Try Free

Why Solar’s 50-Year Growth Run Just Ended

Latitude Media November 21, 2026 30m 4,917 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Why Solar’s 50-Year Growth Run Just Ended from Latitude Media, published November 21, 2026. The transcript contains 4,917 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"I'm Shail Khan. I lead early stage investments at Energy Impact Partners. Welcome to Catalyst. So every year around this time, Jenny Chase, who is a solar and clean power analyst at Bloomberg NEF and has been tracking the solar market even longer than me, publishes a long thread of her opinions on..."

[00:00:00] Shail Khan: I'm Shail Khan. I lead early stage investments at Energy Impact Partners. Welcome to Catalyst. So every year around this time, Jenny Chase, who is a solar and clean power analyst at Bloomberg NEF and has been tracking the solar market even longer than me, publishes a long thread of her opinions on solar. Some are popular, some decidedly are not, and all of them come from someone who's been paying attention to this industry for two decades or so. At this point, it's kind of the closest thing solar has to a mini State of the Union. We actually did an episode going through some of her opinions once before back in 2022. I read the whole thread, I pick out the ones that I think are the most interesting or most surprising, and then unpack them with Jenny. The last time we did it was four years ago, as I said, which in solar is a very long time. So it seemed like time to do it again. Before we start, as I mentioned last week, we're going to wrap up 2026 with an Ask Me Anything episode. Send us your questions. You've got until December 8th to send them to catalyst at latitudemedia.com. We'll answer as many as we can in the last episode of the year. In the meantime, Jenny Chase is coming up next. Jenny, welcome. Thanks for having me. Okay. Lots to talk about in the solar world. I want to start by giving you one last opportunity to change your mind. As you know better than I even, it has been a fool's errand for years and years and years and years and years and years to predict a down year for global solar installations. Many have tried, none have succeeded. And yet you predict 2026 will be the first down year for global, new global solar capacity since, I don't know, the year 2000 maybe? [00:01:50] Jenny Chase: Ever. I mean, since records began. I mean, we have records back to 1976 and there's never been a down year in that time. Okay. Wow. 2026 is going to be the first down year, or it is the first down year. I mean, it's November now. There's, it's not going to check. It's not, there's not going to be a last month reversal. I'm sorry. Last year, about 655 gigawatts of solar was installed. And this year it's going to be about 584 or so. [00:02:18] Shail Khan: Down year for global solar is surprising to everybody, I suspect. It's really a China story, right? [00:02:24] Jenny Chase: Predominantly. It, it's not only a China story. I mean, China is more than half the world market. So when China, something happens in China, it is a big part of the world story. But basically this is what we have been saying will happen for years and years, which is that solar is starting to saturate out. It's starting to hit negative feedback effects. So you're getting a lot of solar in sunny hours in many parts of the world, including most, much of China. And that means that you're getting curtailment of solar generation and low power prices on spot markets. And that is, that means that it's less attractive to build solar. It means that policymakers are setting policies to build less solar. That's, I mean, the big change in China was that there was a policy change mid 2025 to force renewable energy developers to sell on the spot markets for power, rather than getting a fixed power price. But that was, that policy change in China was partly a response to saturation effects coming up, to curtailment, to low prices. And that is just something that we're seeing everywhere. And that is slowing down solar in a lot of the markets where it used to be really big. So this saturation effect is a global thing. It is happening in certain markets at once, but it's a big deal in places from Brazil to China. Much of Europe now has a very low power prices in sunny hours. And this isn't going to go away, not even if we have an energy storage boom, which is perhaps what we are having, that keeps us building solar, but it doesn't reverse the negative feedback mechanisms completely. We don't have a lot of solar, we don't actually need that much more [00:04:12] Speaker 3: energy storage boom. But we have a lot of solar power all at once. Catalyst is brought to you by Antenna Group. Antenna Group is the communications and marketing partner behind the most influential companies in energy, climate and infrastructure. For three decades, Antenna has helped