Try Free

Who is Mark Carney? Victor Davis Hanson on Canada’s future — Full interview

The Really Big Show November 18, 2026 48m 7,750 words
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Who is Mark Carney? Victor Davis Hanson on Canada’s future — Full interview from The Really Big Show, published November 18, 2026. The transcript contains 7,750 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"Big Show with Jim Cech and Ian Burns. I'm Jim Cech. I'm here with Victor Davis Hanson. Thank you for joining me, Victor. Thank you for having me. And just give you a bit of an intro for people that don't know you. I mean, you're pretty famous. So a historian spent his life studying war, farming,..."

[0:06] Big Show with Jim Cech and Ian Burns. [0:11] I'm Jim Cech. [0:11] I'm here with Victor Davis Hanson. [0:14] Thank you for joining me, Victor. [0:16] Thank you for having me. [0:18] And just give you a bit of an intro for people that don't know you. [0:21] I mean, you're pretty famous. [0:22] So a historian spent his life studying war, farming, and why great countries rise and fall. [0:28] And that's why we got you here today. [0:29] A senior fellow at Stanford's Hoover Institution. [0:33] Teached sometimes at Hillsales College and still farms on the family land in California. [0:37] And you just wrote a new book, The Counter-Revolution. [0:40] Did I get that right? [0:41] Yes. [0:42] Thank you for joining us. [0:44] We want to talk, and I know you've said a lot on your own channel there, about Mark Carney. [0:51] Yeah. [0:51] Who is Mark Carney in your idea? [0:56] Like, who is he? [0:59] Well, I think he's the first Canadian prime minister that at one time was a citizen of three countries. [1:06] And he had a distinguished but fairly long career in Great Britain in the financial industry. [1:14] And it seems that his preparation for your prime ministership was sort of an international financier, part diplomat. [1:25] But he was a believer in the, I guess, people, I don't mean it necessarily in derogatory, but a globalist idea rather than what we had come to expect from both left and right in Canada, that people had been steadily, their entire lives had just resided in Canada. [1:43] And they were determined to turn it around so the Canada that we knew 20 years ago, 30 years ago, where the Canadian dollar was actually stronger than ours, and for many of the per capita income, while a little bit lower, was pretty much equivalent to ours. [2:02] And not the Canada that is, we feel, different than it was, at least economically, socially, politically, than it had been traditionally. [2:13] Who would have thought, like, I mean, like 10 years ago, that we would be in this fight with America? [2:20] You think these two nations kind of walk hand in hand, or even our media, we share a ton of media, like most Canadians are kind of immersed in American media culture and all that. [2:29] And all of a sudden, this person who has three different passports, comes in, drops in as the Prime Minister of Canada, has himself said that he's a globalist and an elitist, and all of a sudden has turned this nation against America to his advantage, I guess, because it is how he won that election. [2:52] But is it, in your mind, to the advantage of the Canadian public, though? [2:56] No, I don't. I should reiterate that the American attitude, as I adjudicated, is not anger at Canada, but a feeling that when Canada is strong, and it follows its tradition, that it's a huge producer of natural resources, timber, oil, and it's a very confident people. [3:20] And on D-Day, it had its own beach. It had the fifth largest navy in the world in World War II. [3:26] That's the Canada that we feel most comfortable with, because it's not a subordinate. It's a partner. [3:34] So we have the North American continent to protect. We count on, say, Canada right now to produce 20 icebreakers better than we could. [3:44] We have NORAD that we protect our shared continent from a strategic attack. All of that is what we grew up with. [3:51] But when Canada is not fully utilizing its resources, and we are very sympathetic to what's happening, because we did it. We opened our borders. [4:04] We have clamped down in the past on our natural resources. We've done a lot of this, and it didn't work out very well. [4:12] And maybe we will do it again, as we saw in the midterm. But it's one of empathy, and we feel that the relationship will be stronger, whoever is president or prime minister, if policies in Canada and the United States are synchronized so that we're both the leaders of the North American continent. [4:32] But when Canada's per capita income is lower than some of our poorest states, and that wasn't true. [4:42] I grew up traveling in Europe and lived in Europe, and I was so envious of my Canadian compatriots at universities in Greece, because their dollar was worth so much more than ours was. [4:54] And now just to think that it would be 70 or 75, it's incomprehensible. [4:59] 69 today. 69 today. [5:02] In 2014, when Stephen Harper was here, we had the highest middle class in the world. [5:10] And now we have 25% of our population at food insecure, and that's according to our own Department of Agriculture. [5:16] We had half of Canadians at financial breaking point. [5:19] And yet the media in Canada, we can talk about the media in a bit here, but the media in Canada portray him as a savior of Canada, yet our economy seems to be going the exact opposite way of where America's economy is going. [5:34] Yes, and I think all Americans, I live in the interior on a farm, but I work each week at Stanford University, and it's kind of a cosmopolitan Bay Area. [5:45] And one of the things you've noticed the last five or six, you bump into Canadians, there's 50 or 60,000 of your top people coming to the United States. [5:56] Mr. Carney himself was educated in the United States, I think two of his daughters were, I think two of them reside here. [6:04] So what's happening is, whatever your politics are or mine are in Canada, you have your top people, and it's almost like a brain drain. [6:14] And it's not going from America to Canada, it's going vice versa. [6:18] You would think that we have so many more people than you do, that a lot of Americans would be going to Canada, but you have a much smaller population, but you're going to the United States. [6:28] And that's not in Canada's interest to lose your best and brightest, because let's say a doctor or a medical researcher can make three or four times more in the United States than he can Canada. [6:40] Or a person that, speaking as a person who just had a serious cancer operation, from the time I was diagnosed to the time I was operated, it was eight days, nine days. [6:53] And the surgeon had the flu, so it was a little bit delayed, it would have been immediate. [6:57] But to hear stories of people that I hear all the time from Canada that come over here for medical care, it doesn't seem like the Canada that we know. [7:06] So we don't like the rhetoric from our part, and we understand art of the deal and all of that, but that's rhetoric. [7:15] There's a deeper problem, and that is it's very hard to be symmetrical when Canada's policies under Carney are not working, and he seeks redresses to make up for them. [7:29] And one of them is, why in the world would he think Canada has anything in common with communist China, which is the greatest violator of trade, whether it's dumping or patent infringement or copyright theft or currency manipulation? [7:45] Or why would he be wanting to mimic the EU, which has 150 million more people than we do, and yet its GDP is $10 trillion smaller? [7:56] And it has lower growth per year than almost every state in the United States, much less our total. [8:03] So I don't know why he sees those, either for politically or economic reasons, they're not in the interest of Canada. [8:13] The observer feels that way, that you cannot trust the Chinese. [8:17] And the Chinese have a bad habit that when they see a partner that they think is a subordinate, [8:24] they interpret that partner's magnanimity as weakness to be exploited, not as respect to be reciprocated. [8:31] So I, it's confusing to a lot of us in the United States. [8:37] Mark Carney made that speech in Davos, which was like a stick in the eye, it seemed like, to America. [8:41] But that Davos speech, many people in the world, Europeans and even the Chinese applauded it. [8:50] And Hillary Clinton, I think just yesterday, had come out and said that Mark Carney, the leader of the free world. [8:56] And that Davos speech, though, what did you make out of it? [9:00] And he quoted Thucydides as well, and I mean, you're a student of history there, [9:04] and the strong do what they can, the weak suffer what they must. [9:07] What was he trying to say? [9:09] And does he get that right? [9:11] Well, what he was trying to say is that Donald Trump, in so many words, was a reflection of the new United States. [9:22] And the new United States was no longer democratic or liberal-minded or part of the West. [9:30] And in that vacuum, he, Mark Carney, was going to elevate Canada to the status of the United States [9:40] and be the North American representative of a more ecumenical world, [9:46] along with the United Nations and international organizations and the EU and, I guess, China as well. [9:55] But if you take away the rhetoric, I'll just give you a couple of statistics. [10:01] There was an increase in gas that hurt and the war was unpopular, but the GDP is 3.4. [10:09] It was just revised. [10:10] We just created 165,000 jobs in October. [10:15] The unemployment rate fell to 4.1. [10:19] We just reached $87,000 in median average income. [10:24] That's a new record. [10:24] Our poverty rate is now 10.1. [10:27] And our stock market is 20,000 points higher than it was four years ago. [10:33] So in AI, if you look at the top 10 companies and you see your market capitalization in AI, [10:42] digital media, software, space exploration, satellite launching, eight or nine of the 10 are American. [10:50] And 70% to 80% of your population lives within 100 miles. [10:56] And given we speak the same language, there's going to be nationalist differences. [11:01] But in the past, we had created this. [11:05] I mean, some years, if Canada wants a $10 billion surplus in the United States, that's all right. [11:12] Nobody cares about that. [11:14] But the idea that under Carney, you would want $50 billion psychologically for Americans, [11:20] they don't quite understand that. [11:22] But even that would be a minor thing. [11:25] If Canada's would spend 2%, it did it last year, supposedly. [11:30] But for year on year, it was not spending 2% of its GDP, which is a meager amount on defense. [11:35] Not that we're spending five yet. [11:37] So what I'm getting at is that the old idea that Canada had all of these rich natural resources [11:46] that had this wonderfully trained population, it had this Western, this European, [11:52] it was part of the Anglosphere and the Anglophone countries that have this enormous work ethic. [11:59] And it was even outproducing per capita than we were. [12:02] And we had this kind of magical corridor between North America and southern Canada [12:10] and the northern part of the United States. [12:13] It was almost its own entity that was so successful. [12:17] And that you would see that it depended a lot on adapting to, but not losing sovereignty, [12:23] but adapting to and taking advantage of this dynamic economy. [12:28] And you would do anything to try to work out verbal or cultural differences, [12:34] but under no circumstances would you go to China, which is the chief rival of the Western world, [12:41] is building three nuclear weapons a month, three coal plants a month as well, [12:46] while they're selling us, dumping below the cost of production, solar and wind machines. [12:52] You wouldn't think that would happen. [12:55] For your own interests is what I'm trying to say. [12:57] Not for our interests, but for your interests. [13:01] Mark Carney talks about the new world order and middle powers. [13:05] Is that a serious discussion? [13:07] Because we can't, I mean, we talk about it a lot on this show. [13:10] We can't seem to think what middle powers is in Canada. [13:13] Like you said, Canada now meets the NATO target. [13:15] But we did that through a slate of accounting where we moved the Coast Guard. [13:18] Yes. [13:19] It wasn't in there. [13:19] We moved the Coast Guard's budget of like $2 billion into the military, [13:24] which they don't carry any, they won't even carry a sidearm. [13:27] So it's a little bit of sleight of hand there. [13:30] But this middle power thing, like what do you make of this middle power claim that he continues to make? [13:36] Well, he thinks it's based on his prior globalist status, familiarity with international fora and not on what it's really based on, [13:47] which is basically two things, military and economic power, to a lesser extent, cultural influence. [13:54] And I say this very carefully because I've written books on World War II. [14:00] Canada taught the United States the convoy system. [14:04] When World War II broke out, we ignored it and we paid dearly. [14:07] Canada, remember, had been in the war much earlier than us. [14:11] And it had developed, it had a wonderful Navy. [14:14] And Canadians were considered some of the best per capita armed people in the world and the best fighters. [14:22] So when you see now, he's talking about a middle power. [14:26] The natural question is, is this the Canada of 1942 or 5 or the 50s? [14:33] And you have 79 45-year-old F-18s. [14:40] They were a good plane, but they're 45 years old. [14:43] And of large ships, you used to have 150 to 200. [14:48] You have about 30. [14:50] And so when he says that, you ask yourself, well, he's a middle power, power. [14:54] So he has expansive and legitimate claims of the Northwest Passage. [14:59] So if the Russians come in and say that de facto, we're going to do what the Chinese do with the Philippines or the South China Sea, [15:08] we're just going to appropriate the Northwest Passage. [15:11] And China, I mean, maybe Russia and China with the Arctic Circle. [15:16] Or maybe they say, you know, three-fourths of Canada is uninhabited, basically. [15:22] Two people per 100 square miles. [15:24] Or maybe they have natural resources that are better appropriated by us. [15:29] In that not-so-impossible scenario, who is he going to call? [15:34] What is he going to do with 79 jets if he's a real middle power? [15:39] Like Turkey is a middle power. [15:40] It's got the second largest army in NATO. [15:43] It's got 300 late-model jets. [15:47] And economically, if out of the 30 westernized industrial nations, [15:53] if his country is the lowest GP annually and its standard of living is declining, [15:59] where is the economic middle power? [16:02] And at that trajectory, it won't be a middle power. [16:05] It will be equivalent to, you know, a Latin American country in terms of GDP. [16:11] And maybe not even a Latin America if he were, if that policy were to continue. [16:17] So that's a rhetorical. [16:19] He's talking about himself, that he has a high profile because he's anti-American. [16:24] And that plays well in the salons of Europe and in the enemies of America. [16:29] And he's carved out that niche. [16:31] But it's confusing that with the hard power of economic dynamism and military power, [16:37] which he doesn't have, he can't match his rhetoric with those two criteria. [16:43] You said anti-American, but I just want to ask you, is it anti-American or anti-Trump? [16:49] Because we have Maya Johnson here as his COO now. [16:53] We have Barack Obama that visits quite a bit. [16:55] And we have, you know, several other, you know, high-end Democrats that are here all the time. [17:03] Is it Trump that, and it seems almost personal, or is it anti-American rhetoric? [17:09] I think a lot of it is anti-Trump, but I think it's the anti-Mas, it's half the country. [17:17] And that was what, it's half the country according to polls, [17:23] that he feels that there are people in the United States, [17:26] and he's correct, on the two coasts. [17:29] Like your country, we have that Alberta-Ontario divide, [17:35] or Alberta-Quebec, or whatever term we use. [17:39] And it's a bi-coastal country with some enclaves around the Great Lakes [17:43] that has about 20% of the territory and about 50% of the population. [17:49] Everything else is the vast, less populated red states, [17:53] but much greater territory. [17:55] And they're antithetical. [17:56] And he feels that his long-term strategy is that the blue or left or progressive [18:04] or now the democratic socialists are going to build on this midterm victory. [18:10] And probably he thinks, I don't think he's read history, [18:13] because the history of the last 20 years is that two years is a lifetime, [18:18] as Ronald Reagan and Barack Obama and Bill Clinton knew, [18:23] that everything changes can change. [18:25] But he feels that he's in sync with the future of left-wing socialist America. [18:32] And he thinks that he's on the cutting edge, [18:34] and that people are applauding him in the United States, and they will win. [18:39] But what he doesn't understand is that's a great risk, [18:42] because by employing rhetoric that's not just anti-Trump, but anti-mega. [18:49] In some cases, it comes off as anti-American. [18:53] And what do I mean by that? [18:55] Symbolic, maybe not important or existential, [18:58] but when people at a Canadian sporting event boo the Spar Swangled Banner, [19:02] that is spread all over conservative news across the country. [19:07] And then you hear people say, [19:09] I don't like those Canadians or something like that. [19:13] So he creates that climate. [19:16] But we know what he's doing. [19:18] He's trying to interfere in American politics. [19:23] And what's ironic about it is the Republicans and the conservatives [19:28] didn't cancel the Keystone Pipeline. [19:31] They didn't say to Canada, after they had invested a lot of effort [19:35] into diluting their tar sands to make it more flowable and fluid, [19:40] we don't want that pipeline. [19:42] If it was up to us in the earlier days, [19:45] we would have said, we'll buy all the oil you want, [19:50] and we'll integrate our economies to a greater degree. [19:52] Let's just try to iron it out so maybe there's a smaller deficit. [19:56] Symbolic. [19:57] Maybe it's a symbolic act. [19:59] But it's something we can work with. [20:00] And, you know, he didn't want to do that. [20:04] He felt that there was going to be a left-wing tsunami, [20:09] and he was right about the midterms, [20:10] and he was going to contribute to that. [20:12] A lot of people were resentful [20:13] because he basically campaigned in the United States, [20:18] maybe not physically, [20:19] but he was telling the blue voters of Montana, [20:24] and he was telling them of Michigan and Minnesota [20:27] and other New England states that all of their problems was due to Donald Trump [20:35] and that he had punished them to get even with Carney. [20:40] That wasn't quite accurate, but that's what he said. [20:42] And he thinks he's now very successful. [20:45] It's gone to his head. [20:46] But again, we're neglecting the essentials. [20:49] The problem is that he enacted policies that don't allow Canada [20:54] to be a full, equal partner of the United States [20:57] in the fashion they always had been under Harper and Mulroney. [21:02] We admired that. [21:03] We don't want Canada to be less economically successful or military. [21:08] We want them to be either the same as we are [21:11] or more successful given their smaller population. [21:14] That's what most Americans want. [21:16] So we're baffled by all of this, as well as some people in Canada. [21:24] I interviewed Ambassador Hoekstra in that one interview [21:27] when we asked him that question, you know, [21:29] when Mark Carney said that, you know, [21:33] thinking about America was going to invade Canada, [21:36] and then we asked him about is there an election interference, [21:39] and then Hoekstra said that, you know, there is, [21:42] and that they're watching that closely, [21:44] and that story kind of blew up in Canada. [21:45] I mean, it almost seems like Mark Carney has a personal agenda [21:51] with Donald Trump, and, like, you know, [21:53] maybe it has something to do with the Net Zero Alliance, [21:56] the G-Fans, and all that stuff that kind of ended [21:58] because of, you know, Drill Baby Drill, [22:02] and, you know, the anti-energy policies, [22:04] now pro-energy policies. [22:05] Is any of that kind of, like, ring for you, or where is that? [22:09] Yes, absolutely. [22:10] I think you're very accurate in your diagnosis. [22:13] I think he felt that he had adopted Donald Trump, [22:18] despite his often crude and inflammatory rhetoric, [22:23] he adopted a set of policies, [22:25] and there were two things he didn't like about them. [22:28] One, ideological. [22:29] They were confident in free market capitalism, [22:34] producing as much, [22:35] we're the greatest producer of natural gas and oil [22:38] in the history of civilization now, [22:40] and he felt that these were antithetical to his positions, [22:45] and more importantly, he feared they were going to work, [22:49] and if they worked, [22:50] it would show a dire contrast [22:52] between a robust America [22:54] with this really high GDP [22:57] and its military is getting strong. [23:00] Everything is going in a good direction, [23:02] despite what people said about the midterms, [23:04] and he felt that that would be a referendum on him [23:08] and that the United States would get more and more powerful, [23:11] whereas if he interfered [23:13] and the left came into power, [23:15] they would cancel as much as... [23:18] They would never have a pipeline with Canada. [23:20] They would be agreeing with him [23:22] that it was wind and solar [23:23] and they would want a smaller military [23:26] and they would want socialized medicine like... [23:29] And that would be an affirmation of what he was doing. [23:33] We would be poor and less robust, [23:36] and he would like that [23:38] because the differences wouldn't be a start between Canada [23:41] and 60,000 or 70,000 Canadians wouldn't say, [23:44] I'm going to go to the United States [23:46] for my knee replacement or my bypass. [23:49] They would say, it's socialized medicine. [23:51] There's no need to go there. [23:53] It's just as bad as here as far as weights. [23:55] Or maybe they would say, it's just as good as here, [23:58] but it would be similar to Canada. [24:01] And that was his view. [24:04] I don't think it's going to work for him. [24:06] And what's sad about it is, [24:08] he interpreted the art of the deal, [24:11] excessive rhetoric, 51. [24:13] So he said the same thing about Greenland. [24:15] And he felt he got a better deal in Greenland. [24:17] And he feels he'll get maybe a $10 billion surplus Canada will have rather than 50. [24:23] But he took that personally, [24:26] and then he did something that no Western leader really has done. [24:30] He went to China and basically said, [24:32] we want a special relationship with you. [24:35] Even though that they have been, [24:37] they got a million people in labor camp. [24:40] They absorbed Tibet. [24:41] They thought in the Philippines all the time. [24:43] They run videos about nuking Japan. [24:46] They're anti-Western. [24:47] And they're against all of our allies. [24:49] So you talk to people from these countries, [24:53] and you mentioned Canada. [24:54] They don't know. [24:55] Is he on their side or our side? [24:57] It's not just the United States, in other words, especially in Asia. [25:02] And so we don't understand why he would reach out to Canada [25:05] other than despite Trump or I don't know. [25:08] But its system is not in the interest of Canadians as we knew them. [25:14] Anti-energy policies. [25:16] That's kind of like been the demise for Europe and the United Kingdom, [25:19] Canada as well. [25:20] I mean, we've had under the liberals here with Justin Trudeau, [25:23] and it seems to continue, [25:25] even though there's different talk at the podium, [25:26] but not much has changed on the ground. [25:29] Anti-energy policies and open immigration. [25:31] And those were policies of the United States as well. [25:35] And energy seems to be like the biggest thing for a vibrant middle class. [25:40] And we've seen that in Europe, [25:43] the lessening of the middle class and, you know, like all that stuff. [25:46] I mean, Ian, my co-host here, he went back to the UK [25:49] and he said he had to decide when he worked for the government [25:52] and his wife worked in medical and they had to decide [25:55] when they were going to turn their heat on. [25:56] He said it was that expensive just to heat their home. [25:58] So anti-energy policies, is that one of the keys, though? [26:02] Like, because the United States seems to be winning on the economic front [26:05] with pro-energy policies now. [26:07] It is. [26:08] And you're absolutely right in so many facets [26:11] because we just have a big plant, an Audi plant. [26:15] And Trump is saying the tariffs did it, $1.2 billion. [26:20] And we've had about five of these. [26:22] But when you actually read the small print [26:25] and why they are locating here, [26:28] yes, it is the tariffs to some degree, [26:30] but mostly it's the energy cost for a third to two-thirds, [26:33] depending on the country, cheaper. [26:35] And they're not competitive in places like Germany [26:38] and Italy and the UK. [26:42] And they have a kind of a blind spot. [26:44] There was a poll not long ago where people in the UK said, [26:47] if you were a state in the union, [26:49] where would you rank among the 50? [26:52] And they all said in the top 10. [26:54] But actually, in terms of per capita income, [26:58] they would be right with Alabama and Mississippi [27:00] among the bottom three or four. [27:02] But they didn't understand that. [27:05] And I think they don't really – [27:07] and when we had the Olympics, [27:09] there was this kind of phenomenon in our popular media [27:11] that people actually got out to the middle of this country [27:14] and they thought this is Oklahoma [27:16] and this is, you know, Indiana and this is poor. [27:19] And they were just shocked about the inexpensive food, energy. [27:25] This is before they ran gas, everything. [27:27] And so, yeah, I think that's – [27:31] Germany has – [27:32] he basically took the powerhouse of Europe [27:35] and dismantled it with green energy [27:37] in a very cold climate [27:39] that has a lot of cloud cover [27:42] and it was just insane. [27:43] And then to rectify that, [27:45] they put themselves entirely dependent [27:49] on Russian national gas. [27:51] Now we're sending about 15% of Europe's liquid national gas. [27:55] And another thing that could be happening, [27:58] we don't quite understand [27:59] with all of Canada's huge fossil fuel resources. [28:04] You had one pipeline. [28:05] It took years to build. [28:07] But we didn't understand [28:09] why you weren't doing what we were doing [28:11] and making the pipeline [28:12] so you could export this precious commodity [28:16] that you have in abundance [28:17] and will get, you know, [28:18] to the rich countries of Asia especially, [28:21] but also Europe. [28:21] But it seemed like you were more integrated [28:25] with the United States as far as energy [28:28] than you were Alberta, to take one example, [28:31] was with other provinces. [28:33] So I'm just getting to the point [28:35] where there's such enormous history [28:38] of Canadian economic robustness and success, [28:42] and yet this all seems self-inflicted. [28:46] It's almost as if it's – [28:47] if you said, [28:48] I'm going to be prime minister of Canada, [28:52] and I'm going to make sure [28:53] that the Europe's are condescending to us. [28:56] I'm going to beg them for their approval, [28:58] but they're going to kind of snicker behind my back [29:00] and think that I'm a blowhard. [29:02] And then I'm going to go over to communist China, [29:04] and they're going to think, [29:06] hmm, what a naive. [29:07] Let's see how many ways [29:08] we can take advantage of them. [29:09] And then I'm going to take [29:11] our biggest trading partner [29:14] and our century-long economic partner [29:18] and military partner, [29:19] and I'm going to insult it [29:21] and put my bets that socialism, [29:24] like it is taking off in Canada, [29:26] will take off in America, [29:27] and I want to get ahead of the curve. [29:28] You couldn't have done a better job than he did. [29:32] Is it self-interest, though? [29:35] Because if you take the Europeans, too, [29:36] because they know that the elites [29:37] are doing really well, [29:38] and then the middle class [29:39] is being crushed and pushed down. [29:41] And the same thing seems to be happening in Canada, [29:43] because, you know, Mark Carney, [29:44] obviously a lot of his wealth [29:45] is tied to Brookfield options, [29:46] which is heavily invested [29:48] into green technologies and that. [29:51] Is it all self-interest, [29:53] or is there another reason why, [29:54] like anti-energy and pro-immigration, [29:58] like wide open borders, [29:59] like Canada is now opening up the tops again? [30:02] Yes. [30:02] What is the reason? [30:03] Like what could be the logic behind this? [30:07] A lot of it's ideological, [30:09] but a lot of it you're right. [30:10] Until he was caught, [30:13] the news in the U.S. [30:14] said that over 90% of his stock investments [30:17] and portfolio were invested [30:18] in what he would call a satanic United States. [30:22] Why would he do that? [30:23] Why would he create an economy [30:25] where investment was not competitive for Canadians, [30:29] but he would invest his own portfolio [30:31] in the United States? [30:33] And he suffers from the same elite attitude [30:38] that has been so pernicious in the United States. [30:41] We have elites and they're all for open borders. [30:44] But when you have crowded ER rooms [30:46] or you have crime spikes [30:48] or you have 15 different languages [30:50] that you have to go through on the phone [30:54] to get a prescription, [30:55] the people who enacted those policies [30:58] have concierge doctors [30:59] or they live in enclaves where there's no crime. [31:03] And so they experiment almost on the middle class [31:06] as a laboratory rat. [31:08] They have all these utopian ideas, [31:09] but they never suffered the consequences [31:12] of their ideology or policy. [31:14] And I think he fits that very well. [31:16] He's been all over the world. [31:18] He's very wealthy. [31:19] He's a multimillionaire. [31:20] And he feels the Canadians are ripe for experimentation. [31:24] And according to the statistics I've looked at, [31:28] people who have come to Canada the last few years [31:32] are creating an immigrant Calgary every year. [31:36] Or to put it another way, [31:38] all of your first generation immigrants [31:40] and your second generation immigrants [31:43] are about 35 or 40% of your population. [31:48] And there's been no Marshall Plan on Carney's part [31:51] or Trudeau's saying, [31:53] if we're going to create a Calgary every year, [31:55] what is the effect on poor Canadians [31:57] that need a hip replacement? [31:59] Or how about a house in Ontario [32:02] or in British Columbia? [32:03] Where are we going to put all these people? [32:05] Because they don't care [32:06] because they have nice homes [32:07] and they have nice incomes [32:09] and they have private doctors [32:10] and they get around the system [32:12] that they create for others. [32:13] It's a very well-known phenomenon [32:15] here in the United States. [32:16] And it's what caused this kind of populist outrage [32:20] against it. [32:22] And I do think you'll, [32:23] because the Canadians are very practical people. [32:25] And I do think you will have the same [32:28] and you are experiencing the same pushback now. [32:31] And I think that's another thing [32:32] that Carney is aware of, [32:34] that he's not really popular. [32:36] He's popular only to the degree [32:38] that he ginned up this anti-American wave [32:41] or anti-Trump wave [32:43] and was successful in the midterms. [32:46] But long-term, I don't think he's going to, [32:48] this is a popular thing that Canadians want, [32:50] his economic and military policies, [32:54] much less his outreach to communist China. [32:57] One of the key tenets of a healthy democracy [33:02] is a free and independent media. [33:04] And that we're lacking here in Canada. [33:05] Most of the mainstream media [33:07] are all subservient to the government. [33:09] The CBC broadcaster takes [33:10] $1.5 billion from the taxpayer [33:13] and then the rest of them are taking [33:14] almost a billion dollars altogether. [33:17] And Mosa now are very subservient [33:19] to the government [33:20] and haven't held him accountable. [33:23] And he does very few interviews. [33:24] Like if you look at the President Trump, [33:26] he does like what, [33:28] he does two, three interviews a day [33:29] and he'll sit down with the New York Times [33:31] with the four-on-one and he'll do that. [33:34] But Mark Carney won't even sit down [33:35] with the subservient media. [33:37] He won't even respond to an email from us anymore [33:39] and we're accredited media and all that. [33:41] And they won't even respond. [33:43] And how much of his power [33:45] is just that refusal to answer questions [33:50] and be held accountable? [33:52] Yeah, I think it's a lot [33:53] because I think he feels [33:55] as an internationalist or a globalist [33:57] that the way he comports himself, [34:00] the way he answers questions, [34:02] the way his intonation, [34:05] his attitude, [34:06] it comes across as condescending and aloof. [34:09] And he knows that the trademark of Canada has, [34:12] I mean, we all grew up [34:14] with the Canadian Mount Police [34:15] and the lumberjack and the oil worker. [34:18] It's a can-do, pragmatic, [34:20] very strong middle class [34:22] that really resents pretension and arrogance. [34:26] And it's sort of England [34:29] without the English class system. [34:31] It's got the politeness and the lawfulness, [34:33] but it also has kind of the American emphasis [34:36] on the middle class [34:37] and pragmatism, muscular labor. [34:40] And that's why we all admire Canada. [34:42] And I don't think he feels comfortable [34:44] without Canada. [34:45] And each time he talks, [34:46] he's afraid he's going to say something [34:48] or sounds like something [34:50] that really gets the Canadian truck driver angry [34:54] or the Canadian small farmer angry [34:57] or the person who works [35:00] in the oil and timber industries. [35:02] And so he just feels like, [35:04] I feel much more comfortable in Europe [35:06] in the Davos cloud. [35:08] That's my people. [35:09] That's who I want to talk to. [35:11] I'm an internationalist. [35:12] You can kind of see that when he's there. [35:14] You can see him light up [35:15] when he's in those crowds [35:17] versus when he's talking here in Canada. [35:19] He does. [35:19] Yeah, he feels, [35:21] if I get over to Europe [35:22] and I get into our international forum, [35:25] I can really dazzle these people [35:26] and contrast myself [35:28] with the often crude Trump [35:30] or the explosive Trump [35:32] or the inarticulate Trump [35:33] or the historically, [35:35] as he thinks, ignorant Trump. [35:37] And that contrast will sway them [35:39] and that will bring benefits to me [35:41] and maybe even to my country. [35:42] But they look at him [35:45] as a medieval jester. [35:46] They really do [35:47] as somebody who entertains them. [35:49] But other than that, [35:50] he's just an entertainer. [35:51] There's no there there. [35:53] Because when he asked [35:54] for special treatment from the EU, [35:56] they sort of said, [35:57] that's an interesting idea. [35:59] We'll have an association with you, [36:01] but you want to have EU type benefits? [36:05] Are you serious? [36:06] What do you bring to the table? [36:08] And that's the way China [36:09] will treat him too. [36:10] China will be merciless. [36:12] They have no history [36:14] of ever, ever treating [36:16] a subordinate on an equal basis. [36:20] We've got about five minutes left [36:21] and I could spend [36:21] the rest of the day with you. [36:22] But I do want to ask you [36:23] about AI. [36:24] How important is AI [36:25] and how big was that moment [36:27] when a Canadian, [36:29] or one that has roots in Canada, [36:31] caught that starship? [36:33] Like how big of a moment [36:34] is that for the United States of America? [36:35] Oh, it was very symbolic [36:37] because it came right after [36:38] the people in Texas, [36:40] the new governor-elect, [36:43] Gina Hinaosa, [36:45] had said that she was going [36:46] to go after Elon. [36:49] And AOC said he was [36:51] the least intelligent, [36:53] informed person she'd met. [36:57] And he's kind of in America now. [37:02] The left loved him, remember, [37:03] because he did something [37:04] the left had always said [37:06] was impossible, [37:06] but they wanted. [37:07] They wanted somebody [37:08] to break up [37:09] and enter the big three. [37:12] GM, Chevy, Ford, [37:14] nobody could do it. [37:15] And he did it. [37:16] And he did it with an EV [37:17] and they loved him. [37:18] And he gave money [37:20] and he voted for Hillary [37:22] and he voted for Joe Biden. [37:23] And then he did the worst thing [37:25] you can do to the left. [37:26] He was an apostate. [37:27] And he flipped [37:28] and then he started giving his money [37:30] to conservative candidates [37:31] and they never forgave him for that. [37:34] And they're out to destroy him. [37:36] And the more that they destroy him, [37:39] they said they were going [37:40] to destroy Tesla. [37:42] It hasn't been destroyed. [37:43] Its stock is pretty much recovered. [37:45] They said SpaceX will, [37:47] you know, [37:48] we have a new alternative. [37:50] Blue sky, it didn't work. [37:52] SpaceX has, I think, [37:54] it's got over 100 million [37:55] or maybe it's even more, [37:56] 400 million users. [37:58] They said they were going [37:59] to destroy Starlink. [38:03] Starlink now is the reason [38:05] that Ukraine is still fighting, [38:07] but it's used by everybody. [38:09] I'm on it right now [38:10] from a remote farm. [38:12] And the space thing [38:14] is so visual. [38:15] He's an authentic. [38:17] Thomas Edison, [38:18] Alexander Graham Grell [38:19] and Wright Brothers [38:20] are one person. [38:21] And he's an enormous asset [38:22] to the United States. [38:24] How big is that AI race? [38:26] And is it a must win [38:27] for the United States [38:28] more than China? [38:29] Yes. [38:29] It's a race of all races. [38:31] Absolutely. [38:32] Yes. [38:33] China, as we saw with NVIDIA, [38:35] they are appropriating [38:36] our technology [38:37] as much as they can. [38:38] They have 300,000 students here [38:40] and it's a de facto confession [38:43] that they're emulative. [38:44] They don't have the system [38:46] or the atmosphere [38:47] or the rewards [38:48] that will attract talent [38:50] to the same degree [38:51] that we do. [38:52] So they're derivative of it [38:54] and they have to appropriate [38:55] technology from us. [38:57] And we are ahead of them. [38:59] Nobody's thought [39:00] that was possible. [39:01] We're ahead of them [39:01] in digital media, [39:02] software now, [39:04] AI, space. [39:06] Elon launched more satellites [39:08] last year [39:09] than all the world [39:11] put together. [39:12] He's just making, [39:13] he's running, [39:14] he's embarrassing China. [39:16] So AI is what is going [39:20] to fuel the economy [39:22] and to the degree [39:22] that a country supports it [39:24] and doesn't try [39:25] to over-regulate it [39:27] but does, you know, regulate. [39:30] So it prevents [39:30] about three questions. [39:32] Do you want China [39:33] to be the AI leader [39:35] with no regulations? [39:36] And we saw what they did [39:37] at the Wuhan lab. [39:38] We saw what they're capable of. [39:41] Or do you want the West? [39:42] And so far, [39:44] Europe is well, well behind. [39:46] So that's the United States [39:47] for the West. [39:48] And would Canada [39:49] want the United States [39:50] to be the leader in AR [39:51] or does it want [39:52] its special relationship [39:53] with China to be? [39:55] I think that answers itself. [39:57] And so we're having [39:59] the same problem [39:59] with data centers. [40:01] And so even when [40:02] the people in AI [40:03] say to communities, [40:06] we'll take that old [40:07] shopping center [40:08] that's vacant. [40:08] You already have roads [40:10] and you have sewage [40:11] and water [40:12] and we'll promise [40:13] that we'll recycle [40:14] the water [40:14] and we won't draw [40:15] all the water [40:15] and we'll create [40:17] a power generation plant [40:18] somewhere in your community [40:20] to be net zero draw [40:22] on your power bill. [40:25] They still oppose it [40:26] because the left feels [40:27] that Donald Trump [40:29] got ahead of everybody. [40:30] Joe Biden had got [40:31] everybody in the room [40:32] and said, [40:32] you're going to do this [40:33] and you're going to do this [40:34] and you're going to do this [40:35] and you're going to do this. [40:36] And these tech lords [40:37] are all left wing, [40:39] whether it was Zuckerberg [40:40] or whether it was Bezos [40:41] or whether it was Elon [40:43] or whether it was NVIDIA. [40:45] They said, [40:46] we would rather deal [40:48] with the devil Trump [40:49] because he has one thing [40:50] in common. [40:51] He wants America [40:51] to be preeminent [40:52] and so do we. [40:54] So he's going to be like [40:55] Roosevelt in World War II. [40:57] He's going to reach out [40:58] to the opposite people. [40:59] This time it's kind of reversed, [41:00] conservative to left wing, [41:02] not left wing to conservative. [41:04] And he's going to let us [41:05] do what we need [41:06] to beat the Chinese [41:08] and be the best [41:09] and that will help [41:10] in Trump's view [41:11] of the United States. [41:12] And there will be regulation [41:13] but it won't be stifling [41:15] and we'll win this. [41:17] And the left got, [41:18] you know, [41:18] they looked at, [41:19] you can see what [41:20] they're saying right now [41:20] when they revised [41:21] the job report [41:22] and the GDP [41:23] up to three, four [41:25] and the Atlantic Bank [41:26] said that we could [41:28] grow five percent [41:29] in the fourth quarter. [41:30] Almost immediately [41:32] the talking point [41:33] was let's shut down AI. [41:34] And the subtext [41:35] was AI [41:36] helping the Trump administration [41:39] and the U.S. economy [41:40] and therefore [41:41] it's going to be [41:42] very hard for us [41:43] to say affordability, [41:45] affordability, [41:45] affordability [41:46] when the economy [41:47] is starting [41:48] to really take off. [41:49] So they have political [41:51] and partisan reasons [41:52] to stop it. [41:53] But you can't, [41:53] if we stop it, [41:54] we're going to, [41:55] all of us in North America [41:56] are going to be in trouble [41:57] because the Chinese [41:58] won't stop. [42:00] And we're the best at it, [42:02] the North Americans. [42:03] And I'd say that [42:04] in the widest sense [42:07] because one of the ironies [42:09] of this conversation [42:11] is that some of your best people [42:12] that are comparable [42:14] or even better than ours [42:15] are leaving Canada [42:16] and I see them everywhere [42:17] in Silicon, [42:18] I work in Silicon Valley [42:19] at Stanford [42:20] and you see Canadians [42:21] everywhere. [42:23] And that's another thing [42:24] that we don't talk about, [42:25] Carney. [42:26] He started a brain drain. [42:28] Everybody says, [42:29] well, Canadians [42:29] are all mad [42:30] at the United States [42:31] and they're going home. [42:32] There's 60,000 or 70,000 [42:33] of them are leaving [42:34] every year [42:34] and they're the most trained [42:36] and skillful [42:37] in these vital new technologies. [42:42] Yeah, Elon Musk [42:42] could never accomplish [42:43] what he accomplished [42:44] in the United States [42:46] that he accomplished. [42:47] Like he couldn't have done [42:47] that in Canada. [42:48] I do want to give you [42:51] a chance to talk [42:52] about your book [42:52] though. [42:52] You've got that new book [42:53] on Counter Revolution. [42:54] If you could just tell us [42:55] about that book [42:56] and we'll put a link [42:57] in there as well [42:57] for people that are interested. [42:58] Oh, thank you. [42:59] Well, it was written [43:01] about six months ago [43:04] and its argument [43:06] is that the second term [43:09] of Donald Trump, [43:10] he didn't want to address [43:12] as he did the first term, [43:14] the symptoms [43:14] of the Progressive Project [43:16] but he was going [43:18] to talk about the causes. [43:20] Why do they have power [43:21] when they're not controlling [43:22] at times the Supreme Court, [43:24] the presidency [43:25] or the Congress? [43:26] And his answer was [43:27] K-12, [43:29] the School of Education, [43:30] academia, [43:31] Hollywood, [43:32] professional sports, [43:34] the foundations, [43:35] the administrative state [43:37] and especially the media [43:38] have conspired [43:41] in a way [43:41] to control the narrative [43:43] and they said [43:44] they were going to do that [43:45] and Gramsci's sense [43:46] of marching [43:47] through the institution. [43:48] So what did he do? [43:49] He said, [43:50] I'm not going to allow [43:51] the universities [43:51] to charge 50% [43:54] or 40% overhead, [43:55] 15. [43:56] I'm going to close the border [43:57] so they don't have [43:58] a new demography. [43:59] I'm going to deport people. [44:00] I'm going to charge [44:01] a tax on remittances. [44:03] I'm going to try [44:04] to build up [44:05] the industrial base [44:06] of the United States. [44:07] I am going to try [44:08] to go after [44:10] the universities [44:10] that they have [44:11] enormous endowments [44:12] they're going to pay [44:13] a tax on their [44:14] endowments. [44:14] They're going to respect [44:15] Supreme Court decisions [44:17] on DEI. [44:19] They're going to follow [44:19] civil rights protections [44:21] for people. [44:22] No more segregated [44:23] dorms by race. [44:25] So it was a very manifest, [44:27] widespread [44:27] counter-revolution [44:29] to really try [44:30] in four years [44:31] to overturn [44:33] what are undermined [44:35] this progressive revolution. [44:37] And it went everything [44:38] from the trans issue, [44:40] which he's kind of [44:41] really did stop [44:42] in a lot of states [44:43] to voter ID, [44:44] to all of these things [44:46] that had been [44:46] institutionalized. [44:47] And that explains [44:49] a large part [44:50] why the anger [44:52] was so furious [44:53] against him. [44:54] So the book is [44:55] January 6, [44:57] he was polling [44:58] 25% people [44:59] wrote him off. [45:00] How did he come back? [45:02] Not why, [45:03] I'm glad he came back, [45:04] but just disinterested. [45:06] How did he come back? [45:07] And it was usually [45:08] because five criminal [45:10] in civil suits [45:11] raiding Mar-a-Lago, [45:13] trying to take him [45:14] off the ballot, [45:15] four attempts [45:16] where the Secret Service [45:18] had to return shots [45:19] at a would-be assassin. [45:21] And he gained empathy [45:23] and he grew stronger. [45:25] And when he was [45:25] in the wilderness, [45:26] people saw [45:27] the socialist alternative [45:28] with Joe Biden [45:30] and Dash Obama's [45:32] third term, [45:33] and they didn't like it. [45:34] So he really benefited [45:36] actually from being out [45:37] in the wilderness [45:38] for four years. [45:38] And he learned [45:39] from his mistakes. [45:40] And this time, [45:41] he thought he was [45:43] going to wage [45:43] a very controversial [45:45] but holistic [45:46] counter-revolution. [45:47] And the [45:48] MAGA movement [45:50] and the counter-revolution [45:51] will depend on [45:52] its success [45:52] in the next two years. [45:54] And if it fails, [45:55] I think the left [45:56] will get stronger. [45:57] And as the left [45:58] fears that it's winning, [46:00] it's getting more [46:01] and more radical [46:02] and more and more strident. [46:03] And I end the book [46:06] with saying [46:06] one of the legacies [46:08] of Donald Trump [46:09] will be not what he did, [46:11] but what he did [46:12] to the Democratic [46:13] and left-wing opposition. [46:15] They became so crazy, [46:16] they got further [46:17] and further left [46:18] so that the party [46:18] of Bill Clinton [46:19] is completely [46:21] unrecognizable now. [46:24] That moment, [46:25] is that a turning point [46:27] when he, [46:28] when that assassination attempt, [46:29] when he stood up there [46:30] and fight, fight, fight, [46:31] and then I think, [46:32] you know, [46:32] are they going to make [46:33] a statue of that moment [46:34] one day? [46:35] Because that turned [46:36] Elon Musk the next morning, [46:37] that turned Mark Zuckerberg [46:38] the next morning. [46:39] Elon Musk came out [46:40] and said, [46:41] I'm with this [46:42] and I think Zuckerberg said, [46:43] that's the toughest guy I know. [46:45] Yeah, all of a sudden [46:46] people as diverse [46:47] as Robert F. Kennedy, [46:48] Tulsi Gabbard, [46:50] Joe Rogan, [46:51] all these people said, [46:52] wait a minute, [46:53] that was not scripted [46:55] and he's defiant [46:56] and he almost got killed. [46:58] The man next to him [46:59] got killed [46:59] and it still didn't stop him. [47:01] And he kept, [47:02] yeah, absolutely. [47:03] And so did the Mar-a-Lago rate [47:05] and so did those travesties [47:06] of lawfare. [47:08] And that was the irony, [47:09] that the more they tried [47:10] to destroy him psychologically, [47:11] spiritually, [47:12] financially, [47:13] physically, [47:13] the stronger he got. [47:16] And that's why [47:17] he won the primaries. [47:18] DeSantis and those people [47:19] said to themselves, [47:20] if we criticize [47:21] what they're doing to him, [47:23] then we might as well be him [47:25] because we agree with it. [47:26] But if we agree [47:28] with what they're doing to them, [47:29] then we're traitors [47:30] to the conservative side [47:31] and we're siding [47:34] with these vigilante [47:35] lawfare people. [47:36] So it was, [47:38] I just charted [47:39] how he came back [47:40] and what he intends to do. [47:42] And it's still [47:43] in media's race [47:45] because we don't know [47:46] the ultimate verdict. [47:49] We'll see. [47:51] I could talk to you all day, [47:52] but I do want to respect [47:54] your time. [47:54] Again, [47:55] that book there, [47:56] if you want to pick it up, [47:57] we'll put the link [47:57] in the comments here too [47:59] as well in the description. [48:00] So if you want to pick up [48:01] that book. [48:03] Thank you. [48:04] And I appreciate your time, [48:06] Mr. Hanson. [48:07] And thank you. [48:09] And pray for Canada. [48:12] I am. [48:13] I do all the time. [48:13] I love Canada. [48:14] I have a brother-in-law [48:15] who's Canadian. [48:16] And we all like Canadians. [48:19] I want to make that very clear. [48:21] We want Canadians to seed [48:23] beyond our wildest expectation. [48:26] Thank you. [48:26] Thank you for joining me today. [48:28] Thank you. [48:29] Thank you for...

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →