Try Free

Ukraine allies hold news conference from Berlin summit as Trump returns from Putin talks

PBS NewsHour November 20, 2026 1h 7m 8,372 words 3 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Ukraine allies hold news conference from Berlin summit as Trump returns from Putin talks from PBS NewsHour, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 8,372 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"the right and easy. We want more, not less, for Europe and the world. And we work substantially and with a very clear compass. As long as it is necessary, we will support Kiev. If it comes to Friedensverhandlungen, then we will join us. We can only work with Ukraine and Europe. A Yalta-Format will..."

[11:10] the right and easy. [11:12] We want more, not less, [11:14] for Europe and the world. [11:18] And we work substantially [11:20] and with a very clear compass. [11:23] As long as it is necessary, [11:24] we will support Kiev. [11:26] If it comes to Friedensverhandlungen, [11:29] then we will join us. [11:31] We can only work with Ukraine and Europe. [11:37] A Yalta-Format will not bring peace. [11:41] And, ladies and gentlemen, [11:43] I have today, [11:46] a piece from the Berlin Mauer [11:48] as a gift. [11:50] This Berlin Mauer [11:53] has only a few meters from here [11:55] and 35 years [11:57] to our continent. [11:59] The Mauer brought [12:01] violence, [12:02] and peace. [12:04] And exactly for that Yalta. [12:06] With Berlin, [12:07] with the case of the Mauer, [12:09] we connect a different message [12:11] and a different world. [12:12] Freiheit und Frieden [12:13] sind stärker [12:14] als Unterdrückung und Teilung. [12:16] Sie erinnern sich, [12:18] 1987 [12:19] hat Präsident Reagan [12:21] hier in Berlin [12:22] gerufen, [12:23] Mr. Gorbatschow, [12:24] tear down this wall. [12:26] Wir sagen heute, [12:28] Präsident Putin, [12:29] beenden Sie den Krieg in der Ukraine [12:32] und lassen Sie uns gemeinsam [12:34] nach diplomatischen Lösungen suchen. [12:37] Wir wollen nie wieder in einem geteilten Europa leben. [12:41] Wir wollen in Freiheit und wir wollen in Frieden leben, [12:45] zusammen mit der Ukraine. [12:47] Das Treffen in Shenzhen war offenbar vor allem ein Bildtermin. [12:51] Wir haben heute in der Sache in unserem Kreis dreierlei erreicht, [12:55] das unsere Botschaft mit Nachdruck verbindet. [12:57] Erstens können wir nach diesem Berliner Gipfel mit großer Zuversicht sagen, [13:02] gemeinsam werden wir die Ukraine auch im gesamten nächsten Jahr kraftvoll unterstützen. [13:08] Denn hier geht es um unser aller Sicherheit. [13:11] Also müssen auch alle einen Beitrag dazu leisten. [13:14] Die Europäische Kommission hat gestern einen Vorschlag vorgelegt, [13:19] der für 2027 zusätzliche 45 Milliarden Euro vorsieht. [13:24] Diese Mittel sollen in der Europäischen Union alle gemeinsam mobilisieren. [13:29] Dafür gab es heute breite europäische Unterstützung. [13:33] Ich bin dafür sehr dankbar. [13:35] National leisten die Mitglieder der Koalition Großes, [13:39] auch die außerhalb der Europäischen Union. [13:41] Ich will das ausdrücklich sagen. [13:43] Andy Burnham hat es gesagt. [13:45] Großbritannien allein hat gerade neue Hilfen [13:47] in Höhe von über 11 Milliarden Euro angekündigt und zugesagt. [13:51] Die Balten, die nordischen Staaten, die Niederlande und andere helfen vorbildlich. [13:57] Diese starke Unterstützung leisten wir alle nicht, um den Krieg zu verlängern. [14:02] Wir wollen diesen Krieg beenden. [14:04] Wir leisten unseren Beitrag, damit sich die Ukraine wirkungsvoll verteidigt, [14:09] solange sie es muss. [14:12] Wir leisten diese Beiträge, um Friedensverhandlungen überhaupt erst zu ermöglichen [14:16] und sie aus einer Position der Stärke herauszuführen. [14:20] Und dass die Ukraine die Brücke von Kerch schwer beschädigt hat in der letzten Nacht noch einmal, [14:26] ist eine deutliche Warnung, ist ein deutliches Zeichen auch der Schwäche von Russland. [14:32] Allein im Oktober hat Moskau über 50.000 Soldaten verloren. [14:36] Das ist die Größenordnung, die die amerikanischen Truppen in fast 20 Jahren Vietnamkrieg insgesamt verloren haben. [14:46] So viel verliert Russland in einem Monat. [14:50] Russland muss deshalb begreifen, es ist Zeit, die Waffen niederzulegen. [14:54] Wir haben zweitens eine klare Idee vom Frieden. [14:57] Heute haben wir uns auf mögliche Friedensgespräche auch vorbereitet. [15:01] Diese Gespräche sollen die Ukraine, Russland, die Vereinigten Staaten und Europa umfassen. [15:05] Kommen sie zustande, eröffnet das die bisher beste Chance für Frieden. [15:10] Schließlich, im Europäischen Rat in Dublin haben wir in der letzten Woche vereinbart, [15:15] dass Deutschland, Frankreich, Großbritannien, Polen und Italien für Europa sprechen. [15:20] Das werden wir gemeinsam mit den Brüsseler Institutionen tun. [15:23] Wir werden uns an den klaren Prinzipien orientieren, über die auch heute Einigkeit bestand. [15:30] Ziel ist und bleibt eine souveräne Ukraine in einem sicheren Europa. [15:35] Ausgangspunkt einer territorialen Verständigung muss dabei die sogenannte Kontaktlinie sein. [15:41] Die Ukraine muss ihren europäischen Weg gehen können. [15:46] Sie muss auf Hilfe beim Wiederaufbau zählen dürfen. [15:49] Im Gegenzug sind schrittweise konditionierte Aufhebungen von Sanktionen gegen Russland denkbar. [15:56] Und schließlich und letztendlich nach einem Waffenstillstand muss Kiew starke Sicherheitsgarantien erhalten. [16:01] Das wird Auswirkungen auf die euroatlantische Sicherheit haben. [16:05] Darüber wird in den Verhandlungen zu sprechen sein. [16:08] Und meine Damen und Herren, hier braucht es jetzt die richtige Sequenz, die richtige Reihenfolge. [16:13] Erst Frieden in der Ukraine, dann Verständigungen zur euroatlantischen Sicherheit. [16:18] Moskau weiß, seine Maximalforderungen vom Dezember 2021 sind nicht realistisch. [16:25] Nach einem Frieden in der Ukraine muss Europa sicherer sein als vorher. [16:30] Und deshalb bauen wir auf eine stärkere europäische NATO. [16:34] Das dient letztendlich auch Russlands Sicherheit. [16:37] Zu gegebener Zeit ist aber auch mit Moskau über militärische Gesprächskanäle, über Risikoverminderung und Transparenz zu sprechen. [16:44] Das ist im Interesse beider Seiten. [16:47] Wir sind handlungsfähig zu Sicherheitsgarantien für die Ukraine. [16:52] In diesen Tagen läuft, und Sie wissen das vermutlich alle, unsere erste gemeinsame Militärübung, Koalisia. [16:59] Sie zeigt, die Koalition der Willigen ist bereit, mit den Vereinigten Staaten zur Absicherung eines Friedens beizutragen. [17:06] Ich will abschließend danken den Gesandten der Vereinigten Staaten, Steven Witkoff und Jared Kushner, dass sie nach Berlin gekommen sind. [17:13] In den letzten Monaten haben wir eng zusammengearbeitet, aufbauend auf die Ergebnisse des Berliner Gipfels im Dezember des letzten Jahres. [17:21] Die USA wissen, ohne uns