About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of DAY 44: SIGURADONG MAY MAKUKULONG! Mga Lihim na Bank Accounts sa Impeachment Trial, Ibinunyag na! from Bohol TV Show, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 19,216 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"argument for the defense your honor um honorable listo are you still bound by the same um person who will make the argument honorable of the lima i believe with a kind indulgence of the honorable impeachment court but we wish to manifest that there is a change in the public prosecutor who will be..."
[0:00] argument for the defense your honor um honorable listo are you still bound by the same um
[0:07] person who will make the argument honorable of the lima i believe with a kind indulgence of
[0:12] the honorable impeachment court but we wish to manifest that there is a change in the public
[0:17] prosecutor who will be doing the oral argument the honorable lila dilemma is currently addressing
[0:23] a very important and urgent concern and in this regard your honor it will be the honorable
[0:29] congressman chel giocno who will be representing the prosecution panel um understood and we
[0:36] understand we wish um honorable the lima well um we start with the prosecutors and then it will be
[0:44] followed by the oral arguments coming from the council for the respondents um attorney giocno
[0:51] sorry honorable giocno i'm used to your previous hat um we start with the honorable giocno for
[1:02] our government you can take your seat um attorney um good morning your honors morning you have 15
[1:11] minutes honorable giocno you may proceed before we start counting the minutes your honor if i may just
[1:17] seek some clarification from the honorable court please um if your honor in all the orders of the
[1:24] honorable court in the pleadings of the respondent as well as the pleadings of the prosecution we have
[1:31] referred to the vice president as the respondent but um i was surprised yesterday morning when the
[1:38] counsel for the respondent introduced herself as counsel for the accused we all know that this is
[1:47] not a criminal proceeding this is a sui generis proceeding and of course we do not want to condition
[1:53] the minds of anyone that this case is criminal in nature therefore may i seek clarification from the
[1:59] honorable court how should we address the vice president sarah zimmerman duterte as with previous
[2:08] as with previous our rulings of the previous impeachment court and as this um court and the
[2:12] presiding officer has always been consistent with we address the um respondent vice president as um the
[2:21] respondent that's why the chair also refers to um the opposing side as counsel for respondents accordingly
[2:29] your honor may i move to strike the statement of council for the respondent when she introduced
[2:37] herself as counsel for the accused so that the public will be properly guided maybe here from um attorney
[2:44] sila first attorney just a quick um correction your honor the tsn will bear out that the defense or the
[2:53] counsel for the respondent did not refer to the respondent as accused by itself but as respondent
[3:01] dash accused your honor now um if the prosecution which is a clarification why the defense refers to the
[3:08] vice president as respondent accusing this proceeding um even though um the prosecution feels that this is
[3:16] not a criminal um action per se the articles of information will show the articles of um impeachment will
[3:24] show that um the charges are criminal in nature your honor oh first of all may i respond if your honor
[3:32] please then i will be also um kindly let attorney sila finish thank you i would just ask um for also an
[3:39] opportunity for a rejoinder after the response of the honorable congressman um child job honorable joke
[3:48] no may may may may may may make um rebuttal we appeal to the record if your honor please i distinctly recall
[3:57] hearing the word accused not respondent accused and i believe the transcripts will bear me out second um
[4:05] if your honor please this is clearly not a criminal case by any stretch the there is no criminal liability
[4:14] involved in this case this is a case involving the fitness of the vice president to continue in office
[4:21] and as we all know it's sui generis therefore it would be improper and it may even lead to misconceptions
[4:29] if the respondents council were to refer to the vice president as the accused i have not rejoinder um
[4:39] are you done honorable jack no yes your honor rejoinder attorney sila yes your honor um the records will
[4:44] show that uh at no point in time um from the start of this hearing until today that the defense um referred
[4:53] to the vice president as accused alone in fact we are consistent in referring to the vice president as
[5:01] respondent accused now if the worry of the gentleman is um a supposed misconception and the use of the term
[5:11] accused in conjunction with respondent accused then um i think there is no uh no greater danger than a
[5:21] misconception in the idea that the constitutional presumption of innocence does not apply in this
[5:28] impeachment proceeding or that the bill of rights under which that guarantee is embedded does not
[5:35] apply to this impeachment case your honor finally any sir rejoinder if any uh any sir rejoinder um
[5:42] the honorable joke now before the chair makes a ruling thank you your honor the bill of rights your
[5:47] honor applies to all proceedings however when we speak of the presumption of innocence proof beyond
[5:54] reasonable doubt that is clearly only applicable to criminal cases and we do not want either this
[6:02] court or especially the public to be misled into believing that those particular burdens imposed in
[6:10] criminal cases apply in this particular case your honor that's all quick sir debato your honor um yes
[6:20] before the chair makes a ruling attorney shila again your honor the records will show that at no point
[6:25] in time did the defense claim that the quantum of proof needed in this impeachment case or for this
[6:31] impeachment court to arrive at any decision is proof beyond reasonable doubt i think the quantum or the
[6:37] degree of proof needed to be shown by the prosecution in order to discharge its burden of proof is um
[6:44] embedded or ingrained in the decision of the court in the 30 versus hor your honor and so that statement
[6:51] that uh the constitutional presumption of it's not debatable your honor it's not a matter of debate your
[6:56] honor um we're talking about the guarantee of the constitutional right to presumption of innocence your honor
[7:04] in fact the records will also show and um the media reports would show that um the honorable jocno um
[7:15] stated that the constitutional presumption of innocence does not apply in this case which we find
[7:21] is dangerous to convey to the general public at sa lahat ng mga mag-aaral ng batas
[7:27] um since i will now i'm sorry your honor but since i have been alluded to may i respond briefly to that
[7:34] briefly counsel and then we shall call these intramurals to an end so that we can proceed to the
[7:39] main um agenda for today which are the oral arguments after the chair makes a ruling briefly
[7:44] honorable jocno if your honor please the ruling in duterte versus house of representatives particularly
[7:51] the statements about what have should happen in a trial really are what we call obiter dicta kasi po wala
[7:58] pa pong trial nung umabot ang kasong iyon sa supreme court so any statements made by the court about the
[8:06] trial are not binding they are simply as an aside as mentioned in the case itself and i think that's
[8:15] very clear from the decision thank you you are now make a ruling um no need attorney sheila um
[8:21] chair will make a ruling the um chair has checked the tsn attorney sheila is correct um she said
[8:29] respondent accused to quote on page four of the tsn the same appearance for the respondent accused your
[8:37] honor secondly um there are given that it's sui generis admittedly given that the very first um
[8:46] ruling on impeachment um in the case of indre horileno um actually impeachment but that was a
[8:53] judge wala pa pong constitutional officers at that time because this was pre-1973 um really
[9:00] referred to impeachment processes as um criminal in nature second as correctly pointed out too in duterte
[9:10] which um the honorable jocno characterized as obiter um from his point of view stated
[9:17] in part impeachment is primarily for the protection of the people as a body politic and not for the
[9:24] punishment of the offender impeachment is primarily a legal process in the sense that like administrative
[9:32] cases it results in the removal of a public officer and like criminal cases it requires evidentiary rules
[9:41] and due process share therefore rules um against the motion of the um council rather the motion of the
[9:51] honorable jocno a member of the panel of prosecutors and will not so delete um the referral of um
[10:01] the council for the respondent to the respondent there's respondent um accused so thank you thank you
[10:08] your honor um um can we now go to the main agenda of the day um attorney jocno yes um rather honorable
[10:14] jocno forgive me for my lapses um honorable jocno no worries no worries no worries your honor um
[10:22] um can you repeat the question bagu yung actual na can we proceed um honorable jocno with your
[10:31] oral arguments thank you honor may it please the honorable yes you have 15 minutes
[10:36] let me state at the outset where the prosecution stands the prosecution is confident in its case
[10:45] we believe in our evidence and we trust the independent judgment of this honorable court and whatever
[10:52] the threshold is however this court decides the issue before it today the prosecution will do its job
[10:59] malinaw po ang obligasyon ng prosecution ilatag ang ebidensya at patunayan ng mga paratang para
[11:07] makamit ang hustisya at pananagutan malinaw rin po ang tungkulin ng hukumang ito suriin
[11:15] ang ebidensya timbangin ang mga argumento at magpasya ayon sa konstitusyon at sa ating batas those
[11:23] responsibilities we respectfully submit belong together last week we heard four distinguished members
[11:32] of the honorable supreme court as amici curé ang sabi po nila on the meaning of the phrase all
[11:40] members of the senate ay iba iba meron pong nagsulong ng verbal legis forgive my legalese racial legis
[11:49] meron pong contextual and functual approach at meron commonsensical and rational interpretation
[11:56] but perhaps we can begin with the simplest formulation of the question the constitution
[12:03] requires two-thirds the question before this court is two-thirds of how many for amici different
[12:13] approaches different reasoning yet all are one in saying that the number to convict is not fixed at 16.
[12:22] all four have concluded expressly or essentially that 16 is not an absolute number it can change
[12:31] under certain circumstances the prosecution does not intend to suggest which former justice has the
[12:38] best approach but perhaps you will allow me on behalf of the prosecution to share another lens through
[12:50] which the different views may be considered it is a principle that runs through our constitution and i
[12:57] submit is at the heart of our constitution it is also the principle that or the very reason why this
[13:04] honorable court exists and that is accountability our 1987 constitution may properly be understood in its
[13:15] essential respects as an accountability constitution that principle is explicit in article 11 itself the first
[13:27] section provides with it starts with the declaration i quote public office is a public trust and it
[13:35] commands public officers to i quote at all times be accountable to the people these words are not
[13:43] incidental they are about the constitutional architecture in which impeachment operates government
[13:50] authority does not belong to those who temporarily exercise it galing po yan sa sambayan ng pilipino
[13:58] public officials exercise authority in trust for the people and because power is held in trust for the
[14:04] people power carries with it accountability sa akin pong pananaw ang pananagutan ay may dalawang panig or two
[14:14] sides the first is answerability the first is answerability o pananagutan ang opisyal na pinagkatiwalaan
[14:20] ng kapangyarihan ay dapat humarap at sumagot kapag hiningi ng constitution and the second is responsibility
[14:28] the constitutional institutions entrusted with enforcing accountability must themselves responsibly
[14:36] perform the duties assigned to them acknowledging that the people have an interest in a process
[14:42] that functions according to the commands and safeguards of our accountability constitution the
[14:49] house is given the exclusive power to initiate impeachment cases but the senate this august body
[14:55] is given the sole power to try and decide them and when senators sit for that purpose the constitution
[15:02] specifically requires them to take an oath or affirmation packet pop because you are not dealing with
[15:11] ordinary legislative business you are exercising an extraordinary constitutional function as an
[15:18] impeachment court and this is the only time in the constitution that members of the senate are
[15:24] required to take an oath separate from the oath they took when they assumed their office kayo po you
[15:32] hear you examine you deliberate and ultimately you judge viewed through the lens of accountability
[15:40] therefore the threshold question is not merely ano ang pinakamadaling arithmetic the question is
[15:47] what interpretation faithfully allows the institutions involved to perform the responsibilities the
[15:54] constitution has assigned to them while respecting the safeguards the constitution has itself imposed that is
[16:02] the contribution of the accountability lens sa tingin po ng prosecution lubhang mahalaga ang aktibong
[16:09] partisipasyon ng hukom sa paglilitis pagkilatis sa kaampuk kaangkupan of fitness ng opisyal ang
[16:16] ginagawa sa impeachment trial paano ito gagawin ng senador na hindi naging hukom dahil hindi naman
[16:22] nga kapag-opak na kapag-opak na wala naman sa mga pagdinig para masuri ang mga testigo at dokumento
[16:31] hindi po ba ang utos ng konstitusyon ay mapanagot sa taong bayan ang mga opisyal sa lahat ng panahon
[16:38] hindi ba sa impeachment case ang kumakatawan sa taong bayan ay kayo po mga senador judges
[16:46] kanino haharap at mananagot ang impeached official kung absent o hindi available ang wes sa
[16:54] bakanting upuan at mesang malamig this calls to mind the ruling of the court in avellino versus
[17:01] cuenco in this case the court accepted 12 was sufficient for quorum taking account that the
[17:09] members abroad or beyond the senate's coercive power of course avellino involved a legislative quorum
[17:16] under the 1935 constitution not the two-thirds vote for impeachment conviction it does not decide
[17:24] this case but it demonstrates why constitutional membership language must be interpreted with
[17:31] attention to the institutional circumstances hindi automatic na ang base o denominator ay laging 24.
[17:42] now some may cite another case bayan versus samora to support a fixed number argument however that case
[17:50] of bayan did not interpret the voting threshold requirement in that case the supreme court merely
[17:56] described rather than ruled upon the prevailing math the reference to 16 votes in bayan was merely an
[18:04] arithmetical illustration of compliance not a doctrinal definition in that case mathematically whether
[18:12] the senate had 23 or 24 active members at that time two-thirds of either number would still amount
[18:19] to 16 senators 16 votes constituted unquestionable compliance under either metric ang ruling ng supreme
[18:28] court dito ay hindi pinalna hatol ukol sa threshold na maaring mag-iba depende sa sitwasyon let us imagine as
[18:37] some of the amici curiae were asked at the last hearing or oral argument a situation
[18:43] na may senador na hindi nakapag-oath for whatever reason okay i legally prevented from performing a
[18:50] senator's job dahil nakakulong at suspended sa katungkulan dahil sa utos ng batas each of them cannot hear the
[18:58] evidence deliberate and vote their inability to participate is beyond dispute and yet if the
[19:04] denominator is fixed at 24 conviction would always require 16 votes absurd po ito yes the constitution
[19:15] deliberately makes conviction harder by imposing the two-thirds requirement but making it harder is not
[19:23] the same as making it depend on senators who are not judges or who are incapable of acting as judges that
[19:31] would be tantamount to an acquittal by default a failure to arrive at the threshold number cost not by the
[19:38] judgment of the incapacitated senators but by their mere inclusion in the denominator this brings us now to
[19:47] a matter that has already entered the discussion may nagsasabi po na kung ibahin ng hukumang ito ang
[19:54] kanilang pasya sa isyong ito mababago ang rule sa kalagitnaan nitong paglilitis sa aming paniwala po ay hindi the
[20:04] constitutional rule has not changed noon nagsimula ang trial ngayon tumatakbo ang trial at maging pagdating sa final
[20:11] vote two-thirds pa rin po ang requirement what this court must determine is the constitutionally
[20:18] applicable membership given the senate's actual legal capacity to perform its impeachment function
[20:25] mindful of the circumstances before the court ang pinagpapasyahan po ay kung sino constitutionally
[20:33] ang dapat isama sa bilang but there is another misconception if your honors please that begs
[20:40] clarification a change in the denominator should not be described as simply lowering the votes
[20:47] needed to convict why because the arithmetic moves in both directions if 24 senators are counted 16 votes
[20:56] are required to convict nine votes prevent conviction now suppose the court determines that 20 senators should
[21:03] be counted two-thirds of 20 would require 14 votes to convict but what is sometimes if not often
[21:11] omitted from this discussion is that seven votes would prevent conviction so a different
[21:18] denominator does not guarantee conviction it changes the arithmetic on both sides
[21:24] parehong panig ang naapektuhan ng bilang that is why the constitutional issue should not be reduced
[21:31] to binabaan ba ang boto para makonvict the more accurate question is ilan ang constitutionally
[21:39] dapat bilangin once that denominator is constitutionally determined the fraction operates upon
[21:45] it two-thirds remains two-thirds and this brings the matter back to us the house prosecution panel also
[21:54] stands under the principle of accountability a responsibility is not to find the most favorable
[22:00] arithmetic a responsibility is to prove the articles of impeachment within the bounds of justice a
[22:07] responsibility in the prosecution does not change whether this court determines that the applicable
[22:12] numerical requirement is 16 or some other number if the court determines 16 we present our evidence
[22:20] if the court determines another number we present the same evidence because the evidence does not become
[22:26] stronger or weaker depending upon the denominator the articles do not change the burden imposed upon the
[22:34] prosecution does not change in the same breath the responsibility of this court to render independent
[22:41] judgment remains the same and whatever the court decides the prosecution will respect that decision
[22:49] because ultimately two-thirds remains two-thirds ayan po ang aming pananagutan ayan din ang inaasahan
[22:58] ng taong bayan maraming maraming salamat po your honest you don't want to make use of the remaining
[23:07] two and a half minutes council there is no rebuttal council um no i'm finished your honest okay um
[23:15] chair will now recognize attorney um michael poa for um his 15 minutes uh for oral arguments on this
[23:25] matter you may proceed attorney po when you're ready good morning mr senate president sir presiding officer
[23:33] honorable senator judges panel of the prosecutors magandang umaga po sa inyong lahat may it please the
[23:40] court your honors the supreme court has reminded us time and time again that when the law is clear
[23:49] there's no room for interpretation there's only room for application now with those words in mind perhaps
[23:58] your honors we should not complicate what the constitution has made simple the issue confronting
[24:06] us today boils down to one question how many votes to convict the answer of the defense is straightforward
[24:15] and simple 16. Bakit po 16? Simulan po natin sa procedural aspect last july 6 2026 on the very first day
[24:27] of trial the presiding officer ruled that the voting threshold to convict is 16. at that time no senator
[24:36] judge objected no senator judge sought reconsideration no senator judge appealed your honors that was over two
[24:47] months ago thereafter witnesses were able to testify evidence was presented and the parties already in the
[24:57] middle of trial relying upon such ruling of the presiding officer so bago po natin pag-usapan yung nilalaman
[25:06] ng saligang batas marahil dapat rin po natin itanong tama pa bang buksan muli ang issue na ito at
[25:15] pagbotohan because your honors reading the rules on impeachment under rule number six wala nga pong nilagay
[25:25] na time frame within which a motion for reconsideration can be considered naturally because that should have
[25:32] been brought up at the earliest opportunity after mabigay po yung ruling pero hindi po nangyari yun masahin rin po
[25:42] natin yung mga rules that have subtatory effect to this to these procedures for example yung senate rules po rule 33
[25:52] gives a senator two session days within which to seek reconsideration for a measure that has been
[25:59] approved obviously legislative po yung function na yun pero kahit ipilit po natin yung rule na yun dito sa
[26:07] impeachment proceedings lumipas na po yung two session days pasong paso na po now let's look at the rules of
[26:16] court for example where parties are generally given 15 calendar days to file a motion for
[26:22] reconsideration kahit po yun matagal na pong lumipas pasong paso na rin po and forgive me for going into the
[26:31] more technical aspect even if we were to consider the ruling of the presiding officer as an interlocutory
[26:40] order which the court may modify upon a finding of sufficient grounds para po sa depensa hindi na rin
[26:48] po applicable yun dahil wala naman pong sufficient ground wala pong supervening event ang punto po
[26:56] namin wala naman pong nagbago mula July 6 2026 hanggang ngayong araw yung mga sinasabi po natin na mga
[27:06] senador na hindi nakapag-participate of course with the exception of senator legarda ay hindi na rin
[27:12] po nakapag-participate nung July 6 bago pa na issue yung ruling so one thing is clear nothing in the rules
[27:21] suggests that the ruling of the presiding officer may be challenged indefinitely or modified arbitrarily
[27:30] because your honors kung ganun ang ating magiging panuntunan edi pati po yung ruling doon sa pag-issue
[27:38] ng subpina sa mga bank records ay pwede pa rin palang buksan muli at pagbotohan yun palang mga ruling
[27:46] ng presiding officer sa bawat objection ay pwede pa rin balikan your honors that should not be done because
[27:54] the parties must be able to rely on the rulings of the presiding officer otherwise your honors that
[28:02] will run contrary to the basic principle of what is an orderly conduct of a fair trial now more
[28:12] significantly kung ibababa po natin yung voting threshold when trial is already underway in fact
[28:20] na sa kalagitnaan na po tayo your honors that will go beyond the procedural that will already
[28:27] raise questions if the respondent vice president is being afforded due process guaranteed by the
[28:36] constitution due process which according to the supreme court in duterte versus hor must be present in
[28:44] every stage of the proceeding at kahit isan tabi muna natin yung mga procedural concerns
[28:52] na yan pareho pa rin po yung sagot namin 16 let's now proceed to the substantive aspect and we will be
[28:59] raising five quick points first point your honors the language of the constitution is clear there's no need
[29:08] for further interpretation under article 11 section 3 paragraph 6 nakasulat po dyan no person shall be
[29:18] convicted without the concurrence of two-thirds of all the members of the senate the text states all members of
[29:28] the senate it does not say all members present it does not say all members participating and that
[29:37] distinction matters because kung susuriin po natin yung u.s constitution at dun po binase yung ating
[29:45] sariling saligang batas dun po sa provision nila sa voting threshold to convict nakasulat po dun
[29:52] klarong klarong klaro members present so if the framers of our constitution wanted to adopt the same
[30:00] formulation they could have easily done so but they did not in fact your honors kung susuriin din
[30:07] natin ang ibang provision ng ating konstitusyon meron pong provision na nagsasabing members present
[30:14] lamang pero pagdating po dito sa voting threshold to convict iniwan po ng framers natin na all members
[30:24] of the senate so what does that mean we look at article 6 section 2 where it states that the
[30:31] senate shall be composed of 24 senators so ibig sabihin po nun yung denominator pagdating sa threshold
[30:40] ay 24 unless magkaroon po ng vacancy and a vacancy only arises when there's death resignation
[30:50] disqualification disqualification or expulsion by a sitting senator wala pong ganong nangyayari
[30:57] ngayon absence your honors does not create a vacancy non-participation does not create a vacancy
[31:05] being detained because of criminal charges does not create a vacancy and therefore your honors the
[31:13] current formulation is 24 senators two-thirds of which is 16 and that is not an arithmetic that is simply
[31:24] advanced by the defense that is an arithmetic that has been upheld by the supreme court in the case of
[31:31] bayan versus zamora dun po faced with identical language two-thirds of all members of the senate
[31:40] sinabi po ng supreme court na ang denominator ay 24 at yun po treaty concurrence lamang ang
[31:49] pinag-uusapan paano pa po pagdating sa impeachment that might result into the removal of the highest
[31:57] officials of the land at wag na po tayong lumayo tingnan po natin yung nangyari dun sa impeachment trial
[32:05] against the former chief justice renato crona nung panahon po na yun hindi po 24 ang senators 23 lamang
[32:14] because nanalo po sa pagkapangulo ang dating senador noy noy aquino and even with that vacancy
[32:22] hindi naman po binaba ang voting threshold 16 votes pa rin to convict now that begs the question
[32:31] bakit po pagdating kay former chief justice corona hindi binaba yung voting threshold pero pagdating
[32:40] dito sa impeachment laban sa vice president sarah duterte kahit walang vacancy ipinag-uusapan
[32:48] yung pagbababa ng threshold i will leave that question hanging with you your honors to my second point
[32:56] parati nating naririnig yung abilino versus cuenco but that case simply does not apply because that case
[33:04] is about quorum at yung pinag-uusapan na coercive jurisdiction ng senate ay napag-usapan lamang
[33:12] dahil kung titignan natin yung provision on quorum specifically article 6 section 16 paragraph 2
[33:19] nakasulat po kasi dun that both houses have the power to compel the attendance of its members for
[33:26] purposes of quorum dito po sa impeachment wala pong ganun so that is irrelevant your honors let us not use
[33:35] the rule on quorum to rewrite the constitutional provision for the voting threshold to convict to our
[33:44] third point your honors maari bang bumoto ang mga hindi nagpa-participate well to us respectfully
[33:52] unless the impeachment court prohibits them from doing so they can vote because as mentioned last week
[33:59] we are a court of records maari naman pong basahin ang tsn or transcript maaring reviewin ng journals
[34:07] maari na nga pong mapanood ang nangyayari sa trial through videos now if that senator judge does not feel
[34:15] that he or she can render an impartial judgment dahil nga absent po siya well your honors hindi lang
[34:22] naman yes or no ang boto pwede namang mag-abstain pwede namang mag-inhibit but we have to emphasize
[34:31] that abstention or inhibition do not create vacancies and therefore it should not affect the denominator
[34:40] the denominator remains to be 24 two-thirds of which is 16. and 16 your honors is not a figure that
[34:48] was chosen by the defense it is the consequence of the constitutional language ngayon your honors since
[34:56] we're talking about consequences that brings us to our fourth point your honors if we were to lower the
[35:04] threshold here we will not be lowering the threshold in a vacuum may consequences po yan marami pong
[35:12] constitutional provisions na maapektuhan for example yun pong pag extend or pag revoke ng martial law yun pong
[35:21] pag expel ng isang membro ng senado and more importantly yun pong pag amienda mismo ng ating saligang batas
[35:30] now are we going to also adjust the thresholds in those provisions because if we were to do that
[35:38] hindi na po threshold ang tawag dun moving target na po yun para sa mga taong gustong mag-benefit sa
[35:46] circumstances to our final point your honors the two-third super majority is obviously a constitutional
[35:56] safeguard for the respondent it ensures it ensures na hindi po matatanggal ang matataas na opisyal
[36:04] ng ating bansa dahil lang hindi niya kaalyado ang mayorya sa impeachment court but in the same manner
[36:13] it is also a constitutional safeguard for the senator judges themselves because your honor if absence
[36:21] detention detention would change the denominator then your honors you will be opening yourselves up
[36:29] to being coerced being intimidated being threatened by those who wish to manipulate the result of the
[36:38] impeachment process conversely kung we will stick with that denominator of membership then your honors
[36:49] yung pagiging absent will suddenly not matter you will not be forced to leave the country just to change
[36:58] the denominator there is nothing to gain by filing criminal charges to detain certain senators just to
[37:06] manipulate the result of the impeachment process so as you see your honors it's a two-way safeguard
[37:13] ang super majority based on membership as the denominator is really a safeguard para hindi po maabuso
[37:22] ang proseso and in closing your honors circumstances change political alliances shift majorities come
[37:34] and go but at the end of the day the constitution must remain while we understand that with everything
[37:43] that's going on some may say that this is inconvenient but your honors the constitution is not tested merely
[37:52] when things are convenient in fact the constitution is tested most when things are precisely inconvenient
[38:01] and with that we submit your honors maraming maraming salamat po at this juncture um thank you attorney
[38:14] poa at this juncture we shall um entertain um interjections from um senator judges if any um senator judge
[38:23] um alan you may proceed sir good morning mr presiding officer the chair shall give you a
[38:34] a variable period before that mr president can i make a short manifestation since yes you may proceed
[38:40] yes because on the first day of uh the hearing uh of the trial i actually brought this up and i've said
[38:48] it many times that um i'm guided by three books the holy bible the constitution of the philippines and
[38:56] the rules of the senate and the rules of the impeachment court we brought it up in the first day because
[39:03] we believe it's jurisdictional we brought it up in the first day not because we do not want any
[39:10] discussion or argument mr presiding officer we welcome the argument we welcome the discussion on
[39:17] this issue but in the supreme court or if it's in the senate before we pass the rules of the senate
[39:26] because if we did it before we passed the rules of the senate all parties would have been informed
[39:31] and all parties would have had the chance to go to the supreme court we brought it up in the first day
[39:40] because then we would have had the option at least me whether i would participate or not
[39:46] because then i would have to decide for myself whether this court has jurisdiction or does not
[39:51] have jurisdiction because it is very clear in the constitution that there is a possibility that a
[39:57] body can have jurisdiction yet it may disappear when there is grave abuse of discretion that amounts to
[40:06] luck or excess of jurisdiction so dun po sa mga nagsasabing ayaw namin pag-usapan tong issue na to gusto po namin
[40:18] pero timing is essential there is a time for everything under this world a time to be born the time to die
[40:26] but to discuss it in the middle of the uh of the trial just before the prosecution is ending and just before
[40:35] the uh the defense will be presenting their evidence is um not only inconvenient or uh
[40:45] uh uncomfortable i use the word mistrial as a word of accountability not to plant that it may happen
[40:54] but to warn because definitely whatever the result of this impeachment both parties or any filipino can
[41:01] go to the supreme court that's a right of any filipino wala tayong pag-usapan lahat pwedeng pumunta
[41:08] sa supreme court ang tanong binibigyan ba natin sila ng basihan na pumunta sa uh sa supreme court that's
[41:16] why each and every member of this court present or not is free to make a statement to remind all of
[41:22] us to remind the senator judges to remind um uh the prosecution to to remind the uh defense
[41:33] as part of accountability that we cannot be in lack or excess of jurisdiction alam mo
[41:40] this is no laughing matter uh every single part of this impeachment is serious
[41:48] pero alam nyo naman po kami dahil ako nagsimula bilang konsihal batang kali ako at sabi
[41:54] nung mga kasing edad ko sabi sir parang spaghetti na ang ano ang impeachment sabi ko anong spaghetti
[42:01] pababa ng pababa pataas ng pataas kapag nawala yung iba tapos tingin natin dito sila kikiling dito sila
[42:10] kikiling bababa pag bumalik sila ano tataas so yes it is a serious uh matter but it becomes ridiculous
[42:23] if we interpret it in a ridiculous way so having said that this is an oral argument and
[42:29] uh we will i will personally participate in the discussion mr president but may i reserve the right
[42:35] later on when we go to the voting if we insist on voting on this because on the record i would prefer
[42:42] and i would insist that if there's a question on the threshold the question be brought before the
[42:49] supreme court because not because we cannot there are many theories one theory is we can decide one
[42:56] theory is we cannot decide but even if i say we can decide the question on my side is timing so i'm not
[43:03] saying we can decide but if we can we should have decided this when we were passing the rules of the
[43:09] impeachment court because we knew it's an it's a possibility we're not talking about theory lang here
[43:15] there are real politics happening here it's not an accident
[43:28] na panay nasa opposition yung wala na nandito so i i won't go into political statements because
[43:34] we all took an oath but i also won't be blind to it diba i hindi dapat gumawa ng mga akusasyon
[43:41] dito pero hindi rin pwedeng bulag bulagan dito na walang nangyayari talaga dito sa ating bansa so mr
[43:48] president before i ask my question i'll leave you with my hope if the filipino people hope for justice and
[43:54] accountability if the prosecution hope for conviction if the defense hopes for acquittal i hope that the
[44:05] evidence will be so damning so so so damning that 24 senators will convict or the evidence will be so
[44:17] so obviously not worthy of an impeachment charge that all 24 senators will acquit kasi kung ganon wala
[44:28] natong usapan na threshold wala nang usapan ng political persecution wala nang usapan ng politika so we
[44:36] all took an oath but the reality is that oath is tested every day outside this court inside this
[44:44] court mr president i i have not felt intimidation among our colleagues even if we have disagreements
[44:52] among each other i have felt the courtesy the respect um i have had heated debates with many many of you
[45:00] here and if i offended you like i did senator zubiri i hope one day forgiveness between us the back here i
[45:09] mean here seatmate ko pa naman ngayon ah siya lang ang nakasigawan ko ng ganong kagrabi sa loob eh eh 1998 ko pa
[45:19] siya kasama but that's not my point my point is inside the court i think the defense and prosecution
[45:25] will say nararamdaman natin yung fairness but the reality is that this court does not exist in a
[45:32] vacuum may nangyayari dito sa sa sa labas no so mr president with your permission just a few questions
[45:42] to both panels uh honorable congressman the gentleman may proceed and has a variable period of two minutes
[45:49] you may proceed when you're ready honorable jockner is recognized as well sir just like with the defense i
[45:56] won't argue because you've already argued your position so i can practical matter lang assuming the
[46:04] impeachment court votes that the threshold is not um so by the way i agree with you it's not fixed 16
[46:12] but our disagreement is that it's fixed with the number of senators and if 24 is the number of senators
[46:20] who are members who are alive who have not resigned for me that's what's fixed 24 so two-thirds is 16
[46:28] having said that i owe it to all of you to listen so if your theory is correct and that
[46:36] pwedeng mabawasan yung 24 kahit hindi sila patay kahit hindi sila nag-resign how will we apply that so like
[46:45] in our situation now what if senator jingoy gets bailed tomorrow and he appears whether tomorrow or the day
[46:54] may judgment what if senator lauren lagarda signs the treaty of paris and comes back to the philippines
[47:03] under that treaty so 22 now so how do we apply what we're talking about now in the view of the prosecution
[47:11] i think that we are operating here as an impeachment court and therefore we should
[47:22] adopt the principles that apply to judges as um to the best as i understand the rules if your honor
[47:28] please the judge of the court where a case is pending the general rule is that they can only
[47:35] participate and eventually vote if they heard and personally receive the evidence the only exception
[47:43] recognized is where a judge for example um is replaces another judge or is detailed to another court
[47:51] and now has the duty to decide cases that he did not hear or she did not hear himself or herself
[47:58] at as a tingin ko po yun nang dapat mag-apply po dito in this particular case we are not talking about
[48:06] a judge who suddenly was assigned to the impeachment court but rather we are speaking of all the members of
[48:13] the honorable senate impeachment court only that some of them are not within are not here for one reason or
[48:21] another and i believe that we must face that reality na ganun nga po kaya kami po'y naniniwala na
[48:28] yung mga nakakapagdinig lang ng mga testimonya makakapagbasa ng record because this is really a question
[48:37] where the evidence is so crucial in determining accountability okay um let me agree with you first
[48:45] that it's so crucial and let me agree with you na kasama sa oath ng bawat isang judge is to uh review the
[48:53] evidence before coming out with an uh a verdict i'll go to that later the difference with the judges is
[49:01] may rules nga sila pwede silang palitan anytime pwede ka mag pairing judge pagdating po sa ca at saka
[49:08] sa sandigan bayan you only need two out of three and they have certain rules na kung kailangan unanimous you
[49:15] add two from the pool of uh uh uh justices so mas akin tayo for example sa supreme court but ang
[49:23] supreme court kung hindi sila makamajority uh but because may nakalive or may vacancy they will wait for
[49:29] that they will not make it so if there are only 10 supreme court justices now and uh only five says yes i
[49:36] don't think they will make a a decision but let's let's put that aside kasi nga sui generis let me go to
[49:43] your point na dapat kasi nakikita nila yung ebidensya in your reading the prosecution's reading is there
[49:50] anything that uh let me take as an example the the pandemic some judges did the the hearings through
[49:59] ano diba through electronic means so is there anything in our rules that will prohibit
[50:07] uh the four senators who are here now to participate electronically is there anything in the
[50:14] constitution that will prevent this impeachment court from doing that in your view may i respond
[50:23] your own name thank you yes uh you may just proceed um honorable jockner thank you first to the first
[50:37] question of um your honor i i would have to respectfully disagree that this honorable impeachment court is
[50:45] akin to the supreme court no no sorry i said it's sui generis but i'm saying if we compare it to the
[50:51] rtc mtc ca it's different kasi yung rtc mtc ca mapapalitan sila anytime diba so if your rtc judge is uh
[51:03] takes six months leave the case can be assigned to someone else if he uh dies or retires it can be
[51:09] assigned to someone else so i'm saying that unlike the senate hindi pwedeng palitan yung apat but but
[51:19] that's not my point you can you can disregard that that my question is do we have uh if you want to
[51:26] give your opinion about the supreme court that's that's okay with me i'm just saying my main question
[51:30] is is there anything in the constitution on it or in our rules in your reading that prevents us from amending
[51:37] our rules and allowing participation by electronic means um may i address that question after i just
[51:44] the first question that your honor propounded i i believe that this honorable court really is called
[51:50] upon by the constitution to conduct a trial meaning for to receive evidence unlike the supreme court which
[51:57] can rely on the records of the case uh sila po kasi ay appellate court at uh hindi naman sila nagtatanggap
[52:05] mismo ng ebidensya in this particular case it is really crucial and vital that the decision on
[52:12] accountability be made based on the evidence at uh kung wala po dito yung mga mahistrado talaga pong sa pananaw namin hindi nila hindi sila
[52:23] makakapagpa siya ng let me interject so far so far until this day ha wala pa kayong ebidensya
[52:30] ang punipresent na kailangan amoyin o tikman sa ngayon ang ebidensya pa lang na nakita ko sa inyo kailangan
[52:37] tignan kailangan pakinggan and if you use electronic means yes wala pang pangamoy panglasa yun pero pwedeng tignan
[52:44] pwedeng basahin so so far everything you've done here the demeanor of the witness the documents the um
[52:53] even the intramurals between the the defense and prosecution so but sir you're going to the wisdom
[53:04] whether it's wise to go into electronic ang question ko is there anything to prevent us
[53:09] from doing that kasi hindi ba dapat yun munang tanungin bago yung threshold so kung alimbawa inamend
[53:15] natin yung rules pwede sila magpartisipate the 24 walang problema ngayon inamend natin yung rules
[53:20] ayaw nila magpartisipate then baka then baka dapat natin questionin na bakit ayaw nila magpartisipate diba
[53:29] for for all we know senator batu is willing to take his oath we don't know go ahead sir thank you your
[53:35] honor the the rules of this honorable court and even of the senate are really within the power
[53:42] of uh your honors to amend if you so choose and um i cannot really say anything beyond that because
[53:48] that is um your power no i wanted your honest opinion and i appreciate it because i might have
[53:54] overlooked there might be something saying there na kailangan physically present because my reading
[54:00] also is that we can amend and we did try to amend for the senate no not for the impeachment uh
[54:07] court but the the rest is uh history so ano yung magiging practical na so for example if we say senator
[54:15] lauren attended half of the trial but if she says she continued to watch it so if she comes back a week
[54:22] before the impeachment um will she be allowed to vote or not well that is within the the jurisdiction and
[54:30] power of this honor yes but that's why if i that's why i'm asking i will ask both of you because uh
[54:38] how will we apply it that you think is fair some sides ninyo so the defense practically answered it by
[54:48] saying dapat pareho everyone that's why i'm addressing it to the to the of course the you will know the
[54:54] opinion of this court by how it decides later on for all this is all theoretical for all i know uh
[55:03] senator legarda's medical leave will will continue uh i don't know what will happen to the three other
[55:08] senators i'll tell you my next question in your view can this impeachment court order ordinary courts like
[55:18] this sandigan bayan to uh produce uh senator uh senator marcoleta and senator jingoy to attend
[55:29] this impeachment trial first if you're honest please as far as the electron electronic um trials are
[55:36] concerned um i i believe that there would this is my opinion that there would be an inability on the
[55:43] part of the person watching an electronic uh through electronic means this kind of proceeding to assess
[55:51] the credibility of the witnesses and as well to really understand and grasp what is happening in
[55:59] the trial there's no substitute for being here in person in in fact i believe that that would be fair
[56:07] to the respondent that uh everyone would be present here and physically able to assess the evidence
[56:16] so tingin ko po as far as um whether the question of participation of the judges is concerned
[56:22] is really meant to safeguard the respondent and that is why we believe that it's important that all the
[56:30] members of the court who will decide and vote on this case should be able to hear and see the
[56:37] evidence right here inside the courtroom i agree with you eighty percent that's ideal but for
[56:44] example when it takes the whole day having coffee either in our office or in the lounge and looking at
[56:50] the television is sometimes even uh better when i don't understand this although i do talk to my sue
[56:58] two seat mates uh i do look for for example the villiards are better in the numbers than i am so i ask them
[57:05] when it's a very very what we call this commonsensical issue that i think i'm so high tech
[57:13] i go to robin and say robin and noting in mo uh dito of course my sister's a lawyer i i i asked
[57:21] sometimes before a different opinion i asked senator mix because he's in the majority i'm in the minority so
[57:27] i mean there's different ways to appreciate it but i do respect your your your opinion and i i do think as a
[57:34] general rule the ideal talaga is to be here and to not to talk and talk about but the reality is we
[57:41] have four senators that are not here and some feel that they're endangered of being taken out of play
[57:47] also so that's the reality there so if we want to lower the threshold will we also be looking at not
[57:54] lowering the threshold but allowing them to participate if i may respond to the second question discussion so
[58:01] just go ahead your your honor was also asking if this honorable court can order the sandigan bayan to
[58:08] produce the the members of the court who are within their jurisdiction i would have to answer that
[58:15] that is a matter that the sandigan bayan should decide because they have jurisdiction over the case
[58:22] as well as the person of the accused and i would say i would think that um while this court may make
[58:29] its um sentiments known to the sandigan bayan ultimately it is that court that should make that
[58:36] decision would you like to know my opinion of course your honor no because if you don't i won't say it
[58:41] but if you do i think the senate cannot order the sandigan bayan to produce the senators here but
[58:49] i think the impeachment court can i think the impeachment court being sui generis and at the
