About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Robles asks if Pagayunan can testify on legitimacy of CALE88 as a business — ANC from ANC 24/7, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 2,162 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Please. Ma'am, para lang po magka-idea kami, no? Based on our open source research, kayo po ay karir official ng FDA, di po ba? 23 years na po yata kayo. Actually, in the government service, I'm 36 years already. But in the FDA, started in 2000. Okay. 26 years? Yeah. Okay. Salamat po sa servisyo..."
[0:00] Please.
[0:01] Ma'am, para lang po magka-idea kami, no?
[0:06] Based on our open source research,
[0:10] kayo po ay karir official ng FDA, di po ba?
[0:13] 23 years na po yata kayo.
[0:16] Actually, in the government service, I'm 36 years already.
[0:20] But in the FDA, started in 2000.
[0:24] Okay. 26 years?
[0:26] Yeah.
[0:26] Okay. Salamat po sa servisyo niyo.
[0:29] Yes, government service.
[0:31] I hope you understand. I have to ask you some questions as part of my job.
[0:37] So kung pwede pong answerable by yes or no, sagutin niyo po ng yes or no.
[0:43] Ngayon, kung may kailangan ipaliwanag, I'm sure bibigyan po kayo ng opportunity
[0:47] ng counsel for the respondents.
[0:50] Ngayon, kung hindi niyo alam yung sagot or hindi niyo kayang ipaliwanag,
[0:53] pakisabi na lang po para hindi natin i-extend pa po yung discussion.
[1:00] So ang una po po ang tanong, yung pong proseso ng pag-apply ng Certificate of Product
[1:08] Registration, di po ba parang lumalabas na two-stage process po yan, di po ba?
[1:15] Kailangan muna meron kang license to operate. Tama po ba?
[1:20] Opo, Your Honor, because the license to operate is one of the requirements for product registration.
[1:26] So kailangan muna, i-rehistro mo yung factory.
[1:32] That's what you called food establishment.
[1:35] Yes.
[1:35] So it can be manufacturing.
[1:37] Oo.
[1:38] Ngayon po, so kaya po napansin ko, ang sinubit yung dokumento, dalawang set po ito,
[1:48] tapos dalawa yung Certificate of Product Registration.
[1:52] Isa po yung for export, isa po yung for local. Tama po ba?
[1:56] Yes, Your Honor.
[1:57] At kasama po, dun sa ano, can we request the tech to project the two Certificate of Product Registration?
[2:08] So ito po yung dalawang Certificate of Product Registration.
[2:13] Medyo maliit po yung sulat, yung ano, no?
[2:17] Pero babasahin ko na lang po.
[2:18] Yung una, ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration,
[2:23] Calyes Sweetened Banana Chips, with FDR Registration Number, FR-400-900-4164.
[2:40] Ito po yata yung para sa local. Tama po ba?
[2:44] Yes, Your Honor.
[2:45] Apo. Kayo po yung nakapirma. Tama po?
[2:47] Yes, Your Honor.
[2:48] Parang two pages po ito, hindi po ba?
[2:52] Yes.
[2:55] Ngayon, yung pangalawa, ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration na nakalagay, raw material,
[3:07] Calyes Sweetened Banana Chips for Export Market Only.
[3:12] Ito po yung FR-400-00-9768-567. Tama po?
[3:22] Yes, Your Honor.
[3:22] Ang tanong ko po, assuming na merong license to operate yung isang company, no?
[3:32] At mag-apply sila ng Certificate of Product Registration for processed foods,
[3:39] gano po katagal normally tumatagal yung pag-proseso ng opisina nyo bago mag-issue ng ano?
[3:46] On the average po?
[3:48] We have the... Yes, Your Honor.
[3:50] So I will... Our objective or our target is we have to follow the ease of doing business timeline.
[3:59] So it should be like for us, our target is 20 days.
[4:03] 20 days.
[4:04] For the Center for Food Regulation and Research, the timeline now starts at when the payment was posted.
[4:11] And it will be... Kasi may payment pa po yun, Sir, Your Honor.
[4:16] So it will... The process kasi is online.
[4:19] So it will not be forwarded to the Center for Food for Evaluation if this application has not been...
[4:28] The payment has not been posted.
[4:29] So that's the existing...
[4:31] Ang tanong ko po, Ma'am, kasi sinasabi nyo payment, ibig sabihin that was pre-cleared already.
[4:38] Yeah, it was pre-assessed.
[4:40] Pero ang normal po is, let's say, bago po akong kumpanya, na meron akong license to operate,
[4:46] nag-apply po ako ng Certificate of Product Registration.
[4:48] On the average, from the time I file my application, up to the time ma-issue yung Certificate of Product Registration,
[4:56] ano po yung common experience?
[4:57] Normally, gaano po katagal?
[5:00] Gaano katagal, Sir, Your Honor?
[5:02] Bago ma-process at ma-approve.
[5:03] Yeah, we always target on 20 days, but because there is an influx of application, then we have some backlog.
[5:12] Yun po yung tanong ko.
[5:13] Gaano po katagal, on the average?
[5:15] On the average, like...
[5:16] Considering your backlog.
[5:19] Maybe like 30 days maximum.
[5:22] 30 days.
[5:23] Mga ganun po.
[5:24] Anyway, so, ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration.
[5:29] Napansin ko po, may inattached din po kayo dito sa parehong set ng documents.
[5:39] Meron pong license to operate na inattached kayo.
[5:43] Ay, we attach even if it's not submitted by the company because what was testified is all the documents that was submitted
[5:53] because it's already in the system of FDA, the license to operate, so para lang makita ko.
[5:59] So, in effect, can we go to the next slide, please?
[6:04] Ito pong license to operate na to, kaya nyo isinattached, sinasabi nyo na ito yung license to operate ng kumpanya in support of the requirements of the application.
[6:16] Tama po ba?
[6:17] Yes, because the license to operate that was attached, that it means na valid, it was renewed.
[6:26] Hindi, at tinatanong ko po, ito po ba yung license to operate in support of the application?
[6:33] During the time that the CPR was applied, ang LTO po nilang na nakalagay doon sa, naka-indicate po sa CPR, is yung iba po yung LTO number.
[6:48] Nasaan po kaya yun?
[6:50] Doon po.
[6:50] Nandun sa records namin, sir, but…
[6:53] Bakit po itong inattach nyo, eh?
[6:55] Yun yung supposedly yung kasama ng application?
[6:57] Eh, sir, kasi expired na siya because the validity ng LTO is until October 9, 2022.
[7:06] So, ang tanong ko po, ito po ba o hindi ang LTO na in support of the application?
[7:13] Hindi po siya yung LTO. In support ng application during that time, the application was filed because the license to operate number there is 855-7334.
[7:31] And the expiry date is until October 9, 2022.
[7:38] So, the company has filed for the renewal.
[7:41] Opo. So, ito po kasi, contrary to what you're saying, ang nakalagay po dito, October 9, 2027.
[7:50] Because it was already renewed.
[7:52] Before you answer, Ma'am Marilyn, Attorney Justin?
[7:55] Yes, Your Honor.
[7:56] We are just objecting, Your Honor, because we're just confused since the prosecution has already stipulated that Cali 88 Foods Corporation is already compliant in relation to its application for a certificate of food registration.
[8:17] No, no, Your Honor.
[8:17] The line of questioning appears to be on the question.
[8:23] Secondly, Your Honor, we're pertaining to a renewal, Your Honor.
[8:26] So, we do not see.
[8:28] It appears to be inconsistent, Your Honor.
[8:30] On one hand, they were stipulating.
[8:32] Allow him to finish.
[8:33] On the other hand, they are now questioning the compliance and the assessment made by the FDA.
[8:40] Your Honor, what we stipulated on is that they submitted the requirements.
[8:46] And the CPR was issued in the report.
[8:48] We request a back rate, Your Honor.
[8:50] Now, Your Honor, what we are asking the witness is regarding the supporting documents.
[8:56] We would just like to know if the proper supporting documents were submitted because, as the witness said, before a CPR is issued, a valid license to operate must exist.
[9:08] And we are looking at this license to operate, Your Honor, and it does not have a date of issuance.
[9:16] Yes, Your Honor.
[9:17] So, can we just be allowed to ask the witness regarding this so that she can explain?
[9:23] Just then, I'll allow it and then move to your next point, Attorney Ray.
[9:28] Yes, Your Honor.
[9:28] But given the statement of Attorney Ray, of the extent of his stipulation, we request a back read of the transcript right now to confront him with the exact stipulations he made.
[9:40] Because otherwise, if that is his position, we have been misled in giving up our direct examination and will ask that we be allowed to reconduct the same, Your Honor.
[9:49] This is all fairness, Your Honor.
[9:50] We ask a back read of the transcript of stenographic notes and the exact wording that were uttered from the mouth of Attorney Ray, just for fairness, Your Honor.
[10:00] Attorney Ray, you stipulated that Cal 88 complied with all the requirements of the FDA and that the permits and licenses were duly issued in accordance with law.
[10:17] I remember my exact words, submitted all of the requirements and they were issued.
[10:22] So, now you're questioning what?
[10:24] No, Your Honor.
[10:24] I'm just trying to clarify from the witness because the document does not state when the LTO was issued.
[10:33] And if you get a date or not a date, so?
[10:36] Then we can, the court would be informed if the requirements were properly complied with.
[10:44] Your Honor, we ask a back read of the DSM.
[10:47] Precisely, precisely, counsel, you stipulated that...
[10:52] They submitted the requirements and the CPR was issued.
[10:55] No, we request a back read, Your Honor.
[10:57] In due course.
[10:58] Yes, Your Honor.
[10:59] And that they complied, I think Attorney Justin asked for that they complied with the requirements of the FDA and that therefore the license was issued in due course.
[11:09] Well, we're trying to clarify this particular document, Your Honor.
[11:13] This is my only other point, Your Honor.
[11:16] After this, I'll move on, Your Honor.
[11:19] I'd rather that you move on, counsel.
[11:22] Move on to your next point.
[11:23] Ngayon, ang isa pong, Ma'am Pilar, ang isa pong punto na sinasabi po ng prosecution,
[11:32] kaya kayo pinresenta, kasi daw po, kayo ay tetestigo na ang Calye 88 Food Corporation ay engaged sa lawful, legitimate export business of sweetened banana chips.
[11:48] Ang tanong ko po, after po ma-issue itong Certificate of Product Registration, minonitor niyo po ba yung negosyo ng Calye 88?
[11:59] Your Honor, that's not part of our job because safety quality yung aming proseso sa pag-evaluate po ng application.
[12:12] So, hindi niyo po matestatistiguhan na lawful, legitimate ang negosyo ng Calye 88 at hindi niyo rin po mapapasinungalingan yun, di po ba?
[12:24] Kasi hindi niyo naman binantayan ang operations nila. Tama po?
[12:30] Kindly answer through the mic, Ma'am. Don't just shake your head.
[12:33] Tama po.
[12:35] Hindi. Ulitin ko po, Your Honor, na hindi po kasama yun sa trabaho namin.
[12:40] So, hindi po akong makasag-inlay part ng job.
[12:45] Your Honor, I am just asking the witness because the purpose said that she will testify that the Calye 88 is engaged in lawful export business.
[12:56] So, I am trying to clarify if she can. Now, the other ano, hindi niyo rin po masasabi kung totoong nagmanufacture ng banana chips for export ang Calye 88.
[13:10] Can we allow Attorney Ray?
[13:12] We are now really confused, Your Honor, and it is at this point that we will respectfully insist a back-read and production of the transcript of stenographic notes
[13:21] because the direction of Attorney Ray's cross-examination is diametrically opposed to his previous stipulations, Your Honor.
[13:30] This is the only other point, Your Honor.
[13:31] We have to be able to be clarified of the extent of the stipulations.
[13:34] This has nothing to do with the certificate of product registration examination, Your Honor.
[13:39] This is not a debate. Kindly allow Attorney Justin to finish and then I'll allow you to comment.
[13:43] We are just asking, Your Honor, that the extent and the words uttered by Attorney Ray be produced through a back-read of stenographic notes
[13:51] which I'm sure Attorney Ray understands is normal in court proceedings and in courts of record
[13:57] for us to exactly know the extent of the stipulations.
[14:00] And his response to our request of clarification, the reason being, Your Honor, is because we withdrew our direct examination precisely
[14:09] of the extent of the stipulations.
[14:14] Otherwise, we already expressed our intent to continue with our direct examination, Your Honor.
[14:21] Our objection right now, and I hope Attorney Ray would allow me to finish,
[14:25] is that the track of his cross-examination is diametrically opposed to the previous stipulations he already made.
[14:33] Can I be allowed now, Your Honor, to say my piece?
[14:36] Are you done, Your Honor?
[14:37] We just asked that the records be clarified.
[14:40] My questions now have nothing to do with the stipulation.
[14:43] I am asking the witness, after the issue once of the certificate of product registration,
[14:50] did she keep track of the business?
[14:52] Your Honor, I think that's even part of the stipulations that the extent of production
[14:57] which was offered by the presiding officer, the tonnage, is outside the competence of the witness, Your Honor.
[15:03] I would have to sustain the objection.
[15:07] Forgive me, Attorney Justin, short of a back-read.
[15:09] I'm still getting a copy of the TSN.
[15:11] Apologies, sir.
[15:11] I would have to sustain the objection, Attorney Ray,
[15:14] on the ground that it has already been asked and answered specifically by the presiding officer
[15:19] that the witness would not be qualified to testify as to whether or not these were actually manufactured
[15:27] and or sold and as to the quantities produced and or quantities sold, locally or internationally.
[15:33] So the witness will not be able to answer that, sir?
[15:35] Yes, the witness would not be able to answer that.
[15:37] Your Honor, I'm ending my cross.
[15:39] Thank you.
[15:40] And I redirect, Attorney Justin.
[15:42] None, Your Honor.
[15:43] But we just request an appropriate time for the back-read just so for our copy.
[15:48] As soon as I get it.
[15:49] As soon as I get the complete set.
[15:50] We will do that before we direct.
[15:51] No redirect examination.
[15:53] If there are no interjections...