Try Free

Wind vs. Solar Energy — — Peter Zeihan

Zeihan on Geopolitics November 20, 2026 5m 941 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Wind vs. Solar Energy — — Peter Zeihan from Zeihan on Geopolitics, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 941 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"hey everybody peter design here coming to you from yosemite national park specifically in upper matterhorn canyon beautiful part of the park today we're going to talk about solar versus wind on a cost basis while i am going up to where did it go there it is matterhorn pass right there so the first..."

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: hey everybody peter design here coming to you from yosemite national park specifically in upper matterhorn canyon beautiful part of the park today we're going to talk about solar versus wind on a cost basis while i am going up to where did it go there it is matterhorn pass right there so the first thing that wind has an advantage over solar is in aiming a wind turbine spins on its axis so whatever direction the wind is coming it will angle itself to go straight into the wind that is something solar can only do if you make it tracked solar which means introducing literally thousands of moving parts per installed megawatt at extreme cost in order to track with the sun and if you fail to do that you're giving up 25 of what you could possibly glean in the first place the second thing that gives wind an advantage is height the relationship between the height of the turbine and the length of the blade and the strength of the wind currents higher up is logarithmic so if you get wind it's about 25 stronger you're going to roughly double the amount of electricity that you generate once you take those things into account and as you go up the currents get stronger we'll give you more from further up all right i've made it to the glacial shelf when uh this should all be snow and well it's a good thing global warming isn't real uh anyway uh there's the pass right there that is my next stop it's as gnarly as it looks uh this is matterhorn peak over here we have burrow pass the one pointing up is one of the finger peaks this somewhat stubby guy over here is dog head he's not as stubby as he looks when you're up close and back over there is whirl and then of course all that below me is uh upper matterhorn okay uh the next big thing is longevity uh your typical wind turbine is going to last 25 to 30 years as long as it's properly maintained uh maintenance is real uh but it's per megawatt it's by far the lowest maintenance cost of any type of power generation green or conventional certainly cheaper than nuclear when it comes to maintenance anywho uh that's not how it goes with solar with solar the inverters have to be swapped out at least once a decade and the panels themselves lose coherence over time they lose about one half of one percent of generating capacity per year i mean it really depends upon the circumstances um and so while the cost of making a module has gone down and like you know it's gone down amazingly over 80 percent um the generating capacity per cell per square inch has only improved by like five to eleven percent in the last 30 years so they've gotten cheaper but they haven't really gotten better and whereas with wind you can always go higher and higher and higher you can't get closer to the sun in any meaningful way with a solar panel all right we'll do the last bit from the top and here we are from the top of matterhorn peak or excuse me no matterhorn pass matterhorn peak is up there we are sure as shit not doing that whoa i'm gonna live uh and then down here is spiller canyon and on the other side of horse creek peak pass i need better names here is horse peak creek going down in twin lakes and then this is spiller canyon which is arguably after merced canyon itself the most uh stunning uh valley in all of the park and that's where i'll be tomorrow anyway um let's finish up this video so we've talked about acreage and maintenance and lifespan and elevation uh the last big thing of course you know shocker night and winter despite what people have dreamed of we have never once been able to generate solar power at night the moon just doesn't cut it i've tried and then winter um for those of you who don't live within 10 degrees of the equator there's a significant seasonality solar generation and if you're north of roughly the iowa minnesota border you're looking at getting maybe if you're lucky uh 20 percent of the power generated in the winter that you would have gotten in the summer and keep in mind that the entirety of canada and the entirety of western europe is above that line so it's not that solar can't be part of your solution but it certainly can't be the mainstay uh as for the numbers uh despite the world honestly being obsessed with solar and building it out everywhere uh this last year 2025 was the first year ever that solar actually surpassed wind in terms of total generation at about 27 terawatt hours however the amount of money that has been spent on installing wood on a global basis is only 40 percent of what has been spent installing solar and that's before you consider problems with transmission and that most people don't live where uh it's sunny whereas you can build a wind turbine nearly anywhere if you're willing to go up anyway that's the end of it you're looking at about it be somewhere between two and a 2.4 times return on wind investment versus solar investment you go offshore that number gets even higher i'm looking at you trump administration uh and that's it for today everyone have a good one [00:05:53] Speaker ?: Thank you.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →