About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of The Exact Moment This Officer Realized He Screwed Up from Audit the Court, published November 17, 2026. The transcript contains 7,366 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"on may 17th 2025 deputies with the el paso county sheriff's office in colorado responded to a disturbance call at a motel and contacted defendant timmy davis as he was driving away from the property sergeant jared harman who was named deputy of the month by the east colorado springs rotary club in..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: on may 17th 2025 deputies with the el paso county sheriff's office in colorado responded to a disturbance call at a motel and contacted defendant timmy davis as he was driving away from the property sergeant jared harman who was named deputy of the month by the east colorado springs rotary club in february of 2026 transported mr davis to a hospital for a blood draw sergeant harman deactivated his body-worn camera before the draw was performed so the procedure was not included in the footage mr darvis was subsequently charged in the el paso county court in colorado with driving under the influence which included the lesser included offense of driving while ability impaired and driving with excessive alcohol content the defense filed a pre-trial motion under colorado's body-worn camera statute seeking to exclude evidence stemming from the unrecorded portion of the arrest and a hearing was held on the issue people call sergeant jared harman
[00:00:56] Speaker 2: sergeant if you'd approach me else for anyone thank you honor and good afternoon sergeant harman would you please state your full name and spell your last name for the record sergeant jared harman
[00:01:05] Sergeant Jared Harman: h-a-r-m-o-n thank you and what do you do for work uh i am currently the beacon middle health sergeant
[00:01:11] Speaker 2: and um who are you the beacon middle health sergeant for uh the el paso county sheriff's office well let's start with how long have you been employed by the el paso county sheriff's office and i don't know i've spent 22 years
[00:01:22] Speaker 4: and judge i apologize before we proceed that i would like the court to give the garrity
[00:01:25] Speaker 5: advisement thank you i do need to advise you that anything you say must be said of your own free will and without according to any threats or promises or coercion anything you say may be of course used against you or any other person in any subsequent criminal proceeding in this court um or any courts of the state and you do have under the law as you know um a privilege to refuse to make any disclosure which might tend to incriminate you you do have a right to consult with an attorney regarding this if you wish are you wishing at this time to consult with an attorney for any reason no ma'am the court
[00:02:00] Speaker 1: gives sergeant harman a so-called garrity advisement and he confirms that he does not wish to consult with an attorney before continuing with his testimony the so-called garrity warning takes its name from the 1967 case of garrity v new jersey in which new jersey police officers were investigated for allegedly fixing traffic tickets during the investigation the officers were informed that they could exercise their fifth amendment privilege against self-incrimination if they wished but that doing so would cost them their jobs the officers cooperated but when they were criminally prosecuted they moved to suppress their statements as involuntary and coerced the supreme court held that the threat of being fired was sufficiently coercive as to undermine the officers free choice and render their statements involuntary and subject to suppression well here as sergeant harman was testifying as part of his job duties and his expected testimony could potentially incriminate him the garrity advisement served to ensure that he understood his rights to refuse to incriminate himself
[00:02:57] Speaker 2: and to consult with an attorney sergeant do you remember the morning may 17th 2025 at or about 12 30 a.m or zero zero thirty hours uh vaguely but due to the body cam yes i do remember that and do you remember what hospital you transported uh mr davis to the memorial central and that was for a blood draw it was do you remember what happened about 1 21 a.m on that same day
[00:03:21] Sergeant Jared Harman: um i'm assuming that's the point where my body cam was turned off this time you know the people move
[00:03:26] Speaker 5: to admit people's number two and others any objection no objection okay people's two is admitted you may publish as you wish thank you
[00:03:40] Speaker 2: and sergeant we just saw at the end of that body board camera footage that there was a beeper buzz um there was some tapping and then you put your hand over the camera could you
[00:03:52] Sergeant Jared Harman: explain what happened there yeah the beeper buzz is the camera every so often it lets you know that it's still on and running um and then my hand over the screen was me turning it off you turn the camera off yourself correct why did you do that because my brain stopped working there and i turned my camera off when i'm in a hospital so that i can protect hipa violation from happening so that was to protect
[00:04:15] Speaker 2: personal information correct so what's your role in the blood draw procedure itself so when a lot of
[00:04:22] Sergeant Jared Harman: this comes in i verify when the blood is drawn um and then i watch the blood being taken from the person
[00:04:29] Speaker 4: let's just start with were you in court last week regarding a similar body worn camera issue yes ma'am and you were read the guarantee advisement correct and you indicated you wanted to speak to counsel yes ma'am did you speak to counseling not yet no okay so you have not spoken to counsel at all regarding this matter no ma'am so when you cited hipaa earlier that is not your normal practice of
[00:05:00] Sergeant Jared Harman: patrolling it depends if i forget it's turned off so there are times when i'll go through i just don't
[00:05:07] Speaker 4: even think about it being on or off okay so my question is how many other instances like this where you have a blood draw in the hospital do you turn your body warm camera off for the blood draw
[00:05:17] Sergeant Jared Harman: i'd say quite a few a lot i don't know i don't know what a lot would be like i said this first two cases i've ever come up against this on okay so at least two at least two okay so i have some really
[00:05:30] Speaker 4: boring law statutes to go through with you go for it um so apologies beforehand but sergeant you were aware that there was a body one camera statue that was implemented on july 1st 2023 correct
[00:05:44] Sergeant Jared Harman: is that the 23 24 31 902 i am not i'm actually not aware of that statute to tell you the truth i know it's a stem from the senate bill 317 correct that i don't know um but i would ask the court to take
[00:05:59] Speaker 4: judicial notice of 24 31 902 or take judicial medicine that's existence so your testimony is today that you are not aware of the body one camera statue that was implemented not in that exact
[00:06:12] Sergeant Jared Harman: statue no ma'am okay i would have to look it up and see our okay if i painted you a copy of that
[00:06:19] Speaker 4: statute would it refresh your recollection i'll tell you i never read it before okay you've never read the body one statue okay if there's an instance where your body one camera is turned off you are to record
[00:06:30] Sergeant Jared Harman: and document that correct it's yours yeah i think the policy says something you're supposed to give a verbal confirmation of why you're turning it off okay and you did not write or report any anything about that body one camera i don't think i don't think since we've had body cameras i've ever verbally documented anything when turning a body camera on or off okay so you would be in violation
[00:06:54] Speaker 4: of your policies and procedures correct yes ma'am okay in this case um you did have your body one camera on for the majority of the interaction with mr davis correct yes ma'am okay however at the hospital hospital during the blood draw um no other officers with you no it was just you just me there was no other means of recording the blood draw that you were aware of actually there's a camera inside of that room as far as i understand okay there's a camera and did you collect that surveillance footage okay are you aware of anybody else that collected that surveillance footage no ma'am so me as a defense attorney today standing here would not have that surveillance footage probably not okay so part of the the reason why the senate or less later and your department initiated some kind of body warm camera policy is for a means of accountability correct yes ma'am it's to ensure that blood draws are done
[00:07:53] Sergeant Jared Harman: properly correct i don't think the body camera would say that the blood draw was done properly no right but
[00:08:01] Speaker 4: defense attorneys or other individuals can watch and make sure standard policies and procedures were done correctly right if the camera captures it yes okay and so there is no other means or mechanism if a camera doesn't capture it for somebody to make sure that the blood draws done correctly
[00:08:20] Sergeant Jared Harman: sure it's me right you guys entrusted me don't quote loss before buying cameras that's all we had
[00:08:28] Speaker 4: right but there's now by one camera in place statutes placed correct corruption correct exactly because now the statute states they're the presumption of misconduct if the body one cameras turn off correct okay so
[00:08:41] Sergeant Jared Harman: body cameras are great but they're fallible so they don't catch everything and i can give me examples of why on the ddui body cameras are not great before we continue i want to give a big thanks to
[00:08:52] Speaker 1: the sponsor of this episode rocket money running a youtube channel involves a surprising number of subscriptions between editing software research tools and services i occasionally need for a particular project i've definitely signed up for things use them once or twice and completely forgotten i was still paying for the months later that's one of the reasons i've been using rocket money one thing i really like about rocket money is that it brings all my recurring subscriptions together in one place so i can see exactly what i'm paying for and if i find something i no longer use with rocket money i can cancel it in just a couple of taps what i also like is that you can connect your financial accounts and see your transactions in one dashboard you can even organize your spending into categories which makes it much easier to separate business expenses from personal ones and see where your money is going and the best part is that you don't have to spend hours going through bank statements or keeping track of everything in a spreadsheet rocket money makes it easier to stay informed about your finances without turning it into another task on your to-do list rocket money's premium features are worth paying for but you can start with a seven-day free trial sign up at rocketmoney.com audit the court using the link in the description or by scanning the qr code on screen if it's not for you you can easily cancel in the app before your trial ends thanks again to rocket money for sponsoring today's episode so let's pivot to uh
