House prosecution team holds press briefing on Day 38 of impeachment trial — October 12, 2026

[0:59] financial transactions. [1:01] Pinilit mang ikutan ang batas, [1:03] pero ang totoo, kusang [1:05] lumabas. Matagal ko na pong [1:07] sinasabi na hindi confidential [1:09] ang katotohanan. [1:10] Ang kabuhang hindi yan tineklara ay yung [1:12] nakabold na numerong 817 [1:15] milyon. [1:16] Isang forensic expert at [1:19] respetatong financial analyst, [1:21] Atty. Alexander Cabrera. [1:23] Sinuri ang mga dokumento, [1:25] pinagtapat ang mga datos, [1:26] inilabas ang totoo. [1:28] Ito po ay summation po [1:31] ng ending balances po sa iba't-ibang [1:34] banko na [1:35] pag-aari po ni B.P. Sarah, [1:37] na kanyang asawa. [1:41] At kinumpir lamang po [1:43] namin yung ending balances [1:44] po ng banko, galing po sa bank account, [1:48] sa kanila pong nakadeclare [1:49] na cash. Taon-taon [1:51] ito ang mga halagang inilatag ng [1:53] witness. 190.6 [1:55] milyon pesos noong 2022, [1:58] 167.3 [2:00] milyon pesos noong 2023, [2:02] 264.2 [2:04] milyon pesos noong 2024, [2:06] at [2:06] 195.7 [2:08] milyon pesos noong 2025. [2:11] Kinumpirma rin niya [2:12] na sa kanyang metod, [2:13] hindi niya binilang ng dalawang [2:15] beses ang parehong [2:16] asset. [2:17] At yung tanong na ating [2:18] gagalanggalang ng [2:19] Senate President, [2:20] sa 2025, [2:21] ang kabuhang hindi niya [2:22] tineklara ay yung [2:22] nakabold na [2:24] numerong [2:24] 817 [2:25] milyon. [2:26] Tama po. [2:27] Sunod-sunod na inilahad ng [2:28] witness ang summary [2:29] ng mga undeclared [2:30] assets ng B.C. [2:32] tulad ng bank account [2:33] na nakapangalan mismo [2:34] kay VP Sara Duterte [2:36] at maging [2:37] ang asawa nito. [2:38] Ang table 2 po [2:39] ay nagre-refer po [2:40] sa mga bank accounts po [2:41] na nasa pangalan po [2:42] ng spouse po [2:43] ni VP Sara. [2:44] Maging ang joint accounts [2:45] na silip din. [2:47] Maging bank records [2:48] na nakaugnay sa asawa [2:49] ng D.C., [2:50] lumabas din. [2:52] Isa, [2:52] sa pinakamalaking bahagi [2:54] ng report ay [2:54] ang mga bank accounts. [2:56] Pinagsama ni Cabrera [2:57] ang ending balances [2:58] mula sa iba't ibang [2:59] account ni Sara Duterte [3:00] at ni Manz Carpio [3:01] at inihambing ang mga ito [3:03] sa cash declaration [3:05] sa Salen. [3:06] Kasama rin sa kanyang [3:07] pagsusuri ang mga [3:08] insurance policy. [3:10] Ayon kay Cabrera, [3:11] may humigit kumulang [3:12] 17 policies. [3:14] na hindi niya nakita [3:15] sa mga Salen [3:16] at sinuri niya. [3:17] Kabilang dito, [3:19] ang FWD policy [3:20] na binayari ni Carpio [3:21] ng P10.6M [3:23] sa isang bagsahan [3:25] noong May 25, 2024. [3:28] Ipinaliwanag din ni Cabrera [3:29] na hindi lahat ng deposito [3:30] ay itinuri niyang income. [3:33] May mahalagang ibinawas niya [3:34] kabilang ang loan proceeds, [3:37] rolled overtime deposit, [3:38] investment proceeds [3:39] at transfers [3:40] sa pagitan ng sariling account. [3:42] Damay rin, [3:43] pa di real properties. [3:45] Maging ang mga negosyong [3:46] nabanggit, [3:47] hindi pinalusok [3:48] ng prosekusyon. [3:49] Why did BP Sara [3:51] include Gencorp [3:52] in her Salen? [3:53] Honorable Jochno, [3:54] the reason why [3:54] I think [3:56] BP Sara included [3:58] Gencorp [3:59] in her Salen [4:00] is [4:00] napaka [4:01] halaga po kasi [4:03] ng Gencorp. [4:04] Malaki po [4:05] ang value [4:06] ng Gencorp. [4:06] Bakit niyo sinasabing [4:08] malaki ang value [4:09] ng Gencorp? [4:10] Kasi po sa loob po [4:11] ng Gencorp, [4:12] meron pong limang [4:12] Jollibee branches pa. [4:14] Ayon sa witness, [4:16] aabot sa halagang [4:16] P35 to P50 million [4:18] ang halaga ng franchise [4:20] ng nasabing [4:21] fast food chain. [4:22] Kunit, [4:23] mukhang hindi [4:24] nagtutugbang halagang ito [4:25] kung ang kapital [4:26] ng Gencorp [4:27] ang pag-uusapan. [4:29] Subalit ang kapital [4:30] lang po ng Gencorp [4:31] ay 1,250,000. [4:34] Ganito rin ang kaso [4:35] sa ibang kumpanya [4:36] na nakakabit [4:37] sa bisaya at asawa nito. [4:39] Tulad ng Metro City [4:40] Chao Foods [4:41] at maging [4:41] ang Cali 88 Foods [4:43] Corporation. [4:44] Timbago sa batas [4:45] ang nasasakdal. [4:47] Kaya naman, [4:48] katakataka [4:49] kung bakit nila [4:50] hindi nito alam [4:51] ang mga paglabag [4:52] sa salingang batas [4:53] kaugnay [4:54] ng sinumpaan [4:55] itong tungkulin. [4:56] Si BP Sara [4:57] ay isang [4:58] mapanuring [4:59] abogado. [5:01] Ang kanyang kabyak [5:02] si Attorney [5:02] Manscarpio [5:04] ay isang [5:05] tanyag [5:05] na abogado. [5:07] Bakit kahit [5:07] isa man lang [5:08] sa kanila [5:09] hindi sa ulado [5:11] ang Article 7 [5:12] Section 13 [5:14] ng ating [5:15] Konstitusyon? [5:16] Strike 2 na po ito [5:17] Mr. President [5:18] Officer. [5:19] Maybe, [5:20] just maybe, [5:21] they intentionally [5:22] ignored [5:23] the said [5:24] law thinking [5:25] that they are [5:26] exception to the rule [5:27] because [5:29] for them [5:30] what are they [5:31] in power for? [5:33] Therefore, [5:33] they should [5:33] be [5:34] untouchable. [5:36] Alright, [5:42] salamat po, [5:43] pero we will [5:43] pause for a while [5:44] para po lang po [5:45] mabigyan ng pagkakataon [5:46] na makapagsettle down [5:47] ng ating mga guests [5:48] for today. [6:32] Udi po, [6:33] isang magandang tanghali [6:34] sa ating lahat. [6:34] Nung gabalik po tayo [6:35] para sa ating [6:36] talakayan [6:37] ngayong tanghali [6:38] na ito. [6:39] Makakapiling po natin, [6:40] walang iba [6:40] kundi ang [6:41] advisor [6:42] ng House [6:42] Impeachment Team, [6:43] si [6:44] former Congressman [6:45] Ace Barbers. [6:47] Ang isa sa ating [6:48] mga prosecutors, [6:49] si Representative [6:50] Joel Chuan [6:51] ng 3rd District [6:52] ng Manila [6:52] at ang ating [6:53] Council for the [6:54] Prosecution [6:55] and Spokesperson [6:56] Attorney [6:57] Benjamin J. [6:58] Tulose Jr. [6:59] Baka may gusto po bang [7:03] paunang pananalita [7:04] ang ating mga [7:05] miembro ng panel [7:07] o diretsyon na tayo [7:10] sa ating mga katanungan. [7:11] Kung gano'n, [7:12] i-open na po natin [7:13] ang floor [7:14] para sa mga questions. [7:15] Go ahead. [7:18] Morning po ko [7:19] ang Sen. Atty. [7:20] Balikan lang po natin [7:21] yung mga statements [7:22] during the weekend [7:23] but before that, [7:24] can you give us [7:24] a brief assessment? [7:26] Doon po siya [7:26] naging cross-examination [7:27] ni Atty. [7:28] This time, [7:29] compared to the last [7:30] cross-examination, [7:31] may direksyon po ba [7:32] tayong nakikita. [7:35] Okay, [7:35] ako muna. [7:37] Isa lang, [7:38] sa tingin ko, [7:39] very consistent naman [7:40] yung mga lawyers [7:42] sa defense panel. [7:44] Consistent sila sa [7:45] hindi nila nagiba [7:47] yung mga witnesses [7:49] na ating pinisinta. [7:51] So, [7:51] in fairness to them, [7:52] they're very consistent. [7:57] As mentioned po kanina, [7:58] may mga statements po [7:59] over the weekend [8:00] in relation to impeachment. [8:02] One of which is [8:03] President Ferdinand [8:04] Bongbong Marcos Jr. [8:05] We know him [8:06] that he usually [8:07] does not express [8:08] his opinion [8:09] to the impeachment [8:10] matters. [8:10] But, [8:11] one statement po [8:12] from him, [8:13] he mentioned that [8:14] threat at the highest [8:16] level, [8:17] kung i-koconsidera niya, [8:18] kung totoo po, [8:19] itong Chinese remittances [8:20] na natanggap daw po [8:21] ng KAL88. [8:22] The President himself [8:23] stating this, [8:24] what do you think [8:26] does this state [8:27] to the case [8:28] of the prosecution? [8:29] I think si Kong Barbers [8:33] po ulit ang makakasagot. [8:35] So, ano, [8:36] hindi, [8:37] talagang [8:37] very alarming kasi [8:39] dahil merong [8:40] national security [8:42] implications yan. [8:43] Kaya, [8:44] kung ito'y mapapatunayan [8:46] at merong [8:46] mabigat na [8:47] ebidensyang [8:48] magpapatunay [8:49] na talagang [8:49] may tinanggap [8:51] na pera [8:52] na ganung [8:53] kalaking halaga [8:54] pumasok [8:55] sa isang kumpanya [8:56] na posibleng [8:59] ginamit [9:02] para pagpondo [9:03] sa political [9:05] activities [9:06] ng ating [9:06] pangalawang [9:07] Pangulo, [9:08] kung ito'y [9:09] mapapatunayan [9:10] sa isang [9:10] malalimang [9:12] investigasyon, [9:12] therefore, [9:14] napaka-alarming [9:16] at nakakatakot [9:17] ito. [9:18] At ito [9:19] ay may serious [9:20] national security [9:21] implication. [9:24] Well, [9:25] Wiggy, [9:25] if [9:26] these [9:27] allegations [9:28] are found [9:29] to be [9:29] true [9:30] and accurate [9:30] by the [9:31] senator judges, [9:32] it may have [9:33] national security [9:34] implications [9:35] as mentioned [9:35] by Kong [9:36] Ace. [9:37] And again, [9:38] insofar as [9:39] these impeachment [9:39] proceedings [9:40] are concerned, [9:41] ang pinag-uusapan [9:42] natin dito [9:43] at the end of [9:43] the day, [9:44] tinutukoy natin [9:45] is, [9:45] is the vice [9:46] president [9:47] still fit [9:48] to continue [9:48] to hold [9:49] that position, [9:50] a second [9:51] highest official [9:51] of the land? [9:52] And lagi, [9:53] mabalik tayo [9:54] dun sa question, [9:55] no? [9:57] Was there [9:58] culpable [10:00] violation [10:01] of the [10:01] constitution, [10:02] did she [10:02] betray [10:03] the [10:03] public [10:03] trust? [10:04] So, [10:05] in looking [10:06] into this [10:07] issue, [10:07] if she, [10:09] in fact, [10:09] received funds [10:10] from [10:11] foreign [10:13] government, [10:14] no? [10:14] Which [10:14] has taken [10:16] aggressive [10:16] actions [10:17] against [10:17] our [10:17] country, [10:19] certainly, [10:22] this [10:22] constitutional [10:22] provisions [10:23] will come [10:24] into play [10:24] and they'll [10:24] be considered [10:25] by the [10:26] senator [10:27] judges [10:27] if they [10:27] were, [10:28] in fact, [10:29] violated. [10:29] Again, [10:30] we've already [10:31] stated before, [10:33] the vice [10:35] president is [10:35] absolutely [10:36] prohibited [10:37] from receiving [10:38] gifts or any [10:41] compensation [10:42] from any [10:43] foreign [10:43] government. [10:44] So, [10:44] I'm sure [10:45] that's a matter [10:46] that they could [10:47] look into. [10:47] And, [10:48] you know, [10:49] ultimately, [10:50] I'm sure [10:52] they'll [10:52] weigh in [10:53] on that [10:53] issue. [10:54] Seryoso ba [10:55] itong [10:56] paglabag, [10:59] hindi lang [10:59] sa [11:00] constitution, [11:00] but [11:00] isa tiwala [11:01] ng bayan, [11:02] kung [11:02] tumanggap [11:03] talaga siya [11:03] ng [11:03] ganitong [11:04] pera [11:04] from [11:05] another [11:05] country, [11:06] which [11:06] has [11:07] taken [11:07] aggressive [11:07] actions [11:08] against [11:08] us. [11:08] Okay, [11:09] last na lang po, [11:10] sa pagbubukas po [11:11] nung day [11:12] 38 ng impeachment [11:13] trial, [11:13] may press [11:14] conference din po [11:15] si [11:15] Vice [11:16] President [11:16] Sarah [11:16] since it's [11:17] the 91st [11:17] anniversary [11:18] daw po [11:18] ng OVP. [11:19] And, [11:20] she [11:20] said po [11:22] na may [11:22] lumapit [11:22] daw po [11:23] sa [11:23] kanya [11:23] at [11:23] kinukumpara [11:24] daw po [11:24] siya [11:25] kay [11:25] former [11:25] Vice [11:26] President [11:26] Judge [11:26] Mer [11:26] Binay [11:27] that [11:28] during [11:28] that [11:28] time, [11:29] inuulan [11:30] daw po [11:31] ng [11:31] paninira [11:31] sa [11:32] kanya. [11:32] Ang [11:32] sagot [11:32] po [11:33] niya, [11:34] alam [11:34] niyo, [11:34] wala [11:35] si [11:36] Binay [11:36] sa akin [11:36] dahil [11:37] hindi [11:37] siya [11:37] umabot [11:38] sa [11:38] impeachment [11:38] not [11:39] once [11:40] but [11:40] twice. [11:41] How [11:41] do [11:41] you [11:41] read [11:41] this [11:42] behavior [11:43] of [11:43] VP [11:43] Sarah [11:44] now [11:44] that [11:45] she's [11:45] on [11:45] trial? [11:54] Ako [11:54] personally [11:55] ang [11:55] opinion [11:56] ko [11:56] dyan [11:56] ay [11:57] itong [11:59] nangyayaring [12:00] impeachment [12:01] proceedings [12:01] ngayon [12:02] ay [12:03] hindi [12:04] ito [12:05] gaya [12:05] ng [12:06] naiisip [12:07] ng [12:07] iba [12:07] na [12:08] ito [12:08] ay [12:08] isang [12:09] political [12:10] persecution [12:11] against [12:12] the [12:12] Vice [12:12] President. [12:13] Definitely [12:13] not. [12:14] Why? [12:15] Because [12:15] nakita [12:16] naman [12:16] ninyo [12:16] at [12:16] nakita [12:17] ng [12:17] ating [12:17] mga [12:17] kababayan [12:18] ang [12:19] mga [12:19] ebidensya [12:20] ating [12:20] inilatag [12:21] ang mga [12:22] testimonya [12:22] mula [12:23] sa mga [12:23] credible [12:24] na mga [12:24] witnesses [12:24] gaya [12:25] nga [12:25] nga [12:25] sinabi ko [12:26] kanina [12:26] ay [12:27] hindi [12:27] nila [12:28] na [12:28] impeach [12:29] yung [12:29] mga [12:30] witnesses [12:31] na [12:31] impirisinta [12:32] ng ating [12:32] prosecution [12:33] panel. [12:34] So [12:34] again, [12:35] ang [12:36] nagsasalita [12:36] dito [12:37] ang [12:37] ebidensya [12:38] ang [12:38] nagsasalita [12:39] dito [12:39] yung [12:40] mga [12:40] dokumento [12:41] itong [12:41] mga [12:41] dokumentong [12:42] ito [12:42] ay [12:43] galing [12:43] mismo [12:44] sa [12:44] mga [12:44] reputable [12:45] institutions [12:46] such [12:46] as [12:46] banks [12:47] at [12:48] mga [12:48] government [12:48] agencies [12:49] na [12:49] hindi [12:50] matatawaran [12:51] ang [12:51] kanilang [12:53] credibilidad [12:54] because [12:54] the [12:55] documents [12:55] will [12:56] speak [12:56] for [12:56] itself. [12:57] So [12:58] yun ang [12:58] aking [12:58] pananaw [12:59] dyan. [12:59] I [13:03] think [13:03] in [13:03] answering [13:03] that [13:04] I [13:04] will [13:04] quote [13:04] the [13:05] statement [13:05] given [13:06] last [13:07] over [13:07] the [13:07] weekend [13:08] by [13:08] one [13:08] of [13:08] the [13:09] senator [13:09] judges. [13:11] It [13:11] was [13:11] stated [13:12] by [13:13] Senator [13:14] Ping [13:14] Lacson. [13:15] Let [13:16] me [13:16] read it [13:16] to be [13:17] accurate. [13:18] Without [13:18] intending [13:19] to [13:19] prejudge [13:19] the [13:20] outcome [13:20] and [13:20] subject [13:21] to [13:21] any [13:21] convincing [13:21] rebuttal, [13:22] the [13:22] defense [13:23] may [13:23] present [13:23] during [13:24] the [13:24] cross [13:24] examination [13:24] of [13:25] prosecution [13:25] expert [13:26] witness [13:26] attorney [13:27] Alexander [13:27] Cabrera. [13:28] Congress [13:28] shall [13:29] joke [13:29] not [13:29] to [13:30] have [13:30] tied [13:30] up [13:30] the [13:30] issues [13:31] under [13:31] article [13:31] 2 [13:32] with [13:32] remarkable [13:32] clarity [13:33] precision [13:33] and [13:34] coherence. [13:34] So [13:34] in [13:35] other [13:35] words, [13:36] we're [13:36] here [13:36] to [13:37] point [13:37] that [13:37] this [13:39] serious [13:40] allegations [13:41] and [13:42] evidence [13:42] that [13:43] we've [13:43] seen [13:43] so [13:43] far [13:43] cannot [13:44] be [13:44] easily [13:45] dismissed [13:45] by [13:46] saying [13:46] that [13:46] these [13:47] are [13:47] just [13:47] a [13:48] product [13:49] of [13:49] political [13:50] persecution [13:51] or [13:51] whatever [13:52] other [13:52] motives. [13:53] So [13:53] as [13:54] mentioned [13:54] the [13:54] important [13:55] here [13:56] is [13:56] to [13:57] give [13:57] them [13:57] to [13:58] give [13:58] a [13:59] public [14:00] and [14:01] public [14:03] and [14:04] apparently [14:07] members [14:08] of the [14:08] impeachment [14:09] court [14:09] also [14:10] because [14:10] there are [14:13] serious [14:14] questions [14:15] before the [14:15] court [14:16] based on [14:17] not just [14:18] allegations [14:18] of the [14:18] prosecution [14:19] based on [14:19] official [14:20] records [14:20] government [14:21] records [14:21] bank [14:22] records [14:22] which [14:23] shows [14:23] financial [14:25] picture [14:26] of the [14:27] vice [14:28] president [14:28] so [14:28] you should [14:29] have [14:29] to [14:30] with [14:30] credible [14:32] evidence [14:32] from [14:33] the [14:33] other [14:33] side [14:33] of [14:36] the [14:37] court [14:39] as we [14:39] listened [14:41] to [14:41] the [14:42] cross [14:42] defense [14:44] sabi [14:44] ko [14:44] nga [14:44] consistent [14:45] sila [14:45] sa [14:46] hindi [14:46] pag [14:46] giba [14:47] ng [14:48] testimony [14:49] ng [14:50] witnesses [14:50] kumbaga [14:51] parang [14:52] habang [14:54] pinakikinggan [14:55] natin [14:55] yung [14:55] kanilang [14:56] pagtatanong [14:56] nanguhula [14:57] nga kami [14:58] kung saan [14:58] papunta [14:58] para bang [14:59] tinotorture [15:01] tayo [15:01] dito [15:01] para [15:02] pakinggan [15:03] yung [15:03] mga [15:03] ganong [15:04] klaseng [15:04] tanong [15:05] again [15:05] they [15:06] were [15:06] not [15:06] directly [15:08] asking [15:08] questions [15:09] pertaining [15:10] to [15:11] the [15:11] findings [15:12] kung [15:14] gano [15:15] kabigat [15:16] itong [15:16] mga [15:16] findings [15:17] na [15:17] isinama [15:18] dito [15:19] sa report [15:19] so [15:19] again [15:20] I feel [15:21] that [15:21] this [15:21] is [15:21] like [15:22] parang [15:24] pinapahaba [15:25] na parang [15:26] natutorture [15:26] tayo [15:27] para makinig [15:28] dun sa mga [15:28] questions [15:29] that [15:29] sometimes [15:30] are [15:31] irrelevant [15:32] to me [15:33] Well [15:37] unang-una [15:38] tingnan muna [15:38] natin [15:39] yung [15:39] konteksto [15:40] paano [15:41] na [15:41] paano [15:42] niya [15:42] sasabihin [15:43] na [15:43] kung paano [15:45] naging [15:45] dalawang [15:46] beses [15:46] siyang [15:46] in-impeach [15:47] unang-una [15:48] kasi [15:49] yung [15:49] kanyang [15:50] impeachment [15:51] ay finahil [15:52] noong [15:52] 19th [15:53] Congress [15:53] at [15:54] ito [15:54] rin [15:54] naman [15:55] ay [15:55] base [15:56] sa [15:57] report [15:58] ng [15:59] Commission [16:00] on Audit [16:01] kung saan [16:02] may mga [16:03] notice of [16:04] disallowance [16:05] na naganap [16:06] sa kanyang [16:06] mga [16:07] confidential [16:08] fund [16:08] at [16:09] ito [16:09] ay [16:09] hindi [16:09] naman [16:10] nila [16:10] maipaliwanag [16:11] Pangalawa [16:12] kung maaalala [16:13] ninyo [16:13] nangyari [16:14] rin [16:14] ito [16:15] noong [16:15] 19th [16:15] Congress [16:16] kung saan [16:17] siya [16:17] ay nagbanta [16:18] sa ating [16:19] Pangulo [16:20] sa ating [16:21] First Lady [16:22] sa former [16:22] Speaker [16:23] na [16:24] nag-cause [16:27] ng grave [16:28] threat [16:28] pero [16:29] bagamat [16:30] ganun [16:31] nangyari [16:31] ito'y [16:32] na-file [16:32] sa [16:33] Senado [16:35] pero [16:36] nagkaroon [16:36] ng ruling [16:37] ang [16:37] Korte [16:37] Suprema [16:38] hindi [16:39] naman [16:39] base [16:39] sa [16:40] merito [16:40] ang [16:41] naging ruling [16:42] ng [16:42] Korte [16:42] Suprema [16:43] ay base [16:43] sa [16:44] technicality [16:45] yung [16:46] sinasabi [16:46] po [16:46] nating [16:47] one year [16:47] barul [16:48] so [16:49] ito [16:49] naman [16:49] pong [16:50] pangalawang [16:51] hindi po [16:51] ibig sabihin [16:52] na [16:53] porque [16:53] dito [16:54] ay [16:54] na-dismiss [16:55] ng [16:56] Korte [16:56] Suprema [16:57] ay ibig [16:57] sabihin [16:58] hindi na [16:58] siya [16:58] dapat [16:59] panagutin [17:00] sa mga [17:01] nagawa [17:02] niya [17:02] nung [17:03] nakaraang [17:05] ilang [17:05] taon [17:05] kaya [17:06] ito [17:06] naman [17:07] ay [17:07] ang [17:08] pinagbabasihan [17:09] na natin [17:09] ngayon [17:10] ay yung [17:10] mismong [17:11] substansya [17:11] o yung [17:12] substance [17:12] ng [17:13] impeachment [17:14] at [17:14] hindi [17:15] na [17:15] base [17:16] sa [17:16] technicality [17:17] so [17:17] maliwanag [17:17] po [17:17] ang [17:18] ating [17:18] saligang [17:18] batas [17:19] public [17:20] office [17:21] is a [17:21] public [17:21] trust [17:22] so [17:22] hindi [17:22] po [17:23] porque [17:23] siya [17:24] ay [17:24] vice [17:25] presidente [17:25] ibig [17:26] sabihin [17:27] po [17:27] niyan [17:27] immune [17:29] na [17:29] siya [17:30] sa [17:30] lahat [17:31] ng [17:31] kanilang [17:31] gagawin [17:32] Alright [17:34] Thank you [17:35] Let's hear [17:36] now from [17:37] Gab [17:37] Sirs [17:40] meron [17:42] po lumabas [17:42] na Pulse [17:43] Asia [17:43] survey [17:44] kanina [17:44] kanina [17:45] lang [17:45] Doon [17:47] sa Pulse [17:47] Asia [17:48] survey [17:48] it was [17:49] taken [17:49] yung [17:50] survey [17:50] the [17:51] questions [17:51] were [17:51] fielded [17:52] during [17:53] from [17:54] September [17:55] 17 [17:55] to [17:56] 24 [17:56] kasagsagan [17:57] po [17:57] ng [17:57] trial [17:58] tapos [17:59] may [17:59] lima [17:59] pong [17:59] scenario [18:00] na [18:00] lumabas [18:01] doon [18:01] sa [18:01] scenarios [18:02] parang [18:04] nagtry [18:05] sila ng iba [18:06] ibang [18:06] combination [18:07] of [18:07] presidential [18:07] candidates [18:08] set [18:10] A [18:10] ang [18:11] naglaban [18:12] laban [18:12] daw [18:12] Sara [18:13] Duterte [18:13] Lenny [18:14] Robredo [18:14] Rafi [18:15] Tulfo [18:15] ang [18:16] nanalo [18:16] Sara [18:17] Duterte [18:17] 52 [18:18] closest [18:18] was [18:18] Lenny [18:19] Robredo [18:19] at [18:19] 30 [18:20] set [18:21] B [18:21] Sara [18:21] Duterte [18:22] Erwin [18:22] Tulfo [18:23] Risa [18:23] Honte [18:23] Veros [18:24] Sara [18:24] Duterte [18:25] pa rin [18:25] ang [18:25] panalo [18:26] 57 [18:27] set [18:28] C [18:28] Sara [18:29] Duterte [18:29] Erwin [18:30] Tulfo [18:30] Obama [18:31] Quino [18:31] 57% [18:33] ulit [18:33] ng votes [18:33] kay [18:34] Sara [18:34] Duterte [18:34] set [18:35] D [18:35] Ito [18:36] So far [18:37] D [18:37] So far [18:38] D [18:38] 1 [18:39] 1 [18:39] 1 [18:39] Sara [18:40] Duterte [18:41] vs [18:41] Lenny [18:41] Robredo [18:42] 54 [18:43] against [18:44] 40 [18:44] and [18:45] Sara [18:46] Duterte [18:46] against [18:46] Risa [18:47] Honte [18:47] 60 [18:48] to [18:48] 23 [18:49] Sir [18:50] Tanong [18:51] lang [18:52] Despite [18:53] yung [18:54] survey [18:54] was [18:55] taken [18:55] during [18:56] the [18:56] height [18:56] of [18:56] the [18:56] impeachment [18:57] trial [18:57] it [18:57] seems [18:58] that [18:58] the [18:58] vice [18:58] president [18:59] still [18:59] enjoys [18:59] high [19:00] support [19:01] from [19:01] the [19:01] people [19:02] Do you [19:03] think [19:03] the [19:04] impeachment [19:05] trial [19:05] is not [19:05] making [19:06] an [19:06] impact [19:07] or [19:07] it's [19:08] not [19:08] penetrating [19:09] the [19:10] day-to-day [19:11] discussions [19:12] of the [19:12] people [19:13] Well [19:19] unang-una [19:19] dapat [19:20] alamin [19:21] natin [19:21] saan [19:22] kinandak [19:22] yung [19:23] survey [19:23] dahil [19:24] pag [19:25] ito [19:25] yung [19:25] inumission [19:26] ng [19:26] well [19:27] whether [19:28] malamang [19:29] alay nila [19:29] eh [19:30] unang-una [19:31] nagbibigay yan [19:32] ng mga lugar [19:32] kung saan [19:33] ikakandak [19:34] yung survey [19:34] so baka [19:35] mamaya [19:35] yung mga [19:36] areas [19:37] kung saan [19:38] ito [19:38] kinandak [19:38] eh [19:39] dun sa [19:39] alam nila [19:39] na [19:40] malalaka [19:40] sila [19:42] pangalawa [19:42] napaka [19:43] aga pa [19:46] para [19:46] sabihin [19:47] natin [19:47] na yan [19:48] ay yung [19:48] magiging [19:49] outcome [19:49] dahil [19:50] based [19:50] sa mga [19:51] experience [19:51] natin [19:52] sa [19:52] politika [19:52] since [19:53] time [19:54] immemorial [19:54] lahat [19:55] ang [19:55] nanguna [19:55] sa [19:55] survey [19:56] pagdating [19:57] sa [19:57] dulo [19:58] ay [19:58] hindi [19:59] naman [19:59] ganun [20:00] na [20:00] nakikita [20:00] nating [20:01] resulta [20:02] except [20:03] for one [20:03] for [20:04] former [20:04] president [20:05] josep [20:06] estrada [20:06] pangatlo [20:09] hindi [20:09] natin [20:10] sigurado [20:10] kung yung [20:11] mga [20:11] nakalagay [20:12] doon [20:12] ay puro [20:12] kandidato [20:13] for [20:13] president [20:14] dahil [20:15] to begin [20:15] with [20:16] si [20:16] vice [20:16] president [20:17] ay [20:17] naharap [20:18] ngayon [20:18] sa [20:19] impeachment [20:19] what [20:20] if [20:20] siya [20:20] ay [20:20] na [20:22] convict [20:23] so [20:23] hindi [20:23] na [20:24] siya [20:24] qualified [20:24] pangalawa [20:25] si [20:26] VP [20:26] Lenny [20:26] ay [20:26] consistent [20:27] sa [20:27] kanyang [20:27] sinasabi [20:28] na [20:29] hindi [20:29] siya [20:29] tatakbo [20:30] so [20:31] medyo [20:32] at doon [20:33] sa mga [20:33] ibang [20:33] mga [20:33] nandiyan [20:34] dyan [20:34] ay puro [20:34] mga [20:35] hindi [20:35] naman [20:35] nagde-deklara [20:36] pa [20:36] so [20:37] as we [20:38] speak [20:39] parang [20:39] hindi [20:39] masyado [20:40] pang [20:40] premature [20:41] so [20:41] hindi [20:41] pa [20:42] natin [20:42] alam [20:42] kung [20:42] yan [20:43] ay [20:43] ginagawa [20:43] bilang [20:44] mind [20:45] conditioning [20:45] sa mga [20:46] tao [20:47] o [20:47] pwede [20:48] para [20:48] ipakita [20:49] sa mga [20:49] senator [20:50] judges [20:50] na [20:51] the [20:52] vice [20:52] president [20:52] enjoys [20:53] still [20:54] a [20:55] commanding [20:55] lead [20:56] at [20:56] lalong [20:57] lalong [20:57] sa mga [20:57] reeleksyonista [21:01] kayo [21:01] sa inyong [21:02] magiging [21:02] boto [21:03] so [21:03] hindi [21:04] natin [21:04] alam [21:04] kung [21:05] ano [21:05] ang [21:05] purpose [21:05] ng [21:06] survey [21:06] na yan [21:07] gaya [21:11] ng [21:12] observation [21:12] din [21:13] ni [21:13] congressman [21:14] chua [21:15] tungkol [21:15] dito [21:15] sa [21:15] resultang [21:16] ito [21:16] maraming [21:17] tanong [21:18] number [21:18] one [21:18] bukod [21:19] dun [21:19] kung saan [21:20] ba [21:20] kinondak [21:20] yung [21:20] survey [21:21] baka [21:21] maaaring [21:22] nasa [21:23] teritoryo [21:25] na [21:25] masasabing [21:26] pabor [21:27] sa kanila [21:28] ang [21:28] mayoria [21:29] next [21:30] is [21:31] ano [21:31] ba [21:31] yung [21:31] tanong [21:32] diba [21:32] ang [21:33] tanong [21:33] maliwanag [21:34] ito bang [21:35] mga itong [21:36] personalidad [21:36] na ito [21:37] ay tatakbong [21:38] presidente [21:39] sino sa inyo [21:40] ang iboboto [21:40] nila [21:41] kasi [21:41] sometimes [21:42] yung [21:42] prompting [21:43] of the [21:43] question [21:44] will [21:44] result [21:45] to a [21:46] will [21:46] the results [21:47] will [21:47] vary [21:47] hindi [21:48] naman [21:48] siya [21:49] halimbawa [21:50] itong [21:51] nga [21:51] natanong [21:52] sa [21:53] mga [21:53] nagdeklara [21:54] kunyari [21:54] na [21:54] natatakbo [21:55] isa pala [21:56] nga [21:56] nagdeklara [21:57] ang [21:57] tatakbo [21:57] yung [21:58] mga [21:58] hypothetical [21:59] personalities [22:00] na nilagay [22:01] dun sa [22:01] survey [22:02] wala pa [22:03] namang [22:04] mismo [22:04] nang [22:04] galing [22:05] sa [22:05] kanina [22:05] na [22:05] sila [22:06] interesado [22:06] so [22:07] we [22:07] cannot [22:07] or [22:08] they [22:08] cannot [22:08] command [22:09] a [22:09] support [22:10] dahil [22:11] hindi pa [22:11] naman [22:12] din [22:12] sila [22:12] nagde-declare [22:13] ibang [22:14] marami [22:15] pang [22:15] questions [22:17] at the [22:17] bottom [22:17] line [22:18] ay [22:19] masyado [22:19] pa [22:20] tayong [22:20] maaga [22:20] hintayin [22:21] natin [22:22] ang [22:22] resulta [22:23] nitong [22:23] trial [22:25] na ito [22:26] dahil [22:27] nga [22:27] ang pinag-uusapan [22:28] dito [22:29] karapat [22:29] dapat [22:30] ba [22:30] manatili [22:31] sa [22:32] pwesto [22:32] o hindi [22:32] ba [22:32] karapat [22:33] dapat [22:33] ba [22:34] itong [22:35] politikong [22:36] ito [22:37] na [22:37] umupo [22:39] bilang [22:40] isang [22:40] lingkod [22:40] bayan [22:41] assuming [22:44] that [22:45] the [22:45] results [22:46] are [22:46] accurate [22:47] at [22:47] pinapakita [22:48] nga [22:48] na [22:49] merong [22:50] patuloy [22:51] na [22:51] sumusuporta [22:52] at [22:52] nagtitiwala [22:52] sa [22:53] vice [22:53] presidente [22:53] tulad [22:54] ng [22:54] sinabi [22:55] namin [22:55] dati [22:55] all the [22:56] more [22:56] na [22:57] dapat [22:57] masagot [22:58] ng [22:59] presidente [23:00] sa [23:00] pamamagitan [23:01] ng [23:01] ebidensya [23:02] itong [23:03] mga [23:03] aligasyon [23:05] at [23:05] ebidensya [23:05] na [23:05] nalatag [23:06] na [23:07] ng [23:07] prosecution [23:08] laban [23:08] sa [23:08] kanya [23:08] dito [23:09] sa [23:09] impeachment [23:09] proceedings [23:10] dahil [23:11] mas [23:12] seryoso [23:12] ang [23:13] issue [23:15] dito [23:15] kung [23:16] ganoon [23:16] hanggang [23:17] ngayon [23:17] merong [23:17] nagtitiwala [23:18] sa kanya [23:19] so [23:19] mas [23:19] lalo [23:20] dapat [23:20] alamin [23:20] natin [23:21] kung [23:22] sinira [23:24] ba [23:24] niya [23:24] linambag [23:25] ba [23:25] niya [23:25] ang [23:26] tiwala [23:27] nitong [23:27] mga [23:27] taong [23:28] bayan [23:28] sa [23:29] kanya [23:29] pero [23:30] sir [23:30] would [23:31] the [23:31] prosecution [23:31] use [23:32] these [23:33] figures [23:33] from [23:34] the [23:34] Pulse [23:34] Asia [23:34] survey [23:35] to [23:35] maybe [23:36] siguro [23:37] transmit [23:39] the [23:40] message [23:41] or [23:41] improve [23:42] the [23:42] messaging [23:42] kasi [23:43] it [23:43] appears [23:43] that [23:44] from [23:45] the [23:45] numbers [23:46] sir [23:46] parang [23:48] ang [23:49] pinakamababa [23:50] ni [23:50] VP [23:50] Sarah [23:50] dito [23:51] was [23:51] 52 [23:56] meron [23:57] siyang [23:58] at least [23:58] 50% [23:59] na [23:59] solid [23:59] na [24:00] foundation [24:00] na [24:00] no [24:00] matter [24:01] what [24:01] happens [24:01] during [24:02] the [24:02] trial [24:03] will [24:03] still [24:03] vote [24:04] for [24:04] her [24:04] during [24:06] the [24:07] for [24:07] the [24:07] 2028 [24:08] elections [24:08] is that [24:09] a [24:09] parang [24:10] signal [24:10] well [24:11] maybe [24:11] it [24:12] will [24:12] not [24:12] be [24:13] accurate [24:14] to [24:14] say [24:14] that [24:15] no [24:15] matter [24:15] the [24:16] results [24:16] of [24:16] this [24:16] child [24:17] that [24:17] they [24:17] will [24:17] vote [24:17] for [24:18] her [24:18] baka [24:19] in [24:19] fairness [24:20] to [24:20] the [24:20] people [24:21] who [24:21] were [24:22] made [24:22] part [24:23] of [24:23] this [24:23] survey [24:23] baka [24:24] premature [24:25] to [24:25] make [24:25] that [24:25] judgment [24:26] about [24:26] their [24:26] opinion [24:27] let's [24:27] remember [24:28] when [24:29] that [24:29] survey [24:29] was [24:30] conducted [24:30] it [24:31] was [24:32] madami [24:33] din [24:33] mga [24:33] ebidensyang [24:34] lumabas [24:35] after [24:35] that [24:35] survey [24:35] was [24:36] conducted [24:36] for [24:36] example [24:37] lalo [24:37] na [24:37] itong [24:38] witness [24:38] natin [24:39] at [24:39] si [24:39] attorney [24:40] Alex [24:40] Cabrera [24:40] hindi pa [24:41] narinig [24:42] kung [24:42] itong [24:43] yung [24:43] witness [24:44] na [24:44] pinagtahitahe [24:45] lahat [24:45] nitong [24:46] mga [24:47] different [24:48] bank [24:49] records [24:49] financial [24:50] transactions [24:50] etc. [24:51] na [24:52] pre-resenta [24:52] ng prosecution [24:53] paukol [24:54] sa unexplained [24:55] wealth [24:55] na [24:55] allegation [24:56] against [24:56] the [24:57] vice [24:57] president [24:57] so [24:58] baka [24:59] hindi [24:59] din [24:59] fair [25:00] to say [25:01] to [25:01] them [25:01] na [25:01] kahit [25:03] anong [25:03] lumabas [25:03] dito [25:04] hindi [25:05] magbabago [25:05] opinion [25:06] ng mga [25:06] kababayan [25:07] natin [25:07] sa vice [25:07] presidente [25:08] dagdagan ko [25:09] ng [25:10] konti [25:10] rin [25:11] if you [25:12] recall [25:12] itong [25:13] karang [25:14] halos [25:14] mahigit [25:15] isang buwan [25:16] ang pinag-uusapan [25:18] ay numero [25:18] you are [25:20] correct [25:20] in saying [25:21] that [25:21] there must [25:22] be [25:22] some [25:22] room [25:22] for [25:23] improvement [25:23] dun [25:24] sa [25:24] communications [25:25] aspect [25:26] of [25:27] letting [25:28] the [25:28] people [25:28] know [25:28] kung [25:29] ano [25:29] yung [25:29] nangyayari [25:29] sa [25:29] loob [25:30] ng [25:30] korte [25:30] mahalaga [25:31] yan [25:31] kasi [25:32] ang [25:33] ina-address [25:33] dapat [25:34] ng ating [25:34] mga [25:35] communication [25:37] strategies [25:39] ay yung [25:39] mga [25:39] tao [25:40] na [25:40] hindi [25:41] naman [25:42] palagi [25:42] nakakasubaybay [25:43] hindi [25:44] naman [25:44] palagi [25:45] nakikinig [25:45] sa [25:46] radio [25:48] or sa [25:48] TV [25:49] at [25:49] most [25:50] of [25:50] them [25:50] are [25:50] influenced [25:51] perhaps [25:51] by [25:52] what [25:52] they [25:52] see [25:53] and [25:53] read [25:53] in [25:54] the [25:54] social [25:54] media [25:55] kaya [25:55] dun [25:56] siguro [25:56] sa [25:56] aspetong [25:57] yun [25:57] we [25:58] agree [25:58] that [25:59] there [25:59] is [25:59] a [25:59] need [25:59] to [26:00] improve [26:00] on [26:01] the [26:01] communication [26:01] strategy [26:03] and [26:04] precisely [26:05] targeting [26:06] or [26:06] pinpointing [26:07] yung [26:07] market [26:08] yung [26:08] target [26:09] market [26:09] sa [26:10] communications [26:10] well [26:12] unang-una [26:13] tingnan muna [26:14] natin [26:14] dun sa [26:15] mga [26:15] sinorbay [26:16] siya [26:16] pa lang [26:17] naman [26:17] talaga [26:17] ang [26:17] officially [26:18] nagde-declare [26:19] sa lahat [26:20] pangalawa [26:21] assuming [26:22] for the [26:22] sake [26:22] of [26:23] argument [26:23] na [26:24] totoo [26:24] po [26:24] yung [26:25] mga [26:25] numero [26:26] na [26:27] pinakikita [26:27] nila [26:28] pero [26:29] ang [26:29] tanong [26:29] po [26:29] dito [26:30] ay [26:30] simple [26:30] lang [26:31] karapat [26:32] dapat [26:32] po [26:33] ba [26:33] siya [26:33] para [26:34] sa [26:34] posisyon [26:35] at [26:36] pinakikita [26:37] po [26:37] dito [26:37] sa [26:37] trial [26:38] sa [26:38] tingin [26:39] po [26:39] namin [26:39] hindi [26:40] thank [26:41] you [26:41] sir [26:42] all [26:43] right [26:44] good [26:49] afternoon [26:49] po [26:49] may [26:50] be [26:50] kay [26:50] attorney [26:50] jason's [26:51] procedural [26:51] question [26:52] attorney [26:52] walk us [26:53] through [26:53] what [26:54] will [26:54] happen [26:54] after [26:55] the [26:56] conclusion [26:57] of [26:58] cross [26:59] direct [27:00] and [27:00] redirect [27:01] and [27:01] recross [27:02] of [27:03] Mr. [27:04] Cabrera [27:05] given [27:07] that [27:08] it was [27:08] already [27:09] said [27:09] last [27:09] week [27:09] that [27:10] Cabrera [27:10] is [27:10] the [27:10] last [27:11] witness [27:11] of [27:11] the [27:12] prosecution [27:13] and [27:13] the [27:13] prosecution [27:14] also [27:14] said [27:14] that [27:15] you [27:16] have [27:17] dropped [27:17] the [27:18] article [27:18] of [27:19] impeachment [27:19] on [27:19] bribery [27:20] conclusion [27:22] pa [27:22] ba [27:22] pa [27:22] ano [27:22] ba [27:23] yung [27:23] inaasahan [27:24] natin [27:25] from [27:25] the [27:25] prosecution [27:25] So [27:26] since [27:26] you'll [27:26] be [27:26] our [27:27] last [27:27] witness [27:28] normally [27:30] in [27:31] ordinary [27:32] criminal [27:33] or [27:33] civil [27:33] cases [27:34] what [27:34] will [27:34] happen [27:34] is [27:35] the [27:37] party [27:37] who [27:38] presented [27:39] evidence [27:39] will now [27:40] file a [27:40] formal [27:41] offer [27:41] of [27:41] evidence [27:42] tapos [27:43] the [27:43] other [27:43] party [27:44] will [27:44] be [27:44] given [27:44] a [27:44] chance [27:45] to [27:45] find [27:45] their [27:45] comment [27:46] or [27:46] objections [27:46] and [27:47] then [27:47] the [27:47] court [27:47] will [27:47] rule [27:48] on [27:48] it [27:48] after [27:49] ruling [27:49] on [27:49] it [27:49] and [27:50] then [27:50] that's [27:51] the [27:51] time [27:51] that [27:51] the [27:51] other [27:52] party [27:52] will [27:52] start [27:52] presenting [27:53] their [27:54] evidence [27:54] but [27:55] here [27:56] we [27:57] don't [27:57] want [27:57] to [27:57] preempt [27:58] the [27:58] action [27:59] that [27:59] the [28:00] impeachment [28:00] court [28:01] may [28:01] take [28:01] maaring [28:02] ang [28:03] rule [28:03] na [28:04] gagawin [28:04] nila [28:04] pareho [28:05] dun [28:05] sa [28:05] lower [28:06] courts [28:06] sa [28:06] trial [28:06] courts [28:07] and [28:07] then [28:07] that's [28:08] what's [28:09] going [28:09] to [28:09] happen [28:09] we [28:10] will [28:10] be [28:10] directed [28:11] to [28:11] file [28:11] our [28:12] formal [28:12] offer [28:12] be [28:13] beginning [28:13] chance [28:14] na [28:14] sumagot [28:15] ng [28:15] kabilang [28:16] partido [28:16] the [28:17] court [28:17] will [28:17] rule [28:17] on [28:17] it [28:18] and [28:18] most [28:18] probably [28:18] if [28:19] that [28:19] will [28:19] be [28:19] the [28:19] case [28:19] mokong [28:20] sa [28:21] resumption [28:21] na [28:22] ng [28:22] hearing [28:22] after [28:23] the [28:23] break [28:23] because [28:24] we [28:24] know [28:24] there [28:25] will [28:25] be [28:25] a [28:25] break [28:25] sometime [28:26] mid [28:26] October [28:27] until [28:27] November [28:28] pagbalik [28:29] that [28:30] will [28:31] be [28:31] the [28:31] start [28:31] of [28:31] their [28:31] presentation [28:32] of [28:32] evidence [28:33] but [28:33] as [28:35] I've [28:35] stated [28:35] I [28:36] don't [28:36] want [28:36] to [28:36] preempt [28:36] the [28:37] court [28:37] 's [28:37] action [28:37] kasi [28:37] baka [28:38] naman [28:38] ibang [28:39] procedure [28:39] nila [28:40] dito [28:40] for [28:41] example [28:42] maalala [28:43] natin [28:48] yet [28:48] with [28:48] respect [28:49] to [28:50] article [28:51] 1 [28:52] yung [28:52] confidential [28:52] funds [28:53] dahil [28:54] nga [28:55] daw [28:55] baka [28:55] the [28:56] court [28:56] will [28:57] call [28:58] additional [28:59] witnesses [29:00] at the [29:00] end [29:01] so [29:01] let's [29:03] see [29:03] how [29:03] the [29:03] court [29:04] will [29:04] clarify [29:04] that [29:04] order [29:05] no [29:05] you [29:07] rest [29:07] your [29:07] case [29:07] already [29:08] kasi [29:08] kung [29:08] tatawagin [29:09] yan [29:09] it [29:09] will [29:09] be [29:10] the [29:10] court's [29:10] witnesses [29:11] not [29:11] yours [29:12] so [29:12] pwede [29:12] ka [29:12] na [29:12] magrest [29:13] so [29:14] but [29:15] there's [29:15] that [29:15] ruling [29:15] so [29:16] that's [29:16] why [29:16] we [29:16] ayaw [29:18] na [29:18] magbigay [29:18] ng [29:19] definitive [29:20] assumption [29:22] as to [29:23] how [29:23] the [29:23] court [29:24] will [29:24] handle [29:24] this [29:24] matter [29:25] so [29:25] that [29:27] will [29:27] probably [29:28] be [29:28] clarified [29:29] later [29:30] pagkatapos [29:31] na ng [29:31] cross [29:33] redirect [29:33] recross [29:34] ng last [29:35] witness [29:35] namin [29:35] and then [29:36] we'll [29:36] see [29:37] how [29:37] we'll [29:37] move [29:37] forward [29:38] kasi [29:39] kami [29:39] ang gusto [29:40] sana [29:40] namin [29:40] as stated [29:41] in our [29:41] manifestation [29:42] wag [29:44] nating [29:44] sayangin [29:46] yung [29:46] natitirang [29:47] oras [29:47] pa [29:47] before [29:47] the [29:47] break [29:48] that's [29:48] why [29:48] you're [29:49] requesting [29:49] if [29:49] possible [29:50] that [29:51] the [29:51] defense [29:51] be [29:51] directed [29:52] to [29:52] immediately [29:53] start [29:54] presenting [29:54] its own [29:54] evidence [29:55] already [29:55] pagkatapos [29:56] namin [29:56] mag-conclude [29:57] but [29:58] we'll [29:58] find out [29:59] later [29:59] how [30:00] the [30:01] court [30:01] will [30:02] rule [30:02] on [30:02] this [30:02] kung [30:03] sasabihin [30:03] na ba [30:03] sa direct [30:04] start [30:04] na [30:04] kayo [30:05] or [30:05] sasabihin [30:06] prosecution [30:08] formal [30:09] offer [30:10] muna [30:10] kayo [30:10] of [30:10] evidence [30:11] sa [30:12] normal [30:14] court [30:14] proceedings [30:15] kasi [30:15] pag [30:18] nag-rest [30:18] pag [30:18] natapos [30:19] ang [30:19] presentation [30:21] ng [30:22] prosecution [30:22] witness [30:23] or [30:24] witnesses [30:24] nag-rest [30:26] na [30:26] so anong [30:27] ibig sabihin [30:27] ng [30:28] pag [30:28] nag-rest [30:28] na [30:28] ibig sabihin [30:29] sinasarado [30:30] na namin [30:30] yung [30:31] pinto [30:31] ibig sabihin [30:32] wala na [30:33] kaming [30:33] ipatatawag [30:34] kaya po [30:35] after neto [30:37] after [30:37] mag-rest [30:37] ng [30:38] prosecution [30:38] ang [30:40] normal [30:41] na [30:41] ginagawa [30:41] po [30:42] dyan [30:42] nagsasubmit [30:43] kami [30:43] ng [30:43] formal [30:44] offer [30:44] of [30:44] evidence [30:45] ibig sabihin [30:46] sinarado [30:47] na namin [30:47] yung [30:47] pinto [30:48] wala na [30:48] kami [30:48] patatawag [30:49] na [30:49] testigo [30:49] wala [30:50] nang [30:50] ebidensya [30:50] iprepresenta [30:51] kaya [30:52] eto [30:52] na [30:52] formally [30:53] your [30:53] honor [30:53] ang [30:54] mga [30:54] ebidensya [30:55] na [30:55] naipresenta [30:56] namin [30:56] at [30:57] ihingyan [30:57] ng [30:57] pagkakataon [30:58] yung [30:59] defense [31:00] para [31:01] magbigay [31:03] ng [31:03] kanilang [31:04] mga [31:04] komento [31:04] dito [31:05] and [31:05] then [31:05] that's [31:09] present [31:09] ng [31:09] depensa [31:10] pero [31:11] kagaya [31:11] nga po [31:12] nang [31:12] nasabi [31:12] ni [31:13] attorney [31:13] jay [31:14] nung [31:14] kami [31:14] po [31:14] ay [31:15] nag [31:15] present [31:15] ng [31:16] aming [31:16] mga [31:17] testigo [31:18] doon [31:19] sa [31:19] article [31:19] 1 [31:20] sa [31:20] confidential [31:21] fund [31:21] ay [31:22] sinabihang [31:23] kami [31:23] o [31:24] binigyan [31:24] kami [31:25] ng [31:25] payo [31:25] ng [31:26] presiding [31:27] officer [31:28] na [31:28] huwag [31:28] muna [31:28] kaming [31:29] mag-rest [31:29] so [31:30] as [31:30] we [31:30] speak [31:31] yung [31:31] article [31:32] 1 [31:32] ay [31:32] nakabukas [31:33] pa [31:33] ang [31:34] pinto [31:34] so [31:35] sa [31:35] madaling [31:36] salita [31:36] hindi [31:36] pa [31:37] namin [31:37] naisasara [31:38] so [31:38] paano [31:39] kami [31:39] makakapagbigay [31:40] ng [31:40] formal [31:41] offer [31:41] of [31:42] evidence [31:42] ibig [31:43] sabihin [31:43] paano [31:43] namin [31:44] ipepresenta [31:44] yung [31:44] mga [31:45] ebidensya [31:45] kung [31:46] nakabukas [31:46] pa [31:47] yung [31:47] pinto [31:47] ibig [31:48] sabihin [31:48] maaaring [31:49] meron [31:49] pang [31:49] mga [31:50] testigo [31:50] na [31:51] ipresenta [31:52] ang [31:53] panig [31:53] ng [31:54] prosecution [31:54] so [31:56] ngayon [31:57] ang [31:57] time po [31:58] namin [31:58] kung [31:59] ano [31:59] po [31:59] ipapayo [32:00] sa [32:00] amin [32:01] mamaya [32:01] dahil [32:02] iba [32:02] po [32:03] yung [32:03] sitwasyon [32:04] ngayon [32:05] dito [32:08] panig [32:09] ng [32:09] prosecution [32:10] since [32:10] nanabi [32:10] niyo [32:11] na po [32:11] last [32:11] week [32:11] last [32:12] witness [32:12] niyo [32:13] na [32:13] itong [32:13] si [32:13] cabrera [32:14] and [32:14] following [32:16] that [32:16] logic [32:17] po [32:17] ano [32:18] po [32:18] nangyari [32:19] doon [32:19] kay [32:20] VP [32:20] Sara [32:20] Duterte [32:21] because [32:21] the [32:22] prosecution [32:23] made [32:23] of us [32:24] last [32:24] month [32:25] saying [32:26] that [32:27] at [32:27] some [32:27] point [32:27] you're [32:28] hoping [32:28] to [32:29] present [32:30] or [32:30] to [32:31] call [32:31] the [32:31] vice [32:31] president [32:32] to [32:33] the [32:33] witness [32:33] stand [32:34] so [32:34] what [32:35] happened [32:35] to [32:35] that [32:36] plan [32:38] or [32:38] possible [32:39] plan [32:39] well [32:42] first [32:43] of all [32:44] as [32:45] you've [32:46] stated [32:46] every [32:46] time [32:47] we [32:47] make [32:47] decisions [32:48] regarding [32:48] witnesses [32:49] that [32:49] we'll [32:49] present [32:49] it's [32:50] always [32:51] based [32:51] on [32:51] our [32:51] analysis [32:52] of [32:52] the [32:52] evidence [32:53] that [32:53] we've [32:53] presented [32:53] so [32:54] far [32:54] and [32:55] we're [32:56] already [32:56] satisfied [32:57] with [32:58] the [32:58] evidence [32:58] that [32:59] we've [32:59] presented [32:59] and [33:00] the [33:00] case [33:00] that [33:00] we [33:00] built [33:00] now [33:01] narinig [33:03] na din [33:03] naman [33:04] natin [33:05] declarations [33:10] of [33:10] the [33:10] vice [33:11] president [33:11] herself [33:12] regarding [33:13] matters [33:15] affecting [33:16] itong [33:16] issue [33:17] explained [33:17] wealth [33:18] ano [33:18] ito [33:19] yung [33:19] sworn [33:20] declaration [33:21] nya [33:21] sa [33:22] kanyang [33:22] salen [33:23] yung [33:24] mga [33:24] figures [33:24] nya [33:24] sa [33:25] kanyang [33:25] nang [33:25] galing [33:25] yan [33:26] those [33:26] are [33:26] sworn [33:27] statements [33:28] nung [33:28] sinabi [33:29] niyang [33:29] ang [33:29] yaman [33:30] nya [33:30] ay [33:30] 98 [33:31] million [33:31] as [33:32] of [33:32] end [33:32] of [33:32] 2025 [33:33] she [33:35] also [33:35] spoke [33:35] through [33:36] the [33:36] bank [33:36] records [33:37] official [33:37] bank [33:37] records [33:38] that [33:39] were [33:39] presented [33:39] in [33:39] this [33:40] case [33:40] already [33:40] again [33:41] this [33:42] did [33:42] not [33:42] come [33:42] from [33:42] the [33:43] prosecution [33:43] this [33:44] did [33:44] not [33:44] come [33:44] from [33:44] the [33:45] government [33:45] ito [33:46] ay [33:46] nang [33:47] galing [33:47] sa [33:48] mga [33:48] bank [33:49] records [33:49] ng [33:50] vice [33:50] presidente [33:50] at [33:51] kanyang [33:51] asawa [33:51] she [33:52] also [33:52] spoke [33:53] through [33:53] the [33:54] BIR [33:54] records [33:55] that [33:55] were [33:55] already [33:58] nagsumiti [33:59] niyan [33:59] sa [34:00] BIR [34:00] na [34:00] sinasabi [34:01] niya [34:01] during [34:02] the [34:02] relevant [34:02] periods [34:03] ito [34:04] lang [34:04] ang [34:05] kanyang [34:05] kinita [34:05] so [34:06] we [34:07] don't [34:07] need [34:08] we [34:08] don't [34:08] see [34:09] the [34:09] need [34:09] to [34:09] get [34:10] testimonial [34:10] or [34:12] her [34:12] testimony [34:13] anymore [34:13] when [34:14] the [34:15] records [34:16] most [34:17] of [34:17] them [34:18] which [34:18] came [34:18] from [34:19] her [34:19] already [34:20] spoke [34:20] loudly [34:21] second [34:21] mukhang [34:23] based [34:24] dun [34:24] sa [34:25] naririnig [34:25] natin [34:26] dun [34:26] sa [34:26] cross [34:26] examination [34:27] ng [34:28] kabila [34:28] parang [34:29] without [34:30] not [34:31] to [34:31] preempt [34:32] the [34:33] explanation [34:33] that [34:34] they'll [34:34] be [34:34] giving [34:34] when [34:35] it's [34:35] their [34:35] turn [34:35] to [34:36] present [34:36] evidence [34:37] pero [34:37] narinig [34:38] natin [34:38] for [34:38] example [34:39] sinabi [34:40] nung [34:40] one [34:40] of [34:40] her [34:41] councils [34:41] tumayo [34:42] dun [34:42] sa [34:42] joint [34:43] account [34:43] di [34:43] na [34:43] daw [34:43] niya [34:43] maalala [34:44] and [34:45] dun [34:46] sa [34:46] cross [34:46] parang [34:48] ang [34:48] pinupunto [34:49] is [34:50] alaging [34:53] tinatanong [34:53] alam [34:53] ba [34:53] niy [34:54] yung [34:54] busy [34:54] presidente [34:54] yung [34:55] mga [34:55] transactions [34:56] bank [34:57] accounts [34:57] ng [34:58] kanyang [34:58] asawa [34:58] so [34:59] kung [34:59] sasabihin [35:00] lang [35:00] din [35:00] naman [35:01] hindi [35:01] din [35:01] niya [35:01] tulad [35:02] ng [35:02] mga [35:02] ibang [35:02] witnesses [35:03] natin [35:03] narinig [35:04] na [35:04] madami [35:04] silang [35:05] bagay [35:05] na [35:05] walang [35:05] alam [35:06] eh [35:06] kung [35:06] sasabihin [35:07] lang [35:07] din [35:07] naman [35:08] na [35:08] ganun [35:09] din [35:09] wala [35:10] ding [35:10] alam [35:10] ang [35:11] vice [35:11] president [35:11] sa [35:12] mga [35:12] bagay [35:12] na [35:12] ito [35:12] we [35:13] didn't [35:13] see [35:13] the [35:14] need [35:14] to [35:14] burden [35:17] the [35:18] court's [35:18] calendar [35:19] and [35:19] the [35:19] senator [35:20] judges [35:20] with [35:20] that [35:21] kind [35:21] of [35:21] testimony [35:21] as [35:22] of [35:22] today [35:23] wala [35:23] nang [35:23] plano [35:23] prosecution [35:24] na [35:24] ipatawag [35:25] ang [35:25] vice [35:25] presidente [35:25] that's [35:26] correct [35:26] but [35:26] of [35:26] course [35:27] if [35:27] they [35:27] want [35:27] to [35:28] you [35:28] know [35:28] we [35:31] wanted [35:32] to [35:32] give [35:32] the [35:32] senator [35:33] judges [35:33] the [35:33] chance [35:34] to [35:34] hear [35:34] the [35:35] explanation [35:35] from [35:36] her [35:36] but [35:36] we [35:36] stated [35:37] the [35:37] documents [35:38] have [35:38] spoken [35:39] already [35:39] and [35:40] we [35:41] don't [35:41] see [35:41] the [35:41] need [35:41] for [35:41] that [35:42] but [35:42] if [35:43] during [35:43] their [35:43] turn [35:44] papatawag [35:44] nila [35:44] then [35:45] we [35:45] welcome [35:45] it [35:46] and [35:46] we'll [35:46] be [35:46] ready [35:46] to [35:46] cross [35:47] examiner [35:47] as a matter [35:52] of [35:52] strategy [35:53] legal [35:54] strategy [35:55] siguro [35:55] mas maganda [35:56] ang po [35:56] pwede [35:56] magpatawag [35:57] sa ating [35:57] vice [35:58] presidente [35:58] ay [35:59] ang [35:59] defense [36:00] dahil [36:01] yun [36:01] ang [36:02] kanilang [36:02] pwede [36:02] maging [36:03] legal [36:03] strategy [36:04] para [36:04] may [36:04] paliwanag [36:05] ng [36:06] ating [36:06] vice [36:08] presidente [36:09] yung [36:10] mga [36:10] bagay [36:10] bagay [36:11] na [36:11] halimbawa [36:12] yung [36:13] mga [36:13] dokumento [36:13] na [36:14] ipingresenta [36:14] namin [36:15] alright [36:18] thank you [36:19] Dwight [36:19] G [36:20] your turn [36:22] maganda tanghali [36:23] kong [36:23] Saji [36:23] Kaamino [36:24] Brigada [36:24] News [36:24] FM [36:25] sabi [36:26] po [36:26] ni [36:26] VP [36:27] Sara [36:27] sa [36:27] press [36:28] con [36:28] niya [36:29] nag [36:30] iimbento [36:30] daw po [36:31] ng [36:31] impeachment [36:32] case [36:32] ang [36:32] prosecution [36:33] nag [36:35] umpisa [36:35] nag [36:36] isam [36:36] nag [36:37] umpisa [36:37] raw [36:37] po [36:37] kayo [36:38] sa [36:38] madriaga [36:39] pero [36:40] eventually [36:41] na [36:41] laglag [36:42] or [36:42] bumagsak [36:43] daw [36:43] po [36:43] ang [36:44] kaso [36:44] so [36:45] ngayon [36:45] nag [36:45] shift [36:46] daw [36:46] po [36:46] kayo [36:46] sa [36:46] narrative [36:47] ng [36:47] China [36:47] China [36:48] ang [36:50] binabanggit [36:51] po [36:51] niya [36:51] bumabagsak [36:52] na nga [36:52] daw po [36:52] ang [36:53] impeachment [36:54] case [36:54] against [36:55] her [36:55] Well if that is the case [36:57] we challenge the defense [36:59] mag file sila ng demurrer [37:00] to evidence [37:01] kung sa tingin nila [37:02] wala namang kaming [37:03] naipresenta [37:04] Unang-una [37:05] ito pong [37:06] impeachment [37:07] ay [37:08] kung makikita ninyo [37:09] papano po nila [37:10] sasabihin na [37:11] ito'y [37:11] imbento [37:12] halimbawa na [37:12] lamang po [37:13] sa grave threat [37:14] e [37:15] papano po niya [37:16] sasabihin na [37:16] imbento yun [37:17] e siya po mismo [37:18] hindi naman po nila [37:19] dininay [37:20] natapos po [37:22] yung presentation [37:22] pero never po [37:24] natin narinig [37:25] na dininay niya [37:25] yung mga kataga [37:26] na pagbabanta [37:28] sa presidente [37:29] sa first lady [37:30] at sa former speaker [37:31] sa dum po [37:32] sa confi fund [37:33] mismong yung mga [37:35] tauhan niya [37:37] si miss Gina [37:38] Costa mismo [37:38] nagsabi [37:39] na [37:40] apan sa utos po niya [37:41] ibinigay nila [37:42] itong pera [37:43] dito sa isang [37:45] tao [37:47] na hindi naman [37:48] accountable officer [37:49] so dito naman [37:52] ngayon [37:53] sa unexplained wealth [37:55] itong pinakikita po [37:56] natin [37:56] ay hindi naman po [37:57] itong masasabing [37:58] gawa-gawa [37:59] dahil mismo [38:00] ang AMLOC [38:01] director po [38:01] executive director [38:03] ang [38:04] nagpresenta [38:05] ng mga dokumento [38:07] at mga katibayan [38:09] so [38:10] kung [38:11] sa tingin po niya [38:12] lahat po [38:13] ng ito [38:13] ay gawa-gawa [38:14] lamang [38:14] at wala namang [38:15] naipresenta [38:16] ang prosecution [38:18] sa paniniwala [38:19] ng defense [38:20] at ng ating [38:21] vice-presidente [38:22] e bakit hindi sila [38:23] mag-file [38:24] ng demurrer [38:25] to evidence [38:26] nang sa ganun [38:26] ito po [38:27] ay mahusgahan na [38:29] ng mga senator [38:31] judges [38:31] kung meron nga po [38:32] bang ebidensya [38:33] o wala [38:34] this is a recent [38:38] statement [38:39] by the vice [38:39] president [38:40] na [38:40] gawa-gawa [38:42] lang [38:42] can you [38:44] nag-i-invento [38:45] ang prosecution [38:46] well first of all [38:47] this is not the [38:48] first time that she [38:49] made such an [38:51] accusation [38:52] against the [38:52] prosecution [38:53] we're resorting [38:55] to [38:55] fabricated [38:57] narratives [38:57] etc [38:57] so unang-una [38:59] again [39:00] we will leave it [39:01] to the court [39:02] to determine [39:03] if this constitutes [39:05] a violation [39:06] of the subjudice [39:07] rule [39:07] medyo madami-dami [39:08] na ho [39:08] yung mga [39:09] attacks against [39:10] the integrity [39:11] of the court [39:12] kung dati [39:12] sinasabi [39:13] itong mga [39:15] allegations [39:15] against the [39:16] senator judges [39:16] now against [39:17] the prosecution [39:18] so we'll leave it [39:19] to the court [39:19] kung sa tingin [39:20] may violation [39:21] ng subjudice [39:22] rule [39:22] but more importantly [39:24] again [39:24] kailangan namin [39:25] emphasize dito [39:26] as mentioned [39:27] by Kong Joel [39:28] itong narinig [39:29] natin [39:29] let's just focus [39:30] now [39:31] I'll focus [39:32] and then explain [39:33] well [39:33] hindi ito [39:34] allegations [39:36] ng prosecution [39:37] again [39:37] itong mga [39:38] numero na to [39:39] nakabase to [39:40] sa mga [39:41] bank records [39:43] tax filings [39:47] mismo [39:47] ng vice-presidente [39:48] dun sa mga [39:49] witnesses [39:52] na narinig [39:53] natin [39:53] from [39:54] we heard [39:55] witnesses [39:55] from more [39:56] than [39:56] eight [39:56] banking [39:58] institutions [39:59] tapos [40:00] I think [40:01] six [40:02] from [40:02] insurance [40:03] companies [40:03] at [40:04] again [40:05] itong sinabi [40:07] na [40:07] figure [40:09] ni [40:09] attorney [40:09] Alex Cabrera [40:11] na total [40:11] undeclared [40:12] assets [40:13] as of [40:13] end of [40:14] 2025 [40:14] ng vice-presidente [40:16] na [40:16] 817.8 [40:19] million [40:19] hindi ito [40:21] inimbento [40:22] ng prosecution [40:23] nang galing ito [40:24] sa expert [40:25] witness [40:26] at [40:26] tulad ng [40:28] pinapaliwanag [40:29] niya [40:29] magmula [40:30] last week [40:30] hanggang [40:31] ngayon [40:31] nakabatay [40:32] itong [40:33] ginawa niyang [40:34] very [40:34] conservative [40:36] estimate pa [40:37] ito [40:37] itong [40:38] binigay niya [40:39] na [40:39] 817 [40:40] million [40:40] undeclared [40:41] nakabatay [40:42] ito dun [40:42] sa lahat [40:43] ng mga [40:43] dokumento [40:44] na binigay [40:44] sa kanya [40:45] which ways [40:45] have [40:45] pinad [40:46] yung kahon-kahon [40:48] na nakita [40:49] natin [40:49] ng mga [40:49] bank records [40:50] different [40:51] financial [40:52] transactions [40:52] etc [40:53] yan ang [40:53] pinagbasihan [40:54] nitong [40:55] numero [40:55] na ito [40:56] sabi po [40:58] ni [40:59] attorney [41:00] salvador [41:00] panelo [41:01] naniniwala [41:01] siyang [41:02] mako-convict [41:02] si vice [41:05] president [41:05] saradote [41:06] but on [41:07] the basis [41:07] na [41:08] wala [41:08] rapong [41:09] evidence [41:09] political [41:10] by the [41:12] senator [41:12] judges [41:13] so [41:13] mako-convict [41:14] si [41:14] vp [41:14] saradote [41:14] pero [41:15] wala [41:15] daw [41:15] ebidensya [41:16] gusto [41:17] lang [41:18] daw [41:18] i-convict [41:18] so [41:18] hindi [41:19] daw [41:19] siya [41:19] ma [41:19] acquit [41:21] at the [41:21] end [41:21] of the [41:21] day [41:22] kung [41:22] mako-convict [41:23] ano yung [41:25] basis [41:26] nila [41:26] para [41:28] sabihin [41:28] na [41:28] mako-convict [41:29] siya [41:29] kahit [41:30] walang [41:31] ebidensya [41:31] hindi [41:32] naman [41:32] siguro [41:33] ganon [41:33] dapat [41:34] ang [41:34] tingin [41:34] natin [41:35] sa ating [41:35] mga [41:35] senator [41:36] judges [41:36] huwag [41:37] natin [41:37] tawaran [41:37] yung [41:37] kanilang [41:38] talino [41:38] yung [41:39] kanilang [41:40] servisyo [41:41] para [41:41] sa [41:41] bayan [41:42] because [41:42] itong [41:44] issue [41:44] ay [41:44] hindi [41:45] ito [41:45] ordinary [41:45] issue [41:46] na [41:46] pang-araw [41:47] issue [41:48] because [41:48] how [41:48] often [41:49] do [41:49] we [41:49] conduct [41:50] proceedings [41:51] of [41:51] impeachment [41:51] in [41:52] this [41:52] country [41:53] hindi [41:53] naman [41:54] ito [41:54] normal [41:54] as if [41:55] you're [41:56] doing [41:57] your [41:57] legislative [41:57] work [41:59] hindi [41:59] ito [42:00] ay [42:00] isang [42:00] constitutional [42:01] duty [42:02] na [42:03] pinapakita [42:04] pinipresenta [42:05] ang mga [42:07] ebidensya [42:07] gaya [42:08] nga [42:08] nang [42:08] nasabi [42:09] ng [42:09] Nikong [42:10] Joel [42:11] Chua [42:12] at [42:12] saka [42:12] ni [42:12] attorney [42:13] Jay [42:13] itong [42:14] mga [42:14] ebidensya [42:15] ito [42:15] nagsususumigaw [42:16] ng mga [42:17] ebidensya [42:17] as we [42:19] always say [42:20] the evidence [42:21] speaks [42:22] for itself [42:23] nagsusumigaw [42:25] ng mga [42:25] ebidensya [42:25] kaya [42:26] hindi [42:26] pwedeng [42:27] isipin [42:27] na ito [42:28] ay gawa-gawa [42:28] kung ito [42:29] ay gawa-gawa [42:30] are they [42:31] saying [42:31] na ito [42:32] ay ginawa [42:32] ng [42:32] prosecution [42:33] hindi [42:34] because [42:35] itong [42:35] mga [42:36] ebidensya [42:36] ito [42:37] ay [42:37] nanggaling [42:38] sa [42:38] banko [42:39] nanggaling [42:40] sa [42:40] AMLAC [42:41] nanggaling [42:42] sa [42:42] tax [42:46] filings [42:47] at [42:47] higit [42:47] sa lahat [42:48] lahat [42:48] po yan [42:49] ay nanggaling [42:50] mismo [42:50] sa bibig [42:51] ng ating [42:51] pangalawang [42:52] Pangulo [42:52] so [42:54] saan [42:55] banda [42:55] tayo [42:56] para [42:57] sabihan [42:58] na gumagawa [42:58] o ginagawa-gawa [43:00] lamang [43:01] okay [43:01] unang-una [43:04] maliwanag [43:05] dito [43:05] mga [43:06] dadagdagang [43:07] ko lang [43:07] yung sinabi [43:08] ni [43:09] Kong Ace [43:10] na ito [43:11] paano [43:12] maging [43:12] gawa-gawa [43:13] e [43:13] siya mismo [43:14] yung gumawa [43:15] ng kanyang [43:15] salin [43:15] e [43:17] siya mismo [43:18] nagdeklara [43:18] ng kanyang [43:19] business [43:19] interest [43:20] e [43:21] ang linaw-linaw [43:22] dito sa ating [43:23] saligang batas [43:24] na ang [43:24] vice-presidente [43:25] hindi po [43:25] pwedeng [43:26] magkaroon [43:27] ng kahit [43:27] na anong [43:27] business [43:28] interest [43:28] either [43:29] directly [43:30] or [43:30] indirectly [43:31] so [43:32] hindi naman po [43:34] kami ang gumawa [43:34] nun e [43:35] yung pinresenta [43:36] po namin [43:37] yung salin [43:38] na mismo [43:38] pinirmahan niya [43:39] at pinanumpaan niya [43:41] sa notaryo [43:42] yun po lamang [43:43] yung pinresenta [43:44] so ano po [43:45] yung gawa-gawa [43:46] dun [43:46] yung pong [43:47] pagbabanta [43:48] hindi rin naman po [43:48] yung AI [43:49] never naman po [43:50] nilang [43:50] tinanggi yun [43:52] diba [43:53] so [43:54] hindi ko po [43:55] alam kung [43:56] ano po yung [43:56] gawa-gawa [43:57] na sinasabi po [43:58] nila [43:58] okay [44:00] last na lang po [44:01] um [44:01] dun po [44:03] sa [44:03] cross-examination [44:05] and I think [44:05] si [44:06] attorney [44:06] man [44:07] scarpe [44:07] sinagot [44:07] na rin [44:08] po [44:08] yun [44:09] tungkol [44:09] sa [44:09] pagkas [44:10] sa [44:10] credit [44:11] card [44:11] abroad [44:13] at [44:13] some [44:15] stores [44:15] po [44:15] shoe [44:16] stores [44:17] yung [44:18] sa [44:18] like [44:19] for example [44:20] yung sa [44:20] Japan [44:20] group [44:21] naman [44:21] daw [44:21] po [44:21] kasi [44:21] yun [44:22] yung [44:23] transaction [44:25] so [44:25] kung baka [44:25] may mga [44:26] kasama [44:26] po [44:26] silang [44:27] group [44:27] kaya [44:28] umabot [44:28] po [44:28] ng [44:28] ganun [44:29] and [44:29] kanya [44:30] daw [44:31] po [44:31] yung [44:31] credit [44:32] card [44:32] po [44:33] na [44:33] yun [44:33] and [44:33] at [44:34] the [44:34] same [44:34] time [44:34] ang [44:35] sinasabi [44:35] dun [44:36] sa [44:36] sapatos [44:37] na [44:38] purchase [44:39] daw po [44:39] for [44:39] the [44:40] basketball [44:40] team [44:41] ng [44:42] anak [44:42] po [44:42] kundi [44:42] ako [44:43] nagkakaman [44:43] sinagot [44:46] niya yung [44:47] sapatos [44:47] ng buong [44:48] basketball [44:48] team [44:49] big time [44:51] so [44:52] sana [44:53] sana [44:53] yung [44:54] yaman [44:55] yaman [44:55] yun [44:56] dun [44:56] sa [44:56] kanilang [44:57] salen [44:57] kaya [44:58] nga [44:58] pinag-uusapan [44:59] at [45:00] mahalagang [45:00] maintindihan [45:01] ng ating [45:01] mga [45:02] kababayan [45:03] na [45:03] pinag-uusapan [45:04] dito [45:05] ay [45:06] yung [45:06] sinasabing [45:07] hindi [45:07] maipaliwanag [45:08] na yaman [45:08] dahil [45:10] hinihingi [45:11] lamang [45:11] po [45:11] ng ating [45:12] mga [45:12] batas [45:13] at [45:13] ng ating [45:14] saligang [45:14] batas [45:15] na [45:15] i-deklara [45:16] mo ito [45:16] bilang [45:17] isang [45:17] lingkod [45:17] bayan [45:18] kung hindi mo [45:18] kayang [45:19] maideklara [45:19] ito [45:20] at hindi ka [45:20] tumalima [45:21] sa utos [45:22] ng ating [45:22] saligang [45:23] batas [45:23] meron kang [45:25] nilabag [45:27] at dahil [45:28] ikaw [45:29] ay isang [45:29] mataas [45:29] na opisyal [45:30] ng gobyerno [45:31] ang tanong [45:32] ng taong [45:32] bayan [45:33] dapat ka [45:33] pa bang [45:34] manatili [45:34] in spite [45:35] of the [45:35] fact [45:35] na [45:36] hindi ka [45:36] tumutugon [45:38] o tumatalima [45:39] sa utos [45:39] ng ating [45:40] saligang [45:40] batas [45:41] so [45:41] yun yun [45:42] pangalawa [45:43] yung [45:44] pagkain [45:45] so [45:46] ang ibig [45:47] bang [45:47] sabihin [45:47] nanlibre [45:48] nanlibre [45:50] ng pagkain [45:51] dahil marami [45:51] sila [45:52] nanlibre [45:53] siya [45:53] sa halagang [45:54] 200,000 [45:55] pesos [45:56] mahigit [45:57] big time [45:59] inabunohan [46:02] wala silang [46:07] yan [46:11] wala silang [46:12] yan [46:12] okay [46:13] so [46:13] well [46:14] that is [46:15] their [46:15] excuse [46:16] that is [46:16] their [46:17] defense [46:17] but let [46:18] the court [46:19] establish [46:20] that [46:20] at tingnan [46:21] natin [46:22] kung ano [46:22] yung [46:23] mas [46:23] matimbang [46:24] na [46:24] ebidensyang [46:25] papaniwalaan [46:26] ng ating [46:26] mga [46:26] senator [46:27] judges [46:27] more than the [46:32] purpose [46:33] kung para [46:33] saan itong [46:33] mga [46:34] transactions [46:34] na ito [46:35] wag [46:36] natin [46:36] kalimutan [46:37] ang una-una [46:37] kasing [46:38] tanongin [46:38] dito [46:38] is [46:39] consistent [46:40] ba [46:40] itong [46:41] ganitong [46:41] klaseng [46:42] transactions [46:42] with [46:44] what [46:45] they've [46:45] indicated [46:46] in the [46:47] SALN [46:48] let's [46:49] remember [46:49] from [46:49] 2019 [46:50] onwards [46:50] walang [46:51] nakadeklarang [46:52] cash on hand [46:52] or cash [46:52] in [46:53] bank [46:53] so [46:53] kung wala [46:54] kang [46:54] cash [46:54] on hand [46:55] or cash [46:55] in [46:55] bank [46:55] pero [46:56] posible [46:57] ba [46:57] na [46:58] sagutin [46:59] mo [46:59] or [47:00] kahit [47:01] nasabihin [47:01] mo [47:01] pang [47:02] you [47:02] just [47:02] advanced [47:03] it [47:03] 200,000 [47:05] worth [47:05] of [47:05] a meal [47:06] sagutin [47:08] mo [47:08] ang [47:09] ano ba [47:11] mga [47:11] shoes [47:11] ba [47:12] yan [47:12] Nike [47:12] apparel [47:13] ng [47:13] entire [47:13] basketball [47:14] team [47:14] so [47:15] yun [47:15] yung [47:15] question [47:16] doon [47:16] consistent [47:17] ba [47:17] siya [47:17] doon [47:18] sa [47:18] diniklar [47:18] sa [47:18] SALN [47:19] na [47:19] ito [47:20] lang [47:21] ang [47:21] ari-ari [47:21] nyo [47:22] it's [47:22] in fact [47:22] wala [47:23] kayong [47:23] diniklar [47:23] ang [47:23] cash [47:24] in [47:24] hand [47:24] or [47:24] cash [47:25] in [47:25] bank [47:25] and [47:25] mabalik [47:26] ako [47:26] lang [47:26] very [47:26] quickly [47:27] yung [47:27] doon [47:27] sa [47:28] na [47:28] mention [47:28] mo [47:28] na [47:29] sinabi [47:29] ng [47:29] spokesperson [47:30] ng [47:30] vice [47:30] president [47:31] na [47:31] mukhang [47:33] convinsido [47:34] siya [47:34] magkakaroon [47:34] ng [47:34] conviksyon [47:35] pero [47:35] hindi [47:36] ito [47:36] nakabatay [47:37] sa [47:37] ebidensya [47:38] well [47:46] pangalawa [47:48] yung [47:49] doon sa [47:49] point [47:49] naman [47:50] hindi [47:50] nakabatay [47:50] sa [47:51] ebidensya [47:51] again [47:51] ito [47:52] din yung [47:52] same [47:52] spokesperson [47:53] na [47:53] nagsabi [47:54] ng [47:54] sariswela [47:55] lang [47:55] ang [47:55] nangyayari [47:55] dito [47:56] so [47:56] malinaw [47:57] ang [47:58] ginagawa [47:58] nila [47:58] this is [47:59] mind [47:59] conditioning [47:59] sabi [48:01] nga [48:01] niya [48:01] kung [48:01] mukhang [48:02] nakikita [48:02] na [48:02] niya [48:02] papunta [48:03] to [48:03] sa [48:03] conviksyon [48:04] again [48:04] siya [48:04] nagsabi [48:05] niyan [48:05] pero [48:06] kinukondisyon [48:07] na nila [48:07] yung [48:08] mga [48:08] supporters [48:08] nila [48:09] naisipin [48:10] hindi [48:10] yan [48:10] nakabatay [48:11] sa [48:11] ebidensya [48:12] para [48:12] hindi [48:12] tanggapin [48:13] ang [48:14] magiging [48:14] pag-ahatol [48:15] na [48:15] gagawin [48:15] ng [48:16] mga [48:16] senator [48:16] judges [48:17] at [48:17] ito [48:17] yung [48:17] lagi [48:18] namin [48:18] sinasabi [48:19] na [48:19] napaka [48:19] delikado [48:20] na [48:21] kind [48:21] of [48:21] rhetoric [48:21] na [48:22] mind [48:22] conditioning [48:22] na [48:23] ginagawa [48:23] ng [48:23] kampo [48:24] na [48:24] ito [48:24] at [48:25] this [48:25] attacks [48:26] again [48:26] the [48:27] integrity [48:27] of [48:28] the [48:28] proceedings [48:29] and [48:29] of [48:29] the [48:30] institution [48:30] itself [48:31] at [48:31] ito [48:32] suguro [48:32] yung [48:32] problema [48:33] if [48:33] these [48:34] kinds [48:34] of [48:34] statements [48:34] are [48:35] left [48:35] unchecked [48:36] they feel [48:37] emboldened [48:38] at [48:38] makikita [48:39] natin [48:39] patuloy [48:39] pa [48:40] ito [48:40] lalo [48:40] na [48:41] nilang [48:41] ahatakihin [48:42] itong [48:43] proceedings [48:43] ito [48:43] yung [48:43] credibility [48:44] ng [48:44] senator [48:45] judges [48:45] at [48:45] ang [48:45] credibility [48:46] na [48:46] magiging [48:47] pag [48:47] huhusga [48:48] na [48:49] gagawin [48:50] dito [48:50] lalo [48:50] na [48:50] kung [48:50] hindi [48:51] magiging [48:51] pabor [48:51] sa [49:19] I guess [49:20] kung totoo [49:21] yun [49:21] they'll show [49:21] evidence [49:22] they donated [49:23] it [49:23] but again [49:23] the [49:24] issue [49:25] here [49:26] that [49:27] we're [49:27] trying [49:28] to [49:28] look [49:29] into [49:29] is [49:30] yung [49:30] financial [49:31] capacity [49:32] nila [49:32] to make [49:32] these [49:33] kinds [49:33] of [49:33] transactions [49:34] when [49:34] on the [49:34] one [49:35] hand [49:35] you're [49:35] saying [49:35] you don't [49:36] have [49:36] any [49:36] cash [49:36] in [49:37] hand [49:37] or [49:37] cash [49:37] in [49:37] bank [49:37] at [49:38] least [49:38] you [49:38] did [49:38] not [49:38] declare [49:39] any [49:39] separately [49:40] in [49:41] your [49:41] silence [49:41] diba [49:45] ang [49:45] yaman [49:45] niya [49:46] sagutin [49:47] mo [49:47] yung [49:47] basketball [49:48] team [49:48] ng [49:48] sapatos [49:49] Alright [49:52] Mukha pong [49:54] medyo [49:55] malapit [49:56] nang magbalik [49:57] ating mga [49:57] senator [49:58] judges [49:58] sa pagpapatuloy [49:59] ng trial [49:59] so on that [50:00] note [50:00] pasalamatan [50:01] natin [50:01] ang ating [50:02] mga [50:02] miembro [50:03] ng panel [50:03] si [50:04] attorney [50:04] jay [50:05] si [50:05] kong [50:05] chua [50:05] and [50:06] si [50:06] chair [50:07] ace [50:07] ating [50:08] mga [50:08] kaibigan [50:09] sa [50:09] media [50:09] sa [50:09] ating [50:09] mga [50:09] kababayan [50:10] patuloy [50:10] po [50:10] nating [50:11] sabaybayan [50:11] ang [50:12] pagpapatuloy [50:12] na [50:12] impeachment [50:13] trial [50:13] laban [50:14] kay [50:14] vice [50:14] president [50:15] sarah [50:15] duterte [50:16] magandang [50:16] hapon [50:16] po [50:17] sa [50:17] ating [50:17] lahat