ambitious companies stand out and become category defining brands. Let Antenna accelerate your momentum and you can learn more at antennagroup.com. Catalyst is brought to you by Energy Hub. Energy Hub's software platform gives utilities flexible capacity they can stake their grid planning on, coordinating batteries, EVs, thermostats, and commercial and industrial sites through a single system. This scale is proven. More than 230 utilities across North America trust Energy Hub to manage over 3.6 gigawatts of flexible capacity. Learn more at energyhub.com. Catalyst is brought to you by GridBeyond. Demand flexibility is now an essential part of the data center speed to power playbook. And GridBeyond is the end-to-end solution for flexible energy management. GridBeyond's advanced DERMs and VPP platform helps data centers maximize reliability, reduce costs, and manage all your distributed resources in one place. Ready to transform your distributed energy management? Get started at GridBeyond.com. [00:05:29] Shail Khan: Explain to me why. I mean, we're in this interesting period where like solar in a lot of these markets is very mature and there is a lot of it now. Batteries, grid scale batteries are not as mature yet and we don't have as much of them yet. And so, but it is scaling quickly. Why is it not true that adding a lot of batteries will at least ameliorate that impact? [00:05:52] Jenny Chase: It does ameliorate it. What it doesn't do is kickstart the solar industry back into growth because what we're seeing particularly in Australia and Chile, both markets which have added a lot of batteries this year particularly, we are seeing reduced solar curtailment. But in Chile, average solar curtailment last year was I think 18%, which is really, really high. So, if it's down slightly, that's still a lot of solar that you're just dumping on the market and that's still a very strong reason not to build more solar. The other thing that is happening in these markets that have a lot of batteries is that the first thing you see is that the returns for batteries go down as you get a lot of batteries in. Historically batteries have been built for the ancillary services market significantly. So, they make their money by selling frequency response and black start capabilities and basically all the services that the grid operators value to handle tiny little fluctuations rather than to do bulk arbitrage. Now, bulk arbitrage is what happens when you charge your batteries from solar and then sell the power later when it's more expensive. And the first few batteries in Australia made great money on bulk arbitrage. But now, we're seeing that the evening peak in Australia is already significantly lower in terms of power prices because all these batteries are coming in. So, although the batteries have slightly increased the midday power price, but much more significantly they brought down the evening power price. So, basically batteries eat batteries before they help solar. They are helping solar, but it's relatively small as yet. [00:07:43] Shail Khan: Yeah. And I guess there is a point to make on this global picture, which is like it's all a matter of degrees. Basically what happened is the global annual new solar installation number shot from, I'm just looking at the numbers you all published, from about 100 gigawatts in 2017 to over 600 gigawatts last year. You're now saying it'll be down from 650 gigawatts to 580 or so, and then starts growing again on a global basis actually into the foreseeable future, albeit at much more incremental rates. So, it's kind of a story of like market by market, you get a lot of solar growth and then you reach some plateau where solar starts to get saturated, you add more batteries, that keeps the new solar installations from completely collapsing, but it doesn't create, you know, continued growth of new installations each year. That happens in the mature markets and then meanwhile there's still a lot of markets that just do not have that much solar yet. [00:08:49] Jenny Chase: There are, now China has a lot of solar, and India is adding a fairly constant 50 gigawatts a year of solar. That's starting to get quite a lot of the world's population that is already somewhat solarized. I mean, there are large other populations, there's Indonesia that we're waiting to really break through, there's a lot of Southeast Asian countries, there's Bangladesh, and of course there's Africa. We are seeing increased sales of solar modules into Africa, but that's going to take a lot, it's going to take a long time for those to make really substantial volumes, simply because people are very poor and buying a lot of solar is a lot for them, even though it's cheap now. [00:09:33] Shail Khan: What it looks like you're forecasting is that in Western countries, let's say in Europe and North America, more or less flat. When I say flat, I don't mean no new solar, I mean roughly the same amount of solar installed each year for the next five, six, seven years, something like that. Is that basically the function of what you're saying? It's like batteries combating solar curtailment, essentially? [00:10:01] Jenny Chase: Yes, there's two effects. There's batteries combating solar curtailment, sometimes just by being co-located with batteries, particularly in the residential segment. This year, about 90% of German residential solar systems had batteries there, so that means that the curtailment doesn't have a big impact on those new systems. But also, there's a bunch of auctions in Europe, so governments are still pushing in solar and wind, even though the power prices on the market don't necessarily support it. And the reason for that is basically that we've got renewable energy targets. We want to keep pushing gas out of the mix and making the overall power mix cheaper. The best way to do that is to keep pushing renewables in and also batteries to keep those things in equilibrium. I mean, Germany is supposed to get 80% of its power from renewables by 2030, and it's currently at 58, I think. So that's quite a lot of work to do in the next three years, three, four years. We've got to keep, and there are auction programs which buy large volumes of utility-scale solar for pretty cheap prices. [00:11:15] Shail Khan: The other thing that you noted in your opinions thread that people talk about once in a while, but it's fun to see data for, is as you get to high penetration of solar, the seasonal variation between high solar season and low solar season starts to rear its ugly head. It does so even more in northern climates like where you are. But yeah, give me a sense of how big a difference that is and how big a deal it is. [00:11:47] Jenny Chase: It's actually a really big deal if you're in Northern Europe and you're trying to rely on solar. This whole household, for example, we bought a big battery in spring and we've bought hardly any electricity from the grid from spring to September. But now we're actually buying nearly all our electricity from the grid because come November, the sun just does not appear. You can get 60 kilowatt hours a day from my house solar in summer, and you can get three kilowatt hours in November. And at the same time in November, our electricity use is higher because we're trying to heat the house as well. So really, if you want to run Northern Europe on solar in winter, you just need stupid amounts of solar. And you can say, OK, we'll build a big battery. But if you have a battery that you are only just charging and discharging once a year, even if that battery is incredibly cheap, the economics are just not going to work. But that's one reason why in Northern Europe we have got to build wind, because we're going to have to charge these batteries with something in the winter. Wind, nuclear, doesn't matter to me, but we need something clean that's going to work in winter because solar is not reasonably going to cut it. [00:13:07] Shail Khan: Now that is particularly true in Northern Europe. I mean, how, what does it look like if I'm in, I don't know, Southern Spain or somewhere that isn't quite the same climate? [00:13:15] Jenny Chase: Better, but Southern Spain is still only roughly like New York latitude. I mean, you've got to remember that all of Europe is quite north compared with the US. And although it's not massively cold, there is heating demand in Spain, which also means that you're going to have higher power demand in winter probably. It's probably, it's much easier to run on solar in Spain than here in Switzerland or up in the Nordics. But it's, you want to be running on wind as well. Basically, also whenever you do an energy model of any energy system, apart from maybe India's and parts of the Middle East, the model wants you to build wind for a net zero solution because wind is anti-correlated with solar. It says, look, there are going to be months, weeks or months of the year when you cannot charge your massive batteries with solar, build wind. And there is a danger, of course, that you actually only need that wind for a few weeks a year. So you could say, go on a pathway where you just build loads of solar and storage and get to sort of 90% solar and storage dependency. And then there's no incentive to build wind anymore because you'd only be, you only really need it 10% of the year. So you just build gas. That would kind of lock us into gas as something that the system needs at relatively high levels. Whereas if we keep building wind and solar together, we could probably reduce, we could probably make it a lot easier to get the last bit [00:14:55] Shail Khan: out of the system. What is happening with wind in Europe? I mean, in the US, it's been a rough ride for wind. Above all other sources of generation, the current political administration has taken aim at wind. And so it's really been a tough few years for wind power in the US. What's happening in Europe? [00:15:15] Jenny Chase: Yeah, we're still building it. Quite a lot of offshore wind going on in Germany. And offshore wind, of course, is great because it has really high capacity factors. I mean, wind is a relatively stable sector. The costs don't change massively year to year. The installations tend to be fairly stable globally. Very hard to build without some kind of power offtake contract and therefore quite good visibility on pipelines. And yeah, I mean, we're still building it. [00:15:46] Speaker 3: Catalyst is brought to you by Antenna Group. Name the category. Renewable energy, storage, critical materials, data centers, nuclear. Antenna Group has been the communications and marketing partner behind the industry's market leaders. Antenna helps ambitious companies build their brand and their reputation, elevates executives, and drives demand by turning momentum into market leadership. If your company is ready to lead the market, Antenna is ready to help you get there. Catalyst is brought to you by Energy Hub. Utilities need flexible capacity and they need to be able to stake grid planning on it day in, day out. With Energy Hub's platform, utilities can forecast available capacity with accuracy, optimize dispatch across any DER type, and maintain visibility across the entire system. The platform integrates across more than 80 OEM and aggregator partners, giving utilities the reach they need as markets and regulations evolve. Consistent, verifiable, affordable. Energy Hub is the flexibility platform for the modern grid. Learn more at energyhub.com. Catalyst is brought to you by Grid Beyond. Grid Beyond's DERMS and VPP platform helps data centers deploy more distributed energy and unlock demand flexibility. The company supports developers every step of the way, from modeling your highest ROI energy mix to orchestrating the full set of assets around a data center. The track record speaks for itself. Grid Beyond manages over 1,400 sites and more than 3.7 gigawatts of load across Europe, the UK, and the US. Learn more at gridbeyond.com. [00:17:22] Shail Khan: Right, back to solar and actually like the other end of the spectrum from wind where the projects are very big, particularly offshore. There is a lot of excitement, I would say, particularly in parts of Europe. And now it's starting to show up in the US, but it's still very early days around plug-in solar or balcony solar, as it is often called. You have opinions. I mean, there's a lot of it in Germany, [00:17:48] Jenny Chase: especially, right? Like, really a lot of it. Well, it's not more than five gigawatts. I mean, Yes, there's a lot of it by number, not necessarily by capacity. Well, that's kind of why I think it's a bit overhyped, to be absolutely honest. I mean, sure, the cool thing about solar is it works at any scale. You can get a module, you can plug it in, you can get power out of it. But if it's only one module, it's not a lot of power. Like, yes, you can run your fridge or whatever, most of the time. But not much more than that. Whereas if you properly install panels on your roof, you can also run your car, you can run your heat pump sometimes, you can charge your battery. Just the hype is disproportionate to the amount sold, I think. And I also think that a lot of these panels that you just see going around, suddenly around here, they get broken. They get covered with something. They're actually really bad installs. And I feel like if people's experience of solar is with really bad installs, that's probably not great advocacy. [00:19:00] Shail Khan: Yeah, I think the hype around it is to some extent, an extension of like, why are people excited about residential solar in the first place? It's like this concept of self-determination and the intent to decouple from the powers that be in the electricity world. Now, often you don't do that, right? People aren't actually off grid, but that is a driving motivation. It's incredibly expensive to go off grid. I mean, we have a power grid for a reason. Right. But I think that part of the motivation for residential solar is that sort of a mindset. And balcony solar, plug-in solar is like the extreme version of that. You need no one's permission. You just do it. And then you generate your own power, even though, as you said, it's not actually generating that much power. [00:19:54] Jenny Chase: Yes. It's got to feel good factor, but power is not meant to be exciting. It's meant to be something that comes out of the plug when you need it in adequate quantities and at low costs. And I mean, look, I don't have anything against balcony solar. Do it if you want to. But this isn't going to change the trajectory of the energy transition. [00:20:21] Shail Khan: Let's go back to bigger solar and the bigger picture. As you know, I'm here in the US, we we have really high tariffs on solar imports. And the result of that has been on module imports, I should say, in cells. And the result of that has been that customers in the United States pay upwards of $0.30 a watt for solar modules. Whereas there are parts of the world where the cost of very, very similar modules are down in the, what, $0.10, $0.12 a watt? [00:20:52] Jenny Chase: And they're not similar modules. They're better. [00:20:54] Shail Khan: Yeah, they could be better modules. [00:20:56] Jenny Chase: I know, and they're better. [00:20:58] Shail Khan: So we're paying 3x roughly what you see in China. Have we started to see that affect installation rates? Like, are we falling behind in the United States as a result of the tariffs? [00:21:13] Jenny Chase: Yeah, you fell behind like years ago in 2012. [00:21:17] Shail Khan: Well, not in capacity, not, I mean, maybe in the context of like, of manufacturing, but from an installation perspective, [00:21:27] Jenny Chase: no, you're still pretty slow. Considering how much, considering how rich a country you are, how much sun you've got. Okay, California and Texas are doing pretty, okay, California is, what, 30-ish percent of its electricity from solar. That's pretty good. Yeah. There are areas of the U.S. that are doing pretty well, but particularly, but when you, when you look at overall penetration across the U.S. and also forecasts, you're lagging behind. [00:21:58] Shail Khan: Behind China, specifically. What about? [00:22:00] Jenny Chase: And Europe. And Latin America. [00:22:03] Shail Khan: Okay, so speaking of other regions. [00:22:04] Jenny Chase: India was a bigger market for solar than the U.S. last year. [00:22:07] Shail Khan: India was? Yeah, India's been on a tear. [00:22:10] Jenny Chase: Yeah, yeah. And there are more people in India, to be fair, but they're also a lot poorer. [00:22:15] Shail Khan: Yeah, well, and more economic growth and they need more new power than the U.S. does. I'm not excusing the U.S. I actually think it's frustrating how expensive solar modules are in the United States, but it's interesting to see how that interplays with all the other factors, the tax [00:22:32] Jenny Chase: credits, the incentives. I mean, the other thing is that, I mean, it's simultaneously the case that solar in the United States is incredibly profitable relative to everywhere else, because you've got all these incentives of various sorts. You've got tax credits for doing it. You've got tax credits for using local stuff. You've got extra tax credits if you use some kind of unionised labour, I think. I'm sorry, I've totally lost track of all the extra pork you've got. But at the same time, your costs are just really, really high. So the rest of us are just staring – when we look at the United States, we just kind of stare at you and go, okay, so someone's making a lot of money here. It seems to be lawyers. Manufacturers are desperate to sell to you because they really like selling for 38 cents a watt. But it does mean that your transition is – your energy transition is going more slowly than it could be, and it's a lot more [00:23:28] Shail Khan: expensive. All right. Let's stop talking about Western Europe and the United States. I mean, some of the markets that I think are interesting that people don't really have that much visibility into are places like Pakistan, Bulgaria. Talk to me about what's happening in those markets. [00:23:45] Jenny Chase: Okay. So Pakistan is something I've been banging the drum for for a while, and Pakistan is actually probably slowing down a little bit. Pakistan is really unusual in that the government – in that from 2022, the government and the DISCOMs kind of let the power prices rise, whereas in a lot of other countries that are similarly poor, they've subsidised power to keep the power prices relatively low. It's also unreliable, and people really hate their utility companies. So what has happened is a massive upswing in installations on small businesses, on houses, on factories. And there's about 38 gigawatts of solar in Pakistan. Oh, irrigation. It's also – solar has replaced diesel for irrigation massively across Pakistan, which is causing its own problems because it is depleting the groundwater in various areas, because farmers are just pumping more water than they used to because they don't have to pay for it. Which is complicated, but yeah. So Pakistan is one of the very few countries in Southeast Asia which is having economic growth without increasing its gas imports, which is pretty good for the Pakistan economy. But it is basically because of this completely unregulated, uncontrolled boom in solar, in many cases by people who have watched a TikTok video about how to install them. Apparently, I mean, local language solar installation TikTok is a huge thing in Pakistan. And yeah, people are doing it for themselves. Sometimes, if you don't have power before, then a solar panel's propped up on a stick is actually a big step forward. [00:25:28] Shail Khan: To get to anything approaching like 38 gigawatts that way is kind of amazing. [00:25:33] Jenny Chase: It is astonishing. I mean, I couldn't believe it when I started looking at the numbers. And the data is really bad because nobody is really tracking these things. But we've got the Chinese export data. So we sort of know they're going there. We can actually see them. I mean, if you go on Google Earth and just look at a random roof in Lahore or Karachi, there will probably be solar on it. But yeah, it's really it is really exciting and it's causing big problems for the incumbent power generating sector because there is a very notable decline in demand. [00:26:08] Shail Khan: Other big potential markets that I'm interested in the early days of places like you mentioned Southeast Asia, [00:26:16] Jenny Chase: like Philippines seems interesting. The Philippines is about 60 watts this year. So it's finally starting to make a move. And what's quite interesting is that a lot of this is already co-located with storage. So in previous, Mark, in previous waves, you've had solar without storage going first and then sometimes some storage coming in later. The Philippines, they're building them together for the first time. And yeah, we'll see how that goes. Hopefully, maybe it'll be utterly smooth. And Bulgaria is kind of interesting because it's building a lot of batteries for various government reasons. It's partly to do with a subsidy fund under the European Emissions Trading Scheme, which funds various infrastructure projects in Eastern Europe because they're the poorer countries in the European Union. And it's ended up subsidising a lot of batteries in places like Bulgaria. But Bulgaria also has quite good grid connections to the neighbouring countries. So one of the things it's trying to do is act as a kind of hub for the region. It's going to soak up all the solar from its neighbours and hopefully make money by letting it out later. [00:27:27] Shail Khan: Okay. And then last market to ask you about, just because it's the, I don't know, maybe it's the sleeping giant someday. You mentioned it briefly, Sub-Saharan Africa. What do we see there? [00:27:38] Jenny Chase: We're definitely seeing developments there. South Africa has had a boom. It's rolled back a little bit because South Africa also had a boom because the power grid was very unreliable for a few years. The coal plants got old and stopped working very well. There were rolling blackouts across the country. People got very annoyed. And South Africans are not particularly poor. They have computers. They have fridges. They get really annoyed when their power goes out. And so they spent some of that money on solar panels. And there was a very noticeable wave of solar installations, which has now fallen back because the grid has got more reliable. In fact, the coal plants were maintained. Additional solar was brought in. And yeah, it's now a much smaller market. We do see increases in Chinese exports to Nigeria and Kenya. And in fact, most countries in sub-Saharan Africa. But again, these are still relatively small markets and there's not a lot of evidence. It's relatively difficult to get information from the ground. We think that we are seeing a reasonable upswing in commercial and residential solar as well as there are some mining projects as well. I mean, there are a bunch of gold copper mines across sub-Saharan Africa that now have solar batteries [00:28:59] Shail Khan: instead of diesel. All right. Well, we'll keep an eye on all of these emerging markets. But in the meantime, we will find out whether you are indeed right that it is going to be the first down year since the 1970s for global solar, which I don't think should be an overly negative takeaway in that it's still going to be well over half a terawatt that we're installing globally. [00:29:21] Jenny Chase: Half a terawatt is a lot. I mean, the total global power grid at the end of 2024 was 10 terawatts. So pushing half a terawatt in a year, even if it only runs in sunny hours, it's considerable. [00:29:37] Shail Khan: All right, Jenny. This was a lot of fun. Again, thank you so much. Thank you. Jenny Chase is a solar and clean power analyst at Bloomberg NEF. This show is a production of Latitude Media. You can head over to latitudemedia.com for links to today's topics. This episode is produced by Max Savage-Levinson. Mixing in theme song by Sean Marquand. Anne Bailey edits the video version of the show. Steven Lacey is our executive editor. All of our episodes are out on YouTube. Subscribe to latitudemedia.com for episodes of Catalyst and OpenCircuit. You can also find the audio version of the show anywhere you get your audio podcasts. I'm Shail Khan, and this is Catalyst.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →