Civic › Tampa, FL › November 3, 2026

Barrio Latino Commission - 11/17/26

Tampa, FL City Council November 3, 2026 78 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Tampa meetings

Transcript

SPEAKER_056:20

public hearing for the City of Tampa's Barrio Latino Commission welcome everyone I'm rich Simmons chair of the Commission if you're here to present a project you will have limited time to make your presentation so we suggest being thorough but concise when coming to the microphone you will need to identify yourself and your relationship to the project the commissioners will not ask any questions during your presentation your project should be presented in the following order site plan elevations architectural details wall sections staff presents the staff report we will then ask for public comment please state and spell your name clearly or if you're here to speak for against the project your time will be limited to three minutes so take some time now to summarize your comments following public comment the commissioners will be asking questions in the same order as a presentation next the applicant will have five minutes for rebuttal the public hearing will then be closed after the public hearing public hearing is closed no further ado no further a testimony can be given the commissioners will then discuss the case amongst themselves and make their decision based upon chapter 27 of the city code of ordinances the design guidelines the secretary of interior standards the historic preservation development review committee and the testimony given today at this public hearing the BLC can only act on items that are within our specific jurisdictional responsibility owner agents are independently responsible to obtain any appropriate permits and or approvals if you haven't already done so please silence your cell phones and we'll start with the introduction of the commissioners Peter Furtig good morning and say Blackwell morning Richard Cahill and from staff we have Ron Bela Jared Barnum Heather bonds and Dana Crosby Collier from legal we have the minutes from the October 27th 2026 meeting in our packet as everyone had a chance to review motion to approve second all favor said motion say aye aye opposed motion

SPEAKER_018:29

carries mr. be left good morning commissioners in public my name is Ron Vila I am a planner with historic preservation under announcements we have the staff approvals that are in your packets at the end of this meeting we can receive and file these we put those and we send them out to you so you could review them if you have any questions we can go ahead and discuss that at the end of the meeting as well we have our Tampa bricks and mortar a publication that is featuring the WPA projects that are locally and along with our preservation and progress miss bonds will expand on this discussion at this point so Heather will take the preservation in progress that will discuss the WPH projects in

SPEAKER_039:23

Moreland good morning Heather bonds historic preservation specialist an interesting topic for you all this morning this month's preservation in progress is a look into the impacts of the new deal and the work progress administration in Tampa the new deal was created by the Franklin D Roosevelt administration and Congress in response to the Great Depression these programs addressed a wide range of problems facing our country such as stabilizing or they stabilized banks helped reform the mortgage industry stimulated the economy created jobs and invest in public works particularly in rural and underserved areas and giving Americans a sense of security and hope a few of the new deal programs that we are most familiar with in historic preservation are the CCC which put unemployed men to work in rural and park improvements and taught them skills for future jobs the PWA which built large-scale projects the WPA which concentrated on smaller projects and put artisans to work and the National Archives which is an invaluable repository of historic documents and photographs additionally the 1935 historic sites acts give the National Park Service the responsibility of overseeing the preservation of buildings and sites of national significance and this act paved way for the federal historic preservation legislation in place today the WPA in Florida had a significant impact in mosquito control parks and recreation improvements literacy gains jobs training and school lunch programs the federal writers project documented local history superstition and folklore in Florida with interviews of residents in places such as Key West and Ybor City the WPA office in Tampa was located in Ybor City and operated through 1943 shown here is a WPA sewing room that was housed in the Seidenberg and company cigar factory at 12th Avenue and 20th Street Cascaden Park and swimming pool was built as a WPA project in the late 1930s the construction of the pool brought Ybor City residents much needed relief from Tampa's scorching summers Ybor City social clubs formed baseball teams as did many of the cigar factories beginning in 1938 the inner social league played at Cascaden Park and at times with over 2,000 fans several well-known professional baseball players got their start here at Cascaden Park another one of our Tampa landmarks is the Fort Homer Hesterly Armory in 1922 the land at Howard and Lemon Street in West Tampa was donated to the Florida National Guard Colonel Homer W Hesterly commanded the 116th feed field artillery of the National Guard at Benjamin field Hesterly's cheap troops were called into active duty on September 3rd 1935 to assist with threats of disorder surrounding the city of Tampa's municipal elections the WPA project to construct a new armory building was completed in 1941 and the building was named in honor of its commanding officer the site remained a popular venue for sporting events as well as musical performances and political speeches the National Guard moved out of the facility in 2005 one of the most visible and long-lasting WPA projects in Tampa was the renovation and expansion of Bayshore Boulevard from 1934 to 1938 and the roadway landscaping balustrad and seawall were reconstructed expanded and lengthened the four-lane boulevard which is of a classical urn shaped balustrade was extended all the way north to the plat street bridge two spans of the bridge were removed for the expansion of the boulevard and a pedestrian underpass continued the seawall and balustrad under the west end of the bridge a portion of Bayshore Boulevard and see and the seawall is included in the National Register of Historic Places boundary for the Hyde Park historic district another WPA project was the Peter O Knight Airport on Davis Islands which served as Tampa's main airport from 1935 to 1945 the Coquina block art deco style administration building pictured here was demolished in the 1960s the interior of the building featured a series of seven murals about the history of flight by st. Petersburg artist George Snow Hill which are now located in the airside e at the Tampa International Airport and you can read more about the WPA in Tampa and this month's Tampa bricks and mortar thank you

