Try Free

Prosecutor Cross-Exams Lindsay Clancy's Psychologist Paul Zeizel

Meghann Cuniff November 16, 2026 1h 33m 12,122 words 2 views
▶ Watch original video

About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Prosecutor Cross-Exams Lindsay Clancy's Psychologist Paul Zeizel from Meghann Cuniff, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 12,122 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.

"Good morning sir. Good morning. So yesterday when you first took the stand Attorney Reddington asked you a little bit about your background. Recall that? Yes. And you in this in this field of being a psychologist and a forensic psychologist you circulate a curriculum vitae where all that is..."

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Good morning sir. Good morning. So yesterday when you first took the stand Attorney Reddington asked you a little bit about your background. Recall that? Yes. And you in this in this field of being a psychologist and a forensic psychologist you circulate a curriculum vitae where all that is outlined right? Yes. And fair to say you testified yesterday and on your curriculum vitae you speak briefly about the fact that you have previously testified for the Commonwealth you said as well as for the defense correct? Yes. You referred to defendants and respondents right? Yes. And so one of the things that you've done in the past is to be what's called a qualified examiner right? Yes. You aren't currently not actively doing those examinations are you? I actually have done one but I don't actively do that anymore. Okay and so in those respects is that when you say you testify for the Commonwealth is that primarily the work that you would do where you say you testify for the Commonwealth? Yes. And in those evaluations that you do is it fair to say that you're actually an independent contractor with a company that contracts with the Department of [00:01:36] Kelly Ryan: Correction on those cases? Those are what qualified examiners are that's correct that's how you become a qualified examiner three through the DOC. Right and [00:01:45] Speaker 1: you're an examiner qualified examiner is retained or takes work in doing evaluations in order to perform independent assessments are they not? Yes. So they're [00:01:57] Kelly Ryan: not hired by the Commonwealth? They are because the company that retains the qualified examiners is hired by the Commonwealth and these forensic psychologists are then appointed cases to do these types of examinations. So it's under the big [00:02:16] Speaker 1: umbrella of the Commonwealth. So yeah big umbrella Commonwealth meaning Department of Correction an agency that is under the seal of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. But as far as when we talk about Commonwealth like Commonwealth versus Lindsay Clancy that's the prosecution in those proceedings the Department of Correction sometimes is the moving party, right? Yes. And sometimes it's the district attorney's office who's the moving party. Yes. But it's never the defendant who's the moving party. Never. And in those types of proceedings sometimes if you opine a person is what they call sexually dangerous you would testify for the Commonwealth, right? Yes. And if they're not or if you find that they're not sexually dangerous you'd testify for the respondent. Yes we're neutral. So you're not testifying for the Commonwealth. You're as in the prosecution you're testifying under the big umbrella of the Commonwealth. I think it's a matter of [00:03:15] Kelly Ryan: semantics because if you do an evaluation and you render an opinion that this patient is sexually dangerous when you testify you are working with the district attorney's office and you review your case with the DA and the way I see it is that you're testifying for the Commonwealth as an independent examiner but on that day you're testifying for the Commonwealth or that DA's office. And you haven't done [00:03:43] Speaker 1: that work in closely rough a decade fair to say? No that's not true. Well pre-pandemic correct? That's not true. So when was the last time you testified for the Commonwealth meaning the prosecution in an SDP proceeding? So I was assigned a case through [00:04:04] Kelly Ryan: Suffolk County the sexual dangerous dangerousness unit by ADA Kelly Ryan K-E-L-L-Y and I did that evaluation on July 2nd 2026. And have you testified at a probable cause hearing for that? No I wrote a report which was in lieu of testifying. Where you [00:04:27] Speaker 1: opine that somebody was sexually dangerous? Yes. Okay. Fair to say though the majority of your work here in Massachusetts over the last few years is contracted with the Committee for Public Council Services correct? Yes. And for the fiscal year of 2024 you were paid by CPCS in the open checkbook for approximately $340,000 worth of time and work. That's about [00:04:54] Kelly Ryan: right. We get paid a fixed rate. It's a government rate that's assigned to all examiners. And for [00:05:01] Speaker 1: the fiscal year of 2025 it was approximately $300,000 that you were paid through the Committee Public Council Services. That sounds about right. You also indicated yesterday that you have known Attorney Reddington for a number of years correct? Yes. Fair to say you've done quite a bit of work [00:05:21] Kelly Ryan: with him over the years? That's an expansive term but I work with him. It just requires a yes or a no? Yes. Okay. [00:05:31] Speaker 1: Um and you've also testified that um you have your doctorate in clinical psychology right? Yes. And you testified yesterday or you told us a lot about um your military experience but as you sit here today you are not um a prescriber of medications here in the Commonwealth are you? I am not and I was not yesterday either when I was asked about that. Right. You just you told us all about your experience in the military and having that limited ability to prescribe years ago but as far as you sit here today and in your evaluations that you do today you don't um do forensic psychiatry evaluations do you? [00:06:11] Kelly Ryan: I just that's correct but I just want to clarify for a point of accuracy I was not in the military I [00:06:17] Speaker 1: worked for the department of state. I I believe I said your work with the military but thank you um so in um here in Massachusetts you conduct primarily forensic psychology or you conduct evaluations in forensic psychology correct? Yes for the most part. Okay um and you um are aware that there are particular standards um for forensic psychologists um working within [00:06:50] Kelly Ryan: the criminal justice system right? Yes but just to be a little more clear uh forensic psychologists such as myself also work for police departments doing evaluations for fitness for duty so although though they're law enforcement they're not engaged or accused of any criminal activity. Well I'm referring to your [00:07:13] Speaker 1: role when you come into the court and you testify as you are today as a forensic psychologist that's what I'm referring to you're aware that there are particular standards in place by um the ABA criminal justice mental health standards is one of them right you're familiar with that? Yes. And you're familiar with the American Psychological Association's specialty guidelines for forensic psychology? Yes. And fair to say that with those standards they're not required but people are um encouraged to follow them right? I think that's fair to say. And the criminal justice the ABA criminal justice mental health standards actually identify um the different types of roles that um forensic evaluators have in the criminal justice system including evaluating consulting and treating right? Yes. And so um fair to say standard 7-1.3 indicates that for evaluative evaluative experts the obligation is to make a thorough and impartial assessment based on sound evaluative methods to reach an objective opinion. Would you agree with that? Yes. And so um again in the American psychological association specialty guidelines um section 1.02 indicates that forensic practitioners strive to be unbiased and impartial and avoid partisan presentations of unrepresentative incomplete or inaccurate evidence. Would you agree with that? Yes. Is that a standard you um strive to follow? Yes. Okay um in this case you indicated that um you've been with the case since February 4th of the year 2023 correct? Yes 41 months. And um you've authored a report you said in july um June I believe of 2026 correct? Yes. But you've also um offered other reports or updates of the defendant's condition over the years is that fair to say? Yes. And you um uh provided a report an update I should say in july of 2025. Yes. Do you recall that? Yes. And in that report you identify that as of july 23rd 2025 that um the defendant was residing at Tewksbury hospital do you recall that putting that in? Yes. Yes. And that um there was a planned transfer to Worcester recovery hospital or a Worcester recovery center and hospital do you recall writing that? [00:09:55] Kelly Ryan: I don't know if it was a plan it was a hope and a goal but it was not a official plan. Well I can [00:10:02] Speaker 1: provide you with your report if you'd like to review but it reads currently Miss Clancy resides at Tewksbury hospital with a planned transfer to Worcester recovery center and hospital. That sounds right. Yes. Okay. And that she is presently medication stabilized and is in the process of discontinuing most if not all psychotropic medications demonstrating an emerging capacity to stabilize without them. Do you recall writing that? Yes. So in july of 2025 um it was your opinion that she was stable and she would be um hopefully as you say transferred to a different facility correct? Yes. And you're aware that currently she's still at Tewksbury hospital? Yes. And currently she's still taking psychotropic medications? That's true. Yes. I think you also um right in that report I'll strike that um going back to your most recent evaluation in June of 2026 you would agree with me that um in an evaluation for criminal responsibility being a forensic psychologist it's really important to be as accurate as possible in um your reports correct? Yes. Um you want to make sure you get the facts right right? Yes. Because your evaluation is not just based on what you learn from the individual you're evaluating but also an independent review an unbiased review of the records of the facts. Is that fair to say? Yes. Okay. So in your um report you indicate that the period of evaluation that you had with this individual is approximately 45 hours. Do you recall [00:11:55] Kelly Ryan: writing that and testifying about that yesterday? I think I actually said I've met with her a total of 45 hours but the evaluation was more than 35 hours and I think it was 37 hours. Okay and you also said [00:12:07] Speaker 1: yesterday that in addition to that you've met with her several other times for a total of approximately 60 [00:12:13] Kelly Ryan: times at least? Not 60 additional times but in total yes since the court trial has started a few weeks [00:12:20] Speaker 1: back. Okay. Is that typical for you to spend 35 hours with the person that you're evaluating? It does happen but it's not typical. You also indicated um yesterday that one of how you became involved in this case is attorney Reddington called you and asked you to go check on the I think you said mental well-being [00:12:46] Kelly Ryan: is that what your mental health and mental well-being at the time of her admittance to Breedman Women's [00:12:54] Speaker 1: Hospital which was roughly late January 2023. And your first time there was February 4th correct? Yes. Were you [00:13:07] Kelly Ryan: examining her as a potential patient at that point? I was examining her as a colleague and friend of attorney Reddington to see how she was faring. There was no predetermined notion whether I would be interested or willing or even offered the opportunity to take the case. I was just going to meet with her given the fact that she was in a bed in ICU locked to the bed frame and no one was able to visit her. [00:13:44] Speaker 1: So you went in to visit her? Yes. And when you went in to visit her you indicated that she had recently been extubated in your testimony yesterday. You're aware from the review of the records that she [00:13:57] Kelly Ryan: was extubated on January 28th? Yes. So the difference between January 28th and February 4th. I didn't know the date at that time but I knew she was able to breathe on her own and express verbal language. Yes, [00:14:14] Speaker 1: expressive language. You're aware that she had been communicating with staff at the hospital including [00:14:19] Kelly Ryan: psychiatrists, right? I don't know if I knew at that time but I knew she had been speaking with the doctors [00:14:26] Speaker 1: and staff. Well, but not specifically who it was. A person who goes through major trauma and is at a hospital and has made suicidal attempts. In your opinion, it would behoove the hospital to have that person to talk to a psychiatrist, correct? Yes. Overall. Yes. Now, in addition to meeting with the staff and the psychiatry team, prior to your arrival, were you aware that she had an attorney that had came to visit her a few times? Not Mr. Reddington, [00:15:02] Kelly Ryan: but a different attorney. Yes, I don't know how many times but I am aware that there was an attorney, [00:15:06] Speaker 1: Gelb, who was somehow involved in the case. Okay, so there was somebody that came in to see her prior to you coming in to see her. Yes. Now, you testified yesterday that you performed a mental status exam that day on February 4th. Do you recall that? I do. Where in your report or the previous report from July or your June report do you outline the results of your mental status exam? There is none because if [00:15:36] Kelly Ryan: someone's not capable of just explaining who they are, where they are, and if they're clear of mentition and thinking that I'll meet with them. But if they're not, I won't. So it's a, it's a sin qua non. It's you do that just to make sure you can keep meeting with them and that they are able to understand what you're [00:15:54] Speaker 1: talking about. Standard practice. But you indicated yesterday that she didn't know who she was, right? Yes. She didn't know where she was. Yes. But I believe your testimony was that she did remember what happened but she was foggy as to what happened. Yes, that's correct. And she actually, according to your testimony yesterday, asked you for your phone or to access your phone to make a phone call. Is that correct? Yes. So she was able to communicate with you. Yes. She asked you for something and you clearly understood what she was asking for. Yes. And you indicated that she asked to call her husband, right? Yes. Had you spoken with her husband before that time? I didn't, did not speak [00:16:36] Kelly Ryan: with him at that time. I didn't know him and I had not spoken to him prior to that time. So how'd you get the phone number to call him? I did not have the phone number to call. So she provided you with a phone [00:16:47] Speaker 1: number to dial so that she could call him on speakerphone, right? Yes. And she remembered the number? Yes. And so you indicated on that day on February 4th that she left a voicemail, right? Yes. So in that voicemail message, were you able to identify that it was Patrick Clancy's phone? Did it say, hey, this is Pat, leave a message or something to that effect? I don't remember the salutation [00:17:09] Kelly Ryan: from the voice recording, but there was no evidence that it was not Patrick Clancy. And as far as her [00:17:20] Speaker 1: confidence in the number, she gave it to you with no issue, did she not? That's correct. She didn't have her own cell phone to refer to, did she? That's correct. Or a pad of paper where all the numbers were written down? She didn't. You indicated that she left a message. Do you recall what the message was? [00:17:42] Kelly Ryan: She expressed a love for him, wanted to know how he was doing. And that was pretty much it. And again, [00:17:50] Speaker 1: you said that you didn't write down what the mental status exam was, but the fact that she was able to relay that message, was it clear and coherent what she was saying? Yes. Mental status exams are [00:18:03] Kelly Ryan: multiple levels, different things are asked. If you don't know where you are, it doesn't mean you [00:18:08] Speaker 1: can't have a conversation with someone. And she was able to have a conversation with you that day? Yes. Now, you said you went back on February 6th and met with her again, correct? Yes. And you guys made another attempt at calling Patrick? Yes. Again, did you remember the number? No. Did you have it stored in your phone? No. Did she provide you his phone number to call? Well, it was in my phone. I could [00:18:39] Kelly Ryan: just look it up on my phone. I didn't write it down. I didn't enter his name. Either she gave it to me again or I just looked it up from two days prior. But you don't recall as you sit here today which it was, [00:18:49] Speaker 1: do you? No. And you didn't write a report about that interaction, did you? I did not. So in this second phone call, you were able to actually hear that she was talking with Patrick on the other end, right? Yes. And at that time when you were now second time meeting with her and having this phone call, were you aware that she had already changed her healthcare proxy from Patrick to her parents? I did not know that. Did you talk to Patrick in between the fourth and the sixth to find out [00:19:26] Kelly Ryan: if he had tried to come in to visit her? I didn't speak to him at all so I knew nothing about what his [00:19:31] Speaker 1: plans or intentions were. Your testimony yesterday was that she had called him to tell him that she loved him and to see where they were at, right? Yes. That was your testimony? Meaning what? Their relationship? [00:19:48] Kelly Ryan: That I made no interpretation of what that meant. She left the message and we left it at that. But in [00:19:56] Speaker 1: that subsequent conversation that you were a witness to where they were speaking on the phone and she told them about these voices or explained about the voices. Did she ask about the kids? [00:20:13] Kelly Ryan: She did not, as I recall. [00:20:23] Speaker 1: Now in all of the times over the course of the last few years that you've met with Ms. Clancy, how many times has she told you since the incident that she's heard a voice currently? [00:20:38] Kelly Ryan: She has not heard voices since the event took place in 2023. [00:20:48] Speaker 1: And you've now testified that over the course of a period of time that she did hear voices, right? [00:20:58] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:20:59] Speaker 1: And is that based on one of these 35 hours worth of conversations you had with her? How do you know that? [00:21:08] Kelly Ryan: Well, they were collateral contacts. I spoke to other people. I spoke to other people who I asked the nature of their interactions with Ms. Clancy. And it was not a fishing expedition. I asked them if they can tell me what happened. [00:21:27] Speaker 1: Well, I'm asking you. But they disclosed, pardon me. [00:21:30] Kelly Ryan: You have to let them finish. So they disclosed information to me that Ms. Clancy shared that information with them. [00:21:36] Speaker 1: So who did she tell that she had a voice that told her to kill herself? [00:21:44] Kelly Ryan: She spoke to a chaplain named Sheila Cavanaugh, who I spoke with. And Chaplain Cavanaugh told me that Ms. Clancy told her that she heard a male voice instructing her to first kill her children and then to kill herself. [00:22:10] Speaker 1: So the same message that she delivered to Patrick that day on the phone, you heard from a chaplain at Brigham and Women's Hospital after the incident occurred in January of 2023? [00:22:24] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:22:25] Speaker 1: And so from all of the records that you reviewed of her treatment and all of the interviews with her family, who did she tell that she heard voices telling her to kill herself? [00:22:39] Kelly Ryan: I believe she told family members. [00:22:42] Speaker 1: Which family members? [00:22:43] Kelly Ryan: I believe she may have said that to her mother. She, I believe, told her husband that she felt like killing herself as well. [00:22:52] Speaker 1: So in the records with the providers, you're aware you've reviewed them all and you've sat through all of their testimony. You're aware that when she described intrusive thoughts, she never referred them, referred to them as a voice telling her to kill herself. Did they? Did she? [00:23:09] Kelly Ryan: No, she was referring to. [00:23:11] Speaker 1: It's just a yes or no. No. [00:23:13] Speaker ?: No. [00:23:13] Speaker 1: So as far as her reports of this, these intrusive thoughts that appear over and over in the notes, you would agree that it was simply, when asked about what they were, it was simply that she felt like she wanted to die, right? [00:23:29] Kelly Ryan: Yes, and. [00:23:32] Speaker 1: It's just a yes or no. [00:23:34] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:23:38] Speaker 1: Now, in your report, you go through what's called the sources of information. You're familiar with that part. It's pretty standard in a forensic report, right? Yes. Where you list all of the things that you've gone through and reviewed in compiling the information for your report. [00:23:58] Kelly Ryan: So in my sources of information, I write, I reviewed the following, but that list is not limited to the following. So there might be other pieces of information that I may have reviewed, but didn't put in the list. [00:24:11] Speaker 1: Okay. So not on the list are the Tewkes-Barre hospital records that you said you reviewed recently, correct? [00:24:19] Kelly Ryan: Yes. The 7,000 pages of those hospital notes, I didn't review all of them at the time of the report. [00:24:26] Speaker 1: Did you review records from the Spalding rehab facility? [00:24:29] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:24:30] Speaker 1: That's not contained though in your list, in your report, is it? [00:24:33] Kelly Ryan: I don't think it is. [00:24:35] Speaker 1: And you don't cite to any of the Spalding rehab records in your report coming to your ultimate conclusions, do you? [00:24:43] Kelly Ryan: I do not. [00:24:44] Speaker 1: And how about the women and infant records? Did you list that in your sources of information section? [00:24:52] Kelly Ryan: I do not. She was there for one day. [00:24:57] Speaker 1: Okay. But you've testified about that, right? [00:25:01] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:01] Speaker 1: Did you review them at all? [00:25:03] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:04] Speaker 1: And as far as the McLean records, you don't list the McLean records as a source of information in your report, do you? [00:25:12] Kelly Ryan: I did not, but I did review them. [00:25:18] Speaker 1: Now you've described and you describe in your report that you believe that Ms. Clancy was hypomanic, right? [00:25:26] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:26] Speaker 1: And I believe you testified to some extent and you've written in your report that you identify her as euphoric, excessively energetic for three months postpartum. Do you remember writing that in your report? [00:25:40] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:41] Speaker 1: That you note that she exercised early, right? [00:25:44] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:45] Speaker 1: But you're aware that she exercised pretty frequently before birth. [00:25:51] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:25:51] Speaker 1: And while pregnant with Callan. [00:25:53] Kelly Ryan: And while post-pregnancy with her children as well. Yes. [00:25:58] Speaker 1: So it was part of her routine, fair to say, right? [00:26:05] Kelly Ryan: It's part of everyday living. Things sometimes change when you have a baby and a few weeks later, if you're still doing the same exercise, it's sometimes a reflection of something other than committed to fitness. [00:26:18] Speaker 1: And you identify what you refer to as a marketing scam, being that beach body business, right? Yes. But you're aware that that's a series of workouts in a line of nutritional shakes and exercise plans that millions of people engage in across the country. [00:26:37] Kelly Ryan: Yes. Okay. [00:26:40] Speaker 1: So it's not a scam. [00:26:42] Kelly Ryan: It's just a way of a lifestyle choice. [00:26:44] Speaker ?: That's the... [00:26:44] Kelly Ryan: If you do something for marketing and you lose all your money and there's no effort to get that back, it's a scam. Yeah. You've asked them, you can kind of figure out what his definition is, so... [00:26:57] Speaker 1: Did she tell you she lost money with a beach body? [00:27:00] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:27:01] Speaker 1: When was that? [00:27:03] Kelly Ryan: It was summer of 2022 after her third child was born. [00:27:11] Speaker 1: No, when did she tell you that she lost money? [00:27:13] Kelly Ryan: I don't recall that. [00:27:14] Speaker 1: And is it in your report? [00:27:16] Kelly Ryan: It may be, but I'm not sure. [00:27:19] Speaker 1: Well, I have it with me or do you have it up there? Can you look and point to me where she told you, at what point she told you she lost money in this endeavor? [00:27:33] Kelly Ryan: I don't know where it is, if it's here. It didn't seem relevant whether she lost money in a scam after her child was born. In terms of the big picture of what we're here for today. [00:27:44] Speaker 1: You described it as a scam because you said she lost money. So wouldn't it be important to know if she actually lost money? [00:27:54] Kelly Ryan: I don't really think so. [00:27:55] Speaker 1: Okay. You also identify the five-mile race that she completed. Was it a five-mile race or a 5k race? [00:28:06] Kelly Ryan: Well, I wasn't sure which it was. I was told initially it was a five-mile race. After my report was submitted, it may have been with reflection. A 5k race. [00:28:20] Speaker 1: And you've sat in the courtroom each and every day of this trial. So you've heard all the testimony about the evidence, right? [00:28:26] Kelly Ryan: Actually, I've not been here every day, but I've been here most days. Yes. [00:28:31] Speaker 1: You're also aware that prior to the kids being born, that she considered herself a runner. Right? She had a treadmill at her house. She went to the gym and used the treadmill. She ran other races. [00:28:46] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:28:48] Speaker 1: Now in your report, you indicate that part of the timeline of her medication and her decline is the September time period where she was prescribed the Zoloft, right? Yes. And you indicate that she had reported and it's reflected in the records that she increased the Zoloft and that's when she couldn't sleep for 48 hours straight, right? [00:29:26] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:29:26] Speaker 1: And you're aware of what the instructions were having reviewed everything in this case, what the pill bottle said as far as the plan for the Zoloft? [00:29:36] Kelly Ryan: I'm not sure specifically the incremental plan to go from 25 milligrams to 50 milligrams of Zoloft. [00:29:49] Speaker 1: Well, I have the bottle exhibit number two, certainly not Zoloft, right? Yes. It says take one oral tablet once a day for one week, then increase to two tablets daily thereafter. [00:30:18] Speaker ?: Right. [00:30:18] Speaker 1: Right on the label. [00:30:19] Kelly Ryan: Right. That's 25 milligrams to 50 milligrams. [00:30:24] Speaker 1: And again, having been at the majority of this trial, are you aware that there were 30 in that prescription and 23 left in the bottle when they were inventoried? Yes. And those are pills that were in Patrick Clancy's possession at the time of these events in January, you're aware, right? [00:30:44] Kelly Ryan: Yes. I believe they were in the middle console on the lower part of his truck, the lower part of the middle console in his truck. [00:30:52] Speaker 1: So if there's only seven pills missing from a prescription that requires the person to take a particular dosage for one week or seven days, how did she double the dose? [00:31:03] Kelly Ryan: Well, sometimes when you are given medication, you may have medication of the same exact dosage and the same exact medication another time. And you therefore may have pills that you didn't take the previous month or the month before that. And sometimes people just finish what they've had before and before they go on to the most current dose. So I am aware of what you're referring to, but I don't know if there are other bottles there that she may have had medication still in those pill bottles. [00:31:37] Speaker 1: Well, I'm looking at exhibit number one, a record from CVS pharmacy, which all of these bottles are from. And the only time a prescription for Sertoline is filled is on September 15th, 2022 for 30 pills. You aware of that? [00:31:54] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:31:55] Speaker 1: So there's no prior prescription for Sertoline, is there? [00:31:58] Kelly Ryan: I don't think so. [00:32:03] Speaker 1: Okay. Now in your report, you also refer to 1129 and your report on page eight paragraph two says on 1129 Paula Gelata. Is that supposed to be Rebecca Gelata? Yes. Okay. So it also says that she prescribed Seroquel to treat Ms. Clancy's anxiety, depressed and unstable mood and psychotic symptoms of disassociation and derealization. Where's that in Rebecca Gelata's record that that's why she prescribed Seroquel? [00:32:35] Kelly Ryan: I'm not sure. [00:32:36] Speaker 1: And in fact, you were present when Ms. Gelata testified and said that she prescribed it at 25 milligrams for insomnia, not for anxiety, depression, unstable mood or psychotic symptoms. Did she not? [00:32:52] Kelly Ryan: It's used off label. It's sometimes medications are made from anything. Sometimes they use off label, not for what they're prescribed for. So that's the medication that is used for sleeping, although it's an antipsychotic. [00:33:03] Speaker 1: But you're aware from reviewing the records and hearing testimony that that initial prescription was for a 25 milligram dose, correct? [00:33:10] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:33:11] Speaker 1: I know you're not a prescriber, but you're aware that a dose for treatment of bipolar is significantly higher than 25 milligrams. [00:33:19] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:33:19] Speaker 1: Now, you've described in your testimony in this court, auditory, repeated auditory hallucinations about wanting to kill herself or that she should kill herself and that she is damaged or her brain is damaged, right? [00:33:47] Kelly Ryan: That's correct. [00:33:48] Speaker 1: Now, did you have a conversation with her in one of these 35 hours about that particular voice or thought or belief? [00:33:57] Kelly Ryan: So when I meet with Ms. Clancy, it's not as if I have one conversation on one of the 35 hours. To have thoroughness and exactitude, one does what we call intra-rater reliability. In other words, over the period of time to confirm what someone says to you to help endorse the veracity or accuracy of that, you'll ask that question in a multitude of different ways. So I don't just ask once, did you hear a voice on that day? I asked in different ways over time and her answers pretty much remain the same. [00:34:40] Speaker 1: So, so when you quote in your report when questioned about the nature and content of these horrible thoughts, Ms. Clancy stated, quote, like a really bad and intrusive thought that I didn't feel like it was mine, telling me I should kill myself, your brain is damaged, you're never going to get better, end quote. Where does the quote come from? [00:35:01] Kelly Ryan: Where does the quote come from? Right. She had said that to me. [00:35:04] Speaker 1: To you at some point? Yes. Okay. And this is well after the incident occurred, correct? Yes. And you reviewed all the records to know that she did not endorse that she was hearing a voice to any of her providers between September and January 23rd of 2023. [00:35:26] Kelly Ryan: So when someone. Yes or no, sir. That's a difficult question to say yes or no from because sometimes if someone says something that's inaccurate, it's not an affirmatory or a negative response that's misleading. [00:35:43] Speaker 1: My question to you though, was where in the records from September to January 23rd or 2022, did she tell any of the providers she saw that she heard a voice telling her to kill herself? [00:35:56] Kelly Ryan: It's not in the records. [00:35:58] Speaker 1: Okay. And you're aware that she has spoken to several forensic psychiatrists and psychologists over the course of this case, right? Not just yourself. [00:36:08] Kelly Ryan: Yes. She spoke to three retained experts in April 10th and April 12th of 2026. And then on June 12th of 2026, 1,172 days after I initially met with her, then 1,1220 days after I met with her. That's this the third examiner. [00:36:39] Speaker 1: Well, you're aware that she, you're referring to Dr. Halbrin, Dr. Mack and Dr. Satov, correct? [00:36:46] Kelly Ryan: Correct. [00:36:46] Speaker 1: But you're aware that she also spoke with Dr. Resnick and Dr. Spinelli well before that? [00:36:52] Kelly Ryan: On May 5th of 2023, approximately 90 days more or less later. Yes. [00:37:01] Speaker 1: Yes. And you're also aware, sir, that she has never told, she never told Dr. Resnick in a recorded interview, nor Dr. Halbrin, Dr. Mack or Dr. Satov, that she heard... [00:37:17] Kelly Ryan: Sustained. [00:37:20] Speaker 1: Your testimony is that she told you that she heard this voice. Fair to say she identified to you that it was her own voice that she heard, correct? That's not correct. So she told you that she heard a male's voice? [00:37:37] Kelly Ryan: That's correct. When? On the night of the incident, January 24th, 2023. [00:37:43] Speaker 1: No, I'm referring to the fact that you've now testified that she heard this, as you call it, a persistent, what's the word you use? Persecutorial voice over the course of time. Was that your testimony? [00:37:58] Kelly Ryan: So you're referring to the ongoing negative voices or intrusive thoughts that she was hearing. [00:38:06] Speaker 1: Right. [00:38:06] Kelly Ryan: Where she felt, in fact, other people could hear those voices, thought broadcasting. So there are multiple layers here of hearing intrusive thoughts, hearing voices so loud, that she believed other people could hear her. Those are two separate phenomena, if you will. [00:38:29] Speaker 1: In those voices that you are saying she told you she heard about wanting to die or to kill herself or her brain was damaged prior to January 24th of 2023. Did she say it was her own voice she could hear? It was her own thoughts? [00:38:45] Kelly Ryan: She did not identify whose voice it was. [00:38:48] Speaker 1: Fair to say the only time she specifically said she heard a male voice was when she recounts the events on January 24th of 2023. Yes, that's accurate. And you'd agree that there's a difference between the idea that somebody believes their thoughts would be or could be heard by others and the belief that they are being heard by others, right? [00:39:13] Kelly Ryan: Yes, it's a matter of semantics and it's a level of degreism. Believing and knowing two totally separate things. [00:39:23] Speaker 1: And believing having a fixed belief like that would be a delusion, right? [00:39:30] Kelly Ryan: That's correct. A delusion is a fixed false belief that is unshakable and not something you get rid of either through your own efforts to tell the voice to go away or other people saying just for example [00:39:46] Speaker 1: try to stop thinking about it. And the idea that she believed that something was wrong with her brain or that if she if people could know what was happening that the police might get involved that is something that could happen if somebody articulates those things, right? [00:40:07] Kelly Ryan: Absolutely. It's common sense. [00:40:11] Speaker 1: Now in your report, you also indicate that in your testimony, you indicated that on January 5th of 2023 that that's when Ms. Clancy was discharged from McLean Hospital. And I think your testimony was that she went in there on Seroquel and I think you indicated Klonopin, correct? Yes. And your report says Seroquel and Klonopin. You recall that? [00:40:42] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:40:43] Speaker 1: You're aware that based on the medication journal that is in evidence that she hadn't taken Klonopin since November 27th of 2022. [00:40:54] Kelly Ryan: She had a prescription for that and I think she may have taken some but may not have been on a regular basis. [00:41:01] Speaker 1: But you've seen the pages of her journal to know that she's pretty diligent about saying exactly what she took on each particular date. [00:41:09] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:41:10] Speaker 1: Leading up to her stay at McLean and even after. [00:41:12] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:41:19] Speaker 1: Now, kind of sticking with these medications for a second, you have testified, I think this was yesterday, you testified that you were familiar that after Dawson's birth that she had sought some medication, correct? [00:41:36] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:41:37] Speaker 1: And I believe you testified yesterday that she was on Trazodone, but in fact she was prescribed Zoloft after Dawson and reported she didn't ever take it, right? [00:41:47] Kelly Ryan: That's correct. So after my testimony I reviewed that and I confabulated the Trazodone with another medication, the Zoloft. [00:41:58] Speaker 1: And again, you've talked a lot about that the medications that she was taking, the different medications didn't provide her with any sort of relief. So it's important to know the different medications she was taking and what the reactions were, right? [00:42:10] Kelly Ryan: I don't know if I talked a lot about it. I was asked questions, I answered them honestly. They didn't provide relief. I would agree with that. So that was the whole point of her seeking help. [00:42:21] Speaker 1: And her history, whether it be a medication history, a social history, a family history, those are all important things overall for you to look at and examine when coming to ultimate conclusions, right? [00:42:36] Kelly Ryan: For everyone. Yes, of course. [00:42:38] Speaker 1: So it's important to be accurate when you are recalling or reporting that information. [00:42:42] Kelly Ryan: As much as possible as one can be. Yes, that's true. [00:42:45] Speaker 1: And as far as the medication goes, I think you testified yesterday that she also took medication in nursing school, correct? [00:42:53] Kelly Ryan: Yes, she did. [00:42:55] Speaker 1: And having met with her as many times as you did and reviewing all these records, you're aware that those were in fact, Prozac, Wellbutrin, and Propanol that she took in nursing [00:43:03] Kelly Ryan: school. That's correct. That was for her. What's called glossophobia, G-O-L-L-O-S-P-H-O-B-I-A. It's fear of public speaking. Most common fear for Americans, 85% of Americans have public speaking phobia. Pretty commonplace. But yes, those are the medications that she took while she was in nursing school to go through the program. But that's not what you testified to yesterday. I think I mentioned only one or two medications had taken three. [00:43:34] Speaker 1: Okay. And, um, um, you also mentioned, um, um, today in your testimony, um, you were asked about the date of December 15th. And I believe your testimony was that's the day she went to women and infants. Is that correct? I believe so. Yes. Um, you were asked about the date of December 15th. And I believe your testimony was that's the day she went to women and infants. Is that correct? Yes. Um, would it, if I show you the record, is it fair to say she didn't go to women and infants on the 15th, but it was actually December 20th? [00:44:18] Kelly Ryan: Right. I believe she went to the Mass General Hospital ER on the 15th. [00:44:22] Speaker 1: And you, um, said in your testimony today that at the Mass General ER, she did not get any help. Do you recall that testimony? [00:44:29] Kelly Ryan: She declined admission to the inpatient. She didn't appreciate, didn't want to do that. So, um, [00:44:35] Speaker 1: It didn't not get help. Can you answer? Can you answer? [00:44:39] Kelly Ryan: Go ahead. Thank you, Your Honor. We have something called the subjective baseline, the cognitive appraisal theme. Help is in the eye of the beholder. If she felt she didn't get help, that's how she felt. [00:44:54] Speaker 1: Well, sir, that wasn't the question. And your testimony was she went to the ER and did not get help. That was your testimony, not hers. [00:45:03] Kelly Ryan: Well, my testimony is based on my evaluation of her. This is what Ms. Clancy shared with me. Who am I to doubt what she believes or doesn't believe about the offer for treatment or help? It's her opinion. [00:45:18] Speaker 1: Well, she chose to decline the bed at McLean on December 15th. Did she not? [00:45:24] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:45:24] Speaker 1: And she then indicated to the Mass General Hospital that she was going to opt for an outpatient program at the Women and Infants, correct? [00:45:34] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:45:34] Speaker 1: That's what's in the records? Yes. And did she tell you that as well? Yes. And as it pertains to the Women and Infants, again, after you review the records, you're aware that a referral had been made to her well before her visit to the ER on the 15th for that same program? [00:45:51] Kelly Ryan: I believe so. [00:46:05] Speaker 1: Now, you've indicated in your testimony that it's your opinion that her diagnosis is bipolar disorder with psychotic symptoms, correct? Yes. And fair to say you've reviewed, prior to your report, you had reviewed Dr. Resnick's report. So the question I believe was did you review a report of Dr. Resnick in all your sources of information and before you came to a conclusion about diagnosis? [00:47:10] Kelly Ryan: No, I did not. Well. [00:47:22] Speaker ?: Thank you. [00:47:52] Speaker 1: One moment, sorry. One second. On page four of your report where you list the sources of information, you do identify as number 24, Forensic Psychiatric Evaluation of Philip J. Resnick from 9-27-24. Do you not? I do. And so that's something you reviewed. [00:48:57] Kelly Ryan: I didn't draw my opinion. [00:48:59] Speaker 1: That wasn't the question, sir. [00:49:01] Kelly Ryan: Well, hold on. He asked the question again. Go ahead. [00:49:04] Speaker 1: Did you review his report? [00:49:07] Speaker 3: That's not the question. [00:49:11] Speaker 1: So the question, sir, is did you review Dr. Resnick's report prior to authoring your report or coming to your conclusions about diagnosis? [00:49:23] Kelly Ryan: I reviewed part of that report. And in my report, I perused through the reports. I did not review all of that report from Dr. Resnick or Dr. Spinelli for that matter. [00:49:38] Speaker 1: Okay. Now, in talking about your review of records, you indicated that there are several thousand pages of Cheeksbury Hospital records, correct? [00:49:55] Kelly Ryan: Seven thousand and one page. [00:49:57] Speaker 1: And did you review all of those? [00:50:00] Kelly Ryan: I would say I looked through them, but I did not read every word on every page. They do have a tendency to hang together and are replicative as well. [00:50:12] Speaker 1: Were you aware that on May 26th, 2023, that the defendant was observed by staff in a note stating that she was visible along the unit hallways, self-propelling her wheelchair with her one-to-one staff, that she had a visit with her mother who brought dinner for her. They ate and played games during the visit. Are you aware of that? [00:50:35] Kelly Ryan: On May 26th. [00:50:37] Speaker 1: May 26th of 2023. May 23. [00:50:40] Kelly Ryan: May 23. So, three years ago and a few months? I don't know that. I don't remember. [00:50:47] Speaker 1: That would have been approximately four months after the incident and on the date of Callan's first birthday. [00:50:54] Kelly Ryan: Right? Yes. But you asked if I remember that event and I don't. [00:51:00] Speaker 1: You don't or you do? [00:51:02] Kelly Ryan: I don't remember that she was seen with her mother on that day who brought food and she was seen using a wheelchair to travel down the hallway at the hospital. I don't remember. [00:51:16] Speaker 1: If I tell you that was read from page 176 of the Tewkesbury hospital records, would you agree with that? [00:51:21] Kelly Ryan: I would not doubt that. [00:51:24] Speaker 1: And on December 24th of 2023, were you aware that the defendant was observed at Tewkesbury, monitored on one-to-one for safety, that she accepted medication, meals and snacks, she spent time in the TV room or sitting outside her room, utilizing phone and visited with family. Do you recall that, reading that note on page 613 of the Tewkesbury records? Of 2023? [00:51:52] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:51:53] Speaker 1: Honestly, I don't. And that would have been Cora's birthday. Okay. But would you agree with me that if I read that from page 613 in the records, that that would be within that 7001 page of the record? [00:52:07] Kelly Ryan: I would not doubt that. [00:52:08] Speaker 1: How about on January 24th, 2024, where she's observed in a note from Tewkesbury State Hospital on page 674, saying, where the note reads, patient was visible in the milieu, engageable with both staff and select peers, patient accepted select medications as her baseline, that she was pleasant during interactions, self-propelling in wheelchair in the halls, spending much of the morning in her early afternoon in her room and hall on her electronics. Do you recall reading that record? [00:52:43] Kelly Ryan: Not specifically. [00:52:44] Speaker 1: And January 24th, 2024 would have been the year anniversary of the incident, correct? [00:52:49] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [00:52:50] Speaker 1: But if I read from page 674, you would agree with me that that's part of the Tewkesbury record? [00:52:57] Kelly Ryan: Yes. I believe it's part of the record. [00:53:00] Speaker 1: And on May 26th of 2024, from page 922 of the Tewkesbury record, patient monitored one-to-one for safety. She's been monitored for high suicide risks, accepted medication, says BFK and snacks. She spent some time in the TV room or sitting outside her room, utilizing phone. Would you agree that that's a fair reading of page 922? [00:53:30] Kelly Ryan: I have no reason to doubt that. Okay. [00:53:34] Speaker 1: And that she's also observed on that same day, visible on the unit while utilizing her phone outside her room, was able to make her needs known appropriately. Patient was observed playing dominoes with peers in the TV room. That was later in the day, on May 26th, 2024, which would have been Callan's second birthday. [00:53:57] Kelly Ryan: I would believe that that record is probably accurate. I don't remember looking at that record specifically. [00:54:03] Speaker 1: How about on September 30th of 2024, page 1229 of the Tewkesbury record, where it's noted that she was visible in the unit, attended startup/coffee group, she was assisted with ADLs as needed. She was in safe behavioural control for the duration of the shift. And that later reads, patient visible in the hallways, seated in a wheelchair outside her bedroom, using her cell phone, pleasant approach, social with select peers. That would have been on September 30th, 2024, which would have been Dawson's fifth birthday. Do you recall reviewing that in the record? [00:54:45] Kelly Ryan: Not off the top of my head, but I have no reason to doubt that it's not an accurate record. [00:54:50] Speaker 1: December 24th, 2024, page 1442 of the Tewkesbury records. It says the patient was visible on the unit, utilizing her phone. Her parents were in to visit, and they brought dinner with them. Patient accepted medications and fluids. Patient in good behavioural control, maintaining safety. No SIB noted or reported. Do you have reason to doubt that that's on page 1,442 of the Tewkesbury record? [00:55:21] Kelly Ryan: I have no reason to doubt that that's not an accurate reflection of what took place that day. [00:55:26] Speaker 1: And what's SIB? [00:55:28] Kelly Ryan: Self injurious behaviour. [00:55:30] Speaker 1: And so, December 24th, 2024, that would have been Core's seventh birthday, right? Yes. So, January 24th, 2025, from page 1,514 of the Tewkesbury records. It reads, inpatient treatment goal, to work on my mental health and to feel better. It says, she participated in morning ADL routine with staff assistance. Patient was visible on the milieu at times in the hallway, utilizing her phone. No SIB has been reported this shift. Does that, um, do you have any reason to doubt that that's contained on page 1,514? [00:56:17] Kelly Ryan: I have no reason to doubt that. [00:56:20] Speaker 1: And the further observations on that day were that the patient was visible on the unit. She was social with select staff and peers, and also seen utilizing her phone. Her parents were in to visit and brought her dinner, or excuse me, and they brought dinner with them. Um, that was, again, on January 24th, 2025, which would have been, um, the second anniversary of this incident, correct? Yes. May 26th, 2025, page 1782 of the Tewkesbury records. Uh, it says, she did not engage in any SIB. She was visited by her parents this shift. She attended startup group, group and watched TV. That would have been on May 26th, 2025, which would have been Callen's third birthday. Do you have any reason to doubt that in the record? I have no reason to doubt that. And, um, September 30th, 2025 of the Tewkesbury record on page 2056, uh, reads patient was visible in the hallway using her phone. No SIB or behavioral issues observed or reported. Do you have any doubt, do you have reason to doubt that that is, um, an accurate read of page 2056? I have no reason to doubt that that's not accurate. And that would have been September 30th, which would have been Dawson's sixth birthday, right? Yes. No, on December 24th of 2025, page 76 of the patient notes in the Tewkesbury hospital records. It reads, ate breakfast, refused lunch, took snacks, utilizing phone, assisted with ADLs, spent some time in the TV room, attended PT, resting in bed after lunch. Do you have any reason to doubt that is contained within the Tewkesbury records on page 76? [00:58:26] Kelly Ryan: No. [00:58:27] Speaker 1: And December 24th would have been, of course, eighth birthday, correct? Yes. And on page 152 of the Tewkesbury records, um, January 24th, 2026, this year. So, um, the patient observed for safety, assess mental status, encourage safe behaviour control, monitoring for abrupt behaviour change in an attempt to prevent escalation or self-harm, encourage patient to participate in groups. But that, on this particular day, she was also observed, um, compliant with meds, ate breakfast, participated in coffee group, visible in the hallway utilizing her phone, later visited with parents and had an early lunch. That was on January 24th of 2026. Do you have any reason to doubt that's within the records? No. And that she was later observed to not have any SIB or behavioural issues? Again, on January 24th, 2026. Do you have any reason to doubt that's contained within the Tewkesbury records? No. [00:59:41] Kelly Ryan: No. [00:59:42] Speaker ?: No. [00:59:43] Kelly Ryan: No. [00:59:44] Speaker 1: And again, you reviewed or looked at some of them, but not every one of these. But these are, um, already currently in evidence, correct? Yes. Your Honor, I would move to admit these excerpts as the next exhibit, please. Any objections? [01:00:01] Kelly Ryan: No problem. All right. That may be admitted. Okay, thank you. [01:00:29] Speaker 1: And, um, Dr. Zeisel, as far as the, um, records that I, I just read in, um, do you know if, um, in those records it indicates that she slept well on all of those occasions? [01:00:46] Kelly Ryan: I, I wouldn't know. I, I don't know how. [01:00:52] Speaker 1: Well, you would agree that, um, noting her sleeping habits based on this particular individual's history would be an important thing for the hospital to monitor, correct? [01:01:03] Kelly Ryan: I would agree with that. [01:01:09] Speaker 1: Now, um, in this particular case, well, let me ask you. Are you familiar with the concept of confirmation bias? [01:01:21] Kelly Ryan: Of course. [01:01:22] Speaker 1: And, um, fair to say it's, it's pretty prevalent in, um, most areas of, um, science and, and forensic psychology and psychiatry, correct? [01:01:33] Kelly Ryan: It, of course, is all domains of work and life. [01:01:38] Speaker 1: And as far as, um, confirmation bias for, um, psychiatry or providers, um, I'm afraid to say that, um, clinicians are warned that they may lean towards or support their own theories and overlook contradictory evidence. And that you have to be aware of that, correct? Yes. And again, in forensic psychology, the goal is to give, render an objective opinion, right? Yes. [01:02:02] Kelly Ryan: The facts come to you. You don't go to the facts. Okay. [01:02:06] Speaker 1: And, um, there's a danger for clinicians and, um, forensic psychologists of quickly forming an initial diagnosis before having all the information, correct? Yes. And that confirmation bias accounts for the fact that a lot of times people, clinicians, and, um, providers will cling to diagnoses and interpret subsequent information in light of that kind of already perceived idea. Is that fair to say? [01:02:35] Kelly Ryan: They cling, I just want to make sure I understand what you're saying. They cling to a diagnosis? [01:02:41] Speaker 1: Well, once a diagnosis is reached, they cling to the, that diagnosis when interpreting subsequent information. [01:02:50] Kelly Ryan: That, that happens, yes. [01:02:53] Speaker 1: And, um, but you would agree that in practice of forensic psychology that it's important not to do that, right? [01:03:01] Kelly Ryan: Particularly with the guidelines of criminal responsibility where you don't need a diagnosis. You just need a mental disease or defect. [01:03:09] Speaker 1: Diagnoses are helpful in understanding whether the person was suffering from this legal construct of a mental disease or defect, correct? That's fair to say. And it's fairly accepted in the field that if somebody has a, um, disorder or a diagnosed mental illness, that they then in turn suffer from a mental disease or defect. Or could. [01:03:34] Speaker ?: Okay. [01:03:35] Kelly Ryan: Or could. Because you can have a phobia. Doesn't mean you have a mental disease or defect. If you're afraid to jump out of airplanes, it can make you ineffective and have a defect or a disease. So, yes. It could. Just keep your voice up. Yes, Ron. So it could, but it doesn't always have to. Thank you. Of course. [01:03:54] Speaker 1: And you're aware of the danger of this idea of confirmation bias of having multiple relationships and conflicts in this type of work, correct? Yes. And that's why it's important not to be treating somebody as a patient when you're also evaluating them for this type of, um, legal issue, right? Of course. [01:04:15] Kelly Ryan: You cannot be the therapist and the examiner. The therapist is an advocate. The examiner looks for the truth. [01:04:25] Speaker 1: And. Do you recall in this case, um, submitting recommendations to the court in November of 2025, uh, about the defendant regarding, um, accommodations for her? [01:04:43] Kelly Ryan: I know in general, but I don't know specifically what those accommodations requests were. I can't remember them. [01:04:50] Speaker 1: But you, you wrote, you authored and signed a letter dated November 13th, 2025 to the court, correct? [01:04:58] Kelly Ryan: Yes, but I'm saying I don't remember specifically what those recommendations were. I know I did that. [01:05:03] Speaker 1: I'm not asking you that. I'm just asking if you wrote the letter. [01:05:05] Kelly Ryan: Hold on. Just ask, we ask a question. Doctor, go ahead. If you listen to the question. Yes, sir. [01:05:10] Speaker 1: I'm just asking if you wrote the letter, sir. [01:05:11] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:05:12] Speaker 1: And in that letter, you refer to providing essential clinical findings regarding the transportation of my patient, Lindsey Clancy. Do you recall writing that? Yes. And so, at various points throughout, over the years of this case, you have referred to it as your patient. Have you not? [01:05:30] Kelly Ryan: I wouldn't be, I think, able to define her as something else. She was a patient who I did a forensic evaluation of. [01:05:47] Speaker 1: Well, you referred to the court outside of this evaluation you're testifying about to her as your patient in this letter from November 13th of 2025. [01:05:56] Kelly Ryan: Right. [01:05:57] Speaker ?: Right. [01:05:57] Kelly Ryan: I evaluated Ms. Clancy, who is a patient. If I evaluated her, then she's my patient. As she is other doctor's patients at Tewkesbury and other places that she's been at. [01:06:13] Speaker 1: But you would call her my patient in the letter. [01:06:18] Kelly Ryan: I wrote the letter. Who, whose patient would I be referring to if I'm speaking about Ms. Clancy, given that she's my patient. Yes, I wrote she was my patient. That's correct. [01:06:30] Speaker 1: And you're aware of, again, the APA guidelines on forensic psychology, where it warns therapeutic forensic role conflicts, providing forensic and therapeutic psychological services to the same individual involves multiple relationships that may impair objectivity and/or cause exploitation or other harm. You're aware of that, Section 4.02? Yes. And in this particular case, since the beginning, you've appeared regularly in court hearings, right? Yes. You've appeared with Attorney Reddington at arraignment proceedings? [01:07:09] Kelly Ryan: At his request, yes. [01:07:11] Speaker 1: Both here and at Tewkesbury State Hospital, where you were sitting next to the defendant? Yes. And you also, on February 8th of 2023, participated in a news conference, did you not? [01:07:27] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:07:28] Speaker 1: It was outside the courthouse here? Yes. And you gave an interview with the Daily News, where you commented on Ms. Clancy? [01:07:35] Kelly Ryan: I just made a comment, that's correct. [01:07:37] Speaker 1: And at this time, Your Honor, I'd like to play a clip of the news conference, please. [01:07:43] Speaker 3: Mr. Reagan? Mr. Reagan? [01:07:45] Speaker ?: Why not? Why not? All right. [01:07:47] Speaker 3: Thank you. I can't see the TV. Thanks. [01:07:50] Speaker ?: I can't see the TV. Thanks. I can't see the TV. Thanks. I can't see the TV. I can't see the TV. I can't see the TV. Thanks. I can't see the TV. [01:07:59] Speaker 3: I can't see the TV. Thanks. [01:08:13] Speaker ?: Thank you. I can say that her ethic is absolutely plattent. She's in a very surreal state. [01:08:53] Kelly Ryan: It feels great to her, as she's described to me on multiple occasions. And individuals who can present as being lucid and linear and clear thinking, not make those people not mentally ill. They have the capacity, or on occasion, to be able to do things that they've been doing [01:09:16] Speaker ?: for a long period of time. When you have delusional thinking, fixed beliefs that are unchangeable, and hallucinations, mainly prevent hallucinations, telling you to do things, telling you to do things that are malevolent. [01:09:26] Kelly Ryan: And you believe those voices that some of you need to tell what they say, that's when things go downhill, vaguely, psychically, and infamilially. [01:09:38] Speaker ?: And that's what we see in the most tragic of cases for individuals who should be healthy and normal, and quite frankly, because they're paranoid, worried about what others think, they hold back the way they care. And in some cases throughout the country and the world, these are people who one day will [01:09:56] Kelly Ryan: be functioning well. because they have the onset of hallucinations, which they have to do something. That's when tragedy occurs. [01:10:12] Speaker 1: So, sir, on December 8th of 2023, when you provided that, your observations, you had met with the defendant on two occasions, correct? [01:10:34] Kelly Ryan: I believe three occasions. [01:10:39] Speaker 1: Okay. Had you all, had you, any of the records that have been presented in the course of this trial? [01:10:46] Kelly Ryan: No. [01:10:47] Speaker 1: Any of the records that are listed in your sources of information? [01:10:50] Kelly Ryan: No. [01:10:51] Speaker 1: And as you sit here and testify today, you've testified to the same conclusions, correct? [01:10:58] Kelly Ryan: What, what I said was individuals like that present this way. I was not referring to Ms. Clancy. I said individuals who have these symptoms, like the ones I clarified, present that way. That was not an assessment of Ms. Clancy. That was an assessment of people who go the, through major mental health crises. [01:11:27] Speaker 1: But as you sat here today, you've talked about, um, the fact that people, that she had delusional thinking, the fact that she had command hallucinations, the fact that she believed that, um, these voices, and that she was paranoid and worried, you've consistently testified about that throughout the course of yesterday and today, correct? So. It's a yes or no? [01:11:54] Kelly Ryan: You make it impossible to answer that question. All right, the next question. [01:11:59] Speaker 1: In addition to, um, well, you testified today that, um, a person in a psychotic state can do things they've done before, but it might be hard for them to do new tasks, right? Yes. So if it's something that is part of their daily life, getting up, uh, caring for the kids, eating, making a meal, driving a car, those are things that, um, people do every day. And a lot of times don't even have to think about, right? [01:12:34] Kelly Ryan: Yes. No thinking necessary. But you're. No response, automatic response. [01:12:39] Speaker 1: You're aware that on this particular day of this incident, on January 24th of 2023, that, um, the defendant took Cora to the doctors, right? [01:12:50] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:12:51] Speaker 1: And you indicated in your testimony today that it was for a regular checkup, but in your report, you identify that it was for a stomachache, right? [01:12:59] Kelly Ryan: Yes. She had a stomachache. [01:13:02] Speaker 1: But in addition to maybe her having a stomachache, she had previously had this visit scheduled, and you're aware of that now, correct? Yes. Um, and at the doctor, there was a recommendation made for an over-the-counter medication, right? [01:13:18] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:13:19] Speaker 1: And the defendant was able to process that information, take it back with her, and then later, not immediately after the, um, visit, but later in the day, search for where to get that medication, right? [01:13:31] Kelly Ryan: Okay. Psychosis doesn't lower your intellectual functioning, so you can do all those things. [01:13:35] Speaker 1: So that's correct. Well, that wasn't my question. My question was, did she do those things? [01:13:38] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:13:39] Speaker 1: I said that's correct. Okay. Um, and would you, you've talked a lot about, um, that a person can operate as normally as they can, but fair to say, if you're in a psychotic state, that person themselves has a significant amount of distress, right? Yes. And that in order to mask those symptoms, it requires an enormous amount of control. Does it not? [01:14:04] Kelly Ryan: It depends on the level and the extremism of the psychotic processing. So some people will hear voices that are nominal, they whisper. Some people hear voices that are yelling and screaming. So it's, it's on a range. It's a continuum. So the more upsetting, more powerful, demanding the voice, the more difficult it might be to resist it and do other things. The less, the easier it is. Yes. [01:14:35] Speaker 1: In all of the time between September of 2022 and January 23rd of 2023, at any point in which the defendant heard these voices about harming herself, she didn't act on them then, did she? That's correct. [01:14:52] Speaker ?: That's correct. Yes. [01:14:54] Kelly Ryan: She did not act on those. She sought help instead. [01:14:58] Speaker 1: I would move to admit the recording played as the next exhibit. The recording that was played. [01:15:22] Speaker 3: I moved to enter it as the next exhibit, please. [01:15:23] Speaker 1: That may be admitted. I can find it. Here it is. [01:15:27] Speaker 3: Thank you. [01:15:28] Speaker ?: 284. Thank you. [01:15:30] Speaker 1: I have no further questions at this time. Let's talk about confirmation. Can I sit down, please? [01:15:57] Speaker 3: Hold on. Ms. Buckingham. [01:15:59] Speaker 1: Thank you. [01:16:00] Speaker 3: Have a seat. Confirmation bias. In the field of forensics, interfaces, science and the law, trial of cases, hiring experts, having people give an opinion that a jury is going to listen to. Confirmation bias means that the individual might want to help out the person that they're testifying for. Is that right? It can be, yes. So, in other words, if you have a shooting case, and you're a ballistics guy, and without the ballistics showing that the defendant's gun shot the victim, the government has no case. They may send an email to that witness and say, "Hey, I really need your help here." And that might influence them, right? Yes. Now, you got involved with this case, as you indicated, out of my request, obviously. Yes. Compassion. Correct. The fact you had a young lady that was literally in extreme condition, emotionally, physically, you went to speak with her, correct? I did, yes. Do you care for her? I do. And is that a violation of the canon of ethics for professionals like you, if you care for your patient? Not at all. [01:17:37] Kelly Ryan: Within the ethical standards, it's also noted to do an appropriate and meaningful forensic evaluation. It's strongly suggested you develop empathy and rapport. And when you have those two psychological constructs, you get more information from the respondent. You do not cherry pick the information. You include warts and all in your report. That avoids confirmatory bias. And you avoid confirmatory bias by also not looking at conclusions that other examiners come up with when they render their opinions. And you do your evaluations independent of anyone else. You do it by yourself. [01:18:28] Speaker 3: How many times did you see her? [01:18:31] Kelly Ryan: At the time that my report was 60 times. [01:18:38] Speaker 3: How many hours have you put in, sitting with Lindsay, either in the hospital? [01:18:43] Kelly Ryan: Oh, more than that roughly. [01:18:46] Speaker 3: And you have all of that information that you have brought here today to test in yesterday to testify to this jury. Is that correct? Yes. Are you confirmed bias? Are you, are you not telling the truth just to help Lindsay out? Or is this your opinion based upon your review of the records, your interview of her, whether or not you care for her or not? Overruled. [01:19:11] Kelly Ryan: Overruled. Overruled. I am telling the truth. She can't. She can't. [01:19:17] Speaker ?: Yeah. [01:19:18] Kelly Ryan: You can refer, we've re-asked that question. That answer will be stricken. [01:19:23] Speaker 3: So, you can't tell someone you're telling the truth. Okay. That's up to the jury to decide. Your opinion is based upon all of the times that you met with Lindsay, right? Yes. All of the documents that you've reviewed. All of this, all the exhibits that you're aware of, right? Yes. [01:19:40] Kelly Ryan: As well as collateral contacts. [01:19:42] Speaker 3: And in the course of your treatment and evaluation of her, one of the things the DA asked you about is the request that we brought to the court. For accommodations. Do you recall that question from her? Yes. And is it your understanding that the request that we had seeking help from the judge was that she not be chained to a van when she's brought into this courthouse? No. For five week trial? Yes. [01:20:13] Kelly Ryan: From Tewkesbury to Plymouth. [01:20:15] Speaker 3: And her medical condition with her paralysis and all of the rest of the bodily functions that you lose. That's a concern. Isn't that right? [01:20:24] Kelly Ryan: Very much so. Yes. [01:20:26] Speaker 3: And we also had to have the help of nurses that would be available in the event that there was any type of emergency issue. Correct? That we have to ask of the court. [01:20:34] Kelly Ryan: No, overruled. Yes. They're here every day. [01:20:37] Speaker ?: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. [01:20:41] Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you. Conformation bias. Can you tell this jury, is your opinion based upon money? Maybe you like me? Maybe you want to help her? Or is that based to your best ability as a professional of many, many years? [01:21:00] Kelly Ryan: Yes. Confirmation bias is coming up with a conclusion before you reach an opinion. It's in Latin, a tabula rasa, a blank slate. You draw no conclusion. The conclusion finds you. And if you don't do that, you are at risk of having confirmation bias. [01:21:27] Speaker 3: I'm going to ask you a hypothetical and see if the hypothetical fits within your understanding as an expert of confirmation bias. Let's say that a young woman was involved in an incident such as this that results in the death of her three babies. And that young woman is paralyzed. And that young woman is in a hospital. That young woman is facing indictments for triple homicide. And the incident occurred on January 24th, 2023. And it's not until. 2026. That the district attorney's office hires three doctors. Yeah, sustained. All right, we'll return now to redirect council. Thank you. So as it relates to the concept of confirmatory bias, sir, in your opinion, with your experience, does the period of time within which an expert is hired by one side or another to evaluate a person and give an opinion. In other words, if it's a compressed period of time as opposed to an expanded period of time. Is that one indication of confirmatory bias? Overruled. [01:23:14] Kelly Ryan: It depends on the examiner and the situation. It can be. But individuals who pay attention to that concern should maintain healthful boundaries and not have any confirmatory bias. What does that mean? It means stay in your lane. That's better. [01:23:37] Speaker 3: Now, one of the things that the district attorney did is took the 7,001 pages of the records from Tewkesbury Hospital and read excerpts from them to you. Is that correct? [01:23:57] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:23:58] Speaker 3: And Lindsay, after she was taken from Social Hospital to Brigham and Women's, then from Brigham and Women's to the rehab, Spalding Rehab, she ended up in Tewkesbury. Is that correct? [01:24:14] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:24:15] Speaker 3: And Tewkesbury has been very good. I mean, in your opinion, have they been good with her? Fantastic. [01:24:21] Kelly Ryan: Fantastic. [01:24:22] Speaker 3: But nevertheless, that is still a facility that is a state facility, right? Yes. And the district attorney asked you about the plan to have Lindsay go to another facility, Worcester, I think it was? [01:24:37] Kelly Ryan: Worcester Recovery Center Hospital. [01:24:39] Speaker 3: Is that a relatively new facility? [01:24:41] Kelly Ryan: It's, I believe, the newest facility in the Commonwealth. [01:24:44] Speaker 3: And did we have Lindsay evaluated to have her transfer to Worcester Hospital? [01:24:50] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:24:51] Speaker 3: Was she allowed to make entry into Worcester facility? She was not. [01:24:56] Kelly Ryan: Why is that? She was not allowed because she. Overruled. She was not allowed because she has pending criminal charges. [01:25:04] Speaker 3: That would be this case here, right? [01:25:05] Kelly Ryan: That's this case here. [01:25:07] Speaker 3: And the district attorney took the 7,000 pages in one of the records and apparently went through them to the anniversary of the death of her three children, correct? [01:25:23] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:25:24] Speaker 3: In your opinion, you've been in a lot of medical institutions and facilities in the Commonwealth and out of the state, correct? Yes. Is it your understanding to a reasonable degree of medical certainty that the fact that a woman who is paralyzed is propelling herself down the hall from one room to another is indicative? Is it indicative of anything? [01:25:56] Kelly Ryan: Not at all. [01:25:57] Speaker 3: How about the fact that her mother and father, who have been with her for three years and practically missed not one day of sitting with her and bringing her dinner or lunch, is that something that would be indicative of undercutting the fact that the woman was suffering from mental disease or defect? That's indicative of love. [01:26:17] Kelly Ryan: That's indicative of love. [01:26:18] Speaker 3: How about the fact that she's talking to other inmates or people that are patients? And in your review of the records, would you tell us your opinion as to her level or degree of popularity, bluntly, in that particular ward? [01:26:35] Kelly Ryan: She is extremely, extremely well regarded and well liked on that unit by everyone. [01:26:47] Speaker 3: Overruled. How about in reviewing the records, I didn't hear that she's laughing and partying and having a good time while she's in the Tewkesbury Hospital. Did you see anything like that? [01:26:59] Kelly Ryan: No, Lindsay Clancy has bad days and worse days. [01:27:04] Speaker 3: And when you speak with her and meet with her, a doctor, has she ever mentioned her children? Because apparently according to the question that you underwent, she never talks about her kids. [01:27:20] Kelly Ryan: She does speak about her children. [01:27:22] Speaker 3: What does she say? [01:27:27] Kelly Ryan: She really loves them and misses them and thinks of them every single day, almost every moment of the day. [01:27:40] Speaker 3: And finally, doctor, I'm holding up what has been marked as exhibit one or I, I don't know, for identification. Have you seen this before? [01:27:50] Kelly Ryan: Yes, I have. [01:27:52] Speaker 3: And in your dealing with Lindsay and interview of collateral contacts such as Patrick, do you know what that is? [01:28:03] Kelly Ryan: Yes, I do. [01:28:04] Speaker 3: What is it? [01:28:06] Kelly Ryan: It's called the wish vase. [01:28:09] Speaker 3: And what does that mean and what is it? [01:28:12] Kelly Ryan: This is a vase that Ms. Clancy and her husband purchased in Hawaii when they went on their honeymoon shortly after getting married. Senator, I would suggest, can you approach that? Yeah, sure, seat sidebar please. [01:28:28] Speaker 3: Your Honor, I would hand this to Chrissy to have it back and admit it. [01:28:39] Speaker ?: All right. [01:28:40] Kelly Ryan: Over the Comos objection, that may be admitted. [01:28:44] Speaker ?: Okay, thank you very much. Thank you very much. [01:28:46] Speaker 3: All right. Kamal? Sorry, please, please. [01:28:49] Speaker 1: Doctor, how many defendants that you've evaluated for criminal responsibility have you spent 35 hours evaluating? One. [01:29:04] Kelly Ryan: One. One other one. One other person. [01:29:07] Speaker 1: And how many other defendants have you evaluated that you've testified that you care deeply for them? [01:29:16] Speaker ?: I would say one other one. [01:29:17] Speaker 1: And how many other defendants have you given press conferences about? None. And how many other defendants that you've evaluated have you gone back every day into the lockup to check on? [01:29:35] Kelly Ryan: I was sequestered on all those other trials, so I was not even allowed in the court. [01:29:46] Speaker 1: Now, you were asked about confirmation bias and given a hypothetical about if somebody was asked to examine a gun, right? You recall that line of questioning? Yes, I do. [01:29:59] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:30:00] Speaker 1: You were hired by the defense in this case, were you not? [01:30:04] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:30:05] Speaker 1: Okay. And as far as your conversations with the defendant about her children, you're also aware that she continually refers to this situation as my tragedy, does she not? [01:30:19] Kelly Ryan: That moniker of my tragedy? That's just one of the things I shall say. [01:30:23] Speaker 1: All right. [01:30:24] Kelly Ryan: Thank you. [01:30:25] Speaker ?: You're welcome. [01:30:26] Speaker 3: And what's the reason that with the understanding of the court permission that you go to the lockup and see her during this trial? [01:30:34] Kelly Ryan: I go to the lock. It's a state. [01:30:37] Speaker 3: Well, while she's in Tewkesbury, Council kept referring to SID, SISI. What is SI? [01:30:48] Kelly Ryan: SI is suicide intention or suicide ideation. [01:30:54] Speaker 3: In Tewkesbury, has there been a concern of suicidal ideation? [01:31:05] Kelly Ryan: Yes. [01:31:06] Speaker 3: And what is a result of that SI, as counsel kept repeating to you through the records, is her status at Tewkesbury? [01:31:15] Kelly Ryan: She's on a constant one-to-one to ensure that Ms. Clancy doesn't take her own life. [01:31:21] Speaker 3: And that is somewhat similar to the reference in Brigham and Woman's Hospital when you were talking with her, that there was a nurse that was sitting in the corner of the room at all times. Is that right? [01:31:33] Kelly Ryan: Yes, that's correct. [01:31:34] Speaker 3: Inferentially was able to hear any conversation that you had with Lindsay, right? [01:31:40] Kelly Ryan: I asked those people to leave. Thank you. [01:31:43] Speaker 3: Councilor, can I see you just one? [01:31:51] Speaker ?: Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. [01:32:21] Speaker 3: So finally, I will ask you again, what, to your understanding, is the purpose of you, during this trial, going back as the Council asked you about, to lock up with Lindsay? [01:32:38] Kelly Ryan: To ensure that Ms. Clancy is stable and competent to stand trial. [01:32:44] Speaker 3: Any concerns as far as her SI? [01:32:48] Kelly Ryan: She's in good hands at the moment, but there's always a concern that sits directly below the surface. Thank you. You're welcome. Tuning Buckingham, please. [01:32:58] Speaker 1: Dr. Zizel, in three years, she's never made an attempt to harm herself, has she? Other than January 24th of 2023? [01:33:04] Kelly Ryan: No. [01:33:05] Speaker 1: Thank you. [01:33:06] Kelly Ryan: All right. Anything further? All right, thank you, Dr. [01:33:09] Speaker ?: Thank you, Your Honor.

Transcribe Any Video or Podcast — Free

Paste a URL and get a full AI-powered transcript in minutes. Try ScribeHawk →