Yeah, I handed it to you. Oh, you did? I just said it on top of the file. Yeah. You're on it, Carol.
Okay, so we... Okay.
You can give it to Caroline. You can give it to me now. Thanks.
Good morning and welcome to Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearings. We are beginning with the joint stipulations and will be in recess until further notice. Communications, please stop recording.
Welcome to Pinellas County Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearings. The special magistrate is charged with conducting hearings to determine whether an alleged violation of the county code has occurred. In order to meet that obligation, all parties or their representatives will be allowed an opportunity to be heard on matters relevant to the alleged violation or violations. All witnesses offering testimony or presenting evidence will be required to swear or affirm that the testimony they provide is the truth. The order of presentation will begin with the county presenting their evidence of the alleged violation or violations. And then the respondent shall present his or her case. Both parties shall have an opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses. The special magistrate may question any witness. The clerk will announce the names of the cases from the agenda. When you hear your case called, please respond by coming to the podium with your representative and or any witnesses to be sworn in. When addressing the special magistrate, please speak clearly into the microphone. Any person who decides to appeal the decision of the code enforcement special magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need a record of the proceedings and for such purposes may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. Such record is not provided by Pinellas County.
Going to item number three, code enforcement matter is a lien reduction application. Case number is CCM-21-00014. Owner is Home Solution Investment LLC. Notice address is Brandon Schwalm, manager for Home Solution Investment LLC, 1106 Canyon Edge Drive in Austin, Texas, 78733. The violation address is 6320-146th Avenue North, Clearwater, Florida, 33760.
Good morning. Randy Edmondson on behalf of the homeowner. You're their legal counsel, Mr. Edmondson? Yes, sir.
Okay.
It's my understanding that this involves the lien reduction for 6320-146th Street Avenue North and Clearwater, correct? That's correct. And the lien has been reduced to, this is your signature, $463.21? Yes, sir. Okay. Well, I'll accept that and I've signed the order, so. All right. Very good. You're welcome, sir. Thank you.
Communications, please stop recording.
I'll do it in front of them. Yeah, you can call it.
Moving to item number one, code enforcement lien reduction application. Case number CCM-25-00009. Property owner is Vesantha, LLC. Notice address is Craig T. Teresky, Esquire. And I am going to butcher this. Anu Pama.
I chap on the medico.
Okay. Thank you. I'm so sorry. I'm not fine.
Usually mine's the most difficult.
Vesantha, LLC. 360 Central Avenue, Suite 500. St. Petersburg, Florida. 33701. Violation address is 6201. 150th Avenue, North, Clearwater, Florida. 33760.
Your name, sir? Craig Taraski for the applicant. In your relation to the applicant, his attorney? Yes. This is the property. It's a motion to reduce the lien for 6201, 150th Avenue, North, Clearwater. We're reducing that lien to $669.92? Yes. Okay. Both you and your client have signed, correct? Yes. All right. I'm signing the order right now. I think we have some technological problems how to get a copy of it, but Caroline will tell you. We know what we did. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you very much. Good day.
Off the record, Heidi. So I'll give you a copy of it. Communications. Stop recording.
Okay. Moving to item number 11. The matter is short-term rentals. Section 22-319I, 138-90, Zoning Code Violation. Case number CCM-26-00145, Officer E. Stevens, Owner, GBTB Holdings, LLC. Notice address, GBTB Holdings, LLC, 6924, Stones Throw Circle North. Apartment 8307, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33710. The violation address is 10075, West Bay Street, Seminole, Florida, 33776.
Okay. This is number 11. Ma'am, if you could state your name for the record.
Kara Trucke.
Kara what?
Kara Trucke.
Can you spell that last name, please? T-R-U-C-K-E-Y, and first name is with a C. And your relationship to the property? I am one of the owners. Property is owned by GBTB Holdings? Correct. And you're one of the principals? Correct. And Officer, if you could state your name for the record. Yes, Officer Stevens. I also got a code enforcement. If you could both raise your right hand. Do you swear if I'm any testimony you give today, be the truth nothing but the truth? I do. I have an agreement, a joint stipulation, to be more specific. It's my understanding that there's been an agreement that there'll be a findings of fact on 22-319, which just means that there was violation, but you're in compliance. And then there's been an agreement on 138-90, the short-term rentals to a one-time, I'm sorry, a $100 a day fine. Am I getting this correct? The one doing this right, the short-term rentals to a $100 a day fine, and that could be abated as long as there is compliance by December 14th, 26th? Is that correct, ma'am? Correct. Okay, and there's a one-time court cost of $420. Okay. And, Officer, is that correct? That is correct, Magistrate. Any questions, Mr? No, sir. Okay. Clerk will tell you how you're going to get an order. We're having some copy problems. Thank you. Thank you. Also, we're going to make a copy. Great. We don't list it on here. You put it on the order, but you have to do it for your appraisers. Yes. You see what they do? Now we're going to go to 15. Now we're going to go to 15. So you would go to 15. They just put that, tell me what it is. Right. It should have said short-term rentals. Yeah. This is this.
319 is short. And there's a zoning code violation on it. So what's going to happen? It should have said that, too.
No, it has. Go ahead. What's in the next one? Okay.
Moving to item number 15. Code enforcement matter is 22-299 minimum housing code and 138-3220 zoning code. Case number CCM-26-00140. Officer Hughes, owner is George M. Luttrell. Notice address to George M. Luttrell at 11260, 53rd Avenue North in St. Petersburg, Florida, 33708. The violation address is 11260, 53rd Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33708.
Officer, if you could identify yourself, please.
Officer Hughes.
And your name, sir? George Luttrell. You're the owner of the property? Yes. Both raise your right hand real fast. Do you swear or affirm any testimony you give today be the truth, nothing but the truth?
I do.
I do. What I have before me is an agreement, a stipulation for a violation of the minimum housing code, 22-299, as well as the zoning code violation, 138-3220. Zero, and it's my understanding, Ms. Luttrell, you've agreed to a fine of $100 a day. However, that fine can be abated if there's compliance by February 11, 2027. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay. And there's a one-time court cause to charge of $420. Is that correct? That's correct. Officer, is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. I'll sign the order right now, and the clerk will give you instructions on how you get a copy of it. Okay? I'll give you a copy of your order. I was just going to say I didn't sign the previous one, right? Mm-hmm. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. All right. You get me. Is your son coming today, you? This one, I saw you. Not the son, but the other one. He wouldn't have to put money in there later.
Oh, okay. Do you want me to help you back to your seat?
I can probably get back over there and we'll find out.
Thank you very much. Okay. Moving to number 10. I'll keep in touch with you. I felt bad because you approached me in the men's room. I don't have been told to him. I was good at me. Thank you. Moving to item number 10. The matter is 58-444 for noise. Case number is CCM-26-00144. Officer Stevens, property owner, is DVRS-14 LLC. Notice address is to DVRS-14 LLC, 7259 Vaughn Road, Seminole, Florida, 33776. Violation address is 7259, 131st Street, Seminole, Florida, 33776. That's it.
Sorry. Officer, if you could identify yourself, please. Yes, Officer Stevens, but I'll just kind of code enforcement. And your name, sir? Mike. Excuse me. Michael Lester, property manager for DVRS-14. Yes. If you could both raise your right hand. You swear a firm any testament gift today to be the truth, nothing but the truth. I do. I understand you've reached a joint stipulation and it was specifically an agreement.
No.
Agreed that there was a violation of 58-444, which is the noise ordinance, and agreed to a one-time fine of $500, while the court costs of $420. Is that your agreement?
Yes.
Mr. Lester, do you have authority to sign on behalf of the property owner?
Yes.
Okay. I'll sign the order right now and let you get instructions out of it. Thank you, Magister. Thank you. I'll be right with you.
Number 16. She'll give you a second. 16. I think she's pretty. Thank you. Item number 16, code enforcement. Matter at hand is 22-231, commercial minimum housing. Case number CCM-26-00141, officer Hughes. Property owner is Jonathan J. Bond. Notice address is Jonathan J. Bond at 13799 Park Boulevard, suite 295, Seminole, Florida, 33776. The violation address is 118th Avenue, Pinellas Park, Florida, 33764. This is a vacant parcel.
Officer, if you could state your name for the record.
Officer Hughes.
And your name, sir? Jonathan Bond. Okay, if you could both raise your right hand. Do you swear if I'm any testimony you give today to be the truth, nothing but the truth? I do. It's my understanding that you've reached a stipulation, more specifically an agreement, regarding the property and that bond. You've agreed that there's been a violation of 22-231, which is commercial minimum housing, and agreed to pay a daily fine of $250. However, that fine can be abated. It goes away if there's compliance by January 12th, 27. Yes, sir. Is that your understanding of the agreement? Yes, sir. The one-time court cost of $420? Yes, sir. And I'm satisfied, and I'll sign your order right now, and she'll tell you when you're going to get the copy of your order. Thank you. Thank you. Good show.
Number 17. Good show. Item number 17. Code enforcement. For 22-299 minimum housing, case number CCM-26-00143, Officer Hughes, owner is Justin C. Buck. Notice address is Justin C. Buck at 11650, 79th Avenue, Seminole, Florida, 33772. Violation address is 11650, 79th Avenue, North, Seminole, Florida, 33772.
Officer, could you state your name for the record?
Officer Hughes.
And your name, sir? Justin Buck. If you can both raise your right hand, please. Do you swear if I'm any testimony we give today, be it truth, nothing but the truth? I do. I do. It's my understanding that we both agreed that there was a violation of minimum housing. At 22, there's 299. We both agreed that there would be a fine of $100 a day. However, that fine can be abated. There's compliance by December 28, 2026, as well as a one-time court cost payment of $420. Is that your understanding, Mr. Buck? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. I'll sign the order right now. The clerk will tell you when you're going to get a copy of it. We have some copy problems today. All right. Thank you very much.
Thank you. Just keep in touch with you.
Before I take it. Yeah.
Moving to item number four, Code of Enforcement, 22-299 Minimum Housing, 20, or excuse me, 58-304 Trash and Debris, 138-3220 Zoning, Case Number CCM-26-00130, Officer Hughes, Property Owner is Beth Doron. Notice address is Beth Doron in care of Mary J. Doron. Address is 11134 91st Avenue North, Seminole, Florida 33772. The violation address is 7290 55th Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida 33709.
Officer, if you could state your name for the record, please.
Officer Hughes.
Your name, ma'am? It's Beth Dorian. Beth Dorian. You could both raise your right hand. Real fast, that one. Do you swear a firm that any testimony you give today be the truth, nothing but the truth? I do. It's my understanding you've reached a joint stipulation and agreement that there was a violation of, let me hear, 22-299, a minimum housing violation, 58-304 Trash and Debris violation, as well as a zoning code violation, which is Section 138-3220. The agreement states that you've agreed to a fine of $100 a day. However, that fine can be abated. It goes away if there's compliance by January 12, 2027. Agreed to pay court costs of $420. Ms. Dorian, is that correct? Yes, sir. Officer, I'm going to sign the order right now. I've already reviewed it. It should tell you how you get a copy. Okay, the clerk. Thank you. Thank you.
Okay. Communications, please stop recording.
I was going to ask you for that. And then these are our notions.
And that's it? Item number 18, Department Code Enforcement Petitioners' Motion
to Initiate Foreclosure.
Case number CFC-26-00006. Officer Hughes, property owner is Yulip. Notice address is Yulip at 12588-128th Avenue, Largo, Florida, 33774.
You can sit, sir, if you want to. Back with that phone down for him. Officer, if you could just state your name for the record first.
Officer Hughes.
And your name, sir?
Yulip, Y-U-L-I-P.
Just the one name, right? Yes. And you're the owner of the property at 12588-128th Avenue, Largo, right?
Yes.
And your name, ma'am?
Yannette Taylor.
Yannette Taylor. And what's your relationship to Yulip? A friend? No. Well, how about today? Are you just here to help them with the case or are you here just to...
Help with the case.
Your personal knowledge of the case? Okay.
Yes.
That's fine. I'm just to be a witness at some time. Yannette what?
Taylor. Taylor. Okay.
The three of you could raise your right hand. Raise your right hand, Yulip. Mr. Yulip. Do you swear or affirm that any testimony you give today would be the truth, nothing but the truth?
I do.
The county's going to put on a case today concerning this motion to initiate foreclosure. Okay? They'll be putting documents in, I presume. Okay? And you'll have a right to object to the documents and you'll have a right to cross-examine. You will, Mr. Yulip, to cross-examine. Okay, you're not an attorney, so if he wants to cross-examine. And certain documents, then when they're done, you can tell me what your position is on all of this and any documents or any argument you want to make and I'll let you have your friend help you, okay? So if you can sit there, whatever's easy, you can stand there, whatever works for you, okay? Go ahead. Officer, I have the package of materials. You do, okay. I was going to say I've got one for you if you need it. Yeah, you're going to add some into evidence, I presume, but go ahead.
Okay.
You do it as a package or just go through them quickly.
Yes, sir. So I am a magistrate officer with the Code Enforcement Division of Pinellas County and pursuant to Chapter 2, Article 8 of the Pinellas County Code and Chapter 162 of the Florida Statutes, the county is seeking a motion to initiate foreclosure against the following respondent, Mr. Yulip. The property in which the county is seeking foreclosure is located at 12588-128th Avenue, Largo, Florida, 33774. The property is not a homesteaded property and is located in unincorporated Pinellas County.
I'm sorry, did you say it was a homesteaded property?
It is not non-homestead property.
Go ahead.
And the county would like to submit into evidence the motion to initiate foreclosure, which consists of the history of the case and the attached exhibits.
Proceed.
Thank you. So we have the notice of hearing for today's date sent to Mr. Yulip and posted at the property. We have the motion to initiate foreclosure, which is signed by the housing official. And we have the motion exhibits. Exhibit A is Pinellas County property appraiser showing Mr. Yulip as the owner and the address in unincorporated Pinellas County. We have a copy of the deed showing Mr. Yulip as the owner. Exhibit C is the notice of violation mailed back in October of 2019. This one being for minimum housing, for the inoperable vehicles, for the trash and debris violation, and for the outdoor storage violation. I'm sorry, and for the fence violation. Sorry, these are old notices. I'm not used to reading them since they're back from 2019. Exhibit D is the notice of hearing for that. That was on August 10th of 2020. They did have a cancellation of the hearing and that was on July 13th and had been rescheduled to that hearing that happened on the 20th. This was the one that was canceled. You have the affidavit of violation and request for hearing showing the code violations that were already shown and then notice of violation for 22-299, excuse me, 58-270, 58-304, 138-90, and 138-3702. You have the notice of postings for that hearing for both the courthouse and the property. You have the order assessing an administrative fine until compliance is achieved as Exhibit E. You have Exhibit F as the affidavit of noncompliance. You have the magistrate lien as Exhibit G that was recorded on November 5th of 2020. Exhibit H is the lien notice that was sent to him on February 8th of 2024 for over $20,000. On July 27th of 2026, another lien notice was sent to the owner. Exhibit I is an email that was sent by the fire marshal for his area who was very concerned that they'd had a call and had been unable to access the property due to the, I highlighted, the crew was unable to gain access to the property because of major garbage pile.
What's the date on that?
I couldn't, that's in August of this year? It's recent, yes sir. August 21st of 2026. August 21st of 2026.
Do you know how that came about? I mean, was...
They had received some kind of call or complaint to go to this property that had to do with fire, so that's why they went. But they had such a hard time accessing it, and I'll show you pictures in a minute of why. Oh, okay. I just wanted to hear about it.
That's all. Go ahead.
Yes, sir. So the, just the kind of, were they unable to gain access? They also saw major amounts of trash, junk in the yard. I'm worried that if there is a fire, surrounding structures would be in danger and the crew will not be able to make access to the property. As a result of that and the large amount of insanitary trash and debris on the property, it was condemned by the housing official on August 25th of 2026. We have photos dated August 28th. This is basically the driveway area. You can see the large amount of trash and debris. Just everywhere you go within the property, there's a large amount of trash and debris, inoperable vehicles, food that's rotting, containers that are full of water that are standing there. Throughout the entire property. There's a tarp on the roof still. Again, just trash and debris throughout. In sanitary conditions with the rotting food, stagnant water, animals that had been trapped. This picture on the upper right. These are all exhibit K to the motion, right? Yes, sir. Okay.
My photos.
Go ahead. Keep going.
As you can see, this is just from across the street. The front, you can see how much it's blocking the entire house. There's part of the safety issue is also that all the doors and access, there's just very little egress from the property in addition to all the trash and debris. So, magistrate, the property continues to be owned by the respondent, Mr. Yulep. The property is a non-homestead property in unincorporated Pinellas County. The petitioner has an interest in the property by virtue of Pinellas Code Enforcement Special Magistrate lien in the amount of over $20,244.65 as of February 8th, 2024. The lien is accruing daily fines in addition to interest. The petitioners provided respondent with notice that the property was found to be in violation of the county's ordinance. Petitioner provided respondent with notice that the property remained in violation of the county's ordinances after respondent was afforded due process and given a period in which to cure or remedy the violations of the county's ordinance at the property. The respondent has had actual or implied knowledge of the process and procedures employed by the petitioner as Code Enforcement Division and Special Magistrate for imposition of the Code Enforcement lien. Magistrate, therefore, based on the evidence provided in the motion, the county requests that you issue an order granting Pinellas County the ability to initiate foreclosure.
Accept the motion as being the standards for a motion. So I'm accepting it. Not that it has to be into evidence, but the motion's in order, okay? Mr. Yulep, do you have any questions, or I'll even let you ask some questions of the officer?
I have a question. I just... I'm sorry? I have a question. I cannot do nothing. If CT know, like, my everything, help me, CT through everything, because I know I have a leg, I have a problem, condition.
Mr. Yulep, I want... Mr. Yulep, I just want to know if you have any questions for what this officer said.
I have a question? Do you have any questions for her?
Yeah, I want to... What's your question to her? I want... He helped me through everything, CT, and then maybe if he want to pay me a little bit money because my income money is $630.
Do you have any... I'm going to ask for the last time, do you have any questions for the officer? You could help him, Mr. Taylor. I don't mind that. I know you're not a lawyer, but...
He has no question. His main thing is just basically getting help to clean up the place.
Okay. Anything else, officer, any other that you want to add to what you've already testified to?
Not really. It's just, again, it did come to our attention to move forward due to the unsanitary condition and the health hazard for the community. And I'm sorry about you, Taylor. Taylor. Ms. Taylor, she had called me before. I do believe she's truly trying to help Mr. Yulep, and you may want to tell the magistrate what the plan is that you've been working towards.
Yeah.
If you could speak into the...
There you go.
So the thing is, he already knows that it is condemned. He already knows he cannot stay in the place. I've spoken to him about cleaning up the area and cleaning everything up. My main thing is just getting the help of other people to help me help him because he truly cannot do it by himself. And he is a hoarder, so he is willing to basically get rid of everything. But I just need the resources for someone to come and actually move forward with that.
So I could appreciate that, but I really can't do much about getting the resources. Do you understand what I mean? You could discuss that with the officer, but that's not her place. I'm just going to make a decision today whether I'm going to approve the motion that they can proceed with foreclosure.
So can you give us, what, I'm going to say, 30 days, maybe 60 days to get that done? That's where I'm leading. Very good, Ms. Taylor.
Okay, so you're looking for some time. What's your position on that, officer?
So I would like, if you permit it today, because I have explained that we do wait 30 days after before we send it over to the county attorney's office to move forward. And actually, I explained that this is actually just a motion and that it will have to get forwarded over to the county attorney. It'll have to get approved through the board of commissioners to move forward with it. So I would prefer to go ahead just because of how bad it is to continue the process and I'm hoping to get it approved today.
I mean, proceed with the process.
To proceed with the process. You object in any continuances,
right? We had these chapters before.
Yes, sir. I would like to have the foreclosure motion approved today if possible. I got that. Because it will still take time, which will truthfully be more than 30 days to move forward. It is such a large scale of debris that I honestly don't think it's possible to be completed in 30 days. But anything is possible. Yes, ma'am. And I know they were also looking, I believe, at possibly selling the property. And so they're looking at different methods. So my request today is to...
You'd like the approval of this?
I would like the approval today, yes, sir, because of the condition of the property.
Mr. Yulep. Yeah. Okay. You're not living in the property? I sleep in the car. And is the car on the property? Yeah, I have a lot of blankets and...
No, it's not on the property.
Because I scared something wrong if I sleep in my car. Only sometimes I go in my house and I take a shower.
Is anyone else helping you? No. Just this fine lady here.
I able now I try to sell the junk car to go to junk place and then I make the outside look good the driveway. I able to sell the car.
It's a little more serious than that now, Mr. Yulep, in the sense that the fire department's been there and it's a fire hazard. Do you understand what I mean? And that's serious business and I'm very inclined to... I'm going to grant this their motion in a few minutes here. Okay, and I'm just trying to see if there's any way, you know...
That's me 60 days.
But mostly I want to sell my house. I want to go back to my country. I want to sell, really, I want to sell my house. I don't want headache like this. I'm under pressure condition. I don't like that. Sometimes I think... Sometimes I'm thinking I want to burn my house. I want to die. I'm happy like that. And then I put note in my mailbox. I want this way to end my life because I'm under pressure. I pay tax while I cannot sleep in my house. So it happened like this. 48 years in the United States that's... This year happened to me like this.
How old are you, Mr. Yelop?
83, obviously. I don't have a leg and my ice condition no more sea good. And sometimes short breath. I'm feeling I'm feeling very close to die. That's the reason I want to sell my house and then go back to my country. That's it. No one die in my house like that. And then if CT can help me, CT can buy, I very appreciate.
Anything else, Ms. Taylor?
No, I'm trying to get everything together for him. Either sell it or clean it up. No, I got it.
Officer, if you have any information where you could point him towards service agencies that might help him, I'd appreciate it.
Yes, the housing director did ask for the human resources and they've reached out to the community policing department. So they've been trying but I don't know that they've...
Anything else?
No, sir.
I'm going to grant the county's motion to initiate foreclosure and I guess I'll do an order later, Carolyn. How's that going to work?
We can do the order now. It's up to you if you want to wait for the order to get a copy of it or we also will mail it to Mr. Yulek.
Yeah. Put Ms. Taylor on the mailing list, okay, as a friend.
If I can come and write your information, please.
Okay. All right, we're done here. Thank you, sir. Good luck, Mr. Yulek. Thank you. No, I'm just granting the motion.
Oh.
An order initiating foreclosure of the property immediately. That's the whole point.
Okay. And we're...
It's...
I'll never...
I'm sorry. You can... We'll be right with you. You disappear.
Oh, they can start the process. She's telling the truth. You know, they got to go to the county commissioners and also have to do stuff.
Okay. Do we want to go to number 19 and start from here?
Whatever Carolyn wants, yeah. Doesn't make a difference. You might as well... We could always do that last since nobody's here on that right, so we can make it easier for the officers.
I'm sorry. He's talking. Communications, stop recording, please. Moving to item number five, code enforcement, the matter of 22-299 for minimum housing, 154-231 for zoning. Case number is CCM-26-00137. Officer Hughes, the owner is 202106WY-15 LLC. Notice Address is to 202106WY-15 LLC, 3816 Miss Trail Drive, Huntington Beach, California, 92649. Violation Address is 6474, 29th Street North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33702.
Let the record reflect that no one has answered the call and there's no one in the gallery outside of it. We're still looking for... Officer, state your name for the record.
Officer Hughes.
Officer Hughes, if you could raise your right hand, please. Do you swear, affirm, that any testimony we give today be the truth nothing but the truth?
I do.
You may proceed.
Thank you. So the property where the alleged violation exists is 6474 29th Street North, St. Petersburg, Florida, 33702, located in unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner, 2106WY15LLC, has not present for today's hearing and I have not had any contact whatsoever from them.
Okay, understood.
The violations have been in unincorrent since on or before January 13 of 2026, so almost a year now. And I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence, which includes the Notice of Violations, Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser documents, the warranty deed, the son vids for the registered agent, and the violation photos.
I have copies in front of me. Please proceed.
Okay, so I'll just go straight to the violation photos then if you're okay with that. Or did you want me to go through that? No, no, that's okay.
We've got the violations in the file. This is a non-homesteaded property, right?
Non-homesteaded.
They've owned it since 2021, right?
I'm sorry, what since?
They've owned it since 2021.
Oh, yes, sir.
Okay, yeah, just give me the photos
and explain the minimum housing in the zone it goes by.
Okay. So they had had, they had come into compliance with a couple of the minimum housing violations. So the only thing that's left right now is they have a driveway that is severely deteriorated. It's basically just cracked all throughout. What, a large part of the problem also is they have a drainage that goes through in the right-of-way. Right. And it's basically crumbling where there's holes where you can see it all the way down where these pieces of concrete are just lying there. So I did reach out to Public Works right-of-way and ask them to take a look at it because I'm not an expert in that. and their email is the following document which basically says I inspected the driveway and it appears to be beyond repair. The existing pipe is metal and does not meet Pinellas County code. I will contact someone at the stormwater department regarding the ditch cleaning. Please note the homeowner will need to obtain a right-of-way permit from BDRS before any work can be performed within the county right-of-way. So as a result of that is why you will see that they have two violations one for the minimum housing and one for the right-of-way permit required.
So the zoning violation is the right-of-way permit?
Yes, sir. 154-231 is just for the zoning permit required the right-of-way permit to obtain prior to doing any work within the right-of-way which is part of that driveway.
Okay, so the plus I thought before you said the driveway was minimum housing.
Yes, sir. It is. So it's all kind of one. No, I'm trying to think for the
order.
So go ahead. Yes, sir.
So I got it. I got what the problem is.
Okay. So, um, magistrate, the property was re-inspected on November 3rd of 2026. The violations continue. Photos were taken on that date and I would like to submit them as composite exhibit B.
Okay, so pretty much we've got minimum housing on the
owner's driveway
and then we got the zoning for where, which is where the pipe goes underneath the right-of-way to get onto the street.
Exactly. Yes, sir.
And that was what the violations are. Okay, yes, I'll accept all the documents, composite exhibit A and all the associated filings before that. We'll call that A. Okay, and may I give
you composite
exhibit B? Please. It's the, thanks.
Thank you.
Okay, so basically there's been no changes. I went back to the property on November 3rd. The driveway is still in very serious disrepair and same with the driveway. There's no, there's been no changes. There was a zoning clearance application that just has not been completed. So they have not completed anything. I've had no contact.
You say there's been an application but it's not completed. Help me with what that means.
So what that means is it never got issued. So when they first received the notice, again, I was never contacted but I did find a zoning clearance application.
So they filed something but didn't follow through.
Yes, sir.
Okay.
And so again, I've had no contact. They've done nothing to get it issued.
Got it.
So again, just the last picture is just showing that they're just pieces laying over the piping. So magistrate, the county is asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply and have still found in violation to assign a daily fine amount of 100 per day per violation for code sections 22, 299 and 154, 231 and award to the court costs in the amount of $420.
Anything else?
No, sir. That concludes my testimony.
I just want to get the order right. But I'm going to consider the public portion of the hearing closed. I'm going to find for the county. I'm going to find that there's a violation of 22 there's 299, the minimum housing code violation and impose a fine of $100 a day. However, that fine can be abated if there's compliance within 30 days, which is December 13th, 2026, by 5 p.m. Similarly, with regard to 154, 231, the zoning code violation, impose a fine $100 a day, that fine can be abated if there's compliance within 30 days, which is December 13th, 2026, by 5 p.m. and impose costs of $420. So I just wanted to get that technical in your room. Okay. Fine. I think you're going to get mailed the order. You can work it out with Carolyn.
Thank you so much.
Thank you. Moving to
item number six.
I'm going to withdraw that one, I think. These are all the same. Yes.
Yeah. Code enforcement. The matter is 5458-304, trash and debris. Case number CCM-26.
Number six, okay.
Dash 00147, Officer DeVall, owner is Dovetail Homes, LLC. Notice address is Dovetail Homes, LLC, 220 West 7th Avenue, Tampa, Florida, 33602. Violation address is 1665 Myrtle Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, 33756.
Let the record reflect that the gallery is empty and no one has responded for the, no one has stepped up for the to respond. Officer, state your name for the record.
Officer DeVall.
Officer, I understand you've got several of these against Dovetail Homes here today.
That is correct. We have four properties all owned by Dovetail Homes, LLC. They are all vacant parcels that were not being maintained. They have now sold the properties, all of them, and that was reflective as recorded on the 2nd of November, the day that I posted the property. That's what
always happens, right? Yes, but we are
happy that they did sell and we are very hopeful that maybe there's some new development going in there. So I am withdrawing all of these cases. There are four, there were five parcels total that was sold. One of them was in compliance, but these four that are on the agenda, I'm withdrawing all of them.
Okay. We just call, is there anyone, this case here technically is for 1665 Myrtle Avenue. Is there anyone here for 710 Seneca Street, Clearwater, Florida? Booktail again. Anyone here for 708 Seneca Street, Clearwater, Florida, as well as 704 Seneca Street, Clearwater, Florida. Let the record reflect that the gallery is empty and in light of these statements, if you could raise your right hand, did I swear you in yet? Do you swear or affirm that any testimony we get today to be the truth, nothing but the truth?
I do.
Tell me about these four cases again, just for the record.
Again, these were of, there was a total of five vacant parcels. This property owner is certainly familiar with Pinellas County Code and our magistrate process. They had a lot of violations out there. They cleared a bunch of the properties but then continued to not truly maintain the properties. There was a bunch of dumping and debris, a massive amount of overgrowth, and we finally just said it's time to bring before the magistrate again, and then they sold the properties out from under us.
That's what posting does. It does, but
again, we are actually very happy that the properties have sold. We're hopeful that there's going to be some new development because all five of these parcels combined are quite large. It's a big piece of
property now for someone to develop into. We're hoping something very nice. So we're going to remain hopeful and look and see what happens in the next 30 days or so, and if we have continued problems, we will pursue a new property owner.
Understood. Anything else?
That is all.
Let the record reflect that those statements have to do with item 6, 7, 8, and 9. In light of the testimony and request from the county, we accept the withdrawal of case numbers CCM 26-00147, CCM-26-00148, CCM-26-00149, and CCM-26-00150. Do we do orders on that? Or we could just
mark the record as
withdrawn?
Are we? Yeah. I mean, it was just going to be withdrawn on the record. We don't have to do orders. Okay. Consider them
withdrawn on the
record. All right. Thank you. Thank you, officer. Moving to item number 12, code enforcement, short-term rentals for section 22-319-I, case number CCM-26-00146, officer Stevens, owner is Escape Estate, LLC.
Do I need to read this?
Notice address is Escape Estate, LLC, 1484 Bugle Lane, Clearwater, Florida, 33764. Violation address is 1484 Bugle Lane, Clearwater, Florida, 33764.
Officer, if you could raise your right hand, state your name, please.
Officer Stevens, Penelts County Code Enforcement.
Okay. Do you swear or affirm that any testimony to give today be the truth, nothing but the truth?
I do.
Let the record reflect that there's no one in the gallery and no one has responded for and no one has answered for the responded.
You can proceed, officer. Yes, magistrate. The property where the alleged violation exists is 1484 Bugle Lane, Clearwater, Florida, 33764. Located in Unincorporated Pinellas County. The owner of Escape Estate, LLC or their affiliates are not present or represented before today's hearing. The violations have been an occurrence since on or before July 28th of 2026. I would like to enter the Notice of Hearing and Composite Exhibit A into evidence, which includes the Notice of Violation, Pinellas County Tax Collector, Property Appraiser, Deed, Division of Corporations, Notice of Occupancy Letter for our Pinellas County Housing Official dated June 30th of 2025, STR Certificate of Abuse for the property, the rental unit record with timeline, an active Airbnb and VRBO listing.
I have all of those in front of me, officer, so you can just take me through it and I'll do it all at once.
Notice of Hearing. Yep. Our Notice of Violations, Date 727-2026.
And this violation is of one, the advertisement? Yes, it's just an advertisement. Okay, got it. Go ahead.
We have the tax, property appraiser, the deed, the Division of Corporations for Escape LLC. This is a Notice of Occupancy violation that we had sent out on June 30th of 2026, which was given to Escape Estate LLC. This is the short-term rental certificate, which they understand that in the short-term certificate of use, they have restrictions on what they can and cannot do for the advertisement. We have the RELO unit number with a record. The last time that they documented stay was back in August 30th, 2026. This is the Airbnb site. You can see it says 11 guests, which they're not allowed to exceed 10. Oh, I got it. That's a Notice of I can see. And then also 11 on top as well. Right. And then in the information below about the space, they have nothing in there that corresponds with anything that the ordinance requires. Understood. And then also when you go in there, I can still book the property at the time of the investigation. I can still book the property, which means it's active. And again, for the VRBO, this one also states sleeps 11. And again, below in the rooms and bed, four bedrooms, sleeps 11 in numerous places. And again, when it speaks about the property itself, shows sleeps 11, but it has no other information pertaining that is required under our ordinance under 22319 I. And again, I was able to book it at the time of the investigation for the for the days required. Magistrate, the property is also re-inspected on October 29th of 2026. And again, this morning on November 13th, 2026. And the violations continue. Desk investigation completely on this date. And I would like to submit them as a composite exhibit B, which you should have in your possession.
I'm going to accept all the documents referenced by the officer as a composite exhibit A, which is a notice of hearing and all the other documents. And you may proceed with B, sir.
Thank you, Magistrate. Again, this is the newly updated one as of this morning. Again, they're still doing document stays into October. Still sleeping 11, huh? Yes, sir. Again, still sleeps 11, the Airbnb, and no other information pertaining to the items that are required under our ordinance. Right. The affirmative statements, right? I was unable to pull up the VRB website this morning, only for the fact that it was down. But again, on the Airbnb, I'm still able to book the property for the dates shown to show it's still active. Magistrate, the county requests that you find the property in violation in initial order to have the property brought into compliance.
Going to accept the composite B into evidence, and what are you looking for, officer?
Magistrate, the county's asking for the allowance of 30 days to comply, and if still found in violation, assign a single-day fine of $500 per day for the violation of 22319, subsection I, code section, and the court costs of $420.
Okay, second here. Anything else? That'll be it.
Thank you, Magistrate.
I'm going to consider the public portion of the hearing closed. I'm going to fine the respondent in violation of 22, this 319, I think that's I-1, the specific. I'm going to impose a fine of $500 a day. That fine can be abated if there's compliance within 30 days, which would be December 13th, 2026, by 5 PM, as well as a, as well as imposing costs for the county of $420 upon the respondent. They're going to do that order later. I'm not sure you have to ask Carolyn. Thank you, Magistrate. I appreciate it. You have the next one?
Mm-hmm. B, item number 13.
She has the name.
Code enforcement for 22-319, I, short-term rentals. Case number CCM-26-00151. Officer Stevens, owner is Pura Vida Capital, LLC. Notice address is Pura Vida Capital, LLC. At 205, Craig's Run Court in Berryville, Virginia, 22611. Violation address is 1469 Young Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, 33756.
Let the record reflect that the gallery is empty and no one is re-answered for the respondent. Officer, if you could state your name for the record and raise your right hand.
Officer Stevens, Pinellas County Code Enforcement.
You sure if I'm having any testimony to get today, be the truth and nothing but the truth? I do. You may proceed.
The property with the alleged violation exists at 1469 Young Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, 33756. Located in the unincorporated Pinellas County, the owner, Pura Vida Capital, LLC, cannot be present or represented for today's hearing. However, I did speak to Mr. Diego Rodriguez, who I've been working with, referenced this case. And as of last night, magistrate, they are in compliance. Ouch.
Second here. Okay. Go ahead.
Would you like me to go through the entire process? Tell me what you're seeking here. It might be a lot easier. Perfect. The county is asking for finding the facts for Code Section 22319, plus the court cost of $420.
Since they're not here, and this would be findings of fact on a violation of 22319, I guess that's I-1. Am I getting that right?
Yes.
I-1. Okay. I'll enter an order. Okay. I don't need to. I'm going to enter an order that there's been a violation of 22319, I-1, and I'll enter a finding of fact in that regard. That's what you're looking for, right? Yeah. It's going to be I-1 and G-1 as well. I-1 and G-1. Yeah. See, they just put the one on the, I don't get it till now, so I never really, I-1 and G-1.
These are, magistrate, these are older cases which have that. Oh, yeah.
I got it. I got it.
So we're trying to, you know, fix those as we go. Just to make them all the same makes my job easier. But I did speak to him. He's in Virginia. He travels for his business. And I did have a conversation with him last night in the evening.
Okay. Well, I'm going to, so you're just looking for the findings of fact. Finding of fact in the core cost. How much did the core cost? 420? 420. Okay. I'll enter that order. Okay. Thank you, magistrate. I appreciate it. The last one, if you want.
Item number 14, the matter at hand is 22-319 G and I. Case number CCM-26-0. 0-0-1-3-9. Officer Hughes. Owner is Louis Otero and Caitlin Otero. Notice address is Louis Otero and Caitlin Otero to 8410 Rambling Rose Drive in Ultawa, Tennessee, 37363. The violation address is 8697 Orange Blossom Drive, Seminole, Florida, 33772.
Let the record reflect that there's no one in the gallery, no one answered to the call of the list. Officer, if you could state your name and raise your right hand.
Officer Hughes.
You swear if our many tests we get today be the truth, nothing but the truth?
I do.
You may proceed. I have the package in front of me.
Okay, great. This is actually very similar to the last code case. After I posted the property, I was contacted by Mr. Louis Otero, who he and his wife own the property at 8697 Orange Blossom Drive in Seminole, Florida, 33772. He doesn't contest at all that they're operating this as a short-term rental. He did say they live in Tennessee and he would not be available today's hearing. He pretty much just let me know that he was going to be in trouble with his wife because he had forgotten to finish this. So, anyway.
Well, I won't take that into account when I decide what to do with the place, but go ahead.
But, so again, he's not contesting. He asked me if I could go ahead and send him the information again on how to gain compliance. Since that time, he has pretty much, he has applied for the short-term rental certificate. He has inspections scheduled. That will be the last portion and then paying his final amount. So, I can go through the whole thing, but what I am... What are you seeking, officer? What I am seeking today is just that we do find that there is a violation of 22319G for the certificate and 22319I for not having the correct advertisement yet to allow him 30 days to comply and if still found in violation to assign a daily fine amount of 500 per day.
This is 30 days on each violation?
Yes, sir. 30 days for both 22319G, 22319I, and award court costs in the amount of 420.
So, let's just see. So, 319G would first...
Yes, just 319G.
Because he doesn't have the certificate of use yet, right?
Correct.
Okay. And then...
He's close, but doesn't have it yet.
Okay. And the other violation is...
For the advertising, because it's going to need to include his DBPR number, his occupancy limit, his parking limit, and he won't have all that until he gets his certificate approved.
And he's been advertising, and I can see the documents here in the back. Yes, sir. Okay. I'm fine with that. I'll enter that order.
Thank you so much.
Yeah, there's one other item, which is item number 19, code enforcement for respondents' objection to affidavit of noncompliance.
We know something about that already, right?
Sorry?
What are we doing with the last one, the objection?
The respondent was the one that objected, and they are not in the audience today, and I haven't had any communication with them.
Okay. Did you just call this one? Oh. Yeah, let's call it, and we'll just put it on the record. Okay. Please.
All right. So that's for a respondent's objection of affidavit of noncompliance, which is item number 19, case number CCM-25-00103, Officer Duvall. The property owner is Tatiana Surger. Notice address is Tatiana Surger at 12689 Wilcox Road, Largo, Florida, 33774. The violation address is 12689 Wilcox Road, Largo, Florida, 33774.
That's where I can reflect that no one has checked in, nor is anyone here in the gallery regarding 12689 Wilcox Road, specifically respondent's objection to affidavit of noncompliance. Out of what I just said, I'm dismissing the objection to the affidavit of noncompliance.
Dismissing it, not denying it.
Denying it.
Denying it. Okay.
I believe we're all set for today. I have nothing else in need. Communications, please stop recording.