About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Fatal Fetish Murder Trial — FL v. Dwain Hall — Full Openings from Law&Crime Trials, published November 17, 2026. The transcript contains 3,791 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"State may proceed. May please the court counsel. Good morning, members of the attorney. Good morning. On Friday, October 10th of 2025, 32-year-old Sonia Exelby flew from England to the United States. By Sunday, October 12th, she was dead. She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: State may proceed. May please the court counsel. Good morning, members of the attorney. Good morning. On Friday, October 10th of 2025, 32-year-old Sonia Exelby flew from England to the United States. By Sunday, October 12th, she was dead. She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself Alpha Sadist, a man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women. That man is the defendant, Dwayne Hall. Sonia Exelby was a beautiful, kind woman who was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. But sadly, she suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She met the defendant online, and he manipulated her for years. He targeted her because of her mental illness, and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure. And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body. Now, before you can understand why this happened and how this happened, you have to understand a little bit of the history of Sonia Exelby. Sonia was born in England, and she was the youngest of six siblings. She had two sisters and three brothers. Unfortunately, their household was one in which no child should ever have to grow up in. Both of Sonia's parents were mentally ill, and her father also suffered from a drug addiction. Child social services intervened early on and removed all six siblings from the house. All of the siblings were very close. They were split up and sent different places. Sonia was two years old when this happened. And she and her sister, Sara, who was five years old, were placed in a foster home together. And that foster home wasn't much better than what they had at home. They were in that foster home for three years, and then Sara and Sonia were adopted together. Now, even though during that three year period, Sonia and her siblings would periodically see each other and spend time together, when Sara and Sonia were adopted, their adoptive parents thought it would be best if Sonia and Sara had no more contact with their siblings. Now, Sonia was unable to escape the trauma of her childhood. And when she was a teenager, around 13 or 14 years old, she began struggling with mental illness. She started cutting herself and she developed bulimia, which was an eating disorder. And even though she did go to counseling and therapy, her mental health would decline, and she would struggle with her mental illness for her whole life, and be diagnosed with many other disorders. However, when Sonia was 17, there was a bright spot that came into her life. She was working at a movie theater, and she met a man named Stephen Hunt. She was 17, and Stephen Hunt was two years older than her, and everybody called him Stevie. He also worked at the movie theater. They were friends at first, and then when Sonia turned 18, they started dating. Within months of when they began dating, Sonia told him about her mental health struggles. She was very open about the bulimia, being bipolar, having depression. Stevie had a choice to make. He could stay, or he could go. And Stevie will tell you that he believed with his whole heart that Sonia was the woman for him and was the love of his life. He told her, we can make this work, and we can have a great life together. And from that moment on, he never left her. In the meantime, when Sonia was 18, she and Sara were able to find their older siblings and reunite with them. The older siblings were thrilled to be reunited with Sonia and Sara. They hadn't seen them since they were adopted. They had thought of them often and wondered where they were, and there was an ache in their heart all those years for Sonia and Sara. So that was a great time in their life. And over the years, the siblings tried to understand Sonia's mental health and what she'd been going through. They talked about it, but often they would try to spend time with Sonia and plan meetings, gatherings. But due to her mental health, she would not show up many times and she would cancel. And while they would be disappointed, they still loved her and try to plan things with her. But over the years, as it happens with mental health, Sonia's mental health was up and down. There were good times and there were bad times. And those bad times included two suicide attempts by overdose. And you'll learn that most of the time, Sonia was always trying to find some substitute for the cutting. Some outlet that would make her feel alive and feel something again. Unfortunately, she found another outlet for the cutting, about two years before her death. And ultimately, that outlet would lead to her murder. And that began when she got on a website called Motherless. Motherless was a website that allowed users to upload pornographic videos and photographs. It also allowed the members on Motherless to communicate with each other. But the users of Motherless, over the years, started uploading videos of women actually being raped, women being tortured, women being murdered, as well as child sexual adult material, abuse material. The website was shut down this year because of those things. The servers were seized and there was an ongoing criminal investigation. But before it was shut down, Sonia was communicating on Motherless with many different men. She was trying to find somebody that would kill her. Her mental health was declining. She wanted to die. And she knew that she couldn't do it herself. And unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and wild ways possible. And they would send her messages and describe to her how they would kill her. Sadly, due to her mental health issues, this was something that Sonia used as a substitute for the cutting. These things made her feel alive when she would read them. Now, even though there were many men competing for this job, one man would win out. One man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner. And that person was the defendant, Dwayne Hall. Dwayne Hall's username on Motherless, the name he chose, the name he wanted to be called, was Alpha Sadist. And part of his bio on Motherless Red would love to find a domestic pain slut for complete control. And that's what he was looking for. Sonia and the defendant would communicate over Motherless for quite some time. And then they moved to another platform called Sessions, which is a phone app. It's more private. It's encrypted. And the messages were deleted automatically. And you'll learn that the defendant lived in Marion County, and he was married to a woman named Ginger Stein. And he owned his own business called Solver Wolf Roadside Assistance. And what he would do is people would call him. They would say they had a flat tire, something minor wrong with their car. He would respond to where they were and fix their car. Even though he lived in Marion County, he basically serviced Alachua County and the Gainesville area. Now, the first attempt that Sonia and the defendant made for him to kill her happened in March of 2025. She planned to come here, but then that fell through. After that fell through, the defendant realized, "Hey, not only can I kill her, but I might as well get some money from it as well." And he told her that she had to bring $4,000 cash with her when she actually came here for him to kill her. So after the March of 2025 trip fell through, they planned another one. And that trip was planned for Friday, October 10th of 2025, she would come here to the United States. And in September of 2025, Sonia booked that plane ticket. She also booked an Airbnb in Reddick, which is just north of Ocala, from Friday, October 10th to Sunday, October 12th. This was the plan, everything was booked. But now Sonia couldn't tell Stevie and her family that she was coming here. It happened to be on that same weekend, her sister Sara, who lived in Australia, was planning to visit their other sister, named Gemma, who also lived in England, about 45 minutes away from Sonia. So Sonia, her sister Sara and Gemma all spoke, and Sonia said, "Hey, let's make it a sister's weekend. I'll come visit you guys and we'll spend the weekend together." Of course, her sister Sara and Gemma thought that would be fantastic. They would love to see her and spend that weekend together. Sonia told Stevie, "Hey, I'm going to have the sister's weekend with Gemma and Sara." He was also thrilled. Due to her mental health, Sonia did not get out of the house much and she didn't go many places. So, the plan was she would go Friday to Gemma's and come back on Sunday. Well, she messaged Gemma and said, "Well, I'm not going to come on Friday, but I'll come on Saturday." And then messaged her later and said, "Oh, I'm going to come on Sunday at two o'clock." So, when Friday, October 10th rolled around, Stevie set his alarm early in the morning because he wanted to make sure that he could tell Sonia goodbye before she left on the phone. He got up. She was dressed. He'll tell you in the dress with flowers, cardigan, sandals, and a black backpack with pink glitter writing on it. She told him she was going to take a taxi to her sister Gemma's house. He kissed her goodbye and watched her walk out the door. That would be the last time he ever saw her alive again. So, on Sunday, when Sonia didn't show up to Gemma's as planned at two o'clock, Gemma and Sara were disappointed, but again, they weren't worried because this was something that was typical of Sonia, for her not to show up once plans were made. So, they communicated and texted her and said, "Hey, are you coming?" But she never responded. And she was supposed to be back to her house that she shared with Stevie that Sunday evening, October 12th. And when it got later and she didn't come home, Stevie called Gemma and said, "Hey, did Sonia leave yet? Because she's not home." And Gemma told Stevie she was never here. She never showed up. Well, obviously, panic sets in now because nobody has seen Sonia since Friday, October 10th, and they don't know where she is. And they know how fragile her mental health is. Stevie immediately calls the police that Sunday night to report Sonia missing. And while the police are on their way over to Stevie's, he gets on Sonia's computer and he checks and he looks at it. And he sees that Sonia emailed herself a letter from what appeared to be a plane. She said she was on a plane. And he read this letter and it was full of sorrow, depression, regret, and death. And it talked about suicide. Of course, Stevie was panicked. When the officer got to his apartment, he gave them Sonia's computer, he told them about her mental health and mental health, and he showed them that letter. They took all of that information. And then Monday morning, they gave it to a special unit they had in England for missing people. And you're going to hear from the head of that unit, that unit, Sergeant Detective Darin Thomas. Monday morning, he was involved in it, trying to find Sonia. He had a letter, he had a computer, and early on, he's able to find out that Sonia was on a plane from Heathrow in London, went to Atlanta, and then landed in Gainesville. He confirmed she was on that flight. So now he contacts Interpol, which helps with international missing person cases like this. And Interpol contacts the Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Gainesville, since that's where she landed. And they assigned the case agent, and her name is Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie. So now you have Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Gainesville, and they are communicating with Detective Sergeant Darin Thomas in England. They're sharing information. They're trying to find out where could Sonia be. Will they get Sonia's bank records in England? Of course, they want to see where has she spent money, where could she possibly be? And they see that transaction for that Airbnb on Reddit. So they send out two deputies from the Marion County Sheriff's Office. Agent McKenzie says, "Can you go out to this Airbnb? Maybe Sonia's there. Price is averted." This is on Monday. The deputies go out to the Airbnb, knock on the door, look in the windows. No one's there. Sonia's not there. Can't find her. They keep trying to look around and see where she could be. And Agent McKenzie starts doing search warrants or Facebook and other things to try to find out where she is. And then you'll learn that also, when they get her bank records on Monday, they see that there was a charge attempted on one of her credit cards that was defined for $1,200. And this charge was attempted on Saturday, October 11th. And they're like, "What is this about?" And that charge was attempted by a company called Solver Wolf Roadside Assistance. And so they say, "Well, who owns this company?" Wayne Hall owns it. So that one day, agents from FDLE say, "Well, we need to talk to this guy and see what he knows about Sonia." So they call him on the phone. They say, "Hey, we're looking for this missing person. You ran your credit card on Saturday, October 11th for $1,200 and it was declined." He completely lies to them. He says, "Some lady called me Friday or Saturday, said her car broke down and she needed a ride. I said, "Give me your credit card number." She gave me the credit card number. I ran it. It didn't go through. I told her I couldn't help her. And that was the end of our conversation. I don't know where she was. I never met her. I don't know where she was going." And so they say, "Okay. Thank you." And they continue to investigate and try to find it. Again, they're doing search warrant, subpoenas, trying to get records. Well, as they're doing this, Tuesday, October 14th, they say, "You know what? We need to talk to that guy that owns that roadside assistance again and try to get some more information because we still can't find it." They talk to him again. Same thing, lies. Never met her. Never saw her. Don't know where she's going. I don't know anything. Okay, this is strange. But they searched that Airbnb on Wednesday, the 15th. They get permission from the owner and they go in there and they search that and they process it. And they say, "Let's look at the receipts in the trash." They always check the trash. And in the trash, they find a receipt for a Walmart in Gainesville. And the time on the receipt is right before Sonya's plane lands in Gainesville. And they're concerned about what's on this receipt. On the receipts, a person bought a shovel, two different kinds of rope, deodorant and gun oil. This is concerning that this receipt is in the Airbnb where Sonya. They're able to run that credit card to see who bought that. Guess who bought those things? Dwayne Hall. But they want to confirm, is he the one that actually bought that even though his credit card was used? So they go to that Walmart in Gainesville and look for video footage from that time. And you'll see it, plain as day, there he is, buying the shovel, buying the rope, right before she lands in Gainesville, getting all of his supplies. Now based on this, the fact that he ran her credit card, he's obviously becoming their main suspect. He probably knows where she is. So on Thursday, October 16th, Agent McKenzie calls the FBI and asks them for some help. She asks for the cell phone tower records from the defendant's phone on an exigent basis, which means it's an emergency, I need these right away. So she can see where the defendant has been and may be fine, saw in their life. They get those records on the 16th. And they see that he was at the Gainesville airport when Sonny's plane landed on October 10th of 2025. But then they find something more concerning on those records. On the morning of October 12th, which was Sunday, the defendant's phone was at a wooded location in Marion Oaks for an hour and 20 minutes. That evening on Thursday the 16th, some deputies from the Marion County Sheriff's Office go out and they search that area. They don't find anything that night and they make a plan to come back the next day, which is Friday, October 17th. And they're going to bring out a cadaver dog and a field force unit so they can really search that area. Also, at the same time they're searching that area with cadaver dog and field force deputies, Agent McKenzie decides she is going to bring the defendant down to the sheriff's office and interview him. A face-to-face interview and find out what's going on. So the defendant does come down. And Agent McKenzie and Detective Joe Miller from the sheriff's office interview him for four hours, 40 minutes. The first four hours of that interview, the defendant lies for four hours, and you'll see it. He makes up a wild, nonsensical story about why he was at the Airbnb and why he was with Sonia. After he does that for four hours, he changes his mind. They take a break and he says, "Hey, come back in here. I want to recant everything I said for the past four hours." He takes it all back and he admits it was a made-up story for four hours. And he admits, "I know Sonia. I've been communicating with her for years on motherless. She came here to die." He admits that he had sex with her in that Airbnb. He admits he hit her in the face during the sex. He hit her in the breasts. He hit her on the back. And there was light choking. Ultimately, he says, he helped Sonia get what she wanted. Agent McKenzie, after this interview, gets a search warrant for the defendant's house. In his house, in the garage, they find that shovel that he bought at Walmart. That shovel is sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to be analyzed for DNA. On that shovel, they find Sonia's bull. They also get a search warrant for the defendant's car. And in his car, they find a UPS label that shows that on October 14th, which was Tuesday, the defendant mailed a package to someone named Rick Snyder in Ohio. And Agent McKenzie says, "We gotta know what's in this package that he mailed on October 14th, Tuesday." She goes to Ohio. Detectives from the county in Ohio, Washington County, get a search warrant for Rick Snyder's house. They go there and say, "Hey, Dwayne Hall mailed you a package. Where is it?" Rick Snyder's uncooperative at first, but eventually, he gives them what was in the package. Guess what was in the package? A knife, and a sheath, and a bracelet. Because at the same time Rebecca McKenzie, the agent, was interviewing the defendant, they found Sonia's body. They found her body in that wooded area, exactly where the defendant's phone was for an hour and 20 minutes. She was naked in the grave, except for a bra, sandals, and her flower dress was laid over her. She had been stabbed four times on the left side with a knife. Her body was sent to the medical examiner's office for an autopsy. And the medical examiner determined that those four stab wounds were all between four and seven inches deep and they all hit vital structures. And that she died of sharp force injuries, and it was a homicide. And that knife was also sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to be tested for DNA. And guess what was also on that knife? Sonia's blood. And finally, they did a search warrant for the defendant's cell phone. And they get a forensic cell phone examiner to search it. And you'll learn that the defendant tried to erase every trace of Sonia on his phone. He had numerous nude photographs of her and the video. He had all tried to delete. But the forensic cell phone examiner was able to recover them. You'll be able to see those. On his phone, they also found something else. They found numerous images of women being raped, tortured, and murdered. Horrific photographs of women with knives being shoved in their vaginas. Images of women with nails piercing their breasts. And other vile, horrific things. Evidence that the reason the defendant beat, stabbed, and murdered Sonia was for his own sadistic pleasure. After you hear from all the witnesses, and you see all the evidence, we are going to ask that you find the defendant, Duane Hall, guilty. Thank you. Counsel, Mr. Barrett, do you care to make no big statement?
[00:27:22] Speaker 2: I'm going to be brief. And the reason I'm going to be brief is because, if you recall, your selection just told you a set of facts that we all agreed on. And again, if you recall, also said to you that you are the trial of the facts. You will need to listen to all the witnesses, you will need to listen to all the witnesses and determine what actually happened, what were the circumstances of that thing. The judge will give you instructions and it will tell you what you're trying to say is not evidence. We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Duane Hall did not murder. And so the evidence starts now and that is what you will need to use to determine what happened to this survey. Thank you, counsel.