About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Ron Johnson, Dems Spar During Senate Budget Committee Hearing On Social Security from Forbes Breaking News, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 14,092 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"The title of this hearing is Social Security, the Reality, a Legal Ponzi Scheme. I realize this term offends most people who have had FICA taxes extracted from their paychecks for decades, but it is an accurate description of how grossly Social Security has been mismanaged over the decades. The..."
[0:00] The title of this hearing is Social Security, the Reality, a Legal Ponzi Scheme.
[0:07] I realize this term offends most people who have had FICA taxes extracted from their paychecks
[0:13] for decades, but it is an accurate description of how grossly Social Security has been mismanaged
[0:20] over the decades.
[0:22] The Securities and Exchange Commission defines a Ponzi scheme as, quote, an investment fraud
[0:27] that pays existing investors with funds collected from new investors.
[0:33] Delete the word fraud because Social Security is legally sanctioned, and that's exactly
[0:38] what Social Security does.
[0:41] Instead of being angry over the use of a term that accurately describes the deception of
[0:46] Social Security, people should be incensed over the fact that they've been scammed.
[0:53] People often say, don't touch Social Security, that's my money.
[0:57] Actually, it's not.
[0:58] Your money was spent to pay current beneficiaries or fund other government programs as soon
[1:04] as it was collected from your paycheck.
[1:06] Your future benefits will be paid with the money collected from your sons and daughters
[1:10] working at that time, plus money borrowed from the public, now that Social Security is running
[1:16] deficits.
[1:17] Unfortunately, politicians from both parties, either from their own ignorance or willful
[1:23] deception, have misled the American public for decades by promoting the fiction that their
[1:28] entire payroll deduction for Social Security was being invested in a real asset, oftentimes using
[1:35] the term lockbox to earn compound interest yielding an adequate return or an amount for retirement.
[1:43] Nothing could be further from the truth.
[1:45] Social Security has always paid benefits from the revenue it receives from the payroll tax.
[1:51] It has never even invested the surplus proceeds in an asset that has real value to the federal government.
[1:57] The surplus have always been spent and an accounting entry made in the form of a special issue U.S.
[2:05] government bond.
[2:07] Here's a picture of the Social Security Trust Fund that holds those bonds.
[2:10] It's a four-drawer file in Parkersburg, West Virginia.
[2:14] There you go.
[2:14] There is your Social Security Trust Fund.
[2:17] To an outside investor, those bonds would have value.
[2:21] To the U.S.
[2:21] government, they are nothing more than a bookkeeping entry.
[2:24] The real tragedy is that Social Security could be more than solvent had it actually been run
[2:30] as a high-integrity savings and investment retirement plan.
[2:34] In 1983, Ronald Reagan and Tip O'Neill concluded their widely celebrated bipartisan Social Security
[2:40] air-quote fix primarily by raising taxes.
[2:45] Had they admitted that Social Security was a legal Ponzi scheme, decided to end the deception
[2:50] and begin investing the annual surpluses in a Dow Jones Index Fund, that trust fund would
[2:56] now be holding stock access worth approximately $14.5 trillion.
[3:03] Here's a chart in terms of how those assets would have grown.
[3:06] And by the way, I hope all of you read the chairman's memo.
[3:10] It's got the spreadsheet proving that case.
[3:13] And all the assumptions are also on the committee's website.
[3:19] Because benefits already exceed payroll taxes collected, the trust fund bonds are being redeemed
[3:24] to cover the shortfall.
[3:26] The Treasury then asked to borrow an equivalent amount from the public to pay benefits.
[3:31] When the trust fund is depleted, the law states' benefits will be reduced to match the payroll
[3:36] tax receipts.
[3:38] I can't imagine any Congress or President allowing that to happen.
[3:43] But the threat is being used to propose eliminating the FICA tax income cap.
[3:50] Doing so would be economically harmful and grossly unfair, as these charts demonstrate.
[3:56] Now, I just want to go through these.
[3:57] This is, it's imperfect, but this is a pretty good indication of who pays the FICA tax and
[4:03] what kind of benefits.
[4:04] You notice, in terms of Social Security, the top 10% pay approximately 24% of the payroll
[4:10] tax revenue.
[4:12] They receive about 11% of the benefit from Social Security.
[4:17] Now, Medicare, it's a much greater mix-match.
[4:20] Let's put this up.
[4:21] Because there is no cap on the, what ends up being a 3.8% Medicare tax, the top 10% pay
[4:28] 41% of the Medicare tax to get 9% of the benefits.
[4:34] Let's go on to income taxes.
[4:40] You know, we're going to hear it again.
[4:42] Let's tax the rich, make them pay their fair share.
[4:45] Well, when it comes to income taxes, the top 10% earn about 40% of the income.
[4:51] That's always going to be the case.
[4:53] The top 10% are going to take a higher percentage of the income.
[4:57] They pay 74% of the income tax.
[5:02] I mean, at some point in time, you have to admit, yeah, they're paying their fair share.
[5:05] I'll go on.
[5:11] In 19, in 2032, when the trust fund is currently estimated to be depleted, the Social Security
[5:16] deficit is projected to be $511 billion.
[5:18] 21% of the total projected federal deficit of $2.4 trillion.
[5:25] Even if we, again, air quote, fix Social Security with a massive tax increase, 79% of the budget
[5:31] deficit would remain.
[5:33] A better solution, a better solution would be to pass a law that prevents the reduction
[5:39] of Social Security benefits and quit scaring seniors.
[5:44] We should then roll up our sleeves and begin seriously addressing the main problem, our massive
[5:49] debt and deficits.
[5:50] I have a proposal to do just that and would be willing to work with anybody in good faith
[5:56] to avoid a looming debt crisis.
[5:58] That is the only way to ensure we have the financial wherewithal to honor promises made
[6:03] to seniors.
[6:04] That turned over to Senator Merkley.
[6:09] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[6:11] And the beautiful thing about hearings is individuals with different perspectives get to present them.
[6:17] Sometimes those perspectives differ from those who are testifying, and sometimes those
[6:22] perspectives differ for those of us sitting here on the dais.
[6:25] I think the biggest factor scaring Americans right now was your quote this morning.
[6:33] At this point, there's really no way to fix Social Security.
[6:36] You can't fix it.
[6:38] You just shut it down and hope you recover some of your money.
[6:41] That does terrify people across the country.
[6:46] Go ahead.
[6:49] And Mitch, of what my colleague has described is the fact that he does not like the way
[6:57] Social Security is structured.
[6:59] It's part savings.
[7:00] It's part insurance.
[7:01] If you do very well, you don't get all that money back.
[7:05] You don't do so well.
[7:06] You're less affluent.
[7:08] You get back more than you put in.
[7:10] That's the insurance element of this program.
[7:13] He did have some misstatements in there saying that immediately that it is the money paid
[7:19] in that is paid out.
[7:20] Actually, the money, he said the money is not invested.
[7:23] It is invested.
[7:23] It's invested in bonds.
[7:25] And there's a reason for that.
[7:26] Because the collective concern of Congress previously was that that was a reasonable compromise.
[7:37] If you don't invest it, you get nothing.
[7:39] That doesn't make any sense.
[7:41] If you invest it in bonds, well, that's a guaranteed and the safest return.
[7:47] And you don't run the risk of a massive collapse of the stock market.
[7:51] And so that was a decision of Congress to design it that way.
[7:55] That doesn't make it a deception.
[7:58] And that certainly doesn't make it a scam.
[8:00] It makes it a thoughtful solution to the strategy of how we make sure that seniors in their later years
[8:07] have the ability to have some decent basic income.
[8:13] It's really not that much.
[8:15] A lot of seniors get about $1,400 a month.
[8:20] And that's hardly enough to rent the tiniest apartment these days.
[8:24] But it certainly does help over nothing.
[8:27] I do appreciate your holding hearings on this.
[8:29] I encouraged Lindsey Graham to hold hearings.
[8:32] He did agree to one hearing, but only one.
[8:34] So here we are further investigating what needs to be addressed.
[8:39] Every month, about 68 million Americans, including almost a million Oregonians, receive Social Security benefits.
[8:48] And for about half of American seniors that get these benefits, it accounts for half to 100% of their income.
[8:55] But this year, seniors are having a much harder time accessing the benefits that they've earned over a lifetime of work.
[9:03] Because President Trump and Doge recklessly fired thousands of Social Security Administration employees.
[9:10] Now what do we hear?
[9:11] We hear that if you call the Social Security and 800 number, you have to wait one to six hours on the phone to get the phone call answered.
[9:19] The wait time in field offices can stretch two to four hours with an appointment that had been scheduled two to three months in advance.
[9:29] And that applications for benefits that should be processed in 30 days are taking three months or longer.
[9:37] All of this because the President introduced such dysfunction in the Social Security Administration to the harm of millions of Americans.
[9:47] But none of that is proportional to the challenge if the government cannot pay Social Security benefits.
[9:57] Alarmingly, independent estimates by the Social Security Administration and the Congressional Budget Office show that the Retirement Trust Fund,
[10:05] in which the funds are invested in bonds, will be insolvent by the year 2032.
[10:10] And so folks who are coming in as senators today are within that six-year timeline.
[10:15] That's not very far from now.
[10:17] And it's over a decade ago I was pushing for us to make modest changes to Social Security.
[10:22] Because if we had made it over a decade ago, we'd only have to make modest changes.
[10:26] Now we have to make more dramatic changes to honor the obligation that we have made to our seniors.
[10:32] And my colleague is correct that if the Trust Fund goes insolvent, then the benefits that could be paid by the incoming money would be less than what is currently promised by an estimated 22 to 28 percent.
[10:50] Seniors living on fixed incomes can't afford to have a quarter of every dollar, especially as gas disappear, especially if gas and grocery costs keep climbing.
[11:01] So we have to act.
[11:03] This year I held 36 town halls, one in each county in Oregon.
[11:08] And at each one we did a survey on how people would like to see Social Security addressed to make sure it is solvent.
[11:16] The results were clear and consistent across red counties.
[11:20] There's far more red counties in Oregon than purple or blue counties.
[11:24] It was consistent from cities to rural communities.
[11:28] The top response of citizens was raise a cap on the income to which premiums apply.
[11:36] Folks think it's unfair for a local firefighter who pays the exact same contribution as a billionaire hedge fund manager.
[11:44] They want us to make investment income for the wealthiest Americans subject to Social Security premiums as well.
[11:50] For the wealthiest Americans, most of their income comes from investments.
[11:55] Some earn no wages at all.
[11:57] They simply borrow against the assets, so they never pay into the Social Security fund.
[12:02] They should support the trust fund like every other worker.
[12:06] So eliminating the cap on Social Security contributions is good policy.
[12:10] It helps keep the trust fund solvent, pay promised benefits, and it treats all Americans fairly even when they are more affluent.
[12:18] And those things then make for smart budgeting because it restores or resuscitates or ensures that the agreement that is made between the generations is sustained.
[12:35] No one likes deficit or debt, and I have laid out a plan for us to make sure we don't slide into this vortex of debt.
[12:42] On that, the chairman and I certainly agree.
[12:44] We have different answers for how it will be done, just as we have different answers on Social Security.
[12:50] But poll after poll after poll shows citizens do want us to reduce deficits and do want us to reduce debt.
[12:57] It's growing at more than 100%.
[12:58] It's now more than 100% of GDP.
[13:01] And massive debt means massive interest payments, especially as interest rates rely.
[13:05] And this means you compromise the ability to invest in families and infrastructure in those years to come.
[13:12] In less than 20 years, interest payments on the debt will crowd out the ability to invest in the foundations for families to thrive.
[13:18] Healthcare, housing, education, and good-paying jobs.
[13:21] So we need to break that cycle of dysfunctional debt.
[13:25] And to understand that, we have to understand how we got here.
[13:28] So take a look at this chart.
[13:29] We got here because we squandered more than $6 trillion of treasure on deficit financing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
[13:39] We got here because we slashed the taxes for the very wealthiest Americans.
[13:45] We did it twice under President Bush.
[13:47] We did it twice under Donald Trump.
[13:49] Every time my Republican colleagues claimed that cutting taxes to the rich would supercharge growth and decrease deficits,
[13:56] they were wrong every single time.
[14:01] But it's a mantra they've maintained in order to help the wealthiest Americans get wealthier while everybody else in America suffers.
[14:08] It's the billionaires win, families lose philosophy.
[14:13] And in democracy, that shouldn't be our philosophy.
[14:15] It should be families thrive and the affluent pay their fair share.
[14:19] So, we have a lot of work to do, and that includes tackling Social Security.
[14:27] And you can see by our presentations, we have a lot of differences about how that should be done.
[14:34] And with that, let's get on with the hearing.
[14:36] Again, let me be clear.
[14:38] I'm clear in my opening statement.
[14:39] I'm clear in my chairman's memo.
[14:42] I'm not saying shut down Social Security.
[14:44] I was talking about Ponzi schemes are shut down.
[14:46] They can't be fixed.
[14:47] So, no, my proposal is let's change the law so we don't reduce benefits, stop scaring seniors, and then address the overall deficit.
[14:56] So, again, an imprecise comment on TV, I am not suggesting to shut down Social Security.
[15:02] You can't.
[15:03] It's a legal Ponzi scheme.
[15:04] It's a sanctioned one.
[15:07] But with that, we'll turn to our witnesses.
[15:09] Dr. Veronique Derouji is the George Gibbs Chair in Political Economy and Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
[15:19] Her primary research interests include the U.S. economy, the federal budget, taxation, and tax competition.
[15:26] Dr. Derouji.
[15:33] Yeah.
[15:34] Okay.
[15:35] Yeah.
[15:35] Chairman Johnson, Ranking Member Merkley, and member of this committee, thank you for having me today.
[15:40] The title of this, so thank you for having me today.
[15:46] The title of this hearing is Social Security, the Reality.
[15:50] It is a right title because debates over Social Security too often obscure the program's fiscal reality with rhetoric about trust funds, promises, and insolvency.
[15:59] I'm sure everyone on this committee, what?
[16:05] That's not for me.
[16:06] Sorry.
[16:06] I'm sure everyone on this committee knows we have a problem.
[16:10] Defining it correctly is essential.
[16:12] Social Security is a pay-as-you-go program.
[16:16] Two-day workers pay for two-day retiree.
[16:19] From 1983 to 2009, payroll taxes exceeded benefits.
[16:25] The surplus was credited to the trust funds in the form of special treasury securities.
[16:30] Those securities are real legal obligations, but while they are assets to social security, they are an equal liability to the treasury.
[16:40] For the government as a whole, they are not an asset.
[16:43] To redeem the securities, the treasury must raise taxes, cut elsewhere, or borrow.
[16:51] With the rest of the budget also in deficit, it has mostly borrowed.
[16:55] That is how the trust fund can show a positive balance while also adding to the deficits and the debt, which it has.
[17:05] Estimates show that social security has added $1.6 trillion to the debt since 2010, including interest, and will add another $3.4 trillion by 2032.
[17:18] Those surpluses did fiscal damage of their own because they let Congress run bigger deficits.
[17:27] There are many studies on this, but I'll just cite one.
[17:30] An NBR study found that each extra dollar of trust fund surplus came with roughly $1.5 of additional deficit in the rest of the budget.
[17:41] So workers were taxed to pre-fund their retirement, and the money financed deeper deficit instead.
[17:49] Social security cannot borrow.
[17:51] So in late 2032, benefits will be limited to incoming revenue, and that means a sudden cut about 22%, which I think everyone agrees won't happen.
[18:02] So what's important is that we should not wait for that crisis to happen, nor should Congress repeal the automatic cut and pay for full benefits from the general fund,
[18:14] which move the shortfall to another line of the ledger without eliminating it.
[18:20] That shortfall is about $31 trillion in present value over 75 years, and the Cato model estimate that borrowing to cover it would add $46 trillion to the debt over 30 years.
[18:32] That $17 trillion of it will be interest on this additional debt.
[18:39] A larger Medicare shortfall doesn't excuse this one.
[18:42] So we should also be clear about why costs keep rising.
[18:47] Demographics are part of the story.
[18:48] Americans are living longer and having fewer children, so fewer workers support each retiree.
[18:54] But the program's design matters, too.
[18:57] Starting benefits are indexed to wage, which generally grow faster than prices over time.
[19:02] So each new generation of retiree begin with a bigger check than the generation before it, even after inflation.
[19:09] Meanwhile, the full retirement age has risen only two years since the first check in 1940,
[19:16] with Americans who reach 65 now live about seven years longer.
[19:22] Those facts should retire three narratives that keep this debate stuck.
[19:26] The first is that Social Security is fine until its trust funds run out of money.
[19:32] We are already borrowing money for Social Security.
[19:35] The second is that Congress can keep every schedule benefits by charging the difference to the general fund.
[19:42] That only moves the unfunded promise to the rest of the debt.
[19:46] The third is that we can simply tax the rich.
[19:48] Because benefits costs grow automatically, higher taxes chase a moving target.
[19:55] Eliminating the payroll tax cap would close at most about half of the long-term shortfall,
[20:01] while pushing top marginal rates on our most productive professionals, including physician,
[20:06] which we are already short of, past 60% in some states.
[20:10] Americans deserve better than a crisis of Congress' own making,
[20:15] followed by abrupt benefit cuts or enormous tax increase.
[20:19] Congress should act gradually and predictably, protect the most vulnerable,
[20:23] give workers time to adjust, slow the built-in growth of benefits,
[20:28] and align retirement age with longevity.
[20:31] That is the reality I hope we confront today.
[20:34] Thank you.
[20:34] Thank you, Dr. Derugy.
[20:36] Our next witness is Dr. Jason Fichtner.
[20:38] Dr. Fichtner is the Executive Director of the LEMRA Retirement Income Institute.
[20:44] He is also on the Board of Directors for the FINRA Investor Education Foundation
[20:47] and the National Academy of Social Insurance,
[20:50] as well as a member of the Puerto Rico Pension Reserve Trust.
[20:53] His areas of expertise focus on Social Security, Federal Tax Policy,
[20:57] Federal Budget Policy, Retirement Security,
[21:00] and Policy Proposals to Increase Savings and Investment.
[21:02] Dr. Fichtner.
[21:04] Good morning, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Merkley,
[21:07] and members of the Committee.
[21:08] Thank you for the introduction, the warm welcome.
[21:10] I appreciate that.
[21:11] I do have a lot of affiliations, so all opinions I express today are my own
[21:15] and do not necessarily reflect the views of any organization with which I'm affiliated.
[21:19] But thank you for the opportunity to testify today on the myths surrounding Social Security
[21:23] and the fiscal challenges facing Social Security
[21:27] and what these challenges reveal about the federal government's larger spending problem.
[21:32] My central message is straightforward.
[21:35] Social Security's financing shortfall is not an isolated retirement policy problem.
[21:40] It is a symptom of a broader federal budget that has promised more than it is willing to finance.
[21:46] The old age and survivor's insurance trust fund, the OASI trust fund,
[21:50] is projected to be depleted in early 2030s, 2032.
[21:54] But the trust fund should not be mistaken for a pile of marketable savings set aside for future retirees.
[22:00] It is, in practical budget terms, an intergovernmental accounting mechanism.
[22:06] One part of the federal government has credited another part of the federal government
[22:09] with special issue treasury securities.
[22:12] Now, those securities are legal obligations of the treasury,
[22:15] but redeeming them requires the same tools available for any other federal obligation.
[22:21] Raising taxes, reducing other spending, or borrowing from the public.
[22:24] That is why it is fair to describe the trust fund as an accounting gimmick
[22:28] that can obscure the real fiscal choices facing Congress.
[22:32] Trust fund balances records past surpluses and authorizes benefit payments,
[22:36] but it does not eliminate the need for cash when Social Security's annual cost exceeds its dedicated income.
[22:44] Once payroll taxes and other dedicated revenues are insufficient,
[22:47] the treasury must finance the difference in the unified federal budget.
[22:50] In 2026, Social Security's trustees projected that the OASI trust fund would be depleted again in 2032,
[22:57] and that absent legislative action, continuing income would cover about 78% of scheduled OASI benefits.
[23:05] In 2026, Social Security is expected to collect about $1.3 trillion in revenues,
[23:09] while spending roughly $1.5 trillion on benefits and administration,
[23:13] leaving a cash deficit of about $243 billion,
[23:16] or roughly 13% of the estimated $1.9 trillion federal budget.
[23:21] It is not 100%, it is only about 13%, so it's a much smaller of a larger problem.
[23:28] Research by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College notes that,
[23:32] despite the greater risk associated with equities,
[23:35] investing even a small portion of Social Security's trust fund in equities in 1984,
[23:40] after the 83 reforms, would have increased trust fund balances substantially,
[23:45] as the chairman pointed out in one of his charts.
[23:47] The deeper problem is that Social Security is only one piece of that much larger overspending challenge.
[23:52] The federal government is already running large structural deficits.
[23:56] In CBO's February 2026 baseline, the federal budget deficit is projected to be about $1.9 trillion,
[24:02] say $2 trillion for the fiscal year, about 5.8% of GDP,
[24:06] rising to $3.1 trillion in 2036, and 5.7% of GDP,
[24:11] while debt held by the public is projected to be over 100% of GDP.
[24:16] The nation's gross total debt now exceeds $40 trillion,
[24:20] and it's expected to be around $64 trillion in 2036.
[24:24] Interest payments are expected to be more than double,
[24:27] from $1 trillion this year to $2.1 trillion in 2036,
[24:30] but interest costs could be much higher if the current interest rates continue to increase or even stay steady.
[24:37] Social Security, Medicare, and rising net interest costs are among the main drivers of spending growth.
[24:43] This combination matters because financial markets do not evaluate Social Security in isolation.
[24:48] Investors look at the overall fiscal capacity of the United States,
[24:52] the credibility of future policy commitments,
[24:54] and the expected supply of Treasury securities that must be absorbed by global capital markets.
[25:00] Congressional action could remove the requirement that Social Security benefits be limited to dedicated revenues,
[25:05] while the Chairman has mentioned,
[25:07] while pairing that change with a real federal budget reforms that restrain overall federal spending.
[25:13] Doing so would dispel fears that Congress will allow automatic benefit cuts if trust fund depletion is occurred,
[25:19] while also sending financial markets a credible signal that lawmakers are serious about bringing total federal spending under control.
[25:27] Congress should address Social Security's financing shortfall before trust fund depletion forces an abrupt response by the bond market.
[25:35] Reform is not only a retirement policy imperative,
[25:37] it is also a matter of fiscal resilience, household affordability, and financial stability.
[25:42] Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
[25:45] Thank you, Dr. Fichtner.
[25:46] Our final witness is Dr. Catherine Ann Edwards.
[25:48] Dr. Edwards is a labor economist and senior fellow at the National Academy of Social Insurance.
[25:54] Dr. Edwards is also a Bloomberg columnist where she frequently writes about her labor markets,
[25:58] public policy, and inequality.
[26:01] She was previously an economist at Rand Corporation,
[26:03] received her Ph.D. from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
[26:06] Dr. Edwards.
[26:07] If we frame the issue before us, Social Security, for the next 75 years,
[26:35] the answer is raise revenue or cut benefits.
[26:39] But if the question is instead, what do Americans need from Social Security,
[26:45] as I think it should be, the answer is broader in both scope and ambition.
[26:50] The demographic transition that is putting pressure on Social Security's finances is well-trived.
[26:55] The baby boom generation was a large one, the subsequent ones were not,
[26:59] and many people are living longer.
[27:00] The parallel economic transition is as important but less discussed.
[27:05] Social Security's revenue base has suffered from evolutions in our labor market and in our economy.
[27:12] The first revenue hit came from historic increases in wage inequality since the last major reform in 1983.
[27:19] At that time, Social Security's tax base represented 90% of taxable earnings.
[27:24] Today it is around 82.5.
[27:26] The tax cap, designed to keep track of the 90% benchmark, fell behind the runaway earnings of the 6% of workers who earned above it,
[27:35] losing the equivalent of over $100 billion a year in foregone annual revenue.
[27:40] The second revenue hit was the shift in total compensation away from wages towards benefits, including health insurance.
[27:47] In the 1970s, for example, health benefits represented just under 3% of total compensation paid by employers.
[27:55] Over the last 10 years, it was nearly 7%.
[27:58] Contributions to employer health plans are not subject to Social Security's payroll taxes,
[28:04] and neither are contributions to retirement accounts, equivalent to around $200 billion in foregone annual revenue.
[28:10] Meanwhile, the labor share of gross domestic income, how much of our economy workers take home on their paychecks,
[28:17] has been falling this century, reaching a historical low last quarter.
[28:22] In short, Social Security is financed on a shrinking base of a shrinking base of a shrinking base.
[28:29] I'm sure many of your constituents would agree with the conclusion,
[28:33] paychecks don't go as far as reflecting back the decline of the U.S. worker and the mismanagement of the U.S. economy.
[29:13] So what will reform look like?
[29:16] Because as we all agree, some kind of reform is coming.
[29:19] I think there are three options.
[29:20] One, if it is a matter of just paying for promised benefits, the question is tense but simple, pay or cut?
[29:29] I say pay.
[29:31] Eliminate the payroll tax cap, raise the tax rate, invest a portion of the trust fund,
[29:35] make employers of independent contractors pay into Social Security,
[29:39] supplement payroll tax revenue with corporate income tax revenue or capital gains revenue.
[29:43] Two, if reform aims to address the long-term sustainability of Social Security,
[29:50] a truly balanced package would make aggressive investments in the wages and labor force participation of workers,
[29:58] including renewed labor law and pursuing the most effective policy we have yet to deploy
[30:03] that can achieve higher labor force participation, child care.
[30:06] Three, if instead reform is about what Americans need from Social Security,
[30:13] then yes to revenue, yes to investments in workers, but the program itself needs to be expanded.
[30:19] We are at a crucible moment of Americans' economic precarity.
[30:23] It is at a modern-day peak.
[30:26] Social Security is a tool at your disposal.
[30:29] Add paid family and medical leave to Social Security's portfolio.
[30:33] Create a robust unemployment system.
[30:35] Bring supplemental security income into the 21st century.
[30:40] I will end by noting that across party lines, Americans have resoundingly said they do not want benefit cuts,
[30:48] even if that means paying higher taxes themselves.
[30:51] In the course of crafting economic policy, the will of the people can be seen as the obstacle or the assignment.
[30:58] In the case of Social Security, I take it as the assignment.
[31:01] Thank you, and I yield the remainder of my time.
[31:04] Thank you, Dr. Edwards.
[31:05] I'd like to start with you.
[31:06] First of all, did you have a chance?
[31:08] I know you just got it yesterday.
[31:09] Did you have a chance to read my chairman's memo?
[31:12] Was there anything there that struck you as inaccurate?
[31:18] I guess your mic didn't work.
[31:20] I can hear you better now.
[31:22] Great.
[31:23] It's easier to riff this way.
[31:26] I had a tight five.
[31:28] Y'all didn't get it.
[31:29] Yes, I did read your memo.
[31:30] Can you repeat your question?
[31:31] Sorry.
[31:32] Was there anything inaccurate in that memo?
[31:35] Because I was just trying to lay out facts.
[31:36] I made some notes about the scheduling tax increase from 1980, but if you're asking if I agree with your characterization that Social Security is a little bit okay.
[31:48] No, I'm not asking you to agree with that, but I mean just the basic facts is what I'm trying to lay out.
[31:53] I mean the demographic facts, I mean I'll put the chart up again and I think we included the actual spreadsheet on that.
[32:02] If they would have acknowledged that this was not an investment vehicle, if they would have just invested these surpluses, we'd have $14.5 trillion in real assets.
[32:11] We'd be talking about increasing Social Security benefits.
[32:14] So again, my point being, you have to recognize the reality of a situation, you're going to fix a problem.
[32:20] And we're not acknowledging that reality.
[32:22] And again, I think another reality we should acknowledge, and again, I emphasize this again because an imprecise comment is going to be used against me.
[32:31] We will never reduce benefits.
[32:35] That won't happen.
[32:36] So why don't we take that off the table, stop scaring seniors to impose what I would consider a very destructive solution, which is increasing taxes.
[32:46] You know, the bigger problem, and you're an economist, I mean, even if you fix Social Security, 80% of the deficit remains going forward.
[32:56] I mean, aren't you concerned about us hitting a debt crisis where creditors look at us and go, I'm not going to loan you any more money.
[33:04] I mean, no matter what you do for Social Security, I mean, the game's over.
[33:07] You know, we are going to be, you know, primarily using our federal budget revenue to pay interest.
[33:12] So doesn't that concern you?
[33:14] Yes.
[33:15] The last, you know, the U.S. debt has been downgraded three times.
[33:19] And on two of those occasions, it was around a political standoff in 2011 and 2000.
[33:26] I think the greatest risk to Americans' debts and the fiscal trust in the federal government is political dysfunction.
[33:36] Don't disagree at all.
[33:37] I find this place highly dysfunctional.
[33:39] I think that Social Security is an easy fall guy in the debt conversation that displaces what should be just the ins and out of the everyday budget of the U.S. government.
[33:49] Having shutdowns, having fiscal crises, having debt limits.
[33:53] I mean, Social Security, for all of the talk, has never missed a dollar of payment and has been warning of the fiscal situation it's in, you know, since I was, like, before kindergarten.
[34:03] And it hasn't been addressed.
[34:04] But I empathize.
[34:05] So, again, what I read, and I read your testimony, you basically have a solution of increased taxes, which, again, when you increase taxes, that is not helpful to economic activity.
[34:17] Okay, I think economic growth is the number one component of the solution.
[34:19] And then other government programs.
[34:20] One of the reasons I'm pointing out the reality of what Social Security is is it is the most beloved and relied on federal program.
[34:29] I am not suggesting we end it.
[34:31] Okay, just that is not my solution is stop scaring seniors and fix the big problem.
[34:37] We have to get serious about the overall debt and deficit.
[34:41] That's my whole point.
[34:42] But let me ask you, because I never get an answer out of people on this, but you want to increase taxes.
[34:47] What do you think is the maximum percentage the federal government ought to take out of an additional dollar of income?
[34:56] In terms of a marginal rate?
[34:57] Yeah, what do you think the maximum marginal rate should be?
[35:02] You know, it's interesting.
[35:02] You ask, I think, for legislative priorities, you need to work on the number of coupons in the tax code.
[35:08] You know, the marginal rate right now for the top 1% is irrelevant to the number of discounts they can claim when filing their taxes.
[35:14] I mean, again, just is there a figure in your head in terms of this is the most the federal government ought to take out of any American's paycheck?
[35:23] Can you name a figure?
[35:24] I don't think there's a I don't think there's a number.
[35:27] You're saying people don't answer this question when you ask them.
[35:29] But I think it's because the number itself is not like a thing.
[35:32] I think they don't want to answer honestly because they're American public wouldn't like it.
[35:39] American public when survey says about 30 percent.
[35:42] If we lift the cap on Social Security, that maximum tax rate would be 53 percent.
[35:46] But sir, the top 1% effective tax rate is 26 percent.
[35:50] I mean, the marginal rate matters less because of how many coupons they claim.
[35:54] And by the way, for the members of the diocese here, I am happy to simplify and rationalize the tax code.
[35:59] That's what we should do.
[35:59] I mean, you're talking about a complex tax code, which also is economically harmful.
[36:03] So again, I do want this hearing to be a discussion and open the debate.
[36:10] I realize me calling it a legal Ponzi scheme is a lightning rod issue to draw attention to what the reality of it is so we can actually get down to solving the real problem, which is $24 trillion of additional deficit spending over the next 10 years, which we're all whistling by the graveyard.
[36:28] But sir, you're saying you would like to address the real problem, but when it comes to the tax code, the real problem isn't the marginal rates.
[36:34] It's the number of coupons that wealthy families are able to claim.
[36:37] They've had the largest reduction in their effective tax rate over the past 26 years, not because their rate was reduced by that much, but because of the number of discounts they're able to claim.
[36:45] I am with you.
[36:46] We have to focus on the real problem, and that is the poorest nature of our tax code and how really only the wealthy have been able to take advantage of that.
[36:53] And again, what I want to do is literally look at rationalizing and simplifying our tax code.
[37:00] Try to do it with the Republicans during the one big, beautiful bill.
[37:03] I got nowhere.
[37:05] I know Senator Wyden knows one of my proposals in terms of taxing all business income at the ownership level.
[37:11] Okay, again, simplify, rationalize tax code.
[37:14] That's my offer moving forward on a bipartisan basis.
[37:17] Let's actually fix these problems by understanding what the reality is.
[37:21] With that, it's Senator Wyden.
[37:22] Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I don't want to breeze past the chairman's remarks.
[37:32] As far as I can tell, this is the first time in decades that a senior senator, the chairman of the Budget Committee,
[37:40] said he would rather shut down Social Security than fix it, in effect saying he would rather throw in the towel than have billionaires pay their fair share.
[37:53] That is, in my view, an astounding statement and one that is going to frighten many older people.
[38:01] On Social Security, Congress can put the program on a stronger financial footing and restore fairness by eliminating the cap on Social Security payroll contributions
[38:11] and passing my billionaire income tax.
[38:14] It makes no sense that a billionaire stops paying into Social Security a few hours into the new year if they even pay anything at all.
[38:24] And this is a welcome development, and the primary idea put forward by my Republican colleagues is to shovel trillions of taxpayer dollars to Wall Street.
[38:38] I led the fight against the effort to do this in the past, and I wanted to be clear that I'll do that in the future.
[38:48] I'll do what's necessary to protect Social Security from the clutches of Wall Street, and if I'm the only one standing against this ill-advised idea,
[38:57] as one of our colleagues has claimed, then I'll gladly man the ramparts against turning over workers' financial security to Wall Street bankers.
[39:09] Social Security does have to evolve to meet the challenges.
[39:14] The challenges of economic and wealth inequality, high costs of caregiving and health care, unequal family policies, and certainly the accelerating growth of AI.
[39:26] The challenges Americans face today are already having a substantial impact on Social Security's financial health.
[39:33] Older Americans claimed Social Security benefits earlier to get extra financial support.
[39:39] Americans are having fewer kids or forgoing them all together because affordable childcare and paid family and medical leave are scant.
[39:47] And the high cost of health insurance makes it more difficult for folks to stay healthy and work.
[39:53] I think, and the chairman said that he wanted to work together, I think that there are smart solutions, and we're committed to doing this.
[40:01] I mean, certainly, the proposition that billionaires shouldn't be able to avoid taxes for years on end, which we can correct through the billionaires' income tax, now supported by 24 senators, is part of the solution.
[40:16] And I think we ought to get started, and I think we ought to take notice of the fact that this proposition of throwing in the towel, folks, which is what we heard,
[40:25] we can't do anything because of the chairman's remarks, I think would be a huge mistake.
[40:31] I think the American people would say, we send you there to roll up your sleeves and fix the problem, not quit on it.
[40:37] And I'm prepared to work with my colleagues to make sure that we fix it.
[40:41] I yield back.
[40:42] Again, I'll say I was talking about Ponzi schemes.
[40:45] You can't fix them.
[40:46] Imprecise statement, I'll admit, but everything I've written, everything I've said, clearly I am not proposing shutting down Social Security.
[40:53] I'm talking about the proposal is literally passing a law so that benefits are not reduced.
[41:00] We're never going to do it.
[41:01] Let's stop scaring seniors, so that's my proposal, is pass a law, make sure that benefits are not reduced,
[41:07] and roll up our sleeves and fix the real problem, which is $24 trillion of 10-year deficits.
[41:13] The chairman said, you said shut it down.
[41:16] I was talking about, I was, again, imprecise, I was, and read my chairman's memo.
[41:21] I'm talking about you shut, Ponzi schemes are shut down.
[41:25] I am not suggesting, I am not suggesting, an imprecise comment, I admit, I am not suggesting, I'm telling you I'm not, I wrote I'm not, I'm not suggesting shutting down Social Security.
[41:34] You can keep saying it, but I'm not.
[41:35] You said, all right, first I want to thank Chairman Johnson for holding this important hearing.
[41:41] I agree with him that we ought to pass legislation that protects the benefits of Social Security and Medicare.
[41:48] I've had a bill like that for a few years and not one of my Democrat colleagues has signed on, but I think it's important.
[41:54] We need to make sure these benefits are preserved both for Social Security and for Medicare.
[41:58] So Social Security is a promise that our federal government has an obligation to keep.
[42:03] We all know how it works.
[42:04] You spend your life paying into a system that is supposed to be there in retirement to ensure seniors don't fall through the cracks when their working days are done.
[42:13] And that's why it was set up.
[42:16] You know, I think around the country people believe the money you and your employer pay in will be there and be sufficient to pay for their retirement.
[42:23] And I think everybody ought to read the Chairman's memo because it explains the facts.
[42:29] And unfortunately, I've been up here eight years and there's never been a real conversation.
[42:32] So I again want to thank the Chairman for holding this meeting.
[42:36] Unfortunately, today's Social Security is on the brink of failure.
[42:38] The latest estimates show we only have a few years to fix Social Security before it goes insolvent and triggers a massive cut in benefits.
[42:45] Chairman Johnson deserves enormous credit for forcing us to talk about this issue today.
[42:49] Most people in Washington are way too terrified to even take a stand.
[42:52] So what we mostly hear is the argument from the tax hikers.
[42:56] The tax hikers are, in my opinion, liars.
[42:59] We try to blame the rich for all of America's problems and claim that we can tax our way out of this by going after the billionaires.
[43:05] That's what we keep hearing time and day after day.
[43:09] Well, let's let's dig into it for just a second.
[43:12] I did some quick research ahead of this here and here's what I found.
[43:15] Dr. Fisher, if you add up all the wealth, not just the cash, the entire net worth, which counts the value of property, companies, stock holdings, everything American billionaires own, and could magically just like that liquidate all the wealth into real money, how much would you have?
[43:32] Take it all?
[43:33] Take it all.
[43:34] Take it every bit of it.
[43:35] According to Forbes, the analysis of the Forbes 400, the top 400, and you'd have about $8 trillion, excuse me.
[43:43] Okay.
[43:43] So we could tax them, right?
[43:44] But let's just don't tax them.
[43:46] Let's say we're going to go big.
[43:47] Let's take 100%, take all their money, $8 trillion.
[43:51] You're making me sweat here.
[43:53] I need to like wipe my hands.
[43:54] So if you take all that money, would you solve Social Security insolvency problems?
[43:59] No, sir, you would not.
[44:00] You would probably get yourself maybe roughly 10 years of filling the gap.
[44:04] And I think that's one of the chairman's points, too, is we talk about fixing Social Security.
[44:08] If you just put Social Security in isolation as a fix, you're ignoring the larger problem of the federal government spending problem.
[44:15] But also a fix has to be something that's permanent, not just delays the problem for 5 years, 8 years, 10 years, or 20 years.
[44:21] So that would not solve the problem or fix the structural problems of Social Security.
[44:26] Okay.
[44:26] So you take everything, take all their money, liquidate all of it, and you take care of it for about 10 years.
[44:33] Yeah.
[44:33] You also have other problems with the macro effects of taking someone's wealth and investment,
[44:38] and that would reduce economic growth and income taxes and corporate taxes, and that would be harmful to the fiscal government.
[44:43] If we did that and we liquidate all these, liquidate all their ownership, what happened to the economy?
[44:48] I wouldn't say it would crash, but it wouldn't do very well.
[44:50] It definitely would be declining.
[44:52] You would have a lot less investment.
[44:53] You would also be sending a signal that your wealth is no longer your own property.
[44:57] And I think people will see over time when you start off with like an income tax,
[45:00] which is supposed to be only a tax in the top 1 or 2 percent, now it's a mass tax.
[45:04] People will fear that you'll go after the rest of their wealth, not just billionaires and millionaires.
[45:07] Okay.
[45:08] So would it impact jobs?
[45:10] Yes.
[45:11] Okay.
[45:11] So would you have fewer companies?
[45:13] You'd have fewer companies, you'd have fewer jobs, you'd have fewer economic growth, you'd have fewer revenue.
[45:16] What would happen to the stock market?
[45:18] It would not look very good for at least a few days when the people would sell off their assets.
[45:23] So if you sold all the assets of these billionaires, $8 trillion worth of assets.
[45:27] They would have to liquidate.
[45:28] So I don't know, when you think about the ownership of stock markets that go into the top 1 percent, top 5, top 10,
[45:35] you'd be liquidating a lot of the market, which would be a sell-off.
[45:37] And so it's like selling anything.
[45:39] If you have more of something on the market, the price goes down.
[45:41] So you'd have a collapse in the market.
[45:43] So what would happen to everybody's 401k plan?
[45:45] It'd be a 201k the next day.
[45:47] Yeah.
[45:48] So all their 401k plans, any retirement plan they have, all those would be worth less.
[45:54] They'd be worth less.
[45:54] And I think that's an important point to note, too, about investing workers' benefits and taxes.
[45:58] We, a lot of people, are invested in the market.
[46:02] 401k plans, 403b, pension plans.
[46:05] I chair the Portico Pension Reserve Trust.
[46:07] We're invested in the market.
[46:08] Staffers sitting here are part of the Thrift Savings Plan.
[46:11] Their money's invested in the market as well, diversified portfolio.
[46:15] So it is a good question to ask whether or not we should be doing something different with surpluses from Social Security if we have them again.
[46:20] So, you know, you said we're running about $2 trillion deficits, right?
[46:23] So if you took all those billionaires' money, how long would it cover our deficits?
[46:27] Four years.
[46:28] Four years.
[46:29] Then you'd have the same thing.
[46:30] And if you look at CBO, the deficits five years from now are actually even bigger, right?
[46:34] Well, yes.
[46:35] And a quick point on CBO.
[46:36] I know ranking member Merkley walked out, but I think it's important to point out he asked CBO for a letter, which was delivered to him in September.
[46:42] And I want to praise the ranking member for doing this, is ask CBO what would happen if interest rates were a little bit higher.
[46:49] So CBO analyzed what would happen if interest rates went up 100 basis points over the course of 20 years.
[46:55] And their baseline estimate is 4.1%.
[46:57] We're already at 5.1% today.
[47:00] So CBO's estimates and their baseline, I think, are really, really off.
[47:04] So one thing we could do that would actually add money to Social Security is add more jobs, right?
[47:08] We have 39 million people right now in this country working in ages that are not working.
[47:12] So what if all of them went to work tomorrow?
[47:14] Would that have an impact on Social Security?
[47:16] It would.
[47:16] It would.
[47:16] It would be more payroll taxes coming in.
[47:18] It would also be more income taxes coming into the federal government as well.
[47:22] I think, I mean, the only way out of this is we've, I think, I agree with everybody that's been talking.
[47:26] We've got to come up with a plan, right?
[47:28] But this plan has got to be, the only way out of this is you've got to grow the economy.
[47:32] You're not going to grow the economy by taxing.
[47:35] If you take all the money from billionaires, right?
[47:38] And plus, you've got to take all that money to do, the Democrats want to do Medicare for all.
[47:41] They want to do free everything, right?
[47:43] So where's all this money going to come from?
[47:46] So it's the craziest idea ever.
[47:47] And one thing about, I'm a tax economist by training, and the first rule of tax policy is only people pay taxes.
[47:53] So you start hearing about raising taxes on corporations.
[47:56] Corporations don't pay the tax.
[47:57] They'll write the check.
[47:58] But the burden falls on either workers, owners of capital, which can include shareholders and their 401k plan.
[48:03] Customers.
[48:03] Customers and consumers.
[48:04] The estate tax does not fall on the dead person.
[48:07] They're dead.
[48:07] It falls on the beneficiary, which could be a business owner who has to pay a tax to supplement it.
[48:12] So when thinking about tax policy, it's important to think about who actually bears the burden of the tax.
[48:16] And as the chairman said, and I think others, you know, Mr. Ryden as well, we would like to have a broader base with lower rates.
[48:24] Those are more efficient.
[48:25] The problem is as long as we start doing carve-outs, these tax expenditures, then we've got to raise rates to have the same amount of revenue.
[48:31] And then because rates are so high, you have lobbying coming to say we need another exclusion.
[48:35] So the problem goes over again.
[48:36] So you really need to think about how you lower those rates and broaden the base.
[48:39] Thank you.
[48:40] Thank you, Chairman.
[48:41] Senator, maybe I should say Chairman in waiting Cain.
[48:44] If the articles are correct.
[48:46] I would look forward to that opportunity if it should come my way.
[48:50] Thank you to the witnesses.
[48:53] So just the historical context.
[48:55] And I'm so glad that you called this hearing because we're going to have to really dig into this and not wait before we do.
[49:02] In 1935, the country was in the midst of the Great Depression.
[49:05] Unemployment and poverty, especially among older Americans, was incredibly high.
[49:10] So President Roosevelt asked Congress for a social insurance program to help Americans during one of the worst economic downturns in American history.
[49:18] The President's Commission on Economic Security began the work which created the Social Security Act of 1935 from Congress,
[49:27] addressing the needs of people 65 years and older and creating a benefit program structure just as it is today.
[49:34] Those who are working and their employers pay into a system that helps secure a dignified retirement for those who are retired.
[49:42] A February 2026 report from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities shows that 23 million Americans,
[49:50] and those are adults and children, are able to live above the poverty line because of Social Security benefits.
[49:57] 23 million live above the poverty line because of Social Security benefits.
[50:01] And 17 million of those are adults, but 6 million are kids.
[50:07] 17 million of these, age 65 and older, rely only on Social Security benefits for the majority of their income.
[50:18] Without this critical Social Security program, 37 percent of American seniors would be below the poverty line.
[50:26] It's currently 10 percent, that's too high, but it would be 37 percent without this program.
[50:31] Now, I don't want to take the chair's comments out of context.
[50:36] He used the phrase Ponzi scheme today, and he's explained here what he meant by that, but he's not the first person.
[50:43] The word Ponzi scheme has been applied to Social Security by many people over the course of many years.
[50:49] And I just really want to hold up first, what is the right way to label a program where people who are working contribute in order to fund a dignified retirement for the adults who have raised them,
[51:06] for the adults who have been their teachers, their Sunday school teachers, their little league coaches, the community leaders in the communities where they grew up.
[51:15] That's what Social Security is. People who are working contribute, and their employers do, too, so that the adults who have raised them and been leaders of the community who are now in retirement can be above the poverty line rather than below.
[51:31] Now, some look at that and say, that's a Ponzi scheme. Others look at it and say, well, gosh, doesn't the Bible say respect your elders? Doesn't the Bible say honor your father and mother?
[51:41] I mean, there is a value that is behind the Social Security program, the way it is funded, that says those of us who are still working, we've got an obligation, whether we acknowledge it or not.
[51:54] We have an obligation to the generation that came before that gifted us in so many ways.
[52:00] And so that's why the Ponzi scheme label creates such opposition on this side.
[52:05] I mean, even calling it a legal Ponzi scheme, people hear Ponzi scheme. Ponzi schemes are bad.
[52:09] Honoring your father and mother, respecting your elders, not bad. Command it.
[52:15] And so that's why language like this creates challenges.
[52:18] But I do agree with you. We've got to do something, and we better do something sooner rather than later.
[52:24] So I'm going to start with you, Dr. Edwards.
[52:28] We often talk about, you know, the great Tip O'Neill and Reagan deal to promote Social Security stability in the 1980s, but they waited until the 11th hour.
[52:36] Benefits were going to be cut. Benefits could be cut as early as 2032 if we don't do anything.
[52:43] What are the virtues of doing it before we get to the 11th hour?
[52:47] Give Congress a little bit of an altar call about why we should act before the 11th hour.
[52:53] The longer you wait, the more expensive the...
[52:56] How about to Dr. Fitchner or...
[52:58] Well, I would actually take three points for that, Senator.
[53:01] First, let me applaud you for you working across the aisle with various other senators on the Republican side for bipartisan solutions.
[53:06] So I thank you for that.
[53:08] The reason you want to act sooner rather than later are three things.
[53:11] One is the opportunity cost of time.
[53:14] So when I was at Social Security, I actually signed three of those trustees' reports, the last one in 2010.
[53:19] I'm not saying I support the solution, but back in 2010, had you just solved Social Security, just that part of the problem, on the payroll tax side,
[53:27] it would have been 1.92% of taxable payroll, two pennies.
[53:31] Now today you're at 4.4.
[53:32] If you wait to trust fund depletion, it's five.
[53:34] So the opportunity cost is...
[53:35] And that sort of picks up, Dr. Edwards.
[53:38] The fix gets more expensive.
[53:39] Gets more expensive.
[53:40] Two, it also then crowds out other potential priorities you might want to do, or the ability to fix other parts of the budget that are driving the spending increase,
[53:46] whether it's health insurance or other parts in the discretionary budget.
[53:50] The third is fear.
[53:51] Fear is a real thing.
[53:52] And what we are now seeing, and there's evidence to show this, is that people are making one of the most important decisions in their financial retirement,
[53:58] when to claim Social Security.
[53:59] They're taking it early because they're hearing about trust funds being depleted,
[54:02] or Social Security going bankrupt, or Congress won't fix it, and they'll just let benefits be cut.
[54:07] As the Chairman said, no one thinks that any Congress or President is going to let benefits be cut.
[54:11] So that fear is very important.
[54:12] Mr. Chair, could I just ask if Dr. Rishi would answer this question?
[54:15] Why should we fix it now rather than wait until the 11th hour?
[54:18] I think all day I agree entirely with Dr. Edwards and Dr. Fickner.
[54:22] I mean, waiting, the longer you wait, the more painful the price to pay, whether you do it on the benefit side or on the tax side.
[54:32] But also, I mean, there is a real risk of actually being put in Congress in a position where they will be tempted to kick the can down the road yet again.
[54:43] And I actually think that if you do this, there's a real risk to actually really scare the bond market
[54:53] because this is a commitment of just isolating Social Security, which is the small part of the enormous problem that we have.
[55:03] But it is a problem nonetheless.
[55:04] It is effectively saying that you can't even fix that.
[55:08] How are you going to fix the rest?
[55:10] I'm going to conclude right there.
[55:12] I do believe if we can be focused on fixing the Social Security stability issue,
[55:19] that could be a stepping stone to fixing broader problems and a confidence builder.
[55:24] I entirely agree.
[55:27] But really, I mean, I think it is important to drive home the message that if you can't even fix this,
[55:34] that everyone agrees Social Security is actually the easiest thing to fix.
[55:39] I mean, it is beloved and no one wants to lose on any front whatsoever.
[55:46] If you don't fix this, you're sending a very strong message that you will not increase primary surpluses.
[55:53] And I worry that the moment you make that decision and you send that signal, inflation could rise.
[55:58] Thank you all for answering that question about why to act sooner than later.
[56:01] Thanks, Mr. Chair.
[56:02] And, you know, listen, I appreciate your comments and I don't disagree with them.
[56:06] Obviously, I'm calling it a legal policy scheme to draw attention to the problem.
[56:10] And, again, it does accurately describe the money flows because people have been misled.
[56:20] They really do think their money has been put in a lockbox and it's been accumulating interest.
[56:25] That just wasn't the truth.
[56:27] And had that been acknowledged in 1983, you'd have $14.5 trillion.
[56:30] So, again, don't disagree with that.
[56:34] And the whole point of this is let's get into an honest discussion with the actual facts.
[56:40] Let's not use imprecise statements and, you know, because obviously I'm not suggesting we end it.
[56:45] I'm trying to save it.
[56:46] I'm trying to save this country, okay?
[56:48] I'm trying to avoid a massive debt crisis.
[56:52] Senator Graham.
[56:53] Thank you, Chairman Johnson and Ranking Member Markley for holding this important hearing.
[57:01] And thank you to our witnesses for being here today.
[57:04] When I was a young girl, I lost both my parents.
[57:07] So, my brother, Lindsey, and I had to rely on Social Security benefits to make it.
[57:13] So, I know what these benefits meant to our family and I know what they mean to families in South Carolina across our state.
[57:20] They rely on that check to pay their bills every month.
[57:24] So, I believe we must protect Social Security and we need to ensure that benefits can be paid to Americans who already depend on it.
[57:33] But we also need to be realistic about the challenges facing the program.
[57:37] According to Social Security Trustees Report, the Trust Fund for Retirement and Survivor Benefits will become insolvent in 2032.
[57:46] If Congress fails to act in a timely manner, the money coming in at that point would cover only 78% of scheduled benefits.
[57:55] A cut to benefits of that scale would cause hardships for beneficiaries already struggling to pay their bills.
[58:01] For many seniors in South Carolina, that could mean having to choose between paying for groceries, keeping a roof over their head, or receiving health care.
[58:13] Part of the problem is that we have fewer workers paying into Social Security for every person receiving benefits than we did in previous generations.
[58:22] And the longer Congress waits to address the shortfall, the harder it's going to be to find a solution.
[58:29] We need to do a better job preventing fraud and improper payments.
[58:34] Taking steps to safeguard Social Security is an important part of protecting its long-term future.
[58:41] But Congress must still address the gap between what the program collects and what it has promised to pay.
[58:48] When we consider different proposals to solve this issue, we need to ask some basic questions.
[58:55] How much will these proposals actually help?
[58:58] What will they mean for working families and small businesses?
[59:02] And will they put Social Security on a more sustainable long-term path?
[59:08] Republicans and Democrats should be able to agree that we need to protect the people who currently depend on Social Security
[59:14] and make sure the program is there for future generations.
[59:18] I believe that today's discussion will help us better understand what it will take to accomplish that goal.
[59:26] So my first question, Dr. Fitner.
[59:30] What reforms could Congress consider to strengthen Social Security without reducing benefits for Americans who already depend on it?
[59:38] So I think this is something that Dr. Edwards said, too.
[59:40] When you're thinking about just Social Security, again, putting it in isolation, you basically have three options.
[59:45] One, you raise taxes.
[59:47] Two, you reduce benefits, which you said take off the line.
[59:49] Or three, you borrow money to make up the gap.
[59:52] The other option, which I think is more holistic, is to think about what Social Security is supposed to do.
[59:56] And you start your statement by saying those who needed it were getting Social Security to pay it.
[1:00:00] Senator Kaine made a great good point earlier when he said, how do we describe the program?
[1:00:04] So technically, the program is the old-age survivors and disability insurance programs.
[1:00:10] This is an insurance program.
[1:00:11] It was never meant to be someone's retirement.
[1:00:13] It was meant to keep people out of poverty.
[1:00:15] They got disabled to cover work.
[1:00:16] It's a work replacement program.
[1:00:18] It's an insurance policy.
[1:00:19] So one thing, thinking about holistically how you look at Social Security, is what income do people have from working?
[1:00:24] What do they have from their retirement savings?
[1:00:26] And where does Social Security fit in as an insurance program to make sure people aren't poor
[1:00:30] and people who are disabled get income they need?
[1:00:33] And I think that's one way to look at it.
[1:00:34] That could be something where you reduce benefits for top earners
[1:00:36] or look at how you can recapture some Social Security on a tax form for those who have more earnings in one year.
[1:00:42] And in less years, you don't have to recapture as much.
[1:00:44] But it's rethinking what the program is because it really is a social insurance program.
[1:00:49] So what you're discussing, does that give the flexibility to make gradual reforms that will protect current beneficiaries?
[1:00:57] You can, but this is a lesson from the 83 reforms.
[1:01:00] It's Congress raised the retirement age from 65 to 67 for what is the quote-unquote full retirement age.
[1:01:06] Now we're changing the language thanks to the Claiming and Clarity Act, which I applaud.
[1:01:09] But that was done over a 40-year period.
[1:01:11] So it wouldn't affect the cash flows coming in, but it would affect future beneficiaries.
[1:01:16] If you're trying to protect current beneficiaries, so those who are close to it, from any changes,
[1:01:20] then your only options are, one, bringing in more revenue, which means a tax increase or borrowing.
[1:01:25] If you don't want to avoid having benefit changes.
[1:01:28] If you're trying to even reduce things like the cost of living allowance, so people would still get a higher benefit next year,
[1:01:33] but it's their slower growth, that would help some, but it's still not going to solve, quote-unquote, your cash flow problems.
[1:01:39] Thank you.
[1:01:41] Dr. Ruggi, what would happen to the federal budget and national debt if Congress relied on additional borrowing
[1:01:48] to cover Social Security's upcoming shortfall?
[1:01:51] So, first, I'm sorry for your loss.
[1:01:57] So, according to the, if we think about Social Security alone, that's a, and maintain benefit,
[1:02:08] didn't raise taxes and borrow the entirety, it would be roughly $46 trillion in borrowing
[1:02:14] with $17 trillion of that in interest payment.
[1:02:18] If we look at the entirety of the, of, of, of the budget, I think CBO project that if, when the trust fund,
[1:02:29] trust funds dries up, it's roughly over $130 trillion of borrowing, including interest over 30 years.
[1:02:43] So, it's, uh, a lot of borrowing.
[1:02:49] So, what impact could that have on working families and small businesses, do you think?
[1:02:54] So, as I said, I think the, the moment, the moment Congress makes the decision to borrow the entirety of,
[1:03:02] uh, to, to basically just kick the cam down the road and, and, and, and not, uh, do any structural change
[1:03:09] to the, to the program or not raise, um, primary surpluses, it is sending a strong signal to markets
[1:03:17] that, uh, they're not going to be able to, that they're not going to be willing to do the hard thing of,
[1:03:23] of doing, uh, reform on Medicare, which is the even bigger problem.
[1:03:29] Um, that signal sends, um, I think a shock wave through, um, the bond markets with probably the fear
[1:03:37] that they will be paid back, um, um, in, and, uh, with inflated money.
[1:03:43] And I think there is a chance that we see something like we've seen in, in, in 2021,
[1:03:48] but bigger where actually you see inflation rising before, before we've actually borrowed the last,
[1:03:58] the last dollars. So, and then of course, interest rates go up, um, and that doesn't help anyone.
[1:04:04] That doesn't help retirees. That doesn't help, uh, families. Inflation, Americans do not like inflation.
[1:04:11] Uh, higher interest, uh, interest rates make life more unaffordable as Americans have
[1:04:19] learned, um, you know, since 2021. So, it's, uh, it's not a solution.
[1:04:25] Thank you. Thank you. Senator Warner. Um, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I, I gotta tell you,
[1:04:30] I was shocked and disappointed, frankly, with your comments this morning on Social Security.
[1:04:37] You can't fix it. You just shut it down and hope you cover some of your money.
[1:04:43] No, I'm reading a quote from you on Fox News. You may want to say one thing on Fox News.
[1:04:47] I was talking about Ponzi. Excuse me. Let me have my time back. I think it's outrageous.
[1:04:52] Dr. Druzzi, you made a good point earlier. We don't want to scare the American public.
[1:05:00] This is outrageous scare tactics. The American people deserve better. This is totally predictable.
[1:05:08] We've known, in 2010, we had my first gang, the Gang of Six, included Mike Crapo, Tom Coburn,
[1:05:16] one of the best fiscal conservatives in the Congress, Saksby Chambers. We had a plan to fix this.
[1:05:22] It's math. You made the point. If you can't fix this one, you're never going to deal with Medicare in the
[1:05:27] other entitlements. Our plan was relatively simple. And the reason we need to do it now is the problem
[1:05:34] gets worse because the hole gets bigger. I mean, the irony of Social Security when he first put it
[1:05:40] together, and I will grant this, when Roosevelt put it in in 33 and said, gosh, you hit 65,
[1:05:45] you're going to get a check. It's not a bad deal because average life expectancy was 58 or 59.
[1:05:52] You outlive the odds, you're going to get money. But that's not the case. We want to make a political
[1:05:56] blame. Blame the doctors because we're all living longer. But to say we can't fix this is outrageous.
[1:06:05] There are three components. They've been the same since the bipartisan Gang of Six,
[1:06:10] building off Simpson Bowles, but still do the same. You can slightly adjust the age,
[1:06:15] the same way Tip O'Neill and Ronald Reagan did in 1983. And I'll get to the question in a moment.
[1:06:21] If you move, you know, over two years, slightly raising to 68 by 2050 and 69 by 2075, that gives
[1:06:33] you a lot of room. And I've yet to meet a young person under 35 that thinks they're going to get
[1:06:37] Social Security. And I've yet to hear anyone say, oh, don't touch that if you get a solemn promise.
[1:06:44] Second, we got to adjust the cap. You got to have more revenues, or it is a Ponzi screen. And, you know,
[1:06:54] a cap at $185,000 is, I don't think, fair. It's not equitable. There are ways to raise the cap,
[1:07:01] a variety of ways. You could raise that cap and then have a gap on not raising it too much for,
[1:07:06] you know, 250 to 500 and reassert the cap over a million. You could look at raising the cap on
[1:07:12] some of the capital gains, since more and more we see people not derive income or their wages from
[1:07:20] income, but from capital gains. There's a variety of ways. And one thing that I'm going to propose,
[1:07:24] and I'm looking forward to working with the incoming Chairman Cain on this, is we don't know
[1:07:29] with AI what life expectancy is going to look like. So I believe we ought to, whether we set it,
[1:07:37] the solvency rate at 50 or 60 or 75 years, we ought to say we're going to make it solvent for that
[1:07:45] period of time. And every 10 years, do an adjustment. And if Congress doesn't do an adjustment,
[1:07:51] they shouldn't get paid. You want to put a really enforceable requirement on fixing Social Security for
[1:07:58] every 10 years. Cut off the pay, maybe not so I can piss off everybody, not only to Congress,
[1:08:05] but staff as well. I mean, Social Security is the most solemn promise America has made,
[1:08:13] and it is imminently fixable. I do worry that, you know, if we try to do 75 years forever or some,
[1:08:20] you know, we can't predict a shorter solvency test with a mandatory fix every 10 years,
[1:08:29] with real teeth would make sense. But please, Mr. Chairman, and, you know, don't go out there
[1:08:37] scaring Americans to make political points on Fox News. This is too freaking important. You talk about,
[1:08:45] we got to be straight. This is math. This isn't policy changes that much. It's math.
[1:08:54] But you can't get, the one way you guarantee you can't get there, you raise the age, whatever,
[1:09:00] because I don't think anybody that's started a plan, that's why I say under 35, maybe be under 30,
[1:09:06] you know, should be, have that benefit taken away. But if anybody starts this, the one way it is a
[1:09:12] Ponzi scheme, if any of my Republican friends say, this program doesn't need more revenue,
[1:09:18] so we're not going to touch the cap, then you got a guaranteed freaking disaster. And if the whole
[1:09:24] no tax, no revenue crowd, then, Mr. Chairman, you're right, people should run for the exits.
[1:09:30] I think we're a better country than that. And I hope with a new majority, we'll have more reasonable
[1:09:36] partners to try to get this done. Because, you know, this is my last time. I'm not going before
[1:09:40] the voters again. I commit to get this done. We should all be penalized if we allow 2032 to hit,
[1:09:47] and 22% across the board cuts. That would be outrageous. We've known it. The time bomb is
[1:09:52] ticking. And we're going to need people to stop freaking posturing on their favorite cable show
[1:09:57] and actually come to the table with solutions. Thank you.
[1:10:00] Did you read the chairman's memo?
[1:10:03] I'm more interested in reading what you're saying in public airways.
[1:10:06] That's fine. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[1:10:06] You can't bother to read all the facts, but I would suggest you do that,
[1:10:09] and you'll know that that's not exactly what I was meaning. Senator Padilla.
[1:10:14] Thank you, Mr. Chair. I associate myself with the comments of several of my colleagues
[1:10:20] in calling out the outrageous comments of shutting down Social Security. I know you keep saying we're
[1:10:27] taking it out of context. It is a direct quote, and we can queue the video if we'd like. I'll tell
[1:10:33] you what else is outrageous, though. The timing of this. We're having a late in the second year of a
[1:10:39] congressional session post-election day hearing on the economic anxiety that maybe Americans are
[1:10:46] feeling about the the solvency of Social Security when, for the last two years, the President and
[1:10:54] the Republican majority have been doing only taking actions, only making economic anxiety worse.
[1:11:03] We want to talk about how, you know, why the deficit situation has gotten worse.
[1:11:08] We can point to the tariff policies. We can point to the Iran war, which is unauthorized and unpopular.
[1:11:14] We can talk about the cuts to health care overall, but no, they don't want to talk about that. They
[1:11:19] want to shift the blame here all of a sudden to Social Security. So let's call out the facts for what they
[1:11:29] are. When you cut taxes for the ultra-wealthy and the largest corporations, and you cut health care
[1:11:38] access, that's where we ought to be looking. Because there's, when the President wants it,
[1:11:45] there seems to be money for a war. The Congress is not authorized, but there's not money to address
[1:11:49] Social Security. There's money for a war and tax breaks for the most wealthy, but there's not money
[1:11:56] for health care, for working families in America, or to buttress Social Security. That's the contrast.
[1:12:04] That's the contrast, and that's the frame for this conversation. Now, to Social Security more
[1:12:09] specifically. The administration has claimed a big win. No taxes on Social Security this hit,
[1:12:16] through the Anything But Beautiful Bill Act. But the truth is that the substantial majority
[1:12:22] of low- and middle-income seniors will not benefit from this new tax deduction. Nor will Social Security
[1:12:29] beneficiaries younger than 65, including people with disabilities and those on survivor benefits.
[1:12:36] And of course, the deduction fails to compensate for the drastic cuts to health care and food assistance
[1:12:41] in the Anything But Beautiful Bill that have left millions of lower-income seniors worse off. Question for
[1:12:47] Mr. Edwards. Can you shed a little bit more light and specificity on how the Anything But Beautiful
[1:12:54] Bill impacted Social Security solvency? It was an unfunded tax cut to Social Security's revenue,
[1:13:03] so it moved up the insolvency date, or moved up the trust fund depletion date. So the Anything But
[1:13:10] Beautiful Bill, that's my name for it, not the other people's name for it, made this problem worse? Yes,
[1:13:16] it moved up trust fund depletion because it cut Social Security's revenue without making up for it in any
[1:13:21] either. So that doesn't sound very beautiful to me, if you genuinely cared about this. Let me, I know my time
[1:13:28] is running quickly here, just to ask you to comment on the contribution of immigrant workers to the
[1:13:35] system. It came up in the last discussion we had here in committee on Social Security, as you know,
[1:13:40] but I'll have you articulate in your words, so many workers in the United States who are not citizens,
[1:13:48] different immigration status, who pay into Social Security but cannot benefit from Social Security.
[1:13:54] This administration, the Republican majority, has been hell-bent on trying to crack down and deport
[1:14:01] so many immigrant workers, whether they're undocumented, many with work permits, many legal
[1:14:05] permanent residents. Is that helping address the solvency concern for Social Security? Yes, no, and how so?
[1:14:13] Immigrants, whether they are unauthorized or authorized, pay into Social Security
[1:14:17] and are an unequivocal windfall for its bottom line. Thank you, appreciate the succinct answer. Mr.
[1:14:24] Chair, I'd like to submit for the record two reports, one from the Cato Institute, Immigrants'
[1:14:32] Historical Effects on Government's Budgets from 1900 to 2023, as well as an article from Bloomberg
[1:14:39] Government. I think the title says it all, undocumented immigrants are well documented,
[1:14:44] just ask the IRS. Without objection. Thank you, thank you all. I think we are waiting for Senator
[1:14:53] Lujan. Senator Kennedy, do you have any closing statements? Well, if we're waiting for Senator
[1:14:59] Lujan, and there's also a vote on that we need to go and vote on, but I think the point that my
[1:15:05] colleague Senator Padilla raised is a good one, and I know one other commonality between at least
[1:15:11] Dr. Fichtner and Dr. Edwards' testimony, the idea of broadening the base, if you could broaden the base,
[1:15:17] and okay, I've got three for three on that, that is an issue. The fact that the way people make income
[1:15:24] has shifted from wage and salary subject to Social Security taxes to other forms that are less subject
[1:15:29] to, and so if we're going to try to update broadening the base, and maybe you can broaden the base and
[1:15:34] lower some of the rates, or you can broaden the base without lowering the rates, but then, you know,
[1:15:39] guarantee solvency in that way. I like seeing that commonality three for three. I won't ask you to
[1:15:46] comment because Yahweh has arrived. We get a chance later, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate
[1:15:55] the responses from the panelists with the questioning from Senator Kane. What I heard from each of you is
[1:16:03] that Social Security should be fixed. Is that accurate, Dr. Edwards? 100%. Yes, sir. Yes, I appreciate that.
[1:16:13] There's been a lot that has been said today. What I was surprised by is how this hearing was previewed
[1:16:21] this morning. What was shared with me was a transcript from an interview at 830 this morning on
[1:16:28] Big Money in the Morning, Fox Business Networks. I missed it. I didn't watch it live, but I have
[1:16:36] the transcript, and in it, a Senate Republican leader said clearly that George W. Bush would be in a lot
[1:16:50] better shape if he would have privatized Social Security back then. It also said that it reads that
[1:17:01] Ronald Reagan and Tip O'Neill, if they would have acknowledged this is a Ponzi scheme, that things
[1:17:09] would be better. This being Social Security, the interview is about Social Security. The person
[1:17:16] conducting the interview is a gentleman by the name of Brian Brenberg. Now that I went to votes, I was
[1:17:24] looking on social media. The interview is all over social media, so there's there's something magical
[1:17:30] about watching videos. The words are said, and I'm not talking about one or two lines out of the
[1:17:41] interview. Listen to the whole thing. The segment of the interview at this point referencing Social
[1:17:48] Security said, again, this is a scam. It's grotesque. At this point, there is really no way to fix Social
[1:17:57] Security. It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it, cannot, can't. Sometimes my accent gets in the way
[1:18:05] of how I can communicate with others. The leader then went on to say, you just shut it down and you
[1:18:14] hope you can recover some of your money. So look, I have some technical questions. I'll submit them into
[1:18:22] the record. I agree that seniors should not be getting scared, that politicians need to be aware
[1:18:31] of words that we use to suggest that Social Security cannot be fixed. And then to, I know I'm going to
[1:18:41] be corrected in just a little bit, then to say that's not really what was said. Watch the interview.
[1:18:52] Three PhDs here, two of them coming from conservative think tanks, all have said Social Security should
[1:19:05] be fixed. Now you might have different ways of fixing it. One thing I appreciate about Democrats,
[1:19:12] Republicans, Libertarian friends, things of that nature is oftentimes we have the same values and the
[1:19:20] same goals. There's just a different way of getting there. But if the Republican position in the United
[1:19:30] States Senate now is Social Security cannot be fixed, there's a problem. We don't have shared values.
[1:19:37] And so, look, I'm not new to the Senate. I'm not new to the House. And I run a few campaigns. And you
[1:19:47] know, there's all kinds of training and people teach you how to spin what you said when you put your foot
[1:19:51] in your mouth. And then you're trying to say, oh, no, no, no, that's not what I conveyed. You're putting
[1:19:57] words in my mouth. I just think we need to be more thoughtful in how we communicate to the American
[1:20:04] people about protecting and fixing Social Security. I don't know about the constituents in other states,
[1:20:10] but constituents in my state are having a heck of a time. And I'm talking about folks that have not
[1:20:18] made $10 million or $50 million or $100 million. These are folks that are working every day,
[1:20:24] some of them paycheck to paycheck, trying to get into the middle class. Diesel's over six bucks.
[1:20:31] I think it just went under six back in New Mexico. But it's still hurting our ranchers and our farmers.
[1:20:36] Food's more expensive for many reasons. We've got to get this one done. And I certainly hope that even
[1:20:42] though several of my Republican colleagues may have a different path and approach to fixing Social
[1:20:48] Security, that we can indeed agree Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. It needs to be fixed. It
[1:20:55] needs to be protected. And it does not need to be privatized. Thank you for the time. And I would
[1:21:03] ask you, did you read the chairman's memo? Just, just Mr. Chairman, did you? I'm just asking, you know,
[1:21:11] I watched your interview at 830 this morning. So the person I was referencing, because I didn't say it out,
[1:21:16] Mr. Chairman, it was your interview, Senator Johnson, your interview on Fox News business
[1:21:21] this morning saying that Social Security cannot be fixed and all the rest. So if I'd ask unanimous
[1:21:27] consent to submit the transcript into the record so it can complement the chairman's memo.
[1:21:31] That's fine. Again, I've admitted to- If there's no objection, is that allowed?
[1:21:35] I've no objection. I've admitted to a less than precise comment. But if you read the chairman's memo,
[1:21:42] obviously, I'm not suggesting we should end it. The point I was making, Ponzi schemes can't be
[1:21:50] fixed. I've even gone into the fact that, you know, Social Security is obviously different from that,
[1:21:55] because a Ponzi scheme, once it's discovered, they don't get new investors. You know, we continue to
[1:22:02] have people pay into this. My broader point is, even if we fix it, you got 80% of the deficit still
[1:22:10] remaining, and we fixed nothing. That's my broader point. But you'd have to read the memo,
[1:22:16] as opposed to pouncing on imprecise, admittedly imprecise comments. Mr. Chairman, you can describe
[1:22:22] your comments as imprecise and all the rest of you like. I'm admitting to imprecise comments.
[1:22:26] I am in no way, shape, or form suggesting we shut it down. What I suggested the solution would be,
[1:22:33] right in my opening comment, we should pass a law to make sure that benefits are never reduced.
[1:22:39] Mr. Chairman? That's somebody who's proposing to me. But again, the only way we can honor those
[1:22:44] promises is if we address the overall deficit problem, because even if you fix Social Security,
[1:22:51] it's 20% of the problem. You've got 80% sitting over there. You spend all this time and angst and
[1:22:57] political capital trying to fix, trying to understand the problem, it'll still blow up in your face.
[1:23:02] That's my broader point. Again, I admit to imprecise language on an interview this morning. Got it.
[1:23:09] I'll be paying the price for that. I got it. But what I'm trying to do in my short time as chairman,
[1:23:16] I'm just trying to lay out the facts, which is why I asked the Democrat witness. In the chairman's
[1:23:20] memo, anything you disagree with? Anything inaccurate? If there is, let me know. We'll change.
[1:23:27] I'm going to do a larger report that I'm going to offer in December. The U.S. federal budget,
[1:23:33] the reality. Just laying out facts. Because you never solve a problem if you don't first admit
[1:23:39] you have one. And then secondly, understand the reality of it. And I agree with Senator Cain. We
[1:23:45] said, you know, the reason there's, I said it right up front, I realize calling it a Ponzi scheme
[1:23:50] offends people. I got it. You know, I agree. We need to honor those promises. We're not going to be
[1:23:57] able to honor those promises if we don't look at the whole problem. Folks, if we just fixate on 20%
[1:24:04] with, and we can argue about this, I think very damaging, destructive solutions. And raising taxes
[1:24:11] has never particularly worked. Okay? But anyway, that's the point. Again, I'm sure you'll keep using
[1:24:17] this, you know, my imprecise comments against me. I would ask you to just read the chairman's memo.
[1:24:22] Mr. Chairman, I know, when I did not use them against you, I just shared the comments with
[1:24:28] everyone here. You, I think shared with everyone that it was you that shared them. I did not do
[1:24:36] that. But now they're in the records. Everyone can take a look at them. I appreciate it. I got it.
[1:24:40] I'm saying read the chairman's memo. You'll understand exactly what I meant. And the proposal
[1:24:45] would be, not shutting down Social Security, the proposal would be, let's pass a law that prevents
[1:24:51] benefits from being reduced. And then let's roll up our sleeves. And let's work on the big problem,
[1:24:56] which is $24 trillion in deficits. Let's not add more government programs that,
[1:25:01] you know, are just as fraudulent as some of the ones we're seeing, for example, Minnesota.
[1:25:05] Again, so we can have this conversation, we can be honest about it, and we can,
[1:25:11] or we can just hop on an imprecise comment and blow it up, which is what's going to happen. I got it.
[1:25:15] You know, I realize I'm making myself a lightning ride here, but the only way people are going to
[1:25:22] watch this hearing is what we talked about is the legal Ponzi screen. Otherwise, we've had hearing
[1:25:28] after hearing. Nobody pays attention. Maybe now the American people pay attention. If I got to pay a
[1:25:32] political price for that, that's fine. I really don't care. I'd rather go home. I think that's
[1:25:39] enough for this hearing. We've got to do some votes. I want to thank the witnesses for appearing
[1:25:44] before the committee today. The hearing record will remain open until 2 p.m. tomorrow for the submission of
[1:25:48] statements and questions for the record to the committee clerk. The hearing is adjourned.
[1:25:52] Thank you.