[00:10:19] Speaker 2: the body warm camera and the statutes and policies surrounding that what is your awareness as the procedure for body or care pertaining to hipaa or personal information like that well now it's updated
[00:10:31] Sergeant Jared Harman: as of the case of yesterday so now my body camera will be running completely every time i do a body
[00:10:36] Speaker 2: every time i do a blood draw so to your understanding of policy you properly follow the procedure um i i
[00:10:43] Sergeant Jared Harman: will say that's kind of two s no i do not follow the policy procedure because i stay updated with it the way i should have um but based on my belief at the time yes i believe i follow the policy so sergeant
[00:10:57] Speaker 5: harman did testify today that he did not follow the procedure right that's correct as noted and as
[00:11:07] Speaker 4: testified to sergeant harman is also subject to another body or camera violation for doing the same exact thing it doesn't happen it's not common what division hurt the issue uh division i believe g
[00:11:25] Speaker 5: division g recently dealt with this issue with this officer that's correct he did not testify right
[00:11:31] Speaker 4: because of his invocation of counseling did that get um reset it did get reset for him to consult with
[00:11:37] Speaker 5: an attorney i just don't i help me out because i fail to see how often sergeant harman observing the blood draw equates to a recording by other means so so it's your position that recorded by other means can include the testimony of the officer and his observations yes your honor so you're you're conceding
[00:12:04] Speaker 6: that this officer did not follow protocol um no i don't think that's quite correct i think we can suppose but not concede but you didn't have anybody from the officer say that it was a hipaa issue you
[00:12:15] Speaker 5: didn't have anybody from the hospital say it was a hipaa issue whether it was prohibited by pop hospital
[00:12:20] Speaker 6: policy or anything along those not specifically a hipaa issue your honor but just a privacy interest
[00:12:26] Speaker 5: generally doesn't this talk about redactions the blurring of information that might be on a video that might raise privacy concerns uh yeah that's that is true that doesn't raise me a justification for turning off a camera i miss reading that oh no i think that's accurate so you're saying a mistaken
[00:12:49] Speaker 6: belief is sufficient to rebut the presumption yes because the presumption is only given if it shows
[00:12:59] Speaker 4: intentional disabling rather than negligence just a brief response there is nothing in the statute that requires intentionality or bad faith thank you i'll take this under advisement i'll issue a written
[00:13:13] Speaker 1: order before readiness at the conclusion of the hearing the judge takes the defense's motion under advisement stating that she will issue a written order before the pre-trial readiness conference colorado's body-worn camera statute which is codified in section 24-31 902 of the colorado revised statutes requires a peace officer to wear and activate a body-worn camera when responding to a call for service entering into a premises for the purposes of enforcing the law or in response to a call for service during a welfare check except for a motorist assist or during any interaction with the public initiated by the peace officer for the purpose of enforcing the law or investigating possible violations of the law in other words when an officer is performing law enforcement functions during an encounter with a member of the public the camera generally must be recording the statute does permit an officer to turn the camera off in limited circumstances including to avoid recording personal information that is not case related but here the blood draw was evidence collection and therefore directly related to the case against mr davis the statute also states that if an officer fails to activate a camera as required there is a quote-unquote permissive inference in a subsequent legal proceeding that the missing footage would have reflected misconduct by the officer now because the inference is quote-unquote permissive the jury is allowed but not required to assume that the officer engaged in misconduct while their camera was off additionally the statute attaches a quote-unquote rebuttable presumption of inadmissibility to any statements or conduct sought to be introduced in a prosecution through the peace officer that were not recorded due to the peace officer's failure to activate or reactivate the body-worn camera as required and that were not quote-unquote recorded by other means this means that the evidence must be excluded unless the prosecution presents sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption of inadmissibility now here the people argued that sergeant harman's own observations of the blood draw constituted recording by other means a position that the judge ultimately rejected including that sergeant harman violated the statute by turning off his body camera the case then proceeded to a jury trial where after the party's opening statements the people called deputy draper who was first on the scene in response to the motel disturbance call followed by
[00:15:27] Speaker 4: sergeant harman you will also hear from officer harman actually sorry let me correct that sergeant harman you will hear testimony from him today that there is a law in polygraph there's procedures and policies but most importantly a law that says there are certain times when you have to keep your body on camera on there's certain times it's okay keep it off this court found that he violated that wall he didn't follow the law now you don't have to think that mr harman is a bad person right but you can certainly think that it's concerning if a sergeant who is tasked with training other officers training the investigating officer on this case the only other officer you'll hear from right you can certainly find it concerning that he is sworn an oath to uphold the law to protect mr davis to protect you all to protect myself and that he violated that law so the district attorney said that this is a simple case and i encourage you to look past that assertion people please tell your first ones
[00:16:41] Speaker 7: yes your honor people would call deputy draper what is it that you do for work sir i'm a patrol
[00:16:45] Speaker 8: deputy with the el paso county sheriff's office and how long have you been with el paso county
[00:16:50] Speaker 7: sheriff's office since 2018. being that you've been with episode for several years were you on patrol on may 17th 2025 i was and around midnight did you respond to any calls i responded to the travel lodge
[00:17:05] Speaker 8: in the cimarron hills district of el paso county in el paso county colorado colorado yes
[00:17:11] Speaker 7: what happened what happened when you responded to that call when you arrived on scene
[00:17:15] Speaker 8: um so we were dispatched to the a disturbance um and when i arrived um as i was pulling up to the scene um mr davis who's over there um was leaving the travel lodge and got into his car as i was pulling up behind him and started driving away um i had initiated my red and blue lights and he continued to drive away i got out of the vehicle and yelled for him to stop and which he eventually did and why did you ask him to stop because at that point i was there investigating a
[00:17:53] Speaker 7: possible crime so then so if he exited his vehicle you obviously saw him did anything stand out about his
[00:17:59] Speaker 8: what you saw on him or spoke to him um his voice was slurred um when i got closer his eyes were bloodshot glassy did he make any statements to you uh he had made a statement that he had literally just got here okay did he say from where he came from um yeah he he said that he was celebrating uh a birthday of a co-worker and they were a local a strip club that he yeah he was there did he make any statements about what he did um at that adult place um i had um i had asked him if he had been drinking um and he had said yes he had had i believe a couple beers and or a couple shots did any other officers
[00:18:50] Speaker 7: arrive on scene to assist you uh deputy collinger and uh sergeant herman and so after those other two officers arrived on scene um what was your hand in the investigation um once uh mr davis was
[00:19:06] Speaker 8: detained and express consent was explained to him deputy calling or sergeant herman basically they're the ones that dealt with mr davis and i left to go to another call and so at that point did your
[00:19:18] Speaker 7: involvement in this investigation end correct no more further questions your honor okay um so you
[00:19:23] Speaker 4: didn't see or necessarily have time to look at any driving behaviors right i wasn't looking for driving behaviors so you didn't see any particular driving behaviors right no and he did stop correct correct and he stopped within that same parking lot that we've been talking about right yes he didn't pull
[00:19:40] Speaker 8: out onto like a street right so no he didn't pull out onto a street he stayed in a parking lot i just want
[00:19:46] Speaker 4: to note you never noted anywhere that you had actually smelled alcohol on him correct i did not
[00:19:53] Speaker 7: was the purpose of you yelling stop for him to stop regarding any type of driving infraction no there was no driving infraction the people called deputy harman it approached me i'll swear you in please
[00:20:03] Speaker 5: swear affirm under penalty of perjury that the testimony you're about to give us the truth and nothing but
[00:20:07] Speaker 7: the truth go ahead have a seat good morning sir uh please state your name and spell your last name for
[00:20:12] Sergeant Jared Harman: the record sergeant jared harman h-a-r-m-o-n and what do you do for work sir i currently work for the opac county sheriff's office in the supervisory capacity for the beacon co-responder unit how long
[00:20:24] Speaker 7: have you been working with um episode 22 years now um so being here for 22 years were you working on the night of uh may 17th 2025 i was and during this interaction uh were you wearing a body cam i was and where's that body cam located center of my chest and was that body camera activated on uh urchin it was that body cam activated during your involvement with this case was and for the
[00:20:49] Speaker 4: questions at this time your honor morning sergeant good morning so you were called to the travel lodge right correct yes you were just called there to um assist in the investigation yes ma'am right in your interaction with mr davis he was compliant right correct he was polite yes as an officer you write a report right usually yes ma'am and i know you weren't the primary officer here but it's still possible to mark in your report possible dui observations correct yes ma'am okay and as a sergeant you know if you wasn't documented it didn't happen right yes ma'am you would note that someone was slurring their speech in a report correct i would yes if somebody was off balance right yes ma'am and if you smelt an odor of alcohol correct and none of that was wrote was written or noted in your report no ma'am and deputy i want to just help explain to the jury a little bit so i'm going to use you for your assistance um talking about some pre-trial procedures okay okay and in this case there was a former hearing right yes ma'am you have been a part of those hearings right a few and specifically you were called to testify in a hearing like that in this particular case right correct you testify just like today under penalty of perjury right correct i just want to talk just a bit about your el paso county sheriff's office policies and procedures okay okay you know that there is a colorado state law that says law enforcement has to have body-worn camera on right yes ma'am has to be on and recording um if you're interacting with the public right correct you're a sergeant correct yes ma'am so you've been in the game a long time right on time okay and so may i approach
[00:22:35] Sergeant Jared Harman: judge you may if applicable any reasons the reporter was not activated or deactivated must be documented
[00:22:42] Speaker 4: in a supplement and so officer after reading that if there's a time when your body one camera's turned off you're supposed to document that correct if applicable yes okay um and so the law states that and i'll go back to that hearing we had you're aware that the court found you're a violation of
[00:23:01] Speaker 6: of colorado law correct objection personal knowledge lack of personal knowledge owner
[00:23:06] Speaker 4: judge can take judicial notice of her court order instructions a little answer actually i'm not aware i was in violation of colorado law okay judge i would be asking the court at this time to um take judicial notice of the court order that there was a body one camera violation and by in violation of
[00:23:22] Speaker 5: colorado law but will she take judicial notice of the prior um order that was issued indicating that
[00:23:29] Speaker 4: there was a violation of the body one camera statute are you aware that there was another finding by a
[00:23:36] Speaker 2: judge objection speculation questions if he's aware um it's all overrule go ahead are you aware of
[00:23:46] Speaker 4: another finding recently um in the last month or two um a finding in this judicial district in county court that you were also in violation of a body warm camera i was not i was not advised of that one yet because that case is too long going okay i'm nothing further thank you for your time sergeant yes
[00:24:04] Speaker 7: ma'am to me redirect john yes your honor officer you referred to department policy on cross-exam uh regarding turning off your body cam and you said if applicable could you explain that so i didn't think it
[00:24:18] Sergeant Jared Harman: applied just for the fact that in the previous cases that we mentioned it was new information to me that i did violate any portion of that law reason being in the old pass county sheriff's office policy in the very beginning of that it says that i'm allowed to turn that body camera off during sensitive information uh portions uh so going to a hospital in my opinion is something that i've done for a long time is when i'm in the blood draw room i have a tendency to turn off my body camera so it's something that i've done quite frequently um this case in the case you referred to are the only two that have ever gone to court where it's been an issue so at that point i didn't think it applied just one more question
[00:24:56] Speaker 7: about the blood draw is there any documentation or paperwork that needs to be completed filled or signed prior to a chemical blood draw there is documentation yes and what is that documentation
[00:25:10] Sergeant Jared Harman: it's a form that comes inside of the blood kit inside that form is basic information who that individual is what occurred that day it's a short synopsis it has a line in there for an individual's blood to be drawn has to be signed by that individual so them giving permission for us to do that at the bottom of that form there's another signature that has to be done by the person withdrawing that blood and then a witness signature which would be mine sergeant harman concludes his trial testimony by
[00:25:38] Speaker 1: describing the consent form that accompanies a legal blood draw which must be signed by the suspect whose blood is drawn the individual performing the draw and a witness before the phlebotomist who performed the draw testified in front of the jury the defense objected to the admission of the blood evidence on so-called chain of custody grounds the chain of custody is the trail of possession that traces an item of evidence from its collection to its presentation in court in order for evidence to be admitted the party offering it must show that the item is authentic and that it has not been altered substituted or tampered with along the way now for a blood sample this means connecting the vitals tested at the lab back to the individual whose blood was drawn through each person who handled them in this case the court heard the phlebotomist's preliminary testimony and the attorney's arguments outside the presence of the jury before deciding if the blood sample would be admitted it's delilah faulkner
[00:26:30] Speaker 6: last name is f-a-u-l-k-n-e-r and where did you work during may 17th 2025 at memorial central hospital in the emergency department do you recall if you're working around midnight that night i don't recall that specific night and this fall whose name appears in the requesting officer's signature field on this
[00:26:53] Speaker 4: form i believe it says harman when you're doing the blood draw you have the name from the officer right correct on the form correct okay and so if the name on the form is somebody that you do not know yes then you don't know whose blood you're actually taking right are you asking if i confirm the name personally yeah typically no okay so you you never confirmed the name in this case no you were taking it off of a form yes okay you were essentially looking at a form saying it's this person's name yes but you really don't know if that is the actual person whose blood you're drawing
[00:27:35] Speaker 5: i get the name from the officer okay okay so um the question is whether or not her testimony is needed just for the purposes of this chain of custody mini hearing that we're having um i agree i think that the crux of the issue really is the testimony of the phlebotomist um she stated she testified that
[00:27:58] Speaker 4: she doesn't take any formal id so i i guess that's an issue on its own in the sense that she did not identify him when she took the blood she was just relying on essentially statements from harman um his body worn camera was off at that time so even if they did recall officer harman to get at you know i told her this is timmy davis this is what happened and this is how we kind of directed through the process he can't testify about that under the court's ruling um so there's no way to link her
[00:28:25] Speaker 5: knowledge of this being him it's looking at this as totality and it's in it's in its totality as far as the chain of custody issue court finds that at this time the people have established a sufficient chain of custody and foundation for admission of the blood evidence the court's not relying obviously on the handwritten name timmy davis on the tubes uh and it has found that that his written name on the tubes as well as the kid are hearsay without exception as stated by miss kovach the crux really is the identity of mr davis and here the body worn camera evidence established that mr davis was at the hospital the individual present in the blood draw room right before the draw according to what was what was recorded by the body worn camera footage from sergeant herman was the sample that was collected from mr davis it's not a perfect chain as we know there are gaps uh but any remaining gaps including miss faulkner's lack of any sort of independent recollection of mr davis himself and her lack of involvement really after the kit was handed off will go to weight rather than admissibility at this time so the objection to the chain of custody is overruled at this time the judge overrules the defense's
[00:29:37] Speaker 1: objection determining that the people had established sufficient chain of custody and foundation for admission of the blood evidence and that the remaining quote-unquote gaps in the chain of custody went to the weight rather than admissibility of the evidence this determination permitted the members of the jury to hear about and consider the blood evidence and assess the believability and persuasiveness of that evidence for themselves ms faulkner was then called to testify
[00:30:02] Speaker 6: again this time in the presence of the jury maybe calling miss delilah faulkner okay okay if you
[00:30:08] Speaker 5: would approach me i just need to swear you in for the jury do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth whole truth and nothing but the truth okay you can go ahead have
[00:30:16] Speaker 9: a seat um yes i don't have a specific recollection of that night but per my documentation yes and
[00:30:23] Speaker 6: could you tell me on that form that you have there uh whose signatures appear on that form um it's my signature on the bottom and would you have verified who the patient was uh that you were going to draw
[00:30:34] Speaker 9: the blood from um i do not recall if i verified the name but the name is given to us by the police
[00:30:40] Speaker 6: officer who was the listed subject in this case timmy davis and would your signature be on that form if you had not taken the blood from timmy davis no it would not you have no recollection of mr davis
[00:30:54] Speaker 4: aside from today correct correct if you saw him on a street prior to today you would not have recognized him correct you don't remember this specific night i do not you don't remember the specific blood draw no and you have done how many blood draws probably a thousand or so you don't recall the officer in this case i do not you don't collect any identifying information correct correct you don't gather an id a birth date to verify that the name on a sheet is equated to a subject right i don't have personal recollection of that night so okay understood you can't link a name to a face right correct then talking about that barcode a little bit as well just like the name it's meaningless because you can't like link it to a person correct i cannot no that's the same thing with the barcode correct you it's just a number because you can't associate it to anyone right for me personally no okay may this witness be excused uh yes okay thank you miss faulkner ms faulkner finishes her
[00:31:58] Speaker 1: testimony after the defense cross-examines her regarding the identification process that she followed when drawing mr davis's blood the results of the blood test are only significant if the sample tested was actually drawn from mr davis and ms faulkner testified that she had no independent recollection of performing the blood draw that she did not check mr davis's identification before completing the draw and that she could not connect his name to a face the defense's line of questioning appeared to be aimed at undermining the jury's confidence in the fact that the blood sample was actually taken from mr davis well the people then called their final witness and after the close of evidence the parties deliberated over the final jury instructions the court instructed the jury and both sides delivered closing arguments before the case was submitted to the jury people's next witness good afternoon could you please state
[00:32:45] Speaker 4: your full name and spell your last for the record please yes my name is jennifer beckstrom b-e-c-k-s-t-r-o-m and where do you work in a spectrum i am employed with the colorado bureau of investigations or cbi
[00:33:00] Speaker 6: and what is your position for cbi i'm a forensic toxicologist and what was the ethanol result in
[00:33:07] Speaker 4: this case ethanol was detected in the blood sample at 0.179 grams per 100 milliliters plus or minus 0.009 this opinion is based on the per se limit in colorado and the per se limit to operate that vehicle is 0.08 and this ethanol level is above a 0.08 some obvious questions to start off okay you did not witness this blood draw no i didn't and you've never met mr davis before no i haven't all you have in front of you that you test are test tubes right yes that's correct and you have a code that's in front of you as well right the case number the yeah the serialization right yes but you cannot say with certainty that the blood was drawn from mr davis right i was not present at the blood draw no frankly it's defense's position that the ruling of body wearing camera of this court's ruling in that body were in camera motion has effectively not impacted the prosecution's case whatsoever i think when we first all read that order it would be the logical implication that the blood would not come in they found a way to circumvent that um so at this point there has been effectively no kind of sanctionary
[00:34:25] Speaker 5: measures or any kind of impact on their case and the consequences of sergeant herman's failure to comply with this statute or just does not agree that this alone permits the court to expand the inference beyond what's in the statute in terms of specifically telling the jury that they can infer mishandling of the evidence and i think it's better to leave that up to the jury to decide to leave it as footage would have reflected misconduct and then the parties can argue what that could have been and then the jury can weigh it as they wish wish just like the rest of the instruction proposes we would be requesting in the second paragraph that at the very end it says would have reflected misconduct by the peace officer we would be requesting uh by sergeant harman just make it a little bit more applicable to this case i think that's fair paragraph three will read in this case sergeant harman deactivated his body worn camera during the blood draw and evidence collection process i want to welcome our jurors back back on the record in 25t 5253 people versus davis people ready to proceed yes your honor defense defense rests at this point okay the defendant is charged with committing the crimes of driving under the influence with the lesser included of driving while ability impaired and driving with excessive alcohol content in el paso county colorado on or about may 17th 2025 the defendant has pleaded not guilty instruction number 17 the district attorney is obligated to comply with the colorado rules of criminal procedure 16. this rule governs governs discovery in criminal cases the rule requires that all witnesses that the prosecution intends to call at trial be on a witness list provided to the defense at least 35 days before trial in this case the phlebotomist was not listed on a witness list at least 35 days before trial this rule is in place to ensure a fair and impartial trial is given to the accused under both the colorado and united states constitution you may or may not consider this in your deliberations it is entirely your decision to determine what weight if any shall be given to this evidence instruction number 18 the district attorney in this case was given a court order to provide defense counsel with body worn camera time stamps by a certain deadline the court has found that the district attorney violated that court order you may or may not consider this in your deliberations it is entirely your decision to determine what weight if any shall be given to this evidence structure number 19 under colorado law peace officers are required to wear and activate their body worn camera during certain interactions with the public for the purpose of enforcing the law or investigating possible violations of the law if a peace officer fails to activate body worn camera as required or tampers with body worn camera footage or operation when required to activate the camera there is a permissive inference in any legal proceeding that the missing footage would have reflected misconduct by the peace officer in this case sergeant harman deactivated his body worn camera during the blood draw and evidence collection process there is a permissive permissive inference that the missing footage would have reflected misconduct by sergeant harman a permissive inference allows but does not require you to find a fact from a proof of another fact or facts if you determine that inference is justified by the evidence as a whole it is entirely your decision to determine
[00:37:48] Speaker 6: what weight shall be given the evidence ladies and gentlemen like my colleague here said this isn't simple davis and then we have that per se limit pointing away excessive alcohol content you're intoxicating mr davis's bac was twice this level excessive alcohol content what we're talking about here is not just impairment not just intoxication what mr timmy davis was doing was perilous target harman was nice enough he
[00:38:16] Speaker 4: seemed harmless but that's even more dangerous he is a sergeant he testified to his training he's been a part of this for a very long time the appearance of the law is not an excuse he is in a position of authority of you know arresting people doing things like that doing the right thing unacceptable the district attorney in opening said it this is a simple case they said it to you right now this is a simple case it's just not not it's just not in order for example to be reliable they had to prove it was properly handled in a store instead of getting that you are getting an instruction two times they were not there they were caught cheating and you would give an instruction saying that you can get that anybody what we have in this case right now it's lobotomists who cannot identify the blood virus and toxicologists who cannot do that a sergeant that has been found by this court to have violated colorado state law missing body worn camera footage where if you are instructed you can for misconduct and made not being on the blood vial they have to show you this was a reliable result that is their burden reason to doubt the law says you can infer something happened to that the law tells you that you can and if our results are not reliable that 1.179 was not reliable how we know that law says so mr davis not
[00:39:45] Speaker 5: guilty at all i understand that there may be a verdict as to one count i don't want to know what it is but i understand as to another count the jury may be divided without telling me anything about the deliberations or telling me what the split might be without telling me any details do you believe that any further deliberations might assist this jury in making progress toward a unanimous vote vote as to that one count okay mr davis if you'd stand please i'll read the verdict it's the verdict in 2525253 people versus davis we the jury find the defendant timmy levain davis not guilty of following deliberations the jury
[00:40:26] Speaker 1: returned its verdict finding mr davis not guilty of at least one of the charges brought against him this trial demonstrates the importance of officers knowing understanding and following the laws that establish legal obligations that they are required to fulfill the authority entrusted to law enforcement officers comes with a corresponding set of duties to the public and officers cannot comply with these duties if they do not know what they are now in this case sergeant harman a supervisor with more than two decades of experience testified that he had never read the body worn camera statute and that he routinely deactivated his camera during hospital blood draws in the belief that department policy permitted it his unfamiliarity with the relevant law shaped mr davis's trial with the people being required to change their case strategy and rely on a less effective witness and the jury returning a not guilty verdict after it was instructed that it could infer misconduct from the missing footage a recording requirement reflects a legislative judgment that cameras protect both the public and the officers who wear them and that judgment can only operate if the officers operating the cameras know when the law requires them to record let us know if there is a case or courtroom interaction that you would like us to explore in the comments below thank you for watching and don't forget to like and subscribe so we can help foster a more informed society