[58:54] highest order and having plenary rules uh can with the proper coordination compel in the same manner that
[59:04] if we have a witness uh that is charged under uh contempt but then my criminal case the rtc or sandigan bayan
[59:16] can order the senate with the proper um coordination na ilipat sila don so of course ultimately our
[59:26] opinions are subject to supreme court ruling but i i'm quite clear hindi pwede yung senado yung senado can
[59:33] ask can ask the sandigan bayan can you allow them to but they cannot compel but i think if we're going to
[59:39] give full constitutional uh if we're going to give a full meeting to our constitution 24 members we can
[59:47] compel the sandigan bayan do we want to do that i don't know no but what i do not want is a uh mistrial
[59:57] and i want uh so better not here and you said it a little bit but i'll give you just this chance you
[1:00:03] want to elaborate why in your view it's not a mistrial if we lower the the threshold i respectfully
[1:00:12] submit your honor that it's well within the power of this court to make that decision i we have heard
[1:00:18] from the amici curate and none of them if i recall mentioned anything about a possibility of mistrial
[1:00:25] and at the same time it is this court and this court alone that was given the power and authority by the
[1:00:31] constitution to try and decide impeachment cases the four distinguished gentlemen and i um we should
[1:00:43] have also invited a lady amicus but uh as senator pia and senator risa always reminds us senator uh i mean
[1:00:53] senator camille na dapat gender inclusive um the four were gave given a theoretical framework and asked a
[1:01:07] question na sa tingin nyo sa constitution di ba ano yung threshold they weren't given the full blow of
[1:01:14] what's happening in politics uh what's happening in everything etc and they were not really um thrown the
[1:01:25] question that when you start the trial and many of the senator judges would not have participated at
[1:01:32] the start if we did not say it was 16 then you changed it in the middle so i i respect that's why i
[1:01:39] didn't participate i i don't think it's debatable the the 24 no having said that we're going to have a
[1:01:46] vote today so i'm forced to at least participate at this stage but i do respect their their opinions that's
[1:01:52] why sabi ko i welcome the debate that was sana sa supreme court di ba so that's my last question do you
[1:01:59] what do you think it would be better but let's assume that the vice president is convicted
[1:02:04] walang problema pag 16 17 until 24 we will all agree with that di ba even the defense agrees di ba
[1:02:11] yes pag 16 pataas ang nag convict there are still some questions you can bring to the supreme court but not
[1:02:17] the threshold yes di ba okay but if ang nag convict is 15 or 14 there will be uh questions so yun yun
[1:02:27] ahuli kong question should the court decide should the impeachment court decide or should the supreme court
[1:02:32] decide your honor i believe that the matter is not yet justiciable and cannot yet be brought to the
[1:02:40] supreme court kasi nga po wala pa pong boto at hindi po po natin alam kung ano ang magiging resulta
[1:02:47] ng pagboboto if for example the votes come out to 16 or more then there is no issue to bring to the
[1:02:54] supreme court if we if a petition is filed now the supreme court in my view could easily say
[1:03:01] sandali lang wala nasa nang issue dito eh hindi pa naman kayo bumoboto malay namin kung umabot na kayo
[1:03:08] and 16 then there will be nothing for us to decide that's why in my view the only time that this
[1:03:14] case will be justiciable to bring up to the supreme court is when an actual vote is done and a number
[1:03:21] less than 16 is uh arrived at and that is deemed sufficient to convict well two things obviously
[1:03:29] this court at the start of the hearing disagreed with you because senator escudero as presiding
[1:03:35] officer made a ruling i clarified that a few days or a week later senator lacson uh had a
[1:03:43] clarificatory question i'm not sure if here or some media there was another uh senator i don't know if
[1:03:49] if it was senator erwin was that may nagtanong din dito or was it senator kiko uh i i know senator
[1:03:57] lacson asked about it and i know senator escudero answered the issue is now justiciable diba so obviously
[1:04:06] the court and you have different opinions there but assuming assuming tamayin sayo kasi may point
[1:04:11] karen eh now even if we said it's uh justiciable the question now is will the supreme court say it's
[1:04:19] justiciable then why don't we just not discuss the threshold then when we vote so on 14 then we just
[1:04:28] say there's 14 votes then both of you bring it to the supreme court that's that's does that mean she's
[1:04:32] convicted or not we we don't have to say 14 therefore she's acquitted or 14 therefore she's convicted you
[1:04:41] let the supreme court kung 16 they wala tayong problema so i'll throw back to you that question
[1:04:46] although i said last now so with your forgiveness diba if it's not justiciable for the supreme court why
[1:04:52] is it justiciable for us right now why do we have to decide today what the threshold is yes kindly wind
[1:05:01] up that's it you can avail of the next time i'll only say last two times so thank you honorable jocknamian
[1:05:09] sir yes in in my view your honor it is only justiciable as far as the supreme court is concerned
[1:05:15] when an actual vote is had so that whether there was a ruling made earlier or not even if any party
[1:05:23] had brought it to clarify that a vote on the on the um guilt on conviction or acquittal yeah not not a vote
[1:05:32] on whether or not what the threshold is can i just clarify that sir you're you're saying it's only
[1:05:37] justiciable once the vote on the verdict right are you talking about the vote on the verdict or you're
[1:05:44] talking about the vote on the threshold the vote on the verdict that's clear thank you sir yeah thank
[1:05:50] you mr presiding officer thank you thank you thank you senator judge um alan gayetano senator judge um
[1:05:57] aquino is recognized thereafter senator judge laxon thereafter senator judge villaneda uh let me return the bible of
[1:06:10] uh center kaya tano uh magandang araw mr presiding officer magandang araw uh attorney poa and attorney chel
[1:06:22] before my time starts anyway we have a variable two minutes today let me just commend our two um
[1:06:29] two councils for today thank you for thank you for presenting the arguments very clearly
[1:06:34] no maraming maraming salamat okay so may i ask your opinion on this no after today do you think that the
[1:06:47] decision of this court with regard to the question at hand do you think that it is uh up for judicial
[1:06:57] review kunyari po attorney chel hindi nyo nakuha yung yung side ninyo will you be raising it to the supreme
[1:07:04] court i also have my own opinion on the matter but i'd like to get your opinion first uh
[1:07:14] uh sige attorney poa go ahead uh sa amin po just to be very straightforward and candid uh definitely
[1:07:21] there's a possibility that we will be raising this to the supreme court uh precisely because your honors
[1:07:27] when the respondent accused uh you know started and entered we entered her for for her in these
[1:07:35] proceedings expectation was yung conviction threshold is 16 votes so sa atin kung papalitan natin yun in
[1:07:44] the middle we feel that that is really a justiciable issue kasi po diba nasabi na rin ng presiding
[1:07:51] officer at that time nung nabigay yung ruling na kung sino man ang gustong komisyon ay pwede nang umakyat
[1:07:58] sa supreme court ultimately and we're not questioning that you can uh decide no kung ano yung
[1:08:06] threshold but ultimately i think we can all agree that the final arbiter will be the supreme court
[1:08:11] so i will say there is definitely that possibility your honors thank you attorney poa attorney chel
[1:08:16] we respectfully submit that uh it is within the exclusive power and authority of this court
[1:08:21] to make that decision if your honor please and um if you look at even the jurisprudence that we have
[1:08:28] i think it would also point in that direction okay um i'm not arguing with the two of you
[1:08:34] pero ako po personally no yung power to try and decide ng impeachment court uh pagating sa
[1:08:42] impeachment ang aking interpretasyon yan po'y patungkol sa guilt or innocence ng respondent in fact
[1:08:50] i disagree with um chief justice puno that that decision can even be raised to the supreme court because
[1:08:57] in the constitution nakalagay we have the sole power to try and decide but in this particular case
[1:09:04] ang pinag-uusapan kasi natin is an interpretation no an interpretation uh which is why i would say
[1:09:12] that after deciding today uh it can be raised to the supreme court and that whatever their decision
[1:09:19] is should be something that we should all uh take cognizance of no in fact on the first day of trial
[1:09:26] senator laxon already clarified that it is already a justiciable issue and even back then it could have
[1:09:32] been raised so whatever the decision is today uh to our dear colleagues here and and i hope my
[1:09:38] fellow senators are also listening ako po naniniwala na mahalaga rin na mapakinggan natin kung ano
[1:09:44] yung position ng supreme court and i say that not having agreed with them in their previous decision on
[1:09:51] the matter remember nung nag na-raise yung issue ng impeachment a year ago they struck down the
[1:09:59] impeachment in duterte versus house of representatives where they did not in my humble
[1:10:04] opinion they did not do a verbal legis approach kasi napakasimple ng modes of impeachment and yet
[1:10:10] nagkaroon sila ng interpretation kung paano dapat gawin yung isang mode of impeachment i didn't agree with
[1:10:16] that but when that decision was done sumunod po kami no so uh attorney po let me just mention na hindi
[1:10:24] laging verbal legis ang supreme court in fact sometimes they are verbal legis sometimes they use
[1:10:29] the contextual or functional approach and in this case na pinag-uusapan natin yung
[1:10:36] pag-iintindi sa napakahalagang kataga sa ating constitution after our decision which of course we should
[1:10:44] uphold then uh if there are parties in fact maybe even judges may themselves bring it up no i don't
[1:10:52] know is that possible attorney child can a can a judge also bring up a case to the supreme court uh
[1:10:58] asking for clarification or for guidance that would probably be not accepted by the court because the
[1:11:05] supreme court your honor does not have jurisdiction over declaratory relief cases so it's really only uh
[1:11:12] the parties probably who could raise it up and they would have to look for an actual ripe dispute at
[1:11:19] this point um there is as yet no vote taken by this honorable court so your position attorney child uh
[1:11:26] honorable joke no is that um it only is right on the final decision not even on a decision today there
[1:11:34] because as yet there is no injury if your honor please if ever there would be an aggrieved party that um
[1:11:41] being injured would only happen after the actual vote is taken okay attorney po may i get uh the
[1:11:47] position of the defense in your case i'm guessing uh even after today maaari ng maaakyat sa supreme court
[1:11:55] definitely your honors although i agree with the distinguished council na pag senator judge
[1:12:01] baka hindi pwede not because of declaratory relief but because really the court will not give uh an advisory
[1:12:08] opinion no no kung ano yung tamat ano yung mali without a controversy but your honors para sa amin
[1:12:15] justiciable na po ben like you said uh we we we are not saying that uh uh kumbaga we agree with the fact
[1:12:24] that pagdating sa pag sole uh power to try you know supreme court uh the impeachment cases belongs to the senate
[1:12:32] that's not that does not include uh itong uh voting threshold uh para sa amin po when you say
[1:12:39] sole power to try and hear impeachment cases it's really the evidence and like you said to determine
[1:12:43] guilt or innocence but pagdating sa interpretation ng voting threshold while you can have your own
[1:12:49] interpretation finally it will still have to be decided by the supreme court if we deem it proper to
[1:12:54] bring it up and for us uh the fact that there was already a ruling and we relied on that ruling
[1:13:00] and now it's suddenly changed honor for us at least that is already a justiciable controversy all
[1:13:05] right marami salamat and uh let me commend again our two councils thank you for presenting your
[1:13:09] sides today thank you senator judge bamakino senator judge laxon is recognized you may proceed sir you have
[1:13:16] two minutes thank you sir presiding officer mine are not questions but uh observations you know uh on
[1:13:24] possible misinformation uh resulting from uh in my view no uh misleading statements made by both
[1:13:34] the prosecution and the defense number one is the prosecution
[1:13:40] and with all due respect uh congressman no
[1:13:44] sinabi niyo pa na all four amici curie agree na yung 16 is not absolute i disagree because
[1:13:52] si justice hascuna was very empathic all means all so that's one point so defense in the corona
[1:14:01] impeachment uh case you're correct no 23 lang kami uh because uh president uh or then senator aquino
[1:14:09] was uh elected president the threshold was maintained at 16 hindi kami bumbaba ng 15
[1:14:16] because two-thirds of 23 is 15.33 and we rounded up 0.33 to one i believe ito rin yung sinusunod
[1:14:27] yata sa mga sa corporate practice di po ba so hindi wala kaming binaviolate o wala kaming ginawa
[1:14:34] na nag-lower kami o hindi namin ginalaw yung 16 because hindi namin pwedeng galawin because
[1:14:40] uh 15.3 still was still 16 at that time thank you so yun lang po mr presiding officer um for the
[1:14:48] information of senator judge laxon we will make a um corresponding ruling along those lines
[1:14:54] depending on the result of the vote um later senator judge yes um who if your honorable
[1:15:02] may i simply make a manifestation in response to the comments of um the observations of the good um
[1:15:10] um your honor uh center laxon ang as ang pagkaintindi ko po ang sinabi po ni justice as kuna
[1:15:18] ay um 24 ang bilang except in cases of permanent vacancy because of death resignation or removal so
[1:15:28] sa amin pong pananaw ay hindi po fixed absolute na 16 ang number akong may mamatay may matanggal may mag
[1:15:36] resign according to of justice as kuna maaring bumaba ang uh number and i recall that was in response to
[1:15:44] one a question by one of the members of the court sorry noted your honors if i may um yes attorney po may
[1:15:51] respond your honors i totally agree with uh of course senator laxon and thank him for giving us the facts
[1:15:57] no at about 15.33 but i think your honors and this is not uh addressed to senator laxon i think this is
[1:16:04] also an issue that the court might want to consider kasi noong narinig po natin yung amici last week
[1:16:11] iba-iba po kasi meron nag sabing round down round up parang yung ginagawa natin sa math meron
[1:16:18] naman po nag sabing disregard yung fraction so that's also a very important point your honors because
[1:16:25] well without anyone asking at least this representation's opinion there your honors is when it's 15.33 or
[1:16:32] quite 15.01 or 14.01 we have to round up because if we do not we will never meet the threshold but at
[1:16:40] least that's my humble opinion your honors but again i thank senator laxon for the clarification julie
[1:16:45] noted attorney po senator judge villoneva is recognized for his interjection you uh you have two minutes
[1:16:54] sir you may proceed when you're ready mr president uh presiding officer before i uh ask questions mr
[1:17:02] president i would just like to make a short manifestation considering mr president that
[1:17:09] even during the time when uh we had the amici kurei here and my time is up the amici kurei made
[1:17:18] statements i couldn't even butt in or uh share my views as a senator judge um i'm kind of envious when i
[1:17:26] uh heard our minority leader taking the podium and get uh more time than uh than most of us but i am
[1:17:35] i am not i'm not complaining mr president but just to put on record mr president because uh in fact
[1:17:41] mr president i have 12 points here for for uh the prosecution and 12 points here for the defense but i
[1:17:48] will only point out one thing later on mr president but uh may i just make a short manifestation during the
[1:17:54] uh time when we had the uh time when we had the amici kurei um i couldn't help but uh uh wanting to uh
[1:18:02] comment on what uh justice as kuna made mention that when there's the denominator
[1:18:10] uh um i uh naging uh 16 or 15 na lang mr president parang wala na hindi na po pwedeng magkaroon
[1:18:19] ng impeachment dahil fixed ang 16 so gusto kong ipoint out sana yun and uh and that to me mr
[1:18:27] president uh gave me the uh idea na now you can never say never sabi ni justin bieber um doon naman po
[1:18:38] sa sinabi ni uh uh former chief justice panganiban binanggit po niya yung kwento doon sa dalawang magulang
[1:18:49] na pinag i-explain yung anak e gusto kong sabihin hindi dalawa yung magulang na magde-decide
[1:18:55] uh marami po yung magde-decide 24 pangalawa yung panganay na anak hindi pwedeng gamitin yung
[1:19:05] ibang prinsipyo o pulisiya na ginamit mo sa panganay na anak at hindi mo gagamitin doon sa ikalawang anak
[1:19:11] but having said that mr president may i just pause uh one question to uh both parties and uh i joined senator bam for
[1:19:20] uh congratulating uh the honorable jock no and the attorney po ah kayo yung dalawang favorite
[1:19:26] ko dito sa impeachment trial and every time you speak we we all listen maraming salamat po yung
[1:19:32] question ko po uh first to uh the defense panel um binanggit niyo po na 16 is a fixed number
[1:19:45] but the framers of our constitution did not say the word or number 16 but instead they use
[1:19:56] two-thirds and in fact i believe during the time when uh justice askuna is uh explaining his uh
[1:20:04] position i i still believe with all of my heart that 16 is not fixed on his mind and i would agree with
[1:20:13] the uh uh congressman joke um the framers should have said 16 but instead two-thirds the uh us
[1:20:24] constitution said uh members present pero hindi din po yun ang inilagay so kung ganun po hindi ho ba
[1:20:32] napakalinaw din no article 11 that indeed the sole power to decide and try belongs to the senate your
[1:20:43] your honors uh if i may respond your honors dun po sa tanong kung bakit hindi po nalagay yung 16 of
[1:20:49] course i will be just giving my humble opinion on the matter but kaya po hindi 16 because as i
[1:20:55] mentioned during the oral argument and i think also mentioned by uh this is distinguished opposing
[1:21:00] counsel wala naman po kaming sinasabi na fix at 24 what we're saying it's fixed at the at the membership so
[1:21:09] meaning kung 24 po yung members 24 now when will that change pag meron lang pong vacancy and that's
[1:21:16] when death resignation uh disqualification permanent disability or expulsion hindi po ba kaya po two
[1:21:24] thirds secondly uh i could only surmise might be stylistic because pagdating sa house one-thirds of all members
[1:21:31] of the house dahil yung house po uh nag change po yung numero nila depending kung magkaroon ng additional
[1:21:37] district etc but again kaya po hindi na sulat na 16 at least in my humble opinion ay dahil po papano kung
[1:21:45] 24 yung senators pero may isang uh na vacate yung seat so that's why it remained fractional two-thirds at least
[1:21:55] that's my humble opinion your honor thank you for that but i also believe that the framers themselves
[1:22:00] know very well the number 24 so again uh when you said a while ago that 16 is 16 uh i'm not sure of
[1:22:08] that but i i respect your uh opinion in the position to uh uh congressman na joke no isang question
[1:22:15] lam po no if would you believe would you agree with this representation that indeed the purpose
[1:22:21] of that particular provision in the constitution to have two-thirds is to ensure that uh it would
[1:22:29] require super majority and deliberately harder than uh ordinary um uh decision coming from the senate
[1:22:41] yes your honor i would submit that um that is the reason why that number was um put in the in the
[1:22:48] constitution and and you affirm that two-thirds is a uh super majority and indeed uh uh a harder uh
[1:22:58] number that you need to reach in order to deliberate and decide on a very important matter yes uh your
[1:23:05] honor because we are talking about accountability here yes thank you very much and one last point that
[1:23:10] i'd like to raise kung bumoto po kami dito at i embrace yung uh at ipatupad yung threshold should not be fixed
[1:23:30] at 16 what would what do you think would happen with other um other uh matters like for instance the one uh
[1:23:41] uh attorney poa made mention dun sa martial law na two-thirds din ang kailangan sa expulsion
[1:23:49] ng isang miyembro ng senado two-thirds din ang kailangan now what is very dear for all of us the
[1:23:56] changing of the constitution which is three-fourths pwede rin po ba ito na uh magbago dahil magbabago
[1:24:05] bo ang denominator uh representative jock no thank you honor in my opinion nothing would change insofar as
[1:24:13] those so those other provisions are concerned kasi po ang pinag-uusapan po natin dito ay
[1:24:18] nakabase sa article 11 ng ating constitution on public accountability and we are talking
[1:24:24] specifically of one of the primary accountability mechanisms which is impeachment so any decision by
[1:24:31] this honorable body as an impeachment court will not affect the other provisions of the constitution in
[1:24:38] my opinion only in the impeachment which is found in article 11 of our constitution that we have the
[1:24:45] sole power to try and decide yes your honor thank you very much thank you mr president thank you um
[1:24:55] senator judge alan caetano is recognized what is your pleasure sir it's just a manifestation mr
[1:25:01] presiding officer you may proceed sir pinag-uusapan natin kung dapat supreme court ang mag decide
[1:25:07] actually may role sila dito at pwede silang decide because there is actually a pending case called
[1:25:13] cayetano versus aquino and i didn't file it against bam aquino but alphabetically kasi una siya so it does
[1:25:21] discuss all of these discussions uh about numbers so i just wanted to put that on the record mr
[1:25:26] president that actually if the supreme court does take up the case and decide uh tapos yung pinag-uusapan
[1:25:33] natin dito but if not yun nga ang question but in the case of francisco the supreme court made it very
[1:25:40] clear that pag ang pinag-uusapan ay yung uh uh rules uh nung impeachment justiciable yung issue of course it has
[1:25:49] to be right thank you mr president thank you um while waiting for the intervention of other senator judges if
[1:25:59] any the chair would like to um make of record the chair's response to the procedural issues raised
[1:26:06] earlier by attorney poa this is in order to give um the court's view on the matter and so that um so
[1:26:15] that um any of the parties specifically attorney poa and the respondent wishes to um bring it up
[1:26:20] the picture would be complete um so to respond on the procedural issue raised by attorney poa
[1:26:27] pertaining to the applicability of um the rules of the senate on appeal and or the rules of court
[1:26:34] on appeal um on september 8th the chair treated senator judge erwin tulfo's manifestation as an
[1:26:42] appeal announced the procedure for its resolution and set the matter for consideration by the senator
[1:26:47] judges no senator judge then challenged the propriety or timeliness of that action if the objection
[1:26:56] relies on section 91 rule 33 of the rules of the senate a motion for reconsideration must be made on
[1:27:05] the same day or within the next two session days applied party passu therefore or on equal footing
[1:27:12] both periods have lapsed both with respect to the july 6 ruling and the september 8 ruling um the september 8
[1:27:21] ruling must consequently be given the same finality now claimed for the july 6 ruling under the
[1:27:27] rules of the senate and the objector cannot invoke lapse to shield the earlier ruling while this
[1:27:34] regarding the identical lapse that protects the later action if the objection as pointed out by
[1:27:41] the respondent relies on the judicial 15-day period the pertinent provisions of rule 37 of the revised
[1:27:48] rules of court it allows reconsideration of a judgment or final order within the period for appeal
[1:27:54] ordinarily 15 days from notice today september 23 is the 15th day the last day for that
[1:28:02] regulatory period for seeking reconsideration however the judicial records under rule 37 periods rather
[1:28:11] under rules 37 and 45 and 65 of the rules of court um to the mind of the chair do not apply
[1:28:18] senator judge dulfo's appeal is not a remedy arising under the said rules it arose from the rules of the
[1:28:26] of this impeachment court the controlling provision instead are rule 6 in relation to rule 22 of the
[1:28:34] impeachment rules rule 6 makes the rules of the senate and the rules of court merely supplicatory
[1:28:40] applicable only when appropriate they cannot convert this internal appeal into a remedy under rules 37 45 or 65
[1:28:48] of the rules of the rules of court rule 22 and rule 6 govern and prescribes no regulatory period for
[1:28:56] seeking a vote on a ruling of the chair as pointed out also earlier by the council for respondent attorney
[1:29:03] poa the court therefore cannot also impose a deadline absent from its own rules more importantly the mere passage
[1:29:12] of time does not transform a prior interpretation into an immutable rule this is this fine support in
[1:29:19] people versus amigo gr number 11 67 19 the supreme court recognized that in it's this that its
[1:29:28] decisions are quote not petrified rules grown rigid once pronounced but may be reconsidered upon further
[1:29:36] reflection in light of new perspectives close quote the july ruling issued during an ongoing proceeding is not a
[1:29:45] final judgment on any article of impeachment it cannot claim greater therefore this issue cannot claim
[1:29:52] greater immutability than the judicial doctrine itself where the governing impeachment rules prescribe no
[1:29:58] period and no final judgment has been rendered the court remains free to reconsider its interpretation for
[1:30:06] the record and so that your um records as well um attorney power will be complete thank you honors um what is the pleasure of
[1:30:14] attorney um mr presiding officer i didn't quite catch the start of your statement but you did say
[1:30:27] something to the effect that no one questioned it and i'm not sure what the it was but i'm just putting
[1:30:34] on record that on september 8th i did stand up and question whether this is the proper forum whether this
[1:30:41] is the proper place to even discuss an interpretation of the two-thirds of all members just for the record
[1:30:49] also yes um that is no one did so i just want to be clear that that i'm not sure what that reference
[1:30:57] what that was in reference to so i'm making clear that i did stand up on a particular issue the point
[1:31:03] was um senator judge pia and the point raised by procedural point raised by attorney pova is that
[1:31:10] the period to um appeal the july 6 ruling has lapsed um and my the ruling of the chair was no period is
[1:31:20] provided for the rules for in the rules and any ruling can be questioned at any point in time and that
[1:31:27] the 48 um 48 um 48 hour two day period found in the senate rules and the 15 day period found in the
[1:31:34] rules of court um will not have precedence over the rules on impeachment itself which does not prescribe
[1:31:40] a period to appeal a ruling of the chair that was simply the statement okay i understand that portion
[1:31:46] but there is a portion before that where there is a reference to no one stood up i'm just making
[1:31:52] it clear that i stood up you might maybe if you can give me in relation to appealing the ruling um in
[1:31:59] relation to appealing the ruling um but it can still be done up to today it was because i was saying is
[1:32:05] this the proper venue to even discuss this because when the presiding officer made a ruling on july 6
[1:32:12] we all accepted it because it was verbal legis it was a literal interpretation of the constitution it is
[1:32:20] the ordinary meaning as any law student would know ordinary meaning no need for further interpretation
[1:32:28] but now or not even now um as of september 8 when it was brought up then it appears that we now have to
[1:32:42] give it more than its ordinary meaning more than its ordinary intention and that's why
[1:32:50] at that time i asked tama ba ito na dito to it discuss you know mr presiding officer because
[1:33:00] goes into the heart of this discussion can we even have this discussion here and i raised it i was
[1:33:07] standing here when i raised that point mr presiding officer thank you julie noted um senator judge pia
[1:33:17] we confirm rather the point raised by senator judge pia that she did say do we even have the right to
[1:33:23] decide on this um the point um made by the chair was that no appeal um it was not considered an
[1:33:30] appeal nor was an appeal made to the house as to that ruling at that time but again um it can be
[1:33:36] raised at any point in time similar to this one any other senator judge who wishes to make an
[1:33:42] interjection senator judge i'm sorry senator judge erwin tulfo manifested earlier you may proceed sir when you're
[1:33:50] ready you're ready you have two minutes mr presiding officer just a quick interjection
[1:34:18] the present reality is that some of our members
[1:34:21] others are beyond the coercive power or jurisdiction of the senate one is on medical leave abroad with no
[1:34:32] definite return date another is in hiding two others are under the custody of the sandigan bayan
[1:34:41] or the bureau of jail management ito po ang factual circumstances na umiiral ngayon at hindi naman
[1:34:50] po ito umiiral o umiiral nung tayo po ay magsisimula pa lamang sa ating proceedings naitanong ko lang po
[1:34:59] kasi naitanong din po nababasa ko sa social media ang tanong po ng mga kababayan natin ng mga netizens
[1:35:05] kaya makatwitted lamang po suriin natin ngayon kung paano nakaka-apekto ang mga bagong
[1:35:12] pangyayaring ito sa computation po ng two-thirds vote na hinihingi po sinasabi ng ating
[1:35:21] constitution kung titignan pa ginoong a presiding officer the constitution uses a fraction not a
[1:35:32] fixed number former cj puno emphasized that article 11 section 3 6 uses fraction rather than fixed number
[1:35:41] like 16. had the framers intended an immutable number they would have expressly indicated a numerical
[1:35:51] figure because it is a fraction the mathematical baseline dynamically moves or varies depending on
[1:36:01] structural operational situational factors affect affecting the senate composition may
[1:36:12] nagsabi rin po na siguro noong panahon po noong ginagawa ang konstitusyon ang mga kaso po
[1:36:20] ng mga senador noon either subversion sedition yun po mga kaso pero ang mga senador po ay hindi po
[1:36:30] nakakasuhan ng kriminal plunder at kung ano ano pa kaya po hindi siguro naisip na mga
[1:36:38] framers mga framers mga framers mga framers mga framers mga framers mga framers ayon po dito sa isang
[1:36:40] abogado nagpadala po sa akin ng noong na maaring wala po itong panahon na ito nung tinatag ang
[1:36:47] 1987 constitution dahil ang mga kaso ng mga senador noon tulad na lang po ng ama ng ating
[1:36:54] prosecutor dito subversion po yata panahon ng marshal or after marshal panahon ng marshal o sedition
[1:37:02] rebellion hindi po plunder hindi po pagnanakaw kaya po iniisip nila ng mga senador na hanggang
[1:37:13] ngayon ay hindi po makakasuhan ng mga terribling kaso yun lamang po uh mr presiding officer
[1:37:19] mr presiding officer um before i recognize senator judge alan kayetano or senator judge soto may please
[1:37:27] first instruct the clerk of court to call the role since we suspended yesterday so um the members present may be
[1:37:34] placed on um record the clerk is directed to call the roll call call of members senator judge aquino
[1:37:41] senator just kayetano alan senator just kayetano pia senator judge de la rosa senator judge ejército
[1:37:50] senator judge strada senator judge go senator judge ontiveros senator judge laxon senator judge lapid
[1:37:59] senator judge legarda setto judge marcoleta setto judge marcos setto judge padilla setto judge pangilinan
[1:38:08] setto judge soto the third setto judge tulfo irwin setto judge tulfo rafi setto judge villanueva
[1:38:17] setto judge villar camille setto judge villar mart setto judge zubiri the presiding officer setto judge
[1:38:26] With 20 Senators present, Chair declares the presence of a quorum.
[1:38:33] Senator Judge...
[1:38:34] Mr. Presiding Officer, with your indulgence.
[1:38:37] Yes, Attorney Bauer.
[1:38:38] Just for the record, Your Honors, and of course, this is nothing against Senator Irwin.
[1:38:43] You would like to comment?
[1:38:44] Yes, just briefly, Your Honors.
[1:38:46] You may proceed, sir.
[1:38:47] I respect actually that he brought up the issue last September 8th
[1:38:52] because we really want to know what the treatment should be here.
[1:38:56] So that was perfectly valid for us, Your Honors.
[1:38:59] But, Your Honors, just for this representation to put on record,
[1:39:02] that what we said that there is no change.
[1:39:05] We are not trying to mislead the public in our oral arguments.
[1:39:09] We said that since July 6th,
[1:39:12] when the ruling passed until today,
[1:39:15] there is no change.
[1:39:18] Except for Senator Legarda, who is now on medical leave,
[1:39:21] because the other Senators who did not participate today,
[1:39:26] on July 6th,
[1:39:27] did not participate.
[1:39:29] So, just for the record, Your Honors,
[1:39:31] just so we are not construed as trying to mislead the public
[1:39:35] in the arguments that we are making, Your Honors.
[1:39:37] But again, this is nothing against Senator Irwin Tulfo.
[1:39:40] It's just really to correct the record, Your Honors.
[1:39:42] I see him nodding and said,
[1:39:43] I guess he seems to be imparting that none is taken, Attorney Bauer.
[1:39:47] Thank you, Senator Tulfo.
[1:39:48] Senator Judge Alan Cayetano?
[1:39:52] May I give way to Senator Judge Camille Villar?
[1:39:55] With the indulgence of Senator Judge Soto,
[1:39:58] Senator Judge Camille Villar is recognized.
[1:40:03] Sorry, Bo.
[1:40:04] What is your pleasure, ma'am?
[1:40:06] No, I just wanted to manifest also or respond to the manifestation of Senator Irwin Tulfo.
[1:40:18] The lady may proceed.
[1:40:19] While I respect all of our colleagues here, all of you,
[1:40:25] I think we should be reminded that the senators that are being detained and who are not here right now,
[1:40:38] that is not their choice.
[1:40:40] And I think it's unfair to call them out that their crimes are of plunder and of theft,
[1:40:49] because none of those senators have been convicted.
[1:40:52] There are a lot of questions about why they're not even here in the first place.
[1:40:59] And as the youngest member of this August body, can we stop it with these attacks on each other?
[1:41:12] We are senators of the Philippines.
[1:41:16] Let us give each other due respect.
[1:41:20] Let's give Filipinos due respect.
[1:41:24] Hindi naman tayo pwedeng kung ano-ano nalang sinasabi natin dito tungkol sa mga colleagues natin, di ba?
[1:41:33] Huwag naman, di ba? Konting respeto naman.
[1:41:36] Kasi lahat naman po nang wala dito,
[1:41:39] hindi naman po sila napatunayan na may sala.
[1:41:46] Hindi po sila plunderer.
[1:41:50] Hindi po sila magnanakaw.
[1:41:52] Hindi po sila napatunayan na ganun.
[1:41:55] So huwag naman tayo tumayo diyan at maglo-blow ng ganun.
[1:42:01] I afford my colleagues to respect.
[1:42:05] And I just hope that our colleagues can do the same for those that are here and are not here.
[1:42:16] Yun lamang po. Maraming sila.
[1:42:18] Noted. With the indulgence of Senator Judge Allen,
[1:42:22] Yes, are you making an interjection or a manifestation?
[1:42:25] It's on the same topic, very short.
[1:42:27] You may proceed, sir, before I recognize Senator Judge Soto and then Senator Judge Padilla.
[1:42:32] Thank you, Senator Judge Soto. Forgive me for interjecting just on this point.
[1:42:36] And Senator Camille said it better, but I do promise to myself to afford the respect to everyone and have a healthy discussion.
[1:42:47] I do see the point of Senator Tulfo Irwin in distinguishing between martial law and what's happening now.
[1:42:57] The point I just want to make is that we have different views about that.
[1:43:00] And if we answer here, it will turn political.
[1:43:03] But I think we've answered or we've made our own allegations outside the impeachment court.
[1:43:10] But just for the record, as Camille, Senator Judge Camille said it better.
[1:43:18] Let me put it this way. If we amend the rules to allow electronic, then many of these arguments will go away.
[1:43:28] So, Senator Judge Irwin, I take in good faith yung dinidistinguish mo between martial law cases and here.
[1:43:38] Except nga yung stand namin kasi is that may politika din dun sa ibang cases.
[1:43:43] But let's not elaborate on that. Let's just respect each other's decision.
[1:43:48] And the emotions from Senator Camille came also from we visit kasi our colleagues.
[1:43:54] And visibly, diba, Mr. President, their presiding officer, visibly they're upset also with everything that's happening from their own liberty,
[1:44:04] from them not able to participate, from the threshold being changed.
[1:44:09] But we're all trying to do our best. Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[1:44:12] Thank you, Senator Soto. Thank you, Senator Judge Allen.
[1:44:15] Senator Judge Padilla, Senator Judge Soto is giving way.
[1:44:19] With the indulgence of Senator Judge Soto, Senator Judge Padilla is recognized.
[1:44:24] What is your pleasure, sir?
[1:44:28] Maraming salamat po sa aming kakapamahalang lukukom at sa ating pong ginoong Pangulo.
[1:44:38] Nais ko lamang pong magtanong sa ating mga, sa ating pong depensa at sa ating pong konsekusyon.
[1:44:45] You may proceed, sir.
[1:44:48] Apo.
[1:44:50] Ah, lahat po tayo tumanggap ng panunumpa.
[1:44:55] Lahat po tayo.
[1:44:56] Ah, alam ko ang mga abogado tumanggap ng panunumpa na sinabi po nating lahat na ating po proteksyonan ang konstitusyon.
[1:45:08] Ito po ay unang tanong sa depensa bago po sa prosecution.
[1:45:15] Ito po bang ginagawa ninyo ngayon sa debating ito, sa pag-uusap na ito, dala po ba ninyo ang inyong panunumpa?
[1:45:25] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:45:29] Nakaalala niyo po ba ang inyong sinabi noong kayo po ay nanumpa?
[1:45:33] Opo.
[1:45:34] Na itaguyod po ang ating saligang batas.
[1:45:36] Iyan.
[1:45:37] Itaguyod ang saligang batas.
[1:45:39] Kayo po ngayon ay nandidito profesional?
[1:45:43] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:45:45] Kayo po ay nandidito dala ang inyong murad?
[1:45:51] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:45:53] Kayo po ba ay nandidito bilang politikal?
[1:45:59] Hindi po, Your Honours.
[1:46:01] Maraming salamat po.
[1:46:02] Thank you po.
[1:46:04] Tanong ko po sa ating kaibigan.
[1:46:06] Bagamat tayo po ay laging magkahiwalay sa opinion pero kayo po ay ginagalang ko.
[1:46:14] Same po, Your Honours.
[1:46:15] Bilang isang ama, ako po ay saludo sa inyo at isang revolucionaryo din.
[1:46:20] Kayo po, hanggang ngayon po ba ay pinaninindigan ninyo ang inyong panunumpa na kayo ay magiging matapat at itataguyod ang saligang batas?
[1:46:34] Opo, Your Honours.
[1:46:35] Sa inyo pong pagiging profesional?
[1:46:41] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:46:42] Sa inyo pong pagiging moral?
[1:46:46] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:46:47] Kayo po ba ay nandidito politikal?
[1:46:50] Hindi po.
[1:46:52] Naniniwala po kayo na ang konstitusyon ay dapat dumaan ba sa tatlong sinasabi ng konstitusyon kung paano siya amendahan?
[1:47:03] Yung pag-amenda po mismo ng saligang batas?
[1:47:05] Opo.
[1:47:06] Tama po yun.
[1:47:08] Kayo po, naniniwala?
[1:47:09] Yes po, Your Honours.
[1:47:10] Ano po yung tatlo na yun?
[1:47:12] CONAS, Your Honours, Constitutional Assembly, Constitutional Convention or People's Initiative, Your Honours.
[1:47:19] Naniniwala po kayo doon?
[1:47:21] Yes, Your Honours.
[1:47:22] Marami salamat po.
[1:47:24] Thank you, Your Honours.
[1:47:25] Thank you, Senator Judge Padilla.
[1:47:27] Senator Judge Soto is recognized for his interjections.
[1:47:30] You have two minutes, sir.
[1:47:31] You may proceed when you're ready.
[1:47:32] Thank you, Your Honours.
[1:47:33] Thank you, Your Honours.
[1:47:34] Mr. Presiding Officer.
[1:47:35] Thank you very much.
[1:47:38] Mr. Senate President, my esteem colleagues and the members of the prosecution and the defense.
[1:47:53] May I first ask again, when the ruling was made by the presiding officer by citing the number 16, when was it made and how was it made, Your Honours? Just to refresh my memory.
[1:48:12] July 6th.
[1:48:13] July 6th.
[1:48:14] The original ruling on the threshold, Your Honour.
[1:48:17] And how was the ruling, how did it come about, Your Honour? Was there a question? Was there a motion on the floor?
[1:48:29] None, Your Honour.
[1:48:30] It was part of the chair's opening statement after being elected as presiding officer. And the chair stated the reason they're at during the opening statement and thereafter, too, in order to afford anyone who disagrees with it the opportunity to bring it up before the Supreme Court at the soonest possible time.
[1:48:52] Because I said at that time, the last thing I want is for a vote to be taken on the final verdict on impeachment, and it will still not be the end of it. That the debate, the divisiveness will still continue, and that this is not what our country and people need at the moment.
[1:49:11] All right. So, in other words, Your Honour, Mr. Presiding Officer, it was part of a statement made by the presiding officer and was not born out of a question or a motion or something to that effect. Am I right, Your Honour?
[1:49:30] That is correct, Your Honour, with the caveat that later in the afternoon, Senator Judge Alan Peter Cayetano and the following day on July 7, Senator Judge Lacson asked if that statement was a ruling of the chair, and the chair answered in the affirmative that it is the ruling of the chair and therefore of the court, given that nobody objected to or repealed that statement.
[1:49:58] All right. That brings me to the point that was raised by Senator Irving Tulfo thereafter, a few weeks thereafter, asking about the number.
[1:50:11] Because as I see it and the way I understand it, it was not exactly a ruling. It was part of a statement, and it was called a ruling by members of media and understood that way by some of our colleagues.
[1:50:31] But nevertheless, I just wanted to place that record. And so, I would want to clarify an issue that Senator Irving brought about. This is regarding the number. This is the issue of the number, the number 16.
[1:50:48] I don't see the number 16. I don't see the number 16 in the Constitution. Ang alam natin, two-thirds.
[1:50:56] So, my proposal to the amendment of Senator Irving Tulfo is that we retain the fraction. We must be faithful to the Constitution. Two-thirds.
[1:51:12] In other words, in answer to the questions earlier by some of our, I think, colleague of ours and the member of the prosecution, we are now 20 here present.
[1:51:27] If Senator Legarda arrives from abroad, she can vote. If Senator De La Rosa decides to appear and takes his oath, he can vote.
[1:51:41] And if the Sandigan Bayan allows our two incarcerated colleagues to attend, they can vote. Therefore, what are we saying?
[1:51:57] We're saying to those who are within the coercive powers of the Senate, two-thirds vote. Not 16. Not any other number. Two-thirds.
[1:52:07] I think that is what Senator Irving Tulfo was bringing out when he brought that question.
[1:52:19] So, therefore, at this point, as I said, in support of the motion of Senator Tulfo, I move to amend that by saying that we retain the two-thirds to those who are able to vote.
[1:52:39] Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[1:52:42] Thank you, Senator Sato. Julie Nute. What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Irving Tulfo?
[1:52:50] Mr. Presiding Officer, we'd just like to make a comment because my name was mentioned earlier.
[1:52:57] I'd like to take this opportunity.
[1:53:00] If there's a pain in what I've spoken about about how many of our members are, I'm going to be able to do it.
[1:53:08] But I just told the President of the Presiding Officer and the President that I didn't have convicted of a plunderer of our members.
[1:53:19] Further, the statements were not attacks against our fellow senators, but merely confronting the present reality that some senators are physically or legally unable to participate in the impeachment trial.
[1:53:39] The issue of detained senators is so intertwined in the determination of the nominator.
[1:53:49] We cannot discuss baseline without touching on the reasons why four of our senators are absent.
[1:53:58] We cannot proceed because bakit natin pinag-uusapan at i-re-raise ang issue kung sino ang bibilangin kung lahat tayo po ay narito.
[1:54:09] I was just sounding off the questions of the people of their netizens.
[1:54:16] That's what I brought it here.
[1:54:19] Kung hindi po natin naririnig mga kasama natin na ba everyday po, before coming over, I looked at the social media, the newspapers, I looked at reports.
[1:54:30] Hindi lang po pupunta ko dito ng sarili ko, iniisip ko, iniisip ko yung gusto sabihin ng taong bayan.
[1:54:35] Because we represented those people.
[1:54:39] They voted for us.
[1:54:41] Kaya karapatan din po natin na marinig sila dito through us who were voted by these people.
[1:54:50] Yun lamang po ginaong Pangulo, ginaong Presiding Officer.
[1:54:53] Noted and entered into the records.
[1:54:57] Senator Judge Padilla, before we go on lunch break, I guess, because it's 12.
[1:55:02] What is your pleasure, sir?
[1:55:03] Di noong tagapamahalang hukom, ang nais lamang po namin ipaalam sa taong bayan, unang-una na.
[1:55:17] Kaya po namin nababanggit ang mga kasama namin sa minurya na sa kasulukuyan ay nasa piitan.
[1:55:25] Sapagkat malinaw naman po na baka ito na rin ang huli ko dito ng araw eh.
[1:55:32] Hindi ko na rin alam eh.
[1:55:35] Pinaliliwanag lang po namin sa inyo na may pinagdadaanan ng minurya.
[1:55:40] At hindi po dapat sana na kaming mga tayo pa dito ang nagdidiin sa mga kasama ninyo.
[1:55:49] Bahay natin to eh.
[1:55:53] Ipinaliliwanag lang po namin na huwag naman sana kaming parang ipag tinagtutulakan nyo pa na kami na desisyonan na ng korte.
[1:56:04] Na kami ay mga convicted na.
[1:56:07] Sana'y naman ako maging convicted.
[1:56:10] Pero huwag naman ganyan.
[1:56:11] Kayong mga kasama namin, ang una namin hiniling sa inyo na sana ang pinag-usapan natin dito, yung rules natin.
[1:56:17] Pinayagan natin silang lumabas at nakiusap tayo sa Sandigang Bayan.
[1:56:23] At yun naman ang sinabi ni Chief Justice Puno na pwede naman tayong makiusap sa Sandigang Bayan.
[1:56:29] Na pinayagan sana silang pumunta rito at makisama at makiusap.
[1:56:33] Naiintindihan po namin ang punto po ninyo.
[1:56:37] Kayo yung mga kasama namin, inirispeto namin kayo, ay intindihin din niyo po ang kalagayan namin.
[1:56:42] Bilang kayo ay mga kasama namin dito, tayo naman po yung nagumpisang magkakaibig at magkakasama, pare-parehas tayo na numpa dito.
[1:56:51] Huwag nyo naman kaming idein.
[1:56:54] Ang hearing ko sa biyernes na.
[1:56:56] Di ko alam kung ano pa susunod.
[1:56:58] Baka mamiss ko na kayo.
[1:56:59] Maraming salamat po.
[1:57:00] With the permission of the Senator Judges, again as the Chair earlier stated, yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Mark Villar?
[1:57:13] Yes, I'd just like to make a manifestation.
[1:57:16] The gentleman may proceed with this manifestation.
[1:57:19] Thank you.
[1:57:21] In defense of what my sister said earlier, I think we have to keep in mind the effects of the words that we use in this trial.
[1:57:30] Many of our colleagues, for one reason or another, are unavailable.
[1:57:37] Some have cases.
[1:57:38] And through no fault of their own, of course.
[1:57:42] But I think it's important the words that we use in respect to our colleagues who are not guilty yet.
[1:57:46] I think that's a very good point.
[1:57:48] They're not guilty.
[1:57:50] And when we use these words in public, kahit paano may effect din sa ati mga colleagues.
[1:57:54] So I think my sister is correct in saying that we should be considerate of our colleagues.
[1:57:59] And I respect that.
[1:58:01] And I think I just wanted to make that point as well, that there are colleagues here who are, for one reason or another, who are not here.
[1:58:08] But we can speak for them, us in the minority.
[1:58:11] So we want to stand up for them.
[1:58:13] And I think it's well within, I think it's very reasonable for us to give them that courtesy that we refrain.
[1:58:22] Refrain from saying things that can have an adverse effect on them.
[1:58:26] So that's all, Mr. President.
[1:58:28] I just like to make that point.
[1:58:29] And I think that we really have to always remember, refrain from saying things that can have an adverse effect on them.
[1:58:40] So that's all, Mr. President.
[1:58:42] I just like to make that point.
[1:58:43] And I think that we really have to always remember that the words that we use also here, especially to our colleagues, do have an effect.
[1:58:52] And that's something that we should always keep in mind.
[1:58:54] So thank you very much.
[1:58:55] The manifestation, as Julie noted, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Soto?
[1:58:59] Well, I really want to avoid these furious statements at this point, Mr. President.
[1:59:04] That's why I called for the previous question.
[1:59:07] And the previous question was a motion by Senator Tulpo that I amended.
[1:59:12] And the amendment is that we retain the two-thirds of those who may vote.
[1:59:17] Questioning nila, kung gusto nila.
[1:59:18] With the permission of Senator Judge Soto, we take that in the meantime under advisement.
[1:59:27] Senator Judge Pia is recognized.
[1:59:30] Kayatano.
[1:59:30] Thank you, Mr. President.
[1:59:40] I have quite a few things, no?
[1:59:42] But in reverse order, the former Senate President, who he knows I have so much respect for him, the only issue that we would be facing if we consider the amended question that His Honor, Senator Judge Soto, presented to us is it would be revising the words of the Constitution.
[2:00:07] It would now be two-thirds of those who can vote, two-thirds of those who are present.
[2:00:13] And if we look at the history of the Constitution, our Constitution, it has been mentioned many times, but just to put context, the history of our Constitution, the 1987 Constitution, is fairly identical on this particular provision on the 1972 Constitution.
[2:00:29] And also the same as the 1935 Constitution, except for the three-fourths vote, and it refers to all senators.
[2:00:38] Now, those constitutions, the 1935 in particular, was based on the U.S. Constitution that refers to two-thirds of those present.
[2:00:46] And we did not choose to adopt that.
[2:00:48] Again, I'm not the first to mention this.
[2:00:49] This was mentioned by one of the Amici Curi, and it was also mentioned here.
[2:00:56] But that is what is going to happen.
[2:00:58] Again, we are changing the word being.
[2:01:00] And I go back.
[2:01:02] This was going to be part of my final statement before we have to vote, is that do we have the right to make that vote?
[2:01:12] Do we have that authority?
[2:01:15] Because when it comes to justiciable questions, that belongs to the Supreme Court.
[2:01:20] I will save my longer explanation on that later on.
[2:01:23] But what I do want to mention, because this now is in connection with some statements made by the parties, in particular, and I respect both of you.
[2:01:35] You are both very good lawyers.
[2:01:36] Thank you for the time that you have taken.
[2:01:38] The prosecution through prosecutor, congressman, prosecutor, Chell Jokno, mentioned that he does not recall that any of the Amici Curi mentioned the word mistrial.
[2:01:52] I don't recall either.
[2:01:54] We are alike in that recollection.
[2:01:58] But I do have my personal notes, and then I ask my staff to check, and anyone is willing, anyone can verify that.
[2:02:05] I had asked former Chief Justice Puno if my understanding of his statement was accurate, and I posted, and I will do it again now, that the two situations when the Supreme Court may review the decisions made by the impeachment court.
[2:02:27] And the first case is when the impeachment court denies a senator judge's right to participate, and the second one is when the respondent is denied a fair trial, therefore denied a due process.
[2:02:49] I asked Chief Justice Puno if tama yung narinig ko, and he said yes, and both parties may give their own opinion, or we can refer to the stenographic notes.
[2:03:01] And then after that, he even said that this is reviewable by the Supreme Court and can result in the nullity of the case.
[2:03:09] So he may not have used the word mistrial, but he used the word nullity.
[2:03:13] And then I have no right naman to question the presiding officer unless I disagree with his opinion, but he's more than willing to clarify, because I have long submitted to the reality that our memories are not perfect.
[2:03:32] So I'm always willing to be corrected if I remember incorrectly.
[2:03:36] The way I understood the presiding officer's statement is,
[2:03:40] And it's the same thing that Senator Judge Alan Cayetano was saying, and I agree, my prayer is that the evidence is so convincingly one way or the other,
[2:04:00] para we can move on, para we're not left in the sea of doubt, drowning, trying to breathe, you know, we need to be able to move on.
[2:04:09] What's my point?
[2:04:09] My point, Mr. Presiding Officer, is that I agree with you that we want to put finality here,
[2:04:17] but I may not agree with some views that this cannot be justiciable, because we may disagree with the Amici Curie.
[2:04:30] No one says that we are bound by all their statements.
[2:04:33] In fact, they had somewhat conflicting statement in as much as I tried to reconcile.
[2:04:38] So I don't need an answer, but if we may allow the parties to answer if they would like to answer.
[2:04:45] Thank you.
[2:04:45] If they would like to, who would...
[2:04:49] Your Honours, I'll begin.
[2:04:54] Briefly, sir.
[2:04:55] Yes, Your Honours. I think it's justiciable.
[2:04:58] But basically, I'm looking at Article 8, Section 1, which is the expanded certiorari jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
[2:05:06] So basically, Your Honours, wala naman kasi talaga tayong word na mistrial sa Philippine jurisdiction, hindi ba?
[2:05:11] But that will can be brought up upon grave abuse of discretion.
[2:05:14] Yun lang naman po yun talagang punto dun.
[2:05:17] So as far as political questions are concerned, obviously, that is not reviewable by the Supreme Court.
[2:05:23] Pero kung meron mang naging grave abuse of discretion, then definitely it is reviewable by the Supreme Court, Your Honours.
[2:05:29] Honourable Jokno, briefly.
[2:05:33] Thank you, Your Honour.
[2:05:34] I think two rules are very clear.
[2:05:37] First, that the Supreme Court cannot give advisory opinions.
[2:05:40] And second, that it has no jurisdiction over declaratory relief.
[2:05:44] And our position is that if this question were to be brought up to the court now, it is not yet ripe for determination because there's been no vote yet.
[2:05:56] There's yet no aggrieved party and no injury.
[2:05:59] Therefore, we respectfully submit that it is not justiciable at this time.
[2:06:04] Thank you, Honourable Jokno.
[2:06:10] Senator Judge Alan Gaitano is organized.
[2:06:12] Mr. President, let me be totally honest.
[2:06:24] And I'll talk about myself, but I think some of our colleagues feel the same way.
[2:06:28] If we're going to vote on this issue, we're not going to participate.
[2:06:31] Because we don't think it's a matter that we can vote on.
[2:06:35] You don't taste poison.
[2:06:37] You don't vote on what's right or wrong.
[2:06:42] So we don't think it's a matter of interpretation.
[2:06:46] So I do very much see the point of Senator Soto to call the previous motion.
[2:06:52] So I'd like to ask you to clarify the procedure because the judicial procedure and rules of the Senate are now.
[2:07:01] Are we decided to vote on it?
[2:07:05] Then we will just not participate.
[2:07:07] Or can we appeal first and see if a majority do not want to vote on it?
[2:07:12] What is the better procedure, Mr. Presiding Officer?
[2:07:15] And again, we won't argue to death because we've argued this pretty much.
[2:07:21] And I think everyone has their idea.
[2:07:22] But if we're going to proceed, I do not want to be a part of it.
[2:07:26] But I will continue to respect our colleagues and the integrity of this court.
[2:07:31] The chair took the manifestation and amendment to the motion of Senator Judge Soto in advisement at this point in time.
[2:07:38] Because prior to the vote on Senator Judge Irwin Tulfo's appeal,
[2:07:42] the chair will explain exactly what we are voting for and what an I and a nay vote would mean.
[2:07:49] So the ruling is there will be a vote?
[2:07:52] There will be a vote today as agreed earlier in the advisory issued by the court.
[2:07:59] And no one is appealing the ruling of the presiding officer that there will be a vote?
[2:08:06] I think the more appropriate procedure, your honor, would be, if at all, if the chair may suggest procedurally,
[2:08:15] to raise a point of order as to the, if I get the point of your honor correctly,
[2:08:23] as to the presence or absence of the power of the impeachment court to act on this matter
[2:08:32] in regard to interpreting Article 11, Section 36.
[2:08:36] So with all due respect to our colleagues, just so that, you know, we can decide and there will be no delay
[2:08:42] and then all the arguments have been laid out.
[2:08:45] So for all the arguments that have been said that this is a motion for the consideration,
[2:08:50] that this has been settled long ago, I mean, the records will bear out the different reasons.
[2:08:56] I raised a point of order, as stated by the presiding officer.
[2:09:05] Questioning the Senate sitting as an impeachment court's power to interpret or to reopen this issue.
[2:09:13] To address this issue in the impeachment court, because I believe the position of his honor should be in the court.
[2:09:22] I will rephrase.
[2:09:23] So we are raising a point of order of the power of the impeachment court to raise this issue at this time.
[2:09:31] Both with respect to the power and the timing.
[2:09:33] Yes.
[2:09:36] In response to the point of order, if I may, for the record, your honor,
[2:09:43] any objection with respect to the court's authority to interpret Article 11, Section 36,
[2:09:50] must also operate, as stated earlier, in pari-passu,
[2:09:55] meaning to say the July 6 ruling itself of the court, which the Honorable Cayetano clarified to,
[2:10:02] is an interpretation of the phrase, all members of the Senate.
[2:10:08] That authority cannot be recognized when it supports one interpretation,
[2:10:13] and then denied when the same provision is on appeal.
[2:10:17] The question may concern the correctness of the interpretation,
[2:10:20] but not, to my mind, the court's authority to make it.
[2:10:24] Whatever interpretative authority supported the July 6 ruling must apply with equal force
[2:10:30] to the resolution of the present appeal.
[2:10:34] This finds support in the Manila Prince Hotel case,
[2:10:39] GR No. 122156,
[2:10:42] that says the impeachment court is not precluded
[2:10:44] from resolving procedural and other issues at the outset.
[2:10:49] In fact, even the Duterte VHOR ruled that the Senate can decide with respect to how to interpret
[2:11:02] and implement the word fortwith,
[2:11:04] and in fact found no grave abuse of discretion at that time.
[2:11:09] Accordingly, with due respect to the distinguished Senator Alan Cayetano,
[2:11:17] the court regrets that the point of order of the good gentleman is not well taken.
[2:11:24] Thank you for that, Mr. President,
[2:11:26] and a one-minute explanation before I make an appeal.
[2:11:29] It is very obvious that we do have to make an interpretation
[2:11:34] because at the end of the trial, we have to vote,
[2:11:40] and depending on the number of the votes,
[2:11:42] the presiding officer has to say whether the person is found guilty or innocent.
[2:11:47] So that's obvious.
[2:11:48] What we're questioning is that if you look at the history of the impeachment court,
[2:11:53] we've always considered all members all,
[2:11:56] and it's only when they're removed, they're resigned, or they're dead
[2:11:58] before we lower the threshold.
[2:12:01] And that is why on the first day, we questioned.
[2:12:04] That's why in the first day, in a sense,
[2:12:08] naunahan nyo kami, Mr. President Officer,
[2:12:10] because that was your also political sense and the wisdom given to you to make that clear
[2:12:16] because there were so many rumors
[2:12:17] because we just came from a tumultuous change of leadership,
[2:12:22] and we were arguing about the numbers, which is also in the Constitution.
[2:12:27] So when we got to where we were on July 6, when we were beginning,
[2:12:32] we wanted to assure ourselves that this will be a court
[2:12:36] that will accord all fairness to everyone,
[2:12:39] and that our vote will be counted.
[2:12:42] On a side note, that's why the whole team,
[2:12:47] hindi lang umubra lahat,
[2:12:48] nagpatubo ng balbas,
[2:12:49] because quietly, at least malaman nyo ngayon,
[2:12:53] this is a symbol, don't shave our votes.
[2:12:55] And when you made that ruling on the July 6,
[2:12:58] we almost all shave.
[2:12:59] Buti na lang hindi pa kami mag-shave
[2:13:01] because we feel if you make that ruling today,
[2:13:04] you make that vote today,
[2:13:05] there will actually be vote shaving.
[2:13:08] Again, I said a while ago,
[2:13:10] and I'll stick to that,
[2:13:11] tapos na lahat ng arguments,
[2:13:13] we do have to decide.
[2:13:15] So I moved that,
[2:13:16] I appealed the decision of the presiding officer,
[2:13:20] and I'd like to see who are for and against,
[2:13:24] saying that this is out of order.
[2:13:28] There is a,
[2:13:30] yes, Senator Judge Pangliden.
[2:13:32] Yes, Mr. President,
[2:13:33] just a procedural matter.
[2:13:35] There was a appeal to the ruling of the chair,
[2:13:39] and that being the case,
[2:13:42] under our rules,
[2:13:43] we will have to vote
[2:13:43] on the appeal,
[2:13:46] whether we will agree with the appeal
[2:13:48] or support the appeal or not,
[2:13:51] for the record, Mr. President.
[2:13:52] Yes, that's correct, Mr. President.
[2:13:53] Sir President,
[2:13:54] Senator Pia would like to be recognized.
[2:13:58] Senator Judge Pia is recognized.
[2:14:01] It's actually just a clarification
[2:14:06] I'd like to seek,
[2:14:07] Mr. Presiding Officer.
[2:14:09] And I quote, no?
[2:14:10] So please,
[2:14:12] I'm happy to be corrected
[2:14:13] if mali yung notes,
[2:14:15] well, hindi na to notes.
[2:14:15] This is a quotation
[2:14:16] that I ask my staff to give me.
[2:14:20] This is from the ruling of his honor
[2:14:22] on July 26.
[2:14:25] After stating the constitutional provision
[2:14:27] on two-thirds of all members of the Senate,
[2:14:30] the presiding officer went on to say,
[2:14:32] this is the prevailing law today,
[2:14:34] and whether we agree with it or not,
[2:14:36] we must abide by it.
[2:14:38] However, those who disagree
[2:14:39] are not without recourse
[2:14:40] because this is without prejudice
[2:14:42] to the right of any party
[2:14:43] who holds a different view
[2:14:45] to seek judicial relief.
[2:14:46] And should the Supreme Court,
[2:14:48] which possesses the sole authority
[2:14:49] to interpret the Constitution
[2:14:51] by virtue of its power
[2:14:52] of judicial review,
[2:14:54] render a different ruling
[2:14:55] on this question,
[2:14:56] other than what the chair has stated,
[2:14:57] this court and this representation
[2:14:59] shall faithfully abide
[2:15:00] by that ruling of the Supreme Court.
[2:15:02] So may I just ask clarity
[2:15:04] from his honor,
[2:15:05] the presiding officer,
[2:15:07] if the reconsideration now
[2:15:10] is a digression
[2:15:10] from his earlier statement
[2:15:12] on July 6.
[2:15:13] A regression?
[2:15:16] A digression.
[2:15:17] Well, a change.
[2:15:20] Should the appeal
[2:15:21] of Senator Irwin Tulfo be won,
[2:15:25] then the ruling of the court
[2:15:27] will be changed.
[2:15:28] If it is lost,
[2:15:29] then the ruling of the court
[2:15:31] as verbalized
[2:15:33] by the presiding officer
[2:15:34] on July 6
[2:15:35] shall be maintained.
[2:15:36] Following our...
[2:15:37] I think it's not...
[2:15:42] I'm not sure if it's in the rules,
[2:15:43] no,
[2:15:43] but our practice
[2:15:44] that if there's any person,
[2:15:47] any member of the impeachment court
[2:15:50] that questions the ruling
[2:15:52] of the presiding officer,
[2:15:53] they may raise it.
[2:15:54] That's what we're calling it.
[2:15:55] Who voted in favor
[2:15:55] of the majority.
[2:15:56] That would be correct.
[2:15:57] And then does it follow
[2:16:00] that whatever that decision is
[2:16:03] consistent with,
[2:16:04] still consistent
[2:16:05] with the July 6 ruling,
[2:16:09] that party,
[2:16:09] whoever is not satisfied
[2:16:11] with that ruling
[2:16:11] can go to the Supreme Court?
[2:16:13] Is that the position
[2:16:14] of the presiding officer?
[2:16:15] That is the position
[2:16:16] of the presiding officer,
[2:16:17] yes.
[2:16:18] I agree with Attorney Pooh
[2:16:19] that it is a justiciable
[2:16:21] controversy,
[2:16:22] even from July 6
[2:16:24] up to if at all
[2:16:26] whatever decision
[2:16:27] we will be making today.
[2:16:29] Okay.
[2:16:29] Whichever way it goes.
[2:16:31] Thank you.
[2:16:32] And I'd just like to end
[2:16:33] with a statement
[2:16:35] that it is our position,
[2:16:37] well, at least
[2:16:38] I can only speak for myself,
[2:16:39] no,
[2:16:39] but if there are members
[2:16:41] who have the same view,
[2:16:43] then feel free
[2:16:44] to adopt my position.
[2:16:46] It is our belief
[2:16:47] that only the Supreme Court
[2:16:49] can interpret the Constitution
[2:16:51] except na po yung literal meaning,
[2:16:53] yung ordinary meaning
[2:16:54] na pinaliwanag ko na kanina.
[2:16:56] And so if the impeachment
[2:16:59] court's decision
[2:17:00] is to interpret this
[2:17:03] in a different way,
[2:17:04] and clearly,
[2:17:05] dear colleagues,
[2:17:05] this is an interpretation
[2:17:06] because even the Amici Curie
[2:17:09] would have different
[2:17:10] explanations
[2:17:12] on how all members
[2:17:15] would be interpreted.
[2:17:17] Yung bang kasama ba dun
[2:17:19] yung detained?
[2:17:20] I mean,
[2:17:21] I have a whole list here
[2:17:21] and I can read it
[2:17:22] but di ko nagagawin
[2:17:23] kasi it's on record
[2:17:24] naman po.
[2:17:25] Sino yung may exclude dito
[2:17:27] yung dead,
[2:17:28] permanent disability,
[2:17:29] ang dami hong explanations.
[2:17:31] So kaya po ang position ko
[2:17:33] is this is for the Supreme Court.
[2:17:35] This is not within the authority
[2:17:37] of the impeachment court.
[2:17:39] And so if this body
[2:17:42] will decide to proceed
[2:17:43] with an interpretation,
[2:17:45] then I will no longer be able
[2:17:47] to participate
[2:17:48] in that decision.
[2:17:49] To be clear lang,
[2:17:51] in that decision,
[2:17:51] as of now,
[2:17:52] yun lang naman po
[2:17:53] ang aking position on this.
[2:17:55] Thank you.
[2:17:56] Mr. President,
[2:17:58] Officer.
[2:17:59] Yes, Senator Judge Soto.
[2:18:00] Yes, partly I concur
[2:18:02] with what Senator Pia Cayetano
[2:18:03] was saying.
[2:18:04] And as a matter of fact,
[2:18:07] if the court decides
[2:18:10] to approve
[2:18:12] the motion
[2:18:15] of Senator Tulfo,
[2:18:16] which I proposed
[2:18:17] to be amended,
[2:18:21] and it is carried,
[2:18:23] then it becomes
[2:18:24] justiciable.
[2:18:25] That's the time
[2:18:26] that they can bring it up
[2:18:27] to the Supreme Court.
[2:18:28] If we do not act now,
[2:18:29] nobody can bring it
[2:18:30] to the Supreme Court.
[2:18:31] It's actually
[2:18:35] a good move
[2:18:36] so that once and for all,
[2:18:38] somebody will bring it up
[2:18:40] to the Supreme Court
[2:18:41] if the motion
[2:18:44] is approved.
[2:18:47] Thank you, sir.
[2:18:48] Anyway, procedurally,
[2:18:49] the chair made a ruling
[2:18:51] in relation
[2:18:52] to the point of order
[2:18:55] of Senator Judge
[2:18:56] Alan Cayetano,
[2:18:58] which was appealed
[2:18:59] by the good gentleman
[2:19:00] from Taguig,
[2:19:02] as pointed out
[2:19:03] by Senator Judge
[2:19:04] Francis Pangilinan.
[2:19:06] We now proceed
[2:19:07] to a vote
[2:19:07] and divide the House.
[2:19:09] Before we proceed
[2:19:10] to the vote,
[2:19:11] an A or yes vote
[2:19:13] is in favor
[2:19:14] of the appeal
[2:19:15] of Senator Judge
[2:19:16] Alan Cayetano.
[2:19:18] An A or negative vote