Naresh Bhatt’s Alleged Affair, Harsh Messages Examined at Trial

[0:26] just to give us some context of what we're looking at investigator zamis could you tell us [0:32] what's on the screen at this time yes it's a whatsapp conversation that would have been between [0:38] the user of item 101 um that would be in green um and another subject at the um five seven three one [0:49] zero four nine eight four two three two phone number on whatsapp um and those would be the [0:54] incoming messages to the device and so the range of this chat between bot nd and user four two three two [1:09] is from february 20th 2024 going down through march 5th 2024 yes with the court's permission judge [1:37] i'm going to ask investigators zamis to read the texts that are present for the jury and i can [1:45] assist by reading the other part that's okay with the court that's fine i'll start i'll read off [1:53] naresh bot bot nd number ending in eight six four three investigator zamis could you read the replies [2:00] for the user four two three two yes sir this time stamp starts at february 20 2024 at 8 0 6 a.m i need [2:12] a colombia girl ha ha ha ha that's the one i'm going to present to you at any moment and voice [2:20] presents me with one from here i need to fall in love to also be able to nationalize myself here and [2:26] then invite you to go on a trip to colombia okay please introduce me to the colombian girl today [2:34] i need a good girl ha ha ha ha ha okay ready when she arrives i will introduce her to you she is about [2:44] to arrive thank you so much if we both like each other we will marry in the future that seems perfect [2:53] to me it seems great with that we do just one wedding and that's it yes sir how long does it take [3:00] to bring that girl for me we don't know because the trip is scheduled with the person who is going [3:05] to take her to the border with the united states but we believe that this month or at the beginning [3:10] of next month it will arrive okay send me photos then uh good evening friend nareth i want to leave [3:21] you this message because until now i remember looking at the document that i have an appointment [3:26] for march 8th at 9 o'clock a.m because of the police issue that i had remember it will be next friday i will [3:32] have it you want to ask friend if you are always going to do me the favor of accompanying me to court [3:38] today i would ask you a big favor if you can help me but if you can't because of your new job don't [3:43] worry there's no problem nothing will happen ready i wish you have a happy night and please give me a [3:48] response as soon as you can okay i will talk to my manager today for day off on friday and i will let [3:57] you know okay good sir i will thank you very much where is my girl i will go court with you guys how long [4:09] does it take to come colombian girl for me still in the border ha ha ha ha we haven't introduced her [4:18] to you because we heard that your wife might be here and that you're back with her home so we better [4:24] said that when her wife isn't here we'll introduce her to you [4:28] okay my friend thank you very much for taking your time and going to accompany me [4:32] uh no he arrived yesterday he is already with us he arrived around five o'clock in the afternoon [4:44] we are doing divorce my wife is here temporarily because we are working on divorce in court and she [4:52] is paying rent to stay here we thought that it was that you had returned home i mean you had returned to [4:59] live with your wife but okay no problem friend you can hardly go it's cut off down i'm sorry and i will [5:08] introduce you to my sister okay thanks um friend good evening i want to ask you a favor i don't know [5:16] if it's possible and if it's not possible make it possible for you to collaborate with me once again [5:22] and a thousand apologies it's because my brother called me and told me that well sumers needs the [5:28] money for the rent i'm aware and i know we are late and the rest of us also asked him for a deadline and [5:34] we intended to give him his rent money today but the problem is mine the truth is that last night my [5:40] car ran out of breaks and today i woke up early to take it to the workshop and i will fix it [5:45] it was worth 4.95 so with this what i want to ask you for a big favor is if you can give me time until [5:51] friday night when i already receive my check um and i will put in part of the rent and we will give it to [6:00] you excuse me but i didn't have this expense of with my car but friend i know that you have collaborated [6:06] with us a lot and we are blessed by god for finding a family as kind as yours but if you [6:11] see that you cannot help me this time don't worry i will get you the money whatever but if you can [6:16] help me i would appreciate it very much please let me know thank you good night okay you can pay [6:24] whatever you have now and pay later the rest of money where is my girl i want to colombian girl if she [6:34] wants to talk to me now i can talk to her and if we like each other we can start new life after my [6:41] divorce paperwork done do you want me to try to read the spanish or uh i don't want to butcher it so [6:54] i would say it speaks for itself okay um she is there at the house with my sister-in-law tatiana [7:01] go down and tell much and yada to introduce her because i'm at work now i am at work now and i will [7:07] arrive home at two o'clock in the morning ha ha ha let's see if platonic love comes to you again [7:14] do you think she liked me i already met her and like her if she wants to talk to me please tell me [7:23] and her we can talk now i'm seriously asking for your favor my friend i should talk to her i didn't [7:31] think you already knew her i should talk to her but it would be tomorrow because as i said i'm at work [7:36] now and i get home at two o'clock in the morning okay good night see you tomorrow and if it comes to [7:44] that my sister doesn't give me a positive answer i will tell you and do my best to talk to some [7:48] colombian friends who work here in the company okay so don't worry i'm in those trying to see how i can [7:55] since you have told us helped a lot okay sir same thank you i have no further questions for [8:13] investigators amos at this time us good morning good morning ma'am i'm going to go through some of the [9:12] things that the commonwealth has already asked the looking at your forensic examination report [9:23] the 62 page document that we just saw on the screen prior to the break um that is not the entire total [9:32] of the searches that you found on the iphone correct that's correct there's are there what thousands yeah i [9:41] think so so this uh document does not represent every single search that naresh bot ever made on [9:50] that iphone correct correct um and you are pulling things that you believe to be relevant to your [9:57] investigation right yes ma'am that means that we're not getting you know every single search um throughout [10:03] this document you should have it in the full reports that were sent to you but in this document that's [10:08] correct thank you and to be clear um quite a number of these searches in this 62 page report [10:23] they don't have that time stamp right correct so the way these are written you have them numbered [10:30] sequentially correct um but that doesn't mean you necessarily know what order these go in that's [10:37] correct those are just ids assigned by the software so it could be that um uh all of the uh items that [10:46] have that don't have a time stamp they could all be after let's say august 1st for example correct [10:52] you just don't know because we don't have that time stamp associated exactly and i think you said [10:57] on direct examination that can be um because uh the system removes that from its uh from the database and [11:10] i'm maybe not using the precise wording but no you're basically right um the those records are maintained [11:17] for a certain amount of time depending on what the source is and once they're removed from the [11:22] main database they may be stripped of their metadata so yes you're correct so it's not necessarily [11:27] um an action taken to remove these it could just be that the system is is removing it for space or [11:33] whatever yes picking it up at 2 43 p.m audio video call 253 audio video call um the translator has a note [11:50] here that says rajah literal meaning is king or ruler but here it is used as term of affection like [11:56] dear or sweetheart um dear i'm sorry i don't think the rest of that one's translated oh i'm sorry yeah [12:06] it is dear i have left daughter at yagya's place please take her with you i have work tomorrow as well [12:12] i will not come there so don't leave her here or there uh i have been kicked out at home i can go [12:19] anywhere but tomorrow i will know go there neither will i come home don't stress me bye and then okay [12:26] i have left this date or i'm sorry that was him not her so this is now bots response okay i have left [12:35] the state february 16th 8 29 p.m continuing february 16th at 8 30 p.m send daughter and child custody or [12:50] give her to me or give her to me or keep with you you told me you will go to dmv so you left daughter [13:03] do not trouble the daughter listen to your heart not others i will leave my parents and come tomorrow [13:13] if you want to you leave me in such a situation and walk away and arguing on it i have work tomorrow [13:21] stop um what am i supposed to do i had to call out of work yesterday too there are criteria for calling [13:33] out to every 16th at 10 0 2 p.m life which is more important life or work you've put me in a [13:50] situation where i might even lose my job every 16th audio video call when you are alone you talk nicely [14:04] but whoever has been instigating you you may eventually regret audio video call if we could just [14:25] if we could just talk for a moment we could resolve this now do whatever you want february 16th at [14:33] 10 19 p.m raja or deer i'm out of i'm at work please and there's a note from the translator that raja is [14:42] a term of affection like deer or sweetheart if we talk we can work things out otherwise what can i say [14:53] tomorrow saturday nema has doctor's appointment at 10 a.m please take care of it bye february 16th 2024 at [15:07] 10 33 p.m it's extremely busy today and then does nema have insurance right now um and i have work [15:18] tomorrow too what am i supposed to do who should i leave the daughter with yagya is upset and doesn't [15:23] want to i'm sorry i can't read that from the translator leave after it could be yeah um and then at 11 49 p.m [15:55] there are criteria for calling out i called out at last hour yesterday unknown sender unknown sender [16:11] february 17th 9 44 a.m hi nema this is manassas pediatrics you have not completed your registration [16:18] please plan to arrive 20 minutes early to complete this in office and then february 17th at 9 46 a.m [16:28] looks like her phone calls his phone twice um and then a text at 9 46 a.m says nema doesn't have [16:39] insurance how am i supposed to take her 9 48 there is but do whatever your people tell you to do 9 48 [16:51] a.m another call from her phone to his phone and then a text that says i don't have car slash money [16:58] slash phone nothing i can't take her i have work at night starting next week i won't even have money to [17:10] buy diapers for our own daughter if i don't go to work 9 51 a.m your own people must have told you [17:20] that do what they say 951 bye 952 you are responsible for everything because you have everything [17:33] money is more important to you than your daughter and your family you act as though nobody else has [17:39] a job like yours or as if it's such a big deal 10 47 you must care so much about the family that's [17:49] probably why we getting divorced oh so you care that's why you treated my mother father relatives [18:00] and friends so well and brought the police to our home for security 10 57 you forced me to do all that [18:09] i'm human being too uh-huh audio video call february 18th audio video call audio video call i need my keys [18:25] audio video call audio video call audio video call 7 23 pm i put in front of stop sign and then a audio [18:38] video call audio video call um give mandira's by continuing this is bot at 7 37 give mandira's stuff [18:57] and then audio video call we're at 7 35 pm 7 40 audio video call and she sends him a tick tock link and [19:19] then another tick tock link please delete it i don't need to see this please do not provoke me for suicide [19:35] february 18th 2024 10 48 in the evening audio video call poor nemo what kind of stepfather would [19:46] what kind of stepfather she would probably love have sorry i'll read it again poor nemo what kind of [19:56] stepfather she would probably have audio video call you are choosing a wrong way do you think the person [20:07] who advising you for right thing if from think it from your heart take it from your heart confirmed by our [20:27] the paul interpreters the days are coming this february 19th 1 30 a.m the days are coming that you [20:40] will regret a lot you are so cruel you can't do anything for money what kind of husband you'd get [20:53] you'd get next my daughter will suffer more how her stepfather would treat her audio video call [21:04] on february 19th 2024 7 31 a.m happy birthday dear may all your wishes come true 9 38 in the morning [21:22] february 19th i will come to pick our daughter at 10 15 for a few hours if you allow me otherwise you can [21:32] take care of her audio video call 9 44 a.m she is sleeping 9 45 wake her up and get the milk ready [21:46] okay then 9 46 coming now 9 49 i'm getting things ready for our daughter i'll wake her up once [21:57] everything is ready what time will you bring our daughter back i have work tomorrow night i can also [22:02] let you take our daughter if you need to i'll bring her back in a few hours it's at 9 50 9 56 waiting by [22:11] the stop sign 9 58 okay uh at 1006 i haven't fed our daughter any solid food please feed her 12 22 in the [22:34] afternoon unlock my mobile and give it to me i will pick it i will pick up 12 41 no this is my phone i [22:44] earned money to buy this seven plus i have documents and stuff i can't give my effort is there i meant [22:57] the old one no i will not give 12 43 okay 12 44 i'm done with what i needed to do for our daughter [23:17] what time should i drop her off 12 45 you can drop any time okay in the same spot in 10 minutes [23:27] 12 45 okay are you going to take our daughter tomorrow night or not 12 56 waiting here 12 56 audio [23:37] video call 12 57 okay 1 32 p.m audio video call 134 are we going to file our taxes jointly or separately [23:53] and what are we going to do about the police report audio video call 237 reply me or call me back [24:09] 3 30 p.m i will find out and let you know 3 30 audio video call 331 call me once what are you going to [24:19] do about the police 4 36 p.m i will find out everything and let you know later 4 36 audio video call [24:29] 4 38 what is there to find out about the police there's plenty of time for taxes i was thinking [24:37] of doing the taxes next week but there's no time when it comes to the police this had never happened [24:53] on a birthday before even after calling so many times on your birthday look at how much attitude [24:59] you're showing this is what ruins everything between us audio video call 4 46 p.m hi 4 46 audio video call [25:11] february 24 8 38 p.m okay regardless of what sarita and others said what's wrong with writing [25:33] one email for me have you been living with sarita all these years you should at least understand that [25:38] much and i haven't asked you to write anything particular just write whatever it is true whatever [25:44] you told the police or write whatever you feel like in your own way thank you march 18 9 31 p.m text [26:28] message video image sent from tiktok march 6 2024 unknown sender investigator zay zaymas i'm going to [27:32] show you a three-page document have it marked for identification as 453 copy has been provided to [27:40] council first two pages where i'm handing the third page to council now could you take a look at this [27:50] tell us what that is yes these are native text messages between monta kafla's phone and naresh bot's [28:01] phone that's data that you had extracted from naresh bot phone yes is that a true and accurate copy it is [28:08] i offer this into evidence as 453 any objection all right without objection that'll be received as commas 453 [28:59] and permission to publish 453 you may publishes on the wolf describe for the jury what it is we're [29:10] looking at yes always scroll it up just tell us as i'm scrolling what we're looking at okay um this [29:21] is a report from celebrate insights um and it's showing that these are chats and native messages which [29:27] is just the um text messaging app that comes with the iphone so the the regular texting app tell us what [29:57] we're looking at now in the blue bubble yes this is a text message from monta kafla's phone to naresh bot's [30:07] phone um in nepali and the translation is nema is crying what's the date that the phone number [30:18] eight two three six it says to the right of it bad memory is this regarding the bad memory contact name [30:25] that was saved in the rest by phone yeah so that contact is actually associated by the [30:31] software not by that doesn't mean that was in the contacts list in that way so the software is [30:36] pulling that from somewhere else um so it could be from an application it could be from something [30:41] that's deleted but it's associating that with her phone number so this is a message from [30:47] eight two three six to naresh bot phone eight six four three yes this is in the nepali language [30:58] where the sender is saying nema is crying did you read off for us the time stamp that this message was [31:05] sent to naresh bot phone looks like it was sent on july 28th of 2024 at 9 42 p.m just if you go to the [31:17] bottom it has the sent time stamp and it looks like it was read on the 29th at 5 55 p.m we're going to [31:42] look at page two tell us what we're looking at here yes it's another message from monta kafla's phone [31:58] sent shortly after the previous message and um also read on the 29th of july 2024 at 5 55 p.m so sent on [32:09] the 28th read on the 29th yes and what was the message that was sent from eight two three six to [32:17] the rush bot phone it says come fast investigator zamus the utc has it already been converted on [32:49] the message sent by eight two three six yes that's in eastern daylight time can you explain for us what [33:02] we're looking at now this is a um the user of item 101 naresh bot's phone would have um held their finger [33:13] over the text or held something over the text message and liked it so um it it's like he liked [33:20] the message and what was the date that the user of the rush bot phone liked the message from [33:28] eight six four three come fast august 14th 2024 this is the last page investigator zamus can you describe [33:44] for us what we're looking at now yes um this is a previous it looks like some sort of contact attachment [33:52] that was from july 8th of 2024 um and the system message is showing that it was deleted on august 14th [34:02] of 2024 at 11 38 a.m in local time this message was deleted off of where somewhere within that um text [34:13] message thread this message was deleted off of the rest bot phone correct august 14th yes wrapping this up [34:43] did you see any text messages between mop the coughle's phone number and the rest bot phone [34:53] july 30th july 31st august 1st august 2nd no were there any communications from [35:04] mop the coughle number to naresh bot phone ever as far as what you saw in the phone after august 2nd no [35:18] for the questions cross