About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Pastor, Wife Sentenced for Years of Abusing Their Daughters — Full Hearing from Law&Crime Trials, published November 15, 2026. The transcript contains 21,381 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Well, all right, so let me turn to defense counsel. I think what I would like to do is address state beat Benjamin Garland first. Of course, I don't mind if y'all stay in here. It makes no difference to me. I don't think the state has proof. I just want to make sure what proof was put on is..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Well, all right, so let me turn to defense counsel. I think what I would like to do is address state beat Benjamin Garland first. Of course, I don't mind if y'all stay in here. It makes no difference to me. I don't think the state has proof. I just want to make sure what proof was put on is separated, so to speak, just so the record is clear. Any objection to doing that way? No. Okay. All right, we'll start with state beat Benjamin Garland. Just to give a brief procedural history, Mr. Garland. I was found guilty by a jury earlier this year of seven counts of aggravated rape of a child to which the court has previously sentenced Mr. Garland on each of those to life in prison without parole, six counts of aggravated sexual battery, solicitation of sexual exploitation of a minor, and then a violation of the Child Protection Act, two, I think two violations, counts 15 and 16, each one a violation of the Child Protection Act. And we're here for sentencing on, well, all counts, really, although one through seven have been sentenced. There is arguments as to, I guess, consecutive, and then as to the other counts, all sentencing options, I guess, are up for decision today. Okay. I have a pre-sentence report. Does the state have any objections or amendments to the pre-sentence report for Benjamin Garland?
[00:02:11] Ms. Parker: No. No.
[00:02:13] Speaker 1: All right. All right. Any, for Ms. Parker, any objections or changes? No. All right. So I'll make the pre-sentence report for Benjamin Garland, Exhibit 1, and I've kind of already asked, but just to make sure the state had any proof other than the pre-sentence report. All right. Ms. Parker.
[00:02:37] Ms. Parker: I do have four letters that I would like to make for the court. Okay.
[00:02:39] Speaker 1: I don't know if the court wants to mark them as a collective exhibit or individually, but...
[00:02:40] Speaker ?: Yeah, I'll go ahead and take them up. And without objection, they'll just be collective exhibit 2. Other than that, you're out early on. All right.
[00:02:44] Speaker 3: Okay.
[00:02:45] Speaker ?: All right.
[00:02:46] Speaker 1: All right.
[00:02:47] Speaker ?: All right. All right. All right.
[00:02:50] Speaker 3: Ms. Parker. I do have four letters that I would like to make for the court.
[00:02:52] Speaker 1: Okay. I don't know if the court wants to mark them as a collective exhibit or individually, but... Yeah, I'll go ahead and take them up. And without objection, they'll just be collective exhibit 2.
[00:02:58] Speaker ?: All right.
[00:02:59] Speaker 1: If you'll give me just one moment, I want to read these and then I'll turn to argument. All right. As in, can I make these collective exhibit 2? All right. I'll hear...
[00:03:28] Ms. Parker: Judge, I would ask that all through from the trial hearings and exhibits be incorporated by reference into that which the court can consider for purposes of this sentencing hearing.
[00:03:39] Speaker 1: All right. And I will say, just in case needed, I didn't know if they were, we do have all of the exhibits from the trial here, but the proof from the trial as well as the exhibits will be incorporated into, and I'll make findings on the record as well. And Judge, could I get the laptop? Yes. Wireless or the laptop? Wireless.
[00:04:05] Ms. Parker: All right. So, beginning with Mr. Garlick, I don't have too much to go into on that one. The enhancement factors under 435-114, I think clearly we have factor four. The court has routinely employed this where appropriate. Conceded that age is certainly a requirement under all of the offenses in play here. However, exploitation of a minor, that being the offense in count 14, requires the victim to be merely under 18 years old. Ag sex battery requires the victim to be under 13 years old. And ag rape of the child requires the victim to be eight years old or less. So, regarding the victims, during the charge date range, Garlick would have been three to five years old. The factor therefore applies to all counts listing her as a victim. The state submits, including counts 15 and 16, regarding continuous sexual abuse of a child. At most, she would have been five. And at the youngest, she would have been three. So, I do believe that factor four is going to apply to all of the counts where Garlick is listed victim. Garlick would have been four to six years old during the commissioning of the offenses. Therefore, the state submits that factor four applies at least to count 13, aggravated sexual battery, wherein she is listed as the victim, five to eight years old during this date range. The state does not submit that the factor applies to count six. What was her age? She was going to be five to eight years old during the charge date range in the indictment. So, factor 14, the defendant abused the position of public or private trust. I think that clearly applies here across the board. There is no offense at issue in this trial that requires any kind of proof of an authority figure relationship with any of the victims. Therefore, I believe it is well within the court's discretion to employ factor 14 to enhance any of the offenses for which Benjamin Garlick has been convicted. Consecutive sentencing, you know, the state is going to obviously go travel under 40, 35, 115, B5, that he's been convicted of multiple offenses involving sexual abuse of a minor. And the state would, you know, there's not going to be any proof here as to the sort of residual effects that, you know, the victims have suffered. But the state would point out a case that was just released October 1st that upheld trial court's imposition of consecutive sentences under that code section and rejected the defendant's claim of error due to a lack of proof regarding the effect of the abuse on the victim. In that opinion, the court reaffirmed that not all of the aggravated circumstances listed in section 40, 35, 115 must be present to support imposition of consecutive sentencing. It cites State B. James. What's the name of that case? State B. The one that I have up on the screen? Oh, yes. McElweth, okay. Okay. It cites State B. James Powers. You know, it also states State B. Matthew Kirk McCorder, wherein the court concluded that consecutive sentences were appropriate even though no evidence was presented of any residual physical and mental damages to the victim when the other aggravating circumstances were all present. So I would also just say, you know, I think that one could employ a fair measure of common sense considerations of the impacts. One thing I've thought about over the years, the first case I ever tried in Rutherford County, Angela Montgomery, involved a victim who testified that, you know, it dawned on him at some point as the things were happening in the household that he was going to lose his virginity to his mom and that was very deeply troubling to him. Um, and he did testify at trial, like I consider that I did that I lost my virginity to my girlfriend, like much later as an adult. Um, I, you can only do this work so long, um, calling our kids to the witness stand to testify about this and that without, uh, you know, apologies to, you know, any promise keepers types or anything. But, but, but eventually you get to feel that the very notion of virginity is sort of overplayed. Certainly its significance, uh, is overemphasized, uh, in society. That's the way I feel about it. However, I think there comes a point in time in every child's life where their peers are going to start talking about that kind of thing. And kids are going to feel a lot of pressure to either preserve that state of being or lose that state of being as the case may be. But at any rate, there's really no avoiding the fact that victims in this case are going to wonder where do I fall in to that construct given my history. So, um, the notion that, that the residual impact, and that's just one example, um, that I think brings home the fact that the, that the notion that the residual impact of, uh, this type of abuse, uh, is anything other than severe and long lasting is preposterous. So, um, so, um, that's really all the state wants to submit to the court's consideration regarding, uh, Benjamin Garlick. He's already been sentenced from the bench to, uh, life without the possibility of parole, uh, by operation in a statute regarding his aggravated rape of the child convictions. Um, so beyond that, the, the court has, uh, you know, could run consecutive life sentences without possibility of parole. Um, as far as his aggravated sexual battery convictions, um, the state submits that some, somewhere in the upper end of, uh, the 8-12 range is appropriate for Mr. Garlick under all the circumstances. Um, and the state certainly submits that, um, that consecutive sentencing, um, among those counts or among the various aggravated child counts is all appropriate under the circumstances. As far as, um, continuous sexual abuse of a child, of course, uh, we know that the, the court has wide discretion for those. Um, you know, the state actually took care in the filing of its notice regarding, uh, 39-13-5-18, not to include any specific offenses that would overlap with any of the other offenses that were put before the jury's consideration. So I don't think we have a merger situation there. Um, you know, the, uh, the only question, I think, would be, you know, whether or not they, those two counts merge. Those two counts merge with one another. And the only argument that I think could be made for that is that they share one victim out of three. Because one is under the theory of three or more offenses happening to one victim, and the other is, uh, offenses happening to three different victims. Uh, one of those victims being, uh, you know, uh, who is, uh, the, the victim listed in the, in the preceded count. I, I don't think it really stands up to, uh, some kind of block-burger analysis because the elements are different. And I can't even remember whether it's two or more children or three or more under the theory. Um, but at any rate, the state has a sentencing range, two, I think it's just two. Um, so it's, it's not, it wouldn't even be necessary to consider, uh, Abigail as one of them. But the, uh, um, the court has a range of 15. I mean, it's an A felony traveling under the, these offenses. So, uh, the court consents anywhere between 15 and 60 years on each of those counts. Uh, that's sort of part of the statute is that, uh, the court consents anywhere in the range, um, of an A felony. So, uh, I think somewhere on the higher end would also be appropriate for those counts. Um, beyond that, the, the state will submit the matter for the court's consideration and to, uh, make the decision, uh, as the court sees bid. All right, Mr. Parker. Miss Spoke, it's three or more children if, if, under a theory involving three or more incidents, okay. Two, it's only two children if it's five or more. So, as the state elected it, I do think it would require three things.
[00:14:33] Speaker 1: All right. All right, Mr. Parker.
[00:14:37] Ms. Parker: Um, can you, Judge, if you switch to, um. Oh. I don't need it. I just don't. I can turn it off.
[00:14:44] Speaker 1: That's fine. Well, it's on the camera now, so just watch your notes, Your Honor.
[00:14:47] Speaker 3: Thank you.
[00:14:48] Speaker 1: Thank you, Your Honor.
[00:14:49] Speaker 3: All right. Um, looking at the pre-sentence report in this case, um, which is really the only proof specific to this hearing that's in front of you. It notes that my client is a low risk, um, for re-offense, which honestly doesn't really matter because he already has a life sentence without parole. Um, but I do think that is a factor for the court to consider, um, as a mitigating issue somewhat, also a mitigating issue. My client has no criminal history. Um, I, I would allege that that mitigating factor applies here to what extent. Again, it matters. I'm not sure. But, um, uh, I do believe that applies. I, I disagree with the state that, um, the vulnerable victim can be enhanced for age on a count where age is a specific element of the count. Um, the McElrath case doesn't address that specific fact, but it does, um, the, that court, that trial court tried to use that factor in that case and that, the court of criminal appeals said it doesn't apply, but not for that particular reason. It was something else that was wrong with the court's application of that factor. Um, but I, I don't think that we can say, well, because the age required was eight and they were younger than seven, that now we get to enhance them again because the charge is already enhanced due to the child's age. Um, it's the child's age which creates the aggravation and the enhancement to a higher level felony. So I don't think we can also use that as an enhancement to enhance the sentence within the range for that higher level offense. Um, you know, I, I come around to, um, I think that the goals of sentencing and the principles of sentencing and when you get into a situation where you're talking about making life sentences consecutive, I mean, you, you can't make a life sentence more than a life sentence without parole especially. Um, and if we start giving people 500 year sentences, um, what are we really, what is the purpose of that and what goal of sentencing does that affect? Um, rehabilitation is not an issue here because he's not getting out. Um, he's already being punished the maximum that he can be punished and, um, there's no need to deter him from creating further crimes. He's not going to be out. There's no need to protect the public from him committing further crimes because he's not going to be out. And so, um, those are the main principles of sentencing and the main goals of sentencing. And I don't know how making anything consecutive to a life sentence, um, further the, furthers those goals in this case. Um, if you'll look, you know, I know the courts read the letters that we submitted and I think it's probably pretty clear from the testimony at trial that my client spent his, really his entire life spreading the gospel. Uh, spreading the gospel and that he has continued to do that while he's in jail. And he doesn't have control over who's sitting next to him in the pot in jail. But, um, even other people who are in jail, um, have good things to say about him and, and indicate that he does nothing in jail except for continue to spread the gospel. Um, certainly we're here to punish him for acts, which the jury convicted him of, which are heinous. He continues to maintain his innocence. Um, but I don't, I think the reason we have sentencing hearings is because the court is also, um, supposed to consider the other things that Mr. Garlick has done in his life, which would weigh in favor of, um, not giving the sentence that, that the state is asking for. Um, I also disagree with the state about the merger issue because those two, um, one of the continuous abuse of a child counts, the difference between that count and the underlying count was that one, um, happened. One, there are no dates, so we can't tell if these happened on two different dates. We can't tell if it's two separate occasions. The only difference was, as I recall, that the child, um, said there was ejaculation one time and there wasn't one time. And I don't remember that testimony from the trial, but that's how they separated it out into the election of offenses. And I don't believe that that is proof sufficient that that's two different acts. Um, again, I don't know how much any of this matters because we already have a life sentence without parole, but, um, I do think because of the election and those counts being so closely tied together that that offense should merge. Um, with regard to the other counts, um, he's already getting all of, most if not all of these crimes are either 100% or 85% crimes. Um, and some of that did change at some point over the course of while this case was pending. Um, so I don't know if the state has already figured that out, but, um, I think that, um, I think that most of them are under 85% before it went to 100%, but I'm sure we can, we can talk that through. Um, so enhancing him within the range, he's already going to be serving, um, the majority of at least 85% of whatever sentence he gets, unlike most crimes in Tennessee, which you're paroled for after 30% or whatever the percentage is. So that's already a sort of enhancement that's built into the statute for the service percentage. Um, and regardless of all of that, he's going to get no benefit for anything that he does, any good behavior or anything else that he does in prison because he's got a life sentence on top of all of this. So what we are asking the court to do is to not make any of the sentences consecutive, um, and not to imply the vulnerable victim enhancement. Um, certainly there are, uh, other factors that the state has cited that we would acknowledge probably apply in this case, but are they enough to enhance him to the top of the range in the situations where he's not already required to be sentenced there? Um, our argument would be no and that any sentence that the court gives him should just be a concurrent sentence to one life sentence without parole. Um, and, uh, I also wanted to ask the court, um, and we may do this later about, um, if he can remain in Rutherford County, at least until we get the motion for a new trial filed. Um, I know that the court had issued an order.
[00:21:41] Speaker 1: I thought it was filed or is it?
[00:21:44] Speaker 3: Well, we did want to till today for sentencing, but I think if we don't do another one today, then he would get taken. So we're basically just asking to continue that order. Um, and I don't remember if the language says until further order of the court or until sentencing or what that is, but that that's, um,
[00:22:04] Speaker 1: Well, I've got a motion for new trial filed September 16th.
[00:22:08] Speaker 3: Oh, I'm sorry. Uh, yes, Your Honor. That was filed based on the life sentence counts. It's not based on any of the other counts. Okay. Um, because he was sentenced on those. So, I mean, you have to file the 30 days of sentencing. So it's a little bit confusing about whether or not that should be filed or not. But as far as, um, that is really related to the argument about the constitutionality of the life without parole sentence. It's not related to anything that actually happened at trial because we don't have any of those transcripts or any of that.
[00:22:35] Speaker 1: Okay. Yeah. I'm not doing an order to that effect.
[00:22:38] Speaker ?: Thank you, Your Honor.
[00:22:38] Speaker 1: All right. We're here on, uh, again, sentencing, uh, State v. Benjamin Garlick. Case number 91404. Uh, the court, court has already read into record the, uh, convictions that Mr. Garlick, um, has, as a result of the, uh, jury's finding. Uh, there are, uh, as, uh, counsel have, uh, covered, uh, several other issues the court has to decide. Um, in determining what an appropriate sentence is for these offenses, I've considered the evidence presented at the trial, which, uh, the court presided over. Uh, I will say, uh, that I went back and, uh, actually reviewed my notes, um, that I took during the trial. Uh, I've also, uh, looked at some of the, uh, exhibits, uh, today, uh, relating to the trial. Uh, I've also, uh, considered, uh, any proof at the sentencing hearing, which consists of the percentage report, uh, as well as, um, the, uh, letters of, uh, in support of Mr. Garlick. Uh, I've considered, uh, as I mentioned the pre-sentence report, uh, the results of the validated risk and needs assessment conducted by the department, uh, that's contained in the pre-sentence report. Uh, I've also considered the principles of sentencing, uh, and arguments made today to any, uh, uh, typically I would say sentencing alternatives, but, uh, alternatives as to the length and manner of sentence in this case. Uh, I've considered the nature and characteristics of the criminal conduct involved, um, the, uh, uh, evidence, uh, and, uh, arguments made as to mitigating and enhancing factors. Uh, I've also considered, uh, statistical information provided by the administrative office of the courts as to sentencing practices for similar offenses in Tennessee. Uh, and, uh, there's been no allocution or statement made by the defendant on his own behalf, uh, today at the, uh, sentencing hearing. Uh, as typically, uh, I try to do in most cases, I look back at 40, 35, 102, uh, as well as 103 that might apply, 104, sometimes that's, that applies. But 102, uh, and, and none of these are any more important than the others, but, uh, remind myself, uh, that, uh, every defendant shall be punished by the imposition of a sentence justly deserved in relation to the seriousness of the offense. Um, this chapter, uh, is to assure fair and consistent treatment of all defendants by eliminating unjustified disparity in sentencing and providing a fair sense of predictability, criminal law and its sanctions. Um, and the rest of that, uh, chapter is equally as important. Uh, and I won't go through the whole chapter and state it on the record, but, uh, will just indicate that it's always a good place to start, uh, as a reminder of what the court's, uh, role is, uh, in, uh, sentencing. Um, in considering, uh, I may jump around just slightly and then I'll, and then I'll, there'll be some, uh, uh, I guess some method to this, but in, uh, looking at counts, uh, eight through, uh, really 16. Um, he is, uh, Mr. Garland is range one standard defender, uh, although, uh, 15 and 16, uh, was again, going back to the, the quote bouncing game, uh, in which his prompt, front private would touch hers. Why she was on top of him and chair in the guest room. Uh, I think all of these and, and the, the facts, of course, there's many more in the trial. would certainly lead to a finding that it wasn't necessarily the age, although it has something to do with it. And it is an element of aggravated sexual battery. But, and perhaps the, well, it is an element to some of the offenses. However, it's the nature of this horrible abuse that really is what the court would find rendered her particularly vulnerable. She had no outside, if you will, folks that she could go to being homeschooled. Her only resource was her mother and her sisters, and the way that these crimes were perpetrated, rendered her particularly vulnerable. Forensic interview notes, first time that it happened, it was in her dad's room. Of course, the door was closed, they were by themselves. After disclosing, she was then told it was wrong, that her mother would talk to her father. The second time it happened, she was in a hotel room without her mother. It was only her, her father, and her sister, I think, was asleep on another bed or maybe at a different part of the bed. The second time it happened, stated that her father listened to music during this time. Her testimony was that she didn't even know it was wrong when Benjamin Garlick touched her. The first sexual abuse happened in the bedroom after she told him that her private hurt. He took her into the room and told her to lay down, testify that he would lock the door. It's not really the age, although, again, that certainly plays a part in it. You would expect a child of three to five or four to six or five to eight to react differently to this horrendous treatment than maybe a 15 or 16-year-old. But it's the particular way that it was accomplished, and it's the particular way that the facts support a finding that they were particularly vulnerable. For those reasons, I find that factor four should apply to all the counts. Factor seven was not suggested. I think, really, that would only apply in this case, if at all, to count 14, and that is defense-involved victim was committed to gratify the desire for pleasure or excitement. Factor 14, or excuse me, count 14, being the solicitation of sexual exploitation of a minor. And so I will apply factor seven only to count 14. As to factor 14, State v. Kimball, Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals, as well as State v. Carrico, which is a Tennessee Supreme Court case, finds that an adult occupies a position of presumptive private trust with respect to the minor when the adult and child are members of the same household. I think, clearly, the facts support the fact that these three victims that we had before us in these counts were biological daughters of the defendant. The court, though, has to look, and this is looking at State v. Blackstock, Tennessee Supreme Court case in 2000, that the court must look to see whether the defendant formally stood in a relationship to the victim. So, really, you don't have to look to Blackstock simply based on the fact that he was the father to these children. The fact support finding that factor 14 applies in this case, and the court gives great weight to factor 14. The court also gives a great weight to factor 4 in making it sentencing determination within the range for those remaining counts. As far as mitigating factors, um, the court has heard the arguments as to the mitigating factors primarily, um, I believe that, uh, the argument is, uh, that the letters in support would indicate, uh, one, uh, who, since his incarceration, uh, has, uh, folks that he's incarcerated with have nothing but good to say about him, that he's He's helped others, uh, in, uh, their, uh, religious, uh, endeavors, uh, but, you know, the, I mean, my recollection is that testimony at trial, uh, was that, uh, Mr. Garlic devoted his life, uh, to religious endeavors, um, I think that was his livelihood, was going from, uh, uh, from town to town. Uh, preaching, uh, preaching, um, I don't think there's any question, uh, uh, uh, his, uh, his family was involved in the same ministry that he then was involved with. And so really it doesn't, uh, it doesn't ring, uh, as important, uh, that one now in prison or jail rather, uh, is helping others, uh, in their, uh, religious quest, uh, that the same individual who did the same help, uh, before this case was at the same time, uh, sexually abusing, uh, his children. Uh, and so, uh, certainly, uh, to what extent I commend Mr. Garlic for helping those in the jail, uh, who, uh, come to him for advice, uh, I give that zero weight in my sentencing decision, uh, today. Uh, I don't find that it, uh, would, uh, uh, give the court any reason, uh, to, uh, think that that was, uh, mitigation. Quite frankly, he did the same thing while he was abusing, uh, his, uh, his own daughters. Uh, any other, uh, mitigating factor, uh, uh, I would give, uh, uh, suggested I would give a no weight to that, uh, as well. Um, and I've heard the arguments as to consecutive, uh, sentences. Um, you know, I don't think that the, uh, I don't think the defense of Ms. Parker is, is totally off base in her statement that he has, um, life without parole. Uh, how, uh, how much worse, uh, could you get? Uh, what purpose would serve, um, giving consecutive sentencing? Um, of course, the court is bound by statute and that is there's no consecutive sentence unless, um, 40, 35, 115 allows it. So I'm gonna address those factors and then, uh, I will, uh, address what I think is the appropriate sentence, uh, in this case. Um, the, uh, 40, 35, 115, 2, uh, in looking at State v. Perry, which is the Tennessee Supreme Court case of 2022, allows the court to look at, uh, the, uh, amount of criminal activity. Uh, oftentimes that's the number of convictions, both before trial, uh, before the trial court for sentencing, as well as prior convictions. Clearly, uh, Mr. Uh, Garlick has no prior convictions. However, um, his criminal activity in this case, just considering the convictions before the court, uh, there's no finding other than it is extensive. The time span over which it occurred, uh, is approximately two years. Um, Mr. Parker's correct. There's really, uh, no dates. Uh, uh, there are, um, I guess, estimates, if you will. Some come from Ms. Chantel Garlick in her statement, uh, not only to, uh, DCS and investigators, but also, uh, to, uh, Mr. Harris as he testified to at trial. Uh, so we're talking about a two year period, uh, approximately, um, the frequency of criminal activity within that time span, uh, just on the conviction, the convicted offense, uh, is clearly extensive. Um, even Ms. Chantel Garlick, uh, in statements said, uh, that got the worst of it. Okay. Uh, really what that tells me is, uh, we may, this may just scratch the, uh, the tip of the iceberg, if you will, and that may combine sayings. Um, but we have seven, in this case, uh, convictions for aggravated rape of a child. Okay. Which, uh, have already, uh, required the court to sentence Mr. Garlick to life in prison without parole. Uh, we have, uh, another six counts of aggravated sexual battery involving three victims. Uh, we have a count of solicitation of sexual exploitation of a minor involving the, the, the pornographic, uh, program or video that was shown. And then we have violation of Child Protection Act. Uh, if there was ever, I guess, a, um, a criminal offense, uh, that illustrated, um, extensive criminal activity, it's counts 15 and 16, which the jury both found. Uh, the geographic span over which criminal activity occurred, well, we know for sure Tennessee. We also know North Carolina, uh, certainly there may be other, uh, I can't make a finding as to other because, uh, I don't recall the proof being there. But, um, and then any other fact about the defendant or circumstance surrounding the activity present or prior that informs the determination of whether criminal activity was considerable or large in amount, time, space, or scope. Um, you know, these, these girls, uh, were so young. Um, when you watch the forensic interviews, um, I think it's clear, uh, that while they were, uh, reciting, telling about instances that they could remember. Uh, certainly, uh, think that it's reasonable for the court to assume, uh, that again, these are not the only, uh, times that Mr. Garlick has, um, abused these children. Now, I want to be clear for the record, uh, that proof is not before the court. Uh, however, when you consider circumstantially, uh, the fact that, uh, it was two years before, um, really thank goodness for Mr. Harris when he finds out, uh, that he immediately reports this. Um, I think it's, um, I think it's reasonable to assume in that two year period, uh, that there was more criminal activity against these, uh, girls, um, than even the state knows about. Uh, but factor F, uh, I don't give a lot of weight simply because it's not proof before the court. Um, but based upon that, uh, uh, I'm gonna apply 4035-115-2. In looking at 4035-115-5, which the state, uh, kind of hangs their hat on, if you will, in this case, the defendant's convicted of two or more statutory offenses involving sexual abuse of a minor. With consideration of the aggravating circumstances arising from the relationship between the defendant and the victims. The time span of undetected sexual activity, the nature and scope of the acts, the extent of the residual physical and mental damage to the victims. I want to start with the last, uh, that the state, uh, talked about. Um, I would note, uh, that in looking at, uh, state v. Kimball, citing state v. Kissinger, uh, that our Supreme Court has stated that every rape or sexual battery offense is physically and mentally injurious to the victim. Um, serious bodily injury includes an aspect of mental impairment. We don't have serious bodily injury in this case, so I don't make that finding. Um, but I rely on the fact, uh, that, um, the, uh, the proof in the record is that these girls lost the family that they knew. Not only their mother and father, but extended family, um, to some extent they lost each other. Although, uh, there's, there's really no proof before the court, but assuming that they are together now. Um, they lost really their childhood. Um, although the court, uh, or rather the state argues, uh, that it's common, uh, for, uh, situations like this, uh, to have, um, residual effects. I think that's credible. Uh, I think it's probable. I can't imagine a rape or a sexual battery, uh, in these, uh, like we have in this case that it could not be mentally injurious to, uh, the victims in this case. Um, while certainly, uh, these girls may have a better life now, um, they will never have, uh, their biological family. Now, in this case, uh, I have no qualms in saying, um, I think that's a good thing. Uh, however, I think I can consider, uh, the fact, uh, that there, uh, is, uh, residual damage to the victims in this case. Uh, I find that the aggravating circumstances are rising from the relationship. Again, this is a biological father who has abused these girls sexually in every way, uh, that you can imagine. The allegations, uh, included, uh, penile vaginal, penile anal, oral. We've got aggravated sexual battery of multiple counts of touching. We have multiple events with the same victim. We have multiple events with, uh, three victims. Uh, there's really no manner in which Mr. Garlick could have abused his own daughters, uh, than what the proof shows. Again, the time span, uh, at least over two years. The court suspects it could be longer, uh, but, uh, I won't make that finding, but certainly at least over the two years. And so I find that, uh, factor five, 40, 35, 115, uh, applies. And so, you know, now to the, um, let, let me go back and make a finding within the range. I guess I should have done that before I talked about consecutive. Um, as to counts, eight, nine, 10, 11, and 12. Um, those relate, uh, to the victim. Uh, it is appropriate based on my findings of, um, enhancing and, uh, considering any mitigation, which I find none applies, that a 12-year sentence within that range is appropriate. As to count 13, I find that a sentence of 12 years within that range for the same reasons is appropriate. Um, as to, um, count 14, solicitation, uh, I find, uh, that's a C felony. I find that a six-year sentence, uh, is appropriate. Uh, and then as to, uh, count 15, uh, and 16, both of those, the range is 15 to 60 years. Um, the General Assembly has found that, uh, the facts that form counts 15 and 16, that it's appropriate, uh, for a judge to consider the full range of punishment. The offense to which the defendant was convicted. Uh, this is a heinous crime. Mr. Garlick comes before the court, says nothing, no allocution, uh, through his attorney, which he's entitled to, maintains his innocence in the, in the face of overwhelming evidence. In the face of, uh, these three children going, uh, before strangers, uh, and telling what happened to them multiple times. In the face of coming before, uh, a jury, uh, that they're unfamiliar with, sitting in front of a courtroom full of people, sitting beside a judge that they've never seen before, continue to tell their story of the abuse, uh, that occurred at the hands of their father. Um, the, um, the, um, the breadth of the abuse is really just unimaginable. Based on the facts, uh, before the court, based on the horrendous nature of the actions of Mr. Garlick, based on the fact that Mr. Garlick has yet, in the face of overwhelming evidence, to stand up and say that in fact he did this, which is his right. Uh, uh, I find a 60 year sentence, uh, on counts, uh, 15 and 16 is the only appropriate, uh, sentence, uh, for the court to consider. In looking at consecutive sentencing, finding two factors apply. Um, the, um, giving, uh, great weight to factor five, uh, also, uh, giving great weight, uh, to factor two. Uh, the court finds, uh, the appropriate, uh, sentences are, uh, or excuse me, sentences in the following fashion are appropriate. Um, counts one through five, uh, deal with, uh, the, um, same victim.
[00:47:18] Speaker 4: Uh, those are all life without parole.
[00:47:23] Speaker 1: I find that those sentences should all run concurrent to one another. Uh, count six, uh, involves.
[00:47:33] Speaker 4: Uh, no different than. Having a voice. Before this court, I think.
[00:47:42] Speaker 1: Should also have a voice, uh, before this court and be heard. And so I'll run count six consecutive to counts one through five. Count seven. Uh, the, uh, victim. Uh, for the reasons stated as well as. Certainly, again, has a voice in this court. I run count seven consecutive, uh, to counts, uh, six and one through five. As far as counts eight through 12, dealing primarily, well, the. Uh, those 12 year sentences will be, uh, concurrent to one another.
[00:48:22] Speaker 4: Count 13, uh, which involves, uh, uh, that 12 year sentence will be, uh, consecutive, uh, to counts eight through 12.
[00:48:36] Speaker 1: Uh, count 14, uh, will be, uh, concurrent to count, uh, 13. Uh, but counts eight through 12, uh, will be consecutive, uh, to counts one through five, six and seven. Count 13, uh, will be consecutive to eight through 12 and one through seven. Count 14 is concurrent to count 13. Uh, and that leaves counts 15 and 16, the 60 year sentence on both. Um, the, uh, uh, uh, the state argues against a merger. Uh, the defense, uh, argues that they should merge. Out of an abundance of caution, um, because there is one overlap, uh, the state may very well be right. Uh, however, uh, I'm going to merge counts 15 and 16 for, uh, a single 60 year sentence. However, count 15 is going to be consecutive to 14, 13, eight through 12, and one through seven. That results in three consecutive life without parole sentences, uh, and then consecutive to that, uh, an additional 84 years. I find that that sentence is appropriate. I find that the facts of this case are horrendous. They are beyond anything, uh, well, that this court has heard, uh, and I think, uh, it's appropriate sentence. There will be no fines assessed. Mr. Garlick will be rendered infamous in order to provide a biological specimen for DNA analysis. Um, there will be, um, to the extent that there's community supervision for life. Uh, I guess technically that, uh, that, uh, is a finding that should be made and counts eight through 16. Uh, so it needs to be on the judgment. Um, and I will order that he remains local until the motion for new trial could be heard. Is there anything I've left off from the state's perspective?
[00:50:51] Ms. Parker: No.
[00:50:52] Speaker 1: Um, Ms. Parker from the defense perspective, anything?
[00:50:56] Speaker 3: Uh, would you do a separate, uh, like an order for that?
[00:51:00] Speaker ?: Or do you want me to type one up pretty distinctly?
[00:51:02] Speaker 1: Uh, I can do that at one. Yeah, I'll do that and give that to, uh, all right. All right, um, do y'all need to take him out or can we go into the next, I don't mind taking five minutes if we need to swap out. I mean, he's, he's done, so.
[00:51:25] Speaker 5: Yeah, we'll go ahead and take him out here on it. All right, why don't we do this?
[00:51:27] Speaker 1: I'll take like five minutes and, uh, really no more and be, I'll be right back in. Thank you.
[00:51:32] Speaker ?: Thank you.
[00:51:32] Speaker 1: Thank you.
[00:51:33] Speaker ?: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. All right, all right, I've read the two additional letters, so those will be collected, uh, exhibit two. All right, I will, uh, hear from the state, uh, any proof? Uh, no, Judge. That's the one to be heard. All right, all right, Ms. Uh, Ms. Rocky. Uh, yes, sir, I'm sure. Uh, so in addition to the collective letters? Uh, no, Judge.
[00:53:46] Speaker 4: That's the one to be heard. All right, all right, Ms. Uh, Ms. Rocky. Uh, yes, sir, I'm sure.
[00:53:49] Speaker 1: In addition to the collective letters as part of our proof, I also have, uh, my client's brother present, uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:53:52] Speaker ?: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:53:57] Speaker 1: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:01] Speaker ?: Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:02] Ms. Parker: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:06] Speaker 1: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:09] Speaker 6: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:20] Speaker 1: Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:21] Speaker 6: Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:22] Speaker 1: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:28] Speaker ?: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter.
[00:54:31] Speaker 1: Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Uh, to be able to read the letter. Yes. All right. If you'll step around. Uh, there is a step up. So please watch your step. Uh, and have a seat. And if you'll speak directly in the microphone. And you can move that microphone, uh, side to side and forward and back as needed. All right. You may, you may ask.
[00:55:02] Speaker 6: Okay. Uh, state your name and if you can spell your last name.
[00:55:06] Speaker 5: My name is Wolfgang Burgess. My last name is B-A-R-G-A-S. I am an assistant pastor, uh, in Santa Ana Baptist Church. Uh, I work there full time. And I'm here to testify on behalf of my sister. Um, growing up, she was my parents' favorite daughter. I'm not ashamed to say that. Me and my other sister, we tried our best, but she always stood out. Um, everyone she met, can't say a bad thing about her. Growing up, she was always listening to what my parents told her. Always followed their advice. She always listened. She, she did what she, she was told to do. She went to, to nursing school for a bit. And she made friends there. They all loved her. When, word got out about, what happened here. We had people who were praying, fasting for her. Because they know the type of person that she is. I know the type of person that she is. And it saddens my family. They tried. And, it breaks our hearts. But, we try our best. And, we know that, that her God will work and help her out.
[00:56:40] Speaker 6: And, Mr. Vargas, did you travel here today?
[00:56:42] Speaker 5: Yes, I, traveled here, tried to, with what we could to, someone to be here for her. Because, someone needed to be by her side. And, know that, we support her. We're always here for her. Anything she needs. Um, we sacrificed a lot. My dad had to close his business to move over here to try to help her out. My mom, Rod, they drove over here just to be here and support her. We've done everything for her. And, we'll keep doing everything we can for her.
[00:57:11] Speaker 6: Okay. Um, so, who in the family is standing by her?
[00:57:16] Speaker 5: My, my mom, my dad, my sister, um, our family in Mexico. Uh, our churches, my pastor, their pastor. Everyone that's close to us, aunts, um, we're all here in support.
[00:57:34] Speaker 6: And, Mr. Vargas, will you remain in your sister's life while she's incarcerated?
[00:57:39] Speaker 5: Yes, I, I speak with her every single weekend. I will keep on talking to her and never lose that connection with her.
[00:57:46] Speaker 6: Okay. Uh, and, and when she's released? Whenever she's released, whenever that may be, would you still be willing to provide support to her?
[00:57:57] Speaker 5: Of course. Okay.
[00:57:59] Speaker 6: Is there anything else that you would like the court to know?
[00:58:02] Speaker 5: Uh, simply that, um, my sister's the courtroom person. And, I don't think it can be a single person in this world that knows my sister and can say one bad thing about her. Uh, that is all.
[00:58:21] Speaker 6: Thank you, Mr. Clark.
[00:58:22] Speaker 1: I'll cross the examiner. Uh, I have a brief question. It may have been covered. I want to make sure. So, prior to this, uh, uh, I guess this trial, if you will, were you close to your sister?
[00:58:34] Speaker 5: Yes, but the long distance made it hard since I lived in California and Tennessee. But, she would, whenever they came over, we would spend time. And, you know, we, I, she was the closest I was always with, with, not my smallest sister, but better, because I'm the eldest. All right.
[00:58:51] Speaker 1: Fine. Any follow up to that?
[00:58:53] Speaker 6: Well, um, I guess do you remember whenever your sister relocated?
[00:59:01] Speaker 5: Yes, it was a, it was a sad day that, that day she just called the family and crying and just, since we've always been together, just at that moment had to come where she had to move to a different state and start a new life. So, it was hard, hard adjusting, you know, having family pictures and she's not there because she's all across the, the states, uh, she's always been part of our family.
[00:59:29] Speaker 1: Say that again.
[00:59:30] Speaker 5: She's always been part of our family.
[00:59:32] Speaker 6: Okay. And all of your families in California? All of our families. Well, I guess aside from Mexico. Yeah. Is that right? Okay. And, um, and so would you still see her from time? Do you still see her from time to time even though, due to the distance? Uh, yes.
[00:59:48] Speaker 5: They would come over and when they, when they would travel they would come visit us and we, we, we would be there with them. Spend time. We went to, uh, we got to go to Yosemite, uh, as a family, for the family trip, so we, we did where we could.
[01:00:04] Speaker 6: Okay. And then did she ever change as a person after she got married?
[01:00:15] Speaker ?: Uh, no.
[01:00:16] Speaker 5: If anything, she, she became, I saw her mature a lot. But being a parent gives me changes you and seeing the way that she, she, she viewed now. Uh, she, she always stayed the same. We always spoke about the same things. We have a lot of themes in common. So, we always make each other laugh the same way, talk about the same things we enjoy. So, nothing ever changed in that, in that aspect.
[01:00:43] Speaker 6: Okay.
[01:00:44] Speaker 5: I saw her grow up to be, uh, an adult woman.
[01:00:54] Speaker 6: All right, Mr. Burgess, anything else you can think of? Thank you for being here.
[01:00:59] Speaker 1: All right, you might step back. Watch your step. All right, Ms. Rocky. If, can you pull that microphone kind of toward, and ma'am, if you'll step to the microphone, I'll hear you. All right, go ahead.
[01:01:27] Speaker ?: I want to thank you for the opportunity to speak to the court. I have the $200 in the door. You already have the door.
[01:01:46] Speaker 7: It's amazing. It's the worst thing I could possibly imagine. There's not a day that goes by that I do not cry and pray for the Lord to heal the pain and trauma my girls have had to endure. My heart brings for them every single day. I trusted a man that should have never trusted and I will carry them for the rest of my life. I'm the one who went to the authority. My daughters are safe now. They are in loving homes where they are cared for and protected and I am very grateful for them. And that is what matters most to me. I have not seen my children for more than three years. My love for them has never wavered and never will. And I will keep praying for their hope being, their happiness and most of all their healing for as well as human. Since the verdicts, I have been in the county jail. I have used that time to look hard at myself and to set goals for my life. I have applied for the programs offered at the detention center and I'm on the waiting list. While I wait, I have been leading Bible studies and teaching Spanish classes to another whatever in my unit because I want to be useful and to do some good where I am. In prison, I pledge to enroll in every educational program available to me to earn the highest degree that I can. I intend to spend my time becoming a better person. I ask the court for mercy and for the chance to show that for the rest of my life, the rest of my life will be different. I respect this court. Thank you, your honor, for your time and for him.
[01:03:39] Speaker 1: All right, very well. All right, Ms. Rocky, anything further?
[01:03:45] Speaker 6: That'd be our first question.
[01:03:48] Speaker 1: All right, I'll hear from Ms. State. Do you need the screen again? I do.
[01:04:05] Ms. Parker: All right, so I'll start addressing some of the things that Ms. Rocky put in her sentencing memorandum. She cited factor nine trying to sort of underscore the fact that her client cooperated with notified authorities. The state would submit that the proof actually runs the contrary, that, you know, she eventually came clean to some extent when the authorities interrogated her, but overall, she tried desperately to keep this from the authorities. Whether you're thinking about it, whether you're thinking about it through the lens of how long this clearly went on for, for years without saying anything about it. You know, her own, by her own statement at one point, she said that she first heard about it. And, you know, her search history goes back, that we could find, went back to August of '22, and, you know, a year before the end of the day at range. So she sat on it for a really long time without doing anything to notify the authorities. Eventually something was said, done, that I think pushed her over the edge, and so she tried desperately to find someone who could help her keep it in-house. Judging by the text messages between her and Patrick Harris, he was kind of the perfect candidate because he was, you know, her bet was that he was going to be such a close personal to Benjamin that, you know, he wouldn't feel the need to notify the authorities. But it was only at the insistence of Patrick Harris that the meeting was arranged in the Walmart parking lot, where they initially spoke to the police about these things. What we also know is that by then she already started changing her story to some extent regarding how many children had been abused and when she first learned about it. You know, she tried to persist in false heads when Detective Wilkinson interviewed her at the forensic interview. And then eventually she came clean and got a little more honest about a timeframe. So I don't think, you know, the court should put much weight, if any, in factor nine. Factor four, you know, saying that the defendant did not play a minor role in these charges, but these charges are facilitation of aggravated rape for child and aggravated child neglect. She, she is in fact the lead role for those offenses. I don't think factor four applies. The change of the law in July, on July 1st of 2021, I agree with Ms. Rocky's assessment that the law did change. And it changed in regards to both offenses that she is, stands convicted of today. Um, prior to July 1st, 2021, for the offense of aggravated child neglect, uh, the punishment would be, uh, serve at 85%, and it cannot be reduced, uh, below 70%. I believe after July 1st, 2021, that becomes 100%. Um, same with facilitation of aggravated rape for child, but prior to July 1st, 2021, facilitation of rape for child, aggravated child, what have you, um, I believe, uh, would be 30%. And it was changed to, uh, 100% after, uh, July 1st, 2021. Um, I believe. But, at any rate, where counts 17 and 19 are concerned, um, we're talking about . So, what I want to address is whether or not there's proof in the record for your honor to, um, for your honor to refer to that would indicate that the jury's verdict does not pertain to anything that occurred between the beginning of the date range. So, remember, the reason, the provenance of the start range, start date of the range is that is . So, and that's based on people's recollections that things happened. The, um, let's see. Um, and so that's gonna be February the 13th of 2021. So, we're dealing with, you know, about four months and a couple weeks between that birthday and, uh, the change in the law. Um, her testimony, or, or at least her forensic interview transcript is what I've put up, put up on the screen here. Um, you know, um, and, and I do, I mean, I applaud Miss Rocky for sort of taking a stand on, you know, election issues, uh, and sort of to where the state decided, okay, fine, we'll elect. Um, but what we elected was the incident wherein, uh, she was, she was, uh, performing fellatio and I remember her mother telling her to fight him off physically, uh, the next time he tried something, um. And is this, are you talking about a specific count?
[01:09:56] Speaker 1: I'm sorry? I don't have the elections in front of me. So, what count are you, I just want to make sure I'm following on the counts of your argument.
[01:10:04] Ms. Parker: Um, I've got them right.
[01:10:07] Speaker 1: Well, I've got the verdict for him, so that was.
[01:10:13] Ms. Parker: Right, so, uh, it, yeah, I mean, I guess it should be reproduced on there. So, uh, the way to think about it is 17 and 19 are both. Right. All right, so, um, the facilitation of aggravated rape of the child in the state's election, uh, says, she refers to her allowing Benjamin Garlic to have continued access to her after she told, uh, Chantel, uh, that Benjamin had sexually abused her, where said access resulted in Benjamin Garlic subsequently making Abigail perform an act of fellatio upon him, during which she recalled Chantel Garlic advising Abigail Garlic to defend herself by hitting Benjamin Garlic. Okay. Big mouthful, uh, but all that to say that it does refer to that specific incident. Uh, now, I, I'm firmly of the opinion that, uh, you know, despite the fact that there is no, uh, existing case law on, on point, that facilitation of sex offenses such as this should be considered an ongoing offense, just as, uh, a course of conduct, ongoing offense, just as child neglect is, uh, in the case law. Uh, but, you know, in abundance of caution, we went ahead and elected because there is no such case law authority as of, as of now. I will point out that if you look exactly at what the child says in her forensic, which would have been substantive proof before the jury, um, she says, you know, um, let's see. So she says, I don't like it. He, I, I, I don't want to hit him. My mom says to hit him. Now, it's hard to even tell whether or not her mother told her to do that on one occasion or more than one occasion when she went to her mother to report what was going on with her. Um, in essence, this could technically apply to multiple different, um, incidents where she has that thought in her head. Um, and, you know, it's, it's hard to say. But I do think that one thing that the court can glean fairly and infer fairly from the, from the proof is that any incident where she is engaged in this activity at the behest of Benjamin Garlick is going to post-date a point at which Chantelle Garlick has reached a level of resignation. Uh, to where instead of taking the information from her child and, you know, I would think initially trying to shut it down. Uh, first of all ascertain whether or not it's actually, there's actually something to it. Um, according to, to her statements, you know, Benjamin blamed his porn addiction and, you know, that was the problem. So, uh, I, I think it could be fairly inferred that she took that as some kind of, you know, this is what's going to be the cure is I'll get over my porn addiction. And, uh, but by the time this is happening, we've had incidents where, and according to, to her testimony, she told her mother about this stuff numerous times. Numerous times. Uh, and by the time the incident of her memory, uh, at issue here is happening, we've reached a place where, where Chantelle has, has abandoned, you know, the, the thought, uh, that she is going to be able to effectively stop it. She's resigned, it's going to continue, and her advice to her child is to fight him off. Now, you know, that, is it possible that happened in the four months, all contained in the four months, um, in two weeks between, uh, her third birthday and the change in the law? I, I, I submit it's not reasonably likely. Um, now, counts 18 and 20. Let, let me, let me just follow up with a question.
[01:14:36] Speaker 1: Go ahead. I think you covered this briefly, but remind me of where the suggestion of the, the third birthday. That's the beginning of the date range as charged in the indictment. No, I understand that. I'm saying, how did the state, again, come to that?
[01:14:55] Ms. Parker: Statements made by both and, uh, Chant, and the defendant Chantelle.
[01:15:02] Speaker 1: And it was, was the, were the statements just the statement of this has been going on two years?
[01:15:07] Ms. Parker: Yeah, it started when I was three, you know, or, um, or, um, in Chantelle's case, she said, I first heard about it two years ago, right? So, um, I, and I can't remember whether or not Chant, Chantelle specifically said when she was three. Um, but, uh, the, the reason that that was the date designated was because it was the third birthday of, of Abigail. Um, I mean, you could have. I mean, you could post, if, if all Chantelle garlic said to the police when, or to Patrick Harris and his testimony was that she first learned about it two years ago, I guess you could just poke, like, back date two years from the date that she's having that communication. Well, I mean, that was going to be my, my question.
[01:16:01] Speaker 1: So if we're looking at August of 2023, okay, which is trip to North Carolina, the communication with Patrick Harris, uh, the, um, uh, involvement of police. I mean, that's, I mean, that's August of 2023. And so if the statement is eventually I've known about it for two years or about two years or around two years or whatever that exact statement was, um, the state picked the birthday just because, Hey, this started when I was three. I mean, it's, it's, it's just a date.
[01:16:42] Ms. Parker: Well, and it's a, and it's a, and we're also contemplating the charges against Benjamin garlic, which has nothing to do with when she first told her mother. No, I understand. Okay.
[01:16:49] Speaker 1: Um, I mean, from, from my memory of the proof and, and Ms. Rocky, um, if you want to respond to this kind of sub point now before you like it, you kind of forget it or what have you, not that you would, I don't mind hearing from you or you can just, I'll hear from you as the rest. So either way, I know you're going to have a lot to say about not only, uh, release eligibility, um, but I guess also, uh, uh, merger as well thing. Um, okay. I think that, I think I understand what the state's point is. So, carry on.
[01:17:43] Speaker ?: Okay.
[01:17:44] Ms. Parker: Um, and I will also leave it to, uh, Ms. Rocky, but I'm, I would like someone to point to where facilitation is listed in 4035, 501. AA post, uh, post, uh, July 1st of 2021, um, as far as it being included as a 100%. Uh, cause when I'm looking at 40, when I'm looking at 4035, 501 AA as it presently exists as of today, it lists all of those offenses that we're talking about here. You know, break the child, um, but, you know, at the end of the list, it says, um, conspiracy to commit any of these offenses, criminal attempt to commit any of these offenses, or solicitation to commit any of these offenses. So, I don't doubt that facilitation is included, given the breadth of it, but I just, when I was looking at it in preparation for the hearing just now, I was having trouble finding the word facilitation in that statute. Um, at any rate. Which helps Ms. Rocky. Which helps Ms. Rocky. I'm just trying, you know, I'm, I'm not trying to, uh, to mistake the law. I'm trying to get it right so we don't have to deal with this again. And, um, and, you know, the law is the law.
[01:19:16] Speaker ?: All right.
[01:19:17] Ms. Parker: So, these are, this is Abigail's situation here. So, let's talk about the Victoria. Um, in, um, in, it counts 18 and 20. Here's, here's the thing about Victoria. From, from our trial, I don't have a transcript, but, for, but clearly from both, uh, uh, Ms. Moore's trial notes and, uh, Ms. Reddick's trial notes, there are clear notations that, that mirror each other. Um, that was trial testimony on direct. She testified that she thought she was six or seven when the hotel incident occurred. Um, you know, she turned, uh, six years old on, uh, May the 22nd, 2021. So, again, in this instance, we just have a little over a month difference between when she turned six. I would also submit that when someone is saying I would have been six or seven. They're clearly not trying to indicate they just turned six, right? If anything, they're well into six, closer to seven. Um, that's what she testified to on direct. On cross, she clarified that she was seven when the hotel incident occurred. So, she would have turned seven, May 22nd, 2022, well after the law changed. Um, and, so, I think that there is proof in the record that, uh, was, you know, that, from Victoria, that places, uh, the date associated with these offenses, uh, beyond the, the change in the law.
[01:20:59] Speaker ?: Okay.
[01:21:00] Speaker 1: And that's, that would be, as to both counts, uh, 18 and 20. That's correct. Okay.
[01:21:07] Speaker ?: Okay. Okay.
[01:21:09] Ms. Parker: Merger is another thing brought up by, uh, Ms. Rocky and her memorandum. So, my understanding of the law, and, and I haven't done a ton of research on, on these counts. I would agree with Ms. Rocky that they arise from the same, uh, transit, act or transaction. Um, where I would disagree is, is, you know, the, the language that basically comes after that, which is, you know, a court next examines the statutes to determine whether the crimes of which the defendant was convicted constitute the same offense. Uh, if each statutory offense includes an element not contained in the other, the offenses are distinct. So, I, under the circumstances, uh, I, I believe that there are, um, you know, one is, is attached to, uh, I mean, for instance, there's the element of especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, and neglect, um, and, uh, for facilitation of, uh, aggravated rape of child, um, Um, there is also, there is, uh, the actual sexual offense that was facilitated contains elements that are not required under, uh, neglect. Um, as such, I would submit that they're standalone convictions, um, and, you know, I was thinking about, I was thinking that, you know, you could have a situation where someone was, someone would facilitate, uh, a rape of child, um, but have a slightly different relationship, or would have, it would have occurred over a less, uh, lengthy period of time. I know Ms. Rocky's gonna say we've gotta be tied to our one incident, um, but, but, not for neglect. Neglect is ongoing. So, I could see a situation where, where someone, uh, could be, uh, convicted of, or could facilitate rape of a child, but, uh, the portion of especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, under different circumstances would be insufficient, because it's not the case. The child's mother, or so forth, or so forth, or so forth, or so on. Um, enhancement factors are the same, that, as far as particular vulnerability because of age, again, for, uh, should it be eight for ag rape of a child. Uh, and as much as we're tied to ag rape of a child, uh, due to the election, um, she's still significantly younger than that. Um, and I would echo, uh, some of the sentiments that, uh, your honor raised regarding homeschooling and, and everything else in your ruling on Mr. Garland.
[01:24:13] Speaker 1: Um, can I ask you, going back just briefly to counts 19 and 20? Sure. The, the state, um, made an election. Uh, and I think we would all agree, I mean, it's a very, uh, it's, it's kind of an all-encompassing election. Um, generic might be a word, and that is that following the disclosure that, uh, uh, in count 19, um, ABGs, uh, being sexually abused by Benjamin Garlick, that, uh, subjected her to years of, was an election necessary based on the charge of aggravated child neglect? No. Because there were two separate, um, victims. Right.
[01:25:12] Ms. Parker: I mean, I think Miss, Miss Brockie's argument is that it's not counts 19 and 20 that are an issue for merger. It's going to be counts 18 and 20 are an issue for merger, and counts, uh, 17 and 19 are an issue for merger.
[01:25:28] Speaker 1: No, I understand that, but I guess my point is, um, or my thought, I mean, 17 and 18, um, are specific. I mean, the, the election is, is specific. And so, and Miss Rocky, I'm neither trying to make nor not make an argument on your behalf, but why couldn't count 19 and 20 encompass everything except 17 and 18 within the proof? And, and I'm kind of going back to this merger argument.
[01:26:02] Speaker ?: Right.
[01:26:03] Speaker 1: I'm, I'm.
[01:26:04] Ms. Parker: Which would not, which would not require a merger. I would certainly agree that, that there was no election required in the neglect counts because of the clear case law that it's an ongoing offense. And I think what your honor is proposing to me is, is, I guess I, are you saying the state could have said in its election that. I'm not saying the election is, is faulty.
[01:26:29] Speaker 1: I'm just saying could, could one look at this, uh, and say, okay, 19 and 20 stand on their own because those encompass, let's just say two years. Uh, we've used that term. Uh, we've used that term. And I think that's, uh, that's very consistent with testimony. Um, and just because there's one act within those two years. That is elected within, and I'll ask you, Ms. Rocky, the same questions in just a moment, just, just, uh, in reverse. Um, what, why would they have to merge just because 17 and 18 as elected would have naturally occurred within that two year period that formed the basis for 19 and 20? Right.
[01:27:15] Ms. Parker: So, I mean, I think there's also a different analysis. Is there not from victim to victim? Because in the case of, you have, uh, facilitation of the specific rape of a child incident, right? Um, and then there's the language in recognition of the fact that the state need not elect a specific incident. And it's an ongoing course of conduct defense that has subjected Abigail to two years of abuse. When you're talking about there is only the other one. That's only the proof that was before the, before the jury was that, um, you know, she, it happened to her once. She told her mom about it and it happened to her again in the hotel and that's it. Okay. So, all right. However your honor wants to deal with that, you know, I think we might be sort of in, in, uh, case of first impression territory on some of these things. I don't think there's any case law directly on point for, for all of the stuff, but, um, at any rate. Um, enhancement factors, I think four applies. Factor 14, uh, the position of public or private trust, again, I think that clearly applies across the board. Um, so consecutive sentencing, we've already been over this aspect of it, um, and the nature of the proof it's gonna be before the court. Um, regarding two offenses that must, uh, you know, with, with the consideration given to these other, uh, factors. Um, you know, I'm the, to the extent that this is an argument raised by Miss Rocky in her, in her memorandum. I think it, I think it is. Uh, the specific language of 435.115, uh, B5 is, you know, statutory offenses involving sexual abuse of a minor. Right? Um, and the statute really doesn't speak at all to whether other offenses, especially those that happen to relate directly back to sexual abuse of minors, are off limits for, uh, consecutive sentencing. Once that criteria is met or established. So I don't really know. You know, I mean, is, if it, if aggravated child neglect, um, wherein the especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, uh, element is sort of tied to the fact of the sexual abuse. Um, whether or not those are fair game for consecutive sentencing. Um, you know, the, the word statutory, I think it would be something an appellate panel might hang, might hang on or pay close attention to. But I don't know. Maybe they wouldn't. Um, these are certainly all offenses that involve sexual abuse of a minor. She was negligent because she allowed sexual abuse to go on, um, and, you know, she facilitated specific instances of rape for child, um, because those instances occurred after she knew about it. Um, so, I don't, um, you know, it might be that, that, you know, the court's gotta sort of pick one or the, one or the other. I, I don't know. Um, but, uh, certainly the facilitation of rape of a child is going to apply, uh, to the definition because it would be as, inasmuch as that, the offensive facilitation attempt conspiracy is gonna necessarily incorporate the elements of the offense that's been facilitated or conspired to or solicited, uh, I think it's gonna meet the statute. Um, so, again, I, I do think consecutive sentencing applies, you know, whether or not, um, the court feels there's any kind of cause for merger, um, or, uh, whether or not the court feels there's some kind of limitations to the consecutive, uh, sentencing statute as applied to the neglect, uh, counts. Uh, I would submit that the proof is, uh, sufficient to show that, that the defendant should be sentenced in accordance with the laws that existed after July 1st, 2021, first of all, um, that consecutive sentencing should apply. Uh, and that based upon, uh, uh, the enhancement factors present, uh, she should be considered near the top of the range. Uh, and, um, what I've always gone back to is that statement in the forensic interview, um, which sort of hit me like a bolt of lightning the first time I ever heard it. When she said, "Mom tells me to fight him off." I mean, there was proof in the record of what she weighed at a doctor's business. And it was like 30-something pounds. You know, at five, um, when she went to our kids. Um, you know, it clearly began when she weighed a lot less than that. And it went on for an extended period of time. And, um, the, the level of betrayal involved, um, from a mother. Um, because, I mean, if you, if you can't look to your mother for protection, then who can you look to? Um, I think that it, it truly shocks the conscience, um, and the, the state would ask that, uh, Miss Garlick, uh, receive, uh, no less than, uh, 20 years to serve.
[01:33:21] Speaker 4: All right.
[01:33:26] Speaker 1: Do you mean total or as to 19 and 20? Total affected 20 years, sir. All right. All right. Ms. Rocky.
[01:33:51] Speaker 6: And your Honor, I filed, uh, on behalf of my client, defendant's statement of mitigation, mitigating factors and motion for merger and concurrent sentencing. Um, and so I'll try to make sure I respond to each, each one that, uh, General Amelman mentioned. In regards to the mitigating factors, factor nine is, you know, whether or not move and assist the authorities in uncovering the offenses committed by another person. Um, and I understand the general's argument in regard to that, but however, it is still Miss Garlick who reached out to Patrick Harris and she was out of state in North Carolina, pled to him stating that she needed help and she needed a plan to execute. And so Patrick Harris testified that ultimately he can't do anything and he can't make a report unless she does it. And so Miss Garlick comes back from North Carolina and then meets Patrick Harris and the officer in a parking lot and made the report. And so up until that point in time, like it was her, she, she did meet the authorities and she did make the report stating that Benjamin Garlick was doing these things to her children. Um, and then afterward she takes the daughter to the CAC, um, to be interviewed. She takes the daughter to our kids to be examined. Um, and so she, so I would submit to your honor that she did assist the authorities in that regard. Um, and now there were a lot of testimony, um, you know, in regard to, to Benjamin Garlick's potential abuse or control of, of Miss Garlick during the marriage. And so I'll, I'll submit those to, to the court as to whether or not it was acted under, uh, domination of another person because he was, he was the one that was in control. Um, and so, and that would be factor 12. Factor 11, although guilty of a crime movement, committed the offense under such unusual circumstances, uh, that it is unlikely that it sustained intent to violate the law. Um, and so the convictions ultimately rest on a failure to act. Um, not on any sort of act of, uh, of abuse by Miss Garlick. And upon learning of the abuse, Miss Garlick went to the authorities. Um, and even on the testimony on which I recall, which has been, you know, a couple months now, was that even with Patrick Harris. Patrick Harris's testimony was he couldn't, he couldn't recall what Miss Garlick's, what the two years prior really meant. Whether it was pornography or actual, uh, sex abuse. And then asked, okay, well, you know, whenever you learned about this, you know, did you, did you advise, did you do anything? And he was, well, I knew she put up the, the porn app or the porn tracker app on the phone. Um, it was, it was controverted in, in trial, um, as to numerous times, you know, so the children told the mother numerous times. But in Abigail's forensic interview, she says, well, I told mom at the other house, but they had just come back from North Carolina. So was it that the minor child told her at the other house, which is North Carolina. And then by the time they got back to Tennessee, I'm telling her again, you know, that issue was, was controverted. Or even if, even if she. Um, whenever she was three years old, back at the time, the February 13th of 21. Did she tell her then? And then it wasn't up until 23, whenever the mother went and met with Patrick Harris in the parking lot with the officers to make the report. All of those are unknown. So we really don't know any for sure date. All of the dates are unknown other than the actual date of the report, which was in 23. Everything else was, well, whether it was, uh, with Ms. Garlick's interview two years prior. So there was one and then, well, when I was three or four, but then it was at the other house. Uh, so there were a lot of moving factors and potential dates. But moving on. Um, factor four, movement played a minor role in the commission of the offense. I mean, Ms. Garlick committed no act of sexual abuse. She did not touch these children. Um, the harm was inflicted by a different person, and that was Mr. Garlick.
[01:39:22] Speaker 1: Uh, you're on factor four? Yes. But isn't the state's point that you're right. She, she didn't abuse the children. In other words, what she's charged with is the child neglect and the facilitation. Correct. I mean, how do you, how do you respond to their point that based on what she's convicted of, like she is the person?
[01:39:48] Speaker 6: Well, the honor, I'll just submit that, that issue to the court. Um, and then, I mean, cause they were tried as, as co-defendants. Um, but at factor 13, she has no criminal history. She remained on bond for three years, um, without any sort of violation or new charge. Uh, got put on a wait list for programs through the jail. She hasn't had any disciplinary infractions. Um, sought permanency for, for her children. Um, which are additional, there are additional children other than the ones that, um, were an issue in this case. So, I, I will, I will submit those, those factors to your honor. Um, and then in regard to the enhancement factors, I would ultimately have the same argument as Ms. Parker did, is that, uh, the age is an element of, of the crime. Um, and then, so I had that, the, a factor that is an essential element of the offense may not be used to enhance the sentence. Um, and then factor 14, which is the position of trust. Um, I, I'll submit that issue to your honor. Um, as for merger, which, based on the previous conversation, because there's, you know, the issue of 17 and 19, and then counts 18 and 20, should those be merged based on the victims? But then, I guess as your honor was stating, whether or not, I guess 17 and 18 and 19 and 20? Under the ag-, is that, under the aggravated neglect?
[01:41:51] Speaker 1: No, I think I was asking 17, 19 and 18 and 20. Um, I think I was putting the lawyers on the spot with my question, of which there might not be an answer. And there may, there may not be.
[01:42:02] Speaker 6: Um, but, so in regard to, at least from the case law and the statutes that I've read, um, the, the state's election of offenses ties each facilitation account to the neglects. Um, and it's just, if, if, if, because you can't, there, the argument is that, ultimately to get the neglect, that's how you get the facilitation. Right? Um, and so, so the state elected on count 18, uh, which is Ms. Garlick allowing Benjamin Garlick, continued access after VG's disclosure, which resulting in penetration in a hotel room. And then, it elected count 20 as her acts of omission following that disclosure. And so, which results in Benjamin Garlick's subsequent rape of VG in a hotel room. So, it's the same omission, the same disclosure, and the, it's the same single act. And now, I, I, the especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel adverse effect, obviously, which the state charged, um, it, it, it's just that there's nothing in count 20 that exists apart from, from count 18. And then, as for AG, count 17, which is the post-disclosure access resulting in an act of fellatio. And then, count 19 is the post-disclosure omission that, in the state's election, subjected AG to years of abuse. And so, ultimately 17 is inside the 19.
[01:44:05] Speaker 1: And so, when the state elects... Let me ask you this, and, and I'll pose this to the state as well. Is, um, so your position is, um, 17 and 19 are related in that when 19, uh, as an election, and, and I agree with the state, they're not required to do an election. However, that, the acts of omission following the disclosure of being sexually abused by Benjamin Garlick relates back to 17, specifically, of the disclosure of, uh, Benjamin Garlick making ABG perform an act of fellatio. And then the same 20, where it says the disclosure, and this is from VG, uh, that it goes back to 18, and that was the disclosure. Does, I mean, do the parties agree that they're related in that sense?
[01:45:03] Ms. Parker: I'm not sure I understood the question exactly, Judge.
[01:45:08] Speaker ?: Okay.
[01:45:09] Speaker 1: The, um, okay, so, what I'm hearing Ms. Rocky say is this. Count 19 refers to, um, the aggravated child neglect was an act of omission following the disclosure of being sexually abused. And that that specific abuse that was disclosed goes back to count 17, and that was this specific elected event of telling Ms. Garlick that Benjamin Garlick made her perform an act of fellatio. Oh, no.
[01:45:45] Ms. Parker: I, I don't, I, I do not think that the state ever intended to elect that the, the only, the only thing, again, neglect is ongoing force of conduct. So, I, I believe that the jury would be well in his right to hear all the proof in this case, and if they believed collectively that, that Ms. Garlick was told about abuse at any point in time, and the abuse happened at any point in time afterwards, that, that they could find her guilty, if they found it especially heinous, atrocious, and cruel. And, uh, but no, I, I don't think that this, I think I just heard your honor say, did, does it relate back to, did she have to disclose about that specific incident that was?
[01:46:35] Speaker 1: Here, let me tell you, here, here's why I'm asking, okay? Because I could certainly see an argument, uh, as, specifically on the merger issue, all right? That, that count 17, that, that disclosure is made to Chantelle Garlick, specifically as a state elected. That, uh, that Benjamin Garlick made her perform an act of fellatio upon him, during which she recalled Chantelle Garlick advising her to defend herself. If that's the, if that's the elected offense in 17, which it is, found guilty, then count 19 specifically states that it was the acts of omission following that disclosure. In other words, the aggravated child neglect.
[01:47:27] Ms. Parker: Uh, I think the, the, the problem with that is, is that you, the court seems to be looking at it through a lens of the state was required to elect a certain disclosure.
[01:47:43] Speaker 1: I'm not saying you're required to elect, what I'm saying is, the argument against merger, I think, is very strong from the court's perspective. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Count 17 occurred. Okay. As convicted. Right. And then, and if you read it, it's, it's clear, I've read it four times, I'll read it again in the record. It is what it is. The, that disclosure was made, and then you turned to count 19, after that disclosure. Okay? That's when the child, the period of child neglect occurred. In other words, the, there has to be a disclosure at some point, factually, for the child neglect to occur. There's no disclosure ever that there's no child neglect. So, my question is, does the events that form the basis for count 17, is it reasonable, factually, for the court to find that those occur? That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:48:44] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:12] Speaker 4: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:16] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:20] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:31] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:36] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:49:37] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:50:01] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:50:09] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:50:10] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:50:11] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:50:13] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:51:32] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:51:33] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:51:34] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:04] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:20] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:32] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:34] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:38] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:52:39] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:16] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:31] Speaker 1: The child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:36] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:38] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:39] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:46] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:50] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:51] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:52] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:56] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:53:57] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:54:28] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:54:31] Ms. Parker: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:54:33] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:54:38] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:03] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:06] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:21] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:22] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:22] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:28] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:29] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:53] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:54] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:55:55] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:56:51] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:57:26] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:57:51] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:01] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:02] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:07] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:08] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:30] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:58:51] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:08] Speaker 6: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:32] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:39] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:51] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:52] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:54] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[01:59:55] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:00:51] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:00:52] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:01:52] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:01:53] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:02:53] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:02:53] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:02:56] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:02:57] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:03:47] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:03:53] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:39] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:40] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:47] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:48] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:51] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:04:53] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:05:11] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:05:13] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:05:35] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:05:38] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:06:13] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:06:16] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:06:50] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:06:52] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:19] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:20] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:21] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:23] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:48] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:07:49] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:15] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:18] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:45] Speaker 4: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:46] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:47] Speaker 4: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:49] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:08:52] Speaker 4: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:09:05] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:09:07] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:10:05] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:10:06] Speaker 4: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:10:10] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:05] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:08] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:13] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:14] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:16] Speaker ?: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur.
[02:11:18] Speaker 1: That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. That's when the child neglects occur. To find in the same way I found Benjamin Garlick. That that factor applies. Although the amount of criminal activity within the neglect. I think was large as I found previously. I don't know. I don't think that factually. The law would allow that finding. In looking at five. The defendant is convicted. Two or more statutory offenses involving. Sexual abuse of a minor. With consideration of the aggravated circumstances. Arising from the relationship. Between the defendant. And the victim. Or victims. In this case. The elements of aggravated child abuse. Counts 19 and 20. Are that. Ms. Garland knowingly neglected. The child in count 19. And the child in count 20. Um. Age included. In such a matter. As to adversely affect. The child's health. And welfare. And said neglect. Was especially heinous. And atrocious. Or true.
[02:13:43] Speaker ?: Um.
[02:13:43] Speaker 1: It would. Seek to me. That. If the court. Couldn't consider. Factor five. As involving. A statutory offense.
[02:13:51] Speaker ?: Involving.
[02:13:51] Speaker 1: Sexual abuse. It would be. Because of the strict reading. Of the statute. Uh. That says the defendant. Is convicted. Two or more. Offenses. Involving. Sexual abuse. When I read that. As common. Language. That. I guess. Any lawyer. Or judge. Wouldn't read that. It appears to me. To apply. To. An offense. A statutory offense. That involves. Sexual abuse. Not a set of facts. That involves. Sexual abuse. But. An offense. In and of itself. Aggravated child neglect. Does not have. The elements. Of sexual abuse. Of a minor. Uh. And so. In and of itself. Aggravated child neglect. Does not have. The elements. Of sexual abuse. Of a minor. Uh. And so. I'm going to find. That by law. Uh. That that factor. Um. Does not apply. To counts. 19. And 20. And so. In considering. Uh. That. Uh. Factor five. Does apply. To 17. And 18. Uh. The sentence. That. I'm going to. Hand out. Uh. 17. Is.
[02:15:07] Speaker ?: Uh.
[02:15:07] Speaker 1: Again. A 12 year sentence. To serve. Uh. In 18. Is a 12 year sentence. To serve. Those will be consecutive. To one another. Uh. For a 24 year sentence. Count 19. 25 years. To serve. Count 20. 25 years. Uh. To serve. Uh. Those will be. Current. Uh. To. Each other. And to counts. Uh. 17 and 18. Uh. For really. An effective. 25 year sentence. Uh. Incorporated. In that. So it'll be 24 years. 17 and 18. Concurrent. With the 25. 19 and 20. Uh. That'll be a sentence. To serve. Now. Release eligibility. Uh. I'm gonna specifically find. Uh. Based on. Testimony. Uh. One moment.
[02:15:59] Speaker ?: Well. Based on the testimony.
[02:16:01] Speaker 1: Of the trial. Uh.
[02:16:03] Speaker ?: And really based on the argument of the state. Not that it's proof.
[02:16:06] Speaker 1: But. Uh. That it's certainly. Is more likely than not. Based on these facts. Uh. Uh. That. These. Crimes. They encompass. Count 17. Uh. Through 20. Uh. Occurred. After. July 1st. Of 2021. I don't disagree. That there's a. There's some question about that. That it should. Favor. The. Defending. Uh. The problem. With this. Is that really the only reason. That the state. Chose. The date. To put on the indictment. Was because it was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Was her birthday. And she. Made this statement. That it happened. When I was. Three. However. If you take the two years. That. The defendant. Said. It's been going on. Um. Really. That's further away. From the February date. Uh. Than even the July 1st. Day. Uh. I know we're not. Saying that. Exactly. Two years.
[02:17:18] Speaker ?: Prior to.
[02:17:19] Speaker 1: August 13th. 2023. Or 14. Uh. To occur. I understand that. However. Um. Using the. Um. The logic. That we don't know. That it occurred. That it started. On the birth date. Of 2021. Um. Coupled with. Ms. Scarlett's statement. It's certainly more likely. That it occurred. After. July 1st. In 2021. Uh. And so. Therefore. I would define. That the effective date. Of these offenses. Is. Uh. July 1st. Of 2021. Is there anything else. I need to address. From the state's perspective. You. I mean.
[02:18:02] Speaker ?: You mean.
[02:18:02] Speaker 1: The effective date. Is. Post. Post. Yes. Yes. She'll be rendered. In from this order. To provide a biological. Specimen. DNA analysis. That we don't find. Assess. Ms. Rocky. Anything else.
[02:18:17] Speaker 6: I need to address.
[02:18:18] Speaker ?: Thank you.
[02:18:19] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you. Alright. Otherwise.
[02:18:23] Speaker ?: We will be adjourned.