gibt es keinen Frieden. [17:25] Wir wissen, mit den Vereinigten Staaten an unserer Seite steigen die Chancen auf Frieden. [17:31] Als Koalition der Willigen haben wir heute gemeinsam in diesem Sinne deutlich gemacht, dass die Vereinigten Staaten neue Verhandlungen mit Russland in Gang setzen, begrüßen wir. [17:41] In diese Verhandlungen wollen wir uns einbringen. [17:43] Wir wollen es im Team mit Kiew und Washington tun. [17:46] Die Vorbereitungen dazu laufen auf Hochtouren. [17:49] Und noch heute Abend kommen europäische, ukrainische und amerikanische Berater hier im Kanzleramt zur nächsten Runde zusammen. [17:57] Auf dieses Teamwork können die Vereinigten Staaten, kann Präsident Trump zählen, solange wir dasselbe Ziel verfolgen. [18:04] Dieses Ziel ist und bleibt ein gerechter, dauerhafter Frieden für die Ukraine und Sicherheit für Europa und die ganze Welt. [18:12] Vielen Dank. [18:13] Herr Bundeskanzler, Herr Bundeskanzler, Herr Bundeskanzler, Herr Präsident, Herr Minister, [18:29] Herr Bundeskanzler, Herr Bundeskanzler junge Sieben, Jared, sehr geehrte Anwesende, unsere Team, sehr geehrte Journalisten. [18:34] Heute haben wir ein sehr wichtiges Treffen. [18:36] It was a strong event of our Koalitions, and we tried to make this meeting more than 40. [18:46] We have now tried to protect ourselves and protect our state and our diplomaties. [18:55] I want to thank Friedrich for the support of our organization. [19:05] The support of Ukraine is a strong resource for us, especially now, before the winter. [19:13] It's what Russia can bring to be more constructive to be in any way. [19:20] We thank all the partners who are ready to be active in the working room, [19:25] I thank the United States of America, [19:42] I thank the United States of Germany, [19:47] I thank the British, I thank the United States, [19:52] I'm very thankful to the EU. [19:55] I'm grateful to the EU. [19:57] I'm grateful to the EU for 45 billion dollars for the next year. [20:02] This is a huge success. [20:05] The EU Commission has been involved in this work. [20:09] It's important that the EU and the EU are now in our next year. [20:14] It's very thankful to the EU. [20:17] For a part of the European AXA, EUROPEA SAFETIC RACETSANQUIERS [20:22] A Even the European Union's office will be eliminated by the European Union. [20:26] The European Union will continue to run an implementation. [20:31] This is important. [20:36] He has been a part of the project in the 2018 and the 2020 election. [20:40] Russian Raketen with Jet-Shellet-Drohnen, and we have to deal with a real defense. [20:48] It's not a clear word. [20:50] Russia has made all of these proposals for a Deskalation. [20:56] These proposals were made by different partners. [21:02] Putin has always said no. [21:04] The Deskalation in the energy sector, in the Schwarzen Meer. [21:09] Every day there are new attacks on Ukraine. [21:16] There are dozens of opportunities. [21:21] Russian Shachet, Poshkodov, Wollodimerski Sobor. [21:24] One of the most important things to all of us is to talk to the people of Ukraine. [21:29] The Vladimir-Kathedrals in Kiev were also affected by the government of Austria and the Netherlands. [21:36] Therefore, the protection of the United States, the protection of our energy, the protection of our logistics. [21:43] This is our first priority. [21:45] These partners, today, are the biggest priority. [21:49] We are concerned about the F-16. [21:50] We have a big difference. [21:51] We are concerned with our strategy. [21:52] We are concerned about the F-16. [21:54] We have to continue to help the F-16. [21:56] We are concerned about the F-16. [21:58] That's why we are concerned about the F-16. [21:59] We are concerned about the F-16. [22:00] We work with F-16 and other fluggeräte. We need to help, which can help, and in which areas we need. [22:16] We understand, when we need to do this. We need to deal with the anti-Balist. We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. [22:32] We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. [22:48] We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. [23:04] We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. [23:07] We need to deal with the anti-Balist program. [23:16] We need to deal with the anti-Balist program in this country. [23:22] I am the important to have that anti-Balist program. [23:28] It is very important that Europe will represent five countries plus the European Union and NATO. [23:36] And America completely understands why the European Union and the EU needs to understand, [23:42] why the stark opposition to Europe is successful today. [23:47] We will have a separate conversation with the US. [23:54] We have a meeting with the agenda of Ukraine, Europe, America and Russia. [24:01] We are very concerned about the agenda of Ukraine, Europe, USA and Russia. [24:08] And we have to decide that the agenda of Ukraine, Europe and America must work together, [24:15] and we will be able to do everything. [24:18] And we will be able to do everything, so that Russia is a crucial job. [24:24] It is a crucial job, it is a crucial job. [24:27] It is a crucial job, it is not a time for people. [24:30] It is very important to us to die. [24:32] We are not willing to do everything in the winter. [24:35] We are not willing to do everything in the winter. [24:38] We are ready to do new sanctions, [24:40] we are ready to support Ukraine and the new countries. [24:44] We are ready to support the United States and the US. [24:48] We are very concerned that the USA will be very careful. [24:51] We are ready to support the United States and the United States and the United States and the United States. [25:06] We have concerned that U.S. would go to the U.S. for the major". [25:12] And you can know the United States and the United States and of course they will be that [25:25] European security. It is also a guarantee of security for all of us, as well as the NATO. [25:34] The EU needs to be recognized for us. We all do this as well as the NATO. [25:40] And we have to know how to do this in Europe. [25:45] And here we have to do everything, so that in Europe we have no war. [25:55] And we have to support this integration. We have to be integrated with the European Union. [26:02] We have to make possible solutions for the NATO. [26:06] And we thank all of our partners and partners for support, all of our participants. [26:13] We thank our partners, our friends and our partners in this event. [26:17] Slava Ukraine! [26:21] Thank you very much, Mr. Chancelier, for the invitation and the organization of this summit. [26:27] I thank, of course, the President Zelensky of being at our side, [26:32] as we are, especially with his people and his own. [26:35] And it was a pleasure to meet the Prime Minister Andy Burnham. [26:38] And we have had the chance of having, in effect, the two specials, Mr. Chancelier Wilcoff, [26:44] and the President Trump, who have pu échanger with us during this summit. [26:48] It's the 18th summit of the Coalition des Volontaires, [26:51] that we have held at this level since its creation at Paris, [26:54] it is a little more than a year and a half. [26:57] Mr. Chancelier a parfaitement rappelé ici les enjeux et décrit en détail les choses. [27:01] Je ne veux pas ici répéter ce qui a été dit. [27:03] Mais, au fond, si nous caractérisons la situation aujourd'hui, [27:08] l'Ukraine résiste sur la ligne de front. [27:10] Elle reprend même du terrain. [27:12] Mais la Russie a décidé, depuis la fin de l'été, [27:15] d'attaquer massivement Kiev et les civils, [27:18] avec des actions d'une violence et d'une cruauté inédites, [27:22] avec, avant l'hiver, la volonté de couper la ville en deux, [27:26] de casser les infrastructures de transport, [27:28] de casser les infrastructures énergétiques. [27:31] Et à côté de ça, il y a eu plusieurs discussions qui se sont faites [27:35] qui ont montré les positions très maximalistes de la Russie. [27:38] Voilà la situation nous en sommes. [27:40] Et donc, le 1er objectif qui a été affirmé ici, [27:43] et notre priorité à tous, si on veut être crédible, [27:47] même dans les négociations de paix, [27:49] c'est que l'Ukraine tienne et soit dans les meilleures situations [27:52] possibles pour négocier. [27:53] Et donc, la priorité des priorités, c'est le soutien [27:56] à court terme à l'Ukraine. [27:59] C'est ce que nous faisons en livrant de nouveaux radars, [28:02] des autodirecteurs, en accélérant les travaux sur Freya, [28:06] et nous organiserons dans quelques semaines à Paris [28:08] un nouveau sommet de la coalition Freya [28:11] pour, justement, l'antidrone et l'antibalistique. [28:15] C'est de déployer des nouveaux systèmes antimissiles [28:18] et des intercepteurs nouveaux. [28:20] Et il faut que tous les membres de cette coalition, [28:23] tous les membres présents dans cette salle aujourd'hui, [28:25] fassent le maximum pour livrer les capacités à l'Ukraine [28:28] dont elle a besoin pour résister. [28:31] Tous ceux qui ont des intercepteurs disponibles doivent les livrer. [28:34] Tous ceux qui ont la capacité de livrer des images supplémentaires [28:37] doivent les donner. [28:38] Tous ceux qui ont la capacité de donner des moyens qui sont des moyens [28:40] de défense et de protection des citoyens ukrainiens doivent le faire maintenant. [28:45] C'est la priorité des priorités. [28:48] Deuxième chose, c'est que nous devons aussi améliorer [28:51] notre protection de Kiev. [28:53] Et la coalition des volontaires doit pouvoir trouver aussi [28:55] de nouvelles voies et moyens pour protéger Kiev [28:58] dans les semaines qui viennent. [28:59] C'est l'élément clé. [29:00] L'Ukraine tient sur le front. [29:02] Elle est attaquée dans sa population civile. [29:04] Nous devons être là. [29:05] Et ça n'est pas confrontationnel, [29:08] c'est aider l'Ukraine à résister. [29:11] Mais c'est notre devoir maintenant. [29:13] Le deuxième élément, c'est les garanties de sécurité. [29:16] C'est clé pour négocier la paix, c'est clé dans la durée. [29:19] Ces garanties de sécurité, nous les avons finalisées [29:21] dans leur contenu en janvier dernier. [29:24] Les émissaires du président Trump étaient déjà avec nous, [29:27] accompagnés du général Klinkiewicz, [29:31] et nous avons validé le schéma présenté [29:34] par nos chefs d'Etat-major en janvier dernier. [29:37] Nous avons donc une planification. [29:39] Le soutien à l'armée ukrainienne [29:41] et le format de l'armée ukrainienne [29:42] sur les années qui viennent. [29:43] Les pays membres de la coalition qui sont prêts à déployer [29:46] après la paix loin de la ligne de front sur le sol ukrainien. [29:49] Les pays qui sont prêts à faire un deuxième rideau [29:51] et les solidarités en dernier office. [29:53] Ce schéma reste valide. [29:55] C'est celui qui assure notre sécurité. [29:57] Et dans le moment où nous sommes, [29:59] face aux maximalistes des positions russes, [30:03] je pense qu'il faut rouvrir la question, en effet, [30:05] de l'adhésion de l'Ukraine à l'OTAN, [30:07] ce que j'ai proposé il y a quelques jours. [30:08] C'est le bon moment. [30:09] Elle a été écartée au 1er semestre 2022, [30:12] dans un contexte qui était totalement différent. [30:15] Je pense qu'aujourd'hui, la question se pose, [30:17] y compris pour nous Européens le jour d'après, [30:21] parce que l'Ukraine sera un pays très fortement équipé [30:24] avec une armée nombreuse, [30:26] et pour notre sécurité dans la durée, [30:28] sa présence dans l'OTAN est pertinente. [30:31] Dans ce contexte aussi, je veux dire qu'au moment où nous nous parlons, [30:33] et pour montrer que la coalition des volontaires [30:35] est quelque chose de très concret, [30:37] l'opération qui a été annoncée à Paris le 13 juillet dernier, [30:40] l'opération des coalitions décidées en Pologne, [30:44] qui permet de déployer nos capacités, [30:47] d'entraîner nos forces pour le jour d'après, est encore. [30:51] On a plus de 2 500 soldats qui sont déployés, [30:55] et je remercie la Pologne pour son accueil. [30:57] On a des opérations terrestres, aériennes, [30:59] mais également maritimes. [31:01] Une douzaine de pays qui sont actifs dans cette coalition. [31:05] La France fournit 1 100 soldats qui sont déployés [31:07] dans cet exercice, mais qui montrent la crédibilité [31:11] de cette coalition des volontaires. [31:14] Mon dernier point est pour dire que dans ce contexte, [31:17] parce que nous serons crédibles sur les autres éléments, [31:20] c'est-à-dire le soutien à court terme de l'Ukraine [31:22] et les garanties de sécurité, [31:24] dans les termes que je viens d'évoquer, [31:26] nous avons la volonté d'engager évidemment [31:28] les discussions de paix avec la Russie. [31:30] Soyons honnêtes, la Russie jusqu'alors [31:32] n'a pas manifesté d'éléments concrets de paix. [31:36] Néanmoins, ce qui a été acté, c'est que le bon format [31:39] pour parler de la paix, c'est d'avoir autour de la table [31:42] Ukraine, Russie, Etats-Unis, Europe. [31:45] C'est donc le format qui sera suivi [31:48] dans les détails qui ont été évoqués [31:50] et qui doit permettre de traiter des sujets de territoire [31:54] qui sont la responsabilité du président Zelensky, [31:58] qui a la légitimité seule pour le faire, [32:00] des questions de sécurité [32:02] qui sont la responsabilité des Européens. [32:06] Parce que c'est la sécurité de l'Europe [32:08] et parce que nous sommes engagés [32:09] dans cette solution des volontaires [32:11] et la question de la reconstruction [32:13] des éléments de long terme et des réassurances [32:15] où il faut avoir l'Ukrainien, [32:17] européen, américain pour le faire. [32:19] C'est tout ça qui doit être acté [32:21] dans des discussions de paix [32:23] que nous organiserons selon ces termes. [32:25] Je vous remercie beaucoup [32:26] et je veux ici dire au président Zelensky [32:27] combien nous sommes conscients [32:28] que les semaines à venir [32:29] sont des semaines critiques pour son pays, [32:32] pour sa population et pour notre Europe [32:36] et je pense que cette coalition des volontaires [32:38] était au bon moment, au bon niveau [32:40] et qu'elle a mobilisé en manière inédite [32:42] en effet, 40 représentants, [32:44] et je remercie, je remercie, je remercie, je remercie, je remercie. [32:47] Et donc je remercie, je remercie, je remercie, je remercie, je remercie, je remercie et presse. [32:57] We are gathered in Berlin today to show our strong and united commitment to just and lasting peace in Ukraine. [33:09] And we have assured President Zelensky of that. [33:13] There are three big positives coming out of this gathering here today. [33:19] The first is that the Coalition of the Willing, hosted by Friedrich, has put on a huge show of support today. [33:28] So many people coming from all parts of Europe. [33:32] Never a greater turnout, I don't think, for a coalition of the Willing. [33:37] A tremendous and much needed show of support. [33:40] A critical moment for Ukraine ahead of the winter. [33:43] And beyond that, the mood. [33:45] The mood was stronger, more united, more determined than ever to stay the course in support of President Zelensky and the people of Ukraine. [33:56] Such a huge positive to take from today. [33:59] The second is the involvement in our discussions today of our US colleagues, Jared and Steve. [34:08] And we all thank them for being in the room with us today. [34:13] It makes a real difference and it takes forward the prospect of real negotiations. [34:20] The third positive, as Chancellor Merz said correctly, is not only are we strong and organized, we are also ready to enter negotiations. [34:35] The second is that Europe has a clear and consistent and united negotiating position. [34:42] It is not for the aggressor in this conflict to set out wide-ranging and unrealistic security demands. [34:54] That much we are all absolutely clear about. [34:57] However, we are ready to enter serious discussions on European security as long as it is matched with a serious discussion and crucially only first if there is a peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia. [35:19] So big positives. [35:20] But today, as President Zelensky said, has been a very difficult day indeed in Kiev with the damage done to historic buildings, the damage done to diplomatic missions in Kiev, and the winter, as Emmanuel said, will be very difficult indeed. [35:41] The damage that has been done to bridges, which could affect the running of the city and people's safety across the winter period. [35:52] So we have to be ready for that. [35:54] And the message that I brought here today, is that we have to step up again, and we will step up again, and we will step up again, Volodymyr. [36:03] You can assure your people of that, not just Britain, but other partners around the table. [36:08] That's not just Britain, but other partners around the table. [36:09] That's exactly the same. [36:11] And I commend the EU for the package that is coming for. [36:15] For a significant financial package, which does so much to bolster Ukraine's position in this critical moment. [36:23] But Britain plays its part two, having a 10 billion pound package of support at the recent budget. [36:32] And today we are committing to a thousand long-range drones, British built, working with Norway to British built, [36:44] attack, fast attack votes. [36:46] So our commitment is there, and it will be there going forward, working with all of our colleagues in the coalition of the willing, for as long as it takes. [36:59] And I hope that message is heard very clearly in Moscow. [37:02] For as long as it takes, we will be there at the side of Ukraine, and we will not falter. [37:10] And that's the biggest weapon we have together, the solidarity between all of Europe, which has been on display today. [37:21] And I hope that has been seen around the world. [37:25] The point was made by a number of colleagues. [37:28] This is a lose-lose situation. [37:31] But perhaps the biggest losers are Russia. [37:35] They are losing as many men every two to three months as they lost in the whole nine years of the conflict between Russia, or I should say the Soviet Union and Afghanistan all of those years ago. [37:54] That was judged a disaster, but the loss of life is on a much greater scale here. [38:00] And how much land have they taken? [38:03] No more than 0,2% more Ukrainian territory for that huge human cost. [38:12] So let's be clear, Russia is losing men. [38:17] Russia is losing ground, and Russia is losing the battle to break Ukraine. [38:24] Because from what I've seen of the resilience of the President, and from what I've seen of the resilience of the Ukrainian people, they are unbreakable. [38:35] And they should know that with VETOS at their side, they can carry on to fight this with everything that we've got. [38:43] But this clearly has got to be a moment to move towards peace because of the US involvement that we've seen today and the progress clearly that is being made. [38:54] Europe is ready to enter these negotiations. We are clear about what we will accept and what we won't accept. [39:02] But we are also clear that we stand with Ukraine today, tomorrow, for as long as it takes, until this unjust war is over. Thank you. [39:16] Thank you very much. On behalf of Steve and I, I'd like to thank Chancellor Mertz for hosting us here so graciously. [39:23] And I'd also like to compliment Chancellor Mertz and President Macron and Prime Minister Burnham and President Zelensky on a very substantive and successful gathering here today. [39:34] I'd also like to thank some of the other European leaders who have been so essential in helping us shape our point of view, [39:40] helping us design the right pathway forward. Amongst them is Prime Minister Maloney from Italy. [39:46] I'd like to thank Prime Minister from Poland, who's been helpful, [39:49] Ursula von der Leyen from the EU, and obviously Secretary General of NATO, Mark Rutte, [39:55] as well as the President of Finland, Alex Stubb, and Jonas Gahr, the Prime Minister of Norway, [40:01] who have all been really engaging with us on a very regular basis in a very substantive and informative and deliberate way. [40:08] What we came away from today with is really seeing that Europe is very united and very, very strong in their support of Ukraine. [40:18] And we saw, and we relayed this to President Trump when we spoke to him after the meeting, but we also will go back and relay this to the Russian delegation, [40:26] which is we see strength and unity and commitment, but we also see a real desire for peace. [40:33] And I think that we're doing a lot of work to organize on how to give it the best shot to get there. [40:40] After a war that's gone on for this long, that's so emotional and tough and with huge costs from a human perspective, [40:50] it's very, very hard to get both sides back to the table and back to peace. [40:54] But I do believe we're making significant steps towards doing that. [40:58] And it's going to be very, very hard to achieve it. [41:01] But by working together, everyone here is committed to giving it their best shot. [41:05] And I believe and I hope and I pray that we will be able to be successful. [41:10] President Trump sent Steve and I here today and then called into the meeting to give an update on his conversations in Shenzhen [41:18] with President Xi and President Putin, where he sent a very strong message to both of them on the desire for peace [41:24] and would like to engage both of them very aggressively to get there. [41:28] And I'm not going to go into the private discussions that he had. [41:31] I'll let him disclose that when he's ready. [41:34] But I believe he also came away believing that peace is achievable and we need to all work together to try and achieve it. [41:42] For Steve and I, this is deeply personal. [41:44] You know, we speak to a lot of people who are being impacted by the war. [41:48] You know, last week I was speaking to a friend of mine who's from Krematorsk [41:51] and she was telling me about her brother who's fighting on the front lines and how dire the situation is [41:56] and how a lot of the area where she grew up has been destroyed and a lot of, you know, friends who have been killed in the battle. [42:02] And a lot of people feel very hopeless and like they don't have a – they don't have any say in what's happening. [42:08] And they really would like to see peace. [42:10] And on behalf of those people on both sides, Steve and I are working very, very hard to try and do whatever we can do [42:17] to see if we can help bring this horrible war to an end, to stop the fighting, the killing, the suffering [42:23] and all of the negative things that come from war. [42:28] When Steve and I started on this a year ago, we very quickly defined that for us, success in an outcome would be to have a sovereign, secure, prosperous [42:39] and free Ukraine at the end of the war. [42:41] And I do think that the negotiations and the outcomes that we're discussing – and it's very important that we're here in Europe [42:47] and you're hearing this from us directly – we do believe that that is very achievable. [42:51] We think we've made a lot of progress in the last year towards a pathway with Ukraine to the EU. [42:57] And before we got involved, everyone had spoken about that Ukraine needed security guarantees. [43:02] And obviously that was not offered. [43:04] And Steve and I went to President Trump and said, is that something you'd be open to? [43:07] And he says, absolutely, write them up. [43:10] Obviously, I have to make sure I go through Congress and we do it in a responsible way that's in line with my principles and values. [43:15] But we've made a lot of progress working with President Zelensky and the Coalition of the Willing on what those security guarantees can look like. [43:23] We've also been making a lot of progress on a post-war prosperity plan. [43:26] We've been working with the World Bank and BlackRock and President Zelensky's team. [43:30] And the EU has really been excellent at spearheading that effort. [43:34] And I think that we've made progress towards defining what a successful and strong Ukraine can look like hopefully after this war. [43:42] In September, when Steve and I first went to go visit Russia and Ukraine, the negotiations were really dead in the water. [43:50] And it was looking very, very hopeless. [43:52] And we came up with a plan working with our European colleagues to try and get the trilateral format back up and running. [43:58] It took us some time and some hard work to do that, but we were able to achieve that just recently. [44:02] That's led to some humanitarian breakthroughs. [44:05] There's going to be thousands of prisoners of war who will be going home to their families in the next weeks, which will be obviously a great gesture and a great relief for people. [44:15] And then in addition to that, most importantly, Russia has agreed to engage in the multilateral format with the Europeans. [44:22] And part of that was us explaining to the Russians that we do believe that Russia having Europe at the table will be essential to ending this war in a just and long-term durable way. [44:32] And the Russians are willing to trust that instinct on our behalf. [44:35] And I believe that after today we can go back with an even stronger affirmation that we believe that, we've heard that, and there's real commitment to that. [44:44] So the next steps for us is obviously to work in close coordination after this press conference. [44:49] Steve and I are going to be meeting with all the NSAs, which make up the negotiating team. [44:54] And we appreciate the leaders really giving their full time and commitment to that. [44:59] We're going to be working on joint proposals. [45:02] Obviously, we want to make sure that everything we're doing is unified. [45:05] And I also want to be able to reiterate that President Trump wants to make a deal with Europe by his side. [45:11] He's not looking to impose anything unilaterally. [45:13] He wants to do it with Europe and Ukraine. [45:15] And any deal we do will be in close consultation with Ukraine and with Europe. [45:19] And that's something that he also asks us to come here today and reassure people in that regard. [45:25] I would say the progress of the meeting, and I think we'll make further progress after, is that I do feel like our positions are becoming much closer, [45:32] much more detailed and more aligned in that regard. [45:34] And that's just going to be critical to getting to the next set of talks. [45:39] Finally, I'll just address, you know, post-war security. [45:42] I think the discussions today on Coalition of the Willing, everything they discussed today are elements of what post-war security. [45:49] And I appreciate that Chancellor Mertz brought up the right mechanisms for communication, transparency, crisis management, and then potentially reciprocal de-escalation. [46:00] There is a lot of infrastructure already in Europe that we can draw on, like the NATO-Russia Council. [46:04] I think that will be very important to work on in a solution. [46:07] But obviously NATO will be a central pillar of whatever we work on in this – in the settlement. [46:14] And hopefully it will be a much stronger NATO that really has the ability to be a protector of the peace and not seen as provocative, [46:21] which is obviously not the nature of NATO in that regard. [46:24] And we have to finalize the credible guarantees. [46:27] So in final, I'll just conclude to say that our goal is really to end this war and to really help build a durable peace. [46:35] We are very committed, President Trump will do whatever it takes to do that. [46:39] He's instructed us to commit as much time as possible. [46:42] And we will continue to do that in full coordination and unity with our European partners. [46:47] Thank you. [46:50] Thank you. [46:54] Thank you. [46:55] Herr Bundeskanzler, ich hätte nach den Äußerungen von Herrn Putin in China gefragt, [47:00] wie ernst Sie eigentlich das Angebot von Gesprächen an die Europäer und die Einladung nach Moskau nehmen, [47:08] wenn gleichzeitig gesagt wird, dass er einen Waffenstillstand ablehnt und der Ukraine mit massiven Vergeltungsschlägen [47:14] für den Angriff auf die Brücke von Kersch ankündigt. [47:17] Oder eine Frage an Herrn Macron und den Premierminister. [47:21] Der Kanzler hat eben Yalta erwähnt. [47:24] Wie groß ist eigentlich Ihre Sorge, dass die drei großen Atommächte untereinander eine Vereinbarung treffen, [47:31] die eine Art Yalta auch für Europa bedeuten könnte? [47:34] Danke. [47:37] Herr Kollege, wir sind selbstverständlich zu Besprechen mit Russland bereit. [47:41] Das haben wir immer gesagt. [47:43] Diese Bespräche sollen nun auch bald stattfinden, und zwar im Format Ukraine, Russland, Europa und den USA. [47:51] Das kann zum Beispiel in den Vereinigten Arabischen Emiraten geschehen. [47:57] Unsere gemeinsame europäische Position, dazu habe ich eben umrissen. [48:02] Wir hoffen nun, dass auch Russland zu diesen Gesprächen bereit ist, so wie mit den USA vereinbart. [48:10] Das ist das Format. [48:11] Und auf dieser Ebene sind wir selbstverständlich bereit, mit Russland zu reden. [48:16] Wir wissen, dass dieser Krieg nur endet, wenn es eine diplomatische Lösung gibt. [48:21] Aber dieser Krieg muss enden mit einer Ukraine, die ihre territoriale Integrität bewahrt, [48:26] die starke Sicherheitsgarantien auf ihrer Seite hat und die vor allem eingebettet ist in europäische Sicherheit. [48:33] Das ist der entscheidende Punkt. [48:35] Und über diese Themen sind wir selbstverständlich bereit, mit Präsident Putin zu reden. [48:40] Wo diese Gespräche stattfinden, ist eine andere Frage. [48:44] Dass wir da nach Orten suchen, wo sie auf neutralem Boden stattfinden können, das dürfte offensichtlich sein. [48:51] Eine Frage für Sie? [49:00] Ja. [49:01] Eine Frage für Sie? [49:02] Jalter. [49:03] Jalter. [49:04] Ah. [49:08] Sur ce sujet, je n'ai pas tellement de commentaires à faire. [49:10] Sur quelque chose, c'est normal que dans des formats comme celui-ci, [49:13] il y ait des réunions qui permettent de définir entrepuissances dotées des choses. [49:18] J'ai vu, en tout cas, le texte qui sortait de la réunion. [49:21] Il me semble que l'agenda n'était pas à Yalta. [49:24] Ce sont des éléments qu'on peut partager ou ne pas partager, [49:31] mais ça ne conduit pas à une réorganisation du monde. [49:37] Je pense qu'aujourd'hui, s'il y a un élément critique pour la réorganisation de l'Europe, [49:43] sa sécurité, c'est exactement la réunion qui s'est tenue à Berlin. [49:47] Et je pense que s'il y a un chemin pour redonner une vigueur et une vitalité [49:51] au multilatéralisme et à l'ordre mondial, [49:54] c'est ce qui peut se tenir entre les Etats-Unis, l'Europe et la Chine. [50:00] Ce qui s'est passé aujourd'hui était un format. [50:02] Il avait sa pertinence à coup sûr pour les intéressés. [50:05] Et les conclusions avaient leurs intérêts pour les intéressés. [50:10] Et ce n'est pas l'idée que je me fais d'un Yalta sans pouvoir vous dire pour autant [50:14] que je serais heureux d'avoir un Yalta aujourd'hui. [50:17] Là où les choses ont changé, c'est que, comme vous l'avez compris, [50:19] les Européens ont décidé, justement ce sursaut, et entendent bien décider pour eux-mêmes. [50:29] Et l'Europe n'est pas un sujet au menu des discussions, [50:34] mais c'est un ensemble de puissances qui veulent construire leur propre avenir. [50:40] C'est ainsi qu'il faut l'entendre. [50:42] Et l'Europe a son [50:42] a son propre choix. [50:44] C'est l'Université d'Ovéné Live. [50:45] C'est l'Université d'Ovéné Live. [50:46] C'est l'Université d'Ovéné Live. [50:50] C'est l'Université d'Ovéné Live. [50:55] Novena Live. [50:57] Nach den Ergebnissen des Treffens hier in Berlin, [51:01] hat man sich wirklich einen physischen Platz [51:04] in den Verhandlungen mit Russland gesichert? [51:06] Und sind Sie bereit, Putins Vorschlag zu folgen, [51:09] erst nach Moskau zu kommen und dort Gespräche zu führen? [51:12] Und die Frage an Jared Kushner and Steven Witkow. [51:20] Es geht jetzt um die Garantien für die ukrainische Sicherheit [51:24] nach Art des Artikel 5. [51:27] Wie könnte das aussehen, solche Garantien? [51:30] Und an den Präsidenten Zelensky, wissen wir, [51:33] welche Details aus den Verhandlungen in China sind? [51:38] Es gibt keine Translation. [51:42] Ja. [51:55] Nein, nein. [51:57] Wir haben ja über unsere Vorstellungen hier ausführlich berichtet, [52:02] die wir haben im Hinblick auf Formate und im Hinblick auf [52:06] gemeinsame Vorgehen. [52:07] Und ich will das noch einmal erläutern, [52:10] warum ich den Begriff Yalta verwendet habe. [52:13] In Yalta ist Europa aufgeteilt worden. [52:15] Wir lassen es nicht zu, dass Europa neu aufgeteilt wird. [52:19] Sondern wir, und so wie Präsident Macron es gerade gesagt hat, [52:23] nehmen unser Schicksal selbst in die Hand. [52:25] Und wir wissen, dass wir dies zusammen mit den Vereinigten Staaten [52:30] von Amerika tun wollen. [52:31] Ich bin sehr dankbar, dass die Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika [52:34] heute, vertreten durch die beiden besonderen Beauftragten [52:38] des amerikanischen Präsidenten, die noch einmal betont haben, [52:41] dass sie diesen Weg gemeinsam gehen wollen. [52:44] Und genau da ist die Zukunft der Ukraine. [52:47] In einem Europa, das frei ist, das sich selbst verteidigen kann, [52:51] und das die territoriale Integrität der Staaten garantiert. [52:55] Und genau darüber haben wir gesprochen. [52:57] Und genau das wird das Ziel sein solcher Gespräche. [53:00] Die können anfangen, die müssen anfangen. [53:02] Und wir werden dies sehr, sehr konstruktiv begleiten [53:05] und werden dieses Angebot selbstverständlich annehmen, [53:08] wenn es zu Bedingungen stattfindet, die für die Europäer, [53:11] für die Ukraine und für die Amerikaner zu tausend sind. [53:22] Ich denke, Sie haben die Frage stoppt. [53:24] Wenn Sie die Frage wiederholen können, [53:26] dann werde ich sie antworten. [53:28] Die zweite Frage war zu den USA. [53:33] Okay, kein Problem. [53:43] Ich wiederhole sie noch einmal. [53:46] Meine Frage war die Sicherheitsgarantien für die Ukraine. [53:57] Ja, wir danken Ihnen für Ihre Unterstützung. [53:59] Die erste Frage war die Sicherheitsgarantien für die Ukraine [54:03] nach Artikel 5 von NATO. [54:06] Wie könnte das aussehen? [54:08] Wie sollen wir das verstehen? [54:10] Sure. [54:14] Ja, so that's a very big development [54:16] that we've been able to achieve. [54:18] And I think we've gotten the Russians comfortable [54:20] with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine [54:23] would be based on Article 5. [54:25] And I think that comes with at least what the Russians are saying, [54:28] which is their intention is when this war is over [54:31] to not have another war in the future. [54:33] And I know that there's a lot of skepticism and disbelief [54:36] on that concept in Russia. [54:38] But that's why it's important to restart the dialogue [54:40] between Europe and Russia. [54:42] Let people discuss it. [54:43] Let them hear it from each other. [54:45] The last time I believe they spoke was over four years ago. [54:48] And I think that a lot's changed in four years. [54:50] War changes people. [54:51] And, you know, maybe the nature is the same. [54:54] Maybe the nature is different. [54:56] But I think it's something we have to not rely on trust and intentions. [54:59] We have to work on what's the system of incentives and interest [55:03] to make sure that whatever agreement we come to is something [55:06] that will be, you know, kept, will be monitored. [55:09] There will be huge deterrence and there will be massive consequences [55:13] if it's ever violated. [55:14] And so we need to all work together on what that is. [55:17] And I will say from America's perspective, [55:19] giving an Article 5 like security guarantee is a really, [55:22] really big deal. [55:23] And I think that that's something that President Trump is open to. [55:27] But obviously it has to be in America's interest to do that. [55:30] And we also have to make sure that it's part of a broader security [55:33] package, right, in the sense that what we discussed today [55:36] with Coalition of the Willing and the work that was done last year [55:38] and the work that we continue to update, it all has to go together. [55:43] And obviously today Ukraine is a different Ukraine than the Ukraine [55:46] that was attacked back in the day. [55:48] I think they've shown their resilience, their strength, [55:50] they've evolved tremendously and now become one of the best [55:53] militaries in the world. [55:54] And that's going to be a very critical element. [55:56] I think that there's security guarantees, there's deterrence, [55:59] there's layer defense. [56:00] There's layer defense. [56:01] But I also think that having the right communication channels [56:04] and mechanisms to reinvigorate them and maybe to make some slight [56:07] modifications to them to make them more useful so that we can learn [56:12] from what went wrong here. [56:14] Clearly something wasn't working or else we wouldn't be in this war today. [56:17] And let's figure out how to create a system with clear understanding [56:20] on both sides. [56:21] But I do think a security guarantee has the potential to be a cornerstone of it. [56:26] And the goal is to make it as strong, as durable and as good as possible. [56:30] Not so that you have to use it, but you make it so good so that hopefully [56:33] you never have to use it because the deterrence is so strong. [56:39] Hello, Mr. President. [56:42] I have a question for the French press. [56:46] A propos of the summit that was held this morning to Shenzhen without the Europeans. [56:50] Can you confirm that you have talked about Donald Trump? [56:53] Do you have talked about the optimism of the President of the U.S. [56:55] that they are also optimistic as the Ukrainian. [56:57] Do you, Mr. President, could you move to Moscow? [56:59] I have a second question. [57:00] Is there a possibility that the parties who don't support the Ukraine [57:05] will come to power in many European countries? [57:07] Is there a yes, that in the country and theאניsень and the腕s dictionary [57:10] at the time we won't be supported? [57:11] How do you support it? [57:12] How do you bring that towards French press? [57:17] Thank you very much. [57:18] I did this job. [57:19] You became a good friend. [57:20] He said that Trump had five minutes to fala in Shenzhen has Teddy, [57:21] as Mr. President, were going to have talked about [57:23] the common word of speech and an attentive presence. [57:26] I hope to be therefore the difficult part of our customers [57:28] who has wanted to create and give of mutual support. [57:32] and that's why he has shared with us his first impression [57:37] and that he has taken with us by the touch of his representatives [57:40] to be there and to have this chat telephonic. [57:42] After, I will not comment on a meeting at which I was not. [57:46] On the discussions, we have never caught the contact with Moscow. [57:50] We have always had different contacts with the Russian authorities. [57:56] Now, the question is in the definition of what? [57:59] And it's the priority of the moment. [58:03] But if we put things in the right order, [58:04] the priority of the priority is to help Ukraine resist [58:07] and to defend this moment. [58:09] We have to first say, okay, the Ukraine has done [58:11] in a critical moment, we need a security guarantee. [58:14] And then we must be able to re-engager these discussions. [58:22] And that must be in the best days, [58:24] and we will find the place where we can go for it. [58:26] For the next, I will not present the choice democratic [58:29] that will make the people French. [58:31] And then, as I said, I believe that this is what the last quarter [58:34] of an democratic decision should be for the security of France [58:39] and the European Union to be established. [58:41] For France, the security of Europe is very important. [58:44] And what I have in my election of 2022, [58:46] which is taken after the war of Russia in Ukraine, [58:50] in its second phase, so after the February of 2022, [58:54] is that what is happening in Ukraine is our security. [58:56] And no one can ignore it. [59:00] And so, in the same time, the debate must be [59:02] democratically organized, [59:05] so that our compatriots can measure the impacts of such a decision [59:09] proposed by such a party. [59:11] They understand the security of France and Europe. [59:13] They want the security of France and Europe. [59:15] And so, it's not something that you can take away from the light. [59:17] And so, it's not something that you can take away from the light. [59:19] And that's what we can do. [59:21] And that's what we can do. [59:23] I will ask my question in English. [59:29] I will ask my question in English. [59:31] I will ask my question in English. [59:33] I will ask my question in English. [59:35] I will ask my question in English. [59:37] I will ask my question in English. [59:39] I have a question to the three leaders regarding the phone call from the US President, [59:43] which Mr. Kushner just mentioned. [59:45] The US President seemed very upbeat and in a positive mood, [59:49] and basically seemed to have said that it is a shame that the Europeans are wasting so much money. [59:55] It is a shame that the Europeans are wasting so much money for weapons, [1:00:00] and that Putin really Frieden wants. [1:00:03] Are you concerned that the US President might have too rosy, [1:00:08] or that he is fallen for Putin's charm offensive, [1:00:14] and that he is in no surprise? [1:00:18] And the Kanzler has also said that it should not be surprised. [1:00:23] And maybe their question was not quite a bit, [1:00:25] and it would be yes to China, [1:00:26] or perhaps it would be a question that you would stop buying weapons, [1:00:28] because the US government would stop buying weapons, [1:00:29] because the US government would stop using weapons in order to buy weapons, [1:00:31] and the US would be very useful. [1:00:32] And I would say that it could be a bit of money. [1:00:33] Andy, would you like to start? [1:00:34] Okay. [1:00:35] Thank you for your question. [1:00:36] Okay. [1:00:37] Thank you for your question. [1:00:39] To Rosie Pitchin. [1:00:40] No, certainly not. [1:00:41] That was not the phone call from the President, [1:00:42] who we heard from the President this afternoon. [1:00:44] No, certainly not. That was not the phone call we heard from the President this afternoon. I would say quite opposite. To be honest, he talked about the horrific loss of life, including the loss of young Russian lives, and he spoke quite passionately about that subject. [1:01:06] It goes back to the point I was making, nobody is winning this war, and I include Russia when I say that they are losing perhaps the most from what is going on in the failure to move towards a resolution. What the phone call pointed to was the huge progress that I mentioned, that Jared had talked about so clearly before. [1:01:30] We've got to a position here now, where there is no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine in the room. There is no decision about European security without Europe represented in the room. There is clarity about that and how that would be done. [1:01:48] So I think, as I said before, huge progress has been made. There is a greater degree of alignment, certainly in my time of office. I can see alignment coming here, that is hugely helpful. Nobody wants escalation. I think it's really important that I make that point. We are steadfast, we are strong in our support for Ukraine, but nobody wants escalation. [1:02:14] The thing that we could see now would be an energy system by a brain moving through the Black Sea. There are things that could be done on the back of the prisoner exchange, that was agreed, so you get further steps towards the program. Those things could happen. [1:02:32] The Ukraine must be in the center of negotiations, but we will be with Volodymyr behind him every step of the way, providing all the support he needs in that process. [1:02:39] providing all the support he needs in that process. [1:02:43] So I would say for the first time in my period as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, [1:02:52] I see alignment, I see people saying the same thing, I see solidarity across the floor in Europe, [1:03:03] strong united European position and that gives some grounds for optimism that there can now be progress. [1:03:12] But obviously there is one person who can determine that more than anybody else and that is President Putin. [1:03:19] President, I just want to say in answer to that question, the President has adamantly supported a peaceful end to this war. [1:03:28] He has been undeterred in saying that. [1:03:32] He sent Jared and I here specifically to be a part of this coalition of the willing [1:03:38] and he has given us instructions on doing everything possible to end this war and peace to support of that effort. [1:03:45] And what I heard from him on the call today was that he mentioned these very same principles [1:03:50] to the other two leaders who he was meeting with. [1:03:53] So he made Ukraine a peaceful end to this, a principle part of that trilateral treatment. [1:04:00] And I think he should be commended for that. [1:04:04] And just to answer specifically your question on the weapons, it's a very small industry relative to the size of the U.S. economy. [1:04:11] And nothing would make President Trump happier than to have that industry go down because we have peace throughout the world. [1:04:18] And I think that being involved in these wars just only makes you realize how horrible war is. [1:04:24] War is negative sum. Everyone loses from war. [1:04:27] And peace is positive sum. [1:04:29] If you can figure out how to redirect resources away from having to buy weapons, that's a great thing. [1:04:34] But if you see what happened in Europe because they redirected away from that for too long. [1:04:38] And so there has to be obviously a balance. [1:04:40] But know that President Trump's sole motivation in doing this is obviously he wants to bring peace. [1:04:45] He thinks that there will be huge dividends to the world on peace. [1:04:48] And he also wants to stop the suffering from that. [1:04:51] So the concern you raised has no consideration in his thoughts. [1:04:57] And he really wants to push a peace with everything that he has to do. [1:05:02] As a matter of fact, I can't say that Russia has won a 26th year on the field of Ukraine. [1:05:09] But the answer is that Russia has won a 26th year on the field of war. [1:05:14] And Russia has tried to counteract with ballistic rockets against the civilization. [1:05:19] And Russia has tried to counteract with ballistic rockets against the civilization. [1:05:23] And the question here is not the Widerstands of the people, but it's unfair rules, even in the war, it's unfair and unfair rules. [1:05:36] We can also rechna, that Russia will fight against the unity of Europe. [1:05:46] This war by the time, Russia lost the war, and Russia lost the war. [1:05:56] And Europe to split, that's not been able to. [1:06:01] And our today's session, I thank the partners, was a proof. [1:06:05] I am sure that Putin has given certain questions with President Trump. [1:06:11] President Trump, we know not, what they have spoken about. [1:06:14] President Trump has held a signal about what he wanted to do. [1:06:21] And his message was, that he wants to end the war. [1:06:24] But I would like to say to our colleagues and to you, and also to the President of the United States, [1:06:30] that a strong Europe is not only important for Ukraine in the war, but also for Europe itself. [1:06:39] And to the journalist who asked this question, where have you seen the shame in Putin? [1:06:46] That's a personal question. [1:06:49] Thank you. [1:06:51] Thank you. [1:07:00] Thank you. [1:07:03] There you go.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →