Try Free

The Rights of Nature: A Global Movement - Feature Documentary

Issac Goeckeritz | Filmmaker November 20, 2026 52m 8,397 words 2 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of The Rights of Nature: A Global Movement - Feature Documentary from Issac Goeckeritz | Filmmaker, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 8,397 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"Our minuscule brain cannot perceive what is the might and sophistication of nature. Yet, without me needing to understand everything, the world exists. The land is not real estate. You own real estate. That there is land and nature, and nobody owns that. This idea of time, my brain can stretch back"

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Our minuscule brain cannot perceive what is the might and sophistication of nature. Yet, without me needing to understand everything, the world exists. The land is not real estate. You own real estate. That there is land and nature, and nobody owns that. This idea of time, my brain can stretch back 30 years, the land's millions, and I get to be connected to that. [00:00:47] Speaker 2: Since the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, humans have viewed nature as a resource from which to extract commodities: fish, energy, minerals, timber. Nature is also seen as a place to dispose of waste, often without considering the impacts it may have on the human condition, whose lives depend on a healthy ecosystem. Today, these environmental challenges continue. But a new idea, pulled from ancient indigenous practice, may provide the Earth with a rights-based solution. [00:01:26] Speaker ?: "You are the child. [00:01:27] Speaker 1: You are the child, and that land out there, that Earth mother of yours is your parent. No human owns your mother." Ecuador, a land known across the globe for its untouched ecosystems. [00:01:40] Speaker 2: Each year, hundreds of thousands of tourists travel to experience the country's rainforests and rivers, as well [00:01:47] Speaker ?: as the exotic Galapagos Islands. [00:01:47] Speaker 2: In Ecuador, and across much of South America, the idea of Mother Earth, or Pachamama, as it is known in indigenous Andean cultures, has a presence in everyday life. There is no distinction between human and non-human nature. Para los indígenas, la naturaleza es la madre tierra, la Pachamama. Y eso no representa una suerte de metáfora. Es una realidad. Hay mucho que aprender de las comunidades ancestrales. La confirmación de la naturaleza es la madre tierra, la Pachamama. La naturaleza es la madre tierra, la Pachamama. Y eso no representa una suerte de metáfora. Es una realidad. Hay mucho que aprender de las comunidades ancestrales. La confirmación de ciertos elementos de la naturaleza, que ya se conocían en las comunidades ancestrales, la naturaleza es la madre tierra, la Pachamama. Y eso no representa una suerte de metáfora. Es una realidad. Hay mucho que aprender de las comunidades ancestrales. [00:02:18] Speaker 3: La confirmación de ciertos elementos de la naturaleza, que ya se conocían en los [00:02:35] Speaker 4: milenios atrás. Antes que el reconocimiento a la naturaleza, creo que debe haber un reconocimiento profundo hacia las comunidades ancestrales. Y creo que ese es el punto de partida. [00:02:52] Speaker 2: It is at this starting point, that in 2008, the constitutional assembly of Ecuador considered taking a new approach to their political view of nature, as not just a resource, but as a living entity, capable of being legally represented. [00:03:07] Speaker 5: En el caso de Ecuador, la constitución del Ecuador ya contenía el reconocimiento al derecho a un ambiente sano en su versión anterior. En el año 2008, se decide avanzar un poco más y se decide este reconocimiento de los derechos de la naturaleza. Y allí se articulan tanto las miradas de diferentes pueblos indígenas, como también las organizaciones ambientales. [00:03:32] Speaker 2: El país es un país que los diez años pasados ha vivido por unos procesos de conflictividad [00:03:33] Speaker ?: ecoterritorial muy fuerte, ¿no? [00:03:33] Speaker 2: Porque al implantar los proyectos mineros o petroleros o agroindustriales, han habido como muchas tensiones por la gente que habitan tradicionalmente esos territorios. Ecuador ya se trata a un país de la naturaleza. Ecuador ya se trata a un país que se afecta a la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata a un país que se trata a un país que se trata a un país que se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata a un país que se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:03:45] Speaker 6: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:04:04] Speaker 2: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:04:30] Speaker 7: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:04:40] Speaker 8: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:04:42] Speaker 7: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:05:00] Speaker 5: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:05:17] Speaker 9: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:05:32] Speaker ?: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:05:33] Speaker 2: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:06:59] Speaker 3: Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. Y aquí se trata de la naturaleza. [00:07:32] Speaker 2: Known as sumac cauce. Or buen vivir. But going as far as giving it legal standing. Was still a stretch for some. [00:07:41] Speaker 3: El debate se fue dando. En diversas instancias. Con diversas intensidades. Pero, soy franco. No creí que íbamos a caminar tanto en el tema de los derechos de la naturaleza. [00:07:53] Speaker 10: Como muchos abogados consideraban que no podía darse. Porque decían, pero como la constitución, la naturaleza puede ser un sujeto de derechos, si la naturaleza no puede protegerse a sí misma, si la naturaleza no puede escribir un documento para presentarlo en la corte. Pero la comprensión vino cuando se comparó a la naturaleza con la aplicación de los derechos de los niños. Y como un niño recién nacido ya tiene todos los derechos de los niños, aunque no pueda ir a la corte y no pueda presentar un documento escrito. ¿Por qué? Porque es necesaria la tutoría de alguien de esos derechos. Y en la naturaleza el acuerdo fue entonces que tutor de los derechos, representante de los derechos de la naturaleza, podía ser cualquier ciudadano del país. [00:08:42] Speaker 9: Pero lo veíamos casi como imposible que realmente se incluya en el constituyente. Sin embargo, yo creo que el Ecuador estaba pasando por un momento muy preciso. Entonces queríamos cambiar un poco la historia de la Amazonía y de lo que estaba ocurriendo en Ecuador. [00:08:55] Speaker 6: En el campo del reconocimiento de la naturaleza como sujeto de derechos es revolucionario. [00:09:01] Speaker 9: Y era un momento de transición política, de mucho cambio, que la gente esperaba cosas muy novedosas. [00:09:07] Speaker 3: Recuerdo que algunos asambleístas de la derecha me preguntaban, en calidad de presidente de la Asamblea, si lo que íbamos era a establecer una suerte de comisarías para el gato, comisarías para el perro, pues comisarías para la lora, comisarías para el mono. Fue usado entonces como una cuestión irónica para burlarse de los derechos de la naturaleza. Pero se aprobaron los derechos de la naturaleza y estamos hablando ahora de la necesidad de contar con una declaración universal de los derechos de la naturaleza. [00:09:38] Speaker 2: As a result of the constitutional assembly, Pachamama, or Mother Earth, was recognized as a legal entity and written into the Ecuadorian constitution. Ecuador became the first country to establish the rights of nature at a national level. Nature legally could no longer be seen just as a set of natural resources to be exploited. In 2009, the nearby South American nation of Bolivia also referenced Pachamama in its constitution, acknowledging that nature had the right to protect and defend itself. These two reforms, in Bolivia and Ecuador, would soon have impacts elsewhere. [00:10:19] Speaker 6: Efectivamente, yo creo que los derechos de la naturaleza ha sido uno de los, yo diría que uno de los grandes aportes que ha dado Ecuador, y que ha dado Ecuador al mundo. Somos parte de la naturaleza. El ser humano no solo necesita de pan para vivir, no necesita pan y dinero. El ser humano necesita esta relación existencial con la naturaleza. [00:10:39] Speaker 2: Aotearoa, the land of the long white cloud, is the Maori name for New Zealand. The country's two main islands, the north and south, are home to snow-capped volcanoes, ancient forests, and rivers flowing from rugged mountains to the ocean, through canyons and across vast pasture lands. Nature is intertwined with New Zealand's national identity. [00:11:09] Speaker 11: When we introduce ourselves, we refer to our mountain, we refer to our river, we refer to our marae, or that place, the home that our forebears, our ancestors were born. It's connecting us to place. It's firmly implanting our identity. [00:11:25] Speaker 2: The first people to settle New Zealand were Polynesian explorers, the ancestors of the Maori. They established settlements on both the north and south islands some 700 years ago. The Dutch map maker and explorer Abel Tasman was the first European to visit the islands, followed by Captain James Cook 127 years later. The British government signed a treaty with Maori chiefs on February 6th, 1840. But the treaty had both an English language version and a Maori version that were not identical in content, as the Maori version welcomed settlers to share the land. But the English version stated that the Maori would become subjects of the British crown. The treaty also introduced an alien and incomprehensible concept to the Maori, that of land ownership. [00:12:19] Speaker 12: Take, for example, the Whanganui River. The people of the Whanganui River say the river is me and I am the river. And when I first looked at that, it seemed to me to be a little bit sort of something out of James Cameron's avatar. But the more you look at it, the more you realize that the indigenous people have a completely different view of nature than European New Zealanders. And so it's a question of reconciling traditional ideas, indigenous ideas, with the way in which the crown has been traditionally thinking over the years. [00:13:04] Speaker 2: The Maori tribes, or iwi, view themselves as kaitiaki, or guardians and caretakers of the land, which is viewed as a living entity. They do not view themselves as simply owners, but as stewards. They do not view themselves as the future. [00:13:19] Speaker 1: When you are born to wherever it is that you are born on the planet, that there then becomes the thing that you are connected to. The land is not real estate. That there is land and nature, and nobody owns that. I don't care if you're the owner. I don't care if you're the CEO of something that I can't spell. I really don't care. You don't belong here. [00:13:50] Speaker 2: It's hard to overstate the anger and frustration the Maori have felt for generations over the Treaty of Waitangi. On the North Island's Wanganui River, local iwi have sought rights for the river for over 140 years. Prior to European exploration and settlement, Maori grew crops along river terraces and build wares to trap eel and lamprey during upstream migrations. They built over 80 settlements and fortifications along the river's 290 kilometers. The rapid-filled river was not simply a place that provided sustenance. It was a part of who New Zealanders were and are. [00:14:31] Speaker 8: It was there before I came here. I might own the 1,400 acres that I've got. I've got a white man's piece of paper to say it's mine, but it's not mine. It belongs to everybody. I'm only the caretaker while I'm here. I can't take it with me when I go. [00:14:50] Speaker 2: For centuries, Maori used the river for transport and trade, navigating it with large dugout canoes. The 1840s brought European exploration and missionary work to the Wanganui, and by the late 19th century, large river streamers carried passengers and freight from the coast to settlements upstream. The river was advertised as the Rhine of New Zealand, attracting thousands of tourists to the Wanganui. Today, the river and its lands are used for farming, forestry and tourism. But decades of poor logging and agricultural practices have taken a toll on the Wanganui and its watershed, a well-known fact to both Maori and those of non-Mauri descent. [00:15:41] Speaker 8: If they hadn't cut a lot of that bush down, there wouldn't be so much debris coming down the river. And if they hadn't cut that bush down, the river wouldn't have flooded so much. Today, because of all the land development and the erosion problems, it's just crazy. The environment is getting hammered. [00:16:00] Speaker 2: Elsewhere in New Zealand, Maori have sought to recover their rights to Tiuera, a 2,127-square-kilometer region of ancient moss-covered forest that is home to 7,000 Tuhoi. This mountainous region historically was their homeland. The Tuhoi people are known as Natamariki Otikohu, the Children of the Mist, a name that marks them as inseparable from the land. However, in the 19th century, the New Zealand crown, or government, aiming to control fertile Tuhoi territories, pushed them off the land in a deadly scorched-earth campaign. Those Tuhoi that survived were relegated to a landlocked territory with no access to traditional fishing grounds, and they descended into extreme poverty. [00:16:54] Speaker 12: I'm sure many outsiders think that New Zealand is very much an idyllic country, and in many respects it is. But the fact of the matter is, there have been wrongs happened. As the demand for land grew stronger and stronger, the Tuhoi people were increasingly locked out of any decision-making. And then in 1954, without any discussion whatsoever with the people of the land, the particular area was made into a national park. And what that meant is that it was all governed by central government in Wellington. And those people who lived in the land, who had lived on the land for hundreds and hundreds of years, were totally locked out of its administration. [00:17:48] Speaker 1: For two generations that has been the arrangement. The National Parks Act took responsibility away from Tuhoi people and took it to the capital, under the guise that they could better govern and manage a land they knew nothing about. [00:18:09] Speaker 12: And it's my experience that if there were two parcels of land, one Māori land, one general land, and land was required for development, land would be taken under the Public Works Act, and it was invariably Māori land that was taken. [00:18:25] Speaker 2: National Park goals in New Zealand generally include preserving nature and facilitating visitation. But here, Tiyawira National Park conflicted with a connection between people and place that was so essential to the Tuhoi. It was an artificial structure of an air of management laid over a land that did not need it. [00:18:46] Speaker 1: Living with the land, living with nature is hard. But hardship is the thing that makes us tough. You then start to see how much you need each other. And so when government has taken that responsibility away from Tuhoi people, our relationships to each other eroded. [00:19:11] Speaker 2: It was at this crossroads, both at Tiyawira and on the Whanganui River, that the New Zealand government realized it needed to address the wrongs inflicted on the Māori. Could recognizing both nature's rights and those of the indigenous Māori people provide a solution to a century-old conflict? [00:19:32] Speaker 12: In terms of the New Zealand recognition of the rights of nature, we were dealing with a number of these settlements and dealing with the aspirations of the various tribes. And then we had to say, well, if we transfer the river or ownership of the river to the local iwi, it'll be World War III. And if we transferred a national park or what had been a national park to the iwi, there would be trouble because people would say we were giving away something that was their birthright. And so we had to try and explore ways in which we could reach just and durable settlements without getting ourselves into trouble. I mean, good old politics at its best. And the result is a truly unique settlement. And fortunately, the various groups that we were dealing with provided the answer. Get away from Western concepts of ownership into something else and recognizing that maybe the river just owns itself. maybe the forest, the Uruweras own themselves. [00:20:49] Speaker 2: The Tiuwera Act of 2014 granted the legal rights of a person to the former Tiuwera National Park. For the 40,000 Tuhoi, the return of Tiuwera was more than just about land-having rights. It was central to Tuhoi identity, a key to a sustainable future. The agreement, part of a larger $170 million settlement from the Crown to settle the historic grievances held by the Tuhoi, also included a public apology. [00:21:21] Speaker 12: The Crown apologizes for its unjust and excessive behavior and the burden carried by generations of Tuhoi who suffer greatly and who carry the pain of their ancestors. Let these words guide our way to a green stone door, Tataupunamu, which looks back on the past and closes it, which looks forward to the future and opens it. [00:21:53] Speaker 2: Under the Tiuwera agreement, the Tuhoi will share management of the lands with the Department of Conservation, but neither will own the land. The land will own itself. The goal is to seek to establish an intergenerational principle-based system to manage Tiuwera drawn from Maori traditions and a focused responsibility to the land that involves asking what is best for the land rather than a set of regulations. [00:22:23] Speaker 1: Well, how can a bunch of humans represent the voice of nature? It's a board that does not represent humans. We have this delightful conversation about things like, oh, well that stakeholder wants that and that person... We don't see humans. No, no. I am nature. Nature is connected to everything. I have a memory that is timeless. I can't see things in annual plans. For us, what applies here is that 1,000 years of history, we don't live in legislation. [00:23:03] Speaker 2: Three years later, in 2017, similar rights were also extended to the Whanganui River. In a landmark decision that made global headlines, the Whanganui River was granted the same rights as a person. This recognition allowed the river to be heard in court. The Whanganui River claimed settlement known as the Tiawa Tupui in Maori describes the Whanganui River as an indivisible and living whole. From the mountains to the sea, incorporating its tributaries and all its physical and metaphysical elements. Appointed with the care of the river are two guardians, one from the government and another from the Whanganui River Iwi. The details will be worked out in time, and many in New Zealand and elsewhere in the world are optimistic about the model. [00:23:59] Speaker 12: When one looks at it for the first time, it's strange, the idea of a natural resource owning itself. But once you reconcile it with the aspirations of the indigenous people, then there is a way through. [00:24:14] Speaker 8: I'm the river and the river is me. You've got to respect the river, you know, she's beautiful, she's a beautiful thing. It's... it's our life. [00:24:26] Speaker 1: Reconnection with land and nature makes us good people. It can work anywhere that people respect nature. [00:24:37] Speaker 2: The rights of nature developments in New Zealand are part of a growing number of nations redefining their relationship with nature. Iceland specified in its 1971 Nature Conservation Act that humans and nature should engage in such a way that life or land be not needlessly wasted, nor see fresh water or air polluted. The High Court of India's Urukaran State ruled that then Ganggochi and Yamunotri glaciers, as well as lakes and forests in the Himalayan region, have legal rights. The court also ruled the Ganges River sacred to a billion Indians, and the Yamuna River had the same legal rights as people. The rivers, both badly polluted, were to be legal and living entities, which advocates hoped would improve efforts to clean up these watersheds. Though in July 2017, India's Supreme Court overturned the Ganges and Yamuna River's ruling, it did uphold the ruling on Himalayan glaciers, lakes and forests. [00:25:48] Speaker 6: I think that many countries are having some fantastic decisions. But for us, who live in urban areas, I think it's very important to recognize that it's part of nature. [00:26:01] Speaker 10: For the people of large cities, the distance from nature has been very big. Many times, children in schools, in schools, in schools, they don't know where they consume water. So, the problem is how to make sure everyone understand it. [00:26:21] Speaker 2: Could the rights of nature take root in a populous, increasingly urbanized nation with the world's largest economy? In 2013, the City Council of Santa Monica, California, with broad public support, voted unanimously to pass a Sustainability Rights Ordinance to help ensure that nature will continue to thrive. [00:26:43] Speaker 13: Right now, it's really urgent in cities to really reconsider how we develop. And that doesn't just mean build buildings. How do we, as human beings, evolve and develop? We need healthy relationships with nature. And nature is a community, like the human community. What does that look like in law? That looks like in Santa Monica, the Sustainability Bill of Rights. [00:27:06] Speaker 2: Santa Monica is a city of 100,000 people west of Los Angeles on the shores of the Pacific Ocean. It is just one of over 150 communities in the United States to enact a Community Bill of Rights. Santa Monica is a progressive, affluent community with a strong commitment to sustainability. But after hearing about rights of nature movements elsewhere, they wanted to take their efforts a step further. [00:27:34] Speaker 14: Santa Monica has been looked at as a national leader in urban sustainability for decades. We were literally the first city with a sustainable city plan in the United States way back in 1994. [00:27:46] Speaker 13: By 2010, when the Citizens United decision was advancing, great concern about are we going to have more money going to polluters? What are we going to do in a place like Santa Monica to safeguard what we're already doing? Is our plan enough? And hence, the rights of nature was laid on the table. [00:28:09] Speaker 2: In 1994, Santa Monica established a comprehensive sustainability plan. The 2013 Rights of Nature Ordinance stated that natural communities and ecosystems possess fundamental and inalienable rights to exist and flourish. Residents can now bring forward legal action on behalf of nature. [00:28:32] Speaker 14: And so really that bold statement on behalf of the city that we all have the right to clean water, we all have the right to clean air, and nature has to have the ability to thrive and so nature has rights as well. We put all of those principles into the Sustainable Rights Ordinance and we actually made it enforceable. [00:28:50] Speaker 13: And so development here is a really big struggle. And some of the developers are big corporate entities. Their rights to gain profits do not supersede the community's rights or, most importantly, the rights of nature to thrive. What does that mean? There's a boost with some people's thinking about it. Our planet and our watershed are not about profit making. And we need to not maximize its destruction for profits. [00:29:17] Speaker 2: While the new law has been highly popular with residents of Santa Monica, implementation has not been as successful. [00:29:24] Speaker 14: The city has struggled with the same thing that rights of nature has struggled with throughout the world, which is how do you actually make it enforceable. In the case of Santa Monica, we're also a very built out city which is very different from a lot of these areas that have a river system to protect or a rain forest or a pine forest. And so the sort of nature that you would really sue over to protect, really it's a very urban environment in which we all live. And really Santa Monica Bay would be the one natural area that exists there. And the Clean Water Act is a pretty darn good tool to use, which is federal law, to make sure that Santa Monica Bay gets cleaned up. [00:30:02] Speaker 15: Here in the states, the notion of environmental standing is fairly well established. So you don't need the habitat to have its own sort of legal existence for it to be protected if enough people care. Litigation is expensive and I think certainly the city can do it on its own nickel. But for private individuals to do it, you have to get a lawyer interested and the prospect of having to, you know, pay private counsel a $10,000, $20,000, $50,000 retainer is going to turn off a lot of people. [00:30:35] Speaker 14: From the standpoint of actually any citizen using the law to enforce against violation of those rights, that has yet to occur. [00:30:45] Speaker 2: Despite the rights of nature not having immediate legal impacts in Santa Monica, supporters believe that the idea can inspire people to rethink their relationship to nature. [00:30:57] Speaker 13: You know, could it be made more effective? Absolutely. And I think every community needs to see what's the foothold that they can get and to internalize what are they already working on that could then be uplifted. And if nothing else, the rights of nature allows us to reconceptualize who we are part of Mother Earth. [00:31:20] Speaker 14: I think there's a real big question on the rights of nature, whether these are just a great value from the standpoint of awareness to the public. What's really interesting about the Santa Monica experience is back in the 1990s, our groundwater supply was so polluted that literally 0% of our water, our drinking water was coming from our local groundwater. But this city boldly went after the polluters to actually clean up the aquifers and provide the public, restore our right to our local water supply to the public. It was extraordinary. And in a lot of ways, it was sort of, you know, the motivation to show that, you know, this right for nature really can exist. And Santa Monica has already fought for it using different methods to make it happen. So that's why this work is so important to give these sorts of examples of realizing that you can speak up for resources that can't speak up for themselves. [00:32:18] Speaker 2: Several hundred miles east of California is the state of Utah. Home to world-renowned national parks such as Zion and Arches, a desert state, Utah is facing environmental issues of its own. Great Salt Lake is under pressure from water diversions and expanding population and climate change. Stakeholders are exploring whether and how laws might be changed to guarantee a minimum inflow for Great Salt Lake, which currently has no right to water. [00:32:56] Speaker 16: Whether you characterize it as a right of nature or whether a river is entitled to have a water right or a lake is entitled to have a water right allocated to it, that's a very difficult thing to do in a state like Utah where the water is already fully appropriated. Convincing our very conservative legislature to do anything that would even be remotely viewed as treading on private property rights is really problematic. [00:33:22] Speaker 2: Great Salt Lake is a Utah icon as famous as the Mormon Tabernacle Choir or its powdery ski slopes. [00:33:30] Speaker 17: I still remember the first day I came out here and I stood there and looked around and I was just blown away. I couldn't believe that a place like this existed. [00:33:38] Speaker 2: The lake is an extraordinary ecosystem vital for over 5 million migratory birds traveling north and south across the Americas. [00:33:48] Speaker 18: And we get anywhere between 30, 50, even heading up towards 100% of North America's populations of some of these bird species. [00:33:56] Speaker 2: Great Salt Lake also contributes to Utah's economy through the brine, shrimp and minerals industry, as well as through the money spent by bird watchers, hunters and tourists. All economic and recreational activities are dependent on adequate water levels in the lake. But changing climate and a population expected to double to 6 million by 2060 will create pressure to build more dams and divert more water from streams and rivers, including the Bear River, the lake's major tributary. In short, the future of this unique resource is threatened unless a right to water is established. [00:34:37] Speaker 19: The water picture and the Great Salt Lake relationship is a very fragile one. The lake is very dependent upon water. So as the population grows and they consider what their values are, Great Salt Lake oftentimes is left out of that picture. [00:34:57] Speaker 18: You've got greater water demand for irrigation. You've got greater water demand for cooling, for electricity. So we've got this squeeze from population growth and climate change. Utah water in general, and Great Salt Lake as well, is kind of trapped in the jaws of this vise that are closing on us. [00:35:15] Speaker 17: The lake is at 4193, right now the historic low is 4191. And so we're within two feet of the historic low. Where the salinity of the south arm rises to the point where the brine shrimp industry is impacted. Where the harbors are impacted. Recreation, birds. That's our biggest challenge I think going forward is keeping water in the lake. Lakes don't do well about water. [00:35:45] Speaker 20: The ways in which water has been used in Utah and the laws that govern it originated at a time when perhaps it made sense to incentivize people to use as much water as they could to help provide a strong economic foundation for the more arid states in the American West. [00:36:02] Speaker 2: Back then, environmental concerns, preserving water for lakes, wildlife and recreation, or supplying water to huge cities were not factors in determining water needs. As a result, current Utah water law is based on a belief system that no longer matches today's reality. Agriculture, which consists of about 2% of Utah's total economic output, uses about 80% of Utah's total water. While indoor water use is only about 2% of all water used in the state. [00:36:37] Speaker 21: The system as it's currently set up actually works against using water wisely and incentivizes farmers to use as much water as possible. Even though they don't actually need that much water to use it or lose it principle. There's actually plenty of water to expand the population without developing new sources of water. We are not running out of water. [00:37:03] Speaker 2: But even though plenty of water is available for Great Salt Lake, because it has no legal rights, the lake cannot purchase or lease water shares. [00:37:13] Speaker 17: The law simply does not allow us to set water aside just to sit there in the lake for the values of the lake. The state water laws are such that the water in the lake is considered wasted. Looking for an opportunity for groups to be able to go out and buy water rights, lease water rights from agriculture in order to keep water flowing to the lake. It's just we don't have a mechanism to do that right now. [00:37:39] Speaker 2: One solution would be a viable in-stream flow law, which would allow water rights holders such as farmers to sell, donate, or transfer their water rights to a river or lake, providing a financial incentive. Utah water law does include protections to the environment, stating that a water right can only be granted if by removing the water from a river or stream, the environment will not be affected. While this part of the law has been overlooked in the past, pushing for its enforcement could return water shares to the state, thereby increasing water flows into Great Salt Lake. [00:38:16] Speaker 16: The legal tool is there to force them to. By forcing it forces takings, lawsuits, and other things. It will simply delay the implementation of any of this for decades while it works through the courts. If it can be done through market-based transfers without violating priorities and without violating property rights, I think we'll find willing sellers who would do a variety of things. The biggest problem with that is the environmental community has trouble competing on the economic basis, and that often leaves the environment on the outs looking in. [00:38:50] Speaker 2: Could a rights of nature law help Great Salt Lake? Some think so, but gaining significant public support could take time. [00:38:58] Speaker 18: I think the reason we have water concerns for Great Salt Lake is because the Great Salt Lake is an afterthought if it even makes it that far. And if we can build public concern about Great Salt Lake, then that will build up into political support. [00:39:13] Speaker 16: And to me that's the key, is if this can be couched in terms of we are trying to sustain this resource for the benefit of all of us. And I think today it probably is more feasible than ever before. [00:39:26] Speaker 2: Utah isn't unique. Many nations and communities across the globe struggle to provide rights for their ecosystems. Ecuador, despite being the birthplace of the modern Pachamama movement in 2008, has yet to see the law become fully operational. [00:39:46] Speaker 7: I think people in Ecuador really like the fact that we have this rights of nature law. I think they're proud that this country was the first one to include that kind of thing in their constitution. But I do believe that there's a big chasm between this law as it's written and the way that it's put into practice. For Ecuador, I think in a big way, it is left quite empty. [00:40:14] Speaker 2: In 2011, a section of the Villa Cabomba River in Ecuador was damaged by road construction. An American couple who owned property along the river sued and eventually prevailed in court. [00:40:29] Speaker 22: If you cut down the width of the river by half, the river current picks up everything that was thrown in and takes it downstream. [00:40:39] Speaker 2: Ecuador upheld its rights of nature law, making global headlines and setting a legal precedent for the application of the rights of nature. However, enforcement of the ruling has proven difficult. Very little has actually been done to restore the damaged section of the Villa Cabomba River. In other places in Ecuador, the law seems to have no force, as mining activities continue with no plans for the mitigation of environmental damage. [00:41:10] Speaker 9: Ecuador, a pesar de ser el país que reconoce derechos de la naturaleza, permite que entre la minería a gran escala. En este mismo periodo, nosotros incluso hicimos un juicio contra la empresa Acuacorriente, que es la empresa que tiene el primer contrato en condominador para el tema de minería a gran escala. Entonces, había muchos casos que eran evidentes, el tema de la minería era evidente para un país que nunca ha tenido minería a gran escala, que de repente lo tenga, teniendo derechos de la naturaleza. [00:41:35] Speaker 10: Por ejemplo, en la constitución se sostiene la defensa de las fuentes de agua y de los cauces de agua. Sin embargo, de aquello, en este momento la ley de minería dice que a las mineras se les tiene que garantizar todos los servicios, incluyendo los servicios hídricos, lo cual significa que la minera sí puede afectar los cauces y las nacientes de agua. Estas contradicciones gubernamentales tienen, de hecho, una serie de condicionantes muy difíciles para que los derechos de la naturaleza se apliquen. [00:42:11] Speaker 3: Primero hay gente que nunca va a aceptar que la naturaleza tenga derechos. Ya en la práctica tenemos serias dificultades, porque para los abogados y abogadas, para los jueces y juezas, es difícil dar ese paso. Entonces muchos no entienden que ni siquiera se requiere un marco jurídico, leyes predeterminadas para poner en vigencia los derechos de la naturaleza, porque la constitución abre la puerta para aplicarlos sin ley alguna. Es más, yo tengo mucho recelo de que se quiera establecer una ley que norme los derechos de la naturaleza, cuando los derechos de la naturaleza deberían permear todas las leyes. [00:42:48] Speaker 2: Ecuador. Ecuador's world-famous Galápagos Islands lie 1,000 km from the mainland. This unusual archipelago, where Charles Darwin did much of his pioneering work on natural selection, is home to a rich array of wildlife, including species found nowhere else on Earth. The islands, with their white sand beaches, animals and tropical vegetation, are increasingly popular with tourists. In 2018, the island saw over 225,000 visitors, nearly 20 times the level from the 1960s. The population of the Galápagos has also increased from about 1,000 in the 1950s to over 30,000 people today. This human tide has created significant conservation challenges, with a greater need for fresh water supplies, electrical generation and waste disposal. Increased construction, including that of illegal hotels and houses, pose even more challenges. Invasive plant and animal species are also threatening the Galápagos' unique biodiversity. [00:43:59] Speaker 4: Twenty endemic species are now critically endangered. [00:44:09] Speaker 2: In 1998, a special regime for the Galápagos Islands was established to help manage tourism, and a new law was designed to restrict migration to the islands. But these efforts only brought marginal improvements. A subsequent study recommended a cap on visitors, but the report was set aside, and its recommendations not implemented. [00:44:33] Speaker 7: Basically, when we talk about rights of nature versus development, versus human interest, versus economy, all those things, it really boils down to money. It's like, what do we value? Is this worthwhile or is this worthwhile? We have now said, economy is everything. And I think we're really moving farther and farther away from any kind of potential to recognize that nature itself has value and should be recognized as having rights to exist. [00:45:07] Speaker 2: If tourism and development are detrimental to nature in the Galápagos, could the new rights of nature law be used to limit that development? Perhaps yes, but whether the law will be applied is another question. The money earned by tourism may limit the political will to enforce such a law. [00:45:26] Speaker 4: So, it's going to be a process within the Ecuador itself, how to implement those rights that will take, possibly, decades. [00:45:39] Speaker 9: It's like when there was a slavery in the United States. You do all the issue of abolishing the slavery and that the slave goes from object to subject to rights. So, it's not legal to take it. It's not legal to take it. It's not legal to take it. Because it's absurd. You understand that it's absurd. It's absurd. Today, we understand that these laws, that simply do not harm the nature and the contaminant, are absurd. To treat it like a person, you should say, why do we not let it contaminate? So, it's a very radical change. It's a very radical change to think about the object to subject. It takes time. Definitely, here in Ecuador, we haven't been able to implement it 100%. It takes time. But for us, it's one of the only solutions to understand how to achieve this balance with the nature and to understand it as a person. [00:46:29] Speaker 2: So, what does the future hold for the rights of nature? Changes in the legal system are a reflection of social changes, which typically take time to take root and grow. The rights of nature movement reflects a new way of thinking about the human relationship with nature. And with patience and perseverance, change can happen. [00:46:52] Speaker 5: If we want to think about what is the meaning of the recognition of the rights of nature, I like to think about it as an opportunity. It's to say, an opportunity to begin to generate questions. I think there were questions that were already answered in a certain way. I'm going to start to see, in the recognition of the rights of nature, a door open to begin to show the diversity of ways to work with the ecological issues that exist around the world, and many times have been opened. [00:47:21] Speaker 10: I think it's fundamental to recognize the nature as our mother, all living beings as our brothers, and recognize that society won't have a good exit from the future if we break those ties of family with our mother and our brothers. [00:47:42] Speaker 3: The rights of nature are an opportunity. I would like to see it as an opportunity to build another civilization. A civilization that will definitely overcome the anthropocentric vision. We don't want that the human being is the center and the dominator of all nature, but that we all have the opportunity, all living beings, including human beings, of course, to live with dignity. [00:48:08] Speaker 2: Despite challenges, the Rights of Nature movement continues to gain momentum. In New Zealand, following the Whanganui River and Tiwira settlements, attention turned to Mount Taranaki. In 1865, the New Zealand government took the mountain from the local iwi and gave ownership of it and surrounding lands to European settlers. But the Maori view this snow-capped, dormant volcano as an ancestor and seek to care for it in that fashion, not simply as one might care for a piece of property. [00:48:41] Speaker 11: If you talk about legal personality, I mean, ultimately someone needs to be the voice. In order to make those decisions, you need a set of values. Now, that's tough because whose values? You know, if you think about a mountain being your grandparent, it actually just starts with how would you like your grandparent to be treated? And so, you know, you think about that in the context of it becomes quite personal and you can start thinking about actually what is important. [00:49:09] Speaker 2: In 2017, a memorandum of understanding was signed by the Maori and the New Zealand government to give the mountain legal personhood. The Maori hope their story can continue to inspire the world to reconsider our relationship with nature. [00:49:28] Speaker 11: But I think, you know, we've got an opportunity to demonstrate what can be achieved. Because we have a once-in-a-generation opportunity to develop a new model, which could be a blueprint not only for New Zealand but I think globally, from the perspective of how we care for places, and I think also the relationship that we can have as people. [00:49:47] Speaker 2: Today, over 100 nations have some form of legal rights for nature in their constitutions or federal laws. The United Nations has taken up the question of considering a Universal Declaration for the Rights of Nature. And though courts in industrialized countries seem less willing to grant nature a legal right as they have in Ecuador or New Zealand, each step provides a model and inspiration for others. They provide a foundation for a more sustainable future for humans and the physical world they share. [00:50:25] Speaker 1: The reconnection of people with the land has to do with restoring our relationships to each other. Regrowing our sense of purpose, our sense of community and our kindness to each other. We get that because of what we observe about nature. We see the relationships between trees and insects, between mist and land, between rock and mud. And we see how in that extreme diversity, everything works together. Reconnection with land and nature is your sense of security about the future. [00:51:23] Speaker ?: Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature. Reconnection with land and nature.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →