companies wouldn't have invested. They still get these huge subsidies. And we were told that by doing this, we would bring down the price of energy. And yet what has happened is we've gone through the net zero cycle. Britain, of course, has the highest industrial energy prices in the world. And that doesn't look like changing. And as for household energy prices, they're about the second or the third highest, depending on what time of year you look. And then as we became more and more dependent on net zero, more and more dependent on renewables, remember, the policy was to dash to net zero, to get there by 2030 for electricity generation, not for everything. That wasn't until 2050, but for electricity generation to get there by 2030. That was Ed Miliband's aim. Everything was sacrificed to do that. No amount of money would be spared. No amount of subsidy would be spared. The cost, hang the cost. The price, hang the price. Security of supply, hey, don't worry. Anyway, these windmills will be ours. They'll be more secure. But of course, it also transpired, and I suppose people who must have known this all along, that our electricity grid, the grid that carries electricity through the country, was never built for renewables that it can't carry. The grid was basically built for what's known as reliable, dispatchable power from a relatively small number of power stations close to the population centers. I give you Battersea power stations, a classic example of that. But to cater for renewables, which sometimes have to be switched off or switched on or gas brought on, plus, of course, the renewable power was landing from the sea in unpopulated areas where there was no grid. So, suddenly we were faced with this multi-billion task of both extending the grid and upgrading the grid to a smarter grid to handle this surge in renewables. And that was a huge cost as well. So that if you add together the cost of subsidizing renewables, particularly offshore wind and upgrading the grid, by 2030, when Mr. Miliband wanted us to hit net zero, we will be spending on these two things, according to the OBRs and their forecasts, 40 billion pounds a year, 40 billion pounds a year to upgrade the grid and to subsidize renewables, which, although they're meant to be the cheapest, still require a subsidy, or big companies like RWE and their financiers, KKR, the huge American capitalists, simply won't invest. Now, 40 billion is a lot, and you would think, well, we need some return for that. And no one has been quite able to, first of all, those who believe in this, and they often deny that that's the real cost, but it's there in black and white. And then they say, oh, but there's huge benefits. Well, Bjorn Lomberg has come up with this really quite innovative website. It's called NetZeroCostBenefit.com. And what you can do in this, you go onto this site, is you can then plug in a country and find out, and he'll explain in a moment how he uses all UN-approved climate science data and so on, to, well, what are the costs and what are the benefits? So I did that for Britain. You can do it for any country. And according to the website, if you do it for Britain, the cost of getting to net zero by 2050 will be 695 billion pounds. 695 billion pounds by 2050. And the impact that will have on reducing our carbon emissions, UK emissions and getting to net zero will make the world less warm. Oh, yes, the world will be less warm. I'll tell you, according to the website, how much less warm it will be? It will be less warm by 0.00376 of a degree Celsius. I'll just say that again. 0.00376 of a degree. Not 0.1, not 0.01, but 0.003. That's it. It's not exactly going to save the world if we're heading for a catastrophe. And according to this, what do we get back by 2100 by the end of the decade? According to this website, 11p on the pound is not huge. It's for an investment of almost 700 billion pounds, which is a hell of a lot of money, which taxpayers and energy users will have to cough up for. And of course, from the figures you can see, it makes almost no difference to global temperatures whatsoever, Britain getting to net zero. It's spending a lot of money for very little. Anyway, enough for me. Let's now speak to Bjorn Lomberg, political scientist, visiting fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institute, and he's the creator of the net zero cost benefit dot com website. Bjorn,
[00:10:54] Bjorn Lomberg: welcome to the Andrew Neil report. Thank you, Andrew. It's great. And thank you very much for for all those stats. Now, I don't have to say all the boring stuff, right? My job is to do the boring
[00:11:06] Speaker 1: stuff. So, I mean, just talk us through this. First of all, what is the statistical basis for these calculations? Because people will want to know is this? Oh, well, is this is this just made up figures designed to give the result you want? Oh, so on what basis are the calculations made?
[00:11:26] Bjorn Lomberg: Oh, so you made me make become boring again. Yes. So absolutely. So this is all based on the best science that we have. And of course, on economic, because we're also talking about the cost benefit. So the zero point zero zero three seven six degrees that you mentioned, which is essentially a third of one hundredth of a degree centigrade, which is very, very, very little. And I've also shown you the graph. You literally can't see the difference between the two. You actually have to zoom really hard in on the the on the pen in order to see the difference of of the outcome over the century. But that comes from the so-called climate model that's called magic. This is the one that every UN climate panel has used. It's a very simple model that simply takes in how much do you emit of CO2 and methane and all the other greenhouse gases. And then it comes out with how much will the world warm. So what I do is I simply run it with what we assume is going to be the standard policy, which is roughly the new UN middle scenario, what we expect happens if nobody does anything more. And then we do it if Britain goes net zero. So it's simply two computer runs in one of the UN's own climate models. And then you get the one third of one hundredth of a degree centigrade. That is absolutely incontrovertible. Everybody would agree that's roughly what it's going to give. The question then is, how much is this going to cost? And how much good is it going to do? And that, of course, are different questions. The first one, how much is it going to cost? So the UN has made a lot or they've basically requested a lot of models to be made of how much is it going to cost to cut a lot of different types of CO2 and other greenhouse gases over the next half century. They have about 500 scenarios. Since then, there's been another about 500. So let's roughly say a thousand. It's like 960 or thereabouts. Of all of those, only six of them actually manage to go net zero because it turns out it's so fantastically expensive. Nobody wants to make those kinds of models. Now, if you look at all of these, and I show that on the website, it's very clear as you cut more and more CO2, it becomes more and more expensive. And so what we find is of these six, three of them are super optimistic. They assume already by now we would have cut somewhere between 25 and 40% of our emissions, which of course we haven't globally. So I discard those because they're no longer relevant. They might've been relevant a long time ago, but they're no longer relevant. The last three show a cost to the world of 7.8% of GDP and of 18% of GDP. This is an economic cost. Again, remember when people talk about climate change and climate policies, they often think of, oh, that we have to buy solar panels and we have to buy electric cars and all this other stuff. But you also get stuff for it. You actually get some electricity or you get a car that at least sometimes can move. So it's not that cost that these models are estimating. They're estimating the fact that as you get much higher electricity prices and energy prices in general, your growth goes down, which of course is exactly what Britain is seeing and lots of other countries around, especially in the rich part of the world. It's not that we can't grow, but it's that we grow less. What these models essentially show is what is the accumulated cost over the century of not having as cheap energy as you otherwise would have had. And that is less growth. And that's what turns into this three, eight or 18% of GDP. I take the middle one, which I think is the fair one. I'm not taking the super cheap one. I'm not taking the super expensive one. I'm taking the middle one. It also happens to be what we sort of estimate from almost all of these models and I show all that on the website. So that's where the costs come from. So remember the 695 billion pounds that you talked about. That's the cost to the UK discounted because you need to say that future costs are worth less. That's how you work and everything. If you just summed it up over the century, it would be almost 3 trillion pounds. But given that much of this loss is going to come far into the future, the present day value, it'll feel like we're 700 billion pounds less well off. So what's the benefit? That's the third bit that goes into this. Well, there's been a lot of estimates of this. And this is what climate economics has spent the last three decades on. There are two major meta studies. You could call them synthesis studies. One is by Richard Tull, one of the most heavily quoted climate economists in the world. The other one is from William Nordhaus, the only climate economist to win the Nobel Prize. They give about the same number, but I show how they differ a little bit. And I take the average of those two. So I'm essentially saying, what is our best estimate of this from the best period climate economic modeling? And then I look at the world, how much damage are you going to get? And again, you are going to get real damage because climate change is a problem. And then I look at how much will Britain's dash to net zero reduce that damage. And the answer is over the century discounted 74 billion pounds. So you end up spending 700 billion pounds and you do 70 74 billion pounds of good for the rest of the world. Of course, this is not at all going to affect Britain, but it will affect everyone a tiny bit around the world. That is why you get this 11 pence back on the pound. And of course, this is not the true number. There's no way we could know this about, you know, a century out in the future and all these estimates, but it gives you a rough estimate. And it certainly is an estimate to tell you every year throughout this century, Britons will be paying more every year in lost GDP than the net benefit of this climate impact every year. And remember, this is the net impact across the entire world. That's why this is important. And that's why I think it's interesting for almost everyone to go to, you know, net zero cost benefit.com because it tells you, what can my country do? And of course, the answer is unless you're China or India, not very much.
