Good morning, everybody. If I could ask you to take your seats and come to order, please. I'd like to call this meeting of Tampa City Council to order. Please take your seats and silence all cell phones, conversations. If you need to talk, if you'd go outside, we'd appreciate it. So why are we here this morning? I'd like to call this meeting to order. Clerk, I'm sorry, start with an invitation, please. Everybody rise for a moment of silence. Councilman Mateskalko, to lead us in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. Thank you. Clerk, would you please call the roll? Miranda, Mateskalko, Hurtat, Young. Here. Well, this is a special meeting. We start off with six and we'll end with seven. Our first order of business today is the swearing in of our seventh member of Tampa City Council, Robin Lockett. And I would like to, if you are family and you've invited people up that you want to be with you, before I start that, I actually want to acknowledge at least a couple of people I see in the audience. Commissioner Gwen Myers is in the audience, newly re-elected Commissioner Gwen Myers, by the way. And I see on the back wall, I see Representative Louise Salazar from the State House. Oh, chair, everybody's correcting me. I'm sorry, it's Chairwoman Gwen Myers. Wow. Not only re-elected, but she was elected to become the Chairwoman of the County Commission. I think I got everybody, and if I didn't, I apologize. So now with the star of the day, our Councilwoman-elect, last time we could say that, Councilwoman-elect Robin Lockett, I'd like to recognize our clerk, Shirley Fox-Knowles, to administer the oath of office. Go ahead. Mornings where, that I will support, uphold, and defend the Charter, and ordinances, of the City of Tampa, the Constitution and laws, of the State of Florida, and the Constitution and laws, the Constitution and laws, of the United States of America, of the United States of America, that I'm a resident, that I'm a resident, and elector, and elector, of the City of Tampa, of the City of Tampa, and am entitled to hold, and am entitled to hold, the Office of Council Member of the City of Tampa, the Office of Council Member of the City of Tampa, to which I've been elected, to which I've been elected, And that I will faithfully perform the duties of said position into and of which I'm about to enter. So help me, God. So help me, God. I state your name. I'm Robin Lockett. A citizen of the State of Florida and of the United States of America and being employed by or an officer of the City of Tampa, Florida and a recipient of public funds. As such employee or officer, do hereby solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States and of the State of Florida. Congratulations! Clerk, you need her to sign those now? Yes, please. Councilwoman Lockett, sign your documents. I understand that you have a couple of folks that you'd like to speak. If individuals would like to speak, if you would go to the podium and start with your name, please. I guess we both are nervous. I'm usually the behind the scenes person. Start with your name, please. My name is Ida Walker, and I should know better. But anyway, my name is Ida Walker, and Robin Lockett is my sister. She thinks she's my oldest sister, but she's actually my younger sister. Can I pause you for one moment? Yes. Why are you standing there? Come take your seat. You know, if you left that empty for another minute, Vieira was going to come back. I'd like to recognize former Councilman Louis Vieira, current state representative. All right. I'm sorry. Continue. I just want to say that one of the things I've, as her older sister, I've been in her life all of her life. And one of the things I know about her is her passion. So she's been passionate about the community and the people of the community. And she has shown that passion from time to time. And she was the same way in the family. So there was a lot of debating going on. Yeah. Yeah. But one thing that I know about her is that she will, she will represent the community and she will represent it well. And I'm happy to be here with my other family members on behalf of our mom. This is her Bible that she was sworn in on. We, one thing that I know that she will be totally happy and she will be proud of today. And, uh, I want to wish Robin the very best and, uh, welcome to the city. My name is Xavier Owens. Robin Lockett is my mother. Um, I'm just proud, honestly. She works super hard. Uh, she's been built for this moment as long as I've been alive. You know, she's always been an activist, community first, my friends first, her family first, whoever it comes to. You know what I mean? So, um, she just always been somebody that always kind of understood the mission and put herself aside for the good of the mission. And I just know she's going to do the same thing in office. So this is kind of just kind of full circle. It's not really a shock to me. It's just full circle. You know what I'm saying? Robin is a petition. Yeah. Come on up. That's not bad. All right. Talk with your name, please. Hi, I'm Mikayla Grace. I'm your National Juneteenth Ambassador Legacy Queen. Hi, my name is Rajne Lezen. I'm Junior Miss Juneteenth Tampa Bay. Hi, my name is Kylie Downey and I'm Little Miss Juneteenth Tampa Bay. Hello, I'm Edwin Costa, President of the National Juneteenth Ambassador Initiative Program. Hi, my name is Kamaya Downey and I'm a proud National Juneteenth Ambassador. Yes. Hi, my name is Aris Washington and I'm a proud National Juneteenth Ambassador. I prepared a speech for you. Good morning, distinguished officials, honored guests, and members of our community. On behalf of the National Juneteenth Ambassadorship Initiative, it is my honor and privilege to congratulate our newly elected City Councilwoman for District 7, the Honorable Robin Lockett. Today, we are not simply celebrating a woman who has earned a seat at the table. We are celebrating a woman who has consistently made room at the table for others, especially young people like us. Although all of our ambassadors could not be present today because of the Great American Teaching, I am proud to share that thanks in part to your guidance and encouragement, as well as those of Councilwoman Nyah Young, several of our ambassadors are presenting at various schools throughout our community today. Those of us who are present will also be participating in the Great American Teaching immediately following this ceremony. Councilwoman Lockett, you have supported the National Juneteenth Ambassadors from our very inception. Long before you earned this title, you were already demonstrating the qualities of a true leader. You showed up for us. You encouraged us. You celebrated our accomplishments. And most importantly, you made us feel that our voices mattered. Your passion for youth has never gone unnoticed. You, along with Councilwoman Nyah Young, have consistently made us feel special. Whenever we are in your presence, we never feel like we are just children attending another community event. You made us feel like we are in the room and that we have something valuable to contribute. And that means more to us than you may ever realize. Sometimes adults tell young people that we are the leaders of tomorrow. But you have helped us understand that we don't have to wait until tomorrow to make a difference today. As National Juneteenth Ambassadors, the importance of knowing our history and our legacy and exercising our civic responsibilities. Today, we have the privilege of witnessing history unfold right before our eyes. And while many people will celebrate the title that you have earned, we want to celebrate the heart that you have long before you received it. The title may be new, but your commitment to the community is not. Councilwoman Lockett, as you begin this new chapter of leadership, please note that you have an entire generation of young people watching, learning, cheering, and believing in you. Thank you for seeing us before the world recognizes us, for encouraging us before we reach our fullest potential, and for reminding us that leadership is not about how important you become, but how important you make others feel. Congratulations, Councilwoman Robin Lockett. District 7 has gained a Councilwoman, but we are grateful that we have not lost a champion. And I personally want to thank you for surprising me at my sweet 16th party. May God bless you as you serve, lead, and continue to inspire. Thank you. Congratulations, Robin. Welcome to the dais. We're happy to hear it. And you know, something that might not occur to you now for the rest of your life, you are honorable, Robin Lockett. Yeah. Well, so those of you that don't know, we had great American teaching this morning. I think most of the folks up here today, including our mayor participated at various schools around Hillsborough County. And that was one of the reasons why we had the late start. Um, but we do have a full agenda in front of us. And now we have a full council with seven votes. I would like to start that agenda with, can I get a motion to a, what's that? Oh, we're gonna do photos. What's that? Oh, let's do another roll call. Yes. Okay. Very good. Now we've got a new roll call. That's good. Uh, so we're gonna, I have to make one motion adoption and then, uh, well, since you're there, do you want to take the picture now? Do you want to, while you're standing there? Okay. Yeah. Come on everybody. Smile and be pretty. This is your, put your mics down. Sitting down or standing up first? Seated first. Um, can you put that? Thank you. All right. One, two, three. Who wants us to re-take the pictures in a couple days? Hey, um, Mr. Chair. Councilman Carlson. Um, we, we missed, um, Curtis Stokes was just here. He was a former council member. Oh, he was appointed. What was it? 12 years ago? It was Curtis. I didn't see Curtis. He walked out, but he was a, he was a former council member appointed also. I did not see him. I missed him. Sorry about that. Um, okay. Now, okay. Let's, we're gonna give, if you guys, for conversation, if you clear the room and have that conversation outside, cause we got a busy agenda. Bye guys. Okay. I need a motion to approve the minutes of the regular session held on November 5th, 2026 and the evening session held on November 12th, 2026. I have a motion from Councilman Maniscalco. Second from Councilwoman Hertek. All those in favor, say aye. Councilwoman Young. Now my brain is in his mouth. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed. The ayes have it. Those have been approved. Okay. Everybody's quieted down. Okay, good. Um, approval of the agenda. Well, we can cross the group photo. Off of that. Um, pre for our previous discussion, we're going to, um, do items 64 through 78, which are as the charter amendments, second reading. Um, there is a public hearing. There will be opportunity for public comment after each one of those 64 through 78. After those are done, we will have on agenda public comment. And depending on the schedule, our plan is to break for lunch around two, two 30. So FYI, um, after the, depending on how that works out, we'll have off agenda items, public comment before, right before lunch. And then depending on how the schedule goes, we won't get to the consent agenda until after probably lunch. Uh, I saw your hand go up, Mr. Shelby. I think you're, uh, the, the, uh, the goal is to allow for off agenda public comment before council breaks. Yes. Per our agreement. Um, and so everybody's, everybody's clear with what, how the state, the flow is going to go. Yeah. Okay. Very good. So let's go through staff reports and see if what we need staff councilwoman her tech. Yeah. We do have a quick administrative update. Yes, we do. Okay. And that is still correct. Mr. Bennett. Chief. Okay. Okay. Very good. Okay. Staff. Let's one at a time. What do we need here? Is staff needed for 86? Well, 87 is going to be the commission staff center. People are going to be here. 86. No. No for 86. No staff. No staff. 87. They're going to be here. Correct. Is that, is that still true? Councilman Miranda. Yes. Okay. Uh, 88. Do we need it though? They'd like to present. Okay. So yes. Okay. Yes. Uh, 89. Yes. Okay. 90. Okay. And can I get a motion to receive and file an ID one motion councilwoman her text from councilman a scout call. Those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. I have a motion to approve the agenda for councilwoman her tech. A second for councilman, a scalco. All those in favor say aye. Aye. And the addendum. That's right. We have the addendum. Was there anything I missed on that? No. Okay. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. Ayes have it. Thank you. It's approved. Um, and I need a personal point of privilege. I need to break. You guys can remain in your chairs if you'd like. I have to step out of chambers for one moment. Well, no, let's just wait. Okay. Thank you guys for your patience. And let's get into it. I'd like to recognize Mr. Tinkler. Mr. Chairman. Mr. Shelby. The items we're taking up are items number. Again, it's 64 through 78. These are non quasi judicial proceedings. Would you like to make a motion to open the public hearings? Second. I have a motion from Councilman Maniscalco. A second from Councilman Miranda. Open all public hearings. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. Ayes have it. Again, Mr. Tinkler. Good morning to you, sir. Good morning, counsel. For the record, I'm Ken Tinkler with Carlton Fields. I'm here in your role as outside counsel solely limited to charter amendment issues. As you know, this is second reading on each of these items. I'll just start with the first and we'll have 15 public hearings here. Item number 64 is the proposed ordinance asking the electors if they wish to create section 2.15 of the city charter. This new section would give the ability to city council to override and thus render void an executive order promulgated by the mayor under the charter and providing for an effective date. Very good. Okay. So that is item number 64. Is there any comments? Just one question. Mr. Is this the one that you need five votes override the mayor? Correct. Executive order. In order for them to approve it is four votes. To execute on it is a five vote. Clarification on the question. With regard to the substance of the charter amendment, would that, is the purpose of this thing require the five votes or not? Not this one. On the substance of the charter amendment, the ballot question provides by affirmative vote of no less than five city council members acting by resolution. Okay. Let me provide, I think there's a misconnect. So the amendment that we're considering gives council the ability to override an executive order by the mayor's office with five votes. Correct. The council to pass this today requires four before it goes to the, to the mayor. That's going to make sure. Correct. Yeah. Very good. Just, just want to make sure we're fine. Okay. Very good. Clarity is better. Okay. Any further discussion? Sure. Is it councilman? So, you know, I've been here almost 12 years. The only time that this has come up was with the, uh, citizens police review board and it got settled before. Is this absolutely necessary? Do you, do you feel, or is it like a, you know, just in case if a situation comes up in the future or? I think what's, do you mind if I respond? Is that okay? I don't want to go out of turn. Okay. Um, part of this, in fact, I've had this discussion with the mayor is, you know how we use every once in a while we have these, uh, what we consider charter crisis where we don't have a mechanism to fix. Let's say a future mayor somewhere down the line decides for cost savings or whatever. They want to lock up old city hall and different outside of business hours. Then they signed an executive order, sealing the building. We don't have any way of reversing that order. Um, I, there were several other examples of very similar. Oh, you know, the other extreme, of course, not I was on the positive side of the mayor on this, but like, let's say, uh, during a health crisis at COVID when some of the executive orders were passed, let's say that this council was a different council and there were, you know, the city was being shut down and the council disagreed with that shutdown. This would give this, this provides a check and balance system to counter that. Again, it would require five, which we all know we're receiving five votes is very difficult, but it would provide a check and balance. So for example, during COVID that they bring that up, the mayor closed the parks, right? Right. Would we be able to override and say people need to be outside? We disagree. Yes. Okay. All right. Thank you. Okay. Very good. It, I think this would be very rarely used and, and I said this before, but power does not come from documents. Power comes from building consensus among people and working with people because power is, is people and anybody who's intimidated by something like this shows that they don't know how to build consensus. Thank you. Yeah. And I think, I think a lot of these things as we move through these today, our approach those because I don't, you know, substance and all these, these are not a lot of heavy lifting items, right? For the most part, with the exception of one. I look at government as we see up and down the ladder from the local level, all the way up to the national level as the way it works in the United States of America is through checks and balances and balances and having balances and having checks and having, having that relationship so that not one entity controls the narrative or not one entity controls everything. So to be able to have that type of balance. And I think this, this provides a little bit more balance, a little bit more check. Okay. Is there anybody in the public who wishes to speak to this item? Ms. Pointer? All right, with your name, please. Good morning, Stephanie Pointer. So we're only talking about the five. Well, first of all, that would require five of you to agree on something, which damn near never happens. Second of all, I just want to point out one executive order that was given that I think some of you, actually, you guys got blamed for by some ding dong who was running for the house, um, Bob Buckhorn center or whatever it is over there at Julian B lane. Y'all didn't agree to that. Everybody, we have to, I want to see all the letters where people promoted that because when we named Lisa Cheshire park, it took a lot of work on our part, but poof, here we go. We'll name something. But I, the letters, the argument from the mayor on this was that she had issued emergency orders will nobody disagreed with those during COVID. And it just takes a hell of a lot. And guess what? Our president is checked by our legislative branch as well. So this is not asking for miracles. I mean, honestly, I would fall out unless it was something absolutely crazy going on. So thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Hearing none. Okay. That closes public comment. Councilman Carlson. Move. Oh, can I get a motion to close? Motion to close. Councilman Miranda second. Councilman Maniscalco. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed. Councilman Carlson. Yeah. For file number E2 026 dash 8 CH2. Ordinance being presented for a second reading adoption ordinance relating to the government of the city of Tampa, Florida, submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of Tampa of 1975 as amended to create section 2.15, providing the ability to city council to override and thus render void an executive order promulgated by the mayor under the charter providing effective date. I have a motion from Councilman Carlson second from Councilman Miranda. Please record your vote. One, two, three, four, five. Motion carried unanimously. Thank you. And it was unanimous. You know, we need to keep you around. Whilst I love you all, we have a rule in Tampa city council chambers. We don't allow boos. We don't allow claps. It's not audience participation because what happens is that starts and then we lose track of where we are or there may be a speaker and we can't hear what they're saying. So if you could applaud in silence, I would love that. Thank you. Mr. Tinkler. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Next item number 65 as a proposal to amend the charter section 2.04. This regards the ability giving to clarify the city council has the ability to create and fill additional staff positions to assist city council. As long as the funds are allocated within the city council's budget, removing the requirement for prior mayoral approval, providing an effective date. Councilman Maniscalco. So I think this is safe because after amendment three, we're not going to have any money anyway. So I'm fine with this. Yeah. You know, an example of mayor actually asked me of this. I said, you know, we have a good example of this. Tanya, who's actually for the clerk's office. We don't, she, she doesn't, she's not, doesn't work for us. But if for some reason the clerk, because of amendment three, pulled that, we may have to replace that person. Sure. Go ahead. It was a shortage of cash. I was chair, worked out with the clerk of the office. We shared half the salary so we could have somebody there for the public to come in and speak with. That's how that happened way back. But yeah, I could definitely see a time where like in that position was vacant. We might, we might have to fill that position, something like that. Okay. Any further discussion? Hearing none. Is there anybody in the public that wish to speak to this item? Shocking. You just need to sit up here. Good morning, Stephanie Pointer. That is the pot calling the kettle black. If somebody's worried about the budget for you guys getting one or two extra people. There are many municipalities who have a legislative aide who handles everybody's business, who takes care of the chair as well. Um, so we're talking about $100,000 a year, maybe when she's building a $40 million warehouse for TPD, a $40 million warehouse. And that's what it was called on the last time it was on the agenda was a warehouse. Go figure pot calling kettle black. And you know what? If the communications department acted like we have eight public officials in this city instead of one, then maybe nobody would be asking about it. But I have screamed for years about how the communications department ignores this body. And I'll give you the primary example. There was nothing put out that city council was delayed till 11 o'clock today. The only communications that was done was a sign put on this door. Now I knew it, but why would the administration ignore something like that when people have to come down here and pay to park? It's just rude and disrespectful. So the bottom line is when you have people who work in the administration who are constantly trying to undermine this body, maybe this body needs another, another person to help with what you've got to get done. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Say with the name, please. Good morning, Fran. Tate. East Tampa. I agree with everything that Stephanie said. The sentence that gets it for me that I love removing the requirement for prior mayoral approval. That gets it for me. But she's right. You guys need more help. She's right. Very few people knew about the meeting change today. If you had printed your agenda prior to leaving home, you would have read 11 a.m. But nobody does that because you guys do it for us. So, yes, I agree. Thank you. Anybody else in the public wish to speak to this item? Yes, sir. Come on up. And please take a moment to check your cell phones. Make sure they're on silence. Good morning, sir. Start with your name, please. Yeah. David Phillipson for the record. And I just want to alliterate, alliterate, follow up on what this, the elder just said. As far as the meeting change, I had no idea. So I think you guys need to do a better job of that. Other than that, I will see you guys during citizens' comments. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else? That closes public hearing. Council, any discussions? Hearing none. Okay. Can I get a motion to close? Councilman Maniscalco, second from Councilwoman Hurtek. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed. The ayes have it. Councilwoman Lockett, are you ready to read this one? Do you want to? I know you're new. I haven't really gotten all of this stuff. You're welcome to pass if you'd like. But if you want to give it a shot, this is a good, safe one to give it a shot at. And we can help you through it. Can you just read it? Start with file number. Okay. So I move file number E2026-8. Chapter 2. Chapter 2. Ordinance being presented for a second reading and adoption. An ordinance relating to the government of the city of Tampa submitting to the electors of the city, a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of Tampa of 1975. As amended to amend section 2.04 to clarify that city council may create and fill additional staff positions to assist city council. As long as the funds are allocated within city council's budget. Removing the requirement for prior mayoral approval. Finding any, I'm sorry, providing an effective date. That's it. Thank you. I have a motion for councilwoman Lockett. I have a second councilman Menescalco. Please record your vote. Motion carried unanimously. Thank you. Mr. Tinkler. Thank you. Next item on number 66 as a proposal to amend the city charter. It has the electors to amend the city charter to amend section 2.03. We're clarifying city council's ability to require members attendance, providing for an effective date. As you may remember, this is just simply regarding a word change from the current charter. Councilman Menescalco. Yeah. I mean, this is, this is an easy no brainer, but you know, I, I believe, you know, you need to show up and you need to show up on time. So I'm good. And this is already in the charter. It's just changing. It's just the word. It's the word of about the required tenants. Gotcha. Anybody else? Hearing none. It closes public comment. Motion to close. Councilwoman Herchek. Second from, I'm sorry. Councilwoman Young. Second from Councilman Menescalco. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed. Aye. Councilwoman Young. So, in the CH22026-8 Chapter 2, I move an ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption and ordinance relating to the government of the city of Tampa, Florida, submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the Revised Charter of the city of Tampa of 1975, as amended, to amend Section 2.03, clarifying city council's ability to require their members' attendance, providing an effective date. Second. I have a motion from Councilwoman Young. I have a second from Councilman Miranda. Please record your vote. Mr. Kerri, unanimously. Thank you. Mr. Tinkler. chinkler next is item number 67 a proposal to ask the electors to amend section 2.08 of the city charter clarifying the ordinance reading procedures must follow general law and clarifying that three city council members must vote in the affirmative to require the whole text of proposed ordinance to be read at first at final reading as opposed to only the title of the ordinance where general law requires two readings of an ordinance thank you council i have any questions hearing none is anybody public who wants to speak to this item motion to close to councilwoman her tech second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed i as have it councilwoman her tech yes ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 2.08 clarifying that the ordinance reading procedures must follow general law and clarifying that three city council members must vote in the affirmative to require the whole text of a proposed ordinance be read at final reading as opposed to only the title of the ordinance when general law requires two readings of the ordinance providing an effective date i have a motion from councilwoman her tech i have a second from councilman miranda please record your vote motion care unanimously thank you very much mr tinkler next item is item 68 this is a proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 4.01 of the city charter and create section 4.03 of the charter to strike the current mayoral term limit provision and replace it with a more restrictive provision that mandates that no person who has served as mayor for more than six years may be elected as mayor again providing that such provision applies only to times served as mayor after the adoption of said amendment providing an effective date very good this council has questions councilman manascoco so as you know i love history and tampa history and i was thinking back like 70 years uh with people that have served as mayor and tried to come back so uh in 59 the incumbent mayor lost the incumbent mayor that mayor came back in 63 lost in 67 tried coming back again in 71 didn't win and then in more more recently in 2011 a mayor that has served tried to come back and did not win so i mean i i i understand it but it's it's very hard to come back you know i mean there's no game oh the person has been mayor they're going to get reelected automatically historically at least since 1959 it hasn't hasn't been like that you know what i'm saying is let the people choose and let the people vote uh if they don't want you they don't want you if they do they elect you again but historically it's very hard going back to the 1950s so i i don't see that it's necessary is what i'm saying so i'm just going to be a no vote on this okay councilman carlson yeah i i we um you know i was on the charter review commission 2016. we we as city council ultimately put in um restrictions for city council and uh the president has restrictions uh the governor has restrictions the mayor should also have restrictions and um i'm very in favor of restrictions but i think it should be limited to two terms and that's what i pushed in 2016 and and the mayor at the time fought back against it um my objection to this is this is this is written for one person to to enable one person to bypass what should be the rules and i think we need a process that applies to everybody it should it should allow no more than two terms starting on may 1st next year and that's why i'm voting against it it's it's resetting the time so anybody who served before can can serve another eight years councilman young um well i guess to kind of answer i just wanted to know when this would take effect when would it be effective with mr tickler i'd be effective upon the approval of the electors no i mean when would it would it march so for this election cycle it would not anyone running in this election cycle would not be affected by this this would go into the election would happen at the same time they would be being elected or not and should this be should this pass by the electors then it would go into effect immediately going forward okay councilwoman lockett oh i think that um in something like this i agree with uh councilman uh um maniscalco that the people will decide as to whether they want someone to come back or not right we put a lot of restrictions uh going forward and so forth but the people will make a decision as to whether someone should come back or not so i with that my that thought in mind that's why i'm stating no councilman carlson yeah and just because there was maybe some confusion my objection to it is that it resets the clock if it didn't reset the clock i would be fine with it and of course it couldn't apply to this election but because it resets the clock i object to it if we can change that language so it doesn't reset the clock then i would vote for it well i think that i think the thinking behind when this was crafted if i wasn't part of that decision making but the premise of what is the legal term about you know retroactive you don't know what the law is you know you can't be guilty if the law didn't exist you can't retroactively correct and our the reason that we put forward the language that you have is also from an equal protection standpoint that you're not singling out any individuals who previously served as mayor yes that was the i think the legal premise but it's doing the opposite it's an accommodation for one person and that's what object okay any further discussion is there any public that wishes to speak to this item uh good morning stephanie pointer i would like to submit the memo for the record that the mayor sent to you guys this morning um and it's like four or five pages long it's my understanding that the media has it so i don't know why everybody doesn't have it it should have it should have been in the record on thursday or friday um so anyway um which i'm sorry miss miss pointer which which memo are you the memo from this morning from the mayor i want to put it in the record because it's back to make sure yeah i will absolutely i think it's very interesting that the mayor asks for it to go under a legal review for it and oh by the way here's lawyer number one lawyer two is upstairs but i want to put this in the record thank you um yes you can have this copy now as to somebody coming back and doing it again here's my problem with it because in local elections it's about name recognition so somebody who's been the mayor before for six years eight years four years they have a name recognition that's that anybody else who's running is normally not going to have so there's already the hurdle there that they have to overcome to get the name recognition and i think that you know you've done two years or you've done i'm sorry you've done two terms it's time for you to go find something else to do you know if you want to run for the legislature do it if you want to run for governor do it but eight years of the same same and then take a skip and come back is just it's not appropriate because it does not allow other good people to have a fighting chance when they're running for the mayoral race and you know by the same token or but didn't you guys just level the playing field to put miss locket on on city council you did the exact same thing you said we're going to make sure that everybody's got a level playing field because if we put somebody up here who's running for office they have a leg up well this person if they come back after serving two terms or most of two terms then they have a leg up because everybody knows them they've all seen them and of course as i said during five minutes ago the comms department glorifies the mayor and forgets that you guys exist thank you thank you mr dos yeah i want to regret dawson 68 i want the first thing is i'd like to see more clarifying language in the way that it's written and proposed to the voters because it can be somewhat confusing and as the term limits we need more youthful exuberance and i'll uh piggyback on what miss pointer said two times is enough you know young people typically will say something like you know we're tired of seeing the same old damn faces we would like to see some term limits in congress at the federal level and state level as well so whatever it is make the language clarifying and i think that this right here will inspire young people to come out because i'm sure they're tired of seeing everybody the same old names over and over and over again and it would give some some young people some aspirations hopefully to participate in the processes that control their futures that's all i have to say on that david phillipson for the record and i am a voter in this county uh in regards to term limits i believe i i concur with uh mr carlson carlson that a two-year term limit is enough i have seen many things happen in politics i have seen people just run and run and the corruption it's it's crazy and i also agree with uh what stephanie had said you know you need new people you can't just have the same old you know drop of the hat candidates or politicians that run you know you need fresh blood you need new ideas and i think a two-year term limit good enough eight years now you don't you don't need to extend it you need to cut it to two and that's it thank you thank you anybody in the public wish to speak to this item hearing none public comments closed can i get a motion to close or you want to speak no real quick you know in regards to the same names and whatnot tampa is different from 2019 i'll say pre-covet to now i mean a lot of new people have come here our population has increased about 25 000 people i believe um even from 2003 to 2011 or 1959 to 1967 when i say i look at history i see uh things change rather quickly i mean look at the state of politics at the federal level where we were in 2012 or when i got into politics in 2010 it's like a different universe you know and who would have thought it was such a short period of time it feels like yesterday but things change rapidly and another thing is when you leave office people forget you like i heard last night you know you leave office and my phone's i had a former mayor tell me one time on my last day i sat in the office and at home or somewhere and my phone didn't ring and go it's interesting one day to the next or even council members you know i stopped getting invited to stuff so things change people forget you know and uh anyways that's it thank you yeah i think this is a this is an interesting one because one is this is when you look at the charter as a whole as a governing document over a longer period of time this isn't about 2027 2028 2029 this isn't you know until the next counselors or the next voters decide to change something this is about the structuring documents so this particular the way this is crafted is blind to today's politics so the the which i find which i found positive and intriguing the way this was this has nothing to do with elections coming up in march 2027 but is more applicable to elections that are coming up in you know in 31 and 35 and 39 as we move forward so for that reason i think that it's it's worthy of consideration by the voters and i'll probably be supporting this to pass it to the voters to may have to make the decision because again this is not about in fact this is completely not effective in 27 has no effect on the election whatsoever completely ambivalent to that um it's about the future and i think the voters deserve an opportunity to weigh in on that any further contact nope hearing none can i get a motion to close motion close council manaskakos second council miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it okay i i think you said you're going to vote no so you're not going to read this council miranda you're going to vote okay um councilman carlson are you still a no okay uh robin lockett councilwoman lockett was allowed to read this oh you're gonna vote no too well so we already know it's going to fail so motion yeah someone can do okay i make a motion to deny file number e2026-8 chapter four that's it item 68. okay all those available of denial put yes and if you if you if you supported it then it would be no so it's an opposite of what you think okay motion carried with clinton and her tech voting no very good item number 69 mr tinkler next item item 69 is a proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 6.02 clarifying that the four-year term of office under the section only applies to the mayor and city council members and removing language referencing the 1979 adoption okay anybody have questions about this one no anybody in the public wish to speak to this okay can i get motion closed i have a motion to close by council member maniscalco second from councilman miranda all in favor aye any opposed councilman miranda can you please read this no no i was next oh i'm sorry yeah no i thought you you read the denial but go ahead yeah i have an ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption e2026-8 chapter six item 69 an ordinance relating to the city of government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 6.02 clarifying the four-year term of office under this section applies only to the mayor and city council members and removing language referencing 1979 adoption providing an effective date okay so i have a motion from councilman vanescalco i have a second from councilman miranda please record your vote motion carried unanimously with clinton being absent at vote okay excellent mr tinkler on to number 70. item number 70. item number 70. proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 6.06 to clarify that a majority vote under said section requires no fewer than four members of city council to increase or decrease salaries of officers of the city provide the city council may act under said section pursuant to resolution ordinance and providing an effective date okay anyone have questions about this yes yes so when we and i think i asked this last time officers of the city would the city council with four votes be able to increase or decrease the salary of a department head that that exists today uh in terms of your ability to alter salaries by resolution like this is to clarify that it can be done by resolution ordinance and set out the vote required so really it's i mean it's already there it exists we have the i mean if we wanted to do it today we could do it in another fashion not exactly as written but we have the ability to do that correct as i understand it there was a an issue several months ago regarding whether you can act by resolution or ordinance and this adds that ability by ordinance thanks okay any further discussion does anybody the public wish to speak to this item okay i have a motion to close councilman menescalco second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed i said that council miranda of 1975 is amended to amend section 6.06 to remove obsolete language clarify that a majority vote under said section requires no fewer than four members of the city council to increase or decrease salaries of officers in the city provide that the city council may act under said section pursuant to resolutions or ordinance providing an effective date i have a motion councilman miranda second from councilman menescalco please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you mr tinkler item number 71 is a proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend 6.05 to remove the obsolete residency requirement reference in the oath of office for non-elected city officers just to add to that this was a cleanup item you'd already removed the residency requirement this is just taking out of the oath very good council any questions hearing none is anybody in the public wish to speak to this item hearing none i'm going to close motion close council miranda second councilman menescalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it councilman carlson 71 please m71 file number e2026-8 ch6 uh ordinance being presented for a second reading adoption an ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the lectures of the city they proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amendment to amend section 6.05 to remove the obsolete residency requirement reverence and the oath of office for non-elected city officers providing effective date okay i have a motion from councilman carlson i have a second from councilman moscow i did i i just didn't say i closed public comment but i did right before miranda uh closed the hearing i did yeah you asked for public comment yes yes thank you just want to be clear that's fine thank you i just make one go ahead yeah um even though i made the motion of this i i objected to and was against the original um charter amendment um because i believe that the top officers of the city should live in the city so that they get to experience what happens in the city all this is doing is removing obsolete language from the oath cleaning it up exactly okay so we have a motion we have a second please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you item number 72 mr tinkler item 72 proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 7.05 to ensure accordance with state law providing an effective date thank you council have any questions hearing none is anybody the public wish to speak to this item seeing none can i get a motion to close council councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed the ayes have it councilman lockett would you like to read item number 72 file number e2026-8 chapter 7 the ordinance being presented for the second reading and adoption an ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 7.05 to ensure accordance with state law providing an effective date second thank you i have a motion from councilwoman lockett i have a second from councilman miranda please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you item 73 item 73 proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 7.07 to allow city council to initiate mid-year budget changes without the need for mayor recommendation and in a manner consistent with general law providing effective date thank you council have any questions yes so councilman scoffer we had a a global pandemic that no one was expecting and you know you had to make a lot of changes things shut down i mean it was extraordinary extraordinary circumstances by doing this my question to council is to initiate mid-year budget changes you know what if something happens that's catastrophic and you know we're short of funds or we have to i mean how do you feel about that will we be spending more than we should and be putting ourselves in a position we have future council putting a future council in the city in position where like well we made all these budget changes early on now we have a crisis you know we got to dip into the reserves or you know what do we do from there i'm just saying like you know just because you can spend it doesn't mean you should spend it councilwoman youngman councilwoman her take so um i had an opportunity to attend um some of the negotiations for tampa fire yeah so with with this um charter amendment let's say you know they they you know they came to the resolution and you know comes to council let's say we're like no that's you know that doesn't work would that would this impact that like they would have to go back to the table like what what would be the the process for that for that i'm just thinking because i was just thinking about that i know that was you know well let me let councilman her tech speak and then i'll understand um honestly yeah i mean we're in charge of the budget ultimately but the problem is once the budget passes we can't do anything about it like we're not allowed so we passed a budget in september yeah in september we can't make any changes to that we're not allowed all changes have to come from the mayor and that that's what this changes this allows us to make changes to the budget so if we see something say there's something with a park that has a big problem and we're hearing from our constituents that they want it fixed right then we can actually look at the budget move some things around if the administration is like we don't have money for that we can say oh we'll find the money and we can do that right now we have we don't have that ability right now everything has to go through the mayor and the mayor has to be the one to bring it to us and that's the only way we can approve or deny so that um that would have nothing to do with it so the the um the administration when they when they go into negotiation what they've done is they've always held the money and assumed that it will pass and if it doesn't then they can reallocate it so so for um all of the different unions that's what they've done i'll give you a real-time example is this last budget cycle this last but and and and and i totally understood why but why this council didn't buy into it we were anticipating the potential passage of amendment the administration remember the the controversy about them under representing revenue and sandbagging and under represented it well that sounded like on the surface a good fiscal policy but but the problem what we're bound by by the charter now by doing that council gave away their responsibility for the budget so because we couldn't like we were if in the minute let's say the situation is reversed we have another pending something happens with the budget and we're going to want to be fiscally responsible and fiscally prudent if we don't have this ability we give away our authority of having budget authority we because once we pass it we no longer control the budget if if we were able to say you know what in the beginning of the fiscal year i think we're going to leave a hundred million dollars in unset aside in a pot for the just in case we can't do that because if we do that we no longer control that hundred million dollars if we had some ability like this we could say you know what this idea is in the beginning of a fiscal year this idea is not really fully baked yet maybe come july when we have more information or come june we have more information we're just going to put this money here and then in july let's revisit how we're going to spend that money this gives us the ability to do that council 100 100 so i have a question um so what happens now when uh the budget passes and you're saying that so once the budget passes you have no more authority and so we have one bite of the apple okay okay so if this passes and let's say you have the authority to uh create or uh do something different doesn't the mayor still have the power to doesn't a mayor still have power to move it or not no that so who moves it she's the administration they they still have the no okay let me clarify you still have the the mayor would still under this have the same authority they have tomorrow that they have today council would just have additional authority to be able to niche right now what happens is for so for robinson's you know this so then it hasn't gone through a budget cycle with us we the council works on the budget the mayor prepares an initial presentation and then they wash their hands of it they they hand it to the council now we have 100 control of that at the end of this fiscal year we'll have 100 control of that when we pass a budget we hand it back to the mayor now they have a if they want to make changes let's say there's additional revenue sitting in a pot if they want to make change it if we see that revenues there we can't say we can't by council motion say i see that there's an extra 20 million dollars in this pot we should invest this in this park we have to go to the mayor and have them initiate that budget amendment we are we don't have the authority by charter to do that this would give us the authority to initiate it now the mayor could still veto and then we'd have to override it so it basically provides just that again check and balance a balance between the two branches of government by providing this opportunity and i'll go back to that same example of let's say the clerk tiny's position let's say council had to hire that well we set our budget in october and then that position empties in february or march and we don't have the money in our budget we don't have the ability to initiate a budget amendment to add money to be able to hire that person by doing this we do councilwoman hurt you want to say something yeah um so um so what i was going to say is we actually well i started something a few years ago where um the money that's that we have at the end of 2026 will be coming back to us in they'll come to us with a report in january to say hey this is the money we had left over in 2026 and then council kind of talks about how they'd like to spend it so all we can do is do a request for the mayor to spend the money the way we ask it doesn't have to happen she doesn't have to agree to it so even though there's money left over and we're the ones that are that are bound to spend it we don't have the ability to move that money to where we want to go the administration has to approve it and so this would allow us in january to say hey this is the money that's left over this is where we want it to go boom done okay councilman miranda then councilman carlson uh a couple of little things here first of all the mayor presents mayor makes a budget for the coming year of uh 20 28 as a win 20 27 for 28 and he's done usually in august and september he's got to be done by september 30th approved and sealed because that's when the next year changes so that's the mayor's budget that after that's compiled and they do call you in and they say i've been involved and everyone the mayor they go by you go with the finance office and they tell you exactly how it is that's number one number two after that process then the mayor brings a budget to the council and one way or another and it becomes the council's budget then we do with that budget whatever we feel is necessary the mayor is not involved technically however then here's where the thing is and by the way i almost begged this council not to get involved on anything rewarding anything rewarding whatever it was until that vote was taken and you can check the record on the third of november they turned it down four to three and that's why we're in the problem we have today we have a commitment that we can't meet obligation financially and that's all i'm going to say so the mayor's budget in my mind if we go with this we're actually changing the form of strong mayor government to something less than the strong mayor government so who is going to be the mayor the council or the person elected mayor we have a judicial responsibility for financial and other obligation to reject or approve whatever is done in the other house that's what we do we either approve it or we approve it or we start something and we approve it send it a little word for confirmation and so forth and so on so i'm not going to support this i think this weakens the system of the strong mayor and you can't have eight people running a city you can't have eight people running any business one has got to be responsible for it where there's seven others in support or in rejection of what that one wants that's all i got to say councilman carlson as i said in the beginning i think there needs to be more collaboration the charter clearly sets up two equal powers uh it doesn't reference um strong mayor at all in it and there's no there's no reason for the one body to be stronger than the other but we've seen in the last 15 years under the last two administrations they've usurped the power of city council and we need to balance it and so um coincidence i've run in different parties i've run in three different former mayors in the last few days and all of them talked about how they would pick up the phone and have conversations and collaborate and the last two mayors have chosen not to do that and so what this does is it forces collaboration in case we get another mayor that doesn't want to do it can i respond um council miranda i think that well one it doesn't take i don't think it changes balance because there would still be a process where this council will vote and we vote it goes to the mayor she can veto so we still have that check and balance with this there's still a check and balance and so all this does is again it's and i don't i'm not you know i'm not i think i think i think as council pertech alluded something like this this post cycle money and stuff we have we have had some collaborative relationships with how this stuff has been done and we've done it with handshake deals and the administration has been relatively um forthcoming and worked well with this council and how we disposed of excess money or shifted money from from pots to pots but we see in fact we go through this but this this uh agenda item to these agenda items today every every week we are moving tens if not hundreds of thousands sometimes millions of dollars between budgets and that's all done by one person that's all done by the mayor moving money from pot constant movements of money i don't necessarily think that it's a bad thing again find me another solution if if tanya left tomorrow and the clerk was not able to fund that position and we didn't have the budget within our council budget that we passed on october 1st there's no other way for me to fund that position without an ability if let's just say the mayor's just like they're hating and i know it's shocking to think that sometimes the mayors don't like council but let's say they are there's no way for me to fund that position without this ability councilwoman here uh councilwoman come back so i'm a process person so i'm curious about the process uh you find money you want something done the administration has to enforce it right how do you she has she still has the power to do it or not how will she be enforced because you will be we will be running around circles because we said oh we found a million dollars and we want sidewalks and then she uh she doesn't implement it you hear that you know you hear all these things now so you find it she still has the authority to implement it or and uh make it happen so how would that happen we we can't make her do anything we can't make her implement and that's i mean you see we we fight that all the time all you have to do is look at fire station 24 and so um but from the dais we're saying this is a this is important to us we're going to keep our eye on it and the public wants it so we don't generally do anything up here that we haven't heard from the public about and so the public can put their their focus and and push on the mayor too but it really doesn't matter because we can again we can approve a budget that has money in it that we want and she won't use it so that doesn't change that this just changes our ability like he said for things that we do control so we do control the city council budget we do control things like that but this would say if we're hearing from the people that they want this park fixed you know something like that we can actually put the money there the mayor doesn't have to spend it but then the mayor's the one that gets stuck with the bad press for not doing the part that the people asked for so there's there's some pressure there yeah just one last thought and i share this with the mayor so i'll share it with you all as well because when i was getting she was pushing back on me on this one and i said well the irony of this is you you as a one person can initiate a mid-cycle budget amendment one person if this was to go into effect practically speaking we require five people so if one person could do this i mean it would require five people to agree as opposed to now one person only has to agree so one person can independently call for a mid-cycle budget of one person for us to do that we'd have to have five people up here agree to do it and i thought that was and again it just our the litmus test our our chore is that much greater to be able to get to that level than to have one person i think that's what retains that strong form mayor of government because she independently acts as an executive where we have to act as a collegiate legislative body which i think everybody in the city thinks we control the budget anyway this just gives us a little bit more of that council miranda and thank you for that but here's the thing it's not about this mayor everybody said this mayor it's about the mayor period whoever the mayor is there's tomorrow in the future whoever that person is and the way i read into this is we are getting to be now part mayor part council members and that's not what i got elected to do i got like to be a legislature they got elected to follow what we do and any mayor who would be stupid enough and let me put it real plain english to do something like that and create a problem with seven elected officials it's not as smart as i thought that mayor would be any mayor who it is this one or anyone going forward because they have to come here for us to pass things that they need we don't have to go there and that's the problem we have yeah i mean we all need to take that as account this is not about this mayor this is not about this council this is about the voters in the city of tampa councilwoman young quick i think i heard you say in order in order for us to initiate this mid-year budget review you need five votes you would need four but then if she vetoed it would have to come back to be in it it would have to come back for five okay so that would still give the mayor the ability mr shelby did i say something wrong no you didn't say something wrong martin shelby city council attorney i was making you nervous when you put that light i have had the opportunity to um confer with uh independent council and i have the the charter in front of me um when we talk about veto and mr tinkler i'm sure has tremendous uh grasp of all this um we're referring to ordinances now i'm familiar with the fact that there are times that the mayor does sign resolutions but i'm i cannot say whether the charter provides for vetoes of resolutions and i'm not prepared to opine on that and maybe we need to bring in maybe the city attorney or maybe the cfo to find out the process with regard to this because i certainly wouldn't want the voters to do something that conflicts with other provisions in the charter that don't make it applicable am i speaking on point the the point i wanted to make sure was clear in the record is what you're proposing to do is to amend an existing provision of the charter section 7.07 to remove the language upon the recommendation of the mayor from that existing section and add a provision in a manner consistent with general law as it exists right now this action is by resolution uh typically and i would defer to the city attorney as far as how it's always been done here typically there's not a veto power over a resolution however there may be budget because of this need to be consistent with general law that would require an ordinance so i just want to make sure that was clear for the record what you're amending right so if i hear you correctly the initial action of initiating the proposal is a resolution but would require a budget amendment that would be have to be done by ordinance which would be subjected to a mayoral veto if it is required under general law okay i i'm going to suggest to council that we defer consideration of this item until we hear from city attorney and if city attorney is listening if you could opine on this and we'll we'll take this item back up after we move through the rest of the agenda is that okay with unanimous consent okay because i do want to make sure we have all the information before we take a legislative action on this okay we're going to move on to consider uh consider item number 74. item number 74 proposal uh proposed ordinance to amend section 9.02 asking the electors to remove the obsolete requirement the chief building inspector shall be an ex-officio director of the zoning adjustment board uh just for your background there is no zoning adjustment board at this time very good is anybody opine that position okay uh hearing no discussion on council anybody in the audience wish to speak to this issue hearing none motion to close by councilman miranda second by councilman nescalco all those in favor say aye i oppose the eyes have it thank you councilman where did i leave off that councilman young file number e2026-8 chapter 9 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city of the city of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 9.02 to remove the obsolete requirement that the chief building inspector job oh sorry is that the that's the right one right yeah oh sorry okay i want you to say you again though i like sorry sorry to remove the obsolete requirement that the chief building inspector shall be the ex-official director of the zoning um adjustment board providing an effective day sorry i wonder what that's going to look like i have a you're going to forever be a whoop i have a motion councilwoman young i have a second councilman miranda please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you item number 75 and uh latest lady of staff would you please confer with the city attorney's office that they're on that for us please 75 please item number 75 proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 10.07 to provide a procedure for citizens initiatives and referendums that is in accordance with general law providing an effective date okay any council have any questions on this one hearing none anybody the public wish to speak to this item hearing none motion to close to councilman ran it second councilman scott call is a favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it councilwoman hertick yes item number 75 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 10.07 to provide a procedure for citizens initiatives and referendums that is in accordance with general law providing an effective date i have a motion from councilwoman hertick i have a second from councilman miranda please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you 76 please item 76 is a proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 10.06 to remove obsolete an obsolete reference to the year the provision took effect for your information discussion on removing the obsolete year hearing none is there anybody in the public wishes to speak to this item hearing none i have motion closed to councilmoretta second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed the ayes have it councilman maniscalco 76 correct okay an orange relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa 1975 is amended to amend section 10.06 to remove obsolete references to the year the provision took effect providing effective date i have a motion from councilman maniscalco second councilman miranda please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you item number 77 item 77 uh proposed ordinance asking the electors to amend section 11.03 to remove obsolete reference to the terms of office terms of officers elected in 1975. okay any questions about removing the opposite language hearing none anybody in public wish to speak to this item hearing none motion closed councilman miranda second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed i save it councilman miranda presented for second reading adoption that's the file number 20 e 20 26 slash 8 chapter 11 orders being presented for second reading adoption an ordinance related to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 11.03 to remove obsolete references to the terms elected officers elected in 1975 by preventing an effective date i have a motion councilman miranda second councilman maniscalco please record your vote any vote motion carried unanimously thank you item number 78 item 78 is a proposed ordinance asking the electors if they wish to amend the city charter to create article 12 section 12.01 which will create the appointed position of and an office of inspector general okay anybody have any questions councilman meniscalco in your opinion and this is of anybody do you think that this will be abused because no my question is i mean there's we have you know the state ethics board we have locally we have our auditing you know i don't want this to run rampant and we have an inspector general that says you know i'm a hammer looking for a nail and just start does anybody feel that way or do they feel comfortable that you know this will work as intended councilman her tech um considering that we're going to be the ones appointing them i don't um i think that uh in places that have had this they've taken it very seriously and they've only used it when necessary um the great thing is the public can put things forward and they can be looked at things that we might not even know about um and they can do a quick cursory look to see if it's something to even consider and they may decide no so i i i haven't seen this be abused in other places that have it and i think sometimes um maybe when something's new there might be some more interest in it but i think as time goes on it really becomes a space where when you really need something to happen it will happen yeah and and i want to be you know respectful of the board members specifically the ones that i mentioned before you know one being my appointee who supports this and then mr creighton who supports this and the effort that they put into it so okay thank you very much councilman brandon i just want to know we have a budget for this as one individual how many are they going to have under that person working i don't have the way the way we're dealing now with ourselves and i'm not for against anything until show me the money and i show what i can do i don't think we have the money to do what we want to do i'm not talking specifically about this but this will i need to know what is this going to cost the public needs to know what this is going to cost no one has told us you're the budget officer inspector general sounds great but is it going to be with staff not with staff with office i don't know the public doesn't know that's one locket yeah i have a question in regards to uh the actual budget as you know how much is it going to cost but i also was thinking that as time progressed this would be something new is there a way that we can creatively um uh bet an agency to do it initially and then as as uh issues continue as problems or issues continue to grow then you know we filled in the the department and have a department coming because of the budget uh cuts but just being creative in regards to not throwing everything in one pot just building up to that pot because of the budget uh crisis i'll let council i'll i'll answer mine for carlson go ahead do that no okay um well let me i'll speak to this in general the if y'all harken back a couple of years ago i actually initially had discussed this mid-year budget cycle changes one of that motivate one of the motivators behind that was is this council has the ability to launch investigations the problem is we never had you could have the ability but you know if you don't have the money you don't have the ability so we did not have the ability to to do investigations that was the that was the origin of at least this this type of of line of thinking that through our the charter review commission our advisory committee had a lot of discussion about this they created a version of this which has been uh i would say more flushed out in the version that's before us they pivoted away from our existing charter responsibilities for investigation to establish this ig as an independent the irony you talk about checks and balances the irony to this is under our current charter this council has the ability to investigate this ig has a ability to investigate us so so nobody is immune to this yes they they are they any any function of our contracts our um the administration our public policy this council our books everything about this if they detect or believe that there's something that needs to be looked at they have the ability to do that so again my origin story of this was giving give the council the ability to uphold our version of what's currently in the charter this is now morphed out of that initially but not that i'm opposed or against it i'm i'm here i'm i think you have a hard time voting against an inspector general i'm saying politically i think the public wants transparency they want the ability for government to check and balance itself um i think i would have a hard time not passing not voting for an inspector general councilman carlson yeah and i can get into case studies if you want but um uh the this administration in the first four years that i was in um used the full resources of the city to attack city council members and and and some of them you know destroy their reputation bankrupt them etc and it's well documented anybody who wants to do it can google creative loafing justin garcia and look at the stories that were written about it was appalling the things that happened but using the communication department the political activists or political office of the city the legal department and even the the the so-called ethics commission of the city if all of that is controlled by the mayor and they can use those weapons against us we need a third party that's fair and unbiased that can they can weigh in nobody's investigating the mayor on anything and there's plenty to investigate them about but for some reason um you know a city council mayor was missing two text matches and the the the the full weight of the city was put behind trying to push that person out of office and that that's a really disgusting thing to do we need to stop that in the future i think the way we solve it is to have the right to fire the city attorney and it's not the city attorney's fault because i've spoken to several of them stay on topic that's not and they uh they they were they've been threatened by mayors and and if a mayor can threaten it and a city attorney to to essentially break florida borrower rules then we've got a real problem we need a third party to investigate thank you councilman i maybe i'm i'm out of whack but our own police department can investigate us the fbi can investigate if somebody has a problem they go see them and they take the evidence is there the department of law enforcement fdle can investigate us i'm not against somebody coming on but do i really need that if i have any one of these maybe i'm wrong can the fdle investigators somebody files a charge can the fbi investigators can the department of justice investigators they can do anything they want if there's a there's a case i think you're referring to legal as well but this is also policy well budget fiscal responsibility that aren't necessarily illegal but improper this is something wrong if you do something wrong you should be investigated but i mean this inspector general would have wider responsibility to go beyond just absolutely locking you up i don't know what else is wrong but if you would investigate it for no wrong doing that we don't need anyone but i think it's that tie pardon me i think it's that tie i need an inspector general to investigate that time i'm clear what i'm saying is that you know i want to compromise i don't i don't mind somebody having here but we have a system now that to me works somebody in the city or somebody an individual says if we do something wrong we're investigated without knowledge so what are we going to have somebody do an audit i don't know tell me the young lady's going to tell us in a minute well you know it's interesting though i know the mayor's been beating this drum hard on this one is that about the charter review commission and us regarding whatever this is something the charter review commission did pass this was beefed up version of it but they actually i don't know was it do you know was it unanimous for the ig i don't believe so no okay okay but it was so it was i think it was overwhelmingly in favor of this if i remember correctly but okay um hold on uh councilwoman lock did you want to speak your file that was on yeah just have a question uh does anyone know has this are there are there igs anywhere else and how do they work and and what's the function different cities different counties different so the best one miami's one that does a very that has a very robust and that's been very effective i think maybe mr tinkler knows a little bit more about miami's and do we have an idea of how much this was called would cost well let me let me address that for one i'll get to my memo in a second but um all of these things and i know you rose that the pro the problem is the mayor's assertion that there's no fiscal analysis on these things until until until something is flushed out until you actually have a structure it's impossible because it's like it's like giving the accountability to hire staff well until we actually present an opportunity to hire staff we don't know what that looks like or who that staff is same thing until there's a proposal to stand up an ig of what that structure would look like it would be impossible to do that type of analysis because it's right now it's just on a hypothetical because this ig may be a person of one there may be a person of a half there may be a 20 year hour week person you know until it stood up it's impossible to actually accurately do a fiscal assessment of what the budget impact would be on any of these things um mr shelby wanted this from the from the mayor that was the one that um stephanie pointer had introduced into the record okay okay very good mr shelby you wanted to say something yes council also a reminder with this particular uh budget amendment um it does require an implementing ordinance is that correct correct this proposed ordinance uh asking the electors whether to amend the charter and right but should it should it be approved by the voters it would still require an ordinance creating the position or the office is that correct the office and position uh are created by charter it requires an implementing ordinance in order to set the initial budget yeah for this office and then it has a provision as to how it fits into the annual budget process and just a reminder then council my point in raising that issue is that is to be determined if the voters do accept this and then that is also subject to what normally is your process to create an ordinance drafting public meetings public hearings and also subject to the mayor's approval or veto you know and i'm glad you said that mr shelby because i think i wish i would have said this in the beginning of my personal remarks is this council today is taking up these charter amendments we are not the final say the voters are the bosses what this council is doing is just handing it to the voters just like our forefathers in the city did when they created a charter they handed it to the voters to make it a decision of what that charter is going to look like it shouldn't be any one of us or anybody sitting in the other building making that decision it should be the voters to make that decision that's what we're doing here today let's just remove i think we should just remind everybody this is about just handing this off to the voters of city of tampa to make this determination in march and as soon as this particular hearing is done i'm going to introduce my response to that stuff in the memo as stephanie did the mayor's okay is there any further questions on this particular item you know council moranda if i may i it's fine and i'm so happy to hear that that the only that the voters are going to make the final decision all of this but i want to make sure that the voters get all the information no matter i'm not talking about this one i'm talking about any one of them that goes along with the amount of money that it takes for whatever item it is we have to have a budget set for whatever because we're coming now not on lean times on leaner times that you haven't seen in a long long time and when you start talking about 35 to 40 million the first year and 65 to 70 million the second year you're talking about a heap of money that you cannot replace especially when you got to give it away to somebody else is anybody else i'm going to open up the public comment if they're hearing other comments if you're here from the public and you wish to speak to this item uh one at a time please approach the podium start with your name you'll have three minutes stephanie pointer first of all it came up in the meetings over and over again we have an ethics commission guess who controls it the mayor as a matter of fact i filed seven ethics complaints and couldn't get the ethics committee to meet so i went to the chair's house and knocked on her front door she had me in gave me iced tea talked to me then i got a letter from the city certified mail that said you can't do that well we've all learned that stephanie doesn't follow the rules very well so bottom line is the ethics commission does zero with this stuff what i found is they do things with staff mainly um the internal audit department they are looking at systems and procedures all you got to do is look at what they turn out every month and i'm not saying that's a bad thing i'm just saying that's what they do it has nothing to do with this one has nothing to do with the other um and so if the ethics commission actually was doing something they should have been the ones to decide if you were going to investigate councilman dingfelder they should have been the ones to decide they were going to investigate councilman goods they should have been the ones to actually do something about the lobbyist registration not being followed and they should have done something with the ethics complaints because they were very very clear so bottom line is um and and why would you investigate how much money this is going to cost i'm going to tell you this as a realtor when i go meet with somebody they say how much could i get for rent i say i don't look until i get the job because i'm not going to waste my time doing something if i'm not going to get the job well there's no reason to investigate how much this is going to cost until it actually passes and i'll give you a perfect example of how it's a non-existent issue how many years was it in the charter that we could have a budget analyst years and years and years i don't know when it was did you guys put it in 2016 i don't know but you still didn't hire that person for the longest time uh count uh chairman uh clandinen made that happen so bottom line is i think this is necessary and i'm not just talking about for the mayor i'm talking about in general because when things are jacked up you've got to have somebody to investigate it and there are other cities i don't i'm not the smart person here i'm just the person here to shoot holes in the arguments against doing this and i don't think that there nobody should be above it and one other thing councilman miranda said we can call fdle i don't want tallahassee here they can stay up there those people are crazy i don't want to call them to come down here because they come up with crazy stuff look at the doge report oh my god we're giving away we're getting kids teeth cleaned that's a waste of money i don't want tally here if they call me i'll tell them you're a nice person we're not supposed to respond to public comment but stephanie you didn't ask us before you said that don't blame us when fdle starts knocking on your door okay next public speaker please i'm sorry valerie bullock i'm all fun inspector general i remember the guy he worked for um mobility he came in here week after week after week telling his story and he could get no relief from the union or any other department and that's just the only one i'm gonna talk about because we all know it's many more nobody should have to work or for me live like i'm walking on eggshells are in fear and we need an inspector general he have to investigate you all that'll be good too because it really doesn't matter if we're trying to do what's right all i'm saying is the system that we have been using it's not working i remember the lady she um i can't even think of what department she was in but she was a horrible department head and she had somebody terminated before she left and that was just one of the people the following week she comes up here and get an award but morale was low in her department and it's not right we do need somebody to investigate and we might have all these departments but if it's still going on that tells me the department is not working or what they're doing is not working no one should be above reproach and it should never be a one-man show thank you thank you next good afternoon friend tady's timber it's important to have ig you have ig's in the federal government you have ig's in the state you have ig's in some local agencies we need an ig i always thought we had one we don't have one we need an inspector joe please thank you thank you next brittany llewellyn good afternoon chair and members of city council first i'd like to congratulate councilwoman lockett on her appointment nearly two months ago on september 24th i stood at this podium and asked you to protect four non-negotiable pillars for an office of inspector general true independence clear investigative authority dedicated staffing and stable funding since that day i've watched council take public input seriously forwarding recommendations to legal counsel advancing the proposal unanimously on october 1st and refining the language so tampa doesn't end up with an oversight office in name only thank you for listening to the residents who showed up and for doing the work to get the structure right on november 5th a fair question was raised from the dais what do igs actually accomplish we don't have to guess as i shared with each of you in a follow-up email on november 9th we have decades of evidence right here in florida across cities and counties the independent igs in the 21 documented cases i provided have uncovered millions of dollars in waste fraud and improper billing recovered taxpayer funds exposed procurement and contracting abuses and helped strengthen accountability and public trust and we don't have to look exclusively to other florida municipalities to understand why independent oversight matters tampa has its own history that underscores the importance of accountability tampa is growing rapidly and managing public resources responsibly is increasingly important as our city continues to develop our oversight should match our ambition i urge you to vote yes today preserve the core pillars that make this office effective and remain committed to those principles through every remaining step of this process including any further consideration that may be necessary so tampa voters have the opportunity to establish a truly independent office of inspector general thank you thank you very much next speaker please okay so i just heard in this for the first time so i'm going to try to remain calibrated chagrette dos so anyway i'm trying to remain calibrated because i just heard for the first time that this city always had the ability to launch an investigation now so the question was never about whether the power to investigate existed it's like who gets to use the power and who determines how the power is used now when that kind of power sits in a political office it can be aimed at people and apparently it has been which i didn't know about other than myself uh back in 2017 when your own police officer falsified a report that had me looking at five years in prison it cost me over a million bucks worth of property and nobody did anything and this is not something i'm making up this is something that anybody in the world can go look into the record and see to this day nobody's looked into this when you all write the language as it is now but when you do the implementation make sure that you give it a reach back ability so that they can go back and look at some of the old things that apparently people just said it to i have kids who have caused degrees who never would have had them had i not fought for myself not a damn attorney in this city tried to help me without giving me some crazy ass amount we're talking about gregory holder who's no longer a judge who called mike victor the mayor's bodyguard to create a false report and don't trust your grant dolls look it up you always had the power to do something about it and did nothing so now i'm sitting here hoping that the supreme court considers my reconsideration uh for the case that was in front of them that they already denied certiorari on and now we already know what was already going on the whole time you know my father got sick and he's a veteran as well and part of what pisses me off when i talk to people is i'm vested in this thing you know uh i took the hills and the oath does never it never ended when i took the uniform off it ends when the casket drops and it keeps on going even after that because i could be somewhere in a uh national cemetery but i think it's bs that people take these oaths and they don't take them seriously your public servants your job is to serve the public not somebody's private interest and i still ain't got my goddamn properties but i'm going to tell everybody who doesn't know just go look it up if you live at 517 to scandy street and brandon uh in branfield 12 725 branfield driving riverview uh 517 uh no was it 25 34 clairside drive in val rico or 43 36 vinegar cove here in tampa you're actually in my damn property there's no way your properties cleared title because i'm still sitting in them and no process took me off of them and it happened right here in this city because nobody took the time to look into it vote for the damn inspector general and give him some respect power thank you is there anybody else in the public who wish to speak to this item go ahead this is just reference item number 78 inspector we're gonna we're gonna get to public comment here shortly mr council carlson i i i think to clarify but also to respond i think we ought to somebody ought to define the legal advice we got as to what the city council's powers are for investigating you do wish to speak yes okay go go ahead ryan hayes and if i could just be as transparent i'm advocating for an ig um it's as simple as having a paralegal you don't need them but they do make an attorney's job a lot easier more sophisticated so i am advocating for an ig for the city of tailpool thank you mr hayes councilman carlson go ahead i'm gonna cause would you feel would you feel comfortable um answering that question about what um what the city council's investigative powers are now what they're limited to mr shelby's back in the room he probably could be right i think that's beyond the scope of uh what you've engaged mr shelby the question is what what what are the limits to the city council's current investigative powers as written in the charter while he looks that up would you like to yeah i just want to thank the lady in bajer's book earlier i received your email i read it and you answered all the questions that i uh that i asked and i appreciate very much council i didn't hear the full question in the context but i will say this you have you have dealt you have had personal experience as a legislative body with that provision but i think i think it's limited to legislative legislative yeah that and i believe that's the interpretation of the city attorney's office we're not allowed to we're not allowed to investigate employee matters or uh lawsuits against the city and things like that correct mr steady yeah chairman member city council scott steady city attorney you know i love these easy questions but i would agree i think that i've talked to previous city attorneys when i looked at it it's it's narrow to effectuate your legislative authority that if you need to investigate things in order to pass ordinances and things like that so it is narrow people think that we have broad investigative authority and like to investigate the mayor's office or whatever and we cannot we cannot we are very narrowly restricted which is one reason why we need this outside body and i well i have the mic let me just mention one more case study that i mentioned before when one of the cases came up against city council members years ago and that the city attorney's office was not defending them there came a question as to whether city council could approve settlement agreements and we were told at the time that the city attorney could approve the settlement agreements without our approval but the charter clearly says that we have to approve settlement we have to approve payments and we have to approve agreements or contracts and um and it turns out that a city attorney in 2018 under the prior administration wrote a two paragraph memo saying uh it's my opinion that only the city attorney can sign can approve settlement agreements and and pay them and they must do so without city council approval and we spent more than a year going back and forth with i think two different city attorneys arguing this and we finally got it overturned but then the question was what about all the documents that had been approved essentially illegally and i had to fight we had two or i think two different votes of city council to even enable me as a city council member to look through the documents and it turned out that one of them which was a federal investigation was missing and then the question is what motivated the city attorney 2008 to 18 to do that were they ordered by the mayor at the time and were they hiding something and that's that i i presume is something that invest inspector general could look into because there's there was it appears that there was something dirty at that time but we we can't get the documents to prove what it was thank you is there any further discussion on the side of mr shelby just to follow up with the actual language of section 2.14 investigations it begins with the words in the exercise of its legislative powers the city council and then it goes on from there so um uh that interpretation is the literal um legislative power yeah okay very good any further questions on this councilman lockett would you read that again for us mr shelby yeah i'll read the whole thing for the purpose of um uh clarity um in the exercise of its legislative powers the council or any special committee thereof shall have the power to conduct such investigations and hold such hearings as the council shall deem necessary expedient and proper and shall have the power to compel the attendance of witnesses and production of evidence by the issuance of all forms of subpoena and shall have the power to punish for contempt by fine not exceeding 100 and each day any such attempt shall continue shall be deemed a separate offense that's the entirety thank you councilwoman lockett so just a quick question in regards to since we have not had this unexpected uh general and if one if we if this is put on the on the ballot and community uh turns around and says yes will there be a conversation is that when the conversation would be had in regards to it being retro allowing it not not retro but let mr shelby would you please opine on if this passes the ballot if the voters say yes to this what would be responsible of the council's responsibility to stand up the intent of this of this charter change i'm i'm not prepared well maybe i could ask mr tinkler because you're bothering mr tinkler for item number 78 in the inspector general if this council was to pass this today and it was to and the mayor was to sign it and it was to go forward to the voters when it comes back what would be the expectations of this council to stand up this process the provision uh subsection c outlines that an implementing ordinance uh is required in order to effectuate this position and put in place the appointment the selection committee the committee's membership procedures uh competitive merit-based process set the number of personnel provide for the initial funding and provide that employees are entitled to the benefits of other city boys okay any further questions hearing none we've heard from the public we have a motion to close from councilman menescafco a second councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye opposed the ayes have it councilman carlson would you like to read this one please uh move item 78 file number e2026-8 ch12 ordinance being presented for secondary adoption ordinance relating to the government of the city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa 1975 as amended to create article 12 section 12.01 creating the appointed position of an inspect an office of inspector general setting the office's purpose providing for independent activity and non-interference by city officials authorizing use of legal and human resources city services requiring implementation ordinance be adopted on certain on a certain schedule specifying the role of the office under the charter granting certain powers including subpoena authority requiring cooperation by city officers employees and contractors setting appointment method term removal method and process to fill vacancies by city council providing for office budget request process providing effective data i have a motion for councilman carlson second from second councilwoman young please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you and a question for council council i wasn't going to do this publicly but since um from the public they submitted the letter that we'd received from the mayor for those of you that don't know if you hadn't checked your email we my i did provide a copy of the dais but i kind of felt like at this point before we finish this discussion i know we have the one to go i felt like for public disclosure it was important that i read this publicly do you guys mind everybody good i don't see the purpose of it i think it's a waste of time it's a public record just like any other backup materials that's available to the public okay well i just i i know that people are always clamoring like what's happening back there i didn't know if you wanted if it was one i mean the basic thing is the mayor's against all of them no this is my response your response yes please because because because because please do read your response sorry yeah because the other had been submitted the record i felt that was appropriate to um so we had received a letter from the mayor with and by the way i had had a i had a meeting with the mayor yesterday and it was a good meeting we didn't agree on anything but it was it was a cordial meeting it was you know it was a pleasant enough meeting um and response to that this morning at 10 o'clock an hour before this meeting started we received a letter from the mayor with their positions on these particular charter amendments i will say from the very beginning i've been clear in my position in this is that our charter which is our governing document passed by the voters that governs the city of tampa outlines these procedures and these procedures are set where we fulfilled our responsibility as and my responsibility as chair along with staff and then council as a whole to set up the charter review commission they work through their process just as an advisory capacity to this council the charter review commission is an advisory panel they don't actually have authority they just reviewed and did all the dirty work and then handed us up to us to make the bad decisions which is why we're here today um anyway in response to what stephanie pointer had put into the record this is my response thank you for your memorandum regarding the proposed amendments to the city of tampa charter while i respect your right to express concerns about these proposals i must take strong exception to both the premise and the implications of your memorandum tampa city council has followed the procedure established by the city charter a governing document approved by the voters of tampa this has not been rushed arbitrary or careless exercise the charter review commission conducted its work pursuant to the process established by our charter its members devoted considerable time and effort reviewing proposals evaluating their merits and considering the future structure of our municipal government city council has taken its responsibility equally seriously we retained independent legal counsel specifically to assist council in evaluating these proposed charter amendments that council has thoughtfully reviewed the proposed changes the legal implications and their relationships to the existing charter in addition some of our city attorneys have participated in reviewing and evaluating these proposals these amendments have not been developed in a legal vacuum they have been subjected to a deliberate process involving the charter review commission an independent legal counsel city attorney staff and the elected members of this city council frankly i take great offense at the implication that city council the members of our charter review commission or the attorneys who have advised us have somehow been negligent in carrying out our responsibilities your memorandum repeatedly calls for legal reviews fiscal evaluations and operational assessments in a manner that suggests that these matters have been ignored or that the individuals entrusted with this process have failed to exercise their appropriate diligence that characterization characterization is neither fair nor warranted the members of the charter review commission deserve recognition for their public service not an implication that their work was inadequate our independent legal counsel and city attorney staff deserve respect from our professional judgment not an implication that their legal review was insufficient and simply because the admiration the administration disagrees with the proposals and the members of council deserve acknowledgement that we have exercised our responsibilities in accordance with the very charter we have been sworn to uphold a disagreement over public policy does not constitute a failure of due diligence nor does the administration's opposition to a proposed amendment establish that that amendment is legally deficient fiscally irresponsible or procedurally improper we welcome legitimate questions and constructive recommendations we've never suggested that the proposed charter amendment should be exempt from legal scrutiny or thoughtful consideration but we will not accept the suggestion that this process must begin again simply because the administration is dissatisfied with the outcome there is also an important distinction that should not be lost in this discussion the charter review commission serves as an important advisory function city council has its own responsibility and authority under the charter and state law the fact that council may reach a different conclusion from the commission on a particular proposal does not diminish the commission's work or invalidate the council's judgment that is how the process is designed to function the charter does not require unanimity between the mayor city council and the charter review commission before the voters before the voters may be asked to consider changes to their government and that brings us to the fundamental issue this city charter belongs to the people of tampa it does not belong to the mayor it does not belong to the administration and it does not belong to this city council the voters approve the process by which the charter may be reviewed and amended we have followed that process now having exercised our responsibilities we believe the voters should have the effort opportunity to exercise theirs these proposed amendments are not about strengthening checks and balances i'm sorry these proposed amendments are about strengthening checks and balances establishing meaningful accountability protecting the independence of the legislative branch and ensuring that no single branch of municipal government exercise authority without appropriate oversight they are not an attack on the mayor of this office and i'll go off script for a second the mayor and i have a working relationship this is not an attack on the mayor or the mayor's office they are an acknowledgement of a fundamental principle of american government power should never be concentrated that exercise in it are effectively insulated those exercise in it are effectively insulated from independent oversight the administration is entitled to oppose these amendments it's entitled to advocate against them and it's entitled to explain to the public why it believes the existing government structure should remain unchanged what it should not do is characterize a duly authorized carefully considered and legally reviewed charter amendment process as inadequate merely because the resulting proposals would establish additional checks or ex on executive authority our responsibility is not to protect the institutional power of an elected official including ourselves our responsibility is to protect the integrity of our our government and the rights of the people we represent the mayor has a voice in this debate city council has a voice in this debate but the people of tampa deserve the final word okay that's it okay that being said hand a copy to the clerk for the record thank you ken tinkler we left off on 73 and we had asked our city attorney to come in and chime in city attorney scott steady did you uh were able to research and have an answer for our questions yeah should i wait to councilman hertac comes back so we all this is important yeah why don't we why don't we take a breather i need to catch my breath anyway after my rant what a meeting to start with okay you have a you have a full dais and you have our full attention okay start with your name please i will uh chairman members city council scott steady city attorney so this is extremely important so i want to make sure we take the time to to walk through this and uh we've had all of 15 minutes to to talk but i think we've we've got a handle on it justin is here with my office uh talk to marty and as well as dennis that we've been talking about these things so i just want to run through a few things to put uh the issues in context in the charter right now uh under section 2.10 veto every ordinance so it's references ordinance that the uh mayor has the ability to veto all right and currently in adopting the budget the initial budget it is clear let me look at the language here i've got it so in in the initial adoption that we talked about the process where the mayor proposes the budget it comes to city council then city council adopts the budget it's clear that in that process it's adopted by an ordinance and it actually provides specifically in exercising the power of the veto the mayor shall have the authority to disapprove the budget or any appropriation passed by city council in the whole or in section by section items in any item section part or otherwise etc etc so now we're changing a provision that talks about uh budget amendments and to make it and we've talked about this earlier so budget changes so that the way the language was before because the mayor would initiate those changes it was done by resolution and so that does not provide for a veto so if we want to if the city council wants to be able to make those changes to make it consistent with the process and i would say the balance of power between the legislative brian's we should change the language from a resolution to an ordinance and that fixes the problem you can make the change but again to make it consistent with the original adoption of the order of the budget to change the resolution to ordinance and marty and i talked about that so that would be a a simple fix which i don't believe we'd have to re-notice that we could do that today that would go ahead could mr tinkler who has this language show us what that change would look like do you have the full the full language that you could present on the wolf and show us what that language would look like by any chance justin justin anybody sure the language uh in front of you on the tv screen is what is proposed at the moment uh if you're looking to change by resolution here uh you would change it to by ordinance however you may also want to include language then that it's city council initiated items are done by ordinance as opposed to all budget amendments are done by ordinance in any case should you wish to make edits along these lines it will require re-advertising and a new public hearing that's now the city attorney just had a different opinion on that well right i think that's marty that's more of our call and whether the whole process is to be able to make changes that's what the public hearing is for so would it be i mean if we if let me let me ask a question um with ken get your attention on this all three of you guys can opine on this what i just saw on that overhead that if you struck resolution and changed ordinance that was still only about city council initiated amendments it would not change our procedure for mayoral amendments if we wanted to leave that by resolution because she's not going to veto her own resolution actually if i can add to that mr chairman martin shelby city council attorney because she makes the recommendation and justin will confirm this on budget amendments excuse me budget amendments made by resolution there is a specific line for the mayor's signature there is no veto power provided within resolution under your charter so uh i i do support that change the question is whether we comply with state law with regard to notice if we do make this change and that's something that i have not discussed well let me make could i make one other change other uh observation so we're talking about this so i i've noted this and and i i believe the mayor might have noted this when he talked to your chairman that it talks about mid-year changes so i'm going to add another issue to discuss it talks about mid-year changes which suggests one change the language says from time to time so if we're going to really look at this provision i think we need to look at not only the issue of the veto it always says time to time i disagree with the interpretation because mid-year was to me is any time other than the beginning of the end is is but the language says time to time would suggest any time more than once yes that was that that was my reading of this oh so okay as long as everyone understand it could be more than one time a year yeah okay i mean i just that's what is what is the ballot question does it use the term mid-year i don't know no the ordinance talks about the ordinance the ordinance has mid-year and it's whereas in its recitals but but the voters and and maybe mr tinkler knows specifically the voters are not it's right here it says in the whereas is it said section 707 a revised charter of the city of tampa as amended provides for mid-year mid-year budget changes when appropriate and when recommended by the mayor and it has been proposed that the referendum be submitted to the voters of city of tampa to amend the charter to enable the city council to initiate mid-year budgetary changes at their discretion that's only in the ordinance it's not in the budget line it's not in the i see that means clear because i mean the mayor obviously uses that language right now to do 364 days a year of mid-year budget resolutions yeah so i mean that's how in practice that's how that works now mr tinkler uh what's in front of us today in section two is it two no i'm sorry go up um the rest so in that section right there where it says by resolution on line three is by striking resolution and put ordinance is that the only change that would be required in this document that would seem to be de minimis enough not to have to affect advertising the challenge you have is this provision affects all budget amendments it allows for the current process that you have today so if you made that change you're then triggering all budget amendments to be by ordinance including the mayor mid-cycle budget correct so i understand you do a lot of budget amendments uh through the year that would be a lot of budget that would be a lot of ordinances yeah okay um can we then include we've got to try to fix this can we put as we talked before marty about leaving resolution subject to the mayor's veto so that we retain i think the issue is and i'm you know i didn't make this issue this is issue i'm trying to deal with today that i understand city council wants the authority to amend the budget but to make the consistent power between both end for both the legislator and the mayor she should be able to veto those changes given the language in the original approval for the budget so i understand mr tinkler's concern and i was just talking to dennis right if we make budget amendments which we make 200 a year that could require it to be done by ordinance so we have a problem here i'm trying to figure out how to deal with it go ahead marty here's a suggestion the city council by by uh five votes however you want to word that shall have the power from because that basically negates the veto situation so if it would require if it requires from the beginning five votes to amend the budget well i change that language the city council by five votes shall have the power okay i'm not speaking for the mayor here but that effectively to me creates the same dynamic that was intended in the original budget so i think again i'm not speaking for the mayor but i would say that that creates the balance that was intended in the book so what are the consequences mr shelby of putting this back to first reading putting it back to first reading yeah there's it would it would it would require it would require it to come back at a second reading at a date to be determined assuming we can get publication timely and that you can have a second reading and adoption public hearing in a timely fashion to allow for a potential mayoral veto and irrespective of mayoral veto whether you can even make the time to be able to have it heard at second reading and adoption before this the winter break because you will not be meeting again after the last meeting in december until after the deadline set by the supervisor of elections to make the ballot councilwoman her check then carolson um however if we pass it with more than four votes it makes the idea of a veto move here's well let me just just for the purposes of context talk about the difference between a resolution and a veto certainly the advantage to doing it by i'm talking about what you just said i'm talking about getting it on the ballot i'm not talking about it that okay you're talking about getting it on the ballot yes if it has five votes it's moot because she can't veto it well she still vetoes no she can no she can she can certainly veto it okay this can anything that's passed unanimously by the city council can be vetoed by the mayor okay the question then the question then is to go through the process to allow for the mayor to be able to veto it and then return it to city council okay and then it has to come back not at a special call meeting not at a workshop not at a cra day but but a regular meeting of which there are very few left between now and the time of the deadline which is the beginning which is the beginning of january before your first meeting in january any others before i ask for calls any other suggestions i may just want to share one thing this and this may or may not factor into your decisions but there are advantages and mr rojero is here to be able to the ease of doing budget amendments and the speed for which with which you can do budget amendments compared to the process of doing it by ordinance which requires two readings public notice and a public meeting and an adoption hearing and then it first goes to the mayor right but i think where we're agreeing that creating an ordinance is problematic because there's 200 amendments but the problem is if we don't deal with the language that's a resolution we aren't recognizing the balance that's there originally i mean i understand that recognizing the board i'm going to speak again a city attorney recognizing city council wants to be able to amend the budget more after the original budget but to me to restore the balance that's inherent in the original budget process the mayor should be able to veto and then come back to city council to consider it and so that's the that's the that's the issue here today so we don't want to create an ordinance because we don't want to create an ordinance every time we change it but somehow we need to address to me the balance but i'm sorry um from councilman carlson young because i want to address exactly what you said but by practical speaking though if we've made the scrivener change the city council by a vote of five shall have the power from time to time to and do this in essence all practically speaking that that is that super majority does do that again i'm going to say that's better but i'm you know i don't again i'm trying to be neutral between my two clients there is a process that involves a veto explaining but i'm going to say you remove the veto aspect from this particular process but you'd have to have five votes to do that that's better that's better that's better than i'm not speaking for the mayor here just in terms of what you've advertised and all simply adding in the city council by five affirmative votes i think is within the scope of what you put forward so that that would negate the problem that we've identified everyone would you also and young first enough by your time councilman carlson yeah i'm okay with the modification you made but but we should not do anything that causes us to come back to us again if we can't approve it today with the changes we ought to prove it as is um this is another one of these things which is a a kind of worst case scenario protection for the public um you know seven representatives of the public versus one where if if a mayor tries to do something and it's not going to apply to this mayor anyway um if uh if if the if a mayor tries to spend money in a way that the public doesn't agree with and the city council doesn't agree with then there's a tool that city council can override it but what it what mr said he don't you think it's got this is not this is a rhetorical question but it's everything what this says is it sets up forced collaboration or or it sets up a chess game there are other tools that the mayor can use to try to stop things but there's but it forces collaboration too what should happen in a situation like this is uh if a mayor disagrees with city council they should call all seven not just four and they should have a conversation about okay how can we talk through this um what happened what's happened in the last 15 years is that two mayors have just bullied everything through i understand and this is not how the city should operate and so the purpose of this is to is to rebalance the power because the last two mayors have taken power away from the public and city council so would anybody entertain a motion to read the city council upon a vote of five or more votes shall have the power and then leave for us unchanged chairman could i could i could you acknowledge and let john speak on this issue yeah go ahead i'm sorry absolutely good afternoon council john bennett chief of staff and congratulations uh to councilwoman locket um my only point is it's not about the mayor's strict ability to veto what i was asking the city attorneys to opine on was the veto is a process to get a feedback which then council would use their five votes to override the veto so it what it does is it it ceases information coming from the administration no matter who the mayor is of why they're vetoing it and i just think that front loading of five two doesn't allow that full process to happen that was my only point thank you sir okay uh please martin shelby city council attorney the other concern that i have is section 2.10 the veto does not reference a resolution whatsoever and the whole process that the chief of staff had alluded to into the feedback and the timing and the process of it is all contained in section 2.10 and no other place and it refers to only an ordinance well that that that that's why we said um i vote i negate the use to negate the use of the veto clause by adding that language would kind of eliminate us from having to use that clause but in essence having so having all right off the bat the the bar would be set at five or more so that you had a super majority of those of council that may be true that but that applies to no other resolution anywhere ever passed by city council well this is new this is right so i'm going to speak and hold on one second let me ask councilwoman young she's very patient and no it's okay because i've been just getting more information so my question is in regards to if we are voting on this today because it sounds like we're seeing if there's changes that can be made or taking it or taking it without having to go back to first we will lose time we won't have time so is that the direction because pretty much what i'm asking is obviously we've kind of been going back and forth with this and just to kind of level set and bring it back if you could just as simple as terms explain what exactly is in front of us right now um what what would we be voting for what would the voters be voting for because we've everyone has kind of talked about it so to bring it back what exactly are we looking at and what are we voting for in as simple as terms as possible forgive my handwriting no you're fine what what i'm hearing and please let me know if i got this in accurately is what you're looking to add in is that the city council by the affirmative vote of five council members just putting it that way to make sure there's not a confusion that you have to vote five times affirmative vote of five council members shall have the power from time to time during the any fiscal year after adoption of the annual budget which is there uh therefore by resolution to be appropriate to any municipal purpose any funds not needed for the purpose originally appropriated or to appropriate any unappropriated cash surplus to any municipal purpose in a manner consistent with general law all of the language that is not underlined uh or stricken through is in your existing charter that is your budget amendment process today what you'd be taking out is the upon recommendation of the mayor you would be inserting a higher bar as to a five vote five council member agreement to such an action and you'd be adding in the provision in a manner consistent with general law in case there are requirements otherwise that would require different action if we have legal consensus that this is an acceptable amendment i would look for a motion i have a motion councilwoman her attack is there second second councilman carlson discussion mr shelby you want to chime in may i ask a question does this mean then that all budget amendments by resolution must be by a super majority vote all budget amendments in my read yes generally they're unanimous say that one more time attorney shelby the by just just that lasted that you said by five all all this has a global effect on all budget amendments so what that does now is normally a lot of your budget amendments appear on the consent agenda which are unanimous by unanimous consent and that's usually the way it does it gotcha but this now in your charter puts the provision in that there has to be at least five affirmative votes of city council members which if it passes in the in the consent section would be that i would think or not necessarily we have our our cfo would like to opine start with your name please uh good afternoon council dennis rojero chief financial officer no and and thank you for surfacing that uh mr shelby i had not made that connection as you said mr chair yeah the overwhelming number of budget amendments are passed unanimously and that's great but one of the advantages of the city of tampa is our flexibility in amending the budget requiring a super majority on every budget amendment would mitigate that flexibility and that concerns me without further research see i just i i i maybe i'm missing it but that doesn't seem to be a problem it just doesn't seem to be a problem i don't know which motion is on the floor but we had we had a motion we had a second i the maker of the motion has rescinded their make the motion for time being okay here's the here's the issue for instance a lot of things on the consent agenda are two parts the first is the contract the second is the budget amendment so does the budget does the contract require four votes and if it's contentious and it gets a four to three can it then be killed because you then require a super majority on the part two to move the money and i can't answer that from a legal perspective but from a real world perspective yes it would because you cannot affect the contract if the funding isn't available to do it and what am i missing again city council's budget in the beginning of the fiscal year we make these budget amendments which generally are non-controversial but if there was something i would think that you would want to have a super majority to pass a budget amendment south power that's all i'm going to say i mean i guess i could justify that you want to have a super majority on something that's so that controversial it doesn't seem like a bad policy but yeah it does i mean i'm okay well i i no longer have the the motion on the floor is item number 73 not amended so that current motion reads as you see in front of you um is there any further discussion initially as i was listening the example that you gave out under understood the example that you were giving that was but as we were talking about and kind of breaking it down and seeing the complexities of it i could see how it could make these meetings even longer than what they are um but i i i get where you are coming from but listening to it now and seeing like what the process would look like you know if maybe if we had more time to take this back but obviously i mean we're coming up on the deadline so we don't have a lot and i'm just working through that process i think i'm not sure how effective that's only much well we could ask as a compromise the mayors if we were to make a amendment to this that says that city council mid-cycle mid-year budget amendments are done by res by ordinance but then mayor uh or administration mid-year cycles are done by resolution if she would accept that and because the only problem the only problem we have is it but it's a veto so if the mayor would be willing to not veto that compromise that that if council is done by ordinance and we could rewrite that language and push us back to first we'd still have time without a veto correct if we didn't have a veto we don't have time because there has to be two weeks notice we don't have time for or 10 10 days we don't have we don't have time for the concept mr chairman martin shelby the concept is a good one to make the city councils be by ordinance and keep the process with the administration being such as it is because the advantage and council has talked about the advantages to doing things by ordinance rather than resolution in terms of transparency in terms of requiring two readings and not just to vote on the consent docket the fact that it has to be fully vetted the public has the opportunity to talk at the second reading about the budget amendment so it cannot be that would address a fear that the administration any administration may have a view on a weekly basis coming up with a different budget amendment and having them repeatedly because the process would be slowed down slowed down but then it would require more scrutiny and transparency so so mr shelby i don't have a calendar in front of me if we made this change that the council initiated budgets of amendments would be done by resolution i'm sorry done by ordinance no eliminating that we're done by ordinance what council councils well we would have we would retain the same language for them so the administration would still be able to make to do the same budget process they have today we would just be inserting another process that council would be able to make mid-term mid-cycle budget amendments by ordinance right all ordinance that would be there because it's an order yeah because that's that's part of the process maybe tinkler ken you could maybe weigh in on this what does that do on our if we're to make that change today what is the real term implications where are we at in the process and how can we get it on the march ballot the key here would be uh amending coming up a language in 707 that still follow tracks what we advertised initiate mid-year budget changes without need for mayor recommendation that makes it an alternative process if you want us to go down that path uh what i would recommend is deferring continuing this public hearing to the end of the day so we can have time to go back and forth have an actual written document that's typed for you uh that fits within that box and also complies with florida statutes with regard to notice correct that's that's why everything that we would have to bring forward has to fit within this framework that we've advertised can you come back by four o'clock we'll make it work yeah okay can i get a motion to continue this item to 4 p.m i have a motion from councilman carlson second councilman scott all those papers aye aye aye opposed so i said oh yeah go ahead so um question for the gentleman uh so can you put that language back up on the wolf real quick so we're saying we want to put it in by resolute by ordinance not resolution so but what but what you're saying is by resolution with the ability for the mayor to veto wouldn't work what we would have to craft is a second process here okay where we're not messing with your current process that allows for resolutions but okay thank you well that allows for city council to initiate a change without the recommendation but the mayor gets the ability to veto because it would be done by ordinance we look forward to your voodoo thank you okay uh so we've continued this item to 4 p.m now we are going to take public comment on on agenda items on agenda items do does uh does staff have cards for me somebody out there look for cards marty would you look for cards for me well imagine that the first card i pulled stephanie pointer you know it says p-o-y-n-o-r and she's yelling at me in all caps miss pointer would you please start with your name stephanie pointer that's the way i always write my name thank you um number six the transfer of funds for picnic island pier where sog is certainly excited to see that and remember picnic island pier is not just a bougie pier to hang out on it is a pier that many people throughout the city come down there and go fishing off of that pier to supplement their food budget so um i would love if somebody would ask staff to report on a timeline for getting it fixed considering the fact that it's out of commission and so is the um ballast point pier that we're waiting on from insurer from fema um that'd be one of those things that mid-year if you got extra money get on it um let's see here i don't have a whole lot to complain about i thought it was interesting that we're going to pay some legal bills for for uh council members and i had never seen that before i've seen them get hung out until after they paid for it out of their own pocket number 54 the contract for stormwater is very interesting to me i'd like to know how that's going to enhance our stormwater services in the city and if we are going to be able to see that because a lot of what has been reported by the folks in my community has never ended up on a stormwater map anywhere so i'm just hoping maybe that's a correction um let's see here the charter amendments i'm tickled pink that i got to get up and speak all on all of them um and it looks like most of the rest of the stuff is um public hearings for today so this is like a workshop day yay um and i can't wait to see what mr rojero has for you i really wish that we could see those before we came into council because they never get here until the day of which i can understand to some degree they want to hand them to you guys first but um it doesn't give us much time to level on them and um i know um that mr perry usually brings his brings me a copy when he comes but sometimes it's so small i can't see it so i'm i'm old i got bad vision but um thank you very much and oh i forgot to say this earlier congratulations miss lockett thank you don't don't go far i got one more speaker and then you're back up valerie bullock then stephanie pointer valerie you're our last on agenda item speaker and then we're going to go to the off agenda item speaker valerie bullock i want to speak about item number 15 the transfer of funds from belmont height little league to jackson height and i don't see how that is really good for the people of belmont height belmont height is the forgotten little league they are they are the only one in tampa that have been to the rural series as many times that they have been but when we start talking about improvements it's usually usually for other parks and really belmont height should be on the historical national register and the state register for all that they did but moving 125 000 to jackson height i thought that was the glazier field it was a private partnership between the glaziers and on the city of tampa they got more money than the people in belmont height do and i think this is just a bad idea we need help at belmont height it shouldn't be used as a slush fund which is so which is done so routinely for east tampa and i want to talk about number 80 and i think it's 81 and 82 um over here on number wait where i'm at oh wait a minute y'all it's it's 81 where the affordable housing is between 80 to 120 percent i don't think they should be getting money because that's market rate if not it's so close to it and on 82 i support the affordable projects the clonks over there in on grant park in the city of tampa because grant park have not had any apartments built over there multi-family apartments for a while and i met them at the cra and i talked to them and they're really pushing for affordability i'm not talking like the big money people i'm talking about below 80 percent thank you thank you valerie okay um uh stephanie pointer followed by david phillipson followed by donald uh gear see how that see how that efficient we are when you're not here start with your name please uh stephanie pointer um first of all i want to point out that the second project she was talking about is at 120 which is not affordable that's the market rate okay so i want to talk about helping my friends um my friends who ran for office and we currently have the statute where the there's code enforcement are supposed to pick up the signs and this year during the elections um in november someone called vanessa lester i don't know who i wasn't privy to the gall and then she had all the signs picked up throughout the entire county by the democrats so then somebody else had to go back and put them all back out and i would like to propose that we have an ordinance a resolution whatever you want to call it that says that city staff does not pick up from the first day of early voting through three days after the elections because every it caused more garbage in the dump it causes lots and lots of bad stuff for the earth i mean i spent two hours putting back out signs that other people had already spent time and energy to put out and if you only do it for that 18 day period normally that's once every two years or when we have city council elections but honestly people say oh signs don't work that's absolutely not true signs do work especially for the people who are running for election closer to home because you guys don't have and and and you know this none of you have the money to run commercials and there are people who are not on the internet who are are watching regular television at night and the only way they learn who's on the ballot is by seeing the signs but for code enforcement to pick them up and then other people to come in behind them i don't want my kids living on a dump pot pile of political signs and it's just really really simple to take them down i would also like for code enforcement to go ahead and take care of this one that's on the fence it's not supposed to be there for more than 30 days prior to the election it's not supposed to be bigger than eight square feet and i forgot what the other thing is but the bottom line is that we've got people who were in office before that now i mean if you were in office before you should know the rules not do whatever the hell you want to do so i i think it bodes really really badly that this gentleman right here is not in violation of one part of the code or two parts of the code but three parts of the code and so he's just left his middle finger in the air to show everybody he can do what he wants to do i would like somebody to make a motion about the political science being saved during the election period and not being discarded thank you and just last call david phillipson is gone i'm not seeing it okay uh donald kieri donald come on up followed by john green and then valerie bullock again and sugar doss and ryan hayes and fran tate good afternoon members of the board my name is donald choir um i came here for a little bit of guidance um maybe you guys be able to provide this for me uh my company and i have been struggling trying to find funding uh for what we're trying to do for hillsborough county and the city uh we already currently are certified with the county and the city and uh we're wondering if this funding will fund this endeavor we're trying to do so i guess to give you the nature of our company our company is a don q fitness it's a network of health and fitness professionals we have personal trainers in our network we have chiropractors in our network dietitians nutritionists massage therapists and um it's i guess if you if you think about what you have with a gym membership right you get a membership at a gym or whatever corporate gym you go to and what it gets you is access to the facility and the equipment uh membership with our company what you get is your own professional of each of those i mentioned so uh your membership will get you your own personal trainer your own dietitian your own massage therapist chiropractor etc etc we're in our 10th year of business now we're doing business with uh with government and uh what we're trying to do now is for those that can't afford our programs because i've referenced you know the corporate gyms but our our programs are much more expensive because of um everything that we offer um which which you know rightfully so um we're trying to do the bridge the gap for hillsborough county and city residents is provide um free programs for individuals that can't necessarily afford our traditional programs and then the way we're doing that is um we're seeking out those certifications that we have with the county and city and seeing um which ones would fund this endeavor so uh you know we're going to pluck our our professionals out of that pool the the fitness instructors specifically and kind of distribute them into county and city of uh tampa recreation centers so those that can afford a at least a recreation card they could come in and just do exercise um with our fitness instructors so um it seems pretty simple but um trying to get someone that can give us a direction through the certifications we have with the county and the city has been hard to try to find out you know what exactly um we need to do and who we need to go to so we're trying to do that we pride ourselves on providing programs that are are honest and low cost for individuals that can't necessarily afford the full package again of getting all those professionals um and uh it's just been a little bit of a struggle but uh we love doing business with the the county or the city we're not causing any resistance here we're just trying to find some direction so thank you donald thank you for your patience today and out you to your left is our chief of staff he's got a card he'll bar you into the appropriate resources within the city thank you very much i believe john green is left i don't see him valerie bullock tag your back up followed by mr dos and i believe mr hayes is gone and then fran tate will be the last speaker now okay valerie's passing uh mr dos on non-agenda items i've got dos and then fran you'll be closing us out yeah we do it in order then the dos first take take second sir sir you're first then the clerk has the right names and that's all in order okay that's cool um chagrette dawson i'll be a little bit more calibrated this time i hope so i had to keep my notes and um forget my academic background but you know as a as a soldier as a person who understands the constitution not just because i studied it and attended a great institution of higher learning we were it was kind of thrown at us and i actually growing up in mississippi i learned about the preamble of the constitution there's a word in it called posterity and our obligations to do things for future generations we're supposed to leave this country in a better place than what we founded and i don't think that we're doing that um um i want to say i'm kind of i'll say this plainly i was disappointed in what i heard today about what the power of the city was and and what they could have done about investigating things and part of the underlying story to my situation which is why i so uh much wanted inspector general was i when i was being prosecuted i actually went to the city's police department and their ig gave me the runaround and they gave me the runaround and told me what i was going to be able to get once this thing concluded i guess they thought i was going to lose my case uh because it seemed to have been set up that way and it was for those reasons that i delved into understanding the law a little bit better um and i i actually am grateful for my background as a union steward because it helped me deal with adversarial situations i hope you all really take the time to give the inspector general the power that he needs or she needs and you know great countries fall because people lose trust in their government and i hear it all the time i just in in my capacity as a podcaster or other other things but just being around people don't believe in the government and things like what i heard today is one of the reasons why i i you know i'm vested in it and you know my service time uh compensates me but that's not a good place to be uh with the other things that go on in our nation so i'm hoping that this uh well actually i want to let me stop here i want to do an official request for that that um for the transcript here but also the ordinance that you read that told the made everybody go silent as to what the power of the city should have been and what should have happened when the first time i came in here and told you all that i needed those 7 000 emails because just the fact that you knew that i've been prosecuted and those emails were held during a criminal prosecution should have been enough to inspire people to say especially because we have lawyers on the on the uh uh council to say let's look into that because he's talking about attorney and judicial misconduct in the city that being said i shot the greatest institution of high learning in the city of tampa the university of thomas jefferson high school mistake i was gonna since he went here i was gonna call last but it's okay you can come up first if you'd like go ahead mr hayes thank you very much come back we don't we can't grand afternoon uh city council women city council men i literally left and i was watching live and then i heard i was up like third so i wanted to come back i've been waiting since 10 45. i wanted to personally congratulate miss robin lockett um actually just seeing you throughout the course of years being fortified in the front being unwavering committed and it's you're persistently passionate and that's what fuels my drive as well it's reciprocated and you are truly going to make a remarkable and just a prodigious role model and inspire other individuals i brought you some flowers is there any way that i can have those flowers delivered i can hand them to her motion please they're on her desk i literally came great lakes please um if our legislative aid is out back um sebastian if you would like to bring the flowers up we could have one of the legislative aids bring them up thank you okay i appreciate it so much um god bless positive energy sanctuary i wish i could have hand given you the flowers but they're on your desk and thank you everybody i have to go because i'm parked in an inappropriate spot right so i'm a good one everyone wait wait wait wait to publicly acknowledge that there we go permission to come up and give the flowers yes and thank you for thank you for asking permission miss tate start with your name please and you will be the last public speaker today thank you sir fran tate east tampa resident and i won't go in the rest of the type obligations but that's that's fine um the ordinances that's my wheelhouse please please separate the powers separate them so that the community does not have to witness the going back and forth that we've had to witness for a few years now between the executive office and the legislative office separate as much of it as you can words like thus render void an executive order promulgated by the mayor under the charter removing the requirement for prior mayoral approval um anything anything these ordinances that you see where you okay this one without the need for mayoral recommendation separate separate powers it's stressful it's been stressful it's been stressful for the community to hear the comments and to know what we know that's going on between that office and with you all you all are who we elect we trust you all to represent us and represent us to the best of your ability if there's a situation that needs to be taken place taken care of in your district by all means take care of it don't argue back and forth take care of it for us because we voted you in and we're trusting and relying on all of you to take care of us separate the powers as much as you can thank you thank you that concludes public comment councilwoman hertech you wanted to respond to something that had been said um yeah i just wanted to say um i had the same question about belmont heights park and i got the answer was they had finished the field and so that was money that was left over so i just wanted to make sure because i had the exact same question thank you okay i have no other questions we're going to move to the consent agenda can i can i ask that we um since since the planning commission is sitting here right now if we could get through those let's just knock out the extension we can take this one okay but yes danny loves us okay uh public safety uh madam robin lockett as the chair of public safety would you please not anymore oh you got you got an old one move items one through five so i move items one through five repeat after me okay so i move items one through five second i have a motion i have a second all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it councilwoman young would you move item six through 15. i move item six to fifteen i have a motion of councilwoman young i have second council miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it okay this is this is not correct you told me public safety this morning this was this was incorrect where's the one that i printed for you i have robin lockett as infrastructure no is the that the boxes that i printed for you yeah no no this this this one's got her on twice though this one has robin on twice as chair oh oh so that's so that okay so this yeah this was just this was just misbranded okay so are you okay that robin moved your committee on the it's fine public safety committee i'm sorry yeah you're right so i'm sorry so you want me to move the infrastructure uh yes all right um no let's go back to so let's fix this so now now we're going to go back to robin lockett robin you were right move 16 through 27 to say just i move item 16. i move items uh 16 through 27. on the pages that's why i have a motion for rob you were i have a motion from councilwoman lockett i have a second from councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it and finance committee councilman miranda would you move item 20 29. i have motion from council miranda second from councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it councilman carlson would you move items 30 through 51. yeah i'm going to i'm going to accuse myself from item 51. my firm does not work on this matter or anything related to it but just in case we have a an issue related to it i'm going to recuse myself and fill a form later so i'd like to move 30 through 50. i have a motion from councilman carlson to move 30 through 50. a second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have a councilwoman young would you move 51. i move item 51. i have a motion from councilwoman young second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it motion care recalls an abstain thank you um 52 through 55. i have a motion councilman her tech a second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it can i get emotions to set the public hearings from 56 to 59. i have motion councilman maniscalco second round from miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it and we did open all public hearings i did it earlier okay oh there we go for the 130. my suggestion is make motions to open all public we have a motion councilman maniscalco to open all public hearings i have a section from councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it item number 79 or 60. did i miss one yeah 60. oh i'm sorry oh i sure did i'm sorry item number 60. item 60. well i thought he enjoyed being here so much we would just bypass all of those dani good afternoon council uh item number 60 is file number tacpa 2404. this is an ordinance updating the future land use section of the tampa comprehensive plan you heard this at your first reading on october 22nd it is back before you today for second reading we've addressed all your motions since that hearing i have a presentation a brief presentation if to kind of go over those changes if you if you want to hear that um with that i'm available to answer any questions just for clarification so several of these public hearings i was not here for vote and i believe councilman young i have read the records and i'm prepared to vote councilwoman young same year i've read the records i'm prepared to vote okay and councilwoman lockett you were you have read the records and you're prepared to vote on these items yes okay put your mic yes okay so everybody's ready so where item number 60. um is there any discussion on item number 60. i don't think so yeah um no discussion is everybody in the public here wish to speak to item 60. hearing none i have a motion to close from councilman matascalko second from councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it uh councilwoman lockett would you read item number 60. file number file number ta slash cpa 24-04 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance amending the tamper comprehensive plan updating the future land use section providing the repeal of all ordinances in conflict providing the severability providing an effective date thank you i have a motion from councilwoman lockett i have a second councilman manascalko please record your vote item number 61. item 61 is file number ta cpa 2405. this is an ordinance amending the tampa comprehensive plan updating the housing section to the plan um you heard this at your hearing on october 22nd and it's back before you today for second reading consideration that concludes my presentation available for any questions council have any questions hearing none is there anything the public wish to speak to this item can i get a motion i have a motion closing councilman manascalko second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed i said that councilman carlson would you read 61. move item number 61 file number ta cpa 24-05 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption ordinance amending the tampa comprehensive plan updating the housing section providing for appeal of all ordinances that conflict provide for severability providing effective date i have a motion from councilman carlson second council miranda please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you item 62. item 62 is file number ta cpa 24-06 this is an update to the coastal management section of the comprehensive plan uh you heard this at the first adoption hearing on october 22nd is back before you today for a second reading um that concludes my presentation available for any questions does council have any questions hearing none anybody in the public wish to speak to this item close motion to close with council miranda second councilman manascope all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed ayes have it councilwoman young uh file number ta cpa 24-06 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance amending the tampa comprehensive plan updating the coastal management section providing for repeal of all ordinances in conflict providing for severability providing an effective date okay i have a motion from councilman young a second councilman miranda please record your vote motion carried with carlson vote and no 63 63 63 is file number uh cip dash cis fy 27 to fy 31. this was heard at your first reading for adoption on october 22nd it is back before you today for a second reading and we're available to answer any questions now so i have any questions hearing none anybody the public wish to speak to this item i get a motion to close close close councilman scotter second councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye i oppose eyes have it councilman goldman herket file number cip-cis fy 27 to 31 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption an ordinance amending the tampa comprehensive plan capital improvement program and capital improvement sections schedule of projects by replacing the fiscal year 2026 through fiscal year 2030 capital improvement section schedule projects with the fiscal year 2027 through fiscal year 2031 capital improvement section schedule of projects provide providing repeal of all ordinances in conflict providing for severability providing an effective date i have a motion from councilwoman hertech and second councilman scotter please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you very much okay we're going to move on to quasi-judicial if you're here to speak to any of the quasi-judicial hearings you have to be sworn in please stand raise your right hand and be sworn in by our clerk item number 79 good afternoon counselor leo debato laban development coordination item number 79 is ab2 2617 for the property located at 1601 north franklin street suite 1607 the request is for alcoholic beverage sales small venue classification beer wine and liquor consumption on premises only site plan modifications were required between first and second readings those changes have been completed the plan has been certified and a copy has been provided to the clerk and i'm available for any questions does council have any questions hearing none applicant anything to add yeah jim porter with akerman 401 east jackson street you'll recall this was before you before we had an issue with the legal it's been cleared up and we just ask for your approval thank you thank you very much anybody in the public wish to speak to this item hearing none i motion close councilman miranda i have second councilman menescalco all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the eyes have it councilman menescalco thank you very much i have an ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption order proving a special use permit su2 for alcoholic beverage sales small venue beer wine and liquor consumption on premises only and making lawful assail beverages regardless of alcoholic content beer wine and liquor on that certain lot plot or attractive land located at 1601 north franklin street suite 1607 tampa florida is more particularly described in section three providing that all ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict are repealed repealing ordinance number 2021-81 providing an effective date okay i have a motion from councilman menescalco i have a second councilman miranda please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you item 80 thank you council bye jim thank you again mr chairman uh leo debata laban development coordination item number 80 is ab22621 for the property located at 1018 east cass street the references for alcoholic beverage sales with a small venue classification for beer wine and liquor consumption on-premises and package sales consumption off-premises site plan modifications were required between first and second readings those those changes have been completed the plan has been certified and the copy has been provided to the clerk and i'm available for questions council have any questions hearing none applicant matt were you sworn in i don't believe that i was matt please raise your right hand and be sworn of our clerk do you swear or affirm that the testimony that you're about to provide is the truth and nothing but the truth i do thank you matt go ahead do you have anything to add to the record uh council members nothing uh beyond what was already reported by mr debardo laban uh just echoing what he said uh all requested modifications to the site plan were met uh we are here today requesting approval of the second reading thank you thank you very good uh any further questions hearing none anybody in the public wish to speak to this item i have a motion to close to council miranda second councilman menescalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it councilman miranda thank you chairman number 80 number a b2-26-21 when it's being presented for second reading adoption an ordinance approving a special use permit su2 for alcohol beverage sales small venue beer wine and liquor consumption on premise and package sales off-premise consumption making lawful the sale of beverage regardless of alcohol content beer wine and liquor on that certain lot plot or track of land located at 1018 east cast avenue tampa florida more particularly scrapped in section three providing that all ordinance and parts of ordinance and conflicts are repealed repeating ordinance number 2023 164 providing an effective date second thank you i have motion council miranda i have a second councilman manescalco please record your vote motion carry unanimously thank you item number 81 good afternoon justin baske legal department i'm here for item 81 on the agenda this resolution would exercise the city's authority under florida statutes section 196 1978 30 to opt the city out of the 80 percent to 120 percent ami affordable housing ad valorem tax exemption for the 2027 tax roll state law requires the city to find based on data from the shimberg center for housing studies that affordable and available housing units exceeded renter households in the zero percent to 120 percent ami category for each of the preceding three years the applicable report show surpluses of 3994 units in 2023 4873 units in 2024 and 6538 units in 2025 and thus satisfying the statutory requirement and allowing city council to adopt the opt-out resolution if adopted qualifying multi-family developments would not receive the 75 percent ad valorem exemption for units serving households between 80 percent and 120 percent of ami for the 2027 tax rule thank you okay council have any questions hearing none is there any public wish to speak to this item stephanie did you want to come up and speak of course you do you know you're all that stands between us and lunch um good afternoon stephanie pointer i i i support you guys bailing out on this because the mark this market rate it is market rate whether we like it or not and we really need to be concentrating on the 30 50 70 and we should not be supplementing market rate housing and then we have to spend all the money to monitor it on top of that so when we do that when we are bailing out and we are saving money that we can put towards those those lower income rates thank you thank you any else can i get a motion close second close councilwoman her text second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed eyes have it can i get somebody to move the resolution i motion to move the resolution by councilwoman her text second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the ayes have it thank you item number 82 good afternoon council susan johnson velez legal department item number 82 is a development agreement between the city and klontz properties for a 14 unit affordable housing development located at 38 12 and 38 16 temple street this development agreement is being proposed pursuant to what we commonly refer to as house bill 1339 which allows for residential development to be constructed in commercial or industrially zoned properties provided that at least 10 percent of the units will be affordable and affordable for these purposes is defined as 120 percent of annual median income or ami or below that this developer is proposing that all 14 units are will be developed i'm sorry will be affordable and the property will be restricted by a land use restriction agreement imposing the affordability restrictions so eric cotton is here with to present additional information from the zoning department the developer is also here to make a presentation and following their presentations i would ask council to please announce the date and time of the second hearing at the end of this item i'm available for any questions if you have them thank you mr cotton go ahead to the presentation start with your name good afternoon eric cotton development coordination um following up on with ms johnson village this indicate this is a what we call house bill 1339 so one of the precursors to the live local act that um has been utilized by a lot of people in some reason sometimes the live local can't be utilized so they use the house bill 1339 to try to accomplish the affordable housing um staff doesn't have any any objections to most of the requests on here as you can see this is the property in question um it has two fronts well that was a quick three minutes two fronts um temple and and because the way the zoning code reads these two are front yards even though the property itself is oriented south and to the north is a commercial property um zoning is commercial excuse me and they are asking for a couple of waivers i'll blow this up below i'll blow it up this way and just go over the waivers real quick um they're asking to reduce the vehicle use area which you can see right through here from eight feet to one foot this is strictly for where the dumpster is located um the other requests are to reduce the setbacks along both temple and 50th in order for the building to fit on there the property starts up high and runs low as it goes south so in order to make a usable building footprint the property is oriented again to the south which is another waiver they are asking for and then there's a provision for um in east tampa there's a provision for um transparency because the property is facing south that's where most of the openings are for the property itself but on the size they're asking to reduce the transparency i have talked to ralph schuler who's the architect involved in this development um they are going to add additional windows on the elevations on the sides both on temple they're still not going to be able to meet the 20 that's required for the front but they will be closer to that by adding additional windows and if i have any questions for me do i have to try answer them for you this council have any questions hearing none after anything you'd like to add who's the applicant mr schuler anything you'd like to add ralph schuler uh the architect for the project uh yes essentially what eric and i have worked very hard to to coordinate this project it's it's it's a it's an interesting process but a process that i think was useful we really don't have any anything to add in in what eric has said is um the project has actually about six foot of grade change between north to south that's the reason why we oriented is to save save stormwater money we originally tried to orient it differently and it was going to cost several hundred thousand dollars more um obviously people park in the garage in the parking parking lot and walk in that's our front the two sides we did add a couple extra windows as eric said and um we're really interested in getting this approved and moving on thank you and for just for clarification we just we just need to acknowledge this was the first public hearing and then schedule the next book can i okay i understand i just want to make sure i was that way i met is everybody in the public wish to speak to this item the public speak go ahead my name is cynthia klontz and this is my son parker and we are in front of you this is a cra approved project so we're just we're legacy owners so you're part of the application you're part of the application yes sir yeah it's cons properties we've been in front of you and you approved our our cra so we're partnering with the cra on this so as legacy owners we are happy to announce that we we're moving forward and hopefully you'll see this project completed at the end of 2027 and i want to thank you for having faith in us as like legacy owners not a big developer um we're doing this we're doing this for the people and we have the support of grant park um we've been owners for close to 30 years um many of you have been out to our property so we're excited to um finish our construction documents hopefully in the next couple weeks and have our groundbreaking so i just want to thank you thus far for all your support thank you for us for this project anybody else in the public wish to speak to this item miss pointer you're standing between us and lunch good morning stephanie pointer i have a problem with a dumpster being afoot from the property line there are two dumpsters sitting on the front edge on manhattan right now that just drives me bonkers because they were put in before the code figure it out do it the right way nobody should have to drive by and look at other people's garbage because that's what it ends up being it ends up being piled up out there and when it's that close to the road other people take that as a go get them and go ahead and illegally dump next to them both of the dumpsters that i'm talking about always have extra garbage there around the dumpster which is not appropriate um did anybody ask what percentage this is because when i read it it said 120 ami 120 ami we just discussed this that's market rate again 120 is market rate and we're going to obviously they're getting cra money to do market rate housing i mean i could be wrong but that's what i read and please confirm or deny it whatever you want to do thanks well when you have a chance for a rebuttal when we're done and anybody else in the public let's follow up start with your name please valerie bullock when i um talked to stephanie and she showed me the paperwork i was rather alarmed so i went to send and i asked her did you all change the ami she told me no it's still at 35th and 80. so okay anybody else in the public wish to speak this up okay apple you have an opportunity for a rebuttal come on up so with our developer cindy klontz with klontz properties our developer agreement um we're no higher than 80 percent of the ami and we've added two units we're at 14 units not 12 and the units are at the 30 50 and 80 percent of the ami in our developer agreement we don't have anything in there that says we're at 120 percent of the ami thank you very much okay very good that concludes your rebuttal thank you okay any council have any further questions hearing none yeah i have a motion close to councilman miranda a maniscalco second council miranda all those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it yes we're gonna do that you want me to do it go ahead okay second public hearing is scheduled for december 3rd 2026 at 10 30 a.m in city council chambers 315 east kennedy boulevard third floor tampa florida three three six zero two so you copied that date and time applicant okay very good thank you so much okay we're gonna do one more item and then we're gonna go to lunch go ahead um i want to remove item 84 from the agenda and reschedule it for uh january 7th 2027 at 315 east kennedy boulevard tampa florida 33602 okay i have a motion to reschedule item number 84 to july 7th and as stated by councilwoman her text from council miranda all those in favor say aye aye oppose the ayes have it we're going to hear id383 really quick and then if anybody else we're going to go to lunch after that kamari bar has been set i i hear it um kamaria pettis knuckle from the legal department um we're here for item number 83 which is um fdn 2665 this is before you for city council to consider the recommended order of the hearing officer just for your um so just to explain what this process is um councilwoman lockett um since you're new to city council respectfully i created this flow chart just so you could follow along to see where we are and this is also just a reminder for city council and i'll go to through this relatively quickly um the applicant filed a request with the zoning department on march 6th regarding the legal non-conforming use of a grocery store staff denied the fdn request on june 3rd 2026 the uh petition for the staff denied the request then a petition for review and appeal was filed by the applicant on june 17 2026. um a review hearing was conducted by a hearing officer normally review hearings by a staff decision are heard by city council but this is a formal decision application where it's heard for before a hearing officer so that de novo hearing already took place and that took place on august 18th the hearing officer filed a recommended order with the city granting the petitioners the petition and approving the legal non-conforming use of the structure that was held on that decision was sent to the city on september 1st 2026. i had a resolution that city council approved scheduling the matter for a public hearing for today and that's where we are today so now this recommended order is before you each of you have a copy of the recommended order these are the actions that city council can take city council can adopt the recommended order as the final order reject the recommended order or modify the recommended order if you choose to um you may not reject or modify any findings of facts this is this is in the law according to 2761 that governs the process for all review hearings and you also have a copy of that that um code section with you so this is the last slide i want to have and then i'll go to my final thought my final points and leave it up leave it up to you um city council if city council rejects or modifies a conclusion of law and must state with particularity in the final order its reasons and must make a finding that a substitution of conclusion of law is as or more reasonable than which was rejected or modified i will um a code section 27-61 allows parties to file requests for oral arguments and exceptions regarding the um recommended order from the hearing officer the city of tampa did not file or or the petitioner did not file requests for oral arguments or exceptions regarding this matter so i will turn it over to city council you have the recommended order and again just as a reminder these are the actions that city council can take regarding this matter i recognize councilwoman her check um i make a motion to adopt the recommended order as final i have a motion councilwoman her tech adopting the recommended order as final second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the ayes have it unanimously thank you okay i'm going to make myself a liar i'll listen real quick yes this yeah exactly let's move um id number i 86 file number f okay i have a motion councilwoman her tech on 86 a second from miranda councilwoman young all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the eyes have it okay yeah 86 it is 227 we're gonna come back at 3 30 after lunch um we are going to pick up on the 80s administrative update yep okay we are at lunch tomorrow lunch i'd like to call this meeting to tampa city council order clerk would you please call the roll it's miranda manaskako her tech here young lockett carlson and clinton here we have a physical corner thank you i see we have our special guests here today item number 87 visit tampa oh oh administrative update it's super fast i don't see john know dennis dennis are you doing the administrative update oh yes thank you council good afternoon dennis rogero chief financial officer yes you know again we were anticipating we discussed with councilwoman her tack discussion of amendment three um as you know i'll give you just a quick couple quick talking points and then what we anticipate in the very near future first of all you'll recall that the budget you adopted pretty much presumed that amendment three would pass okay it was one of two scenarios we called it the sustainment budget so that really puts us on a firm footing as we get ready for these headwinds in doing so as you know we bolstered the general fund to its highest level in years so we remain right now in a very good financial situation but as you know we anticipate lose anticipate losing about 40 million dollars 65 million dollars just in fiscal year 28 and 29 so the headwinds are coming having said that and as we discussed ma'am you know as we work to develop you know short medium long-term solutions to discuss with council it seems practical to maybe combine that discussion after a little more time with the discussion we're coming back to council in january on and that's the closing of last fiscal year's book doing that as we speak right now and it's going to take weeks so we were wondering if council would like to combine the discussion of those two items for a broader picture does that coincide with what we discussed ma'am um yes but also i wanted i wanted you to talk a little bit about what the administration is currently doing oh okay to prepare um because you all are doing round tables you're you're doing things in-house and i just wanted the public to understand because other municipalities right now are just cutting things like left and right and we aren't because a we planned for this but b what are we doing and i think that's what the public would like to know uh i'm sorry ma'am councilwoman young and then just for the um just for clarification you said combined discussion with what we're talking about in january what will we be talking about in january we are scheduled to come before council in january january with the results of last fiscal year of course it ended yes yeah take it takes weeks and weeks and weeks to close the books and figure out what happened okay all right as as uh as a lead-in to what we're doing right now i do want to share with you again we remain in a very strong financial position and that's good that allows us to rebound and plan on ahead uh to put it simply you've got two main levers right you got revenues coming in and you got expenses going out from an expenses going out perspective many of us have been here before right the great financial crisis the pandemic and many of the leadership here many council members we've weathered a similar storm hopefully it won't be that bad so we've done it before we'll do it again what's that going to entail the largest and you've heard us say this before the largest recurring expense in the city is typically personnel we're going to look at personnel now many or almost all of the dozens and dozens of position requests in the current year budget that were not approved are going to help us out tremendously from a bottom line perspective again it was a sustainment budget there were dozens of requests for new positions to expand services we haven't done that but doesn't mean we can't further scrutinize existing positions looking at the vacancies and vacancy rates where we can establish efficiencies and speaking of efficiencies and effectiveness during the great financial crisis and you may have heard this before it's about the time that i came on to the city and we instituted what we called the eet efficiency and effectiveness task force the eetf uh chief of staff the mayor they were at the heart of it in the police department then and it expanded to a city wide exercise i anticipate we'll do similar exercises going forward short term holding vacancies perhaps not advocating anything yet long term looking at the service levels right now can they be increased or maintained with less positions from an operating expense perspective review of our contracts our obligations going forward again we're a big city we have a lot technical term of long-term obligations that we can look at and i'll let procurement speak to that from a revenue inflow perspective uh i i would be remiss if i didn't mention that next month the community investment tax renewal is going to start that's going to help tremendously from a project perspective again over 15 years we anticipate almost 800 million dollars but it's going to take a while to ramp up and it is over a 15 year time frame other revenues you know we have established we've done a very good job in recent history of establishing and indexing the fees we charge especially in our enterprise agencies we're going to go over that with a finer tooth comb than we have for some of our other fees again i'd i don't want to belittle the impact because you know the general fund property taxes that's our largest revenue source and the general fund is our most flexible revenue source it's it's going to have an impact it will we anticipate it will have an impact beyond the general fund this is such a vast uh adverse impact that i anticipate the enterprise agencies will feel pressured the community redevelopment agencies will feel pressured and it's not just us right it's statewide other localities what are they going to stop doing that people may look to the city to do so we've got to look at the inflows and we've got to look at the outflows and that's what we'll be prepared to talk in more detail with city council does that does that cover what you were wanting to hear ma'am yes councilman carlson and council miranda he gets to go after he'll look alike um i was talking to mr here right here also um yesterday the day before and i and as much as i disagree with the administration on a lot of things in this case whether it was from his office or the administration um they looked ahead and presented a budget to us that anticipated amendment three and we as city council voted for that and so many people were vocally including the mayor were vocally against amendment three but while the sky is really falling for a lot of government agencies it's not falling for us and we're going to have to make some tough decisions in year three and four but for this year i think we all ought to use the message that city council working with administration anticipated amendment three and we put in a budget that anticipated amendment three that makes us it's the truth and it makes us look better than a lot of the other governments now we have flexibility that we can do that but the other thing is that we also have um as you kind of said suddenly we've started uh finding ways to save and in addition of the 23 percent and the general fund reserve we've we've tried to set aside some funding and and some long-term savings so that we could uh cover some of the uh the the lost revenue in the in the second year so again that planning started several months ago and if we take if we take the politics out of it the truth is and the accurate statement is to say we and the administration months ago prepared for at least the first couple years and we were given the projections for the first four years to know what what impact this will have i think that also there will be other things that will that will affect this um uh baby boomers more and more are downsizing and one of the things we see um you know as we're out in the neighborhoods people's people who are new to tampa say you you um increase my property taxes by 10 times and what that always is is one of the biggest questions that the property appraiser gets what it means is that somebody had homestead exemption let's say they were their their their taxable value was 100 000 and then they sell the house for a million dollars the new owner has to pay tax on plus or minus a million dollars not a hundred thousand and so the property tax goes up because the value the the taxable value is up we didn't raise the taxes because we haven't raised our um property taxes since the last mayor but um the uh as that happens as as as as baby boomers and some gen extras started to retire and downsize they're going to be selling their houses and those housing the houses they're selling will go way up in value and i don't know how much you put that in your model but that kind of thing will be happening and we have pages and pages of fees some of which haven't been raised in 40 years and we we've started looking at them not to try to cover amendment three but just because the people who are using those services are not paying their fair share and it wasn't fair probably in the first place that general fund was covering some of that and so i think it's it's a challenge for us looking forward but this is a case where the city council administration worked together in a very positive proactive way and we have good news this year and we shouldn't talk about skies falling we should say yeah we did the right thing we've already planned for amendment three and if i made no i think i think you framed that very well and if i can pull that thread just a little bit you know we are constantly as i've indicated before surveilled by the big credit agencies both s p and moody's just finished finished their surveillance of the city and have affirmed our current credit ratings which are fantastic right and they did that in part because of our forward thinking because of the budget that we adopted that you adopted looking ahead taking into account what could happen if amendment three passed thank you mr chair and thanks again for being here you were here during the years 2007 i mean 07 and 2011 right came in in 2009 our administration yes that mayor did a wonderful job because when she had to go through she had a i believe we cut over 700 jobs it was difficult yes and these are the things that worry us and the people not only work in the city but around us you're looking at a when you go back up and start looking at from washington dc on down i don't think they understand what's happening in a wrong way because we're real next to going to maybe a slight recession at some point the cost of goods are up and the interest rates are up and these things have a way of having people become unemployed for a while and i'm concerned about that because that would have nothing of fact on the city of tampa even though we're we're prepared for it it's very hard to deal with it let me put it that way and so i'm sure that you guys in the administration are looking at ways of making some changes and whatever you got to do to make the city solid as solid as that can be and i'm not looking for anybody losing their job but there's a possibility of a lot of things coming and that depends on really not us it depends on what the the mood of the government is up in washington the mood of the people over the country that you see prices continue to rise because everything is going up on a daily basis it's just really almost understandable so the ones that get caught in this are the ones in the lower end of the income and these are the ones that oddly enough more likely to be the first cut no matter where i'm not talking about the city of tampa i'm talking in general terms so they're going to have a double whammy if this happens because they're the laborers that make things work and keep the the city going or the county going or or their jobs going make it cleaner and better for us to live here so i'm concerned all the way around that i'm afraid what could happen may happen i'm not saying it is going to happen but i'm just very concerned on the possibility of it happening i don't know what the interest rates are in the market now the stock market you may know more likely better than we do but it was one time much lower than it's going to be i believe and another interest rate will certainly hurt hurt a lot of people but it's necessary yeah councilman young then we're going to move on to the next item because at four o'clock we're going to break for our remain charter amendment councilman young no i just to piggyback off of councilman carson i remember when we were you know setting that budget and i was one of the people that said why do we have to have to do this so i you know hey i'm not afraid to admit when i was when i'm wrong but i think that you all having that foresight um is very much appreciated so thank you for for bringing it to us and recognizing that in the event that this happens um that we are prepared and i always hear um you know you talk about that we have a great uh credit rating and i think that that is definitely because we all are you know making you know sound and great decisions so thank you all just for having that foresight for us and while we know it's going to be a big impact thank you all for bringing something to us that we can you know we can plan but we also know that we can be prepared so thank you very kind thank you okay and if i hear things correctly i believe councilwoman hertech you wanted to make a motion to have this brought foot back for january 21st oh i'll give that put your light on councilwoman locket hi i started to have just a human aspect of this because in regards to personnel people being laid off is this an opportunity uh it will take work but it also take conversation for us to build partnerships with other agencies so that you know individuals if they do have to if they are laid off it's not because of them it's because of something that's out of their control that we build partnerships with people or we know we have a list of agencies where they can look for a job that may have an opening just to connect so they won't be unemployed is that yes ma'am and i have been remiss congratulations thank you yes uh you know remembering again uh the great financial crisis and and we'll uh we'll revisit all those mechanisms and all those partnerships you know as councilman miranda said i think it was six or seven hundred positions that were eliminated about half of them had people in them okay so to the extent possible we we endeavored not to show people the door and of course we do that again uh and again i don't want to be premature in discussing layoffs or anything like that but we i think we have to plan for all eventualities in terms of working with partners just as you said thank you so yes i would like to add to the presentation on the 21st um conversations about amendment three thank you can i make you can i make a friendly amendment as well in that presentation would direct our financial staff to bring back the last five years of non um non-homestead exemption revenue uh and other sources of revenue uh to show the growth or the pattern of the last five years and then the projections for the next five years taking that taking into account amendment three and what's sources of revenue they're not subjected to and yeah that amendment is accepted thank you i have a motion i have a second all those are here say aye aye opposed the eyes have it thank you thank you thank you council no um february january 21st okay very good okay uh we're going to do um visit tampa bay and the tampa convention center david and then uh ken for those of you waiting in the rings as soon as we're done with this presentation we'll bring you guys up you guys always put me after like the really tough conversations i'm not quite sure if i'm going to get in a complex about this good afternoon council david ingram i'm executive director of tampa camp convention center today i'm here to talk about our metrics is for the convention industry here in the local area as well as i brought my friends from visit tampa bay i have santiago karate here president ceo and adam de piero chief sales officer just to start to give you some background if we can bring up the presentation just a quick background the city contracts visit tampa bay to sell and market the destination so that's the city and the center collectively the way that happens is the visit tampa bay team looks at events that are 18 months out and further and those are going to be the big large citywide events that we have so think about like soft week any time that the divine nine are here they bring high economic impact they bring high attendance to us those are what they're going to focus in on internally the ctcc staff focuses on what we call short-term business those 18 months and within and that's going to basically be your regional and local somewhat semi-state of florida events that are going to be conferences meetings things like that they may or may not have some room attached to it but that's what we focus in on and then one of the key metrics that i wanted to share with everybody is our events that we have booked at the center this is a good indication of where how strong we are at the center and what business that we have brought in i'd love to be able to come up here every year and say hey we book millions and millions of events we have thousands of people coming in the reality is we book about 90 to 100 events a year the good thing about that is the third of those events that we have are our citywides so those are the big impactful events that are coming in so that's a really strong healthy number for us if you look at the chart you can see this year fiscal year we had 95 events already next fiscal year in 27 we're projected to hit 99 because we continue to sell that number should go over 100 and then for 28 29 and 30 you can see those numbers there are pretty strong one caveat to those numbers that i always like to give and this is always goes back to our friends pre-covid time in pre-covid most events booked anywhere between five to eight years in advance post-covid they now come into anywhere from one to two years and then the associations come three to four so that's why you see some of those numbers are a little soft but realistically we're still on pace to actually meet our averages and i like to always throw this out due to our friends over at visit tampa bay the furthest date out we have contracted on the books right now is 2038 and is that my cue to stop just kidding um so 2038 so that's actually good for us it shows that the the convention industry is strong and the the demand for the center is high the next and critical piece that we want to look at is our exhibit hall occupancy the reason for that is because that's the prime real estate that all those citywides really want to be in so if you need to have an exhibit hall you need to have a general session you need to have a large banquet facility that's the space that they're looking for so that's what's going to drive the demand that we have the industry itself has kind of said at 70 percent you've hit maximum occupancy the reason for that is because each event varies from length and you also have move in move out and some holidays that folks don't want to book so for us in 25 we hit 70 which is right at maximum this year we were fortunate enough to be at 73 percent next year at 27 we're looking at moving into that number of 74 between our contracted events any confirmed and any tentatives that we have so that's a really good sign and in 28 we're actually ahead of schedule because we're at 68 percent already those numbers are really good indication for us to be able to say we're strong and moving in the right direction in the at least in the short term the one thing i always want to put a caveat to that slide though is it's a problem because right now we're full when we're full we can't bring anything else in so at the end of the day we're starting to turn away business because we don't have the space or the time frame available for them again it's a really good problem to have and i'd be very fortunate to have say that it's like i'd have all those numbers peaked and tight tightened tightened up but at this point in time we're in a really strong position and now i'd like to turn it over to my friend santiago carrada for the destination update santiago and i use the same hair brother per plus well good afternoon it is so great uh to be back home if i can if i can just say that i think many of you know i spend almost a decade here and visited this chamber often under two different administrations so it's great to be back to see so many friends that are still here congratulations to our new councilwoman the honorable robin lockett and thank you uh councilman miranda for bringing us to the forefront uh councilman miranda really follows the tourism industry so uh if you want uh your in-house expert he's right there um one of the things uh that i'm going to say that that you may not be expecting is that for years three and four that we're talking about that maybe we're going to experience some of these severe cuts uh or moderate cuts uh if we build a larger convention center some of that will be remediated uh it is private revenue and and i was lucky enough to run our city's convention center for almost two years and know the kind of revenue that flows through the center so it's counterintuitive that we're here asking for this in light of amendment three and some of the recent financial uh commitments to the tampa bay rays but we are because it's the solution to a looming problem you're not going to recoup 40 million from the convention center per year but you're certainly going to recoup millions every year and i'm glad that david alluded to 2038 we're booking business at 2038 because there's no room to book it before 2038 that's why we're booking business out to 2038 that's abnormal 35 38 abnormal tourism if we could have the presentation tourism really matters to our county these are 25 economic development numbers that we don't run a third party runs for us and i think the big number there uh is that 691 million dollars in state and local taxes if you take out the tourism tax which is about 68 million dollars you see how much tax revenue is generated by visitors to this destination and when we talk about this is county but when we talk about the city three out of our four sub markets exists within the city west shore downtown and north tampa bush those are our major major tourism areas within the city then we have east county that represents brandon in the fairgrounds as well but three out of the four sub markets are being impacted by these numbers consistently uh next slide please or can i do it oh i have a clicker here we go nine and a half billion dollars in total economic impact it's not just about hotel stays we're impacting a lot of industries and a lot of jobs in our county you saw on the prior slide almost 62 000 employees in the industry so what we do impacts a broad spectrum of tourism assets within the city and when you think about what those assets pay in property taxes if it's a restaurant if it's a hotel it's really it really benefits us for those businesses to do well because they're paying property taxes to the city and the county david showed a lot of uh the collective uh events these are the events that we have directly been engaged with bringing uh to the convention center and you see some of those economic impact numbers and total rooms that have been sold uh during those years when you look at 28 29 30 don't fret there's still plenty of time to book business uh where we have openings again conventions meetings and events are are very systematic they need certain times of the year to be able to be booked so even though you see some of those numbers we still have plenty of time and those are very strong numbers for us to be this far out one of the reasons we're here is about convention center expansion the city the convention center has done a feasibility study we've done a number of studies with reputable uh companies jll and the hunden group and we are losing about 248 000 room nights a year because of a number of factors either not enough room at the convention center too many hotels in this case doesn't mean we have too many hotels it means the convention has to use too many hotels to make it work because to this day and we're talking about 30 40 years later marriott water street is still our largest hotel in hillsborough county no one has come close to that many rooms in a property so when this says too many hotels it's not a good thing it's a bad thing because we're having to place these big conventions in hotel rooms in west shore and hotel rooms in downtown sometimes up north tampa bush out to east county that is the reason why too many hotels and some conventions just don't want their people scattered to that many hotels so again uh we're i think at a at a crucial point as far as how much business and how much economic impact we want to drive to the city and there are a number of ways to finance i don't have to tell the team here how to finance an expansion through bonds uh that can be paid off and still have a profit every year from the operations of the center so yes you're having to take a tough bite at the front end but it's going to deliver and you have an award-winning team at the convention center and then you have a very aggressive sales force at visit tampa bay as you can see from the numbers our convention competitive set not dictated by us but dictated by the industry includes these great cities right now we have the smallest convention center in the entire group uh so we are really competing with massive expansions fort lauderdale just had an expansion and added a hotel uh nashville is humongous uh all of these have added a lot of space over the last so many years and we're competing with these cities to fill rooms here so again thank you so much i'm gonna turn it over very quickly to our chief sales officer adam depiro uh most of the things i presented all those big groups uh are attributed to him and his team but he does this each and every day and he'll kind of wrap up where we are as far as our study and the need for expansion mr depiro good afternoon my name's adam depiro i'm the chief sales officer with visit tampa bay and have the privilege of working with our team at the city at the tampa convention center and our entire hospitality community to welcome these business events to our destination as santiago mentioned we have a competitive set here and you know i want to elaborate a little bit more on some of the development updates that have occurred within our competitive set and then how tampa is positioned relative to those destinations so uh i'm going to apologize about the size of the font here but uh this is some date did you do this this is actually hunden partners uh and this is this is pretty recent what what uh is showing up there is investments by by destinations currently or just recently completed uh in in hosting events and specifically their convention center and what you would find on this slide is that of our 10 competitive destinations seven are either currently in the process of expanding or enhancing their convention center or have recently completed theirs and then there are two that actually could be added there because louisville completed a major expansion of kentucky international convention center in 2018 and then charlotte in 2019 so that really brings the total to nine out of those 10 destinations that santiago just shared and and i would add that the reality is we compete with everyone as you know we're competing against chicago we're competing against st louis we're competing against new orleans phoenix the list goes on and on but but as santiago mentioned we really hone in on those 10 destinations based on similar sizes um yet they are larger than us the other thing i want to just add is that outside of our competitive destinations there are a number of destinations that see the value of bringing business events in and are actively trying to catch up to us so we really are keeping our eyes focused on savannah on rally on the palm beaches and some of these that really haven't gone after our events in the past but due to increases they're really trying to pursue events and take them away from tampa bay so as santiago mentioned on this slide as a result of fort worth's recent investment and expansion we now are officially the smallest convention center uh among the setup there uh you see us on the on the far right there with our 200 000 square foot exhibit hall and and i'd like to add that you know we we work so well david showed that slide with with the percentages if you were to ask anyone in the industry we are so efficient um working collectively the city uh visit tampa bay our hospitality community and maximizing every square inch of our convention center so that's a point to be really proud about but it is very difficult to stomach the amount of business that we turn away that wants to be here that we can't accommodate so the potential is there and it's not just about bringing in bigger events yes if we had a larger center we could attract bigger events it's not just about retaining the events that continue to grow that eventually could or do outgrow us it's also about the ability to secure and operate concurrent events when you look at these other destinations there's not just one big event happening geez you know orlando and atlanta they have multiple events producing millions in economic impact happening simultaneously so that's that's somewhat of a missed opportunity with our one ballroom and some of the limitations that we have within our building so on that slide you'll see that along with an expansion of the convention center it is important that we have increased hotel supply and i'm going to click here and show you another slide with with small print but really three of our competitor destinations um have invested in new hotel development uh one that's probably familiar to you all is the uh fort lauderdale the new 800 room omni that just opened up down there really right out front of the convention center miami is preparing to open up an 800 room grand hyatt connected to their convention center and i don't want to discount the investment we've had the pendry is going to be tremendous it's luxury inventory that we we really need as a community and those studies have shown that however the pendry is 220 rooms and the reality is that they'll likely commit maybe 50 to 100 rooms to conventions when appropriate so it doesn't move the needle by a large margin really what convention organizers uh and and event professionals look for is large convention hotels and back to santiago's point about the quantity of hotels needed sometimes being a deterrent you know convention organizer most often would like to have three four hotels so that their attendees can all network so that everything is close by and walkable from logistics and then also for contracting so you know atlanta just opened a 976 room signia new orleans has a thousand room omni being built right now even raleigh is is adding a 600 room omni so these investments are happening outside of tampa bay um walkability you know that's a great strength for our destination um event professionals attendees for conventions come here they have a great experience they love the walkability they love the transportation offerings that the city has provided um it is a top consideration you know walkable hotel rooms for for attendees that come in now what you're looking at with the pinpoint there that pinpoint is on tampa convention center and you're seeing hotels within one mile generally for the industry walkable is considered one half mile and in tampa bay we have 11 hotels currently that are within one half mile of the convention center and of those 11 hotels we have over 3 000 hotel rooms among those 11 hotels about 3 377 and then the pendry will add to that an important note is that not every hotel room gets committed to business events you have other needs you have business travelers that come in leisure family that are here for vacation all the the individuals that we market and promote to business travelers in tampa we see roughly about 1200 to maybe 1800 in the summer months rooms of those 33 hundreds that are committed to groups so i just i want you to know for for large conventions um generally fewer hotels are appreciated and um finally the last slide here um our competitors uh we're about 1500 rooms below the average of all of our competitors within that half mile district so so um there's a real opportunity that along with an expansion we would the recommendation say is that we really need another anchor hotel like santiago mentioned that the terror tampa marriott water street is is still remaining our largest hotel but really a thousand room property that could commit about 800 rooms to these conventions uh would be ideal per the different studies that have been produced um you know attendees want to be here as we said as a community we have done an incredible job marketing promoting the destination the events that come here have a great experience um we we've really just earned an excellent reputation so we uh we hope that uh that you know the results from the study the lost business that we talked about the um you know investments in our competitor destinations um we'll encourage you to consider this investment that these studies recommend so that we may remain competitive uh as a destination for events so thank you for the opportunity to share this and i'd like to ask if you have any questions we'd be delighted to answer those for you yeah one one last uh comment uh we would not be doing this in isolation we have uh spoken with hillsborough county hillsborough county is supportive of an expansion uh obviously through through the tourism development tax we've talked to the administration here we would not appear before you if we didn't have a collective agreement that this investment makes sense for our our economic development and our county and city um we are really up against the clock fyi so i see i have two lights on if you could keep it to like 30 seconds because i'm forgot i got a tick tock can we just can we just talk structurally about this then because this is a really big topic i know that that's what i'm afraid of because i mean i think this this conversation itself is worthy of discussion i don't think our clock allows that today um i i would rather i mean can can we continue this for discussion on another council there yeah i think you want to bring some numbers up in my mind i heard okay real real quick because real quick they tell us uh i've learned from different and not from you gentlemen on the street that tampa's ranked one of the highest room occupancy in the whole country is that true right now year to date through october we lead our competitive set in occupancy at over 73 percent downtown is over 75 percent and when you think about that you're talking about every three out of four rooms are being booked and maybe that fourth room couldn't be booked so again our numbers are the highest in occupancy we consistently lead our competitive set in a number of different categories whether we're talking about conventions meetings leisure travel we look at all of that central business district uh and we're usually near the top as far as our occupancy numbers and i want to follow the chairman's request i'm going to make it real short as possible and what we have here is something that's unique is something that if we don't compete you're gone in five or six years because you don't come here they go somewhere else because they have a larger space you have a broad approximately uh one how many how many people can fit into that convention center for a convention at one given time realistically you're probably looking about 20 000 at one time so the problem is that if you have two twenty thousand you can only handle one that is correct if you had two twenty thousand you can handle two and w event with the same space just about you need you need to have another area to build that of course and i'm looking at something realistically like at the restaurant business a restaurant by itself in the desert doesn't sell but if it had 30 hotels and 30 in the desert it will sell because people want to go see what what's going on and i think that's what tampa has now they've never had before i mean i remember there was no one living downtown there's a lot more people and i'm sorry i'm taking another minute and then i'm finished he's sharing every the nice way but anyway i like to see something happen maybe we put up for 30 days from now something we can spend at least a half hour to an hour with you because it's so important to the viability of the whole of downtown including all the other people that have pizza places bars the strass the theater tampa theater all everybody's included here because this is the mouthpiece that feeds the body that's all thank you councilman carlson yeah i'm just going to throw some ideas out and then i'd like when we bring you back if you could talk about them then what what i've always been missing on the convention centers is metrics competitive metrics and what i'd like to see is the the competitive set that you listed but the standard metrics against it like you know in the financial markets you have debt equity ratios and cost per store or revenue sales per store things like that i'd like to know what those metrics are for the every time i've asked this kind of question the administration gets defensive and then they send out press releases about how great the convention center is i'm not questioning whether we should have a convention center or or whether it is has an economic impact i want to just know what the metrics are because if we're going to justify expanding it i want to know how efficient we are and what we use compared to our competitive set and and part of that i studied economics and numbers i'm a numbers person not an economic impact person i don't believe in economic impact numbers but things like room nights and and revenues uh surplus those kinds of things i understand taxes that that are generated and then second um i'd like to know more about what you all think about the parcels in and around um i think dr k owns the property across street they were talking about doing something embassy suites is going to double uh or that was in their planning way to double um you know what are the other opportunities directly around or the property within a short walking distance um and then there are other big property owners within that mile radius that say hey why don't you bring it and move it you know i spent i i'm a sci-fi person so i spent a lot of time in orlando you know just one of their buildings is bigger than ours and they've got like four of them so how do we how do we compete with las vegas and and and orlando and these others we're we're constrained by space we we could get a hotel that added another meeting room but how do we really expand to be competitive in the future and the last thing is that all of south tampa especially harbor island davis island tgh all of us are being trapped in traffic half the day now because of that right turn underneath the convention center and i brought the city staff before us several times but they refused to change it what we what we need to do is not allow pedestrians to cross when the light is not is not in their favor or move them to the to the south side um the people in davis island i met with tgh the other day harbor island the hyde park all of south tampa they can't get down platte street they can't get on bay shore it's causing gridlock all of downtown it's that turn in the one by pamela garage we got to figure out how to fix that somehow thank you okay very good uh councilman her to take the gavel for a second yes i recognize chair clinton um i hope the stage works for you because i think we have a new council next may 1st on um june 24th we have a workshop i hope that maybe by then some of these items will be more fully baked and you've heard the concerns and questions from council yeah i'd like to make a motion that this agenda item be continued to the workshop session held on june 24th 2027 to be the first order of business you don't have to sit here all day like you did today and then to block out we have no more than um two other additional items on that day okay i have a motion from chair clinton i second from council member maniscalco all those in favor aye any opposed thank you very good thank you so thank you guys thank you appreciate it okay um as promised our four o'clock time certain is now 4 18. mr tinkler how's that voodoo that you do so well good afternoon council uh we're back on item 73 the proposal to amend section 7.07 to allow city council to initiate mid-year budget changes without the need for the mayoral recommendation in the manner consistent with general law uh in working with the city attorney uh this afternoon uh we've come up with language that both of us support you can see on your screen and then we've handed out copies so you have it individually what we're proposing is to leave the existing language uh that is in the charter in the first clause the city council upon recommendation of the mayor shall have the power from time to time during any fiscal year after adoption of the annual budget therefore by resolution and then adding in new language or the city council without the recommendation of the mayor shall have the power from time to time during any fiscal year after adoption of the annual budget therefore by ordinance and then it continues with the existing language to reappropriate to any municipal purpose any funds not needed for the purpose originally appropriated or to appropriate any unauthor and unappropriated cash surplus to any municipal purpose and this was the additional language we had already proposed in a manner consistent with general law the rationale behind this is it tracks uh exactly what we had posted uh for this meeting in terms of the removal of the recommendation of the mayor and also then uh keeps your existing process in place it would only be for city council without the recommendation of the mayor budget amendments that would trigger the need for an ordinance so that is where we have any questions and we appreciate the time to make sure uh that you've got to hear this i i would recommend you reopen for public comment and i'll just do do the whole thing okay i have a move i have a motion to reopen the public hearing from councilman scott goes second councilwoman her tech all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it okay um this council have any questions of staff okay um is there anybody in the public that wishes to speak to this item i have a motion to close with councilwoman her check i have second councilman scott call those in favor say aye aye opposed the eyes have it um what is the language that we need to read now the language is the same the agenda item okay the agenda item is the same okay all right the title is identical the title is identical thank you okay councilman man scalco uh this is an e-2026-8 chapter 27 ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption ordinance relating chapter seven is that's it no no no it's my fault okay this is file e or file number e-2026-8 chapter seven ordinance being presented for second reading and adoption ordinance related to the city of government city of tampa florida submitting to the electors of the city a proposed amendment to the revised charter of the city of tampa of 1975 as amended to amend section 7.07 to allow city council to initiate mid-year budget changes without the need from er recommendation and in a manner consistent with general law providing an effective date i have a motion from councilman manaskalco second from second councilwoman young please record your vote motion carried unanimously thank you so mr tinkler thank you so much the end of the road from my project it is the end of the road you're gonna miss you're gonna miss all this mr mr shelby just a point of personal privilege i just want to say uh especially today um mr tinkler thank you for the work that you've done and i want to uh especially thank the city attorney scott steady and justin vaske of his office for working with you together to be able to resolve this issue and i'm i'm very grateful and i'm sure the city council does as well always the best i appreciate the council giving us the time to put this uh in typed writing versus my handwriting uh that's for sure and yeah glad to work it out no i do i definitely do i appreciate the work that goes into this and i know they uh you know it's anguishing and getting pulled from multiple different directions so i'm very very much appreciative and scott you know what a fan i am you know thank you thank you justin and thank you mr tinkler thank you yeah i just i just want to say real fast um and thank you to scott and marty and justin everybody but as we all went out trying to figure out what attorney to get for this your name came up from everybody i talked to and i assume the same thing and and it's not often that we that we get the very best and so um it showed in your work so thank you so much for coming over thank you for taking on the assignment okay kudos thanks again thank you council okay we are moving right along because i know somebody who would like to get out of here a little bit early to put on their makeup but enough about me uh item number 88 no no no no michelle van lom real estate good afternoon chair city council welcome council member lockett glad to see you here today if we can have the presentation on july 30th 2026 council already had a full presentation on district chief warner and on firefighter isaac royal so i will be brief um while all firefighters and every member of our temper fire department comes to work knowing that they put their life and their physical safety on the line when they come to work they don't expect that violence and that danger to come to them on august 14 1981 that violence did come to tampa station fire uh fire station one and district chief warner died right at the scene and firefighter royal lasted about five six days later he did die of his wounds we are here today to memorialize these two brave men who dedicated their life to our community and to their jobs district chief warner he started with the city of tampa in 1963 with the police department in 1965 he then transferred to the fire department he was drafted in 1967 and served during the vietnam war he returned again to the tampa firefighter fire department sorry it's been a long day and he served distinguished 15 years with the department uh until the time of his death he instilled in his family his two sons a sense of community and dedication and giving back he was married and you can see with his two sons as his one son is also a retired district chief from the tampa fire department the family has three generations of dedicated firefighters and service people to the city of tampa fire department he was a man remembered by his son as someone that despite his deep commitment to the department also made time to for his family and at age when fathers weren't always remembered for the time they spent with their kids he made sure to be with his sons whether it was playing baseball taking them fishing and also talking about community service i talk faster than i click firefighter isaac royal was a first year firefighter when he died on that day he had envisioned for himself a long career with the tampa fire department and he was very excited about the job that he was embarking on in the career that he thought you would have at the time of his death he was survived by isaac senior and his mother maddie royal his younger brother bobby was only 16 at the time of his brother's death he mourned him as an older brother a mentor someone who taught him how to drive taught him how to swim and was also driving him to sporting practice and was one of his biggest cheerleaders his absence in the family was felt both by obviously his parents leaving at such a young age and also by his brother who lost a best friend and a brother the fire department has reviewed this request and they are recommending that the actual building of fire station one be named in honor of retire district chief franz warner and firefighter isaac royal and it is supported by our local firefighter union 754 and if council so chooses to move forward with this we ask that it be set for first reading on january 7th or any time thereafter and i'm available for questions councilmanescalco if you have questions and then would you please since uh in the absence of councilman vera now that you're on public safety would you please make that sure so that was your your best presentation on something like this it was so heartfelt because you brought these individuals to life with so many details about who they were um i've met the family members because you know many times they do for the anniversaries of this you know of what happened august 4th 1981 they'll do something um at the firefighter museum which is right across the street you know uh what's interesting is and this is what i learned from bill wade who if you know with the tampa fire he's retired now as he gave me a tour and we talked about the story there are bullet holes from that day still in the doors of this firehouse and i know it's known as the big house it has many nicknames station one uh but i'm glad to see that it's not just a street sign that it's more than that because they certainly deserve this i mean they were murdered in cold blood essentially and um you know doing renaming the firehouse it's i couldn't have thought of anything better so i totally support this and i'd like to make a motion to set this for then first reading second all right thank you very much i have a motion for councilman manescalco setting the uh public hearing that's the second from councilman miranda january 7 january 7 2027. okay all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the ayes have it thank you so much appreciate it would council with permission with unanimous consent would you all mind us skipping to 90 real quick susan johnson velez has a time commitment good afternoon council susan johnson velez legal department item number 90 is a response to a council motion from late october in which council asked staff to bring back a resolution doing a number of things related to data centers among them preparing an interim development control or moratorium ordinance to allow staff time to review the comprehensive plan the land development code and the city code so that we could come back to council with recommendations on regulations for data centers it also seeks to schedule two public hearings for that ordinance the first one according to the motion was december 3rd 2026 at 501 pm and the second reading would have been january 7th of 2027 so because of the timing of bringing this resolution forward got delayed a little bit the resolution does set the first public hearing date for december 10th instead of december 3rd so i'm happy to answer any questions that you all may have otherwise um i would ask council to um approve the resolution if it's your pleasure okay any questions any discussion here i have a motion from councilman ascalco to move the resolution second councilman miranda all those in favor say aye aye aye opposed the eyesight thank you thank you very good okay our last bit of business if i've got this math correct is 89 last but certainly least uh tough tough crowd thanks just 30 seconds yeah i just want to say thank you to um uh mr o'hera and his team um we had this on the calendar before and they had some information but his team went back and did even deeper research and and that's what we're going to see today i think thank thank you sir and and thank you no i appreciate your time and the meetings we've had i i want to also thank ms kopeski both of you thank you great contributions to making this a better product i sure appreciate it if i can have the presentation up dennis rojero chief financial officer deferred maintenance capital asset investment you see the agenda what we'll be going through a brief recap of the response that councilman carlson referenced that we provided uh last month deferred maintenance and capital investment discussion we're not always the same thing the citywide overview uh major departments needs and questions uh i apologize council and i already apologized to councilman carlson we simply could not get it done in time to get it on on base so you have it now and we have copies we did provide the overview in the addendum however so thank you for your patience first to level set uh real quick a recap of that initial response you know as the 49th largest city in the u.s uh you'd be right in presuming that we've got a great deal of capital assets out there that we've got to take care of and you see it right there bottom center of the slide nearly four billion dollars in capital assets take a moment real quick what are our capital assets so the public and everybody knows out there there are streets there are bridges there are parks there are water and wastewater facilities they are our public buildings our public safety buildings everything from an infrastructure perspective we need to provide the services that we're here to provide as part of the operating budget and you'll find this in both places and that's one of the reasons i wanted to bring this up you see at the top of this deferred maintenance funded via capital improvement projects okay that's our five-year cip but you also have deferred maintenance uh rear its head in our operating budgets okay there's there's many gray areas when you talk about capital investment and deferred maintenance and they often overlap which is one of the reasons as you'll see in a little bit we didn't want to confine this subject too narrowly and here is our overview you see right there 2.7 a little over 2.7 billion dollars in the lower right by far in the upper left you can see transportation and storm water are our largest needs that's probably going to surprise nobody but what may surprise some is the not insignificant needs in water and wastewater 600 million dollars in total despite having a three billion nearly a three billion dollar pipes program out there and this is where i'm going to start going into detail i'm going to skip around a little bit but we'll come back to this because i want to highlight some things and provide some context this is your wastewater but before i jump into wastewater uh again water wastewater up there in the upper left by far the most we've invested in recent history is water and wastewater again that pipes program and you see these needs in wastewater they've been itemized uh fiscal year through fiscal year 23 300 million dollars now water and wastewater has a great deal of money they don't have any deferred regular maintenance they are keeping their maintenance in line with their metrics and their time frame so if we confined the discussion to just that i'd have nothing to show you here right it'd be zero they're good to go and yet you see 300 million dollars worth of needs in wastewater those are capital rehabilitation and replacement needs that's why you don't want to in my opinion you don't you don't want to confine the discussion too narrowly because then you don't get the whole picture we always want councils and the public's eyes wide open so you get a three billion dollar plan and yet we still have 600 million dollars total needs in water and wastewater here oh sorry in the water department they're set up a little differently their needs are 300 million dollars throughout their water pipeline system there's really nothing to itemize at this time but again those are not deferred regular maintenance items those are capital rehabilitation and replacement and and again one of the reasons i reiterate that is the question could be asked you know we've got a great plan it's about seven years old now but the pipes program it was well thought out as you know we've stuck to it the rate the the rates we've stuck to those the borrowing we've stuck to that the spending we've stuck to that it's been a resounding success so you can probably guess why we still need 600 million dollars that's cost escalation that plan as well thought out as it was seven years old now okay as to give you an example the uh average us cpi inflation figure post pandemic it's been about over 30 percent much much higher than was anticipated in the plan the plan did include cost increases but nothing like that and much much higher than the inflationary history prior to the pandemic okay so as as well as that plan was life happens and you're going to see that again later on in this presentation so 300 million dollars in wastewater you have the itemization and 300 million dollars in water moving on we're also going to keep seeing in the departments keeping up with the deferred regular maintenance and that's great but continuing unfunded needs for capital replacement moving into solid waste three slides and you have them with you worth of 150 million dollars in needs ranging from 30 million dollars all the way down to 50 000 and again we've invested a great deal recently in the waste to energy facility nearly a quarter of a billion dollars but they still have needs facilities is in a similar situation just like the enterprise agencies we just talked about no deferred regular needs but it's pretty self-explanatory you see there about over 112 million dollars capital rehabilitation over the next 10 years they've got a very nice detail as you see here stemming from their recent facility condition assessment and part of their master plan you can see they've broken out their needs by fiscal year over that 10-year period and subdivided it into the particular portfolios fire police etc on to stormwater the second highest back up real quick to give you the overview again the second highest with 815 million dollars in the upper left again that probably doesn't surprise anyone they have some similarities with the pipes program as you know a well thought out plan back in 2016 taking care of about a quarter of a billion dollars in needs and you see the beginning of our assessment journey right here 2016 over on the right there's over 250 million dollars of needs being addressed so why the 815 million dollars in additional needs well those that were here may recall the initial plan identified 750 million plus in needs okay almost three quarters of a billion dollars the initial phase took about a third of that 250 million dollars but that 500 million dollars in needs never went away right it's been sitting there and it's planned on being addressed in the future only again this is 10 years old that 500 million dollars isn't 500 million dollars anymore it's over 800 million dollars in all likelihood as we've shared with council in the past the watershed master plan that i think will be done in about a year is going to refine those costs and refine those needs provide a report to city council and the public with the potential of increasing the existing uh improvement assessment transportation again uh i don't i don't imagine anybody's surprised by this a little over 830 million dollars worth of needs with over 500 miles on the right you see of pavement in either failed very poor or poor condition many of their signals at end of life and a sidewalk component there transportation's needs as you can probably imagine they're simply too expansive to illustrate here and the department can provide more detail but the bottom line i think as we all know is there is not and has not been sufficient funding on the bright side as you know our community investment tax renewal begins next month that will help a great deal don't get me wrong again for the transportation portfolio i think we anticipate almost 200 million dollars in revenue over the next 15 years that's a significant influx we can do some great things with it but it's not over 800 million parks and recreation uh again it's a funding issue you see their needs about 122 million dollars they they just simply don't have the funding for a consistent city-wide proactive maintenance program they fix as they have to fix to make sure things are at a minimum safe operating condition and they will tell you many of their assets are simply repaired only when they're about to fail or they've deteriorated again it's a funding issue they are generally funded and i think the needs speak for themselves go back to so there there's the detail there's the overview the departments are available of course mr baird's here also to provide any any additional information i'm here to answer any questions of course we can continue talking about it in the future the takeaway the 49th largest city in the u.s we have a great deal of needs we've invested a great deal and uh thank you for your time and your patience i appreciate it i have a i was i was going to ask a question you have a question counselor go ahead well those two questions then we'll do statements no but can i just summarize what he sure i just just just to summarize a couple things that i talked to him offline about um there was a part of the part of the evolution of this was that i had remembered that vic beady when he was head of mobility said something like two billion dollars in deferred maintenance and i think you said you and your staff kind of remember that too um as you kind of alluded to quickly in the beginning that you you think that included aspirational stuff not just the maintenance and so that's why some folks remember the two billion dollar number the 800 million uh yeah 830 million is just for the maintenance and so whether you include it in cip or aspirational stuff there's a much bigger number that's that's all of that yes sir um and the last thing i want to say is that um i appreciate the administration uh being transparent about this because it's not it's not a punitive thing it's it's in companies you have to know where you stand all the time and we you all gave us a report on debt you've given us a report on this we need to know where we stand financially because when we're making decisions uh about financial issues we need to understand the context what's the debt what's our revenues what's the impact of a3 and what's the impact of this thank you thank you i'm sorry if i could if i could just pull that thread just a little bit now thank you this was a very useful exercise i think for the city also and again i appreciate y'all's input and it demonstrated that although we had to search for it we had a great deal of discussion we have a very good handle as you see of what our needs are and they are significant thank you sir thank thank you councilwoman young um two questions you were um naming out our capital assets so i got streets public safety buildings parks and there were a few other things that you called out yes you've got uh streets bridges yes public buildings and public safety buildings water and wastewater facilities and infrastructure did i already say parks or did you say parks you've got parks somebody said parks okay yeah parks and recreation i think that covers it am i missing parking parking garage oh parking thank you yes okay and then also you said um for when we're talking about waste uh wastewater you said that there are capital rehabilitation and something capital rehabilitation and uh replacement thank you thank you just want to make sure i have my notes right thank you i have i have a question about enterprise funds how do we have if we have enterprise funds that are fully funded by user fees how do we have deferred maintenance why is it why why would we have deferred maintenance why aren't those projects being accomplished on schedule since it's in one side and out the other that's a good question and i guess i'll start with the pipes program and water and wastewater since that's probably the gorilla in the room you know uh when we started the pipes program again we had a full foot a full-fledged plan for 20 years nearly three billion dollars and then again life happens costs go up at some point in the future as we continue we're uh it's a 20-year program we're not even halfway through at some point in the future we will have to decide how we are going to make up that shortfall from a business perspective they're operating just as they should they're making a profit and they're reinvesting it into their facilities but between now and the end of that 20-year period the city will have to decide how to make up that shortfall so that is something we and of course our users should anticipate that we're going to have to meet that gap because they're enterprise funds yes sir you're either going to have to meet that gap or you're going to have to curtail the price program okay i have one more question but i'll defer to councilman Miranda first thank you chairman that was a great question you asked and i believe that program started out to be 1.5 million a mile the pipe program correct now that i don't know but i'm sure mr beard and it went up to 4.5 million a mile or something like that yes brad baird infrastructure mobility administrator just in the last three years to replace a water pipeline is was in 19 in 2023 one and a half million dollars a mile today 2026 it's four and a half million dollars a mile that's the problem we have three times as much just in the last three years so that 300 million you saw for water that's a hundred percent pipeline replacement that needs to go out on a postcard um my other question was that's just crazy my china uh donald trump um tariffs uh police and fire something's not adding up there either i mean i get that the cit like so we have some really facilities especially within fire that are in dire need of repair the numbers don't seem right to me considering knowing how how bad shape some of these buildings are where where am i what am i missing as far as deferred maintenance on some of these fire stations that are just such crap shape the best example uh if i can find the slide here on facilities you'll see in the upper right there's a caveat that says breakdown upper right right below the 67 percent breakdown by facility use and you'll see excluding hq excluding headquarters that's big blue we don't intend to do any major rehabilitation or replacement on big blue and it is significant so it's not included here since we're not going to so that that answers my one question because that big blue was one of but the fire stations themselves and the maintenance that is required i mean some of these stations are almost total rebuilds well that's what i would that's what i would argue that it's just maintaining what they have but really it's not the issue of the building itself it's the fact that we have they're bursting at the seams so the buildings themselves are are okay it's just not some of those buildings not all of them but but i'm saying i've been in a couple of them but 28 million dollars may fix some of that but really our our problem is we need to rebuild for for size yeah i would i would just love to see another look at if you guys when you guys come back for this and i'm sure i'm sure we're going to see this presentation again i'd like to reevaluate especially fire and of course i know some i know we're probably going to kick this down to the next council and next administration big blue too late for us now so um you know we'll have that discussion after next may or whoever's up here will have that discussion after next may but those fire station things again i'd like to see a reevaluation of what the actual deferred maintenance really looks like to be able to bring the stations that people are working in really poor conditions and you know question about our service levels and some of those stations of what it really takes to build bring those back up to speed councilman cross you had a follow-up question yeah um following up on on what uh chair said um in the private sector and a lot of government agencies you would then take this document can can can av show this again cttv can you put it up on the public monitors you would take this document and you go department by department and ask the department heads to figure out how we're going to solve this and then they would come back to us they present the mayor of course but then come back to us i i really wish over the next i'll leave it up to you and the department heads but i really wish the department heads would come back and just schedule for us one a month um and and figure out how we're going to how we're going to deal with this we know that affordability is the biggest issue out there right now so we can't jack up all the rates but we need to be prepared with some kind of plan and the other thing is i and i talked to rory a little bit about the nine percent water increase i that's a that's a re-rating from the county fee that has to go down but i don't think people can afford a nine percent increase right now but if you're gonna if you have to do re-rating because of the bonding i wonder if there's a way of looking at updating pipes and if you have 600 million here and you have to re-rate is there a way that we can somehow combine those we should kick that vote to the next council but we can start preparing it and putting it together over the next few months uh because there's there's got to be a look over a 10 or 20 year time horizon because it's it's not acceptable uh that that we have this the way it is i don't think anybody thinks it is but we we just need to be proactive about planning and we know that we all hear complaints every day about about the state of the roads and there's not an easy revenue source for that but um you know how how would how would we solve that we just need to be proactive about looking so the public knows we have some kind of plan and i don't mean a plan that takes five years to work with some engineering firm we just need to sit down and figure out where the revenue streams we now we know how much we need to spend we know the aspirational expenses but we know how much we need to spend and one of the big questions that we're getting especially around beta bay and el prado is how come the city is spending on bike lanes and they're not fixing potholes and so we need to be able to explain everything in context um you know if it's a federal grant it only goes to bike lanes we need to that is an easy message but um but we need to be able to explain what what our plan is and when people could expect that the roads and other things would be fixed thank you can i make a can i make a suggestion to council members somebody take on the task that our next regular scheduled council meeting that they make a motion that starting in february that one department head a month you fully flesh this out so you see what it really looks like as we move into the budget cycle of next fiscal year that one budget head a month come in and do a complete presentation encompassing what their current needs are what their unmet needs are what their deferred maintenance is and we can start that in february and maybe do one per month during staff reports okay well because that was going to let somebody else have that well there's i mean we're not going to be able to get through all the departments yeah exactly if you did it if you did one per meeting but yeah well not one per month okay so i have to look and project out what all those meetings look like so i make a motion that starting on february 18th under staff reports that let's start with who do you want to start with parks how's that parks that parks and rec department head come in with additional staff and support as needed to present to tampa city council their current unmet needs their deferred maintenance and their projections for fy 28 and that that motion continues on the for every city council every other city council meeting and every other every other city council meeting once a month or every other city council meeting and that we will rotate parks and rec transportation storm water we'll put wastewater and water together okay wastewater so then water i would probably and then parking if i were you i would consider taking the enterprise funds out and just focusing on the non-enterprise funds first you think so yeah what about parking though yeah but but then you're not doing the police and fire and stuff like that that's true okay so eliminate water and wastewater eliminate parking and we won't have convention add fire and add police yeah public safety well we need the police inspired two separate could you you're going to need to have the enterprise funds at some point yeah eventually but get through the non-enterprise funds first yeah well this will be a continuing item that we can add in to roll through with the thing i would recommend the thing i would recommend maybe adding to the verbiage is um you didn't specifically say this but just to specifically say to and recommend alternate choice of financing funding for uh to to resolve the current maintenance and aspirational may i recommend um maybe since this was your motion maybe getting together figuring out what the motion should be and bring it back in two weeks with a list so i will volunteer then two weeks to bring back this motion only flight by the way i will volunteer sam to bring i was volunteering bill but okay the re the only reason i hesitate is for sure i'm not going to be here after you know i'm turned out i can't be here and so i think somebody just i i will i will i will take my own suggestion or my office will take it and we will bring back that out of the next regular schedule i think it's just better i agree that was my gut to begin with when i got conned into the other no no no i think it's a good conversation i rescind my motion and i should also point out martin shelby city council attorney with regard to the fact that there's going to be changes obviously come may just a reminder for your budget um and finance advisory board their term is co-terminus with councils so just so you know that as well you'll have you'll have them coming on i understand that and we'll comply okay that concludes our regularly scheduled program thank you thank you very much for your patience and sticking with us all day um new business councilman carlson yeah thank you thank you again to i think every department was involved in that and not just your staff so thank you all for that took a lot a lot of time and so thank you everybody for doing that i think the public will really appreciate that um i just i want to have three things one is to file my form 8b for item 51 from earlier i have a motion to receive and file from i'm receiving follow the councilman carlson second councilman scoffo all those in favor say aye aye opposed i said um uh stephanie pointer mentioned this morning the asking for a scheduled uh further repair of ballast point and picnic island pier so i would like to make a motion to ask city staff to submit a written report on january 23rd as to an update and timeline for the repair and reopening of the ballast point and picnic island piers i have a motion from councilman carlson second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed eyes have it thank you i got it right there it's a written report it's written yeah january is it 20 21st did i write that down wrong okay okay 21st okay so just for the for the record that motion is for the report to come back as a written report on january 21st 2027. yeah and then lastly um uh i don't want to bring up any specific cases but um i had a long conversation with scott uh study today about the issues we faced in the first four years i was here regarding reimbursement of legal fees and um and ultimately we voted to let city council have the right to vote to reimburse or not but there there are fine line differences between what's covered and what's not and i can give you examples if you want but i talked to scott and since we have scott everybody likes him and trusts him he's very neutral i would like to get scott to write a document that just defines that um so that a future city attorney future council can look at it and and see what the intent was and he's on board with this yeah and so um i didn't clear the exact verbiage of this but he was okay with the concept motion to ask legal staff to submit a written report on january 21st to describe and clarify the city attorney's opinion on how and when the city will legally defend city council members and the mayor okay i have a motion from councilman carlson second councilwoman her tech all those in favor say aye aye opposed the ayes have it that's it thank you yes okay councilwoman lockett do you have any new business thank you i've had a great time well there's one of us i think i think i think that motion fails zero zero to one councilwoman young i have one motion i move to make a motion to present an off-site combination on november 29th 2026 for the 100th church anniversary celebration for the new bethel progressive missionary baptist church located at 2914 east north bay street i have a motion from councilwoman young i have a second councilman maniscalco all those in favor say aye aye opposed the ayes have it councilwoman her tech councilman maniscalco yeah so a few weeks ago i had mentioned the affordable energy resolution and i passed it out i'm not asking for anything other than this council want to feel comfortable moving forward with something like that or is it something that you don't think it's in that city business i think it crosses the line jerry says it's a psc issue and yeah because we'll be in the gaza and everything else if we start doing that okay this is my gut feeling going to court that doesn't doesn't do any good we don't have the power okay so a few weeks ago i brought up some uh individuals from the public regarding um it's a florida affordable energy resolution basically regards to um you know higher electric bills and whatnot so um instead of just making a motion i pass it around to council members to take a look at it if council you know like a straw that they you know had the stomach to pursue something like that if they would be interested instead of putting anybody on the spot and saying okay vote it up or down however you know we had a policy that we brought up a while ago that if it's not related to city business that's outside the city's purview because we don't regulate electricity bills it's the public service commission at the state level um you know that was it councilman miranda i understand to have compassion for that but the city is in the same spot the individuals are when they raise their rate they raise our weight in fact the city uses you know how much dollars a day for electricity seventy thousand dollars a day electric bill yeah so there's where we're at we're in the same boat they are yeah and i know that this evening at 6 30 at the naacp uh tico is having there's a community meeting and tico is presenting as to what they're doing you know and opening it up for uh people in the community to ask their questions bring their utility bills did the rate reductions that they're doing so i know that they're being proactive in that case um but that was it if there's no appetite for we just leave it so so for background just to give you some background i'm familiar with it you know you're familiar with other issues that with council how we got here because what we got how we got here was there were issues with like say cuba we used to sit in that chair uh issues with cuba which we don't control foreign policy there were issues with afghanistan um there's all there's a whole bunch of issues in israel and gaza things that we have no control over so we as a council decided that um we have a city council rule that if if it's not within our control if we if i can't pass an ordinance or pass you know controlling that issue that we it would be inappropriate for us to have those to have those motions or make that have that business and take that time out of our schedule that we only we only we know our lane and stay our lane and do the stuff that we control it let the let the legislature and let um the congress and the president and do all the stuff that they do yeah and i've written letters to the public service commission you know asking them to instead of approving rate heights and rate increases that they be mindful of you know working it doesn't preclude us from being individual activists i guess my question is is resolution is the resolution asking you to do something or is the resolution asking you to just confirm or just acknowledge that the rates are too high yeah and so making a statement they're not so again a statement is one thing but in regards to just showing support for constituents now i'm now i'm coming from the organizing uh community aspect of it we would have to change our rules because our rules say that we don't is it in writing your rules in writing yeah so when so my one suggestion when these individuals come to you individually we tell them that's not what they're saying though because then you're because if you are then he wouldn't be bringing it up here yeah well i'd tell it just like he was trying to be nice i control it no but they've come they've had meetings with you guys and and we say it we say it to them okay i mean the bill was recent was the israel stuff yeah yeah i'm just i'm just i'm just saying but it's that that's the kind of stuff yeah having worked on the other side of some of this stuff i know that some groups they get bonuses based on them i don't think these letters are effective and one thing is we have passed rules or resolutions in the past for issues directly related to the city and the legislature watch was watches what we do and sometimes they react the next day it changed the law to to stop us from doing what we're doing so you take a you take a democratically controlled um city council and you send a letter to a republican controlled legislature and they're probably going to do the opposite it's going to have the opposite impact yeah and so anyway okay all right i'll leave that okay councilman moran do you have any new business thank you for bringing it to our future yeah thank you no way i do appreciate it we're all empathetic with it i mean just like on all these issues you know what we know all of our politics we know where our politics are at but i i started washing my clothes on the weekend to save money it's i mean the electric bills are um i got a couple a couple things one i want to again say thank you staff for uh the support and and going through the council's responsibility thus far and so we see what comes back from the mayor's office on the charter this has been a long long road i mean months and months and months thank you hager thank you mr shelby thank you to all the staff and everybody including uh sam and everybody else that's had a part of this um those of you uh if you've been paying attention to me you see my eye is kind of weird my left eye next week i'm having eye surgery try to correct it because it's like kind of droopy and kind of weird um so when you see me next sam punched me in the eye and that so so if so if you see me and i look really really awful that's why sam punched me in the eye okay motion to receive and file i have most councilman right a second councilwoman her check all those in favor say aye aye opposed