About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Mamta Kafle Bhatt Trial: Naresh Bhatt Faces Cross-Examination — Part 2 — Nov 5 from JH, published November 21, 2026. The transcript contains 11,066 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Welcome back thank you thank you step back a little bit and then we will launch forward with some more you told us. You never ever put your hands on mom correct? Yes, never no domestic violence at all. Yes. You heard through testimony that Mamta is telling other people something different, right?..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Welcome back thank you thank you step back a little bit and then we will launch forward with some more you told us. You never ever put your hands on mom correct? Yes, never no domestic violence at all. Yes. You heard through testimony that Mamta is telling other people something different, right? Yes. Why is Mamta saying that you are abusing her? I don't know. Could it be because you are or you were? I don't know. The rice feeding ceremony that was December of 2023, right?
[00:00:59] Nuresh Bhatt: Somewhere I don't recall the exact date somewhere November end or December beginning somewhere I don't know.
[00:01:05] Speaker 1: And you said that date got changed.
[00:01:09] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:01:10] Speaker 1: Why?
[00:01:11] Nuresh Bhatt: Because Mamta has some injury.
[00:01:13] Speaker 1: Yeah, where?
[00:01:15] Nuresh Bhatt: On the basement, not the basement, middle floor.
[00:01:17] Speaker 1: And how did she get this injury?
[00:01:21] Nuresh Bhatt: As per her, she fell down the stairs, last stairs with the jacket, something like that.
[00:01:26] Speaker 1: She told you? Yes. That she fell down the stairs?
[00:01:30] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:01:31] Speaker 1: This was in December of 2023?
[00:01:35] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know exactly in December or somewhere. It was like first date, before first date of rice feeding ceremony.
[00:01:43] Speaker 1: I'm going to show you what I'm having marked for identification as 455.
[00:01:54] Speaker 3: Of course you may.
[00:02:03] Speaker 1: Is that a photograph?
[00:02:05] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:02:06] Speaker 1: What is that a photograph of?
[00:02:08] Nuresh Bhatt: Mamta.
[00:02:11] Speaker 1: Is this a communication Mamta was making to you?
[00:02:24] Nuresh Bhatt: I believe yes.
[00:02:27] Speaker 1: This is your Facebook Messenger account, correct?
[00:02:33] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:02:35] Speaker 1: Mamta's communicating with you on December 11, 2023, correct?
[00:02:47] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:02:47] Speaker 1: Are these true and accurate depictions of what Mamta looked like on December 11, 2023?
[00:02:57] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know the date. Yes, she's Mamta.
[00:03:00] Speaker 1: But is this what she looked like in December of 2023?
[00:03:07] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know that.
[00:03:09] Speaker 1: You said she had an injury?
[00:03:11] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:03:11] Speaker 1: Where?
[00:03:12] Nuresh Bhatt: She has like somewhere, I forgot which side, somewhere right side or left side, somewhere here.
[00:03:20] Speaker 1: On her face? She had an injury? Yes. And she sent you a photograph of the injury to her face.
[00:03:25] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:03:26] Speaker 1: This is the photo of her injury to her face?
[00:03:28] Nuresh Bhatt: Similar, but exactly. I don't recall. Similar photo. Yes.
[00:03:31] Speaker 1: So this is a true and accurate depiction of what Mamta looked like in December of 2023, correct?
[00:03:37] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:03:38] Speaker 1: I offer this withdrawal. One more question. This is a screenshot that Mamta has taken from her device, correct?
[00:03:48] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know that.
[00:03:49] Speaker 1: Well, you're the IT guy. Take a look at the exhibit.
[00:03:54] Nuresh Bhatt: IT guy doesn't mean I'm IT for the Facebook or something like that. Sure.
[00:03:57] Speaker 1: But this is a screenshot, correct?
[00:04:01] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:04:01] Speaker 1: And this is a screenshot to you, Nuresh Bhatt?
[00:04:06] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:04:07] Speaker 1: That's a true and accurate screenshot that Mamta sent to you in December of 2023, correct?
[00:04:13] Nuresh Bhatt: No. She did not send me this screenshot. She sent me the picture. As far as I remember, she sent me the real picture, not the screenshot.
[00:04:27] Speaker 1: She sent you the picture?
[00:04:28] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:04:29] Speaker 1: But is this a true and accurate depiction of what Mamta looked like in December of 2023?
[00:04:34] Nuresh Bhatt: Mamta looked like, but I don't know about this screenshot. Mamta looked like, yes.
[00:04:38] Speaker 1: Got it. So with that foundation, I'll offer this entire document into evidence as Commonwealth's 455. 455? 455, yes.
[00:04:50] Speaker 3: Okay. Any objection? Judge, I don't have an objection. All right. Without objection, that will be received.
[00:04:59] Speaker 4: I'm sorry, what was the number again?
[00:05:01] Speaker 3: 455.
[00:05:02] Speaker 4: I'm sorry, what was the number again?
[00:05:03] Speaker ?: 455.
[00:05:11] Speaker 3: Permits to publish. Of course.
[00:05:16] Speaker 1: Mr. Bob, you see what's being published for the jury right now?
[00:05:35] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:05:35] Speaker 1: That's blood on Mamta's hand, correct? Yes. And that's blood in her nose, correct?
[00:05:43] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:05:44] Speaker 1: And that's a bruise under her right eye, correct?
[00:05:49] Nuresh Bhatt: Looks like yes.
[00:05:52] Speaker 1: He also sent you a video on top of this photograph, correct?
[00:06:08] Nuresh Bhatt: I do not exactly recall. She sent me yes.
[00:06:15] Speaker 1: What does that say right underneath that video?
[00:06:19] Nuresh Bhatt: This is second time.
[00:06:21] Speaker 1: What does that mean to you, sir?
[00:06:24] Nuresh Bhatt: Whatever she's sending is just, not first, is second time. That's what she's saying.
[00:06:29] Speaker 1: Meaning this is the second time you've injured her, correct?
[00:06:33] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[00:06:34] Speaker 1: So this is the second time that she sent you these photographs of herself?
[00:06:38] Nuresh Bhatt: I did not injure. I did not, even like when this happened, even I wasn't in the ground floor. I was on the upstairs floor.
[00:06:45] Speaker 1: I know you're saying you were somewhere else, but she's saying this is the second time you caused this injury, correct?
[00:06:52] Nuresh Bhatt: That is the, uh, uh, this word saying yes.
[00:06:55] Speaker 1: And as soon as she says to you, this is the second time, you don't ask, how you doing? Are you okay? You're saying to her, I'll sign the divorce papers.
[00:07:05] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:07:08] Speaker 1: Why are you trying to divorce her when she sends you photographs of her abuse to her face?
[00:07:14] Nuresh Bhatt: I did not abuse, she falls somewhere.
[00:07:17] Speaker 1: That's not my question.
[00:07:18] Nuresh Bhatt: Okay.
[00:07:19] Speaker 1: My question is.
[00:07:20] Speaker 3: He's asked the question with words. He's trying to respond. You have to let him respond.
[00:07:27] Speaker 1: Sorry, Judge. This is the second time. Your response to her is, I can sign divorce papers, correct? Did I read it right?
[00:07:43] Nuresh Bhatt: You read it right.
[00:07:45] Speaker 1: Read the next line after you say, I can sign divorce papers.
[00:07:49] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't want this.
[00:07:54] Speaker 1: What does that mean?
[00:07:55] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't want, like, whatever, like, on the picture, I don't want this.
[00:08:00] Speaker 1: Meaning you don't want to see these photos anymore?
[00:08:03] Nuresh Bhatt: No. Because what she happens, she tried to tell me, like, I have done it because I wasn't, I wasn't even there. So that's, I'm not responsible for that.
[00:08:17] Speaker 1: I'm going to hand you a photograph that mark it as 456 for identification. Tell me if you recognize this photograph.
[00:08:31] Nuresh Bhatt: The larger form of this photo, I guess.
[00:08:33] Speaker 1: And that's what Mopta looked like in 2023? In December of 2023? When you say look like, what do you mean? That's, all right. In 2023, this is a photo of what Mopta looked like at that time, correct?
[00:08:54] Nuresh Bhatt: I did not see her at that time. When she was taking a picture and then sending me, I don't see her at all at that time. I was upstairs, she was downstairs.
[00:09:04] Speaker 1: Let's try this. I'm publishing, I'm publishing 455. I have before you, another document, 456, right?
[00:09:25] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:09:27] Speaker 1: 456 is just a clearer, bigger image of what's in front of you right now?
[00:09:35] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:09:36] Speaker 1: I offer this into evidence as commonwealths 456.
[00:09:39] Speaker 3: No objection. All right. Without objection, that'll be received.
[00:09:42] Speaker 1: Commissioner Publish.
[00:09:43] Speaker 3: You may.
[00:09:46] Speaker ?: This is a better image than the screenshot she sent to me. This is a better image than the screenshot she sent to me.
[00:09:54] Speaker 1: This is a better image than the screenshot she sent to you, correct?
[00:10:17] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:10:18] Speaker 1: Again, it's even clearer that she has blood on her hands, correct?
[00:10:24] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:10:25] Speaker 1: And her nose.
[00:10:26] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:10:27] Speaker 1: And a bruise to her right eye.
[00:10:29] Nuresh Bhatt: Looks like yes.
[00:10:31] Speaker 1: You're saying you did not do this to her?
[00:10:34] Nuresh Bhatt: If I have to, like, why does she have to send the picture to me? I wasn't there.
[00:10:38] Speaker 1: As proof of domestic violence.
[00:10:43] Nuresh Bhatt: It's not right.
[00:10:45] Speaker 1: It's not right.
[00:10:46] Nuresh Bhatt: No, picture is right. Picture is right, but like I did, it's not right. I never touched at all in my whole life. Never. Not only Mamta, not any family member, not at all.
[00:10:59] Speaker 1: The only time you touched Mamta is when you chopped her up?
[00:11:02] Nuresh Bhatt: That was after Mamta left.
[00:11:04] Speaker 1: The only time you touched Mamta is when you're stuffing her into a trash can? That's the only times you touched her?
[00:11:11] Nuresh Bhatt: I touched means, like, physically touched means, like, this whole life we touched. That doesn't mean, like, I beat her or, you know, something like that.
[00:11:19] Speaker 1: Then what's this photograph?
[00:11:22] Nuresh Bhatt: Doesn't mean necessarily I beat her?
[00:11:25] Speaker 1: Isn't this Mamta saying to you and to all of us, you did this to her?
[00:11:30] Nuresh Bhatt: I did not.
[00:11:30] Speaker 1: She also shared it with her family. Is she misleading them to think that you're some horrific monster?
[00:11:45] Nuresh Bhatt: No. No. No.
[00:11:46] Speaker 1: I'm going to approach the witness with two additional photographs, have them marked as 457 and 458. Copies being provided to the house.
[00:12:34] Speaker ?: Let's see.
[00:12:46] Speaker 3: Approach. You may.
[00:13:06] Speaker 1: Recognize these photographs? Yes. What are they photographs of?
[00:13:09] Nuresh Bhatt: Monta.
[00:13:11] Speaker 1: This is what mocked would look like in December of 2023?
[00:13:15] Nuresh Bhatt: Somewhere, at some point.
[00:13:18] Speaker 1: And these are true and accurate depictions of what she looked like in December of 2023, correct?
[00:13:25] Nuresh Bhatt: Looks like, yes.
[00:13:26] Speaker 1: All of these in evidence is Commonwealth's 456.
[00:13:29] Speaker 3: You already have 457.
[00:13:30] Speaker 1: Sorry, 457 and 458. Sorry, Judge. Any objection? One moment.
[00:13:34] Speaker 3: Wait. There's not a question. Any objection? I object because I think he wants to qualify something about those photographs. Well, I need a question for him to qualify.
[00:13:45] Speaker 1: I can step it back. Let's have Mr. Bach qualify the photograph.
[00:13:49] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't believe this is at my home.
[00:13:52] Speaker 1: Okay.
[00:13:53] Nuresh Bhatt: Because I see the cows on the back, but I don't know where she take the picture, but look like the cows. We have a leather cows. These are different cows. I don't know where it is.
[00:14:02] Speaker 1: But as far as like Manta's face, that's what she looked like in December of 2023?
[00:14:06] Nuresh Bhatt: Looked like a little different, but like similar, but not the same.
[00:14:11] Speaker 1: Other than where she took the photo, that's Manta, that's what she looked like in December of 2023?
[00:14:17] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. I don't know where she took the photo, and then I see the background. That's not look like, you know, we don't have any type of these type of furniture at home.
[00:14:25] Speaker 1: I hope this is in evidence as 457, 458.
[00:14:28] Speaker 3: I don't have an objection. All right. Without objection, those are received. I'll be sure. You may.
[00:14:41] Speaker 1: What's happening to your wife's right eye?
[00:14:54] Speaker 5: There is a redness underneath the eye. It's a bruise, right? Bruise, I know. Dug.
[00:15:01] Nuresh Bhatt: Dug, yeah.
[00:15:03] Speaker 1: Bruce, yes. You did that, right?
[00:15:06] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[00:15:08] Speaker 1: 458. They focused on your wife's right eye. What's happening to your wife's right eye in this photograph? It's smaller than the prior. It's healing, correct?
[00:15:31] Nuresh Bhatt: It's smaller than before.
[00:15:34] Speaker 5: It's the same picture. It's just better than before.
[00:15:41] Speaker 1: You did this to Mamta?
[00:15:45] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[00:15:46] Speaker 1: Again, according to you, this is from her falling down the stairs. It's according to Mamta. According to Mamta, who's not here to tell us this? But according to you, this is an injury.
[00:16:10] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:16:11] Speaker 1: A moth of falling down the stairs. Yes. The stairs are flat, correct?
[00:16:21] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know how to describe.
[00:16:26] Speaker 1: It's like this. I don't know how to describe. We're not talking about, like, a jagged mountain. We're talking about a flat piece of stairs, right? And she only hits her right eye and her right nostril.
[00:16:49] Speaker 6: We're talking about a mountain. We're talking about this chair. I know.
[00:16:55] Speaker 1: Moving on. I'll pass the report.
[00:17:06] Speaker 5: Thank you. Thank you.
[00:17:37] Speaker 1: Mr. Bott, you saw in these, you saw in this text message exchange from your wife, On exhibit 455, not only did she send you two photographs, she sent you a video, an 11-second video. Do you remember seeing that on this exhibit?
[00:18:19] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:18:20] Speaker 1: Judge, I'm going to have this thumb drive marked as 459. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council.
[00:18:54] Speaker ?: I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:27] Speaker 1: I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:28] Speaker 3: I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:29] Speaker ?: I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:29] Speaker 3: I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:30] Speaker ?: I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council. I'll show it to the council.
[00:19:46] Speaker 5: I'll show it to the council.
[00:20:05] Speaker 1: And permission. I've shown Ms. Lennox permission to approach. Mr. Bot. Sir, I've just shown you a video of this thumb drive. Who is that a video of?
[00:20:37] Nuresh Bhatt: Can I see one more time?
[00:20:38] Speaker ?: OK.
[00:20:44] Nuresh Bhatt: Question.
[00:20:45] Speaker 1: Who is that a video of?
[00:20:47] Nuresh Bhatt: Mamda.
[00:20:48] Speaker 1: Is that what Mamda looked like in December of 2023? Yes. This is a video that Mamda sent to you in December 2023. Correct?
[00:20:58] Nuresh Bhatt: I believe a little different.
[00:21:01] Speaker 1: But that's what Mamda looked like in December 2023?
[00:21:07] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:21:08] Speaker 1: I'll open this into evidence as Commonwealth's 459. No objection.
[00:21:11] Speaker 3: Without objection. That'll be received.
[00:21:16] Speaker 1: Permission to publish.
[00:21:17] Speaker ?: You may.
[00:21:17] Speaker 3: For the record, this is a two-second video.
[00:21:24] Speaker ?: For the record, this is a two-second video.
[00:21:36] Speaker 1: I'm stopping at one second. Thank you, Mr. Bot.
[00:21:56] Speaker ?: Mr. Bot.
[00:21:56] Speaker 1: This is a video that Mamda sent to you, correct? Which one?
[00:22:03] Nuresh Bhatt: Which one I don't recall. I don't recall. Similar. Some sort of video she sent me, but I don't recall which one.
[00:22:12] Speaker 1: This is what Mamda's right eye looked like in December of 2023?
[00:22:18] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. She has something here as well. I don't see that somewhere, somewhere around here.
[00:22:22] Speaker 1: That's her face swollen. That's her face swollen.
[00:22:25] Nuresh Bhatt: No, black spot at that time. That's what I recall, not 100%, something I see like that.
[00:22:30] Speaker 1: And this is a bruise, right? Yeah, the redness coming out of her eye, that's a bruise. Again, sir, you're certified life-saving measures, correct?
[00:22:43] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know the bruise or not, but like the .
[00:22:46] Speaker 5: I don't know if it's bruise or what, but I see there's a red mark in there.
[00:22:51] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know the exact meaning of bruise.
[00:22:54] Speaker 5: I don't.
[00:22:55] Nuresh Bhatt: Exact meaning of bruise. I don't know the exact meaning of bruise.
[00:22:59] Speaker 3: Okay, I'm going to ask you to put the mic up so that when you're speaking in English, the jurors can hear you.
[00:23:04] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know the exact meaning of the bruise.
[00:23:06] Speaker 1: Blood vessels have broken in her eye from making impact with something, correct? That's a bruise? Yes.
[00:23:13] Nuresh Bhatt: Okay.
[00:23:27] Speaker 1: Judge, I'm going to have another thumb drive marked as Commonwealth's 460.
[00:23:33] Speaker 3: Okay. Ms. Lennox, have you seen this one? I've seen it. Okay. Perfect.
[00:23:42] Speaker 1: And permission to approach. Of course. Ms. Clark, I'm going to show you in an 11-second video. Tell me if you recognize who this person is. Yes.
[00:23:52] Nuresh Bhatt: You recognize that?
[00:23:53] Speaker 1: Yes. Who's that? Mamta. This is Mamta in December of 2023. And I'll play the video so you can. Yes.
[00:24:04] Nuresh Bhatt: Can you make a little bit, yes. Louder? Yes. From the start. So something going on in the background. I don't hear that.
[00:24:12] Speaker ?: Sure. This video that I played.
[00:24:14] Speaker 1: This is a true and accurate video recording of your wife in December 2023. this is a true and accurate video recording of your wife in December yes evidence as commonwealth 460. All right without objection that will be received.
[00:24:48] Speaker 3: I played the video once I'm going to play again to see if we can get more
[00:25:18] Speaker 1: volume from this video feed playing the video it's the bot yes it sounds like somebody's speaking Nepali yes who's speaking in the background my mother mother what is your mother saying in this video it's not clear
[00:25:58] Nuresh Bhatt: can I I'm gonna listen one more time say the answer it's not clear I want to listen one more time it's not clear I will play the video again my mom is saying tomorrow or day after tomorrow I have to go something like that
[00:26:25] Speaker 1: where is Manta in this video where is she in the house
[00:26:31] Nuresh Bhatt: I cannot see on the background look like a little bit more I can see the windows but I don't know where the windows are exactly
[00:26:48] Speaker 1: yes that's the master bedroom correct
[00:26:50] Nuresh Bhatt: I can you a little bit more
[00:26:56] Speaker 1: yes look to the right yes of the of Manta's left ear yes I see that white bathtub I see that that's the bathtub that you dropped Manta into correct I see that so this is in your house yes your mom can clearly be heard in this video yes where are you I was on the master room so when did Manta according to you fall down and get this injury
[00:27:26] Nuresh Bhatt: uh evening somewhere like she sent me the picture first and then video picture everything and then it was evening I don't recall the exact time seven eight nine something like eight between eight to
[00:27:36] Speaker 1: nine something like that she just sent you a picture she said one two three plus yes videos yes this is her just documenting an accident where she falls down the stairs could you repeat the question one more time Manta went through a lot of efforts to document this would you agree with me to document this would you agree with me on that yes yes yes Manta sent you two photos a video made another video made another photo Manta went through great lengths to make sure this gets preserved forever
[00:28:35] Speaker 6: looks like yes Manta looks like yes and you're saying she's
[00:28:41] Speaker 1: created all this evidence all this evidence to document an accident
[00:28:47] Speaker 4: whatever that happened I wasn't even there that not happened on the upstairs that happened in the downstairs
[00:29:03] Speaker 1: that happened in the downstairs I just have to ask the question before I move on you did this to her right no you're gonna just stand by that you never put your hands on her never she's just creating documentation subject to interpretation I don't know that if Manta was here what would she say about this
[00:29:27] Nuresh Bhatt: she might gonna say the truth she's gonna say that she
[00:29:30] Speaker 1: recorded herself after falling down a flight of stairs I'm gonna move on from this I'm gonna hand 460 to the court
[00:30:02] Speaker 3: he has 459 right there as well it's the thumb drive right by your left hand
[00:30:08] Speaker 1: yes Ashish friend of yours
[00:30:23] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:30:24] Speaker 1: good friend
[00:30:28] Nuresh Bhatt: not good not bad it's a friend
[00:30:32] Speaker 1: got you a good deal on a really nice house right
[00:30:35] Nuresh Bhatt: no I gave him like no give me this offer I I put the money I gave him like you know I want to put only this much money
[00:30:44] Speaker 1: okay
[00:30:47] Nuresh Bhatt: it was like I searched that home for almost a year
[00:30:50] Speaker 1: it's a beautiful house beautiful
[00:30:57] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:30:58] Speaker 1: that's a house where a happy family should be today
[00:31:03] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:31:05] Speaker 1: because of you that's never going to be the case
[00:31:09] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:31:12] Speaker 1: Ashish you heard him testify correct
[00:31:17] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:31:18] Speaker 1: did he lie
[00:31:22] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't think so but just some mistakes but that's not lie
[00:31:25] Speaker 1: let's let's iron those mistakes out
[00:31:28] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:31:28] Speaker 1: Ashish testified that he came over to talk to you regarding regarding something about Mamta right yes all right Ashish told all of us in front of you that you were sleeping in a room
[00:31:48] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:31:48] Speaker 1: Mamta came to take the blanket away from you
[00:31:53] Nuresh Bhatt: go ahead
[00:31:56] Speaker 1: so far so far is that what he said or he said something different
[00:31:59] Nuresh Bhatt: i believe little i understand little different
[00:32:02] Speaker 1: okay i'll finish my part then you can explain Ashish testified that you told him that you were asleep Mamta came in you then swatted your arm knocking Mamta to fall down striking her face on the bed is that what Ashish said
[00:32:23] Nuresh Bhatt: that's what not i understand what i understand he said i was on the not was sleeping this lying lying down with the blanket putting on she wanna say something and then i say i don't want to talk to you that's what i did we can watch
[00:32:50] Speaker 1: but let's let's flesh this out tell us what happened in this situation with Mamta
[00:32:55] Nuresh Bhatt: i wasn't talking to her
[00:32:58] Speaker 1: right you two were already separating
[00:33:02] Nuresh Bhatt: separate rooms yes
[00:33:04] Speaker 1: separate rooms
[00:33:04] Nuresh Bhatt: yes she wanna do something or talk something i say i don't want to talk it's the blanket not like you know pushing off she'd never fall down that that that time never fall down she didn't fall down no
[00:33:16] Speaker 1: she didn't fall down and she didn't strike her face no she's just made that up
[00:33:24] Nuresh Bhatt: he did not make that up he said that i don't want to talk to her go away that's i that's what i heard
[00:33:35] Speaker 1: that's what you heard ashish say yes okay let's talk about baltimore yes who lives there
[00:33:58] Nuresh Bhatt: in what context i one of my friend male female two two three males and then i don't know a lot of females i know two of the females yes
[00:34:12] Speaker 1: on the evening before this is sunday july 28 you said you saw mamta dead on the ground july 30th so this is the two days before you were in baltimore correct yes okay the fbi agent that testified judah pent remember him i was there yes he made a whole exhibit showing where you were when where mamta was right yes okay on july 28 you were in baltimore correct yes mom to text you come fast yes when you saw the text message you went home yes i called back and then i went home when you got home did you get into a conflict with mopta no is there any arguments no she's telling you come fast meaning come home
[00:35:21] Nuresh Bhatt: because she say like nema is not sleeping nema crying
[00:35:25] Speaker 1: and so she was having you driving from maryland baltimore to manassas park to put the baby to sleep
[00:35:34] Nuresh Bhatt: usually that's what i do and then she wanted me at home she wanted you home yes she didn't trust you
[00:35:40] Speaker 1: being out and about correct that's not the case did you testify earlier that mopta did not trust you around other women i wasn't with the women that was he luck but manta didn't trust you in this relationship right sometimes yes sometimes no but you're saying she wanted you to come home that way you can be home and she can see what you're up to
[00:36:07] Nuresh Bhatt: yes okay
[00:36:16] Speaker 1: i'm going to transition a little bit into your google searches again on your white house military office laptop you were searching to send a new year's message to a girlfriend yes
[00:36:39] Nuresh Bhatt: who was the girlfriend i do not remember searching of this i do not have a girlfriend at all
[00:36:49] Speaker 1: you also were searching on your top secret clearance white house military office account your ex-fiancé right sure you were looking up lalita bot on your military account correct i don't remember that don't recall that lalita what i didn't remember i'm going to show mr bot commonwealth's exhibit 321 permission to publish commonwealth's 321 steve
[00:38:06] Speaker 3: any objection all right without objection you can publish it
[00:38:20] Speaker 1: okay mr bot i'm highlighting for you line item 275-276-277-278
[00:38:34] Nuresh Bhatt: i see you see yes refresh your memory i do not still remember when i search yes if it's in my
[00:38:40] Speaker 1: laptop i have searched and you are searching for your ex-fiance the woman you were supposed to marry before mamtha not before mamtha before mamtha yes right so you were supposed to marry lalita yes the horoscopes didn't work out right no and the father said no go for you no oh tell us what happened in that scenario it is a different one
[00:39:10] Nuresh Bhatt: explain uh my dad and then i went that home and then some other stuff doesn't match so that's why
[00:39:17] Speaker 1: why we did not go forward right you said the horoscopes didn't align that is the another girl that's a different girl yes you're supposed to marry a different girl yes after this girl yes what was that other girl's name puspandjali but puspandi what was her last name whatever p p bot yes and then you're supposed to marry l bot yes and you ended up marrying manta yes the fathers for those two prior bots told you no go not the first
[00:39:50] Nuresh Bhatt: one second one yes horoscope the first one other stuff doesn't match so lalita bot p bot
[00:40:03] Speaker 1: and i'm focusing you in on line item 280 who's dr dev kota who's that
[00:40:14] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't remember that is that a interest you had in a female i don't think so i don't remember that again this is four months before manta's death right you're researching these women
[00:40:38] Speaker 1: i don't know this women i don't know i'm just asking the date this is april 17 2024 you're searching dr dev kota yes lalita bot yes i gotta ask you because it came up the colombian girl you had a very long text communication with your tenant yes rodolfo
[00:41:29] Nuresh Bhatt: i believe that's the right name sure
[00:41:37] Speaker 1: this text message exchange about a colombian girl came up at a time where you and manta were trying to not be with each other
[00:41:54] Nuresh Bhatt: yes yes okay
[00:41:57] Speaker 1: this guy rodolfo was trying to get this colombian girl through the border for you
[00:42:07] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't recall at that time it was not the serious but like now i see the text message i did the text message yes but like you know it wasn't anything serious or nothing about like i'm gonna marry colombian girl or something like that i never did that who else would think that's a joke
[00:42:28] Speaker 1: ask rodolfo so you think it's a joke rodolfo would think it's a joke you're saying that colombian girl was not being transported into the united states i don't know
[00:42:41] Nuresh Bhatt: about any girl i never connected to any girl i never talked to any girl i never be in relationship with any girl
[00:42:55] Speaker 1: do you know a guy named akash yes who's akash to you one of my tenant he lived with you in wickersham that is correct he lived with you in wickersham with his wife and his daughter that is correct you two had a falling out
[00:43:21] Nuresh Bhatt: that is correct his wife caught you twice with other women correct did he know who that woman is that is my sister two different women no not two different women we're gonna come to this trust me but two
[00:43:42] Speaker 3: different women are seen leaving your you cannot keep yourself under control in the courtroom step out
[00:43:53] Speaker 1: akash sorry judge ahead akash confronts you about there being two different women coming out of your bedroom that's not right no i know i know you're saying it's not right but this is what akash confronted you about right
[00:44:17] Nuresh Bhatt: no
[00:44:19] Speaker 1: do you remember akash's wife's name no akash told you that his wife heard you having sex with two different women that's what akash confronted you about no what was akash confront what was akash talking to you about
[00:44:42] Nuresh Bhatt: in what contest uh to uh getting out of the apartment that wasn't the reason he need my car and then he want to pay an installment i don't want to give him that because i was going for deployment the deployment come back and then he has a lot of stuff in my room then i want to you know say like hey like you need to move out he want to stay there he needs the apartment and then car i did not give him that's the reason once i go to the alabama because we have not going good and then i told him move out as soon as possible and then he was saying a lot of stuff so like i say like i need to move you out then when he moved you out even he like you know poop pee at my apartment then he left when i was in alabama helping with one another my friend in the military i don't know if any of that is true
[00:45:36] Speaker 1: my that is true yes i mean you do lie sometimes though right yes so was that a truthful statement
[00:45:42] Nuresh Bhatt: or is that a lie hundred percent truthful statement okay akash yes is he a liar i believe yes you don't think akash is an honest man in after that incident because he and then i do not have that type of relation maybe like he's trying to do that yes but
[00:46:06] Speaker 1: you agree with me about this no i'm going to tell you the part you should agree to that akash spoke to you two different times about two different women coming out of your bedroom no he didn't talk to you about that no at all no okay will you agree with me on this mom would you agree with me on this point no let me ask you a question mom the kafla beautiful woman yes smart yes educated yes loved that baby yes loved you yes through all of this shenanigans
[00:47:14] Speaker 4: she never stopped loving you
[00:47:28] Speaker 1: through all of this domestic issues with you and her she never stopped loving you
[00:47:35] Nuresh Bhatt: so sometimes when we're quarreling we would not talk to each other otherwise yes
[00:47:59] Speaker 1: even when you were quarreling she cleaned your house
[00:48:04] Nuresh Bhatt: i use to clean except the kitchen except the kitchen okay
[00:48:16] Speaker 1: through the quarreling she kept your according to you just the kitchen clean
[00:48:26] Nuresh Bhatt: majority of the time bathroom uh vacuum almost me i can say 90 percent of the time i do clean
[00:48:37] Speaker 1: and kitchen whatever in the kitchen she does and she the part that she did she did a good job on it she kept your kitchen clean yes our kitchen she kept your belly full
[00:48:56] Speaker 6: yes yes she celebrated your birthday
[00:48:58] Nuresh Bhatt: we never celebrated my birthday
[00:49:06] Speaker 1: didn't you see a text message oh yes on that way yes so she acknowledged you in a loving way yes even during the quarreling she loved you always yes
[00:49:21] Nuresh Bhatt: you stopped loving her right the same way i i also love her
[00:49:33] Speaker 1: i think you show love differently than how mop the shows it
[00:49:36] Speaker 4: i don't think i don't think so where are you sitting right now sir
[00:49:48] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't know what do you mean on chair you're alive aren't you
[00:49:59] Speaker 1: oh yes you're in one whole piece aren't you yes but the love that you show for your baby's mother your wife was to dismember her that's the kind of love you offer that's not the love yeah i know that's not love i'm asking is that the love you give to mamta
[00:50:24] Speaker 4: i don't know that you don't know if you don't know what is that you don't know what please repeat your question
[00:50:41] Speaker 1: not only did you cut her up and we're talking about love
[00:50:49] Speaker 4: i accepted that
[00:51:05] Speaker 1: say that again sir yes but you didn't just stuff her into a trash can you chopped her up to make her fit
[00:51:15] Speaker 4: that's not love no
[00:51:30] Speaker 1: that's a crime
[00:51:32] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:51:33] Speaker 1: the worst kind almost the worst kind you can commit against your wife yes would you agree with me that murder is worse
[00:51:44] Nuresh Bhatt: i'm not agree with you you don't agree with me or you do hold on i don't understand
[00:51:52] Speaker 1: you concealed her body
[00:51:54] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:51:55] Speaker 1: you admit that's a crime yes and you admit you committed it yes there's no question you committed the crime of concealing a dead body yes let's talk about the second crime you're charged with defiling a dead body that's a crime you committed yes so we're clear you're guilty of defiling a dead body for the jury
[00:52:40] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:52:40] Speaker 6: but you're also charged with murder right
[00:52:47] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[00:52:48] Speaker 6: that is the worst crime that can be committed
[00:52:52] Speaker 1: against a person
[00:52:55] Speaker 4: yes and you have been thinking about killing mapta for months i never think about that never ever
[00:53:15] Speaker 1: you typed it out sir it's in your google searches
[00:53:21] Speaker 4: okay i never did that everything that you did do to mapta was willful not everything
[00:53:38] Speaker 1: everything you did to mapta was deliberate
[00:53:41] Speaker 4: but i don't understand the word
[00:53:50] Speaker 1: your intention you had the utmost intentions to commit a crime against mapta
[00:53:58] Speaker 4: No.
[00:54:06] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[00:54:11] Speaker 1: When you – I'm going to jump back into the bedroom. Mamta's dead. How do you get her from the bedroom to the bathroom?
[00:54:37] Speaker 4: Are you asking me?
[00:54:40] Speaker 1: Yes.
[00:54:41] Speaker 4: How did you get her to the bathroom?
[00:54:47] Nuresh Bhatt: I carried her. I need to consult about this work.
[00:55:02] Speaker 3: It's okay. Not with him. You can consult with another interpreter.
[00:55:06] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes, sir, you can come up. I'm sorry. Mr. Swede, he's ready to answer.
[00:55:27] Speaker 4: So, I was carrying her just above her abdomen and dragging her.
[00:55:33] Speaker 1: So, her body was still connected to the floor as you pulled her into the bathroom?
[00:55:46] Speaker 4: Yes, sir. No. No. No. No.
[00:55:51] Nuresh Bhatt: I can't recall all those single events or small events. Yes, once it was, but I was so panicked, I can't remember every single event.
[00:56:06] Speaker 1: Sure.
[00:56:07] Speaker ?: But you dragged her into the bathroom, right?
[00:56:07] Speaker 1: Sure. But you dragged her into the bathroom, right?
[00:56:11] Speaker 4: You pulled her into the bathroom? Yes. Yes.
[00:56:14] Nuresh Bhatt: Was she actively bleeding as you're pulling her into the bathroom?
[00:56:18] Speaker 4: No. No. You saw the crime scene photos, right?
[00:56:21] Speaker ?: Yes. Yes.
[00:56:23] Speaker 4: You saw how Blue Star was applied into the bedroom in the bathroom?
[00:56:27] Speaker 1: Yes. You pulled her into the bathroom? Yes. Yes. Was she actively bleeding as you're pulling her into the bathroom? No.
[00:56:35] Speaker 4: You saw the crime scene photos, right? Yes. You saw how Blue Star was applied into the bedroom in the bathroom?
[00:56:42] Speaker ?: Yes.
[00:56:43] Speaker 1: That line from the bed to the bathroom, that's all of Mobta's blood as you're pulling her in, correct?
[00:57:04] Speaker 4: Yes. Yes. You saw, before you pulled her into the bathroom, a pretty
[00:57:34] Speaker 1: substantial pooling of blood. Correct? Yes.
[00:57:37] Speaker 4: That blood was so… What's wrong? There was such a large amount of blood that it dripped down through to the bottom of that I don't know exactly how much blood was there. It was a lot though, right? I don't know that.
[00:58:11] Nuresh Bhatt: At some point…
[00:58:12] Speaker ?: I don't know when, but I'll ask, you recognize this to be a crime scene, right?
[00:58:12] Nuresh Bhatt: Right?
[00:58:13] Speaker 1: Right? Right?
[00:58:15] Nuresh Bhatt: Right? Right?
[00:58:17] Speaker ?: At some point.
[00:58:18] Speaker 1: At some point, I don't know when, but I'll ask, you recognize this to be a crime scene, right?
[00:58:35] Speaker ?: Right?
[00:58:36] Speaker 1: Sure.
[00:58:37] Speaker ?: I did not think at that time. Sure. But at some point, you realize, uh-oh, I need to clean this up.
[00:58:37] Speaker 4: Is that fair to say? That's fair to say? It's like a mix of Nepali in English kind of…
[00:58:49] Speaker ?: I have to consult on him.
[00:58:50] Speaker 1: Right?
[00:58:51] Speaker 4: So, I did not think about that. I did not think at that time.
[00:58:53] Speaker 1: Sure. But at some point, you realize, uh-oh, I need to clean this up. Is that fair to say?
[00:58:59] Speaker ?: It's like a mix of Nepali in English kind of, I have to consult on him. So, I did not think about that for a long time, like with purpose of crime.
[00:58:59] Speaker 4: At some point, you realized this is a crime. You know, someone that you are a brother, one of the other.
[00:59:03] Nuresh Bhatt: So, I did not think about that for a long time, like with purpose of crime.
[00:59:08] Speaker 4: At some point, you realized this is a crime. Yes.
[00:59:15] Nuresh Bhatt: And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up.
[00:59:21] Speaker 4: Yes.
[00:59:22] Speaker ?: And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up.
[00:59:22] Speaker 4: Yes.
[00:59:23] Speaker 1: And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up. Yes.
[00:59:27] Speaker ?: So, at that time, I thought it was a moral crime.
[00:59:27] Speaker 4: So, at that time, I thought it was a moral crime.
[00:59:32] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[00:59:33] Speaker 1: And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up.
[00:59:39] Speaker 4: Yes. And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up.
[00:59:45] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. And when you recognized it as a crime, you had to clean it up.
[00:59:51] Speaker 4: at that time i thought it was a moral crime not a legal crime i did not know anything about legal
[01:00:00] Speaker 1: crime at that time well that was a mistake wasn't it okay what at the time you thought it was a
[01:00:09] Speaker 4: moral crime to dismember mamta so dismembering any dead body is a moral crime a big crime and the worst
[01:00:27] Speaker 1: kind would be dismembering your wife yes and you didn't want anybody to find out about this so you
[01:00:36] Speaker 4: decided to clean the crime scene yes you bought gloves from home depot right yes i bought but
[01:00:52] Speaker 1: that's not with that purpose you were doing gardening that day no what were you going to use these rubber thick waterproof type gloves on the date that you found your wife dead the real i went to the home
[01:01:08] Nuresh Bhatt: depot not purpose of the buying the gloves just before i return i usually buy something when i go any store just that's the what i find next next to the checkout register it has no purpose related to that but just i bought it doesn't mean it it i did at that time doesn't mean it's related to that
[01:01:31] Speaker 1: would you agree with me you're a smart man
[01:01:40] Nuresh Bhatt: i'm very hard working more than smart i'm smart as well but hard working you're very clever too aren't you
[01:01:48] Speaker 1: in some context yes paying with cash is almost untraceable would you agree with me on that yes turning off your phone so the cell towers can't pick up where you are is pretty smart correct
[01:02:05] Nuresh Bhatt: buying with the cash cell phone has nothing to do but mostly i buy credit cards wherever walmart wherever i go usually i use credit cards so you bought the gloves home depot
[01:02:31] Speaker 1: you go to another store you go to the walmart right yes yes you buy extra strong trash bags right yes at leedle apologies uh you bought i'm sorry i'll step it back the trash bags you bought at leedle
[01:02:53] Speaker 4: i don't know if they are extra strong or strong with looking at a photograph of the trash bags you bought refresh your memory
[01:03:25] Nuresh Bhatt: maybe i have bought trash bag but i don't know which bag i don't know that
[01:03:28] Speaker 1: i thought looking at a photo of what you bought that day would that refresh your memory maybe of course this photograph refreshes your memory of the trash bags you bought this one right here
[01:03:49] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't have exact memory but similar type of trash bag i don't know exactly which one
[01:03:57] Speaker 1: you used every single trash bag from this box right no when you went to the walmart you bought a three pack of knives right yes you used those knives to carve up manta correct somewhere yes in some way yes after you used those knives on manta you discarded them you threw them out
[01:04:32] Nuresh Bhatt: i put somewhere at the donation
[01:04:38] Speaker 1: the donation bin in loudon county no at the baby place got it at the babysitter's trash yes you said those knives could be reused that's why you didn't put them in the trash you put it outside the trash yes did you wash these knives
[01:05:03] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't remember
[01:05:19] Speaker 1: do you remember the name of these knives no but you kept one of them the smallest one you kept in your house yes right the cops recovered that from your house yes did you use that knife on mata the little one
[01:05:38] Nuresh Bhatt: no you only use the two other ones on mata just try to use not a lot so that's why i try to give somebody who can use that
[01:05:57] Speaker 1: the cleaning supplies you bought this on wednesday july 31st at the chantilly walmart no no you bought cleaning supplies from a walmart on july 31st i do not recall the date but yes
[01:06:28] Nuresh Bhatt: not at the chantilly somewhere else this is during the period of time that you're
[01:06:33] Speaker 1: discarding things of manta's right yes okay you bought a two pack of air fresheners right would it refresh your memory to see what i'm looking at
[01:06:51] Nuresh Bhatt: i do not recall every single i recall like few of those if i showed you a photo of all the things
[01:06:57] Speaker 1: without refreshing memory sure finish your approach you may
[01:07:06] Nuresh Bhatt: buy this buy this i have a memory of buying this i have a memory of buying this this this you're
[01:07:13] Speaker 3: welcome to walk up yes of course miss lennox
[01:07:20] Nuresh Bhatt: i have a memory of buying this bananas rice
[01:07:27] Speaker 1: this glade air fresheners soap soap or glade air fresheners lysol disinfectant wipes and a car air freshener
[01:07:42] Nuresh Bhatt: that's all i remember if it's in the receipt i might buy but like no sometimes you buy you don't remember
[01:07:47] Speaker 1: every single sure so it's in the receipt you bought it right yes if you're on video buying it these are the things you bought yes you used a carpet cleaner to clean up manta's blood yes and you used almost the entire can correct i don't know how much i use definitely a pretty intensive heavy cleaning job is that fair to say no in the bathroom yes well you also had to get the blood out of the rug was that easy for you to do yes was it easy for you to clean mantas blood out of that rug yes it was easy
[01:08:38] Nuresh Bhatt: just mentally it wasn't easy physically it was easy
[01:08:44] Speaker 1: but you did such a good job cleaning mantas blood that from the naked eye nobody could see blood in see blood in that bedroom carpet
[01:09:02] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[01:09:03] Speaker 1: you said you said the bathroom was a little bit harder
[01:09:11] Nuresh Bhatt: yes why was that harder mentally it was very tough
[01:09:16] Speaker 1: how about physically
[01:09:21] Nuresh Bhatt: yes a lot of water is that where you use the saw
[01:09:31] Speaker 1: sure here in the bathroom is that where you use the saw on mapta's body
[01:09:37] Speaker 5: did you put mop this body in the bathtub on the floor or in the shower did you put mapta's body in the bathtub on the floor or in the shower
[01:10:15] Nuresh Bhatt: the hospital or in the shower or in the shower or in the shower or in the shower or in the bathroom
[01:10:29] Speaker 5: the all medical medical process intubation that was on the blanket on the floor and when i disposed that was on the back of this post
[01:10:45] Speaker 1: there was a lot of blood pouring out of mapta's body right
[01:10:57] Nuresh Bhatt: uh pouring one ago q
[01:11:01] Speaker 1: when you chopped off her limbs blood is pouring out
[01:11:08] Nuresh Bhatt: that's how the blood
[01:11:32] Speaker 1: got underneath the bathtub past the caulking correct
[01:11:38] Speaker 5: i don't know that exactly
[01:11:43] Nuresh Bhatt: how that get there
[01:11:45] Speaker 1: and when it was time to actually clean up the bathroom you turn on all the water
[01:11:57] Nuresh Bhatt: only one tab only one tab uh one
[01:12:04] Speaker 1: the shower the beds up or the sink the bath tub but turn it on and let it push out water for at least two hours
[01:12:18] Nuresh Bhatt: no
[01:12:19] Speaker 1: how long did you let the water run
[01:12:23] Nuresh Bhatt: just half pull the bathtub and then clean and then let it go
[01:12:27] Speaker 1: you said you filled the bathtub half full with water yes addy addy addy half fill the water all right we got a bathtub in your bathroom you fill it up halfway with water
[01:12:56] Speaker 5: i fill up half and i clean up and then let it go and then again half filled and clean up but i never filled up on the top okay
[01:13:09] Speaker 1: you don't dispute that your water meter in one hour was 111 gallons
[01:13:16] Speaker 5: i'm agree with that
[01:13:24] Speaker 1: i want to go back to akash real quick and then i'll move past him can you repeat yes i'm letting you know mr bot i want to talk a little bit more about akash
[01:13:47] Speaker 5: and then i can move past okay
[01:13:57] Speaker 1: question for you sir you said you've never ever been violent with mata right yes were you ever violent towards anyone else
[01:14:19] Nuresh Bhatt: uh last fight i have when i was second kidnapped before and after i never remember anyone you never what i never had anyone i never remember i never had no no not anyone how about threatening to hurt somebody i don't know which sense he was talking about but i don't believe anything i have done that
[01:14:45] Speaker 1: i'm trying to get you to akash but i'm asking you questions first didn't you threaten akash to hurt him when akash was living in your apartment you had a gun i never had a gun in my life
[01:15:14] Nuresh Bhatt: you never had a gun in your life personal gun never ever had in my life did you have another type of gun at my home never at my work if work required yes in personal never
[01:15:28] Speaker 1: when you were a fairfax cop or trying to become a fairfax cop you got a gun right not personal at the work i have to leave at the work and so when you were inside of your apartment at the wickersham with akash did you ever pull a gun on him i never had a gun at that time i wasn't in a police department i'm going to jump forward a little bit more we're past akash let's talk about the liberty gas station that's pretty far from your house correct
[01:16:26] Speaker 5: that depends on 20 30 minutes sure
[01:16:39] Speaker 1: you went to the liberty gas station you ate some food
[01:16:46] Nuresh Bhatt: yes
[01:16:50] Speaker 1: you did not have your phone on you at that time when you went to liberty gas station right you left
[01:16:56] Nuresh Bhatt: it at your house i don't recall exactly
[01:17:02] Speaker 1: when you saw the fbi's map it shows your phone pinging in manassas park yes so when you went to liberty gas station your phone
[01:17:15] Nuresh Bhatt: was in the house that's what i said that he said but i don't recall in my top of head yes okay yes
[01:17:24] Speaker 1: you also had manta's phone on you when you went to that liberty gas station correct yes you discarded some things in the donation box yes shoes
[01:17:43] Nuresh Bhatt: other clothing items of mantas both uh mine i i don't exactly recall but mine and her whatever the common yes and then especially i remember the shoes i don't remember anything else
[01:17:56] Speaker 1: that's not withdrawn after you finished discarding at the liberty gas station you didn't go directly home correct that's not correct where did you go after the liberty gas station
[01:18:16] Nuresh Bhatt: directly babysitter place
[01:18:19] Speaker 1: isn't it true that you went to the south riding recreational center after the liberty gas station no are you sure about this hundred percent a hundred percent yes this is not a lie lie not lie
[01:18:42] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't know where you're talking about the name of the place but like uh what is the name
[01:18:48] Speaker 5: what is the name that you mentioned just before it was the south riding
[01:18:53] Speaker 1: recreational center it was further up on route 50.
[01:19:02] Nuresh Bhatt: south riding recreational center i did not stop any what i remember i did not stop anywhere any recreational center or whatever i never stopped anywhere except the one stop sign your car the tesla
[01:19:22] Speaker 1: is a pretty smart car yes records a lot of things would you agree with me on that yeah i knew that so if your tesla car records you at the south riding recreational center which is telling the truth you
[01:19:37] Nuresh Bhatt: or the tesla i know where i was so i just did not where exactly it is if i see the map i can tell you which way i come back otherwise i don't know if it's tesla so i don't think so it was on tesla record so i want to clear one more thing please clarify uh the person who came from liberty gas station to
[01:20:10] Speaker 1: testify you were asking mr adhikari that's who testified uh i forgot the name i remember it and you
[01:20:22] Nuresh Bhatt: you were showing the another car going on opposite direction and then he said like that's not the car he recalled recall i wasn't there i was in the opposite direction i can show you the if you have a map i can show you where i go
[01:20:44] Speaker 1: judge i don't recall the exhibit number i can get it momentarily but this is the fbi's cellular mapping that was offered to evidence
[01:20:56] Speaker 3: are you looking to show it to him to refresh are you looking to publish to show it to mr bob that's
[01:21:01] Speaker 1: mr bob this is a 40 page document that was admitted into evidence that's far so good on page 33 where is the liberty gas station liberty gas station's on the bottom left that's your car right yes okay according to you yes when you left the gas station you drove go ahead i don't know how to describe this
[01:21:55] Nuresh Bhatt: scientific stuff i can tell you where i go you could say right or left i go this way this way come this way this way and then somewhere this way and then this way i left okay so what you just demonstrated is
[01:22:09] Speaker 1: you pulled out of the gas station made a right route 50 again right made another right
[01:22:17] Nuresh Bhatt: made another right on i don't know where i make another right but i make another right and then there was a uh empty space uh and then there was a one traffic light that's what i remember and then i throw the phone and then just come go this way that's what i was getting at so you answered my
[01:22:34] Speaker 1: question this is where you discarded mop this phone yes did you actually destroy the phone did you break the phone physically yeah no what did you do to the
[01:22:58] Nuresh Bhatt: phone just uh i stopped next to the signal and then there was a side of the road i just threw on the side of the road and it's nally did you power the phone down no
[01:23:14] Speaker 5: thank you sorry nally um your uh ordinary is a drain drain you throw it into a drain
[01:23:23] Nuresh Bhatt: the drain to in a kid sidewalk could you be thrown janey i don't know how to say it's drained you know by the sidewalk
[01:23:32] Speaker 1: and you don't recall which street you were on when you tossed her phone
[01:23:39] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't i don't
[01:23:44] Speaker 1: you definitely threw the phone down into like a sewer drain and sorry if my we're not on the same page of what we're talking about you threw the phone into a drain
[01:24:08] Speaker 5: it's not a stop sign it's a red light stop and that's where i dropped that red light
[01:24:38] Speaker 1: i'm trying to see if we can figure out from you where this phone is that's why i'm asking you questions okay is the phone in the drain where we cannot find it anymore
[01:25:07] Nuresh Bhatt: i don't know i don't know that i'll move it on
[01:25:19] Speaker ?: so so so so so so
[01:25:50] Speaker 1: judge i'm going to have two photographs marked as the first one marked as four four nine for identification the second one is 454 identification
[01:26:16] Speaker 3: may we approach you may
[01:26:25] Speaker ?: you may Thank you.
[01:27:16] Speaker 3: All right. All right. The Commonwealth is withdrawing one of the exhibits, and the other is coming in without objection.
[01:27:33] Speaker 1: You may. It's 449 for identification. Do you recognize this photograph? Yes. What's this a photograph of?
[01:27:44] Nuresh Bhatt: It's my photograph.
[01:27:46] Speaker 1: When is this a photograph of you?
[01:27:50] Nuresh Bhatt: I think it's during my graduation in the Army. I don't exactly recall. It looked like I was in the graduation ceremony.
[01:27:59] Speaker 1: 2017, 2018?
[01:28:01] Nuresh Bhatt: I believe 2017.
[01:28:03] Speaker 1: 2017.
[01:28:03] Nuresh Bhatt: I'm not 100% sure. Maybe 20. If it's 2018, I don't know. Somewhere 2017 or 2018. It's in my Facebook.
[01:28:12] Speaker 1: This is a true and accurate photo of yourself around 2017, 2018? Yes. It's in evidence as commonwealths. 449. No objection.
[01:28:21] Speaker 3: All right. Without objection, that's received. Quickly publishing for the jury.
[01:28:33] Speaker 1: I'll do a walk by judge.
[01:28:48] Speaker 5: Pretty proud of the day, right?
[01:28:53] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:28:54] Speaker 1: Happy to be a United States soldier?
[01:28:59] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:29:02] Speaker 1: Did Mokta enjoy your status as United States soldier?
[01:29:11] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know. At that time, she wasn't unseen.
[01:29:14] Speaker 1: Yeah, but when she became unseen, isn't she proud of you to be a military husband?
[01:29:21] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:29:21] Speaker 1: She supported you in all your endeavors, right?
[01:29:24] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:29:25] Speaker 1: She supported you when you went to Pennsylvania?
[01:29:28] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:29:29] Speaker 1: She supported you when you went to Wisconsin?
[01:29:31] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. Yes.
[01:29:35] Speaker 1: Well, you went to Wisconsin without even telling her, right?
[01:29:40] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:29:41] Speaker 1: Didn't you testify that you just left? No. And left Mokta high and dry?
[01:29:46] Nuresh Bhatt: No, I did not say that.
[01:29:47] Speaker 1: You didn't say that?
[01:29:48] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:29:49] Speaker 1: But still, your memory growing up or when you came to this country to join the military so you could wear the uniform. You said, if I recall, that you walked into a Walmart and you saw a soldier getting recognition. Yes.
[01:30:25] Speaker 5: People were thanking that military officer for his service to this country.
[01:30:39] Speaker 1: That's what you wanted, right? Yes. Yes.
[01:30:42] Speaker ?: Yes.
[01:30:42] Speaker 1: It was all about the ego for you, wasn't it? No. You wanted to be the big man on campus making money, big house, new car, beautiful wife.
[01:31:03] Speaker 5: Yes, but I don't accept that as an ego.
[01:31:15] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:31:16] Speaker 1: It was all a lie, wasn't it?
[01:31:19] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:31:20] Speaker 1: It was all for show, wasn't it?
[01:31:23] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:31:24] Speaker 1: You never got deployed into a combat zone?
[01:31:28] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:31:30] Speaker 1: You were distributing food in Wisconsin?
[01:31:34] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:31:37] Speaker 1: And I'm not trying to diminish that service. But you were very proud that these Afghan refugees were thanking you and taking pictures with you, saying to you, thank you for your service. That made you feel good, right?
[01:31:56] Speaker 5: No.
[01:31:57] Speaker ?: No.
[01:31:57] Speaker 5: No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No.
[01:32:06] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:32:07] Speaker 1: Maapta also tried to inflate your ego, correct? No.
[01:32:13] Speaker 5: No. No. No. No. Yes. She called you her king. Yes. You didn't call her my queen. Yes. Do you have any text messages where you ever call her your queen? That's not the normal culture. But it's normal
[01:32:56] Speaker 1: for the wife to elevate the husband's status and call you the king? No. It's a different
[01:33:04] Nuresh Bhatt: culture. You got to live that culture to understand. I'm learning it through you, sir. I had another name for her. So that's not, I, you know, sometimes I prefer, sometimes I don't prefer. Usually
[01:33:19] Speaker 1: people give like name each other. What was the name you gave to Mata? Surma. Surma. Surma. And what does Surma mean?
[01:33:31] Nuresh Bhatt: Bahadur? Brave?
[01:33:34] Speaker 1: Prayer? Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Brave. Thanks, sir.
[01:33:51] Speaker ?: Judge, I'm going to have a four-page set of photographs marked as 447 for identification copies provided to Council. Permission to approach Mr.
[01:34:05] Speaker 1: Bob. You may. I've been letting this go for a while because I was had some hope that you're going to finish today. It is. Do you anticipate being done in the next 15 minutes?
[01:34:22] Speaker 3: 15. Of course, intelligence.
[01:34:39] Speaker ?: I'm trying to make good use of the court's time that's available. Judge, I think.
[01:34:58] Speaker 1: I'm trying to make good use of the court's time that's available, Judge, I think. I don't think we're going to finish, but I do, I would like to try to use the rest of our time that is available.
[01:35:17] Speaker 3: Okay. Okay. Can I ask how much time that is going to? That would be 16 minutes. That's what's available.
[01:35:25] Speaker 1: I'm moving, Judge. Okay. Four, four, seven, four photographs, one, two, three, four. Do you recognize this?
[01:35:42] Speaker ?: Yes.
[01:35:55] Nuresh Bhatt: What is that, sir? It is my home in Nepal.
[01:36:03] Speaker 1: That's your house in Nepal?
[01:36:05] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. Family house.
[01:36:07] Speaker 1: Family house. That's not the mud hut that you described earlier, correct? That's actually where your family's from?
[01:36:14] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. We built this home somewhere 10, some years ago, 10, 15 years ago.
[01:36:19] Speaker 1: I offer four, four, seven into evidence at this time.
[01:36:24] Speaker 3: Any objection? Can we clarify what, when that, where, when that photo is from?
[01:36:32] Speaker 1: Mr. Potts said he made it, they built the house 10 years ago? I heard 10, 15.
[01:36:37] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't recall, 10, 15, something like that. There we go. And then this is even, I don't know, like, is.
[01:36:48] Speaker 3: Any objection? I have no objection. All right. Not objection.
[01:36:52] Speaker 6: I have no objection.
[01:37:20] Speaker 1: We're going to mark this photograph as 461, but not offer it at this time.
[01:37:32] Speaker 3: All right. Do you want to take the 447 exhibit, please, and bring it to the clerk?
[01:37:39] Speaker 1: Sir? I'm going to take this, take a look at this, tell me if you recognize this.
[01:37:46] Speaker 3: Judge, can we approach? You may. Okay. Do you want to see that name? Okay.
[01:37:52] Speaker ?: Do you want to see that name? Okay. Do you want to see that name? I'm going to see that name? I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name. I'm going to see that name.
[01:39:39] Speaker 1: Sir, recognize this is a photo within a photo, correct? You recognize the photos within this photo? Not the words.
[01:39:58] Nuresh Bhatt: No, it looks like screenshots or some different screenshots. Some sending option. I don't know.
[01:40:05] Speaker 1: The photos that are in the photo. Are these photos that Mabta had sent to you previously?
[01:40:23] Speaker 4: Can you please answer the question one more time? Yes. Sorry, ask the question one more time. Yes, yes.
[01:40:33] Speaker 1: We're looking at two photographs, right? Two screenshots. And these two screenshots are of photographs, right?
[01:40:48] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:40:49] Speaker 1: These are photos that Mabta sent to you in December of 2023? No.
[01:40:56] Nuresh Bhatt: Did she ever send these photos to you?
[01:40:57] Speaker ?: No. Did she ever send these photos to you?
[01:40:58] Speaker 1: No.
[01:40:59] Speaker ?: Okay.
[01:40:59] Speaker 1: Okay. Okay.
[01:41:01] Speaker ?: Question. Nadia Navarro. Yes.
[01:41:01] Speaker 1: Nadia Navarro.
[01:41:02] Speaker ?: Nadia Navarro. Nadia Navarro. Yes.
[01:41:03] Nuresh Bhatt: When she lived in the apartment.
[01:41:04] Speaker ?: Okay. Nadia Navarro. Yes. When she lived in the apartment. With Mabta. Okay.
[01:41:23] Speaker 1: Question. Nadia Navarro.
[01:41:27] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:41:29] Speaker 1: When she lived in the apartment with Mopta, this was at the Wickersham address?
[01:41:38] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:41:39] Speaker 1: Did she ever live with you and Mopta at the Heather Courthouse?
[01:41:43] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[01:41:54] Speaker 1: There was an occasion, a situation, where you were giving compliments to Nadia, and to Mopta?
[01:42:12] Nuresh Bhatt: What comes to me?
[01:42:14] Speaker 1: I'll try to clarify. When you were in front of Mopta and in front of Nadia, you said to Nadia that her looks that she's an A-plus and that Mopta's looks is a C-minus?
[01:42:36] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[01:42:37] Speaker 1: Never said this?
[01:42:39] Nuresh Bhatt: Even we did not before deployment, we did not meet like that, just a baby shower ceremony? No, never.
[01:42:53] Speaker 1: Did you ever make compliments to Nadia and Mopta while on a FaceTime?
[01:43:00] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't recall anything like that. Never.
[01:43:07] Speaker 1: Question for you, sir. Your application to become a United States citizen, your immigration documents, you put on that document that you were born in Nepal, correct?
[01:43:33] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:43:35] Speaker 1: You also put on that immigration document to become a United States citizen a date of birth in February of 1987, correct?
[01:43:53] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:43:56] Speaker 1: You were not born in Nepal, correct?
[01:43:59] Nuresh Bhatt: My mom, dad, they know I was born in India, New Delhi.
[01:44:03] Speaker 1: How about the United States government?
[01:44:09] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:44:10] Speaker 1: You told the United States government that you were born in Nepal, correct?
[01:44:16] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:44:16] Speaker 1: That's a lie.
[01:44:19] Nuresh Bhatt: It's not a lie, it's a culture. I did not lie with do any intention because that's how we grew up over there.
[01:44:37] Speaker 1: Judge, I believe I'll be able to finish within the next five minutes.
[01:44:40] Speaker 3: Okay.
[01:44:53] Speaker 1: Question, answer, question, answer, okay? Sir. You told everybody today that you are a liar, right?
[01:45:05] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:45:09] Speaker 1: You've been lying about MAMTA for over two years, right?
[01:45:16] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:45:18] Speaker 1: You've been lying about how MAMTA died for two years?
[01:45:22] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:45:22] Speaker 1: Didn't you tell the police and the family and the community and everybody that was willing to listen to you that she ran away?
[01:45:30] Nuresh Bhatt: Not for two years, maybe three weeks.
[01:45:33] Speaker 1: No. It's since 2024. I see what you're saying. I'll withdraw. For, from... July 29, 2024. Up until the date that you were arrested, August 22, 2024, you lied to everybody during that period of time about where MAMTA is, correct?
[01:46:02] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:46:07] Speaker 1: You want us, not us, you want the jury to believe that you're telling the truth today?
[01:46:24] Nuresh Bhatt: Of course.
[01:46:26] Speaker 1: And you want them to believe you today, and if they do, you get a huge benefit, right?
[01:46:36] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know about the benefit.
[01:46:40] Speaker 1: You beat the case if the jury believes you, correct?
[01:46:45] Speaker 4: I'm 100% honestly.
[01:46:52] Nuresh Bhatt: I put everything in front of everybody.
[01:46:55] Speaker 1: Today?
[01:46:56] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:46:57] Speaker 1: But not previously?
[01:46:59] Nuresh Bhatt: That is correct.
[01:47:02] Speaker 1: And you're telling the truth today only to beat these charges, right?
[01:47:09] Nuresh Bhatt: Whatever I did, I accepted that 100%. Whatever I haven't done, I never accepted. I never done.
[01:47:20] Speaker 1: You didn't find MAMTA dead, right? Sure. You killed her.
[01:47:34] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[01:47:35] Speaker 1: You did. No. The evidence that we presented shows that you killed her. Would you agree with that?
[01:47:44] Nuresh Bhatt: No, that's your job. You're presenting. So, no.
[01:47:47] Speaker 1: It's a difficult job, isn't it?
[01:47:50] Nuresh Bhatt: I don't know.
[01:47:55] Speaker 1: You've been planning to kill MAMTA for months, right?
[01:47:58] Nuresh Bhatt: Never.
[01:48:05] Speaker 1: When MAMTA called the police, that truly upsets you, correct? In February 2024, MAMTA called the cops on you?
[01:48:18] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:48:19] Speaker 1: You were holding her documents?
[01:48:21] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:48:22] Speaker 1: Those documents are the reason that she would have became a United States citizen?
[01:48:26] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:48:28] Speaker 1: And if she had gotten her citizenship, she would have left you, right?
[01:48:32] Nuresh Bhatt: She already have 10 years of permanent resident card.
[01:48:35] Speaker 1: But she wasn't a United States citizen, right?
[01:48:38] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:48:39] Speaker 1: And if she had gotten that, she would have been free from you, correct?
[01:48:43] Nuresh Bhatt: Even like, she doesn't need citizens to be free. She has already 10 years of permanent resident card. She doesn't need to do anything.
[01:48:49] Speaker 1: But she wanted to be a U.S. citizen like you, right?
[01:48:54] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:48:55] Speaker 1: And you made sure that did not happen.
[01:48:58] Nuresh Bhatt: No. That's your perception.
[01:49:03] Speaker 1: It ultimately is going to be their perception. But because of you, she will never be a United States citizen and she will never be with us ever again.
[01:49:16] Nuresh Bhatt: The document even you presented, you can check. I fill up those forms. I have handwriting. All I have done that. You can see that. I have filled out. I have handwritten. Those are my handwritings.
[01:49:37] Speaker 1: I'm going to end with these last couple questions. after you chopped up Mamta. You were talking to Nima blaming Mamta?
[01:50:07] Speaker ?: Please
[01:50:08] Speaker 1: repeat the
[01:50:09] Speaker ?: question.
[01:50:10] Speaker 1: Didn't you testify that after Mamta's dead, you're talking to Nima blaming Mamta. Isn't that what you said? You were blaming Mamta? You were telling this to your daughter? What memory were you trying to give Nima when you're talking to her?
[01:50:48] Nuresh Bhatt: I wasn't trying to give her any memory. She doesn't understand. What I'm blaming at that time, you did not do a good thing. You leave us behind. Everything messed up. You did not do a good thing. You keep threatening multiple times. I did not take that seriously. So she did. That means we are miserable. Daughter is miserable. Myself is miserable back.
[01:51:23] Speaker 1: She was the bad memory in your life, Mamta? Remember you changed her name in your phone to bad memory? At
[01:51:32] Nuresh Bhatt: one time, yes. bad memory run away.
[01:51:34] Speaker 1: So she used to have a name in your phone?
[01:51:37] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:51:38] Speaker 1: And then you changed it to bad memory?
[01:51:41] Nuresh Bhatt: No, I never saved her name with Mamta because I have six or seven other phone numbers with Mamta. I save I save her name with Surma.
[01:51:50] Speaker 1: Surma.
[01:51:51] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:51:51] Speaker 1: Brave.
[01:51:53] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes.
[01:51:54] Speaker 1: So she did have some term of affection from you in the beginning. She was brave, she then became the bad memory, and then you deleted her name entirely from your list. Is that fair to say?
[01:52:10] Nuresh Bhatt: No.
[01:52:19] Speaker 1: Because of you, because of what you've done, Nima will never have a mother ever again.
[01:52:27] Nuresh Bhatt: Correct.
[01:52:34] Speaker 1: You're now the bad memory to Nima, correct? Repeat one moment. Sure. And last question. Because of what you've done to Mamta, you are now always going to be the bad memory in Nima's life.
[01:53:01] Nuresh Bhatt: Yes. Myself, Nima, yes.
[01:53:07] Speaker 1: No further questions.