SPEAKER_0114:37

Heather so moving down our agenda we will have legal address the board at this time

SPEAKER_0314:44

good morning Dana Crosby call your city attorney's office I'd like to inquire if any member of the board has a conflict of interest with any item on the agenda this morning thank you seeing none has anyone engaged in an ex parte communication on any item on the agenda this morning thank you and under continuations we have

SPEAKER_0115:05

one reflected on our agenda which is blc-26-0000128 for the address of 1901 East 7th Avenue this request came from the agent to continue to a future date when they continue to a future date they will have to re-notice per section chapter 27 149 of the code of ordinances if we could get a motion to continue to the future please motion to continue to the future second hi and at this time everybody that wishes to testify please stand up and raise your right hand including staff for the swear-in I do our agenda item that we're going to discuss this morning is blc-26-0000197 this is for the address of 2712 East 12th Avenue currently it's a vacant parcel the request is for new construction for a single-family residence with site improvements the total square footage is approximately 1900 square foot the underlying zoning attached to this parcel is yc2 and the style that they're going to reflect is a craftsman style I'm going to share some photos with you at this time starting with the Sanborn map this is the 1929 Sanborn map showing the property which is circled over here the red area is the boundaries of the local district of Ybor city this is zooming in our vicinity map showing that it is a vacant parcel just to the north you have the interstate that came through obviously in 1929 you don't see the interstate you see the concentration of the fabric and then when the interstate came through an urban renewal you see a lot of opportunity there for development with the vacant parcels that are there looking from the aerial property in question has the pin on it there is or was some challenges implementing this request and keeping the tree on site we do have mary bryson with natural resources when we get into questions if you have any questions she could answer those questions you do have a contributing structure to the east there was development that was approved over here on this parcel just last month and then you have new construction that came through so this area is is moving forward as I spoke there is a grand tree on site that with this the latest request with the agent working with city staff that the tree could remain and the development of the parcel can move forward as well this is just looking at another perspective of the tree on site the canopy some of the power lines and then you see the interstate to the north this is the empty parcel just to the west that received approval you see a portion of the new construction that was also approved moving to the east side you have this structure here it is a contributing structure when we did our inventory we had to kind of think outside the box to capture some of the structures that are of the period and this one here is going through some discussion with our office to bring it back this is looking down 12th avenue to the east to the end of the district back with within the district you see some of the contributing structures as you get a little further away from the subject site and directly across the street you have a non-contributing structure so with that I will have the agent and the owner address the board and do his presentation could you pull up his presentation please good morning commissioners

SPEAKER_0220:07

leo martinez are here I am the owner of this parcel today we will present for a new single family resident to study to rebuild on this property first to show some data about the the structure this structure will be set back 20.4 inches from the front based on the findings about the tree and the preservation of the tree it's going to be set back 10 foot from the rear 9 foot 7 from one side 12 foot 2 from the other side and it's going to have a max height of 28 foot it's also being proposed to be to cover up to 42.7 percent of the whole lot so we're still going to have 57.3 green space remaining here on the site plan we can see you know we're going to have a ribbon driveway that is going to have nine foot on the east side two concrete strips south center you'll require one space for a single family home so at this parking space on the side will accommodate for that we're going to have scoring driving from walk room finish three foot square score joints no stamp or color on concrete ac and fence we're going to have the ac pad at the rear behind the house screen no new fence or gates we can also see here on the side plane that the tree is shown right here on the front of the property we're showing a 20 foot radius around the tree and we're proposing the turkey to be right behind the the the tree protection zone here on the front elevation similar as the other house we're going to have a gables and eve 6 6 12 main 3 12 on the porch 2 by 8 barge rafters wood louvers rafter tails pose no fascia no gutters the porch is going to have tapered columns and brick piers with poor caps knee brackets finish big board ceiling the openings one over one cloud windows door 10 lights wood entry door no side lights uh bronze lanterns and hardware the side and rear elevations are going to follow the same language on all four sides um here to show some details all the construction metals will have a cmu um first floor then it's going to follow a framing uh second floor on the porch we're going to have suspended the floor that are going to be uh formed with cmu peers lbl beans pt joist one by one by four uh tng wood porch floor no slab no field inside the tree protection zone the peers um saved by airspace route investigation work in the sun supervised by an isa certified arborist the columns are going to be tapered square columns 12 inch to two eight inch fiber cement wrap knee brackets uh big board ceiling here here is a close-up detail of how we're going to accomplish the um the lattice skirt look on the side with the brick columns basically we're going to wrap we're going to paint that whole um stem wall black on the back then we're going to form the piers with bricks and have a fold um um lattice um um skirt on the window details both windows both floors are going to have recessed windows to to to to look um identical the sash sits back from the from the face of the casing on both floors not flush uh for instance on the block wall bringing the first floor to the same outside face as the frame second floor so the reveal reads same up and down here um a couple of samples of the hardware and lanterns that we are proposing to use on the front of the structure um just to elaborate a little bit more about the roof suppose uh rafter tails barge rafter working lures and you know bracket owning on the back to accommodate for the ten foot set back in the rear similar to to our property finish base brick pier and lattice skirt um as shown on on the image here on the roof we will have architectural awful asphalt shingles uh 30-year charcoal colors of the whole structure are going to remain to air tones beige and whites and um i think that's it good morning ron villa staff with historic

SPEAKER_0125:05

preservation preservation when we review the project we put our application of the standards into place which are the ybor city design guidelines and the secretary of interior standards on page four of your staff report your our standards uh speak on the height the width the facade widths the setbacks the spacing and uh similarities that details and form so i wanted to touch upon the site plan for a minute staff feels that this application is consistent with the ybor city design guidelines we reviewed the plans on november 6 2026. part of the challenge that we had moving forward was keeping the tree he had to push it back so the face of the of the porch is not consistent with the with a blocked face because of the tree so that's that's the uh the nuance that we have here you see the jog and the uh apron uh coming in here and and the driveway in working with transportation there's a design exception a det design exception through transportation that he could request that's an administrative function he could straighten this leg out and then when the apron comes out here the apron won't have the six foot flare on this side because of the challenges on this parcel so there is a process if this is to move forward i would request that the design exception through transportation has to be uh reviewed and approved as well to fix this little dog leg that it has there the rear and yc2 the rear is a 10 foot he's he has that 10 foot set back here he does have that visor just to bring to your attention that as long as that visor is not greater than three foot in depth that he could put that there and no variances required so he tried to work very hard with the challenges with this parcel um to accommodate everything and not come forward with any variances i just wanted to elaborate on the the staff report and as i stated we have mary with natural resources here if you have any questions and i'll be available

SPEAKER_0527:17

as well thank you mr villa anyone here from the public wishing to comment have to ask no i don't see any okay uh we're going to ask some questions of your presentation you went through it pretty quickly so i think we're going to get into it a little bit more detail okay a little bit of deja vu uh yeah

SPEAKER_0427:44

saw a similar last month um okay i do appreciate you trying to follow up on some of the some of the questions we had from previous project i do want to talk about though the the attachment of the hardy to the cmu and how that's going to align with the wall above because the wall above is still frame and that's correct yes so is it is it being directly attached to it because i think there's a detail

SPEAKER_0228:12

there that still needs to be worked out um so yeah so basically we're going to have the siding go right on top of the of the frame wall on the top and then at the bottom we're going to have fourings going on top of the of the actual um cmu and then have the siding installed on top of the fourings

SPEAKER_0428:30

um okay i'm not sure that that's necessarily represented in the sections that we looked at but that that sounds good there's just a jog there the three then the other detail that i'm not exactly clear on yet is the wall location the the window location in the wall how that's going to actually

SPEAKER_0228:54

be achieved all right so the idea here is to have both uh top and um and bottom have the both windows same depth what we're going to be doing is on the cmu portion the window is going to be recessed sitting on the window on the window seal on the second floor we're going to have to recess that window instead of a flange window we're going to have to recess it in the frame we're going to have to case that in and and trim it to match the one at the bottom okay because the i think the window

SPEAKER_0429:23

that you have in the presentation is is actually a thin window yeah probably because that's what we

SPEAKER_0229:30

found for the presentation but yeah no they're going to be recessed in the actual opening so on the on

SPEAKER_0429:37

the first floor it's going to be a flange window and it's going to sit on a precast cell we're supposed

SPEAKER_0229:42

to be on on the first floor it is not going to have the flange it's going to be recessed in the wall sitting inside the the opening of the lintel blocks and and sealed on the second floor is going to be the same thing it's going to be screwed through the sides into the actual frame then it's going to be waterproof i mean it's going to be waterproof screwed into a size and then going to have the trim go inside and the front so they they both will look the same yeah yeah i'm trying trying to go there but i'll do the same thing here yeah so the the window and i i only bring this up because i want

SPEAKER_0430:57

to make sure you work this out before you get out in the field and start start constructing this on the ground floor there's a flange window made to go into a mainstream wall sitting on a precast sill so it's recessed back to the to the notch in the precast sill and you're going to use the same type of window on the second floor to allow you to recess it in correct can you go back to maybe a presentation i just have a question about the porch overhang and one of the elevations that looked like the overhang was relatively short i think it was in an elevation so that section shows

SPEAKER_0232:05

that's that section shows the front porch yeah right let's go from so here's the side plan two more down front elevation side elevations that right elevation yeah that's that's a misrepresentation but it's going to have a two foot overhang on all sides okay yep i know the rest of the board

SPEAKER_0632:38

probably has better expertise in this but is there a plan for gutters i don't see anything in relation

SPEAKER_0232:45

in this case we won't be using gutters we're going to keep it without the gutters then what we're going to do is on the side we're going to do a catch basins drainage system that is going to send all the water uh to the front of the property through ads and and the catch basin system no further questions

SPEAKER_0533:06

downspouts on it so we're going to clarify that in our motion yeah on the right it's got a hatched

SPEAKER_0233:18

area on the side of the house yeah that was the last minute change so we'll do away from the gutters and we'll have uh keep you know without the gutters zoom in a little bit the elevations we'll go with the elevations the elevations don't show the gutters that you know stay on the side plan so yeah um um

SPEAKER_0734:10

your port section please um it appears in this in this drawing that the porch is intended to be wood framed with a crawl space below and wood plank but if you go to your materials slide probably like five slides later right there you show concrete porch and stairs which is it it's going to be

SPEAKER_0234:44

it's going to be a wood uh floor on top it's going to be wood frame with wood plank in this case yeah yeah in this case it would need to be a wood flare um a wood floor on top because we're going to be doing a floating uh floor on that front porch just to preserve the tree again something we

SPEAKER_0735:02

commented on last time make sure before you come before the board everything is aligned it's really frustrating um back to the site plan please uh to the larger so for staff has transportation seen this or not they have looked at it uh through the process when

SPEAKER_0135:34

somebody makes application we have other reviewers within the city natural resources one transportation we have zoning that looks at it and storm water that looks at it as well so they looked at it the change didn't make it here there there is something that uh normally happens when there's a challenge there that transportation wants six foot flares on each side of that apron so in the event that they can't do that it's too close to their property line they have to go through that design exception process that as i stated it's administrative and they could cut it off so instead of having that flare on that side it'll it'll be truncated and they can't do that because there's a power pull there

SPEAKER_0736:12

and a transformer there that's correct correct um my my question really was have they looked at it from a turning perspective because that that angle and that as you come in and turn and get into the drive

SPEAKER_0136:26

seems a little harsh yeah have they commented on it they have commented on it they believe that it

SPEAKER_0736:32

could be met with those minor modifications using an suv uh-huh yeah the only other question i have on the site is i i noted the overhangs but it seems like the nine foot seven is actually to the building face is that correct the setback the nine foot seven yes so are you looking for an exception to the oh it's a three foot side isn't it yes i'm sorry i'm sorry that's my that's my bad um that's it for

SPEAKER_0537:07

now thank you let's go back to the site site plan so the overall width of the site is 43 feet 43.75 yes 43.75 and i see some notes on there for the two of the piers or the columns for the porch could you describe what you're going to do there i think it's because it's in the tree yeah there are two columns

SPEAKER_0237:42

that are going to follow that are going to fall into that protection radius so we're going to do in that case we're going to have an isa certified arborist do uh what is called an air spading where they're going to expose the the opening of the foundation of those piers and see if it is doable to put the columns on on those locations and then you know accommodate based on that but that's basically what is going to happen so only only on those two spots that is going to be a pier then everything is

SPEAKER_0538:09

going to be floating on top of that what's going to happen on the other column that doesn't happen

SPEAKER_0238:13

the other column is going to follow the same it's going to it's going to follow the same design that one just doesn't fall into that uh radius so that one is fine to to do it as as we're proposing basically a concrete path foundation with the pier on top okay so so you're proposed are you going to

SPEAKER_0538:30

like root prune that area where that foundation is going to be to get that it depends on the

SPEAKER_0238:35

water that the the arbores recommend once that the time comes to do it uh what he mentioned to me is like usually in this case because it is far farther away from the tree doesn't doesn't usually create an issue but if if it comes to to an issue that they find like a root or something in there he said that he they can propose you know a fix or solution for it mary daniel it's bryson natural

SPEAKER_0039:01

resources and i have been sworn i'm a certified arborist um the air spading will determine the location of the pier we can shift you know slightly either to the left or the right to accommodate the roots um at the 20 foot mark where the building actual frontage starts they will actually do a root prune through an arborist they will do the root pruning you know they can call me out when they do the air spading and i can work with them and make sure that the tree is accommodated but they will provide the air spade and we will make adjustments as we need to if it's a small root less than two inches we can root prune if it's a larger root we may have to adjust okay so it seems like everyone's

SPEAKER_0539:52

aware of what's going to happen out out there and it might be a field condition the applicant worked very

SPEAKER_0039:59

diligently with natural resources and staked a lot and staked the building and we tugged and pulled and

SPEAKER_0540:05

yes okay great um i guess when i'm looking at the site plan i mean there's you're very tight on the eastern side at nine nine seven right is there a way to shift that you know when we're talking about a car getting in there and a full-size suv you're opening your door right into your house and or you're opening your other door right onto the property line did you look at shifting that a little bit more because your side yard setbacks are three foot and that you know shifts the driveway can you talk

SPEAKER_0240:40

us through your thought process on that yeah i mean this this is the final um design but before this we did go to like many you know locations and we have to relocate a couple times i worked with john on on transportation on the city and uh the the driveway did have it was in a steeper angle before he and i uh we went through it and we kind of like model it and we figured out for like uh i think it was a truck size and with that angle we were able to uh accommodate into that route going out to the back now we still have another seven inches to the side we could potentially propose to like put the driveway all the way to to the side of the fence and keep you know that other gap to to the other side i guess but we also had that that uh power pole on the front that makes it difficult to yeah i mean you're the tree is like pushing to one side then the pole is pushing to the other side sure yeah i just

SPEAKER_0541:39

figured maybe another foot or two to get over and and be able to you know i'm worried about that transformer and the the pole there backing in and out and stuff and then you you're right up against the house so a little relief there would be beneficial um i think that's something you could work with staff i know you said you've already staked it you know so it's just extremely tight and you know i mean we were talking before the meeting about our student drivers and kids and i don't know if they'll be able to negotiate that turn well um the front setback is is obviously a lot more than one normally we'd normally see this is because of the tree i think you've done a nice job there you know making this lot buildable and saving the grand oak so that you know i'm okay with that uh the finished floor elevation does it you never really talked about that can you address that is it adjacent you know

SPEAKER_0242:34

kind of matches adjacent houses oh it's gonna match the the the other proposed structure on the side we're gonna have uh three risers to the porch then one more rising into the house so about two feet

SPEAKER_0542:43

about two feet off the sidewalk okay and we talked about gutters uh ac in the back trash i assume will probably be in the back as well at the end of the driveway all right you uh throw up your elevations

SPEAKER_0743:01

again please throw up put your elevations up again uh the other the other sheet with the three thank you there was a note here about uh the position of knee brackets i assume that was at the rear the rear overhang yes um can staff speak to that comment really quickly the front elevation oh was it the bracketing

SPEAKER_0143:30

of the upper as this request developed there were some brackets that were here they came out to the side and and to the side over here see here i believe this is a bracket it looks like there's a little arching or something yeah these were not period appropriate they're not placed properly so these should be removed that was the comment that i was making on the the front elevation i agree even the

SPEAKER_0744:01

ones in the yeah central yeah so so those are what drew my attention okay um okay and then back to now the windows are what again they are single hung one over ones one or one single home and uh what type of what material again wood uh clad wood clad and then can you speak to the the overhang at the rear

SPEAKER_0244:39

first yeah so basically we we have to maintain a 10 foot setback of the rear or otherwise uh when we have to go to a venue so we try to avoid the variance and by doing this we still can provide some uh shade and cover on the rear porch without actually falling into the 10 foot rear setback so explain to me the size of the brackets to me they seem a little overkill um well yeah i mean in this case we're proposing to do probably uh three by three size of of the brackets like three foot down three foot out

SPEAKER_0745:18

but it's it's a three foot overhang right yes i don't think you need a three foot long bracket i don't think you need that um i would i would request that you revisit that it seems it seems huge considering the

SPEAKER_0245:33

overhang is only three so so what happened in this case is the house next to to us they they had the same design and you know we just follow whatever they did on that case so we could like you know be

SPEAKER_0745:44

similar to what they did i would ask your structural team to review that okay if you're not doing the calcs yourself have somebody else review that because to me it seems like so basically the actual overhang of the whole structure is what you're no the three foot overhang is fine i'm i'm saying the size of the bracketing and the length a three by three oh yeah in this case a three foot by three foot length in this case seems a little overkill and i would ask that you revisit that with your design team whoever's engineering this okay just review it and confirm yeah 100 we'll do the three foot overhang is great i think you i think that's just spot on right you want to give protection you want to get a little bit of cover for anybody out there on that little porch god bless them um but just the size of the bracket itself how far it goes down seems a little overkill okay thank you that's

SPEAKER_0546:38

really all my comments location good okay we're going to go ahead and close the public hearing and we can have discussion amongst ourselves mr k i am good thank you my only comment is i agree with the east

SPEAKER_0747:13

side tightness and i understand that there was a lot of work done in the field but having um witnessed how how easily you can hit a house and a foundation with a car and i made my comment earlier we do not have mostly small cars in this community in the city um and you get you don't even have to have a large issue you get a big enough car in that driveway especially young drivers um someone's going to hit that house going to hit that foundation so i'm a little nervous about that as well that's that's my

SPEAKER_0647:47

concern i have no further comments just i agree with everything she just said just if there is any way to shift it to give a little bit of space on that right side i think that would be several

SPEAKER_0548:04

different issues there no comments yeah i think this is a nice uh project i think it's uh well developed it looks very you know eerily similar to a project that we just saw last month and uh but i think the design is good i i think a couple things a shift in that house so maybe there's some conditions that we place on this to see if we can shift that over give you a little bit more breathing room on the right side we need to talk about the design exception for the driveway removal of the knee brackets and uh update that rear overhang so uh i like the project uh it's a great little neighborhood up there and i

SPEAKER_0648:42

think it'll be a welcome addition to the neighborhood i just want to add i don't know if we haven't noted for

SPEAKER_0548:47

the conditions was clarification on the porch material we did that was our discussion move to

SPEAKER_0749:09

grant a certificate of appropriateness for the drawings and documents presented this public hearing in blc 26-0000197 for the property located at 2712 east 12th avenue with the following conditions um that all drawings be revised and updated including the site plan sections and details for this project specifics and that they are consistent between the different types of drawings that specifically the porch material and detailing be consistent including the material board that the window installation drawings are consistent with discussions today and decisions made today including whether or not it's flanged or not and then it's appropriate setback at the upper story um that the um and then that includes the sighting detailing as well and how it ends um and that the east side of the um the east side drive be revisited to see if there's any way to widen that just a bit to provide a little bit more comfort between the building and the parked vehicle um in that the brackets at the front porch that are indicated be removed and the bracket at the rear porch be reconsidered in terms of its height and that the design exception through transportation be applied for and be reviewed and approved by transportation because based upon the finding effect the proposed project is consistent with the eboard design guidelines of the city of tampo for the following reasons that it is consistent with the height and width spacing alignment similarity of details and forms building and building materials per the eber city design guidelines and the secretary of the

SPEAKER_0551:19

interior standards for rehabilitation second uh for the applicant before we take a vote on this there's been a number of conditions that have been placed on this application could the applicant acknowledge that they are okay with these uh additional conditions yes the applicant acknowledges yay all in favor said motion say aye aye opposed motion carries congratulations thank you heather bonds historic preservation

SPEAKER_0352:00

specialist the next item on the agenda is a project update that is for the ybor city historic district design standards i think it's been since early next last year that we presented on this subject um so we're here to give an update on those standards and then also for those of you who are new to the board i'm gonna touch on uh this project as well all right so our update is that we have officially completed the full draft of the ybor city historic district design standards so a little overview of what i'm going to go through today is i'm going to present each of those sections and then our adoption timeline that we're aiming for as well just a recap and for those that are new to the commission the existing guidelines were adopted 40 years ago in 1986. they have been we have been through some revisions the last in 2003 over 20 years ago the current preservation guidelines have been effective as a helpful and broad how-to however as a review of you reveal i cannot put those two words together review tool to evaluate projects going before the blc there are challenges with overly broad language and unclear diagrams previous staff assessments of the existing guidelines found that there needs to be more emphasis on rehabilitation it lacks references to the secretary of the interior standards which are codified in our code as a reveal view tool new construction section lacks depth the overall document is not formatted in a method that is informative and instructional some illustrations lack detail required to be of assistance and tend to be more extreme as a comparison method further development is needed for the consideration of auditions relocations and demolitions and there's been plenty of advances in technology that necessitates periodic updating again it's been well over 20 years since the last update and there's been new products and advances in preservation and construction methods an additional section should be added to address certain elements such as color accessibility and environmental topics so with that we've updated our objectives for the new standards which are to create a new modernized standards and formats that will be codified and adopted to assist owners and developers in meeting their project goals in a historically sensitive manner it has been reformatted for better organization we have utilized the city of tampa style book for fonts colors and style consistency as well as to fit into ADA compliance we've aimed to make this document usable with project tools such as checklists and project matrixes and we've also changed the title from guidelines to standards to conform with the written language of the code and to enforce that these are more than guidelines that they are codified standards so with that i'll introduce our ybor city historic district design standards there are six sections we have an in-depth introduction section section one is maintenance which is more guideline driven and informative to provide useful information for caring for historic structures we start with maintenance as that is the first defense and preservation sections two four through four are the sections which provide the standards that staff will guide our reviews by rehabilitation new construction and setting and site components that this board will also use for their evaluations of projects coming before you and finally an appendix that will include reference materials so our introduction it has been updated and reformatted with new pictures and text also to include the yc7 and yc9 zoning descriptions which are not currently addressed in our current guidelines but i have an asterisk here because our guidelines or our new standards are almost already out of date because we're currently going through and overhauling our entire section 27 code so if any section of the yc zoning districts are affected we will be updating that with these code updates once we know the final draft may change pending any code or zoning changes the introduction will also include useful guidance to the blc processes and project matrixes these are the topics included in the introduction and some of the page features the introduction will serve as an introduction to our process and provide expectations to review processes project types and information that they may need to prepare for public hearings the outline of a general hearing agenda as well as the history of ybor city and its importance as a national landmark district one of the important pages that you all should give specific attention to is this matrix here the project process matrix that is all the different types of projects that come through our office and the determination whether or not it comes before the board or an administrative review so after this meeting we'll be sending you the entire our new ybor city design standards for you all to review that is one section that you all may want to make comments for and then section one previously maintenance and rehabilitation were in the same section we are breaking maintenance out to provide specific guidance on maintaining historic structures these are the preemptive actions homeowners or business owners should take to continuously or annually maintain their historic properties these are some of those sub these are the subjects that we address in maintenance and some examples of how the pages are laid out these will include helpful tips to make a historic property more energy efficient encouraging periodic home inspections and basic window maintenance we also address flood adaptation which is based on the national park services guidelines on flood adaptation for rehabilitation on historic buildings each of these sections will address a certain action it's laid out in two pages that can easily serve as an individual handout or document with the front side that includes background and guidance as well as recommended actions on the back side we include images of recommended and not recommended actions and examples and we try to use examples from inside the district to show that these are very doable projects such as a window rehabilitation section two is rehabilitation and this starts the standard sections that are going to be codified with rehabilitation each section starts out with a firm shall statement followed by guidance and listed permissible actions we then list specific non-permissible actions which are the actions that we would find non-compatible with historic preservation in most examples we've included successful projects from within the district and other local historic districts to show how rehabilitation can be successfully completed in rehabilitation we address 14 criteria subjects with windows having three subsections based on the treatment of windows rehabilitating replacing or deleting and adding openings the first nine criteria subjects address specific general elements on historic structures then we address specific structural types including the rehabilitation of accessory structures storefronts industrial buildings and former cigar factories we will also address rehabilitating structures for the purpose of reuse and the use of substitute materials on historic structures that's another item that you all may want to pay some close attention to in these sections we want to emphasize the importance of retaining historic materials and the character of each structure therefore each section is three or four pages to provide clear examples we include several visual examples which include historic references which we often require applicants to provide in this hearing we say show historic presidents so we've kind of gone ahead and provided some historic examples in the standards each standard page which is the rehabilitation new construction and site component sections will have the following components on their pages the title of the criteria topic in this case the screen went blank up here building materials the criteria standards a one sentence specific standard to meet the criteria topic typically with the word shall to convey its requirement these standards will be what staff uses to evaluate each project and will be provided on a project evaluation worksheet for both staff and developers to utilize in project planning and evaluation key terms such as definitions to provide consistent understanding between staff the board citizens and developers context an intro paragraph that contains background information or why the criteria is important to ybor city and guidelines these are the shoulds and the shalls of how to meet that standard and a list of actions as permissible and not permissible actions to provide at-a-glance guidelines to support each standard the flip side of each standard sheet will provide examples such as diagrams pictures illustrations plans and some ai-generated renderings to convey historic preservation methods we primarily use the ai to convey non-permissible actions so that we're not using pictures to shame people within the district so we like to use ai in those cases also in rehabilitation we've added historical references of each criteria subject so again when presenting to the blc we ask applicants to provide those historical references so again we're adding to the functionality and user friendliness of this guide section three is new construction it's similarly formatted as rehabilitation with codified standards clear definitions background or historical relevance and defined actions and illustrative examples a new construction each criteria is addressed also in a two-page layout which could be printed out individually during pre-application meetings with applicants as a single two-sided document this will help spur the initial conversations with owners developers and staff again each criteria is listed at the top with a shall standard guidance and lists are provided to clearly indicate the permissible and non-permissible actions and helpful illustrations are provided on the reverse side the fourth section reviews standards of all other site elements beyond historic resources on sites such as electrical boxes sidewalk furniture menu boards benches lights tables trash bins also includes landscape features like fences we have artificial turf standards and driveways and parking lots and parking standards setting and site components are the other visual components on a site that support the historic context in the setting they are also the non-historic elements that support modern needs such as mechanical equipment solar panels and other utilities this section provides the standards to these components on site in a manner that does not distract from the surrounding historic resources we've added signage to this section which is currently on its own in the design guidelines which will add context to the general guidelines it provides additional visual examples lists permissible and clear non-permissible approaches for signage and again we've added standards for artificial turf sidewalk furniture public utilities solar panels and addresses accessibility modifications which are not currently addressed in the current guidelines and nearing rehabilitation and new construction each criteria is supported by a two-page layout with a shall standard context background text and clear permissible and non-permissible actions and examples i mentioned we've added signage to setting and site component we've broken that up into three individual sections historic signs new signs and then a whole section on inappropriate sign types for ybor city we've also included an additional reference sheet for the historic sign types that are found throughout ybor city to help inspire any new signage finally our appendix this is the final section it includes sources guides and acronym lists since we live in acronyms in our departments style descriptions of the most common historic building types in ybor city and other resources for historic preservation project planning we've provided the ybor city color palette in in the guide in the new standards as well you can see here this is an example of one of our architectural source sheets and we also have an individual page for each of the four treatments under the secretary of interior standards and that's preservation rehabilitation rehabilitation reconstruction and restoration we mostly in this department use rehabilitation but there are the other three stamps standard sets that can be used based on specific projects as part of our goal to make this document usable we've included worksheets at the end of each of the three standard sections these clearly list each of those shall standards for each of the criteria these sheets provide a breakdown to convey expectations evenly to owners agents board members and staff reviewers they can be used as part of pre-application meetings an amendment to the staff report or just part of the board review process so into our next steps this process is defined by code which instructs us next to notice for public input within the district seek approval recommendations from the blc to the hpc then the hpc will make the recommendation to city council for two hearings and for adoption that broken down into process steps just last week we provided the hpc with their copy of the standards we're now providing the blc with a copy you'll be getting that hopefully later today in email we are your little homework assignments we're going to give you guys two months hopefully to january to provide us comments back as well as the hpc we will take those comments from the hpc and the blc and begin editing the documents then we will go out for public outreach with neighborhood associations and other stakeholders in the community then come back to the blc with a final draft that you all will be provided to make your recommendation to the hpc and then again the hpc will make their recommendation to city council you all as the regulatory and review board you all will be the ones using this document so we appreciate all of your input that you may be provide that you will provide and then here is our hopeful timeline like i said i hope to get the comments back from you all in january and then throughout early next year we'll be doing the revisions public outreach getting your comments to the hpc and providing those final edits and hopefully by may of next year we can schedule that hpc hearing and have the new document adopted by code or adopted by city council next year

SPEAKER_051:09:57

so with that if you have any questions i'm here how would you like us to comment on this i mean you're going to be getting five if not seven different sets of comment well probably more from other things

SPEAKER_031:10:15

is it mark up the pdf or keep a list or i'll say however you all are most comfortable if you want to mark up the document we can do that if you want to provide a list of your comments we can also take it that way we want to make sure that you are comfortable and we want to get all of your comments to do all that

SPEAKER_071:10:37

with the advent of ai there are many tools that you can use yes and review has a great great process for review comments or a blue beam review where we can actually review and send you a remarks document that gives you the page and what we're actually marking up so there's several oh i'll educate you

SPEAKER_031:11:02

we have many different personality and generations on our board so i will accept your comments however

SPEAKER_061:11:07

anybody is most comfortable with perfect one question for me just being still on the newer side of the board when we're reviewing this i know there's been questions about specifications on things like colors since coming onto the board in the one sheet that we had it just kind of had like a color grid in our notes do we need to give feedback on language verbiage and how specific we should go with colors i know that's just been kind of a big topic since coming on the board and some discussion around that so i wasn't sure if like specific colors need to be notated that sort of thing our color palette has

SPEAKER_031:11:47

always been broad um we right now it's a picture frame that we have that has actual paint swatches but we don't specify the brand or the name we just have people kind of circle what color they're using as the body the accents and the trim um so we have we don't want to be um we like to be more broad because everybody uses different paint colors and we don't want to support a certain brand of color so we we've always been more broad in the color schemes but i know a few years ago we've added colors um the blues weren't there before and we've added the the blues based on trends um and i think ron was part of that finding which blues would be most historically accurate but if there's other colors you would like to see on there or colors you find less appropriate that can be discussed as well i call them more hues than actual colors but there are um to expand on your question about certain areas we have put certain percentages for sizes of murals or when you have rooftop additions how far back it should be we do have specific numbers and percentages so that is somewhere that you guys may look at and if you think um 20 back on a rooftop say bar or structure is too much or too less so we can discuss those numbers that you see in this document if we do have a lot of comments we may come back and do a workshop to come out and really discuss some of these things that you may need refinement on or have major questions on if we find that you all make the same comments or have different ways you're going with certain things we may just come back and have a workshop to discuss those items are there new

SPEAKER_071:13:45

diagrams regarding the site context and how setbacks are indicated and that sort of thing when you were talking about the setback for additions at the roof just thinking of recent discussions in the last year have any new diagrams been included regarding that yes we do have new diagrams okay and i said

SPEAKER_031:14:03

i've been sitting here even if i don't have a case before the blc to listen to your conversations and i've been taking notes to see what you guys comment on the most what you all seem to what alerts you all so i've tried to um we've tried to put as many of those type of things in our standards based on the

SPEAKER_051:14:23

conversations you all have and this is still a uh i know it's a snapshot in time of where we are and it's kind of a breathing living document right it's how it's a process to update this in the future i don't know if there's a set timeline you one thing where i'm going with this is uh like the building code change that's coming up i think there's certain provision that in there for rooftop structures that they're kind of tightening the the controls on that um is that something that we're going to have active references to like the local you know whatever the building code is so that

SPEAKER_031:15:04

references that at the same time um the way our code is written there are certain areas that say whichever standards are stricter or firmer is usually gets precedence during reviews of course when something's safety or building code that'll take precedence um so with these design standards i talked about the three sections that are standards and then we also have the appendix and the introduction that i hope that we can add to through the appendix through time without having to go through this whole process that perhaps as long as we're not adjusting standards and we're just adding things to the maintenance section or other areas that people can use as references that perhaps we don't have to go through the whole process and it really can be a living document so this is just what five years ago the national park service came out with that flood adaptation document we're now going through elevating structures in some areas so as the national park service or the federal agencies put out more documents hopefully we can add those to our appendixes and references as well on behalf of the

SPEAKER_051:16:17

board thank you for all your hard work and helping to coordinate all this it's a huge lift so we look forward to the light reading over the holidays a little light reading yes like i don't have everything to do right thank you very good thank you uh can we have a motion to receive and file today i'll make the motion to receive and file the documents and the staff approvals move to receive and file submitted

SPEAKER_071:16:59

documents and exhibits from today including the staff approvals and the presentation

SPEAKER_051:17:05

materials all in favor send motion say aye aye aye carries uh next bar latino public hearing is tuesday december 15th 2026 before the holidays um seeing no other business uh the chair wishes everyone a happy thanksgiving uh and don't eat too much turkey and we'll see you in about a month we are of about to future thank you

Speaker1:17:35

of about to future thank you