Try Free

Senate Judiciary Committee Holds Confirmation Hearing For Trump Judge Nominees

Forbes Breaking News November 19, 2026 2h 49m 25,151 words 1 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Senate Judiciary Committee Holds Confirmation Hearing For Trump Judge Nominees from Forbes Breaking News, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 25,151 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"which had obviously been prepared in advance. So it appears that a federal district court appointment for life is the consolation prize if you lose in an election for the Texas Supreme Court. Republicans are violating committee norms to rush through this nominee because they want to deny to the..."

[0:00] which had obviously been prepared in advance. [0:03] So it appears that a federal district court appointment for life [0:07] is the consolation prize if you lose in an election for the Texas Supreme Court. [0:13] Republicans are violating committee norms to rush through this nominee [0:16] because they want to deny to the incoming senator any voice in the process. [0:22] Also on today's slate is Eric Hamilton, nominated to the District of Nebraska, [0:27] currently serving as a senior Department of Justice official, [0:30] defending the Trump administration's blatant unconstitutional actions in court. [0:36] What did the court say about Mr. Hamilton? [0:38] A federal judge said, quote, [0:40] the court is left with little confidence that he can be trusted to tell the truth about anything. [0:47] What a legacy. [0:49] Finally, the two North Carolina nominees before us today have played leading roles [0:53] in the prosecution of FBI Director James Comey [0:56] for the alleged crime of posting a picture of seashells. [1:02] One of the President Trump's efforts to seek revenge against his political enemies. [1:08] Here's what one Republican member of this committee said about the seashell prosecution. [1:14] Some bonehead in North Carolina thinks that it's a crime. [1:18] Well, they better damn sure have information to back it up. [1:21] Because if all it is is a picture, that person should lose their job. [1:25] But instead of losing their jobs, it appears some of these people are being considered for lifetime appointments. [1:33] I yield. [1:38] Thank you to ranking member Durbin. [1:39] We'll now turn to the introductions of our nominees. [1:43] And we're going to start with the visiting senators who are joining us [1:46] and then turn to our colleagues on the committee. [1:49] And because of a series of scheduling conflicts, we're going to do these a little out of order. [1:53] And so we will start with Senator Young. [1:57] Well, thank you, Chairman Cruz, ranking member Durbin, members of the committee. [2:02] It's an honor to introduce Joe Falvey. [2:05] He's a fellow Hoosier and a United States Marine. [2:08] As nominee to serve as a district judge in the Northern District of Indiana. [2:15] Joe embodies the Marine Corps mantra, honor, courage, and commitment. [2:20] Joe has dedicated his entire life in service to our great nation. [2:25] If confirmed, the Northern District of Indiana will gain a judge that exhibits integrity, collegiality, [2:32] and an unparalleled work ethic. [2:36] Joe hails from South Bend, Indiana, home, of course, of the Fighting Irish. [2:40] He graduated magna cum laude from Notre Dame, where he participated in the ROTC program. [2:47] The Falvey family has a long history of military service, and Joe proudly followed in their footsteps. [2:55] He received his commission as a Marine Corps officer in 2009, [2:58] where he pursued the hardest path and became an infantry officer. [3:04] Joe went on to serve with distinction in two of the fiercest combat zones of our lifetimes, [3:11] Marja and Sanjin, in the dreaded Helmand province of Afghanistan. [3:16] Joe saw significant combat, and he was awarded the Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal [3:23] with Valor device for heroism under fire. [3:29] In one incident, his unit became pinned down under heavy Taliban machine gun fire. [3:36] Joe left the safety of their defense and ran under fire to their mortar position. [3:43] He personally readjusted their mortar fire onto the enemy and forced the Taliban attackers to retreat. [3:52] I always have a special level of respect for our judicial nominees who serve in uniform, [3:57] but it's extremely rare to see one with a combat record like Joe's. [4:05] After his tour on active duty, Joe graduated from Yale Law School, [4:08] where he was a notes editor in the Yale Law Journal. [4:11] Along with law review, Joe served as president of the Catholic Law School Association [4:17] and vice president of Yale Law's Federalist Society chapter. [4:22] It remains unclear to me when Joe slept. [4:27] Following law school, Joe clerked for three renowned jurists here in Washington, [4:32] Dabney Friedrich on the district court, [4:34] Thomas Griffith on the D.C. Circuit, [4:37] and Chief Justice John Roberts. [4:40] Joe has a distinguished record of service in both the civil and criminal realms. [4:47] In four years at Jones Day, Joe helped litigate some of our judiciary's most complex civil matters. [4:54] But his commitment to public service called him back home to South Bend, Indiana, [5:00] where he joined the Northern District as a federal prosecutor. [5:04] After less than two years as a line prosecutor, [5:07] he was elevated to acting chief of the criminal division for the Northern District, [5:12] a true testament to his competence, work ethic, and dedication to justice. [5:19] In February of this year, Joe was made chief of the appellate division. [5:24] Those who've worked with him repeatedly extol his brilliance, [5:28] his work ethic, and his collegiality. [5:31] I've had the pleasure to get to know Joe through this process. [5:35] The thing that stands out about Joe to me is that [5:38] despite his sterling credentials and his achievements, [5:42] he's as humble and down-to-earth as he can be. [5:45] Joe's humility and thoughtfulness will serve him well on the bench, [5:49] and if anyone has any questions about the dedication to the Constitution, [5:54] Joe demonstrated he was willing to risk his life defending it on the battlefield. [6:00] Joe, you truly make me proud to be a Hoosier and an American. [6:05] Joe's proudest achievement, though, is marrying Catherine, [6:08] who unfortunately couldn't make it today. [6:10] Catherine was also a Marine Corps officer, [6:13] and, like myself, an intelligence officer. [6:16] To use Marine Corps terminology for a second, [6:19] Joe and Catherine have two fire teams of children. [6:23] That is, eight children. [6:25] I also want to recognize Joe's father, Judge Joseph Falvey, Jr., [6:30] who's here with us today and serves on the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. [6:35] Thank you for your own service to our nation, sir. [6:38] I am grateful to President Trump for making this exceptional nomination, [6:43] and to this committee for your consideration. [6:46] I'm confident you'll walk away just as impressed by Joe as I am. [6:50] Thank you. [6:51] Thank you, Senator Young. [6:53] Senator Budd, you're recognized. [6:56] Thank you, Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Durbin, [6:58] my colleagues on the committee, [6:59] and Senator Tillis for partnering with me on the judicial nominations before the committee today. [7:04] Ensuring principal constitutionalist judges are confirmed to the federal bench [7:09] is a privilege and responsibility that I take very seriously. [7:14] It's my honor to introduce two upstanding nominees from North Carolina. [7:19] Phil Albert, President Trump's nominee for U.S. District Judge for the Middle District of North Carolina, [7:24] and Brian Myers, President Trump's nominee for the U.S. District Judge for the Eastern District of North Carolina. [7:30] Mr. Phil Albert currently serves as the first assistant U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of North Carolina. [7:39] Previously, he served as assistant U.S. attorney in the Eastern District's criminal division. [7:45] He's also a major in the U.S. Army, where he serves as a judge advocate [7:49] and has served as an active duty captain, now a major. [7:53] Mr. Albert began his legal career as a law clerk to U.S. District Judge Terrence Boyle [7:58] of the Eastern District in North Carolina, [7:59] the longest-serving U.S. District Judge in active service. [8:04] He's a proud graduate of the Duke University School of Law [8:07] and received his bachelor's degree from the Dartmouth College. [8:11] Judge Brian Myers currently serves as U.S. Magistrate Judge for U.S. District Court [8:16] for the Eastern District of North Carolina. [8:18] Previously, he was executive assistant U.S. attorney [8:22] for the Eastern District of North Carolina [8:23] and served as an assistant U.S. attorney in the criminal division. [8:28] Judge Myers likewise served his country with distinction [8:31] as a member of the United States Marine Corps, [8:34] finishing his military service as chief trial counsel [8:37] at Marine Corps Air Station New River. [8:41] Additionally, Judge Myers knows his way around the U.S. Senate, [8:45] having served as an aide to former United States Senator Jesse Helms, [8:49] whose legacy stands tall in the Old North State. [8:53] Judge Myers graduated cum laude from the University of Richmond School of Law [8:57] and received his undergraduate degree from Davidson College. [9:01] Both of these accomplished nominees before the committee today [9:03] have deep ties to North Carolina [9:05] and possess the experience, legal knowledge, and sound temperament [9:09] necessary to effectively serve in the roles for which they have been nominated. [9:13] I'm confident that Mr. Albart and Judge Myers are strong constitutionalists [9:18] who are highly qualified to uphold the merits of the U.S. Constitution [9:21] on the federal bench. [9:23] And I look forward to seeing their nominations advance out of this committee [9:26] and come before the full Senate. [9:28] Thank you. [9:29] Thank you, Senator Budd. [9:32] Senator Fisher, you're recognized. [9:34] Thank you, Senator Cruz, Ranking Member Durbin, [9:38] Members of the Committee, [9:39] I'm honored to introduce Eric Hamilton today. [9:43] It brings me great pride to say that President Trump has nominated him [9:48] to fill a vacancy on the U.S. District Court for the District of Nebraska. [9:54] In September, Judge Bob Rossiter notified me and Senator Ricketts [9:58] that he would be taking senior status on the Nebraska federal bench. [10:03] I thank Judge Rossiter for his dedicated service to our state. [10:08] Filling this seat without delay is of the utmost importance [10:12] to the U.S. District Court for the District of Nebraska. [10:16] Doing so will continue its rich tradition of reverence for the law [10:21] and for our Constitution. [10:24] The District of Nebraska has only three authorized judgeships, [10:29] leaving the District Court with one of the nation's highest pending cases [10:33] per judgeship. [10:35] Moreover, the District of Nebraska has experienced a considerable increase [10:40] in its workload over the last year, [10:42] with both new filings and pending caseloads increasing substantially. [10:48] With that urgency in mind, [10:51] I set out to identify the best candidates to fill this vacancy [10:54] upon learning of Judge Rossiter's plans. [10:57] There are more than a few of the sharpest, [11:00] most principal legal minds that call Nebraska home. [11:03] This proved to be a blessing and a curse, [11:06] as Senator Ricketts and I considered several candidates [11:10] to recommend to the President. [11:12] As we pored over the backgrounds, [11:15] the experience, [11:16] and qualifications of several such candidates, [11:19] we agreed that Mr. Hamilton possesses the knowledge, [11:22] experience, and temperament for this position. [11:27] Mr. Hamilton was raised in Omaha, Nebraska, [11:29] and he received his undergraduate education [11:32] at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. [11:34] He began his legal education at UNL [11:38] and later transferred to Stanford University, [11:41] where he received his JD while serving on the Stanford Law Review. [11:47] Mr. Hamilton would eventually come home to Nebraska, [11:50] serving as Solicitor General [11:51] in the Nebraska Attorney General's Office [11:54] from 2023 through 2025. [11:58] There, he drew on his deep understanding of the law [12:02] and extensive litigation experience [12:04] to represent the state's interests [12:07] before courts throughout the United States. [12:11] When Attorney General Hilgers announced [12:13] Mr. Hamilton's appointment as Solicitor General, [12:17] he described him as a very talented attorney [12:20] with a wealth of experience [12:21] who would serve the people of Nebraska well. [12:25] Presently, Mr. Hamilton serves [12:27] as Deputy Assistant Attorney General [12:30] over the Federal Programs Branch [12:32] of the Justice Department's Civil Division, [12:36] where he leads the federal government's defense [12:38] of significant legal challenges [12:40] to executive branch actions and policies. [12:44] Before his service in Nebraska [12:46] and the federal government, [12:48] Mr. Hamilton worked [12:49] as an Assistant Solicitor General [12:51] in the Texas Attorney General's Office, [12:54] as Associate Counsel [12:55] to President Trump [12:57] in the White House Counsel's Office, [12:59] and as an Associate [13:00] at the Washington, D.C. law firm [13:03] Williams & Connolly. [13:05] Mr. Hamilton has shown himself [13:07] to be a capable, sober-minded, [13:10] legal professional [13:11] in many capacities. [13:13] He has represented states, [13:15] including Nebraska, [13:17] as well as the federal government [13:19] in high-stakes litigation. [13:22] These experiences have prepared him well [13:24] for the judgeship [13:26] for which he has been nominated. [13:29] Nebraska's state motto [13:31] is equality before the law. [13:34] This principle serves as a guide [13:36] for our state and our nation, [13:39] and this principle is the standard [13:42] which we should evaluate [13:44] any nominee for this judgeship. [13:47] I am proud to recommend Mr. Hamilton [13:49] to this committee [13:51] and champion his record. [13:55] Mr. Hamilton has argued [13:56] on both sides of disputes [13:58] between states [13:59] and the federal government. [14:02] That experience provides him [14:04] with a unique perspective [14:05] on federalism, [14:07] constitutional law, [14:09] and the proper balance [14:11] of state and federal authority. [14:13] It will serve him well [14:15] on Nebraska's federal bench. [14:18] During the recent conversation, [14:20] I was struck not only [14:22] by his deep knowledge of the law, [14:24] but by his enthusiasm [14:26] for upholding it. [14:29] I have no doubt [14:30] that Mr. Hamilton [14:31] will be an excellent judge [14:33] and apply the law equally [14:35] and fairly. [14:37] I appreciate this committee's [14:38] consideration of his nomination, [14:41] and I thank you [14:42] for allowing me to introduce [14:44] and speak in support [14:47] of Mr. Hamilton this morning. [14:49] Thank you, Senator Cruz. [14:50] Thank you, Senator Fisher. [14:52] Senator Bozeman. [14:54] Thank you, Chairman Cruz [14:56] and Ranking Member Durbin [14:57] very much, [14:58] and to my colleagues [15:00] that serve on this very, [15:01] very important committee. [15:03] It's an honor to be with you today [15:04] and with my friend [15:06] and fellow senator, [15:08] Senator Tom Cotton, [15:09] to introduce Justice [15:11] Cody Highland, [15:13] President Trump's [15:13] outstanding nominee, [15:15] to serve as the United States [15:16] Circuit Judge [15:17] for the Eighth Circuit. [15:20] Cody is a native of Arkansas. [15:22] He earned his undergraduate degree [15:24] from the University [15:24] of Central Arkansas [15:25] before completing [15:27] his legal studies [15:28] at the University of Arkansas [15:30] Little Rock Bowen Law School. [15:32] He has experience [15:34] in private practice [15:35] in addition to providing [15:36] legal counsel [15:37] to the Arkansas Public Service Commission [15:40] and Department of Public Safety. [15:42] He was also [15:43] a legislative liaison [15:45] and aide [15:45] to our dear friend [15:46] Governor Mike Huckabee. [15:48] Cody's service [15:49] in those roles [15:50] as well as his exemplary performance [15:52] as prosecuting attorney [15:53] in Arkansas's [15:55] 20th Judicial District [15:56] made him a top candidate [15:57] to serve as the U.S. Attorney [16:00] for the Eastern District of Arkansas [16:01] during the first Trump administration. [16:06] Senator Cotton and I [16:07] were pleased to recommend him [16:08] for that role [16:09] and will both attest [16:11] to the tremendous job [16:12] he did improving public safety [16:14] and holding criminals accountable. [16:16] In fact, at the time [16:17] he was sworn in, [16:19] his jurisdiction included [16:20] four communities [16:21] with some of the highest crime rates, [16:24] violent crime rates [16:25] in the United States [16:26] per capita. [16:28] Cody worked incredibly hard [16:30] to turn the tide, [16:31] especially by targeting [16:32] gun crimes, [16:34] gang activity, [16:35] eagerly partnering [16:35] with local, state, [16:37] and federal agencies [16:38] to protect communities [16:39] and stand with law enforcement [16:41] to make everyone safe. [16:44] That body of work culminated [16:46] in his appointment [16:47] to the Arkansas Supreme Court [16:48] by Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, [16:50] where he has honorably served [16:52] since 2023 [16:54] and was subsequently elected [16:56] to a full term. [16:58] Cody has all the qualities [16:59] he's want in a federal judge, [17:01] extensive real-world [17:02] and courtroom experience, [17:04] sound judgment, [17:05] and a deep commitment [17:06] to upholding the law [17:07] rather than legislating [17:09] from the bench. [17:11] I'm confident [17:11] that his integrity [17:12] and his temperament [17:13] will be assets [17:15] to the Eighth Circuit. [17:16] I strongly urge my colleagues [17:18] to join me [17:19] in supporting his nomination. [17:21] Thank you very much. [17:22] Thank you, Senator Bozeman. [17:23] Senator Ricketts. [17:26] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [17:27] Thank you, Ranking Member, [17:28] for holding this important hearing. [17:30] I very much appreciate it. [17:31] My senior senator [17:32] has done a fine job [17:33] of talking about Eric Hamilton, [17:34] but I will add my voice [17:35] as well. [17:37] It's a privilege [17:37] to be able to introduce [17:39] and support [17:40] an exceptionally qualified [17:42] Nebraskan [17:43] for this important role. [17:45] Eric Hamilton [17:45] is President Trump's nominee [17:46] for the U.S. District Court [17:48] in Nebraska. [17:49] Now, I have known Eric [17:51] since he was 18 years old. [17:54] About 20 years ago [17:55] when we were both [17:56] getting involved in politics [17:57] is when I had the opportunity [17:59] to meet him. [18:00] And I will tell you, [18:02] back then he had hair. [18:03] I did not. [18:05] But you'll notice [18:06] he has adopted [18:07] the very sleek look [18:09] that I support here [18:10] in the U.S. Senate. [18:13] Senator Fischer [18:13] and I recommended [18:14] Eric Hamilton [18:15] to the president [18:16] because of his dedication [18:18] to public service [18:20] and his commitment [18:21] to the rule of law. [18:23] His career [18:24] and record highlight this. [18:26] Eric has served [18:27] as our country [18:28] with distinction, [18:29] serving now [18:30] in two presidential administrations. [18:33] In these roles, [18:34] he has defended [18:35] and protected [18:35] American values [18:36] and freedom. [18:38] He carried on this service [18:39] back in Nebraska [18:40] as our solicitor general. [18:42] In Nebraska, [18:43] he defended the bills [18:44] passed by the state legislature, [18:46] including Nebraska's law [18:48] to protect pre-born babies [18:49] after 12 weeks. [18:51] In his current role, [18:52] he continues to defend [18:53] both Congress's statutes [18:55] and Executive Branch actions. [18:57] As Deputy Assistant [18:58] Attorney General, [18:59] Eric took the historic [19:00] enforcement action [19:01] against Chinese-based [19:02] Sui Regroup. [19:05] This was the first time [19:06] that the U.S. government [19:08] forced a Chinese company [19:09] to divest [19:11] after a review [19:12] by the Committee [19:13] on Foreign Investment [19:14] in the United States, [19:15] otherwise known as CFIUS. [19:17] Eric served our state [19:18] with integrity. [19:20] He fought for Nebraskans [19:21] and our way of life. [19:23] He is a sixth-generation Nebraskan [19:25] raised in Omaha. [19:26] He graduated [19:27] from Millard West High School, [19:29] received his bachelor degree [19:30] from the University [19:30] of Nebraska-Lincoln, [19:32] and as my senior senator mentioned, [19:34] graduated from Stanford Law. [19:36] In Nebraska, [19:36] our motto is [19:37] the good life. [19:39] If confirmed, [19:39] Eric will continue [19:40] to represent [19:40] and protect [19:41] the good life [19:42] in my state. [19:43] Mr. Chairman, [19:43] thank you for the opportunity [19:44] to introduce Eric Hamilton. [19:46] I encourage the Committee [19:47] to support his nomination. [19:49] I recommend him most highly. [19:51] Thank you very much [19:52] for your time this morning. [19:54] Thank you, Senator Ricketts, [19:55] and I feel confident [19:56] that your comments [19:57] on his sartorial style [19:58] will at least earn him [20:00] the votes of Senator Lee [20:01] on this committee. [20:02] Senator Cotton. [20:09] Senator Cruz, [20:10] Senator Durbin, [20:11] members of the Judiciary Committee, [20:13] good morning. [20:14] It's an honor [20:14] to appear with Senator Bozeman [20:17] on behalf of the President's nominee [20:20] to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals [20:22] and my friend, [20:23] Justice Cody Highland. [20:25] I want to commend the President [20:27] for his excellent choice [20:29] and thank Justice Highland [20:31] for his continued commitment [20:32] to public service [20:33] now in the federal judiciary. [20:36] And I'd also like to thank [20:38] the Highland family, [20:40] his wife, Jana, [20:41] their four children, [20:42] Claire, Katie, [20:43] John Reagan, [20:44] and Ethan, [20:45] their beautiful grandchildren, [20:45] for their support [20:47] and encouragement [20:48] to him during this process. [20:52] Justice Highland's legal experience, [20:54] his track record [20:55] from both the bench [20:56] and the lawyer's table, [20:57] and his unwavering respect [20:58] for the rule of law [20:59] make him an ideal candidate [21:02] for this position. [21:05] Earlier this year, [21:05] Justice Highland [21:06] was elected [21:07] to be a justice [21:08] on the Arkansas Supreme Court, [21:10] but his service [21:12] predates the election [21:13] because he twice [21:14] earned the confidence [21:16] of Governor Sarah [21:17] Huckabee Sanders, [21:18] who earlier appointed him [21:20] to fill vacancies [21:21] on the court [21:22] on two separate occasions, [21:24] beginning in 2023. [21:29] Before joining [21:29] our Supreme Court, [21:31] Justice Highland [21:31] served as general counsel [21:32] for the Arkansas Department [21:34] of Public Safety [21:35] and, [21:37] with the unanimous support [21:38] from all of us [21:40] in the Senate, [21:41] served as the United States Attorney [21:43] for the Eastern District [21:45] of Arkansas. [21:45] During his tenure [21:48] as U.S. Attorney, [21:50] Justice Highland [21:50] increased the office's caseload [21:52] and cracked down [21:53] on violent crime, [21:55] which helped reduce homicides [21:57] by 24% [21:58] and drive-by shootings [21:59] by 55% [22:00] in Little Rock [22:01] during his first full year [22:03] in office. [22:05] In addition, [22:07] Justice Highland [22:07] was elected twice [22:09] as the prosecuting attorney [22:10] for the 20th Judicial District [22:12] of Arkansas. [22:14] He's also the recipient [22:15] of numerous awards, [22:17] including the champion [22:18] of Justice Award [22:19] from the Arkansas [22:20] Prosecuting Attorneys Association [22:22] and the Chairman's Award [22:24] from the Arkansas State [22:26] Police Foundation. [22:29] I am pleased to join [22:30] Senator Bozeman [22:31] not only to introduce [22:32] but to offer my full support [22:35] to the president's nominee [22:37] to be a United States Circuit judge [22:39] for the Eighth Circuit, [22:41] Justice Cody Highland. [22:43] I urge my colleagues [22:44] on the committee [22:45] to do the same [22:46] and give your prompt attention [22:47] to his nomination. [22:49] Thank you all [22:49] for allowing me to appear. [22:51] Thank you, Senator Cotton. [22:53] Senator Cornyn, [22:54] you're recognized. [22:54] Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [22:59] I want to add a few words [23:01] of introduction [23:01] to what you've already said [23:03] about James Sullivan, [23:04] who's been nominated [23:05] to be a district judge [23:07] in the Western District of Texas. [23:09] I know there's been [23:10] some commentary [23:12] about the late nomination [23:14] of Judge Sullivan, [23:16] but I want to point out [23:17] that he is not a [23:19] Johnny come lately [23:20] to this federal judicial [23:23] evaluation process. [23:25] In fact, last year, [23:27] he was considered [23:28] for a vacancy [23:30] in the Austin Division [23:32] of the Western District [23:33] of Texas, [23:34] but because he had been appointed [23:36] as a member [23:38] of the Texas Supreme Court, [23:40] that did not work out. [23:42] And in fact, [23:43] Judge Andrew Davis [23:44] was appointed [23:45] to that vacancy. [23:46] But suffice to say, [23:49] his background [23:51] and qualifications [23:52] were very favorably reviewed [23:55] by not only Senator Cruz [23:57] and myself, [23:58] but also our [23:58] Federal Judicial [23:59] Evaluation Committee. [24:01] For a long time now, [24:02] Senator Cruz and I [24:03] have had a bipartisan [24:04] Federal Judicial [24:05] Evaluation Committee [24:07] that has helped us [24:08] in this process. [24:09] And by vetting, [24:10] the various people [24:11] have indicated some interest. [24:13] And Judge Sullivan [24:14] was a product [24:15] of that process [24:16] and came out [24:17] very highly rated. [24:20] Before joining [24:21] the Texas Supreme Court, [24:23] where I happen to have worked [24:24] for about seven years [24:25] as well, [24:28] Judge Sullivan [24:28] was general counsel [24:30] to Governor Greg Abbott, [24:32] a former attorney general, [24:35] a former member [24:35] of the Texas Supreme Court [24:37] himself, [24:37] and somebody [24:38] who's pretty demanding [24:39] in terms of the quality [24:41] of legal representation [24:42] that he insists upon. [24:44] And he got that [24:45] with Justice Sullivan. [24:47] In each of the roles [24:49] that Justice Sullivan [24:50] has held, [24:51] he's demonstrated [24:52] exceptional legal acumen [24:54] and personal integrity. [24:57] He worked as an appellate litigator [24:59] in private practice [25:00] and an adjunct professor. [25:02] And I didn't realize this [25:04] or remember this [25:05] until Senator Cruz mentioned it, [25:07] but he played football [25:08] at Westlake High School, [25:09] which is a powerhouse [25:11] in Austin, Texas, [25:13] where my own daughters [25:14] happened to go to school. [25:16] And he also, of course, [25:18] proud alumni of Rice [25:20] and Harvard Law School. [25:22] I have no doubt [25:24] that Justice Sullivan's [25:25] strong Texas roots [25:27] and the fact he has passed muster [25:29] with the bipartisan [25:32] Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee [25:34] that Senator Cruz [25:35] and I have instituted, [25:36] I have no doubt [25:40] about his ability [25:42] to serve in this [25:43] important position. [25:44] But there is one thing [25:46] I want to mention, [25:46] Justice Sullivan, [25:47] that I know [25:48] Senator Kennedy [25:50] may have questions about, [25:53] and that is you appeared [25:54] as an extra [25:55] in the movie [25:56] Dazed and Confused. [26:00] But considering that role, [26:04] and again, [26:04] Senator Kennedy, [26:05] I'm sure will have [26:06] questions about that, [26:07] I have every confidence [26:09] that you will be [26:10] all right, [26:11] all right, [26:12] all right. [26:13] So congratulations, [26:16] James, [26:16] on your nomination [26:17] and I look forward [26:18] to supporting [26:18] your confirmation [26:19] here in the committee [26:20] and on the Senate floor. [26:25] I thank Senator Cornyn. [26:26] I will give as a warning [26:28] that that invocation [26:29] of Matthew McConaughey [26:32] may in fact [26:33] have cost [26:34] Justice Sullivan [26:36] Senator Kennedy's vote [26:37] given the University of Texas' [26:40] ass-kicking of LSU [26:41] this weekend. [26:44] But with that, [26:46] I will recognize [26:47] Senator Banks. [26:49] Thank you, [26:50] Mr. Chairman. [26:50] Great to be with you. [26:51] I know that Joseph Falvey [26:52] has already been introduced [26:54] by Senator Todd Young, [26:56] but I'm very honored [26:57] to come and show [26:58] my support [26:58] for Mr. Falvey [27:00] and to be with all of you [27:01] in front of this [27:02] distinguished committee. [27:04] I'm glad that [27:05] President Trump [27:05] nominated Joseph Falvey [27:07] to the United States [27:09] District Court [27:10] for the Northern District [27:11] of Indiana. [27:11] He couldn't have found [27:12] anybody better. [27:13] Joseph Falvey [27:14] was born [27:15] and raised [27:16] in South Bend, Indiana, [27:17] the home [27:17] of the Fighting Irish. [27:19] Joe is a devoted husband [27:21] and father [27:21] of eight children, [27:24] including a baby [27:25] that was just born [27:26] weeks ago. [27:28] His eighth child, [27:30] who I understand [27:30] he calls, [27:31] and I love this, [27:32] he calls him Jimmy, [27:33] which is my nickname [27:34] at home as well. [27:37] After graduating [27:38] from Notre Dame, [27:38] Joe served his country [27:40] as a member [27:40] of the United States [27:41] Marine Corps. [27:42] He deployed to Afghanistan [27:44] and earned [27:45] multiple combat awards. [27:49] Following his military service, [27:51] Joe attended Yale Law School. [27:53] He clerked in the office [27:54] of the Indiana Solicitor General [27:56] and later completed [27:58] several prestigious [27:59] judicial clerkships, [28:01] including with Chief Justice [28:03] John Roberts [28:04] of the Supreme Court [28:05] of the United States, [28:06] also, by the way, [28:08] a Hoosier. [28:09] Joe worked as an associate [28:10] at Jones Day [28:12] in Washington, D.C., [28:13] before coming home [28:14] to Indiana. [28:15] He currently serves [28:16] as the chief [28:17] of the appellate division [28:18] of the U.S. Attorney's Office [28:20] in the Northern District. [28:22] My good friend, [28:23] who you all confirmed, [28:24] Adam Mildred, [28:25] the current U.S. attorney, [28:26] can't say enough good [28:28] about the important work [28:29] that Joe has done [28:30] with him [28:30] and his service [28:31] over the past year. [28:33] My apologies [28:34] to Adam, though, [28:35] because his office's loss [28:37] is our country's gain. [28:39] Joe has a sterling resume. [28:42] His character, though, [28:43] is even more impressive [28:44] than anything [28:45] that you see on paper. [28:46] He has selflessly [28:48] served his family, [28:50] his country, [28:50] and his state, [28:52] and in private practice, [28:53] he took on cases [28:54] that fought for election integrity [28:55] and religious liberty. [28:58] I have said before [28:59] that anyone who, [29:00] anyone can say [29:01] the right things [29:02] in these interviews [29:03] that we have [29:03] with prospective nominees, [29:06] but you can't fake courage. [29:08] And I want judges, [29:09] I want to support [29:10] and vote for judges [29:11] who have always done [29:12] the right thing [29:13] and look no further [29:15] than Joe Fowby [29:16] to find someone [29:16] who fits that bill. [29:18] Instead of running [29:19] from danger [29:20] or from difficult [29:21] legal questions, [29:22] Joe has taken these things [29:23] on for the good [29:24] of the American people. [29:26] Now, more than ever, [29:27] our country needs judges [29:28] who love America [29:29] and love our Constitution. [29:32] And Joe has been a warrior [29:33] for the Constitution [29:34] and for everything [29:35] that makes this country [29:36] the greatest country [29:36] in the history of the world. [29:37] So I'm very proud [29:39] that President Trump [29:40] nominated Joseph Fowby [29:41] and I appreciate [29:42] your consideration [29:44] and your support [29:45] of him today. [29:46] I look forward [29:46] to casting my vote [29:47] on the floor [29:48] of the Senate [29:48] very soon [29:49] to confirm him. [29:50] Thank you. [29:51] God bless. [29:53] Thank you, Senator Banks. [29:54] Senator Tillis. [29:56] Thank you, Senator Cruz. [29:57] And I want to thank [29:59] the administration [30:00] for bringing forth [30:01] nominations [30:02] that Senator Budd [30:03] and I worked hard on [30:04] to get before [30:05] this committee. [30:06] I think that Senator Budd [30:10] covered the landscape [30:11] well on both Brian [30:14] and Phillip's background. [30:16] So I want to respond [30:16] to the comment [30:17] that was made here [30:18] about a member [30:19] of this committee [30:20] who said some bonehead [30:22] brought a suit [30:22] based on a picture [30:25] in the sand [30:25] called 8647. [30:27] You're looking at that bonehead [30:28] or you're looking [30:28] at that member. [30:30] And I did say [30:30] that that person [30:31] was a bonehead [30:32] because it was dumb [30:33] and I don't see [30:34] anything coming [30:35] out of that investigation. [30:36] But does anybody [30:37] in the 12 years [30:38] that I've been [30:38] on this committee [30:39] honestly believe [30:41] that if I thought [30:42] that person [30:43] was associated [30:44] with this [30:44] that they'd be [30:44] before the committee? [30:46] Does anybody remember [30:47] how many nominations [30:48] I have crushed [30:49] because they denied [30:51] that January 6th [30:52] was a dark day [30:53] in the city? [30:55] Anybody want to do that? [30:57] Does anybody want [30:58] to remember [30:58] how many judges [30:59] that I've confirmed [31:00] on the other side [31:01] of the aisle to be fair? [31:03] So the point here [31:04] is why don't we be fair here? [31:06] John Locke once said [31:07] to prejudge [31:08] other men's notions [31:09] before we'd look [31:09] due to them [31:10] is not to show [31:11] their darkness [31:11] but to put out [31:12] our own eyes. [31:13] Instead of judging [31:14] these nominees [31:15] that people should know [31:16] damn well [31:16] when I've made it [31:17] through my vetting [31:18] why not ask them [31:19] a question [31:20] and give them [31:20] a fair hearing [31:21] which I have done [31:22] for the last 12 years [31:23] on this committee. [31:25] Brian and Philip [31:26] are going to make [31:26] great judges. [31:27] Every Republican [31:28] is going to vote [31:29] for them [31:29] because they're [31:30] great judges. [31:31] I think they're [31:31] even going to pass [31:32] the Kennedy test. [31:34] If they don't [31:35] I've told them [31:35] they're never going [31:36] to live it down. [31:37] But the point here [31:38] is trying to attack [31:40] people before you've [31:41] even taken a second [31:43] to ask them a question [31:44] is what's wrong [31:45] with this town. [31:47] Why don't you give [31:47] people a chance [31:48] to answer a question [31:49] before you condemn them? [31:51] And especially [31:52] for somebody like me [31:53] that has had no nonsense [31:54] for this administration [31:56] or any administration [31:57] that does something [31:59] like that. [32:00] And for the record [32:02] Mr. Chair [32:03] I would like to submit [32:05] my formal comments [32:06] into in the interest [32:08] of brevity [32:08] I deferred on my [32:09] formal comments [32:10] to cover that point [32:11] that was raised [32:12] by Senator Durbin [32:13] who I respect [32:14] and I've enjoyed [32:15] serving with [32:16] but I think [32:16] that comment [32:17] went too far [32:18] and I'd also like [32:19] unanimous consent [32:20] to submit additional [32:21] letters of recommendation [32:22] including from a Duke [32:24] law professor [32:25] for Mr. Albert [32:26] and other letters [32:27] of recommendation [32:28] for my two nominations. [32:29] Without objection [32:32] they'll be entered [32:33] into the record. [32:33] Thank you Mr. Chair. [32:35] Senator Graham. [32:38] Thank you. [32:39] Thank you Mr. Chairman. [32:40] I'm pleased to be [32:42] introducing Grayson Lambert [32:44] President Trump's nominee [32:45] to be a United States [32:46] District Judge [32:47] for the District [32:48] of South Carolina. [32:49] To fill this vacancy [32:51] President Trump [32:52] could not have made [32:53] a better choice [32:54] than Grayson Lambert [32:55] a native of South Carolina [32:57] he already has [32:59] an exemplary record [33:01] of public service [33:02] to our state. [33:02] Since 2021 [33:04] he's worked [33:05] for Governor [33:05] Henry McMaster [33:06] first as a senior [33:08] legal counsel [33:09] and most recently [33:10] as the governor's [33:11] chief legal counsel. [33:13] In that role [33:14] he was at the forefront [33:15] of the most pressing [33:17] constitutional [33:17] and appellate issues [33:19] facing South Carolina. [33:21] Before entering [33:22] public service [33:23] he spent nearly [33:24] a decade [33:24] in private practice [33:26] where he handled [33:26] a wide range [33:27] of complex cases. [33:30] He received [33:31] his bachelor's degree [33:32] from the University [33:33] of Virginia [33:34] and his law degree [33:35] from Duke [33:35] where he graduated [33:36] with high honors [33:38] and served as executive [33:39] editor on the Duke [33:41] Law Journal. [33:42] After graduating [33:43] he was a law clerk [33:44] for Judge Dennis Shedd [33:46] on the U.S. Court [33:47] of Appeals [33:47] for the Fourth Circuit. [33:50] Many members [33:50] of his family [33:51] including his wife [33:53] and one of his three sons [33:54] are here with him today. [33:56] I know Grayson [33:57] will make them [33:58] and South Carolina proud. [34:00] He is highly qualified [34:02] and has the exact [34:03] kind of sterling character [34:05] as a person [34:06] and distinguished reputation [34:08] as a lawyer [34:09] that is necessary [34:10] for service [34:11] in the federal judiciary. [34:13] I look forward [34:13] to supporting [34:14] his nomination [34:15] and I would like [34:16] to encourage [34:16] all my colleagues [34:18] to do the same. [34:19] Thank you. [34:20] Thank you [34:23] and I thank all [34:23] the senators [34:24] that came to join us [34:26] in the Senate Judiciary Committee. [34:27] We'll now move on [34:28] to the business [34:28] of the hearing [34:29] and let you get [34:31] on to your busy schedules. [34:34] With that [34:35] we would ask [34:36] that Justice Highland [34:37] will you please [34:38] come forward [34:39] and I'll now administer [35:02] the oath. [35:03] Will you raise [35:03] your right hand? [35:06] Do you swear [35:07] that the testimony [35:08] you're about to give [35:08] before this committee [35:09] will be the truth [35:10] the whole truth [35:11] and nothing but the truth [35:12] so help you God. [35:15] Thank you very much. [35:16] Have a seat. [35:19] It's our normal practice [35:20] to allow you [35:21] if you desire [35:21] to introduce the people [35:22] that are with you [35:23] including your family [35:24] and then you may give [35:25] your opening statement. [35:27] Justice Highland [35:28] the floor is yours. [35:30] Thank you Mr. Chairman. [35:32] First of all [35:32] I'd like to extend [35:34] my thanks to [35:35] Senator Bozeman [35:35] and Senator Cotton [35:36] for their kind words [35:37] and really a lifetime [35:39] of support of me [35:40] in any role [35:41] that we've ever [35:42] played in the state. [35:44] They are [35:45] they love [35:46] the state of Arkansas [35:47] and they're great leaders [35:49] and I appreciate [35:50] their friendship. [35:51] I'd like to thank [35:54] Mr. Chairman [35:56] the chairman [35:57] and ranking member [35:58] Durbin [35:58] for having this committee [35:59] having me sit [36:00] at this table [36:01] and be given [36:01] an opportunity [36:02] to be heard. [36:04] I'd like to thank [36:05] President Trump [36:06] for the nomination. [36:08] I understand [36:09] the grave implication [36:10] of taking [36:11] an Eighth Circuit [36:12] court seat [36:13] if confirmed [36:14] by this Senate [36:15] and I appreciate [36:17] the faith [36:17] and the trust [36:18] that he's placed [36:18] in me. [36:19] I'd like to recognize [36:22] my wife [36:23] Jana. [36:25] Jana is an incredible [36:27] partner for me [36:29] and has been. [36:30] She has truly [36:31] been with me [36:32] every step of the way [36:33] and some of those [36:34] steps weren't easy [36:35] and so [36:36] you'll never find [36:38] a more selfless [36:39] caring [36:40] person [36:42] that gives you [36:43] unconditional love [36:43] no matter how bad [36:44] my day may be. [36:46] I know that at the end [36:47] of that day [36:47] I get to come home [36:48] to a wife [36:49] who loves me unconditionally [36:50] which is an incredible [36:52] blessing to have. [36:54] I've got [36:55] my daughter Katie [36:56] who is pregnant [36:57] with her first child [37:00] Elsie [37:01] due in December. [37:03] Her husband John [37:04] is with me [37:05] and then my son [37:06] John Reagan [37:07] is with us. [37:09] My son Ethan [37:10] who is an Arkansas [37:10] State Trooper [37:11] and was awarded [37:14] the Trooper [37:15] of the Year [37:15] last year [37:16] as a rookie [37:16] with two of his colleagues. [37:18] Couldn't be here today [37:19] because he's working [37:20] and my daughter Claire [37:21] who has our three [37:22] beautiful grandchildren [37:23] back in Arkansas. [37:27] I would be remiss [37:29] if I did not [37:30] recognize my parents. [37:34] Any good life [37:35] begins with a firm foundation. [37:38] My sister Kami [37:39] and I [37:39] were blessed [37:40] with two parents [37:41] Jim and Kay Highland [37:43] who loved us unconditionally [37:45] who had us in church [37:47] Sunday morning [37:47] Sunday night [37:48] and Wednesday night. [37:50] Every night [37:51] before we would go to bed [37:52] we would sit in a circle [37:53] on the floor [37:53] and pray to the God [37:55] who created us [37:56] and the Savior [37:56] who loved and redeemed us [37:58] and I cannot thank them [38:00] enough for that upraising. [38:04] And the great thing [38:05] about my parents [38:05] is they never lived [38:06] a hypocritical moment [38:08] and so it never undermined [38:10] the lessons [38:10] that they taught us [38:11] nor the source [38:12] of those lessons. [38:14] And so [38:16] my mom's at home today [38:18] she couldn't make it [38:20] but we lost my dad [38:21] in 2018 to cancer [38:22] and I would give anything [38:25] to have him sitting here [38:27] today with us. [38:29] You know [38:30] any career [38:31] that leads to a situation [38:33] where you're sitting [38:33] at this table [38:34] doesn't happen [38:36] in a vacuum. [38:38] And senators [38:39] if there is any sort of [38:41] if anybody ever [38:42] attributes success [38:44] to my career [38:45] in any sense [38:46] those laurels [38:48] don't belong to me [38:49] they belong to [38:51] the people [38:51] who came alongside me [38:52] and helped me [38:54] along in the journey [38:54] and there are too many [38:56] of them to name [38:57] but I would like [38:58] to single out [38:59] Gunnar Bartlett [39:00] who is my clerk [39:02] of the Supreme Court [39:03] Gunnar is a wonder kind [39:04] of organization [39:06] and legal acumen [39:07] and then there are [39:10] just the people [39:11] that came along [39:12] and without them [39:14] I couldn't have made [39:15] it this far [39:15] Troy Braswell [39:17] Circuit Judge [39:18] Hugh Finkelstein [39:19] Carol Cruz [39:20] Joan Shipley [39:21] Jonathan Ross [39:23] just to name a few [39:24] and I'm sure [39:25] that I'm leaving [39:26] some out [39:26] and I'm sure [39:26] that they're going [39:27] to call me out [39:28] for that [39:28] when I get home [39:28] but it has been [39:31] an incredible journey [39:32] accompanied by [39:33] committed public servants [39:35] and Senators [39:37] and Senators [39:37] I will just say [39:38] in closing [39:39] if confirmed [39:41] by the Senate [39:41] I understand [39:43] the gravity [39:43] of the role [39:45] I'm about to play [39:46] again if confirmed [39:48] and I don't take it lightly [39:51] I feel the weight of it [39:53] I have engaged [39:55] in public service before [39:56] and felt that way before [39:57] but it is an honor [39:59] to bear that [40:00] and one of the things [40:03] that I want to make sure [40:04] that if I am confirmed [40:05] by the Senate [40:06] that at the end [40:07] of my career [40:08] I've heard it said [40:09] that it isn't titles [40:10] who honor men [40:11] but it's men [40:12] who honor titles [40:13] my goal is for people [40:15] to say Judge Highland [40:17] brought honor [40:18] to the title [40:19] of Eighth Circuit Judge [40:21] and so with that [40:22] Mr. Chairman [40:22] I'll close [40:23] thank you Justice Highland [40:29] welcome [40:30] congratulations [40:31] on your nomination [40:32] you've had a distinguished [40:34] career in public service [40:35] as a local prosecutor [40:37] as a U.S. attorney [40:38] and now as a justice [40:40] of the Arkansas Supreme Court [40:41] let's begin with your experience [40:44] as a local prosecutor [40:45] what did that work teach you [40:48] about the importance [40:49] of the rule of law [40:50] to ordinary Americans [40:52] Senator [40:55] that everybody is treated equally [40:59] we had several cases [41:01] you know [41:02] you obviously have [41:03] all the violent crime [41:04] and things like that [41:05] that come [41:06] and that you deal with [41:07] but we also had cases [41:09] with white collar crime involved [41:11] and you know [41:13] inevitably [41:13] as a prosecuting attorney [41:15] you probably get those calls [41:16] that say [41:16] hey can you let this one go [41:18] but we didn't [41:20] we never pulled a punch [41:21] Senator [41:21] not one time [41:22] and I think what that led to [41:25] was a trust [41:27] in our motivation [41:28] that we were going to [41:30] apply the law equally [41:31] and that no matter [41:33] what your station in life [41:35] you know [41:37] we were going to apply [41:38] the law [41:38] and the facts [41:39] and give you [41:40] a fair shake [41:41] and so to me [41:43] one of the things [41:45] that I learned there [41:45] was [41:46] how important it is [41:48] to be consistent [41:49] with the law [41:50] so that people [41:51] don't lose faith [41:51] and trust [41:52] in the law [41:53] from there [41:56] you served [41:57] as United States Attorney [41:58] where your office [42:00] prosecuted violent gangs [42:02] and drug traffickers [42:03] and individuals [42:04] who exploited children [42:05] tell us about that work [42:07] and how your experience [42:09] as a federal prosecutor [42:10] impacted you [42:11] and prepared you [42:12] to be a federal appellate judge [42:14] well Senator [42:17] the work that we did there [42:19] again [42:20] you know [42:20] we give credit to [42:22] the AUSAs [42:24] and the local law enforcement [42:26] and federal law enforcement [42:27] we had incredible partners [42:28] when I took over [42:30] Little Rock was [42:32] had a real problem [42:33] with violent crime [42:34] and so [42:35] we set about [42:36] to try to make [42:38] a tangible difference [42:39] and move the needle [42:40] with violent crime [42:41] in Little Rock [42:42] and other areas [42:43] and so [42:44] you know [42:45] Arkansas's [42:46] at the time [42:47] their parole system [42:48] was weaker [42:49] and so you had people [42:51] that would go into [42:52] the state system [42:53] and come out [42:53] many of them [42:55] with criminal histories [42:56] as long as your forearm [42:57] and so our goal [42:59] was if we caught them [43:00] with a weapon [43:02] we were going to [43:04] adopt the case [43:05] and [43:06] we were after [43:08] the trigger pullers [43:09] and Senator [43:09] there were several [43:10] trigger pullers [43:11] in our city [43:13] and so [43:14] by the end of 2018 [43:17] our caseload [43:17] had increased 83% [43:19] and it's one thing [43:20] to increase your caseload [43:21] it's another thing [43:22] for it to have [43:23] an actual impact [43:24] on public safety [43:25] but [43:26] that year [43:27] homicides went down [43:28] 24% [43:29] drive-by shootings [43:31] went down 55% [43:32] and we had an overall [43:34] drop in crime [43:35] with the exception [43:35] I think of rape [43:36] all across the board [43:38] and so that doesn't [43:40] happen in a vacuum [43:41] that just wasn't [43:42] the U.S. Attorney's Office [43:43] that was the Little Rock PD [43:44] that was the Arkansas [43:45] State Police [43:46] that was the [43:47] 6th Judicial District [43:48] Prosecuting Attorney's Office [43:49] and our office [43:51] and we worked together [43:52] in order to bring [43:54] a level of attention [43:57] to the glaring problem [44:00] of violent crime [44:01] and it's something [44:02] that we're pretty proud of [44:04] you're now serving [44:07] on the Arkansas [44:08] Supreme Court [44:09] tell this committee [44:10] what you have learned [44:13] from that role [44:13] and what characteristics [44:17] define a principled [44:20] federal appellate judge [44:22] well Senator [44:25] I guess there are [44:26] several things [44:27] but the first thing [44:27] that comes to mind [44:28] is the importance [44:30] of separation of powers [44:31] the role of the legislature [44:33] and the role of the [44:34] executive [44:35] and making sure [44:36] that as a Supreme Court [44:38] in the judiciary [44:39] we maintain our role [44:40] and we don't get [44:41] outside our lane [44:42] that you know [44:45] Justice Scalia [44:46] famously addressed that [44:47] in a committee [44:48] talking about [44:49] its importance [44:50] and the diffusion [44:51] of power [44:51] that is [44:53] a hallmark [44:54] of our process [44:56] and so we have [44:57] to maintain our roles [44:58] and certainly [45:00] the application [45:03] of the law [45:05] and having fidelity [45:07] to the text [45:08] of our law [45:09] and we had cases [45:10] in front of us [45:11] where that became [45:12] an issue [45:12] and their ranking member [45:15] Durbin mentioned one [45:16] that we overturned [45:20] you know [45:20] 75 year precedent [45:21] because of the plain language [45:23] of the Constitution [45:24] and so fidelity [45:26] to the text [45:27] is critical [45:28] Senator [45:29] and I'm committed [45:30] to that [45:31] and you know [45:34] the other thing [45:35] is we take the cases [45:36] as they come to us [45:37] we don't prejudge them [45:39] we read the briefs [45:42] we read the record [45:42] and we make decisions [45:44] based on the law [45:46] and the facts [45:46] and you have to be willing [45:48] to separate your emotion [45:50] your personal preferences [45:52] your affiliations [45:54] from that consideration [45:56] and so [45:57] that's a lesson [45:58] that has been [45:59] reinforced to me [46:01] as a Supreme Court Justice [46:02] Thank you [46:03] Ranking Member Durbin [46:04] Justice Highland [46:05] welcome [46:06] and to your family [46:07] and friends [46:08] I'd like to make a point [46:09] at the opening [46:10] responding to my colleague [46:12] and friend [46:12] from North Carolina [46:13] this is a process [46:16] of advice [46:16] and consent [46:17] you are seeking [46:19] to be part [46:21] of the second highest court [46:23] in the United States [46:24] of America [46:24] I'm sure that is not [46:26] lost on you [46:27] as you sit at that table [46:28] secondly [46:29] you're asking [46:30] to be given [46:31] that opportunity [46:32] for life [46:33] for the rest [46:34] of your natural life [46:35] you can serve [46:36] in that capacity [46:36] to say that we take [46:38] this seriously [46:39] it's exactly what [46:39] we're supposed to do [46:40] up here [46:41] we're asked to [46:42] ask serious questions [46:43] so that we can understand [46:45] whether you [46:46] are right for that job [46:47] it is also quite possible [46:49] that we are troubled [46:51] by the fact [46:51] that we've had [46:52] the response [46:53] to your questionnaire [46:54] an extensive questionnaire [46:56] as to your background [46:57] we've had access [46:58] to that for [46:59] seven days [47:01] that's it [47:02] you would be [47:04] the shortest period [47:05] of time [47:05] of any nominee [47:06] that we've received [47:07] a questionnaire [47:08] in the 30 years [47:09] that I've [47:10] 28 years [47:10] that I've served [47:11] in this committee [47:12] so to think [47:13] that we're asking [47:13] tough questions [47:14] that's the reason [47:15] we have limited opportunity [47:17] to review your background [47:18] and you are seeking [47:20] the second highest court [47:22] in the land [47:22] for a lifetime appointment [47:23] that's important [47:25] in August [47:26] you spoke to a group [47:27] of law students [47:28] about the selection process [47:29] to the federal bench [47:30] you told them [47:32] you had expected [47:32] to receive a call [47:33] from President Trump [47:34] informing you [47:35] of the intent [47:36] to nominate you [47:37] to this 8th circuit [47:38] instead you received [47:40] a call from staff [47:41] at the White House [47:41] asking if you'd be [47:43] interested in filling [47:44] a district court vacancy [47:45] calling yourself [47:47] calling yourself [47:49] quote belligerent [47:50] you declined the offer [47:52] when asked by [47:54] the White House staff [47:55] if they should quote [47:56] go back in the Oval Office [47:57] and tell the President [47:58] you're rejecting [47:59] an opportunity [48:00] to do an appointment [48:01] to the federal bench [48:02] you responded [48:03] and I quote [48:04] yes that's exactly [48:05] what I want you [48:06] to tell the President [48:07] of the United States [48:08] conservative law professor [48:10] Josh Blackmon [48:11] criticized you [48:12] for publicly airing [48:13] this information [48:14] claiming it quote [48:15] demonstrated [48:16] absolutely terrible judgment [48:18] which should permanently [48:19] disqualify you [48:20] from holding public office [48:22] do you consider yourself [48:24] belligerent justice [48:25] senator I do not [48:28] do you believe [48:29] that temperament [48:30] is an important part [48:31] of service [48:32] on the judiciary [48:33] yes senator I do [48:34] can you control [48:35] your emotions [48:36] if you're given [48:36] this opportunity [48:37] senator I think [48:39] that my career [48:40] as a prosecuting [48:41] attorney [48:41] U.S. attorney [48:43] and Supreme Court [48:43] justice [48:44] have demonstrated [48:45] time and time again [48:47] that my emotions [48:48] don't get involved [48:49] as a prosecuting attorney [48:51] there were cases [48:52] that you know [48:53] you would like to bring [48:56] but you didn't have [48:56] the evidence [48:57] and so we couldn't bring it [48:58] there was a homicide case [48:59] where we actually [49:00] had to drop the charges [49:01] because we knew [49:02] that the witness [49:04] that we had [49:04] we discovered [49:05] was lying to us [49:07] so we had to drop [49:07] the charges [49:08] then there are cases [49:10] that you don't want [49:10] to bring [49:11] but you have to [49:12] because the law [49:13] and the facts [49:13] require it [49:15] and so I think [49:16] that I've demonstrated [49:17] that I can discipline [49:19] my emotion [49:20] and look at the law [49:21] and the facts [49:22] as it relates [49:22] to an individual case [49:23] yes sir [49:24] earlier this month [49:25] the former executive director [49:26] of the Arkansas [49:27] Supreme Court Office [49:28] of Professional Programs [49:30] was arrested [49:31] and charged [49:32] with 65 felony counts [49:34] for allegedly tampering [49:36] with bar exam scores [49:37] in the state of Arkansas [49:38] including adding points [49:40] to the scores [49:41] that allowed them [49:42] to pass rather than fail [49:44] the alleged misconduct [49:45] took place [49:46] between 2020 [49:47] and 2025 [49:48] you've sat on the Supreme Court [49:50] since 2023 [49:51] is it accurate [49:53] that the Office [49:54] of Professional Programs [49:55] is an agency [49:56] of your court [49:56] it is [49:59] it is Senator [49:59] when were you first [50:01] made aware [50:01] of these irregularities [50:03] with the bar exams [50:03] I was first made aware [50:07] probably approximately [50:10] May Senator [50:11] but again [50:13] the information [50:14] was [50:14] pardon me [50:15] which year [50:16] what year [50:17] this year [50:19] your honor [50:20] when were the individuals [50:25] who should have failed [50:26] the bar exam [50:27] but are now practicing [50:28] notified [50:29] of the discrepancies [50:31] in their scoring [50:32] Senator I'm sorry [50:34] could you repeat [50:35] that question [50:35] when were the individuals [50:37] the people [50:38] who took the bar exam [50:39] and were told [50:42] they failed [50:42] but are now practicing [50:43] notified [50:44] of this discrepancy [50:46] Senator I will tell you [50:48] that that entire issue [50:51] is subject to [50:51] a federal and state [50:53] criminal investigation [50:54] and the truth is [50:56] it's part and parcel [50:58] of that investigation [50:59] over 11,000 files [51:02] were deleted [51:02] that we're required [51:04] to keep [51:05] as a court by rule [51:05] for 25 years [51:07] and so we have [51:08] we have had [51:09] to [51:10] try to put together [51:12] with the help [51:13] of other agencies [51:14] to recover those files [51:15] some of them [51:17] most of them [51:18] are still unavailable [51:19] and so we're trying [51:20] to get our hands around [51:22] exactly what the universe [51:23] of [51:23] the problem is [51:25] and so [51:26] given [51:27] the ongoing criminal [51:29] investigations [51:30] we have [51:32] there's been no [51:33] communication [51:34] at this point [51:34] it would be inappropriate [51:35] at this time [51:36] because we really don't know [51:37] the full extent [51:38] to what the problem is [51:40] for clarity [51:42] I would like [51:43] to have you [51:44] state for the record [51:45] under oath [51:46] whether you played [51:47] any role [51:47] if not [51:48] you can say that as well [51:50] in the wrongdoing [51:52] that's been alleged [51:53] in that office [51:53] absolutely not [51:56] Senator [51:56] thank you [51:57] I think I'm next [52:03] and then Senator Blumenthal [52:06] Judge [52:08] I take it [52:11] that your interests [52:16] did not lie [52:18] and do not lie [52:19] in serving [52:21] as a trial judge [52:23] would that be [52:24] a fair statement [52:24] that's correct [52:25] Senator [52:25] and [52:28] you expressed [52:30] that to the White House [52:32] so I appreciate it [52:34] yes Senator [52:35] and it was [52:36] a courteous phone call [52:37] it was [52:37] appellate work [52:39] I have really enjoyed it [52:41] on the Supreme Court [52:42] and [52:42] I just told them [52:44] that I would prefer [52:45] to stay on the Supreme Court [52:46] rather than [52:47] you know [52:48] it has nothing to do [52:48] with [52:49] I have federal district [52:51] judge friends [52:51] who are brilliant [52:52] great judges [52:53] it has nothing to do [52:54] with that [52:54] it has to do with fit [52:55] and [52:56] and [52:57] and really my interest [52:58] in appellate work [52:59] versus trial work [53:00] and you were talking [53:01] with the [53:02] office of [53:04] White House Counsel [53:06] yes Senator [53:08] okay [53:08] were you rude [53:14] to whom Senator [53:17] to [53:18] when White House Counsel [53:19] called you [53:20] oh absolutely not [53:21] Senator [53:21] and I think [53:22] if you talk to them [53:23] they would tell you [53:23] that as well [53:24] okay [53:25] were you belligerent [53:27] no Senator [53:29] again this was a [53:31] 10 minute [53:31] extemporaneous speech [53:33] to first year law students [53:34] and when we speak [53:35] extemporaneously [53:36] sometimes we use [53:37] words we shouldn't [53:38] the proper word [53:40] was probably resolute [53:41] in the [53:42] as it relates [53:43] to being a [53:44] an appellate court judge [53:46] versus the other [53:47] I mean [53:47] you know [53:48] Senator [53:48] Arkansas is a small state [53:50] you know [53:51] the FBI [53:51] had conducted [53:52] a background investigation [53:53] and probably talked [53:54] to a hundred people [53:55] and so [53:55] it was out [53:56] and so [53:57] you know [53:58] it was important to me [53:59] that people understood [54:00] this was not about [54:02] anything other than [54:04] the president has the [54:05] constitutional authority [54:06] to make that decision [54:07] he made it [54:08] I was [54:09] I had another opportunity [54:10] but it wasn't a fit [54:12] for me [54:12] and I enjoy my work [54:14] I've got a great job [54:15] on the Arkansas [54:15] Supreme Court [54:16] it's unbelievably [54:18] fulfilling [54:19] and you know [54:20] I enjoy the appellate work [54:21] Senator [54:22] so you like [54:23] your interests [54:25] and I take it [54:26] your expertise [54:27] lies on appellate work [54:29] as opposed to trial work [54:30] well that's correct [54:32] Senator [54:32] I don't know [54:33] that I would [54:33] ascribe expertise [54:34] to my appellate work [54:36] yet but I'm hoping [54:37] to get there [54:37] and you expressed [54:39] that to White House [54:40] Council [54:40] I did [54:43] when they inquired [54:45] about the district [54:45] court seat [54:46] I said [54:46] that I think [54:48] I would prefer [54:48] to stay on the Arkansas [54:50] Supreme Court [54:50] and thank the president [54:52] for his consideration [54:52] and they went back [54:54] and talked to the president [54:55] is that right [54:56] Senator [54:57] I don't [54:57] I don't know [54:58] well let's assume [54:59] they did [54:59] because the president's [55:01] generally [55:01] it's been my experience [55:03] more involved [55:04] in his second term [55:05] than his [55:06] than his first term [55:07] and the president [55:08] apparently said [55:10] okay [55:10] man wants to be [55:13] on the appellate court [55:14] as opposed to the trial court [55:16] and he's qualified [55:17] so let's go with [55:18] appellate court [55:19] is that [55:20] what happened [55:21] Senator [55:23] I'm just not privy [55:26] to exactly [55:26] what happened [55:27] I can tell you [55:28] that [55:28] I guess [55:29] what I'm trying [55:30] to find out [55:30] is what's the big deal [55:32] Senator [55:33] I don't know [55:34] people have preferences [55:36] and some lawyers [55:38] like being in court [55:40] and some lawyers [55:41] like writing [55:41] and arguing the briefs [55:44] if I don't [55:45] but I appreciate [55:48] your honesty [55:48] I mean you weren't [55:50] privy to the conversations [55:51] Senator I wasn't [55:53] I can tell you [55:53] that I was contacted [55:54] in late June [55:55] by two men [55:56] I greatly admire [55:57] about whether [55:58] they could submit [55:59] a letter to the president [56:00] for me [56:00] and went through [56:02] that process [56:02] and once another nominee [56:04] was announced [56:05] Senator I haven't heard [56:07] a thing until [56:08] you know [56:08] last Tuesday [56:10] I kind of think [56:11] it's cool [56:12] that you would say [56:15] to White House [56:16] Counsel [56:17] look [56:17] you know [56:18] I like appellate work [56:20] I don't like trial work [56:21] I mean I could do it [56:23] but I'm going to turn down [56:25] the honor [56:25] of being a federal [56:26] district court judge [56:28] because I want to do [56:30] appellate work [56:32] we [56:33] I mean an ambitious [56:36] purely ambitious person [56:38] would have said [56:39] sure [56:40] I can learn [56:41] to like it [56:42] Senator I think [56:44] it's important [56:44] that you know yourself [56:46] and again [56:47] with that speech [56:48] it was about resiliency [56:49] and the fact that [56:52] even at my stage [56:53] of a career [56:54] I wanted to be [56:55] vulnerable with them [56:55] at my stage [56:56] of a career [56:57] you still have [56:59] professional disappointments [57:00] sure [57:00] and as a law student [57:02] you were talking [57:03] to a bunch [57:03] of law students [57:04] about the experience [57:05] and that's what's happened [57:06] yes sir [57:06] and you kind of [57:07] made some flip comments [57:09] oh yeah [57:09] I've never done that [57:11] and maybe [57:13] in hindsight [57:14] you'd express things [57:16] in a different way [57:16] I would have used [57:18] the word resolute [57:19] and put it into context [57:20] I've never had to regret [57:22] anything I've said [57:23] it's [57:23] oh okay [57:25] I don't mean [57:26] to overstay my welcome [57:28] and until [57:28] until General Cruz [57:30] gets back [57:31] he asked me to preside [57:33] so I'm going to hush [57:34] and turn to Senator Blumenthal [57:36] thank you Senator [57:39] Justice [57:41] who won the 2020 election [57:43] Senator [57:46] Joe Biden [57:48] received [57:49] the electoral vote [57:51] and was certified [57:52] by this congress [57:53] as president [57:54] of the United States [57:55] and served [57:55] four years [57:56] as president [57:57] who won [57:59] the popular vote [58:01] Senator [58:02] the popular vote [58:03] is not what's important [58:05] respectfully [58:06] I mean [58:06] it's the electoral college [58:07] and Joe Biden [58:09] received those votes [58:09] I asked you [58:10] a factual question [58:12] who won [58:13] the popular vote [58:14] nationally [58:16] Senator [58:17] respectfully [58:19] the electoral college [58:20] is what dictates [58:21] and Joe Biden [58:22] was certified [58:23] I know [58:24] what the constitution [58:25] provides [58:25] Mr. Justice [58:27] I'm asking you [58:28] as a factual matter [58:30] who won [58:32] the largest [58:33] number [58:34] of votes [58:35] nationally [58:37] also known [58:38] as the popular vote [58:39] I'm aware [58:40] of the electoral [58:41] college [58:41] as an institution [58:42] and its role [58:44] I'm asking you [58:46] a separate question [58:48] who got [58:49] the largest [58:50] number [58:50] of votes [58:51] in the United States [58:52] of America [58:53] in 2020 [58:54] Senator [58:55] again [58:56] as a [58:59] judicial nominee [59:01] let me [59:02] make a suggestion [59:04] to you [59:04] just tell me [59:05] I'm not going to [59:07] answer that question [59:08] you'll save [59:08] all of us time [59:10] Senator [59:10] I think it gets [59:12] into a political question [59:13] I'm not going to answer [59:14] that question [59:14] you're not going to answer [59:15] why [59:17] because again [59:19] Senator [59:19] I think it's going down [59:20] a political track [59:21] on an issue [59:22] that happened [59:23] six years ago [59:24] and I don't want [59:25] to come close [59:26] to a potential [59:27] ethical violation [59:28] with [59:28] an ethical violation [59:30] in answering [59:31] a strictly factual question [59:33] you know [59:34] this is a test [59:35] of your independence [59:36] we know [59:37] by now [59:38] the White House [59:40] has told you [59:40] don't answer that question [59:42] I'm simply asking you [59:45] about how independent [59:48] you're going to be [59:49] of this White House [59:51] let me ask you [59:52] another question [59:54] was the Capitol [59:57] attacked on January [59:58] 6, 2021 [59:59] Senator [1:00:01] there was certainly [1:00:02] violent acts [1:00:07] that day [1:00:08] people were prosecuted [1:00:10] for those acts [1:00:11] and anytime [1:00:12] there's sufficient evidence [1:00:14] for [1:00:14] to establish [1:00:16] that a criminal [1:00:17] conduct has occurred [1:00:19] people need to be [1:00:20] prosecuted [1:00:21] and they were [1:00:23] so you are agreeing [1:00:27] with me [1:00:27] that the Capitol [1:00:28] was attacked [1:00:29] Senator [1:00:32] I'm just saying [1:00:33] that there were [1:00:34] violent acts [1:00:34] committed that day [1:00:35] that people [1:00:36] were prosecuted for [1:00:36] No, you're not [1:00:37] agreeing with me [1:00:37] that the Capitol [1:00:38] was attacked [1:00:39] Senator, I'm not [1:00:39] going to get into [1:00:40] the characterization [1:00:41] of what that was [1:00:41] Not going to answer [1:00:42] the question again [1:00:43] right? [1:00:52] Senator [1:00:52] respectfully [1:00:54] I think I've [1:00:55] answered the question [1:00:56] there were violent [1:00:57] attacks [1:00:57] there were [1:00:58] I haven't [1:00:59] respectfully [1:00:59] or not [1:01:00] answered the question [1:01:02] everybody in this room [1:01:03] knows that you [1:01:04] haven't answered [1:01:05] the question [1:01:05] you know [1:01:06] you haven't [1:01:06] answered the question [1:01:07] I know you [1:01:08] haven't answered [1:01:09] the question [1:01:09] but most importantly [1:01:10] for you [1:01:11] your audience [1:01:13] of one [1:01:14] which is [1:01:15] the White House [1:01:16] knows you haven't [1:01:17] answered the question [1:01:18] I'm not going to [1:01:20] waste the time [1:01:21] of this committee [1:01:22] by observing [1:01:25] with all due respect [1:01:28] of course [1:01:29] that you have shown [1:01:30] a complete lack [1:01:32] of independence [1:01:33] of this White House [1:01:36] and you would [1:01:37] not answer [1:01:38] this way [1:01:38] to the voters [1:01:40] of Arkansas [1:01:40] if you were [1:01:42] a candidate [1:01:42] for the court [1:01:45] there in your [1:01:45] present position [1:01:46] because they would [1:01:49] defeat you [1:01:49] handily [1:01:50] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:01:52] Senator Schmidt [1:01:56] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:01:58] I'm not going to [1:02:03] we had a good [1:02:05] conversation [1:02:05] in my office [1:02:06] I appreciate [1:02:07] your time [1:02:08] and based on [1:02:10] your record [1:02:11] and your opinions [1:02:15] you are [1:02:17] a judge [1:02:19] that I think [1:02:19] is fair to [1:02:20] characterize [1:02:21] you rule [1:02:21] based on the law [1:02:24] not how you [1:02:25] want it to be [1:02:25] is that fair [1:02:26] that's correct [1:02:28] Senator [1:02:28] I did want to [1:02:29] ask before [1:02:30] I ask you [1:02:31] two questions [1:02:31] first is [1:02:32] just the fundamental [1:02:34] nature of our [1:02:34] constitution [1:02:35] and a judge [1:02:36] you know [1:02:37] ruling on these [1:02:38] really important [1:02:38] questions [1:02:39] do you share [1:02:41] the belief [1:02:42] that the founders [1:02:43] did that our [1:02:44] rights [1:02:44] are [1:02:46] predate [1:02:47] the constitution [1:02:48] I do [1:02:51] Senator [1:02:51] and that [1:02:52] the constitution [1:02:53] this brilliantly [1:02:54] drafted document [1:02:55] was meant [1:02:55] to secure [1:02:56] those rights [1:02:57] to protect [1:02:57] those rights [1:02:57] government [1:02:58] doesn't grant [1:02:58] anybody rights [1:02:59] just like the [1:02:59] king doesn't [1:03:00] grant anybody [1:03:00] rights [1:03:01] they come to [1:03:02] us from [1:03:02] our creator [1:03:03] right [1:03:03] they're protected [1:03:04] by the constitution [1:03:05] I agree [1:03:05] Senator [1:03:06] we all bring [1:03:08] our own [1:03:09] experiences [1:03:10] to this place [1:03:11] and to where [1:03:12] you're at [1:03:13] a very defining [1:03:15] time in my [1:03:16] journey here [1:03:17] was my time [1:03:18] as attorney general [1:03:20] in Missouri [1:03:20] and [1:03:22] what I found [1:03:25] one of the biggest [1:03:25] takeaways [1:03:26] was that you're [1:03:27] surrounded by a lot [1:03:29] of really smart [1:03:30] people [1:03:30] in the legal world [1:03:32] whether they're judges [1:03:33] or people in this [1:03:35] place [1:03:35] some smarter than [1:03:37] others in this place [1:03:38] but to me [1:03:40] the [1:03:42] differentiator [1:03:44] the separator [1:03:46] between those [1:03:47] I think who should [1:03:48] really be entrusted [1:03:49] with the [1:03:50] power that's [1:03:53] granted by an [1:03:53] office [1:03:54] or from the [1:03:55] people [1:03:56] the difference [1:03:57] is [1:03:57] whether or not [1:03:59] an individual [1:04:00] has courage [1:04:01] because it's [1:04:03] really easy [1:04:03] to sort of [1:04:05] go along [1:04:05] and get along [1:04:07] go to the ribbon [1:04:08] cuttings [1:04:09] or go to the [1:04:09] cocktail parties [1:04:10] but the question [1:04:11] is [1:04:12] is somebody [1:04:14] ascending to a [1:04:15] position like you [1:04:16] might be ascending [1:04:16] to willing to get [1:04:17] the side eye [1:04:18] at a DC cocktail [1:04:19] party [1:04:19] or [1:04:20] you know [1:04:21] the American [1:04:22] Bar Association [1:04:23] throws shade [1:04:24] your way [1:04:24] are you willing [1:04:25] to deal with [1:04:26] all that [1:04:26] and rule [1:04:27] based on your [1:04:28] conscience [1:04:28] and the law [1:04:29] the 8th Circuit [1:04:31] Court of Appeals [1:04:32] in my view [1:04:33] we can roll [1:04:35] the tape back [1:04:35] someday [1:04:36] I think will be [1:04:37] the most important [1:04:38] circuit [1:04:39] for the next 20 years [1:04:41] in this country [1:04:42] I'm not going to get [1:04:42] into all the reasons [1:04:43] why [1:04:43] obviously Missouri [1:04:45] I'm familiar with it [1:04:46] Missouri is in the [1:04:47] 8th Circuit [1:04:48] the biggest state [1:04:49] in the 8th Circuit [1:04:50] actually [1:04:50] but it's going to [1:04:53] play a really [1:04:53] important role [1:04:54] in the really [1:04:55] heady and heavy [1:04:57] constitutional questions [1:04:59] that are going to [1:04:59] come before this country [1:05:00] depending on what [1:05:02] happens in 2 years [1:05:03] or what happens [1:05:04] tomorrow [1:05:04] or 10 years from now [1:05:05] that [1:05:06] the court that you [1:05:08] may sit upon [1:05:09] or sit in [1:05:10] is going to rule [1:05:11] on some of the [1:05:12] most important questions [1:05:13] in the history [1:05:13] of our country [1:05:14] and so I guess [1:05:15] the question [1:05:16] for you [1:05:17] if [1:05:18] you know [1:05:19] my theory of the case [1:05:21] is that courage [1:05:21] is the most [1:05:22] important thing [1:05:23] once you have a baseline [1:05:24] of all the [1:05:25] important things [1:05:26] that you have [1:05:26] can you [1:05:28] describe to me [1:05:30] an instance [1:05:30] where you [1:05:32] made a decision [1:05:33] or you ruled [1:05:34] or you [1:05:34] you know [1:05:35] in any one [1:05:36] of these positions [1:05:37] that you've held [1:05:37] that you knew [1:05:39] would be really [1:05:39] unpopular [1:05:40] and that you knew [1:05:41] that [1:05:42] even friends [1:05:44] of yours [1:05:44] might call you [1:05:46] crazy [1:05:46] or even worse [1:05:47] can you [1:05:49] describe an example [1:05:50] that you [1:05:51] have taken on [1:05:53] in your career [1:05:54] yes senator [1:05:57] you know [1:05:59] as a prosecuting [1:06:00] attorney [1:06:00] you know [1:06:01] as you know [1:06:01] there are decisions [1:06:04] you make [1:06:04] that don't make [1:06:04] friends [1:06:05] we had a situation [1:06:07] and I had three [1:06:08] counties [1:06:09] Faulkner, Van Buren [1:06:10] and Searcy County [1:06:10] when I was [1:06:11] prosecuting attorney [1:06:11] and we had a sheriff [1:06:13] who was the same [1:06:16] political party [1:06:17] that I was [1:06:19] very very popular [1:06:20] and a good man [1:06:21] but he had [1:06:22] a criminal [1:06:23] conviction in his past [1:06:25] that prohibited him [1:06:27] from being able [1:06:28] to serve [1:06:28] I made the decision [1:06:31] to remove him [1:06:31] pursuant to Arkansas law [1:06:33] which didn't make [1:06:35] the people of [1:06:36] Searcy County [1:06:37] very happy [1:06:37] but I felt like [1:06:39] it was [1:06:39] again [1:06:40] when we talk [1:06:41] about the law [1:06:42] it has to be [1:06:42] applied equally [1:06:43] and so [1:06:44] that was one [1:06:45] one that's a little [1:06:47] more [1:06:47] I guess [1:06:47] a little lighter [1:06:48] but still [1:06:49] nonetheless [1:06:49] difficult [1:06:50] we had a [1:06:52] pretty notorious [1:06:53] speed trap [1:06:54] in my district [1:06:56] from my hometown [1:06:56] and I remember [1:06:59] giving the [1:07:00] commencement address [1:07:01] to law school [1:07:03] graduation [1:07:03] and they were [1:07:04] reading my bio [1:07:05] and of course [1:07:06] nobody ever cares [1:07:07] about the bio [1:07:08] when you're being [1:07:09] introduced [1:07:09] until he got [1:07:11] to the part [1:07:11] where he said [1:07:12] he's also [1:07:13] responsible [1:07:13] for shutting [1:07:14] down the [1:07:14] Damascus [1:07:15] speed trap [1:07:15] and the place [1:07:16] erupted [1:07:17] with applause [1:07:18] and so [1:07:19] there's a lesson [1:07:20] there [1:07:20] but the bottom [1:07:21] line was [1:07:22] that was my [1:07:23] hometown [1:07:23] that mayor [1:07:25] was my [1:07:25] biology teacher [1:07:26] a man for whom [1:07:28] I had great [1:07:28] affection [1:07:29] a man that [1:07:30] went to church [1:07:31] with my mom [1:07:32] and dad [1:07:32] but we still [1:07:34] had to do [1:07:35] the right thing [1:07:35] and call [1:07:36] for the [1:07:37] investigation [1:07:37] and then make [1:07:39] a determination [1:07:39] as to what [1:07:40] was going to [1:07:40] happen there [1:07:41] that was difficult [1:07:43] we also [1:07:44] prosecuted [1:07:45] the UCA [1:07:47] president [1:07:48] and chief [1:07:48] of staff [1:07:49] mayors [1:07:50] a captain [1:07:50] of the sheriff's [1:07:52] office [1:07:52] state senators [1:07:55] when I was [1:07:55] a U.S. attorney [1:07:57] a lot of elected [1:07:58] officials [1:07:58] and you know [1:08:00] there's always [1:08:00] that undercurrent [1:08:01] of oh please [1:08:02] don't do this [1:08:03] don't go here [1:08:05] but we did [1:08:06] we never pulled [1:08:07] a punch senator [1:08:08] and not because [1:08:08] we're trying [1:08:09] to big dog [1:08:10] or to show [1:08:11] our power [1:08:11] it's because [1:08:12] the law [1:08:13] has to be [1:08:14] applied [1:08:14] to everyone [1:08:15] and so [1:08:16] I guess [1:08:18] I guess [1:08:18] I would [1:08:18] characterize [1:08:19] our tenure [1:08:20] and look [1:08:21] I'm biased [1:08:22] because it's [1:08:23] my tenure [1:08:24] I would say [1:08:25] that we were [1:08:26] never afraid [1:08:26] of blood [1:08:27] in the water [1:08:27] if we had [1:08:28] to make a [1:08:28] decision [1:08:29] it was the [1:08:29] right decision [1:08:30] we were not [1:08:31] afraid of blood [1:08:32] in the water [1:08:32] and all the [1:08:34] things that [1:08:34] surround it [1:08:35] whether it's [1:08:35] phone calls [1:08:36] media inquiries [1:08:38] friends being [1:08:39] disappointed [1:08:39] that was never [1:08:41] a consideration [1:08:42] and so [1:08:44] senator [1:08:45] if I'm [1:08:45] confirmed [1:08:46] to the [1:08:46] 8th circuit [1:08:47] I don't [1:08:48] think I'm [1:08:48] going to [1:08:48] have a [1:08:48] problem [1:08:49] making [1:08:49] decisions [1:08:50] that are [1:08:51] based on [1:08:51] fact [1:08:51] and law [1:08:52] and letting [1:08:53] the rest [1:08:53] fall by the [1:08:54] wayside [1:08:54] well we have [1:08:55] well I appreciate [1:08:56] that answer [1:08:56] we have that [1:08:57] in common [1:08:57] too [1:08:57] I happen to [1:08:58] take on [1:08:58] some speed [1:08:59] traps [1:08:59] in my day [1:09:00] back in [1:09:00] Missouri [1:09:00] I called [1:09:01] it taxation [1:09:02] by citation [1:09:02] so [1:09:03] so we [1:09:05] appreciate [1:09:06] your service [1:09:07] and I pray [1:09:08] for you [1:09:09] and all [1:09:09] that lies [1:09:10] ahead [1:09:10] thank you [1:09:11] thank you [1:09:11] senator welch [1:09:12] thank you [1:09:13] justice [1:09:14] highland [1:09:15] you have [1:09:15] done [1:09:15] the impossible [1:09:16] you got [1:09:17] the senator [1:09:18] from Arkansas [1:09:19] to come [1:09:20] back here [1:09:20] where he used [1:09:22] to be on [1:09:22] the judiciary [1:09:22] committee [1:09:23] it's good [1:09:23] to see [1:09:24] senator [1:09:24] cotton [1:09:24] you know [1:09:26] the judicial [1:09:26] philosophy [1:09:27] is one [1:09:28] of the [1:09:28] elements [1:09:28] of advice [1:09:29] and consent [1:09:30] so I want [1:09:30] to talk [1:09:30] to you [1:09:31] a little [1:09:31] bit [1:09:31] about [1:09:31] that [1:09:31] I don't [1:09:33] have a [1:09:33] problem [1:09:34] with you [1:09:34] having a [1:09:34] preference [1:09:35] for one [1:09:35] type of [1:09:36] judicial [1:09:37] work [1:09:37] versus [1:09:37] another [1:09:38] but [1:09:39] the [1:09:40] comments [1:09:41] you made [1:09:41] after [1:09:42] there were [1:09:43] protests [1:09:43] and after [1:09:44] the George [1:09:45] Floyd [1:09:45] incident [1:09:45] and there [1:09:46] was some [1:09:47] criminal [1:09:47] activity [1:09:47] and to [1:09:48] the extent [1:09:49] that you [1:09:49] talked about [1:09:50] people who [1:09:51] are prosecuted [1:09:52] or people [1:09:53] who committed [1:09:53] crimes should [1:09:54] be prosecuted [1:09:55] I agree [1:09:55] with that [1:09:55] and I also [1:09:57] agree with [1:09:57] the right [1:09:57] of peaceful [1:09:58] protest [1:09:58] but one [1:09:59] one of the [1:10:00] questions [1:10:01] I want [1:10:02] to ask [1:10:02] is whether [1:10:02] after [1:10:03] the events [1:10:04] here [1:10:04] on January [1:10:05] 6th [1:10:06] where there [1:10:07] were [1:10:07] people [1:10:08] who [1:10:09] used [1:10:10] the pepper [1:10:11] spray [1:10:12] the batons [1:10:14] of police [1:10:14] officers [1:10:14] to beat [1:10:15] them up [1:10:15] they were [1:10:17] prosecuted [1:10:17] they were [1:10:17] convicted [1:10:18] do you have [1:10:19] a point [1:10:19] of view [1:10:19] about [1:10:20] the wisdom [1:10:21] of the [1:10:22] president [1:10:23] to pardon [1:10:23] those [1:10:24] people [1:10:24] senator [1:10:27] respectfully [1:10:30] I wouldn't [1:10:31] presume [1:10:32] to [1:10:32] take a [1:10:34] position [1:10:34] on what [1:10:34] the president [1:10:35] was thinking [1:10:35] what information [1:10:37] the president [1:10:37] had in front [1:10:38] of him [1:10:38] to make [1:10:39] that decision [1:10:39] let me just [1:10:39] interrupt [1:10:40] I understand [1:10:41] that but [1:10:41] the president [1:10:42] basically did [1:10:43] a blanket [1:10:43] pardon of [1:10:44] everybody [1:10:44] who was [1:10:45] involved [1:10:45] without [1:10:45] doing [1:10:46] any inquiry [1:10:47] into [1:10:47] who the [1:10:48] cop beaters [1:10:48] were [1:10:48] who did [1:10:50] other people [1:10:52] who may [1:10:52] have been [1:10:53] incidentally [1:10:53] in the [1:10:54] area [1:10:54] so [1:10:55] would it be [1:10:56] your view [1:10:56] that before [1:10:57] a presidential [1:10:58] pardon [1:10:59] is issued [1:11:00] there should [1:11:01] be a [1:11:02] full inquiry [1:11:03] into what [1:11:04] the circumstances [1:11:05] were [1:11:05] and what [1:11:06] the crimes [1:11:07] were [1:11:07] of the [1:11:08] person [1:11:08] who was [1:11:08] being [1:11:09] pardoned [1:11:09] and make [1:11:10] a distinction [1:11:10] between a cop [1:11:11] beater and [1:11:12] somebody who was [1:11:12] on the [1:11:13] periphery [1:11:14] senator [1:11:15] again respectfully [1:11:17] the pardon [1:11:19] power is [1:11:20] reserved to [1:11:21] the president [1:11:22] of the United [1:11:23] States [1:11:23] right [1:11:24] we know [1:11:24] I don't [1:11:26] know what [1:11:27] the process [1:11:29] was in [1:11:29] that particular [1:11:30] case [1:11:31] let me go [1:11:31] on [1:11:32] there was [1:11:34] one of the [1:11:36] rights that [1:11:37] injured people [1:11:38] have is the [1:11:38] tort system [1:11:39] and they can [1:11:40] present their [1:11:41] case [1:11:41] to a jury [1:11:43] as you know [1:11:44] and the jury [1:11:45] makes a [1:11:45] determination [1:11:46] A is their [1:11:46] liability [1:11:47] B what [1:11:48] should be [1:11:48] the damages [1:11:49] and I [1:11:51] understand [1:11:51] there was a [1:11:52] case involving [1:11:52] Old Dominion [1:11:53] where first [1:11:55] responders who [1:11:57] showed up [1:11:58] got toxic [1:12:00] injuries [1:12:00] there was a [1:12:04] tractor trailer [1:12:05] that carried [1:12:05] formic acid [1:12:06] and that's [1:12:07] apparently a [1:12:08] very extremely [1:12:09] dangerous substance [1:12:10] and the [1:12:13] individuals who [1:12:14] were the first [1:12:15] responders got [1:12:16] health problems [1:12:17] according to the [1:12:17] majority opinion [1:12:18] and they suffered [1:12:20] reactive airway [1:12:21] dysfunction [1:12:22] a very brutal [1:12:23] injury [1:12:23] it's like you [1:12:24] drive [1:12:24] like you're [1:12:26] breathing through [1:12:26] a straw [1:12:27] the jury [1:12:28] considered all [1:12:29] the evidence [1:12:29] found Old [1:12:30] Dominion liable [1:12:31] because it knew [1:12:33] that this [1:12:34] formic acid [1:12:35] was there [1:12:35] but did not [1:12:36] give a heads up [1:12:37] to the first [1:12:38] responders [1:12:38] a simple [1:12:39] heads up [1:12:40] to allow them [1:12:41] to protect [1:12:42] themselves [1:12:43] and in your [1:12:45] dissent [1:12:45] you said [1:12:48] that the law [1:12:48] does not permit [1:12:49] juries to convert [1:12:50] transitory or moderate [1:12:52] injuries [1:12:53] into generational [1:12:54] wealth [1:12:55] first of all [1:12:56] how is it [1:12:57] that you [1:12:58] describe these [1:13:00] as these injuries [1:13:01] as transient [1:13:02] or moderate [1:13:03] when the jury [1:13:04] found that they [1:13:05] were quite extreme [1:13:06] Senator [1:13:08] I'm in a tough [1:13:10] position [1:13:11] first of all [1:13:12] you're taking [1:13:12] the position [1:13:13] that my friends [1:13:14] on the majority [1:13:14] took [1:13:15] so I [1:13:15] understand [1:13:16] that case [1:13:18] just went down [1:13:19] I don't think [1:13:21] the mandate [1:13:21] has been issued [1:13:22] in that case [1:13:23] there could be [1:13:24] procedural opportunities [1:13:25] for a rehearing [1:13:26] and some other [1:13:27] things [1:13:27] and Senator [1:13:28] respectfully [1:13:29] I would just [1:13:29] I would hate [1:13:30] to comment on that [1:13:31] knowing that [1:13:32] it could be [1:13:33] coming back [1:13:34] to the court [1:13:34] if the mandate [1:13:35] had gone down [1:13:36] I'd be happy [1:13:37] to talk about [1:13:37] my position [1:13:39] here's what [1:13:39] does concern me [1:13:40] there are fewer [1:13:42] and fewer ways [1:13:44] for people [1:13:44] who are injured [1:13:45] as a result [1:13:46] of corporate [1:13:47] bad conduct [1:13:48] I mean this [1:13:49] is pretty astonishing [1:13:50] this company [1:13:51] that had a billion [1:13:52] dollars in profit [1:13:54] did not [1:13:55] find it necessary [1:13:57] to give a heads up [1:13:58] to first responders [1:13:59] who are among [1:14:00] the best people [1:14:01] in all of our [1:14:01] communities [1:14:02] in Arkansas [1:14:04] and in Vermont [1:14:04] those folks show up [1:14:06] and to deny them [1:14:08] the heads up [1:14:09] that they're going [1:14:09] to walk into a place [1:14:11] where they're breathing [1:14:11] and it's going to [1:14:12] cause permanent damage [1:14:13] is really concerning [1:14:15] to me [1:14:16] so the judicial [1:14:18] philosophy question [1:14:19] here is what's [1:14:20] at the heart [1:14:20] of my concern [1:14:21] with you having [1:14:23] this lifetime [1:14:24] appointment [1:14:25] so I'd just like [1:14:26] you to explain [1:14:27] how you square [1:14:28] the I think [1:14:30] derogatory [1:14:31] language that used [1:14:33] towards the plaintiffs [1:14:34] powerball winners [1:14:35] when they had [1:14:36] these very severe [1:14:38] injuries [1:14:38] that were all [1:14:39] avoidable [1:14:40] by a simple [1:14:41] heads up [1:14:41] by an incredibly [1:14:43] wealthy [1:14:44] and successful [1:14:44] corporation [1:14:45] yeah senator [1:14:47] again [1:14:48] I would love [1:14:50] the opportunity [1:14:50] to talk to you [1:14:51] about that case [1:14:52] and visit with you [1:14:52] about it [1:14:53] and the rationale [1:14:53] you've got the [1:14:54] you've got the [1:14:55] opportunity right now [1:14:56] but again [1:14:57] we have ethical [1:14:58] considerations [1:14:58] from the Arkansas [1:15:00] Code of Judicial [1:15:01] Conduct [1:15:01] and that mandate [1:15:03] has not been issued [1:15:03] at least as of [1:15:04] last night [1:15:05] and so it just [1:15:07] is something [1:15:07] that I shouldn't [1:15:09] discuss in public [1:15:10] okay [1:15:10] I yield back [1:15:11] thank you very much [1:15:12] thank you senator [1:15:15] Welch [1:15:15] I'd like to enter [1:15:16] into the record [1:15:17] senator Coons [1:15:19] thank you chairman [1:15:47] Cruz [1:15:47] great to be at this [1:15:48] confirmation hearing [1:15:49] with you [1:15:49] and Justice [1:15:50] Highland [1:15:51] welcome [1:15:51] I appreciate [1:15:52] the opportunity [1:15:53] to engage [1:15:55] with you [1:15:55] on a couple [1:15:55] of questions [1:15:56] this morning [1:15:56] we are in the [1:15:58] middle of a [1:15:58] three vote series [1:15:59] in the capitol [1:16:00] so please [1:16:01] understand [1:16:02] members are [1:16:02] coming and going [1:16:03] as a result [1:16:04] I had the [1:16:06] honor and the [1:16:07] blessing of [1:16:07] clerking for a [1:16:08] circuit court judge [1:16:09] and was interested [1:16:10] in your views [1:16:11] on a couple [1:16:12] of issues [1:16:12] that may be [1:16:13] relevant to [1:16:14] your service [1:16:14] do you agree [1:16:16] that judges [1:16:17] should rule [1:16:18] based on the [1:16:19] facts and the [1:16:19] law [1:16:19] yes senator [1:16:21] and do you agree [1:16:22] judges should not be [1:16:23] influenced by external [1:16:25] pressure political [1:16:25] pressure to rule in any [1:16:27] particular way [1:16:27] I agree [1:16:28] senator [1:16:28] president trump [1:16:30] on march 25th [1:16:32] said at a public [1:16:33] event quote [1:16:34] we got rogue judges [1:16:36] that are criminals [1:16:37] they are criminals [1:16:38] what they do to our [1:16:39] country [1:16:39] the decisions they [1:16:40] hand down [1:16:41] hurt our country [1:16:42] close quote [1:16:44] is it is it possible [1:16:45] for a judge's decision [1:16:46] to be fully correct [1:16:47] as a matter of fact [1:16:48] and law [1:16:49] even if it differs [1:16:50] from the president's [1:16:51] desired outcome [1:16:52] senator I think that [1:16:56] would be the case [1:16:56] for any person [1:16:59] not just the president [1:17:00] and so do you have [1:17:03] an opinion about [1:17:04] whether it is or [1:17:05] can be a crime [1:17:06] for a judge to rule [1:17:07] against president [1:17:08] trump's desired [1:17:09] outcome [1:17:10] in a particular case [1:17:11] as he stated [1:17:12] senator can you [1:17:14] rephrase the question [1:17:15] I'm sorry [1:17:16] the president said [1:17:17] we got rogue judges [1:17:18] that are criminals [1:17:19] they're criminals [1:17:20] the decisions they [1:17:21] hand down [1:17:21] hurt our country [1:17:22] is it a crime [1:17:25] for a judge [1:17:26] to rule [1:17:27] against president [1:17:28] trump's desired [1:17:28] outcome [1:17:29] senator I would say [1:17:31] it's not [1:17:31] if the judge [1:17:33] is ruling [1:17:33] based on the law [1:17:34] and the facts [1:17:34] it's not a crime [1:17:35] for him to [1:17:36] rule [1:17:37] period [1:17:39] and if [1:17:39] folks disagree [1:17:40] with that [1:17:41] they disagree [1:17:41] with that [1:17:42] so if you [1:17:43] handed down [1:17:43] a decision [1:17:44] that differed [1:17:45] somehow significantly [1:17:46] with the president's [1:17:47] publicly stated [1:17:48] desired outcome [1:17:49] would you consider [1:17:50] yourself a rogue [1:17:51] judge or a criminal [1:17:52] well senator [1:17:54] we're going to make [1:17:56] decisions based on [1:17:57] the facts and the law [1:17:58] and if there's [1:17:59] criticism of [1:18:00] those decisions [1:18:01] which I've had [1:18:02] in my time [1:18:04] there have been [1:18:04] people who disagree [1:18:05] with the positions [1:18:06] we've taken [1:18:07] good minds can [1:18:09] disagree [1:18:09] and so [1:18:11] if I'm confirmed [1:18:14] by the senate [1:18:14] my approach [1:18:16] will be to take [1:18:17] the briefs [1:18:18] and the record [1:18:19] and to make [1:18:20] a decision [1:18:21] based on the law [1:18:22] and let the chips [1:18:25] fall [1:18:25] thank you [1:18:26] I've worked [1:18:27] hard with my [1:18:29] colleague [1:18:29] senator cornyn [1:18:30] and others [1:18:31] to legislate [1:18:32] about judicial [1:18:33] security [1:18:34] and judicial [1:18:34] protections [1:18:35] I'm concerned [1:18:35] about steadily [1:18:36] rising threats [1:18:37] against judges [1:18:38] which come from [1:18:39] all corners [1:18:40] of our political [1:18:40] universe [1:18:41] do you think [1:18:42] statements like [1:18:43] the one I just [1:18:43] quoted president [1:18:44] trump [1:18:44] saying [1:18:45] make federal [1:18:46] judges more [1:18:47] or less [1:18:47] safe [1:18:48] well senator [1:18:52] I certainly [1:18:54] agree with [1:18:55] you that [1:18:56] you know [1:18:56] security [1:18:57] is an issue [1:18:58] when I was [1:18:59] the United States [1:19:00] attorney [1:19:00] we brought [1:19:03] the first [1:19:03] RICO case [1:19:04] in 17 years [1:19:06] against 55 [1:19:07] white supremacists [1:19:09] that were part [1:19:10] of a new area [1:19:11] nation group [1:19:12] a few days later [1:19:14] we discovered [1:19:15] I didn't discover [1:19:17] my law enforcement [1:19:18] agents did [1:19:19] that they had put [1:19:19] a hit out on me [1:19:20] in one of my [1:19:21] AUSAs [1:19:22] and so [1:19:23] US marshals [1:19:24] from around the [1:19:25] country swarmed [1:19:26] in on us [1:19:27] and took my wife [1:19:28] and I [1:19:29] and put us [1:19:29] in protective [1:19:30] custody [1:19:30] it was a pretty [1:19:31] serious threat [1:19:32] so I know [1:19:34] full well [1:19:34] when we engage [1:19:37] in public service [1:19:38] like this [1:19:39] it can draw [1:19:40] the attention [1:19:41] of the wrong [1:19:42] people [1:19:42] but as far [1:19:44] as characterizing [1:19:45] the president's [1:19:45] comments [1:19:46] I don't understand [1:19:50] the context [1:19:51] within which [1:19:51] it was said [1:19:53] and so [1:19:53] I would defer [1:19:54] on commenting [1:19:55] on his particular [1:19:56] comments [1:19:57] I understand that [1:19:58] in 2020 [1:19:59] you wrote an article [1:20:00] in the Democrat Gazette [1:20:01] the Arkansas Democrat Gazette [1:20:03] about civil unrest [1:20:04] in many cities [1:20:05] in the summer of 2020 [1:20:07] in the wake [1:20:07] of George Floyd's murder [1:20:08] you were the US attorney [1:20:10] at that point [1:20:11] and you described [1:20:12] those protests [1:20:13] as an insurrection [1:20:14] were the events [1:20:17] of January 6th [1:20:18] 2021 [1:20:18] also an insurrection [1:20:20] senator [1:20:22] can you refresh [1:20:23] my recollection [1:20:24] on exactly [1:20:24] what I said [1:20:25] on that [1:20:26] I mean [1:20:27] at least [1:20:28] what I [1:20:28] maybe give me [1:20:29] some context [1:20:29] what I have [1:20:30] is that there [1:20:30] were widespread [1:20:31] protests [1:20:32] this was the [1:20:33] so-called [1:20:33] Black Lives Matter [1:20:34] protests [1:20:35] following the murder [1:20:35] of George Floyd [1:20:36] many of which [1:20:38] were peaceful [1:20:38] some of which [1:20:39] devolved into violence [1:20:40] in different cities [1:20:41] around the country [1:20:41] and you called [1:20:42] that an insurrection [1:20:43] well [1:20:44] senator [1:20:44] I don't [1:20:45] I don't remember [1:20:46] using that word [1:20:47] but if I did [1:20:48] I remember [1:20:50] the protests [1:20:51] and many were peaceful [1:20:52] probably most were peaceful [1:20:54] some were not [1:20:56] and we had to deal [1:20:57] with that violence [1:20:58] we had [1:20:58] windows knocked out [1:21:00] all down Capitol Avenue [1:21:02] it was a real problem [1:21:04] and so we wrote that [1:21:05] I remember writing [1:21:07] an article [1:21:07] was it [1:21:08] Back the Blue [1:21:09] was that the [1:21:10] Back the Blue [1:21:11] I believe so [1:21:12] I just [1:21:12] I don't remember [1:21:13] using the word [1:21:13] insurrection [1:21:14] but as far as [1:21:15] January 6 [1:21:16] insurrection [1:21:18] has a [1:21:19] precise legal term [1:21:22] I would [1:21:24] I would [1:21:24] allow [1:21:25] senator [1:21:25] that [1:21:26] certainly [1:21:27] there were [1:21:27] acts of violence [1:21:28] that people [1:21:29] were prosecuted for [1:21:30] and convicted of [1:21:32] and [1:21:33] you know [1:21:34] anytime [1:21:35] as a prosecutor [1:21:36] if you have [1:21:36] sufficient evidence [1:21:37] that crime [1:21:38] has occurred [1:21:39] people need to be [1:21:39] prosecuted [1:21:40] but that's [1:21:42] that's probably [1:21:43] as far as [1:21:44] I'd like to go [1:21:45] with that [1:21:45] what's the impact [1:21:46] on a prosecutor [1:21:47] or a prosecutorial team [1:21:48] if the person [1:21:49] that they have [1:21:50] investigated [1:21:50] produced evidence [1:21:51] on [1:21:51] taken to trial [1:21:52] and gotten convicted [1:21:53] is then pardoned [1:21:55] well I mean [1:21:57] how does that impact [1:21:58] career law enforcement [1:21:59] when hundreds of people [1:22:01] who've been convicted [1:22:02] of in some cases [1:22:03] violence against law [1:22:04] enforcement [1:22:04] are pardoned [1:22:05] as a group [1:22:06] as a whole [1:22:06] yeah senator [1:22:07] I think it depends [1:22:08] on the individual [1:22:09] case [1:22:10] you know [1:22:12] as prosecutor [1:22:14] we would always [1:22:16] get letters [1:22:17] from [1:22:17] the governor [1:22:18] indicating that [1:22:20] they were considering [1:22:20] a pardon [1:22:21] and most of the time [1:22:23] those weren't welcome [1:22:24] sir [1:22:25] understood [1:22:26] last question [1:22:28] if I could [1:22:29] you had some [1:22:31] you're familiar [1:22:32] with the Arkansas [1:22:33] rules of judicial conduct [1:22:34] which bars [1:22:36] candidates from [1:22:37] publicly identifying [1:22:38] as a member [1:22:39] of a political party [1:22:40] during your run [1:22:42] for the court [1:22:42] of appeals [1:22:43] in Delaware [1:22:44] we don't have [1:22:44] judicial elections [1:22:45] so this whole concept [1:22:47] was somewhat novel [1:22:47] to me [1:22:48] but during your run [1:22:49] in 2016 [1:22:50] you sent out mailers [1:22:51] urging voters [1:22:51] to vote for you [1:22:52] in the Republican primary [1:22:54] or the Democratic primary [1:22:55] and had a [1:22:56] if I understand correctly [1:22:58] your face next to a tag [1:22:59] for the Republican party [1:23:00] how did that square [1:23:02] with the relevant rule [1:23:03] senator [1:23:06] honestly I don't remember [1:23:07] the exact circumstances [1:23:09] of that [1:23:10] I think it was a [1:23:11] you know [1:23:12] sending [1:23:13] we sent mailers [1:23:14] to Democrats [1:23:15] and we sent mailers [1:23:16] to Republicans [1:23:17] and they [1:23:17] they vote in [1:23:19] either one [1:23:20] and so [1:23:20] but I [1:23:21] senator I don't remember [1:23:23] the exact circumstances [1:23:24] of that [1:23:24] okay [1:23:25] thank you for your answers [1:23:27] today [1:23:27] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:23:28] thank you Justice Highland [1:23:29] thank you for your testimony [1:23:31] you're now excused [1:23:32] and the [1:23:33] the second [1:23:34] panel [1:23:34] if you will [1:23:35] approach the [1:23:37] thank you Chairman Cruz [1:23:38] if each of the nominees [1:24:24] will raise your right hand [1:24:26] do you swear [1:24:27] that the testimony [1:24:27] you're about to give [1:24:28] before this committee [1:24:29] will be the truth [1:24:30] the whole truth [1:24:31] and nothing but the truth [1:24:32] so help you God [1:24:33] thank you [1:24:36] you may be seated [1:24:37] it is our normal process [1:24:40] to allow you [1:24:40] if you desire [1:24:41] to introduce [1:24:42] the people that are with you [1:24:43] including your family [1:24:44] and then you may give [1:24:44] your opening statement [1:24:45] we'll start on my left [1:24:47] and move down the line [1:24:48] Mr. Albert [1:24:50] the floor is yours [1:24:51] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:24:55] and thank you to [1:24:56] ranking member Durbin [1:24:57] for holding this hearing [1:24:58] first I would like to thank God [1:25:01] without whom [1:25:02] none of this would be possible [1:25:04] I would like to thank [1:25:05] President Trump [1:25:06] for the honor [1:25:06] of this nomination [1:25:07] and to Senators Tillis [1:25:09] and Budd [1:25:10] for their support [1:25:11] I would like to thank [1:25:14] my wife Lindsay [1:25:14] of 11 years [1:25:16] who has been with me [1:25:17] my entire legal career [1:25:18] since my clerkship [1:25:20] in Elizabeth City [1:25:21] North Carolina [1:25:21] I would like to thank [1:25:23] my father and my mother [1:25:24] who flew to Raleigh [1:25:27] to drive up to DC [1:25:28] to attend this hearing [1:25:29] I would like to thank [1:25:31] my judicial mentors [1:25:33] Judge Terrence Boyle [1:25:35] and Judge Jim Dever [1:25:36] without your mentorship [1:25:38] again I could not be here today [1:25:40] my law school mentor [1:25:43] Judy Hammerschmidt [1:25:44] is in attendance today [1:25:46] I'm grateful for her support [1:25:48] at key points [1:25:49] during my career [1:25:50] I have several friends [1:25:53] and mentors [1:25:53] from the Army [1:25:54] some of whom [1:25:55] are in attendance today [1:25:56] Major Adam Woolrich [1:25:58] Colonel Carr [1:26:00] Lieutenant Colonel Jason Moy [1:26:04] Colonel Young [1:26:05] Colonel Vanghaus [1:26:06] Colonel Gowell [1:26:07] and Judge Fredrickson [1:26:09] I'm grateful [1:26:10] for your mentorship [1:26:11] as a young Army attorney [1:26:13] again I'm thankful [1:26:15] to the committee [1:26:15] for this opportunity [1:26:16] I'm honored [1:26:18] and if I'm fortunate [1:26:20] enough to be confirmed [1:26:21] I look forward to the opportunity [1:26:23] to continue my life in service [1:26:24] which began [1:26:26] when I enlisted [1:26:27] in the United States Army [1:26:28] at the age of 17 [1:26:29] and continued [1:26:31] as a JAG officer [1:26:32] and then an assistant [1:26:33] United States attorney [1:26:34] thank you [1:26:36] thank you [1:26:40] you may [1:26:41] you have the floor [1:26:42] good afternoon [1:26:44] Mr. Chairman [1:26:44] Ranking Member Durbin [1:26:46] and members of this committee [1:26:47] thank you for holding [1:26:48] this hearing today [1:26:49] I'd like to start [1:26:51] by reiterating my thanks [1:26:52] to President Trump [1:26:53] for the honor [1:26:54] of this nomination [1:26:55] it is truly a privilege [1:26:57] to be considered [1:26:58] for this opportunity [1:26:59] to serve my country [1:27:00] thank you also [1:27:02] to my senators [1:27:03] Senator Young [1:27:04] and Senator Banks [1:27:05] for their very kind [1:27:07] introductions [1:27:07] for their support [1:27:09] and for all the important [1:27:11] things they do [1:27:12] day in and day out [1:27:12] for our state [1:27:13] I'd also like to thank [1:27:16] the judges [1:27:16] for whom I clerked [1:27:18] Chief Justice John Roberts [1:27:19] Judge Tom Griffith [1:27:21] and Judge Dabney Friedrich [1:27:23] I learned so much [1:27:25] while working for each of them [1:27:26] and I'm continually grateful [1:27:27] for that opportunity [1:27:28] finally to introduce my family [1:27:31] I'm joined today [1:27:32] by my father [1:27:33] Joe Falvey [1:27:34] he and my mother [1:27:35] Ann Falvey [1:27:36] are the parents [1:27:37] of nine children [1:27:38] foster parents [1:27:39] of many more [1:27:40] and they've set the example [1:27:42] for me in every way [1:27:43] I'm also joined [1:27:45] by my brother-in-law [1:27:46] and sister-in-law [1:27:46] Nicholas and Ellen Schilling [1:27:48] and their children [1:27:49] and last but certainly [1:27:51] not least [1:27:52] is my family [1:27:53] our eight children [1:27:55] watching from home today [1:27:56] if they've managed [1:27:56] to make it this far [1:27:57] are one daughter [1:27:59] and seven sons [1:28:00] including the newest member [1:28:02] of our family [1:28:03] our new son [1:28:04] who was born [1:28:04] just three weeks ago [1:28:05] saving the very best [1:28:08] for last [1:28:08] the very best [1:28:09] is my wife Catherine [1:28:10] I'm so grateful [1:28:12] for all of them [1:28:12] again thank you [1:28:13] for holding this hearing today [1:28:14] and I look forward [1:28:16] to your questions [1:28:16] thank you [1:28:18] Mr. Falvey [1:28:18] and I will say [1:28:19] your daughter [1:28:19] it must be one [1:28:21] really tough girl [1:28:22] she is [1:28:23] yes Senator [1:28:24] Mr. Hamilton [1:28:25] you're recognized [1:28:26] thank you Chairman Cruz [1:28:28] and Ranking Member Durbin [1:28:30] for the invitation [1:28:31] to appear before [1:28:33] the committee today [1:28:34] it is a privilege [1:28:35] to be with you [1:28:36] I want to start [1:28:37] by thanking [1:28:38] President Trump [1:28:39] for the honor [1:28:40] of this nomination [1:28:41] and Senators Fisher [1:28:43] and Ricketts [1:28:44] for putting my name [1:28:45] forward [1:28:45] to the President [1:28:46] for consideration [1:28:48] I am truly grateful [1:28:50] for their support [1:28:51] the greatest gift [1:28:53] that I've received [1:28:55] in life [1:28:55] is being born [1:28:57] my parents' son [1:28:58] I would not be [1:29:00] in this chair today [1:29:01] if it were not [1:29:02] for the love [1:29:03] support [1:29:03] and encouragement [1:29:04] that I've received [1:29:06] from my parents [1:29:07] my mother [1:29:09] is in Omaha [1:29:10] watching online [1:29:11] I admire her [1:29:12] for so much [1:29:14] particularly [1:29:15] her unending optimism [1:29:17] and the courage [1:29:19] and grace [1:29:20] with which [1:29:20] she has confronted [1:29:22] health challenges [1:29:23] in her life [1:29:24] my father [1:29:26] was the hardest working [1:29:28] and most unflappable [1:29:29] person I've ever known [1:29:31] he unfortunately [1:29:32] passed away [1:29:33] earlier this year [1:29:34] and I know [1:29:36] he would have loved [1:29:36] to be here today [1:29:38] I've been blessed [1:29:40] to work with [1:29:41] and under [1:29:42] so many [1:29:43] very talented lawyers [1:29:44] throughout my career [1:29:46] far too many [1:29:47] for me to recognize [1:29:48] today [1:29:49] but I do want to thank [1:29:51] my very first mentor [1:29:53] in the law [1:29:54] Judge Thomas Hardiman [1:29:56] of the U.S. [1:29:57] Court of Appeals [1:29:58] for the Third Circuit [1:29:59] I had the honor [1:30:00] of clerking for [1:30:02] Judge Hardiman [1:30:03] in my first year [1:30:04] after law school [1:30:06] and I have learned [1:30:07] a great deal [1:30:08] from him [1:30:08] if I am fortunate [1:30:10] enough to be confirmed [1:30:12] I will follow [1:30:13] the example [1:30:13] he set for me [1:30:15] with that [1:30:16] Mr. Chairman [1:30:17] and Mr. Ranking Member [1:30:18] I thank you again [1:30:19] for the invitation [1:30:20] to appear today [1:30:22] and I look forward [1:30:23] to answering [1:30:23] the committee's questions [1:30:24] thank you [1:30:26] Mr. Lambert [1:30:27] you're recognized [1:30:27] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:30:29] and Ranking Member Durbin [1:30:31] I appreciate the committee [1:30:32] holding this hearing today [1:30:33] I want to start [1:30:35] by thanking the president [1:30:36] for the honor [1:30:36] of this nomination [1:30:37] to serve in a state [1:30:38] and a country [1:30:39] that I love so much [1:30:40] I appreciate [1:30:41] Senator Scott [1:30:42] and Senator Graham's [1:30:43] support [1:30:43] through this process [1:30:45] and I'm blessed [1:30:46] to have much of my family [1:30:47] here with me today [1:30:48] first is my wife [1:30:49] of 16 years [1:30:50] Mary Beth [1:30:51] I thank God [1:30:52] every day [1:30:53] that we get to share [1:30:53] this journey together [1:30:54] the Lord has blessed us [1:30:56] with three sons [1:30:57] the oldest of whom [1:30:58] turns 10 [1:30:59] in a couple of weeks [1:31:00] and is here today [1:31:01] they've been studying [1:31:02] the founding [1:31:03] in school recently [1:31:04] and he's excited [1:31:05] to see the constitution [1:31:06] in action [1:31:06] our younger sons [1:31:08] ages 7 and 4 [1:31:09] are at home [1:31:10] with my in-laws [1:31:11] probably certainly [1:31:12] not having made it [1:31:13] this far [1:31:14] in watching the hearing [1:31:15] my parents [1:31:16] Lanny and Nancy Lambert [1:31:17] are here [1:31:18] without their love [1:31:19] and support [1:31:19] I would never have made it [1:31:21] to where I am today [1:31:22] my aunt Miriam Hare [1:31:24] is here as well [1:31:25] she's always been there [1:31:27] for my siblings [1:31:27] and me [1:31:28] and that continues today [1:31:30] speaking of my siblings [1:31:32] they're here as well [1:31:33] my sister Caroline [1:31:34] is here with her husband [1:31:35] Jonathan [1:31:36] and my brother Bryant [1:31:37] is here [1:31:38] they came up from [1:31:38] South Carolina [1:31:39] his wife Lindsay [1:31:40] is back home [1:31:41] with my nieces [1:31:42] and nephews [1:31:43] beyond thanking my family [1:31:45] there are two other people [1:31:45] I must thank [1:31:46] the first is Judge Dennis Shedd [1:31:48] of the 4th Circuit [1:31:49] for whom I clerked [1:31:50] he showed me [1:31:51] what it meant [1:31:52] to read the law carefully [1:31:53] study the record closely [1:31:55] and answer the question [1:31:56] presented thoughtfully [1:31:57] in every case [1:31:58] the second is [1:32:00] Governor Henry McMaster [1:32:01] he has given me [1:32:03] the opportunity [1:32:03] to serve our state [1:32:04] for the last five [1:32:05] and a half years [1:32:06] and has been a friend [1:32:07] and mentor every day [1:32:09] Mr. Chairman [1:32:10] and the committee [1:32:11] thank you again [1:32:11] for holding this hearing [1:32:12] and I appreciate you [1:32:14] considering my nomination [1:32:15] thank you very much [1:32:18] Mr. Myers [1:32:19] you're recognized [1:32:20] thank you Chairman Cruz [1:32:22] ranking member Durbin [1:32:23] and members of the committee [1:32:24] thank you very much [1:32:26] for holding this hearing today [1:32:27] President Trump [1:32:28] thank you for this nomination [1:32:30] it truly is the honor [1:32:31] of my career [1:32:32] to be sitting here [1:32:33] in the Senate today [1:32:34] Senator Tillis [1:32:35] and Senator Budd [1:32:36] thank you for recommending [1:32:37] me for the nomination [1:32:38] and for your support [1:32:39] throughout the process [1:32:40] thank you also [1:32:41] for the kind words [1:32:42] that you said about me [1:32:43] and my family [1:32:44] I'm very pleased [1:32:45] and privileged [1:32:46] to be joined today [1:32:48] by several family members [1:32:49] and friends [1:32:50] here in the Senate [1:32:51] I want to start [1:32:52] with my beautiful wife [1:32:54] of 20 years [1:32:55] Erica Myers [1:32:56] she's been my best friend [1:32:57] since we met [1:32:58] at Davidson College [1:32:59] over 30 years ago [1:33:00] and I wouldn't have [1:33:01] achieved anything [1:33:01] in my life [1:33:03] without her love [1:33:03] and support [1:33:04] and the sacrifices [1:33:06] that she has made [1:33:06] and that my family's made [1:33:07] has allowed me [1:33:08] to have a career [1:33:09] in public service [1:33:10] and I could never [1:33:11] thank them enough [1:33:12] she's an extremely [1:33:13] accomplished attorney [1:33:14] and there is no question [1:33:15] that she is the better [1:33:16] attorney in our household [1:33:17] very importantly [1:33:20] she is an excellent mother [1:33:21] to our wonderful [1:33:22] eight-year-old daughter [1:33:23] Marley [1:33:23] who's also here today [1:33:24] Marley recently [1:33:26] began her career [1:33:28] in public service [1:33:29] she was elected [1:33:30] as the third grade [1:33:31] classroom representative [1:33:33] for her student council [1:33:34] she is missing [1:33:35] her student council [1:33:36] meeting today [1:33:36] and that is certainly [1:33:38] appreciated [1:33:38] because she is here [1:33:39] learning about the constitution [1:33:40] Marley thank you very much [1:33:42] we are very proud of you [1:33:43] I'm also fortunate [1:33:45] to be joined by both [1:33:46] of my parents [1:33:46] Bill Myers [1:33:47] and Sherry Myers [1:33:48] thank you both [1:33:50] for all the support [1:33:50] and love you've shown me [1:33:51] throughout my life [1:33:52] and all the opportunities [1:33:53] that you presented [1:33:54] I've had many friends [1:33:57] and mentors [1:33:57] who have supported me [1:33:59] throughout my career [1:33:59] two of them are here today [1:34:01] Frank Bradshaw [1:34:02] and Bobby Higdon [1:34:03] I very much appreciate [1:34:05] them coming all this way [1:34:06] to attend this hearing [1:34:07] last I want to mention [1:34:10] certainly my sister [1:34:11] and her husband Kelly [1:34:13] and my two-year-old nephew [1:34:14] who are watching [1:34:15] remotely from Colorado [1:34:16] and my in-laws [1:34:18] John and Cecil Thomas [1:34:19] who are watching [1:34:20] from West Virginia [1:34:20] Mr. Chairman [1:34:22] thank you very much [1:34:23] I look forward to answering [1:34:24] the committee's questions [1:34:25] thank you [1:34:26] Justice Sullivan [1:34:27] you're recognized [1:34:28] Chairman Cruz [1:34:31] Ranking Member Durbin [1:34:32] esteemed members [1:34:33] of the committee [1:34:33] thank you for having me here [1:34:35] and holding this hearing today [1:34:37] I have more than two minutes [1:34:39] of gratitude [1:34:40] but I will try to be brief [1:34:41] I'll start by saying [1:34:43] thank you [1:34:43] to President Trump [1:34:45] for giving me the honor [1:34:46] of this nomination [1:34:47] to serve [1:34:48] on the Western District [1:34:49] of Texas [1:34:50] I'm also very grateful [1:34:52] to you Chairman Cruz [1:34:54] and to Senator Cornyn [1:34:55] both for the kind introduction [1:34:57] and the warm welcome [1:34:58] to my family [1:34:59] and for recommending me [1:35:00] to the White House [1:35:01] for this important position [1:35:03] in a district [1:35:04] that is a judicial emergency [1:35:05] right now [1:35:06] I also want to thank [1:35:08] Governor Greg Abbott [1:35:09] who has given me [1:35:11] so many opportunities [1:35:12] to serve the people [1:35:13] of Texas [1:35:14] first as an Assistant [1:35:15] Solicitor General [1:35:16] and then as his [1:35:18] General Counsel [1:35:18] as the Governor [1:35:19] and then by appointing me [1:35:21] as a Justice [1:35:22] of the Texas Supreme Court [1:35:23] it has been an honor [1:35:25] to work with him [1:35:27] and I'm very grateful [1:35:29] for his support as well [1:35:30] I'm joined today [1:35:32] the Sullivans [1:35:33] are rolling deep [1:35:34] and I'm going to start [1:35:37] with my lovely wife [1:35:39] Alethea Sullivan [1:35:40] I'm going to follow [1:35:41] the Judge Myers precedent [1:35:42] Alethea is also [1:35:43] the best lawyer [1:35:44] in my household [1:35:45] and she is also [1:35:47] a member of the Board [1:35:48] of Regents [1:35:49] at Texas Southern there [1:35:50] and most importantly [1:35:52] I think to both of us [1:35:53] she is the mother [1:35:55] the very fierce [1:35:55] and proud mother [1:35:56] of our son Conan [1:35:58] who is here today [1:35:59] like the barbarian [1:36:00] or like the late night [1:36:01] talk show host [1:36:02] you'll know both of them [1:36:04] by the hair [1:36:05] I'm also joined today [1:36:07] by my hero [1:36:08] my father Pat Sullivan [1:36:09] and my stepmother Joyce [1:36:11] thank you dad [1:36:12] for coming up here [1:36:13] to support [1:36:13] I'm joined by [1:36:15] my beautiful mother-in-law [1:36:16] Joyce Samaras [1:36:17] who made the trip down [1:36:19] from Massachusetts [1:36:19] thank you Matt [1:36:21] for being here [1:36:21] joined by my brother John [1:36:23] and his wife Lauren [1:36:24] my uncle Mike [1:36:26] and my cousin Mary [1:36:27] six of my outstanding [1:36:30] past and present law clerks [1:36:31] on the Texas Supreme Court [1:36:33] Judge Al [1:36:34] retired Judge Allen Albright [1:36:36] whose seat [1:36:37] I have the honor [1:36:37] of having been nominated [1:36:38] to fill [1:36:39] Judge Albright [1:36:40] thank you for your service [1:36:41] to the Western District [1:36:42] of Texas [1:36:42] and for being here today [1:36:43] and like Mr. Falvey [1:36:45] I'm very grateful [1:36:46] that Judge Griffith [1:36:47] was here [1:36:47] I learned from Judge Griffith [1:36:49] that an oath [1:36:50] faith is a promise to God [1:36:51] and if confirmed [1:36:52] I look forward to [1:36:53] living up to that promise [1:36:54] every day [1:36:55] in the position [1:36:56] for which I'm nominated [1:36:57] I welcome your questions [1:36:58] and thank you for your time [1:36:59] thank you Justice Sullivan [1:37:02] and I will commend [1:37:03] you and your wife's [1:37:05] choice of name [1:37:06] for your son [1:37:07] I will say [1:37:09] your son Conan [1:37:10] should know [1:37:11] I just yesterday [1:37:12] quoted [1:37:13] the opening line [1:37:15] of Conan [1:37:15] to a friend of mine [1:37:17] with regard to [1:37:17] the most recent election [1:37:19] and that opening line [1:37:20] is of course [1:37:21] from Friedrich Nietzsche [1:37:22] that which does not kill you [1:37:24] makes you stronger [1:37:25] and so [1:37:26] I will say [1:37:27] Conan much like [1:37:28] learned hand [1:37:30] has a name [1:37:31] that is a weighty name [1:37:32] that he must live up to [1:37:33] and I'm confident he will [1:37:35] all right [1:37:37] let's start with you [1:37:41] Justice Sullivan [1:37:41] you've served [1:37:43] in the Texas SG's office [1:37:47] as general counsel [1:37:49] to Governor Abbott [1:37:49] and on the Texas [1:37:50] Supreme Court [1:37:51] how have each [1:37:53] of these experiences [1:37:54] shaped your understanding [1:37:55] of the role [1:37:56] of a federal judge [1:37:57] Chairman Cruz [1:38:00] having seen [1:38:01] the business [1:38:03] of the courts [1:38:04] from many different [1:38:06] perspectives [1:38:06] I really [1:38:09] I admire [1:38:11] and understand [1:38:12] how important [1:38:13] it is [1:38:14] even though [1:38:14] it's a simple thing [1:38:15] to say [1:38:16] follow the law [1:38:17] that's something [1:38:18] that is expected [1:38:19] of the parties [1:38:20] who are in front [1:38:20] of the courts [1:38:21] and it's expected [1:38:22] of the judges too [1:38:23] as Justice Highland [1:38:25] mentioned earlier [1:38:26] judges are not exempt [1:38:28] from that [1:38:28] simple admonition [1:38:29] and judges [1:38:31] and justices [1:38:32] also have to stay [1:38:33] in their lane [1:38:34] I have seen [1:38:36] the business [1:38:36] of the courts [1:38:38] from the perspective [1:38:39] of an appellate advocate [1:38:41] when I was [1:38:41] in the SG's office [1:38:42] where you served [1:38:43] with distinction [1:38:44] as solicitor general [1:38:45] Mr. Chairman [1:38:46] I have seen it [1:38:47] when I have appeared [1:38:49] in front of district judges [1:38:50] including in the [1:38:51] western district [1:38:51] of Texas [1:38:52] I've seen it [1:38:53] from the perspective [1:38:54] of a client [1:38:55] when I was [1:38:55] Governor Abbott's [1:38:56] general counsel [1:38:57] and we were working [1:38:58] with our counsel [1:38:58] in the attorney general's office [1:39:00] and I've now seen it [1:39:02] from the other side [1:39:02] of the bench [1:39:03] and I think that [1:39:04] that was [1:39:05] the most profound [1:39:07] feeling [1:39:09] that I had taken [1:39:10] the oath [1:39:11] to uphold [1:39:12] and defend [1:39:12] the constitution [1:39:13] and laws [1:39:14] of the United States [1:39:15] and of the state [1:39:16] of Texas [1:39:16] but it's something [1:39:19] that you can say [1:39:19] and that you can promise [1:39:20] but the first time [1:39:22] and obviously [1:39:23] I can't speak [1:39:23] about which case [1:39:24] it was on [1:39:25] there was a case [1:39:26] that we had heard [1:39:27] I was fairly new [1:39:28] on the court [1:39:29] and I thought [1:39:30] a lot of these [1:39:31] are pretty tough [1:39:32] but this one's [1:39:33] pretty easy [1:39:33] I think [1:39:34] this side wins [1:39:35] and then I read [1:39:36] something [1:39:36] that one of my [1:39:38] beloved colleagues [1:39:39] on the Texas Supreme Court [1:39:40] had written [1:39:41] and I realized [1:39:42] that he or she [1:39:44] had thought of something [1:39:45] that I hadn't [1:39:45] and instead of [1:39:48] being in the role [1:39:49] of an advocate [1:39:49] and saying [1:39:51] I'm going to dig in [1:39:52] I'm going to pound [1:39:53] on the table [1:39:53] and I'm going to [1:39:54] I'm going to show [1:39:54] that they're wrong [1:39:55] I had my mind [1:39:57] changed [1:39:58] and I think [1:39:59] that that's a really [1:40:00] really important thing [1:40:01] that a judge [1:40:02] has to have [1:40:02] the maturity of mind [1:40:04] to listen fairly [1:40:05] and to decide [1:40:07] thoughtfully [1:40:07] and to be willing [1:40:09] to have his or her [1:40:09] mind changed [1:40:10] and having seen [1:40:11] the litigation process [1:40:12] from all those [1:40:13] different angles [1:40:14] if confirmed [1:40:15] it'll be my honor [1:40:16] to do that [1:40:17] on the western [1:40:18] district of Texas [1:40:19] Thank you Justice Sullivan [1:40:22] Mr. Hamilton [1:40:23] I will say [1:40:24] I'm proud [1:40:25] that we have [1:40:26] not one [1:40:26] but two [1:40:27] alums [1:40:28] of the Texas SG's office [1:40:29] on this panel [1:40:31] myself [1:40:32] being yet another [1:40:34] alum of that office [1:40:35] I'm particularly proud [1:40:36] of the work [1:40:37] the Texas SG's office [1:40:38] has done [1:40:39] for a couple decades now [1:40:41] you've served [1:40:42] not just in one [1:40:43] state SG's office [1:40:44] but in two [1:40:45] serving as Nebraska's SG [1:40:48] tell us what [1:40:50] your experience [1:40:51] litigating [1:40:52] both in Texas [1:40:53] and Nebraska [1:40:54] how that has prepared [1:40:56] you to be [1:40:57] a district court judge [1:40:57] Thank you for the question [1:41:00] Chairman Cruz [1:41:01] state attorneys general [1:41:03] offices are [1:41:04] terrific places [1:41:05] to work for [1:41:06] anyone who [1:41:07] loves our constitution [1:41:08] and is interested [1:41:10] in our system [1:41:11] of government [1:41:12] in a state [1:41:13] attorney's general office [1:41:15] you see up close [1:41:16] the system [1:41:18] of federalism [1:41:19] that we have [1:41:20] you will [1:41:21] litigate [1:41:22] oftentimes [1:41:23] against the [1:41:24] federal government [1:41:25] while at the same time [1:41:27] defending [1:41:28] state statutes [1:41:30] and state [1:41:30] executive actions [1:41:31] so [1:41:32] I had a [1:41:33] very broad practice [1:41:34] in both [1:41:35] the Nebraska [1:41:36] and the Texas [1:41:38] attorney's general offices [1:41:39] and enjoyed the experience [1:41:41] very much [1:41:42] Mr. Falvey [1:41:45] you have had [1:41:47] the chance [1:41:47] to clerk [1:41:48] at all three levels [1:41:49] of the federal judiciary [1:41:50] including for [1:41:51] Chief Justice Roberts [1:41:52] and you currently [1:41:54] serve as the chief [1:41:55] of the appellate division [1:41:56] of the U.S. attorney's office [1:41:57] in the northern district [1:41:58] of Indiana [1:41:58] what have those [1:42:00] experiences taught you [1:42:02] about what makes [1:42:02] an effective federal judge? [1:42:05] Senator I've learned [1:42:06] a ton from those [1:42:07] experiences [1:42:07] one that I'd mention [1:42:09] is the important role [1:42:10] that courts play [1:42:11] in our constitutional system [1:42:12] our courts play [1:42:14] very important role [1:42:15] but at the same time [1:42:15] it's very limited [1:42:16] their responsibility [1:42:18] is to decide [1:42:19] properly presented [1:42:20] cases and controversies [1:42:21] and only that [1:42:22] and so adhering [1:42:23] to that role [1:42:24] is an extremely [1:42:25] important responsibility [1:42:26] that I really appreciated [1:42:28] coming out of my clerkships [1:42:29] one other thing [1:42:30] that I took away [1:42:31] from them [1:42:31] is the importance [1:42:33] of treating [1:42:33] everyone with [1:42:35] respect and dignity [1:42:37] at all times [1:42:37] you know [1:42:38] the judges [1:42:39] for whom I clerked [1:42:39] the courts [1:42:40] where I clerked [1:42:41] really prided themselves [1:42:42] in treating [1:42:42] every single litigant [1:42:44] every single person [1:42:45] every single person [1:42:46] who's in the courtroom [1:42:46] with unfailing respect [1:42:50] unfailing dignity [1:42:51] at all times [1:42:51] I think that's [1:42:52] an important lesson [1:42:53] that I'll certainly [1:42:54] take with me [1:42:54] if I'm fortunate enough [1:42:56] to be confirmed [1:42:56] as a district judge [1:42:57] Mr. Lambert [1:42:59] you've had an extensive [1:43:01] career in private practice [1:43:02] and you now serve [1:43:03] as the chief legal counsel [1:43:04] to South Carolina [1:43:05] Governor Henry McMaster [1:43:06] in that role [1:43:07] you defended state laws [1:43:09] against constitutional challenges [1:43:10] including before [1:43:11] the fourth circuit [1:43:12] and the South Carolina [1:43:13] Supreme Court [1:43:14] how has representing [1:43:16] the state of South Carolina [1:43:17] and constitutional litigation [1:43:18] shaped your understanding [1:43:20] of federalism [1:43:21] and the proper relationship [1:43:22] between state governments [1:43:24] and the federal judiciary [1:43:25] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:43:27] it's been an honor [1:43:28] to represent South Carolina [1:43:29] in those cases [1:43:30] and what it's shown me [1:43:32] firsthand [1:43:32] is the important balance [1:43:34] between the relationship [1:43:36] between the federal governments [1:43:37] and the states [1:43:37] the federal government [1:43:39] is one of enumerated powers [1:43:40] and it can do [1:43:41] what the constitution grants [1:43:43] through article 1 [1:43:44] article 2 [1:43:45] and article 3 [1:43:45] to do [1:43:46] the rest of the power [1:43:47] and the sovereignty [1:43:48] resides with the states [1:43:49] and it's been a privilege [1:43:51] to represent South Carolina's [1:43:52] efforts to legislate [1:43:54] within its constitutional sphere [1:43:56] and to ensure [1:43:57] that federal courts [1:43:58] don't overreach [1:43:59] and preclude the state [1:44:01] from doing what the constitution [1:44:02] allows it to do [1:44:03] I will say Mr. Lambert [1:44:06] when you start invoking [1:44:07] article 1 section 8 [1:44:08] you are speaking [1:44:09] my love language [1:44:10] Judge Myers [1:44:12] thank you for your service [1:44:14] as a marine judge advocate [1:44:16] you also served [1:44:18] as a federal magistrate judge [1:44:19] in the eastern district [1:44:20] of North Carolina [1:44:21] for six years [1:44:22] what of those responsibilities [1:44:24] taught you [1:44:25] about the responsibilities [1:44:26] of a federal district judge [1:44:28] yes sir [1:44:30] over the course [1:44:31] of my career [1:44:32] I've been very fortunate [1:44:32] to have held [1:44:34] several positions [1:44:35] in the federal government [1:44:37] starting as a [1:44:38] United States Marine [1:44:39] I took an oath of office [1:44:41] I've taken that several times [1:44:43] as a prosecutor [1:44:45] and an assistant [1:44:46] United States attorney [1:44:47] I learned the value [1:44:48] and the impact [1:44:50] that one case [1:44:51] can have on an individual [1:44:52] and certainly a community [1:44:54] as well as the victims [1:44:55] if there are any [1:44:56] in that particular matter [1:44:58] when I became [1:45:00] a federal magistrate judge [1:45:02] and appointed by the [1:45:03] fortunate enough [1:45:04] to be appointed [1:45:05] by the district judges [1:45:06] in the district [1:45:06] I made the change [1:45:08] from being an advocate [1:45:09] to being a neutral arbiter [1:45:10] of the facts [1:45:11] and neutral arbiter [1:45:13] of the case [1:45:13] in that role [1:45:17] I have learned [1:45:18] to hear each case [1:45:21] impartially [1:45:22] which I have done [1:45:23] throughout my entire career [1:45:24] I have learned [1:45:25] to listen to both sides [1:45:29] I apply the facts [1:45:31] and the law [1:45:32] apply the law as written [1:45:33] and that is the only way [1:45:36] that the rule of law [1:45:38] and the constitution [1:45:39] can be upheld [1:45:40] I subscribe to that wholly [1:45:43] a deep understanding [1:45:46] of the separation of powers [1:45:47] and the limited role [1:45:48] of the judiciary [1:45:49] is essential [1:45:49] to a judge [1:45:51] it has been [1:45:52] as a magistrate judge [1:45:54] and if fortunate enough [1:45:55] to be confirmed [1:45:56] that is how I would operate [1:45:57] as a United States [1:45:58] district judge [1:45:59] and Mr. Aubert [1:46:00] thank you for your service [1:46:02] in the Army Reserve [1:46:03] JAG Corps [1:46:04] you've also clerked [1:46:05] for Judge Boyle [1:46:06] and served as a federal [1:46:07] prosecutor [1:46:08] fighting violent crime [1:46:09] in eastern North Carolina [1:46:11] how has your military service [1:46:14] and experience [1:46:14] as a prosecutor [1:46:15] shaped your understanding [1:46:17] of justice [1:46:17] and the responsibilities [1:46:18] of a federal judge [1:46:19] in particular [1:46:21] my military service [1:46:23] allowed me to practice [1:46:24] as both a prosecutor [1:46:25] and a defense attorney [1:46:26] so I've represented [1:46:27] individual criminal defendants [1:46:29] and I've been able [1:46:30] to view the justice system [1:46:32] through that perspective [1:46:34] and that lens [1:46:35] that sits with you [1:46:37] as you become a prosecutor [1:46:38] particularly [1:46:39] in the Department of Justice [1:46:41] where the mandate [1:46:42] is to seek justice [1:46:44] that's the mandate [1:46:46] it's not to get convictions [1:46:47] it's not to [1:46:48] indict people [1:46:50] it is to seek justice [1:46:51] and so I'm guided [1:46:53] by that principle [1:46:54] as a prosecutor [1:46:55] and as a federal judge [1:46:57] if I'm fortunate enough [1:46:57] to be confirmed [1:46:58] it would be another opportunity [1:47:00] to promote justice [1:47:01] while following the rule of law [1:47:03] thank you [1:47:04] Senator Coons [1:47:05] I'm sorry I keep catching you [1:47:11] when you're turning [1:47:11] your head [1:47:12] so I apologize [1:47:13] for doing that to you twice [1:47:14] urgently needed legal advice [1:47:16] my apologies [1:47:17] we have a vote going on [1:47:18] that we may both [1:47:19] same thing [1:47:20] we may both need to go vote on [1:47:22] let me just congratulate [1:47:24] each of you and your families [1:47:25] thank you for your service [1:47:26] military or judicial [1:47:28] or otherwise [1:47:29] and thank you for your attention [1:47:31] to today [1:47:32] it is [1:47:34] I've served on this committee [1:47:35] for 16 years [1:47:36] I have presided over [1:47:38] or attended [1:47:38] dozens and dozens [1:47:40] of confirmation hearings [1:47:41] I will tell you [1:47:43] there are some components [1:47:44] of today's hearing [1:47:45] there are a bit of a surprise [1:47:46] Mr. Sullivan [1:47:47] I expect it's a surprise [1:47:49] to both of us [1:47:49] you're here today [1:47:50] since two weeks ago [1:47:51] you were on a ballot [1:47:52] in Texas [1:47:53] seeking a different job [1:47:54] my issue is not with that [1:47:56] it's with the timing [1:47:57] and the turnaround [1:47:58] the Constitution [1:47:59] entrusts us as senators [1:48:00] with providing advice [1:48:02] and consent [1:48:02] on nominations [1:48:03] to the federal judiciary [1:48:05] and that means [1:48:06] we need the time [1:48:07] to interview you [1:48:08] to review your backgrounds [1:48:09] to be prepared [1:48:10] for a hearing like this [1:48:11] and to take seriously [1:48:12] what is a lifetime appointment [1:48:14] I have never seen this happen [1:48:17] in my 16 years [1:48:18] we typically get a month [1:48:20] to review committee questionnaires [1:48:23] so that we can be prepared [1:48:24] and do our jobs [1:48:25] and that just did not happen here [1:48:27] I'm also concerned [1:48:29] with the significant variance [1:48:30] between your years of experience [1:48:32] and the judges [1:48:34] you will be replacing [1:48:35] when I was just 10 years [1:48:36] into being a member [1:48:37] of the Delaware Bar [1:48:38] a then senator called [1:48:39] and asked me [1:48:40] if I would be interested [1:48:41] in being nominated [1:48:42] to the federal bench [1:48:43] and I said [1:48:44] absolutely not [1:48:45] I'm wildly unqualified [1:48:47] I have never been [1:48:49] at a trial [1:48:50] I haven't conducted depositions [1:48:52] I was in private practice [1:48:53] and although I had clerked [1:48:55] for a circuit court judge [1:48:56] I did not consider myself [1:48:58] at just a decade [1:48:58] out of a school [1:49:01] of some renown [1:49:01] but that was really [1:49:02] my only potential qualification [1:49:04] so if I might [1:49:05] Mr. Hamilton [1:49:06] you've been nominated [1:49:07] to replace [1:49:08] Judge Robert Robert [1:49:10] Rossiter [1:49:10] do you have any idea [1:49:12] how many years of experience [1:49:13] Judge Rossiter had [1:49:14] when President Obama [1:49:16] nominated him [1:49:16] to the seat [1:49:17] for which you're nominated [1:49:18] Senator I don't know [1:49:21] I'll tell you [1:49:21] it was 35 years [1:49:22] and how many years [1:49:24] have you been practicing law sir [1:49:25] I graduated in 2013 [1:49:28] so I've been working [1:49:30] in the law for 13 years [1:49:31] Mr. Lambert [1:49:33] you've been nominated [1:49:34] to replace Judge Cain [1:49:35] any idea how many years [1:49:36] of experience he had [1:49:37] no senator [1:49:38] I'll tell you [1:49:39] it was 25 years [1:49:40] you graduated from law school [1:49:41] if I understand correctly [1:49:43] about 14 years ago [1:49:44] yes senator [1:49:45] Mr. Falvey [1:49:46] have you been nominated [1:49:47] to replace Judge Philip Simon [1:49:49] nominated by President Bush [1:49:51] any idea [1:49:53] how many years he had [1:49:54] when nominated [1:49:56] by President Bush [1:49:56] Senator I'm not certain [1:49:58] I believe he was [1:49:59] in his early 40s though [1:50:00] he was young [1:50:01] he was only 16 years [1:50:02] out of law school [1:50:03] and in practice [1:50:04] you graduated law school [1:50:06] if I understand correctly [1:50:06] in 2017 [1:50:07] you weren't even a lawyer [1:50:09] when President Trump [1:50:10] was first elected [1:50:11] look the broader point [1:50:13] I'm simply making [1:50:13] is the lack of time [1:50:15] for us to be fully prepared [1:50:16] to question you [1:50:17] and the relative brevity [1:50:19] of your time [1:50:20] as practicing members [1:50:21] of the bar [1:50:22] let me ask an unrelated [1:50:24] but distinct [1:50:24] and I think important question [1:50:26] since you were just talking [1:50:27] about the importance [1:50:28] of taking the oath [1:50:29] to uphold and defend [1:50:29] the Constitution [1:50:30] Mr. Sullivan [1:50:32] can you just tell me [1:50:33] what the 22nd amendment [1:50:34] provides [1:50:34] Senator if I'm remembering [1:50:39] correctly [1:50:40] and I carry it [1:50:41] over my heart [1:50:42] because sometimes [1:50:42] it isn't in my brain [1:50:43] but if I [1:50:46] if I'm remembering [1:50:47] it correctly [1:50:48] it is [1:50:50] no person shall be elected [1:50:54] ah yes [1:50:57] I'm sorry [1:50:57] thank you [1:50:58] thank you [1:51:00] genuinely [1:51:00] Senator [1:51:01] no person shall be elected [1:51:03] more than twice [1:51:05] I believe [1:51:05] to the office [1:51:06] of the president [1:51:07] has President Trump [1:51:08] been elected [1:51:08] and served now [1:51:09] twice as president [1:51:10] the [1:51:12] President Trump [1:51:14] has been certified [1:51:15] as the winner [1:51:16] in the 2016 [1:51:16] and the 2024 [1:51:18] is he eligible [1:51:19] to run for president [1:51:20] again in 2028 [1:51:21] so Senator [1:51:22] as a nominee [1:51:24] for a federal [1:51:26] district court [1:51:27] it would be [1:51:29] a violation [1:51:30] I believe [1:51:30] of Canon 5 [1:51:32] for me [1:51:32] to opine [1:51:34] on something [1:51:35] like that [1:51:36] and so [1:51:37] respectfully [1:51:39] I'm not [1:51:40] I'm not so sure [1:51:42] that I can [1:51:42] I mean [1:51:44] I can [1:51:44] I can certainly [1:51:45] tell you [1:51:45] how I would [1:51:46] think about [1:51:46] approaching [1:51:47] a problem [1:51:48] like that [1:51:49] but [1:51:49] this seems [1:51:51] like both [1:51:51] it certainly [1:51:52] seems like [1:51:53] it's [1:51:53] the sort of [1:51:54] thing that is [1:51:55] a subject [1:51:56] of ongoing [1:51:56] political debate [1:51:57] and Canon 5C [1:51:58] of the canons [1:52:00] that would apply [1:52:01] to us [1:52:01] as nominees [1:52:02] could [1:52:02] that's a very [1:52:03] disappointing answer [1:52:04] it strikes me [1:52:05] as just [1:52:05] bracingly clear [1:52:06] on the face [1:52:07] of it [1:52:07] a textualist [1:52:09] anyone [1:52:11] who has read [1:52:12] the constitution [1:52:12] and is [1:52:13] sitting before me [1:52:14] for confirmation [1:52:15] for a lifetime [1:52:16] appointment [1:52:17] I don't think [1:52:17] it is the subject [1:52:18] of political debate [1:52:19] I respect your reading [1:52:20] of Canon 5 [1:52:21] and if I were asking [1:52:22] you a question [1:52:24] that was the subject [1:52:25] of vigorous political [1:52:26] debate [1:52:26] and unsettled [1:52:27] as a matter [1:52:27] of constitutional law [1:52:28] or interpretation [1:52:29] or application [1:52:30] I could respect [1:52:31] that answer [1:52:31] but the question [1:52:33] whether someone [1:52:34] can serve [1:52:34] a third term [1:52:35] as president [1:52:36] of the United States [1:52:36] I think is only [1:52:38] unresolved [1:52:38] in the mind [1:52:39] of President Trump [1:52:39] who has repeatedly [1:52:41] said that he's [1:52:42] thinking he might [1:52:43] run for a third term [1:52:43] but the amendment [1:52:46] is bracingly clear [1:52:47] no person [1:52:48] shall be elected [1:52:49] to the office [1:52:50] of the president [1:52:51] more than twice [1:52:52] he's demonstrably [1:52:53] been elected [1:52:54] certified [1:52:54] and served [1:52:55] twice [1:52:55] I don't understand [1:52:57] how there's any [1:52:57] political debate [1:52:59] here sir [1:53:00] could you help me [1:53:01] understand your answer [1:53:02] Senator [1:53:04] the [1:53:05] it strikes me [1:53:08] that the reason [1:53:08] that we're talking [1:53:11] about this [1:53:11] is because [1:53:12] you've [1:53:12] you've mentioned [1:53:14] comments that the [1:53:15] president has made [1:53:16] about this [1:53:17] in the press [1:53:18] and so [1:53:19] what I can tell you [1:53:20] is about how [1:53:21] whether it's [1:53:21] with the 22nd amendment [1:53:23] or any other [1:53:23] and I do appreciate [1:53:25] the refresher [1:53:25] on it [1:53:26] that's why [1:53:28] they write these [1:53:29] things down [1:53:29] and I keep it [1:53:30] with me [1:53:30] I would be looking [1:53:32] to the text [1:53:34] of the provision [1:53:35] and the original [1:53:37] public meaning [1:53:37] of that text [1:53:38] you know [1:53:39] what it meant [1:53:41] to the people [1:53:42] and the states [1:53:43] who ratified it [1:53:43] at the time [1:53:44] that they did it [1:53:44] my recollection [1:53:46] is that that was [1:53:47] in the wake [1:53:47] of the Roosevelt [1:53:48] Franklin Delano Roosevelt [1:53:50] Is there any [1:53:51] possible way [1:53:52] to interpret [1:53:53] that amendment [1:53:54] as meaning [1:53:54] anything [1:53:55] other than [1:53:56] no person [1:53:56] shall be elected [1:53:58] and serve as [1:53:59] president [1:53:59] for a third term [1:54:00] I can't [1:54:01] I almost can't [1:54:01] imagine a provision [1:54:02] that is clearer [1:54:03] than this [1:54:03] and you're right [1:54:04] I agree with you [1:54:05] about the historical context [1:54:06] we had a president [1:54:07] who served four terms [1:54:08] there was a broad [1:54:09] discussion debate [1:54:10] and an amendment [1:54:11] to the constitution [1:54:11] was adopted [1:54:12] that says [1:54:12] no one can serve [1:54:14] a third term [1:54:14] how is it in any way [1:54:16] controversial [1:54:16] that any person [1:54:19] elected [1:54:19] President Trump [1:54:20] or anybody else [1:54:21] President Obama [1:54:23] there's no debate [1:54:25] about this [1:54:26] in my view [1:54:26] Mr. Lambert [1:54:28] are you willing [1:54:28] to proffer [1:54:29] any view [1:54:30] on the 22nd amendment [1:54:31] whether or not [1:54:32] it can be enforced [1:54:32] or is it simply [1:54:33] up to interpretation [1:54:35] Senator [1:54:36] the text [1:54:37] of the 22nd amendment [1:54:38] seems clear [1:54:40] that no one [1:54:41] may serve [1:54:42] a third term [1:54:42] and that would [1:54:44] include [1:54:44] President Trump [1:54:45] or anyone else [1:54:46] who might seek [1:54:46] a third term [1:54:46] that would include [1:54:47] anyone [1:54:47] Senator [1:54:47] thank you [1:54:48] for your courage [1:54:48] Mr. Falvey [1:54:50] any opinion [1:54:50] about the 22nd amendment [1:54:51] to the constitution [1:54:52] of the United States [1:54:53] Senator [1:54:54] I certainly [1:54:54] appreciate [1:54:55] Justice Sullivan's [1:54:56] concerns [1:54:56] in my view [1:54:58] I think [1:54:58] the text provides [1:54:59] that no person [1:55:01] and person [1:55:02] is a category [1:55:02] that includes [1:55:03] President Trump [1:55:04] can serve [1:55:05] more than two terms [1:55:06] in office [1:55:06] I'm always open [1:55:07] to the possibility [1:55:08] that there's legal [1:55:08] arguments out there [1:55:09] that I'm not aware of [1:55:10] I'm not a scholar [1:55:10] in this area [1:55:11] if there are arguments [1:55:13] along those lines [1:55:14] I'd be very happy [1:55:15] to consider them [1:55:16] but that's my understanding [1:55:17] of the text [1:55:18] Senator [1:55:18] so your understanding [1:55:20] Mr. Falvey [1:55:20] not to put words [1:55:21] in your mouth [1:55:21] is that President Trump [1:55:22] is not eligible [1:55:23] to serve for a third term [1:55:23] as president [1:55:24] anybody [1:55:24] who has served [1:55:25] two terms [1:55:26] is not eligible [1:55:26] for a third term [1:55:27] Senator [1:55:28] the 22nd amendment [1:55:28] says no person [1:55:29] can serve [1:55:30] more than two terms [1:55:30] so it's your [1:55:31] understanding [1:55:33] third term [1:55:34] Senator [1:55:34] President Trump [1:55:35] is a person [1:55:36] subject to the 22nd amendment [1:55:38] thank you [1:55:38] all I'm going to say [1:55:40] I've asked the same question [1:55:41] of previous panels [1:55:42] of nominees [1:55:43] who were unwilling [1:55:44] or unable [1:55:45] to deliver an answer [1:55:46] just because someone [1:55:47] raises an outrageous [1:55:49] and unfounded [1:55:50] challenge or argument [1:55:51] about a legal principle [1:55:52] doesn't mean [1:55:53] that it is so subject [1:55:55] to political debate [1:55:56] that you cannot render [1:55:57] an opinion about that [1:55:59] when it is this clear [1:56:00] I recognize and respect [1:56:02] that the canon [1:56:02] prevents you from [1:56:03] giving us your opinion [1:56:04] on something [1:56:05] that is genuinely [1:56:06] the subject [1:56:06] of ongoing [1:56:07] jurisprudential debate [1:56:09] this is not that [1:56:10] and as you heard me [1:56:12] question the circuit [1:56:13] court nominee [1:56:13] our president [1:56:15] makes statements [1:56:15] as arguably all [1:56:18] elected officials do [1:56:19] that should not be [1:56:20] outcome determinative [1:56:21] of your ability [1:56:22] to give us your [1:56:23] conclusions about [1:56:24] foundational matters [1:56:25] of constitutional law [1:56:26] thank you Mr. Chairman [1:56:27] thank you [1:56:29] Senator Tillis [1:56:30] thank you Mr. Chair [1:56:32] thanks everybody [1:56:32] for being here [1:56:33] I hope I talked [1:56:34] to Senator Banks [1:56:35] on the floor [1:56:37] I said I hope you [1:56:38] I was hoping [1:56:39] that the members [1:56:40] who were leaving [1:56:41] had left [1:56:41] before I went [1:56:42] into my tirade [1:56:43] about 86-47 [1:56:45] but you know [1:56:47] I feel very strongly [1:56:48] about showing [1:56:50] respect to the noms [1:56:51] and asking them [1:56:52] a question [1:56:53] before you insert [1:56:55] behind them [1:56:56] your thoughts [1:56:58] on their thoughts [1:56:58] number one [1:57:00] I will tell you [1:57:00] I'm not an attorney [1:57:01] I watched a lot [1:57:02] of law and order [1:57:03] and I've sat next [1:57:04] to this guy [1:57:04] for a couple [1:57:05] of congresses [1:57:05] I think that [1:57:06] the second amendment [1:57:07] is pretty crystal clear [1:57:09] but the way [1:57:10] the question is asked [1:57:11] is to try and pin you [1:57:11] down [1:57:12] and to try and [1:57:13] get the president [1:57:14] angry with you [1:57:15] it's just another tactic [1:57:16] here that I will not miss [1:57:17] Mr. Albert [1:57:19] tell me what your role [1:57:21] was at 86-47 [1:57:23] thank you Senator [1:57:25] so I'm the first [1:57:27] assistant U.S. attorney [1:57:28] in the eastern district [1:57:30] of North Carolina [1:57:31] so as the first [1:57:32] assistant [1:57:33] I'm the number two [1:57:34] in charge of the office [1:57:35] obviously [1:57:37] indicting the former [1:57:39] director of the FBI [1:57:40] is a very high profile [1:57:41] case that received [1:57:43] a lot of upper [1:57:44] management attention [1:57:45] ultimately my role [1:57:48] in it was to [1:57:50] serve at the U.S. [1:57:52] attorney's direction [1:57:53] provide him advice [1:57:55] as necessary [1:57:57] and take steps [1:57:59] in the case [1:57:59] did you formulate [1:58:00] a strategy [1:58:01] to bring the prosecution [1:58:02] or the indictment [1:58:03] I did not senator [1:58:04] did you come up [1:58:05] with the boneheaded [1:58:06] idea to indict him [1:58:07] over a picture [1:58:07] in the sand [1:58:08] I did not senator [1:58:09] did you at any point [1:58:11] when somebody [1:58:11] questioned it [1:58:12] say don't question [1:58:13] that just order [1:58:13] just do what HQ [1:58:15] is saying do [1:58:15] senator [1:58:18] it wasn't [1:58:19] presented as an HQ [1:58:21] is saying to do this [1:58:22] got it [1:58:22] okay [1:58:23] that was a cheap shot [1:58:24] on my part [1:58:25] but good clarification [1:58:26] Mr. Meyer [1:58:27] same set of questions [1:58:28] thank you senator [1:58:31] Tillis [1:58:31] because I'm asking [1:58:33] this question [1:58:34] because it was [1:58:35] suggested by my [1:58:37] colleague that y'all [1:58:38] were like co-conspirators [1:58:39] in this [1:58:40] and that's why I'm [1:58:41] going to focus [1:58:42] all of my attention [1:58:42] on this [1:58:43] go ahead Mr. Myers [1:58:44] thank you senator [1:58:45] my involvement [1:58:47] in the the case [1:58:49] of United States [1:58:49] versus Comey [1:58:50] is a there's a [1:58:51] matter of public [1:58:52] record in that case [1:58:53] which is that I [1:58:54] signed a search warrant [1:58:55] in my duties as a [1:58:56] United States [1:58:57] magistrate judge [1:58:58] I signed that search [1:58:59] warrant pursuant [1:59:00] to my review [1:59:01] under rule 41 [1:59:01] you play any role [1:59:02] in saying hey [1:59:03] this is a good idea [1:59:03] this picture on the [1:59:05] sand is a really [1:59:07] dangerous thing [1:59:07] you play a role [1:59:08] in formulating this [1:59:09] no you didn't [1:59:10] it's a rhetorical [1:59:11] question [1:59:11] so that's the point [1:59:14] you guys are [1:59:15] great noms [1:59:16] you all know [1:59:17] that we have [1:59:18] Senator Butt [1:59:20] and I worked on this [1:59:21] you aren't the [1:59:21] president's noms [1:59:22] you are noms [1:59:23] that the president [1:59:24] support it [1:59:24] that's the way [1:59:25] this process [1:59:25] is supposed to work [1:59:26] and that's why [1:59:27] I stand by your [1:59:28] nomination [1:59:29] I think you're [1:59:29] going to make [1:59:29] great judges [1:59:30] and you're [1:59:30] going to get [1:59:31] confirmed [1:59:31] Mr. Sullivan [1:59:33] you made the [1:59:34] right answer [1:59:36] that I think [1:59:39] every one of you [1:59:40] I appreciate [1:59:41] the way you [1:59:41] answered that [1:59:42] question about [1:59:42] the 22nd [1:59:43] amendment [1:59:43] these are the [1:59:43] gotcha questions [1:59:44] that we're guilty [1:59:45] of when the roles [1:59:46] are reversed [1:59:47] we'll probably be [1:59:48] guilty of it [1:59:49] next Congress [1:59:49] but you answered [1:59:51] it correctly [1:59:52] because what you're [1:59:52] really trying to [1:59:53] say is the plain [1:59:54] letter of the 22nd [1:59:56] amendment [1:59:56] is there [1:59:58] the letter [1:59:58] of the text [1:59:59] but by virtue [2:00:01] of you being [2:00:01] a sitting judge [2:00:02] you may find [2:00:03] some novel argument [2:00:04] somebody's going [2:00:05] to put forth [2:00:05] it's going to be [2:00:06] really difficult [2:00:07] to question the [2:00:08] plain letter [2:00:08] of the text [2:00:09] but that's all [2:00:09] you said [2:00:10] and you said [2:00:12] nothing more [2:00:12] or less than that [2:00:13] so in the interest [2:00:15] of time [2:00:15] we have votes [2:00:16] we're going to have [2:00:16] people going in [2:00:17] and out [2:00:17] so I'm not going [2:00:18] to take any more [2:00:19] of your time [2:00:20] except to congratulate [2:00:21] you all [2:00:21] on getting [2:00:22] the nominations [2:00:23] and I look forward [2:00:24] to supporting [2:00:26] your confirmation [2:00:26] and I am going [2:00:27] to try and come [2:00:28] back for another [2:00:30] lesson from Senator [2:00:31] Kennedy [2:00:31] if I have time [2:00:32] Senator Kennedy [2:00:37] oh I'm sorry [2:00:41] I'm sorry [2:00:41] do you want to go [2:00:43] before or after [2:00:44] Joe [2:00:44] yeah [2:00:45] go ahead to [2:00:47] Senator Kennedy [2:00:48] then we'll go [2:00:48] to Senator Durbin [2:00:49] thank you [2:00:50] Mr. Lambert [2:00:55] what deference [2:00:58] if any [2:00:59] does a federal [2:01:01] court [2:01:03] now owe [2:01:04] to a [2:01:08] to a rule [2:01:11] or regulation [2:01:12] promulgated [2:01:14] by the executive [2:01:16] branch [2:01:17] Senator [2:01:20] under the [2:01:21] Loper Bright [2:01:21] decision from a few [2:01:22] years ago [2:01:22] the Supreme Court [2:01:23] overturned the [2:01:24] Chevron doctrine [2:01:25] so now it's the [2:01:27] job of the courts [2:01:27] to determine [2:01:28] what is the best [2:01:30] reading of a statute [2:01:31] rather than [2:01:32] deferring to an [2:01:32] agency's [2:01:33] interpretation [2:01:34] of a statute [2:01:35] that might be [2:01:36] ambiguous [2:01:37] there's also [2:01:38] still under [2:01:40] the Kaiser [2:01:40] decision [2:01:40] the our [2:01:41] doctrine [2:01:42] that remains [2:01:43] for deference [2:01:44] to certain [2:01:45] agency regulations [2:01:46] and how they're [2:01:47] interpreted [2:01:47] which is a [2:01:48] slightly separate [2:01:49] matter than the [2:01:49] agency's [2:01:50] interpretation [2:01:50] of the statute [2:01:51] itself [2:01:52] the Supreme Court [2:01:57] hands down [2:01:58] opinions [2:01:58] all the time [2:02:01] obviously [2:02:01] interpreting the [2:02:02] Constitution [2:02:03] suppose [2:02:07] suppose the [2:02:11] Supreme Court [2:02:11] hands down [2:02:12] a decision [2:02:13] that can be [2:02:15] fairly interpreted [2:02:16] by saying [2:02:19] that you [2:02:20] cannot use [2:02:22] race [2:02:22] race [2:02:25] the federal [2:02:25] government [2:02:25] can't use [2:02:26] race [2:02:26] or any [2:02:27] government [2:02:27] can't use [2:02:28] race [2:02:28] to [2:02:30] discriminate [2:02:35] against people [2:02:36] let's take [2:02:39] DEI as an [2:02:40] example [2:02:40] and you have [2:02:43] rules and [2:02:44] regulations [2:02:45] within an [2:02:46] agency [2:02:46] that [2:02:48] actually [2:02:49] establish [2:02:50] DEI [2:02:51] what do you [2:02:56] do about [2:02:56] those rules [2:02:56] and regulations [2:02:57] do you just [2:02:59] leave them [2:02:59] on the books [2:03:00] Senator [2:03:01] the Constitution [2:03:02] controls over [2:03:03] any other [2:03:04] source of law [2:03:04] in this country [2:03:05] that's true [2:03:06] and if something [2:03:07] is inconsistent [2:03:08] with the [2:03:08] Constitution [2:03:09] it cannot be [2:03:10] enforced [2:03:11] depending on [2:03:13] what the agency [2:03:14] was or what [2:03:15] the regulation [2:03:15] was and the [2:03:16] particular claim [2:03:17] for relief [2:03:17] sought [2:03:17] you could [2:03:18] presumably see [2:03:19] declaratory or [2:03:19] injunctive relief [2:03:20] preventing the [2:03:21] enforcement of the [2:03:22] regulations that [2:03:23] were inconsistent [2:03:23] with the [2:03:24] Constitution [2:03:24] well [2:03:25] I understand [2:03:27] that but [2:03:28] let's suppose [2:03:29] an agency [2:03:29] didn't try [2:03:31] to enforce [2:03:33] the rule [2:03:35] that's in [2:03:36] violation [2:03:37] of a [2:03:37] Supreme [2:03:37] Court [2:03:38] precedent [2:03:38] it's just [2:03:40] there [2:03:40] but it [2:03:44] could be [2:03:44] confusing [2:03:45] for somebody [2:03:46] who's [2:03:47] interested [2:03:48] in [2:03:49] adjusting [2:03:51] his behavior [2:03:52] in accordance [2:03:52] with the [2:03:53] rule or [2:03:53] regulation [2:03:54] of the [2:03:54] agency [2:03:55] so what [2:03:55] do you [2:03:56] do about [2:03:56] the rule [2:03:57] do you [2:03:57] just leave [2:03:58] it there [2:03:58] do you [2:03:59] have to [2:03:59] go through [2:04:00] notice [2:04:01] and comment [2:04:02] what do [2:04:03] you do [2:04:04] from the [2:04:05] judicial [2:04:05] perspective [2:04:06] Senator [2:04:06] courts [2:04:07] federal courts [2:04:08] are courts [2:04:08] of limited [2:04:08] jurisdiction [2:04:09] you've got [2:04:10] to go back [2:04:10] to article [2:04:10] three and [2:04:11] look for [2:04:11] a case [2:04:11] or controversy [2:04:12] if someone [2:04:13] suffered an [2:04:14] injury in [2:04:15] fact [2:04:15] from the [2:04:16] rules still [2:04:17] being on [2:04:17] the books [2:04:18] they could [2:04:18] come into [2:04:19] federal court [2:04:19] and bring [2:04:20] that claim [2:04:20] if there [2:04:21] were no [2:04:21] injury [2:04:22] in fact [2:04:22] a federal [2:04:23] court would [2:04:23] lack [2:04:24] jurisdiction [2:04:24] to enter [2:04:24] any sort [2:04:25] of judgment [2:04:25] about that [2:04:26] rule [2:04:26] and presumably [2:04:27] at that [2:04:27] point [2:04:28] it would [2:04:28] be to [2:04:28] the [2:04:28] agency [2:04:28] or to [2:04:29] congress [2:04:29] to act [2:04:30] until a [2:04:31] live case [2:04:31] came before [2:04:32] a court [2:04:32] with [2:04:32] jurisdiction [2:04:33] okay [2:04:33] fair [2:04:34] enough [2:04:34] judge [2:04:37] sullivan [2:04:38] are you [2:04:40] an [2:04:41] originalist [2:04:42] senator [2:04:44] kennedy [2:04:44] i am [2:04:45] an [2:04:45] originalist [2:04:46] and [2:04:46] what does [2:04:48] that mean [2:04:48] what that [2:04:50] means to [2:04:50] me [2:04:51] senator [2:04:51] and the [2:04:52] way i've [2:04:53] done it [2:04:53] on the [2:04:53] texas [2:04:54] supreme [2:04:54] court [2:04:54] i start [2:04:56] from the [2:04:56] proposition [2:04:56] we write [2:04:57] these things [2:04:58] down for [2:04:58] a reason [2:04:59] the text [2:05:00] of the [2:05:00] constitution [2:05:01] the statutes [2:05:02] enacted by [2:05:03] this congress [2:05:04] or by the [2:05:04] texas [2:05:04] legislature [2:05:05] even a [2:05:06] contract [2:05:07] a private [2:05:08] law [2:05:08] tell me [2:05:08] what [2:05:08] originalism [2:05:09] is [2:05:10] we need [2:05:11] to [2:05:11] understand [2:05:12] what is [2:05:13] the law [2:05:14] what was [2:05:15] written down [2:05:15] and what [2:05:17] was the [2:05:17] original [2:05:17] public [2:05:18] meaning [2:05:18] of the [2:05:20] words that [2:05:20] a free [2:05:20] people wrote [2:05:21] meaning [2:05:21] to whom [2:05:23] meaning [2:05:24] to the [2:05:24] language [2:05:25] community [2:05:26] at the [2:05:27] time [2:05:28] that [2:05:28] a text [2:05:29] became [2:05:29] law [2:05:30] what is [2:05:30] what is [2:05:31] a language [2:05:31] community [2:05:32] well that's [2:05:33] probably [2:05:33] just a high [2:05:34] falutin way [2:05:35] of saying [2:05:35] how did [2:05:36] how did [2:05:37] normal folks [2:05:37] using the [2:05:38] English [2:05:38] language [2:05:39] understand it [2:05:40] when the [2:05:41] statute was [2:05:41] passed [2:05:42] in 2025 [2:05:43] I'm talking [2:05:43] about the [2:05:44] constitution [2:05:44] well obviously [2:05:45] with the [2:05:46] constitution [2:05:46] the US [2:05:47] constitution [2:05:47] it's not [2:05:48] amended nearly [2:05:49] as frequently [2:05:50] if we were [2:05:50] talking about [2:05:51] a statute [2:05:51] we'd be [2:05:52] talking about [2:05:52] textualism [2:05:53] but we're [2:05:54] talking about [2:05:54] originalism [2:05:55] so maybe [2:05:57] I wasn't [2:05:59] clear [2:05:59] we're talking [2:06:00] about the [2:06:00] constitution [2:06:01] sure [2:06:01] so tell me [2:06:03] again quickly [2:06:04] your definition [2:06:05] of originalism [2:06:05] originalism [2:06:07] is [2:06:07] understanding [2:06:08] and adhering [2:06:09] to the [2:06:10] meaning [2:06:10] of the [2:06:10] text [2:06:11] as it [2:06:11] was [2:06:11] understood [2:06:12] to [2:06:12] speakers [2:06:13] of the [2:06:13] English [2:06:13] language [2:06:14] at the [2:06:14] time [2:06:14] that it [2:06:15] became [2:06:15] ratified [2:06:16] and became [2:06:16] part of [2:06:16] the [2:06:17] constitution [2:06:17] okay [2:06:18] so you [2:06:18] go back [2:06:19] and look [2:06:20] at the [2:06:21] time [2:06:22] the [2:06:22] provision [2:06:24] or the [2:06:25] amendment [2:06:25] was ratified [2:06:26] and see [2:06:26] what people [2:06:27] thought [2:06:28] not so much [2:06:29] what they [2:06:29] thought [2:06:30] but what [2:06:31] words [2:06:31] were [2:06:32] what the [2:06:32] words that [2:06:33] were used [2:06:33] would have [2:06:34] meant to [2:06:35] the people [2:06:35] using [2:06:35] them [2:06:36] at the [2:06:36] time [2:06:36] okay [2:06:37] it's not [2:06:37] a secret [2:06:38] intention [2:06:38] tell me about [2:06:38] the eighth [2:06:39] amendment [2:06:39] okay so [2:06:40] the eighth [2:06:41] amendment [2:06:41] let me see [2:06:42] if I can [2:06:42] speed this [2:06:43] long [2:06:43] it [2:06:43] violences [2:06:44] cruel and [2:06:44] unusual [2:06:45] punishment [2:06:45] right [2:06:46] that's [2:06:46] right [2:06:46] okay [2:06:47] do you [2:06:50] apply [2:06:51] why don't [2:06:52] you apply [2:06:53] or do [2:06:53] you apply [2:06:54] an originalist [2:06:55] interpretation [2:06:56] to the [2:06:56] eighth [2:06:56] amendment [2:06:57] so [2:06:57] senator [2:06:58] kennedy [2:06:58] that's [2:06:59] the way [2:06:59] that I [2:06:59] would do [2:06:59] it [2:07:00] okay [2:07:00] so [2:07:01] at the [2:07:02] time [2:07:03] the eighth [2:07:03] amendment [2:07:04] was adopted [2:07:04] I think [2:07:05] it was [2:07:05] 1791 [2:07:06] but don't [2:07:07] hold me [2:07:07] to that [2:07:08] one of the [2:07:09] punishments [2:07:10] that was [2:07:10] generally [2:07:10] accepted [2:07:11] was cutting [2:07:12] off somebody's [2:07:13] ear [2:07:13] would you [2:07:14] support [2:07:15] a statute [2:07:16] by congress [2:07:17] to provide [2:07:18] that we [2:07:19] could cut [2:07:19] people's ears [2:07:20] off [2:07:20] well [2:07:21] senator [2:07:21] kennedy [2:07:21] as a [2:07:22] nominee [2:07:22] to be [2:07:22] a district [2:07:23] judge [2:07:23] I would [2:07:23] be bound [2:07:24] by u.s. [2:07:24] supreme [2:07:25] court [2:07:25] precedent [2:07:25] and [2:07:26] well [2:07:27] you just [2:07:27] told me [2:07:28] that you're [2:07:28] an originalist [2:07:29] and it [2:07:29] depends on [2:07:30] what people [2:07:31] thought [2:07:31] in 1791 [2:07:33] in 1791 [2:07:34] it was [2:07:35] okay [2:07:35] to cut [2:07:36] somebody's [2:07:37] ear off [2:07:38] as punishment [2:07:38] it was [2:07:40] okay [2:07:40] to brand [2:07:41] somebody [2:07:43] so under [2:07:44] an originalist [2:07:44] your interpretation [2:07:46] those are [2:07:46] acceptable [2:07:47] those aren't [2:07:48] cruel and [2:07:49] unusual [2:07:49] punishments [2:07:50] correct [2:07:50] and just [2:07:51] justice [2:07:51] scalia [2:07:52] in some [2:07:52] of the [2:07:53] dissents [2:07:53] that he [2:07:53] had [2:07:54] for cases [2:07:55] like roper [2:07:56] and atkins [2:07:57] limiting [2:07:57] the death [2:07:58] penalty [2:07:58] that was [2:07:59] part of [2:08:00] the argument [2:08:00] that was [2:08:00] made [2:08:01] but [2:08:01] I'm [2:08:02] not a [2:08:03] nominee [2:08:03] for anything [2:08:04] but to [2:08:04] be a [2:08:04] district [2:08:05] general [2:08:05] are you an [2:08:05] originalist [2:08:06] or not [2:08:06] I am [2:08:07] under [2:08:09] originalism [2:08:10] in the [2:08:10] eighth amendment [2:08:11] why [2:08:11] are you [2:08:14] saying [2:08:14] that the [2:08:14] eighth amendment [2:08:15] we don't [2:08:16] use [2:08:16] originalism [2:08:17] no I [2:08:17] think that [2:08:18] we do [2:08:18] but we [2:08:19] also use [2:08:19] originalism [2:08:20] to understand [2:08:20] what the [2:08:21] judicial power [2:08:21] in article [2:08:22] three means [2:08:23] you're talking [2:08:23] in circles [2:08:24] judge [2:08:25] I'm just [2:08:26] asking you [2:08:26] if you're [2:08:27] an originalist [2:08:27] and what [2:08:28] people thought [2:08:29] in 1791 [2:08:30] controls [2:08:31] then why [2:08:34] would it be [2:08:34] unconstitutional [2:08:35] if you think [2:08:36] it would be [2:08:37] for us to [2:08:38] pass a statute [2:08:38] that we can [2:08:39] cut somebody's [2:08:40] ear off [2:08:40] for robbery [2:08:41] as a nominee [2:08:42] to be a [2:08:43] district judge [2:08:43] I think [2:08:44] it would be [2:08:44] unconstitutional [2:08:45] because the [2:08:45] U.S. [2:08:46] Supreme Court [2:08:46] has said [2:08:47] so [2:08:47] so you [2:08:48] think [2:08:48] so we [2:08:49] U.S. [2:08:50] Supreme Court [2:08:50] doesn't apply [2:08:51] originalism [2:08:52] there [2:08:52] as a [2:08:53] as a [2:08:54] district judge [2:08:54] it would not [2:08:55] be my place [2:08:55] to grade [2:08:56] their homework [2:08:56] but I don't [2:08:57] they either [2:08:57] do or they [2:08:58] don't [2:09:00] you're talking [2:09:00] in circles [2:09:01] sometimes they [2:09:02] don't [2:09:02] senator [2:09:03] but [2:09:03] but you [2:09:04] think [2:09:04] they should [2:09:05] that [2:09:06] that's the [2:09:07] way I would [2:09:07] do it [2:09:07] as a judge [2:09:08] but I would [2:09:08] adhere to [2:09:09] stare decisis [2:09:10] I'd follow [2:09:11] precedent [2:09:11] so you [2:09:12] think [2:09:12] the Supreme [2:09:14] Court's [2:09:14] wrong [2:09:14] in using [2:09:17] the evolving [2:09:18] standards [2:09:19] litmus test [2:09:25] well [2:09:25] senator [2:09:26] I have [2:09:28] probably [2:09:28] made statements [2:09:29] in the past [2:09:30] to that effect [2:09:31] but as a [2:09:32] nominee [2:09:32] for a [2:09:33] district judge [2:09:34] judge [2:09:36] Griffith [2:09:36] for whom I [2:09:37] clerked [2:09:37] would say [2:09:37] whatever thou art [2:09:38] play well [2:09:39] thy part [2:09:39] and at the [2:09:40] bottom of the [2:09:41] federal judicial [2:09:42] hierarchy [2:09:42] it wouldn't [2:09:42] be my place [2:09:43] to grade [2:09:44] their homework [2:09:44] on the [2:09:45] Supreme Court [2:09:46] it sounds [2:09:46] like you [2:09:47] just did [2:09:47] well [2:09:49] no I have [2:09:50] in the past [2:09:50] but I wasn't [2:09:51] a nominee [2:09:51] then senator [2:09:52] I went way [2:09:53] over [2:09:54] I'm sorry [2:09:54] Mr. Whomever's [2:09:56] presiding over [2:09:57] this [2:09:57] senator [2:09:59] Durbin [2:09:59] thank you [2:10:01] senator [2:10:01] Lee [2:10:02] judge [2:10:04] Sullivan [2:10:05] were you [2:10:07] on the [2:10:07] ballot [2:10:07] on November [2:10:08] 3rd [2:10:08] in Texas [2:10:09] yes [2:10:11] senator [2:10:11] for what [2:10:12] place to [2:10:13] justice [2:10:14] Supreme Court [2:10:15] of Texas [2:10:16] and when did [2:10:17] you realize [2:10:18] you were [2:10:18] going to [2:10:19] lose [2:10:19] I forget [2:10:22] what time [2:10:22] it was [2:10:23] on the [2:10:23] evening [2:10:23] of [2:10:23] November [2:10:24] 3rd [2:10:24] but [2:10:25] my [2:10:26] expectation [2:10:27] is that [2:10:29] whenever the [2:10:30] governor [2:10:30] canvases [2:10:31] the results [2:10:31] of the [2:10:31] election [2:10:32] I know [2:10:33] the official [2:10:33] time [2:10:34] but I'm [2:10:34] trying to [2:10:34] understand [2:10:36] this rebound [2:10:37] I've just [2:10:37] never seen [2:10:38] anybody [2:10:38] what an [2:10:39] amazing [2:10:39] story [2:10:40] I've been [2:10:40] a candidate [2:10:41] in a lot [2:10:42] of elections [2:10:42] never had a [2:10:43] consolation prize [2:10:44] like this [2:10:45] so here you [2:10:46] are running [2:10:47] for the [2:10:47] Texas Supreme [2:10:48] Court [2:10:49] and you [2:10:50] don't know [2:10:50] you've lost [2:10:50] until the [2:10:51] night before [2:10:51] but yet [2:10:52] you've got [2:10:53] a questionnaire [2:10:53] filled out [2:10:54] to file [2:10:55] the next day [2:10:56] the next day [2:10:57] for this [2:10:57] federal court [2:10:58] position [2:10:58] what am I [2:11:00] missing here [2:11:00] there's a [2:11:00] there's a lot [2:11:01] of activity [2:11:02] involved here [2:11:02] in terms of [2:11:03] your candidacy [2:11:04] and why [2:11:05] you're here [2:11:06] today [2:11:06] well [2:11:07] ranking member [2:11:08] Durbin [2:11:08] I believe [2:11:10] as chairman [2:11:11] Cruz [2:11:11] and senator [2:11:13] Cornyn may [2:11:13] have mentioned [2:11:14] with their [2:11:14] kind [2:11:15] introductions [2:11:15] I first [2:11:17] raised my [2:11:17] hand for [2:11:18] federal judicial [2:11:19] service [2:11:19] I believe [2:11:21] I submitted [2:11:21] an application [2:11:22] to the [2:11:22] federal [2:11:23] judicial [2:11:23] evaluation [2:11:24] committee [2:11:24] in Texas [2:11:25] in March [2:11:26] of 2025 [2:11:27] and so [2:11:29] it wasn't [2:11:32] like it was [2:11:32] an all-nighter [2:11:33] to fill out [2:11:34] the questionnaire [2:11:35] I've been [2:11:36] interested [2:11:37] I feel called [2:11:38] to serve [2:11:39] ranking member [2:11:40] Durbin [2:11:40] and I'm [2:11:41] honored to [2:11:42] be here [2:11:42] today [2:11:42] and I'm [2:11:43] here today [2:11:43] because the [2:11:44] president [2:11:44] nominated me [2:11:45] and I was [2:11:45] told to be [2:11:46] here [2:11:46] you certainly [2:11:46] have friends [2:11:47] in high places [2:11:48] if you can [2:11:48] lose an [2:11:48] election one [2:11:49] night [2:11:49] and file a [2:11:51] questionnaire [2:11:51] the next [2:11:51] morning [2:11:52] for a [2:11:53] different [2:11:53] judgeship [2:11:53] that's [2:11:55] quite a [2:11:55] rebound [2:11:56] I think [2:11:57] Mr. [2:11:58] Obar [2:11:58] Judge [2:12:00] Myers [2:12:00] both of [2:12:00] you have [2:12:01] pivotal [2:12:01] roles in [2:12:02] the second [2:12:03] Trump [2:12:03] administration's [2:12:04] most recent [2:12:05] efforts to [2:12:06] prosecute [2:12:07] former FBI [2:12:07] director James [2:12:08] Comey [2:12:08] is that [2:12:09] correct [2:12:09] Senator [2:12:12] I played [2:12:13] a role [2:12:13] in that [2:12:14] prosecution [2:12:14] I'm no [2:12:15] longer [2:12:15] playing a [2:12:15] role [2:12:16] in that [2:12:16] prosecution [2:12:16] that's [2:12:17] what I [2:12:17] want to [2:12:17] ask you [2:12:18] about [2:12:18] at [2:12:19] President [2:12:19] Trump's [2:12:20] urging [2:12:20] the Justice [2:12:20] Department [2:12:21] is implausibly [2:12:22] claiming [2:12:23] that former [2:12:24] FBI [2:12:24] director [2:12:25] Mr. [2:12:25] Comey [2:12:26] threatened [2:12:27] to kill [2:12:27] the president [2:12:28] because he [2:12:30] posted a [2:12:30] picture [2:12:31] of seashells [2:12:32] in the [2:12:32] formation [2:12:33] of the [2:12:34] numbers [2:12:34] 86 and [2:12:35] 47 [2:12:35] on social [2:12:36] media [2:12:37] is that [2:12:37] true [2:12:37] Mr. [2:12:38] Obar [2:12:38] Senator [2:12:40] that is [2:12:40] what the [2:12:40] indictment [2:12:41] alleges [2:12:41] you serve [2:12:42] as first [2:12:43] assistant [2:12:43] U.S. [2:12:44] attorney [2:12:44] in the [2:12:44] eastern [2:12:44] district [2:12:45] of North [2:12:45] Carolina [2:12:46] since [2:12:46] 2025 [2:12:47] that's [2:12:48] correct [2:12:48] Senator [2:12:49] the [2:12:49] first [2:12:49] assistant [2:12:50] is the [2:12:50] second highest [2:12:51] ranking [2:12:51] official [2:12:52] in that [2:12:52] office [2:12:52] correct [2:12:53] that's [2:12:53] correct [2:12:54] senator [2:12:54] typically [2:12:55] oversees [2:12:56] the [2:12:56] operations [2:12:57] and [2:12:57] supervises [2:12:58] a large [2:12:58] staff [2:12:59] of prosecutors [2:13:00] and professional [2:13:00] staff [2:13:01] correct [2:13:01] yes [2:13:02] senator [2:13:02] yet [2:13:03] you've [2:13:03] taken [2:13:03] an [2:13:04] unusually [2:13:04] hands-on [2:13:05] approach [2:13:06] to the [2:13:06] Comey [2:13:06] prosecution [2:13:07] in April [2:13:08] 2026 [2:13:09] you and [2:13:10] a case [2:13:10] agent [2:13:11] directed [2:13:11] the FBI [2:13:12] to conduct [2:13:13] keyword [2:13:13] searches [2:13:14] of trial [2:13:15] transcripts [2:13:16] from U.S. [2:13:17] versus [2:13:17] Gambino [2:13:18] a case [2:13:19] Comey [2:13:20] prosecuted [2:13:20] more than [2:13:21] 30 [2:13:21] years [2:13:21] ago [2:13:21] what [2:13:22] were you [2:13:22] looking [2:13:22] for [2:13:23] senator [2:13:24] I believe [2:13:28] the public [2:13:29] documents [2:13:30] indicate [2:13:30] what we [2:13:30] were looking [2:13:31] for [2:13:31] which was [2:13:32] any [2:13:32] reference [2:13:32] to [2:13:33] 86 [2:13:33] in that [2:13:34] Gambino [2:13:34] trial [2:13:35] transcript [2:13:35] did you [2:13:36] find it [2:13:36] there was [2:13:38] no [2:13:38] reference [2:13:38] senator [2:13:38] why [2:13:39] would you [2:13:39] go to [2:13:40] the [2:13:40] prosecution [2:13:40] of an [2:13:41] italian [2:13:42] american [2:13:42] why did [2:13:43] you pick [2:13:44] that one [2:13:44] so [2:13:47] senator [2:13:48] I need [2:13:48] to be [2:13:48] careful [2:13:49] because [2:13:49] this is [2:13:50] an ongoing [2:13:50] criminal [2:13:51] prosecution [2:13:52] yes [2:13:52] it is [2:13:53] and [2:13:53] so [2:13:54] I [2:13:54] need to [2:13:55] limit [2:13:55] my answers [2:13:56] to [2:13:56] public [2:13:57] information [2:13:58] because [2:13:58] it's [2:13:59] not [2:13:59] fair [2:13:59] to [2:13:59] mr. [2:14:00] comey [2:14:00] my [2:14:00] colleagues [2:14:01] in the [2:14:01] eastern [2:14:01] district [2:14:02] or the [2:14:02] court [2:14:03] to [2:14:03] litigate [2:14:04] that case [2:14:05] here in [2:14:05] front of you [2:14:06] today [2:14:06] let's see [2:14:07] what else [2:14:07] you did [2:14:07] you traveled [2:14:08] around the [2:14:08] country [2:14:08] interviewing [2:14:09] witnesses [2:14:09] including [2:14:10] to phoenix [2:14:11] what did [2:14:12] you do [2:14:13] in phoenix [2:14:13] sammy [2:14:15] sammy [2:14:15] the bull [2:14:16] was interviewed [2:14:16] in phoenix [2:14:17] senator [2:14:17] who is [2:14:17] sammy [2:14:18] the bull [2:14:18] he is [2:14:20] a mobster [2:14:21] who was [2:14:23] a witness [2:14:24] in the [2:14:25] john gambino [2:14:25] trial [2:14:26] and what [2:14:26] did he have [2:14:27] to do [2:14:27] with seashells [2:14:30] senator [2:14:30] again [2:14:31] I believe [2:14:32] that [2:14:32] 302 [2:14:34] from the [2:14:35] fbi [2:14:35] has been [2:14:36] put into [2:14:36] the public [2:14:37] record [2:14:37] so he [2:14:38] was [2:14:38] he was [2:14:39] questioned [2:14:40] about his [2:14:41] knowledge [2:14:41] of the use [2:14:42] of the term [2:14:42] 86 [2:14:43] how did that [2:14:43] turn out [2:14:44] how did that [2:14:48] did you find [2:14:48] any reference [2:14:49] did he help [2:14:50] you [2:14:50] senator [2:14:54] he discussed [2:14:55] his knowledge [2:14:56] of the term [2:14:57] 86 as it was [2:14:58] used in the mob [2:14:58] you initiated [2:15:01] you initialed [2:15:02] I'm sure [2:15:02] each page of the [2:15:03] warrant [2:15:04] an affidavit [2:15:05] when the justice [2:15:06] department sought [2:15:07] a search warrant [2:15:07] to access mr. [2:15:09] comey and his wife's [2:15:10] personal email [2:15:11] accounts and search [2:15:12] history right [2:15:12] senator I reviewed [2:15:14] and initialed that [2:15:15] warrant [2:15:15] is that customary [2:15:17] did you do a lot [2:15:18] of that [2:15:18] what do you mean [2:15:21] by customary [2:15:22] well criminal [2:15:22] investigation [2:15:23] usually the first [2:15:24] assistant has some [2:15:25] supervisory and [2:15:26] administrative [2:15:27] responsibilities [2:15:27] you're the man [2:15:29] on the case [2:15:29] here right [2:15:30] so senator [2:15:32] I'm not the [2:15:33] assistant united [2:15:34] states attorney [2:15:34] that indicted [2:15:35] the case [2:15:36] or signed [2:15:37] the indictment [2:15:38] I did play a [2:15:40] role in the [2:15:40] investigation [2:15:41] as [2:15:42] is this unusual [2:15:42] for you to play [2:15:44] that role [2:15:45] it's not unusual [2:15:47] I would [2:15:48] I would agree [2:15:49] with you senator [2:15:50] that it's not [2:15:51] necessarily common [2:15:52] but it's not [2:15:53] unusual for the [2:15:54] first assistant [2:15:54] to play a role [2:15:55] in a criminal [2:15:56] investigation [2:15:56] who asked you to [2:15:56] do this [2:15:56] the united states [2:15:59] attorney [2:15:59] he did [2:16:00] and there was [2:16:01] no one else in [2:16:01] the office he could [2:16:02] turn to to take over [2:16:03] the prosecution of [2:16:04] this case [2:16:04] senator the case [2:16:07] was taken over by [2:16:08] others in the office [2:16:09] I'm not currently [2:16:10] playing a role in that [2:16:11] case [2:16:12] did this case ever [2:16:13] come up in your [2:16:13] interviews with the [2:16:14] justice department [2:16:15] or the white house [2:16:16] counsel office for [2:16:17] this judgeship [2:16:17] so it [2:16:19] it came up [2:16:21] when I raised it [2:16:22] just as a [2:16:25] as a matter [2:16:26] I think that would [2:16:27] have been of concern [2:16:28] to the committee [2:16:29] like I [2:16:29] understood the committee [2:16:32] may be interested [2:16:33] in this prosecution [2:16:34] so I raised it [2:16:35] as a potential [2:16:36] topic of [2:16:38] questioning [2:16:39] at a hearing [2:16:40] I'm sure the white house [2:16:40] was very interested [2:16:41] judge Myers [2:16:42] as a US magistrate judge [2:16:44] you signed off [2:16:45] on search warrant [2:16:45] for the personal [2:16:46] email accounts [2:16:47] and search history [2:16:48] of Mr. Comey [2:16:48] and his wife [2:16:49] is that true [2:16:49] yes senator [2:16:51] that is correct [2:16:51] two months later [2:16:53] you were contacted [2:16:53] by senator Budd [2:16:54] about your interest [2:16:55] in this judicial [2:16:56] vacancy [2:16:56] true [2:16:57] senator I do not [2:17:00] remember the exact [2:17:01] timing I do not [2:17:02] think it was that [2:17:02] that short of a [2:17:04] turnaround however [2:17:05] well I will [2:17:06] I could be wrong [2:17:07] on that so I'm not [2:17:08] going to hold you [2:17:09] to it but did this [2:17:10] case ever come up [2:17:11] in your interviews [2:17:11] with the justice [2:17:12] department or the [2:17:13] white house counsel [2:17:13] not to my recollection [2:17:15] no sir [2:17:15] it didn't come up [2:17:16] at all [2:17:17] senator if I may be [2:17:19] clear on what my [2:17:20] involvement in this case [2:17:21] is since [2:17:22] October of 2020 [2:17:23] I've served as a [2:17:24] United States [2:17:25] magistrate judge [2:17:26] any warrant that [2:17:27] is presented to [2:17:28] a United States [2:17:29] magistrate judge [2:17:30] and certainly in the [2:17:31] Eastern District of [2:17:31] North Carolina [2:17:32] and elsewhere [2:17:32] as is customary [2:17:35] I take my duties [2:17:36] very seriously [2:17:37] I review them [2:17:38] pursuant to rule [2:17:39] 41 of the federal [2:17:40] rules of criminal [2:17:41] procedure [2:17:41] that warrant was [2:17:43] presented to me [2:17:44] I reviewed it [2:17:45] as is a matter of [2:17:46] public record [2:17:47] in that case [2:17:48] as it is [2:17:49] there is a [2:17:49] redacted version [2:17:50] filed in that case [2:17:51] with my signature [2:17:52] on it [2:17:53] I was the duty [2:17:54] magistrate judge [2:17:56] presented to that [2:17:57] day [2:17:57] it's presented to [2:17:59] whoever is sitting [2:18:00] as the magistrate [2:18:01] judge on duty [2:18:01] that day [2:18:02] that is the extent [2:18:03] of my involvement [2:18:04] sounds administrative [2:18:06] so Justice Sullivan [2:18:09] I just have a few [2:18:10] minutes left here [2:18:12] under the Kennedy [2:18:13] standard [2:18:14] during your time [2:18:15] in the Texas [2:18:16] Attorney General's [2:18:17] office [2:18:17] you represented [2:18:18] the state [2:18:19] in a Fifth Circuit [2:18:20] case [2:18:20] Hartfield v. Thaler [2:18:22] do you remember [2:18:23] that case [2:18:23] I remember the case [2:18:24] Senator [2:18:25] it involved [2:18:26] an intellectually [2:18:26] disabled man [2:18:27] Jerry Hartfield [2:18:28] who was imprisoned [2:18:30] without a valid [2:18:31] conviction [2:18:32] for more [2:18:33] than 30 years [2:18:34] you defended [2:18:36] Mr. Hartfield's [2:18:37] imprisonment [2:18:37] including in an [2:18:38] October 2012 [2:18:39] rehearing petition [2:18:40] the Fifth Circuit [2:18:42] responded to your [2:18:43] petition [2:18:44] castigating you [2:18:45] for the nature [2:18:46] of the petition [2:18:47] and saying [2:18:48] the writing was [2:18:49] disturbingly [2:18:50] unprofessional [2:18:51] and this petition [2:18:52] reveals a lack [2:18:54] of respect [2:18:54] for the court [2:18:55] do you remember that [2:18:56] Senator [2:18:57] I do remember that [2:18:58] and I also remember [2:18:59] I believe two days [2:19:00] later [2:19:01] sending a letter [2:19:02] of apology [2:19:03] to the Fifth Circuit [2:19:04] for having given [2:19:05] that impression [2:19:06] I am very grateful [2:19:08] that the judges [2:19:09] on the Fifth Circuit [2:19:10] for whom I have [2:19:11] the utmost respect [2:19:12] have accepted [2:19:13] that apology [2:19:14] and have certainly [2:19:18] grown a lot [2:19:19] as a lawyer [2:19:19] and seen quite a bit [2:19:20] in the many years [2:19:22] since that happened [2:19:23] Justice Sullivan [2:19:24] we all make mistakes [2:19:25] what did you learn [2:19:25] from that mistake [2:19:26] one of the big things [2:19:28] that I learned [2:19:29] Senator [2:19:29] was that [2:19:31] it's possible [2:19:32] to disagree [2:19:33] without being disagreeable [2:19:35] I now serve [2:19:36] on a multi-member court [2:19:37] and there have been [2:19:39] opinions of mine [2:19:40] that a colleague [2:19:41] disagrees in dissents [2:19:42] and I've written [2:19:43] dissents as well [2:19:44] but I always assume [2:19:46] good faith [2:19:46] on the part of people [2:19:48] who disagree with me [2:19:49] I've also learned [2:19:50] to be a little more [2:19:51] careful about word choice [2:19:53] one of the [2:19:54] one of the problems [2:19:55] with the petition [2:19:56] that you mentioned [2:19:56] is that I used [2:19:58] the word folly [2:19:59] and I was later told [2:20:00] by a friend [2:20:01] that hey [2:20:01] the root of the word [2:20:03] folly is fool [2:20:04] and there's no cause [2:20:05] for calling anybody [2:20:06] a fool [2:20:06] and that's why [2:20:07] I apologized for it [2:20:08] Senator [2:20:09] thank you Justice [2:20:09] thank you Mr. Chairman [2:20:10] thank you [2:20:12] Senator Plumenthal [2:20:13] thank you [2:20:15] Senator Lee [2:20:16] I'm going to try [2:20:20] to be expeditious [2:20:21] this is a big panel [2:20:22] and I have some questions [2:20:24] that I'm sure [2:20:24] you have anticipated [2:20:26] so let me begin [2:20:29] and go right down [2:20:31] the line [2:20:32] who won [2:20:33] the 2020 election [2:20:34] Senator [2:20:36] President Joseph Biden [2:20:38] was certified [2:20:38] the winner [2:20:39] of the 2020 election [2:20:40] who got the highest [2:20:41] popular vote [2:20:43] Senator [2:20:44] I'm not entirely sure [2:20:46] of what the popular vote [2:20:47] results were [2:20:48] President Biden [2:20:49] was certified [2:20:50] as the winner [2:20:50] you don't know [2:20:52] what the popular vote was [2:20:54] I believe news reports [2:20:57] reported it as [2:20:57] Mr. Biden [2:20:58] getting a higher [2:20:59] so Mr. Biden [2:21:01] won the popular vote [2:21:03] he was certified [2:21:04] the winner [2:21:05] of the election [2:21:05] Senator [2:21:06] okay well [2:21:08] that's an original answer [2:21:11] you don't know [2:21:11] next [2:21:13] Senator Blumenthal [2:21:16] in 2020 [2:21:17] through the electoral college [2:21:18] Joe Biden [2:21:19] was certified [2:21:19] the winner [2:21:20] of the presidential election [2:21:21] who won the popular vote [2:21:23] who got the highest number [2:21:24] of votes [2:21:25] in the United States [2:21:26] of America [2:21:26] Senator [2:21:27] in our constitutional system [2:21:28] the president [2:21:29] is selected [2:21:30] through the electoral college [2:21:31] not through [2:21:31] the popular vote [2:21:32] you're assuming [2:21:33] I don't know [2:21:34] the constitution [2:21:36] no Senator [2:21:37] I'm sure you're [2:21:38] familiar with the constitution [2:21:39] so tell me [2:21:40] who got the highest [2:21:40] number of votes [2:21:41] Senator [2:21:43] I think the question [2:21:43] implicates a matter [2:21:44] of public [2:21:45] and political controversy [2:21:46] so it would be [2:21:46] inappropriate [2:21:47] for me [2:21:49] as a judicial nominee [2:21:50] why is it a matter [2:21:50] of controversy [2:21:51] it's years ago [2:21:53] and it's a matter [2:21:54] of public record [2:21:55] Senator [2:21:56] my understanding [2:21:57] is it remains [2:21:57] a political controversy [2:21:59] and so [2:22:00] it would be [2:22:00] inappropriate [2:22:00] for me [2:22:01] to [2:22:02] I think it remains [2:22:03] a political controversy [2:22:04] in the minds [2:22:05] of one man [2:22:06] which is [2:22:08] President Donald Trump [2:22:09] and others around him [2:22:12] keep it in political controversy [2:22:15] as a result [2:22:16] I don't know [2:22:17] why you are keeping it [2:22:18] in political controversy [2:22:20] and demonstrating [2:22:23] a lack of independent [2:22:26] judgment [2:22:27] and truth telling [2:22:28] for that matter [2:22:28] sir [2:22:30] I'm sorry [2:22:33] what is the question [2:22:34] who won the popular vote [2:22:36] in 2020 [2:22:37] Senator [2:22:38] under our constitution [2:22:40] it's the vote [2:22:41] of the electoral college [2:22:42] that has constitutional [2:22:43] significance [2:22:44] Joe Biden [2:22:45] was certified [2:22:46] as the winner [2:22:47] of the [2:22:48] 2020 election [2:22:50] when the electoral votes [2:22:53] were tabulated [2:22:53] let's save time [2:22:56] ditto [2:22:57] same answer [2:22:59] senator [2:23:00] ditto [2:23:02] I agree with Mr. Hamilton [2:23:04] Senator [2:23:08] I don't think [2:23:09] I can improve [2:23:09] on Mr. Hamilton's answer [2:23:11] I think you probably could [2:23:16] who won the popular vote [2:23:19] I forget which [2:23:23] which of the panelists [2:23:24] it was [2:23:25] but [2:23:25] under [2:23:26] Canon 5 [2:23:27] I don't think [2:23:28] it would be appropriate [2:23:29] as a nominee [2:23:29] for me to get into that [2:23:30] so you're invoking [2:23:32] Canon 5 [2:23:33] for refusing to answer [2:23:35] a strictly factual question [2:23:37] it has been reported [2:23:38] numerous times [2:23:40] as [2:23:42] was indicated [2:23:44] by Mr. Albart [2:23:45] it [2:23:46] was reported [2:23:48] in the newspapers [2:23:48] you've read newspapers [2:23:50] that reported it right [2:23:51] I [2:23:59] don't get the newspaper [2:24:01] anymore [2:24:01] tried to [2:24:02] you don't get [2:24:04] it anymore [2:24:05] well this was a few years ago [2:24:06] you [2:24:07] you weren't reading [2:24:08] the newspaper [2:24:08] in 2020 [2:24:10] or 2021 [2:24:11] I was [2:24:19] I was certainly [2:24:20] following news coverage [2:24:21] and [2:24:22] did see that it was reported [2:24:24] that in 2020 [2:24:25] Joe Biden was certified [2:24:27] as the winner [2:24:28] and [2:24:29] you read as well [2:24:30] that he won the popular vote [2:24:32] correct [2:24:32] senator [2:24:34] my answer [2:24:35] on that question [2:24:36] isn't changing [2:24:37] okay [2:24:38] just so everybody understands [2:24:40] the reason I'm asking this question [2:24:41] is a test of your independence [2:24:43] you are going to be [2:24:45] the voice [2:24:46] and face [2:24:47] of justice [2:24:47] to anybody [2:24:49] who appears [2:24:50] in your courtroom [2:24:51] if you are confirmed [2:24:52] and [2:24:54] they're relying [2:24:55] on [2:24:56] your [2:24:57] objectivity [2:25:00] and resistance [2:25:03] to any [2:25:04] political [2:25:05] loyalty test [2:25:07] which is [2:25:08] unfortunately [2:25:09] what you're demonstrating here [2:25:11] Sir Robert [2:25:12] was the Capitol attacked [2:25:13] on [2:25:14] January 6th [2:25:15] 2021 [2:25:15] Senator [2:25:18] I believe the Supreme Court [2:25:19] has described [2:25:20] what happened on January 6th [2:25:21] as a breach [2:25:22] of the Capitol [2:25:22] I do agree [2:25:24] and condemn [2:25:24] the violence that day [2:25:26] Senator [2:25:32] there was violence that day [2:25:34] there was trespass that day [2:25:35] the Supreme Court [2:25:36] has described those events [2:25:37] as a breach of the Capitol [2:25:38] if I'm fortunate enough [2:25:40] to be confirmed [2:25:41] I would certainly adhere [2:25:42] to all Supreme Court precedent [2:25:43] Supreme Court opinions [2:25:44] Mr. Hamilton [2:25:46] Senator [2:25:48] I agree with the answers [2:25:49] of Mr. Albert [2:25:50] and Falvey [2:25:51] Sir [2:25:56] same answer [2:25:57] same answer [2:25:57] same answer [2:25:59] same answer [2:26:01] well [2:26:02] you know [2:26:04] justices of the Supreme Court [2:26:06] have described [2:26:07] what happened [2:26:10] on January 6th [2:26:11] as an attack [2:26:12] are you aware of that [2:26:14] Mr. Albert [2:26:14] I was not [2:26:17] Senator [2:26:17] well if [2:26:20] Justice Barrett [2:26:25] said that [2:26:28] quote [2:26:28] a mob of rioters [2:26:29] breached the Capitol [2:26:30] on January 6th [2:26:32] 2021 [2:26:32] and [2:26:36] United States District [2:26:37] Court [2:26:38] Judge Timothy Kelly [2:26:41] a Trump appointee [2:26:42] said [2:26:42] as the court [2:26:43] has said many times [2:26:44] the attack [2:26:44] on the Capitol [2:26:45] on January 6th [2:26:46] 2021 [2:26:47] was a perilous event [2:26:49] it was an attack [2:26:50] on people [2:26:50] including police officers [2:26:52] many of whom [2:26:53] were injured [2:26:53] would you agree [2:26:54] Senator [2:26:56] I would agree [2:26:57] that police officers [2:26:59] were attacked [2:27:00] that day [2:27:01] and there was [2:27:01] certainly violence [2:27:02] that day [2:27:02] and again [2:27:03] I would condemn [2:27:03] that violence [2:27:04] so [2:27:05] you would say [2:27:07] the Capitol [2:27:07] was attacked [2:27:08] again [2:27:09] Senator [2:27:10] I would look [2:27:11] to what Justice Barrett [2:27:12] said [2:27:12] and if we need [2:27:13] to characterize [2:27:14] what happened [2:27:15] broadly [2:27:16] to call it a breach [2:27:17] Is there anyone [2:27:18] on this panel [2:27:19] who is willing [2:27:19] to say [2:27:20] the Capitol [2:27:21] was attacked [2:27:22] on January 6th [2:27:24] 2021 [2:27:24] nobody [2:27:29] it's a sad day [2:27:32] thank you [2:27:33] Mr. Chair [2:27:34] Thank you [2:27:37] Senator Lee [2:27:38] Thank you [2:27:39] Mr. Chairman [2:27:39] Justice Sullivan [2:27:41] I'd like to start [2:27:41] with you [2:27:42] a moment ago [2:27:43] the suggestion [2:27:44] was made [2:27:44] that this was [2:27:45] some [2:27:45] this nomination [2:27:46] was somehow [2:27:46] a consolation [2:27:47] prize to you [2:27:48] now knowing [2:27:48] how these [2:27:49] processes [2:27:50] typically unfold [2:27:51] I wanted to give [2:27:52] you the chance [2:27:53] to respond [2:27:53] to that [2:27:54] because I suspect [2:27:54] this is not [2:27:55] something that arose [2:27:56] from the ether [2:27:57] spontaneously [2:27:58] two weeks ago [2:28:00] after the election [2:28:00] results [2:28:01] Senator [2:28:02] thank you [2:28:02] for the opportunity [2:28:03] to speak [2:28:04] to that [2:28:04] Senators [2:28:06] Cornyn and Cruz [2:28:07] have their [2:28:08] bipartisan [2:28:09] FJEC [2:28:10] the Federal [2:28:10] Judicial Evaluation [2:28:11] Committee [2:28:12] very talented [2:28:14] lawyers [2:28:15] who devote [2:28:15] a lot of [2:28:16] volunteered time [2:28:17] to helping [2:28:18] to vet [2:28:19] and make [2:28:19] recommendations [2:28:20] to our good [2:28:21] Senators [2:28:22] about names [2:28:23] to put forward [2:28:24] for judicial [2:28:24] nominations [2:28:25] I submitted [2:28:26] my paperwork [2:28:27] to the FJEC [2:28:29] the questionnaire [2:28:31] to the FJEC [2:28:32] in March of 2025 [2:28:34] about two months [2:28:35] after I took [2:28:36] my oath [2:28:37] as a justice [2:28:37] on the Texas [2:28:38] pre-court [2:28:39] about 18 months [2:28:39] before you were [2:28:40] nominated to this [2:28:40] position [2:28:41] that's right [2:28:41] before your election [2:28:42] that's right [2:28:43] I interviewed [2:28:44] with the members [2:28:46] of the FJEC [2:28:47] and as was mentioned [2:28:50] in some of the kind [2:28:51] introductory remarks [2:28:52] they thought [2:28:54] well of me [2:28:55] they also thought [2:28:56] well of my friend [2:28:57] now Judge Andrew Davis [2:28:58] on the Western District [2:28:59] of Texas [2:29:00] in Austin [2:29:00] but in the summer [2:29:02] of 2025 [2:29:03] as is mentioned [2:29:05] in my questionnaire [2:29:06] I had the honor [2:29:08] and the privilege [2:29:09] of coming up [2:29:10] and interviewing [2:29:10] in person [2:29:11] with Senator Cornyn [2:29:12] and with Chairman Cruz [2:29:13] and answering [2:29:16] their questions [2:29:16] about the call [2:29:18] to service [2:29:19] that I heard then [2:29:20] and continue [2:29:21] to hear now [2:29:22] and so the [2:29:24] as you pointed out [2:29:26] Senator [2:29:26] this was not [2:29:28] some flight [2:29:29] of fancy [2:29:29] or something [2:29:31] that just materialized [2:29:32] on a particular [2:29:33] night in November [2:29:34] with both of our [2:29:35] Texas senators [2:29:36] both serving [2:29:37] on this committee [2:29:38] being lawyers [2:29:38] I can only imagine [2:29:39] that you delved [2:29:40] into all sorts [2:29:40] of things [2:29:41] rule against perpetuities [2:29:42] the fertile octogenary [2:29:43] and corollary [2:29:43] difference between [2:29:45] the doctrine [2:29:45] of worthier title [2:29:46] and the rule [2:29:47] in Shelley's case [2:29:47] but we'll leave that [2:29:48] for a different day [2:29:49] I do want to get back [2:29:50] to a conversation [2:29:52] you had with a couple [2:29:53] of my colleagues [2:29:53] a few minutes ago [2:29:54] about original public meaning [2:29:56] I appreciate your remarks [2:29:57] on that [2:29:57] my own view [2:29:59] my own view [2:29:59] my own view is that [2:30:00] original public meaning [2:30:01] ascertaining the original [2:30:01] public meaning [2:30:02] either as to a provision [2:30:03] of a statute [2:30:04] or a provision [2:30:04] of the constitution [2:30:05] looking to how those words [2:30:07] were commonly understood [2:30:08] by the public [2:30:09] at the time of their adoption [2:30:10] either into statute [2:30:11] or into the constitution [2:30:13] is not just a good [2:30:15] interpretive philosophy [2:30:17] it's also a good [2:30:19] interpretive philosophy [2:30:20] that is itself grounded [2:30:21] in the letter [2:30:22] and spirit [2:30:23] of article 3 [2:30:24] article 3 section 1 [2:30:25] makes clear that the judicial power [2:30:27] of the United States [2:30:28] is vested in the supreme court [2:30:29] and in such inferior courts [2:30:31] as congress may [2:30:32] from time to time [2:30:33] ordain and establish [2:30:34] article 3 section 2 [2:30:36] makes clear that [2:30:37] the judicial power [2:30:38] encompasses the power [2:30:39] to decide cases [2:30:41] and controversies [2:30:42] arising under federal law [2:30:43] in the U.S. constitution [2:30:44] tell me if you agree [2:30:46] with my assessment [2:30:47] that this is itself [2:30:48] rooted in [2:30:48] and most consistent [2:30:51] with article 3 [2:30:54] and how it protects [2:30:55] the separation [2:30:55] of powers [2:30:56] the fundamental [2:30:57] horizontal constraint [2:30:59] in the constitution [2:30:59] I think that that's [2:31:01] very well said [2:31:02] senator [2:31:02] the phrase [2:31:06] judicial power [2:31:07] alone [2:31:07] might not [2:31:09] if you just saw [2:31:10] those two words [2:31:11] and knew nothing [2:31:12] about how [2:31:14] the people who ratified [2:31:15] the constitution [2:31:16] the people themselves [2:31:17] understood it [2:31:18] you might not be able [2:31:19] to take away [2:31:20] the notions of [2:31:21] stare decisis [2:31:22] that we have [2:31:23] or any of the ways [2:31:27] that the Anglo legal [2:31:30] tradition [2:31:30] the common law [2:31:31] tradition [2:31:31] came over [2:31:33] to this country [2:31:34] but the people [2:31:36] wrote it down [2:31:37] at that time [2:31:37] for a reason [2:31:38] and so [2:31:40] and then [2:31:41] you know [2:31:42] as a nominee [2:31:43] to be a federal [2:31:44] district judge [2:31:45] with many illustrious [2:31:47] predecessors [2:31:47] when as you pointed out [2:31:49] the congress did [2:31:50] from time to time [2:31:50] ordain and establish [2:31:51] those district courts [2:31:53] but we [2:31:54] any of [2:31:55] all of us [2:31:56] if we are so fortunate [2:31:57] as to be confirmed [2:31:58] we'll stand on the [2:31:59] shoulders of giants [2:32:00] who have [2:32:02] tried to adhere [2:32:03] to what those words [2:32:04] meant [2:32:05] to the people [2:32:05] when they ratified them [2:32:06] now you also got [2:32:09] some pushback [2:32:10] on the textualism [2:32:11] and original front [2:32:12] based as I understood [2:32:14] it [2:32:15] on a suggestion [2:32:16] that somehow [2:32:16] this would compel you [2:32:18] to elevate [2:32:20] outdated norms [2:32:21] and understandings [2:32:23] above and beyond [2:32:25] proper judicial [2:32:26] considerations [2:32:26] that is not how [2:32:27] I understood it [2:32:28] nor did I understand [2:32:29] you to be saying [2:32:29] that you would [2:32:30] disregard binding [2:32:31] precedent [2:32:32] it is actually [2:32:34] a good case study [2:32:35] in this [2:32:36] because you're [2:32:36] currently [2:32:36] we normally [2:32:37] don't have people [2:32:38] here whom we call [2:32:39] justice [2:32:39] who are seeking [2:32:40] to become judge [2:32:41] rather than justice [2:32:42] you now sit [2:32:43] on a court [2:32:44] of last resort [2:32:45] is that correct [2:32:46] that's correct [2:32:47] the court [2:32:48] of last resort [2:32:48] being the supreme [2:32:49] court of the state [2:32:50] of Texas [2:32:50] different principles [2:32:53] apply when you [2:32:54] serve on a court [2:32:55] of last resort [2:32:56] either a state [2:32:57] supreme court [2:32:57] as is [2:32:58] your current job [2:33:00] or on the [2:33:01] US supreme court [2:33:02] than they do [2:33:03] when serving [2:33:04] on a federal trial [2:33:05] court or another [2:33:06] inferior court [2:33:07] is that correct [2:33:07] that's exactly [2:33:08] right [2:33:08] and so that [2:33:10] really explains [2:33:11] for the difference [2:33:12] here and accounts [2:33:13] for the fact [2:33:13] that you're not [2:33:14] saying that [2:33:15] textualism [2:33:16] and originalism [2:33:16] allow you to [2:33:17] escape a binding [2:33:18] precedent [2:33:18] either binding [2:33:19] circuit precedent [2:33:20] or binding [2:33:21] supreme court [2:33:22] precedent [2:33:22] would you agree [2:33:23] with that [2:33:23] I would have [2:33:23] to agree [2:33:24] with that [2:33:24] and you're [2:33:26] comfortable [2:33:26] taking off [2:33:27] your hat [2:33:27] as a justice [2:33:28] on a court [2:33:29] of last resort [2:33:30] to becoming [2:33:31] a federal district [2:33:32] judge [2:33:32] it would be [2:33:33] my honor [2:33:33] if confirmed [2:33:34] sir [2:33:34] thank you [2:33:35] Mr. Falvey [2:33:37] tell me [2:33:38] you know [2:33:38] Madison [2:33:39] in federalist [2:33:40] 45 [2:33:40] described the [2:33:41] powers [2:33:41] of the states [2:33:42] as numerous [2:33:43] and indefinite [2:33:44] those reserved [2:33:45] to congress [2:33:45] as few [2:33:46] and defined [2:33:47] what can you [2:33:49] tell me [2:33:49] about what [2:33:49] remains of that [2:33:50] you know [2:33:51] in a sense [2:33:52] one could argue [2:33:52] with [2:33:54] I believe [2:33:55] it was [2:33:55] Justice Stone's [2:33:56] observation [2:33:57] about the [2:33:57] 10th amendment [2:33:58] that it's just [2:33:59] a truism [2:33:59] that acknowledges [2:34:01] all that is [2:34:02] not surrendered [2:34:03] has been [2:34:03] retained [2:34:04] what remains [2:34:06] at its core [2:34:07] in the few [2:34:08] and defined [2:34:09] versus numerous [2:34:09] and indefinite [2:34:10] distinction [2:34:11] Senator [2:34:15] I think [2:34:15] in short [2:34:16] the constitution [2:34:16] remains [2:34:17] the constitution [2:34:18] continues to [2:34:19] vest legislative [2:34:20] power in this [2:34:21] body [2:34:21] but only the [2:34:22] enumerated powers [2:34:22] laid out [2:34:23] in article one [2:34:24] nothing more [2:34:25] nothing less [2:34:26] and the 10th [2:34:27] amendment [2:34:27] continues to [2:34:28] make clear [2:34:29] to reinforce [2:34:30] that anything [2:34:31] not vested [2:34:32] in this body [2:34:33] remains with [2:34:33] the states [2:34:34] I do want [2:34:36] to before [2:34:37] my time expires [2:34:38] I want to [2:34:38] compliment [2:34:38] both you [2:34:39] and Justice [2:34:40] Sullivan [2:34:40] having survived [2:34:41] a clerkship [2:34:42] on the D.C. [2:34:43] Circuit [2:34:43] with Judge [2:34:44] Griffith [2:34:44] the known [2:34:45] tyrant [2:34:45] you seem [2:34:47] remarkably [2:34:47] well adjusted [2:34:48] the reason [2:34:49] I can say [2:34:49] that [2:34:49] the reason [2:34:50] it's funny [2:34:50] is that [2:34:50] Tom Griffith [2:34:51] is like [2:34:51] the nicest [2:34:52] guy in the [2:34:52] world [2:34:52] and I would [2:34:53] imagine [2:34:53] was a [2:34:54] fantastic [2:34:54] mentor [2:34:55] I would [2:34:56] imagine [2:34:56] that you'd [2:34:56] bring that [2:34:57] same [2:34:57] experience [2:34:59] the same [2:35:00] pattern [2:35:00] of mentorship [2:35:01] that he [2:35:01] provided [2:35:02] to you [2:35:02] to your [2:35:03] law clerks [2:35:03] absolutely [2:35:05] Senator [2:35:05] Judge [2:35:06] Griffith [2:35:06] was a [2:35:07] tremendous [2:35:07] mentor [2:35:08] and if [2:35:09] I'm [2:35:09] confirmed [2:35:10] would be [2:35:10] a model [2:35:11] for me [2:35:11] in how [2:35:11] he approached [2:35:12] his job [2:35:12] and the [2:35:13] seriousness [2:35:13] with which [2:35:15] he took [2:35:15] his obligations [2:35:16] as a judge [2:35:17] and Senator [2:35:18] I really [2:35:19] appreciate [2:35:19] your kind [2:35:19] words [2:35:20] about Judge [2:35:20] Griffith [2:35:21] six of my [2:35:23] past and [2:35:23] present law [2:35:24] clerks [2:35:24] are here [2:35:24] on the [2:35:26] Texas Supreme [2:35:27] Court [2:35:27] and Judge [2:35:28] Griffith [2:35:29] for us [2:35:29] as law [2:35:30] clerks [2:35:30] credentialed [2:35:31] us [2:35:31] trained us [2:35:32] and then [2:35:32] fought for [2:35:33] us [2:35:33] and I know [2:35:34] that speaking [2:35:34] for myself [2:35:35] I wouldn't [2:35:36] be appearing [2:35:36] before this [2:35:37] esteemed [2:35:37] committee [2:35:37] today without [2:35:38] Judge [2:35:38] Griffith [2:35:39] I'm so [2:35:39] grateful [2:35:39] he was [2:35:40] able to [2:35:40] be here [2:35:40] before [2:35:41] thank you [2:35:42] very much [2:35:42] Mr. Chairman [2:35:43] I see my [2:35:43] time's [2:35:44] expired [2:35:44] thank you [2:35:45] Senator [2:35:46] Booker [2:35:46] thank you [2:35:50] very much [2:35:50] Mr. Chairman [2:35:51] first of all [2:35:52] to the nominees [2:35:52] congratulations [2:35:53] on your [2:35:53] nominations [2:35:54] a lot of [2:35:55] my sentiments [2:35:55] expressed today [2:35:56] are not [2:35:56] directed [2:35:57] necessarily [2:35:57] at you [2:35:58] all [2:35:58] but at [2:35:59] the process [2:35:59] that the [2:36:00] Judiciary [2:36:00] Committee [2:36:00] is going [2:36:01] through [2:36:01] but I [2:36:02] just really [2:36:03] want to [2:36:04] ask [2:36:04] and maybe [2:36:05] I can [2:36:05] start [2:36:06] with [2:36:06] Mr. [2:36:09] Obard [2:36:11] I'm pronouncing [2:36:11] it right [2:36:11] sir [2:36:12] Obard [2:36:13] forgive me [2:36:14] sir [2:36:14] and you're [2:36:15] not from [2:36:15] Hendersonville [2:36:16] are you [2:36:16] I'm not [2:36:17] Senator [2:36:17] that's where [2:36:18] my daddy's [2:36:18] from so I [2:36:19] love your [2:36:19] state [2:36:19] but you [2:36:22] know article [2:36:22] 2 section [2:36:23] 2 clause [2:36:24] 2 of the [2:36:25] constitution [2:36:26] I imagine [2:36:27] correct [2:36:27] I need to [2:36:29] be refreshed [2:36:30] specifically [2:36:31] but [2:36:31] I did not [2:36:33] go to a [2:36:33] real law [2:36:34] school like [2:36:35] our chairman [2:36:35] Ted Cruz [2:36:36] did so [2:36:37] I had to [2:36:38] refresh my [2:36:39] recollection [2:36:39] too [2:36:40] but it [2:36:40] expressly [2:36:40] names the [2:36:41] Supreme Court [2:36:41] justices [2:36:42] lower federal [2:36:43] court justices [2:36:44] are covered [2:36:44] by the [2:36:45] clauses [2:36:45] provisions [2:36:46] that [2:36:46] nominating [2:36:47] federal [2:36:47] judges [2:36:47] should have [2:36:48] the [2:36:48] power [2:36:49] to give [2:36:49] consent [2:36:50] the advice [2:36:51] and consent [2:36:52] of the [2:36:52] of the [2:36:52] Senate [2:36:53] that's what [2:36:53] we're [2:36:53] doing here [2:36:54] today [2:36:54] and [2:36:55] and so [2:36:56] I'm [2:36:57] curious [2:36:57] we've [2:36:59] had back [2:37:00] to bat [2:37:00] nominations [2:37:01] hearings [2:37:01] without the [2:37:03] consent of [2:37:03] the minority [2:37:04] we're rushing [2:37:04] these things [2:37:05] through [2:37:05] we have [2:37:05] seven [2:37:06] judicial [2:37:06] nominees [2:37:06] in today's [2:37:07] hearings [2:37:07] this is [2:37:09] never [2:37:09] how [2:37:09] I've [2:37:10] been here [2:37:10] 13 [2:37:10] years [2:37:10] never [2:37:11] how [2:37:11] we've [2:37:11] done [2:37:11] it [2:37:12] in [2:37:13] the [2:37:13] body [2:37:13] of [2:37:14] work [2:37:14] of [2:37:14] all [2:37:14] the [2:37:14] people [2:37:14] before [2:37:15] us [2:37:15] do [2:37:15] you [2:37:15] think [2:37:16] two [2:37:16] weeks [2:37:16] is [2:37:17] enough [2:37:17] time [2:37:17] to [2:37:17] give [2:37:18] advice [2:37:19] and [2:37:19] consent [2:37:19] as [2:37:19] the [2:37:20] Constitution [2:37:20] lays out [2:37:22] on the [2:37:23] body of [2:37:24] your record [2:37:24] the reading [2:37:25] of your [2:37:25] in other [2:37:26] words [2:37:26] two weeks [2:37:26] for [2:37:27] a [2:37:27] lifetime [2:37:27] appointment [2:37:28] in your [2:37:29] general [2:37:29] observations [2:37:31] is that [2:37:31] enough [2:37:31] time [2:37:32] to [2:37:32] evaluate [2:37:32] a [2:37:32] judge [2:37:33] Senator [2:37:34] I [2:37:34] don't [2:37:35] want [2:37:36] to [2:37:36] suggest [2:37:38] committee [2:37:38] on [2:37:39] how [2:37:39] the [2:37:39] committee [2:37:40] should [2:37:40] best [2:37:40] go [2:37:40] about [2:37:41] its [2:37:41] job [2:37:41] Mr. [2:37:42] Lambert [2:37:42] is that [2:37:42] what [2:37:43] you [2:37:43] would [2:37:43] say [2:37:43] to [2:37:43] yes [2:37:44] senator [2:37:45] I [2:37:45] think [2:37:45] that [2:37:45] belongs [2:37:45] to [2:37:45] the [2:37:46] Senate [2:37:46] how [2:37:46] it [2:37:46] exercises [2:37:47] its [2:37:47] advice [2:37:47] and [2:37:48] consent [2:37:48] prerogative [2:37:48] I [2:37:49] appreciate [2:37:50] that [2:37:51] a lot [2:37:52] Mr. [2:37:52] Myers [2:37:53] yes [2:37:54] senator [2:37:55] I do [2:37:55] believe [2:37:55] that [2:37:55] that [2:37:56] would [2:37:56] belong [2:37:56] to [2:37:56] the [2:37:57] Senate [2:37:57] senator [2:37:58] I [2:37:58] would [2:37:58] say [2:37:59] with [2:37:59] regard [2:37:59] to [2:38:00] my [2:38:01] ability [2:38:01] to [2:38:01] serve [2:38:02] I [2:38:02] have [2:38:02] a [2:38:02] lifetime [2:38:03] of [2:38:03] federal [2:38:03] service [2:38:09] would [2:38:10] you [2:38:10] say [2:38:10] for [2:38:10] law [2:38:11] journals [2:38:11] I [2:38:12] don't [2:38:12] know [2:38:12] that [2:38:12] I've [2:38:13] written [2:38:13] any [2:38:13] okay [2:38:13] how [2:38:14] many [2:38:14] opinions [2:38:14] have [2:38:15] you [2:38:15] rendered [2:38:15] in [2:38:16] your [2:38:16] time [2:38:16] or [2:38:17] amicus [2:38:17] briefs [2:38:18] have [2:38:18] you [2:38:18] written [2:38:18] your [2:38:19] body [2:38:19] of [2:38:19] written [2:38:20] work [2:38:20] can [2:38:21] you [2:38:21] give [2:38:21] me [2:38:21] some [2:38:21] estimation [2:38:22] of [2:38:22] what [2:38:22] that [2:38:22] might [2:38:22] include [2:38:23] senator [2:38:24] as a [2:38:24] sitting [2:38:25] United [2:38:25] States [2:38:25] magistrate [2:38:26] judge [2:38:26] I [2:38:26] have [2:38:26] written [2:38:27] hundreds [2:38:29] of [2:38:29] orders [2:38:29] if [2:38:31] you [2:38:31] were [2:38:31] in [2:38:31] my [2:38:31] position [2:38:32] would [2:38:32] you [2:38:32] think [2:38:32] that [2:38:33] it [2:38:33] would [2:38:33] be [2:38:33] a [2:38:41] has [2:38:41] been [2:38:42] reviewed [2:38:42] yes [2:38:42] sir [2:38:42] so [2:38:43] let's [2:38:43] multiply [2:38:43] that [2:38:43] by [2:38:44] seven [2:38:44] today [2:38:45] the [2:38:45] body [2:38:46] of [2:38:46] work [2:38:46] of [2:38:46] everybody [2:38:46] here [2:38:47] what [2:38:48] I'm [2:38:49] seeing [2:38:49] here [2:38:50] is [2:38:50] that [2:38:51] I've [2:38:51] been [2:38:51] here [2:38:51] 13 [2:38:52] years [2:38:52] and [2:38:52] this [2:38:52] is [2:38:52] not [2:38:53] one [2:38:54] party [2:38:54] or [2:38:54] another [2:38:54] but [2:38:55] the [2:38:56] norms [2:38:56] of [2:38:56] this [2:38:56] institution [2:38:57] continue [2:38:57] to be [2:38:58] eroded [2:38:58] as [2:38:59] different [2:38:59] people [2:38:59] are [2:38:59] seeking [2:39:00] some [2:39:00] kind [2:39:00] of [2:39:00] advantage [2:39:01] and [2:39:02] here [2:39:02] we [2:39:02] have [2:39:02] people [2:39:03] here [2:39:03] from [2:39:03] North [2:39:04] Carolina [2:39:05] and [2:39:05] South [2:39:06] Carolina [2:39:07] a number [2:39:07] of people [2:39:07] have come [2:39:08] here [2:39:08] from [2:39:08] Texas [2:39:08] states [2:39:09] in [2:39:09] which [2:39:09] the [2:39:10] people [2:39:10] of [2:39:10] those [2:39:11] states [2:39:11] have [2:39:11] put [2:39:11] Democrats [2:39:12] into [2:39:12] position [2:39:13] you see [2:39:14] this [2:39:14] was [2:39:15] not [2:39:15] planned [2:39:15] this [2:39:16] is [2:39:16] a [2:39:16] post [2:39:17] election [2:39:17] race [2:39:18] to get [2:39:18] people [2:39:19] on the [2:39:19] bench [2:39:20] in [2:39:20] states [2:39:20] without [2:39:21] having [2:39:21] to go [2:39:22] through [2:39:22] a process [2:39:23] that we've [2:39:24] had [2:39:24] for years [2:39:25] which is [2:39:25] getting [2:39:26] both [2:39:27] senators [2:39:27] from those [2:39:28] states [2:39:28] to agree [2:39:29] in this [2:39:30] case [2:39:30] to me [2:39:30] it [2:39:30] sounds [2:39:30] like a [2:39:31] profound [2:39:31] opportunity [2:39:31] for [2:39:32] new [2:39:33] senators [2:39:33] from [2:39:33] Texas [2:39:34] new [2:39:34] senators [2:39:34] from [2:39:35] South [2:39:35] Carolina [2:39:35] new [2:39:35] senators [2:39:36] from [2:39:36] North [2:39:36] Carolina [2:39:36] to work [2:39:37] together [2:39:37] across [2:39:38] the aisle [2:39:38] like we've [2:39:39] seen [2:39:39] many states [2:39:40] do [2:39:40] to find [2:39:40] people [2:39:41] to recommend [2:39:42] many of [2:39:42] you probably [2:39:42] would have [2:39:43] come through [2:39:43] that process [2:39:44] fine [2:39:45] but what we're [2:39:46] having right [2:39:46] now is [2:39:47] just another [2:39:48] point in the [2:39:49] United States [2:39:49] Senate [2:39:49] where we're [2:39:50] breaking it [2:39:50] and once it's [2:39:52] broken [2:39:52] it can't be [2:39:53] fixed [2:39:53] and I'm already [2:39:54] hearing from [2:39:55] people that [2:39:56] saying if [2:39:56] Republicans are [2:39:57] willing to do [2:39:57] this [2:39:58] well God bless [2:39:58] America [2:39:59] when we have [2:39:59] the majority [2:40:00] we're going to [2:40:01] do to them [2:40:01] the same kind [2:40:02] of spirit [2:40:02] that we're [2:40:03] seeing done [2:40:03] right now [2:40:04] which is [2:40:05] potentially [2:40:06] going to [2:40:06] stop [2:40:06] good judges [2:40:07] from getting [2:40:07] on the [2:40:07] bench [2:40:08] so this [2:40:10] to me [2:40:10] is wrong [2:40:11] there's no [2:40:13] way and I [2:40:13] have a really [2:40:14] good staff [2:40:15] for in the [2:40:17] short days [2:40:17] that we have [2:40:18] to evaluate [2:40:19] and do our [2:40:20] constitutional [2:40:21] duty [2:40:22] there is just [2:40:24] no way [2:40:25] that we will [2:40:26] be able to [2:40:27] achieve that [2:40:28] in this short [2:40:28] period of time [2:40:29] and yet again [2:40:31] I am watching [2:40:33] the norms [2:40:35] of the Senate [2:40:35] and the [2:40:37] constitutional [2:40:38] dictates [2:40:38] be undermined [2:40:41] for petty [2:40:42] political [2:40:43] advantage [2:40:43] and more [2:40:46] and more [2:40:46] on both [2:40:47] sides [2:40:47] we can [2:40:48] point fingers [2:40:48] this institution [2:40:50] this august [2:40:52] committee [2:40:53] is eroding [2:40:56] its ability [2:40:56] to do [2:40:57] what I think [2:40:58] is in the [2:40:58] best interest [2:40:58] of the people [2:40:59] who elected [2:41:00] us to be [2:41:00] here [2:41:01] and so [2:41:03] we're going [2:41:03] to literally [2:41:04] hear [2:41:04] in a matter [2:41:05] of a month [2:41:06] or two [2:41:06] after January [2:41:08] my colleagues [2:41:09] probably in [2:41:09] good faith [2:41:10] saying [2:41:10] you guys [2:41:11] can't do [2:41:12] this [2:41:12] you guys [2:41:13] shouldn't [2:41:13] do this [2:41:14] you're breaking [2:41:14] the norms [2:41:15] of the Senate [2:41:15] and I'm going [2:41:17] to hear people [2:41:17] to the left [2:41:18] of me [2:41:18] and the right [2:41:18] of me [2:41:18] saying [2:41:19] you did [2:41:20] it to us [2:41:21] it is wrong [2:41:23] that you all [2:41:24] are being rushed [2:41:24] through this process [2:41:25] any objective [2:41:27] person [2:41:28] would say [2:41:29] that this is a [2:41:31] response [2:41:31] to an election [2:41:32] where people [2:41:34] in this country [2:41:35] have spoken [2:41:36] but this is [2:41:38] clearly an attempt [2:41:39] to subvert [2:41:40] the will [2:41:40] of the people [2:41:41] to race people [2:41:42] onto the bench [2:41:43] against the norms [2:41:45] that have been [2:41:45] established [2:41:46] on this committee [2:41:47] for so many months [2:41:49] many of you [2:41:50] are probably [2:41:51] eminently [2:41:52] qualified [2:41:53] qualified [2:41:53] for the positions [2:41:53] you've dedicated [2:41:56] your entire lives [2:41:57] to public service [2:41:58] but the shadow [2:41:59] that this process [2:42:00] is putting over [2:42:01] your appointment [2:42:02] is going to make [2:42:03] people question [2:42:04] you for a long time [2:42:06] we are weakening [2:42:08] the judiciary [2:42:09] as a result [2:42:10] of the politics [2:42:11] of an institution [2:42:13] that our founders [2:42:15] said [2:42:15] should be [2:42:16] standing against [2:42:18] the popular [2:42:19] swings of our time [2:42:21] you all know [2:42:23] our founders said [2:42:23] that the senate [2:42:24] should be [2:42:25] the cooling dish [2:42:26] in which sound [2:42:28] objective opinions [2:42:29] are made [2:42:29] South Carolina [2:42:31] Texas [2:42:32] North Carolina [2:42:35] has really good senators [2:42:37] on both sides [2:42:38] of the aisle [2:42:38] that are going to be [2:42:39] representing them [2:42:39] in the next congress [2:42:40] they would have come up [2:42:42] with really good decisions [2:42:43] on who their judges [2:42:44] should be [2:42:45] that would have [2:42:46] affirmed [2:42:47] the integrity [2:42:48] of the judiciary [2:42:49] that would have [2:42:50] affirmed [2:42:51] the spirit [2:42:52] of our democracy [2:42:53] that would have [2:42:55] helped us [2:42:55] to restore faith [2:42:57] in our institutions [2:42:58] but everybody [2:43:00] in this room knows [2:43:01] we are at a nadir [2:43:03] a low point [2:43:04] in America [2:43:05] for Americans [2:43:06] trusting [2:43:07] their institutions [2:43:08] believing [2:43:09] in the rule of law [2:43:11] believing that judges [2:43:13] are above politics [2:43:14] this is another sad day [2:43:18] another cynical effort [2:43:21] another pathetic attempt [2:43:24] where people are looking [2:43:26] at short-term [2:43:26] political gain [2:43:27] at the cost [2:43:29] of the enduring strength [2:43:30] of our institutions [2:43:31] I recommend one book [2:43:33] for everybody here to read [2:43:35] how democracies die [2:43:37] these are great authors [2:43:40] that looked [2:43:41] at countries all around [2:43:43] that have [2:43:43] a constitutional republic [2:43:45] just like ours [2:43:46] but one of the signs [2:43:47] of the death [2:43:48] of their democracies [2:43:49] was when the spirit [2:43:51] when the spirit [2:43:53] of the intent [2:43:55] of founders [2:43:56] is not followed [2:43:57] where one side [2:43:58] tries to get political [2:43:59] advantage of the others [2:44:00] and bends the rules [2:44:02] breaks the spirit [2:44:04] violates the trust [2:44:06] and this is not [2:44:07] a left or right thing [2:44:08] because I've watched [2:44:09] both parties do this [2:44:11] in the 13 years [2:44:12] that I've been here [2:44:13] I'm just simply saying [2:44:14] that this is yet another [2:44:16] step at a time [2:44:18] where we could have paused [2:44:19] and done this a right way [2:44:21] and I know confidently [2:44:23] because I know senators [2:44:25] from both of the [2:44:26] all of these states [2:44:27] I've watched them [2:44:28] including our chairman [2:44:29] find bipartisan compromises [2:44:31] and get things done [2:44:32] the future judges [2:44:35] from the great state [2:44:37] of Texas [2:44:37] North Carolina [2:44:39] South Carolina [2:44:40] all of them [2:44:42] should have gone [2:44:42] through a bipartisan process [2:44:44] as opposed to what [2:44:46] clearly looks [2:44:47] to everybody [2:44:47] who's losing trust [2:44:48] in this institution [2:44:49] and in our judiciary [2:44:50] clearly looks [2:44:51] like yet another time [2:44:53] where somebody [2:44:54] is trying to get [2:44:55] political advantage [2:44:56] and race something through [2:44:58] where my staff [2:44:59] is telling me [2:45:00] with all the body [2:45:01] of work that you're doing [2:45:02] it doesn't give us [2:45:03] the opportunities [2:45:04] to do our constitutionally [2:45:06] dictated job [2:45:09] it's disappointing to me [2:45:11] I've watched time [2:45:12] and time again [2:45:13] the erosion of this institution [2:45:14] and the erosion [2:45:15] of this committee [2:45:16] and this is clearly [2:45:17] one of them [2:45:17] God bless each [2:45:18] and every one of you [2:45:19] and your families [2:45:20] that are behind you [2:45:21] thank you for your years [2:45:22] and careers of service [2:45:23] I'm sorry that you're [2:45:25] going to be appointed [2:45:25] to the bench [2:45:26] under the cloud [2:45:27] that's been created [2:45:28] by this committee [2:45:29] you know there's an old adage [2:45:33] that hypocrisy [2:45:34] is the tribute [2:45:35] that vice plays to virtue [2:45:38] this committee has just [2:45:41] been treated [2:45:42] with a passionate lecture [2:45:46] from senator booker [2:45:47] that just like captain [2:45:52] renault and casablanca [2:45:53] he is shocked [2:45:54] shocked to find gambling [2:45:56] in this institution [2:45:57] he cannot believe [2:46:01] that a republican senate [2:46:03] would be confirming [2:46:04] judges nominated [2:46:06] by a republican president [2:46:07] in the lame duck [2:46:10] after an election [2:46:11] you know [2:46:15] you don't need [2:46:17] a particularly long memory [2:46:19] to recognize the hypocrisy [2:46:23] in what senator booker said [2:46:24] just two years ago [2:46:26] in 2024 [2:46:28] there was a democrat [2:46:31] by the name of [2:46:32] joseph robinette biden [2:46:33] who was in the white house [2:46:34] just two years ago [2:46:36] in 2024 [2:46:37] where there was an election [2:46:38] in which the american people [2:46:40] overwhelmingly [2:46:41] voted to throw the democrats [2:46:45] out of the white house [2:46:48] the house and the senate [2:46:49] and they elected [2:46:51] a republican president [2:46:52] they elected [2:46:52] a republican senate [2:46:53] they elected [2:46:54] a republican house [2:46:54] and the democrat party [2:46:57] was resoundingly repudiated [2:46:59] just two years ago [2:47:00] and what did the same [2:47:02] senate democrats [2:47:03] who just gave us [2:47:04] sanctimonious speeches [2:47:05] do [2:47:05] they rammed through [2:47:07] 22 federal judges [2:47:09] in november and december [2:47:11] before leaving [2:47:12] by the way [2:47:16] my friend from new jersey [2:47:19] also said [2:47:20] this is not a left [2:47:21] or right thing [2:47:22] we need to stand up [2:47:23] senator booker [2:47:26] and every other democrat [2:47:28] on this committee [2:47:29] i believe [2:47:30] voted for all 22 [2:47:32] of those judges [2:47:37] that is called [2:47:38] the operation [2:47:39] of democracy [2:47:41] and that is called [2:47:41] our constitutional system [2:47:43] in which presidents [2:47:45] appoint [2:47:45] or nominate judges [2:47:47] and the senate [2:47:48] provides advice [2:47:49] and consent [2:47:52] it is true [2:47:53] on january 3rd [2:47:55] the democrats [2:47:55] will take a majority [2:47:56] again [2:47:58] i wish that it [2:47:59] were otherwise [2:48:02] but until january 3rd [2:48:03] the senators [2:48:04] who are currently elected [2:48:05] still have a job to do [2:48:07] and we are going to do [2:48:08] our job [2:48:10] i'd also like to [2:48:11] enter into the record [2:48:12] a letter supporting [2:48:13] justice sullivan's [2:48:14] nomination from 48 [2:48:15] members of the texas bar [2:48:17] including eight [2:48:18] state representatives [2:48:19] they all praised [2:48:21] justice sullivan [2:48:22] and stated quote [2:48:23] those of us who practice [2:48:25] with or against him [2:48:26] know him as a lawyer [2:48:28] whose word could be relied on [2:48:29] he was always prepared [2:48:31] candid about the strengths [2:48:33] and weaknesses of his position [2:48:34] and unfailingly courteous [2:48:37] to opposing counsel [2:48:38] he gave straight answers [2:48:40] and he gave them promptly [2:48:42] lawyers on the other side [2:48:44] of the matter trusted him [2:48:45] and that trust [2:48:46] was never misplaced [2:48:47] without objection [2:48:49] i will enter this letter [2:48:50] into the record [2:48:51] at this point [2:48:55] it appears there are [2:48:55] no other senators [2:48:56] uh... here to ask questions [2:48:58] so i want to thank [2:49:00] each of the nominees [2:49:01] for your testimony today [2:49:02] written questions [2:49:04] for the record [2:49:04] may be submitted [2:49:05] until wednesday [2:49:06] november 25th [2:49:08] at 5 p.m. [2:49:09] and with that [2:49:10] the hearing is adjourned [2:49:11] is adjourned [2:49:14] for the

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →