About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of π¨ Karen Read Reveals Secrets About John & Brian Albert in Newly Released Transcript from Loophole Lawyer, published July 9, 2026. The transcript contains 3,130 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Did he have aspirations to be somewhere else? Yeah, off the police department. Oh, he just was like kind of done? And there's some news I never heard of. Apparently, John O'Keefe no longer wanted to be a cop. John came over to me when everyone's milling around at the hillside and was on my own..."
[0:00] Did he have aspirations to be somewhere else?
[0:03] Yeah, off the police department.
[0:04] Oh, he just was like kind of done?
[0:07] And there's some news I never heard of.
[0:09] Apparently, John O'Keefe no longer wanted to be a cop.
[0:12] John came over to me when everyone's milling around at the hillside
[0:15] and was on my own going,
[0:17] Brian Albert likes me.
[0:18] Brian Albert likes me.
[0:20] And he sounded like a giddy schoolgirl.
[0:22] The way you described it to me, it sounded like,
[0:24] and I'm not putting words in your mouth at all,
[0:26] the information flowing my direction sounded like
[0:30] the new kid at a high school who just gets the blessing
[0:33] from the captain of the football team.
[0:35] Absolutely.
[0:37] He was so almost giddy.
[0:39] He likes me.
[0:40] He likes me.
[0:41] Like I'm in that inner circle-ish.
[0:44] So tell me more about the waterfall.
[0:46] The second place was the waterfall.
[0:49] Yep, I'd probably been there with John two other times.
[0:52] Like, again, these weren't places we normally went to.
[0:56] And I was gabbing the whole time,
[0:59] and John was kind of standing right behind me
[1:01] and talking to Matt McCabe and this man, Nick.
[1:04] And around 12, the lights came on,
[1:08] and suddenly there was talk of,
[1:10] let's go back to someone's house.
[1:11] The transcript of the interview between Karen Reed
[1:14] and Gretchen Voss, an author,
[1:16] were obtained via FOIA requests,
[1:18] and they contained fascinating information.
[1:20] And in this video, we are going to learn something about John.
[1:23] And I don't think anybody knew.
[1:25] In addition, we get to hear about
[1:26] how John and Brian Albert met.
[1:28] Yes.
[1:29] And John's apparent love for Brian Albert.
[1:32] Let's watch.
[1:33] And John is telling me,
[1:35] let's go by the Alberts.
[1:36] Jen is texting me.
[1:37] We're invited over there.
[1:38] And this was really the first I was hearing about it.
[1:41] I had thought up until this point,
[1:43] if we were going to move along with this group,
[1:45] we were going to get food.
[1:47] So it's not until I leave McCarthy's
[1:49] that this is the first time I hear
[1:51] that we're invited to this house,
[1:53] which I'm already uncomfortable with
[1:55] because I wasn't personally invited,
[1:57] nor did I even really engage
[1:58] with the people who own this house.
[2:00] I don't think I spoke to Brian's wife, Nicole,
[2:03] other than to say hi, if I even did.
[2:05] I mean, it was kind of like blanketed hellos,
[2:08] but I didn't talk to their grown daughter who was there.
[2:12] And I barely spoken to Brian in the eight days
[2:15] that I knew him, Brian Albert.
[2:17] Yes.
[2:18] So I wasn't loving this idea,
[2:22] but having told you what I told you about John
[2:26] and how he's got these little windows
[2:27] of doing what he wants to do,
[2:30] I knew that Brian was on the job with John
[2:33] and yet John and he never socialized.
[2:36] So I thought, all right, if I were in his shoes
[2:39] and this was another person from Fidelity,
[2:41] I would want John to, you know, support it.
[2:45] And this is a colleague.
[2:47] So I said, all right, John, whatever you want,
[2:49] then fine, we'll go.
[2:51] And did John have any relationship with Brian, really?
[2:55] Nope.
[2:56] We coincidentally, as I think I mentioned,
[2:59] met Brian formally for the first time, John and Brian.
[3:03] It appeared that they were meeting for the first time
[3:06] on January 22nd.
[3:07] We know that Karen Reed and John met Brian Albert
[3:10] at the hillside and they actually took a picture together.
[3:14] We were at the hillside.
[3:16] That was, John and I were coming back from the Bruins
[3:19] and they were just coincidentally there.
[3:22] And do they have like a lot of shop talk,
[3:24] like, hey, I'm a cop too?
[3:26] Very little.
[3:27] There was some kind of altercation.
[3:31] This is January 22nd, a week prior to John's death.
[3:35] There was some altercation outside of C.F. McCarthy's
[3:39] back on the other end of town.
[3:40] We're all up at 138 at hillside
[3:45] and there was some altercation in McCarthy's involving spouses
[3:51] that he, the husband, was out with another woman
[3:55] and there was some blow up at C.F. McCarthy's
[4:00] and Brian Albert, Chris Albert, and another man that was with them
[4:07] that knew John were talking about heading over there
[4:09] and beating someone up or roughing someone up.
[4:12] And there was some buildup going on
[4:15] where they were debating leaving the women at hillside
[4:18] and going to get into this fight.
[4:20] Ah, there's nothing better than overweight, middle-aged, suburban white men
[4:24] getting into a little brawl at a bar.
[4:26] John went outside with them to discuss
[4:28] and I didn't know what they were talking about at the time
[4:30] but John came back in.
[4:33] He said they want to go beat somebody up.
[4:35] I said, well, you're not going to go, are you?
[4:37] Like, do we even know?
[4:38] Who are these people?
[4:39] I don't think anything happened.
[4:42] I don't know where the Alberts went after that.
[4:45] We left now, again, January 22nd.
[4:49] We left probably around 11 from the hillside,
[4:53] maybe closer to like 11.45.
[4:56] And I said bye to Brian Albert and shook his hand
[5:01] and I said, oh, it was nice to meet you.
[5:05] You know, I'm sure we'll see you again now that we know you.
[5:08] And you and John are on the job together.
[5:10] And he was shaking my hand with his right hand
[5:15] and kind of pulled me in and said, you, we like.
[5:19] You, you, we like.
[5:22] You're cool.
[5:23] And the intimation was, but the other half of this couple,
[5:26] yeah, that's, it was very pointed.
[5:29] You, we, like.
[5:30] And then he kind of, you know, half cocked his head to John.
[5:34] How far was John when he did that?
[5:37] Me to David.
[5:38] But it's a bar, so it's loud.
[5:40] You don't think John heard that?
[5:43] No.
[5:44] I know John didn't hear that.
[5:46] Present at this interview is three of Karen's 79 attorneys,
[5:50] Alan Jackson, David Donetti, and Liza Little.
[5:54] It didn't mean anything to me.
[5:55] It meant more after the waterfall a week later,
[5:59] where there was no interaction.
[6:01] John said, hi, went out of his way.
[6:04] When we got there, went out of his way to shake
[6:06] Brian Albert's hand and Brian Higgins' hand.
[6:09] When John walks in, so we tend to focus,
[6:11] I tend to focus anyway, on him and Higgins.
[6:14] Watch the embrace between John and Brian Albert.
[6:18] It's an oddly long embrace.
[6:20] And Brian ends up realizing that John is kind of, like,
[6:24] touching too long.
[6:25] And then he hugs him back, like, twice.
[6:27] It's very strange.
[6:28] It is some subservient.
[6:30] You pointed that out.
[6:31] There is a subservience happening with John here
[6:34] to both of these men.
[6:35] Watch for John and Brian Albert,
[6:37] who's the man to the left of Brian Higgins
[6:39] with the vest on.
[6:41] Gotcha.
[6:41] Wow, John.
[6:42] So here we go.
[6:44] Yeah, look at him.
[6:44] Yeah, he's sort of leaning in.
[6:45] He's almost, like, bowing.
[6:46] Yep.
[6:47] And then watch Brian Albert.
[6:49] Look, see, he grabs him back.
[6:51] Like, okay.
[6:51] And they're still talking.
[6:53] And then it looked like,
[6:56] especially when I watched the surveillance,
[6:58] it looks like we're with my colleagues
[7:00] and John's my significant other.
[7:01] This is absolutely fascinating
[7:04] because Karen Reed is recalling
[7:07] exactly what happened at the waterfall
[7:09] on the night for which John O'Keefe died.
[7:12] She claims that John was just hanging in the back
[7:15] as if he didn't really know anybody there.
[7:17] And it's sort of true,
[7:18] except for the fact that we did see
[7:20] John O'Keefe and Brian Albert
[7:22] speaking together for over 20 minutes.
[7:25] And Samantha and I covered that
[7:26] in our video together.
[7:28] So now John is there at 11.02 and 45 seconds.
[7:31] So if you look right in the middle,
[7:33] we have John,
[7:35] then we have Brian Albert,
[7:36] and then you have Brian Higgins.
[7:37] Higgins is sort of hanging behind Brian Albert
[7:40] for most of this conversation.
[7:41] You'll see Higgins is now leaning in a little bit
[7:44] closer to Brian Albert,
[7:45] but John is talking to Brian Albert specifically.
[7:48] It's clearly a conversation between him and Brian Albert.
[7:51] 100%.
[7:52] Which is interesting.
[7:53] Did Brian Albert testify
[7:54] that he really didn't converse with John on this night?
[7:57] Yeah, so that's not true,
[7:58] obviously,
[7:59] because you're going to see it's over 23 minutes.
[8:01] So from here until 11.23, 11.25,
[8:05] they're going to be talking,
[8:06] those three exclusively.
[8:09] Brian Albert has like moved his positioning.
[8:11] So now he's actually facing John even more so.
[8:14] It doesn't look like we're with cops.
[8:16] And I'm with John who knows these people.
[8:20] I'm socializing and talking to everybody.
[8:22] And John's hanging in the back nearly the entire 90 minutes we were there
[8:27] and getting drinks, going back and forth to the bar, closing out tabs.
[8:32] But he did not interact with Brian at all.
[8:36] This is a very odd and incorrect statement by Karen Reed.
[8:40] Based upon the time for which they were there,
[8:42] actually, John O'Keefe spent the majority of it speaking with Brian Albert.
[8:47] Eventually, when Karen makes her way all the way around the big old Brian Patrick Higgins,
[8:52] then you see John hanging in the back as if he wasn't really wanted
[8:56] or no one was really talking to him.
[8:57] But initially and throughout most of the night,
[9:00] he was speaking exactly with Brian Albert,
[9:03] contradicting what Karen is saying here.
[9:05] And then in the aftermath of what happened the following morning on January 29th,
[9:12] it started to click.
[9:14] Like John was persona non grata.
[9:16] They lived three miles apart.
[9:18] John was on the force for 16 years.
[9:22] I don't know how long Brian was, but longer than John.
[9:25] And this is a drinking town.
[9:29] Everybody goes to the same three or four bars.
[9:32] And these two men who are drinkers have not socialized.
[9:39] And now in hindsight, and I, again, didn't know who Brian Albert was prior to January 22nd.
[9:46] But in hindsight, it's like, yes, this was a purposeful avoidance.
[9:51] I'm not even from Canton.
[9:54] I didn't.
[9:55] I owned a house in another town.
[9:57] And yet I knew who everybody was just from sports and bars.
[10:03] And that these two men had not warmed up to each other.
[10:07] You'd have to do that intentionally in that town.
[10:10] Throughout the 170-page transcript from this interview, Karen Reeve references Brian Albert
[10:16] and little Colin Albert a majority of the time with regard to who could potentially have
[10:22] attacked John O'Keefe.
[10:23] Here she's setting up a potential motive for Brian Albert.
[10:27] Yes.
[10:28] But clearly on the waterfall video, which they had for over 20 minutes, these two were talking,
[10:34] conversing, cuddling.
[10:35] There was no visible animosity at all.
[10:39] And it makes you wonder why she never revealed in this 170-page transcript that one of the
[10:46] 10 potential people in this entire world that could have killed John O'Keefe had the biggest
[10:52] motive known to human apes, the elimination of a rival male.
[10:56] And of course, was speaking about Brian Patrick Higgins, old Higgy Bear.
[11:00] My personal read of Brian is that he was standoffish.
[11:04] He was gruff.
[11:05] He could have been missing his three front teeth.
[11:09] She's speaking about Brian Albert, not Brian Higgins.
[11:12] Yes.
[11:13] And I wouldn't have known.
[11:15] So he, the two times I was in his company, he had like a ski vest on and a stocking hat,
[11:23] beard, and just gruff is the perfect, perfect word for him.
[11:27] When this discussion at the Hillside on January 22nd was taking place about potentially getting
[11:33] in this fight and then it seemed to have diffused and they called off the dogs, John came over
[11:39] to me when everyone's milling around at the Hillside and was on my own going, Brian Albert
[11:44] likes me.
[11:45] Brian Albert likes me.
[11:46] And he sounded like a giddy schoolgirl.
[11:49] Well, who wouldn't be giddy if Brian Albert liked you?
[11:51] He's so dreamy.
[11:52] Yes.
[11:53] And at the time, didn't really mean much to me.
[11:57] It was in the immediate aftermath of John's death that our private investigator said,
[12:04] we've heard that the homeowner has a history.
[12:09] He's an aggressor and he doesn't get along with many people.
[12:14] And I told David and Paul, that's funny because on January 22nd, John was acting relieved that
[12:21] he had made some landfall, so to speak, with Brian Albert or that they had even met and
[12:30] that we all seem to be getting along okay for the hour and a half that we were at the Hillside
[12:36] on January 22nd.
[12:38] The way you described it to me, it sounded like, and I'm not putting words in your mouth
[12:42] at all, but the information flowing my direction sounded like the new kid at a high school who
[12:51] just gets the blessing from the captain of the football team.
[12:54] That's what it sounded like.
[12:56] Absolutely.
[12:58] He was so almost giddy.
[13:01] He likes me.
[13:01] He likes me.
[13:02] Like I'm, I'm in that inner circle-ish.
[13:06] John lamented to me that he foresaw his role at the sex offender registry going to a civilian.
[13:15] I mean, he was, and as I said earlier, John had no pretension, bravado, cockiness at all
[13:24] about being a cop.
[13:25] He just wanted to do his job and leave.
[13:29] And when he took on the kids, he was given special dispensation to not live within the,
[13:35] whatever it is, 10, 10 mile radius of Boston proper.
[13:39] Can I ask you a quick question about that?
[13:41] What about Brian Albert?
[13:42] No, I think he, I think it's for the first 10, there's some time.
[13:49] I think it's for the first 10 years you're on the force.
[13:53] Apparently there is some residency rule with regard to being a Boston cop and living, I
[13:57] guess, around or near Boston for the first 10 years that you're on the force.
[14:02] And John was given an exemption because of the situation with his sister's kids.
[14:08] He knew, per his own admission, you know, I can't wait.
[14:13] He was always looking at the chart of when he could retire and how much could he live on
[14:18] and what's the soonest he could get out constantly, like it would change somehow from one day to
[14:24] the next.
[14:25] And the pecking order, you want to be on a specialized unit, the gang unit, the drug unit,
[14:31] the fugitive unit, the sex offender registry is, well, I guess.
[14:37] Don't worry.
[14:38] I won't write that.
[14:40] Did he have aspirations to be somewhere else?
[14:43] Yeah.
[14:44] Off the police department.
[14:45] Oh, he just was like kind of done.
[14:48] And there's some news I never heard of.
[14:50] Apparently John O'Keefe no longer wanted to be a cop.
[14:53] The six months leading up to his death, we had been working with my friend, my best friend,
[14:57] who's a consultant, and her husband, who's very close to John, about John potentially
[15:05] putting wheels in motion to take over his father's plumbing business.
[15:08] So John, John was a talented plumber.
[15:13] We definitely know Karen is not lying about that because we heard about all the pipe John
[15:16] laid in Canton.
[15:18] And he had done it.
[15:19] When he was on Duxbury, he kind of did part-time Duxbury and part-time helping his father's
[15:27] plumbing business.
[15:28] I mean, his father was slowing down physically and, but had a rich customer base and customer
[15:35] loyalty, but didn't have the business savvy, but really could have turned it into something
[15:42] if John wanted to commit to that.
[15:43] I mean, now I think, I don't know if John was ever going to pull, he wasn't a risk taker.
[15:47] He, he wasn't entrepreneurial.
[15:51] Yeah.
[15:51] He was not, did not have the entrepreneurial spirit.
[15:56] Perhaps he didn't have the entrepreneurial spirit, but calling him not a risk taker is
[16:01] a hundred percent false.
[16:02] My man risks his life every single day as a police officer.
[16:06] I'm way too much of a pansy to do that.
[16:09] Being an entrepreneur is easy in terms of risk.
[16:11] Um, but he was entertaining and I think at least satiated his frustration with his, with
[16:18] his role at, at A1.
[16:20] Right, right.
[16:21] So back at the bar, real quick, what is Brian Albert like at this bar?
[16:27] He, he is the ice sculpture that the congregation happened around.
[16:32] He plants himself and it was the same way at the hillside.
[16:39] He plants himself and everyone just kind of mills around.
[16:43] Like you go to the mountain if you want to talk to him, like monotone.
[16:47] And if you can't hear him, then you've got, you've got to lean in, just standoffish.
[16:52] We'll end the video right there.
[16:54] But this transcript is absolutely fascinating, giving us perfect insight into exactly what
[17:01] Karen Reed was thinking and what she probably would testify about at her deposition and
[17:06] her eventual civil trials.
[17:09] Throughout the 170 pages of this transcript, she fails to mention the affair she had with
[17:15] Brian Patrick Higgins.
[17:17] I'm not sure if it's out of embarrassment, which I could totally understand being naive
[17:22] or just ignorant to the fact that there was one person on this entire earth that had the
[17:28] means, motive and opportunity to kill John O'Keefe.
[17:32] And that was our old cuddly, but violent Higgy Bear.
[17:35] But no matter what Karen admits to, we will never, ever stop producing these videos until
[17:40] the real killer, Brian Higgins, is brought to justice.
[17:43] Loophole lawyer, we riding for justice.
[17:49] We would not stop dropping these facts every week to Brian Higgins, like the justice for
[18:01] John O'Keefe.
[18:03] For Johnny, simple crime at times, few names.
[18:07] One of these ten did it.
[18:09] We screaming the claims.
[18:11] This case was easy, no smoking mirrors.
[18:17] Small area, quick timeline, limited suspects.
[18:20] No errors, ten people involved.
[18:22] That's the whole damn crew.
[18:23] Remove the kids in the McCabe.
[18:24] Now we down a few, three left standing, Brian Albert, Higgy Bear.
[18:28] Chloe the dog, just chilling right there.
[18:31] I didn't do it.
[18:32] I'm a good girl, fact.
[18:33] Chloe innocent, she get a clean pass.
[18:36] We will not stop dropping these facts every week.
[18:40] Brian Higgins locked up.
[18:43] This for John O'Keefe.
[18:52] We screaming the claims.
[18:55] Yeah.
[18:56] Down to Brian's.
[18:59] Only one of them means motive, opportunity.
[19:01] That's Higgy chilling.
[19:03] Chris, but when it's real.
[19:05] I kiss gay Jeff.
[19:06] They're the one who sealed the deal.
[19:08] Brian Albert, nah, the guy.
[19:10] We got the facts lined up.
[19:12] Watch the truth fly.
[19:13] Hide in conclusions.
[19:14] We stay patient and cool.
[19:16] Once the evidence hit, they simple fool.
[19:19] I didn't do it.
[19:20] Dog, I didn't do it.
[19:22] Chloe cleaning out of picture crystal clear.
[19:24] Followed by three question marks.
[19:25] Justice for John O'Keefe.
[19:27] Every week.
[19:33] Brian to Brian to Brian Higgins.
[19:35] Locked up.
[19:36] Justice for John O'Keefe.
[19:38] Justice for John.
[19:45] We screaming the day.
[19:46] Join Samantha Bonino every.
[19:54] Nuna with loophole.
[19:55] Lawyer goes home.
[20:06] John O'Keefe.
[20:12] Let's go.
[20:23] Let's go.