[00:18:27] Speaker 1: But it's fascinating, I must say it's an eye opener. So I just want to kind of belt and brace a couple of things here. And the first is just to make clear that the the statistical basis of this website and of the calculations that are made on it, it involves the work that's been done by UN approved climate scientists. It's not the figures. It's not the fantasies of some climate skeptics or climate change deniers. These are the the kosher figures that the UN uses. Yes. The only thing is, remember the cost.
[00:19:15] Bjorn Lomberg: So the benefit estimates, I was talking about the 74 billion you're going to get. The UN actually decided because they were so small, they decided back in 1998 that they didn't want to discuss them anymore. So those are no longer UN numbers, if you will. But yes, they're still the best numbers. And again, it's the numbers of, if you will, the only kind of economists to win the Nobel Prize. So yes, this is the best we know. It's not the truth, but it's the best we know.
[00:19:41] Speaker 1: And the other thing that jumps out, Bjorn, is that we spend, just speaking of the UK, but I should emphasize to viewers and listeners around the world that you go onto this website, you can put your own country in and find out what it means for that. But on the UK one, we spend 700 billion in the way you've described by 2050. And we make an almost infinitesimal difference to global temperatures rising.
[00:20:13] Bjorn Lomberg: Yeah. And of course, everyone knew that, as you also mentioned in the beginning, England, sorry, the UK, we often confuse that when we're outside of the UK, right? But the UK just doesn't matter all that much. And everyone has said that, right? So right now, the UK produces about two thirds of 1% of global greenhouse gas emissions. So you're already a very, very small bit. But remember, even if you go net zero, you will still be producing something up till 2050. And because we were already expecting you to produce less, because you've already committed to some of that path, the actual reduction of the global emissions that would come in the 21st century, which are the ones that will actually determine how much temperature rises, is one quarter of a percent. It's 0.24%. I don't know if you've seen it, it's very bottom of the website for the UK. And again, it's there for all countries and country groups. And, you know, it's just amazing that people in the UK sort of have talked themselves up. And I know that I'm from Denmark, and we've done the same thing in Denmark, we're like, oh, we're going to change the world, you know, we're going to tell people how wonderful it is, and they're all going to follow us. But of course, if what you have produced is basically an incredibly expensive power system, nobody's going to look at you and say, oh, I want to do that. They're going to say, oh, this is exactly what we should avoid. Indeed, because you see your heavy industries being
[00:21:50] Speaker 1: hollowed out because the industrial energy costs are so high. And it seems, I thought it was very interesting that, you know, it's hugely expensive, as you say, almost 700 billion. But of course, with economic growth, you can generate generate a lot more revenues. But I thought the interesting point that you just made is that one of the costs of getting to net zero is the higher energy costs, which in return reduces economic growth. So the very mechanism whereby might get you to be able to to pay for all this. Actually, you're stymied because it's actually the reducing growth and
[00:22:39] Bjorn Lomberg: therefore revenues. Yes, you we should just be careful here. Because again, as you also say, this is not just a climate skeptic and sitting and raving and saying there's nothing there or something. This is, you know, over the century, almost all models estimate everyone is going to become much richer, you know, so twice as rich in the UK, maybe seven, 10 times as rich in sub-Saharan Africa. So the world is going to be much, much better. Even if we make climate policy like the net zero, we will still be much richer, but we will be less much richer. And of course, one of the things that we unfortunately will leave our kids and descendants with is that they will be less able to handle many of the problems they're going to find from climate change. But also, and that of course goes to the African point I just made. Remember, the most vulnerable people to climate live in sub-Saharan Africa. Yeah. And then good, well-meaning people in rich countries like the UK will say, "Oh, we should help them by cutting carbon emissions." Well, actually, they are vulnerable because they're poor. And remember, poor people are vulnerable to virtually everything. They're more vulnerable to the disease and hunger and poverty and bad education and pretty much anything you can think of that matters for human welfare. You're much more vulnerable to what's. And one of the best ways to get Africa to become less vulnerable is to get them out of poverty. And one of the things that does that, we've seen that very powerfully with China and now India is trying to emulate that is by getting much, much more energy. And so not surprisingly, most African leaders don't look to the UK and say, "Ooh, we could go net zero." They look at China and say, "We could get rich." And, you know, if you or I were in that position,
[00:24:40] Speaker 1: we'd be saying the same thing. Of course, because we've all benefited. All major economies from the industrial age onwards have benefited from cheap energy. We've seen the way America now leaves Europe behind in the dust because it's got cheap energy and European energy is very expensive. And yet we're constantly told by politicians, and it happened again in Britain this week, that the more we move to renewables, the cheaper energy becomes. As a government minister appeared on British Broadcasting this week, they're talking about there's a new, there was a, they tried to make it a new announcement, but actually it was announced in January of this year is yet another offshore wind farm north of east and west. It's being built by RWE, financed by KKR. So it's big green and big capitalism together. They got a guaranteed strike price, as they do to do this. So there's a massive subsidy in it, that even that wasn't enough. And what the government was really announcing this week was another billion from the so-called national wealth fund, which isn't a national wealth fund, but that's for another day, to sweeten the deal. Another billion, essentially, of taxpayers' money. So it strikes me that if renewables were going to lead to cheaper energy, if they could produce more cheaply, why does it keep on needing subsidies and taxpayers' money?
[00:26:10] Bjorn Lomberg: And that's a very good question. Of course, it shows you that this is, to a very large extent, a mirage. So the idea is to say solar and wind, and you hear this all the time, is the cheapest energy you can possibly get. But of course, what they never tell you is when the sun is shining or when the wind is blowing. That's potentially true. It's not true everywhere, but it's true in a lot of places. When the sun is shining, it's incredibly cheap. When the wind is blowing, it's incredibly cheap. But remember, when it's not, it's incredibly expensive. It's actually infinitely expensive. And people will sort of blindly say, "Oh, we should just have batteries or something." Remember, the UK have batteries for less than half an hour of its electricity grid right now. You need batteries for about a month or three months, depending a little bit on how much you think you're going to run out. And the honest answer is, that will cost the UK every year. Because remember, you have to replace these batteries every 10, 15 years. That will cost you between 10 and 15% of GDP every year. This is just not affordable. So I've made another graph that I think you'll love, and I'll send it to you, then maybe you can also share that. But it's one that nobody's done, and I kind of know why. But it's very, very interesting. So if you take the official numbers from the International Energy Agency, we can find numbers for about 100 countries around the world of how much do their electricity cost. So this is both for households, and for industry, and then we weigh them. So it's the, you know, the weighted app, if you use for a lot for industry, the industry accounts more, more. So it's essentially how much did the country pay per kilowatt hour. And then out of the x axis, I show how much of your energy do you get from solar and wind. And up the y axis, you see how much do your electricity cost. And what you see is, as you get more and more solar and wind, you get more and more expensive energy. And this is true for 100 countries. What is phenomenal is there's not one country in the world that has a lot of solar and wind and cheap electricity. So again, there's a lot of conversations that you can have, oh, it could both get cheaper, it could get more expensive. But the empirical facts, and this is data from 2025, but we also have it from back before, is that no, when you get more in solar and wind, you end up with more expensive energy because you have to pay for those extra backups. Remember, it's a little bit like, you know, if you think about it, if I told you, Andrew, you could have this incredibly cheap electric solar powered car, you'd be sort of like, ooh, maybe I'll buy that. Until I tell you, oh, but here's one thing, it'll only drive when the sun is out. So you know, if there's a cloud, or if it's dark or something, you won't have. So what you suddenly realize is, oh, I have to have two cars. Of course, I'll save the fuel in the daytime when the sun is shining. But suddenly, I have to invest in two full cars. And that, almost inevitably, ends up being a lot more expensive outfit. And that's the problem that we're in right now. We both have to pay for the unreliable main grid that we're now having, and the reliable backup that we don't use very often, but we still have to pay for all of it.
[00:29:42] Speaker 1: You see, I just feel we're now just gaslighted on an industrial scale by politicians who are the net zero zealots and supporters. Because when they say that renewable power is cheap, and that wind power could be the cheapest of all, though sometimes they're out of solar, but taking the wind power, particularly offshore wind, what they're talking about is the marginal cost of wind. When the wind is blowing and the turbines are turning, the marginal cost of that electricity is very slight. But that's not the cost. That's just the marginal cost. That doesn't include the capital cost of building these windmills. And the last time I looked, RWDE and Siemens and so on, they're not charities. They put billions in, they expect a return on their capital investment. It doesn't include the cost of having to upgrade the grid, which as I explained at the beginning, we don't have a grid that's fit for purpose for renewables. That's another multi-billion pound investment. Then we have to build the grid to where that energy is coming on shore, because we don't have a grid in a lot of these remote parts in the north of Scotland, or even on the on the Norfolk coast. And then the point you've alluded to, there is then the cost, at the moment, it's it's backup gas. We keep gas-fired electricity stations ticking over to click in when we get, what do you call it? A dunkelflout, or something in Germany. Dunkelflout, yeah. Yeah, that's the, I knew you would know the proper words. And, or even when the wind just, or actually, funnily enough, when the wind is blowing too much and they have to close the wind power down, and we fire up the gas power station. So we're actually paying the wind people not to generate electricity, and then we pay the gas people to fire up their generating stations to provide us with electricity to make the gap. That's a cost as well. So all that should be taken into account, should it not? And when you take all that into account, there is no way that, first of all, the marginal cost exercise is irrelevant, and there's no way that renewables are the cheapest.
[00:31:56] Bjorn Lomberg: No. And you're absolutely right. We're being gaslighted because people constantly will tell you it's the cheapest source of energy, solar and wind, but they never tell you if you disregard all the other costs. But that, of course, is irresponsible in any reasonable setting of the world. And now, when we look at the world, when you look at almost a hundred nations, if you can't find a single one that has lots of solar and wind and low electricity prices, but you can find plenty of ones that have lots of solar and wind and very high electricity prices, the evidence seems to suggest that they're wrong. And, you know, look, 20 years ago, I guess people could sort of be forgiven for just being enthusiastic. But by now, yes, it feels more like we're just simply, well, we want you to keep paying for this because we think climate change is such an existential threat that, yes, you would never have said yes had we told you the real cost, but we kind of had to delude you into this because it's a really important issue. And that, of course, touches on a really important point. If climate change was this end of the world, which a lot of people will tell you it is, then all of the calculations I just showed you would also be wrong. If this was, you know, if climate change was this meteor hurtling towards Earth and we'd all die unless we, you know, basically went net zero by 2050, of course, we should do it, because that's the only rational decision. You know, we would get rid of the meteor, of course, for whatever cost it is. But it's not. We know from three decades of research, climate change is a problem, but it's not the end of the world. In many ways, if you look at some of the most important indicators and how many people die from climate related disasters like floods, drought, storms and wildfires, it's dropped by more than 99% in per person risk. Why? Because when you get richer, you don't die as much from anything. It has virtually nothing to do with climate and everything to do with economics. And this is true in a lot of different cases. Yes, we get more heat deaths. We get fewer cold deaths also. And of course, as you get richer, you both reduce heat and cold deaths because we have really good technologies to avoid this. So the simple point here is to say it's a problem. It's not the end of the world. And that's why we need to stop gaslighting everyone with these fake prognoses and be honest about it. Netser is going to be fantastically expensive. And unfortunately, it doesn't deliver
[00:34:38] Speaker 1: even for the world. I'm taken by what you said there, that the renewables are the cheapest as long as you don't count the costs. I'm speaking to you from Washington DC at the moment, where many years ago, the mayor once told me that he said, "This is a really safe city, Andrew, if you don't count the murder rate." Well, there you go. But this would seem to be the Washington approach to climate. Listen, we are where we are now. And I won't go into how we ever ended up here. But I've been detecting signs that maybe more people are beginning to say what you've been saying for some time on this net zero business that the emperor has no clothes. It seems to me one of the great cons of the modern age, one of the great fantasies, expensive fantasies. Are there signs that it's beginning to be rumbled or
[00:35:42] Bjorn Lomberg: not? Oh, of course. Yes. I think a lot of people. So remember, 20, 30 years ago, when the Cold War was over, we needed something else. And climate change was this amazing thing where we could all get together and save humanity. And of course, for politicians, it was incredibly alluring because they got to say, "The world is ending because of climate change. But if you vote for me, I will make that go away." Right? But with things that'll only cost stuff 10, 20, 30 years down the line. That's a great thing for a politician to say. But now we're 20, 30 years down the line. And the costs are coming in. And when people start realizing how much it costs, they start voting for the other people. And so I think a lot of politicians are starting realizing this is not going to go down well. In the UK, the Conservatives have now said they don't want to support NETSER anymore. Reform has for a very long time been saying that. And I think that's part of its allure. This is true in France and Germany as well. The upstart parties are coming out and saying, we don't want to do this. Of course, it's a whole immigration bit as well. But the fundamental point is, when you have very unpopular policies, and then somebody comes and says, well, maybe we should get rid of them, as Donald Trump did, people will start saying, maybe we should. And again, my plea is to the, if you will, the sensible middle parties, maybe you guys should not keep giving the, you know, hand over the keys to the, to the castle, to the outsiders, when you're pretty good at governing. But just don't do this incredibly stupid climate policy, where you say, let's spend lots of money to do very little good. Again, you also said, just to make sure this is not saying that climate change is not a problem. It's not saying that we should do nothing, but we need to find a much more effective solution. And just to give you one, if you focus on innovation, research and development into green energy, if we could make green energy cheaper than fossil fuels, we would have solved the whole thing. Everyone, you know, not just rich, well-meaning Brits and others would switch, but everyone in the world, also Africans. The point here is, if you look at the US where you are right now, they actually did this back in the early 2000s. They found a way to frack gas. And that's why gas is now phenomenally much cheaper in the US than anywhere else. Now, gas is not the total solution, but it emits half as much as, as, as coal. And what the Americans did was because they make gas cheap, they stopped using nearly as much coal, and they have cut their carbon emissions more than any other country. Why? Because the economics made it so. I'm not saying this is the full solution or anything. And of course, if we could get fourth generation nuclear to work, there are many other ways. But the whole point is to say, instead of trying to tell everyone, I'm sorry, would you mind having the most expensive energy in the world? You know, that's just not going to win elections over decades. But if you could get the
[00:39:04] Speaker 1: cheapest, oh, and green, that will win. Yeah, but they lied to us by saying that, you know, renewables are right, and they will be cheap. If they'd be more honest, if they said, look, we need renewables to save the planet, but it's going to cost you a lot more money. I mean, that would probably be wrong as well, to say that, but at least it would be more honest, it wouldn't be lying to us.
[00:39:26] Bjorn Lomberg: I love the fact that we're down to down to saying that we would like people to be more honest. I'd like
[00:39:32] Speaker 1: them to be honest. Yeah, I think the best we can hope for is more honest. And then we'll try and take them from there. I mean, every now and then, I think the British government is beginning to see the light. They, you know, in a way here in America, the whole net zero thing has been abandoned. Who knows what will happen now? The Democrats are back on the hill. But even in Germany, you can begin to see the net zero religion, the zealotry beginning to crumble under these, the energy costs that it's produced. And so in Britain, Ed Miliband was removed from energy policy. And as I say, the chancellor and the budget said that the priority now must be cheap energy. And that they would not connect any renewables to the grid unless it meant cheaper energy. To which when we were doing the live coverage, I said, well, that means you won't be connecting any renewables. But of course, they won't stick to that. And he we've got Andy Burnham now out at COP 31, I think it is in in Turkey. And even though he's he his government is actually moving a bit away from it, he can't stop grandstanding, none of them can. He's just told in Turkey, quote, the climate crisis is upon all of us now, we're going to lead the way we're
[00:41:01] Bjorn Lomberg: going to show you what they can't help themselves. No, no, it's catnip for politicians. But unfortunately, it is going to be very costly for all of us. And I think that will be the undoing. And I think you're right. A lot of people are starting to see that if you look at the Democrats in the US, very clearly, they've stopped saying, you know, I don't know if you remember back in for the 2020 election, every candidate was saying this is the end of the world. And, you know, they were basically competing who could come up with the largest trillion amount that they were going to spend on climate change. And now almost all of them are saying, Oh, all of the above, sure, we should have more solar and wind, but we should also have more of everything else. And I think that's just a realization that it's really hard to sell in the long run, that people have to pay a lot more for their energy. And we I don't know if you saw that in New York, there was a, you know, they basically had a reckoning, they had promised that they were going to, you know, cut, I can't remember 30 40% below. Yeah, by 2030. And they were going to put forth a document on how to do that. And of course, they just kept pushing it, because they didn't actually want to tell anyone how they were going to do that, because it get to be very expensive. And then, as you can do in the US, they made a court case out of it. And the judge essentially said, Well, you've said you want to do this. Now you have to show us how and then they came out and said, Okay, we're not going to do it. Because, you know, when when you have to push all these costs on people, politicians start realizing they're not going
[00:42:39] Speaker 1: to get reelected. Yes. So let's try and you've already done a lot of work on this, let's give them a different script. Let's, let's, we accept that you and I certainly we both accept that rising temperatures are a problem, and that we need to confront that we don't accept I think I'm writing saying you, we don't accept the catastrophism that goes with it. But we accept that the globe is warming, that man is playing a role in that, and that we should do something to mitigate the rise in temperatures to some extent. Now you've talked about the importance of investing in innovation, in getting on top of new ways of producing energy, cheaper ways of doing it, greener ways of doing it, too. Can we give them a script which they could dine out on that they can virtue signal on, and that gets them off the net zero hook? So Andrew, I would love if I had a simple
[00:43:39] Bjorn Lomberg: answer to that, because then I would have won. So the argument that we've done, so we worked together with 50 of the world's top climate economists, three Nobel laureates, to try to find out what is the best way to spend money if you want to do something about climate. And the short answer is invest a lot more in energy R&D. So that was the solution I gave you. The problem is that doesn't sound nearly as exciting. You're essentially giving money to eggheads and hope that you come up with solutions 10 or 20 years down the line, instead of showing, oh, here's the new wind turbine part, or here's the new solar part, or whatever. So it's harder to do. But the beautiful thing about this is, it is much, much cheaper. So the reality is, the UK and every other country, certainly rich countries in the world, should commit, and that was what we suggested, to spend 0.1% of their GDP on green energy R&D. Right now, we spend about a fifth of that. So it would be a substantial increase, but still much, much less cost than what we're currently allowing ourselves. And of course, the beauty of investing in green energy R&D is not only will you end up getting much cheaper green energy in the long run, but you also get lots of other stuff along the way. As you may have heard, you know, the point of when the Americans went to the moon, what you got out of was Velcro, which is not entirely true. But, you know, but the point is, you get like a better battery for your phone, and you get a lot of other things along the way. But also, and this is important, we talked briefly about that. For most people on the planet, it's not going to matter one jot what you or the UK or even very big parts of the of the world, like the OCD does, as you can also see on my website, it is not about cutting temperature, it's about getting people out of poverty. Because if you're in poverty, yes, you're going to be hit by climate, as you will be hit by all these other catastrophes, as we talked about with disease and so on. But if we get people out of poverty, we can also make sure that people will have much better lives, not just for climate. But of course, if you get out of poverty, you stop having your kids dying and you get them better educated and all these other things. So I think it's the dual track of saying, you should fix it cheaply through energy R&D. Yes, it's not going to feel as sexy, but it's going to be much, much more effective. And then we really have to focus on saying, if you want to help people now, if you want to help people in the next half century, this is about making sure they get out of poverty. And so again, one of the great ironies of the world is when you spend in DFID or in the World Bank or anywhere else on helping poor people, increasingly, that goes to solar panels. And so you're essentially telling people who are starving, here's a solar panel. It's not that that's not a nice thing. But it's not their first or even their third priority in Sub-Saharan Africa. It's actually their 31st priority, according to Afrobarometer, 31st out of 34 priorities they have. So no, this is not what we should be focusing on. It's the economy, it's jobs, it's the lack of corruption, it's less disease, it's better education, these very simple things. But even as we're doing all that, and all that makes
[00:47:11] Speaker 1: eminent sense to me, I see the UN's latest environment program emissions gap report for 2026. It says that even if countries deliver on their current pledges when it comes to CO2 emissions, that the world is heading towards 2.6 degrees of warming. And I assume that's 2.6 going back to a base, not 2.6 between now and the end of the century. How worried should we be, though, that that is on the cards, that it could warm by 2.6 degrees? So my model, and pretty much everyone will
[00:47:47] Bjorn Lomberg: come out in that range, my model shows about 2.8. So that's from pre-industrial time. So you're absolutely right. That's from pretty much the coldest period in the last 1000 years. But yes, it is a substantial temperature increase. But you know, just to give you a sort of sense of proportion. So one of the things that will happen because of climate change is sea levels will rise. So they'll rise somewhere between 30 and 100 centimeters over the rest of the century. But remember, over the last 150 years, sea level also rose probably 20, 25 centimeters. So it'll rise more. And that's why it's a problem. But just to give you a sense of proportion, you know, if you ask a really old person who lived through most of the last century, that's probably a woman, you know, say, what were the important things that happened? She'll mention the world wars and the incredible growth rate and the fall down the Berlin Wall and some other things. But she will not say, oh, and sea levels rose. And that's because we fixed this. And if you need somewhere to look, you know, Holland is the great place. The Netherlands have basically made a very large swathe. About 40% of their country used to be underwater. And they have made it not underwater. If you've ever flown into Amsterdam, Shiphole Airport, it's the only airport I think in the world that has on its website, it says they're very proud that they were the former site of a major naval battle. You know, it's four meters below sea level. And you would never know if you were there, because this is stuff we fix. And then again, you'll say, oh, but isn't it going to be incredibly expensive? Well, actually, the Dutch have made an estimate of how much they've spent over the last half century to keep their country safe. That's all the dikes, all the stuff you see. But remember, a lot of stuff behind the scenes as infrastructure. The total cost of that is 10 billion euros over 50 years. That's virtually nothing out of the Dutch budget. So again, I'm not saying climate change is no problem, because we'd rather have it not have another, you know, 75 centimeters to sail our eyes, for instance. But it is not something that we want fixed. So again, we should fix it smartly by investing in green energy R&D. We're not going to succeed in our current policy, because eventually everyone will then just elect Donald Trump's instead, when they get sufficiently annoyed about their electricity prices. But even if you succeed it, as the website show, you know, Britain reducing temperatures by 0.003 is just not going to make a difference. It is just not going to be noticeable even in 100 years. And that's the real tragedy. We're essentially doing something that will cost lots of money, deliver virtually no benefits. And we know that there is going to be a really poor cost benefit ratio. But we could do much more good if we spent our money well.
[00:50:51] Speaker 1: Well, Bjorn, let's hope Sense breaks out because of work of people like you are doing before we squander so much more money on this mad net zero pursuit, this mad dash, because we need money for so many other things, from relief of poverty to defending the nation. that to be squandering it, you know, as I mentioned, 40 billion in Britain by 2030 on on mixture of subsidies and upgrading the grid. It's just such a waste. So I hope people pay attention. And I'm grateful to you today for coming on and explaining for developing this website, net zero cost benefit.com. Go to it and learn and use it. Bjorn Lomberg, thank you for being on the Andrew Newell Report. Andrew, great to talk to you. Well, that's it for today. Remember that if you're watching on YouTube and you like this video, leave us a comment and subscribe to the Andrew Newell Report. If you're listening podcast, give us a follow and review in your podcast apps. I'll be back soon with another Andrew Newell Report. But for the moment, it's goodbye.