Civic › Pinellas County, FL › November 16, 2026

Code Enforcement & PCCLB Special Magistrate Hearing November 16, 2026 9:00 AM - Nov 16, 2026

Pinellas County, FL Board of County Commissioners November 16, 2026 408 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Pinellas County meetings

Transcript

Speaker0:09

Good morning. My name is Jeff Fuller. I'm the Special Magistrate assigned to the Pinellas County Code Enforcement Special Magistrate agenda for today, November 16th, 2026. Welcome to Pinellas County Code Enforcement Special Magistrate hearings. The Special Magistrate is charged with conducting hearings to determine whether an alleged violation of the county code has occurred. In order to meet that obligation, all parties or their representatives will be allowed an opportunity to be heard on matters relevant to the alleged violations. All witnesses offering testimony or presenting evidence will be required to swear or affirm that the testimony they provide is the truth. The order of presentation will begin with the county presenting their evidence of the alleged violations, and then the respondent shall present his or her case. Both parties shall have an opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses. The Special Magistrate may question any witness. The clerk will announce the names of the cases from the agenda. Pay attention to the clerk's announcement because we don't follow, for a variety of reasons, the number that's on the agenda. When you hear your case called, please respond by coming to the podium with your representative and or any witnesses to be sworn in. When addressing the Special Magistrate, please speak clearly into the microphone. Any person who decides to appeal the decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need a record of the proceedings and for such purposes may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. The record is not provided by Pinellas County. Heidi, could you read item number five, please? Item number five was rescheduled from November 9th, 2026. Department is PCCLB, Code Section 489.1271I. Case number CLB-MG26-00294. Citation number CLB-CT26-00546. Defendant Renato Terra Borelli. Notice address to Renato Terra Borelli, 13222, 98th Avenue, Seminole, Florida, 33776. Renato. Renato. Renato. Tera Borelli at gmail.com. And PCCLB investigator N. Nichols, plaintiff's witness. Pinellas County Code Enforcement, 631 Chestnut Street, Clearwater, Florida, 33756. Email address is nnichols at pinellas.gov. And Kirby Kreider, Esquire, Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB, in care of Natasha Creighton, Legal Assistant, Legal Secretary. Pinellas County Attorney's Office at 315 Court Street, 6th Floor, Clearwater, Florida, 33756. Email address is kkreider at pinellas.gov and nacredin at pinellas.gov. Violation address is 13222, 98th Avenue, Seminole, Florida, 33776. Who is here for that case? Good morning, Magistrate. Kirby Kreider, Assistant County Attorney on behalf of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. I have with me Investigator Nichols. Please come up to the podium. Hi, I'm Renato Tarabarelli. This is my wife, my representative. What's your wife's name? Angelica. Investigator Nichols, Renato, and Angelica, would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes. All right. The county may proceed. You may have a seat right there and come back up when they've presented their case, and you'll have an opportunity to question the witnesses. Thank you. Investigator Nichols, can you state your name for the record? Yes. My name is Investigator Nichols. And how are you employed? With the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. And do you have any type of training or experience specialized to your employment? Yes. Administrative and field training. Thank you. And you heard the case as described. Did you issue a citation on this matter? I did. Okay. And I'm going to go ahead and put this on the screen. You can step over with me so you can see it. This is already part of the record, but you issued a citation on 8-6 for a violation of Chapter 49.1271I deliberately and willfully violated the county work order, or stop work order. Is that correct? That is correct. Is this a fair and accurate representation? It is. It's already in the record. Who first became involved, did you determine if the parcel that you were called out to was in Pinellas County? Yes, I did. And did you review any documentation to prove that? Yes. We normally checked with the property appraiser to verify the parcel and the owner of that property. Magistrate, would you like me to show what I intend to introduce to you? Yes. Yes, sir. Please. Senator Nichols, is this a fair and accurate representation of the information you reviewed regarding this complaint? Yes, it is. And when reviewing the property appraiser's information, you were able to prove that this property was located in Pinellas County. Is that correct? I did. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as County 1. Any objection to Exhibit 1? Exhibit 1 will be admitted into evidence. Back us up a little bit. Can you tell me how you first became aware of this issue? So we received a complaint that several neighbors contacted PCCLB regarding a new, or not a new residential home, but there were remodeling taking place at a property in Seminole. Their concern was that all the properties around that specific area were STRs. So they were thinking it was STRs, which is a short-term rental. And the neighbors diligently did their own homework and see that there were no permits. So the complaint was filed with our office, and that's when I investigated. And on July the 7th, did you visit the property? I did. Okay. I'm going to show you some more photos. I want to focus on this photo first. Do you recognize this photo? It looks like there's two of them there. Yes, I do. Okay. And then we see that this orange ticker, yellow ticker, is that a stop work order? Yes. That was placed once I conducted my investigation of the property. And is this a fair and accurate representation of the stop work order? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as County 2. Any objection to Exhibit 2? The only one she's put in are the two photographs that are up on the screen. Exhibit 2 will be admitted into evidence. Out there on July the 7th, what else did you notice? Did you take any more photographs other than that stop work order? Yes. So once I went to the property, a couple things happened. When I approached, there were vehicles on the property. Actually, there were workers on the property doing work. So I walked onto the property on the curtilage and announced myself who I am. And there were about three to four workers that were working on the property. I introduced myself to them. And one spoke English. English, he informed me of what he was doing. And once I tell him why I was here, then they decided that they didn't want to speak to me anymore. So I started to photograph the property along with the workers there. And basically, at that time, I called law enforcement because they were inside the home hiding. So law enforcement came out. They cleared the property. And the gentlemen that were there working, they got in their vehicle and took off quickly. I was able to capture their face to see who was on the property at the time. And you took some more pictures on July the 7th. Is this some more pictures that you took from that date? Yes. And the importance for your investigation is showing that this clearly is there's work being done. Is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county three. Any objection to Exhibit 3? Exhibit 3 will be admitted into evidence. Now, you mentioned that you called law enforcement to aid in your investigation. Is that how you were able to get inside the home? So that's one way I was able to get into the home. But the worker that was there who spoke English had basically he had the property. He was in control of the property. And I asked, can I see what he was doing? So he gave me permission to at least check the work he was doing inside the garage and inside certain part of the house. So he walked with me, and I was able to capture the images on the inside. Once he left, law enforcement came, and they wanted to clear the house to make sure no one was there because the entire property wasn't closed. It was open. There was no – some places didn't have windows. There was no garage door, and there were no sliding doors. So the property was actually open. He wanted to clear it to make sure no one was inside for safety issues. Okay, so you were able to go inside with law enforcement and with permission and take some more photos. I'm going to – is this a fair and accurate representation of the photos? That is correct. And does this show you that in your training and experience that obviously work has been being done? That is correct. I'm going to go through some more photos with you so I can ask to move them into evidence. This is all a fair and accurate representation? That is correct. And these are all from July 7th? That is correct. Just one more. Those are all fair and accurate representation? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move these documents in as county composite four. Any objection to exhibit four? Exhibit four will be admitted into evidence. You placed the stop work order, and then – this is going to sound like a dumb question, but what is the intention of a stop work order? Well, the stop work order was issued because at the time the work was being done, I checked our database, the building's database, and no permit was pulled for the work being done at the time. So during that time, while law enforcement was there with me, the owner, Mr. Tabarelli, and his wife did show up, and I explained to him that there was no work order, so – not sorry, there was no permit. So at the time, I would be placed in a stop work order on the building, and no work can be done until it's – the permit is issued and it's in an issued status. At that time, I believe I notified him that he will be receiving a citation originally for no permit, which was taken care of and paid. So that was taken care of. So during that time, it was issued, thought the case was closed at the time, and then, obviously, moving forward, I continued to receive more calls from all the neighbors around him. Okay, so you're getting more calls, and that tells you the calls were – the work is still happening? Yes. So I received a call from the second neighbor. He sent me pictures showing that they were still working in the property. I checked a building's database. No permit was issued. It was, however, in an application status, meaning that Mr. Tabarelli did apply, I believe, the day he was issued the no permit citation. It was applied for, but it was not in an issued status. Let me ask you a question. So although he applied for it, until it's formally issued, no work could have happened. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. And I could show Mr. Tabarelli – Having shown this to Mr. Tabarelli and Mr. Nichols, I would like you to walk through this document with me. You said as part of your investigation that you checked the permitting database. That is correct. Is this a fair and accurate representation of the document that you searched? That is correct. Okay. And we're going to – let's walk through this together. I know it's small. File date is 7-6. Okay. But what is important in your investigation or your training experience is when the permit was issued, right? That is correct. And this document tells us that the permit was issued on 6th. Is that correct? Of August 2026. That is correct. There is another spot where it actually showed issued date. So this is where we normally looked right here. First issue date. So as you can see, the permit hasn't been issued at the time. It hasn't recorded. So this is where you would normally see when the permit is actually issued. Okay. And then the state up here we're seeing on these pages, is that when you pulled it? Yes. So I went back into the building's database system on August 6th. And as of August 6th, there was – it says first issue date. There was no issue date at the time. If we go back to the first one, it says right here they were awaiting payment. So even though Mr. Treberelli applied application-wise on July 8th, I confirmed with the building department what was the holdup. They did check the database, and the only thing they were waiting on was for the homeowner, Mr. Treberelli, to make the payment so that the permit would be in an issued status. And I believe the payment were made, I believe, that day or after the citation was written. And the citation being the citation that we're currently talking about. That is correct. This morning, I would ask to move this as county 5. Any objection to Exhibit 5? Exhibit 5 will be admitted into evidence. So you're getting these complaints. I can imagine that you went back out to the property. Is that fair? That is correct. And did – what did you see? Did it look like it was in the same condition or not? So my second visit to the property, I did make contact with Mr. Treberelli. He was there working on the property with the very same contractors that I saw the first time, which they went into the house. I wasn't able to talk to them, but I was able to talk to Mr. Treberelli, and I asked to let him know that the permit is not issued. And he said that he was waiting still. However, I did inform him that what he's doing, he's violating the stop work order. So that time, I, in fact, gave him a warning and said that you cannot work until the permit is in an issued status. Even though they were using private provided to do the inspection, regardless of the fact, the permit was not issued, so they could not work until that permit is issued. So at that time, we spoke. I took some photos outside showing the work basically from the first time to the second time that there was progress made because he installed doors, windows, and I informed him that please make sure the permit is in an issued status before you continue to work, and I left the property. But it was with a warning. I have some more photos to show Mr. Treberelli with permission. Mr. Treberelli, there's photos. Oh, my God. Okay. I was skipping ahead of myself. I know I just showed Mr. Treberelli some photos from August the 6th. I'm going to show him some more from July 20th. So just keeping in chronological order, turning now to July 22nd, did you go back to the property that day? Yes, I did. All right. I'm going to show you two photos. Here's the first one. Do you recognize this photo? Yes. This is where I got the second call. I went back out there, and this is where I met Mr. Treberelli. He was captured in picture because I was taking a photo of the property showing the work to the rear glass that the work was done. And you can see also there was some – he was doing the trusses or parts of the roof that was being worked on. Okay. And then one more photo from that date. Did you capture this photo? Yes. Is it fair and accurate representation of what you saw that day? Yes. They're still working. Work continued throughout the time from July into the ending of July. And you answered my next question. In your training and experience, this happened after the stop work order, correct? That is correct. So that tells you that work was done after the stop work order was posted? Yes. And I was being fair. That's the day I also gave him a warning that he could also receive another citation. But because I was trying to work with him, understanding he's trying to get into his house quickly, he was informed that a permit must be in an issued status before any work continues. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as composite county 6. Any objection to exhibit 6? Exhibit 6 will be admitted into evidence. We're back up to August the 6th. You go back up to the property. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. I'm going to show you several photos. And then my question for all of these is going to be, did you take this photo? Is this what it looked like when you took the photo? That is correct. When I went back out on the 6th, it's because I received several other calls from neighbors that they were there, and there was actually a contractor on site doing HVAC why I went back out there. But before I went, I did check. No permit was in an issued status at the time on August 6th. Some more photos for you. And this looks like it's of the inside, and we can see that it's very different from when you were in the first time you were in the property with law enforcement and permission. Is that correct? That is correct. So that tells you that work had been done against the sophomore voter violation? That is correct. Do you recognize all those photos I just showed you? I do. A couple more for you. So this looks like some sliding doors, clearly work being done that would need a permit, and can it happen against the stop work order? Is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move those documents in this county composite 7. Any objection to Exhibit 7? Exhibit 7 will be admitted into evidence. Did you prepare an affidavit of licensure in this case? I did. I'm going to go ahead and show this to Mr. Tavarelli. I'm going to show this to you. I want to talk to you about it. It's saying that he had a contractor license from January 1 to August 14th of 2026. Is that correct? That is correct. But the fact that he had a license doesn't negate your investigation that he violated the stop work order. Is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move those documents in this county 7. Any objection to Exhibit 7? Eight. Exhibit 7. I'm sorry. One, two, three. Oh, eight. I apologize. Eight. Any objection to Exhibit 8? Exhibit 8 will be admitted into evidence. That's everything I wanted to kind of get through with you, but I just want to emphasize that based on what you saw when you went out there multiple times, you could tell that work was done post the stop work order being issued prior to the permit being issued. Is that correct? That is correct. No further questions. All right. Do you have any questions for Investigator Nichols? Anything else from the county? Nothing further. All right. This is your opportunity to come up and present your case. Could I have him take a seat? Yes, please. Or would you like him to take a seat? So, well, this is our first time here, so we don't know exactly how to do it, but, well, good morning, members of the board. We would like to begin by acknowledging that we start remodeling our personal residence, not for our B&B reasons, before obtaining the required building permit. We understand our responsibilities as licensed contractors, and we recognize that our personal circumstances do not justify this mistake. At the time, we had sold our previous home, and we were required to relocate with a very short period. Upon receiving the stop work order and the initial citation, we paid 500 penalty and immediately initiate the permitting process. So, we recognize that we should have pulled a permit. Engaging a private provider to ensure proper inspections and compliance with the applicable building codes. We would like to emphasize that the second citation, which brings us here before the board today, was issued on the exact same day our building permit was issued. So, we did end up having, yeah, August 6th. Well, by that time, we had already taken corrective actions and completed the permitting process. We just wanted to say that, you know, we are licensed contractors. We were not working under no license. And owners of Better View Window and Shutter, we take our professional responsibilities very seriously. This year alone, we have obtained 22 building permits through Pinellas County Building Department, demonstrating our established commitment to compliance. This was an isolated incident involving our personal residents rather than an attempt to engage in unlicensed contracting or deliberately avoid permitting requirements. We respectfully ask the board to consider the following circumstances. We do acknowledge the initial violation and we paid a 500 penalty fine. We immediately initiate the process to correct this violation. The building permit was issued on the same day as the second citation. We are licensed contractors with an established history of obtaining permits of our professional work. So, considering the circumstances and our corrective actions, we respectfully request that the board consider dismissing the second citation or alternatively reducing the associated penalty. We sincerely regret this incident and appreciate the board's time and consideration. I just want to show the date of the permit was issued, the placard. So, this is the only evidence we have. Yeah, so it's the same day as the citation was done here. Counsel, any objection to this exhibit? Objection. Yes, if you would. She's going to put it in there. Yeah, okay. Do you want both of these in there? No. Do you object to the citations while we're here, so it doesn't need to go in, but if you want to admit it, you can. This is Respondents 1? Yes. Respondents 1 will be admitted into evidence. That's it. Thank you. Counsel, do you have any questions of the witnesses? No questions. Okay. Anything further? All right. Nothing from the county. If the magistrate would like closings. Let's have a closing argument. Yes, sir. We'll begin with the county. Closing arguments are where you tell me what you think the evidence showed and tell me what you want me to do. We'll start with the county. Thank you. So for the county's closing, I understand that the citation was issued on the same day that the permit was finally issued. But the fact of the matter is the work was happening from the first day that Investigator Nichols went out there all the way throughout when this permit happened. And they got up here and they said that we're licensed contractors, we know better, we regret it, and they should have known better. This wasn't an oversight. They continue to work and they got another citation for it. They willfully violated the stop work order and that's what they were cited for. So I'm asking that this magistrate uphold the citation. Thank you. This is your opportunity to present a closing statement. We agree that we did start working without a permit. Mr. Nicholson, he got into our house without any authorization, just got in there, started taking pictures. Nobody authorized him to get in there. When we got there, he was inside our house without any notice or anything. Even the cop said, hey, good luck for you. The guys are nice and are not complaining that you're invading their property. But that's okay. We were okay with that. And I think we paid the fine that we were supposed to. We did pay for the mistake we made. I just don't think that a second citation was necessary because we had a private provider that was doing all the inspections and everything. I would like to get the penalty removed or not pay for it. I don't think we, I think we paid for it already. But just, I just, no, first. Thank you. Thank you. All right. I'm going to fine that there is a violation of Code Section 489.1271I and issue a fine in the amount of $2,000. Caroline, do you want a break to do an order? We can keep going and we'll do the order as we're doing it. All right. Thank you. Heidi, would you read item number six? Yes. This case, item number six, was rescheduled from November 9th, 2026. Department, PCCLB, code is 22-141, unlicensed contracting code violation, case number is CLB-MG26-00263, citation number is CLB-CT26-00497, defendant is John Christopher Nash, notice address to John Christopher Nash at 18755 Southwest 44th Street, Dunnellan, Florida, 34432. Email address is johnrossb2 at gmail.com and johnnashbritanniaconstructioninc at johnbritanniaconstruction at gmail.com. And Jim Reeves, building official, plaintiff's witness, city of Seminole, 9199-113th Street North, Seminole, Florida, 33772. Jay Reeves at myseminole.com and Robert, sorry if I mispronounce this, Corose, plaintiff's witness, Woodbridge Condo Association, 11715, Ridgeview Lane, Seminole, Florida, 33772. And PCCLB investigator, Jay Padgett, plaintiff's witness, Pinellas County Code Enforcement, 631 Chestnut Street, Clearwater, Florida, 33756. Jay Padgett, J. Padgett at pinellas.gov and Kirby Crider, Esquire, Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB in care of Natasha Creedon, Legal Secretary, Pinellas County Attorney's Office at 315 Court Street, 6th floor, Clearwater, Florida, 33756. Kay Kreider at pinellas.gov, N.A. Creedon at pinellas.gov, Violation Address, Woodbridge Boulevard, Seminole, Florida, 33772. All right, who's here for the county? Good morning, Kirby Crider, Assistant County Attorney on behalf of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. I have with me as witnesses, Investigator Padgett, Jim Reeves, and Mr. Carews. Who is here for the respondent, Mr. Nash? Good morning. My name is John Christopher Nash from Britannia Construction Incorporated, state-certified general contractor since 1998. And who's with you? Briscoe. Can you say your name a little bit louder to the... John Ross Briscoe. Thank you. All right, Mr. Nash, Mr. Briscoe, Mr. Reeves, Mr. Carews, and Investigator Padgett, please raise your right hand. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. I do. All right. The county may proceed. You two may have a seat right up front there if you want. Mr. Greer, Padgett, I'm going to start with you. You heard the case called, and this case has some background to it, but I just want to orient us by starting with a citation. Were you the issuing officer in this case? I was. To the citation? Yes. The violation of the Pinellas County Municipal Code 2214-1, general contractor aiding and assisting unlicensed contractor, John Briscoe, by pulling the permit and proceeding, essentially. Is that correct? That's correct. Now, I don't want to get too astray, but it is my understanding that you also issued citations to Mr. Briscoe. Is that correct? That's correct. Was that matter heard by the magistrate? It was. And then I'm going to show Mr. Nash. All right. Did you testify in that proceeding? I did. Okay. And have you had an opportunity to review the order? Ms. Crater, sorry. If you can use that. Oh, I'm sorry. My bad. Thank you. Communications just told me. Thanks. If you were present for that hearing? I was. And you investigated Mr. Briscoe as well? Yes, multiple times. And can you just tell the magistrate what your understanding of this order was? John Ross Briscoe was cited for unlicensed contracting. He was found in violation for violating county ordinance for those citations. And I promised I'm going to lay the background, but that was in connection with Mr. Nash. Is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask the magistrate to introduce and move this into evidence as exhibit or county one. Can I see the remaining pages? Yes, sir. Maybe in my file, but I haven't found it yet. Okay. All right. Okay. Is magistrate Matthew. All right. Any objection to exhibit one? Exhibit one will be admitted into evidence. For the housekeeping squared away, take us all the way back. How did you get involved in this? Okay. So on April 30th of 2026, I received a phone call from the building official for the city of Seminole, Jim Reeves, about an unlicensed contractor performing installation of an automatic gate and some fencing work at a condo association in the city of Seminole. I apologize. I didn't ask you these questions before. How are you employed? I am a contractor licensing investigator with the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. And do you have any training or field experience that is specialized to your career? Yes. Field and administrative training. So when you're talking about electric gate and your line of work, that's something that you would need a permit for, right? Or do you have to be licensed for? Both. Yes. Permit and a contractor's license. That's correct. Okay. So I interrupted your flow. You just told us that you got this call. What happened next? So the name was familiar to me because I had investigated Mr. Briscoe previously. I then initiated an investigation and conducted a site visit to the location on that day. You're talking about this site, was that in Pinellas County? It is. Okay. And how did you confirm that? I did a database search on the property appraiser's website and determined that the location was within the city of Seminole, which is in Pinellas County. Thank you. Before showing it to the magistrate, may I show it to Mr. Neff? Please. Investigator Padgett. Looks like three pages. The first page, though, is this with fair and accurate representation, all the pages of what you reviewed? Yes, that's a property appraiser listing for the Woodbridge Condo Association, which is in the city of Seminole. In Pinellas County? Correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this into evidence as county two. Any objection to exhibit two? Exhibit two will be admitted into evidence. So what did you do next? You get this call. So I conducted a site visit to the location, and there I met John Ross Briscoe, Jim Reeves, the building official for the city of Seminole, and a Robert Caruse, who is a resident within the association. And when you say he's a resident of the association, did you later come to learn that he was kind of like a project manager? He was heavily involved with the payments for this project? Yes. Okay. And you took pictures that day? I did. I'm going to show some pictures to Mr. Nash. I'm going to show you quite some photos. I'm just going to go through them one by one. And my question for every page is going to be, did you take these pictures? Do you recognize them? I did. So this is the entrance to the condo association where Mr. Briscoe was working. And the above caption is Mr. Briscoe sitting along a bank next to the gate as I arrived at the location. Right here? Yes. Mr. Briscoe? That's correct. And then another picture from April 30 of this. Is there an accurate representation of what you saw that day? It is. So this is the opening to the association. Mr. Briscoe was working on this automatic gate within the compound. This is another caption of the right side of the gate where one of his workers was in a hole working on the post on the right side of the gate. This might be a more zoomed in photo of that, is that correct? Yes. The above caption, that's a worker that worked for Mr. Briscoe. He was down here working on what appears to be this post for the gate. And then the below caption, you see debris, construction materials, tools, various nature of construction work. This point in time, I would ask to move these in as composite county three. Any objection to exhibit three? Exhibit three will be admitted into evidence. At any point, did you see Mr. Nash on scene? I did not. Did you do any type of investigation into whether or not he was a licensed contractor? I did. Did you start by looking at DPDR? Yes. So one of the issues that came up in this case was that there was a permit pulled for the work, but was by a different company. And the association had contracted directly with Mr. Briscoe, who was not licensed. You mentioned that you worked with Mr. Reeves, who is here today as well. Correct. And he reviewed the permit information, but then he sent it forward to you as well. Is that correct? Yes. I received it from the permit tech within his office. All right. I'll show this to Mr. Nash. Okay, just here. I'm going to start the first one. So this is, is this a fair and accurate representation of the permit documentation that you received in the city of Seminole? It is. And kind of what got your interest here? You were talking about it was issued to not Mr. Briscoe? Correct. So Mr. Briscoe is not licensed, so therefore he cannot pull a permit. So the permit was pulled by a John Nash of Britannia Construction. I'm going to show you just the rest of it, so make sure it looks the same as what you reviewed. Is that a fair and accurate representation of the second page? It is. Fair and accurate representation of the third page? Yes. The same question. It looks like it's talking about farming fees. Yes. It looks like it was paid by Britannia Construction. And as you investigated this case, did you ever connect Britannia with Mr. Nash or Mr. Briscoe? So I did speak with Mr. Nash, who is the license holder for Britannia Construction, and inquired about any qualifying documents that may be there for Mr. Briscoe. And he said that he does not qualify Mr. Briscoe's company. And when you say qualify, just for the record, what do you mean? So, really, there's two ways to become licensed. Either you get your license individually, and then you can contract as yourself, or you can have another licensed contractor qualify your company. But there's a process with that, with DBPR. First of all, the licensed contractor has to apply to qualify another company. And he either has to have a 30% stake in that company, or be a W-2 employee. And then DBPR would approve that application and issue a new license for that qualified company. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county support. Any objection to Exhibit 4? Exhibit 4 will be admitted into evidence. I spoke with Mr. Caruse, who was on site during my site visit, and that's who stated that the association contracted with Briscoe Fencing Solutions. And then, did he ever give you any indication that he even knew who John Nash was? No. Okay, and what's your understanding of how often Mr. Caruse was on the site, on the job site? Well, Mr. Caruse lives, like, adjacent to the gate, so he was at, according to him, he was at, he was there every day and saw the project in progress every day. Ms. Crider, please talk into the microphone. Oh, gosh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Pete. All right. Did you do a license search on Mr. Nash? I did. And what did that reveal? That he is licensed through DBPR, state license. And then what about Mr. Briscoe? Mr. Briscoe is not licensed. At this point in time, I don't have further questions for Investigator Padgett, but I do ask for permission to recall. Do you have any questions for the investigator, Mr. Nash? All right. Call your next witness. Thank you. County will call Jim Reeves. Is she even Exhibit? Yes. Good morning, Mr. Reeves. Good morning. Can you state your name for the record? James Reeves. And how are you involved in this case? I'm the building official for the city of Seminole. So what was your first contact with Mr. Nash or Mr. Briscoe? Well, we had an original permit for fence work only to replace fencing on the property. We noticed that there was gate work being done. Gates is being installed, but nobody was ever there. So I made it a point to check it out nights and weekends, and finally was able to catch up with Mr. Briscoe out there one evening. It was probably 5, 530. At that point, I actually got on the phone with Investigator Padgett. He came down. Let me take one step back. We finally got Mr. Briscoe to revise the permit to show the gate work with engineering, et cetera, et cetera. I kind of went back and forth with Mr. Cruz on what was going on because he had a lot of questions and concerns. A lot of the work was being failed. The inspections were being failed. And like I said, we could never really catch the contractor on a job. We would go out for an inspection. It would fail. We just put it in the system, and they would respond. Mr. Cruz showed me his contract because I was trying to figure out what the gates were and where all the scope of work was because it was very vague in the descriptions. So he showed me the contracts. And when I looked at the contracts with Mr. Briscoe and then saw the permit applied for by Mr. Nash's company, that's when I finally caught up with the contractor out there. I caught Investigator Padgett because it was obviously appeared to be a clear case of license lending because we had a contractor, unlicensed contractor, sign a contract with the association, and a licensed contractor pulling the permit. And I think you just answered it, but when you say license lending, this is in your training and experience, what you were witnessing, seeing this permit, and I'm going to show you Exhibit 4 again, was not pulled by Mr. Briscoe. The permit was pulled by Mr. Nash, and the contract was under Mr. Briscoe's company. And that's kind of what triggered you based on your training experience to say, ooh, I think this might be license lending? Well, 100%. I'm a licensed contractor since 1997, so I'm very aware of the construction licensing laws and obviously with my position with the city also. So we have a permit pulled by a licensed contractor, and all of a sudden I have a contract from a disgruntled association by an unlicensed contractor, and that's when the red flag went up and I contacted Mr. Padgett. And I don't want to get too much into it because license lending, even if it's great quality work, but there were workmanship issues too? Well, yes, there's obviously some workmanship issues, 100%. And this is Exhibit 4 as a fair and accurate representation of the permit? Yes. And nothing further at this time, but I would ask for permission to recall. Any questions? The building official here, Mr. Reeves. Okay. Good morning, sir. Can you say your name for the record? Yes, Robert Caruse. And how are you involved in this case? How am I involved? Well, I was the project manager for the HOA for Woodbridge. Do you live there? I do. And how often would you say that you went out to the site? Daily. Okay. And did you ever interact with the person here that is Mr. Nash? No, Mr. Nash, not, no, I wouldn't know what he looked like. I did call him prior to getting involved with Briscoe as to whether he qualified him or not, and he said he did. He gave him a good recommendation. Okay, so Mr. Nash told you that he had qualified Mr. Briscoe. Correct. All right. Who were you paying? Who was I paying? Yes. The association was paying Briscoe. That's where the contract was. With permission, I'm going to show some documents and pages this time. Let's go to the first page. Do you recognize this? Yes. And we see here that it looks like an invoice Briscoe fencing solution. That's correct. John Briscoe. Mm-hmm. And then you're making payments to Mr. Briscoe. Is that correct? That's correct. And then I have more invoices to show you, too. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county 5. Any objection to Exhibit 5? No. Exhibit 5 will be admitted into evidence. Let me back up a little bit here. When we're saying, oh, you're fixing a gate, it's easy to think, oh, it's a picket fence. That's not what this project was, was it? No. Initially, it was strictly for the gates, the electronic gates. But, like, electronic gate, not just a, you know, manual? Like, there was... No, no, no. There was obviously electronic gates, yes. Okay. So not a small project. There was some fencing, PVC fencing, but it had nothing to do with that. Okay. And your understanding was that you were contracting with, to get all of the project done, not just the PVC, right? That's correct. Okay. And that, what I just showed you wasn't the entirety of what was paid, correct? I could show it to the witness, and then I'll show it to Mr. Nash. These are the payments that were being made, correct. Okay, I'm going to ask you about it, but... I'm sorry? I'm going to ask you about it, but before I introduce it. Oh. Yeah. All right. Let's walk through this first page. We see a date of 12-1-2025. It looks like a check in the amount of 17-5-5-0. Is that a fair and accurate representation of the invoice? That's correct. Looking at it, I have one of the yes. Correct. And then we have this next document, which is a couple pages itself. Start with page one of it. Invoice date of August the 9th, 2025. Mm-hmm. And it's to Briscoe fencing. All the payments were made to Briscoe. Correct. And then this accompanies, the next page accompanies this. The payment instruction and accounting number have been redacted, but we see down here that it's Briscoe Fencing Solutions, and you just told me that all the payments were only made to Briscoe Fencing? That is correct. And these last two pages just kind of go along with it. Do they look like a fair and accurate representation? I would say so. Okay. And last page. Does that look like a fair and accurate representation as well? Yes. At this point in time, I'd move this into evidence as county 6. Any objection to exhibit 6? No. Exhibit 6 will be admitted into evidence. Four more things. All right. First one is another invoice. 8-22-2025. Okay. To the order of Briscoe fencing. Correct. Does this appear an accurate representation? Yes. I'm asked to move this in as county 7. Any objection to exhibit 7? No. Exhibit 7 will be admitted into evidence. Now I'm going to show you what's titled on the document as Contractor's Final Payment Affidavit. Okay. Mm-hmm. That's correct. And it's from John Ross Briscoe. That's correct. And this is, obviously you weren't there when it was notarized, but it appears notarized to you. And Mr. Nash's name is nowhere on this? No. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county 8. Any objection to exhibit 8? Exhibit 8 will be admitted into evidence. Belabor the point a little bit, Mr. Caruse, but at any point in time, did you make payments to Mr. Nash? No. Not, absolutely not. The only contact I had with Mr. Nash was twice on the phone. Once in the beginning to confirm that he was, because John Ross, he told me he didn't, he had a general GC contractor that was qualifying him. And that's the only time I had it, except when we had an issue going on with some of the issues now, which brought this about. I called him to let him know that, that there was some issues going on. And that was it. That's the extent of my conversation. I wouldn't, I never saw him on the property. I mean, the first time I see him, it's right now, so. Thank you. Nothing further at this time for this witness, but I'd ask for permission to recall. Okay. Mr. Nash, do you have any questions for this witness? Yes, if you do, call up here and speak into the microphone. Yes, I don't actually have any questions, but I just wanted to make quite clear that I had never said to this gentleman here that I qualified risk offensing. Okay. You'll have an opportunity to present your case. All right. Call your next witness. Thank you. County Woodward Recall and Reservator Padgett for coming back up here. I neglected to show you this when you were up here before, the affidavit of non-licensure. Is this something you prepared in this case? It is. And can you tell the magistrate what your investigation found? So, I found that John Ross Briscoe did not hold any contractor's license with the state or with the county. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as counties nine. Any objection to Exhibit nine? Exhibit nine will be admitted into evidence. A couple more questions for you. Explain. And we heard a little bit from Mr. Reed to what license lending is. So, an unlicensed contractor cannot pull a permit because he's not licensed. Really, there's only two ways you can pull a permit. That's as a homeowner, if you're homesteaded at your property or as a licensed contractor. So, if a licensed contractor pulls a permit for an unlicensed person, that we call that, quote, license lending or aiding and assisting an unlicensed person because they cannot pull a permit. And we saw that aiding and assisting language in your citation. So, that's the situation you were describing in the citation. That's correct. Nothing further. Mr. Nash, do you have any questions for Investigator Padgett? All right. Anything else from the county? Nothing further. All right. Mr. Nash, this is your opportunity to present your case. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen of the board. Firstly, I just wanted to mention that the citation which is against me here is for performing an act which assists a person in an entity engaging in prohibited and certified or unregistered practice. And that, I believe, is incorrect because my understanding is that from House Bill 735, which was enacted back in 2021, there was certain, and this was state legislated, and it was approved and came in, it was enacted in July of 2021, that certain specialty contractors were not required to hold a license. One of those being fencing contractors. So, my understanding is that Mr. Briscoe and Briscoe Fencing Solutions did not require a license to perform their duties. So, I had no knowledge whatsoever of them being unlicensed because I didn't realize that they had to be licensed. And I still believe that that's still the case because it's, you know, it preempted local governments from requiring certain types of licenses for these specialty contractors. That was statewide. Therefore, you know, I disagree with the charges that have been brought against Britannia Construction for aiding and assisting an unlicensed contractor when there was no license required. Any questions, counsel? No questions, but I would like to close. Okay. Anything else? That's basically it. All right. I think as far as all the rest of the conversation, I think there's an appeal being already made by Mr. Briscoe's attorney for another hearing to deal with the other aspects of it. Okay. Which I'll be more than happy to get. We'll go to closing arguments. Closing arguments are where the parties tell me what they think the evidence showed and tell me what they want me to do. Thank you. I think the county has clearly demonstrated that the citation is substantiated. This is not a mere case of it was just fencing. That's why I went down the line of questioning of it's not just a PVC sentence. So any argument about preemption really doesn't have a foothold here because this, no matter how you slice it, is something that you wouldn't have needed a license to do the work that was being performed. You saw the testimony from Jim Reeves who said, in my experience, my vast experience as a city inspector, something's not right here. Mr. Nash is never on the site. All the payments are going to Mr. Briscoe. I mean, it just is what it is, and they got caught. So a preemption argument just really isn't appropriate when we're talking about this level and intricacy of work because that's not something that was preempted, and Pinellas County still does have full authority to enforce our code, especially 2214-1, which is what he was cited for. All right. Mr. Nash, this is your opportunity to make a closing statement. I have known Mr. Briscoe for several years. In my business of Britannia Construction, I've used his services for fencing on several occasions, both commercial and residential fencing projects. During our conversations, probably three or four years ago, he was telling me that he operates a very professional operation, and I'm more than happy to vouch for his quality of work, quality of his workmanship, and his experience. And during our conversations on some of the job sites, he was telling me that he was wanting to increase the scope of his work because his father is a mason, and he wanted to be able to bring scope of work of doing some more commercial-type fencings with concrete structural pillars, you know, together with metal-fabricated fencing, which he makes himself, all fabricated themselves, and powder coats them. And so, you know, I had no problem. And I said to him, you know, that's great. And he had told me that he had purchased all of his theory books and was doing five nights-a-week study at home, self-tutoring, to try and get his county license, contractor's license. And I said, well, to me it makes much more sense if you went for a state license because you don't need to have a state license or license for doing the work that you're doing at the moment. You know, why don't you get a state license and you're covered for the whole of Florida? And so he was in the process of trying to get to learn, do all the learning. I said, if there's anything I can do to assist you, help you, or advice I can give you, please don't hesitate to contact me because I knew that he was a hard-working guy and was only wanting to develop his business and produce more business for his company. And it was, I don't know when it was, a year ago or whatever, he came to me and said, you know, that I've got this possible job, a fencing contract with the Condominium Association here, putting in some security gates and fencing. He told me he'd give me some advice. And I said, well, first of all, you've got to go and get an engineered drawing and get that permitted and follow all the instructions. There's some of the aspects on that particular drawing that you are not licensed to do. You have to have a license for doing the electrical work. So I said, you need to go and find a contractor, an electrical contractor, to go and service that part of the contract, which he did. I said, you have to make sure that your company always has had general liability insurance. He's got a registered corporation with the Division of Corporations in Tallahassee, Florida State, and he has to carry workers' compensation insurance. I said, you have to have all of those in place. But I'll do anything I can to help you progress your company to be able to get your GC license. and get a better scope of work. So he asked me if I could help him with the project at the Condominium Association. I said, yeah, I'll do anything I can to help. I'm not, you know, I'm saying I'm not qualifying a company, but, you know, I'll give you a hand to do it, get all this done. So, knowing that he doesn't have to have a license to perform the job, I said, well, let's get the plans, we'll get them approved, and if you want, you can act as a subcontractor to me, providing you have all those other items, the general liability insurance, the workers' compensation insurance, and the company registered. I said, I'll give you a hand to get it taken care of. I said, but you can just do it, you know, directly with the client. You don't need the license to do that. So, you know, I'll help you get the permit pulled. You can act as a subcontractor to me if you wish, and, you know, we'll get that taken care of. So, the work was started, completed, all the inspections were done. I don't know where the previous gentleman was saying that there was a lot of issues with the inspections. There was only one issue. There were a couple of issues where the inspector wanted to have a calculation done on a voltage drop on the main wiring that the electrical contractor was doing, which Mr. Briscoe had his engineer do the calculations and put it on the plans for the inspector. So, there was no issue there. It came towards the end of the project when all of the inspections had been done. Even the fire marshal had been out there to do all the inspections and everything was approved. But the inspector wanted to know how deep the concrete was on the concrete posts which held the gates up. So, Mr. Briscoe excavated down the side of it, showed the inspector, you know, everything that was done to it to requirements on the drawings. And at that point, that's when the job was closed down. There was no issues with any permits. Everything was done in accordance with the plans. And I don't see where this issue has come from for closing that job there on. All right. Thank you. All right. As to citation CLB-CT26-0497, I'm going to find a violation of Code Section 22-14, subsection 1, an issue of fine in the amount of $2,000. Okay, we're going to be in recess for 10 minutes. Communications, please stop recording. Would you please read item number 8? Department PCCLB, matter is 22-14-6, advertising code violation. Case number CLB-MG25-00314, Investigator Jay Padgett, citation number CLB-CT26-00558, Defendant Everett W. Moore, Notice Address, Everett W. Moore, 12101, 77th Street, Largo, Florida, 3-3-7-7-3, E. Moore at EliteBuildingCo.com, and PCCLB Investigator Jay Padgett, Plaintiff's Witness, Pinellas County Code Enforcement, 631 Chestnut Street, Clearwater, Florida, 3-3-7-5-6, Jay Padgett at Pinellas.gov, and Kirby Crider, Esquire, Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB, in care of Natasha Creighton, Legal Secretary, Pinellas County Attorney's Office at 315 Court Street, 6th Floor, Clearwater, Florida, 33756, Kay Creighton at Pinellas.gov, N.A. Creighton at Pinellas.gov, violation address, Google EliteBuildingCo.com, there was a mistake there. No, there's not. Okay. Who's here for that case? Who's here for the county? Good morning, Assistant County Attorney Kirby Crider, on behalf of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board, and you're with me as a witness, is Investigator Jamie Padgett. Sir, would you state your name? My name is Everett Moore, Jr. Mr. Moore and Investigator Padgett, please raise your right hands. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. All right. County may proceed. You may have a seat. Good morning, sir. Can you say your name for the record? Investigator Jamie Padgett. How are you employed? I am a contractor licensing investigator with the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. In conjunction with that employment, do you have any specialized training or experience? Yes, field and administrative training. You heard the matter that we're here talking about. Were you the officer that issued the citation in this case? I was. All right. Let's look at the citation. So this citation is for 22-14-6, unlicensed contractor advertising general contracting services to include new homes, builds, ADUs, windows, doors, via Google website in Pinellas County, Florida. This looks like your signature. Is this a fair and accurate representation of the citation that you issued? It is. Thank you. Investigator Padgett, can you tell me about your investigation in this matter? So our agency received an official complaint from a homeowner. That initial complaint was for a job abandonment. At the time that Mr. Moore had contracted with the homeowner, he had a qualifier for his company. For that specific incident, I had to refer the homeowner to a different agency. However, I did see that Mr. Moore was still advertising his company without a qualifier, and he was issued one citation for unlicensed advertising. With permission, I'm going to show some documents to Mr. Moore. Thank you, Mr. Moore. Please. So as part of your investigation, you mentioned that there wasn't a qualifier. Can you explain again for this case what a qualifier is? Sure. So really there's only two ways you can become licensed. Either you get your license individually, then you can contract as yourself or your company. The other way, if you do not have a license, you can have another licensed contractor qualify your company. If that's done through the state, through DBPR, that licensed contractor would apply with the state to qualify another company. He either has to have a 30% stake in the company or be a W-2 employee. Once that's all approved through DBPR, then they would issue a specific license for that company. So what happens if the relationship, for lack of a better word, between the qualifier and quality doesn't work out anymore? Can they pull that qualification? Yes. So the license holder would pull his license through the state, and then that license would become inactive. And in the course of this investigation, did you examine whether or not Mr. Moore still had that qualification? I did investigate that, yes. Okay, and I'm going to show you a document. Can you explain to the magistrate what this is, please? So this is our registration through our building department. So state licensed contractors have to register with our building department in order to pull permits. This is the registration for the previous qualifier for Mr. Moore's company. And I see the note here, pull qualifications February 10th. That was prior to the citation being issued, correct? That's correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county one. Any objection to exhibit one? I'll miss it. Exhibit one will be admitted into evidence. Having shown Mr. Moore, I'm going to show you this document that has been provided to me. Can you explain to the magistrate what we're looking at? So that is the license for an Eric North, who was the previous qualifier for Mr. Moore's company. At the time I pulled this license, it was in a current inactive status, not registered to any company because he had pulled his license back in February of 2026. So when you're investigating to make sure it was appropriate to the citation, this was something that you researched? Yes, and I contacted an investigator with DBPR as well. He gave me that specific date of when the license was pulled. Thank you. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this into evidence. Any objection to exhibit two? Can I ask a question about it? Yeah, come up and... It's not necessarily an objection, just like the date that was on there, so the 10th I had applied with the state, and when that came done, and in March when it was given to me, and then I applied with the state for the extension to that. Is that on there? Also, because I see it was handwritten in there. Okay, you'll have an opportunity to present your case and explore that. Yes, sir. Okay. You'll have an opportunity to ask Investigator Padgett questions as well. Yes, sir. Thank you. I will admit exhibit two. Thank you. Laying some more background, as part of your investigation, did you prepare an affidavit? I did. Okay, and I'm going to show this to Mr. Moore. Am I allowed to hear a picture of this? Yeah. Investigator Padgett, I am putting up on the screen an affidavit of non-licensure. Did you prepare this? I did. And what does this reflect? So I conducted a license search for Mr. Moore. I found that he was working on getting his license. However, at the time I did the affidavit, he was not licensed with the state or with the county. And dates were September 30, 2025, to September 30, 2026. Correct. 2026, I apologize. And that is consistent with the date that you issued the citation, correct? It is. At this point in time, I'd ask to move the Sinnes County 3. Any objections to Exhibit 3? Exhibit 3 will be admitted into evidence. Okay. So let's talk about why we're here. What was the citation about? For unlicensed advertising in Pinellas County. And was that online? Tell me more about it. Yeah, so part of our investigations, we look for any type of unlicensed advertising. Part of that investigation, we look at online databases. I found that Mr. Moore is still advertising his company on Google and on his website. And when you say still advertising, are you talking about after the fact that his qualification was pulled? That's correct. Okay. I'm going to show some talking about the foodies page by page. We see elite building concepts. Then we saw on the affidavit of licensure that you were able to link that to Mr. Moore. Can you tell us about that? Yeah, so that's Mr. Moore's company, elite building concepts. And this is captured from Google where he's advertising his company, listed as a construction company operating out of Clearwater. Clearwater is in Pinellas County? Correct. Like this next page is some reviews. Yeah, so these are reviews off the Google page. It's from two months ago at the time when I investigated that indicated to me that Mr. Moore was still working within Pinellas County. This down here, is this indicative of the August 13th date? Is that reflective of when you captured this information? That's correct. Same questions about this next page, but what I want to highlight is he's advertising for remodeling, additions, ADUs, new construction services. Are those all services that you would need a license to advertise? Yes. And he doesn't have one, right? Correct. And more of the same, is this also what you found when you researched his page? Yes, that's from his actual website, elite building concepts, elitebuildingco.com. And then I think we see here elite building concepts, so this is his page? Correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move these in as county composite four. Any objection to exhibit four? No, sir. Exhibit four will be admitted into evidence. You already testified to this, but I did want to show the documentation that you researched. I apologize. Let me show Mr. Moore. You said you were able to link Mr. Moore to elite building concepts. Did you do research through DPVR or SunBus to do that? Yes. All right. Let's start page by page. Is this first page an accurate representation of what you review for elite building concepts? It is. Okay. And then on the second page, we see the officer director is Mr. Moore. Correct. And that's a fair and accurate representation? It is. On this final page, we see again Mr. Moore, link to elite building concepts. That's correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this in as county five. Any objection to exhibit five? Yep. Exhibit five will be admitted into evidence. So in summary, Investigator Padgett, you were able to determine that he did not have a license so it was still advertising in Pinellas County? Correct. Nothing further. All right. Mr. Moore, do you have any questions of Investigator Padgett? Anything else from the county? Nothing further. All right. Mr. Moore, this is your opportunity to present your case. Good morning, sir. At the time, I've been in business for elite building concepts for since 2021. I had a qualifier up until basically he withdrew. He was in the process of withdrawing in February, March there. I don't know the exact date. I think Mr. Padgett recorded the date there. I think I'd spoke with Mr. Padgett at some point in August. I think he called me with Tom on the phone. We had a conversation on the phone and that's when he said, hey, he asked about my website and stuff there. And I didn't really know that you couldn't advertise stuff like that. I was in the process of getting my state license. I took him past all the tests and everything I was doing. I was actually in the process of getting from applying with the DVPR, doing all that stuff there. That's part of my obligation with Mr. North was running out February, March of this year. It just took me a little bit longer to get my state license. I did apply with the DVPR in the state for the extension there. They gave me the extension. They said I couldn't pull no more permits, but I was actively able to still do the work that we had permits. I think, did you speak with Mr. North, I believe? I guess because they said I could still do the jobs that I already had permitted. I couldn't just abandon or walk away from a contract, basically. And now I am licensed now with the state of Florida. And I also, I had asked my, after I spoke with Mr. Padgett, I had called Hebu, who was the marketer who was running my email, and I said, not my email, excuse me, my website stuff. I was like, hey, I'm in violation of, I guess, I can't have my website up and stuff like that advertised and take it down. And then it took them about a month to take that down. So that's where I stand with that. I am a licensed contractor now. You know, there was a gap in between there where my business wasn't qualified or licensed. You know, I am now. And that's where I'm at. All right. Any questions, counsel? Go ahead and have a closing argument. Closing arguments are where you tell me what you think the evidence showed and tell me what you want me to do. The brief, I think the county has showed that the violation is supported. And I understand that now he may be licensed, but the fact of the matter is he wasn't at the time that he was advertised for and he was cited at the time when he wasn't licensed. So the county is asking that you uphold this violation. Okay, thank you. Mr. Moore? Through the process of this, you know, I was basically gearing up to, you know, I didn't know that it was going to take me the time. It took an extended amount of time to get my license. It took me longer than I anticipated to get my license. And I was basically just, my website, I just recently switched to Hebrew and stuff there. And they got it active and working a little bit faster than I thought they would with all the services and stuff that we're at due because I just switched to them like in the beginning of August. Like literally like right then, they got it working a little bit faster. And there was a lapse and then I'm not going to, I'm not here to say there wasn't an in-between times when I had a qualifier and when I didn't. I didn't pull any jobs or do any other work or unlicensed. I'm big on being a licensed contractor. That's why I went to the steps and process over the past couple years. To get my state license and doing all my stuff there. You know, because there is a lot of stuff out there going on and I understand there was a gap there. So it is what it is. All right. Thank you. All right. As to citation number CLB-CT26-00558, I'm going to find that there was a violation of code section 22-14, subsection 6, and we'll enter a fine in the amount of $500. I'm going to see that. It's within 30 days. You're going to get an order and either you can wait for your order or we can send it in the mail. You're going to receive it in the mail either way. You're welcome. And just to let you know, if you need any payment plans or anything like that, you go to 440 and they'll be able to do it. Next item is item number 10. Department is PCCLB 22-14-7, Advertising Code Violation. Case number CLB-MG26-00339, Investigator N. Nichols. Citation number CLB-CT26-00571. Defendant is LaForge Lizette. Notice address, LaForge Lizette at 8997-131st Place, Largo, Florida, 33773, and PCCLB Investigator N. Nichols, Plaintiff's Witness, Pinellas County Code Enforcement, 631 Chestnut Street, Clearwater, Florida, 33756, N. Nichols at Pinellas.gov, N. Kirby Kreider, Esquire, Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB, in care of Natasha Creighton, Legal Secretary, Pinellas County Attorney's Office, 315 Court Street, 6th Floor, Clearwater, Florida, 33756, K. Kreider at Pinellas.gov, N. A. Creighton at Pinellas.gov, violation address, GTB, and Starkey Road. Who's here for that case? Good morning. Kirby Kreider, Assistant County Attorney on behalf of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. Here with me is Investigator Nichols as a witness. And I'm Lizette LaForge. All right. Ms. LaForge and Investigator Nichols, would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes. I do. All right. You may have a seat there, and the county may proceed. Thank you. Good morning, sir. Can you say your name for the record, please? Yes. Good morning. My name is Investigator Norman Nichols. How are you employed? The Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board. And what is your title? I am a contractor, Field Investigation Licensing. In connection with your employment, have you had any training or specialized field experience? Yes. Field and administrative training. You heard the case just described. Were you the officer that issued the citation in this matter? I am. All right. The citation over here today, it was issued Beacon Violation 22, Municipal Code 2214-7. Beacon Windows admitted contractor's license number from Vehicle Advertising Window Services in Clearwater, Pinellas County, Florida. Is this a fair and accurate description of the citation you issued? It is. And is Clearwater, Florida in Pinellas County? Yes, it is. Thank you. All right. So it sounds pretty self-explanatory, so I'm going to get right to the pictures after I show Ms. LaForge. One, can you describe to the magistrate what we're looking at here? Yes. So while I was driving eastbound on State Road 60, Gulf to Bay, however you guys recognize it, while I was driving, I did notice the vehicle to my right, and I was scanning the vehicle to see the type of scope of work that was doing, and I noticed that I did not see any license displayed on the vehicle. So naturally, I captured a picture of it and went back to my office to do the research, come to find out that the owner of the business is a licensed contractor, which there, as you can see, there are no license displayed on the vehicle that should be on the left and the right side and three inches or higher. So the issue here is not the underlying whether or not Ms. LaForge had a license, is that the license number wasn't displayed, is that fair? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move to Sinnes County 1. Any objection to Exhibit 1? Exhibit 1 will be admitted into evidence. Did you prepare any type of affidavit in this case? I did. And in preparing that affidavit, did you do research on DPVR or SunBiz? Yes, so I did check all the website to verify the name of the business, the owner, and to see if that owner is a licensed contractor. This affidavit, did you prepare this affidavit? I did. And I just want to reiterate that although she has a license, the issue here for this case is that it wasn't on the vehicle. Is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this affidavit in this county too. Any objection to Exhibit 2? Exhibit 2 will be admitted into evidence. All right. Ms. LaForge, do you have any questions for Investigator Nichols? No. All right. You may come up and present your case. Thank you for listening. When we received this paper, this citation, we immediately looked at all of our vehicles. We have a fleet of a number of vehicles and we had just had that one wrapped. I did ask the guy who does the wraps and I regularly and repeatedly asked over the years whenever we go get a wrap done to have our license on it. They just overlooked it and when it arrived back to my office, I didn't happen to examine it so I overlooked it as well. So I then called Mr. Nichols and I told him that we had had it immediately wrapped as soon as we got the citation and what could we do about it and he said we'd work with the magistrates to figure it out. So I created a multi-page document showing that we have remediated this issue as well as all of our other vehicles are in compliance just in case you wanted to know because I've always been very proud of my license and I want to have it on my vehicles. This one just was overlooked by my wrap guy who apologized profusely. That's all I have to say. All right. Do you need to see this? Yeah, if you want to. No objection. Would you like me to mark it? Yes, if you would. Yes. I'll mark it as respondents one. Yes, please. Then you can bring it up to me so I can take a look at it. I have an extra copy if you need it. When I did speak to Officer Nichols on the phone, I asked him why weren't we given a warning and he said they were no longer allowed to do that nor could he do anything about it once it was in motion and I completely understood that and being a fan of not having unlicensed contracting, I understood my responsibility was to look at that vehicle and I failed to do so once it arrived back. But it's not something intentional as you'll see from the age of our vehicles. We have old vehicles there where the wraps are already starting to peel and they all have licenses on them. So it was an unintentional, inadvertent mistake. Kirby, would you take a look at this and then put it with the other exhibits? Counselor, do you have questions of Ms. LaForge? I do not, thank you. All right. All right. Well, brief closing arguments. As I have indicated, closing arguments are where the parties tell me what they think the evidence showed. Tell me what they want me to do. The county understands that this may have been unintentional, but the county is going to ask you to substantiate the violation. It was in violation at the time the citation was issued. Thank you. All right. I agree that it was in violation and if I have to pay a fine for that, I accept that. If you can renege the fine, that would be awesome, but, I mean, we were in violation and because of that code violation, it caused us to go check all of our other vehicles and make sure everything was compliant. All right. Thank you. As to citation CLB-CT26-00571, I'm going to find that there was a violation of Code Section 22-14, subsection 7. and issue a fine in the amount of $500. Do we have one more for PCCO? We have 7 and 9, but 9 is just a read-in, I believe, or 7. One of them is just a read-in because we've continued it. 9 is a read-in and then 7 is a no-show. Which one are we going with? We're going to go with item 7 first. Okay. Next case is item number 7, rescheduled from October 16, 2025, PCCLB 22-14-5, no permit, code violation, 22-14-6, advertising, code violation, 22-14-1, unlicensed contracting, code violation. Case number CLB-MG26-00250, CLB-MG26-00251, CLB-MG26-00252, citation numbers CLB-CT26-00421, CLB-CT26-00422, CLB-C226-00423, defendant is Henry Argendary, sorry if I butchered that, notice address Henry Argendary, Argendary 669, Fairwood Forest Drive, Clearwater, Florida, F33759, email address is HenryArgendary83 at gmail.com, and PCCLB investigator C. Furlan, plaintiff's witness, boy, I'm missing this up, Pinellas County Code Enforcement, 631 Chestnut Street, Clearwater, Florida, 33756, C. Furlan at pinellas.gov, and Mr. and Mrs. Kenneth McNichol, 14 Harbor Cove Street, Safety Harbor, Florida, 34695, and Ann McNichol, McNichola at gmail.com, and Kirby Crider Esquire, and Kirby Crider Esquire, Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB, in care of Natasha Creeden, Legal Secretary, Pinellas County Attorney's Office, 315 Court Street, 6th floor, Clearwater, Florida, 33756, K. Crider at pinellas.gov, N. A. Creeden at pinellas.gov, Violation address, 14 Harbor Cove Street, Safety Harbor, Florida, 34695, and via proposal. Is there anyone here for this case? It's a tone twister. Nicole, has anyone signed in for this case? Are you aware of any telephone messages or emails concerning this? I notice in the file there's an email from July 15, 2026, requesting this hearing, but other than that, you haven't heard anything about why there's nobody here? I have not. All right. Thank you. Who's here for the county? Good morning. Kirby Crider, Assistant County Attorney, on behalf of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board, I have with me Mr. and Mr. Nichols and also Investigator Furland. Seeing that the defendant was duly noticed, requested this hearing, and has failed to appear, I'd ask that this magistrate review the file and enter judgment in favor of the county. I'm going to require you to present the case. We'll start with, the county will call Investigator Furland. Oh, yeah. Mr. Horne in. Will the three of you please raise your right hands? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. County may proceed. Good morning, ma'am. Can you say, oh, good morning. Can you say your name for the record? Investigator Cheryl Furland, Pinellas County, PCCLB investigator. And in conjunction with your employment, have you had any specialized training or experience? Yes. Field and administrative. You heard the case described. Were you the investigator that issued the citations in this matter? Yes. And you issued three of them? Yes. Okay. Let's walk through them together. First one ending in 1-2-1. Work without the required permit for bathroom remodel to include demolition and framing in a residential home within Pinellas County in violation of Pinellas County municipal code. Correct. I think you said 1-2-1. It's 4-2-1. Oh, I apologize. I did 4-2-1. That is correct. Next one in this case is 4-2-2 in violation of Pinellas County municipal code 22-14-5 unlicensed advertising to demo and plumbing via proposition within Pinellas County. Correct. Okay. Is this a fair accurate representation of the citation you issued? Yes, ma'am. And the last one is ending in 4-2-3 violation of 22-14-1 unlicensed contracting to the warrant demolition and framing in a residential home within Pinellas County. That is correct. And we're going to walk through this together, but upon first glance, it sounds like it's a bunch of citations for the same activity, but really they're each their own individual code violation. Is that fair to say? Yes, it is. Okay. So when we're talking about this property address, did you verify that it was in Pinellas County? Yes. And how did you do that? Property appraiser. I'll show you three-page it. I'll see more of that. It's colored. Oh, it's a color property card. Yeah. Thank you. All right. In color, is this the address that you listed or that the citations were issued for? Yes. And is that in Pinellas County, Florida? Safety Harbor is in fact Pinellas County, yes. At this point in time, I'd ask to move this into evidence as County 1. Hearing no objection, Exhibit 1 will be admitted into evidence. Scooter, Furland, let's back up. Can you tell me how you got involved in this case? The building department had called me. My understanding was that McNichols had inquired about a permit and the building department had gone out taking pictures and confirmed that in fact there was no permit. There was one applied for but it was never issued and I got called in to verify the work that had been started. At this point in time, did you go take any type of photos? I did. Okay. I'll show you some minor or not. Mine are. Color for the record. All right. This looks like this is two pages but the first page this is what the photographs when you went out to the property that you took, correct? Correct. And second page one photograph is still clearly work being done, correct? Yes. And is this a fair and accurate representation of what you saw that day? Yes. And at this point in time I'd ask to move this in as composite county two. Hearing no objection exhibit two will be admitted. Senator Furland, you said that you got involved in this case about like a permitting issue. What did you look at as far as verifying the permit? Our permitting department to verify that there was no active permit? Is this a fair and accurate representation of the records you reviewed from the building permitting department? Yes, it is. And does that tell you that there was no permit that would have allowed the type of work that we saw in the photographs to happen legally? That is correct. At this point in time I'd ask to move this in as county three. Hearing no objection exhibit three will be admitted into evidence. Did you do any type of investigation on to whether or not this individual had a license? I did. And did you prepare an affidavit that reveals the results of that investigation? I did. I'll show you this affidavit. Is this a fair and accurate copy of the affidavit that you prepared? Yes, it is. And it shows that Henry Argentieri didn't have the license between 2024 and 2026, correct? Correct. At this point in time I'd ask to move this in as county four. Hearing no objection exhibit four will be admitted into evidence. Now I want to talk about one of the citations was for a proposal. And when you say that, what do you mean? Is it like a contract? Yes. This is the proposal as it's stated, property proposal by Golden Touch Contracting LLC. There are several pages here. It goes through the description of work, scope of work for the demolition, subfloor preparation, plumbing, shower construction, tile installation, and finishing. And then labor is at the total price for turnkey labor. Exclusions, materials, unforeseen issues, the work schedule, the payment schedule, workmanship and warranty agreement, other terms and conditions. And investigator, you received this document from the homeowners, is that correct? That is correct. At this point in time I'd ask to move this into evidence as county five. I'm sorry. I'd ask to move this into evidence as county five. Hearing no objection, exhibit five will be admitted into evidence. All right. And then, were you aware that the homeowners made any type of payments to Golden Touch? Yes. They paid check and... That's going to work. I apologize. I failed to redact this document. It's a photograph of a check. I just don't want to introduce into evidence the homeowners routing information. Okay. I will agree that you should redact that. Does anybody have a Sharpie? Sorry. I apologize. You're welcome. They also have Zelle up there. Yeah. Thank you for that opportunity, Investigator Kerlin. Can you tell us what we're looking at right now? That is a Zelle payment it looks like. I think you should also redact the... Right where your finger is the transaction ID. Right? Right where the Sharpie is below it. Thank you. I apologize for the oversight. Well, they're in the public record so it's important that type of information not be in the public record. Yes, sir. So this is a Zelle payment for $1,500 to Golden Touch Contracting. Another one for $2,000 to Golden Touch Contracting. I mean, your understanding is Golden Touch Contracting we established was... A contract. ...to the defendant here today. Well, not here today but the citations were issued to. At this point in time I'd ask to move these documents in as County Composite 6. Hearing no objection Exhibit 6 will be admitted into evidence. To be clear there was no permits issued at the time the work was happening correct? Correct. Okay. And the proposal that we looked at that is why they were cited as well? Correct. Okay. No further questions? Call your next witness. At this point in time the county would call Mr. and Mrs. Nichols. I don't know if... Nichols. Nick Nichols I'm sorry. It's been a long morning. It's okay. Good morning. I just... One question. Is Golden Touch someone that you're familiar with? Is Henry someone that you're familiar with? Not before this... Not before the contract. No. And you paid him for the services for your home? Yes we did. Nothing further? Anything else in the county? Nothing further. All right. As to citation number CLB-CT26-00421 I'm going to find there's a violation of Code Section 22-14 subsection 5 and issue a fine of $500. As far as citation CLB-CT26-00422 I'm going to find a violation of Code Section 22-14 subsection 8 and issue a fine of $500 for citation CLB-CT26-00423 I'm going to find a violation of Code Section 22-14 subsection 1 and issue a fine of $500. Eddie, would you read item number nine? Item number nine was rescheduled to January 27th, 2027. Do you need me to read the whole thing? The department is PCCLB Matters 22-14-7 Advertising Code Violation Case Number CLB-MG26-00327 Investigator N. Nichols Citation is CLB-C226-00565 Defendant is Daniel Munyon Notice address is Daniel Ryan Munyon at 7325 Olmerton Road Largo, Florida 33771 Daniel at Munyon Painting dot com and PCCLB Investigator N. Nichols Plaintiff's Witness Pinalis County Code Enforcement 631 Chestnut Street Clearwater Florida 33756 N. Nichols at Pinalis dot gov and Kirby Crider Esquire Assistant County Attorney for PCCLB in care of Natasha Creedon Legal Secretary Pinalis County Attorney's Office at 315 Court Street 6th floor Clearwater Florida 33756 K. Crider at Pinalis dot gov N. A. Criden at Pinalis dot gov Violation Address 412 St. Andrews Drive Bel Air Florida 33756 Alright this matter has been rescheduled to January 27th 2027 DCLB if we could have a five minute break so they can make the switch Okay we'll be in recess for five minutes communications please stop recording item number 18 department public works environmental management water and navigation the matter is for the appeal of the issuance of dock construction permit WND dash 26 dash 00548 case number CCM dash 26 dash 00156 appellant Holger Peens owner permitty Christobel T Insinius Lena Props Insinius I'm sorry That's okay Notice Address to see attachments subject address 1212 Sunset Drive Clearwater Florida 33755 Parcel ID is 29 or 09 dash 29 dash 15 dash 25956 dash 000 dash 0760 Okay The notice addresses attachments are attached to the agenda so they will be in the record Who's here for that case Everyone involved please come up and who's here for the county Yes Good morning Magistrate David Barrera Assistant County Attorney's Office and I have requisite staff they'll introduce themselves Good morning Melanie Reed I'm the Division Director for Environmental Management over Water and Navigation Mia Pogue I'm an Environmental Specialist with Water and Navigation Hello Chelsea Carter a manager for Water Navigation Mr. Barrera is there going to be testimony Yes magistrate Are you going to have any witnesses Craig Terasky Attorney for the permittees the Insinius I'm one of the homeowners of 1212 Sunset Drive Are you expecting any testimony No sir Okay Will those that are going to give testimony please raise your right hands Do you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I think I'm going to present their position and then we'll have counsel for the person objecting and then follow up with the homeowner that's currently got the permit I understand That's correct magistrate we don't anticipate that the homeowner that is got the permit will be testifying today the Insinias in any event magistrate this is going to be a staff level function I'm here to address any legal issues that might arise as you're aware we're here pursuant of Pinellas County code of ordinances specifically 58-536 regarding appeals regarding any final determinations issued by the department i.e. issuance of a permit Pinellas County Water Navigation did receive an appeal to a permit that was issued with that I'm going to call up Melanie Weed who's going to go through the applicable permit that was issued and what we've received in line with what's being appealed with that thank you I believe you have a power point I also brought the slides we can send you a copy the power point you can just put it up there if not on the yes all right so this matter concerns the appeal filed by Mr. Holdrapeens regarding the assurance of dock construction permit WND 26-00548 so the subject properties are located at 1212 Sunset Drive in Clearwater Mr. Insinius owns 1212 Sunset Drive and Mr. Peens the appellant owns the property located at 1208 Sunset Drive located just to the south this is an aerial photography item from depicting these properties a little closer and the docks are located where the orange arrow is shown so this zoomed in aerial depicts both properties the subject property where our permit was issued is in blue that's the insinius property and the appellant's property is in red to the south the location of the previously permitted shared dock can also be shown on this image in 1986 a permit was issued authorizing the construction of a shared dock serving both properties located at 1208 and 1212 Sunset Drive this slide includes the approved side plan which is on this side as well as a 1997 aerial depicting the dock the permit authorized a 1902 square foot dock structure with two boat lifts I want to note that there's actually a typo on this slide this indicates that there was hurricane damage that occurred to this dock in 2025 the hurricane damage actually occurred in 2024 during the Helene and Milton hurricanes on June 17 20 26 water navigation received an application to partially reconstruct the shared dock the proposed reconstruction was limited to portions of the structure located entirely within the property boundaries of 1212 Sunset Drive owned by the Insidious and following stock review permit WND 26-00548 was issued on July 14th 2026 sure I'm following my slide numbers okay as part of its review water navigation evaluated potential impacts to aquatic resources including seagrass habitat staff required that the reconstructed dock remain within the footprint of the existing or previously permitted structure in order to avoid creating new impacts to existing seagrass resources as shown on this area photograph the historic dock footprint is located within an area containing fewer natural resources than here after the old dock was removed the blue outline shows where the new dock is proposed to or the repaired dock is supposed to go these photos here show the grass in that area these are site photos that were taken from the insinious property in September and depict the existing site conditions within the project area this first photo is looking south this is looking waterward and this is looking forward showing the extent of the dock repair facing north this last slide shows a separate dock permit issued to Mr. Peens by water navigation on January 20th 2026 together with the approved site plan and dock configuration associated with that permit so in conclusion based on the application materials permit history site conditions and staff's review of the applicable permit criteria staff determined that permit WMD 26 met all requirements for issuance accordingly staff respectfully request that the special magistrate uphold the issuance of dock construction permit WMD 26 dash 00548 just a couple questions Ms. Weed the permit that was issued to the insinias to construct a new dock is that new dock contained within the bounds of their property yes no further questions council have any questions please speak into thank you thank you you stated that the incentives applied for a shared dock reconstruction permit is that correct that is correct okay and who were they sharing that dock with the original dock was built in 1986 and at the time there was an agreement between the two parties and where is that agreement located is it in official records it is an official record correct okay and would that be book number that looks like the correct I apologize it's from 1986 11188 page 1732 it is very hard to read that looks like the same document and this document was between the two previous property owners and I do want to note that when water navigation did their research on the previous permit there was no indication that this was a shared dock as required by Pinellas County it appeared that this was a decision by the property owners at the time to share the dock okay what do you mean required by Pinellas County there was no requirement in the permit that the county required that the dock be shared were you here in 1986 I was not but what I stated was that there was no indication in our records okay tell me how did the permit processing take place who contacted who how did and this is I apologize for the permit that was granted 26-00548 on 1212 now how did that process go who contacted who was it the county that contacted the homeowner or was it the homeowner that contacted the county are you referring to the insinuous permit correct okay the I believe from what I've gathered from staff is that the insinuous contacted Pinellas County staff water navigation to discuss installing a dock of their own within their property boundaries and they were notified by county staff at the time that due to the presence of seagrass along their shoreline that most likely we would not be able to be permitting a new dock in a different location than the one that was already in existence and in order for us to permit any dock it would have to be in the footprint of the old dock to prevent any further environmental impacts we have some emails that are from December and January I believe 2025 and 2026 to that effect oh okay I just haven't seen those could you please provide me with a copy of those at your convenience sure yeah I guess who in the county took that first that first conference with the encinas one of our staff members Castilla Aguilar she's no longer with the county but she's the staff member that they were corresponding with via email and I my understanding is that the contractor also spoke to Jesse Sims our program manager I don't have a date on that but asked the same questions and it was confirmed at the time that we would not be able to allow a dock in a different location or place it in a different location the permit application that we received was for a repair of the existing dock structure it was for a repair of an existing joint dock correct correct okay are there two parties on that permit I believe the parties on that original permit were the original property owners back in 1986 and that would be the two neighboring properties correct correct so both of those owners would have correct on the new permit no sir if they do not own the property they cannot sign off on a new permit then how is it over the property line into the property the area in blue is what's proposed to be reconstructed and will be wholly on the insinious property so it will be within the property boundaries of the insinious so there will be no overlap to the property is that a survey you have there on that property appraiser I mean on that one right there is that a survey that's a permit drawing okay well have you had an opportunity to review the original agreement to the vote doc I have okay and uh magistrate at this point I'm going to object to any questioning regarding the existing agreement that's not the issue before the magistrate today the issue before the magistrate today is an appeal of a properly issued permit an existing private agreement is not an issue to the county today magistrate I don't believe that we should on your questioning about it overruled you may proceed okay so on that original permit did uh did did the doc itself straddle the common boundary line or the on the original agreement was the doc itself supposed to straddle the property line that is I believe the intent of the agreement but based on what we can see currently on where property lines are located and where the old structure was located we don't believe it was constructed on the actual property line are we basing that off of a survey we're basing that off of current property lines off the property appraisers website okay and uh can you tell me when was this photo and all the aerial photos that you have taken uh this aerial is from 1997 this one and um can you show me a when that aerial of the dock without or with the I guess the seagrass without a dock there was taken that that's supposed to be the current just a second this is a 2026 aerial was that taken within the last three months or was it taken within the first half of the year usually the aerials are flown in the early part of the year so they would have probably been January so would the seagrass look like that today it would be fairly close there you know I don't think that that would necessarily indicate more growth but within six months you might see more growth but it would not be much different than this you do have photos of seagrass along the rest of the property as well and that is when you guys went out and took it on and this was in September a review okay so this was after or before the dock was permitted this was after the dock was permitted why was this review not done before the the review was done before but we did some additional verifying there's a inspection field inspection report that we have with this application and the date on that one is just a second too many pieces of paper may I consult with staff momentarily yes Mr. Hamilton yes I have the copy for you there thank you madam clerk you're welcome correction after discussing with staff because this was a repair of an existing dock we don't perform full field inspections so one was conducted after the fact as a result of the hearing request okie dokie and would a person normally getting a dock without having a previously destroyed dock have to have the site inspected for grass mitigation standards no not for a repair no what about a new dock being built a brand new dock yes ok thank you Mr. Fuller no further questions council do you have any questions brief redirect magistrate Ms. Weed the existing shared dock has been removed correct correct ok and has staff been able to determine that the new dock will be located within the insinia's property boundaries yes and will placing the insinia's dock near or adjacent to the existing shared dock reduce environmental impacts as required by Pinellas county code yes thank you anything else from the county or do you have another question nothing further from the county magistrate ok Mr. Hamilton we'll hear from you next Mr. Brea did you have an opportunity to give any of the emails that I sent to the county on any of it what are you specifically referring to like any of the emails that I emailed you yeah I did provide them to staff for their review ok thank you so essentially it's our position that this dock this joint dock was inherited by both the homeowners when they bought the properties respectively it ran with the land easement that permits two adjoining lots to share a dock somewhere near the property line hurricane Helene happened and destroyed that dock prior to that there was this dock agreement that had requirements for the parties to build or not rebuild and under that agreement my clients reached out to the neighbors the encinas and ask if they would be willing to rebuild the dock at that point the encinas said no that everybody was going to be building on their own respective property and they'd all be building their own docks so that's what my client did he started to build his own dock as the county showed Holger Peens applied for a dock in 2025 and is almost done with building that dock currently come to find out by some dock workers taking measurements behind the house the neighbors did not intend to hold up their end of the bargain and instead decided to build the dock where it was originally placed thusly limiting my client's use and ability to use that joint dock that they had agreement for forcing my client to build a dock in the middle of their property line which is a customary for that area of Clearwater Harbor because of the long ridge that you have to build out the issue that my clients have and the reason that we're here and we filed this appeal is because they had no notice of this they had no sign off requirement when they built their dock they were required to have the neighbors sign off on it in this case the neighbors were not required to sign off on it because it was a joint dock application it's kind of a bait and switch if you ask my opinion and we would ask that the county would have given my client the proper opportunity to examine all this before a permit was permitted and that did not happen so that's really the basis of our appeal here today we understand that there are environmental issues the preservation of nature and the environment are paramount to Pinellas County and hopefully all of its citizens but fair is fair and this should be done right so in order to protect due process and equal protection we would ask that this be remanded and done appropriately in a original dock format as it is no longer a joint use dock thank you all right council correct to ask council for the permittees so as council for the county had objected earlier making demands on the performance or non-performance or breach of the private agreement between neighbors is irrelevant to today's proceeding there's nothing in that agreement that has delegated authority to enforce the county and there's provisions in that agreement itself that allow the property owners to separate and have their own separate docks in the event of the destruction of the shared dock which has occurred this is not the correct forum to dispute performance or non-performance for breach of that agreement council for the appellants have demanded remand to some other forum this is the forum for them to argue that the county somehow erred in granting the permit I have seen no evidence presented by the appellants to counter or rebut the assumptions and the evidence that the county has relied on to issue the permit I've just heard questions and arguments the rebuild permit was requested by the current permittees does not require public hearing nor does it require the signatures of adjacent property owners the appellant for the council for the appellant has made no argument that the county has erred in processing the permit has not identified any of the review criteria that this permit has failed to meet so I'd respectively ask you to deny the appeal and to confirm the issuance of the permit thank you anything else from the county magistrate I'm going to echo council's statements regarding from the insidious council your honor or magistrate the insidious non-commitment to build a joint dock is not an issue before the magistrate notably in my conversations with staff the insidious were not required to obtain signatures regarding an installation and creation of a new dock because it is a repair it is placement of a dock that is wholeheartedly in an existing location of the bounds of the insidious property magistrate besides conclusory statements made by the appellance council there is no record evidence provided today that Pinellas County has failed to follow its established principles therefore magistrate Pinellas County is going to ask that you uphold the permit that was appropriately issued I didn't receive the actual notice for this case until this morning via email I'm not arguing that right now I just want it to be known on the record I like everything to be out in the open and I think that should be the mantra that the county lives by and I don't feel that that was the case here I think that this whole process was done without the knowledge of my client and we are here now trying to stop the issuance of this permit as it stands thank you any closing magistrate sorry to interrupt an opportunity to combat allegations that notice was not appropriately provided let's wait till he is closing and then I'll let you have a rebuttal thank you okay he's waving magistrate as you're aware notice under these hearings is governed by Florida statute 162 162 requires that certified mailings be issued and if any notice sent by certified mail is not signed as received within 30 days notice may be provided in additional forms magistrate I'm going to share with you this is the tracking information for notice that was mailed regarding today's hearing it was sent certified additionally your magistrate I have multiple affidavits that were submitted to the magistrate regarding mailing of appropriate notice I just want to clarify this for the record yes if you can speak into the microphone everything needs to be recorded thank you madam clark is miss howard here today no and that's the person who signed this affidavit that appears to be it I don't know I'm under my own bar license I didn't receive it so that's it thank magistrate additionally those are the specific certified mailings for John Hamilton at 111 2nd Avenue Northeast suite 703 and both peens addresses that we have on file both 1217 Sunset Drive and 1208 Sunset Drive these are all part of the record as well magistrate all right I'm going to deny the appeal and affirm the granting of the permit recess for lunch okay we will be in recess until 1.30 communications please stop recording I'm going to wait until she gets on to read because she hasn't heard it either I did it was 4 and 11 and she did one which one did you do I don't remember she did one I thought it was 3 or 4 I'll just mess it with you I did 3 so 3 4 and 11 are done communications please go live we have a video appearance and as soon as the junction is made we'll get started on yet she's not on yet no okay I sent her an email telling her that we were ready for her what am I doing I'm doing nothing Caroline the next thing we were scheduled to hear was number 19 and I don't have a file on it yes it was the respondent's objection for his affidavit of noncompliance there's no file no it was his case let me get that for you yes yeah we are live officer Hughes we're live so I don't know if you want to step outside you're on camera what case are you here for item 20 is here okay okay but we've lost our code enforcement officer oh that was her case as well is that do you know if that gentleman is part of this case yeah let her know that you're starting file for number 20 either I gave you the motion to remediate yeah I mean I'm perfectly capable of going through here and missing it but can I look through this is already done or those are supposed to be the stuff I've already done you were going to tell me thank you very much that it was in there yeah because I saw it in there I was like I said that's what he's looking for I knew it thank you you're welcome you're great good afternoon my name is Jeff Fuller I'm the special magistrate who is assigned to the Pinellas County Code Enforcement special magistrate agenda for November 16th 2026 welcome to Pinellas County Code Enforcement special magistrate hearings the special magistrate is charged with conducting hearings to determine whether an alleged violation of the county code has occurred in order to meet that obligation all parties or their representatives will be allowed an opportunity to be heard on matters relevant to the alleged violations all witnesses offering testimony or presenting evidence will be required to swear or affirm that the testimony they provide is the truth the order of presentation will begin with the county presenting their evidence of the alleged violations and then the respondent shall present his or her case both parties shall have an opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses the special magistrate may question any witness the clerk will announce the names of the cases from the agenda listen when the clerk is calling the case names because we do not for a variety of reasons necessarily follow the number that's on the agenda when you hear your case called please respond by coming to the podium with your representative and or any witnesses to be sworn in when addressing the special magistrate please speak clearly into the microphone any person who decides to appeal the decision of the code enforcement special magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need a record of the proceedings and for such purposes may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based the record is not provided by Pinellas County Heidi could you call number 20 please item number 20 code enforcement petitioners motion to remediate code violation case number CCM dash twenty five dash zero zero zero zero two four officer B Hughes owner is joy yelster notice address is joy yelster at forty nine oh nine forty seventh avenue north st. petersburg florida three three seven oh nine location violation address is forty nine oh nine forty seventh avenue north st. petersburg florida three three seven oh nine who is here appearing for the county officer Hughes would you please state your name ma'am joy yelster the two of you please raise your right hand you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I do right we're here on petitioners motion to remediate code violation so the county may proceed ma'am you can have a seat at that table right there and then you'll be called up to cross-examine if you have any or to state your your case thank you magistrate so I'm the magistrate officer with the code enforcement division of Pinellas County and pursuant to chapter 2 article 8 of the Pinellas County code and chapter 162 of the Florida statute Pinellas County is seeking a motion to remediate code violations against the following respondent miss joy yelster the property in which the county is seeking reme remediation action is located at 4909 47th avenue st. petersburg florida three three seven zero nine situated in unincorporated Pinellas county the county would like to sit and submit into evidence the motion to remediate code violations which consists of a history of the case and the attached exhibits which I will go through so we have the notice of hearing for today's remediation sent to miss yelster we have the motion to remediate the code violation signed by the housing official jude reason we have exhibit a showing that miss yelster is the property owner per Pinellas county property records exhibit B is the warranty deed recorded 10-20-21 exhibit C is the notice of hearing when we first came before you for May 12th 2025 we have the affidavit violation and request for hearing with multiple code sections at that time 22 299 58 270 58 304 138 3220 138 and 138 90 exhibit D is the order assessing a mutual or excuse me an administrative fine until compliance is achieved exhibit E is the affidavit of non-compliance exhibit F is the lien that was recorded January 9th 2026 and then I have current photos showing the property on October 20 27th 2026 we get multiple complaints from the neighbors surrounding this home it's pretty much been in a state of outdoor storage and trash and debris for quite a quite a long time and it's gotten worse over the last couple of months so we started receiving a barrage of complaints and the housing official did direct us to go ahead and move forward with remediation you can see that there's drywall that's basically acting as a cover she never finished the zoning clearance for the driveway and there's all the pavers surrounding it there's construction material everywhere are in a large portion of the property behind that drywall there's more items being stored something that's new is there's food items that are now sitting rotting on the property in addition to the construction materials there's couches construction materials just a lot of discarded things on the property you can kind of see from a distance that you've got a washing machine that's been there for probably a year again just all the materials outside and all the way up to the front door I'm not sure if you can actually this is all by the front door it's almost impossible to even post the front door because there's so many items to try to get to it so the property continues to be owned by the respondent the petitioner has an interest in the property by virtue of Pinellas County code enforcement special magistrate lien in the amount of over twenty thousand two hundred seventy nine dollars this lien has been accruing daily fines in addition to interest the petitioner has provided respondents respondent with notice that the property was found to be in violation of the county's ordinance the petitioner provided respondent with notice that the property remained in violation of the county's ordinances after the respondent was afforded due process and given a period in which to cure remedy the violations of the county's ordinance at the property the respondent had actual or implied knowledge of the process and procedures employed by the petitioner is code enforcement division and special magistrate for the imposition of code enforcement lien the property has remained in continuous non-compliance for more than one and a half years following the magistrate ruling and no efforts have been made by the respondent to bring the property into compliance with the executed order i have been in contact by email with ms yoester on many occasions and had let her know a few months ago that we were looking to possibly do the remediation should it not come into compliance so magistrate based on the evidence provided in the motion the county request that you issue an order granting pinellas county the ability to make all reasonable repairs to bring the property into compliance for the trash and debris violation and the outdoor storage violation and charge the violator with reasonable cost of the repairs along with the fine and post ms yoester do you have any questions for officer hughes like this is the first i heard about any lien on my property for one thing but i've cleaned it up it's i got pictures if you want to see it i was cleaning until like one o'clock today all the pavers are gone no not the pavers because i did i was told that the that i did get the zoning clearance to complete a driveway yeah i just haven't started it yet it was so hot all summer i couldn't even get out there so i mean now that it's cool i'm happy to and i'm sorry i have depression my doctor just changed my medication about a month ago so it seems to be helping i don't want to lose my house so are all the construction materials that are in the front all the rotted food is gone we you want to see pictures sure you can show pictures you can put it right here okay i need to um so i my lawn work broke halfway through doing the lawn yesterday but i got most of it i was pulling the rest out my hand um so i put all this in since the last time all that landscaping i've been trying to do stuff but my i just sometimes i'm planning on um getting shells the whole front yard's going to be shelves so i bought all this stuff to put shells down so this won't happen again um i covered the pavers but they're still there um so i have to um tear up the driveway because they told me i have to all the work that i've done already i have to undo it to tear up the drive the asphalt i'm not allowed to have it on top of the asphalt gotcha so i have to take all the pavers i've laid already off get rid of the asphalt and then um i can start to do the paver driveway again i've taken time off to get this done this is still i still have some work to do i just took this picture to show you that i've cleaned up like all the junk is gone it's all just landscaping how the lean thing happens like was i supposed to be made aware of that when you were sent the affidavit of non-compliance it says which was when like the last time there was just one affidavit of non-compliance that was not a two but you said it was january it was recorded in january so i've been getting fines every day since january since the compliance due date right anything further ma'am this is the county so magistrate the picture she showed me does show significant improvement um it looks like what i would like to propose today is um even if you were to grant this motion today which i would like to have granted we do wait 30 days before moving forward with a remediation in case there's an appeal if it comes into compliance then we would have no reason to remediate we would much prefer to see her come into compliance than for us to do the remediation so i will still simply because it has been so it's been a very long time with very little change the driveway never got completed the washing machine has been there i've made continuous inspections left note cards on the door emailed her that remediation would be a possibility if it didn't come into compliance and as i said it was getting worse if the pictures reflect what it currently looks like i would say it looks like a significant improvement has been made the county would much prefer that she comes into compliance and we don't do the remediation i would still like it approved today if you would grant it and of course within 30 days if um it's in compliance or close we would not move forward with the motion i think what i'm going to do is continue this hearing i'm a little giving her 30 days and then you decide whether or not i i think i need to be the interim intermediary um can we do it january 11th um our january dates are i think they could either be the 27th or the 22nd for code enforcement the what january 27th or january 22nd okay i got both of those but i had two the 11th and 15th they're gone and they're not gone but they are reserved um code enforcement we have them for january 27th and then they're it's backwards but their overflow date is the 22nd so it could either be either of those two days we already have cases for those two days okay why don't we go with the 22nd okay so it's going to be more than 30 days that that's which with the driveway issue you may need more than 30 days and by the pictures i i'm gonna that's fine thank you i'll get it but right now it's accruing like every day there's a fine it's been accruing fines ever since the deadline day like a hundred dollars a day um i don't remember that to look and you'll do an order rescheduling yes or i will do the order rescheduling well we would do an order of continue or continuance yeah um and then do an order of continuance yes and we'll send it to you june 22nd january january 22nd 2027 it's hard to say january 20 yes thank you very much you'll receive an order in the in the mail okay thank you majesty do you need to check that first or you want to yeah go ahead what is the rb you right back oh where have you been grandma how do you see the brb i'm like what is it get with it yeah the virtual person is not there okay i move on to item 19. great yeah is mr mcgregor here okay yes let's please read item 19. okay item 19 code enforcement this is a respondent's objection to affidavit of non-compliance case number ccm-25-00099 officer b hughes the owner is kai uh is that hun notice address is kai hun at 16108 49th street north clearwater florida 33762 did i do something wrong i don't know does yours look different my mine looks different yours does look different different addresses different names yep from what his um agenda looks different than mine perhaps this is agenda say something of sedan i'm sorry yeah i'm saltan and argus yeah that was the one we so we fixed it this morning so hi um miss miss hardstock has the correct one do you want to look at mine i do want to look at yours real quick here sure so sorry mrs riley found that that was the one we just yeah thank you you're welcome notes are then i'm gonna hit you on it okay thanks we just have to flip another page okay all right mcgregor this is your motion um to extend to extend i hope pardon to extend yeah okay respondents well respondents objecting the affidavit of non-compliance is the way that it's worded and you had continued it once all right yes we continue uh uh all i know we're waiting on the engineer that's the that's the um how would you say it the um uh the hold up and i think the last thing we've done was in september is that is that when you responded yeah alex okay i'm not sure and i had a kidney stone in the last two weeks of october so i've been out out of the picture for a little bit and i did we had a death in the family at the beginning of october so october has just been kind of blank to me so i haven't been keeping up with what says the county um basically uh the when the compliance deadline was approaching they had asked for 30 days and we did give an additional 30 days however when that 30 days passed they still didn't have the permit um for the additional structures that were added to the property as a result of that we did do the affidavit of non-compliance they did the objection to that and we were before you i believe the reason that you gave the continuance at that time was because they had just applied for the permit um so we were back again today and the uh basically the the permit for the additional structures that were added to the property is still not still has not been issued it currently is in awaiting applicant action as of september 14th of 2026. and that applicant's action is the engineer you're talking about uh they did apply for the permit and now they're waiting and then they responded now they sent it to the engineer and they're waiting for the engineer to do the i guess the structural design so that it'd be approved by uh their department and i do know that they're entering for that sorry do you have any idea for a time frame for that well they told me they're meeting the engineer tomorrow and the engineer's name is pierre m veils v-a-l-l-e-s and the drafts person is jess russell those are the two that are really the reason if there's any delay is based on their schedule i suppose but they do have an engineer and they're paid the clients do pay on time that's that's a good thing contractor is garden incorporated g-a-a-r-d anything further in the county uh just that the original deadline date was may 9th and we're basically uh six months later and it's been basically back on the client's end for two months now um so i still believe it is in non-compliance um so at this point it's an objection to the non-compliance and i believe it still is in non-compliance i will agree that's in non-compliance just but that's just based on the permitting once the permit is issued it will be uh corrected very quickly all right i'm going to overrule the objection to the affidavit of non-compliance maybe the fact that i'm denying this will put a little fire under the engineer and the draftsman kid it might very well do that and i do apologize but i was really out of the pocket october i wasn't in town and then i suffered from some i've done the kidney stone thing so you have my sympathy they're terrible is the virtual one here yet no not at all you go to two of them is that the virtual one yeah we will go to item one 12 is the Richmond we good to go yeah one and two are simply read-ins that i will remark to okay let's proceed to item one okay uh next case is item one this is a re rescheduled for january 27th 2027 code enforcement code sections 138-90 and 154-231 zoning cases case number ccm-26-00068 officer b hughes owner is clearview oaks management condo association inc 90 9887 4th street north suite 104 st petersburg florida 33702 violation address is 40th avenue north kenneth city florida 33709 and parcel id 04-31-16-16-16-110-000-0001 okay that item it's my understanding has been rescheduled for january 27th 2027 correct correct okay please read item number two item number two rescheduled rescheduled it says two november 13th yes that was um heard on friday we backed it up okay go go ahead and read it and i will announce that it's already been heard okay department code enforcement matter 22-299 minimum housing 58-304 trash and debris 138-3220 zoning code case number ccm-26-00130 officer b hughes owner is beth doran notice address is beth doran in care of mary doran 11134 91st avenue north seminal florida 33772 the violation address is 7290 55th avenue north st petersburg florida 33709 okay it's my understanding that uh magistrate matthew heard that november 13th 2026 correct last friday correct all right read in item number three okay item number three continued from october 12 2026 code enforcement uh code section is 58-444 noise ordinance 22-299 minimum housing case number ccm-26-00123 officer b hughes owner is jeffrey borvis notice address is jeffrey borvis at 7801 63rd way north panellas park florida 33781 violation address is 6615 27th street north st petersburg florida 33702 is there anyone here for that case who's here for the county officer hughes okay is jeffrey borvis or anybody for this case here no one has signed in registry i continued this october 12th of 2026 on the petitioner's motion for continuance um you heard from mr borvis since then so not me directly but this morning he contacted our office and he said he had court today and he was out of town i believe um officer hughes might have some information it's if there's a note stating that at today for today's hearing it was sent by mail which is our department but by also email and the property was posted so i don't know if officer hughes has more to elaborate but um he just was out of town it says what do you know officer hughes since the continuance what conversations if any you've had or emails sure so basically uh this the code violations on the agenda were not accurate it's a short-term rental case um so it's actually the minimum housing just for short-term rental certificate and for having the advertising correct and basically i'm going to be testifying today that he is in compliance and request a finding of fact order he basically did not want to do the finding of fact order he disagreed that he was in violation it did get continued he was emailed that it would be today's date he was mailed the notice of hearing that it would be today's date and i posted the property so he is he was very well aware that it would be scheduled for today i did ask my supervisor when he did get his certificate whether they wanted me to continue with requesting a finding of fact and i was told yes i emailed him that and that's when he stated that he disagreed that he was in violation or had been in violation were citations issued on this uh let me see i don't believe so let me double check the street no no magistrate and i usually add them to the case if they did write them so so so what sections are we dealing with here what's on the notice of violation is what um it should be for 22 319 g1 22 319 i1 and 22 319 i2 all right um could you please raise your right hand do you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do county may proceed uh so magistrate the property where the violation exists is located in unincorporated pinellas county 6615 27th street north st petersburg florida 33702 the owner mr jeffrey borbus um is not today here today um however as i stated he was informed last week that it would be on today's date the violations have been on occurrence since our before july 1st of 2026 and i would like to enter the order granting a continuance and composite exhibit a into evidence which includes the notice of violations pinellas county tax collector property appraiser the warranty deed the short-term rental listings and the advertisements right hearing no objection exhibit one will be admitted into evidence so again the first document is the order granting the continuance to today's date we have the notice of violation for the short-term rental dated july 1st of 2026 for 22 319 g1 i1 and i2 we have the tax collector document showing mr borbus as the owner of the property pinellas county property appraiser showing the same the warranty deed showing him as the owner and we have the document showing that he was advertising this as a short-term rental this was as of september 23rd 2026 he had multiple rooms listed as short-term rentals you can see that it's active minimum number of one so being less than 30 and multiple documented stays you have listings showing that it's an active rent rental multiple reviews showing that stayed one night stayed one night stayed a few nights stayed a few nights so it's actively being used as a short-term rental another listing showing it's active minimum of one night same thing showing multiple documented stays again another listing active one night multiple documented stays another listing active minimum of one night and again more documented stays and just another advertising showing the short-term rental more reviews showing that people are staying there and again another listing and and this property had quite a few rooms being listed. So, Magistrate, the property was reinspected on November 9th, and the violations continue. The short-term rental listings and advertisements continue. The owner submitted his short-term rental application on October 2nd of 2026. So, basically, I do have the documents that I'd like to submit to show that he didn't have the short-term rental certificate at the time and was still advertising as such in advocacy. So, basically, it does show that he did apply for it, and fees were still due as November 6th. He was still advertising it as an active listing, minimum nights of one, so still using it as a short-term rental, had multiple documented stays, had changed the advertisement. This time to the entire house versus separate rooms, but was still advertising for less than 30 days and had three different reviews already for the property. You can see here a week ago, a week ago, and two weeks ago. However, on November 10th of 2026, STR 26-00866 was issued. The advertising has been corrected, and it is now and currently in compliance. So, Magistrate, the county request that you find the property was in violation of 22319G1, 22319I1, and 22319I2, that it was in violation and is now in complied, an issue of finding a fact order for Code Sections 22319G1, 22319G1, 22319G1, and award costs in the amount of, Caroline, $230? Correct. $230. All right. I misspoke and accepted Exhibit 1 into evidence. It's Exhibit A. Okay. And then here is Exhibit B that will be admitted into evidence as well. That's the rule. All right. I'm going to find that there was a violation of Code Section 22-319G1, a violation of Code Section 22-319I1, and Code Section 22-319I2. I'm going to find that as of today's date, the property has been brought into compliance. So I'm making a finding of fact that there was a violation of those three statutes. I will also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Magistrate. Okay. Let's move to item number four. Item number four, Code Enforcement 22-319G, 22-319I, minimum housing for short-term rental, Case number CCM-26-00124, Officer Stevens. Owner is AP Properties, Inc. Notice address is AP Properties, Inc. 27100, Coyote Ridge Lane, Johnstown, Colorado, 80534. Violation address is 12091-96 Place, Seminole, Florida, 33772. Who is here for that case? Officer Stevens, but also kind of Code Enforcement, sir. Has anyone signed in for this case? No, Magistrate. Nobody's here for case number CCM-26-00124. I'm looking at the room, and I can account. I know everybody that's in here and why they're here. Have we heard anything about this hearing from anyone from AP Properties? No, Magistrate. You continued the order last time. Or, continued the order, I'm sorry. You did an order of continuance last hearing, and the certified came back for the continuance order, returned to sender to address that was on the record. Any claimant? Magistrate, I did have a conversation with him a few days ago. He's unable to be making it out here. He does reside in Colorado, and he is currently working on his short-term rental application and is almost completed with it. So, we can continue with our proceedings today, and then at the end, I would like to afford him the 30 days to get that taken care of. Okay. Please raise your right hand. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. You may proceed. Yes, Magistrate. The property where the alleged violation exists is 1209196 Place, located in Seminole, Florida, 33772, in the unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, AP, properties, and corporate are not present or represented for today's hearing. The violations have been an occurrence since around or before September 1st of 2026, and I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing, composite Exhibit A in the evidence, which includes the Notice of Violation, Pinellas County Tax Collector, property appraiser, deed, information letter from our Pinellas County Housing Official, dated March 28, 2025, information letter from our Pinellas County Housing Official, dated August 18, 2025, a warning notice for Pinellas County Housing Official, dated November 25, 2025, and a cell report showing no STR application, a rental unit record, and multiple active Airbnb, booking.com, homes and villas by Marriott, VRBO, website listings showing all active. Okay, exhibit number one will be admitted into evidence. Again, this is the Notice of Hearing. Consists of four pages, and then the Notice of Violations, dated 9-11 or 9-1 of 2026, to AP Properties Incorporated. And the next few are the Tax Collector, with AP Properties Incorporated, the property appraiser, and the warranty deed. This includes the Department of Corporations out of Colorado for that property. And the gentleman I've been speaking to is the owner, Patrick L. Glasgow. who is noted on this as the registered agent. The next three pages, or the next three documents, will be the information letters that we sent out, dated March 28th, August 18th, and a warning notice for November 25th. The next is going to be the rental unit application, I'm sorry, the seller record for the property, which at this point in time, dated 9-24, there was no status and no active application started. The next one is going to be the unit record for the actual property at 1209196th place. It is showing active, and you can see active listings, the last one being 8-25-2026, and numerous documented stays throughout the document here. Again, the first one will be the Airbnb. Even though it's showing below the 10 guests that are approved, it does not have any of the required documentation needed for under 22319 subsection I, which is for advertisement. And again, on this date and time, I was able to book this property showing its active status. The next one will be the booking.com, which is almost identical to the other one, showing no documentation at all whatsoever for the advertisement that we require. Homes and villas, the same. And again, I was able to book that property. And the VRBO, again, I was able to book this one for six nights at $1,488. Magistrate, the property was reinspected on September 24th of 2026, initially, and again on 15 November. And the violations continue. Desk investigation was completed on this date, and I would like to submit them as a composite Exhibit B. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B will be admitted into evidence. These documents are almost identical to the other documents that I presented earlier, Magistrate. The only difference is, on this record here, it does show an active application for a short-term rental, which is almost complete. And this is the unit record for the actual property itself. And again, we talked about the property being rented out back in August, and it's actually still being active and currently being rented out as a short-term rental. We have the Airbnb almost identical to the last one. No changes in the websites. I have since sent him, Mr. Glasgow, a template on how each one of these websites should book in accordance to our ordinance. The Booking.com, identical to the one you saw previous, Magistrate. Does not have any of the documentation required in our ordinance. Same thing for Evolve. And again, on all of these, I'm still able to book days for these properties, so it's still showing them active. Same for Expedia. The new one that popped up, FreeCancellations.com, still able to book. Homes and Villas, identical to the first one that we showed earlier. Again, I was able to book it today at the price of $1,500 VRBO. Same. Wimstay is a new one that I've located, showing nine guests, three beds, and two baths, like all the others. Again, no documentation at all whatsoever under 22319, subsection I. I was able to book this property as well. Magistrate, the county requests that you find the property in violation and issue an order to have the property brought into compliance. Magistrate, the county is asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply, and if still found in violation, assign a single daily fine of $500 per day for each violation under 22319G and 22319I and also court costs of $230. All right. Since the hearing started, I haven't seen anybody come into the room and just like when I started it, I know everybody here and why they're here. Did you hear anything further from AP Properties? No, Magistrate. All right. I'm going to find that there is a violation of Code Section 22-319, subsection G, order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days. 30 days is December 16th, 2026 at 5 p.m. I'm going to find there is a violation of Code Section 22-319, subsection I, order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16th, 2026 by 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine of $500 per day. Also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Magistrate. Caroline, any news of our virtual person? No, and I believe Officer Stevens has tried to call as well and no contact. I sent an email as well. We do have a joint stipulation. I believe I provided that for you. She was here for a hearing. Ms. Truckee was here for a hearing on Friday, and she flew back to Wisconsin, I believe, on Saturday. so we were able to have a joint stipulation here done at the hearing, but since it was scheduled for Monday for today, we just had her attend virtually. But has she actually signed the joint stip? Yes, she did. She signed it. Oh, okay. I believe I... Yeah, she was just going to appear to swear in to see that she was the person who signed it, but she was here for a previous case, and it's... I think it's on the last page. No, I'm going to second to that. There you go. Oh, okay. Yeah, so I was... I don't know if we could just read it into record and that we've had a joint stip done. Yeah, and we'll bring the code officer up. Item 12. Yes, item 12. Please read item 12. Item 12 rescheduled from September 21, 2026. Code enforcement, Section 22-319I, Minimum Housing, Short-Term Rental, 138-90 Zoning Case, Case Number CCM, dash 26, dash 00136. Officer Stevens, owner is Truckee Properties, LLC. Notice address is Truckee, Truck Key Properties, LLC. W2009, Finnegan's Ridge Lane, Freedom, is that Wisconsin? Yes. Okay. I'm sorry, 54130. Violation address is 8262, 132nd Street, North Seminole, Florida, 33776. All right. Who's here representing the county? Officer Stevens, Pinellas County Code Enforcement. It is my understanding that the parties have reached a joint stipulation for code violation, code section violation of 138-90, have agreed on a compliance date of 30 days, which is December 16th, 2026 at 5 p.m. A daily fine amount in the amount of $100 per day, and costs the amount of $420. It is signed by Cara Truckee and signed by you, Officer Stevens. Is that correct? That is correct, Magister. Okay. I've reviewed the joint stipulation and will execute the order for joint stipulation, assessing an administrative fine until compliance is achieved. Thank you, Magister. Thank you. Did you get the orders I put on top of your computer? I meant to tell you and I forgot. That's who, item 11. Back to item 11. Caroline, I have Exhibit B on this, but I don't have Exhibit A. For which one? Number 11, which is Avia, Fonseca, Giovanna, Maccaro-Highland. You don't have the Exhibit A? You do? Okay, thank you. I believe that was one that we continued from... It's going to be a final note back. Yes, yeah, that was a final note. Okay. Heidi, would you go ahead and read item 11? Item 11, rescheduled from September 21st, 2026. Code enforcement. There is no code. Minimum housing. Short-term rental. Case number CCM-26-00092. Officer Stevens, owner Avila Fonseca. I'm sorry, that's the last name. First name is Giovanna R. The second name is Elizabeth Vaccaro-Highland. Notice address, Giovanna R. Avila Fonseca. And Elizabeth Vaccaro-Highland. Mailing address is 4505 Lake Place, Parish, Florida, 34219. Violation address is 10437, 52nd Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33708. Who is here for the county? Officer Stevens, Pinellas County Code Enforcement. Is there anyone else here for case number CCM 260092? As I indicated at the last hearing, I know everybody that's in the room, and I know why they're here. So, county may proceed. Would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. Proceed. Magistrate, the property where the alleged violation exists is 10437 52nd Avenue North in St. Petersburg, Florida, 33708. Located in unincorporated Pinellas County, the owner, Giovanna R. Avila Fonseca and Elizabeth Vaccaro-Highland, are not present for today's hearing. They weren't able to make it, considering that it's going to be a finding of the fact case. Magistrate, would you like me to continue? Yes, please. The violations have been occurring since on or before June 4th of 2026. I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence, which includes a notice of violations, Pinellas County tax collector, property appraiser, deed, information letter from our Pinellas County housing official dated March 28th of 2025, information letter from our Pinellas County housing official dated August 15th, 2025, a warning notice from our Pinellas County housing official dated October 20th of 2025, a solid report showing an unfinished STR application, an umbrella unit number of record, an active Airbnb listing. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence. I'd like to show the Notice of Rescheduling Magistrate. It consists of two pages. The Notice of Hearing, that was dated from September 21st of 2026. The Original Notice of Violation on 6-4-2026. And then the Pinellas County tax collector for the subjects that I just spoke about earlier, property appraiser, the deed, and the next three documents are the information letters that are sent out. This is the Acela report showing the short-term rental application and the re-inspection status. This is the Acela platform for the short-term rental application that she was taken care of. Since then, the inspection is complete and the certificate of use has been issued to both parties. Again, this is going to be the rental unit record for that property as well, showing active status with numerous documented stays during that time frame. Then an active Airbnb website, again, at the time not showing any type of requirements under 22319, subsection I. Magistrate, the property was re-inspected on August 28th of 2026 originally, and then again this morning on November 15th, 2026. And the violations have been abated. A desk investigation was completed on this date, and there was no reason to submit a composite Exhibit B in that case. Magistrate, the county is asking for the finding of facts for Code Sections 22319G and 22319I and the responsibility of paying court costs of $230 associated to this case. Thank you. Thank you. I am going to find that there was a violation of Code Section 22-319G, that it has been abated. So I'm making a finding of fact, and it will make no further order. I'm going to find that there is a violation of Code Section 22-319I, that it has now been abated. So I'm making a finding of fact with no further order, and I will assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Madam Strick. I don't think I have one on this one. For 13? Mm-hmm. Booth. What's the name of the person? Booth. Booth. Booth. That was one we continued as well. Officer Stevens, do you have Mr. Booth? Do you have another packet for Mr. Booth? Yeah, it's on the table already. Oh, it's on the table. Oh, so then that means you... Oh, no. Now it's here. Okay. So many cases were all over the place. Mm-hmm. Mr. Booth, you're welcome. The other one's here, too. Do you want me to get on to him? Okay. Heidi, would you read item number 13 from the agenda? Item 13, rescheduled from September 21st, 2026. Code enforcement, short-term rental violation. Case number CCM-26-00104. Officer Stevens, owner is James J. Booth. Notice address is James J. Booth, 8532, 42nd Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709. Violation address is 8532, 42nd Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709. Who is here for the county? Officer Stevens, Spinellis County Code Enforcement. Has James Booth or anyone else signed in for this case? No, magistrate. Have you heard anything by voicemail or email concerning this hearing? No, magistrate. All right. I see everyone who's in the room. I know who they are and why they're here. So the county may proceed. Would you please raise your right hand? Do you sort of tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. All right. I didn't want to interrupt you, magistrate. I did speak to Mr. Booth's son-in-law, Mr. Seville. Unfortunately, he cannot speak for Mr. Booth because he did not have a power of attorney. He had a power of attorney for one aspect of his legal issues, and so we're going to proceed with today's thing. Thank you. The property where the alleged violation exists is 8532 42nd Avenue Street, located in St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709 in the unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, James J. Booth, is not present or represented for today's hearing. The violations have been an occurrence on or before August 25th of 2026, and I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing, composite Exhibit A into evidence, which includes the Notice of Violation, the Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser, Deed, Seller Records for the Property, the Rental Unit Record, Airbnb Website Listing, and VRBO Website Listing. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence. Magistrate, the first two pages are going to be a Notice of Rescheduling. The next four pages will be the Notice of Hearing. That was dated on September 21st, 2026. The next document is the Notice of Violation, dated 825 to 2026. And the next few documents will be a County Tax Collector showing James J. Booth as the legal owner of the property, the property appraiser. The next one will be the Acela showing no status in an application being pulled for that property. The only reason he cannot pull a permit for the short-term rental is because he has the substantial damage issue with his property from the storms. And he's unable to pull that. He is currently in a, has an appeal with the County to get that reassessed. The next one is going to be the Rental Unit Record showing an active status. At the time, it was being rented. It is no longer being rented. This is the Airbnb website. It does not show any of the documentation that's needed under 22319, subsection I. And again, at that time, this property could be rented for four nights at that cost. And the VRBO, same difference. No information pertaining to what is required under our ordinance. And again, it could be rented for three nights at that cost. Magistrate, the property was re-inspected on September 1st, 2026, and then again on October 14th, 2026, and again this morning, 15 November, I'm sorry, on the 15th of November, 2026, and the violations continue. However, the property is currently awaiting to be sold to his father-in-law. And he confided with me this morning that him and his family are going to be moving into that property, which would make it no longer a short-term rental. Desk investigation was completed on this date, and I would like to submit the rest of the information under composite Exhibit B, if possible. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B is admitted into evidence. Magistrate, no change in the seller record except for there is an appeal for the substantial damage case, which they're working on. Again, the active rental unit record showing it's still active, but it hasn't been rented at all since September. And the Airbnb website, still showing active with no information under 22319 subsection I, and that will be for this and the next VRB website. Again, I can rent the property for five nights at that cost, no change. Same VRB website as previously shown. Magistrate, the county requests that you find the property in violation and issue an order to have the property brought into compliance. Magistrate, the county is asking for an allowance of 30 days to comply, and if still found in violation, assign a single daily fine amount of $500 per day for each violation of 22319 subsection G, and 22319 subsection I, and code section, plus a court cost of $230. To bring it into compliance, what they need to do is either add the statements or delete the advertisements, am I right? That is correct. Actually, both, magistrate, because they'll be unable to actually get a short-term rental certificate of use until the substantial damage issue has been resolved. His way around coming into compliance, magistrate, is to sell the property to his son-in-law, and his son-in-law and his family are going to move into that property until they can get the substantial damage issue resolved, and then deal with, you know, the short-term rental at another time if they choose. But I would allow them the 30 days to get that taken care of. All right. I'm going to find that there is a violation of code section 22-13G, order that the property brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16th, 2026, at 5 p.m. I am going to find there is a violation of code section 22-319I, order that the property be brought in compliance within 30 days, which is December 16th, 2026, at 5 p.m. Failing to do so will assess a fine in the amount of $500 per day. I will also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Madam Secretary. Would you please read item number 14? Code enforcement, matter 22-298, minimum housing, 22-299, minimum housing, 58-270, inoperable vehicle, 154-231, right-of-way. Case number CCM-26-00142. Officer Hughes, owner, is Sean Patrick Carr. Notice address, Sean Patrick Carr, 4530 County Road 16, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709. Violation address, 4530 County Road 16, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709. Who is here for the county? Officer Hughes. Is anyone here, in particular, is Sean Patrick Carr here, or anyone for case number CCM-26-00142? No, magistrate. Anybody sign in for this case? No, magistrate. Heard anything by voicemail or email? No, magistrate. I am surveying the courtroom, and there's nobody in here that I don't know who they are and why they're here, so we will proceed with the case. Would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. You may proceed. Thank you, magistrate. The property where the violation exists is 4530 County Road 16, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33709, located in unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, Sean Carr Patrick, is not present for today's hearing, and I've had no contact with him. However, I have had some contact with his aunt, who is currently trying to obtain power of attorney for him. The violations have been in occurrence since on or before December 12th of 2025. I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence, which includes the Notice of Violations, Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser Documents, the Quit Claim Deed, a Condemnation Notice, Citations, and Violation Photos. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence. Did you want me to go straight to the pictures or go through each document? Please go through the documents for the record. Perfect. Okay, so the first document is the Notice of Hearing for today's date. Exhibit A includes the Notice of Violation documents for the minimum housing. Again, for the minimum housing, so the first minimum housing was sent in December of 2025. They sent another one in August because a tenant was living at the property with no power, so they added the 22-298 for occupying the property with no power. The next Notice of Violations for the inoperable vehicle, the trash and debris, and for parking and storing an inoperable RV in the right-of-way. Then we have the Tax Collector Documents showing Mr. Carr as the owner of record. The Pinellas County property appraiser was the same. The Quit Claim Deed. Next is the Condemnation Notice of September 26th, again, making it not habitable by the housing official due to no power. You have the citation that was written and adjudicated guilty back in August for the minimum housing and for the inoperable vehicle and the right-of-way. I did check and was told by Duke Power on October 2026 that there was still not an active legal power at the property. And on October 8th, I visited the property. The Condemnation Notice was still posted. You had the minimum housing violations of boarded windows. The soffit is falling off. You have rotted peeling paint, rotted wood, chipping siding. You have the inoperable vehicle, which is the RV that is currently not operable, nor does it have a current tag. You have the trash and debris items, just like a broken window lying against the property, the table, fish tanks, boards, trash, overgrowth. The reason it was written in the right-of-way as well is you can see where the electric line is. Half of it, or at least a third of it, is in the right-of-way along with some discarded furniture. So, Magistrate, the property was reinspected again on November 6th of 2026, and I would like to enter the... Our photos were taken on that date, and I would like to submit them as composite Exhibit B. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B is admitted into evidence. Okay, so again, on November 6th, I went back to the property. The windows are still boarded. There's still poo and paint. The soffit's still falling down. The siding is still in disrepair. You've got the RV, which is still inoperable, does not have a current tag on the property. The overgrowth and items of debris. And again, it's either like one-third to one-half of it is in the right-of-way. The aunt did tell me that the person, the tenant that was living on the property is no longer there, so that it is vacant. And she is trying to get a power of attorney because until she has that, she can't help bring the violations into compliance. Her nephew, I believe, is in a rehab down south, and so she is aware of it. He is aware of it. But she just needs to get that power of attorney finished so that she can actually start trying to get the violations in compliance. So, Magistrate, the county is asking for the allowance of 30 days, excuse me, 45 days to comply, and if still found in violation, to assign a daily fine amount of $100 per day per violation for Code Sections 22-299, 58-270, 58-304, and 154-231. And we are also requesting a finding of fact order for 22-298. That's the one where they were living on the property without power just in case someone does move back in. I am requesting a finding of fact order for that and to award court costs in the amount of $230. Okay. The 22-298, you're requesting finding of fact. Yes, sir. 22-299, you're seeking a compliance order. Yes, sir. I have a 58-270, and you're seeking a compliance order. Yes, sir. And then I have a 154-231. And also a 58-304 for the trash and debris and the overgrowth. All right. Since the hearing started, have we heard anything from Mr. Carr? No, Magistrate. And no one has come in the room that wasn't here when we started. Okay. I'm going to find that there was a violation of 22-298. I'm going to find that it has been abated. So I'm just making a finding of fact on that and will make no further order. I'm going to find a violation of Code Section 22-299, order that the property brought into compliance within 45 days, which is January 1, 2027 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a finding amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find a violation of Code Section 58-270, order that the property be brought into compliance within 45 days, which is January 1, 2027 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a finding amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find that there is a violation of Code Section 154-231, order that the property be brought into compliance within 45 days, which is January 1, 2027 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a finding amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find that there is a violation of Code Section 58-304, order that the property be brought into compliance within 45 days, which is January 1, 2027 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a finding amount of $100 per day. I will also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Magistrate. Would you please read item number 15? Item 15, Code Enforcement, Code Section 138-90, Zoning, Case Number CCM-26-00152, Officer Duvall, owner is Eleanor Erna Adam, trustee Eleanor Erna Adam, revocable living trust. Notice address, Eleanor Erna Adam, trustee Eleanor Erna Adam, revocable living trust, 2010 Greenbrier Boulevard, Unit 309, Clearwater, Florida 33763, violation address, 2821 State Road 590, Clearwater, Florida 33759. All right, is there anyone here for this case? Case number CCM-26-00152, Eleanor Erna Adam here. I'm looking around the room, and everyone who's in the room, I know who they are, and I know why they're here. Did anybody sign in for this case? No, Magistrate. Have you got any voicemails or emails concerning this hearing? No, Magistrate. Right, who's here on behalf of the county? Officer Duvall, Pinellas County Code Enforcement. Please raise your right hand. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. County may proceed. Thank you, Magistrate. This property where the alleged violation exists is located at 2821 State Road 590 in Clearwater, Florida, which is in unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, Eleanor Erna Adam, is not present for today's hearing. This violation has been an occurrence since on or before April 8th of 2026. I'd like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence. Exhibit A includes the Notice of Violation, Ownership Confirmation through Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser, and the deed. Inspection photos are also included. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence. Okay. The first four pages are the Notice of Hearing sent to the property owner at the address of record. Next is the Notice of Violation for Code Section 13890, which is a zoning violation sent to the property owner in April 8th of 2026. Then we do have from Pinellas County Tax Collector showing the tax bill and the ownership of Eleanor Adam as a revocable living trust. Property Appraiser reflecting exactly the same. The quick claim deed from August of 2023. And then some pictures. This is somewhat of a simplistic violation. It is a zoning violation for not obtaining a zoning clearance for a metal carport-type structure that was installed in the back of the property. It was actually seeded into the ground with concrete. The zone officer was able to confirm it because she was able to get actually back onto the backyard. There is a renter in the property right now, and the renter did allow her to go back there, and she did confirm that the posts are into the ground. My inspections, I was not able to make contact with the renter, but I could see that it was still in the ground. This was an open gate area on the side of the property, so I did see it was still on property. And then this is just from the front of the property. You can still see the metal roofing there. So, Magistrate, the property was re-inspected on November 6th, and the violation continued. Photos were taken on that date, and I'd like to submit them as composite Exhibit B, and I do believe you have a copy of them as well. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B is admitted into evidence, and yes, I do have a copy of it. Okay. So, this is actually on the day of posting as well. I did take just a picture of the front of the property, and I was not able to take a picture from the side yard again. The gate was closed. There was a big truck parked there. I was not able to obtain a picture like I was for my Exhibit A's. But I can still see that the roof line exists. It comes just above the six-foot-high fencing. It is still present on the property. Magistrate, I also did a bit of a search through our database to see if any zoning clearance had been initiated, and there actually had been one that was applied for back in June, but it was deemed to be incomplete, and it was also submitted by the tenant and not the property owner themselves or any representative from the property. So, it was not complete, and it was not processed any further. So, nothing has been done since June when that was initially applied for. So, Magistrate, the county requests you find the property in violation and issue an order to have the property brought into compliance. I do just have my closing. All right. You may proceed with your closing. The county is asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply and if still found in violation, assign a fine in the amount of $100 per day for Code Section 138-90 and award costs of $230 for today's hearing. All right. I'm going to find that there is a violation of Code Section 138-90 order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so will assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. Also, assess the cost, the amount of $230. Great. Thank you, Magistrate. We still have a couple of items to do, but we've been going for two hours, so I'm going to take a 10-minute recess. Communications, please stop recording. Ready for... Ready. Would you please call item number 16. Okay. Code enforcement, 58-270 inoperable vehicle, 58-304, trash and debris, 138-3220 for outdoor storage. Case number CCM-26-00153. Officer Duvall, owner is Robert L. Eli. Notice address is Robert L. Eli, 975-14th Avenue South, Safety Harbor, Florida, 34695. Violation address, 975-14th Avenue South, Safety Harbor, Florida, 34695. Is there anyone here for case number CCM-26-00153? Is there a Robert Ely here? Did anyone sign in for this case? No, Magistrate. Have you received any voicemails or emails about this hearing? No, Magistrate. Okay, I am surveying the room, and everybody here, I know who they are and why they're here. Who's appearing for the county? Officer Duvall from Pinellas County Code Enforcement. Would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. You may proceed. Magistrate, this property where the alleged violation exists is located at 975-14th Avenue South in Safety Harbor, Florida, which is located in unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, Robert Ely, is not present for today's hearing. This violation has been an occurrence since on or before September 3rd of 2026. I'd like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence. Exhibit A includes the Notices of Violation, Ownership Confirmation through Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser, and the Deed. Inspection photos are also included. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted. Thank you. The first four pages are the Notice of Hearing sent to the property owner at the address of record for today's hearing. Next are the Notices of Violation. First one is for the inoperable vehicles on the property. Second is for Trash and Debris. And the third notice is for Outdoor Storage. We have Ownership Confirmation through Tax Collector showing Robert Ely as the owner and Property Appraiser showing the same. The Quick Claim Deed for the property. We'll start with some photos. We have a picture of the front of the property and parked on the lawn in front of the property is a Chevy SUV of some sort. It does not have a current tag at all. The grass is very thick around it, so I couldn't quite tell if this tire was flat or if it was just sunk into the grass with the grass growing up around it, but it definitely has no current tag attached. The vehicle in the driveway actually does have a current tag. Again, just a shot of the front of the property and then up around the front door. When I went to try to make contact with the property owner, it was bags of trash up around the front and some other trash over by the trash receptacle itself. This is over on the side of the property. And then we have some overgrowth down the other side of the property. And the outdoor storage is actually located on the side. So again, this is the front. This is the side of the property. And as I walked more over to the neighboring property and was able to get a better angle, we have quite a bit of outdoor storage along the whole side of the property. There's an actual motorcycle there. I'm not sure if it's currently registered or not, but there's just other miscellaneous items. There's a car windshield that looks like a big piece of glass. There's some PVC fencing, a piece of PVC fencing there. We have a seat of a vehicle. I don't even know what this wood thing is. A bucket used for indoor mopping in the driveway. So, Magistrate, the property was re-inspected on November 6th and the violations continue. Photos were taken on that date. I'd like to submit them as Exhibit B. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B will be admitted into evidence. And I believe you have a copy, correct? I do. Okay. So, again, just re-verifying that the front of the house, the vehicle, the Chevy SUV is still parked as it was. It has not moved at all and still does not display a current tag. Up around the front door, some of the garbage has actually been removed, but there's still a lot of trash items up around the front door. And some other items in the back of the car, this looks like some sort of pad or something that's been pulled from a vehicle. I'm not sure. Any items along the side of the house for outdoor storage still exist. It looks as if maybe there was one item covered with a little bit of a tarp, but still other items all along the side of the property and fully visible from the road. So, magistrate, the county requests that you find the property in violation and issue an order to have the property brought into compliance. The county is asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply and if still found in violation, assign a fine in the amount of $100 per day per code section violation for code section 58-270 for the inoperable vehicle, code section 58-304 for the trash and debris, and code section 138-3220 for the outdoor storage, and award costs of $230. All right. I've seen no one come into the room since we started the hearing. Did we receive during the hearing any voicemails or emails? No, magistrate. All right. I'm going to find that there is a violation of code section 58-270, order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find that there is a violation of code section 58-304, order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find that there's a violation of code section 138-3220, order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026 at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. It will also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, magistrate. Heidi, would you please read item number 17? Department code enforcement case number, excuse me, ordinance number 138-3220, outdoor storage, 138-3505, zoning, shed in the setback and not screened from view. Case number, CCM-26-00155, Officer Duvall, owner is C-Bar Asset Company, LLC. Notice address is C-Bar Asset Company, LLC, 5001 Plaza on the Lake, Suite 200, Austin, Texas, 78746. Violation address is 2173 Capri Drive, Clearwater, Florida, 33763. Is there anyone here for case number CCM-26-00155? I'm looking around the room. I know everybody who's here and why they're here, and I don't see anybody from C-Bar Asset Company, LLC. Did anyone sign in? No, magistrate. And have we received any telephone calls or emails concerning this hearing? No, magistrate. Who's here on behalf of the county? Officer Duvall, Pinellas County Code Enforcement. Would you please raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. County may proceed. Thank you, magistrate. This property where the alleged violation exists is located at 2173 Capri Drive in Clearwater, Florida, which is in unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, C-Bar Asset Company, LLC, is not represented for today's hearing. This violation has been an occurrence since on or before, March 3rd of 2026. I'd like to enter the Notice of Hearing and composite Exhibit A into evidence. Exhibit A consists of the Notice of Violations, ownership confirmation through Pinellas County Tax Collector, property appraiser, and the deed. Inspection photos are also included. Hearing no objection, Exhibit A will be admitted into evidence. Okay, starting off with the Notice of Hearing, we've got the first four pages that were sent to the property owner at the address of record. The registered agent was also included on a copy of this evidence packet. We have the first Notice of Violation, which is for a zoning for the placement of a shed within the three-foot setback, which is not screened with a six-foot-high opaque fence. And then we have outdoor storage, the second violation notice. We have Pinellas County Tax Collector confirming ownership of C-Bar Asset Company, LLC, and property appraiser confirming the same. The special warranty deed of this property dated back in June of 2023. The picture is showing the – this is for Code Section 138-3220 for outdoor storage. We have here – this is a picture of the front of the property. It looks as if this person probably runs some sort of a construction company or something where he does a lot of outdoor work. This is the shed here on the side of the property that we'll be addressing here in a moment. And we have lots of construction-type material with buckets and pieces of scaffolding. We also have here a cement mixer that's located on the front of the property. Zone Violation for the Placement of the Shed. The Shed is within the three-foot rear setback, which is acceptable. But this has an exterior side property or an exterior side yard because this is a corner property. And the shed must be shielded by a six-foot-high fence. So just to give a better visual, this is a street view from 2025 standing out at the street. This is the exposed exterior side yard. This shed right here is located in what would be right here on this area of the yard. So it does – it can be there. It just needs to be screened by a fence coming down that side exterior yard. So, Magistrate, the property was reinspected on November 6th, and the violation continues. Photos are taken on that date. I'd like to enter them in as composite Exhibit B. Hearing no objection, Exhibit B will be admitted into evidence. So the zoning violation 138-3220 for outdoor storage continued. Pictures taken from front of the property. You can see the cement mixer is still parked right up on the front of the property. And we still have the same items for outdoor storage, buckets, pieces of scaffolding, and there's some other miscellaneous items tucked back in there as well. And as you can see, trying to just take better pictures, showing the placement of the shed. This is just taken from a little bit of a distance, showing the side yard. And the shed is still in the same place that it was, and it is not currently screened. And there's been no zoning clearance application for any type of fencing at all. Nothing's been done. So, Magistrate, the county requests you find the property in violation and issue an order to have the property brought into compliance. The county is asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply and, if still found in violation, assign a fine in the amount of $100 per day per violation for code sections 158-3220 for the zoning violation of outdoor storage and 138-3505 for the shed not screened and award the cost of $230. All right. Since we started this hearing, there's been no one who has come in the hearing room. During the hearing, have we received any voicemails, phone calls, or emails? No, Magistrate. All right. I'm going to find that there is a violation of code section 138-3220. Order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026, at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. I'm going to find there is a violation of code section 138-3505. Order that the property be brought into compliance within 30 days, which is December 16, 2026, at 5 p.m. Failing to do so, we'll assess a fine in the amount of $100 per day. I will also assess costs in the amount of $230. Thank you, Magistrate. That concludes the enumerated items on this agenda. Are there any county attorney matters? Hearing none, the hearing is adjourned and closed. Communications, please stop recording. Okay, thank you.