About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Candace Owens vs Andrew Wilson: The Great Debate. from Candace Owens, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 41,385 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"are we live okay so we're officially live uh candace andrew you know good to sit down here with you talking to you guys about uh the conversation that i think started with you being on joe rogan when you said hey i'm offering three hundred thousand dollars and for the audience watching this you..."
[0:00] are we live okay so we're officially live uh candace andrew you know good to sit down here
[0:09] with you talking to you guys about uh the conversation that i think started with you
[0:13] being on joe rogan when you said hey i'm offering three hundred thousand dollars and for the
[0:17] audience watching this you have to know when you see this final product there's a lot of stuff that
[0:21] happens behind closed doors there was still communication till midnight even some of the
[0:25] stuff this morning like it's like you're trying to sell a company it's the last 24 hours that the
[0:29] deal doesn't work out but kudos to the both of you guys that you made it work uh the topic of
[0:34] discussion today how this got prompted is andrew you said there's overwhelming evidence that tyler
[0:40] robinson shot and killed charlie kirk and candace your position was he's a patsy tyler robinson is
[0:47] a patsy so of course we'll talk about a lot of different things but that's kind of how the
[0:50] whole thing got started for the audience watching i think this is uh truly for three different
[0:55] people number one is anybody out there that loves charlie respects charlie his legacy what he did
[1:01] we have a lot of love and admiration for what he did he changed the lives of many people
[1:05] uh uh young men young women you worked with him for many years you guys were friends you've said
[1:10] a lot of good things about charlie respectful towards him you guys may have disagreed on
[1:13] some things but yeah a lot of respect for him the second audience is um the folks out there you
[1:19] that's watching this and so for you you've been wanting something like this to take take place and
[1:24] kudos for andrew for coming out and saying hey i want to have this conversation and for candace to
[1:28] accept it uh so you you have the ability to say i agree i disagree comment to all the stuff that
[1:34] you're doing online and if you want to see more of these things any of the three channels subscribe
[1:39] to the candace show the crucible i'm sure some of the people from crucible are watching as well and
[1:43] the pbd podcast the more you subscribe to this the more we're able to deliver these types of
[1:48] conversations to you and last but not least it's about the two of you my goal is to speak as little as
[1:53] possible 99 of the time it'll be you guys speaking and the audience will be able to see it if i jump
[1:58] in just so everybody knows on the back end both have agreed in the back there's three people
[2:04] representing andrew and three people representing candace to do fact checking so at any point if
[2:10] somebody makes a claim the other can say can we fact check this i can jump in and say fact check this
[2:14] even the folks in the back can say fact check this so it is a very fair conversation that we're having
[2:19] here and so with that being said um kudos to michael knowles your name was mentioned a lot you missed
[2:25] out right now the last 10 minutes we talked about you there's a lot of love and respect here mutually
[2:29] from both parties all three of them here and then of course the great joe rogan that started this
[2:34] conversation and he also volunteered but it ended up being uh this format that we have here today so with
[2:39] that being said andrew your claim is overwhelming evidence that tyler robinson killed charlie kirk
[2:48] opening statements opening comments sure and what i mean by overwhelming is i just find it very
[2:53] convincing that's i think that's what most people mean when they say overwhelming evidence
[2:58] so i have a brief opening statement on september 10th 2025 charlie kirk was murdered many of you
[3:05] already know a lot about the events which occurred after kirk's death you remember the ghoulish laughter
[3:10] celebrations and madness we saw from leftists all over from tick tock invasions debates posts on social
[3:15] media destruction of memorials and things like this within weeks of kirk's death a cottage industry
[3:23] began to form peddling various alternative theories on how he died what special interest may have killed
[3:29] him what nations were involved and was our own government one of them because this was the first
[3:36] nationwide traumatic event in gen z's lifetime the demand for answers was severe and palpable the leading
[3:44] theory from the conspiracy verse is that israel worked with the united states government to murder
[3:50] charlie kirk within a day or two of kirk's death ian carroll claimed that israel killed charlie kirk
[3:56] and the conspiracy caught on like wildfire this theory was built on one misleading piece of evidence
[4:02] that in his final days on around september 8th charlie sent a text message reading jewish donors
[4:08] play into all the stereotypes i cannot and will not be bullied like this leaving me no choice but to
[4:14] leave the pro-israel cause this was sent in the context of a platforming dispute regarding tucker
[4:19] carlson from this scintilla of misleading information it was speculated that israel killed charlie kirk
[4:25] because he would have successfully opposed the iranian war now that's a fun theory and who doesn't
[4:31] like a good fun conspiracy theory i like them but there is no evidence that israel actually killed charlie
[4:36] kirk and if candace has some i'd like her to actually show it to me i'm open to suggestions
[4:42] but to date there hasn't been any there is however tons of evidence that a leftist killed charlie
[4:47] kirk just as charlie feared they would i believe charlie kirk and i have the receipts no i didn't
[4:54] have a dream where he came to me and told me that the left killed him uh no he didn't come to me a
[4:59] dream and say candace owens betrayed him that never happened in fact i don't need dreams of any kind
[5:06] because i hold my possession never before seen messages from charlie kirk to his security team on
[5:10] september 9th 2025 i'm going to share the message with you today which is the first time this information
[5:17] has ever been publicly revealed on september 9th charlie's security team wrote to him yes law
[5:22] enforcement has been fully supportive and agreed to a security plan and posture tomorrow's event will
[5:28] be covered by both my team and the campus pd if additional support is required patrol units will
[5:33] be available i have 11 on site charlie responded with this okay great remind them that they are there
[5:40] for one person's security only because i'm somewhat worried the left is trying to kill me that was a
[5:49] message sent september 9th whatever could he have meant by that well i think he meant exactly what he
[5:58] said that he was worried the left was going to try to kill him now we'll discuss this more later on in
[6:04] the debate and maybe i have more never before seen evidence that exposes just how wrong and in my opinion
[6:10] idiotic many of these conspiracy theories have been but that's what happens when you rely on what's
[6:17] called the evidence of the gaps in other words they don't have evidence they seem to just make up
[6:22] evidence and what did they make up well in my opinion kind of whatever lined the pockets
[6:28] and i think it's ghoulish to profit off of the death of a good man but we came here today to debate
[6:36] and so let's get to it the debate topic today is one my belief that there's overwhelming evidence
[6:40] that tyler robinson killed charlie kirk and two candace's belief that there's overwhelming evidence
[6:45] that tyler robinson was a patsy and didn't kill charlie kirk in some the audience is going to
[6:50] decide who has more evidence supporting their theory my theory is that the state is correct
[6:54] that tyler robinson is the killer at least based on evidence so far in candace's theory that tyler
[6:58] robinson is not the killer and he's a patsy set up by the feds to be clear this is not a question
[7:03] of reasonable doubt if it was reasonable doubt and that's all it was and that's all candace was
[7:09] proffering i wouldn't even be here having the debate with her it's fair to have doubts as a
[7:14] trial has yet to occur and the state hasn't even begun to try to prove their case beyond a reasonable
[7:18] doubt but candace makes a more forceful claim she claims that there's more evidence that tyler is not
[7:25] guilty of murder and was set up as a patsy than there is for the state's case and i just think that
[7:31] that's absurd and she will not be able to demonstrate that in any way in fact she has almost
[7:36] no real evidence at all of her theory whereas my theory is supported by compelling witness testimony
[7:40] physical evidence multiple confessions all of which are independently compelling but which are
[7:46] even more convincing as each piece of evidence corroborates the others you'll notice the term
[7:50] overwhelming was included in both theories this is because candace demanded i defend my use of that
[7:56] term which i think is fair in describing the evidence against tyler robinson she on the other
[8:01] hand only wanted to defend her theory as merely viable that is until i showed her her clips in which
[8:06] she said she believed the evidence of her theory that tyler robinson's and patsy was supported by
[8:11] overwhelming evidence only then did she agree to defend that position regardless we're both
[8:16] defending the claim there's overwhelming evidence on our side so it's worth defining that term when i
[8:21] say the evidence against robinson's overwhelming all i'm saying is that i mean that as of right now
[8:27] i find it very convincing i see almost no evidence at all only speculation on verified claims and suggestions
[8:33] of things that could merely be hypothetically possible dreams vibes feelings things like this
[8:39] almost done by the way i have no problem defending the state's case and welcome candace bringing up
[8:43] any challenges she would like but if i'm honest the reason i was willing to pay the 300 000 was this
[8:48] for this debate was to finally have a chance for someone to demand candace be held accountable for
[8:53] the unbelievable theories and claims she's been making candace's investigation is indistinguishable
[8:59] from a leftist operation she couldn't be doing more damage to the right if she were trying she
[9:04] uses her considerable platform to relentlessly attack one of the most influential conservative
[9:08] outreach organizations for young people and she's making a mockery of the online right-wing commentary
[9:13] class she's harming republicans in an election year by dividing them she's attacking the very
[9:18] organization charlie spent his life building and she's attacking the people he loved including his wife
[9:23] and it cost me three hundred thousand dollars but today i hope that she finally answers for some of that
[9:29] thank you andrew candace did you get it out of your system i did okay great well i'm not gonna
[9:34] waste time with the preamble because i think i just want to get to the substance of the debate and i
[9:38] will just speak to the audience i have obviously had an audience since we've been covering this case
[9:44] people know that there was a personal friendship between me and charlie and diminishing the pursuit of
[9:52] something that makes sense regarding what happened on september 10th by throwing it to this is just
[9:57] people who are conspiracy theorists these are people who are just trying to generate clicks
[10:02] i i don't think that people should be satisfied by that i want people to remember that it's important
[10:07] to think we've been lied to by the government a great many times um over i mean just the last couple
[10:12] of years if you just think of the things that we've learned about our government um and i do want
[10:16] to say this what's been the most disturbing element i think for everyone is that not only does the
[10:23] narrative not make any sense which i'm going to demonstrate i need to waste time with the preamble going
[10:26] through the points or trying to insult you or pretending that i've been running a podcast saying
[10:30] it's just dreams and vibes like i miss cleo and that's the reason why it's taking so many
[10:35] influencers it looks like a billion dollar industry of influencers um to dispute everything candace
[10:40] says it's not because i'm on my platform saying i had a dream last night i don't think that that i
[10:45] think that diminishes you as an argument obviously we have presented a lot of evidence you just
[10:50] presented a text message and said this is evidence well that's how this entire thing began uh you're
[10:54] talking about how israel got into the conversation it was because immediately after charlie died
[10:59] one of the first things we saw was this push to make us all think and remember how much he loved
[11:04] israel it's because the prime minister of israel who's fighting like a 27 front war felt that he
[11:10] needed to come do a little mini tour and to be strangely to to state that i did not kill charlie
[11:16] kirk when nobody um was having that thought that i can remember nobody was going i wonder phoebe netanyahu
[11:22] killed charlie kirk and then we had a round of influencers who lied and said charlie was not
[11:30] changing on israel that he wasn't having any disagreements regarding that topic that the day
[11:35] he died he just loved israel so much and i demonstrated via the text message which you just
[11:40] mentioned uh and you're now contextualizing and pretending it was just about tucker carlson which is
[11:45] is not true it was a part of a broader shift that charlie was having over the last i would say actually
[11:51] on your show it began um since october 7th which is when i began asking myself more questions about
[11:57] israel as well and so yeah when all of these things happen the immediate aftermath and then i drop a
[12:03] text message after everyone is denying that tucker carlson then comes out and confirms the conversations
[12:07] that he had with charlie megan kelly then comes out and confirms the private conversations that she had
[12:12] with charlie people then begin to ask a reasonable question which is why are we lying about this
[12:18] if they were forthcoming with that and they had said hey yeah charlie was starting to ask questions i
[12:25] think after october 7th it's reasonable that people are starting to re-examine our relationship
[12:30] uh with israel we wouldn't be here today but it has been lie after lie after lie debunk after debunk after
[12:38] debunk yes i did share that i had a dream that charlie was betrayed it's not a dream anymore it's a
[12:43] reality i look at what the organization has become the people that they are partnering with the lies
[12:48] that they are telling uh the extraordinary people that they're sending out to say that i never i
[12:52] hadn't speak to charlie since 2018 and it begins to look like a conspiracy and just as a historical
[12:58] fact that entire term was created by the cia to gaslight people after the assassination of jfk
[13:04] so it's not exactly one uh that makes me nervous like calling somebody a conspiracy theorist is
[13:09] essentially saying that they demand further answers they're not accepting the fed slop so
[13:14] um i'm grateful that you came today i don't need to like i said take cheap shots and discuss your
[13:20] manner of debate or your strategy and i'm also grateful that you shared that you have that text
[13:24] message today because everybody watching knows that i i have been demanding not a debate just a
[13:30] open conversation with turning point usa they should be here it shouldn't be you in that chair it
[13:34] should be the person that took charlie's place maybe erica kirk maybe andrew cole that he's a
[13:37] spokesperson and rather than doing that they send us another influencer so let's see how it goes
[13:44] just out of curiosity are you between zero to 100 what is the likelihood that you think tyler
[13:49] robinson shot charlie kirk and killed him based on the evidence right now um i don't know i'd say 75
[13:55] 85 percent candace zero percent zero percent i'm at zero so with what we've seen in terms of the evidence
[14:02] i'm at zero percent so not not only you know that maybe somebody was behind them as a patsy
[14:08] influencing him you're not even saying that he didn't even shoot charlie kirk right i would if
[14:11] you said was he involved that day as i have consistently said on my platform i would say yes
[14:16] he was i i don't know what role he played but as the shooter zero percent do you have any evidence for
[14:21] it uh for what my percentage that he didn't he didn't shoot and kill charlie kirk yes which i'm
[14:28] hoping we're going to get to all of the evidence that he feels that he has i mean i don't i'm not even
[14:33] convinced that charlie was shot from the rooftop on low c that day based on the evidence that has
[14:38] been do you think he was shot i i do not think that charlie was shot from a 30-06 from just shot
[14:46] at all i don't i don't know i i think that a projectile hit charlie and i'm open to other
[14:53] people's presentations but i have not seen any compelling evidence that charlie was shot by a 30-06
[14:59] can we see maybe if we're gonna have an olive branch to each other if maybe we can establish
[15:04] what we consider the facts of the case to be first yeah sure okay so you don't you you're not
[15:10] sure if he was actually shot you're open to alternative theories he was definitely hit with
[15:15] a projectile of some description if we're talking about was he shot from a gun a 30-06 i would say
[15:22] definitively no okay it defies it defies common sense to think that he had a superman neck and even
[15:28] if he did have a superman neck which has been demonstrated uh i think actually recently a
[15:33] youtuber actually set up spalhalla steel cages and shot it and it went through so under no
[15:39] circumstance while i so at least not a 30-06 definitively not a 30-06 150 feet but you're not
[15:46] necessarily closing off the avenue that he could have been shot at all with maybe a smaller smaller
[15:51] caliber okay and then um there's some things that i'm going to make concessions on that i do think we
[15:58] need more answers on and i'm fine with that and we can get to those things as well the other thing
[16:03] is in the timeline one of the things that we dispute i think on the timeline is that you think that
[16:10] uh robinson drove hours away to a steakhouse in the timeline is that correct yes okay and what's the
[16:17] compelling evidence that you think you have there i spoke to the owner of the restaurant um and i
[16:23] uh i've seen the receipt i know the conversation that i had and uh i think it's enough that you
[16:30] know it will be presented obviously if this goes to trial but yes i do believe that he was in pengwich
[16:36] which is near his grandparents home did he give you an unedited copy of that receipt i have seen an
[16:42] unedited copy a copy of that receipt it was not given to me from the owner but i want to before you
[16:46] we get into like all the timeline stuff i want to address what you think is evidence so we can keep
[16:50] this on par with what your claim is since well i think that that's a piece of evidence it's in
[16:54] dispute and that's why i'm yeah but we're trying to get to whether there's overwhelming evidence
[16:59] that tyler robinson did this yeah whether then starting with if you want to use the first part
[17:03] of that for the internal critique yeah like we should go over the actual evidence that we feel
[17:07] the first reason that i think and i think it's compelling evidence is that tyler robinson's rifle was
[17:13] found uh near the crime scene so i would consider that to be very good evidence and also the fact
[17:21] of the matter is is that i dispute this claim that a 30-06 could not have made this wound i think that
[17:26] that's absurd 150 grain remington core locks absolutely could shatter when it hits the neck
[17:33] of any human being when you say that there's some steel neck and it's a smaller caliber you have
[17:37] to make a counter explanation why wouldn't a smaller caliber also go through bone it could i didn't
[17:42] say it can't right exactly so if that's the case then ammunition is going to be the critical key
[17:48] here and if we have frangible ammunition which we do in this case a flex tip round well i'm sorry not
[17:54] a flex tip a soft point round from 150 grain remington core lock that's just a small jacket
[17:59] that goes around the actual lead piece these this thing could have split apart in air for all we know
[18:05] but definitely upon impact and we have the medical examiner who confirms this in a summary my team can
[18:10] bring that up the summarization which means he would have to be a part of some kind of conspiracy
[18:15] as well okay so just to start with your point about saying that the gun was found near him
[18:22] i mean uh near lowe's center or i guess off in the woods that gun did you watch the the testimony did
[18:29] you i'm sorry you watched your preliminary hearing it live okay so forgetting what the summary of the
[18:33] medical report was did you watch the testimony that was given by the uh caitlin oliver the atf woman
[18:40] samantha karner any of those people who went into the science of yes i recall you're talking about
[18:46] the bullet analysis yeah when they went into the dna okay so that's kind of the most relevant
[18:51] part okay i'm not denying i've never denied on my platform or anywhere else that a gun owned by tyler
[18:56] robinson was found near the crime scene right that doesn't that doesn't remove if you think somebody
[19:01] set up as a patsy i you could take a gun out of this room right now and you could walk out and
[19:06] planted in the woods near a crime scene that's not convincing evidence i concur i concur with the
[19:11] fact that that's a possibility so you are you i think have said on a platform that you were a
[19:16] gunsmith okay and for how many years many many years for many years you also said that you were
[19:22] an army sniper i wasn't a sniper in the army okay and i never said that sorry your wife tweeted that
[19:27] you were an army sniper yeah i don't know like 15 years ago she said something does it change 15 years
[19:32] later she said that it was colloquial so army sniper is a colloquial term yeah i'm not an i
[19:38] was never an army sniper okay um what did you do in the army did you teach this she then i corrected
[19:42] it and said you taught rifles in the army not no i didn't teach rifle no i taught rifles as a private
[19:48] citizen okay uh and i was an nra instructor for many many many years alongside my my gunshot as with
[19:56] your expertise when she uh gave testimony on the stand samantha carner that there was dust and there
[20:06] was debris that was found in the gun barrel yep uh and then when we had the person who and this was i
[20:15] believe caitlin oliver who explained painfully about the dna the prince well let's start with a
[20:23] i'm not done you you said something so i'm gonna finish my thought right you don't do a point in time
[20:26] no well sure if you want to respond to it but i want you to respond to two points i want i want
[20:31] you to start with two points okay dust and debris in the gun barrel yeah secondly the fact that there
[20:36] were five sets of prints five plus actually by the end of testimony five sets of prints uh for which
[20:42] we already had the woman who worked for the fbi forensics testify that above two prints if you're
[20:48] taking a sample it it's no longer a science right she testified that when they took the sample of what
[20:54] was on the trigger they saw five plus prints and among those five plus prints tyler robinson's was
[21:01] the most degraded so i would like you to explain how tyler robinson's prints could be the most degraded
[21:08] when she said actually you could have dna on something that you've touched you could have dna
[21:13] on something that you've never touched and to get dna degradation we've they've looked at pieces
[21:19] um uh items 20 40 years on that don't have degradation yet tyler robinson's prints amongst
[21:27] five plus other prints were the most degraded on that weapon yeah so let's get into all three of the
[21:32] claims first with debris when it comes to debris firing rifle doesn't always blow the debris out of
[21:37] the barrel okay that i i you think there could be degree uh i'm sorry debris and dust yeah he just fired
[21:46] the weapon okay not only that he left it in a forest now i don't know if if you agree with me but if you
[21:52] leave a rifle in a wooded area it's also possible that debris could get in that way but i'm not even
[21:58] sure that that's what the case is i think it's far more likely that you fired the shot it just didn't
[22:02] blow all the debris out and it often doesn't you'll find this if you if you take grandpappy's you know
[22:08] dirty rifle and it's all dusty inside the board and you go fire it you'll often look down the board
[22:13] there's still dust okay happens all the time okay and the prints yeah so the prints we don't know
[22:19] all of the details on just yet we do it was it was excruciatingly long we testimony we don't because
[22:25] they haven't gone to trial so we don't know uh on the print front but tyler robinson's dna was on
[22:30] there you made the claim that lance twig's dna was on there and it was not uh well when she gave the
[22:35] testimony no first let's go to your first point because that's wrong we can get a fact check on that
[22:39] what do you mean we don't know until it goes to trial about the degraded prints she testified and she
[22:43] this is the person who took them yes but the problem is is that inside of this particular
[22:47] testimony you agree with me that there's going to be much more of the dna analysis well right but you
[22:53] also would agree that her fact is not going to change that among the prints his was the most
[22:57] degraded so i'm asking you to address that how could that be possible let's give it um let's just
[23:01] grant this for a second as a possibility that his fingerprints were degraded it's not a possibility
[23:07] it's it's a fact the person who took it i'm just granting it for the sake of argument you should
[23:11] grant it because it's a fact that she presented so now so now it's granted so what what do you
[23:16] mean so what yeah so what what does that prove it proves that if his prints were the most degraded
[23:22] amongst five of them you're gonna have to explain how that's possible if he's the one that recently
[23:27] fired the weapon yeah so wait a second you're saying that it's an impossibility that if his fingerprints
[23:34] are the most degraded i'm telling you to explain it you're the you're the gunsmith well wait a second
[23:38] how would a gunsmith give an analysis on fingerprints or dna do you think that i work in a
[23:42] dna laboratory so your answer is i don't know you can just say you don't know you don't have to but i
[23:47] did but i did no you said so what yes i don't know i actually don't have an explanation for that
[23:53] well i think that what it would prove is that it is a more viable theory that people who had stronger
[23:59] prints on the gun may have used it more recently did they tell did they say who else had fingerprints on
[24:05] the gun they named matt robinson explicitly okay and then and this was a part of the testimony where
[24:11] she was speaking about how they got samples of um elimination samples from the home of amber
[24:17] robinson matt robinson and lance twig so those are the three names they named so are you saying that
[24:22] twigs would you like me to finish my statement i just want to make sure i'm clarifying i'm i'm i'm
[24:26] trying to finish the answer but it can't be clarified until the answer comes out of my mouth
[24:30] okay so go ahead this was a portion of her testimony where she was explaining how they got
[24:34] elimination samples from the home and she named matt robinson amber robinson and lance twigs as the
[24:40] elimination samples that she was using um and so she explicitly said she said some of them some so we
[24:46] can assume two out of the three uh were their prints were found on the gun she explicitly named matt
[24:53] robinson um as someone who had prints on the gun and then said there were five people that they had
[24:59] taken that sample from and again what's also relevant here is the earlier testimony which came
[25:07] from uh the fbi forensics analyst i believe it was on day two where she said that when you're using those
[25:13] mixtures and those samples and you get up to five plus it's really hard to make any sort of a
[25:19] determination so both of those things are relevant if you can't explain why his prints are the most
[25:25] degraded and you're saying he is the shooter it's not really a so what it's an open-ended question
[25:29] that people have a right to pursue it's not a conspiracy it's actually proof of my claim that
[25:34] there is evidence that he was set up as a patsy that wouldn't prove anything about him being a patsy
[25:39] it said it's evidence it to support the claim that he could have been set up okay as a passion
[25:44] this is why i said earlier so what because even if it's the case this doesn't have an explanation for
[25:50] it yet that doesn't actually give you any evidence in your corner for tyler robinson being a patsy
[25:54] okay hang on hang on i didn't cut you off right you would need to actually explain how this would
[25:59] demonstrate tyler robinson this is tied into to robinson being a patsy are you claiming that
[26:05] these fingerprints were lance twigs or that he had any dna there i i'm saying that it could be matt
[26:10] robinson it could be amber robinson that sort of information is going to come out during the trial
[26:14] how would that tie into the idea that he's a patch yes because if his is the most degraded prince and
[26:18] the information that i shared on my platform is true that this gun was given to tyler robinson as an
[26:23] heirloom i had conversation with members of the robinson family twigs family both of them you
[26:29] know like i said we're not just dreaming um and if we're having those conversations and they told me
[26:35] that that gun was only given to tyler robinson because it was a family heirloom okay so it was
[26:39] his grandfather's gun or great-grandfather's gun i don't remember the difference uh i don't remember
[26:43] which one it was and so he got it because he's the first born so but he's not much of a shooter is
[26:48] what i was told uh and so he has this because he inherited it essentially so if i get something
[26:54] from my grandpa and i put it up on the shelf and i own this you could see that could be how do we get
[26:58] to the patsy part if you don't let me ever get to the end of the sentence so how could we get to the
[27:02] patsy part okay patiently till we get so that could be a reasonable explanation as to why there was dust
[27:08] in the barrel because he doesn't often shoot this weapon and he is indeed a fisher um and it could also
[27:13] be a reasonable explanation for why we have matt robinson's prints on this obviously lance twigs
[27:19] even if he has prints on things they live together that doesn't really mean anything
[27:22] but that could demonstrate that somebody took his weapon and put it somewhere his prints are the most
[27:27] degraded somebody else's prints there there's more presence of somebody else's prints and that could
[27:32] demonstrate that somebody is taking items from his house and putting it into very but it also could
[27:36] demonstrate nothing so the problem the problem that you have here is that this is pure conjecture no this
[27:41] is hang on this is not evidence that tyler robinson is a patsy it's only evidence that you have
[27:47] conjectured up that uh well if it's the case that these are the the more degraded prints then therefore
[27:55] that means must be patsy because parents finger dad's fingerprints on guns i didn't say describe how
[28:02] this actually links in to robinson being a patsy okay i just described that for you so i'm not i can
[28:09] explain it to you but i can't understand it for you so i'm going to move on from that uh but to just
[28:13] go back to your point about this is not evidence uh you can't make that claim because you're the entire
[28:17] basis for why you think that there's evidence for tyler robinson being the person that took the shot
[28:22] is based off of a hearing under utah 1102 rules meaning that they are doing the exact same thing
[28:28] that i am doing this is the state you said you're here to represent the state well did you watch the
[28:31] preliminary hearing say i was here to represent the state the state's position you think is strong and
[28:35] convincing what i'm here to do is represent my own opinion which is that based on the evidence
[28:42] presented so far by the state the state has presented evidence under utah's 1102 rule but this
[28:48] doesn't demonstrate any patsy no that's very important because that rule is hearsay so you
[28:53] can't say at the same time candace you're not allowed to and what that means under the utah rule
[28:57] which i'm sure you know because i'm sure you watch the preliminary hearing and yourself understand what
[29:01] that means is that the entire hearing was hearsay it means none of that information that was presented
[29:06] is going to be allowed the majority of it the overwhelming majority of it is is not going to
[29:11] be allowed at the trial they're allowed to present when it's just a probative hearing i don't think
[29:14] all the evidence that was that was put in was hearsay okay you didn't watch this case but not only
[29:19] that no no that's this is a huge point i want to well hey we can call for a fact check if all the evidence
[29:24] we need more than a fact check this was every single day they want to go there so they said
[29:29] they had there's a medical examiner's explanation of the shooting that's in the back rob if you want
[29:35] to pull it up and then candace if anybody from your team wants to pull something up no problem as well
[29:40] but they're requesting it if you guys got it pull it up uh so we can show it and in the interim kent
[29:46] is that it yeah so i'll read this what are we looking at just so we know yeah so the this says the
[29:53] bullet or at least part of it sequentially perforated the interior left of mr kirk's neck
[29:58] strap muscles of the left side of the neck this is a summary by the way uh left common uh cartoid
[30:04] on the left internal external jugular veins the bullet also obliterated the left side c27 vertebrae
[30:11] transacted the cervical spinal cord medical examiner observed a significant portion of kirk's cervical
[30:17] spinal cord was traumatically absent mr kirk suffered from other severe injuries including
[30:22] bilateral apical and posterior intercausal hemorrhages pulmonary apical hemorrhages
[30:30] multiple disruptions to the thyroid etc etc so they're the summary of the examinations that he
[30:35] was shot okay that was what they were pulling that up okay and i don't i'm not disputing that
[30:40] he could have been hit with a projectile i we're not disputing that so i don't know why this is brought
[30:44] up as a fact check uh could you bring up 1102 utah rule because this is an unbelievable point that
[30:49] you're making by saying that i am not allowed to infer off of evidence you can infer i'm trying
[30:54] to follow the inference but your entire reason like you you asserted that you believe there's
[30:59] overwhelming evidence on the basis of what we saw in the preliminary hearing the entire preliminary
[31:04] hearing was hearsay yeah i'm fine with your inferences but no you just literally said i couldn't
[31:09] do that yes i can't no i didn't i'm just saying from your inference how do we get to patsy
[31:13] this is how you got to shoot her the tyler robinson did it no no no i didn't get to just shoot her from
[31:19] that yes you did you you again we this is something important so we should pull up a fact fact check
[31:23] about what the 1102 utah and under their constitution for the sake of a preliminary hearing yeah they do
[31:30] not have to have hard evidence they don't have to put people on the trial they don't have to but no no
[31:35] that's why the entire hearing was basically hearsay officer but not all of it like i said the
[31:40] overwhelming majority i mean outside of the one that you don't that you don't want to give
[31:46] what's coming off though outside of no that is what's in dispute it means that your entire brand
[31:51] of saying you don't have evidence you don't have evidence falls apart when the entire preliminary
[31:56] hearing is based off of hearsay in fact lance's testimony before they had about an hour debate
[32:02] actually maybe it was more than an hour debate before he sat and they said this is not going to be
[32:05] allowed you wouldn't even be allowed to do this we'd be able to cross-examine him uh the questions that
[32:09] they're asking glance are all leading and what did he say well i'm the magistrate under utah
[32:14] constitution you know 1102 it is my job to allow all of this so we can see if the state has enough
[32:20] here that we can then move to a trial which will then they would not allow this stuff they would
[32:24] say we get to cross-examine lance lance but you're arguing things i'm not disputing you know but the
[32:29] entire substance of your argument is that people can't infer off of evidence that's what you're saying
[32:34] to me yeah when you say candace here i'll give you the argument which is a fact yeah i'm not saying
[32:39] that off of that didn't say that tyler could have been a patsy you're just you're just literally
[32:43] making stuff up so here's what the position is i'm not making stuff up i'm saying let's pull that up
[32:51] i am doing exactly what the state did i'm looking at a piece of evidence and i am saying but you're not
[32:55] showing me how you get there describe to the audience what yes so this just so everybody who's
[32:59] watching this at home understands what i'm saying even if he doesn't what andrew is arguing is that
[33:05] i don't have the right to extrapolate from a fact like um making it up just purely making it up
[33:12] i'm asking based on andrew can i show my evidence you just showed yours reliable hearsay you'll get
[33:17] a chance reliable hearsay in criminal preliminary examinations the entire uh preliminary hearing that
[33:25] you just saw was on the basis of reliable hearsay and what that means essentially
[33:29] is the people who are making the statements can just say patrick told me that he did this on
[33:35] monday patrick's not here uh and that is they can allow that into the hearing that's just it because
[33:41] it's just meant to be probative and so it's the state saying here's what we have inferred so you are
[33:47] allowed to take a piece of evidence and then you are allowed to infer off of that evidence okay case
[33:53] in point that's a demonstration of to give you that's a demonstration of what i just did
[33:57] i said the prints were the most degraded off of tyler robinson and from that what i am inferring
[34:03] is that it's plausible that tyler robinson was set up that doesn't that's the point in contention
[34:07] that's not a point in contention that's that's the point in contention it's not a point in contention
[34:11] if you're saying it's the point in contention it's not the point in contention i'm telling you that
[34:14] was what the entire hearing allowed for so the evidence that he is describing we're asking you that
[34:19] he is using to argue his case is all based on inference not fact great it's not facts so what
[34:25] they are inferring off of the facts so again we're going to take this and i'm just going to even grant
[34:33] it because it's irrelevant i'm asking how you get to the inference that even if you dispute that piece
[34:38] of evidence that means patsy i'm looking for the logical chain for how you get to that inference what i
[34:46] am telling you is it's the exact same way that when you tweeted i think that this evidence is
[34:52] overwhelming when they say that looks like tyler robinson's car he drives a similar car
[34:58] okay they are inferring that that's tyler robinson can you walk walk me through the inference
[35:02] so that i understand it's it's not a fact it's not a fact when you show a blurry image which you
[35:07] kept citing that we have no no i'm talking about your inference that the fingerprints even if they're
[35:11] degraded equals patsy how do you get that inference i didn't say it equals patsy i think
[35:16] it is enough evidence that it should be explored which is exactly what this preliminary was in the
[35:20] inverse that's not in dispute what's in dispute is when you said i'm using this as evidence that
[35:25] he could have been a patsy i'm asking how do you get the inference to patsy from that because what i
[35:31] am saying is that it shows that somebody else had more dna presence on that gun than tyler robinson did
[35:38] so it is plausible which is all they're doing they're presenting plausibility based off of the facts okay
[35:43] it is plausible that somebody just took his gun and put it there that's it is there equally that
[35:48] that's how it works and is there equally a hundred other plausible explanations i think that's the
[35:52] reason why most people are exploring when things don't make sense so yes at the beginning of that
[35:56] this is how this is how the court process works just so we're clear if there's a hundred other
[36:00] plausible explanations in candace why is it that we should go with this idea that it was a patsy i i'm not
[36:07] saying that we should go with the idea that it was a patsy i am saying that there is oh i thought that
[36:12] was the whole defense though your whole claim my whole claim was that there is more evidence that
[36:17] he has set up that he is set up as a patsy how does that equal evidence of patsy i don't know how
[36:22] many times i can say this like i i'm saying that i am using the exact same mechanism that you are
[36:26] accepting for some reason in the utah courtroom yeah right to say i'm gonna look at the evidence and
[36:31] i'm going to infer an alternative theory so you just saw the states and you're accepting it and they are they
[36:36] have not presented any concrete facts you listed on your own twitter that what you found to be
[36:40] convincing was something that looked like his car pulled into the driveway a blurry image no i didn't
[36:46] the standard white guy coming up the steps that could literally be anyone this never happened you
[36:50] can we get a fact check on that can we pull up his tweet where he goes i didn't say that's what
[36:54] convinced me when you you actually didn't say it's what convinced me but you said this is the
[36:58] evidence that you found to be overwhelming and you you named i believe actually five things i think
[37:03] you said it was his car uh you said it was well there's multitudes of things that i find you just
[37:07] said you didn't say we're gonna get a fact check on that you did go ahead um you said the blurry
[37:11] images coming up the steps quite literally when officer bagley testified they talk about when i'm
[37:15] talking about making inference this is the most i thought was the most absurd testimony i've ever heard
[37:19] and part of me it was actually hull david hull uh they asked him a question how did you know the
[37:25] guy in the maroon shirt was the same as the guy that came up the stairs later that was wearing the
[37:30] american flag black shirt and he said they're wearing the same shoes why is that absurd that's
[37:38] how you decided these two are the same people oh wow what a scientific they're both wearing converses
[37:42] okay that that's an absurd thing to say that is not evidence that these are the same people if we're
[37:48] both wearing converses that was what he said that's what flew on the stand but i don't i still don't
[37:52] understand how that would be absurd if somebody is an absurd thing for instance if somebody were to
[37:56] change their clothes but keep the same shoes on wouldn't you utilize the shoes to try to track that person
[38:01] if they were changing their clothes the idea that on a college campus two people wearing this totally
[38:05] different outfits but both wearing converses can't happen is such an absurdity that i don't even need
[38:10] to like argue that i'm just gonna let people we didn't why is it just concede that point obviously
[38:14] it's absurd i don't say i'm not i'm not sure these are the same people because they're both wearing
[38:18] converse yeah i'm not sure if in context that's what happened but even if it is you can get a fact
[38:22] check on it but even if it is um again and it was utilizing inferences when whenever we're dealing with
[38:29] logic and we're dealing with making a logical inference we're going to take the entire collaboration
[38:33] of evidence and then we're going to make inferences from that you would do that with any type of
[38:37] logical proposition otherwise you could never have a true or false claim you just told me i couldn't
[38:42] so when we're i never that never happened you're just making stuff up so anyway when we're talking
[38:47] about logical inferences what i'm looking for is the logical inferences that you have that tyler
[38:52] robinson's and patsy based on the totality of evidence that you have we can keep going through your
[38:56] other evidence but we should find his tweet where he please where he lists the reasons that he was
[39:00] convinced so let's start with the 30-06 i think that that's fine your team's looking for do you
[39:04] do you remember how long ago that was uh the tweets of the uh five did you delete it or no no okay cool
[39:12] i just look for he said the unless it was his car it was his uh it was the car and it was definitely the
[39:20] staircase photos and it was when the trial was okay she has it perfect if you got skylar has if you want
[39:25] to pull it up so we can see it somebody said so give me the clear evidence right here i want you
[39:30] to provide it right here all i heard from the investigator was we believe this to be tyler
[39:34] robinson is belief something you go as a fact you wrote the car pulling in that's a totally blurry
[39:39] image um robinson getting out of it you have no idea if that's tyler robinson the fact that he has
[39:45] seen four other times on camera the fact being just a standard white boy with brown hair was seen
[39:50] getting walking up staircase the dna on the roof we should discuss that and on the screwdriver that
[39:56] he left behind it's overwhelming man yeah but that's not an exhaustive list just so we're clear
[40:02] you did tweet it but it's not an exhaustive you said i only said this one thing and said that that
[40:08] was overwhelming actually that's not what i said it is you could even put your own clip can you can you
[40:14] fact check if that was said or not i did not hear her so the thing is funny here is like we still
[40:19] aren't getting to any of these inferences so why are you pivoting but just say you were wrong
[40:23] i'm gonna just say i was wrong i'm not wrong so back to the tweet the tweet aspect here it was
[40:28] really funny that's not an exhaustive list of why i find it i didn't say it was exhaustive i just said
[40:32] you said it and on top of the well no you didn't you said that i only said this one thing and then said
[40:38] based on that it's over why didn't you didn't mention that i mentioned the screwdriver dna all these
[40:43] other things you never mentioned any of that so no you're actually incorrect there but on top of that
[40:49] moving over to the actual evidence are you are you uh yes i'm okay anyway back to the evidence
[40:54] you're okay yes actually i'm glad you're asserting that you're okay i wasn't worried about your health
[40:58] i'm just saying that i just said you tweeted this you said no i didn't we got a fact check and now
[41:01] you're like just gonna gaslight me and pretend that i said no gaslighting it wasn't exhaustive
[41:05] i never said that i just said you did say this zero gaslighting i didn't say you couldn't have
[41:09] said more but i would like to address the time if this is how you want to spend it interrogating my
[41:13] position you can do it that way i'm just addressing what you asserted on your twitter was like the
[41:19] hard evidence that convinced you was overwhelming that's literally not what you said that's not
[41:23] actually in fact what happened in that exchange i was here for it so what's your position here yeah so
[41:31] my position is that based on all of the evidence which has been demonstrated at least all the evidence
[41:37] to my knowledge that i am actually not seeing um anything that's compelling as an alternative theory
[41:44] i'm not seeing anything which is convincing me of something otherwise then what the state is
[41:48] presenting is evidence that's that's my position that's what you're asking me so just going back
[41:54] to what you did actually tweet is it fair to like to for me to ask questions about that uh that's
[41:58] that the only tweet you're going to ask me about well we're addressing your claim that the evidence
[42:02] is overwhelming and this is a tweet where you listed what you felt was overwhelming i think that's
[42:05] fair but not i feel like that's fair but not exhaustive just so you know and i never said it was
[42:09] exhaustive you know you said i did sure whatever um but yeah so going back to that all of that as you
[42:14] say to me well candace why are you addressing and making inferences off of the testimony no i never
[42:21] never asked you why you're making inferences i asked you how with the inference you made you got
[42:25] to the conclusion okay so i would like to know how you got to the conclusion um and i'm just gonna
[42:30] throw it right back at you because for some reason you permit yourself to do it and that's
[42:34] what i'm demonstrating is that you permit yourself to do it and then you say when i do it it's
[42:37] a conspiracy right no how are you able to infer off of blurry staircase images that that is tyler
[42:43] robinson yeah so in that particular case what you do is you take that evidence you combine it with
[42:49] other evidence so it's not just that tyler robinson is seen in the staircase why are you calling him
[42:55] tyler robinson in the staircase that's what i want to get to yeah because i mean we'll just use this if
[42:59] you don't agree that that's tyler robinson then you would just have to humor me i think it is so i'm
[43:04] using the name but why do you think it is because you make everybody that's literally what i'm trying to
[43:07] explain to you okay so if you're asking for my inference why i think it's tyler robinson is because a
[43:12] tyler robinson said in his text messages you you'll be able to see me on security footage at the
[43:17] campus said it in his own messages on top of that twigs yes you can pull them up if you want to fact
[43:22] check that he did say yeah i actually think i really did miss that i'm not saying you're wrong i just i
[43:27] don't remember him saying you're going to see me in i'm paranoid but it was pulled that up yeah i
[43:33] twigs himself said that he had something in the staircase that he had some um maybe a tiny bit of
[43:40] doubt but it sure looked like tyler robinson inside of this various uh surveillance footage
[43:45] that he saw so sorry hang on so there's multi there's multiple reasons why it is that i believe
[43:52] that that's tyler robinson not just because of blurry footage did you have a dream just kidding
[43:58] no it's because i combined multitudes of evidences okay uh so let's address those multitude of evidences
[44:03] the first one we're working on a fact check on because i i do not ever remember him tweeting that's me
[44:07] in the stair i mean or texting texting that that's me in the staircase i think that i i i didn't say
[44:14] i didn't say that i said he i literally didn't what i said is that he texted over you'll be able to
[44:21] see me in footage at the at uvu and i'm paraphrasing but that's what he said yeah could we get a fact
[44:26] check on that the second thing you said was lance's testimony where and actually what lance says is i'm
[44:31] not a hundred percent i agree but in terms of what he wears again me pointing out the absurdity uh he
[44:38] wears converses he wears sneakers if his boyfriend is not a hundred percent i'd like to understand why
[44:44] andrew wilson is overwhelmed by it that's what i'm trying to get to and lastly i would like to remind
[44:48] you that lance's statement would not be permitted this was a huge part of the preliminary hearing
[44:53] that they were leading all the questions that were asked asked of him were leading so they would
[44:58] be struck down at the actual trial and also i would like to remind you that he got use immunity for
[45:03] that use immunity i understand which means like that happens by the way all the time and i'm wondering
[45:08] why it particularly happened for lance and this testimony and i would also like to point out that
[45:11] something that's remarkable about this again leaning to my perspective that lance has a lot more
[45:16] which i have said many times lance has a lot more involvement than the feds are are um letting us
[45:21] know i think more is going to come out either because they interviewed him on september 11th and then for
[45:27] whatever reason just ahead of what was supposed to be slated as the preliminary hearing which was
[45:31] initially supposed to be in may they bring him back to do this interview which in my opinion should
[45:38] have never been allowed and i actually agree with the defense that it's a violation of his
[45:41] constitutional rights not to allow them to have cross-examined him but i understand utah 1102
[45:46] do what you do it's all hearsay uh but to allow it in that way for him to just be able to also have
[45:53] use immunity knowing that he's not going to be he's not in any trouble he could literally get up there
[45:57] and lie about anything and he's not going to get in trouble because the use immunity was given to
[46:01] him in april i believe april 28th is when they uh gave that testimony to the defense i think they
[46:06] shot it in like april 20th of 2026. that is not compelling to me for somebody who has used immunity
[46:12] to give a testimony and to say i'm not really sure but definitely like he wears jeans and stuff
[46:18] that's not what he said he did actually you can get a fact check on that skyder i think you said
[46:22] much more than that so so a couple things we have we have rule 801 tyler's messages that says it's
[46:28] not hearsay but first go to what candace is asking about skyler i think you have it you just text me
[46:34] if you want to pull it up you said you have the text if we can uh put that up on the screen thank
[46:39] you it was me look at the pictures from mr veylo footage it was me okay i literally said to you it's
[46:44] not if i said i didn't remember this and i'm happy to have a fact check on that okay i thought i i didn't
[46:48] call for the fact check saying you're wrong i literally said i don't remember that well i'm just saying to
[46:51] you like i'm trying to be concise and then also bring the 801 that you just said what was the
[46:56] other one yep the 801 uh tyler messages saying it's not hearsay if you have that as well there
[47:07] you go wait what are we saying is not here saying a statement that meets the following conditions is
[47:15] not here it was hearsay they said it in the trial hang on hang on okay okay uh uh is consistent with
[47:23] the declarant's testimony and the declarant denies having made the statement or has forgotten
[47:29] or is consistent with the declarant's testimony and is offered to rebut express implied charge
[47:34] that the declarant recently fabricated or acted in recent improper influence or motive
[47:38] and testifying so then wouldn't that mean that a bunch of this wasn't hearsay it so the issue
[47:43] with him i just want to make sure yeah but that makes you would that mean that a bunch of this
[47:46] wasn't hearsay so the opposing party which down the line like i said they talked about this for
[47:51] an hour and a half and they discussed how if lance was in court and he was giving his first party
[47:56] you know giving his testimony as the opposing party whatever all this would be fine they had an
[48:01] issue with how the questions were being asked and that they were not allowed to cross-examine him
[48:05] so that is why his video testimony would not be accepted in the main trial and what i said to you
[48:10] is this entire preliminary hearing is under utah's 1102 so they are allowed to just use hearsay no you
[48:19] didn't say that you said most of it was hearsay actually yeah the overwhelming majority well i mean
[48:24] i mean that's i'm leaning now into my opinion that some scientific aspects which they kept asserting
[48:29] like the federal rule 403 or 402 some of those parts were quite sounds like you're backtracking
[48:34] quite a bit no i'm not backtracking at all what do you feel like let me help you where do you feel
[48:37] like i'm backtracking it was it literally was done under utah's 1102 yeah nobody disputed that
[48:42] what the dispute was is whether or not most of it was overwhelmingly hearsay yes it was yes that's
[48:46] a fact i'm not backtracking on that one of the things how many times did you i mean if you watch
[48:50] the preliminary hearing it's like yeah they constantly i'm 1102 1102 1102 1102 and the
[48:56] reason for that is because it's allowed i'm not saying it's illegal it's allowed at this stage
[48:59] but i'm just reminding you that when you're going to sit across from someone and your claim is going
[49:03] to be where is your hard evidence this is what i heard and i agree with what i'm watching you are
[49:07] watching the state put on a hearsay preliminary hearing and that and all of those things are not
[49:14] going to be allowed right even when they got into witness statements and things of that nature
[49:17] there's a reason why they swear you in and they say you swear yourself the truth the whole truth
[49:22] did you you know write this statement so it's the overwhelming majority of what you saw was hearsay
[49:28] because other people were representing other people's statements they were saying they had
[49:31] conversations we don't know where it came from all allowed at this stage okay but it's hearsay so
[49:37] even a lot of that stuff may not fall under hearsay under what we just read right but the evidence
[49:42] that you're speaking about like when you're just when you say that we're going off vibes you don't know
[49:47] tyler robinson okay his boyfriend is not 100 it was him so i'm going back to your points that you
[49:53] made that this was overwhelming evidence for you that doesn't make sense to me well overwhelming just
[49:58] means you can't consider another option that there could have been another white guy wearing converses
[50:02] on campus do you agree with me that i said that what overwhelming means to me is that it's just very
[50:08] convincing to me yeah and i find it to be completely unconvincing and that's fair i understand that i
[50:12] looked at those blurry photos that they presented and said your your statement on right now is that
[50:19] yeah he's wearing converses and he also that's just crazy these aren't the evidences that i find
[50:23] the most convincing well you said that in your twitter that's not the only thing i've ever said on my
[50:28] twitter about this case right but the question that was asked of you was pretty direct yeah right
[50:32] what what did you find this is not an exhaustive list of all the things that you said in the tweet you can
[50:37] tweet longer too it's not like we're limited now to 240 characters so wait so anything that i tweet
[50:42] and all other tweets that i've ever made are now excluded because i used the word overwhelming in
[50:47] this one well even though all of this information i've said so publicly over and over and over again
[50:53] is what informs my position for why i'm convinced on the case that's bizarre to me i feel like this is
[50:58] andrew versus andrew somebody asked you a question what are the points that you find to be the you
[51:02] know the most overwhelming and you answered you mean from that day from that particular day of the
[51:07] hearing that i was responding to okay this is something you have you find to be more overwhelming
[51:12] yes yes okay go ahead go on what do you find to be more overwhelming yeah yeah can we do this
[51:17] do we want to get into it or do we know do we want to do a quick ad break i'm are you guys good to keep
[51:22] going or i'm i'm fine to keep going but we we can also like to take a quick break doesn't matter to me
[51:27] if we're going into a different topic that may be another 30 minutes 40 minutes i don't want to stop
[51:32] what you find to be more overwhelming yeah yeah so if we're for me it's the confessions
[51:38] the text messages all of that is what i consider to be uh from my opinion that's the most convincing
[51:45] for me okay we should discuss the text message confessions when uh we get back if you'd like to
[51:50] okay that's a good idea folks we're going to take a quick ad break we will be back in three and a
[51:55] half minutes thank you all right you guys for nearly 2 000 years christians have lived continuously in a
[52:00] small village just outside of jerusalem called tai bay they remained through the roman empire the
[52:05] crusades the ottoman empire and countless changes of power today that christian presence is in
[52:09] serious danger one father in the west bank put it simply he said quote i don't want to leave my family
[52:14] is buried here my church is here in tai bay the church is more than a place of worship it's a school
[52:20] a medical clinic a food distribution center and a safe gathering place for families when the church
[52:25] can no longer serve the community families begin to leave and a living christian presence in the holy
[52:29] land begins to disappear but you can help just 35 provides a full day of protection and support for
[52:35] vulnerable christian families and 83 a month can help sustain that protection throughout the month
[52:41] i support the vulnerable people project because 93 of every donated dollar goes directly toward
[52:46] protecting vulnerable families and communities on the ground if preserving a living christian
[52:51] presence in the holy land matters to you visit vulnerable people project.com again that's
[52:56] vulnerable people project.com all right you guys do you feel like you're working harder than ever but
[53:00] still falling behind every month between grocery prices bills and credit card debt growing it can
[53:05] feel impossible to get ahead minimum payments aren't designed to get you out of debt they're designed
[53:09] to actually keep you stuck but pds debt can help they can reduce up to half of what you owe on credit
[53:14] cards personal loans and medical bills and it starts with a free 30-second assessment at pds debt.com
[53:21] stop juggling multiple payments and get one lower monthly payment the savings begin the day that you
[53:26] complete the quick assessment if you're carrying any balance on your credit cards it's costing
[53:30] you money every single day there's no minimum credit score that's required pds debt is the top
[53:35] rated company in the industry with thousands of five-star reviews and a plus rating on the bbb
[53:40] so get your free 30-second personalized assessment today at pdsdebt.com slash candace again that's pdsdebt.com
[53:47] slash candace i also want to tell you guys about the wellness company because by now you've probably heard
[53:52] that there is an explosive outbreak in the us this summer more than 18 000 confirmed and suspected
[53:57] cases of cyclosporiasis have now been nationwide and michigan health officials have confirmed the
[54:03] first two united states deaths associated with that outbreak the cdc says the illness is caused by
[54:09] cyclospora a microscopic parasite commonly spread through contaminated fresh produce can cause severe
[54:15] stomach cramps nausea fatigue and other debilitating symptoms if you get sick the cdc recommends
[54:20] bactrim that's why the wellness company created the medical emergency kit with generic bactrim plus
[54:24] seven additional prescription medications to help treat more than 25 common illnesses and medical
[54:29] emergencies all prescribed before you need them getting your kit is simple you complete a secure
[54:34] online medical questionnaire if it's approved by a licensed physician your kit ships directly to your
[54:39] door so don't wait until you're sick to wish that you were prepared visit twc.health
[54:44] slash candace and use code candace at checkout to save up to 45 dollars off plus free shipping
[54:51] that's twc.health slash candace kits are available for united states residents only okay we're back
[54:58] fantastic i think we're back uh by the way just an fyi for those of you that are watching the crucible
[55:05] there's 30 000 concurrent they're watching support uh andrew wilson that's your your fans of his click
[55:11] that subscribe button and help some grow his business if you're watching candace i think
[55:15] there's 225 to 250 000 concurrent right now we'd like to see that 300 400 000 number on there click
[55:22] that button as well to subscribe and share it with your friends and family and if you're watching it on
[55:26] pbd podcast do the same there as well this allows us to have more conversations like this the mainstream
[55:32] media hates the fact that we're having these conversations right now just so you know they want to
[55:37] control it this is free-for-all this is what's best for the audience that's why we like freedom of
[55:41] speech having said that let's go back into the text conversation you were having right okay let's stay
[55:46] and then we'll go into the cross-examination stuff in about 30 minutes okay that sounds fair um okay so
[55:52] yeah my i i used basically three pillars for the totality of the evidence okay so if you want to know
[55:59] exactly what those three pillars are this is going to be uh the testimony with the text messages
[56:05] and um the confessions this is going to be the physical evidence and this is going to be the
[56:12] totality of the summary of the case okay so uh right now we're we're focusing on one of these pillars in
[56:18] my defense which is fine i understand that i have to defend my claims as well so when we're talking about
[56:23] the messages themselves uh they seem totally valid i have no idea why they wouldn't be valid and i have
[56:30] not heard any good explanation for why it is that these messages should even be questioned the defense
[56:37] hasn't questioned them as far as i'm aware nobody has actually questioned that these messages came
[56:42] from robinson to date except perhaps you and and other other people who are kind of in that camp
[56:49] but why should i question these exactly i'm not sure okay so first let's just go over legally
[56:54] what the point is of a probative hearing the defense is not putting on they're not there to say
[56:59] or to argue or to defend themselves at all they have to address what is being presented by the
[57:05] state okay so they're not here to then say let me give you an explanation for these text messages
[57:10] the relevant portion of what the defense did do was actually before we got to the preliminary hearing
[57:16] i had mentioned that it was initially supposed to be scheduled for some time in may
[57:20] they asked for an extension that that reading through those filings of why they were requesting
[57:25] an extension and why i actually believe their extension should have been granted
[57:30] because they did not receive discovery on their text messages that was one of the reasons there
[57:34] were many reasons why they wanted to have an extension but this was crucial right so forget
[57:38] just the general sense that these messages feel off and and yes you are allowed to have an intuition you
[57:44] are allowed to have a sense and just go this is very weird we're being told this kid had like above
[57:48] a 4.0 tyler robinson he wanted to get away i mean the tech messages almost run
[57:53] uh head to head with themselves like he wanted to get away with it so he thought the best thing to
[57:59] do would be to text a full confession of what he did uh down to what i didn't even remember saying
[58:05] yeah and that's also me in the surveillance footage it it felt a little too on the nose i
[58:10] just people have common sense you just don't text message but then we're also supposed to believe
[58:14] that he put a note under because and burn this and get rid of the evidence but don't worry about
[58:18] that because i'm about to text you a full confession that it felt off it felt weird off the bat
[58:21] the manner in which they were texting we're told he's like a gamer who's using a dremel uh to carve
[58:28] expressions catch batches fascists but then suddenly he's writing like a 1700 player he did get he did
[58:36] actually get the 500k code correct yeah i'm not a gamer so we'll say that we start debating that you'll
[58:42] be way over my head but yes but my point being is just that just first it's a general sense of why
[58:46] people had a reaction these messages uh that seemed like they were written by jane austin rather than
[58:51] than like a kid who games and writes yeah but do you see how that's intuition that is i am i just
[58:56] said that i said just put it parking aside the intuition of just something feels wrong here which
[59:01] you should follow your intuition you should actually do that if you say i think the covid vaccine is
[59:05] running out feels like it's coming out too fast and there's too many celebrities telling me to do it
[59:09] i'd like to take a pause that's good that is you are allowed to do that i believe in intuition
[59:13] now but hang on let me respond a little bit here because you've been going for a minute let me at least
[59:17] respond to a little bit of this so the first thing is is like when people bring up the covid vaccine
[59:22] not trusting the covid vaccine in mass was the science that wasn't just intuition that was the
[59:27] science there was tons of competing science now they tried to suppress it that's true but there was
[59:32] tons of competing science for why you shouldn't take a risky mrna vaccine um and mass and things like
[59:40] now when you're talking about intuition though when you say trust your intuition i'm actually giving a
[59:43] different message you actually should be very wary about trusting just your intuition it is true
[59:49] that intuition can be useful but it has to be tempered with logic reason explanatory power and evidence
[59:56] not just intuition that's why we're parking it aside intuition is the first step something feels
[59:59] off right okay that was my first step with covid i don't like the way it's being pushed it
[1:00:04] shouldn't require a celebrity campaign by the way another element of that is why people don't
[1:00:08] feel good about the charlie thing why do we have so many influencers saying things it's over why
[1:00:11] you guys all using uh the same adjective can you switch it up i'm overwhelmed i'm overwhelmed like
[1:00:16] chill like you could say i found some kind of like compelling i think this should go like i found some
[1:00:22] parts compelling maybe we should you know see at the trial that would be kind of don't you think fed
[1:00:27] slop's a buzzword for the other for the counter industry everyone on the same day of watching this
[1:00:32] trial which was i would say not overwhelming at all nobody came in medium right no one came in like there
[1:00:39] were some interesting aspects this was a little suspect i i but i do think it's enough to go to
[1:00:43] trial they all came in like they were passing away and were going to die from being overwhelmed trusting
[1:00:47] their intuition okay well actually in that scenario they're they're looking at the preliminary hearing
[1:00:51] and have a reaction to it it wasn't their intuition but like how do you know that just getting
[1:00:54] to the substance parking that aside parking aside just a general intuition that sometimes i write
[1:00:58] these messages then we look at the filings which came from the defense and they were requesting an
[1:01:02] extension saying we have gone to the prosecution and we have requested all of this stuff in discovery
[1:01:10] yes you are saying that you took lance's phone okay and that you collected his phone on september 11th
[1:01:17] and that you sent it off or whatever you took a picture of the text messages and we are being
[1:01:22] giving these text messages to review crucially kathy nester said i have not even been given access to my
[1:01:30] client's phone during this hearing she said i had me because it's my client's phone she can't tell you
[1:01:34] as a part of their discovery quest is it's not enough to say to me uh candace i just got a text
[1:01:39] message from candace and i say i didn't send that text message maybe that's what a client's saying we
[1:01:43] don't know because we're not at the trial right maybe he didn't send those messages could there be
[1:01:47] someone who logged into his discord could there be someone who logged in to his apple george could be
[1:01:52] sending text messages right now we are married he has every login that i have and remember he's up for
[1:01:57] a death sentence so if i'm able to sow reasonable doubt with common sense he may come during the
[1:02:03] trial and when they actually have to address these points say i did not write those messages i was
[1:02:09] here lance my boyfriend was logged into my phone logged into my apple id and my icloud sending
[1:02:14] messages i know that we have the capability because my husband does it he has the capability to send
[1:02:17] messages from my phone it is not convincing to the public when for whatever reason the fbi would not
[1:02:25] fbi combined with the sbi it was not the prosecution's fault they made that clear during that
[1:02:29] hearing would not allow them that discovery request to be able to see where did that message come from
[1:02:35] because you're saying my client was here right i want to know that message actually was generated from
[1:02:41] his iphone when he was waiting to retrieve his you know rifle hoping that the pooch doesn't have a bad
[1:02:48] sniffer like just weird messages i want to make sure that yes it was actually him he was holding
[1:02:54] his phone and his boyfriend didn't just log in to his computer when he was home lance was his
[1:02:59] boyfriend that is a that is a crucial fact here that discovery was not met by the time i got to
[1:03:04] preliminary hearing so i remain unconvinced by these text messages just as you feel convinced by them i
[1:03:11] feel unconvinced by okay so then the idea here is the reason that you don't think that these are valid
[1:03:18] text messages and you don't right i i i it has not been proven these messages are valid and they don't
[1:03:22] sound valid to me i don't think anyone even if someone was selling like a i don't know pot on
[1:03:30] the corner would be smarter than to write a full-fledged confession confession he even writes i
[1:03:35] thought i would get away with it and i was hoping never to tell you until old age and then we're being
[1:03:40] told that he wanted to commit suicide and okay but he just said he wanted to get away with it but he's
[1:03:45] not smart enough to um i don't know maybe not text a like it's such a confession like we've never seen
[1:03:50] it i think this would be like the first time ever somebody has start to finish written an entire
[1:03:56] here's i'm in the surveillance footage and i'm here and i'm wearing my converse you know i'm being
[1:04:00] a little facetious here but it was a little ridiculous it didn't it didn't pass the sniff
[1:04:04] test for me you have kids and you love them more than anything i do if it was the case that you thought
[1:04:10] that the your kid was innocent wouldn't you be out telling everybody and their brother that you
[1:04:14] thought that they were innocent and also wouldn't you say wouldn't you maybe recant and say hey i didn't
[1:04:20] actually he didn't actually confess to me he didn't actually none of this happened the way that
[1:04:26] the uh state is presenting it what would have prevented the parents from testifying well two
[1:04:31] things i can answer that and if you if you watch my show i keep telling you it's not vibes so right
[1:04:35] after the shooting happened uh lance twiggs you know the fbi put him into a house safe house they
[1:04:42] paid for they went to the parents as well to matt robinson amber basically said your life's at risk
[1:04:46] there could be somebody who jumps up and wants to avenge charlie kirk and you know we're gonna
[1:04:51] watch you and they went into a federal safe house uh what happens next is that they started thinking
[1:04:58] that the feds were maybe gonna like maybe not as honest as they thought um and how do you know all
[1:05:04] any of that you gotta you gotta watch the show right yeah no how do you know that i i i had a source
[1:05:10] within the robinson family you have a source an anonymous source of course so there's no way for us to
[1:05:14] verify that what you're saying right now is actually even true you find it to be reliable
[1:05:18] hearsay uh no i don't find it to be reliable at all it's just a source i'm just doing what the
[1:05:23] what you're doing is a cool story it's not well you must have hated you're giving us you're giving
[1:05:29] us a cool story you're saying that according to your sources that the reason that the parents haven't
[1:05:34] recanted any of this recanted what they have no statement from the parents wait i just want to
[1:05:38] make sure that i if if it was the case it was being reported in mainstream media that your father
[1:05:43] came to you and said hey is this you is what's going on here and then he and one of his uh buddies
[1:05:50] took you in where you turned yourself in you wouldn't go out and be like no that's not what
[1:05:55] happened that isn't what happened though you're just wrong on this okay maybe i'm paraphrasing so
[1:05:59] what is your sorry just so i'm clear what where is your evidence that the parents turned him in
[1:06:05] well no no i didn't say that you said the mainstream media i said with um a sheriff friend yes but the
[1:06:11] father did confront him the father confronted what tyler robinson and where did you learn this
[1:06:17] that the title i mean that's part of the official documents our fact checkers can pull that up but
[1:06:21] yes i'm saying but when you say official documents do you mean you saw this on cnn or you saw this play
[1:06:25] out in the hearing no this was one of the things that i went through and fact check pre-debate are you
[1:06:28] talking about like the charging documents i think it was in the it could have been in the charging
[1:06:32] documents but i did but i do we can pull them up no and that and yes are you disputing this
[1:06:38] yes do we have that on the back to pull it up i can already tell you what you're talking about
[1:06:42] the charging documents because this is where we had to figure out where this story came from because
[1:06:46] everyone was operating on the assumption that matt robinson turned him in until we got to the
[1:06:51] preliminary hearing and we understood like i said even for that when you are charging someone you can
[1:06:56] use hearsay it's all probative right nothing so they didn't have statements it's not like matt robinson
[1:07:01] even though he was interviewed that night amber robinson was interviewed that night by a fed
[1:07:05] separate rooms uh tyler robinson was interviewed by a fed they did not produce statements saying my
[1:07:10] son did this my son i believe my son did this um but what happened was they did interviews but also
[1:07:15] the crucial person here who you just brought up is mike mitchell mike mitchell is the biggest unknown in
[1:07:21] this entire case everyone keeps saying they heard from mike mitchell this they heard from mike mitchell that
[1:07:25] so when the person wrote up the report that night and it was brian davis who wrote up the what became the
[1:07:31] charging document he uh after they transported uh tyler robinson from the washington sheriff's
[1:07:37] county office uh up to i think it's salt lake city i think it was 4 a.m in the morning that they got up
[1:07:43] there he then writes the uh charging what becomes a charging document so he's basically saying we all
[1:07:49] spoke to a bunch of people and here's the information that we got right we've not seen that
[1:07:54] so it could have come from mike mitchell mike mitchell could be saying i don't know how this negates the
[1:07:58] point though why wouldn't the parents because you don't have a statement from the parents you are
[1:08:02] you are going why wouldn't they just correct the misinformation negate the point the point is is that
[1:08:08] we now got the preliminary hearing if the parents were the ones who said i'm turning my son in
[1:08:14] because he's guilty i didn't say they turned him in yeah this i think you're talking about the over
[1:08:17] you said it's been the narrative everybody's known this the narrative initially which i think you
[1:08:21] agree with was that you know matt robinson knew his kid was guilty and turned him into the police
[1:08:25] station what actually happened in terms of sheriff brooksby who was present there and gave a press
[1:08:30] conference what happened was this mike mitchell character uh essentially peer pressured him and we
[1:08:34] can get a fact check on this we can find sheriff brooksby's uh press conference and he said you know
[1:08:40] they they know it's you and you're gonna come in uh peaceably or people are gonna be banging down
[1:08:45] your door he was a undercover cop which i don't like that i don't know what he did undercover it's very
[1:08:51] hard to find anything about mike mitchell but he worked with them for 20 plus years the police
[1:08:55] officers uh the reason why tyler robinson knew him was because he lived nearby and he was also
[1:08:59] his boy scout leader negate that the parents could write this second and by the way if you
[1:09:04] if you had that point i'm just saying that your your first point which is that the parents did this
[1:09:08] yeah we don't know that the parents never i didn't say that they did ever never you're quoting the
[1:09:12] parents as having said you said that matt robinson said that his kid was you say involved i don't
[1:09:17] want to misquote you confronted him about confronted him yes and i'm telling you that we have not seen any
[1:09:22] evidence that that is true we can fact check that okay because we do have evidence and i'm saying
[1:09:25] it's the charging doc which could have been derived from a statement mike mitchell said two things i
[1:09:29] have already in the back one is the charging doc and the other one is a video of kathy nestor saying
[1:09:34] she hasn't seen tyler's phone okay we can run kathy to go back and then just to go backwards to yeah
[1:09:39] kathy first in court saying she didn't get her client's phone yeah and then i think we'll go to the
[1:09:43] if you're okay with that thing not in dispute these are all things that are not even disputing okay so we don't
[1:09:49] show it we never get to the thing that i am disputing well you were i was just providing an
[1:09:53] answer we were coming back in from a break because you were talking about the text messages
[1:09:56] something that you felt was concrete so it was just my rebuttal to you that it's not concrete
[1:10:00] because they haven't had a chance to actually answer that and she didn't even get to see your
[1:10:04] client's phone so that's effectively again the state saying these messages are real you don't get
[1:10:09] the discovery on these messages just yet she will during trial they will actually don't you think
[1:10:13] that would make their case fall apart if it was the case that they weren't able to actually pull
[1:10:17] the data off the text messages do you think the prosecution would go to court with fabricated
[1:10:21] text messages it's called it's called winners and losers they may not be fabricated but by the way
[1:10:26] as as what they are saying like i said if there was somebody logged into his phone they may not
[1:10:30] be fabricated that's the point so let's get to the big just could be somebody else the parents fact check
[1:10:35] yeah so i was saying i believe what you're talking about was derived from the charging doc which was
[1:10:39] signed off by brian davis uh let's pull it up let's see if that's correct what are we looking at
[1:10:48] robinson's mother explained uh that over the last year or so i'm sorry can you zoom in is this the
[1:10:55] charging doc see it robinson's father reported that when his wife showed him the surveillance
[1:11:00] image of the suspected shooter in the news he agreed that it looked like their son he also believed that
[1:11:05] the rifle that police suspected the shooter used matched the rifle that was given to his son as a gift
[1:11:10] as a result robinson's father contacted his son and asked him to send a photo of the rifle which makes
[1:11:15] sense with the text messages robinson did not respond however robinson's father spoke on the
[1:11:20] phone with robinson robinson implied he planned to take his own life robinson's parents were able to
[1:11:25] convince him to meet at their home yes so this is proving my point is this this is from the charging
[1:11:30] document correct yeah so what i'm saying to you is that three people got interviewed on that night
[1:11:34] mike mitchell got interviewed amber robinson got interviewed and matt robinson got interviewed
[1:11:39] of the three of them only one of them actually wrote a statement which was referred to in this
[1:11:45] preliminary trial he came in i believe in march mike mitchell and he wrote a statement which i find
[1:11:50] to be very shady that they decided to bring why aren't the parents disputing that well first off
[1:11:55] that's the question the parents are not going to ever play in court play to the cameras in court
[1:12:01] when they have a legal team that is going to be advising them not to speak to the court because you
[1:12:05] could your son could go to prison but they're playing to somebody else who's your source i i'm i i'm
[1:12:09] not going to address that they're playing to someone else who's your source but won't go publicly tell
[1:12:13] the media this is not true well what i i did not say to you that i just said i have a source so i
[1:12:19] want to be very clear and take it from somebody who is involved and permanently sued uh when i have
[1:12:25] to take my lawyer's advice i mean there's so many things that i want to respond to when people are
[1:12:29] speaking about yeah but it's bizarre that they would utilize a source which would get the information to
[1:12:32] you but wouldn't just go to the media and be like actually that's all wrong i i am telling you that
[1:12:37] you would nary find a lawyer who would advise you to go to the media oh these this especially when
[1:12:43] your son if i thought that my kid was up for death if i thought that my kid was in any way shape or
[1:12:49] form going to be up you couldn't shut me up or my wife she would be like that's not true that's
[1:12:54] ridiculous there's no possible that never happened these people are lying through their teeth they'd be
[1:12:59] public whether you like it or not yeah i that's for you and your wife but when a judge issues a gag order
[1:13:05] in a case and your son is up for death and your lawyers could be advising you but if you say
[1:13:11] anything you could blow the case you would have a more responsible consideration i see and and we're
[1:13:16] and we're speaking opinion here you're like well i wouldn't care i'd violate it and i'd violate the
[1:13:19] judge's orders and see what happens if you have a source it seems like they're violating it with them
[1:13:24] i didn't i i'm not speaking to a source but i am saying to you is speaking just relevant to what
[1:13:29] this is we have not seen any proof that that statement that is included in this charging
[1:13:35] document i think it is highly likely on the basis of the preliminary hearing that that all came
[1:13:39] from mike mitchell and mike mitchell would be a part he's on the statements of well it's him saying
[1:13:47] the parents told me this the parents could dispute that that's going to come down the line right
[1:13:50] they're going to be able to seat the parents i i will say this putting together context clues
[1:13:55] if the state had it on you know a hundred percent certainty that matt robinson and amber robinson said it
[1:14:02] a five-day preliminary hearing would be a good time to say we have enough evidence and i can tell
[1:14:07] you why matt robinson uh made this statement and here is his statement that he signed that would
[1:14:11] have been a good time to present that evidence that would also be a good time for the defense to say
[1:14:15] that's just totally fabricated wrong time why couldn't they that is completely the wrong time
[1:14:19] because what they're doing is they already said they didn't receive discovery they literally can't
[1:14:23] they literally can't because they can't they did not receive that information no no they just
[1:14:27] received the text messages but in order to that's not the text messages uh the probative information
[1:14:33] yeah we're talking about the information that we just reviewed that's not the text message they
[1:14:36] never presented it the state never never put it on yeah they didn't the defense could easily still
[1:14:42] still have presented this yeah no they could have said they're no no you're you're not allowed to
[1:14:47] in a preliminary hearing yeah the defense is engaging with whatever evidence the state decides to put on
[1:14:53] they did not put this on as evidence brian davis was up there uh so they're not allowed to present
[1:14:59] anything they're responding to the state i'm asking are they allowed to present anything they
[1:15:03] are allowed to say like if there was a conspiracy that they could prove right then and there would
[1:15:06] they present that in one of these hearings no it wouldn't be the right time i disagree i think
[1:15:10] that they not only could do it but they would do it in fact when i talked in depth with my attorney
[1:15:17] they said that's exactly if you had actual evidence that there was fabrications by the feds
[1:15:21] that's exactly when you would introduce that so when in the document that they filed yesterday or
[1:15:27] a couple of days ago the appropriate like what you're doing at this stage of the hearing is the
[1:15:32] state is saying we have enough evidence that we think this needs to go forth the trial hence the
[1:15:37] reason that there's this extraordinary we allow hearsay because it doesn't really need to be perfect it
[1:15:42] can be enough that we feel like we can move forward right um and okay i disagree with that in general
[1:15:46] when somebody's running in prison but whatever uh the next phase is for them to meet in court and for
[1:15:54] the defense to essentially present an argument to the state that says we find this filing to be
[1:16:00] defective in and of itself we don't even have to defend ourselves because you the state have enough
[1:16:05] you know what the laws are on the books and this filing is effective and you should get rid of these
[1:16:09] charges because they don't make sense based on what you can decide based on the law in the books
[1:16:14] so then that's why they then file the dismissal right so in the dismissal what they're doing is
[1:16:19] they are engaging and this is what was widely misinterpreted well yeah they're engaging as
[1:16:23] though as as it's a hypothetical if this is hypothetically true then they're saying all of
[1:16:28] i'm not disputing any of that so that's what i am what i am you're saying no what i'm asking
[1:16:32] specifically is like who could shut up shut parents up who are like no way there's no possible this never
[1:16:38] happened this is ridiculous they would be shouting it on cnn they would be shouting it from the rooftops they
[1:16:44] would be losing their minds and you're like nope the gag order would be enough to to keep them
[1:16:48] quiet not enough for them to talk to your source but enough to keep them quiet i think that that's
[1:16:51] quite ridiculous but i'll even concede this whole point to you let's just say maybe this was
[1:16:57] misconstrued right if there's um there's a little bit of reason to doubt it because we're still waiting
[1:17:02] for the evidence for trial if that's the case then why not take the same standard for the evidence
[1:17:06] that you present you're just waiting for trial well you didn't do that wait a second wait a second
[1:17:12] i just i just want to make sure that i got this right that's your argument to me right
[1:17:16] my argument to you is what my argument your argument to me is that hey wait a second andrew
[1:17:22] there's not enough here that convinces me right well that's actually my rebuttal to you is that
[1:17:28] you are saying why are people engaging in what you term to be conspiracy theories i i i term it to be
[1:17:34] thinking they're just thinking because they're recognizing there are a lot of holes in these stories
[1:17:38] and that this is not strong evidence right this is the reason they're doing it i'm explaining to you
[1:17:43] this is the reason that they're doing it i'm addressing what you view to be overwhelming evidence
[1:17:48] and by the way i want to be clear that which convinces me what yeah well but thus far every point that
[1:17:55] you've brought up every point that you've brought up would you did you feel like this is beyond a
[1:18:00] reasonable doubt i mean you're you realize remember what i said in my opening going to be it's not beyond a
[1:18:05] reasonable doubt it's just what i find convincing is what i find overwhelming so why are you so upset
[1:18:10] when people say they don't find it if that was the limitation of the claims that you made if it was
[1:18:15] just wait a second there's a little bit of problems there's some problems in this case that i have
[1:18:20] questions for that i want answers to nobody have a problem actually at least of all me i would be the
[1:18:26] least likely person to have an issue with you any of your fans anybody saying in fact i've had tons of
[1:18:32] discord calls about this my position's always been clear of course conspiracies exist some of them
[1:18:38] have way better evidence than others but i've seen them myself i know conspiracy in fact the federal
[1:18:43] government has hundreds of thousands of laws about conspiracies they see them everywhere we both know
[1:18:49] this right that's never the what the problem is the problem is when you make claims outside of
[1:18:56] well wait a second i'm just questioning evidence here i'm just questioning what the state's case is
[1:19:01] here i'm just asking questions it's when you make claims outside of that where you claim that
[1:19:06] there's good evidence or good standards you should believe because and then it turns out that it's
[1:19:12] all nonsense or it's wackadoo stuff or it it makes no sense and when we have a chance to cross-examine
[1:19:18] your evidence that you've presented i'm going to show a lot of that a lot of this conjecture that's
[1:19:23] based on literally nothing that leads from no inferences whatsoever like you couldn't even infer it
[1:19:30] logically that's the problem the problem has never been whether or not you just said
[1:19:35] you know there's not enough in this case so far until we get to the trial i remain unconvinced
[1:19:40] i'm sure there's tons of people who remain unconvinced yet until we get to the trial
[1:19:44] i think that's fine i think it's fine there's people who are convinced too that's never been
[1:19:49] my problem my problem is the claims which are external to that okay um i'm not sure i really care
[1:19:57] if you have a problem with what i think in my own spare time i don't understand this like lecture
[1:20:02] that you just gave um but beyond that what i'm saying is that the state is allowed to use this
[1:20:06] is what my problem is you guys are not like yeah you guys think while it's still legal you actually
[1:20:11] you can you are allowed to do that so um but anyway going back going back to you saying i wouldn't
[1:20:16] have a problem i think i just demonstrated pretty thoroughly that what you claim that you have a
[1:20:22] problem with is exactly what the state is engaged in at this stage so it doesn't make it just doesn't
[1:20:26] make sense that's not the case in fact so if people look and they say i'm looking at the gun and i see
[1:20:32] and i'm inferring this and someone else says i'm looking at the gun evidence and i'm inferring that
[1:20:37] they're both doing the exact same thing they're not you're just saying i want to do it for the state
[1:20:40] that's propositionally false i'll explain exactly how it is the case that every proposition is going to
[1:20:47] have a true or false conclusion period that's just logic right it's the law of excluded middle
[1:20:54] all propositions are going to be true or they're going to be false when we get into when we're
[1:20:59] making inferences we're making inferences based on on propositions we can make we can actually come
[1:21:04] to true conclusions with false uh premises inside of a proposition in fact what we're talking about
[1:21:10] here is not whether or not you feel that you're convinced by this evidence that you felt like you
[1:21:15] were right sure but here's the thing when you ask me my reason andrew why are you convinced by this
[1:21:20] i can give you my reasons why i'm convinced by it why it seems reasonable and rational to me to be
[1:21:24] convinced you could even say but andrew i'm just not convinced by it if that was the limitation of
[1:21:30] your claims we wouldn't even be having this conversation that's why i wanted to have the
[1:21:35] conversation in fact was so that we could move into your actual claims that you've made which
[1:21:41] transcend the idea of i'm just asking questions before we get into that your team has one thing
[1:21:46] they want to show before you go into that so if you want to pull that up this is the prosecution
[1:21:51] filing showing defense had full discovery by april 1st they did not that's not true wait a second
[1:21:58] yeah to date the state's prosecutors have disclosed all evidence that is presently and reasonably
[1:22:04] available to them as required under rule 16 utah are criminal to be more precise as of april 1st yeah
[1:22:11] that was that was not that was not 100 that's why that they're caging that by saying what's
[1:22:15] reasonable there was i mean there was an entire and we can pull this up like we should now play the
[1:22:19] kathy nester clip because that that's from there so and they were basically saying you don't need it
[1:22:23] at this stage meaning it's re it's not reasonable that you're asking for this when we're going into
[1:22:28] a hearing that's just going to be based on hearsay and stuff with things of that nature but of course
[1:22:32] by the time a trial comes you're going to get all the discovery show cause yes yeah so that's what
[1:22:36] they're saying yeah i understand okay so that's not even and i'm even fine with yeah we all we all
[1:22:41] know and then by the way just now that the hearing is over and you can also fact check this they now
[1:22:46] at the at the end of the preliminary hearing dropped like an insane amount of the discovery
[1:22:51] stuff they gave to them like the week after you guys can give me the exact amount i don't want to
[1:22:54] say because i don't know my uh um i don't remember how much it was an absurd amount of stuff that they
[1:22:59] gave to them right after the preliminary hearing that they had been asking for because that was one of
[1:23:02] the things that i kept saying on my show is as we were watching that preliminary of the preliminary
[1:23:07] why not just give them the stuff now so they can engage in these arguments as i feel like you it's
[1:23:10] like i want to hear what they have to say about the tech messages i want why can't you just give them
[1:23:14] what they're asking for so that they can actually engage you and uh it didn't happen so but the judge
[1:23:20] ruled that it wasn't necessary at this stage and that was the whole point of that uh because it's
[1:23:25] preliminary to the preliminary yeah would you like to play the kathy video uh well he's saying he's not
[1:23:30] disagreeing so i don't think we need to yeah there's no disagreement that she said that yeah
[1:23:34] so um the yeah so i guess yeah the disagreements now would move into the evidences that you
[1:23:40] have stated on the record which transcend elements of reason why are we having a transcendental
[1:23:49] conversation now because i mean because your entire thing was about looking at the evidence which never
[1:23:56] made sense to me again because all of the evidence that you felt to be overwhelming was here
[1:23:59] say that was bizarre to me you told me that i could take as much time as i wanted to question
[1:24:03] you no but i'm just asking you to just to lay the groundwork of what you're saying is because
[1:24:07] you've made many claims that it trips into something else and i do still want to hold you
[1:24:11] for going through because we've discussed the gun we've discussed your um you can hold me to
[1:24:15] those things but i would like to get into the things we should discuss the screwdrivers so and
[1:24:18] i'll explain exactly what the groundwork is when you make claims which pass the idea of i'm just
[1:24:23] asking questions because the state's evidence is not convincing i think you have to answer for those claims
[1:24:28] because they are in regards to this case you're saying i have a claim it is in regards to the
[1:24:33] assassination of charlie kirk which is what we're talking about not just the case of charlie kirk
[1:24:37] is assassination you should have to answer for the claims that you've made in regards to the
[1:24:43] assassination itself you should yeah agreed so if that's the case then i would i would like to finally
[1:24:49] dive into some of that evidence and dive into it just to be clear and i'm happy to have you talk about
[1:24:56] like i said publicly you want to engage in some conspiracies but i said i want to make sure that
[1:25:00] we get to the substance of our debate the substance of our debate this is the major
[1:25:03] substance demonstrating that all of the quote-unquote evidence that you feel that you have
[1:25:09] which demonstrates that tyler robinson i mean the tyler robinson shot charlie kirk you don't find
[1:25:13] convincing i get it it's well it's been invalidated by the by the testimony that we saw and in your
[1:25:18] answer for when i explained to you that he had the most degraded prints was i don't know okay well there then
[1:25:23] there lies my ability to process that it's just fine for you to not be convinced up to this point
[1:25:32] all of your viewers everybody watching nobody's giving you're conceding nobody's giving a dispute
[1:25:37] that if all your claims ever were were just up to now the evidence that the state's given i'm just kind
[1:25:44] of not convinced that is not what's been happening what's actually been happening is that you've made
[1:25:49] tons of claims uh in regards to this case and in regards to the kirk assassination which are far
[1:25:56] above and beyond i just doubt the state's theory okay yeah i mean sure those are the things i do
[1:26:03] doubt the state's theory i also am welcome to say what i think you know if you want to move into opinions
[1:26:09] if you want to talk about erica kirk if you want to talk about turning point usa like to talk about all
[1:26:13] and get into it i'm totally happy to do that but i just want to say that like i do not feel because i've
[1:26:18] said what's important to me is that we exhaust this topic first of our actual debate claims i do
[1:26:24] not feel that you sufficiently have argued that the evidence is overwhelming sorry question for
[1:26:29] you but i am sorry you feel that way candace one question what what evidence do you need to see
[1:26:35] for you to say tyler robinson killed charlie kirk that's a great question um so i actually expected
[1:26:41] in this preliminary hearing actually the almost the in inverse of what he was saying is true right
[1:26:47] so the this is now the time the state is putting on their evidence that's the purpose of this
[1:26:51] hearing right the state is using hearsay but they're also putting on their evidence so i was just
[1:26:55] expecting some sort of a slam dunk like we got him on camera taking the shot we at least we have
[1:26:59] them clear on camera you're telling me this guy drove 13 hours all around like we can definitely show
[1:27:04] you a picture that it's going to be beyond a reasonable doubt before we even get to the trial people
[1:27:08] they're going to see and go oh crap like it was really tyler robinson um i was expecting to at
[1:27:12] least see evidence that because i had reported early on that uh the source was saying that tyler
[1:27:20] did not step foot on campus that day it is my perspective that he had something to do with
[1:27:24] something i i do believe he was putting like disposing clothes at this stage at this phase i do
[1:27:29] believe he was disposing clothes he was involved somehow um i i find lance to be more uh suspicious
[1:27:35] if i'm being honest with you uh and also like i said the use immunity that was given to lance by
[1:27:41] the feds the fact that the feds didn't ask him any questions the fact that i spoke with lance twigs's
[1:27:45] family and they were like it's very weird that the feds are not asking him more questions he's
[1:27:50] exactly the person um that i would imagine to be involved in some stuff allegedly i'll say allegedly
[1:27:56] uh but uh when we got to the preliminary hearing there was no there was not a single piece of
[1:28:01] evidence that i felt was slam dunk i was waiting for that a photo i mean anything would have made me
[1:28:05] go all right i think this this could be the guy uh if they had handed over the discovery on the
[1:28:10] text messages since that was their big ta-da we've got the text messages that would be the first thing
[1:28:15] that i would hand over but actually who was holding them up like i said it wasn't the prosecution
[1:28:18] they're right to say we we were handing things over and we heard the defense argue on behalf of
[1:28:24] the prosecution saying it's not them and it's not the sbi it's the fbi that's holding on to things
[1:28:29] is the fbi took everything the fbi took the gun the fbi took initially the screwdriver and then
[1:28:35] when i heard testimony about the things that they didn't that they found that were suspicious
[1:28:39] example being the backpack that's something that really bothers me uh that they say they traced
[1:28:45] the shooter they traced the route that he went on and then there wasn't a band we know it looks
[1:28:49] like he's wearing some sort of a backpack we know that there was an abandoned backpack found at the
[1:28:54] bus stop in front of a library and they felt that this should be taken into evidence they took it
[1:29:00] uh the fbi this was the testimony of amanda baker i believe her last name is but you might want to
[1:29:06] fact check that because i think i'm blending last names uh she's so she was the forensics for the fbi
[1:29:11] and then she says she gets a call on the 13th and they stopped testing on this backpack because they
[1:29:18] find that the backpack actually belongs to somebody on charlie's team but if you know the map the layout
[1:29:24] of the campus you're going well what the hell are they doing all the way up this is nowhere near
[1:29:28] anywhere and by the way that's not an acceptable answer for why you just gave it back that's not
[1:29:33] that's like why would you give it back you're acting like no one's ever been killed by somebody
[1:29:36] on their team before right so i found that to be very strange that it was on the exact route that the
[1:29:41] that the alleged gunmen ran and that their excuse was we just gave it back because we heard that this
[1:29:46] was some this belonged to somebody on charlie's team so that to me is you know this is why the
[1:29:52] the investigation itself feels underwhelming when you learn and this is completely crazy to me that
[1:30:00] the some of the artifacts that charlie was wearing were immediately returned to erica that's absurd
[1:30:06] that is absurd everything should be in evidence when you learn that the car that they carried charlie
[1:30:12] in to go to the hospital they had immediately towed cleaned and back up for resale that's absurd that
[1:30:19] should be sitting in evidence and any police officer that you speak to will say or a person
[1:30:22] that's been involved in a crime will say i didn't get my stuff back for years had nothing to do with
[1:30:26] anything it was just around and i and they kept it into evidence until the trial was over and it has
[1:30:31] to be approved i think somebody said by the attorney general has to sign off on giving you those objects
[1:30:35] back and we were told this is all fine and we see this is just one example erica holding the
[1:30:42] uh crucifix uh that's that should be an evidence irrespective if you feel bad for her and think she
[1:30:49] should have you know hold have it and it's sweet that should be an evidence uh immediately paving
[1:30:54] over the crime scene is this is like the craziest thing ever your is like defies common sense you
[1:30:59] immediately and when you heard the guy who did it actually go up on a podcast and explain i got the
[1:31:05] call they said it was a paver emergency i don't i've never in my entire career heard of a paver emergency
[1:31:11] they had already had someone come up and dig up the dirt so by the time he got there on sunday
[1:31:17] the dirt had already been dug up for him to lay down pavers that is what people are looking at and
[1:31:22] going this is weird there needs to be answers for why this was done and he tells us the call came from
[1:31:27] the feds and the governor's office uvus washed their hands of it and what he's saying sounds true
[1:31:33] because we heard during the testimony uh one person described the regions of who was in control of
[1:31:38] everything the feds were in control of the courtyard so in order for anybody to have paid anything
[1:31:42] that was federal territory so to speak i'm maybe not using that in the best cop term but the feds
[1:31:47] were in control of the courtyard so these are things that i think should be answered for why why are we
[1:31:54] doing things differently than you would in any other criminal scenario of keeping the evidence until
[1:32:00] we know more until we're confident uh you know the various decoys i did it i did it it just doesn't
[1:32:06] look right okay so go back to the question so what would you need to see for you to say
[1:32:12] something if they had i was expecting here we have him he took the shot here it is and then i'd be like
[1:32:16] great a clear image of him on the staircase where i'm like that's definitively tyler robinson and he
[1:32:19] was on campus we got nothing we got literally nothing but hearsay of people saying but you basically get no
[1:32:26] case what you know you basically no case on planet earth do you get that sure oh we got a picture
[1:32:32] here's him taking the shot most most of this doesn't take place on a college campus that has
[1:32:35] surveillance everywhere yeah one clear image of his but i don't understand when you're asked if you're
[1:32:41] asked the question what would it take to convince it'd be the same question be asked to me andrew what
[1:32:46] would take to convince you that the oppositionals right that he's a patsy or something like that
[1:32:53] just good clear concise evidence that's been presented right and is being presented that i
[1:32:58] could go through and link all together to see if there's actually some clear picture of there being
[1:33:04] a patsy that's what it would take for me okay just a good i don't disagree just we haven't heard the
[1:33:08] defense just a good evidentiary standard and then of course i would change my mind so so just to
[1:33:15] qualify this so there is a possibility in the next few months that you may come out and say guys it's
[1:33:19] done tyler killed him so you're saying yesterday yeah i think it's very important for the audience
[1:33:23] here that for without question for you is there anything that you could see for you to say yeah
[1:33:27] this guy was a pass of the government of course i'm gonna always follow evidence perfect so my my whole
[1:33:32] thing is just this it's really important to me i don't mind people being truth seekers and justice
[1:33:39] searchers and the internet has helped solve tons of crimes there's no if answer buts about that
[1:33:45] right however there's also people who you know they they not only don't solve crimes but they just
[1:33:51] come up with conjecture and they what's called flooding the zone you flood the zone with tons and
[1:33:56] tons of conspiracy-based ideas and they go nowhere right and in fact they actually take away from a
[1:34:02] legitimate investigation now i'm not even saying anybody here's purposely flooding the zone that's not
[1:34:07] even the claim all i'm saying is is that the claims made absent absent oh uh this is just me
[1:34:16] not being convinced by the state's evidence those become claims and claims have to be defended
[1:34:21] just like mine have to be defended yours have to be defended and that's what we're going to get to
[1:34:25] now yeah you want to get into it would you guys like to take an ad break we'll take an ad break
[1:34:30] and then we'll talk erica kirk and tp usa and cons and the conspiracies that have been conjectured by
[1:34:36] candace owens in regards to this case and charlie perfect folks we'll take a three and a half minute
[1:34:40] break and we'll be back soon all right you guys you have probably seen all the buzz around red light
[1:34:46] therapy lately but what's even more compelling are the stories from people who say completely
[1:34:50] changed their lives one example starts with a woman named natalia she sat across from her
[1:34:55] medical team and got an ultimatum most of us will never have to hear aggressive chemotherapy steroids
[1:35:01] for life or amputation five years earlier a plate of ceviche in peru triggered heavy metal toxins and
[1:35:07] parasites that she never recovered from 20 specialists and hundreds of thousands of dollars later nobody
[1:35:12] addressed the cause just the symptoms with the support of medical journalist jonathan otto she
[1:35:17] refused all three and went after the root cause instead purging parasites binding heavy metals and
[1:35:22] restoring her gut health today she runs swims and cycles on the same legs that she was told that she
[1:35:28] would lose right now you can get the same holistic detox cleanse that she used plus a red life therapy
[1:35:33] belt completely free with every order not discounted free 120 leds red and near infrared working from the
[1:35:41] surface down to the gut and thyroid head to purge my parasites now.com candace buy your detox and
[1:35:48] gut renewal restoration bundle today and get your free red life therapy belt plus your in-depth
[1:35:53] protocol that's purge my parasites now.com candace i also remind you guys about pure talk because you
[1:35:59] do not have to overpay for your wireless network not when pure talk comes in with the same service for
[1:36:04] a tiny fraction of the cost and now for the first time ever pure talk is offering any plan at just
[1:36:08] 15 a month for your first three months there's never been a better time to take pure talk for
[1:36:12] a test drive it's fast it's reliable and you're going to love it you can now get any pure talk
[1:36:17] plan including their unlimited data plans and even their top tier 65 dollar plan for just 15 a month
[1:36:23] for your first three months that's a savings of up to 150 i recommend making the switch today
[1:36:28] because this offer is extremely short-lived switch to pure talk and enjoy your first three months of
[1:36:32] talk text and data for just 15 bucks a month head to puretalk.com owens to make the switch to pure
[1:36:38] talk again that's puretalk.com owens to start saving today and i have to remind you guys about
[1:36:43] american financing because everyday expenses keep climbing and high credit card interest is not making
[1:36:48] life any easier if your budget is feeling squeezed lately there's a smarter way to take back control
[1:36:53] if you're a homeowner your home equity is your best financial tool american financing can help you
[1:36:58] consolidate high interest credit card debts that you have some breathing room timing matters now
[1:37:02] more than ever with a strong chance of an interest rate hike this september waiting could cost you
[1:37:07] thousands and with rates in the fives there's no better time to find out how much you could be saving
[1:37:12] so ditch those 20 interest rates by consolidating you can slash your monthly obligations in fact american
[1:37:17] financing borrowers save an average of 800 a month imagine what that kind of cash flow could do for
[1:37:23] your family there are zero upfront fees and you may even delay up to two mortgage payments to lock in
[1:37:28] your lower rate before september call 800-795-1210 again that's 800-795-1210 or visit americanfinancing.net
[1:37:38] owens that's americanfinancing.net owens okay so we're officially back uh andrew before we go into the
[1:37:45] other issues you want to talk about is it fair to say you're good defending your position of the overwhelming
[1:37:50] evidence yeah okay beautiful you take the lead go for it yeah so i have a bunch of questions for you
[1:37:57] and i want to make it super painless right so uh no traps no gotchas i'm just going to ask them direct
[1:38:05] and i think that as long as they're not loaded if they're loaded you should not respond yes or no but
[1:38:10] as long as they're not loaded if i just directly ask them i'm hoping that you'll just give me a direct
[1:38:14] answer so here's the questions that i have wait before we get into that i would like to just reply to that
[1:38:20] so just to be clear we agreed to debate our claims and then i agreed publicly that i have no issues
[1:38:26] having a conversation with you about other things that i've discussed that were outside of the court
[1:38:30] hearing and things like other evidence that's come across our lap and things that we've been speaking
[1:38:34] about but i just do want to make it clear to viewers that for whatever reason you think that
[1:38:40] you have a right to sort of depose me i'm not opposing you i just want to ask you but you literally
[1:38:46] said that i want to be able to question you this is a meta meta conversation right but okay so now
[1:38:51] we're transcending like i used to use a word to use a word that you're saying but this is but this
[1:38:56] is what you're doing right so this this part to me feels like a bit am i allowed to ask the questions
[1:39:01] i'm going i've already said you can ask questions but i made it very clear to you
[1:39:05] yeah via email and with you in conversation that we should be speaking this isn't like i want to
[1:39:12] i want to ask if you want to depose me you should join i'm not opposing you defense team but you're
[1:39:17] like this is a legitimate can you answer it blah blah it's like i don't know what you're going to
[1:39:21] ask i know and if you have issues with it because i'm not i get it yeah i get it just so we're clear
[1:39:26] usually in in the debate if something's not loaded i'm just direct because you kept saying i'm joe rogan
[1:39:30] they have no evidence they have no evidence and now you're like let's move away from the evidence
[1:39:35] yeah okay anyway so direct question super easy was lance twigs dna on the rifle as far as you know
[1:39:41] we can't say that for sure as far as you know i already answered that in the first part we can't
[1:39:45] say that for certainty i told you the context of which they spoke about those things so no as far
[1:39:50] as you know we can't say that for certainty until we know what other the five sets of prints so that
[1:39:54] would be no as far as you know we can't say that for certainty you can say no as far as i know for
[1:39:59] certain uh we can't say that for certainty actually you can say that for certainty if you're if your energy
[1:40:05] here is going to be like you're my dad and you can tell me how to speak or what i'm supposed to say
[1:40:09] you're you're you're just going to come against the wall i i'm familiar with this debate strategy
[1:40:13] but i am just yes or no yes or no we're not debating anymore we're having a conversation so
[1:40:17] i already addressed that in the first half of this about why no we're still definitely debating
[1:40:21] this is still no it's not a debate this is inclined to you saying i want to probe things
[1:40:26] that sit outside of the evidence i actually already addressed this you asked me you're not
[1:40:31] going to go like where you're you're sitting and i'm on trial i'm not on trial okay great
[1:40:38] let's talk about the foreign legion sure it was a foreign legion do you believe trying to kill you
[1:40:43] yes that's why i reported it to the correct officials in government that's what i was told and
[1:40:48] i handed over that information to tulsi gabbard's office what's your best piece of evidence for that
[1:40:54] well it was positive evidence it was told to me by somebody who is high up in the french government
[1:41:02] i passed off that information to tulsi gabbard's office i also passed it off to trump's office
[1:41:06] don trump's office um and that's all i can tell you i wouldn't be able to probe any evidence because
[1:41:11] i don't have the power to do that i'm not the federal government and i would also like to say
[1:41:14] that this becomes this this other piece of what you do which is when people say this i was told
[1:41:20] this and this is the evidence that i have and i'm willing to have that conversation and write the
[1:41:23] email to the correct government body that deals with this like i can't hack into emmanuel macron's
[1:41:29] bank accounts and say whether or not the information but then you go well where's your evidence it's like
[1:41:34] well my evidence is that i reported it i did the right thing that you're going to do so if somebody
[1:41:37] calls and says hey andrew there's a viable death threat against you and that person definitively has the
[1:41:42] rank to be able to tell you this and you say well what i'm going to do now is i'm going to report
[1:41:46] that to the feds then i go what's your evidence it's like well i got the information and i gave
[1:41:50] the information that i got from who i got it to the right body of people and that's what i did got
[1:41:55] it i just i just want to make sure i'm not trying to trap you i just want to make sure and that's why
[1:41:59] i said i want to know what you're doing now because this has always been the thing it's like we actually
[1:42:03] can't win on the overwhelming claim so we're just going to go and bring up everything that i think can
[1:42:07] try to embarrass her i reported exactly i'm not trying to embarrass you i just want to make sure that i get
[1:42:12] your position i have not said yeah go ahead now you have stated multiple times that you believe
[1:42:17] that israel's involved in the death of charlie kirk can you yes we can pull up the clip i'm sorry
[1:42:23] i'm just saying can i finish the sentence go ahead can you give me the context for what you're are you
[1:42:29] talking about like when i say generally speaking my people think that israel is involved okay where's
[1:42:34] your question yeah do you have any positive evidence whatsoever that israel killed charlie kirk
[1:42:39] well i couldn't say israel was on the ground and shot and killed charlie kirk i would say that
[1:42:43] there are various things that we're trying to establish one being a motive and since i don't
[1:42:48] believe that tyler robinson and his transfery uh is a convincing motive uh because he was fired up
[1:42:56] about politics which lance testified that he never spoke about with him nor do i believe that he was
[1:43:02] you know so into lgbtq issues since lance testified they never spoke about lgbtq issues that he stopped and
[1:43:08] ate at chick-fil-a which if you are into lgbtq issues wouldn't be your lunch before you go kill
[1:43:12] charlie kirk for lgbtq issues uh because you know yeah but do you have positive evidence i'm i'm i'm
[1:43:18] answering the question as i feel like i want to answer it like i said you don't get to for an hour
[1:43:22] and a half but the question i'm asking is about positive i'm telling you that in any case establishing
[1:43:27] a motive and what i and again i already explained this at the top of the show but the reason why people
[1:43:33] find israel to be an interesting question is because truthfully charlie's perspectives
[1:43:38] were changing on israel sure and he was starting to realize how much pressure was being put on not
[1:43:42] just our government uh to constantly fight their wars but also being put on his organization
[1:43:48] personally if people had come out and been honest about that uh rather than rabid claiming he never
[1:43:54] flinched and everybody's lying and this is not true you would probably have people that just go
[1:44:00] yeah that's life people change their opinions i understand and then there was the rabid i mean
[1:44:05] not even that's like everything was about trying to convince the public how much he liked it so then
[1:44:08] other than intuition how you feel about things do you have any evidence israel i i was involved in
[1:44:13] killing charlie kirk i have already said and if you're watching my show and the context of what i said
[1:44:18] this is the general sense of why people think israel's involved we don't nobody has made the claim
[1:44:23] that is israelis there were also you know obviously joe kent made the claim well joe kent who i i think would
[1:44:30] have the right to assert it noted that there were 12 israeli cell phones on the ground that day i
[1:44:35] think most people would like to probe that now it could be maybe they were students you know and
[1:44:39] they were israeli students in utah that day but we'd like to probe that narrative because what we've seen
[1:44:45] after coming from the israeli government the israeli prime minister uh kind of denying that he did it
[1:44:50] which wasn't really necessary was quite busy uh the phone call that happened which no one wants to
[1:44:55] discuss in the hamptons the week prior uh or not the week prior i think it was around august 5th or
[1:45:01] 6th that took place and again the almost desperate lies about charlie shifting opinion on israel
[1:45:08] lead us to believe that there could be an israeli angle in this uh but we cannot say for certainty
[1:45:14] that israel called the shots and this is how it happened but it is definitively i think a thread
[1:45:19] that a lot of us would like to say there's no positive evidence i i whatever you want to say
[1:45:23] however positive negative however you want to say it i don't like positive evidence just have a
[1:45:27] conversation material evidence and other evidences which what we've said is on our show is what we've
[1:45:33] said which is we this feels like a conspiracy building there's no reason to lie about these things
[1:45:40] and yet people are lying uh bb ain't acting right the hamptons thing was weird and the way they tried to
[1:45:46] shove the israel israel narrative down our throat immediately i mean the day he died posting a
[1:45:52] picture of him with an american and israeli ai photo on the president's feed doesn't feel right
[1:45:57] do you have any evidence that erica kirk or tp usa participated in the murder of charlie kirk i've never
[1:46:02] said they participated in the murder of charlie kirk so how could i say that i have evidence they
[1:46:06] participated in the murder of charlie kirk okay so then you don't believe that they did i never have
[1:46:12] said that statement so i'm not going to get you to ask me personal questions about things that i've
[1:46:17] never said on record okay your team is sending messages in the back saying they have a video
[1:46:21] they want to play okay go ahead i don't know what the video is if you're yes you said that there's a
[1:46:34] video you want to play that candace said she has full confidence israel was involved yep yeah he said
[1:46:42] evidence that i that they killed him i said they're this is why people think they're involvement involvement
[1:46:47] if they have the clip they can play the clip yeah they're referring to a clip yeah via who my guess
[1:46:58] is pierre erica i think that there's a reason pierre knew that charlie was dead first i think
[1:47:04] there's a reason he was a priority how why i think france and israel are involved in charlie kirk's
[1:47:11] assassination and um i'm going to put that out there with full confidence okay also involvement i
[1:47:18] understand yeah so you think you you with full confidence you think that yeah i think is yeah i mean
[1:47:25] the person that gave me that thing that i reported said that uh french foreign legion were on the
[1:47:29] ground that day again this would be this would be at a professional limitation for me to then go
[1:47:34] and probe that information that i handed over i can't do that i'm not but you don't have any
[1:47:38] positive evidence okay okay i don't you can you just stop it's it's actually just like annoying to
[1:47:42] hear you keep saying positive evidence i've just asked me what i think i just tell you yes i think
[1:47:48] they are that's a claim no i said here's what here's what i think i have every right to ask you about
[1:47:54] your claim yeah but if there's positive evidence for your statement i literally just said i think
[1:47:58] and i am allowed to think yeah you're allowed to think but you're making a claim i have tons
[1:48:03] of positive evidence that i'm allowed to think i i agree you're allowed to think okay nobody's
[1:48:07] disputing whether or not what i'm asking is if but you have what's your issue then what is your
[1:48:12] issue with this evidence i think uh-huh that israel is involved that's not what that's not just what
[1:48:18] you said you said that it's with it's with full confidence yes then i think that if you had full
[1:48:24] confidence to think when you think if but if you if i said for instance i think i'm going to be late
[1:48:30] to work right with full confidence i would say my evidence for that is that i'm 20 minutes away and
[1:48:35] i need to be there five andrew that's how you would know whether or not you have something let me
[1:48:40] finish let me finish let me finish if it was the case that i said i have full confidence i'm going to be
[1:48:45] late to work i would say my evidence i'm going to be is that work is 20 minutes away right and i have
[1:48:50] to be there in five so i have full confidence that's why i would think that so i'm asking if
[1:48:55] you think that israel and france were involved in the assassination of charlie kirk and you say
[1:48:59] with full confidence i'm just asking for the evidence or at least walk me through the mindset
[1:49:05] of why it is that you could think that with actually don't have to walk you through why i think
[1:49:09] um i can also i can give you something that i think with full confidence i think with full confidence
[1:49:13] that you know you lost the substance of this debate and now you're moving toward things that
[1:49:17] i have said that i think which i can do i'm a lot pertinent to this debate that it's not exactly
[1:49:22] pertinent to this it's not pertinent because these are claims made made about charlie kirk's
[1:49:27] assassination that's the complete substance of the debate no actually would you like to remind him of
[1:49:32] what our debate claims actually were and would you like to remind that you said i could ask you about
[1:49:35] any of these things to my heart's content but you didn't you do not get to structure how i'm
[1:49:39] allowed to reply or ask me why are you structuring how you're allowed to reply i'm just asking you
[1:49:43] direct questions my i have full confidence that you do not feel that you represented your claim well
[1:49:50] and so now what you came prepared to do is to present yourself like a professor of fallacies
[1:49:55] i just want to know and to say you are not allowed to say that you can't you can say whatever you want
[1:50:00] well nobody's disputing that it seems like you are just i'm asking specifically why you think that i've
[1:50:05] already explained to you i explained at the beginning of this why i think israel is is ultimately
[1:50:10] going to be proven to have involvement in this um i just explained to you in the middle and now
[1:50:15] you're wanting me to structure the sentence or provide evidence you don't have to you're just
[1:50:19] allowed to think and i've explained to you my thought process i don't need to structure it in a
[1:50:24] sentence if you feel like a professor today you picked the wrong day don't you think that like
[1:50:28] tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people would want to know what candace owens positive
[1:50:33] evidence for why it is no that israel and france were involved in the most traumatic public
[1:50:39] assassination of gen z's lifetime is that's why they watch my podcast so you're just going to drip to
[1:50:44] them like here's why every time we come across any of these discussions they're watching this in
[1:50:50] context and they know why i'm saying it so for example when you're bringing up what candace where's
[1:50:56] your evidence for france doing this i just told you someone who was high ranking in the french
[1:51:00] government right who's nameless of course of course of course but so there's good reason to doubt
[1:51:06] conspiracy though if i then took it to the federal government like you can't just go out there making
[1:51:10] a claim to the federal government you get in trouble for making false statements and things of that
[1:51:13] nature so and then you go well i'm going to probe that well how can you probe that this happens i can
[1:51:18] ask you well that's not what i'm probing specifically this is my podcast i am sharing my life and my
[1:51:22] experiences and what has happened to me and you're basically coming in like you're gonna what regulate
[1:51:27] when i how i'm allowed to say it if i'm not trying to regulate anything i'm asking a bit like a
[1:51:32] professor trying to regulate and say candace you sound very defensive and like you just don't want
[1:51:37] to answer questions i i i did answer your question three times i just didn't say it in the way that
[1:51:41] you wanted to just kind of obfuscate and you run away from it but i would like for you to actually
[1:51:44] go through every clip that you guys have prepared because i it's pretty i i i think with full confidence
[1:51:50] people will recognize the strategy that you're trying to employ so let's get to the next clip you have
[1:51:54] prepared sure they can pull up whatever whatever it is that you guys have prepared but there but i
[1:51:59] would still i on this point i just want to make sure that you have full confidence that france and
[1:52:04] israel were involved in the assassination of charlie kirk i think and you have no evidence for it at
[1:52:08] all that you'll give us well the hi i i already did tell you where it came from like i said i can
[1:52:14] explain it to you i can't understand that same higher up tell you that he was going to kill that
[1:52:18] france killed charlie kirk or just that you were in danger they said that the french foreign legion was
[1:52:23] involved and on the ground that day i've already said that you just don't like hearing it no and
[1:52:27] it's just out of curiosity when you uh pass down that message to a tulsi or trump tulsi's office yes
[1:52:33] tulsi's office are you giving them who told you that or you're just saying here's what i heard from
[1:52:40] and i have this and i have this information and of course if they wanted to open a file on it which i
[1:52:44] thought was quite mysterious that trump's office never got back to us it was kind of weird about like
[1:52:50] from maybe that maybe they're not the correct office too i did receive a response from uh tulsi
[1:52:55] gabbard's office but i i don't think there was ever any investigation into what i said so the call was
[1:53:01] hey i've been told some the email yes email was i've been told i have information yeah that that that
[1:53:08] the french foreign legion was on the ground during charlie's assassination um uh and that i mean it was a
[1:53:16] a lot of information but you didn't give specifics who it was from not in the first email because i
[1:53:20] figured they would like perfect so if they do contact you 100 are you comfortable giving a
[1:53:25] hundred percent who it is i would absolutely give them as much information as possible if whoever's
[1:53:31] the u.s government why are you not yes it's very strange to me you know so if that's the case now
[1:53:37] they may respond back and say we did you know that's their position that's why i did it in writing
[1:53:41] and so i'm glad that's the case because so so if they and right away in trump's office his like
[1:53:47] margot got right back to me she said it was on his desk so he has that there's no and if you do
[1:53:52] say that and they contact that individual obviously you don't have to leak your sources here is there
[1:53:58] enough credibility where that person would be willing to talk to them and explain to them exactly what
[1:54:02] their sources yes okay i mean that's it seems reasonable and so why he's asking me to defend that
[1:54:07] is like i'm not i think those are two different things that's more something i'm only different
[1:54:11] claims why are they not reaching out to you i've asked that many times on my podcast what do you
[1:54:16] think about that andrew what the fact that she emailed she gave it and nobody reached out to want
[1:54:22] to contact the source probably didn't think it was actionable that's my guess but even if they did
[1:54:27] think it was actionable great every lead should be followed up on within the confines of what's
[1:54:32] rational and reasonable is it fair to say that this is maybe a different individual because this is a
[1:54:37] person that was involved with tpus and had a relationship with charlie no no her relationship
[1:54:43] like this isn't just anybody so if an average person sends it yeah yeah but i mean we don't
[1:54:48] know who the source is we don't know any of this if it wouldn't you if you were in that department
[1:54:54] wouldn't you want to even you assign it to one of your guys there's no guarantee they didn't look
[1:54:58] into it how do we know we don't know how could they didn't come get the information more of the
[1:55:04] information because it was a long file yeah this is a separate this has got nothing to do with the
[1:55:08] debate this is more on on uh well i just i sent the email assuming that you kept saying you go and you
[1:55:13] you make a report you think they're going to come back to you and say hey what's more information
[1:55:18] we're investigating this and that didn't happen and which is what i raised i'm asking did you
[1:55:21] especially because this was at a time where they were saying that they wanted to explore every
[1:55:25] possible lead with i even texted dan bongino but so actually it was three it was three offices let me
[1:55:30] ask the executive office dan bongino and uh the and tulsi gabbard's office okay so a follow-up to
[1:55:38] that is the following if they contact you to say is that specifically to the french government or
[1:55:45] israel's involvement in the killing of it wasn't that wasn't about israel separate things that wasn't
[1:55:49] about israel it was they were saying the french foreign that person as a part of it was saying that
[1:55:53] it was the french foreign legion that was on the ground that so i'm surprised i haven't called you
[1:55:56] then i find that to be very strange too i do as well because who would want to make a report like i
[1:56:00] mean i've never made a report with the federal government let me just ask one question let me
[1:56:04] just ask one question and i'm gonna bring it to you sure the question is in regards to i've not
[1:56:09] seen that clip so i'm seeing it now the full count i'm full confidence i believe that israel french
[1:56:14] was involved is that also based on a source that somebody told you that israel was involved in the
[1:56:22] assassination of charlie kirk or is that a gut feeling uh so in terms of israel i mean what i've said
[1:56:28] is what i publicly have said here i do think that at the end of this we are going to find that israel
[1:56:34] was involved i do uh now when in terms of any of the hard evidence that's been presented i think
[1:56:40] this has been a huge problem that a lot of us have had as have had is that they won't even explore um
[1:56:45] anything else that was going on charlie's life personally so if we're not satisfied that tyler
[1:56:49] robinson did this in any way then every alternative theory should be explored other evidence should be
[1:56:54] brought forward we've done that in our in our capacity like when people keep saying she has no
[1:56:57] evidence it's kind of crazy i think we've broken like more stories than any news source in the world
[1:57:02] i mean down to pictures details police officers uh what the dog's name was because we're not we're not
[1:57:07] the only people that believe there's a conspiracy here the police officers that are were involved the
[1:57:12] many police sheriff's offices um that were departments that were involved that day all believe
[1:57:19] there was a conspiracy down to the u.s marshals believe there's a conspiracy they were
[1:57:22] uh my sources at the u.s marshals were saying they were basically sent in a wild goose chase
[1:57:26] that day but do you see how you say my sources you're not allowed to have sources well the thing
[1:57:30] is funny we've seen a lot to have going on i have sources if i said i have sources that claim none of
[1:57:35] that's true in fact my sources claim that her sources are lying my sources claim that there is
[1:57:40] none of them believe that there's a conspiracy my sources claim all of them really think that tyler
[1:57:45] robinson was a lone gunman if i just said that as hypothetical wouldn't you say what yeah i think what
[1:57:51] probably adds weight is like then when i drop photos of the car that no one was supposed to see
[1:57:55] people go okay her sources are legit so um and then when what i say is then proven in court and
[1:58:00] nobody knew those things uh people are recognizing that my sources are legit when i say charlie uh was
[1:58:06] scared in the last days and then i dropped the text message which you've just learned about a couple
[1:58:10] of weeks ago of him saying he was leaving leaving the pro-israel cause when everyone was lying about that
[1:58:15] then they say i think cancer sources are legit so i think what's happened is i've actually built up a
[1:58:19] report with my audience that it's not vibes and dreams and that's why they keep watching my content
[1:58:24] because i like for example when i just the other day released the content of the shooter on the roof
[1:58:30] doing the lateral crawl then they're going i don't think these are just vibes it seems like cancer
[1:58:35] sources are legit so i've proven myself in the market yeah i'm not sure that that would legitimize
[1:58:39] your sources as being legitimate when it comes to the idea that oh they all believe that there's a
[1:58:44] conspiracy going on which is actually what your claim is now how would that actually hang on hang on i'm
[1:58:49] almost done how was that how would that legitimize well it's not his debate how would he how would
[1:58:55] it legitimize these sources that even if it's the case that you get some court footage or some things
[1:59:00] like this why would it legitimize that your sources are telling you all the marshals believe it's a
[1:59:05] conspiracy of the police believe it's a conspiracy everybody believes how would that legitimize what i
[1:59:10] am saying to you and you are not you are not forced to believe it so let me just explain what i was
[1:59:13] answering here and i think that you understood what i was saying um is i have because people
[1:59:19] trust me uh compiled a lot of information and presented it to the public and this information
[1:59:24] has been uh proven true we've presented photos we have presented videos never before seen stuff the
[1:59:30] public has never seen it and so what that does is your audience goes okay when she says that she has
[1:59:35] these sources clearly she's telling the truth now whether you would then go well i'm going to believe
[1:59:40] her when she says they don't believe they think that there's a conspiracy that's up to you you
[1:59:44] cannot watch my content i'm i'm not here to tell you that you have to watch my content or believe
[1:59:48] everything i'm saying well don't you think questioners should get questioned as well by who
[1:59:55] i'm not committing a crime am i am i just like well i mean collecting almost the people you ask
[2:00:00] questions of not actually committing crimes but what do you mean they should answer questions where like
[2:00:03] at a police station like what are you saying if you're if you want people to come in and answer
[2:00:08] questions for you i have questions about this in the investigation i have questions about this i have
[2:00:13] questions about that you want them to answer your questions doesn't it seem totally fair that you
[2:00:17] answer back the questions people have for you they're not answering our questions so it's also
[2:00:21] fair that they don't answer them so you're okay that's why i said andrew colvette should be in this
[2:00:25] chair he's not but isn't that a double standard no it's not because he's not doing it yeah but what
[2:00:30] that would still be a double standard if you're if you're requesting that he does do it then that seems
[2:00:34] to infer that you think he owes you answers oh so inferences are allowed again and they never
[2:00:38] weren't so that seems to infer that you think that he owes you answers if that's the case then
[2:00:42] don't you owe answers yeah well i feel like i'm answering your questions and his questions about
[2:00:48] i mean i'm talking about andrew cole that he is his position is he's a spokesperson for turning
[2:00:52] point usa so when the crowd turns against turning point usa on the basis of a lack of information
[2:00:59] or because there has been i don't know seeds sown of distrust i would imagine uh and forget
[2:01:06] answering my questions because i doesn't need to be me aren't you sowing a lot of those seeds
[2:01:09] of distrust well i i think they're doing a pretty good job themselves if i'm being honest uh you can
[2:01:13] blame it on candace all you want well i don't love to do that the thing is funny people act like i'm
[2:01:17] i'm around zero i'll be fair with you ground zero of people not trusting turning point usa i think that
[2:01:22] there was some pr there i think there was some pr there sure they could have done better absolutely i'm
[2:01:26] not disputing any of that one thing though that i am i i want to just directly ask you is do you
[2:01:33] actually believe that anybody in tp usa or erica kirk or erica actually participated had ford knowledge
[2:01:41] of or uh facilitated the murder of charlie kirk i'm not going to get myself into a legal pickle here
[2:01:48] everything i've said is on my podcast i i think i think firmly that if i was the investigating officers i
[2:01:57] would i would seat them all and i would ask questions i would at this phase i would okay
[2:02:03] what does that hypothetical does that mean that you do think so i i think it was not a sufficient
[2:02:08] investigation into what is what we know to be true of 80 percent of uh homicides it's usually
[2:02:16] conducted by someone you know right and the fact that that was never even considered that the like
[2:02:21] i said earlier the backpack was returned how do you know that was never considered because they gave
[2:02:26] back the backpack as just one example uh they gave back the backpack they gave back the um that
[2:02:33] doesn't show a conspiracy well i mean it shows that the police trusted everybody and didn't just hold
[2:02:38] things up for a second they ruled them out as suspects that quickly i i i'm not comfortable with
[2:02:43] that investigation it's a pretty big organization there's a hundred million dollar incentive people
[2:02:47] this is 100 million dollar incentive what i'm saying is his organization like they had grown to i think
[2:02:52] it was a hundred and a hundred plus per year yeah per year if that's something you want back
[2:02:56] your team wants to play video if you don't mind there's a there's a video they want to play of uh
[2:03:01] candace said it's impossible to not believe erica's complicit if you guys want to play that video
[2:03:06] yeah that's also just asking so right now their guys are going out and they're going to look for
[2:03:10] evidence and then by may which is fortunately around the corner then she'll see what they found so what the
[2:03:18] f is that performance how could you sit up there and say i i yes i 100 believe tyler robinson did it
[2:03:29] that right there is why it is impossible for me to think that erica kirk is not complicit somehow
[2:03:36] because what that those two thoughts actually don't even follow how would it be the case that even if
[2:03:42] erica kirk did believe that tyler robinson was a hundred percent responsible for the death of charlie
[2:03:48] kirk let's say she believed it with every fiber of her being believed all the evidence because she
[2:03:52] did she just actually did would it then follow that somehow she's complicit in his death i didn't say
[2:04:00] implicit in death you added those two words okay it's what's she complicit in yes so sewing this
[2:04:06] narrative that tyler robinson is guilty so you're chopping up clips like i said you didn't have the
[2:04:10] confidence okay well tell me what does that mean what does complicit mean we are showing a clip of
[2:04:14] her on barry weiss which i can't remember the date that she did that interview uh and erica when she is
[2:04:19] asked are you want you know do you do you feel with 100 certainty that tyler robinson did did this
[2:04:25] and she says i do then again context matters i sit down with erica for four hours under the assumption
[2:04:31] that she had some evidence right like i'm like i actually this is why i did not engage in any like
[2:04:37] erica everyone's questioning what she's wearing and all this stuff i was like i'm gonna wait here
[2:04:42] because i don't know just it feels weird to think that do i did i think that some of her mannerisms
[2:04:48] were weird and stuff like that yeah but that's not you can't convict somebody on weird mannerisms
[2:04:53] and then when i sat down with her and i was expecting for her to say well you know i'm
[2:04:59] obviously the victim on the case and we got to see the shot you know taken or this or that whatever it
[2:05:05] is great you know that's why she's being that's why she has that much confidence two months ago and
[2:05:10] when i sat down with her it was nothing it was nothing okay so this is a conversation how would that make
[2:05:16] her complicit complicit again you said complicit in the death of charlie kirk well if you let me
[2:05:24] finish my sentence i could tell you that but my point being is that then you take a look at this
[2:05:27] and you go okay well this is weird why why would you have this confidence and then when you sit across
[2:05:32] from somebody and you say okay great i want to go out there and defend you now i want people to know
[2:05:36] that you can't say this stuff publicly but you know more things and she just blanks and then she says
[2:05:41] well i'm going to call the lawyer and she called the lawyer again all this is on my show so out of
[2:05:46] context clips it's not going to work because i know what i say on my show so we call her lawyer
[2:05:49] and her lawyer says to us uh she calls him on the phone pardon me and uh it's me her and justin strife
[2:05:56] and he's i'm like okay great what do you guys have he goes well we don't have anything yet that's not
[2:06:01] we're not at that phase yet and i'm like well what do you mean you don't have anything and he says
[2:06:04] well don't you know how it works it's a probable cause hearing so basically the state says that
[2:06:09] they're going to bring this forward and now our people go out and they look for the evidence
[2:06:14] to uh assert that tyler robinson is guilty and so i asked her directly her lawyer directly the
[2:06:20] phones in between us i'm like wait so just so i'm clear you haven't seen anything that the public
[2:06:26] hasn't seen and he says no so i'm going back in my head and i'm going okay so why is erica saying
[2:06:33] with such a degree of certainty like she was sent out to convince the public and and people bit by
[2:06:38] the way i remember even megan kelly was like uh you know let's wait she's gonna have access to
[2:06:43] things i did think she had access things that we didn't have why express that confidence to
[2:06:47] the public as opposed to just being like we don't know yet i feel confident he's probably he's
[2:06:51] involved i don't understand how would any of this make her complicit and then what well i've already
[2:06:56] told you she was she's complicit in in trying to fool the public into thinking this is some open and
[2:07:01] shut how's she trying to fool the public into this if she believes like don't look anywhere else that
[2:07:06] charlotte that tyler robinson killed kirk if she believes that how would that be complicit in
[2:07:12] anything i i i do are you saying that you think she doesn't believe it i i don't believe that at
[2:07:17] that stage she sat down with barry weiss that that's what she believes no but that's my opinion
[2:07:21] right but so when you just say complicit you just mean she believes that tyler robinson killed kirk
[2:07:27] that's it that's what we were talking about that's why i said if your strategy was to dice
[2:07:31] up clips and take it out of context and make it yeah but then why not just play the full thing
[2:07:37] like why because we don't have like infinite amounts of time i'm guessing you probably don't
[2:07:42] want to watch i'm i'm gonna go back to my theory that you didn't feel confident that you could
[2:07:45] defend your your claim that it was overwhelming evidence so now you're trying to move towards
[2:07:50] doctored clips and getting there's no doctor in anything i'm just making sure that we got this
[2:07:54] right that what you're actually saying is that erica was when i re-examined her actions backward
[2:08:00] because i did not have this perspective of her at the beginning which is why it's so funny to me that you
[2:08:06] guys make it seem like i'm ground zero people thought erica was sus from day i forgive him
[2:08:10] and i was not a part of that i did not lean into that i did not contribute to that i was getting
[2:08:16] actually terrible messages from my fans being like candace you and charlie always say to go with your
[2:08:21] intuition you won't address this how we all feel about her things changed for me when i saw that zoom
[2:08:26] call i will tell you that um for sure and the fact that she lied to me so i sat across from her and
[2:08:33] you know got to i wanted to have that conversation publicly but they're probably grateful they didn't
[2:08:37] do it publicly uh she told me some lies and so the next thing that happens naturally when somebody
[2:08:46] lies to you you go when any person lies to you whether it's a toddler people only lie when they're
[2:08:51] trying to obscure something else have you addressed what that lie was yeah i've talked about we have a
[2:08:56] list of lies that we've been told by you we cannot find that i'm sure with her well no i i didn't want
[2:09:01] her to cage up i didn't i didn't want to do this and because i i didn't know what to expect like i i
[2:09:06] didn't i didn't know if she was going to be like i'm so overwhelmed with everything you know and i
[2:09:11] don't know who to trust the organization and i don't know what i'm doing like i didn't know i didn't want
[2:09:16] to just out of curiosity before anything happened with charlie how close were you and erica not very
[2:09:22] close so there's not a relationship no there i mean they're like i would say it's totally normal like
[2:09:28] it's not like there was any issues at all uh she was always we were always nice to each other it
[2:09:33] just is our life went to a different phase right so charlie and i hitting the ground running around
[2:09:38] traveling four days a week now i get married i i find love of my life i get married and i get pregnant
[2:09:44] i've been pregnant i haven't stopped being pregnant and what you want out of life changes you don't want
[2:09:47] to be running around for four days a week and traveling on a plane non-stop you suddenly want to
[2:09:54] start building at home and live i was desiring that suburban life did you guys ever do the double
[2:09:58] dates you george her and charlie was there ever double dates between oh i i was uh you know engaged
[2:10:04] to george quickly we were planning our wedding i was kind of in my bubble with george george traveled
[2:10:08] with me and charlie but erica and him were just starting to date at the beginning of 2019 george and
[2:10:12] i were planning our marriage so george really got to know charlie i wouldn't say that i really got to
[2:10:17] know erica i was just rooting for them because i knew how much charlie wanted to you know find love and so
[2:10:22] i was kind of his wing woman throughout that phase and i was just happy and i never was under
[2:10:29] the impression obviously that they were going to get married when they were dating so it wasn't like
[2:10:32] i would have was conscious i really need to get to know this person and so it was just kind of normal
[2:10:38] that by that time because of where i was in my life that i wasn't spending any time getting to know
[2:10:44] erica so so the complicit part about erica to you is that a gut feeling you think it transformed when
[2:10:51] she lied you can take the lead i'm just asking questions yeah i don't know i don't know for it
[2:10:55] i actually don't under i still don't understand what she's do you think she's complicit in yeah
[2:10:59] so when i say erica's listen that's my opinion when you tweeted erica's too retarded to kill her
[2:11:06] husband yeah would you like to explain how you developed your evidence your positive evidence for
[2:11:11] the fact that erica was um yeah sure so yeah i just think all women are retarded oh so you're
[2:11:18] allowed to just say stuff who knew so and by the way and what dramatically transformed your opinion
[2:11:24] of erica after uh going to the headquarters because you were pretty hostile uh about i wasn't hostile
[2:11:30] towards them you don't think calling somebody too retarded no come on that's like normal tongue-in-cheek
[2:11:36] stuff for me online oh you're being tongue tongue in cheek usually when i call someone retarded i'm
[2:11:41] being tongue-in-cheek yeah like for instance you got supporters i mean if you were if you want to use
[2:11:46] the same exact argument you would take a supporter like owen benjamin he called you bad names and
[2:11:53] one and called your husband bad names are you just you're just like well that's no biggie i've never
[2:11:59] answered him on anything that he said i'm saying that you now are her her biggest defender so do
[2:12:03] you still think she's not her biggest defender do you think still think she's too retarded no no no no
[2:12:07] i didn't know erica kirk i'd never met her before okay but you had an issue with turning point being
[2:12:12] led uh by a bunch of fem bots saying i'm talking about the feminist angle still do and then suddenly
[2:12:18] you go to the headquarters it's a terrible idea you come you go into the headquarters now all
[2:12:21] of a sudden you've got text messages that you're sharing with them you say that you're you and your
[2:12:26] wife are getting involved with management no no i'm not involved in any management attorney well i'm
[2:12:31] pretty sure there is a clip of you where you say that your wife went to their recent conference and
[2:12:36] sat down and then when you were on joe rogan no no no no hang on i'll explain what happened just so
[2:12:40] that you understand yeah so i was invited there to do some debate training that's literally what
[2:12:45] i was invited there to do uh on recommendation so i went down and did some debate that's the first time
[2:12:51] i ever met anybody at tp usa okay and then you said you sat down with erica well i didn't sit down to
[2:12:56] her i talked to her in a hallway so you didn't sit down and speak with erica no i didn't have like some
[2:13:02] sit down long conversation we talked in a hallway okay is that when you gave her the hug yeah gave her the
[2:13:08] hug right there my wife did too we were both very sorry for what happened okay so at what point did
[2:13:12] you start receiving text messages from that you cited in your opening statement oh i just reached
[2:13:19] out to tp usa and said i'm prepping for a debate is there anything that's pertinent that i can use here
[2:13:24] do you find it interesting that people have been asking for you know basic answers to questions and
[2:13:30] you're saying that you walked into their headquarters and reached out and they it's amazing isn't it if you
[2:13:35] reach out in good faith and you're not demonizing them and saying that they're complicit in the
[2:13:38] murder of people's deaths that that perhaps they're actually willing to release things to you that are
[2:13:44] pertinent other than thinking that you know maybe perhaps you're diabolical i don't know i feel like
[2:13:49] if i was going to release that information i didn't i didn't demand that it be released to me
[2:13:53] um i actually never demanded that be released i just simply said that this is what was going on in
[2:13:58] the last 48 hours maybe to the media they could release it they can release it to pbd they decide to
[2:14:03] release it to a guy that called erica too retarded in june so what yeah i just think it kind of shows
[2:14:09] that turning point is sending you as their horse well i don't know they just don't have they don't
[2:14:14] have i don't know where you have the conversation like i don't if they were just releasing something
[2:14:18] in let me ask you a question do you have any evidence of that claim it's not evidence you're
[2:14:23] sharing your opinion that she's too retarded i can't share my opinion that i think it's going to
[2:14:27] register as really obvious to the public that rather than presenting that throughout the course of
[2:14:33] everybody wanting to know what charlie was going through through his last days they decided to
[2:14:37] give it to you to come to my house as some sort of a surprise do you think the public's not smart
[2:14:40] enough to see through that do you think that if you're talking about terrible pr you know that
[2:14:44] there's a huge debate that's coming up that's going to be probably one of the most viewed that
[2:14:49] year and one of the debaters calls you and says i'm taking this position this is the position that i
[2:14:54] feel like there's the most evidence for and candace also agreed to answer many of my questions in regards to
[2:14:59] this so if you got pertinent evidence here that i can use i definitely like take a look what is that
[2:15:04] it was actually amazing to me it really was actually amazing to me how if you approach people in good
[2:15:09] faith and just say hey i'd actually like to know what the facts and details are around this they
[2:15:14] actually do talk to you it's amazing yeah i i i just do not believe a that you that they are doing
[2:15:21] this in good faith i don't believe that anything you have done is demonstrated that's in good faith it
[2:15:24] demonstrates that you walked into turning point usa headquarters and came out a different man because you were
[2:15:28] critical of the organization you were we're critical of erica and now you're sitting here
[2:15:32] going well first i want to interrogate you for an hour and a half about everything you've ever said
[2:15:36] about erica have you ever been critical of somebody that you hadn't met and then you meet them and
[2:15:39] you're less critical of them uh and the inverse has happened too i was right about erica and now i'm
[2:15:44] more but i'm asking you but i'm asking you isn't it the case that there's people you've been critical
[2:15:47] of and then you've met them and you're less critical after you meet them uh too retarded i i feel like if you
[2:15:53] think that she's dumb and you let's just talk about your record i mean you're a person that has
[2:15:58] spent time in what most people would term to be the manosphere talking about feminine well yeah i
[2:16:04] debate against the against feminists and red pillars okay and a lot of the actual so i'm a christian
[2:16:10] ethicist and then you go on to joe rogan and you're like like soft explaining away why erica had to take
[2:16:16] over charlie's company when they don't have a parent at home so now you're a feminist icon like you just
[2:16:20] go into the headquarters and you just shift all of your that's because that's a bizarre criticism like
[2:16:25] nobody's in the bigger girl boss position than you i'm actually no you're in the biggest of the
[2:16:29] girl boss positions like you don't have to do this you just do do this you could definitely not do it
[2:16:35] at all and be fine right but you still do i i would say that you are making a comparison that cannot be
[2:16:41] compared because because erica's husband was just assassinated in front of the world which makes
[2:16:47] sense why she would take the organization no but it makes sense why you would go home to your kids
[2:16:51] just so you know wait a second that's that's bizarre because they don't have a parent they
[2:16:54] don't have a you want to protect they've just suffered a trauma you don't go into the office
[2:16:57] you want to protect your husband's legacy yeah right and you're trying to find some new legacy
[2:17:02] is his children not the organization it's it's both no it yes it is both it's totally rational
[2:17:08] and reasonable to believe that it would be both turning point usa that is part of charlie kirk's
[2:17:12] legs he worked his whole life for it this is why people think she's us and his children now
[2:17:16] for you though to say that anybody's a girl boss right that's like the pot calling the kettle black
[2:17:21] that came out of your mouth no that was you you brought up girl boss girl boss came out of your
[2:17:27] mouth yeah i'm just saying i'm telling you that you brought up this idea that i'm defending some
[2:17:32] feminist nonsense i'm not i'm pointing out that they're there by the way she's not qualified there's
[2:17:37] always objective over his company there's always objective outliers to each situation the in fact it's
[2:17:43] the exception that proves the rule and the interesting thing here is like i'm still just
[2:17:47] as critical of feminism inside of tp usa as i've always been and i'm just as critical of any pro
[2:17:53] zionist position as i've ever been none of that's ever changed by the way i would think it's the most
[2:18:00] rational reasonable thing on planet earth to do if you wanted to actually see an organization change
[2:18:05] to try to work with leadership or reach out to leadership to try to do so doesn't that make the most
[2:18:11] i would like to state for the record that i think erica is underqualified from uh to run that to run
[2:18:16] the organization and on on the more emotional aspects i agree with the what seems to be a
[2:18:25] majority opinion because i'm not gonna say it's scientific that any woman that would leave her kids
[2:18:31] and go right into the office after their husband was publicly assassinated it does not have their
[2:18:35] priority straight okay well i understand that you can have those criticisms but i'm not understanding
[2:18:41] still how that would make her complicit i don't i don't have to keep answering the same question
[2:18:49] your team is asking to play clips so if we want to play this clip to just finish this segment on the
[2:18:54] erica kirk topic we can spend some time on that as well so if you guys are ready in the back
[2:18:58] we're ready and causing that 30-06 diameter as would happen with a pet and explosives as we've
[2:19:06] demonstrated to in the past it accidentally because of how charlie was crouched went up and hit his neck
[2:19:15] and that ruined everything it ruined everything it was problematic it's the reason why tarryl then had
[2:19:21] to scramble to get the cameras down because they were never supposed to see it they could have said
[2:19:28] reasonably that a 30-06 got eaten by charlie much more reasonably obviously than saying that the chicken
[2:19:37] bones in his neck stopped it because he ate vegetables they panicked that was what then that's why
[2:19:46] tarryl's nervous from the phone with me again this is my theory and i am now very much sticking to it
[2:19:51] okay they panicked it's the reason erica had to step out once that's why she would have got gotten on the
[2:19:58] phone with tarryl so quickly because i was going why is tarryl saying well i didn't want erica to
[2:20:01] relive oh that's why i did it he didn't have an answer he was nervous it was crazy but he acknowledged
[2:20:06] that he spoke to erica immediately why did you speak to erica immediately do you believe that there was
[2:20:13] a shape charge that killed charlie hey can i ask you why you keep starting clips mid-sentence
[2:20:18] probably to get to where the clip is no it doesn't seem that way because you can always start a clip
[2:20:22] at the beginning of a sentence like you're just started like it's completely out of context wait i
[2:20:26] i didn't yeah i didn't prepare the clips but yeah i didn't but it's fine to ask it to back like i said
[2:20:31] this this the internet i don't need to say what's happening here because the internet will clock it
[2:20:36] but uh in this episode we are now going and that's why i said we're now going to look at some alternative
[2:20:43] theories i made it very clear that this was a theory that i didn't want to look at this is i believe
[2:20:48] because i don't have every episode on my head and but i'm pretty sure this is an episode where we
[2:20:53] presented the evidence that was in the car the photos of what was in the car right and so we
[2:20:57] are now inferring off of what we see in the car that this very much does look like uh that we are
[2:21:07] see a bunch of shattered road microphone which was an early theory that i was actually interested in
[2:21:12] but couldn't really wrap my head around what was uh the shape charge explosive as i say at the
[2:21:16] beginning episode like i just it was just not my expertise and i was concerning myself with timelines
[2:21:22] and stories and same as it didn't make sense without question terrell farnsworth uh is is someone
[2:21:27] who made me think that we were missing a big part of this story so i'm walking them through uh john
[2:21:33] brace theory if we started to insert what we are actually observing with the evidence that we're
[2:21:40] taking a look at and what took place that day so we're completely in the hypothetical right here uh and
[2:21:45] you're now introducing this if that's the case if you're just hypothetically exploring it that's why i'm just
[2:21:50] asking directly yes but if you but that's obvious when you watch this episode so that's why it feels
[2:21:55] like i'm in the middle of an interview with cnn when they like pull up random clips and they're like
[2:22:00] what's this what's this you watch the episode you know what it is sure do you think that your
[2:22:06] alternative theory i think john bray's theory should be explored yes okay do you do you think
[2:22:11] that charlie kirk was killed with an explosive i think i think that that is a possibility yes okay and
[2:22:16] it should be explored he's done a lot of work on it john bray has done good work and i think that
[2:22:20] that's why that uh theory is now starting to gain steam since we released the second set of the photos
[2:22:28] of what was in the car i think it's viable so this was the big thing i wanted to get into with you on
[2:22:32] the explosives too what what is it about that theory that's actually compelling to you so i looked into
[2:22:37] the explosive mic theory multiple times and the biggest thing that stood out to me is there's no
[2:22:43] explosion there's there's literally no explosion in fact there's videos when the shot rings out um
[2:22:51] that kills charlie at least it sounds like a shot to me people are actually like looking up towards where
[2:22:57] the uh the gun is being fired they're looking away for where their sound is like where's the actual
[2:23:04] explosion well for every person that you say looks away there's gonna be a person that was looking
[2:23:08] forward uh we have former marines that have gotten on and said it looks to me like there's an explosion
[2:23:15] under his shirt right you obviously saw um uh rob o'neill go on to i'm forgetting which platform it
[2:23:24] was where he said it's the first thing i thought was rob o'neill is the man that killed osama yeah and
[2:23:29] i think he's qualified to say what he believes he saw uh we we should actually since they're pulling
[2:23:33] clips we should run that clip of rob o'neill and what he said and what he observed in his experience
[2:23:38] so i'm gonna take that and also there were people who tested like immediately spoke to the media
[2:23:44] that day who said the same thing that they thought that something happened under a shirt that was
[2:23:47] actually if you go back to like my first episode when i was just observing what i saw with my eyes
[2:23:51] i was asking the serious question i was seriously saying why is it like somebody shot him from
[2:23:55] underneath why is his shirt moving first that doesn't make sense to me and uh i'm not as of air
[2:24:00] dispersal from the bullet so when uh when whenever a bullet is shot a projectile shot you can actually run
[2:24:06] this experiment yourself if you have a rifle take it like an empty box of ammunition and put it on
[2:24:11] the table and then fire it near the muzzle and that box will actually blow off the table okay so
[2:24:18] question for you does that box go sideways off the table it can it can yeah you can it depends on the
[2:24:24] dispersal you 3 000 pounds of energy or 2 000 pounds of energy coming at you that's how much it carries
[2:24:30] well it's not 2 000 pounds of energy well we can fact check that how many how many how many pounds
[2:24:35] of energy is it a 30-06 uh being shot 150 yards away that's a great question for grok i'm gonna say
[2:24:41] when we looked at it it was between 1500 and 2000 i'm pretty sure pounds of energy coming at you and
[2:24:46] you just go upward into the side i don't really buy that i mean and i'm gonna just say i just think that
[2:24:52] that's not right but possible doesn't go through on top of that so there's another miracle you didn't get
[2:24:55] blown backwards you didn't it didn't go through but i also want to say that you're saying this can
[2:24:59] happen and rob o'neill is infinitely more qualified i think to speak on that and well because he's
[2:25:05] actually shot and killed people why would that have anything do with anything well because he
[2:25:10] slowed down all the videos of the people he shot to see if their clothes moved well why are you able
[2:25:15] to sort your business because i'm gonna i'm gonna tell you how projectiles were he's not even
[2:25:20] going to just i guarantee you this guy's not going to disagree with what i'm about to say
[2:25:23] if it is the case that you have energy and you have mass and the mass is moving in the air the
[2:25:29] air has to go somewhere it doesn't have a choice i think you're like you're totally bsing right now
[2:25:35] man not only am i not bsing i'm telling you the truth if a bullet is moving in air air has to move
[2:25:41] out of way of bullet but maybe not at the bottom of a shirt here i don't know i i just i disagree with
[2:25:46] that i'd like to say for the record i've watched some of you do these sorts of things where you assert
[2:25:50] something with a lot of confidence and you can fact check it it's complete you're checking bullets
[2:25:55] displace air not about whether it displays air it's where it dispersed the air underneath his shirt
[2:25:59] here it's not underneath the shirt well it's this big and you're telling me it's going to hit his
[2:26:03] neck it's not underneath the shirt it starts up here and the collar's moving and then you see the
[2:26:08] wave here as he's moving backwards no yeah that's not true it's not and we obviously can't show that
[2:26:13] clip i disagree with you okay i understand you can't show it for tos purposes exactly uh i disagree with
[2:26:18] you people can go watch and make up their own minds we don't need to debate it whether or not
[2:26:21] it was the first thing i said was why is his shirt moving first that didn't make sense to me it it
[2:26:26] almost looks just like this it goes across his necklace breaks first before charlie even reacts
[2:26:31] if you watch it in slow his necklace breaks first which i thought was very odd and then you see a puff
[2:26:36] here and the next thing you know there's a there's the uh entry wound on his neck i i would not
[2:26:42] confidently assert that i see smoke i've never said it on my platform that an explosion generally has smoke
[2:26:49] i don't think that there's any quality version of video that would get us to be able to answer
[2:26:53] that question other than terrell's 4k footage that he has from the front so there's a lot of um if you
[2:26:57] look at the israeli pagers it's assumed that it's a similar if not the same type of explosive that was
[2:27:04] used inside the pagers that would have been used inside of this road mic i think that you should since
[2:27:09] you love debating you should debate someone like john bray who's worked on that theory for 11 months
[2:27:14] and ask those sorts of questions of how shape charge would work uh i presented the evidence of
[2:27:18] what was in the car and i also at that episode that you're clipping said john bray has done an
[2:27:24] unbelievable amount of work on this and i think he has debated a ton of people actually regarding this
[2:27:29] topic so that's the route that i would send you on yeah that's fine yeah for the purposes of my show
[2:27:35] i i do believe to answer your question that it is a hypothetical i mean that it is a theory that
[2:27:40] should be thoroughly explored there's two clips uh your team wants to show one of them is the rob
[2:27:45] o'neill clip since we're on it so if you guys are ready in the back before we go to ad break
[2:27:49] if you want to pull it up this is a good time to do so good to see general hold a lot of things bother
[2:28:01] it bothers me about this um nothing in particular it's not like i'm out there saying big lie or a
[2:28:07] conspiracy or someone did it i'm just saying i've been in a lot of shootings i've killed more than a
[2:28:11] handful of people and this thing looked shady off the bat i mean just i've killed people
[2:28:16] closer than i saw the camera and i've never seen a shirt move like that that looks like an explosion
[2:28:21] to me the uh just the fact that no one started doing uh first aid to charlie kirk they were more
[2:28:26] concerned about getting sim cards out of cameras removing cameras and then uh getting him off the
[2:28:31] x somehow there didn't seem a lot of concern for it for his life it seemed like just clean it up and
[2:28:35] then i mean i've been told they paved it over a couple days later and then you get erica kirk uh behind
[2:28:41] all the razzle dazzle and she's really quick to forgive the alleged shooter which technically says
[2:28:47] uh that was him because i forgive him but that you can't forgive candace owens for having an opinion or
[2:28:51] asking questions and they mock people by saying oh i'm just asking questions yeah i'm a seal team
[2:28:56] six sniper i'm asking a lot of questions no one wants to answer them and you're able to ask he's
[2:29:02] actually said very little about the explosive there so he observed he said he's shot people
[2:29:07] up close and he's never seen a shirt move like that and it looked to him like an explosive that's
[2:29:11] what he does but when i play that video at full speed i can't see a shirt moving i can only see a
[2:29:18] shirt moving when we slow it way down so if i'm in real time i'm just assuming this right i mean if i
[2:29:24] was in real time it was in real time and i was in like a close quarters combat you kill somebody's
[2:29:28] situation and i shot them would you even see the shirt move well i just feel like five minutes ago
[2:29:35] you were arguing that it was because the bullet carried air now you're saying you don't see the
[2:29:38] shirt move at all yeah but that's if you slow it down the disbursement of air that's where you're
[2:29:44] going to see it right it's going to be very quick very very very very fast yeah that's not what i saw
[2:29:49] and clearly it's not what he saw and he thinks that there could be an explosive so i'm just saying
[2:29:53] to you when people disagree with you your your opinions on a fact that's all i understand that's
[2:29:57] a good place for us to if you if we have another break and then we can keep answer answering your
[2:30:03] questions yeah i mean i think um yeah sounds good perfect we'll do a quick three and a half minute ad
[2:30:09] break we'll be back for the last segment cool all right thank you all right you guys i want to tell
[2:30:13] you about ethos because life has a way of changing your priorities when you least expect it one day you're
[2:30:19] focused on what's next for you the next you're thinking about a home a family and how to build a
[2:30:23] future that feels secure as your world grows so does your perspective that shift in mindset is what
[2:30:28] led me to make life insurance a priority it's one of those things that's easy to put off but having
[2:30:32] it in place gives me peace of mind knowing that the people that i care about would have financial
[2:30:37] support if the unexpected ever happened getting covered today is simpler faster and more affordable
[2:30:41] than many people realize that's why i love ethos because with ethos you can apply online in just
[2:30:45] minutes no medical exams no waiting rooms just answer a few health questions and you could be
[2:30:50] covered the very same day ethos has 4.9 out of 5 stars on trust pilot with over 5 500 reviews what
[2:30:57] really stands out to me is that ethos helps match you with coverage that actually fits your life your
[2:31:01] goals and your budget with up to three million dollars in coverage and plans starting around 30 a
[2:31:05] month protecting your family can feel a whole lot more doable peace of mind should not be complicated so
[2:31:11] take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through ethos get your free quote at
[2:31:16] ethos dot com slash candace that's ethos dot com slash candace application times and rates may vary
[2:31:24] and i want to remind you guys about tax network usa because i know a lot of people owe back taxes
[2:31:28] maybe you have years of unfiled returns maybe you file every year and you still can't get ahead
[2:31:32] because the balance keeps growing or maybe you withdrew money from a 401k or ira and suddenly got hit
[2:31:37] with a tax bill that you didn't expect whatever caused the problem one thing is certain the irs
[2:31:41] penalties and interest keep adding up every single month if you don't have a plan now you
[2:31:45] could end up owing even more next tax season before the irs starts sending more letters garnishing
[2:31:50] wages or freezing your bank account call tax network usa they've been helping taxpayers nationwide
[2:31:55] for more than 15 years resolving back taxes unfiled returns and serious irs problems
[2:32:00] so whether you owe ten thousand dollars or ten million dollars their team has resolved over one
[2:32:04] billion dollars in tax debt right now they're offering a free irs investigative call to find
[2:32:09] out exactly what you owe and what options you have to fix it so call 866-686-1651 or visit tnusa.com
[2:32:18] candace again that's tnusa.com candace i also want to tell you guys about field of greens because i am
[2:32:24] always looking past the headlines and asking one simple question what is really in the product that i'm
[2:32:28] putting into my body think about it when you buy a steak or a bag of vegetables you see nutrition facts
[2:32:34] label when companies take fruits and vegetables and turn them into a formula you'll often see a
[2:32:39] supplemental facts label instead that makes you want to know more where do the ingredients come from
[2:32:43] how are they processed and can i trust what's actually inside that's one reason i love field
[2:32:48] of greens because their focus is on quality transparency and bringing together fruits and
[2:32:51] vegetables in a convenient daily formula and it actually tastes good wild berry is my favorite but
[2:32:56] strawberry lemonade is a popular choice as well no complicated routine just one scoop mixed with water
[2:33:02] if you want to try it use code candace at checkout for 20 off your first order by visiting field of
[2:33:07] greens.com that's code candace at field of greens.com all right fantastic so andrew if you want to go
[2:33:14] with your last couple thoughts yeah so i just have two two more clips to play okay right and then i uh we
[2:33:21] can do final thoughts i'm guessing um i yeah i feel like uh we got where we were trying to go or at least
[2:33:29] for the most part so um the two other clips i do want to play the twigs clip that one is important to
[2:33:36] me the twigs dna clip yeah and they're going to pull it up just to have you respond well you don't
[2:33:41] have to play it because like if you're saying that when i initially watched it i thought that lance
[2:33:46] twigs is dna like he was directly responding to that because the testimony was a bit confusing they
[2:33:49] started by saying that they were going to um uh like explaining how they got the samples and they
[2:33:55] said lance matt and amberson uh sorry lance matt and amber robinson how they got their uh dna samples
[2:34:01] and then they started speaking about the gun and said you know multiple prints were found on them
[2:34:06] and then they moved and they said lance twigs's dna was found on the screwdriver uh when i went back
[2:34:11] and re-watched it i realized well they haven't officially said that lance or amber are on the
[2:34:16] gun so i think i've already conceded that we don't know that so i think like but if you're if you
[2:34:21] want to know this is directly sent you saying it is on the gun twigs i'm saying that i feel like
[2:34:28] i've already said to you like i've made that concession but just to be clear whenever i make
[2:34:33] a mistake i just correct it so that's why when you were asking me three times i've already said we
[2:34:37] don't know yet and i've corrected that mistake so if the purpose of you showing this is to demonstrate
[2:34:43] that candace makes mistakes sometimes uh when she's taking in a lot of information and she's reading
[2:34:49] through legal documents and she's trying to remember testimony it's just demonstrate something
[2:34:53] else it is in fact the case we're all going to make mistakes i'm going to make mistakes and i've
[2:34:57] already i've already you're going to make mistakes in the case yeah but in this case you were very
[2:35:01] adamant that his dna was on the gun itself yeah so i'm just saying that it's not ruled out we know
[2:35:08] that there's five plus prints i've said this so many times i had to re-watch the testimony again it's
[2:35:13] like nine hours a day it got very scientific when they were speaking about this and i think i wrongly
[2:35:17] extrapolated that they meant all three of them were on the prints when the only person they
[2:35:21] officially named was matt robinson so we don't know yet if um lance twiggs has his dna on the
[2:35:27] prints official dna on the gun officially just yet okay i've already conceded that sure so that's
[2:35:33] fine and then the last one is one with erica kirk sure this is like the erica kirk like
[2:35:40] all right you could just sit down with me erica but we can do it this way this goes back to a
[2:35:44] previous claim that you made yeah sure you know straight to jail straight to jail for questioning
[2:35:51] at least erica i don't care who's mad i really do not care who wants to be upset after this episode
[2:35:58] really you'll be wasting your breath you can spend a billion dollars on influencers because this is all
[2:36:03] becoming increasingly inexplicable you are asking me to be an idiot actually and i cannot do that for
[2:36:09] you someone once commented beneath this show that if the situations were reversed and there were this
[2:36:17] many verifiable lies straight straight to jail yeah so that's the show intro and straight to
[2:36:25] jail straight to jail is a monopoly term okay so do not pass go yeah do not collect 200 yes it's it's
[2:36:31] obviously tongue-in-cheek and then i explained that actually i think that she should be brought in for
[2:36:35] questioning because of inconsistencies so this is the exact episode when i started to think that
[2:36:39] that she should be sat down and questioned uh and i i still believe that i still hold the
[2:36:44] perspective that erica should be sat down and she should be properly questioned do you know that
[2:36:49] she hasn't been um no actually that would be a great thing for the spokesperson of turning point usa
[2:36:54] to say that she's already i mean my guess would be she hasn't because they returned everything to
[2:36:58] her but why do they owe you that though they don't owe me anything that's my show you're watching
[2:37:03] just you know the clips that you're pulling from my show so if i want to say something on my show i can
[2:37:07] say that i didn't say they owe me something i don't think that's ever unless you have another
[2:37:11] clip but if you say like you need to be sat down for questioning and you don't even know if they
[2:37:14] haven't been that's strange right do you know if they have been no i have no idea so you're just
[2:37:20] saying what if they haven't been yeah if you're if you're just kind of filling the air if your entire
[2:37:25] thing is junk if you're no it's not junk if if the query is why is it that erica kirk's not being sat
[2:37:31] down for questioning but you have absolutely no knowledge whether or not she's been sat down for
[2:37:35] questioning or not what that does is it creates an innuendo it creates an inference it creates
[2:37:41] out to the ethos that this should be happening because something's wrong here when you actually
[2:37:46] don't have the knowledge that anything's wrong at all i just think that my opinion is that she
[2:37:51] should be sat down and questions but you're not sure if she hasn't been yeah and you're not sure if
[2:37:56] she has been either so like i said i feel like now you're just kind of filling the air to my knowledge
[2:38:01] because turning points like we want to make sure that you go in there and you defend erica and i
[2:38:05] have to say i don't think you've done an extraordinary job great but i'm not here to defend erica the
[2:38:09] thing is though it's like since four out of five of the clips that you had on the ready when we asked
[2:38:13] you guys ahead of time i mean i want to just assert how professionally we have dealt with this debate
[2:38:19] as you can see we have not planned any gotcha clips for andrew i expressed to him that what we were
[2:38:24] going to do was just to use people for fact checks and it because i might not remember something um or i do
[2:38:29] remember something and you're saying no and that is what i think will register to people as very
[2:38:34] well we express we did not take out of context clips of andrew but i expressly said that i was
[2:38:40] going to bring clean we did not know when you said you were going to bring claims that you want me to
[2:38:44] speak to you didn't say i intend on sitting you down with out of contexted clips to which we said to
[2:38:52] you before in an email any clips you want to share with us send it over let's assert a debate claim
[2:38:56] so that we can both be ready to respond to it this just that's not really what happened well
[2:39:01] what's not yeah this this uh the way that you're framing the exchange that's not that's not actually
[2:39:06] what happened we were negotiating it is true we negotiated out uh the claim itself right which
[2:39:12] one's going to take which position i wanted to make sure that i had at least an hour and a half on
[2:39:15] mine and you got the time for years to question me we did we got through your hour and a half on mine
[2:39:20] roughly an hour and a half now on mine that's basically how this went but in the beginning i did not
[2:39:25] take an hour and a half to just pull out of context this with andrew i actually debated the
[2:39:29] substance of what's going on in this trial and this hearing and i i do think that you fell i think
[2:39:33] you fell short of that there's nothing out of the hang on there's nothing here except holding you to
[2:39:37] account for your claims yes or no well we were supposed to be dating uh to be debating the case
[2:39:43] and whether or not there was overwhelming evidence these are your claims about the case no you then
[2:39:48] admitted that that now you're getting into another sphere and you're you want to talk about the
[2:39:52] transcendentals and things that i've got through and like four out of five of your clips are about
[2:39:56] erica kirk so the general i don't think four out of five even is your turning points horse i think
[2:40:01] just quite a few of them were was there three just made it up or four so you're just making stuff can
[2:40:06] we get a count of how many were about erica i feel like it was three three okay yeah i said four but
[2:40:11] those are extraordinary claims that's which is why you're asking okay well right okay but the point
[2:40:16] being is now you're veering into trying to get me to defend my opinions and then you completely shirk
[2:40:20] responsibility when i point out yours no they're not claims no they're claims erica is too retarded
[2:40:24] you go that's just whatever and then you move on that's a claim and i'm responsible for the claim
[2:40:30] well earlier when i brought it up you said that it was tongue-in-cheek yes sure i that's me responding
[2:40:37] to your criticism of the claim that's all i'm doing here was interested and um and i'm happy to get
[2:40:43] into also the patsy stuff now if you would like to well your team has one more clip they want to play
[2:40:48] seven days ago we were getting into the patsy stuff and you stopped it and i was explaining to you
[2:40:53] oh they have one more clip okay let's go they want to hit the minimum of four clips you were saying
[2:40:59] with erica so 100 this is absurd okay and this is the one you're saying from seven days ago okay while
[2:41:20] they're looking for that do you want to continue yeah i mean can i ask a question i know it's been or
[2:41:25] or like can i ask a question are we not really we're just i'm just gonna okay we're going to hold
[2:41:30] to the actual contract itself the contract is does not say that you are allowed to just question me
[2:41:37] without me being able to respond to you i've never said you can have a conversation you've been able
[2:41:42] to respond to every question i've asked you and by the way the the other thing is is like let's have
[2:41:46] it your way i want it to look like still happy we've done everything andrew wanted to so that people
[2:41:50] can fairly assess the situation so you have it your way i will not ask a question totally fair with me
[2:41:55] so are you good with her asking the question or he said no waiting for the clip okay so you want
[2:42:00] to wait for the clip first okay you guys have it in the back okay beautiful you need to jeopardy
[2:42:23] he told me they had it so that's what i heard okay there come on guys did this crime okay because
[2:42:30] lance twigs has his dna on the towel it's fine lance twigs has his dna on the rifle plans and to be
[2:42:38] clear lance twigs dna was not as degraded as tyler robinson's dna was on tyler's rifle it's tyler's
[2:42:47] rifle oh yeah it's not as degraded on the rifle yeah because i thought he was one of the things
[2:42:52] but i i've already that like that's what i mean when i say that like it just seems like you're not
[2:42:56] actually here trying to engage because i even before you got to this and i knew that you had some
[2:43:00] secret clip plans i said to you when i re-watched the testimony i realized they didn't explicitly say
[2:43:06] lance twigs they said five other profiles were on it and that his was the most degraded so i hope
[2:43:12] your team feels fulfilled in playing that uh is there any more i'm happy to play every clip that he
[2:43:18] has on the ready anybody you said you said you had some new evidence at the beginning of the oh yeah we
[2:43:24] should show that text message that you read just because i think that's important for the public you
[2:43:27] shared it out of context i'll do it on my show i'll share the uh so you're going to read it on my show
[2:43:32] but not show it correct okay i'll show it on my show but that's that's what i'll do i'll show it
[2:43:38] on my can i ask why well because i want to drip out the evidence you know it's that's got to drip out
[2:43:45] that evidence keep people coming back for the show right i don't know if snark serves you so well i'm
[2:43:51] just saying like um yeah i'll i'll release it there um yeah that's that's my intention but yeah i'm fine
[2:43:59] with closings if you want to do clothes well i also would just if if i may ask a question is that
[2:44:04] permitted go ahead um just so i also have clarity since your basis has been evidentiary you keep
[2:44:10] saying that you have evidence or like you are following evidence which one of the charges against
[2:44:17] or all of them do you think tyler robinson is guilty of um the specific charge yeah yeah so i think what
[2:44:26] i think is that um tyler robinson shot charlie kirk yeah but of the seven charges that he's he's being
[2:44:34] charged yeah can we list them real quick i'll tell you exactly which ones we'll pull them up well do
[2:44:38] do you know any of the charges that he's up for right now yeah of course but i want to make sure
[2:44:43] that we have them listed yeah but but like that's can you name one because my my general perspective is
[2:44:48] that you don't actually care about this case you're not following that is that's the that's the question
[2:44:52] just not following it seems pretty like if you're going to engage and you're going to say the
[2:44:56] evidence is overwhelming that tyler robinson is guilty i just think that you should all right can
[2:45:00] you tell me one then let's do the counter you can really hang out this is a great guy no no you just
[2:45:05] got to ask me play clips out of context put me in the hot seat so please just answer this is fair
[2:45:10] all seven since you've been following the case okay sure you go ahead you name one yeah you named all
[2:45:15] seven i'm happy to do that but can you name one i think he's i think he's been charged with murder
[2:45:20] that's actually okay great now name all seven he doesn't even this is like name all seven and and
[2:45:25] and i can you name all seven i i can't then do it sure you don't have to do it no do it i'll count
[2:45:31] them go ahead you don't have to put your fingers up okay hang on name them yeah sure name them uh the
[2:45:36] first charge is aggravated murder because that's what carries a death sentence no that's not that is
[2:45:40] literally not murder okay and so just for people no don't i don't have to do it in a time limit there's
[2:45:45] nothing going on and just to explain people the difference of why that really matters and shows that he
[2:45:48] doesn't actually care about this at all is because aggravated murder uh it's it's narrowly defined
[2:45:54] and because it carries a death sentence i'm not i'm going to answer the question okay you're just
[2:45:57] going to recognize that your strategy of thinking that people are intimidated when you try to put a
[2:46:00] time constraint doesn't work and you'll be better the next time you did i got it i got it give me
[2:46:04] give me the other ones the more you cut me off the longer i'll take do you want to just wait for
[2:46:08] me to finish of why that's a big difference so that no i just want you to list the charges yeah i'm
[2:46:13] gonna do that you just don't get to pretend that there's a time constraint for me to do that well how how long
[2:46:17] does it take you to list seven charges i'm because i'm speaking you just got it sounds like you're
[2:46:20] just delaying it because you don't know i i know all seven of them and i'm gonna say again because
[2:46:24] you're gonna get embarrassed i you don't have to rush this i'm also showing an example of a very flawed
[2:46:30] debate strategy i actually want no time constraint i got one great the second charge is the felony
[2:46:37] discharge of a weapon uh the next two charges are for obstruction of justice okay the next two charges
[2:46:45] are for witness tampering and the final specific charges though that is them obstruction of justice
[2:46:50] obstruction of justice witness tampering witness tampering okay witness and there's no other
[2:46:54] specifics to them well we i can tell you why he's being no no just the the charges and then seven
[2:46:59] yeah see the bad thing is when you try to be an a-hole and it doesn't work what's the seventh the last
[2:47:03] charge is uh violence in front of a minor okay got it so then he's being charged with murder you just
[2:47:09] say aggravated murder that's the distinction you just want to it's a massive it's like you can't
[2:47:15] even you cannot say murder versus aggravated this gets to the entire crux of why him being up up for
[2:47:22] the death sentence and i actually find the defense's filing about why this is not aggravated to be uh
[2:47:31] very compelling of why it's not aggravated actually that the state was going to even try to pull this
[2:47:37] off they should have charged him with just murder um and then i do also again want to stress to
[2:47:42] audiences that that debate strategy of thinking that you have to speak faster or somebody puts your
[2:47:48] hand up and they try to pretend like it's some sport i think he thinks it's a blood sport it's not
[2:47:52] it's about being right and being principled when you're engaging and you can make mistakes i make
[2:47:57] mistakes all the time but at least be genuine in pretending that you care about this case enough to know
[2:48:02] one of the seven charges that are up against tyler robinson when you say the evidence is
[2:48:06] overwhelming that he's guilty um if you would like to move to final statements i'm fine i want
[2:48:11] to make sure andrew has had the time that he has requested i think your team would like to pull up
[2:48:15] the seven charges that he just asked you about if you guys want to pull that up just to confirm
[2:48:20] the seven you went through can you guys zoom in a little bit aggravated murder felony discharge of a
[2:48:26] firearm uh obstruction of drugs obstruction of justice which is counts three and four five and six
[2:48:32] tampering with a witness and seven violent i said offense in the presence of a minor job yeah so five
[2:48:40] six tampering witness third degree felony now i didn't notice something i just was curious about
[2:48:45] if i'm just wondering when you pulled out your phone just before you asked that question did
[2:48:49] somebody by chance text you that question you can check my phone i'm just curious no you can
[2:48:53] absolutely not i didn't i have not had one communication with a single person not even my
[2:48:57] producers who are in there this whole time we were here you want to check my phone i'm happy to do it
[2:49:01] because you're just going to get double embarrassed where's my phone you want to see it i'm just
[2:49:05] curious you can literally do that here you go pbd you're the moderator take it let's see if anyone
[2:49:11] was texted at all during this debate all right about the violent charges or anything i'm looking
[2:49:19] through this you give me permission you have full permission to go through my phone i don't need to
[2:49:23] cheat the last one has nothing to do with it it's just a compliment i haven't even read my tech
[2:49:28] messages that's a compliment he's reading them you're okay you'll give me permission i'm just going to
[2:49:33] read three of them to 11 32 because after that i don't need to read it any other texts could have
[2:49:38] been telegram could have been oh i have a signal you can check that too i only have signal telegram
[2:49:43] i used in russia and that was it i downloaded it for russia i'll take your word for it yeah i don't
[2:49:47] i don't need to like i deeply care about this case i don't need to pretend i get it if you
[2:49:50] deeply care about the case i just you know i have my other question is about the steakhouse receipt
[2:49:55] you just said that you were done asking all your questions so you know yeah nothing there yeah do you have
[2:50:01] the steakhouse receipts my question um i have said several times that i have i have never said i
[2:50:06] have the receipt for the steakhouse i have said the person who's working on that story is going to be
[2:50:09] forthcoming with the receipt and that was what i was responding to and he then dropped the receipt
[2:50:14] he redacted elements of it and i said stay tuned he's the one working on that story okay so you haven't
[2:50:20] actually confirmed that robinson was at that steakhouse all i did as i said earlier in this
[2:50:24] conversation was i spoke to the owner when when i broke that story i think it was back in january
[2:50:28] i spoke to the owner understood what had happened um and that there was a receipt that's it that's
[2:50:34] the extent of what i shared is what happened okay so to be clear there's no receipt no i i just said
[2:50:41] the opposite i said there we don't have a copy of the receipt i the receipt was published online
[2:50:47] yeah right with blurred out person working on this story yeah that blurred that out is what i was
[2:50:52] referring to when i said stay tuned and keep following his stuff because he went to go
[2:50:55] which do what i hadn't done which was he interviewed the actual server so there's no evidence that
[2:51:00] tyler was at that steakhouse i i would say the receipt with his debit card number it would be
[2:51:05] some hard evidence if that i agree with that yeah so that's it but you're questioning me but is there
[2:51:09] as of right now he paid if you're asking me did he pay with a creditor debit card the answer is yes
[2:51:13] no no is there proof that that was actually his debit card that he paid with i think you should
[2:51:19] follow the person that um is behind that story well the reason i'm asking you is because you always
[2:51:24] include it in your timeline that he traveled to the steak yeah we've been building a timeline with
[2:51:28] things that we feel are but is there any actual 1102 approved i think speaking to the owner knowing
[2:51:33] that there's a receipt seeing the receipt uh is good enough to put on on our timeline but the
[2:51:38] receipt itself the question i always had about it is couldn't you just call the merchant like if i've
[2:51:42] ever had a merchant account i just call the merchant account processor and say what's the name on this
[2:51:47] yeah i would i would stay tuned i i feel that the having spoken to the owner that the evidence is
[2:51:53] compelling enough to put onto my personal timeline of what took place on that day and that's where
[2:51:58] it's gonna stay and if it gets debunked i'm happy to take it off if that's what you mean that's how
[2:52:03] an investigation works um like i said i did more than enough it would definitely pass the test by the
[2:52:11] utah 1102 rule for sure for certain to be submitted as hearsay yeah well yeah beyond that because they
[2:52:18] didn't even have receipts they were like bob told me the question but the question is the receipt itself
[2:52:24] it has not been verified to have been tyler i just want to say you're holding me to a higher standard
[2:52:28] than you are i'm not even holding i'm just asking specifically yeah i i've been very forthcoming
[2:52:33] i've told exactly what happened i spoke to the owner i got the tip and i should that be added in an
[2:52:37] official timeline that you did my timeline it's my show and we can add and subtract what we want and
[2:52:42] we do you can do what you want sure but i'm asking should you include a thing that you know
[2:52:47] hasn't actually been verified to be tyler robinson you should if we're trying to build a timeline you
[2:52:52] should yeah you don't think that that falls under remove it if you if someone somehow debunks it but
[2:52:57] i think that the there is very strong evidence that that is where he was and that what's the
[2:53:02] strong evidence just the two people who said that they saw you know i'm i'm actually all good with
[2:53:06] b i i feel like i've sufficiently answered your question about how i got the information what
[2:53:10] happened next uh with the next stage of this investigation being somebody accessing his
[2:53:16] knowing what his debit card wasn't confirming it yes and i do believe that that will happen if it
[2:53:20] does not happen and it gets debunked i'll remove it from my personal timeline that i share on my show
[2:53:24] officer the first officer that was up on the roof do you remember his name officer bagley yeah what was
[2:53:29] his first name christopher christopher um when christopher got up on the roof you talk a lot about how his
[2:53:37] camera died well he talked a lot about that during his camera died yeah do you think that he planted
[2:53:42] that screwdriver up there no no who do you think planted it i if we're just going on my am i allowed
[2:53:49] to have an opinion of course at this stage i would say that i i don't buy his um assertion on the stand
[2:53:55] that he didn't check to see if anybody went onto the rooftop before um he got up there i i do think that
[2:54:04] it's possible it's at least plausible that the the uh screwdriver was planted i don't believe him what
[2:54:09] i can say strongly is that his uh cam died at just the right time his body cam died just the right time
[2:54:17] i think that as you were just grilling me about whether or not i got the merchant receipt for a
[2:54:23] debit card that kind of makes difficult that we just have to sort of trust that a screwdriver was found
[2:54:28] and we don't have any should be evidence of a police body cam but like i said you accept that
[2:54:34] stuff and then are like did you call the merchant and get like it just seems like you well i'm not
[2:54:39] adding hold like i said you hold the prosecution to a wait a second to a bit a higher standard i'm not
[2:54:45] adding unconfirmed evidence to an official timeline that i'm putting out either what do you mean an
[2:54:49] official timeline this is my timeline i made it at home so then it would be official to your show
[2:54:54] sure yeah okay great so then your your official timeline candace owens official timeline includes
[2:55:01] a steakhouse stop that has not actually been confirmed at all well yeah it hasn't even been
[2:55:06] discussed by the prosecution so it's it's not like you're debunking that it happened well there's no
[2:55:11] there's no evidence for it there's no good evidence for it at all there's no camera there
[2:55:16] and the steakhouse receipt itself has never been confirmed to be tyler robinson's i'm assuming this is
[2:55:21] just like a talking point they gave you and you got to like keep pushing this or like i've been
[2:55:24] following it very closely on the receipt you didn't you weren't even following the charges
[2:55:28] of tyler robinson but you really wanted to know because i've been following it very closely on x
[2:55:33] wait i'm calling owners of state houses and having a conversation you're following
[2:55:37] i literally followed the entire trial or the preliminary live i was live with an attorney we
[2:55:42] covered all of it you think because i have a momentary where it lapse where i'm like oh it's
[2:55:47] murder no it's aggravated murder come on you didn't know any of the charges splitting
[2:55:51] hairs it means you didn't follow the preliminary hearing at all no it doesn't mean that at all
[2:55:56] any of the charges against him when this is like the this is like getting literally to the crux
[2:56:01] aggravated murder versus murder it's ridiculous and not only that let's point this out uh one
[2:56:07] of the major things here is that this is your official timeline mine yes who else is going to be
[2:56:14] who else there would be candace what's your issue with that well so the issue is is that the entirety
[2:56:23] of the evidence revolves around two people who claim that he was there and supposedly a receipt
[2:56:28] there's supposedly a receipt where tyler robinson paid for his steak and his soft drink no alcohol
[2:56:36] right no alcohol right you know nothing about the case but um anyway this particular receipt they
[2:56:45] could have called the merchant account confirmed it this type of thing to date this receipt has only
[2:56:51] the blurred information on it that would actually give you the information to confirm whose receipt it
[2:56:55] is we have today nobody has confirmed that this was actually tyler robinson's receipt and yet inside
[2:57:03] of candace owens timeline which she states over and over again when she says this is the longest 13
[2:57:09] hours this is 13 and a half hours the requirement for about what roughly five and a half or six hours
[2:57:16] of that is that he went to the steakhouse and so and that's not been confirmed at all not even a little
[2:57:24] bit i feel like saying that i spoke to the owner of the steakhouse is me like not just being on x looking
[2:57:29] at opinions but actually doing the legwork um and that's why i like i said if you think this builds
[2:57:34] up a rapport with your audience and makes you seem like a serious person we don't have to keep belaboring
[2:57:39] the point here i feel like i've demonstrated that i did as much as i could to confirm this when it came
[2:57:43] in i spoke to the owner of the restaurant um you know obviously took down everything he said noted that
[2:57:50] there was in fact a receipt that he pulled um that receipt that was published is real a debit card
[2:57:56] and a credit card was used if for some reason somebody misidentified something down the line
[2:58:02] or we find out it's a different tyler robinson uh i'm happy to remove it from my timeline but for
[2:58:07] right now i i think that there's enough under the utah 1102 rule for me to keep it there i don't really
[2:58:12] think we need to keep going into circles about this receipt it's it's my time i don't i don't know why
[2:58:16] the 1102 rule would apply here for your because you were constantly cite things that are said in that
[2:58:22] courtroom that have less evidentiary support than me contacting and speaking with the um the owner
[2:58:29] of the restaurant it's not like i dreamed it as just use your expression so it's in my timeline and
[2:58:35] i'm gonna keep it there if that's sure you can keep whatever you want there i'm just saying that
[2:58:38] there's no evidence he was ever there okay thank you no hard evidence anyway yeah we're fine with
[2:58:43] closing okay so the last thing we're gonna do before we go into ad break right after this will be
[2:58:47] final thoughts i'll be asking both of you if anything if if anything on your opinion thoughts
[2:58:53] changed on the case uh and then we'll finish it up from there so with that being said a three and a
[2:58:57] half minute break and we'll come back for final thoughts all right all right you guys if someone
[2:59:01] followed you everywhere that you went recorded what you searched and studied your habits you'd call
[2:59:05] the police when your smartphone does it we call it convenience at zero ghost they believe that you
[2:59:11] shouldn't have to trade your privacy for convenience that's why they created the ghost phone
[2:59:15] a smartphone built to give you more control over your personal information without giving up the
[2:59:19] things that you actually need a smartphone to do the ghost phone has been professionally hardened
[2:59:23] to minimize unnecessary tracking and make your phone substantially more difficult to hack or
[2:59:27] compromise and considering what some of you have been searching lately such as what does it mean
[2:59:32] to be yanking and banking maybe your smartphone doesn't need to know quite so much about you the best
[2:59:37] part is that you don't have to become a cyber security expert to use it you can keep your phone number
[2:59:42] you can keep your carrier you can use your normal apps call text take pictures you get a normal
[2:59:46] smartphone experience but with the privacy and security at the center of it all the difference
[2:59:51] is the phone is built around your privacy rather than building a business around your data
[2:59:54] so yank and bank your way over to zero ghost.com slash candace and use code candace at checkout for
[3:00:00] fifty dollars off your ghost phone that's zero ghost.com slash candace installment plans are
[3:00:05] available at checkout i also want to remind you guys about american financing because it is no secret
[3:00:09] that everything is starting to feel a lot more expensive if your daily essentials are ending up
[3:00:14] on a credit card those double digit interest rates are quietly draining your bank account if that debt
[3:00:18] is starting to feel heavy you should know that you're not alone if you're a homeowner you've likely
[3:00:22] looked at your mortgage rate and thought i shouldn't touch that but american financing offers a smart
[3:00:26] equity loan so that you don't have to it allows you to wipe out high interest debt and lower your monthly
[3:00:30] overhead while keeping your primary mortgage intact it's a surgical strike against debt unlike a
[3:00:35] fluctuating heloc the smart equity loan is a fixed rate loan giving you a predictable monthly payment
[3:00:41] at american financing there are never any upfront fees to find out what you qualify for so talk to
[3:00:45] a salary-based consultant today these experts who are paid to help you save not to sell you more than
[3:00:51] you need can help you if you call 800-795-1210 again that's 800-795-1210 or visit americanfinancing.net
[3:01:00] slash owens again that's americanfinancing.net slash owens i have to tell you guys about nimi
[3:01:05] skincare you know i love them they make the best tallow skincare products i've ever used their tallow
[3:01:11] comes from grass-fed grass-finished cattle raised on a montana farm in a world where so many companies
[3:01:16] hide where their ingredients are coming from that really matters everyone seems to be talking about
[3:01:20] tallow these days but not all tallow is created equally nimi has focused on sourcing exceptional
[3:01:24] ingredients and creating products that people genuinely love to use that's why i've been using nimi's
[3:01:29] sunshine tallow cream and their buzzin tallow balm the sunshine tallow cream has become one of nimi's
[3:01:34] most popular products it's rich nourishing and made with tallow aloe vera avocado oil and shea butter
[3:01:39] to deeply moisturize the skin while it's feeling lightweight and comfortable it leaves your skin
[3:01:43] looking soft hydrated and healthy without that greasy feeling when my skin needs a little extra
[3:01:48] support i reach for the buzzin tallow balm it's a richer formula that helps lock in moisture and leave
[3:01:52] skin feeling deeply nourished and cared for what i appreciate most is that these products are rooted in
[3:01:57] simplicity high quality ingredients american sourcing american manufacturing and skin care that simply
[3:02:02] works so if you've been curious about tallow skin care now is the perfect time to try it visit
[3:02:06] nemeskincare.com to save an additional 10 off your order with promo code candace 10 at checkout
[3:02:12] again that's nemeskincare.com a promo code candace 10 at checkout all right we are finally at the end
[3:02:19] for those of you that are watching it maybe a good commentary for you would be
[3:02:23] the following on if you're a andrew fan and you still are still saying you know what andrew's
[3:02:31] arguments were solid great candace great but did anything change your mind did you watch and say
[3:02:36] you know what i had this position over here this would be an interesting commentary to hear and of
[3:02:40] course for all the people that are watching i was just whispering to them here uh before we wrap it up i
[3:02:45] think whether you're a fan of andrew or not whether you're a fan of candace or not nobody can dispute the
[3:02:52] fact that these guys agreed to sit down and talk live others were thinking this was pre-recorded this
[3:02:58] is not pre-recorded just everybody knows this is purely live this is a little bit scarier than pre-recorded
[3:03:04] because pre-recorded can do edits so whether you agree with them or not let's make sure we respect
[3:03:09] both of them for having this sit down and before the final thoughts i want to make sure you guys hear
[3:03:13] that from me as well for inviting inviting me here as well of course i do know one day uh i think it was last
[3:03:19] week you sent a message on one of our accounts she said can i talk to patrick we got on the call you
[3:03:24] said patrick can you moderate this and then i said great let's do this and so before we wrap up final
[3:03:29] thoughts i'll come to you first yeah she had nothing just nothing any for all of her claims of patsy
[3:03:38] nothing she didn't have a single claim she didn't have a single solid piece of evidence she had no
[3:03:42] positive evidence israel's involved in anything no positive evidence that um france is involved in
[3:03:49] anything no positive evidence tp usa is involved in anything no positive evidence that erica kirk is
[3:03:56] involved in anything when i ask her about her claims about erica kirk yeah it's just fun and
[3:04:01] it's just fun and you know or yeah i do think that she needs to sit down ask some questions but
[3:04:07] or answer some questions but you know what um i don't even know if she has like maybe she has i have
[3:04:14] no idea yes i'm gonna have an official timeline with unconfirmed evidence that's just fine
[3:04:19] hey it's it's hearsay if that's good enough for the state's good enough for me but my biggest
[3:04:23] problem with the state is that they're admitting all this hearsay it's like it's she's a contradiction
[3:04:28] machine on top of all of this the thing that i wanted to get out of this more than anything else
[3:04:34] was to just demonstrate one thing yes it's true i'm not perfect on the case i'm not going to ever
[3:04:40] pretend that i am and never did but what has been very made very clear to me is that there's nobody
[3:04:47] with an alternative theory that has any evidence for it at all none zero and the continuous uh kind
[3:04:55] of expression we're running an investigation what kind of investigation builds a timeline out on
[3:05:03] on a receipt that they don't even confirm what kind of investigation uh tries to make these bold claims
[3:05:10] that israel's involved and france is involved and all these different players are involved and never
[3:05:15] shows any evidence we're just asking questions it's my it's again like i said my opening it's always
[3:05:20] intuition my feelings how i feel about things how i think about things yeah andrew how many times you
[3:05:26] hear this today andrew you can't tell me how i'm supposed to think yeah nobody's trying to tell you how
[3:05:32] to think but you should rationally come to your conclusions based on evidence and facts and the truth
[3:05:38] is is that 90 of what you're saying is simply intuition based it's k it did it came to me in a dream
[3:05:45] it's intuition almost none of it has any evidence at all just i'm skeptical because these people over
[3:05:50] here said things and that makes me skeptical it's like but no evidence note this to the audience to
[3:05:57] everybody watching you might hate my guts that's fair enough i get that i'm not the most likable man
[3:06:03] i understand that too but there was nothing i mean no evidence at all that tyler robinson was a patsy
[3:06:11] that was ever uh put forward by candace this entire debate now maybe you could say that we
[3:06:17] stalemated when it came to whether or not robinson did it she says i found the evidence convincing
[3:06:23] i are unconvincing andrew says he found the evidence convincing okay fair enough maybe you can't do too
[3:06:28] much about that but there was nothing she had nothing for robinson being a patsy nothing for any of her
[3:06:35] conspiracies not a zero zilch and she backed away on a bunch of them this is the first time i think
[3:06:40] she's ever really backed away from the twigs thing first time i've heard her back away from the erica
[3:06:45] thing back away from tp usa being very cautious about making any of those claims now whereas on her
[3:06:51] show much more likely to be making those claims so she just had nothing the entire debate zero candace
[3:07:00] well i think that is quite a conclusion admitting somewhere maybe we stalemated it probably signifies
[3:07:07] what i've been saying from the beginning that you didn't feel that you were strong on the actual
[3:07:12] facts and the evidence which i was willing to engage with you i wanted to go over the screwdriver
[3:07:16] i wanted to go over the towel the things that you've mentioned and you wanted to then move the
[3:07:19] conversation into a defense of erica kirk and her character um and what i've said about erica which
[3:07:26] is my opinion and i have not edited that opinion after discussing with you um i would like to extend a
[3:07:33] compliment to you for being willing to sit down and to have the conversation i still walk away
[3:07:40] feeling that the people who are jumping on the bandwagon about this case don't care about this
[3:07:46] case they don't care about erica kirk it tends to be follow that they take a meeting with turning point
[3:07:51] usa and they come out and suddenly have a lot of junk to say about candace owens and i do want to also
[3:07:59] stress that turning point usa tried to pepper him with something as a surprise he showed clips that
[3:08:05] were meant to be a surprise i did no such thing i stressed to pbd from the beginning that i was
[3:08:10] grateful he was taking this on and that i wanted this to be a clean debate because i believe i can
[3:08:15] win this on the merits and i believe that i did win this fully on the merits by engaging the evidence
[3:08:20] of what has happened um i do still believe that there is more evidence which supports that there are
[3:08:26] more people involved and that tyler robinson has been set up and that none of the evidence that
[3:08:32] was presented was in any way overwhelming which is why i think you wanted to move to end that
[3:08:36] discussion quickly and to speak to me about france and to talk about this pengwich receipt and my
[3:08:43] timeline i i want to remind people that a lot of the at-home investigators which you were open to as
[3:08:51] you called them internet sleuths i think it was on a show that you did right after charlie was
[3:08:56] assassinated that internet sleuths would solve this uh this is the reason why charlie a year
[3:09:01] on is still a conversation every single day trending on twitter i knew charlie i cared about charlie i
[3:09:07] care about um finding out what the truth is here my heart is in the right place i think anybody who
[3:09:12] watches my show or even just watch this debate knows that if i get something wrong i'll instantly
[3:09:16] correct it and own it i don't i'm not arrogant i don't need to sit here and pretend that i didn't
[3:09:20] misspeak on the lance thing it hasn't been ruled out uh but you saw that he just really wanted to
[3:09:25] hammer that point you know part of being a well-meaning person is to concede when you are
[3:09:31] wrong to take something off a timeline when you know it's not right and i would like to think that
[3:09:35] that is why i have earned the audience that continues to follow me because they know my heart's in the
[3:09:39] right place that i deeply cared about charlie and i deeply care about the answers um i want to thank
[3:09:44] andrew's team who are providing the fact checks it's a very small room that they're in um i want to as
[3:09:49] always thank my team who worked really hard to make this happen and flip the set and for to you uh
[3:09:54] pbd just for being a great moderator i think very fair letting us both speak and making sure that
[3:10:00] andrew got out of this what he wanted which is a little more than what i wanted but um i'm very
[3:10:06] content with how i dealt with this and i i won't let i trust i don't need to convince the audiences
[3:10:10] with the magic trick of what they need to think about this debate they can watch it and draw their own
[3:10:13] conclusions beautiful fair from both of you i think the audience won and again uh from the beginning
[3:10:19] all of this is because of how much love and respect we have for charlie kirk a great man that's no longer
[3:10:24] here with us his one year anniversary is coming up here i can't believe it's that quick that is here
[3:10:30] the audience i think you also want if you did support the crucible support the candace show support
[3:10:36] the pbd podcast subscribe to the channel this is how you help these voices get out even more
[3:10:41] especially going into future when this happens you want a lot of independent creators to have
[3:10:45] these types of discussions and last but not least the two of you i uh respect you guys again for
[3:10:50] having this conversation it is not easy to do so hopefully this will lead to more discussions a lot
[3:10:55] of different things we talked about i'm sure there will be a lot of follow-up with that being said
[3:10:59] take care everybody god bless have a great weekend