take the opportunity to welcome everybody to our November 17th meeting. We're going to start with invocation by Commissioner Scheer and a pledge of allegiance by Commissioner Hughes. Almighty and gracious God, we come before you today with grateful hearts for the privilege of living and serving in Pinellas County. We thank you for the beauty of our coastal communities, the vibrancy of our neighborhoods, and the resilience of residents who haul Pinellas County home. Today we lift up our staff, civic leaders, and fellow citizens. As we gather to deliberate on the matters before us, we ask that you grant us wisdom, discernment, and humility. Help us to listen to the voices of our citizens and make decisions that promote safe and a good quality of life for every resident across our county. We also ask for your blessing upon our first responders, educators, health care workers, and each and every person who labors daily to keep Pinellas County strong and free. Guide our discussions today so that even when we have differing viewpoints, we may speak with respect and patience and keep the well-being of our community at the heart of our discussion. May all that is accomplished here today bring you honor and be a blessing to our community. We ask these things in the name of Jesus Christ, our Lord and Savior. Amen. Regence to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay. Let's see. Before we get started, I wanted to thank Corporal Clyde Thornton, Deputy Mike Winnick, Deputy Kevin McSweeney, and Deputy Jeff Atkison for being here, for being here, as you always are, to take care of us here at the meeting. Also wanted to just take a moment and welcome our new Commissioner Hughes today. Good to have you here with us. We had our induction ceremony earlier, but it's good to have you with us. Welcome. And since we didn't have a chance to say anything about it, I just wanted to also thank former Commissioner Scott for his four years of tireless service for the residents of Pinellas County. Wish him well. All right. We're going to go ahead and get started. I think Sherry Holzbacher, CEO of our Homeless Leadership Alliance of Pinellas, has a partner presentation for us. Welcome, Sherry. Nice to see you, Commissioner Eggers and Mewicki. I am Sherry Holzbacher. Thank you for having me today to speak in front of the commission. Sherry Holzbacher, CEO of the Homeless Leadership Alliance, also the HLA is what we call that. And what I'd like to share today is some of the progress has been made as a result of our partnership together. We have really good data, some stories in addressing homelessness as a community, as far as our community response, and how Pinellas County has contributed to that work. And first, though, I want to briefly go over a little bit of difference between what the Pinellas Continuum of Care, the COC, is versus the HLA, the Homeless Leadership Alliance. The Pinellas COC is a governing body. It's a coalition of providers, funders, community members, anyone with an interest or investment in eradicating homelessness or reducing it within Pinellas County. It is HUD-defined, and there's a COC in every area across the country. The HLA is an independent not-for-profit selected by the COC to be its lead agency. We help do logistical administrative support. We help convene meetings. We also apply on behalf of the county of Pinellas for HUD COC program funding every year, and also state funding as well. And we also oversee the coordinated entry system and the HMIS, which is Homeless Management Information System, which collects all data across all programs that serve homeless residents across the county, too. So I wanted to first say and just show that we have data collected over the last several decades. We show measurable progress in unsheltered and sheltered homelessness. Sheltered meaning people who may be in emergency shelters, safe havens, or transitional housing, so not long-term. And then also the unsheltered homeless, that's anyone who is living in a place not meant for human habitation. So that could be on the streets, in a car, in a shed, garage, that is not heated or cooled. And over the course, so in our 2026 point-in-time count, which is our PIT count, it is required by HUD for us to report on this every year. Those numbers go up to Congress, and that's how Congress determines spending priorities and how it will fund COCs across the nation, and how our systems are performing as well. So one piece of that is this point-in-time census. So one night a year, in January, in 2026, we identified 1,949 people experiencing homelessness overall. Of those, 1,314 were in shelter, and 635 were unsheltered. You can see, though, over the past 10 years, there has been definitely a trend line going in the right direction. It's been going down. In 2025, that was a record low for many, many reasons. In 2026, we did see a slight uptick of unsheltered homelessness. Part of that is due to having a cold-night shelter activation the night before, and where we had more people who we may not have been able to find in the past either. But just the overall trend line has been going down. Since 2016, there's been a 44 percent reduction in unsheltered homelessness within Pinellas County. And of course, counting the number of people experiencing homelessness in one night is only one measure. So also, it's important to look at our system performance. These data are collected throughout the year through our HMIS system. So once someone enters into the homeless response system, there are some really important measures that I wanted to share that HUD, the feds look at, that we keep track of as well as a coalition, as the HLA, that between 2024 and 2025, there were 47 fewer days homeless on median average. We look at our supportive housing units that we have throughout. And these are units that are intended for people who have significant disabilities who need additional supports, some treatment, case management in order to maintain their stability and housing. Without it, they would be in jails, hospitals, ALFs, much more expensive, costly interventions. And here, they're able to experience stability with a little bit of support. 98% this last year, but overall, year over year, very high success rates for maintaining that housing. And anyone who exits does not return to the system, or at least 98% don't. And then finally, we've been looking very, very closely at work and doing a lot of work, developing more partnerships for workforce development, paying attention to self-sufficiency. And that's important. People who are able to self-resolve or just need a little bit more training in order to find or be connected to the right housing on their own, that is the best result we can get. And so, within our COC-funded projects, we saw through a lot of work, actually, within one year, especially between 2024 and 2025, and that does continue, went from 38% to 52% of the adults had increased their income during that period. So, achieving those outcomes, it does require resources. And one of HLA's primary responsibilities is bringing in, as I said earlier, funding from HUD, as well as the state to ensure that these, also to offer monitoring, to ensure that these dollars are used appropriately. And so, we apply for those funds on behalf of the COC. Most of these funds do not come through the HLA at all. Federal funds go straight to, between HUD and the provider. There's a direct contract. And for the state funds that we received, which nearly quadrupled since 2022-23, those funds are passed through HLA directly to the providers. We have seen a $1.15 million increase, like 21% increase in HUD funding, which is competitive funding since 2022, year over year. These are resources supporting housing, that supportive housing I was talking about earlier, for people with disabilities and victims of domestic violence fleeing. This is for prevention, diversion, emergency shelter upgrades. When we had hurricanes Milton and Helene, we found out how important it was that our shelters needed to have more access to, needed to be beefed up a bit more in order to continue servicing people. And it's also for other critical services, as deemed by the COC, that is the governing body, that determines what those priorities are. Behind those numbers are real families, individuals, children. And so, through the HUD COC-funded program, for supportive housing program projects that the COC has put forward and HUD has funded through a competitive application process, 91 children received housing and support. And so that was stable housing through these supportive housing units. These programs serve families and children who face significant barriers to housing stability, including, like I said earlier, people with significant behavioral health issues and also mobility disabilities and are survivors of domestic violence. Supportive housing combines a place to live with services that help people maintain that stability. It is a very, it's a cost saver, it, because, as I said earlier, the other options are the streets, jails, hospitals. These are people who do need additional support in order to maintain that, that living. Another important part of our work is helping families navigate homelessness and find a path towards safety and housing. So within the HLA, HLA, we are, we help out with the full system coordination, that system response, we convene all partners, we provide data, we provide technical assistance. We maintain, we stay on top of what's happening federally and statewide, locally, in order to get everyone together on, and just make sure information, we're on the same page, and working together as a coalition. But there are some areas where we do work directly with individuals, and this is one of them. HLA serves as the designated access point for any family who needs emergency shelter. In Pinellas County, we do not have enough emergency shelter for families. We have shelters for individuals, but for families, we have a special coordinated system in place to make sure that the people who need it the most are getting it, are able to use that very scarce resource. From September 2025 through July of 2026, our community navigators, we have two of them right now, assisted 206 families, including 449 children, and 89% of the recorded exits were successful. That means that this is short-term light touch case management. It can turn into longer term, whatever family needs, but they were able to get into shelter, permanent housing, or diversion. And diversion meaning that they are not coming into our homeless response system. We were able to have a conversation, find out, is there a family member that you may need to help make amends with that we can help support? Is there a utility bill that could be paid that would make it to where you don't end up into the system, which is going to cost more, and just go further and further down the hole there. Our navigators convene, they don't do it alone. They convene monthly, bi-weekly case conferences for families and for veterans. And now we started doing this for individuals as well, where we convene all of the local shelters and housing providers to try to get people through the system as quickly as possible to housing stability. We work directly with case managers on calls. But again, limited family shelter capacity and affordable housing continue to remain as significant challenges. And that brings me to why it's so important that we have our partnership with Pinellas County, how we work together. Our partnership, we support several different functions of the county, including cold night shelter coordination. So we activate cold night shelters every year. We work with several nonprofits and faith-based organizations that provide volunteers. We provide staffing. We provide stipends to help, and supplies, materials, cots, mats. And also we convene them together to come up with some best practices and creative ideas for how to get by with what they have, right, to make the most out of what we have available. Last year's cold night season was record-breaking, and we are, I'm not even going to say it because I don't have enough wood around me, but this year is, we're hearing some reports that it's going to be a cold winter. Last year we activated 11 times. The year before that it was 10 times. So last year was record-breaking. We've had years in the past where it was two or three. So we are just seeing an increase year over year on the number of activations that we are having in this area. But through, so last year we served 3,649 individuals, and not all of these individuals are people who are experiencing homelessness. This is cold night shelter program also serves people who live in homes that does not have adequate heating to protect them when it gets very cold outside. We're dangerously cold and sun safe. So it's open to anyone who needs a meal and a place to stay for the night that's warm. And it's been a great way to partner with faith-based organizations and others who want to help and have volunteers but don't know exactly what to do. And this is one of those areas that we definitely tap into. We also, through Pinellas County contracts, we provide diversion. And last year, 121 people were served with 98% successful exits. So they were able to have that conversation, maybe provide some traveler's aid to a friend or family that we have already vetted. We know that that person, that family's on the other side and ready to take them in. And again, it prevents someone from coming into the homeless crisis response system. We also provide monthly performance reporting, system updates, and trend analysis during our monthly coordination meeting with the Pinellas County Human Services staff. So every month we get together, we look at what's happening. We raise up any issues that may be coming in the horizon so that then you could be educated on that as well and given the heads up. So the partnership, and finally, I don't want to forget this, disaster preparedness and response. I remember I came in to the HLA and then right after that we had Helene and Milton. And HLA staff, we were on all the time, daily convening the meetings between Pinellas County Emergency Management and all the shelter providers and housing providers and street outreach teams across the county to make sure that accurate information was going out, was one voice, was correct, and that everyone's needs, the provider's needs were being met. It was a great place to convene and just discuss what was coming up and what people were lacking or any upcoming issues. And so we were able to successfully make sure that people knew where to go before those hurricanes hit. We worked before, during, and after the hurricane until everyone was even following that talk with FEMA, worked with FEMA and held some technical assistance trainings with them and with human services and emergency management to make sure our disaster plan is up to date and working well. So, this partnership is more than about individual programs. It's about having coordination and infrastructure and accountability necessary to respond effectively as a community. One more thing we do during those monthly coordination meetings is that we share, the data that we're sharing is on all the projects and programs that Pinellas County funds, not HLAs, but we just, we have the repository of information, and so we break down those reports as a service to Pinellas County. So, I want to close by acknowledging that while we made measurable progress, we still have significant work ahead of us. I know that there are funding concerns coming up. I do not have my head in the sand there, and we're seeing continued pressure on our shelter system and housing resources, and we know that that funding environment is changing. But we can come together and come up with creative solutions, and we have the right partners around us through the COC and here to come up with that. But we've demonstrated that what can be accomplished when we do invest. And I think that that one, that one graph showing the trend line going down, and all of the people who have been served, and also seeing the number of families who are now not experiencing homelessness were much lower than what we were a few years ago. That is because of that investment. And so, it didn't happen by accident, and we appreciate that partnership and look forward to continuing it into the future. Sherry, thank you. Thank you for the presentation, and thank you for leading the alliance to take care of our own, to take care of our residents who are struggling, whether they're our vets or family members or kids, whatever. And it's a diverse group of people that are struggling, certainly in the economy, the way it's been, and the difficulties people have had making ends meet, I'm sure is maybe part of that elevated number in 26, because that's what we keep hearing about, you know. So, thank you for being, for being that voice and that leadership, that leader in our community for this. Anybody have any questions? Commissioner Nowicki? Well, no questions, but I'm on the COC. And, you know, I just want to recognize you, Sherry, and the whole HL team and our partners and the providers for the work that they're doing. You know, I've seen a real improvement in morale and how people are working together, you know, since the former chair stepped down on April 22nd. You know, there's a more constructive atmosphere, and that matters when we depend on so many organizations really cooperating to help people find housing and stability. And, you know, my experience, the former chair approach, you know, really created a toxic environment. But, you know, you taking over and Councilmember Fig Sanders stepping up, you know, has really showed that the right leadership, you know, and the credit belongs to you and the COC and all the other partners. So, I appreciate your hard work. Thank you. We appreciate you. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Nowicki. Appreciate those comments. Anybody else? Okay. Well, thank you for being here. Appreciate the update and some of the good news that you had to share with us today. Many of us have gotten some emails on the concern, not only about the dengue fever outbreak, but also the, the method to try to control the mosquitoes. And so, um, before we jump into citizens to be heard, uh, Kelly Levy with our public works department and Dr. Cho with our health department are here today to give us a, maybe an update on where we are with, um, with that, that, uh, that, that service, so to speak, and what flexibility there might be and how we take care of, uh, the mosquitoes. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, Kelly Hammer Levy, public works director. So I wanted to provide a little overview on how we do mosquito control. I think we're kind of behind the scenes and a lot of people don't really know a lot about the program until there's a problem, but we have an integrated pest management program and data drives all of our decisions. We collect larva data, we collect traps, and we're looking at how many mosquitoes, what species of mosquitoes, you know, there are 80 mosquitoes, different species of mosquitoes in Florida over, over 80, and about a quarter of, about a quarter of those, um, can transmit disease. We have sentinel chickens in the county that specifically, um, evaluate whether or not we have West Nile, Eastern equine encephalitis, or St. Louis encephalitis in, in the mosquito population. And then we have public health data from partners like the Department of Health. When we, when we have an imported case, which happens quite a lot. I mean, we, on any given year, we'll get a call that there's a travel-related case of malaria or dengue or another mosquito-borne virus. We work with the Department of Health. We go out, we ensure we control breeding, we kill live mosquitoes, um, and our whole goal is to ensure that transmission doesn't get beyond that one travel case. Our primary methods of control are physical control, dumping standing water, encouraging residents to do the same, a lot of public education involved there, and biological control. We use mosquito fish in abandoned swimming pools and those types of stagnant, uh, water bodies. The larva sighting is our key. We try to prevent the mosquito larvae from actually becoming mosquitoes in the first place. That way, they can't spread disease. Adulta sighting is what we use when we have active transmission in an area. We have significant, um, numbers of, of mosquitoes that can transmit disease, and we utilize a ultra-low volume, what's called a ULV truck mounted system, uh, to treat in those areas. Um, and those treatments only occur either late at night, again, depending on the species of mosquito, or early morning to avoid people and pollinators. So what's happening now? We've got, we have dengue fever. It's, it's spread by two, two species of mosquito. Um, it is a day biter. It's called an ankle biter for a reason. It, so if, if you're getting bit during the day, it's probably the 80s aegypti mosquito, um, that's, uh, enjoying your ankles. Um, our first case was in August of 26. It was, it started a cluster in Palm Harbor. Our second cluster was in St. Pete, and our third cluster is in Clearwater, but I do want to say we have cases everywhere in the county. It's just, we have concentrated cases in those areas. Um, as of last week, we had 109 cases in the community. Uh, Dr. Cho can give an update, but I think we're going to be a little higher this week. Um, and we do have 40 cases, commercial positive cases that are being investigated. Um, we also have West Nile here. We've had 67 of our sentinel chickens, um, test positive for West Nile. It's a, again, a different species of mosquito this time. It's a dawn dusk biter. Um, so we have to treat that situation differently. Um, West Nile is typically spread, um, during bird migration season. Um, we're starting to see a decrease in our positive sentinel chickens, which is good news. And we have one case under investigation, one human case under investigation in the county. So Dr. Cho is the medical guy. He's going to talk the medical stuff, but what I wanted to point out on this chart is that people say, well, we only have a hundred people or so with dengue fever. You know, why do you have to do this? Well, only one in four people show symptoms. Okay. So there are a lot more cases out there. They are just not sick. And those individuals are probably going about their lives normally. Um, they may be working outside, they get bit by mosquito, that mosquito then bites a family friend or somebody else in the vicinity. And that person isn't so lucky. So unfortunately we have more people in the community that have dengue. It's just, they're not showing the symptoms. So what are we doing? We're not doing really anything different than we normally do. We're using the exact same products we have always used. Um, we're actively working both dengue cases as well as West Nile. Um, we're doing both aerial treatments and ground treatments. Um, there are limitations. We do not do any aerial, um, applications when the wind exceeds 10 miles an hour. And we cannot fog or treat for adult mosquitoes when the temperature drops below 50. Um, the mosquitoes tend to hide when it's colder and they don't come out until it gets warmer. And we have had an online treatment map up on our website for several years now. Um, so that people can be aware of where we're doing, what we're doing. There's definitions as to each treatment type area, both aerial and ground. Kelly. Um, back of that slide, uh, aside from the wind limitations and temperature limitations, is there anything about night or daylight other than maybe the safety of the, of the helicopter that might be doing it? Is there any other limitations to doing it at night versus during the day? Well, so in Hillsborough and Pasco, they're doing two types of aerial treatments. They're doing aerial adult to sighting. We are not, um, aerial adult to sighting again, dependent on what type of mosquito you are targeting. You want to treat when they're out. So if they're treating for, um, you know, a mosquito that bites at dawn and dusk, then they need to fly at those times. Um, aerial, um, larva sighting. No, you can do larva sighting anytime, but in our area with, um, the safety issues in our community with regard to flying, you have to fly low. Um, we could never do larva sighting at night. Go ahead. So our, our current November treatment plan is, I mean, Clearwater responded very, very well to the aerial larva sighting treatment that was done. Our trap counts are remaining low. Um, our goal is to do one treatment this week, depend, wind dependent, um, and then taper off if the counts and the cases remain low. So Clearwater is trending in a very good direction. We're very happy with, um, with the fact that the, that the trap counts are, are remaining low. St. Petersburg, we had initial good results post, post, uh, treatment, the aerial larva sighting. However, we got, we have counts and cases have gone up in, um, St. Petersburg. I believe eight of the 12 new cases this week are in St. Pete. Um, so our current plan is for, again, an aerial larva sighting treatment this week, wind dependent. And we're also taking those areas where the, um, where the counts are exceedingly high. And we're going to work with the city's code enforcement, um, team to identify those breeding locations and try to work with those property owners to eliminate, um, the excessive breeding in those areas. Um, and then no aerial, um, larva sighting, uh, treatments, um, liquid larva sighting treatments are scheduled for the week of, of Thanksgiving. Um, we have, again, a lot of resources on our mosquito control website. We have a specific web page for dengue. Um, we're doing a lot of, um, social media, next door announcements. We are using alert Pinellas for just those two areas where we're doing aerial larva sighting operations. It's not a countywide operations. We're using it very targeted in, in the areas where we were seeing the most transmission. And as just as a reminder, alert Pinellas is a great resource. Um, I personally believe that every resident who lives here, even part of the year should sign up for this. It's boil water notices, it's hurricanes, it's evacuations, it's, it's issues like this. Um, you know, so that you are aware of, of what's going on when, when there's an emergency in your community. Uh, Kelly on the, the standard treatments that we, that we have, um, I've had several emails from folks talking about, um, the sterile mosquitoes using sterile mosquitoes to try to cut the population. What, what do you, what do you know about that as far as use in Florida and, uh, the success that that might have? I mean, you have to have a breeding program, so you have to grow them. You have to sort them, you know, so, cause you can't, you don't, you don't want to release, you know, the males. So you're only releasing the females. You have to keep repeatedly doing it just like, um, just like these treatments. So they don't live very long. So you'd have to keep breeding them, keep going through that process and, and, um, and keep releasing them. Um, we are not in any way set up to do anything like that. The sterile ones, um, then there's genetically modified mosquitoes, which requires a lot of permitting and is regulated through PA and, and stuff like that. Um, the, uh, I do believe Lee County has, um, some sterile, again, uh, mosquito control, um, capabilities, but again, it's, it's very limited and you have to be really set up to breed, um, sort, then release, and then keep it going like any other treatment because it's not a, it's not a magic bullet for this. Okay. Any, anybody else? I know Dr. Cho is going to have a few comments. Anybody else for Kelly right now? Okay. Go ahead, Dr. Cho. Thank you. Good afternoon. Uh, just to reiterate some of, uh, Kelly's points, uh, Dr. Cho, could you lift that up and speak just a little bit louder? Thank you. Uh, just to reiterate some of Kelly's points, I'm going to give a little background on, on dengue and where we're at. Um, so we're dealing with dengue fever. This is the largest outbreak we've seen in continental United States since the early 1900s, truly largely centered in the Tampa Bay area. As Kelly mentioned, it is spread by the 80s, uh, mosquito, which is common here, uh, in Pinellas County, Florida, as well as the U S. Uh, regarding dengue, there are four serotypes or different types strains, um, dengue one, two, three, and four. So a person can be infected more than one time. Uh, in terms of the 80s, uh, as Kelly mentioned, it is a, um, a day and night biter. It's urban. It lives indoors. The big thing here is that it can reproduce in any standing water. So imagine your, your yard, uh, the dog, dog, uh, food bowls, the, uh, bird baths, uh, even as something as small as a small cap, um, a cap of bottle cap, um, can reproduce this larvae. As, as Kelly mentioned, uh, in terms of those showing symptoms, only one in four symptoms. And I think that it proposed, uh, poses some of the challenges. So you have people that have these infections that are asymptomatic. And if they get, they move around the Tampa Bay area, they can get bitten by the local mosquitoes. And that's probably what's perpetuating these numbers that we're seeing. Uh, of those that show the symptoms, one in 20, uh, can develop severe dengue. And the biggest risk is if they develop later on down the road, a second dengue infection. Uh, but some of the more common, uh, symptoms that we see, uh, includes headache, um, uh, body aches, uh, bone pain, um, retro, um, eye pain, as well as some minor, uh, bleeding. Uh, in terms of the numbers and Kelly touched on these as well, uh, we have an, uh, state Arbovirus report that comes out every Thursday. Our last report shows us at 109 and I do anticipate that number to increase on this next Thursday report. Um, we're content to monitor those, uh, those test tests as well. So showing up for symptoms. Um, hopefully, um, it was continued to hopefully go down shortly. We're also looking at monitoring, um, neighboring counties. Uh, Hillsborough is up to 468 with one confirmed death. Um, so something that we're going to monitor there from a prevention standpoint, um, the, the continued message. So I appreciate the, the, the collaborative effort of getting that messaging out, um, uh, spraying with, uh, EPA, um, approved repellent covering your, uh, skin with, um, long pants and long, um, shirts, as well as, um, draining any standing water. And that part's really the key. Um, I do also want to highlight some of the interventions, some of the activities from both, uh, DOH as well as the partners out there, but a lot of it has been providing health education, uh, into our healthcare community, as well as a community at large, uh, enhancing our, our disease surveillance symptoms, working with hospitals and labs, um, providing outreach and education, distributing repellents and dunks. So to our various partners, uh, working, uh, mosquito with, uh, mosquito control for these targeted interventions. Um, and then really, uh, it's been a collaborative effort working with counties as well as cities. Um, the, the kind of government's been, uh, very supportive, uh, whether it's emergency management, human services, mosquito control, public works, among other partners. So I just want to thank our community partners as well as our staff at the Department of Health. Now, I know there, I'll touch on this as, as, um, this question has come up, uh, BTI is a area of larvae that's currently being used in, uh, Pinellas County. It is a soil bacteria that's activated when it hits water. Um, it does kill the larva, um, for those mosquitoes. Uh, but, uh, there is a number of EPA studies showing it's, it's safety, uh, for humans. So, okay. I'll stop there. Okay. Thank you. Um, any questions for Dr. Cho, Department of Health, uh, here in Pinellas County, director? Um, yes, Commissioner Flowers. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for sharing that information and thank you, Kelly. Um, I know I referred some calls to you because persons were concerned about, um, flyovers, um, while the children were going to school, which the pilots didn't know that school was taking in here at nine 30. So it was nothing that was done intentional, just done based on the ability and the time to fly. Um, question I have is we have some snowbirds that are coming down or already down here and they may not, um, be privy or tune into some of the sites that we have automatically for people that live here. Are we doing anything with maybe some of the hoteliers to make sure that as their guests are checking in, um, they may have some information or could we get some, uh, information to them that they could share with, um, the persons that are coming down so that, you know, I went and bought me some mosquito spray cause I was working in my backyard. So I went and bought spray that had the Dungay thing listed on it. But, you know, can we just try to get some additional information to them for those guests and that way, um, you know, they have it too. Absolutely. We definitely can do that. And I know through our collaboration, we've reached out to the chamber of commerce, schools, childcare, um, facilities among so many different, uh, organizations and facilities out there. So we'll make sure if we haven't done so. Okay. And I want to publicly thank, um, your department again, Kelly. I know I've reached out because there was a group getting ready to have a big activity. They went out to clear the area and they were swarming all around. Um, and there was already spraying scheduled to occur, but you all sent out some additional, uh, support because of how engrossed it was. I want to thank you on their behalf for taking care of that because they were able to have the event and whatnot. And there were no reports of, you know, persons being engulfed in, um, mosquitoes and whatnot. So I want to publicly say thank you for that. Yeah. We've been keeping a very close eye on Facebook for events and stuff. Some of the cities are really good about notifying us that they're having, uh, uh, an event, um, like, you know, jazz fest was here and, you know, obviously the world series, we spent a considerable amount of time down in St. Pete. Um, uh, we're keeping an eye out on all that. And when we do see events, we are, are trying to play, pay special attention to those Saturday morning markets and things like that. Um, but when we know about them, we, we really are putting extra effort because we know it, I mean, it's just, uh, you're going to have a lot of people in a centralized location and it's not likely that they will not encounter a mosquito if we don't do that. We also, um, you know, Dr. Cho and his team, and, and we actually also acquired some additional resources for the school board. Um, we, we received, uh, funding through the department of agriculture to buy what's called a BTI brick, uh, for the school board because just coordinating access on their properties is, as you know, with all the safety requirements is very challenging, but I mean, they've got athletic events and things like that. So, um, we, we purchased, uh, 20,000 BTI bricks, um, that last 30 days, um, and, and worked with the school board maintenance staff so that they can identify where they have problem areas. Um, and we also, uh, purchased about 20,000, um, of these small, um, repellents cans that we're working with, um, Karen and her team, um, to ensure that the unhoused community is, um, you know, one, one can lasts about six sprays, um, full body. So we're trying to make sure that the burn rate, that we can keep up with the burn rate, um, so that folks who are spending a lot of time outside, um, are protected. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Um, anybody else? So thank you both. Uh, Kelly, is there a, is there a schedule of the aerial flying that it's online anywhere so people can, can be made aware of when that's, when that's occurring? Yes. So on our webpage, we have this online treatment map and you can see on, on the one side, it says recent truck treatments. And then on the other side, it says planned and you can click on planned and it'll tell you the date and the time. Um, we have the same thing at the very bottom. If you look across the bottom, it's, you know, see aerial treatments, you click on that tab and you'll see, um, the, what's scheduled for aerial. Um, but with the aerial, um, the aerial larva siding for St. Pete and Clearwater are on there as well, but we're also encouraging folks to sign up for Alert Pinellas. Um, you know, that way, if you happen to be, I mean, even if you're not in St. Pete or Clearwater, but you're planning a day and you're going to be in the area, um, it's always good to get those notifications. So we're again, really push encouraging people to sign up for Alert Pinellas. Um, this was a, uh, a county and a state state of emergency. And, and do we have a sense of the timing of the state of emergency or does it depend on dropping numbers or what, what's the, what's the status on, on that? Um, I, the, the state of emergency that, um, was added to the hurricane East Siasis. Um, I'm not sure when they will, um, when they will eliminate that. I can tell you that, um, due to some, uh, upgrades that are going on at the state level, they've extended our, um, purchase order for chemicals till the end of February. And they also asked us for a plan for January, February timeframe, because again, it's, um, with an El Nino winter, we're looking at a wet winter, which means breeding is likely to continue. Um, so they wanted to, uh, be prepared in case there was additional, um, if this continues on, uh, beyond, you know, January. All right. Anybody else? Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. We're going to go into a citizens to be heard and, um, we're going to start with Pascual Staccato, uh, Susan Bucci will be next. Yeah. The microphone's right there. Yes. Thank you. Good day commissioners. My name is Pascual Staccato. I reside in Dunedin and I have been a resident of Pinellas County for 30 years. On November 17th, 2021, I purchased a vacant parcel of land in Palm Harbor at the County tax deed auction for a total cost of $51,200. At the time of the purchase, the property was classified in public records as a residential lot. After purchasing the lot, I tried selling it to a builder who contacted the County. It was then that the County staff informed the builder and myself that the residential building permits could not be issued because the parcel was actually intended for stormwater drainage. Following the discovery, I questioned the property's residential tax classification, which was subsequently changed to reflect its drainage related use. But what brings me here before you today is a separate issue. The ongoing responsibility for maintaining its draining infrastructure. I recently received the code violation notice requiring me to clean up the property, including the removal of accumulated sediment from its drainage system. And that notice, I am threatened with fines of up to a thousand dollars per day for failure to do so. The notice also indicates fines may also constitute a lien upon any other real or personal property I own in Pinellas County. I was the unfortunate individual to purchase that property at auction. And now the County wants me to maintain the stormwater infrastructure to benefit the County. The road on the street is a county maintained road that drains onto the slot. I offered to donate this entire property to the County without requesting a single dollar in compensation. My offer was reviewed by County personnel and other departments, but ultimately declined. I'm retired and living on social security. Continuing to incur expenses on this property presents a genuine financial hardship. I'm respectfully asking this board for three things. First, please help arrange a pause of code enforcement action while responsibility for the drainage infrastructure is investigated. Second, please direct the appropriate County departments to review the original drainage plans, easements, permits, and maintenance agreements, and provide a written explanation identifying who is legally responsible for maintaining this system. Records indicate a gentleman by the name of Patrick Cullen was also the developer of this entire street. And in 1985, signed documents show that he is responsible to maintain the drainage facilities. He eventually let the property go to foreclosure for failure to pay the property tax, and he lives next door to this lot. And third, I'm asking for your assistance in finding a permanent resolution. I'm asking for help for an arrangement that would allow me to relinquish the property. I simply want a fair, lawful, and reasonable way to bring this situation to an end. Thank you. Barry, is there somebody that can meet with the gentleman outside? You've got a couple of different departments, so I asked Jill to follow up with him. They're going to meet you outside in the lobby. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Staccato. All right. Susan Bucci, followed by Jeremy Warner. Welcome. Hi. So my name is Susan Bucci, and I live in Tarpon Springs, and I've lived there since for about 25 years. It is my understanding that there's been an appeal to the decision that was made at the October 13th meeting, so it's not too late to offer our opinion. After hearing about the rezoning, I recalled a conversation with a school teacher who had taken a position at a Muslim school in Tampa. She only worked there a short period of time because the students were not only rude to her, but they were actually being taught to hate us. This is what's happening on American soil. An FBI agent assured me they were keeping a close eye on the school's activities, and they could not take further action until there was evidence to justify it. The mosque. Should we really be concerned about a place of worship? I spent hours researching. I read a lot about the kindness, compassion, and peacefulness of the majority of the Muslim population. A friend of mine told me her Muslim client was the nicest woman she had ever met. Only a very small segment of the Muslim population is radicalized. Here's why I oppose the expansion. I have confidence in the leadership of Governor DeSantis, so when he declared the Council on American Islamic Relations and the Muslim Brotherhood as terrorist organizations, I am going to pay attention. In the executive order, he cites the Muslim Brotherhood's historic ties to Hamas, global political violence, and what he describes as Islamic ideology incompatible with American constitutional principles. The order also states that the Muslim Brotherhood helped establish CARE in the 1990s and references CARE's inclusion as an unindicted co-conspirator in the 2009 Holy Land Foundation terrorism financing case in Texas. I don't think it could be argued that guns and other weapons have been found hidden in mosques in numerous countries. In my mind, we are better safe than sorry, but I do sincerely apologize to those Muslims who are kind and compassionate. You are being drawn into this controversy when you did nothing to ask for trouble. I think we can all acknowledge that the vast majority of Muslims are peaceful people who deserve understanding and respect, and it is unfair to hold an entire community accountable for the actions of a radicalized minority. We always have choices, but I don't think it would be wise to give anyone in this situation the benefit of the doubt. There's just too much history to choose otherwise. Thank you. Thank you. Jeremy Warner, followed by Shanery Barnes. Hello again. I'm Jeremy Warner. I've been a Pinellas County resident for seven years. This is Raina Warner, my daughter. I think we can all agree that trust in government organizations and law enforcement is crucial. With the recent arrest of another deputy sheriff abusing the ALPR flack system is another reason why I'm here. This is now the third one, and we also had one that was dismissed on all charges with a recent felony charge, brought back up on another officer. In my mind, this is not accountability in any form or fashion. Sheriff Coutier showed up to the last meeting after everyone left and said he would move cameras from one hand to the other. He did say he would adhere to any ordinance of removing flack cameras, which was great. One member of the commission stated that we, the public already have pictures taken by security cameras in airports and private businesses. Those cameras are for local purposes of security while on a specific property. Retention of that data is also very short, is not searchable like the flock ALPR system is. The consumer is also aware that they are being filmed. In public, we are not asked for our consent, nor are we notified of being filmed. Misidentification by the flock ALPR cameras, I brought up two different internal audits, not a third party, two internal. Roseville, California, PD, which by the way does not have any officers that were arrested for misuse, publicized their first report this year. 71% misreads. Okay. You can find that on Business Insider. Okay. Another one, LAPD, also an internal audit, not from a third party, found more misreads. A public county commissioner is elected to do what is right by their constituents. And to say that being elected and making hard decisions is right. In this case, the hard thing should be doing the right thing. And by protecting innocent citizens and eliminating all cameras from being a tool that has been abused, left unchecked, and has clear issues with its hackability and misreads. To gain public trust back, it is imperative the commission take action to remove the cameras and not wait, not wait for the state legislature to make up their mind. I also ask for the immediate resignation of Sheriff Gaultierry. I'm sure he's an upstanding man. However, four officers in the last three years have been arrested, one to include child pornography. That, in my mind, is failed leadership. That is not okay. We have to take extreme accountability for everything we do as individuals. Thank you. Thank you. Shanery Barnes, David Ballard Geddes, Jr. Dear commissioners, at the September 24th declaration of the local state of state of emergency, Pinellas County had just seven confirmed dengue cases in almost one million residents, roughly 0.0007% of the population and zero deaths. Zero commissioners questioned whether these numbers justified a state of emergency. This declaration grants extraordinary powers and eliminates any option for consent or opting out regarding entry without notice and treatment of public and private property. Pinellas County has largely reserved emergency declarations for named tropical storms. Storms involve widespread threats and devastating consequences that residents often cannot prevent or protect themselves against. A mosquito is not a hurricane. The options are to stay inside, avoid our yards, or have questionable substances showered on us by our own government. Dengue prevention should include public education, appropriate clothing, insect repellent, having your own property treated if desired, eliminating standing water, and protection of mosquito predators. What evidence establishes the safety of these pesticides regarding inhalation, skin contact, accidental ingestion, food crops, drinking water, pets, livestock, wildlife, cumulative environmental exposure, and repeated exposure over extended periods of time. Approval by the FDA or EPA is not a guarantee of long-term safety. Examples include DDT, PCBs, PFAs, benzene, trichloroethylene, methylene chloride, aldrin, dieldrin, thalidomide, agent orange, even cigarettes. Substances designed to kill living organisms should be carefully evaluated for their effects beyond the intended target. Mosquitoes and their larvae provide food for the following. Bats, frogs, toads, spiders, mantises, dragonflies, many critical bird species, and many critical fish species. Decreasing natural mosquito predators risks disrupting the ecological balance that regulates mosquito populations. Perhaps the obliteration of their habitats has contributed to our mosquito problem. Transparency and fiscal accountability are crucial with the impending implementation of Amendment 3. It is estimated that the measures taken this year exceeded several million dollars. If cases continued to rise after treatment efforts increased, which they did, that deserves investigation. Terminate the local state of emergency and suspend the aerial and truck-based pesticide applications, please. Publish independent reviews of their necessity, effectiveness, health implications, and environmental consequences. Publish an accounting of all mosquito treatment expenditures. Government's responsibility includes considering legitimate concerns, not assuming that residents must accept toxic exposure. The public deserves transparency, informed decision-making, proportional responses, and respect for rights and well-being. Thank you. Thank you. David Ballard Geddes Jr., and then Annis Sultanem. Good afternoon, Commissioners. David Ballard Geddes Jr. I live on Georgia Avenue in Palm Harbor. The aerial spraying of mosquitoes, in effect, completely destroys the entire ecostructure, killing all of the insects that the bird population requires for their survival, coupled with the fact that Florida experienced over 2,000 fires in Florida, burning all the bird nests in such fires, further coupled with the unbridled development practices, destroying the indigenous habitat that the birds require for their survival, and as well as decades of usage of lawn pesticides, destroying the food source for the birds. With all the destruction of the insects devastating the eco-establishment, the bird population has been reduced to nil. What purpose would the reduction in birds possibly serve? Eliminating the bird population would facilitate an unimpeded deployment of drone activity as the birds serve as an impediment to the drones. A few months ago, Ed Montini of St. Petersburg addressed the forward Pinellas board, explaining his vision of a future drone in a future drone deployment in St. Petersburg, citing that drone warfare is being used very effectively in the Middle East as a drone force strike tactical capability. Dr. Chow again is full of filibustering. First, we'll see helicopters killing the mosquitoes. Next, we'll be seeing drones killing humans using Israeli drone tactics. Thank you. All right, Anis Sultanem, and then Madeline Mongines. Hi, Commissioners. My name is Anis Sultanem. I live in 200 East Lake Drive, Tarpon Springs. I'm here to support the appeal presented by my neighbor Roy Thomas about the expansion of the property 2577 right on the corner of my house. I really have a lot of fears of seeing my house facing a big project commercial instead of living in a residential area. I see a lot of more traffic going to happen or accidents or noise that really scare me and scare my family. The appeal is about a building that's going to cause a lot of distractions for everybody who is living. I'm one of them who live less than 150 feet from that building. And also, I have also seen a lot of violations happen and problem with the neighbor, which is, sorry, the next door neighbor, which is Mr. Roy. And I have a fear I'm going to be next when the building gets bigger and gets more commercial, more traffic there. I mean, I have also another objection of the expansion of the project and make it as or commercial or kind of create a different identity for the whole neighborhood. Thank you. Thank you. Madeline Monjanese and then Greg Pound. Oh, yes, ma'am. You're right. You wave speaking. I apologize. I apologize. Greg Pound and then Nicole Gebbler. Greg Pound, Largo, Florida. I would like this to be seen. We'd just like to bring up the issue. We have another filing that I want to give the county commissioners, just county attorney and the administrator. I guess I could probably leave it up here. Is that correct for you guys? This here is Congress of the United States. This was 2026. And it just simply states a statement on the record, Sharia law, Sharia free America, why political Islam and Sharia law is incompatible with the U.S. Constitution. And the reason it's incompatible is because the foundation of the Constitution is, um, is, is, um, is the Ten Commandments. And so what we have is that's where we have the conflict. We have, it's, um, you know, Islam is, and so that explains it. This is from Congress and it was, and they just, they summarize it in such a well conditioned that people need to read it and see what we're dealing with. Because if it's not dealt with, um, we're going to have major problems. And so, um, but to delay, um, you know, so, so that's, that's, that's what I want to say. The other issue I wanted to bring up here was, um, was, um, you know, if, if we don't get our Ten Commandments back in our schools, we have a lawless society, our society is, is gone lawless. And so what happens is you try to put some order to something that's out of order. And, um, the declaration is the, as I was saying, is the foundation of the Ten Commandments. And that's where our rights come from God. And if we, as a people don't, our constitution isn't working because we're not, we've taken the foundation out of it and we're not teaching it to our children. And so it's really not complicated, but so we just have another filing we want to give you that, um, was filed, just filed yesterday for the, uh, for the attorney and the administrator and so forth. And just, um, it looks like, um, you know, it's coming to a stop, but I'll just read this one last statement here. It says any movement that seeks to place, any movement that seeks to place itself above the constitution must be confronted directly and, and unapologetically. There can be no parallel legal system within the United States. Our country was built on the constitution, which is derived from the Ten Commandments. And that's all I, that's, that's, that's how it all works. And so, um, that's, that's what I have to say. So where do you want me to leave this stuff for, um, for you guys? This was fired in Tallahassee and it's, um, for the county attorney, the administrator and the county commissioners. Thank you. Thanks. Nicole Gebler and then Jessica Kelly. Hello. Welcome. Hello. Good afternoon, chair and commissioners. My name is Nicole Gebler, and I have lived in St. Petersburg my entire life. I've watched Pinellas County grow from a quiet, small town area into a thriving place. It is today. What makes this county and this country special is that people are free to live their lives and practice whatever religion they choose in peace. We need to remember our history. America was not founded as an exclusively Christian nation. It was started by people fleeing religious persecution. At our core, we are a nation of immigrants who bring a beautiful variety of faiths and cultures to our neighborhoods and bringing people together is what makes us grow stronger. That is why I'm honestly disgusted by the racist and bigoted rhetoric being pushed right now against our local Muslim neighbors and their mosque expansion. Those hateful voices do not represent us and they do not speak for how Pinellas County actually feels. Here in this county, we see large and sometimes mega churches, including predominantly white Christian congregations, build and expand all the time without facing this hostility. And if people looked closely, they would see how much the Muslim faith shares with Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, and so many other faiths practice across our beautiful country. All of these traditions share core human values, prayer and reflection, charity to those in need, devotion to family, peaceful living, and treating your neighbor with kindness and respect. In fact, Islam, Christianity, and Judaism all honor the same foundational figures like Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. In Pinellas County houses of worship, every background run food drives, support local schools, care for seniors, and help step up for their neighbors after hurricanes. When we allow a congregation to grow, we aren't losing anything. We are gaining more people invested in making this county and this country better. Amos deserves the exact opportunity to flourish as any church down the road. Protecting equal land right use for one faith protects religious freedom for every faith in Pinellas County. We should be thrilled to have open religious freedom here and welcome any peaceful congregation looking to be positive contributing members to our society. Our Muslim neighbors, please know that you are welcome here. You have the right to worship freely. This community backs you and I back you. I urge this board to reject bigotry. Uphold equal treatment for every faith and keep Pinellas County a place where all congregations are treated with dignity and respect. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Jessica Kelly and then Lisa Offerman. Good afternoon, Commissioners. I'm here for one reason. Equal treatment under the law. This board approved the land use change so a mosque near Tarpon Springs can replace its building with 1,000 square feet. Great. That's a fantastic zoning decision because the First Amendment protects every faith equally and our zoning should too. I looked for a reason that would change my opinion about this mosque. I found no reported crimes, no terror cases tied to this congregation. Its neighbors say they've been good neighbors for years. So I have to ask, why are so many people who invoke their faith worried about 1,000 square feet of a building that's not theirs? Here's what I did find. Last month, a woman cosplayed as a Muslim played a call to prayer in this very building at one of these very podiums, apparently to provoke a fight. And a man was arrested and charged after allegedly calling for a commissioner's beheading over his vote. The disruption and threats in this story came from people opposing the mosque and not from its members. Meanwhile, in Clearwater, the Church of Scientology and its affiliates have bought up around 200 downtown properties, most of them tax-exempt, and many residents say it's taking over downtown. Were those lawful purchases? Where's all the outrage for them? Asking for consistency. A mosque that has broken no law asking for 1,000 square feet deserves decent lawful treatment. I don't follow any scripture, but I've been taught about them. The Hebrew Bible, the Gospels, and the Quran all call us to welcome the stranger and to care for our neighbors. The line between faith and extremism in Florida is very thin. Let me be clear. The moment someone uses God to justify hate, they've left the faith that they claim. This country was founded in part by people fleeing religious persecution. The First Amendment guarantees the free exercise of religion, and Article 6 says that there can be no religious test for public office. Those protections were written for exactly this kind of moment. Fear comes from the uncultured and ignorance. To everyone listening, do me a favor. Visit each other's places of worship. Ask questions. Learn from one another, instead of assuming the worst and letting fear take over. You'll be pleasantly surprised by what you find. So I ask this board to decide on zoning with law and with the Constitution in mind, not fear. We need to be able to all live here and care for one another. Thank you. Thank you, Jessica. Lisa Offerman, and then Dixie Spark, I think. Excuse me. Welcome. Thank you. Just for the record, I did call and ask that a room had more chairs be available so that more people, but there are a lot of empty seats and there are some people out there that would like to be in here. So I don't know if that's possible, but I see probably at least eight empty seats that you could relieve someone from, no, nine, ten, ten empty seats. So maybe the person that's in charge could allow more people to come in. Thank you. Go ahead. Okay. So I'm a resident of Tarpon Springs and I have a few points to make very briefly. I'm confused as to how the members of this commission approved the rezoning. When my husband and I requested the county classify some of our property from residential to agricultural, we had to attend so many hearings. We had so many visits, right? So I find it difficult to believe that careful consideration was provided to the neighbors and those who are impacted most by the request to expand this mosque. That's my first point. I'd also like to call your attention to this article. It was called, is Tampa the new Dearborn? I'm not trying to be inflammatory. I'm just saying that I'm a little concerned about that because 70% of the businesses in Temple Terrace are are owned by in the Muslim community. The, it changes the demographics. So we are, we're a small community in Tarpon Springs. And I'm sorry, if you're talking, I don't think you're listening. Sorry. Did you catch what I said? Commissioner? You were talking about, um, yeah, and then you started talking. So I didn't know if you heard. He asked me a question. I responded. Go ahead. All right. So anyways, I, I just understanding that there are already several mosques, um, in Tampa that are already embroiled in controversy over the impact of the peace and quiet of the neighborhoods, which they exist. It seems to invite this issue into our small community of Tarpon Springs is not the best idea. Given that the sound of donkeys disturbed my neighbors because they're actually earlier and louder than roosters and roosters are often a source of complaint. I can't imagine the issues that will be created with the noise of a horn blowing in densely populated areas, such as the one that's around the mosque. Um, I also would like to remind this board that the application was characterized as a public community gathering place. I don't know how public community gathering place could be classified since there's no trespassing signs all over that area there. That isn't characteristic of any church that I know of or any temple that I know of. So I feel like the application was put through surreptitiously. Thank you. Uh, Dixie spark and Anthony McDaniel. Um, yeah. Hi, I'm here to speak about the mosquito spraying. I personally am an outdoor person. I help with wildlife rescue. I help rescue the shorebirds. And since the mosquito spraying has started, I'm having difficulty breathing. Mind you, I do not smoke. Um, never smoked in my life and I'm having difficult breathing. I've had chest pain since the mosquito spraying has started and have been forced pretty much stay indoors. I can't imagine what this is doing to our wildlife and our birds and our water, our food supply. Also, Florida, because the FWC is spraying our lakes continuously, we have been reported to have the, uh, our lakes in Florida are the most polluted because of this. Anyway, my concern is the acute symptoms from the mosquito spraying, uh, severe and high exposure effects. Inhaling thick mist mist and swallowing large amounts of chemical products can trigger chemical pneumonia, pulmonary edema, muscle tremors, seizures, central nervous system, depression, life-threatening respiratory illness. Children and elderly are especially vulnerable. Individuals with asthma, reactive airway disease, chemical sensitivities face a higher risk of adverse reactions. This is harmful to the pollinators. Broad spectrum, adulticides like synthetic, uh, chemicals do, uh, do not target mosquitoes alone. They kill beneficial insects, including bees, butterflies, dragonflies, and ladybugs. Um, aquatic and wildlife toxicity. Many chemical sprays are toxic to fish, uh, aquatic invertebrates. They leach into the soil and run off into the open water sources. Eliminating beneficial insects and natural predators can disrupt local food webs and occasionally lead to rebound effect where mosquito population actually worsens. Insect resistance. Frequent broad spectrum spraying can drive resistance, creating harder to kill super mosquitoes that require stronger and more frequent chemical interventions. Uh, to minimize risk health and environmental guidelines should be focusing on source reduction, emptying stint standing water using targeted larvicides that are safe. There are many ways to address this other than just spraying. Thank you. Thank you, Dixie. Um, Anthony McDaniel, um, has got, uh, he's a group speaker, so I just need people to wave their hands when I call their name out that have given their three minutes of time. Eileen posh, Maureen's zealous, Pamela LeClaire, and Tina Peters. Okay. Thank you. Um, you'll have 10 minutes. Thank you. Um, thank you ladies for yielding your time. Thank you commission. Uh, for all you do, I really mean that that's not a cynical statement. It's a tough job. And, uh, as a citizen do appreciate all the work of the commission. Sincerely, it's not easy. Um, I come in support of the appeal that I helped put together, uh, to stop the expansion of the mosque. If we, I don't know if we're going to win this. When I was in Sunday school, we were taught a concept, the difference between the letter of the law and the spirit of the law. So I don't know that we're going to win this. I don't, I don't know, but the spirit of the community is that there's grave concerns by the people that live there. Um, there's some people that did not want to come and speak that are living close by. And the reason why is because they lived in Iraq and they lived in Turkey. And when they told me their stories of living in around Muslims who had the upper hand living in Sharia law, I wept. I'm here not because I want to be here. I I don't want to be here. I'm here because I'm gravely concerned about the two ladies that spoke earlier. The two ladies that spoke earlier, I believe the good hearted people. And I wish what they said about Muslims was true. I really do. Um, but the fact of the matter is, I said this a couple weeks ago that who defines Islam? Is it her opinion? Is their opinion? Is it who defines it? And I think we just need to answer that. And for Christians, we know that Jesus defines Christianity. The symbol of Christianity is the cross, a man who gave his life. Muhammad started Islam and he is the best Muslim that's ever lived. You know what the symbol of Islam is? It's a sword. Let that sink in. It's a sword. So I've been asked, the reason why I'm here is that since the meeting on the 27th, I had some people come to me actually from the Pinellas Watchdogs. I want to give them honor. By the way, I'm Anthony McDaniel, president of Florida Faith Foundations. These ladies came to me and said, Hey, we want to help. So we began to work and we began to make contacts with people around the mosque. And we finally found somebody two days before the 30 day deadline. I don't know if this appeal is worth a grain of salt. We don't know what we're doing. I'm not an attorney. We're doing the best we can, but we're doing everything we can to, to stop the expansion of Islam. Let me just tell you, for those people who are sincere, maybe there's two ladies, all of us need to really, okay, Muslim, Islam is a big deal in our country. We just, New York just elected Mom Donnie. Uh, we just elected a Senator. I think the country really needs to go to school in Islam. There's all these opinions. I will tell you one of the best resources I've found is the Center for the Study of PoliticalIslamInternational.org. It's C-P-S-I-I.org. C-P-S-I-I.org. I want to share respect to you. Everybody here is pretty bright people. We need to understand that really Islam, if we just say it's a religion, is really dangerous because there is a side of Islam that is political and very intentional on taking over every host nation. In fact, Mohammed immigrated from Mecca to Medina. He populated, he became political and became a warlord and took over. Every good Muslim was supposed to imitate his life. It's called Hijra. Hijra is the term. So whether you want to get educated or not, they're coming here in big numbers. So I'm actually speaking on behalf of Roy Thomas, who asked me to be here. He's in Atlanta. He's flying. His house is next door to the mosque. Here are his points in respect to him. He said, going back several years, and this is Roy speaking, I called the city code enforcement department to report on the ever deteriorating condition of the property. It was severely overgrown and unkempt. Waste high grass, dead trees, and buildings in disrepair. After several trips to view the property and investigate my complaints, the code enforcement officer said he had cited numerous violations and now it was in the city's hands. The condition of the property has never improved. This is the next door neighbor. Gravely concerned that we're granting them more land, more buildings, more expansion for a very bad neighbor, in his opinion, from the next door neighbor. Number two, five years ago when the property owners requested a zoning change, I attended and voiced my objection. I asked a board member if the violations were still open and what the current fine was. They told me it was approximately one million dollars. Let me say that again. The commissioner at the time told the neighbor that the fines that this mosque had incurred was over one million dollars. How does that happen? However, they were considering lowering it to 100,000. I wonder if they would get the same treatment if they weren't Muslim. No, I'm serious. Have those fines been paid and the violations corrected? Roy wants to know. He actually is much more animated, much more upset, and much more assertive, and I might say aggressive about this. He's the neighbor. I'm just communicating. He's very upset. He really wanted me to stop and ask you and have you respond. I'm not going to do that, but he wants to know if those fines have been paid and have the violations been corrected. Number three, he says, I spoke with the code enforcement officer again, and he said if they're not paying existing fines or moving to correct the violations, there is no point in adding anything else to the list. If it appears that there haven't been any additional complaints since then, it's not because they accepted the responsibility of being a decent, conscientious neighbor. It's because everyone has come to the realization that this is not their goal and never will be. That's significant. Number four, it should have been responsibility. It should have been the responsibility of the county council or the county commission members to do their due diligence and research this information that is readily and easily accessible before agreeing to give these people the opportunity to break more laws and bylaws, which they have no respect for. And I alluded to that in the founder, Muhammad, not my opinion, not these two ladies' opinion who spoke in favor of them. The founder says that every other law is secondary to Sharia law. And I would tell you that most mosques, if you teach the teachings of Muhammad, you are literally practicing sedition, which is conspiring to overthrow the constitution. And I think we need to follow that line of reasoning for those that are listening that are more astute legally than I am. Number five, Roy continues, before extending goodwill and allowing past violations to be overlooked, the council members should have demanded, he capitalized that, demanded a showing of goodwill from the property owner and considered a request after and only after they paid their fines and corrected all the violations. Number six, thank you. I got a clock here. I've been watching. Thank you. We shouldn't be rewarding people for violating our laws. And that is what the council members did because it didn't impact any of them personally. That's his words, not mine. The next door neighbor. Isn't that your primary responsibility as an elected official? To protect our community from people that take advantage and erode the value of the communities we call home. So those are Roy's words. Um, I said a lot in the last meeting. Um, we, I had people come to me and wanted to work together to try to stop the expansion. Like I said earlier, I don't know if that appeal has any effect. I appreciate the County attorney, uh, letting us know on the 27th, that there was a window of opportunity. We've done the best we can for those that are watching this commission meeting by recording. Now's the time to, to, to move away from apathy and move away from comfort. We are not in a comfortable time in America. We're not in a comfortable time. The, the, the people with Muslim oil money are paying for a lot of stuff. We need to learn how to track, track this down. Are there good Muslims? Yes. I had a haircut in Atlanta about a week or so. A Kurdish lady had an accent and I said to her, cause I like to have a conversation. I noticed the accent. Where are you from? Kurdistan. I'm like, wow. And I'm just, I'm a free talker. We started talking. She is a moderate Muslim. She's a wonderful lady. She has largely assimilated to our, uh, way of life, which is built on Judeo-Christian values. The 10 commandments that Greg Pound referred to love your neighbor as yourself. You know, that's, that's how we, it was a great conversation. Her husband's name is Muhammad. He doesn't like Muslims. Interesting. He gets mad at her because during Ramadan, she puts on a hijab out of respect for her tradition. If the Muslims that were similar are coming to our country, we're like that family. We'd be good. But the problem is if you spend any time on the social media, listening to imams across the country, they are basically saying, listen, whether you like it or not, Sharia is coming and we're coming to every household. If you haven't watched that stuff, you need to watch that right now. 81% of the Somali Muslim immigrants that are in Minneapolis are on public welfare of some sort. They're not coming to make our country better or give a great opportunity. There are a lot of largely, a lot of them are coming to, to get what we can give them and undermine our system. Certainly not all fall in that category. But unfortunately, if what I hear is 10% are the expansionist political Islamists, that's a not. In fact, we've seen historically over the last 1400 years, it takes 15% to 20% of agitating Muslims to flip a society. In 30 years after Muhammad's death, the known Christian world was taken over. I'm here to sound an alarm. I don't want to be here. I'm not an expert, but I know about this. And I pray that you guys hear us and work with us to stop the expansion of Islam in general across Pinellas County. Thank you, Anthony. We have another guest group speaker, Tracy Penneke, for four people. I need them to raise their hands, please, when I call them. Jess Griffith, Griffin. Okay. Bryce Griffin. Just raising your hand. That's all. Jennifer McClure. Okay. And Gabriel Greco. Okay. Gabrielle. Sorry. Okay. You have 10 minutes. Yeah, right there. Thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners. Thank you for hearing us out today. I am here not only to speak for myself, but on the behalf of many residents throughout our community who have reached out, shared their experiences, asked questions, and are looking for answers. These are people who care about their families, their neighborhoods, and the environment that we all share. We are here because our voices deserve to be heard. Our community deserves transparency, and we also have a say in decisions that affect our health and the environment. I want to start with what prompted me to look into all of this. On the morning of November 6, the day after the aerial spraying, I woke up to having almost completely lost my voice. At that time, I had no idea that the mosquito treatment had taken place. I want to note, I have a time-stamped voice message from the night of November 5th and the morning of November 6 that document exactly how my voice sounded. This isn't a recollection weeks later. I have a digital record of the timeline, and here we are 11 days later, and I am still symptomatic, and my voice has still not returned to normal. I have never in my life experienced anything like this. My body is always a quick healer. When I told my friend I had no voice, it was only then that I had learned about the aerial spraying. After that conversation, I started looking into what was being sprayed, and I made a public post. Residents immediately began reaching out with experiences of their own. That post received 30,000 views with almost zero scrutiny, which means people are paying attention. As I continued looking into this, I learned that the nighttime spraying had begun on October 15th. Three days later, on October 18th, I started experiencing daily low-grade headaches. I remember that day specifically because I had an event at my studio on that day, and I remember having to take Motrin to make it through the event that lasted seven hours. I rarely get headaches, yet they continued every day for about two weeks. At that time, I still knew nothing about the spraying. It was only after learning the timeline that I started connecting the dots and looking more closely at the whole situation. And I want to be clear that I understand that dengue is a real public health concern. I am a mosquito-prone person, and they're always getting me, so it was definitely a concern for me when I learned about dengue. However, protecting public health means looking at the whole picture, including the effects of the methods that are being used to address it. As of right now, there are some very important questions that remain unanswered. What exactly is being released into our environment? Pinellas County has expanded mosquito control operations involving nighttime spraying, larvicide treatments, and aerial applications. On November 5th, helicopters conducted aerial liquid applications over parts of St. Pete and Clearwater. The county identified BTI as the active ingredient. BTI is a bacteria that produces proteins that are toxic to certain larvae when eaten, but knowing the active ingredient does not tell us everything about the actual product being sprayed over our neighborhoods. For example, the EPA label for Vectabac, WDG, lists 37.4% active ingredients and 62.6 other ingredients that we do not know the names of. We need to know the actual product mixture. What information is available about all of its ingredients? How much is it being diluted? And how much is being applied? Simply naming the active ingredient is not enough. We deserve to know what else is in this product, how it is being diluted, and exactly how much is being sprayed over our neighborhoods. History has shown us that pesticides can remain widely used for years before serious concerns lead to restrictions and cancellations. DDT, and more recently, Dactyl, are examples. We cannot treat government approval as a reason to stop asking questions. We need continued review, complete information, and accountability. A community member and ally, Sarah Jessica, contacted the mosquito control department directly to ask what product was being used during the aerial operation. During that conversation, a department representative identified Vectabac, and according to Sarah, when the representative got to that product, he told her, you're not going to like this one. So, now we have a product name. What we still need is the actual product information. We are asking the county to release the exact formulation, complete ingredient information, dilution radios, and application rates. Residents should not have to make phone calls and piece together verbal answers to find out what is being released into our neighborhoods. We have busy lives, and we're all trying to do our best to survive in this economy as is. I myself have lost two weeks of work due to not feeling well from the spring. So, now we have a product identified for the aerial application, but that still leaves another part of these operations that need to be addressed, the nighttime truck spraying. These trucks have been operating through our communities during overnight hours where people are sleeping. We need the exact names, active ingredients, EPA registration numbers, amounts being applied, routes, and spraying schedules. We need to know whether these products are being rotated, which neighborhoods are being treated, how often the spraying takes place, and what determines when spraying begins, continues, or stops. For aerial applications, we need to know how hard the helicopter is flying, the size of droplets being released, wind speeds, directions, how far the spray may travel beyond the treatment areas. These are basic records, and the public should have access to all of them. As I mentioned earlier, when I shared my experience, residents began contacting me with experiences of their own. People reported headaches, congestion, coughing, throat irritation, loss of voice, and nausea. I also received reports involving children getting sick while playing outdoors, including one mother whose child suddenly vomited while playing outside with other children. One man reported driving on the interstate when the mist from a helicopter flying about 20 feet above his head landed on his windshield, and when he turned on his wipers, it left a smear across the glass. I want to share another part of what I've been seeing. I have an apothecary, and part of my work involves helping people find herbal support when they're feeling sick. During these recent mosquito control operations, three separate customers who have been year-long customers of mine who regularly purchased my elderberry syrup told me it wasn't working for them the way they had faithfully come to expect throughout the years. These are faithful clients. One customer went through two jars. Another finished an entire jar and decided to try something else before buying more, and a third customer reported the same experience. I also supplied other herbal supports I commonly recommend for respiratory complaints that were not working in the way that they usually do. Even in my own experience, the remedies I normally turn to for respiratory support have not provided me any relief. I'm sharing these accounts because they are first-hand reports from people I know personally in our community. They deserve to be documented, investigated, and taken very seriously. This is why I began to put together a community symptom timeline covering reports beginning October 15th and continuing through these recent applications. I would like to pass this on to somebody who can take that. I intend to keep updating it, and I want to include it in the public report. I also want a direct answer from the county. What process is in place for receiving, documenting, and investigating health complaints following these mosquito control applications? Where did this report go? Who reviews them? Are they tracked by date and location? Are patterns being looked at? And are these reports considered when deciding whether or not to continue this extended spraying? We cannot understand the impact of these operations if we are not listening to the people who are experiencing them. Again, I understand the concerns surrounding dengue, and I also understand damned if you do and damned if you don't. But addressing mosquito-borne illness should not mean overlooking real public concerns. What other options have been considered? What non-chemical methods are being used? How is standing water being found and addressed? How is the county measuring whether these applications are actually working? And are targeted treatments and removing mosquito breeding areas being prioritized before broad spraying? We need an approach that protects public health without putting communities and our environment at unnecessary risk. There's another important issue, the public money being spent on these operations. We want a full of count of the money being spent. That means purchase orders, invoices, delivery records, quantity to purchase, contractor payments, and any changes to existing agreements. These are tax dollars being spent in our neighborhoods. Residents have every right to see exactly where that money is going and how these decisions are being made. Commissioners, at the heart of this all is a simple issue. People should not have to fight for basic information about what is being released into our environment. We should not have to piece together answers through phone calls, scattered documents, and word of mouth. We expect the county to make all product information, spraying records, purchasing records, and all other details available to the public. We want to see the records behind these decisions, and we want answers questioned by being raised by the residents. And we want the community included in decisions that directly affect where we live. I also want to recognize everyone who has taken the time to reach out, share their experiences, make calls, gather information, and show up. People have families, jobs, and responsibilities of their own. They are taking time out of their lives because they believe something is important, isn't happening in our community, and we should not have to work this hard to get transparency. So I want to leave you with this. You are here to serve the people of our community. You represent us, and you work for us. Our tax dollars fund these operations, and we are the people who live beneath those helicopters. Thank you, Tracy. Thank you. Ma'am, I have a couple questions for you, if you don't mind. And I apologize if you mentioned it. What part of Pinellas do you live? St. Petersburg, Florida, Palmetto Park. Okay. Do you know how far from the spring you live? I will say on the day of November 6th, I heard them and saw them above my head all day long. Okay. So like you're right there? Right there. Okay. Um, Barry, can we get the ingredients, uh, for the spring? Or is that like some sort of trade secret or? Well, we should know all the ingredients that are being sprayed on us. Hang on, where? You need to let staff respond. The, um, I'll have to get with staff. Um, obviously I don't know the answer to that at this point. Um, but we'll follow up with you. Okay. Yeah, please do. So we can get that to our residents. Yeah. And if you could leave a copy of your comments, could you leave a copy? So, cause I think you had a lot of. I just handed her a community timeline. We got it. Okay. And for the, uh, part about the funding, uh, since we're in a state of emergency, uh, we're receiving state funds, uh, for, for all that. So it's not property tax dollars or whatnot. So it's all state funding. I understand, but we, as the people should still know what would be a straight way. Oh, absolutely. And a state of emergency, like one, less than 1% of the population has been affected by this. Yeah. I'd rather take my chances with dengue, honestly. Yeah. Yeah. So we will, um, we will get that, uh, I promise you, we will get that information for you. Well, we would also like to know all the other ingredients, the 67 points, 62.7% ingredients. You have that. We also want to know. I just want to make, yeah, I was just making sure that we had that your, your questions and your asks. Thank you. And she said we do. So, okay. Thank you. Thank you so much. Appreciate it. Yeah. Commissioner flowers. I wasn't sure. I may have misunderstood when you were, um, asking for certain documents. Did you say that you've requested the documents and you haven't gotten them or, you know, through a public records request? I personally, myself have tried to make an account on the Pinellas County website. And for some reason it keeps on booting me off. So I have not been able to submit that request, but I know members that I'm working with in the community have, but they are giving us the active ingredient. Yes. Which is vector back as has been confirmed. However, that is still less than half of what's being used. I wasn't talking about the specific, I was just talking about all of the items you were saying that you wanted to receive. I can hand, I can put, hand this right on over. No, maybe we're not connecting. Yeah. When you were listing, you were saying the public wants an accounting of, and you gave a list of a number of things I was trying to write as fast as you're talking. I have, but I was just trying to figure out if you had requested those items from us and we had not gotten them to you. I was going to ask that we, I understand what you're saying. Um, and if you had requested them, had not requested them, I was going to ask if we could get them. I'm requesting them right now. Okay. All right. So now we're, we're, yes. Okay. Thank you. And, and we have that information, right? That we're going to, we, what you provided was that the list of questions or was that a timeline? That's the community timeline. And also on the bottom of that are, is a list of questions. Yes. But the main focus of that was to document, uh, people in the community who have been experiencing symptoms of their own. Okay. So if you, could you leave that copy? Absolutely. That'd be great. 100%. That's who I brought it for. Appreciate it. Commissioner Nowicki. Since we're briefly on the topic, uh, Commissioner Latval brought up a reimbursement. I think we've got like one and a half million from the state, but we're pulling another three and a half from County reserves. Do we have written commitment from the state that we're going to get reimbursed for that three and a half million? No, we have, we are receiving, um, material, uh, chemicals from the state, uh, I believe, or reimbursement for that. That's the only part I'll have to break down in terms of the cost we have, because this is all, all out effort. We have overtime costs. We have chemical costs. We have the contract with Lee County. Um, so there's different things. So we'll have to break that down and we'll provide that for you. And also like what precautions are being taken for people who have chemical sensitivities like myself. Okay. Thank you. Appreciate your comments today. Um, all right. Catherine Castiglione. I'm sure I didn't say that right, but please you're next and correct me when you get to the microphone and, uh, then, uh, Luanne Rice is after that. Good afternoon. And I think you said it right. It's Castelloni. Yeah. I think I had our hard G instead of a soft G. You could say Castiglione. There's like three ways to say it. Okay. Thank you. Um, so thank you, Jess. Oh, sorry. Hold on. Let him get that set for you first. Back to three. Thank you. I thought you touched something. Go ahead. Per usual. Jess, thank you so much. That was very elaborate. I don't have the time to do any of that, but Jess and Jen have really been helpful trying to pull the community together to speak on the community's behalf regarding the spray. As you can hear, my voice has been like this for over a week now. Um, and I don't have any dates because I am busy. 99% of the time I take care of these kids by myself, homeschool, and I work full time, but I did want to make sure that I came out here just to, um, give an account of what we've experienced since, uh, the spray started. So he goes to a co-op in Safety Harbor and I don't remember what day it was that we were there, but they, they sprayed directly above us and he has a soccer class. And after it was done, a lot of the kids stated that they were very itchy. They were itching their arms and their legs. And after that day of them being outside, we all developed a cough and now my throat is horrible. You can't barely hear me. So I apologize, but I just wanted to come up here to say that it's really important for us to make sure that we are providing a safe environment for our children. They are our future. We have to do better for them. We have to make sure that we're not poisoning people, that the spray is not harming their, their environment, their, um, lifestyle. We didn't even want to go outside after this. The sun is very important for our immune systems. We should be able to play outside and not be fearful of what is happening in the sky that we are all allowing. Right. So did you have something to say? I kept, uh, when they sprayed at the time and like, uh, the ingredient kept like burning my legs and my arms. Yeah. They were really itchy and they were very uncomfortable. So I just wanted to make sure that I backed up their account that we're just one of many, many, many families that have noticed, um, side effects after the spraying. So I think we should really look into that to make sure that we're not only protecting ourselves, but our children who are the future. Thank you. Thank you. Ma'am, uh, what part of Pinellas do you live? I live in Oldsmar, Florida. All right. Thank you. You're welcome. Okay. Luanne Rice. Luanne Rice, 1209 East Boyer Street, Tarpon Springs. Um, this map, I'm not going to show exactly where, but anyways, this is the Tarpon Springs fun map. It shows 19 and it shows Keystone Road and here's Lake Tarpon and here's a small lake, Salt Lake up above, and here's Keystone Road. Now this road accommodates everybody over on this side. Ma'am, ma'am, can you speak into that microphone so we can hear you? Oh, thank you. I'm sorry. Should I stop from the beginning? Go, yeah, go ahead. Go ahead and start from the beginning. Go ahead. Give it three minutes. Um, this is a Tarpon Springs fun map. This is 19 here. This is Keystone Road and it goes between two lakes. Uh, Lake Tarpon being the larger one, but, uh, Salt Lake, actually there's more bayous up north of that. So like, if you don't use this road, uh, Keystone Road to go east-west, you'll have to go all the way down to Tampa Road, which is, it's crowded and, or up to 54. Um, I mean, there may be back roads before you get to 54, but anyways, there's, the road is used by everybody in the area. And when, right now, I mean, they're saying in, in 22, they did a traffic study and in 22, it was at 50 or 54 percent, uh, utility, but, but you go down that road and depending on what time of day it is, you may have to wait through three lights to go north on East Lake Road. And, you know, how many, how many lights do we want to, uh, sit through? I mean, you know, the traffic backs up into, you know, you're not even in a turn lane anymore. And, uh, you know, there's other, um, institutional, uh, community facilities, whatever we want to call them on this street where, I mean, there's a church that when they have a big gathering, uh, you know, they've had to have police there and stop traffic in both directions to let people out of the parking lots. You know, this street can't be, continue to be enlarged. I mean, what are we going to do? Uh, you know, put a second level or something. I mean, we need to protect this little corridor here for all the people that live on this side of 19 that want to go, uh, you know, East to, uh, you know, Tampa. I mean, a lot of people commute or you go to the airport or, you know, I mean, and the other roads East and West are, are very crowded already and you have to go considerably far out of your way to avoid that street. So I'm just against more and more development on that little, uh, Avenue there that has been, you know, residential and rural for a long time. And people have bought up in that area specifically, you know, for that purpose. So I just, I don't want to see it get backed up all the way to 19 where people are, I mean, people are impatient in traffic already. So that's a point I want to make. Thank you, Luanne. Thank you. Appreciate it. Okay. We have two zoom calls. The first one would be Michelle Watley. Michelle Watley, can you please raise your hand in the zoom application? We'll go ahead and unmute you. Michelle, go ahead and speak, say your name and address and you have three minutes. Good afternoon, commissioners. My name is Michelle Watley. I live in Florida. Residents, including children, as well as animals are reportedly getting sick during and or immediately following the County's relentless spray operations and residents are demanding answers. Yet government agencies continue assuring the public that mosquito spraying is completely safe. So let's address that for a second, shall we? On October 19th, 2026, the Pinellas County government stated, and I quote, BTI is not harmful to humans, pets, or pollinators. And your own website states, the bacteria is safe for other insects, people, and animals. With statements like these, I have to question if you are intentionally misleading the public into believing that you are spraying is simply BTI and carries zero potential risk. Because when you look at the Vecto-backed WDG label, independent safety studies, and the EPA's documented reports of adverse events, they clearly contradict these notions. For one, BTI is less than 40% of the ingredients. So what exactly is the other 62.6% of the formulation? Despite the misleading statements that have literally just occurred, even if the Mosquito District is in possession of the full formulation, they are prohibited by law to share those trade secrets with the public. How can I give informed consent if you refuse to tell us the full formulation? When did protecting a corporation become more important than protecting the public in our environment? But I digress. When the Pinellas County government stated it is not harmful in an attempt to assure what they are dousing their residents in has no possible health risk, were they aware that the Vecto-backed WDG label itself states caution harmful if inhaled and avoid breathing spray mist? Were they aware of the safety study showing that repeated aerosol exposure in mice could increase their odds of experiencing respiratory distress and lung inflammation that could persist for at least 70 days after exposure? The National Pesticide Information Center states that the EPA has been receiving reports of laryngitis, breathing problems, nose and throat irritation, watery or irritated eyes, and headaches during or immediately following a BTI-containing pesticide for decades. Decades. So when you blanket the public in this pesticide and the public starts reporting to you that hundreds of them are experiencing those exact same symptoms or worse during or immediately following your spray operations, the only reasonable action for the county to take is to immediately cease its use within the county and ban its future use to ensure public safety. Furthermore, I reject your mandate mentality that you don't need our consent to expose us to pesticides. The EPA knows do not come without potential safety risk in spite of the greater good. Stop the spray. My rights don't end where your fear begins. Thank you. Thank you, Michelle. Michelle Pendenza. Michelle Pendenza, please go ahead and raise your virtual hand in a Zoom application. We'll go ahead and unmute you. Michelle, go ahead. You have three minutes. State your name and address, please. Uh, hi. Uh, my name is Michelle Pendenza. I'm, um, uh, 30 Pinewood Court, uh, uh, Palm Harbor, Florida, Tarpon Woods. Go ahead. You have three minutes. Okay. Um, my name is Michelle Pendenza Hollage. I'm a resident of Tarpon Woods, uh, neighborhood in Eastlake, unincorporated Pinellas County. Um, some of you may know me as a neighborhood act, uh, advocate for Tarpon Woods, um, an opponent of Amendment 3, uh, but I'm mostly known as Michelle from Nextdoor. Uh, we don't get to pick what people call us, uh, though I do appreciate that I'm frequently called the voice of reason. I'm here today to speak on behalf of my Muslim neighbors. As we are seeing, uh, continue today, a permit to perform construction on their place of worship, Majid al-Rahman, has been met with some friction. I know that there was already intense public, uh, comment on the subject. Uh, we're seeing more of that today. What motivated me to enter this conversation was something I noticed when following the news on this issue. I kept getting alerts out of Loganville, Georgia. They are having almost a mirror image public conversation where the atmosphere is tense and there have been similar theatrics designed to create tension and inflame relations regarding a building permit for a mosque, which is being reframed by their media as an Islamic training center. When people like Laura Loomer are sounding off and former members of Moms for Liberty are acting out in response to what should be a boring public planning discussion, no shade, I know the work is important. It piques my interest. I decided to check the ACLU's nationwide anti-mosque activity page where they track among vandalism and other acts efforts to block and deny permits for mosque construction and expansion. What I saw looking at the state, looking at state after state was a flurry of permit opposition activity in 2018. Then after that, nothing until now. My profession is digital marketing. It's my job to look at data and recognize patterns and trends. 2018 was eight years ago. Eight years ago we were in a very similar spot nationally and politically, with the same president at the same midpoint in his presidency, surrounded by some of the same types of inflammatory personalities. I feel it's very important we do our best not to give air to people who might seek to sow division and start fires in our country to distract the population from other issues that are falling out of favor on the national stage. Ms. Jed Rahman has existed in its current location for over 10 years. To say that it has racked up over a million dollars and wasn't brought before the county magistrate is Michelle, Michelle, thank you for your, that was three minutes, ma'am. No problem, thank you. Okay, that's all the comment cards that I had today. And any questions, comments around the table? And we'll move on to our consent agenda. Is there anything that we need to pull or do we have a motion? Motion by Commissioner Flowers, second by Commissioner Peters. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion carries unanimously. We are on to... Commissioner Eggers, can I just back up just a second? On the public comments, I mean, I know Kelly does a really good job. And I love that Commissioner Latval is asking for the ingredients to be posted. But I do find myself with someone who has breathing issues, sharing many of the same concerns that these people have. And so I think being a little more transparent on the website would be a very, very good idea. Because I certainly would not want to be outside and getting exposed to any of that spraying, given the issues that many of you know I have. So just an FYI, I wanted to say that. And I really think that more transparency is significantly better. And I think it's something that I'd like to talk about and keep track of very closely. So, Commissioners, we do have information out on the website. But to your point, it's more broad. Kelly can point me into a better area. No, don't come up. I, you know, we're not going to debate that here. But I asked for that. I was looking at it while she's sending it to me. I couldn't see it. She says she has it. Fine. Well, we'll make sure it's out there. The public can see that. And it's transparent. I've also asked them, too, what's the certification that it's safe? Where does that come from? Who stamps that? It's not Pinellas County. And so we'll follow up from a staff standpoint. We'll get that information both to you. And we'll post it on our website. And I appreciate that. But I think even if we stay it safe, we always should have that warning that if you have asthma or if you have some other of those things, that you need to take extra protections for yourself and your family members. I mean, I think promoting it and advertising that that's what's happening is good. But I think we also should be reminding people that if you have issues, you need to be very cautious and very aware and take care of yourselves. And that is on our website. Thank you. And I saw that. But we do need to promote that. Thank you. So we'll get David Conner involved and, you know, he'll improve the outreach. Yeah. Well, I think as being raised, there seems to be more questions than answers. Correct. And I think our residents deserve that extra special treatment because this can be, as they pointed out, some health issues that may be arising because of it. So I think, you know, a higher level of, you know. No, I 100% agree. I think the concerns are raised. We need to respond to that concern and help with putting all the information out the best we can. Okay. And while we had that little respite, we had somebody else sign a card. Christine, we had moved on. But if you'll agree to just use two minutes of your time, we'll do two minutes for Christine McClure. Come on up. I was almost moving on. I should have kept my comments quicker. I'll look. Christine, did you waive your time? No, it was Jennifer McClure. It was Jennifer McClure. You've got two minutes. Okay. My name is Chris Clure, and I live in this wonderful county of Pinellas. We need to know what's going on in our county. And we need a way to find out. And we need two meetings a month. It's not good enough to do once a month, and it's not good enough to just post the information on a newspaper nobody reads anymore. We need to have the information posted online, and everybody should find, we all should know where it's going to be posted, what subjects are going to be spoke about, because this is our county. This is my home. I worked my entire life, and most of us did, to live in a paradise such as this. And if things are going on behind our back, we don't know about, I'm not saying there's any wrongdoing, but we should know about it. We should all be attuned to what's going on. We need a website that says when these meetings are to take place, what's going to be discussed, because this is our home, and it's not good enough to pass something, and then we find out about it. And that's what everybody says. You know, something happens, and you say, well, I don't ever remember anybody discussing this. We never voted on this, because they don't know when these meetings take place. We can't have a whole room full of people every meeting. The meeting should be announced online, or wherever they are, a type of way that people actually go. They don't, nobody buys a newspaper anymore except to do a crossword puzzle. It needs to be posted online, and the subjects to be discussed in a clear and concise manner. We need what everybody in America seems, says they want, it's transparency. Agreed. And our agendas are posted online, pinealscounty.gov. You can go there to find out what's on the agenda, what's going to be discussed. Yep. It just gives you topics, and it also gives you some backup information on there. I appreciate that. And the meetings are always held twice a month, correct? Not every month. Sometimes it's once a month. Because there's just not enough to be discussed. Just, yeah, no, there's always something to be discussed, but depends on the situation within the month. Holidays come into play, so we shorten the month a little bit, and we probably have one meeting a month, maybe four months out of the year. So the other eight months, seven months, we have two meetings a year, including multiple budget hearings during June and July. Okay, I appreciate it, and it looks like in this room, most of us have worked hard their entire life to call this home. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. All right. We are going to move on to the regular agenda, item 22. Motion by Commissioner Nowicki, second by Commissioner Latvala. Are there any comments or questions on item 22? Bring up the voting card, please. What's that? Oh. Motion carries unanimously. Item 23. First Amendment to a Resolution Adopting MSTU Project Funding Program Guidelines. We discussed these with the commissioners. The final three bullets are new items to incorporate within the program. Okay. Any questions and any motion, please? Motion by Commissioner Flowers. Second by Commissioner Peters. Any questions? Yes, ma'am. Commissioner Flowers. Not a question, just a comment. I want to thank them for the tracking summary chart, because that, you know, instead of having to look all over for the information, everything was right there in the tracking summary chart. So, I just wanted to say thank you. Oops. Dropped my thing. Just wanted to say thank you for that. Okay. Thank you. Bring up the voting card, please. Oh, you already have. Thank you. Motion carries unanimously. Item 24. This is in your local agreement with the City of Clearwater. Provides them an additional time to complete the City's portion of the Gulf Boulevard improvements. This is part of the Penny for Pinellas Program. Okay. Motion by Commissioner Nowicki. Second by Commissioner Flowers. Any comments, questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 25. This is the same thing, except for the City of St. Petersburg. I'm sorry, St. Pete Beach. This provides additional time for their Gulf Boulevard improvements. Motion by Commissioner Flowers. Second by Commissioner Nowicki. Any comments or questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 26. This is contract with the State of Florida Department of Health for the annual operations of our Health Department. Motion by Commissioner Peters and second by Commissioner Flowers. Questions? Yes, I did have a question. Commissioner Shearer, please. Barry, I was looking at the cost for the school nurse programs. Correct. And it's just the $2 million for 43 full-time school nurses. Do we pick up all the costs for the school nurses? We do. That seems very small. $47,000 for a full-time nurse. Is there no benefits? Those are questions I would have to ask staff. And I don't have Dr. Cho here. But we pay for the school nurse program, correct? Or that's not a shared cost, is it, Chris? No. And it's not every school. And the intent was to get every school covered, but it's not every school. Right. No, I get that. It's just it says 43 full-time school nurses, which is great. But it just seemed like $2 million was $47,000 per nurse. I just want somebody to verify that number because it doesn't look right to me. We'll follow up and get back to you. But that is the cost of the program, but yes. Okay. Sorry. It's not 12 months of the year because school isn't 12 months of the year. And that could be the difference. I don't know the answer. Let me follow up. That likely could be. I know I would use dollars to get some money. Right. And they never. Only during the school year. Some schools only get four hours or they're sharing a nurse. So it's four hours at one school, four hours at another. And mostly they're LPNs, not RNs. So you're looking at about $24 to $30 an hour for salary wage instead of $40 plus for an RN. So we usually add the costs of pension plans and health insurance. I don't think that that's included in this cost. Well, the health department is only going to provide the service if we pay for the service. So I'm just trying to understand the number. That's a great, I can't answer the question. And I look back to staff and I don't think they, Karen, do you have more information on that? Okay. They're probably contracted. Yeah. So there's no. Karen Yasham, Human Services Department Director. I can get a breakdown of the salary per nurse. It is 40 nurses. It is, as Commissioner Flowers mentioned, it's 15 RNs and 24 LPNs. And it is jointly funded by the Department of Health, the Board of County Commissioners, and schools. So they may have, the Board of Health may have other matching funds from the state. Is that what you're saying? Yeah, but I can give a full breakdown of their salaries and their period of time that they operate, right? Because it wouldn't be a full 12 months. It would be the school year. Okay. Sure. I'll get it. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Scheer. Any other questions or comments? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 27. It's a word of bid to Southern Road and Bridge. This is for marine construction. It's a work order contract. So versus doing small jobs, this allows them to act quickly on smaller jobs. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second by Commissioner Flowers. Any questions? I did have questions. Go ahead. Sorry. It's okay. Go ahead. I've got a few questions today. On the bids, you know, I try to do a thorough job of reviewing these, but I didn't just see description in here anywhere of what they bid on. It's a work order. So they do it as a unit pricing. So as a job comes up that's within their capital plan, they can simply give it to that, and it's already bid by a unit pricing. They cobble together the work, and then that becomes the price for the contract. Right. So if it's a time of materials contract, I get that. You know, they bid this much per hour or this much for the material, and then I understand that. But this is an $8 million bid. So obviously they had some kind of projects they were asked to bid on. Tell you, you want to come up and speak to it? Well, we have that, like, with our construction projects. And so somebody says we want to move these walls. We want to renovate that. But we allocate a certain amount of money, but that job or contract can be used to cobble that together rather than bid each and every job. And so they do it for speed. And I get that. I just think it would be nice to have a list of what these jobs entail, because I don't know what we're proving, quite honestly. Yeah. So this is an annual contract. So there aren't specific projects identified. These are these, this is, and it's, the contractor doesn't get that money. So let's say, for example, we're doing a repair job at, you know, one of Park's boat ramps. We would scope out that repair work, apply the unit costs in the contract to that job, and then they'd get a work order simply for that amount for that work. And it goes, and we use it for all their peers. And so it's just a general work order contract that we use for a variety of, of assignments, but it's, it's not guaranteeing them. No, I completely understand what you're saying. It's just, to me, it just looks strange because it's, there's no, there's no time and materials listed. There's no, well, I don't know. I don't know if it, if you're just saying, okay, they bid that they're going to supply this kind of material, this kind of time, it's going to cost this much for this. That I understand, but this is, these are two sums. One came in at eight and a half million and one came in at 11 million. I don't know what they're, again, it's, it's not time and materials or a schedule because it's dependent on the assignment that they're given. So if we have them replace a boardwalk in Sawgrass Lake Park, the, what they give us is going to be a very specific, it's, it's this much, you know, decking, it's this much concrete, it's this much, you know, all of the things needed to construct that, to reconstruct that boardwalk and the work order is very specific to it. And the time that they're given to do that work will be in the work, in the purchase order for that individual assignment. So we have a lot of annual contracts like this for a variety of work, including paving, sidewalk repair, guardrail repair. Like your sidewalk repair, that usually you have them bid a certain amount of sidewalk to give them the price. No, they, no, they can, they can do a job order contracting too. So in other words, you know, it's, it's per linear foot. And so when she goes out to do a job, we say, how much do we have? And then they cobble together for that. That's it. Same thing on this. Per linear foot. So I have no idea what this is. Per unit pricing of that type of work. So everything's broken down within that contract. So then they're using the bid unit pricing for that type of work. Then they will cut, they will pull that together after the scope is defined to be able to create the contract price between them and the County for the work that they're doing. But if I may, commissioner, I think what you're asking is that price per square foot isn't in here. So you don't know what they're actually, do you know how that is broken down within that? So, well, again, it's, it's dependent on the line items that are necessary for each job, but yeah, the, yes, all of the, all of the detailed line items, how much cost per square foot for each individual thing. Yes. Is that, but was, is that within the bid? It, it, yes. I mean, they have to submit the bid. We got two bidders. They have to submit their line items. So that's in the backup materials, what you're saying? Yeah. Well, I didn't, I couldn't find anything like that. So I just get that. Absolutely. Can you get that work? I'll send it to all of you. I just, I have a hard time approving an $8 million contract when I have no idea what I understand, commissioner. Yep. Okay. We, we can, we'll, we can send that detailed itemized list to you. Okay. And I'll have the same question on 29 as well, because it's all the same thing. So I'll just skip that. So any other questions on 27? No. And did I have a motion and a second? There is. Did we already have a motion and a second? Okay. We had a motion and a second. You have that. All right. Bring up the voting. Oh, I'm sorry. Commissioner Flowers. Because the voting tab has come up, so I can't see my, um, can we get rid of the voting? Okay. I got it. I got it. So I was just sharing. I thought I read some of the specifics about what they were asking for. So when I went to, um, when you click on our, on the link for the, for our item, and then on the side where they have the different details of it, I clicked on the specifications where it says attachments. Um, I clicked on specifications, supplemental signed, et cetera, et cetera. And it's the starting at the third page. I don't know if that's what you're looking for, but starting at the third page, it kind of separates out item number, pipe remover, two inch by 18 inch. It kind of gives each thing that they're doing. That's where I found when I was looking for what the, what kind of work they would be doing. We'll send, we'll send it out to the chart. Yeah. I was just sharing, you know, cause I go through all the links that you all put in for the attachments. It's a, it's a binder one it, like starting at page 92, uh, 343. So 92nd page under binder one it B two six. That's when it starts giving the unit price per each, for each item. Yeah. It seems a little expensive, but you know, I'm sure Barry would do a good job not to use it all. Any other questions? Um, we have a motion and a second, bring up the voting card, please. Oh, you already did. There we go. Motion carries five to two item 28. So ranking affirms with, uh, Wharton Smith. This is for the cross Bayou athletic field complex. This is for phase one, which is the design phase as part of the overall project. So I have a question, Mr. Chair, uh, commissioner Peters. So, uh, I do have a question and I fully support this. I don't want anyone to think that I don't support this. I do and it's a long time coming and I'm very excited that it's going to happen. But I have a question on the award and you picked a really great reputable company and the partners, I read their contract and their proposal that all looks great, but I, you know, there's a $150,000 difference and I don't see the other proposal. So I just, I don't know who did the ranking, but why, you know, typically I don't know that we always go with the most expensive one. We don't always go with the least expensive one, but I'm just questioning on whoever did the ranking. Um, cause I know some of these other companies and they're all really good, credible companies as well. So I just, we're going into some tough budget years in the future and I'm just curious why we went with the most expensive Kelly. And I'm sure, like I said, Kimley Horn, they're all really great partners. I mean, obviously it's, you know, we have our engineering team, but we, we also have, um, our professional, um, purchasing team. They put together a team, they rank them, they evaluate the bids based upon criteria that they listed out in the bids. And that's how they make this selection recommendation. Okay. I was just curious. So help me understand a little better. Kelly. Yeah. I mean, this is the CCNA process. So you're basically ranking the firms based on their qualifications, not on cost. Okay. Yeah. So the, you, this is the design that next will come the bid for the actual construction. And so, yeah, I, yeah. Good point, Kelly. Okay. Well, I will move approval. Um, but just know that that's something that I think we have to be a little more. Reputation is great. Um, and, and I know there's some other ones on there that have great reputations, so I would have been confident with pretty much most of them. So just, just thank you. Um, very real, real quickly on the funding for this agreement is available under the Seminole Recreation Facilities Unincorporated, including the fiscal year capital improvement plan. That's for that plan for five years. The 18 million is for the five year plan. Correct. This is the penny for Pinellas. And so these are all the improvements planned, planned. Right. So they still have to be a day designed and be brought back here. Correct. For approval. That's correct. Contracts. Okay. Thank you. Okay. We had a motion in the second. Who was the motion? Commissioner Peters on the motion. Commissioner Flowers on the second. I'm in the motion. Yeah. Okay. Bring up the card, please. Motion carries six to zero. Um, item 29. Item 29 is change order number four with QRC. Uh, this is for another work order contract. Um, this is associated with a lot of work that Jeremy is doing, especially out around, uh, US 19 project. And, uh, so they're expanding that contract to be able to respond, uh, to changes that are needed timely so they can act quickly on project changes. Just that one, uh, uh, can we get a little detail on that, please? Yep. Jeremy. And it's kind of, it's kind of listed within, but he's had, I'll let him speak with it. He's had a lot of issues. Um, well, and the reason I'm asking is we have, uh, uh, uh, a group speaker. Yes. Um, a lot of, a lot of, a few in town, but a lot of out of town people that are, are part, are part of the group speak. So let me finish. So I want to make sure that we try to address, I don't know what questions they have or what they're going to bring up. But if you could just kind of explain what this $10 million contract gets. Sure. So Jeremy Wall, utilities director. Um, I need to first separate the, um, the issues described in the, the item. So this is our annual work order contract specifically for water and reclaim pipeline services. It's a two year annual contract that we do for emergency and, um, unplanned repairs that are bigger and, and, and broader than our current staff can do. That's the purpose of the contract. Through the last two years, we've had numerous emergency breaks on our water and reclaim system that we have utilized the contract amount for that was in the original scope. So when we create these contracts, we don't know the work that's going to come up. So we guess at a number $5 million, $10 million. And then as the work progresses, you eat at the contract amount separate from budget, the contract amount. Um, what's come up currently, which has caused this item to come before you is if you read through the item, change order number three came through. We had emergency break on state road, 580, 36 inch water main. One of the two feeders that feed all the Pinellas County water system, we sent, uh, our crews out and needed to do a change order to the contract to accommodate, uh, the contract amount and allow the, uh, purchasing to allow the contractor to do that work. So at this point, we have run out of plants over the budget or over the contract, but we're nearing the contract limit of the new contract limit. Um, this contract expires in April of 2027. So past April of 2027, we will not have the ability to do an emergency repair through this contract. So one of the items requested in as part of this request is to extend this contract for a year while we are drafting the scope for a new contract for annual water and sewer reclaimed. We started that scope with staff, uh, preparing it and drafting it to replicate the existing contract, uh, several months ago, uh, leadership and utilities. We stopped that and said, let's try a new approach where we no longer. Uh, award this annual contract to a single contractor. Let's redraft the scope and award it to multiple contractors. So we have more of a bench, but that set us back several months. That's not written in here, but that's the reality of why, uh, that is not out for RFP. But we're currently revising that scope and have the RFP out, um, probably in the spring, nine months to award the RFP and we'll have a new set of contract, uh, in place. For 2028. It would overlap. These two contracts would overlap. And then we could stop using the current contract and use the new contract as it's awarded. What's written here specifically about the DOT project is we have had, um, significant delays in the DOT project for lots of reasons. Um, uh, it's a complicated roadway project as you might expect. And it's a major water line when I said there's two feeders, one on 580, the other one comes down US-19, uh, and we're relocating that entire line for a mile of roadway. Uh, it's been a complicated construction project and the DOT contractor, um, and us have been in heated negotiations, uh, over lots of different complications regarded to the project. Uh, the current issue that's identified in here is a leaking valve on US-19. It's a 36-inch valve that connects that feeder line to the booster station right there, uh, north of Countryside Mall at, uh, Evans Road. You see the water tank sitting there right on US-19. That is a booster station that boosts the pressure and pushes the water down to the rest of the county. Um, that valve there has been leaking in the US-19 roadway for many years. As part of this project, we said, look, while we're tearing up US-19, let's fix this valve even though it's not a part of the original, uh, roadway work, we'll include it in the contract. Uh, we've been negotiating with the contractor, the DOT contractor, uh, for many months now to come to a resolution on how to get this done and fixed. Uh, to date, we have not come to an agreement on how that should be completed and what the cost should be for that. We have come to the point in time where if we do not get the pipe fixed, we will come to cause the DOT contractor a delay in their construction. Under the DOT contract, Pinellas County Utilities experiences a dollar penalty for every day of delay the contractor claims. We are currently negotiating 70 claims with the existing contractor. And as opposed to adding more claim possible negotiation points in the future, it was better to just resolve, fix the issue now with our current contractor. So that's the request for you. Um, hopefully that's enough detail in context. I went through there, I went very fast too, so I'm sorry. Yeah. So the request is to add $10 million to the contract, which would accommodate any future emergencies that come up, any additional work on US 19 that's outside the current contractor scope. So we're already under contract on the US 19 with DOT, who has hired Johnson Brothers who then has a pipe contractor that works for them. So anything within the scope of that project, we'll continue to work with them on through that contract. But there are continually items, like I just said, 70 places where we have come to disagreement on the design, what's in the field, what's not in the field, how it should be built, construction means and methods, a variety of things, engineering plans and profiles. So if it comes to a point where we can't find common negotiation place with them, then we will have money and a contract in place through PRC to continue that work, as well as anywhere else in the county. This is, this annual contract is not just a DOT US 19 project contract, it is an emergency repair for the emergency repairs that we do all the time. So we don't want penalties. Absolutely. Yeah. So this, by, by giving you the funds to get that work done. So it doesn't grant me the funds, the funds are already included in my budget accounts in the water fund. This grants me the contract mechanism to hire someone to do the repair. Okay. So of the $10 million, it might not all be used. I don't know. All right. Any other questions? Yeah, Commissioner Nowicki. Oh, well, I'll ask Commissioner. No, you go right ahead. Oh, thank you, sir. So for the US 19 project, it is, would, if we approve this today, would we be paying QRC the same amount that the contractor that we're decoupling with the FDOT contract for, would we be paying them dollar for dollar the exact same price? Uh, I doubt it. We'd pay them less? We have not come to a negotiated price of what the Johnson Brothers contract through the DOT would cost us. Johnson Brothers, I mean, we're voting on QRC, right? I'm sorry. We're voting on the QRC contract. Correct. We're not voting on a job. So I have a price from QRC to complete the work. Okay. Because, I mean, it says correspondence received as an attachment and it says that, I don't know, something was 2.64 million. I'm assuming that's what the contractor with FDOT was getting. And then it says the scope compares with the county's four and a half million dollars. So, I mean, or... Okay. Hold on. Just one second. Okay. No, she... I'm seeing some questions here. Just get one second. Thank you. And then I'll get back to you, Commissioner. Ask the county attorney. All right. Hold on. This has been brought to my attention. We are in mediation, I assume, litigation. Yeah. And with litigation, we really should not be having a broad discussion about terms going on. I don't know what the solution is to get information across, but if there's active litigation, we really should not be discussing this in public. Should we be addressing this item if we are waiting for mediation? I just want to make sure... Well, I want to... Here, here. Hang on. Hang on. So, separate from US-19 project work, which is where the mediation is occurring, we need an emergency contract to be able to respond in situations that we need to complete work that would address any type of situation. Just like they had out on 580 when we had the immediate work. It had to be done then. Right. And that's the reason you have a recorder contract in place. And so, it can be applied to whatever situation. And so, we're not talking anything specific? Gotcha. Okay. Because we are in active mediation. Commissioner Wick, I didn't mean to cut you off. No, no. You're fine. I understand that. I guess I just don't want to vote for this contract if we're paying twice the amount of what the other contractor said they could do it for. With the FDOT contract, I just don't want to pay twice as much. I don't want to vote for that. So, I guess... Having a contract in place to be able to complete work helps us make sure we get favorable pricing on all of our jobs and it gives us the choice about whether to use a work order contract or bid work or anything else because we're not held up by potential delays and penalties and other things that can result from not having an emergency contract in place. Okay. I'm sorry. I mean, I'm okay. I mean, with it, you know, I guess it's just not the full scope potentially. And so, I mean, I think it's good to have those repairs in place. I'm not speaking out against that. You know, I'm just going based on what one email and then now I'm told we can't talk about it. You know, it's an attachment on the agenda item. But so, how am I... I'm just trying to make an informed decision of whether we're paying twice as much. But I guess, I don't know. Well, apparently that's what's being discussed in this... I'm asking. I'm not really... But I'll yield back, you know. You know, yield what other people ask questions and stuff. Yeah. All right. We'll just go continue around. Commissioner Flott. I'm not specific to what we shouldn't be talking about. Um, because you're asking for this amount doesn't mean we'll spend... That's correct. ...necessarily that amount. It could come in less. We've had other requests that have come before us with change orders where maybe they needed a little bit more based on cost of product or, or time for labor, et cetera. So I just wanted to kind of interject that you're asking for this dollar amount, but we may in fact come in under that amount possibly. Yes. Don't know. It's a, it's a not to exceed commissioner. And so it's based upon the projects that we actually end up using. If we, if we complete other projects or we don't have things break, then it's not used. Right. And then sometimes just from previous experience here in other places, sometimes that, and this is nothing against lowest bid, but sometimes that lower bid will get them in the door, but then they'll come back and ask for more because of the costs to complete the work. So, but I'm not getting into the other. Anyway. Just sharing. Okay. Well. Commissioner Shearer. Thank you. Go ahead. Um, so I don't want to hold this up cause I can tell it's a, we got to get it going on this, but just like the, uh, item 27, typically when I see a time and materials contract not to exceed, we don't know what it's going to cost yet. The, I know how much I'm paying for pipe for a lineal foot. I know how much the operator costs for a backhoe. I know what you're charging me for the backhoe per hour, per lineal feet, per quantity. And I don't see that this, I don't see that in these two different, both, both of these lack to me in detail. It's in there. Well, certainly. And I don't speak to public works. I don't know. But for, for our annual contracts, we have two separate sections. We have line items, which would be, we outline six inch PVC pipe, two feet deep, four foot deep, six feet deep. And we make the contractor assign a cost per linear foot for different size pipes, different type of installations, hydrants, valves, different size valves, different types of valves. It's all lineated in a several page line item book. The contractors bid prices. And everybody bids on that. And then a second section is a time and materials or anything we couldn't imagine. And this stuff comes up. That's the way both of them are bid out. I figured that. I just never have seen that. And we'd be happy to set up time for you to go through with staff and go through that to see it. Okay. Or just attach it to them. Would you like a similar? Yeah. And just, I mean, piggybacking off of commissioner Shear, I mean, there on this item, there isn't cost per a foot or linear foot like the other one attached. There's not, um, and this was originally a not to exceed contract in 2025. That's been exceeded three times and was the lowest bid just for the, for the record. This was in a large, and, and that's exactly the purpose. One year you have a very large water break that feeds the entire county and we marsh all resources and we spend what we have to do to fix it. Um, which in this case is the reason the previous amount that we brought to you to extend that contract was, it was exceeding. I'm all for getting the work done. I guess I just have that one question of, are we paying more with these people on the one piece on us 19? Not the whole can can answer that because issue that's that I understand. We can't, but we can't answer it because we haven't concluded that piece. But the unit pricing is bid. Um, and, and I think to the, the concern raised by others from outside is we do intend on having multiple, uh, contractors available on future contracts that they're in the process of releasing now. Okay. But, but in the meantime, and meantime, we need this contract. Okay. All right. If we had our questions out, we've got a speaker, um, for a group. If, if I may, I'm, I'm sorry to interrupt you. Just to, to clarify the mediation. We are in the DOT mediation process. We're not in a, we're not in court. Correct. We're in the DOT contractual mediation process. Okay. All right. Um, James Charles is here. Um, and, and, and he is, um, and he's got Burgess Rand, Jared Masters. Yes. Okay. Uh, Kyle Humphreys and Jeff Erickson. Okay. Um, go ahead. You got 10 minutes. So I had a whole thing written up, but after that discussion, it kind of threw it off the rails here. So I'm going to kind of add a little bit, but first off I would say, you know, a lot of your discussion was stopped because you were told that you had litigation, which that was a complete surprise to us. We are not in litigation with Pinellas County. So I would request that maybe you continue your questioning and get more information from your department before we continue this. Is that possible? Yes. I'm sorry. Yes. I'm James Charles. I'm with Johnson brothers. I apologize. I'm with Johnson brothers. We're the con we're the general contractor for the DOT on the US 19 project. So we have interest in this because the scope that they're, you're talking about the 2.6 verse, you know, 4.5 is our scope that they're taking out. So are you okay. Stop that clock. If you don't. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Um, everybody. Hello. Is this who we're in mediation with? Okay. I have no litigation or we are unaware of any litigation action with the county. We have not filed active litigation. They're not our contractors. We are in the DOT mitigation. Mediation. Mediation. Yeah. Um, can I correct that? Whatever I said. It's actually a DRB process. It's a contractual process for dispute resolution. It's not a legal process. They're not lawyers involved. Um, we've all agreed not to have lawyers involved. So it's just a formal process where they bring in other engineers. The DOT picks a person. We pick a person. They pick a third person and we both present our case. So it's non-binding. It's not a mediation. It's not a legal process. So your reason for being here. My reason for being here is we were caught completely off guard off of the, with, when we saw the agenda items as they characterize the work and our performance and the cost of the work that the county was going to pay for something that we had already priced out. Is everybody crystal clear? Well, continue with your conversation here with your presentation. Okay. Um, so this isn't something we normally do. We don't go in front of county commission meetings. We do the work. We move on. Um, we try to make sure you guys get a good quality product. Um, you know, JBC has been, we've been around for over a hunt for close to a hundred years. Um, we're known throughout the country, especially in the state of Florida for highly high quality, complex and timely construction in the industry. We've consistently won awards from our customers and peers and the industry. The Jupiter federal bridge down in Palm Beach or in Jupiter just last one, just last month when the best in construction, major bridge and Southeast best project from engineering news record. So from D O T and engineering engineering news records, we got all the timely completion bonus on that job. Our project with universal orange County and D O T was a three party contract to get the entrance way for universal setup with Epic with it for the Epic park was a reconstruction of a major intersection in downtown Orlando and a whole extension of the roadway. We got that done through COVID through design changes on time. We finished the turnpike project in Palm Beach County when she obtained several timely completion bonuses. And just down the road from here, the Courtney Campbell causeway, we won the project of the year for design build projects. We have an extensive resume of finishing jobs on time with high quality. There's something going on with this project. It's late. When we opened up the agenda items and we see that there's been ongoing concerns with the quality and progress of the utility work being performed by the F D O T contractor. Those comments represent a complete disregard for the design problems that we've raised. The county, the county's EOR and the county's representatives have delayed and deficient responses. And we have repeated and continuing plan revisions due to errors, omissions and unforeseen conditions. The public needs to at least hear some of that history before you consider taking this work out of our contract. For this scope on Evans Road, we brought up the utility problems associated with the scope more than a year and a half ago. We raised the restraint issue in March of 2025, verified it with field count with county representatives. We had to escalate public and worker safety concerns on May 6th of 2025. After the county required further verification of the problem, we exposed the pipe and showed them that there was a problem. We received multiple revised drawings all the way up through January of this year, which were still marked as advanced copies and not released for construction. The count, we provided pricing to the county for the scope in May. They didn't want the time associated with it. Like he mentioned, for delays, there's a significant portion of, there's a significant cost for that. So they asked for that to be taken out. We resubmitted our price again in July. That's the 2.6 number. And it's just been cricket since then. We have, we got verbal notification that they're going to give it to QRC. We don't know when it was going to be done. We didn't know what the price was going to be from QRC. And then we saw the agenda item, where our work is being disparaged. They're attributing $4.5 million to the Evans Road for QRC to do the work, and an additional $5.5 million for, when we read the agenda item, it looks like it's US-19 work. There's not $5.5 more million dollars of water work on US-19. Before taking Evans Road out of our scope and giving it to QRC under this emergency expedited contract, QRC should be required to quote the scope of work and show the taxpayers and other contractors that their firm price for the equivalent scope of work is the lowest responsible price. The county staff is proposing to decline a quoted price from the contractor in lieu of an unadvertised work order assignment without completion, or without competition, without a firm price, no binding completion date, and without a new competitive solicitation. We're concerned that the applicable public procurement and competitive bidding laws, which exist to protect taxpayer money, have been violated in the proposed transfer of the Evans Road work. Additionally, the county's budget review says the change order number four increases the contract amount by $10 million and adds 365 calendar days to the contract for the purpose of having QRC take over utility work on the US-19 project that is behind schedule. This identifies US-19 as a justification for the full $10 million increase. But again, we don't see $10 more million worth of work out there for utility work. You got about $2.6 million for the Evans Road or $4.5 million if you have QRC to it. Additionally, per the agenda item, the county staff is requesting to complete the work through the county's contractor, which will allow the county to have better control over the work and to help it move forward. I don't know how this is the case when the county staff is recommending to award this scope work with no competitive solicitation, without securing a firm price, and without a binding completion date. We don't even know what their six- to eight-month time frame includes. If they hit their schedule, you might not delay us anymore. If you're paying them to expedite their work, paying them overtime, trying to get them to move faster, we're already here. When the county talks about our quality and progress, it also needs to explain how it handled the utility problems we've raised. It's two simple examples among 70, I think it's closer to 80. For the agenda item scope, Evans Road bypass, the revised restraint plans arrived more than five months after our March 25 question, and further revisions were required and were not received until January 2026. Again, still not released for construction at that time. We're now in November, and we're talking about bringing in another contractor instead of just releasing us for the work. One thing to note, if you guys don't like our price, under the FDOT specifications, you can just have us proceed and track our costs. Another example is a major cross-drain structure. We notified the county engineer of the issue in November 17th of 2025. We didn't get a response until May 27th of 2026. To date, we have still not received signed and sealed or released for construction water main relocation plans a year later. These are just two problems out of the 70 to 80, and it's being represented that the contractor, the Johnson Brothers, is delaying the work on the project. We've identified and quantified six of the matters that we feel were prime contributor to the significant delay on US-19. It totals $20.7 million right now. That doesn't include any of the recent issues, and it's not a full accounting. We're requesting that the county suspend this change order pending a review of the bidding and procurement process. Again, under the FDOT specifications, you can work with the FDOT to obtain written direction for us to proceed under our existing contract while we track the costs and final pricing is resolved. There's no need for an additional contractor to mobilize, be potentially paid substantially more while we continue to delay the project. Additionally, we request that the county commissioners obtain a third-party review of the issues that are delaying US-19. We've been trying to resolve these issues for a long time. We have a $4.5 million change order request for a scope that we have priced at $2.6 million six months ago on an issue we raised 20 months ago, and an additional $5.5 million for an undefined scope on our project that we're unsure even exists. We'll continue to mitigate and work to complete the project no matter what the decision of your board is. But it's important to ask your leadership team why this issue has been so protracted and why the solution is to bring on a second contractor that likely has a financial incentive for extended durations and increased costs as a unit-priced contractor. That's all I have right now. Okay. Thank you. Is there James Charles here? That's me. Oh, that's you. Okay. Thank you. All right. I just want to make sure I got everybody covered that wanted to speak. Thank you. Okay. Okay. So, commissioners, obviously you heard very clearly there's a dispute between contracts, contractors, between the work that's being done, Jeremy's team. That occurs every day on construction projects, and they resolve those. So, you're not being asked to get in the middle of that. You're being asked to give an emergency contract for an amount not to exceed $10 million, of which he may use or he may not, and then let him finish his construction project work. I'd still like to hear some rationale, because we're like this, and I don't need it today, but I'm saying some rationale between the ask for an issue to be resolved, and the long protracted delay. Now, it seems unreasonable. And I'm being very careful, because we're in a non-legal process right now that could change. And when things change and delays occur, then penalties kick in, and then things escalate. That's separate from what you're being asked to vote on today. All you're asked to be in a vote on today is an emergency contract that is at utilities department's disposal, should they need it. And just to be clear, this was all news to me as well, that this was going on. Just because we're saying it's not in court does not mean it's not a legal process. This is a process that is specifically dictated by the terms of the contract that the county has with DOT. So this is something that we're compelled to, it is a process we're compelled to go through pursuant to the terms of the contract. And to be clear, the county does not have a contract with these folks, Johnson Brothers. We have a contract with DOT. DOT has a contract with the contractor. And Jeremy could follow up with each one of you individually and explain some of the history there. But, again, making sure the $10 million that's being put out there needs to be accounted for, dollar, carefully. Correct. And we'll hear about that usage. We can give you a report following that work. All right. Commissioner Latval. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Since we're getting thrust upon us with this information, like all sorts of information, what is the downside of delaying this until we get more information? Jeremy doesn't have a contract in place to be able to, you have money left? Well, come on up and address it then. We have a contract until April so we could start the work. We might not be able to finish it within a six-month time period. Six to eight months is the current time period to do the specific work on Evans Road. So that might eclipse the contract deadline. If it's not approved today and I do not have this contractor lined up, then we're in further negotiation with the DOT contractor, which to date we have not come to agreement on their price, their scope. So this whole replacement was in their original scope, and now it's an extra $2.6 million. So we're not at a place where we're ready to delay, continue to delay the DOT project for this repair. That's why we brought this item like this. Which it could kick in penalties for delay. Correct. And their original proposal had those penalties. We asked them to remove them. And they removed them, but we're still not agreeing on the price to do the work. And you can get with us individually to talk about the discussed delay in responses and that kind of thing. We can talk about that individually. Absolutely. Okay. Thank you. Anybody else? Commissioner Nowicki. Yeah. I mean, I would be, you know, Commissioner Watvala's point, Vice Chair Watvala, maybe future chair, today, I mean, I'd be in favor of delaying it, but, I mean, or just to take out this FDOT contractor piece and approve, you know, $5 million with QRC to do those emergency as needed repairs. I mean, it seems like the point of contention is the FDOT contract and, you know, it's coupled with this emergency repair extension that seems to be, they're coupled together. So, if we decouple the FDOT and say, hey, we'll do $5 million, extend that a year, that would give you time to go with QRC, yeah, QRC to do what you need to do, right? But then you're getting in the middle of the contract dispute between the utilities and what they've been unable to complete, which they feel was in the original scope on this contract. And now we're getting into the actual dispute, which is the issue. And so, without Jeremy having that contract, we're left simply at the mercy of the contractor that they've been unable to come to terms with. Well, respectfully, I mean, we're in the middle of the dispute by voting to decouple a contract to give it to somebody else. That puts us in the middle of the dispute. We recommend approval. Did you have anything? I just want to be clear. You're not under contract with the other contractor. You're trying to get, you're trying to hire somebody to do the work that they've contracted with the DOT? Correct. So, I'm trying to avoid a bridge problem here. So, last time we replaced a contractor, it cost us some money, a lot. So, I'm, this is, you know, I just think maybe we could, I don't want to hold this project, though, but I want to make sure we understand what we're doing. And I'm not sure. I don't know where to go with that. Okay. Any other questions? Any other comments? Okay. Thank you. Any questions, comments before we pull up the card? Am I getting an interest in anything else besides taking a vote today? Mr. Chair, we don't have a motion or a second for this item. Thank you. Yeah, I mean, the vice chair, I mean, if we can bump this. Hold on. I'll ask him, does he want to, did you want to take any action other than what's being recommended? I mean, we've got to bring this in. I don't know how we're not getting in the middle of this, even though we're told not to get in the middle of it. And I don't want to end up in a shade meeting as a result of this vote, but I'll leave it up to you all. Okay. I would personally like to meet with Jeremy. It's been suggested we meet with Jeremy. Jeremy, can we, but I don't want a huge delay. But I don't know how we're going to meet with him after we take the vote. Well, I want some answers to some questions for sure. And I want to make sure that we are equipped to do whatever work we need to do in discussions with FDOT. So, I mean. I do have a question. Yeah, go ahead. So, I think a lot of us have a little discomfort. So, is there any way that we could move this to a future date certain, and that way we have time for Jeremy to explain all of this to a better comfort level? And will there be damage done if we defer this to the December meeting? That's the question. Is there damage done if you wait a month, and we do this in the December meeting, does that put us in a bad place if we have to wait three weeks or four weeks? Jeremy, answer. So, the way the contract with the DOT works is they work off what they call a critical path schedule. So, there's a million items that all have to be done, and there are certain items that if this is not done by this date, then you cause a delay, a day delay. And they count them by days. So, if this work doesn't start within the next 30 days, we will be past the 30-day delay. But the claims are only issued by the contractor. So, the DOT is not going to penalize us. The contractor would then penalize the DOT for a day delay, and then the DOT would backcharge us, is how that functions. So, I can't promise a claim. I can tell you there's been 80, now I heard. So, 10 more than I thought. Claims against us for delays on this project. And my intent is to stop delays on this project and move and complete this U.S. 19 project. It's 800-something days past its, behind its schedule. The water main has to be done before the roadway can go forward. Everyone that lives up there wants this road done. I'm trying to get us out of the way. Motion to approve by Commissioner Peters. I need a second. Second by Commissioner Flowers. Any other discussion? Okay. Bring up the voting card, please. Could you do that again? Bring up the voting card, please. Yep. Thank you. Need two more. Mine's not coming up. I do still have the card up. If you give me your vote, I can record it on here as well. Whose is not coming up? Whose in the vote. So, are you a yes or a no? You're a yes or a no. I'm a no. No. Okay. You're an exciting vote. First meeting, you get to break the tie. Or you could suggest to delay it and see if someone would open to it. Well, this morning. And then we get the process. Yeah. So, I think I like the idea of delaying a month so that we can get some answers for... There you go. Jeremy. So, before, if it dies, then that... Because I don't... If this dies, can it come... That's the stuff we have to know. If this dies, does it come back? Or do we need an amendment that... Because it appeared to me that if we don't do this in 30 days and we don't meet again in 30 days, we get penalized because we're delaying the whole project. That's correct. So, the question is, if this motion dies, what happens then to this agenda item? Does this go away and never come back? Does this put us into penalties with FDOT for a long time? Does this only put us in penalties with FDOT for a week or two until we bring it back? I mean, those are decisions... Those are things we need to know before you give that last deciding vote, I think. So, you're asking several questions, Commissioners. I'll try to answer them the best I can. You're hearing from folks that will make the decision about whether they penalize us or not. Right. Okay. And so, let's be clear on that. The, you heard Jeremy talk about the history of the project and the disputes between, and I don't know the, I mean, those are very technical engineering type disputes. I'm not going to be able to answer the question on, he asked for a third-party review. That's fine. But I can't tell you today. There's a history there. Okay. And we have a billion dollars in construction projects that our project managers are managing every single day. You know, this is one. So, we want this in place to be able to move forward. Whether we get penalized or not, I can't tell you that. And, in fact, probably, the county attorney would probably say not to because that, this is where we could get into other types of litigation. You heard Jeremy respond. He's trying to clean this up, trying to move this project forward. The cost, I would suspect, with the history of this project and the disputes that are occurring, it will cost us a lot for delaying this. Go ahead, Commissioner Hughes. So, this $10 million is kind of an insurance policy? It gets us? It's a contract that we have in place to where Jeremy can, the utilities director, can go out and do work based upon the bid unit price of that when they bid it. Okay. So, they say, we're going to do this type of work, and like he said, a pipe at a certain depth, it's a unit price. And so, since he's in a dispute, one of the options that he would have, it is not directly related to the U.S. 19 project. This is an emergency contract, but he could apply that where he is unable to come to terms with another project. He could pull that work out and be able to get that done and avoid delays, which comes with penalties. I like the explanation. Motion carries four to three, and we, so we are, we are done on this issue. Let's move on. Item 30. This is a renewal certificate, public convenience and necessity with all of our advanced life support providers. A motion by Commissioner Flowers, second by Commissioner Nowicki. Any questions or comments? Bring up the voting card, please. We can clear our timer, too, if you want. The motion carries unanimously. Item 31. This is one new non-medical wheelchair transport service provider. Motion by Commissioner Peters, second by Commissioner Nowicki. Any comments or questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 32. This is amendment two. This is for our agreement with the eight municipalities and three independent fire districts. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second. Second by Commissioner Hughes. Any comments or questions on item 32? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 33. This is our annual excess stop loss insurance policy for high claims. Motion by Commissioner Lett-Valley. Second by Commissioner Nowicki. Any comments or questions on item 33? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 34. This is a reimbursement for a health insurance claim that was caused by an auto accident. Partial recovery. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second by Commissioner Flowers. Any comments or questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Item carries passes unanimously. Item 38. So, a fourth amendment to the lease. This is for the tax collector's golf debate facility. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second by Commissioner Lett-Valley. Any comments, questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Item passes unanimously. Item 36. Under item 36, I'm asking the board to ratify litigation that was filed in the reference case. This was a petition filed when Animal Services took custody of a cruelly treated animal. We have gone to court and had that approved, so we do not have custody of the animal. And I'm asking you to ratify the action taken. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second by Commissioner Nowicki. Any questions? Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 37. Under item 37, I'm asking the board to approve staff's recommendation as set forth in the confidential memo that you all were able to review last week at the work session. Second. Motion by Commissioner Peters. Second by Commissioner Flowers. Bring up the voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. Item 38. I have no reports today. Item 39. Three items, Commissioners. First, yesterday, the Suncoast CEO received notification that four local hospital systems will be partnering with the Crisis Center of Tampa Bay for the sexual assault examinations. So they've come together, and they're trying to resolve that. So as that concludes, I'll bring that to you. As you know, we contracted through the end of the year to give them time. Sounds like they're bringing that together. Four hospitals have weighed in. Four hospitals. Well, we have time. Okay. Okay. We only got to four. Okay. All right. But yes. All right. So there's still others in the week. Any more update on that, Karen? Okay. All right. So that was the good news. Two other items. One, Amendment 3. You know, I'm going to work, following your vote today with the new chair, to schedule additional meetings, as we talked about, to where we can have potentially once a month meeting for, like, a strategic planning meeting, and really talking about priorities, issues, choices, as we begin to rethink about what we do here in Pinellas County government. So staff's already started that process. We've had, you know, multiple conversations with the sheriff, with others, with the superintendent of schools, Dr. Cho, and others. So more to come on that. But I do want to get that on your calendars. So we'll have to redo the calendars that we sent back, that we sent out before, and schedule more time to be able to do that. But I think it's good to get that away from this meeting, or I'm sorry, the work sessions, because that way we can just simply spend the time to focus on those things. So that was one. The other one is, you know, I've heard some concerns about security, and so I propose that we have a security meeting on December the 10th. That is a, that's the next date of a work session that would be a confidential meeting that we will ask the clerk to take minutes on. However, those are not public minutes. And so I would ask that we, you approve us going into a session for security. We can do it after. We'll have to do it at a time certain. I think you did it at 1 o'clock, and we stood around and waited. But we can do it whatever time you want. This one is a little bit less statutorily driven than the litigation meetings, but I would suggest, you know, setting a time for it. And I think on something like this, we could probably list it as the last agenda item and move into the, to that portion of the meeting. And we can move that into the shade meeting. Yeah, what we would do, and this one, again, it's not quite as prescribed by statutes. For instance, that statute says the only people that can be in a litigation shade meeting are the seven commissioners, your attorney, and, and bury. This meeting, you could have quite a few other people in here. Of course, you don't want to have too many because the whole point is to not let the world know what we're talking about as far as security. But for instance, we can't even bring the clerk to the litigation meetings, but the clerk will be at this meeting taking minutes for us. So I think it's a really decision of who, who is appropriate to possibly be in here for that meeting. But yes, we would clear the room otherwise, and it would be a private meeting for you and only those people you wish to attend related to the topic of security. All right. So we'll add that on to this last agenda item. Okay. Do we have agreement there? Nodding, nodding, nodding. Okay. All right. We're good to go. We're good to go. And that concludes my report. All right. Moving on to state legislative program. Are you all right? We got a motion and a second, but commissioner Peters on the motion, commissioner flowers on the second, any additional discussion on that item? Thank you, chair. Yeah. I'm going to be supportive of this and I appreciate Tristan, including in about the childcare, um, though, just, you know, for the record, you know, me, you know, I'm not in for increasing the gas tax, um, or the 911 fee, but I'm going to be supportive, you know, of the, the legislative as a whole, but just wanted to note for the record. I mean, I'm personally not in favor of increasing our gas tax or other fees. Okay. Any, anybody else? Any comments? Okay. Uh, bring up the, uh, voting card, please. Motion carries unanimously. I'm in two, uh, with the exceptions mentioned by commissioner Nowicki. Item 41 motion by commissioner Peters, uh, commissioner flowers second by commissioner Nowicki. All right. Any comments or questions on the federal legislative program? Mr. Chair, just, uh, um, uh, thank you. I said it to Tristan already, but, um, I wanted to publicly thank him for including the requested updates to the legislative federal, um, uh, program. And I've already forwarded, um, our state as well as our federal after we received the update to both sides, NACO, as well as the Florida association accounting so that they could see how they could possibly intertwine our recommendations in with theirs. Thank you, commissioner flowers. Okay. So, um, bring up the voting card. Motion carries unanimously. Uh, and to item 42, which is the selection of the chair and vice chair for 2020. And I'd like to make a motion for Chris Lettvala to be the chair. Motion, uh, for Chris Lettvala for the chair and a second by commissioner Scheer. Are you sure? All right. I'm not sure. When he started campaigning, I got a little nervous. Yeah, I know. That's just, he can't help it. He can't help it. That's just his thing. All right. Um, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, vice chair. Thank you very much. And we move on to the vice chair selection. There's two folks that have expressed an interest and, um, it would be commissioner Scheer, commissioner flowers, um, and, uh, commissioner Peters. Do you have any interest in serving as vice chair? Um, I, I, I actually, I would for the reason that I've stated numerous times before in that I, um, I, um, I personally believe that if you're, and it worked out great for Dave, um, that if you're the chairman and you're up for reelection, that's challenging. And I had other reasons why I didn't approve of it. But after going through an interesting election, um, just having that extra duty, um, can be very challenging. And I think if you're going to be the chair, putting all your energy into that chairmanship and not having to split your time with campaigning. And so for that reason, I, I would be open to it, but I would put that fully at my colleagues because I know in the past, you all hadn't agreed with me on that one and that's fine. Um, but I would, that's, that's the only rationale as to why. Well, I would tell you speaking, just having gone through it, cause we've traditionally not done that. Um, and it, it has been extra for sure. There is no, no doubt about it. Um, uh, I, you know, I had some other issues as well, but, but, um, I kind of leaning back towards the way we've done it in the past, which is trying not to have a person running for office being the chair. So the vice chair would traditionally be the chair of the following year. Um, so that's just my comment and I would tend to agree. So commissioner Nowicki, don't worry. I'm not going to run for vice chair. I know that's probably what everybody was concerned about, uh, jokingly. Uh, but I think it's a, it's a new day in Pinellas. And with that, I motion to make Chris Shear, vice chair motion. Yes. Commissioner. Um, I would disagree with, uh, commissioner Peters. Um, and I understand why she, um, you know, feels that way. I think you did a wonderful job, uh, serving as chair, um, being the age that you are, you had energy, um, to perform your duties. Uh, see, that's why I wanted you to be a little bit older. Uh, yeah, commissioner Hughes is younger than you are. Um, I mean, everybody at the dais is younger than you are, Mr. Chair. Um, but, uh, but juggling serving as chair and, uh, running for election. Um, you didn't, um, do anything inappropriate. Uh, you had the utmost ethics. Um, and I know that commissioner share, uh, and commissioner flowers both have, um, that same ethical standard. Um, I second the, uh, nomination of commissioner share. Uh, and having said that, I do believe that, uh, um, commissioner flowers will be the vice chair, uh, in short order. And I look forward to, uh, voting for her soon. So thank you very much. Okay. We have a motion. So we do have a motion and a second. Thank you. But I do have a comment. Um, and I think commissioner sheer is a wonderful commissioner and a good friend. And, um, you know, I think in the past we've, and it is a new day. That's true. In the past, we usually, um, don't bring kind of the freshmen up at first, but I will say there's something I do want to say. Um, and it's fine if it's not me, cause I wasn't expecting that, but, um, commissioner flowers has put her name in the hat three times commissioner flowers has demonstrated her leadership skills over the many, many years. Um, and most recently getting elected president of fact, I mean, and she has demonstrated leadership at the city, at the commission when she counsel, when she was in St. Petersburg on the school board and at fact, and I, and I just reflect back on the June meeting when we celebrated that accomplishment. And that's a big deal accomplishment to get awarded president of a statewide organization. And, and I, I know there's a motion in a second on the floor. And like I said, uh, Chris is a good friend of mine. Um, but if it were going to be somebody that's going to be running and again, you all disagree with me on that and that's fine. Um, I don't expect, you know, new elections coming up can be quite challenging. And, um, I think, uh, a county wide seat, uh, when you're up for election is not the ideal time. I would rather see him be vice chair once he gets reelected, just as commissioner level said that about commissioner flowers. I think when you're running county wide, um, to have that additional, uh, duty is difficult. Um, but my confidence in commissioner flowers and a, not a county wide seat is extremely high. Um, and again, I reflect on that June meeting when all of us just praise how wonderful she truly is and praise her leadership skills. And so, um, I, I personally, um, would support commissioner flowers as chairman, um, for those reasons. And so, um, my good friend, um, I really would rather see you be vice chairman after the election. And I promise you when you're in the middle of that election, if you are chairman, you're going to come to me and say you are absolutely right. And so, um, I, I, you know, that's just my thought. Thank you. Yeah. Um, and so, yeah, so as an explanation, I, I, I will vote against the nomination only because I, I, I, after having gone through it this year and I'm not county wide, um, um, I, I strongly feel that we need to have somebody that's not, uh, running for office, uh, to be the chair. So that's the only reason I'm voting against, uh, I would vote against commissioner Scheer and commissioner flowers only on that, on that premise. Uh, um, that's just, again, don't, and again, it's nothing personal about either one of you. Yes. Commissioner flowers. Um, first of all, thank you for recognizing that this is the third time that my name has been in the ring and I have been, uh, set aside. Um, commissioner Eggers, if you recall, um, there was a conversation about, and you know, you brought it forward that you were running, um, and you desired to be the chair, which would have been your move up. But if not, you understood. And I said that, um, the colleagues that were seated at that time that they voted for you to be vice chair, knowing that you would be running as a, um, incumbent. Um, and so I said, you all should support him because you voted for him to be vice chair, knowing that the year that he would be campaigning, he would be chair, um, commissioner Peters. I appreciate your, um, desire to put my name in the ring, but as I've said to you all before, and this will be the fourth time, I don't want anything that no one thinks I deserve. I really don't. So, um, yes, I have been blessed to be the president with the Florida Association of Counties. Maybe that was God's way of giving me a gift when I did not get selected by my colleagues to serve in a leadership role here. Um, I have served as chair back to back on the city council in St. Pete when I was campaigning and handled the job, um, with no complaints. I served as chair back to back with Pinellas County school boards when I was campaigning and handled the job, um, with no complaints or concerns. So I will dutifully remove my name because, um, while I am, um, excited that you have put my name in the ring, Kathleen, I'm disappointed at the comments that are being made. Now, it seems like whenever my name comes up here, I'm not positioned. I'm not, you know, there's always some excuse, always some excuse. And so I don't want anything that no one feels like I deserve. And I can read the tea leaves. I don't have the votes. Um, I can be just as effective sitting in this seat, not being chair or vice chair as I could, if I were, I can be just as effective overseeing 22 million people in the state of Florida, um, as a county commissioner and as the president of FAC and as a leading voice with the national association of counties. So even if some people around the table don't think that I deserve to be recognized here and to serve in that leadership role, there are others who do feel like I deserve and should be recognized. So commissioner Peters, uh, thank you so very much. I withdraw my name and, um, I would call the question. Commissioner Hughes. Well, I, uh, I wish you hadn't withdrawn your name cause I was going to second what commissioner Peters and I, I would have voted for you. I think we take this vote and however the vote falls out, then we have a continued conversation. I appreciate you wanting to take your name out of this. I don't think you needed to take your name out at all. Um, so we'll take the vote and, and then continue the conversation. However, the vote goes, may I speak for myself? Oh, you can talk about me. She called the question, parliamentary procedures to take the vote. And we follow that per our handbook, which we don't like to make changes to chairs. So we had, she called the vote. So we will vote on the nomination or the motion, uh, to elect commissioner Scheer as the vice chair. Um, all in favor say aye, you know, let's raise hands, please. Let's raise hands. That's three. Um, I don't, I don't get a chance to everybody else. Else gets all right. I don't understand my, my apology. My apology. Go ahead. Now, everybody seems to be worried about what I would do is the chair and I'm running for vice chair. Okay. But what I would do is chair is let you know that it's going to take a lot of leadership in 2028 to, to, uh, to initiate and get a handle on amendment three and our finances. I have worked harder than anybody. I believe here on the budget. I know it better than I have been studying it. I've been working it. I come to you every year with a written proposals on the budget, what to do about the budget. We're going to need answers on our budget, not this year. And the following year, we're going to have to implement amendment three. Now, uh, I commissioner flowers. I, I respect you very, very much. Uh, but specifically because you are going to be the fact you are the fact president. I think you, you need to keep your eye on that ball and let me work hard on the budget and get us ready for the implementation of amendment three. And so I would appreciate the opportunity to work at that and make it a reality and to make the right decisions financially, not because you don't, we're not worthy, but you got plenty on your plate. So that's what I'd like to say about that. Mr. Chair, just again, my apologies for, for that. Just for a point of clarity and I could have probably rescinded, but according to Robert's rules, once you call the court and I'm just sharing this, so you won't think somebody was trying to shut you down. Once you call the question, you automatically go to the vote. There should, there's not supposed to be in a future discussion, but I'm glad that you had a chance to say what it is that you, that you share. And yes, I have a lot on my plate, but I was built for it, but we're going to call it. We're going to go ahead. Um, so we had, um, three, uh, could we go ahead? I was under Robert's rules of order. I would request a roll call vote. So I'd be a roll call. Chair Eggers? No. Vice Chair Latvala? Yes. Commissioner Flowers? No. Commissioner Hughes? Commissioner Nowicki? Yes. Commissioner Peters? Yes. Okay. Commissioner Peters, I have as an A. Commissioner Scherer, I have as an A. So. So I have an A. Make a motion for Kathleen Peters to serve as Vice Chair. I have a motion for Commissioner Peters to be Vice Chair. I need a second. I'll second. You're, you're in charge. We have a motion and a second for Commissioner Peters. I thought it was like the next meeting. No. If I, if I have the second, I have to give that up. All in favor? They want a voice vote. Any comments or anything? Nope. Oh, sorry. Sorry. Not my, not my role. Commissioner Nowicki, you're recognized. Okay. So, I mean, I would just ask, you know, I appreciate Commissioner Peters putting her name up. And, um, I didn't know this information. I mean, I got an email from Commissioner Scheer and I think an email from Commissioner Flowers. But, I mean, I guess I don't know how, I don't know if something said to the Chair ahead of time. Because he referenced you before for being for Vice Chair. Um, so I didn't know how that came about, I guess. I asked the question. Would you be interested in being Chair? Okay. Or Vice Chair? Okay. At one point it was, and I'm going to use the word seniority. Maybe that's the wrong word. Um, at one point it was, you know, persons moved up as you served, you know, as you came on. Um, but that process kind of got out of the process. And so it just became a acknowledge if you're interested by sending an email, you know. And then, you know, I mean, I pre, you know, he did a great job as Chair, you know. Um, so would you be interested in going from Vice Chair to Chair? Or what would be your plans there? That's traditionally how we work this year. That's why I was surprised when I saw suddenly campaigning. Um, who Vice Chair? Vice Chair typically goes to Chair. Um, you know, I am not campaigning. So I don't have a dog in the hunt. The Chair is typically on the canvassing board. Since I'm not on the ballot, that's not a conflict. And it keeps me completely out of the election, which makes me happy. Um, and so, yeah, so there isn't a conflict with the Chairman not being on the ballot when it comes to the, uh, canvassing board. So, yes, I, the ask question was asked. I did not throw my name out there. Um, but I do feel very strongly that I've brought up year after year that, and, and after going through, um, uh, uh, an election cycle, like we've had this last cycle, I truly believe that enormous amount of energy is going to be had by every single person that's campaigning. Um, and that happens to be the majority on this board. Um, and so, I, and, and I do, you know, I will reserve the right to change my mind, but I believe this will be my last term. So, um, so it would be my last stint as vice chair and chair. So, um, you know, so yeah, I, I welcome the opportunity and, um, and, and if, and if you don't agree with that, that's fine. Um, that's, you know, that's up to the, the will of the commission to do that. Um, okay. Yeah. I mean, I, I appreciate you clarifying that. And, um, I don't even know if, you know, commissioner Shearer is going to run for reelection, but I hope, uh, you would be supportive of him for vice chair if, you know, he decides to run and, and then would win. Um, so that's, that's good. I guess, I mean, I guess I'd be supportive of that motion then for commissioner Peters, if there's nobody else, um, nominating themselves or maybe. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So we had, we had a motion in a second. Okay. Yeah. So, uh, commissioner Hughes, comment. Oh, excellent. Thank you. No, I, I think the, the rationale that commissioner Peters has given makes a lot of sense. I just ran my first campaign ever and, uh, I'm still recovering. So, um, no, it, it makes a lot of sense. Um, I, I would have voted for commissioner flowers, uh, if, uh, commissioner Peters puts her hat and just, you decide to run for vice chair. Uh, we'll support you. Okay. Any other comments? Um, I just have a quick, yeah, it's, I think it's an age thing. Um, um, you made reference a couple of times about campaigning and I'm not exactly sure what that is. Uh, I did post something on social media, um, um, because the tax collector offered his endorsement, uh, when he asked, uh, if I was going to try for the chair and I, um, sent as customary, I sent y'all an email. I don't know if that's campaigning or not, but other than that, uh, we're not allowed to talk to each other. Uh, so my way of communicating that, uh, Mr. Ross was supporting me was by posting something on social media. Um, are there any other comments or questions? Anybody else? Any other nominations? All right. All in favor of, um, of Kathleen Peters as vice chair. Uh, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. All right. You want to give it back? You'll give it soon enough. All right. We are moving on quickly here to commission comments and we'll start with commissioner Scheer. Commissioner Flowers. Going to be a little lengthy. So we have six o'clock, six o'clock hearing and I think I saw food. So I didn't know if you wanted to maybe have people eat first and then go for the six o'clock or whatever. Well, let's just go ahead and see where we get. Okay. All right. Well, thank you very much. So the good stuff, I'll go over that first. Um, I attended my area agency on aging, um, board meeting on yesterday. We're doing pretty good when it comes to looking at, uh, some of the financial hits that we will be taking. Um, when it comes to serving seniors, we raised, we almost raised the $300,000 we were trying to raise with our fundraiser so that we could continue to take seniors off of the wait list, excuse me, off of the wait list for services. Um, so we've been able to assist there. So I'm very grateful and thankful. We're doing what's called a, uh, Mary's, uh, a wish list for seniors. So if any of you want to participate, you can reach out to Ann Marie Winter with area agents on aging. You get a little card like this. It gives you the person's name, their age, and these are all seniors. So it gives you their name, their age, and what it is that they're asking for, for Christmas. So we're like little elves to them. So if you would like to participate, you can see Ann Marie, reach out to her, or you can give me a call. Um, I'm also grateful and thankful for Pasco County working with us on the 60 plus senior, uh, uh, affordable living facility, uh, that's up there. That's moving straight ahead. So again, I'm very thankful for that. There were a lot of changes that have been made by the department of elder affairs, um, that we had to make those changes and approve those changes to our bylaws. One of those is that even if you have a board member who is serving and area agency on aging is receiving financial support, remuneration or grant from that County, um, government that you cannot serve on their board of directors, that doesn't affect me anymore because area agency on aging did not get their, um, social action funding money, but it does affect the representative from Pasco County. Those are things we can't change. That came down from the department of elder affairs. Um, we also moved on the limited use of AI, um, within the system so that we can be a little bit more strategic in our processes. Um, so, um, I'm skeptical about that, but we do use AI in a number of other areas. So, um, that is something that we need to get used to. I attended the veterans day services in Oldsmar. Um, and I really enjoyed myself. I always have a chance to bring my brother and he gets a chance to meet other veterans and talk to them and catch up. So, um, I really enjoyed myself there. Thank you, Dave Eggers for your representation as well. Um, being the chair at the time for, uh, Pinellas County commission, I attended the student school safety transportation committee. We continue to hone some information relative to the utilization and operation of e-bikes. A lot of kids are starting to take those to school, but we want to make sure they're doing that safely. Thank you so much to the sheriff's office for your continued support, uh, in those areas. I attended, uh, St. Petersburg city council's vote. Um, and it was a unanimous vote to name the auditorium at the Enoch Davis center in the city of St. Petersburg after my brother-in-law, Watson L. Haynes, the second. So I want to thank, um, publicly council member Deborah Fick Sanders, um, all of the council members, the mayor's staff and the community that came out to speak in support and on behalf of my brother-in-law. So I look forward to that more information to come. So if you knew Watson and you can make that dedication, um, I would love for you to be able to attend. I also attended the full Pinellas board meeting along with my colleague, um, Chris share, um, commissioner Brian Scott also attended. We did elect officers, uh, commissioner share was elected as the secretary. I was elected as the treasurer, um, Deborah Fick Sanders as the vice chair and mayor Mo Feeney from the city of Dunedin as the chair. So congratulations to everyone in their respective places. I look forward to working with you. Um, so I want to just address a few things that were made, uh, comments that were made since we're not supposed to go back and forth with the individuals who come here to speak. But I, um, it is, it is sad to hear some of the comments that are being made when it comes to a case that involves a permit for use on property and somehow or another, this has turned into Sharia law and an attack on a group of individuals who to the best of my knowledge, they haven't done anything to physically hurt or harm anyone in that community. It's just that those persons don't necessarily agree with their faith. I don't live up there. I don't live right across from there, but I do have a young man who's married to my cousin, a skill Muhammad, I kill who some of you all may know or know of wonderful man in the city of St. Petersburg. Um, I've never had him or any of his associates or any of the persons who, um, are Muslim to act in any way that we have heard comments from. I am not saying that there are not factions and there are factions within all religions that sometimes are what we call extreme. Um, but I'm not willing to paint everybody who is of that particular religion with the same brush. If individuals here that were coming here want to lift up the name of Jesus Christ, they will also know that it was Rebecca who gave birth to twins. One's name was Jacob and the other's name was Esau. Two fighting babies in the womb, um, that came out and long story short, if you want the long story, please attend one of my Bible study sessions. But the short story is that Jacob became the tribe of Israel and Esau, his brother became the Muslim or Islamic tribe. So this warring faction thing has been going on farther, far longer than what was stated here on today. But at that point in time, it had nothing to do with the things that have been expressed here on today. Um, there were two, there were two ladies that came and spoke some very positive, affirming words. Um, I did not get a chance to say to them if they're listening, I will say I am thankful because it took courage for you to come here and to share your concerns and share your thoughts about what was saying and why it's being said for some of the persons as they were speaking. I started thinking about black people, African Americans who were not even considered when the constitution was being written. Um, we were less than a full person. Um, we were not counted as a full person, but we were counted as property. Um, we were, uh, essentially taxable value. And we were in fact, what some individuals use as collateral when they took out loans for their plantations. Some of what was being said today really took me back to that. And I had to ask myself the question, do you feel that way about me, me individually and me when it comes to African Americans or black people? So it was very disheartening. He also, uh, gave some percentage numbers about the number of Somalian people that reside in Minneapolis, Minnesota. And I will tell you that I had a chance to go to Minneapolis when I graduated with my, uh, master's degree from Capella University. That is where their headquarters is. And a lot of what they were saying today is what has come from the federal level on a national stage about Somalians in Minneapolis, Minnesota and, uh, everything from their eating animals to, they are really being a drag and drain on the account economy in Minneapolis. Specifically, there are about a hundred thousand Somalians. And by the way, when they come here to the United States, they're coming in through Canada. We have typically more persons that are Hispanic that come to Florida because of the location. of the state, Minneapolis, Minnesota, and some of the other bordering states have persons that come from Africa, um, and other, um, countries within the nation of Africa, because there are several countries that make up, um, um, Africa. Africa is not one nation, but they come there specifically because that's their port into the United States. Um, and it is true that about 81 to 89% of Somalians are on services and those services include cash benefits, SNAP benefits, and Medicaid. Those are the same services we provide to others who come from other countries into the United States of America, seeking the American dream. There is a population of about 2.914 million people, um, that make up the urban area of, uh, Minnesota. And there are 430,000 individuals that live within the city and those Somalian individuals, or I will say Somalian refugees make up that number. 42% of Caucasian people are on SNAP benefits in the city of Minneapolis, Minnesota. 177,000, uh, individuals that are on benefits are children, 70,000 are seniors, and 56,000 are disabled. For every dollar and 50 cents in local economic activity, I'm sorry, for every dollar that's spent in SNAP benefits, it gives back a dollar and 50 cents in local economic activity. Persons who are receiving SNAP benefits or temporary assistance to needy families have provided $1.1 billion in jobs and economic opportunity for people in Minneapolis, Minnesota. So while some people may think that individuals of a specific race, um, or religion are drained on our economy, they are not just as the farmers whose fields went dry when persons were afraid to go to work in the fields, uh, for fear of being picked up by ice. The good news is, is that the United States of America, those 13 colonies, yes, the lady gave a little civics lesson today. Those individuals came here, not just seeking freedom of religion or from, from being persecuted, but they came here because they no longer wanted to sit under the rule of kings and queens. And when they came here, they inhabited those 13 colonies, and they pushed their way west. People were already living here when they came here, but they pushed their way west. Um, we are supposed to be the melting pot, but you can't be a melting pot if when persons come here, uh, you don't want to include them in your pot. You want to exclude them unless they acquiesce to who and what you are. If you're upset about the number of stores that persons who are Muslim or Islamic, if you're upset about the number of stores that they own, then go buy some, buy up some land, buy up some stores, get to some gas stations and do whatever it is you need to do. Um, they're purchasing those things. They are opening up businesses and people, quite frankly, frequent their businesses. I live on 3rd and 39th on the corner of 5th Avenue and 34th Street. Um, those individuals are, uh, Arabic that own that gas station. When you go to the Sitco, which is on 1st Avenue and 34th Street, um, they're also Arabic. They own that gas station. So if I was upset about them coming into my community, I need to put my pennies together with somebody else's pennies to be able to purchase a gas station or a corner store or a restaurant. Um, I know that they're probably going to keep coming. I fully expect that there will be a lot of rhetoric around my remarks, but to remain silent says that you are sometimes not all the times you're sometimes complicit in the comments that are being made. And it is sad that the issue of the day is property. It has nothing to do with Sharia law or anything of that nature. It is about property and it is about what we can and cannot approve based on SB 180. And quite frankly, if they're upset with our inability to be able to approve or disapprove, they're talking to the wrong body. They need to go to Tallahassee and lobby them and try to get as many people as possible that you can to support Senator Nick DeSiglie and reeling parts of it back that affect us this way. Um, I know that this is long. I did not intend for my comments to be as long, but I just could not sit through another meeting and listen continuously to people come up and say things about individuals when there is no basis behind the people at that location. There, in fact, are people who are extremists. And again, that's in any religion. There are people who are extremists, but I've not seen, and no one has been able to share or provide to me where the people who have requested that extension and we granted it, we voted and we granted it. Um, there is nothing that says to me that those individuals will harm their children or harm their animals. One lady says she was afraid to let her children outside. Um, they've been there for years. Um, I think that they will continue to be good neighbors. Um, saddened that maybe one or two of them, uh, from their congregation doesn't show up to, to share how they feel about how they're being treated. Um, because if they live in this community and they shop in this community, they're paying taxes in this community, whether they are full residents or not, they are paying taxes in this community and they deserve, I think, to be, uh, treated just like anybody else. And that is with compassion. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Latvalla. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Um, on, uh, Monday, November 23rd at 1 p.m., I am hosting a farm share, uh, in the high, at the high point, uh, neighborhood family, uh, center. Again, that's, uh, November 23rd this Monday at one o'clock at the, uh, high point neighborhood family, uh, center. Uh, so all, um, all folks who, uh, need, um, some, uh, food for Thanksgiving week, uh, please come, uh, and if you'd like to volunteer, uh, all are welcome to come and volunteer as well. Um, I gave the, uh, county update at the last month's Big C meeting. Um, I attended the, uh, Largo Veterans Day ceremony, uh, on veterans. It was a wonderful, um, event. Um, I spoke, uh, I believe yesterday at the 20th anniversary of the Allegiant Airlines, um, at the St. Pete Clearwater, uh, airport. Um, and I'd like to wish a friend of mine, uh, Mike Pacek, uh, happy 70th birthday. Uh, 70 is a very important, uh, birthday around here. Uh, he beat you by a few months, Mr. Chairman, but you're right behind. I'll give my best a mic. Yeah, he, he's, uh, he's a few months ahead of you, but you're, you're going to be catching up with him soon. Um, and, uh, also on a more, uh, somber note, uh, and I'd like to thank you all for, um, the well wishes today on the, uh, passing of my, uh, stepfather, Mark Jackson. Uh, he was a wonderful man, um, and he was, uh, my stepdad for about 40 years, um, and he had two, uh, children and two, two stepchildren, um, but, uh, he treated both my sister and I like his own and, um, um, just a wonderful man, very hardworking, um, very godly man, but an interesting, uh, tidbit was that he, uh, either, uh, he coached all of his kids and stepkids, either in baseball, softball, or wrestling. Um, and, um, so I did have a brief, uh, baseball career and, and for a few years, uh, as a kid, he was one of my baseball coaches. Um, but, uh, he was a lovely man and, um, he will be missed. So thank you, thank you, um, Mr. Hughes. Thank you. Uh, I want to say how, how much I feel welcome, uh, with, you know, our County administrator and his staff, uh, and the onboarding they gave me. I really appreciate it. Uh, drinking out of a fire hose wasn't too bad. And, uh, so I, I really appreciate that and, and the help of your, your, um, executive aid as well. So thank you for that. Um, I would say that, uh, of the comments that were made by the public, um, I'm, I'm really concerned about the, the aerial spraying. Uh, I'm concerned about the health effects that people are getting from the aerial spraying. I think that we need more data. Um, are, are the hospitals or, are clinics or keeping track of, you know, people who are having health problems, you know, uh, respiratory problems related to aerial spraying, uh, larvicide is, is, is a common practice, you know, larvicide treatments, uh, in ponds and pools and stuff. Um, it's very, I, I know we, we ended aerial spraying up in Virginia probably 20 years ago. Uh, uh, we, we just stopped it. We just did larvicide treatments. And, uh, so I, I'm concerned about people, their health exposure to, uh, to aerial spraying. And I think some legitimate concerns were expressed here. I think we need to take it seriously. And we need to ask, like, when it comes to a risk assessment, when you do a risk assessment, you're, you're, you're, it's based on the exposure rates, the, uh, um, the rates in which people are, um, infected and with the infection rate being so low, uh, I, I just, I just don't see the, the rationale for the aerial spraying. And so I just wanted to make that comment. Um, I think public health is very, very important there. And, uh, and, uh, and as it relates to, uh, I, I agree with commissioners and flowers about the, um, the bigotry that was being openly expressed here. Uh, it, it, it, religious bigotry, um, I'm sorry. That's what I would call it, but, uh, I will go back to, uh, I think the issue when it comes to rezoning is public notification. And I think, I think we all agree that public notification going from, uh, semi-rural or rural to a commercial or going from semi-rural or rural to like higher density is, uh, should, we should have stronger public notification and it has nothing to do with religion or, uh, ethnicity or racism or anything. It's just the people who live there deserve, they deserve really good public notification. I realize that we, you know, the county met minimum requirements, minimum standard for public notification, but maybe we can amend it. Maybe we can amend the public notification aspect of rezoning ordinance, uh, just a suggestion. And, uh, uh, I look forward to knowing what boards I can serve on, um, and what individuals I can appoint to boards. I think it's really important and chairman Eggers, I admire your leadership style as, as chairman. I've watched you the past year, you know, I didn't know much about the commission. Uh, and when I started my campaign, I check in, uh, remotely and that's a, he's got a great leadership style. So, well, thank you. Appreciate it. Appreciate that. Um, with that, I just, uh, yeah, I'm, I'm grateful to be here. Thanks. I'm the newbie here, newcomer. Welcome. Thank you so much. Commissioner Newick. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm known for my brevity, so I'll keep with that fashion. Um, firstly, um, I'd like to make a motion to appoint commissioner Watvala to PSTA to serve on our December 9th meeting, um, so we have a PSTA board meeting. You're in. Oh, I see. I get it. I didn't understand. I didn't understand. I didn't understand. Yeah, yeah. I think you need to be brought along. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, for, so to have the full county representation. We had a, we had a motion in a second. Yeah. Okay. Um, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Congratulations on that additional board. Would you like to make any other appointment? Well, uh, they probably wouldn't pass, so I, I know how to count the votes. Um, and then secondly, I support commissioner Hughes. I think we need to, um, you know, kind of put an end to the spraying or at the very minimum, get the information of the chemicals fully, their compounds, everything out online to be full transparent or, or we need to stop spraying. Um, and then with that, I'll just, I'll just yield back. So my colleagues can talk. Thank you. Mr. Peters. I, um, you know, I already talked about the spraying. Um, no, I guess I don't have anything. I thanked everybody in the swearing in ceremony this after this morning. And I truly am grateful to have the opportunity to serve some more. And I look forward to your leadership, commissioner Laffield. Thank you. Yeah. And I would, uh, echo those comments. The, the event was very nice and appreciate, uh, the residents again, um, letting me have another four years. Um, I did want to say, um, happy Thanksgiving to everybody, our, our staff and our, our residents. Um, uh, it's always, uh, it's always a wonderful family week. Uh, and I wish everybody the best here. And if you have an opportunity to get out and help others that aren't as, as lucky as some of us, to help them, that would be a good thing to do as well. Um, I just encourage everybody. There's all kinds of Christmas activities coming up, Palm Harbor, tree lighting, Dunedin city parade, Ozone, a golf cart parade and on and on. So they'll have the opportunities to, to be in some of those parades and enjoy that. Um, and so, um, yeah, um, and, uh, I had, had an opportunity to be at that veterans day in Oldsmore. It was wonderful. I always enjoy what they do there. They, uh, they really, uh, they really honor the vets, uh, and really make them feel special. So it was a very special day there. I was grateful to be asked to say just a few words, uh, and, um, and with that, I think I'm going to say the meeting is adjourned so we can get something to eat. Yes. Can I, um, address commissioner Hughes's comment quickly. Yeah. Quickly. Cause we, thank you. Um, tomorrow my aid will be emailing, uh, all of you and all of your aids about a committee form that you can fill out and be as specific as possible and also include the committees you do not want to serve on. Um, and I, uh, I have looked to see, uh, what environmental committees we have, because I know that that is an interest of yours. Um, and I believe that Joel, aren't we allowed to discuss committee preferences out like, and that not be a sunshine issue. I think that's sort of a double-edged sword because some of the committees provide that it's a chair appointment. Some provide that it's an appointment by the board. And so we typically just have all of the committees voted on at the, you know, once the chair decides it, um, if there's anyone in particular, we can look and just see whether it's actually a chair appointment or a regular. Yeah. But, but mainly just make sure you fill out the form. Oh, so thank you, chairman Latvala. Ooh. All right. With that said, let's, uh, uh, the meeting is adjourned. Grab a bite to eat, uh, for the evening meeting. To take the liberty, uh, we have a gentleman that drove quite a ways to be here and couldn't make the afternoon meeting. And I'm going to give him three minutes, uh, to address us. Uh, Chris Smith. Good afternoon, gentlemen and gentle, gentle ladies of the board. Thank you. First off, thank you very much for being gracious and allowing me to speak on behalf of your constituents who have asked me to come here. My name is Chris Smith. I'm an activist slash organizer with the coastal crusaders. I came to speak to you today on behalf of, uh, I think, you know, I came actually so we can skip past that part. But I just want to say, I was thinking on the way here and, and something that I was taught from a young age in church, fell in my spirit, what the devil meant for evil, God will always make good. And why do I say that? Because there happened to be a viral clip that went all across the internet from this very podium that I'm touching right here, right now. And I'm sure that everyone fully expected me to get up here and make a scene about that very topic. But actually, wherever you are, ma'am, I want to say thank you very much for putting the eyes of this nation on Pinellas County. Secondly, I would like to address directly Mr. Brian Scott, Mr. Dave Eggers, Ms. Kathleen Peters, and Ms. Renee Flowers. Please, please address the board as a whole. I will address the board as a whole. Yes, I will. So I have a couple of questions. Have we, why, when we went through public notice, why did we represent this as a community center? What was it that, that forced you to misrepresent this issue? Because let's face it, the facts are that if it's not already in litigation, it will be very soon. I'll make that clear. Because this was a complete misrepresentation and this was a complete failure to your constituents. I find it very ironic. I visited that site today and I walked down the road and they even called the police on me as I peacefully walked and examined the neighborhood and the business district. And what I seen was a beautiful, absolutely beautiful business district and neighborhood. And it makes me wonder, what is the economical impact of this development on them businesses? I seen a few ladies in their little decor stores. And when I looked in, I seen ladies that probably worked their whole entire life to save up enough money to have that little small business. Now, do you think, are you going to take your wife down there and go shopping when we get about two or three thousand Muslims running up and down the street dressed from ahead? Is that my time? Okay. Well, we'll be back. And next time we're bringing help with us. Yes, sir. Thank you for being here. All right. We're moving on to agenda item 44. Thank you, sir. Agenda item number 44 is case number CW 2614. This is a proposed ordinance by the city of St. Petersburg to amend the countywide plan map from residential low medium to residential medium regarding 3.89 acres, more or less, located at 3010 58th Avenue South. The public hearing is properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and the matter is properly before the board to be heard. What is the will of the board? Commissioner Nowicki. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I mean, I would be in favor of approval, though. I guess, you know, it's in a coastal high hazard area. And I know, you know, staff has taken different positions on different developments on coastal high hazard areas. So, I mean, if they feel that, you know, it's not going to be flooded and an issue, then I guess it would be okay. Would you like me to, do you want a staff to come up? I mean, I mean, I'm in favor of it. But I mean, if there's a map, you know, this, obviously, this is a map amendment. And, you know, the actual cases within the city, the city has allowed for developments within coastal high hazard. But Rodney's here to answer any specific questions on this case. Yeah. Because I remember there was one up on, like, by the Gandy. Yeah, that was on ours. On the dog track. And I don't think we were in favor of approving it because it was in a coastal high hazard area. But yet they said, oh, right across the streets, the city of St. Pete. And that's in a coastal high hazard area. And they approved that. And, you know, and part of your direction, Commissioner, was for us to look at our coastal high hazard regulations. Staff is doing that. We intend on bringing those back to you for further discussion because we, to be consistent, you know, and so, but this specific case, I'd defer to Rodney. Good evening, Commissioners. Rodney Chapman, division manager for Pinellas. Commissioner Nowicki, you are correct. The subject property is within the coastal high hazard area. The city of St. Pete and our staff did consult with the applicant, private applicant, on that aspect of the case. And the applicant agreed to record a restrictive covenant, which limits the density on the site to what it currently is, which is seven and a half units per acre. So there actually would be no density increase associated with this requested action. Okay. Well, with that, I'll move approval then if there's no density increases. Second. Can you pull up the board, please? And that is passed unanimously, six to zero, 45. Agenda item number 45 is case number CW 2615. This is a proposed ordinance by the city of Safety Harbor to amend the countywide plan map from retail and services to residential low medium for approximately .46 acres located at 603 Elm Street. The public hearing is properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and the matter is probably before the board to be heard. What is the will of the board? All right. Any questions, comments? Please pull up the voting cards. We're missing one. And by a vote of six to zero, that passes unanimously. And on 46th, there is a request for a continuance. Do we need to take formal action? It's not to a date certain because they have to re-advertise. Yeah. I think if we're just doing a request for a continuance, if it's not to a date certain, I would suggest go ahead and just continue it without inserting a date just to make clear what action was taken. Can you pull up the cards, Commissioner Scheer? And that passes, that continuance passes unanimously. 47. Agenda item number 47 is a proposed ordinance amending the Pinellas County Code Chapter 86 related to the County Drug Paraphernalia Ordinance. The proposed amendments revised County Code Section 86106 clarifying definitions in alignment with recent statutory changes to adjust language and exclude products for xylozine testing to promote the health, safety, and welfare of residents. The public hearing was properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and a matter is probably for the board to be heard. What is the will of the board? I move to move approval. Second. All right. Any questions? Please pull up the cards. That passes unanimously. Item 48. Agenda item number 48 is a proposed resolution electing to not exempt property under Section 196.1978, Subsection 30, Florida Statutes, commonly known as the Live Local Act Property Tax Exemption. The public hearing is properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and the matter is properly before the board to be heard. What is the will of the board? All right. I know we opted out of this, you know, last year. I mean, has there been any, like, issues with developers or have we, you know, heard anything that this is, like, stifled? Any progress on anything? No, this is only for the 80 to 120 provision. And, again, we recommend we continue. We haven't heard any issues. Have you, Glenn? Okay. Thank you. Is there a second? I had a question. Oh, okay. Very, this, the report says that the county finds that the previous three years of the Scheinberg annual report identify a surplus in affordable housing. Are we supposed to use the report itself or are we supposed to determine whether or not there's a? We can use the report itself and we are included within the geographic area of the report. And because of that, we can certify that, in fact, for that, that report says that there's an excess and that gives us the ability to opt out of this. And, you know, and for that, remember, we still have our affordable housing funds. We still use those as leverage. This just makes it automatic that they're tax exempt. So we still have the ability to work with the developers, but it doesn't make it automatic. Well, I just, I, I looked through the, uh, amendment four, which has all the different geographical areas and whether there's a surplus and, uh, for the 80%, uh, there was a 60,000 unit deficit for the 120, it was a 4,000, uh, 4,000 unit excess. So did you average those? How did you determine who's? I'll ask Glenn to come up when, now that we have detailed questions. Okay, good. Uh, good evening, Glenn Bailey, planning division manager. Um, they look at from zero to 120. So that's from zero to 120. We have a surplus. We've taken in all of those 120% and less. And in 2025, the last year was 6,538 surplus. And it's gone up slightly each year for the past three years. Okay. Well, the, um, the information on this report says we're supposed to be looking at between 80 and 120, not zero and 120. The, for the report, it's a complete report, but the zero to 80 is automatic. We don't have the ability to opt out, um, under state, under the new state law. And so that's the reason our only ability is between the 80 to 120. That's correct. Because they're, I mean, it's, it's, when they build those under live local, they can build them anywhere, as you know, um, and then, and they can bypass all local zoning laws. Right. And so this, we, we, we recommend we don't open that up to this. And that way you get to see the product that's being presented before you. Do we have a second on this item? Second. Okay. Any other questions? All right. Can you pull up the voting board? Mine went away, but I'm a yes. And that passes unanimously. Uh, 49. Agenda item number 49 is an amendment by resolution supplementing the fiscal year 2026 budget, recognizing unanticipated revenue and realignment of funds for requesting departments and funds. The public hearing was properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and the matter is probably before the board to be heard. So these are realigning $26. Um, the next item will be, uh, realigning, recognizing revenue for 27. All right. Uh, can you pull up the voting card? And that passes unanimously, uh, item 50 agenda item number 50 is an amendment by resolution supplementing the fiscal year 2027 budget, recognizing unanticipated revenue, unanticipated fund balance and realignment of funds for requesting departments and funds. The public hearing was properly advertised and an affidavit of publication has been received for filing. No correspondence has been received by the clerk and the matter is properly before the board to be heard. What is the will of the board? Any other questions? Uh, commissioner Naliki. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yeah, I kind of brought this up a little bit, you know, our regular meeting about the mosquito, um, you know, spraying cost is that we're realigning money from reserves. Um, and so I just, you know, and I think we said that, I think you said, uh, Mr. Administrator that we don't have it in writing that we're going to get a hundred percent reimbursed from the state. We're not. I mean, I'm, I'm confident of that, but we, that, and that's the reason we, we, uh, asked for the emergency because, um, um, the secretary of agriculture Simpson, um, you know, had stated that we're going to receive some, um, funding for that. And I think largely for the product, um, and most of the rest of that cost will be borne by us. So do we know out of how much of that money we've spent already, or you gotta, you guys got an updated figure? Good evening, commissioners. Chris Rose, office of management and budget. I don't have the amount spent so far, but I can clarify the amount that we do have in writing right now. So the amount of grant that's in writing is 1.485 million. Uh, and we are, we are realigning, uh, 3.5 million. So there is still a difference that we are taking out of reserves to do this. And the majority of that has been spent. Yes. The majority of that has been spent. And to be clear, that initial ask for the 1.458, um, was to get us through December. And then if the, um, impacts are still ongoing in January and February, we can have another ask. So they just were giving us enough to get through December. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. I mean, you know, I'll be supportive of this today, but maybe in our December meeting, you know, if we could get maybe more figures of where we're at, I think, you know, a couple of, uh, commissioners brought up the concerns of maybe wanting to pause spraying. So, um, you know, I just don't want to keep spending money that we're not going to get reimbursed on for something residents are being vocal that they don't want. So we, uh, commissioners, we met kind of at the break and staff's going to work on not only public information, um, answering the questions that were raised. We'll also get you budget figures, um, and, and try to just get to the bottom of where is it certified, where, where's that approval, where's, you know, and, and those, those questions. Um, so we intend on jumping on that immediately and we'll get back to you just as soon as we can. Perfect. Thank you. Comments, questions. All right. Can you pull up the voting card? Commissioner Scheer. And that passes unanimously six to zero. Does anybody have anything else to come before the board? Seeing none, this meeting is adjourned.