Try Free

Mother Told Daughter to ‘Fight Off’ Abusive Father: State

Law&Crime Trials November 16, 2026 29m 4,009 words 16 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Mother Told Daughter to ‘Fight Off’ Abusive Father: State from Law&Crime Trials, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 4,009 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"All right. So I'll start addressing some of the things that Ms. Rockett put in her sentencing memorandum. She cited factor nine, trying to sort of underscore the fact that her client cooperated with notified authorities. The state would submit that the proof actually runs to the contrary. That, you"

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: All right. So I'll start addressing some of the things that Ms. Rockett put in her sentencing memorandum. She cited factor nine, trying to sort of underscore the fact that her client cooperated with notified authorities. The state would submit that the proof actually runs to the contrary. That, you know, she eventually came clean to some extent when the authorities interrogated her, but overall she tried desperately to keep this from the authorities. Whether you're thinking about it through the lens of how long this clearly went on for, for years without saying anything about it. You know, her own, by her own statement at one point she said that she first heard about it when Abigail was three. Um, and you know, her search history goes back that, that we could find, went back to August of '22. Um, and you know, a year before the end of the day at range. Um, so she sat on it for a really long time without doing anything to notify the authorities. Eventually something was said and done that I think pushed her over the edge. And so she tried desperately to find someone who could help her keep it in house. Judging by the text, uh, messages between her and, and Patrick Harris, um, he was kind of the perfect candidate. Because he was, you know, her, her bet was that he was going to be such a close personal, uh, to, uh, Benjamin that, you know, he wouldn't feel the need to notify the authorities. But it was only at the insistence of Patrick Harris that the meeting was arranged in the Walmart parking lot, uh, where they initially spoke to the police about these things. What we also know is by then she already started changing her story to some, to some extent regarding how many children had been abused and when she first learned about it. Um, you know, she tried to persist in, uh, false heads when, uh, Detective Wilkinson interviewed her at the, at the, uh, forensic interview. Um, and, um, then eventually she came clean and, and got a little more honest about the time frame. So I, I don't think, you know, the court should put much weight, if any, in factor nine. Factor four, um, you know, saying that the defendant did not play a minor role in these charges. But these charges are facilitation of aggravated rape for child and, uh, aggravated child neglect. Um, she, she is in fact the lead role, uh, for those offenses. Um, I don't think factor four applies. Um, yeah, the change of the law in July, on July 1st of 2021, I, I, I agree with Ms. Rocky's assessment that the law did change. Um, and it changed, uh, in regards to both offenses that she is, uh, stands convicted of today. Um, prior to July 1st, 2021, for the offense of aggravated child neglect, uh, the punishment would be, uh, serve at 85%. And it cannot be reduced, uh, below 70%. I believe after July 1st, 2021, that becomes 100. Um, same with facilitation of aggravated rape for child, but prior to July 1st, 2021, facilitation of rape for child, aggravated child, what have you. Um, I believe, uh, would be 30%. And it was changed to, uh, 100% after, uh, July 1st, 2021. Um, I believe. Um, I believe. But, at any rate, where counts 17 and 19 are concerned, um, we're talking about Abigail Garlick. So, what I want to address is whether or not there's proof in the record for Your Honor to, um, for Your Honor to refer to that would indicate that the jury's verdict does not pertain to anything that occurred between the beginning of the date range. Because, remember, the, the provenance of the start range, start date of the range, is that is Abigail Garlick's third birthday. So, and that's based on people's recollections that things happened. The, um, let's see. Um, and so that's gonna be February the 13th of 2021. So, we're dealing with, you know, about four months and a couple weeks between that birthday and, uh, the change in the law. Um, her testimony, or, or at least her forensic interview transcript is what I've put up, put up on the screen here. You know, um, and, and I do, I mean, I applaud Miss Rocky for, sort of, taking a stand on, you know, election issues, uh, and, sort of, to where the state decided, okay, fine, we'll elect. Um, but, what we elected was the incident wherein, uh, she was, she was, uh, performing fellatio and remembered her mother telling her, telling her to fight him off physically, uh, the next time he tried something. Um. [00:05:51] Speaker 2: And is this, are you talking about a specific count? I'm sorry? I don't have the elections in front of me. So, what count are you, I just want to make sure I'm following on the counts of your argument. [00:06:03] Speaker 1: Um, I've got them right. [00:06:06] Speaker 2: Well, I've got the verdict form, so that would. [00:06:13] Speaker 1: Right, so, uh, it, yeah, I mean, I guess it should be reproduced on there. So, uh, the way to think about it is 17 and 19 are both. Right. All right, so, um, the facilitation of aggravated rape for the child in the state's election, uh, says, refers to her allowing Benjamin Garlic to have continued access to her after she told, uh, Chantel, uh, that Benjamin had sexually abused her, where said access resulted in Benjamin Garlic subsequently making an act of fellatio upon him during which she recalled Chantel Garlic advising Abigail Garlic to defend herself by hitting Benjamin Garlic. Okay. Big mouthful, uh, but all that to say that it does refer to that specific incident. Now, I, I'm firmly of the opinion that, uh, you know, despite the fact that there is no, uh, existing case law on, on point, that facilitation of sex offenses such as this should be considered an ongoing offense, just as, uh, a course of conduct, ongoing offense, just as child neglect is, uh, in the case law. Uh, but, you know, in abundance of caution, we went ahead and elected because there is no such case law authority as of, as of now. I will point out that if you look exactly at what the child says in her forensic, which would have been substantive proof before the jury, um, she says, you know, um, let's see. So she says, I don't like it. [00:07:48] Speaker ?: He, I, I, I don't want to hit him. My mom says to hit him. [00:07:50] Speaker 1: Now, it's hard to even tell whether or not her mother told her to do that on one occasion, or more than one occasion when she went to her mother to report what was going on with her. Um, in essence, this could technically apply to multiple different, uh, instances. Um, incidents where she has that thought in her head. Um, and, you know, it's, it's hard to say, but I do think that one thing that the court can glean fairly and infer fairly from the, from the proof is that any incident where she is engaged engaged in this activity at the behest of Benjamin Garlick is going to post-date a point at which Chantel Garlick has reached a level of resignation, uh, to where instead of taking the information from her child and, you know, I would think initially trying to shut it down. Uh, first of all, ascertain whether or not it's, there's actually something to it. Um, according to, to her statements, you know, Benjamin blamed his porn addiction and, you know, and that was the problem. So, uh, I, I think it could be fairly inferred that she took that as some kind of, you know, this is what's going to be the cure is I'll get over my porn addiction. And, uh, but by the time this is happening, we've had incidents where, and according to her testimony, she told her mother about this stuff numerous times, numerous times. And by the time the incident of her memory, uh, at issue here is happening, we've reached a place where, where Chantel has, has abandoned, you know, the, the thought, uh, that she is going to be able to effectively stop it. She's resigned, it's going to continue, and her advice to her child is to fight him off. Now, you know, that, is it possible that that happened in the four months, all contained in the four months, um, and two weeks between, uh, her third birthday and the change in the law, I, I submit it's not reasonably likely. Um, now, counts 18 and 20. [00:10:33] Speaker 2: Let, let me, let me just follow up with a question. Go ahead. I think you covered this briefly, but remind me of where the suggestion of the, the third birthday. That's the beginning of the date range as charged in the indictment. No, I understand that. I'm saying how did the state, again, come to that? [00:10:56] Speaker 1: Statements made by both Abigail and, uh, Sean, and the defendant, Chantel. [00:11:01] Speaker 2: And it was, was the, were the statements just the statement of this has been going on two years? [00:11:06] Speaker 1: Yeah, it started when I was three, you know, or, um, or, in Chantel's case, she said, I first heard about it two years ago, right? So, um, and I, and I can't remember whether or not Chantel specifically said when she was three. Um, but I, the, the reason that that was the date designated was because it was the third birthday of. Um. I mean, you could have. I mean, you could post, if, if all Chantel Barlich said to the police when, or to Patrick Harris and his testimony was that she first learned about it two years ago, I guess you could just post, like, back date two years from the date that she's having that communication. Well, start the clock then? [00:11:57] Speaker 2: I mean, that was going to be my, my question. So if we're looking at August of 2023, okay, which is the trip to North Carolina, the, uh, communication with Patrick Harris, uh, the, um, uh, involvement of police. I mean, that's August of 2023. And so if the statement is eventually I've known about it for two years or about two years or around two years or whatever that exact statement was, um, the state picked the birthday just because, Hey, this started when I was three. I mean, it's, it's just a date. [00:12:41] Speaker 1: Well, and it's a, and it's a, and we're also contemplating the charges against Benjamin Garlick, which has nothing to do with when she first told her mother. No, I understand. [00:12:50] Speaker 2: Okay. Um, I mean, from, from my memory of the proof and, and Ms. Rocky, um, if you want to respond to this kind of sub point now before you like, you kind of forget it or what have you, not that you would, I don't mind hearing from you or you can just, I'll hear from you as the rest. So either way, I know you're going to have a lot to say about not only, uh, release eligibility, um, but I guess also, uh, uh, merger as well thing. Um, okay. I think that, I think I understand what the state's point is. Okay. [00:13:31] Speaker 1: Um, and I will also leave it to, uh, Ms. Rocky, but I'm, I would like someone to point to where facilitation is listed in 4035, 501. AA post, post, uh, July 1st of 2021, um, as far as it being included as a 100%. Uh, cause when I'm looking at 40, when I'm looking at 4035, 501 AA as it presently exists, as of today, it lists all of those offenses that we're talking about here, you know, rape the child. Um, but, you know, at the end of the list, it says, um, conspiracy to commit any of these offenses, criminal attempt to commit any of these offenses, or solicitation to commit any of these offenses. Um, so, I don't doubt that facilitation is included, given the breadth of it, but I just, when I was looking at it in preparation for the hearing just now, I was having trouble finding the word facilitation in that statute. Um, at any rate. Which helps Ms. Rocky. Which helps Ms. Rocky. I'm just trying, you know, I'm, I'm not trying to, uh, to mistake the law. I'm trying to get it right so we don't have to deal with this again. And, um, and, um, and, you know, the law is the law. Alright, so, these are, this is the situation here. So, let's talk about the, um, in, it counts 18 and 20. Here's, here's the thing about, from our trial, I don't have a transcript, but for, but clearly from both, uh, uh, Ms. Moore's trial notes and, uh, Ms. Reddick's trial notes. There are clear notations that, that mirror each other that, uh, trial testimony on direct, she testified that she thought she was six or seven when the hotel incident occurred. Um, you know, she turned, uh, six years old on, uh, May the 22nd, 2021. So again, in this instance, we just have a little over a month difference between when she turned six. I would also submit that when someone is saying I would have been six or seven, they're clearly not trying to indicate they just turned six, right? If anything, they're well into six, closer to seven. Um, that's what she testified to on direct. On cross, she clarified that she was seven when the hotel incident occurred. Um, so she would have turned seven, May 22nd, 2022, well after the law change. Um, and so I think that there is proof in the record that, uh, was, you know, that from places, uh, the date associated with these offenses, uh, beyond the, the change in the law. [00:16:58] Speaker 2: And that's, that would be as to both counts, uh, 18 and 20. That's correct. Okay. [00:17:06] Speaker ?: Okay. Okay. [00:17:08] Speaker 1: Merger is another thing brought up by, uh, Ms. Rocky and her memorandum. So my understanding of the law, and, and I haven't done a ton of research on, on these counts. I would agree with Ms. Rocky that they arise from the same, uh, transit, act or transaction. Uh, where I would disagree is, is, you know, the, the language that basically comes after that, which is, you know, a court next examines the statutes to determine whether the crimes of which the defendant was convicted constitute the same offense. Uh, if each statutory offense includes an element not contained in the other, the offenses are disdained. So, I, I, under the circumstances, uh, I, I believe that there are, um, you know, one is, is attached to, uh, I mean, for instance, there's the element of especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, and neglect. Um, and, uh, for facilitation of, uh, uh, aggravated rape child, um, there is also, there is, uh, the actual sexual offense that was facilitated contains elements that are not required under, uh, neglect. Um, as such, I would submit that they're standalone convictions, um, and, you know, when I was thinking about it, I was thinking that, you know, you could have a situation where someone was, someone would facilitate, uh, a rape good child, um, but have a slightly different relationship, or would have, it would have occurred over a less, uh, lengthy period of time. I know Ms. Rocky's gonna say we've gotta be tied to our one incident, um, but, um, but, but, not for neglect. Neglect is ongoing. So, I could see a situation where, where someone, uh, could be, uh, convicted of, or could facilitate rape for a child, but, uh, the portion of especially heinous, nutritious, or cruel under different circumstances would be insufficient because it's not the child. Because it's not the child's mother, or so forth, or so on. Um, enhancement factors are the same that, as far as particular vulnerability because of age, again, for, uh, should be eight for ag rape of a child. Uh, and as much as we're tied to ag rape of a child, uh, due to the election, um, she's still significantly younger than that. Um, and I would echo, uh, some of the sentiments that, uh, Your Honor raised regarding homeschooling and, and everything else in your ruling on Mr. Garland. [00:20:12] Speaker 2: Um, can I ask you, going back just briefly, to counts 19 and 20? Sure. The, the state, um, made an election, uh, and I think we would all agree, I mean, it's a very, uh, it's, it's kind of an all-encompassing election, uh, generic might be a word. And that is that following the disclosure that, uh, uh, in count 19, um, ABGs, uh, being sexually abused by Benjamin Garlick, that, uh, subjected her to years of, was an election necessary based on the charge of aggravated child neglect? No. Because there were two separate, um, victims. [00:21:10] Speaker ?: Right. [00:21:11] Speaker 1: I mean, I think Miss, Miss Rocky's argument is that it's not counts 19 and 20 that are an issue for merger. It's going to be counts 18 and 20 are an issue for merger, and counts, uh, 17 and 19 are an issue for merger. [00:21:27] Speaker 2: No, I understand that, but I guess my point is, um, or my thought, I mean, 17 and 18, um, are specific. I mean, the, the election is, is specific. And so, and Miss Rocky, I'm neither trying to make nor not make an argument on your behalf, but why couldn't count 19 and 20 encompass everything except 17 and 18 within the proof? And, and I'm kind of going back to this merger argument. Right. I'm, I'm. Which would not, which would not require a merger. [00:22:07] Speaker 1: I would certainly agree that, that there was no election required in the neglect counts because of the clear case law that it's an ongoing offense. And I think what your honor is opposing means is, is, I guess I, are you saying the state could have said in its election that? [00:22:28] Speaker 2: I'm not saying the election is, is faulty. I'm just saying could, could one look at this, uh, and say, okay, 19 and 20 stand on their own because those encompass, let's just say two years. Uh, we've used that term and I think that's, that's very consistent with testimony. Um, and just because there's one act within those two years that is elected within, and I'll ask you, Miss Rocky, the same questions in just a moment, just, just, uh, in reverse. Um, what, why would they have to merge just because 17 and 18 as elected would have naturally occurred within that two year period that formed the basis for 19 and 20? [00:23:14] Speaker 1: Right. So, I mean, I think there's also a different analysis as they're not from victim to victim because in the case of, uh, you have, uh, facilitation of a specific rape of a child incident, right? Um, and then there's the language in recognition of the fact that the state need not elect a specific incident and it's an ongoing course of conduct defense that is subjected to two years of abuse. Um, and then there's, when you're talking about there is only the other one. That's only the proof that was before the, before the jury was that, um, you know, she, it happened to her once, she told her mom about it and it happened to her again in the hotel and that's it. Okay. So, alright. However your honor wants to deal with that, you know, I think we might be sort of in, in, uh, case of first impression territory on some of these things. I don't think there's any case law directly on point for, for all of the stuff, but, um, at any rate. Um, enhancement factors, I think four applies, factor 14, uh, the position of public or private trust, again, I think that clearly applies across the board. Um, so consecutive sentencing, we've already been over this aspect of it, um, and the nature of the proof that's going to be before the court, um, regarding two offenses that must, uh, you know, with, with the consideration given to these other, uh, factors. Um, you know, I'm the, to the extent that this is an argument raised by Ms. Rocky in her, in her memorandum, I think it, I think it is. Uh, the specific language of 435.115, uh, B5 is, you know, statutory offenses involving sexual abuse of a minor, right? Um, and, the statute really doesn't speak at all to whether other offenses, especially those that happen to relate directly back to sexual abuse of minors are off limits for, uh, consecutive sentencing once that criteria is met or established. Um, so I don't really know, you know, I mean, is, if it, if aggravated child neglect, um, wherein the especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, uh, element is sort of tied to the fact of the sexual abuse. Um, whether or not those are fair game for consecutive sentencing. Um, you know, the, the word statutory, I think it would be something an appellate panel might hang, might hang on or pay close attention to, but I don't know. Maybe they wouldn't. Um, these are certainly all offenses that involve sexual abuse of the minor. She was negligent because she allowed sexual abuse to go on. Um, and you know, she facilitated specific instances of rape of a child, um, because those instances occurred after she knew about it. Um, so, I don't, um, you know, it might be that, that, you know, the court's gotta sort of pick one or the, one or the other. I, I don't know. But, uh, certainly the facilitation of rape of a child is going to apply, uh, to the definition because it would be as, in as much as that, the offensive facilitation attempt conspiracy is gonna necessarily incorporate the elements of the offense that's been facilitated or conspired to or solicited, uh, I think it's gonna meet the statute. Um, so, again, I, I do think consecutive sentencing applies, you know, whether or not, um, the court feels there's any kind of cause for merger, um, or, uh, whether or not the court feels there's some kind of limitations to the consecutive, uh, sentencing statute as applied to the neglect, uh, counts. Uh, I would submit that the proof is, uh, sufficient to show that, that the defendant should be sentenced in accordance with the laws that existed after July 1st, 2021, first of all. Um, that consecutive sentencing should apply and that based upon, uh, the enhancement factors present, uh, she should be considered near the top of the range. And, um, what I've always gone back to is that statement from the forensic interview, um, which sort of hit me like a bolt of lightning for the first time I ever heard it. When she said, "Mom tells me to fight 'em off." I mean, there was proof in the record of what she weighed at a doctor's business and it was like 30-something pounds, you know, at five, um, when she went to our kids, um, you know, it clearly began when she weighed a lot less than that. A lot less than that. And it went on for an extended period of time. And, um, the, the level of betrayal involved, um, from a mother. Because, I mean, if you, if you can't look to your mother for protection, then who can you look to? Um, I think that it, it truly shocks the conscience, um, and the, the state would ask that, uh, Ms. Garlick, uh, receive, uh, no less than, uh, 20 years to serve. [00:29:20] Speaker 2: to serve.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →