PROSECUTION DROPPED 3 CHARGES?! Defense ERUPTS as Senators React! — IMPEACHMENT WATCH DAY 39

[0:00] Na-drop na yung tatlong Articles of Impeachment ngayong araw na ito, Day 39 para sa Impeachment ni Sara Duterte. [0:20] Ito ang bombshell na binagsak ng prosecution para sa ating lahat. [0:26] At I'm sure lahat kayo nagulat kayo sa narinig nyong balita na hindi na daw ipopursue ng ating prosecution ang tatlong Articles. [0:36] So, ano yung tatlong Articles ito? Pag-uusapan natin ngayon kung ano ba yung nangyari ngayong araw na ito. [0:41] Day 39 sa Impeachment. [0:43] Tapos, titignan natin yung mga highlights ng araw na ito at ano yung mga objections ng defense. [0:49] At ano din ang sinabi dito ng mga senator judges tungkol sa issue na ito. [0:55] And we are going to also analyze and give insights kung bakit ba ito ginawa ng prosecution. [1:01] Ano ba talaga yung strategy nila? [1:03] Tama ba ito? Mali? Ano yung pros at cons na itong decision na ito? [1:09] Makakatulong ba ito sa prosecution o makakasama? [1:11] Makakatulong ba ito sa defense o makakasama? [1:14] Pag-aaralan natin lahat ngayon dito sa Impeachment Watch. [1:18] Magandang araw, maganda gabi sa inyo lahat. [1:20] Ako po si Kristen at ang naglilingkod sa inyo araw-araw tungkol sa impeachment. [1:25] Ito ang last day natin ng Impeachment Watch for the month of October. [1:28] Dahil ang susunod na na-impeachment trial ay mag-uumpisa ulit on November 9. [1:36] So basically one month from now ang sunod na Impeachment Watch at ang sunod na impeachment. [1:41] So kaya ililimit natin at ito yung last natin for the month of October pagdating sa impeachment livestream natin. [1:51] Okay, sa mga viewers, welcome sa inyo lahat at may mga nagpapa-shoutout. [1:55] Sigal just do some quick shoutouts saan before we get started. [1:58] Ayan o, si Takfadidadi, Hila Season niya, pagod na. [2:05] O, pa-shoutout daw kay Nover de los Santos. [2:10] O, tapos sabi dito, first time watching this live. [2:13] Thank you Sir Chris for dumbing down very technical courtroom exchanges for us. [2:16] We try to put it all in layman's terms as best as we can. [2:20] Tapos sa mga DDS supporters, huwag maging bulag sa katotohanan. [2:25] If nakita ko na talagang di-guilty si Sarah, then fine. [2:28] Pero sa mga evidence na nakita natin, wow, magising na tayo para sa ating bayan. [2:32] I agree. Para sa ating bansa, yes. [2:35] Alright, so ganito yun guys. [2:38] At the start of this, there were four articles that were submitted to the Senate. [2:45] Yung apat na articles na ito composed of Article 1, which is regarding the confidential funds. [2:50] Article 2, yung sa SAL-IN. [2:53] Article 3, yung sa bribery. [2:55] Article 4, yung sa grave threats. [2:58] Okay, so pagdating naman sa impeachment, ang una nilang tinakol ng prosecution is grave threat. [3:05] Sumunod dito yung issue sa misuse of the confidential funds. [3:09] At yung pangatlo, yung SAL-IN niya at yung bank records. [3:13] Ngayon, dinrop na nila yung Article 3, which is the indirect bribery. [3:22] Tinanggal na nila yun. [3:23] So wala na yun. [3:24] So yun, hindi na nilang pinresenta. [3:26] So yung issue natin today at yung issue ng defense ay hindi yung Article 3. [3:31] Yung issue ng defense is Article 1 and Article 4. [3:35] Kasi napresenta na yung ebidensya. [3:39] Nagpresenta sila, nagpakita ng mga witnesses, yung prosecution. [3:42] Pinakita na, basically nilabas na lahat ng kailangan na ipakita yung ebidensya. [3:47] Tapos pagkatapos nilabakita yung ebidensya, [3:50] sasabihin nila bigla at tapos na kami, [3:52] idadrop na namin yung mga charges. [3:54] Meron tayong mga kababayan that do not agree with this. [3:57] I myself don't agree sa ginawa ng prosecution. [4:01] And I'll explain kung bakit ako mismo hindi ako nag-agree. [4:04] At ano bang implication na ito? [4:06] Pag ngayon na nag-drop na itong mga articles na ito. [4:10] Alright? [4:10] So, first, pakinggan natin si Congresswoman and Attorney Jingli Wistro [4:17] sa kanyang manifestation. [4:19] And then, papakinggan din natin yung sinabi ni Attorney Sheila Sison, [4:23] aka Ms. Tapia, [4:24] na nagwawala na naman, ano na naman siya, [4:28] nag-rant, at alam mo, grabe. [4:32] Alam mo, may masasabi. [4:34] Meron ako sa papakita sa inyo na [4:35] naglabas ng salita si [4:38] Attorney Lorna Capunan tungkol kay [4:41] Attorney Sison dahil sa mga [4:44] ginagawa niya, yung pananalita niya, [4:47] yung pamamaraan kung paano siya nagsasalita. [4:50] But before we do that, panoorin muna natin [4:52] yung sinabi ni Wistro. [4:55] Okay? [4:56] So, let's get started with that. [4:58] Alright? [4:58] Here we go. [5:03] Actually, nakakatawa nga si [5:04] si Attorney Sheila Sison. [5:08] Alright, here we go. [5:13] Yes, Your Honor. [5:14] Mr. Presiding Officer, [5:15] the Honorable Senator Judges, [5:21] four articles of impeachment [5:22] were filed against the respondent Vice President. [5:27] Today, the prosecution respectfully manifest [5:30] that it will no longer pursue three of them. [5:38] It will stand on one, [5:40] and that is Article 2 on Unexplained Wealth. [5:47] Let me explain in three parts. [5:51] First, our decision to focus on what is necessary. [5:58] During pre-trial, [6:00] the prosecution named numerous witnesses, [6:04] but did not present all of them. [6:08] On the Article on Threats, [6:10] we named 10 witnesses [6:11] and presented only three. [6:13] On the Article on Confidential Funds, [6:18] we named 27 [6:19] and presented only 11. [6:22] On the Article on Unexplained Wealth, [6:26] we named 15 [6:27] and presented 11, [6:30] not counting, [6:32] the individual bank [6:33] and insurance witnesses. [6:34] On the Article on Bribery, [6:37] we will present none [6:40] of the five witnesses we had named. [6:45] In all, [6:46] some 32 witnesses [6:47] will no longer be called [6:49] to the witness stand. [6:52] This reflects [6:53] the prosecution's considered decision [6:55] to focus its case [6:57] only on the witnesses [6:59] absolutely necessary [7:01] for each article. [7:05] Second, [7:07] the proceedings that will no longer be necessary. [7:09] The prosecution has not yet made [7:13] its formal offer [7:14] of documentary evidence. [7:17] Had we proceeded [7:18] on all four articles, [7:21] the impeachment court [7:21] would have had to consider [7:23] the evidence offered for each [7:25] together with the corresponding objections [7:28] and arguments. [7:31] By focusing on one article, [7:34] the matters requiring [7:35] the impeachment court's consideration [7:37] are correspondingly narrowed [7:39] with practical benefits [7:41] for the Senate, [7:44] the respondent, [7:44] and even the public. [7:48] Third, [7:49] why one article is enough? [7:52] The prosecution believes [7:53] it has presented sufficient evidence [7:55] for Article 2 [7:57] to stand on its own. [8:00] All in po tayo dito. [8:03] We believe that evidence [8:04] is substantial and compelling [8:06] and warrants [8:08] the respondent's removal from office [8:10] for culpable violation [8:12] of the Constitution [8:13] and betrayal of public trust. [8:17] Article 2, [8:18] the article on unexplained wealth [8:20] covers three matters. [8:22] One, unexplained wealth. [8:26] Two, violations of the SALIN. [8:29] And three, prohibited business interest. [8:33] We believe we have provided [8:34] sufficient evidence [8:36] on all these allegations. [8:39] In the prosecution's assessment, [8:41] concentrating on this article [8:43] is the most judicious course [8:45] consistent with the evidence [8:47] and our duty to the nation. [8:51] Therefore, [8:52] Honorable Senator Judges, [8:55] beloved countrymen, [8:56] the prosecution formally manifest [8:58] its withdrawal of [9:00] and intention [9:02] to no longer pursue [9:03] Article 1 [9:05] on confidential funds, [9:08] Article 3 [9:08] on bribery, [9:10] and Article 4 [9:11] on threats. [9:13] We respectfully submit [9:15] this manifestation [9:16] to the Honorable Impeachment Court [9:18] for its consideration [9:19] and appropriate action. [9:22] We recall the impeachment trial [9:23] of then Chief Justice [9:25] Renato Corona [9:25] in which the prosecution [9:28] likewise withdrew [9:29] certain articles [9:30] and proceeded only [9:32] on the remaining ones. [9:35] That president [9:35] recognized the prosecution's privilege [9:38] to determine [9:39] which articles to pursue [9:40] and which to draw. [9:43] This manifestation [9:44] is made [9:45] in that same spirit [9:46] to exercise [9:48] the prosecution's judgment [9:50] on which charges [9:51] to pursue [9:52] as well as [9:54] to safeguard [9:55] the interest of the nation [9:56] against betrayal [9:58] of public trust [9:59] and culpable violation [10:00] of the Constitution. [10:02] Thank you. [10:03] Alright. [10:03] So, ito yung manifestation [10:04] na ginawa ni [10:05] Attorney Luizro. [10:07] Ang kong gusto mo, Luizro. [10:08] At interesting nga, [10:09] pag tinignan mo, [10:10] kasi meron nga [10:10] 10 witnesses [10:11] na dapat i-represent [10:12] for grave threat, [10:13] tatlo na lang yung ginawa nila. [10:15] Tapos sa Article 1 naman, [10:17] 27 witness, [10:18] present nila 11 na lang. [10:19] Article 2, [10:20] dapat 15 witness, [10:21] present nila 11. [10:22] Hindi pa kasama yung [10:23] mga bank officials daw. [10:25] What's interesting [10:25] for me is this, [10:26] na ang trabaho kasi [10:29] ng prosecution [10:30] ay ilatag lahat [10:31] ng mga ebidensya. [10:32] Pero at the same time, [10:33] nakikita nila kasi [10:35] yung interest ng public [10:37] pagdating sa issue [10:38] ng impeachment. [10:39] And I really believe [10:40] that they're very sensitive [10:41] sa feedback [10:44] na nakukuha nila [10:45] from the netizens [10:47] at sa mga kababayan natin [10:48] in terms of yung interest [10:50] sa impeachment. [10:52] Ang tingin kong kinatatakutan [10:54] ng defense [10:54] ay baka sobrang mabor tayong lahat. [10:58] At kumbaga, [10:58] mamanihit tayo [10:59] sa sobrang haba [11:01] ng impeachment [11:02] na baka makalimutan na natin [11:04] kung ano ba [11:05] yung mga kasalanan [11:07] ni Sara Duterte. [11:08] So, [11:09] and [11:09] nung umpisa palang [11:10] sinasabi nila [11:11] that they want to finish this [11:12] bago magpasko. [11:13] Yun ang target nila. [11:15] Pero, [11:16] pag pinatuloy nila [11:17] yung articles, [11:20] yung apat na articles, [11:21] talagang lalampas tayo [11:22] ng Pasko. [11:23] Kasi ngayon pa lang [11:23] nasa halos gitna na tayo [11:25] ng October. [11:26] Tapos, [11:26] pag tinignan mo, [11:27] ilang araw [11:27] ang kailangan ng defense. [11:28] Tapos, [11:29] sinasabi nga ng defense [11:30] that they have 90 witnesses [11:31] daw. [11:33] Alright? [11:34] I mean, [11:34] if they had to present [11:35] all 90, [11:35] I don't think they will. [11:37] Masarayan pa ka silang witness [11:38] kasi sa prosecution. [11:39] Kasi yung prosecution [11:40] only has [11:41] 27, [11:42] 37, [11:44] 47, [11:45] 53 [11:45] total witnesses. [11:47] Not counting yung [11:48] article 3. [11:50] So, [11:50] pag tinignan mo dito, [11:51] honestly, [11:52] I don't think they have 90 witnesses. [11:54] I think they're just saying [11:55] they have 90. [11:56] So, [11:56] pag nakita mo ito, [11:58] ang gusto gawin ng prosecution [11:59] is paiklin talaga [12:00] itong [12:01] trial. [12:02] And, [12:04] naniniwala sila [12:05] that article 2 [12:07] is enough [12:07] to impeach [12:08] Sara Duterte. [12:10] Ako, [12:10] ako para sa akin ganito yan. [12:12] All in na sila [12:13] sa article 2. [12:15] Now, [12:15] there is wisdom in this [12:16] but again, [12:17] ako I'm not for it. [12:18] Sinasabi ko sa inyo ngayon. [12:20] I'm actually against this decision. [12:21] But, [12:22] I'll explain muna [12:22] yung what's going on [12:24] in their head [12:24] at ano ba yung wisdom na [12:26] gina, [12:27] o at least yung [12:28] strategy na ginagawa nila dito. [12:29] Kasi, [12:30] ganito yan. [12:31] Pag yung mga, [12:32] judges, [12:32] senator judges sa atin, [12:33] titignan lahat ng mga [12:34] ebidensya, [12:35] mga documentary evidence, [12:37] voluminous yan. [12:38] Ibig sabihin, [12:39] ang dami sobrang mga [12:40] kailangan basahin, [12:42] mga transcripts, [12:43] pag-aralan. [12:44] Although, [12:45] honestly, [12:46] yung mga napakinggan mo pa lang, [12:48] medyo, [12:48] you can make [12:49] an educated decision already [12:53] pagdating doon. [12:54] Pero, [12:55] syempre, [12:55] bubusisihin nila yan. [12:56] Titignan nga yung mga [12:57] ebidensya pinresenta, [12:58] pag-aaralan lahat ng mga araw. [13:00] At sa ganun, [13:01] talagang matatagalan, [13:02] bago makapag-desisyon [13:03] yung mga senator judges, [13:04] ang ginawa ng prosecution [13:07] by saying, [13:08] isa na lang, [13:09] is saying to the [13:10] senator judges, [13:11] o sige, [13:12] just look at this one, [13:14] SALEN, [13:15] SALEN, [13:16] bank records, [13:18] under declaration of wealth, [13:20] and unexplained wealth. [13:21] Tignan lang nyo yan. [13:23] Yan ba isang tao [13:24] na nararapat, [13:26] magkaroon ng pagkakataon [13:27] na maging pangulo [13:28] ng ating bansa? [13:29] Yan ba ang pinapayagan nyo? [13:31] Na hindi nagdeklara [13:32] ng maayos [13:33] ng kanyang SALEN. [13:35] Not by, [13:36] remember, [13:38] yung misdeklaration niya [13:39] is not like [13:40] 10% less [13:41] or 10% more. [13:43] It is [13:43] over 30% [13:46] nung threshold [13:47] na sinasabi nga nila [13:48] na pag lumampas [13:49] ang 30% more or less [13:51] na parang may kalokohan na [13:53] meron ng what they call [13:54] prima facie fraud [13:56] o ibig sabihin [13:58] merong suspicion na [14:00] for na fraudulent to [14:01] nagsinadya to. [14:03] Hindi ito parang [14:04] nagkamali lang [14:05] na pwedeng palitan. [14:07] Kasi yung [14:07] dineklara ni Sarah Duterte [14:08] dito ay [14:09] 98 million [14:11] na sasaliin niya [14:12] sa 2025. [14:13] Pero lumalabas [14:14] ang under declaration niya [14:16] ay umaabot [14:18] ng hindi [14:18] 817 million [14:20] na [14:20] 831 million [14:23] pala. [14:25] Pero remember, [14:26] that's on the [14:26] conservative side. [14:27] And I bet you, [14:28] ang hindi dineklara [14:29] ni Sarah Duterte [14:30] at ng kanyang asawa [14:31] si Manz Carp [14:32] ay umaabot [14:32] ng lampas [14:33] 1 billion. [14:35] Ito pa lang [14:36] yung conservative estimate [14:37] na ginawa [14:38] ng prosecution witness [14:40] sa si Atty. Cabrera. [14:43] Kaya, [14:43] pag tinignan mo, [14:44] ito pa lang [14:44] matibay na sobra [14:46] na mako-convict [14:48] itong si Sarah Duterte [14:49] sa kanyang impeachment trial. [14:51] Ngayon, [14:52] bakit hindi ako [14:53] sang-ayon dito? [14:55] Okay, [14:55] for several reasons. [14:56] Let's first talk about [14:57] reason number one. [14:58] Reason number one dito [14:59] kaya hindi ako sang-ayon [15:00] is pag-isa lang kasi [15:03] para kang, [15:05] let's use the analogy [15:06] of baseball. [15:07] Para kang may batter ka [15:09] na pupunta doon [15:10] sa batter mound [15:10] tapos [15:11] isang pagkakataon lang [15:13] mag-swing [15:14] and dapat [15:15] home run na yan. [15:17] Pag na-miss, [15:18] wala na. [15:19] There's no more [15:19] second pitch, [15:21] third pitch, [15:22] fourth pitch. [15:23] Diba sa baseball, [15:24] meron kang three strikes [15:25] bago ma-out. [15:26] Diba? [15:27] Three strikes. [15:29] Dito, [15:30] isang strike, [15:31] wala na ang laban, [15:32] tapos na ang laban. [15:33] Hindi na magkakaroon [15:34] ng pangalawa [15:35] o pangatlong pagkakataon [15:36] para mag-home run hit. [15:39] So, [15:40] pag tinignan mo, [15:41] instead of four times [15:43] sa magkakaroon [15:43] ng pagkakataon, [15:44] sabihin na [15:44] convict or acquit, [15:46] convict or acquit, [15:47] convict or acquit, [15:48] and convict or acquit, [15:49] isang beses na lang to. [15:50] Kasi all four articles [15:52] are dealt with [15:54] independently, [15:55] individually. [15:57] So, [15:57] kahit ma-quit siya sa tatlo, [15:58] pag isa ma-convict, [16:00] convicted yan, [16:01] tanggal yan sa opisina niya. [16:03] So, [16:04] yun yung reason [16:05] kung bakit hindi ako [16:06] sangayon dito. [16:07] Pangalawa, [16:08] pangalawang rason [16:08] kung hindi ako sangayon, [16:11] gusto ko marinig talaga [16:12] kung ano sasabihin [16:13] ng defense [16:14] at paano nila [16:15] dedepensahan [16:16] yung grave threat. [16:18] Ano sasabihin nila? [16:19] I am so curious [16:21] kung sinong witness [16:22] ang ipapalabas sila [16:23] na magsasabi na, [16:24] ano, [16:25] na hindi talaga [16:27] sinabi ni Sarah Duterte yun, [16:29] nagkaroon tayo [16:29] ng mass hallucination, [16:31] hindi natin narinig [16:32] yung narinig natin [16:33] yung binantaan niya [16:34] yung buhay ng presidente, [16:35] first lady [16:37] at yung dating speaker [16:38] of the house? [16:39] Anong sasabihin niya dito? [16:41] Kasi umamin si Sarah Duterte [16:43] na sinabi nga niya [16:44] na nag-hire na nga siya [16:47] ng hitman [16:48] para patayin si BBM. [16:51] Sinabi niya, [16:52] inulit pa niya [16:52] ilang beses. [16:53] So, sunod naman, [16:56] yung issue ng [16:56] confidential funds, [16:58] malinaw [16:59] na walang [17:00] Mary Grace Piatos. [17:02] Ano? [17:02] Tingin mo may darating [17:03] na pangalan niya [17:04] Mary Grace Piatos? [17:06] Ha? [17:06] Andilim? [17:07] May darating kaya? [17:09] May darating kaya [17:10] na nagpumirma, [17:12] si Chell Jokno [17:12] na nagsabing [17:13] nakapirma din doon? [17:14] Alalahan ninyo, [17:15] pati Chell Jokno [17:16] nakapirma daw doon. [17:17] Sino mo darating doon [17:18] to say na sila [17:20] yung nakatanggap [17:20] ng pera? [17:21] Ano? [17:21] La Chica pupunta? [17:23] Nolasco pupunta? [17:24] Yung mga security officers [17:26] ni Sarah Duterte [17:27] na naglabas [17:29] nung nag-withdraw [17:30] ng 125 million [17:32] sa isang araw? [17:34] O, sino? [17:35] Sino ang witness [17:36] na lahaharap? [17:38] Diba? [17:40] Paano nila papatunayan [17:41] na hindi nilustay [17:42] ni Sarah Duterte [17:43] yung pera? [17:44] O. [17:45] So, yung dalawang yung pa lang, [17:47] mabigat na. [17:47] I would love to hear [17:49] what they have to say. [17:51] So, kaya yun ang rason [17:52] kung bakit [17:52] medyo nalungkot ako [17:54] na hindi na-denrap na [17:56] yung mga kaso [17:56] at hindi na mapapakinggan. [17:58] Ngayon, eto na. [17:59] Pangatlong rason [18:00] kung bakit [18:01] hindi ako agree dito. [18:03] Kasi, [18:04] pwede itong gamitin [18:05] ng defense [18:06] na para [18:08] palitan ng naratibo. [18:10] Napapalabas sila ngayon [18:11] and I, [18:12] I mean, [18:13] I don't want to help [18:13] the defense [18:14] kung anong [18:15] anong sasabihin nila [18:16] pero [18:17] I'm gonna say it anyway [18:19] because I really think [18:20] that the strategy [18:21] if I were the defense [18:22] if I were [18:23] Sara Duterte [18:23] alam mo gagawin ko? [18:25] I'm gonna go [18:25] full blast [18:26] with all my trolls [18:28] at sasabihin ko na [18:29] tignan mo [18:30] political persecution [18:33] kaya [18:34] dinrop nila [18:34] yung dalawang charges [18:36] o yung total [18:36] ng tatlo [18:37] dahil alam nila [18:38] na matibay [18:39] ang ebidensya ko [18:40] na wala akong [18:41] ginawang kasalanan [18:42] na hindi ako [18:42] nag-grave threat [18:43] na ginamit ko [18:44] sa tamang paraan [18:45] ng confidential funds [18:46] natatakot silang [18:47] marinig ang katotohanan [18:48] kaya [18:49] dinrop na lang [18:50] yung mga charges [18:50] para hindi ako [18:51] magkaroon ng pagkakataon [18:52] i-explain [18:53] yung aking [18:53] yung aking [18:54] yung aking posisyon [18:56] yung aking [18:57] innocence [18:58] yun ang [18:59] yun ang gagawin ko [19:00] if I were Sara [19:01] tapos sabi ko [19:02] sa lahat ng troll [19:03] ilabas niyan [19:04] tapos [19:05] sa lahat [19:06] troll army [19:06] lahat ng mga magkocomment [19:07] maglalike niyan [19:08] imagine mo yan [19:09] ang gagawin nila [19:10] malay mo nga [19:11] gagawin nila [19:12] whether I say it or not [19:13] gagawin nila yun [19:14] kasi nga [19:14] mabilis [19:16] mabudol [19:18] pabaya natin [19:19] sa mga naratibo [19:20] depende kung saan [19:21] sila pumapanig [19:22] at ito ang nakikita [19:24] kong pwedeng gawin [19:26] ng vice-presidente [19:27] at ng kanyang team [19:28] para [19:28] baliin yung naratibo [19:31] at ipalabas [19:32] na tignan mo [19:33] mahina yung kaso [19:34] kaya nila ito [19:34] dinadrop [19:35] yun ang rason [19:36] dahil nag-fail [19:38] na nga yung [19:38] remember [19:39] Sara Duterte [19:40] just had a press con [19:41] na sinasabi nga niya [19:42] nag-fail na nga [19:43] magpakita daw [19:44] ng evidence [19:45] at wala naman daw [19:45] evidence [19:46] tapos sabi niya [19:47] kaya tignan mo [19:48] dinadrop na nila ito [19:49] I can really see [19:51] them doing that [19:52] okay [19:53] so yan ang mga rason [19:55] why I don't agree [19:57] dito sa strategy [19:59] ng prosecution [20:00] okay [20:01] ngayon [20:02] si Miss Tapia naman [20:03] I mean si [20:04] Attorney Cizo naman [20:05] ay nag-object [20:06] obviously [20:07] nag-object siya [20:08] I will give her [20:09] the opportunity [20:09] na papakinggan nyo [20:11] yung kanyang objection [20:12] okay [20:13] para namang [20:13] ati Sabina [20:14] para namang [20:15] masabi na [20:16] fair naman tayo [20:17] ito yung objection [20:21] ni Attorney Cizo [20:22] thank the [20:23] lead prosecutor [20:24] for the calendar [20:24] today [20:25] in that [20:26] it now has given [20:27] formal notice [20:28] that the prosecution [20:29] after 38 days [20:30] and [20:31] expenditure [20:33] of government resources [20:34] presenting [20:36] all these witnesses [20:38] and [20:39] so-called evidence [20:40] and spending [20:41] all our time [20:42] coming to court [20:43] is now formally withdrawing [20:46] two of those articles [20:47] for which they had [20:47] presented evidence [20:48] and we respect the decision [20:49] of the prosecution [20:51] however [20:51] whether this will affect [20:52] how the defense [20:54] planned to proceed [20:56] with its presentation [20:57] of evidence [20:57] is [20:58] something that [20:59] we must make clear [21:01] it will not [21:02] because the prosecution [21:03] cannot make decisions [21:05] for [21:06] the respondent [21:07] and the defense [21:08] in other words [21:09] the prosecution [21:10] cannot be allowed [21:11] to have the benefit [21:13] of its accusations [21:14] without [21:15] bearing the burden [21:16] of having those [21:16] accusations [21:17] tested [21:18] and the court [21:19] has already heard [21:20] the prosecution's [21:21] alleged evidence [21:22] and the interpretations [21:23] it laid on them [21:25] and the public [21:25] has been [21:27] already exposed [21:28] to its allegations [21:29] repeatedly [21:30] through long interjections [21:31] interpellations [21:32] direct examinations [21:34] and the many [21:35] conclusions and opinions [21:36] that several of their [21:37] witnesses [21:37] have given [21:38] before this honorable court [21:40] and therefore [21:41] the accusations [21:42] have already entered [21:43] the consciousness [21:44] of those [21:46] who must [21:46] ultimately [21:47] render judgment [21:48] in other words [21:49] the prosecution [21:50] would thus [21:51] retain the benefit [21:52] of having its evidence [21:53] heard [21:53] while the respondent [21:54] would be [21:55] or [21:56] would be at risk [21:58] of being denied [21:59] the benefit of having [22:00] that evidence [22:01] contradicted [22:01] and we feel [22:03] and we believe [22:03] that this is not [22:04] fairness [22:05] and it is not [22:06] in keeping [22:07] with the guarantees [22:08] of due process [22:09] because [22:10] the right to be heard [22:11] is not merely [22:12] satisfied [22:13] by allowing the respondent [22:14] some room [22:15] to present evidence [22:17] on her behalf [22:18] it necessarily [22:19] includes [22:19] a meaningful [22:20] opportunity [22:21] to answer [22:21] material accusations [22:23] already publicly [22:25] advanced [22:25] against her [22:26] especially in this case [22:28] where those allegations [22:29] have been placed [22:30] before [22:31] the very tribunal [22:32] that will decide [22:33] this case [22:33] and all [22:34] for the entire [22:35] country [22:36] and member [22:37] of this nation [22:37] for their hearing [22:39] pleasure [22:40] and so [22:42] we believe [22:43] that [22:43] even as we respect [22:45] the prosecution's decision [22:46] to withdraw [22:48] the three articles [22:49] or the two articles [22:50] today [22:51] in addition to [22:51] article three [22:52] or the bribery [22:53] article [22:54] the prosecution [22:55] nonetheless [22:56] cannot unilaterally [22:57] determine [22:58] how the defense [22:58] will proceed [22:59] or which accusations [23:01] the judges may hear [23:02] and which accusations [23:04] the respondent [23:05] may be permitted [23:05] to answer [23:06] it cannot make decisions [23:08] for us [23:09] and for the respondent [23:10] because to allow this [23:12] would be to confer [23:12] upon the prosecution [23:14] the extraordinary [23:15] and impermissible power [23:18] to control [23:19] not only the presentation [23:20] of its own case [23:21] but also the scope [23:23] and substance [23:23] of the defense case [23:26] now if the withdrawal [23:27] is intended to shorten [23:28] the proceedings [23:29] of this case [23:30] or of the respondent [23:31] or of the presentation [23:33] of the respondent's evidence [23:34] so that the court [23:35] may immediately [23:36] proceed to judgment [23:37] then we believe [23:38] that the resulting process [23:39] would bear [23:40] the unmistakable [23:42] characteristics [23:43] of a misdrial [23:44] a proceeding [23:46] in which [23:46] the fundamental balance [23:47] between accusation [23:49] and defense [23:50] has been so seriously [23:51] compromised [23:51] because again [23:53] on record [23:54] we have spent [23:55] government resources [23:56] time [23:57] energy [23:58] of this court [23:59] and of all the participants [24:00] in this trial [24:01] presenting [24:02] so-called evidence [24:04] and hearing [24:05] testimonial evidence [24:06] from the witnesses [24:08] that the prosecution [24:09] had chosen [24:10] to present [24:10] before this honorable court [24:11] and yet [24:12] the defense [24:14] would now [24:15] appear [24:15] to be forced [24:17] to limit [24:18] its presentation [24:19] or its rebuttal [24:21] to those evidence [24:21] to whatever it is [24:22] that the prosecution [24:23] had decided [24:24] to retain [24:25] in the articles [24:26] of impeachment [24:26] this [24:27] we will never allow [24:28] Okay, pause ko muna yan guys [24:31] So, nakita mo yung ginawa [24:32] ni Ms. Tapia dito [24:33] First of all, [24:34] grabe siya mag-throw [24:35] ng shade [24:35] mag-rant [24:36] itong si Ms. Tapia [24:37] Mahaba itong rant niya [24:38] by the way [24:39] Pag ano yan [24:41] pag marinig mo [24:42] yung kanyang [24:43] mga rant niya [24:44] yung mga sinasabi niya [24:45] remember [24:46] sabi niya [24:47] sinayang daw [24:48] ng prosecution [24:49] yung government resources [24:50] sinayang daw [24:52] ng prosecution [24:52] ng oras [24:53] ng mga senator judges [24:54] sorry ah [24:55] excuse me [24:56] ang nagsayang [24:57] ng government resources [24:59] ay yung kanilang kliyente [25:00] siya yung talagang [25:02] naglustay [25:03] ng mga government resources [25:04] at dahil sa kanya [25:06] kaya nga [25:08] ginagawa itong impeachment [25:09] at hindi po sayang [25:10] ng oras [25:10] dahil po [25:11] kailangan po [25:12] na accountability [25:12] okay [25:13] so [25:14] ngayon [25:16] ito [25:16] syempre [25:18] they're in court [25:18] they're trying to be respectful [25:20] kaya wala sila [25:20] masyadong [25:21] walang [25:21] walang [25:23] banggaan masyado dito [25:24] hinayaan lang ito [25:25] din ng prosecution [25:26] pero sa press con [25:28] dito sumagot [25:29] si [25:30] um [25:31] eto napakita ko sa inyo [25:33] dito sa press con [25:35] dito sumagot si [25:36] ano [25:36] si [25:36] uh [25:37] uh [25:39] si [25:40] prosecutor [25:41] Lorna Capunan [25:44] I want you to hear [25:45] kung ano yung sinabi ni Lorna Capunan [25:46] dahil ako mismo natatawa [25:47] I mean I love Lorna Capunan [25:49] you know [25:49] she's such an awesome lady [25:51] so [25:52] I want you guys to hear [25:53] yung sinagot niya [25:54] kay Miss Tapia [25:55] alright [25:56] here we go [26:01] alright [26:01] wait wait wait [26:02] um [26:03] lastly [26:12] I'd like to say [26:14] parang ano [26:16] because [26:16] because in my years of practice [26:18] I know what bullying is [26:19] I [26:20] I am a [26:21] I am [26:22] defender [26:23] of those who are victims of bullying [26:25] and that's exactly [26:27] what the head [26:27] defense prosecutor [26:28] always does to us [26:30] she bullies us [26:31] she bullies us [26:32] and inserts into her manifestations [26:34] words like persecution [26:35] words like [26:36] accused [26:37] words like [26:38] denial of due process [26:39] words like [26:40] there is no fairness and justice here [26:42] ang [26:44] ang [26:44] ang [26:45] ang [26:46] characterization ko dyan [26:47] kasi mabait [26:48] ang aming mga [26:49] public prosecutors [26:50] she is a [26:51] bully [26:52] and there is no place for [26:54] bullying [26:54] in a senate impeachment court [26:56] not only that [26:57] hindi lang bullying [26:58] gagamitin ko na yung word [27:00] bastos [27:00] binabastos niya [27:02] hindi lang ang [27:02] prosecutor [27:03] prosecution [27:04] pati ang senator judges [27:05] to remind them [27:06] as she did today [27:08] they took an oath [27:09] they took an oath [27:10] of fairness and justice [27:11] they took [27:12] wait a minute [27:13] but they also took [27:14] an oath [27:14] of political neutrality [27:16] tell me [27:17] are all [27:17] of the senator judges [27:19] also [27:19] politically neutral [27:21] I throw it back to them [27:22] meron silang [27:23] sinasabi na oath [27:25] hindi lang yan [27:27] but this does not [27:28] entitle [27:29] them [27:30] the defense [27:31] bully na nga [27:33] binabastos pa [27:34] ang mga [27:35] senator judges [27:36] wag naman [27:37] and [27:37] pag nasubjudice [27:39] ako dyan [27:40] eh [27:41] hindi naman kasi [27:42] hanggang midnight [27:43] daw [27:43] pwede pa [27:43] okay I'll [27:47] pause it [27:48] right there [27:48] wait I'll [27:50] turn this off [27:50] ayan [27:52] nagalot tuloy [27:52] si Lorna [27:53] Kapunan [27:54] and honestly [27:55] Lorna Kapunan [27:56] is [27:56] sobrang [27:57] mahinahon [27:58] tong [27:58] babaeng to [27:59] eh [27:59] kaya nagulat [28:00] ako na [28:00] ganyan yung [28:01] sinabi niya [28:02] dinarecho na [28:02] niya [28:03] si [28:03] attorney [28:05] season [28:05] dito [28:06] and good [28:06] for her [28:07] okay [28:07] kasi [28:07] ngayon [28:08] ganito lang [28:09] what's interesting [28:11] for me [28:11] is I really [28:12] believe na [28:13] as a strategy [28:14] it could be [28:16] a good strategy [28:17] it could [28:17] boomerang [28:18] pero it could [28:18] be a good [28:18] strategy [28:19] I'll explain [28:20] kung bakit [28:21] tingin ko [28:21] naman [28:21] pwede itong [28:22] magandang [28:22] strategy [28:22] kasi [28:23] ang pwedeng [28:24] gawin [28:24] dito [28:24] ang siguro [28:26] ginawa ng [28:26] prosecution [28:27] dito [28:27] sa kanilang [28:28] pagbiglang [28:29] withdraw [28:29] ay [28:30] they [28:31] kumbaga [28:32] they caught [28:33] the defense [28:34] flat footed [28:36] kumbaga [28:37] nabigla nila [28:38] yung defense [28:38] na ngayon [28:39] parang [28:39] magsa-scramble [28:40] na ulit [28:40] anong gagawin [28:41] natin [28:42] kasi [28:42] hindi pa sila [28:43] siguro ready [28:44] sa salin [28:45] kasi remember [28:46] hinahanda pa nila [28:47] yung defense [28:47] sila doon [28:48] o unahin [28:48] dapat na [28:48] grave threat [28:49] as ngayon [28:50] baka kailangan [28:50] na nilang [28:51] unahin [28:51] yung sa salin [28:52] na [28:52] or at least [28:53] yun nilang [28:53] kailangan [28:53] nilang [28:53] depensahan [28:54] yung salin [28:55] and [28:56] but the good [28:58] thing is [28:58] meron sila [28:58] isang buwan [28:59] para maghanda [29:00] para dito [29:00] ngayon [29:01] natatawa [29:03] lang ako [29:03] kasi [29:03] parang [29:05] binaliktad [29:10] binatumo na yung bola [29:11] sa korte [29:12] o sa side [29:15] ng defense [29:16] at parang [29:17] oh [29:17] we'll drop it na [29:18] what do you guys [29:19] want to do [29:19] ngayon [29:20] biglap sabihin [29:20] ng defense [29:20] I want to speak [29:21] I want to speak [29:22] what was interesting [29:23] is this [29:24] sinabi ni [29:25] Bam Aquino [29:25] pinaklarify ni [29:27] Bam Aquino [29:27] sabihin ni [29:27] teka teka teka [29:29] defense [29:29] ang sinasabi ba nyo [29:31] na gusto nyo [29:32] huwag na lang [29:33] i-drop [29:33] yung [29:34] tatlong [29:35] impeachment [29:36] articles [29:37] ibig sabihin nun [29:39] may posibilidad [29:40] na mako-convict [29:41] si Sarah Duterte [29:42] sa isa [29:43] dun sa tatlo [29:44] na din-drop na [29:45] gusto ba nyo yun [29:46] and then [29:47] hindi na makasagot [29:48] yung defense [29:49] at sabi [29:49] ni [29:50] ni [29:51] Senator Bam [29:52] baka gusto nyo [29:53] tanungin muna [29:53] yung kliyente nyo [29:55] kasi mali mo [29:55] matuwa siya [29:56] and I really think [29:57] it's advantageous [29:58] for [29:59] the defense [30:00] na isa na lang [30:01] kailangan nalang [30:02] depensahan [30:03] versus tatlo [30:04] sorry [30:05] apat-dapat [30:06] na naging tatlo [30:07] ngayon isa na lang [30:08] di ba [30:09] ano satingin nyo [30:09] is this more [30:10] advantageous [30:11] for the defense [30:12] or for the prosecution [30:13] ngayon [30:14] for the prosecution [30:15] ang nakikita kong [30:18] strategy nila dito [30:19] ay talagang gusto nila [30:20] matapos lahat to [30:21] by [30:21] before the end [30:23] of 2026 [30:24] so in other words [30:25] kung ang defense [30:27] okay [30:28] how long did it take [30:28] to get to [30:29] article 2 [30:30] ilang araw [30:31] ang sinasayang [30:32] ilang araw [30:34] ang ginawa [30:35] ng prosecution [30:36] para dito [30:37] sa article 2 [30:38] ilang araw ba yan [30:38] 1 [30:40] 2 [30:41] ilang araw [30:42] natin yung pinag-uusapan [30:43] tignan ko lang [30:44] since [30:47] ilang araw ba yun [30:49] months [30:49] okay [30:50] 4.4 [30:51] okay eto na [30:52] maraming araw [30:56] din to [30:56] okay [30:58] for the sal [30:59] and [30:59] dito [31:00] this is where [31:00] they spent the most [31:01] time actually [31:01] okay [31:03] they spent the most [31:04] time on it [31:05] kasi [31:05] dito [31:06] 1 [31:07] 2 [31:09] 3 [31:10] 4 [31:11] 5 [31:12] 6 [31:12] 7 [31:13] 8 [31:14] 9 [31:15] 10 [31:16] 10 days [31:17] ang 10 [31:19] ano ah [31:20] session days [31:21] ang ginamit [31:22] ng prosecution [31:23] out of [31:24] 39 days [31:26] para dito [31:26] sa article na to [31:27] so parang [31:29] roughly 10 days [31:30] ito na yung pinakamahaba [31:32] if I'm not mistaken [31:33] kasi may mga araw naman [31:34] na parang mga [31:35] administrative matters [31:36] ang ginawa nila [31:37] so 10 days [31:38] para dito [31:39] so sabihin natin [31:40] okay [31:41] hulaan natin [31:43] ilang araw [31:44] ang kakailanganin [31:45] ng defense [31:46] para [31:47] magpakita ng mga [31:49] witnesses nila [31:49] pagdating din sa issue [31:50] ng SALEN [31:51] bank records [31:53] audited financial statements [31:57] BIR [31:58] ITRs [31:59] yung mga sinabit na [32:00] annual tax returns [32:01] ilang witnesses [32:03] kaya ang ipipresenta nila [32:05] gano katagal [32:07] pustahan na tayo [32:08] ako tingin ko [32:09] hindi to abot [32:10] ng 10 araw [32:11] tingin ko lang [32:12] tingin ko lang [32:13] november [32:15] 1, 2, 3 [32:16] binigyan na ng [32:17] schedule sa november [32:19] 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 [32:20] 14, 15 [32:21] so tingin ko [32:22] by november [32:23] tapos na [32:24] before the end of november [32:25] tapos na ang defense [32:26] na sa kanilang ano [32:28] sa kanilang [32:29] pagpepresenta [32:30] ng kanilang mga witnesses [32:31] kasi tingin ko [32:33] wala naman silang witness [32:34] sino ba magsasabi [32:35] na tama [32:37] yung ginawa ni [32:38] Sarah Duterte [32:39] pagdating sa SALEN [32:40] sino ang ihaharap nila [32:42] para ikokontrahin [32:44] yung bank records [32:45] ano sabihin nila [32:46] hindi [32:47] galing naman to talaga [32:49] sa [32:49] ano import [32:51] pag import [32:51] ng banana chips [32:52] sige [32:53] sino ihaharap nila [32:54] diba [32:55] tapos kahit sinong ihaharap nila [32:58] nakakatakot yung ihaharap nila [32:59] kasi kahit sino man lang yun [33:01] mahirap kung nagsinungaling [33:03] itong mga [33:03] ano [33:04] mga witnesses na to [33:05] sa kanilang sasabihin [33:06] magsinungaling sila [33:08] perjury yan [33:09] contempt [33:09] okay [33:11] at ano [33:12] ano sasabihin nila [33:13] diba [33:14] sino [33:14] harap na si manscarpio [33:15] so dito [33:16] sa tansya ng prosecution [33:19] matatapos so before december [33:21] by then [33:21] convicted [33:22] and then tanggal na [33:24] si Sarah Duterte [33:25] sa kanyang posisyon [33:26] at hindi na siya pwede tumakbo [33:27] for any government position [33:29] ever again [33:30] okay [33:30] here is the problem [33:32] I have with this [33:33] sabihin ko naman sa inyo [33:34] yung problema ko [33:35] sa strategy na to [33:36] na pinapabilis [33:37] para sa akin [33:38] mas gusto ko nga [33:39] napatagalin to [33:39] hanggang 2027 [33:41] bakit? [33:42] para maalala ng tao [33:44] yung lahat ng kasalanan [33:46] ni Sarah Duterte [33:47] sa taong bayan [33:48] sa bansang Pilipinas [33:49] para sa ganon [33:51] kung may balak si Sarah Duterte [33:54] na ibigay to kay Baste [33:55] para si Baste [33:56] natatakbo [33:56] ay [33:57] 2027 [33:59] hindi ngayon lang [34:00] ngayon [34:00] hindi ngayon na [34:01] kumbaga [34:01] mas gusto ko [34:02] less time [34:03] para sa kalamang [34:04] kapag prepare [34:04] for 2028 [34:05] kaysa mas maaga [34:06] kasi ngayon [34:08] kung matanggal siya agad [34:09] mas maagang [34:10] magpe prepare [34:11] ang mga Duterte [34:12] para si Baste [34:13] yung patatakbohin [34:14] at syempre [34:15] magpapakalat sila [34:17] ng narratibo [34:17] para palakasin si Baste [34:19] maniniwala [34:20] yung mga ibang DDS [34:21] dyan [34:21] okay [34:22] yun ang isang [34:22] kinatatakot ako [34:23] pangalawa [34:24] pag matapos [34:26] itong impeachment na to [34:27] ano na yung susunod [34:28] ng narratibo [34:29] sa 2027 [34:30] kasi remember [34:31] pati ako [34:32] pag-uusapan natin [34:33] yung flood control [34:34] at pag-uusapan natin [34:35] yung budget [34:36] ng 2027 [34:37] which is going to be [34:38] for the month of [34:39] November [34:39] yan ang pag-uusapan [34:40] sorry [34:40] for the month of October [34:42] yan ang pag-uusapan natin [34:43] for the next couple of weeks [34:44] hihibayanan itong budget [34:45] at maraming mga kongresista [34:47] ang maiipit dito [34:48] maiipit ang kongres dito [34:50] pati mga senador [34:51] maiipit dito [34:52] dahil may mga insertions dito [34:53] na hindi dapat [34:53] so matatanggal yung atensyon [34:56] sa mga kasalanan [34:57] ni Sara Duterte [34:58] at mapupunta ngayon [34:59] sa ating mga kongresista [35:01] so strategy wise [35:04] baka hindi ito [35:05] yung best strategy [35:06] in my opinion [35:07] but it can also [35:09] work in their favor [35:10] kasi nga ito naman [35:11] ngayon palang [35:13] kumikilos na kasi [35:14] ang NBI [35:15] ngayon palang [35:15] kumikilos ang [35:16] ombudsman [35:17] ngayon palang [35:17] kumikilos ang DOJ [35:19] sa mga iba't ibang kaso [35:21] na kriminal [35:21] na isasampak [35:22] kay Sara Duterte [35:23] so posible [35:25] na kaya gusto nilang [35:27] mapaiklito [35:27] ay para [35:28] yung mga criminal charges [35:30] ay magumpisa na [35:31] starting [35:32] in January [35:33] 2027 [35:34] kasi yung grave threat [35:36] seryosong criminal charge [35:38] yan [35:38] may jail term yan [35:40] okay [35:41] at hindi lang [35:43] yung jail term niya [35:44] hindi ito parang [35:45] maikiling jail term [35:46] umaki ito [35:47] ng isang level [35:48] dahil [35:49] ginawa niya ito [35:50] online [35:51] so ngayon [35:52] ang jail term niya [35:53] is parang [35:54] 6 years [35:55] minimum [35:55] and up [35:56] if I remember correctly [35:58] so yung palang [36:00] malala na yun [36:01] and then [36:02] meron pang tax evasion [36:03] tapos meron pang [36:05] yung sa issue [36:06] sa confidential funds [36:07] na pinapabalik na ngayon [36:08] ng COA [36:09] so ang dami niyang [36:11] haharapin na kaso [36:12] na kriminal [36:13] and then [36:14] yung nakita nga [36:14] recently ng NBN [36:15] mga properties niya [36:16] na hindi na deklara [36:17] masisise pa [36:19] lahat ng properties [36:19] so she's gonna have to face [36:21] criminal proceedings [36:22] may forfeiture na ng assets [36:24] eto na [36:24] talagang malala [36:25] and they want to do that [36:27] before 2028 [36:28] so okay [36:29] so in that regard [36:30] this strategy [36:32] posibleng [36:33] it can make sense [36:34] kung yan ang strategy [36:36] kasi para sa akin [36:37] gusto ko talaga [36:38] managot si Sarah Duterte [36:39] grabe talaga [36:40] yung ginawa niya [36:41] hindi pwede makalusot [36:42] ang mga ganitong [36:43] mga kilos [36:43] at hindi lang yun [36:45] yung pinakamalala [36:46] sa lahat ng mga hinaharap [36:48] ni Sarah Duterte [36:49] ay yung pagkatuta [36:51] ni Sarah Duterte [36:52] at ang mga Duterte [36:52] sa China [36:53] tridor sa sarili nilang bansa [36:56] kitang kita [36:58] sa mismong statement [37:00] na ginawa ni Sarah Duterte [37:01] na sinasabi niya [37:03] bakit [37:03] masama ba [37:04] na nagnenegosyo [37:05] with China [37:06] opo [37:06] vicepresidente ka [37:08] hindi dapat [37:09] ang pamilya mo [37:10] at ikaw [37:10] nagtatanggap ng pera [37:11] sa China [37:12] okay [37:13] sabihin natin [37:14] ma-defend mo [37:14] yung banana chips [37:15] na yan ha [37:16] yung kali 88 [37:17] na yan [37:17] sabihin natin [37:18] magawa mo yun [37:19] papano naman yung foundation mo [37:20] na nakakuha ng 150 million [37:22] from the Chinese government [37:24] habang ikaw ay vicepresidente [37:25] tapos naririnig natin [37:27] yung mga tahol mo [37:28] yung mga ginagawa mong [37:30] greetings in Mandarin [37:31] tapos nagsalita ka nga [37:33] hindi sa [37:34] mismo [37:34] galing sa sarili mong [37:35] bibig [37:36] Sarah Duterte [37:37] sinabi mo [37:38] at ginaya mo [37:40] at pinaparot mo [37:41] yung sinasabi [37:42] ng China [37:43] na ang Pilipinas [37:45] ang [37:46] nang [37:47] gugulo [37:48] sa Southeast Asia [37:49] paano ang Pilipinas [37:50] ang nagiging [37:51] ang nang [37:52] gugulo [37:53] sa Southeast Asia [37:54] ha [37:56] ginagaya mo yung sinasabi [37:57] ng China [37:58] na Pilipinas [37:59] ang daw [37:59] nang gugulo [38:00] sa Southeast Asia [38:00] kung saan [38:02] ang China [38:03] ang nangbubuli [38:04] sa lahat [38:04] ang mga kapitbahe niya [38:06] tapos [38:06] sa Pilipino [38:08] sa Pilipino [38:08] ang nanggugulo [38:08] kaninong vice-presidente [38:10] ka sa Pilipinas [38:11] o sa China [38:12] yan ang isang [38:13] pinaka [38:14] ayoko talaga [38:14] yung mga [38:15] tridor sa ating bansa [38:16] at ang mga [38:17] Duterte [38:17] tridor sa ating bansa [38:19] haharap din siya [38:20] sa kasong to [38:20] so yan ang mga [38:23] yan ang mga [38:24] hinaharap niyang [38:25] criminal cases [38:26] ngayon [38:28] so dahil diyan [38:29] kaya tingin ko [38:29] baka ito yung [38:30] strategy na ginawa [38:32] ng prosecution [38:33] sunod naman [38:34] binanggit dito [38:36] ng prosecution [38:36] so I'm just going over [38:37] din yung mga [38:38] nangyari ngayong araw [38:40] binanggit ng prosecution [38:41] na pareho lang naman daw [38:42] sa corona case [38:43] kung saan [38:44] dinwrap nila [38:45] 5 out of the 8 [38:47] impeachment articles [38:49] pero [38:49] ang pinagkaiba kasi nun [38:51] dinwrap nila [38:53] yung 5 sa 8 [38:54] bago sila [38:55] nakapagpresenta [38:56] ng ebidensya [38:57] hindi tulad [38:58] ng ngayon [38:58] na nakapagpresenta na sila [39:00] saka nila [39:01] dinadrop [39:01] yung [39:02] yung [39:03] kaso [39:04] okay [39:05] so iba talaga [39:06] yung dating ngayon [39:09] okay [39:10] sunod naman [39:10] sandali [39:12] gusto ko lang sagutin [39:13] yung mga trolls ha [39:13] pwede ako magsagot [39:14] ng isang troll lang [39:15] sarap sagutin eh [39:16] next live [39:17] sabi niya Tridor [39:18] e si Pino yung [39:18] nagbigay ng Scarborough [39:19] Shoals sa China [39:20] excuse me po [39:21] hindi po [39:21] kaya nga po [39:22] nagkaroon tayo ng [39:23] ruling [39:24] from [39:25] own clause [39:25] na sinasabi sa atin [39:27] ngayong West Philippine Sea [39:28] okay [39:28] so pwede ba [39:30] sinong kaninong [39:32] administration na [39:32] namilitarize kaya [39:33] yung mga [39:34] mga ano na yan [39:35] mga lupain na yan ha [39:36] na gumawa ng mga [39:37] artificial islands [39:38] oh [39:39] talaga to [39:40] Naks [39:41] huwag maging tanga [39:42] huwag maging mangmang [39:43] sinabi na nga ni Duterte [39:46] na gusto niya maging [39:46] province ng China [39:48] ang Pilipinas [39:48] hindi mo ba narinig yun [39:49] Naks [39:50] ha [39:51] bingi ka ba [39:52] o bulag [39:52] o tanga [39:53] hindi ko alam kung ano ka dyan eh [39:54] sorry ah [39:55] kung sabihin mo si Pino [39:57] may kasalanan [39:57] tanong ko sa'yo [39:58] hindi ba si Duterte [39:59] may kasalanan din [40:00] tumatanggap siya [40:01] ng mga loans [40:02] sa China [40:03] that's 10 times more expensive [40:06] than the loans [40:06] you will get from Japan [40:08] ha [40:09] nilulubog na tayo [40:11] sa utang with China [40:12] oh [40:14] hindi ka ba naniniwala [40:16] tapos [40:17] nung panahon pa ni Duterte [40:18] nandang mga pogo [40:19] maraming mga criminal [40:20] na mga Chinese dito [40:21] mga sindikato [40:22] na pumasok sa ating bansa [40:24] na inaapi ang ating mga kababayan [40:25] Naks [40:27] pwede ba [40:28] buksan ng mata [40:29] at isip [40:30] at tenga [40:31] pakiusap ko lang ha [40:32] pakiusap lang [40:33] o palitan mo yung pangalam [40:37] tinatawag mo sarili mong Naks [40:39] ano ba yan [40:40] dapat hindi Naks eh [40:42] tanga live [40:42] sorry Naks ha [40:43] you asked for it eh [40:45] you're getting it [40:46] ganun lang sa akin [40:47] ganun lang kasimple [40:48] okay [40:48] ganun lang kasimple [40:50] pasensya na [40:51] gusto ko talagang ayusin [40:53] yung mga naratibo [40:53] ng mga tulad mo eh [40:54] sorry ah [40:55] okay [40:55] sige next [40:56] so [40:58] ngayon [40:59] sinabi naman dito [41:01] may ano lang siguro [41:02] may one or two parts [41:03] akong papakita siguro [41:04] if ever [41:04] kung [41:05] kung interesting pakita [41:07] otherwise [41:07] pag-usapan na lang na ito [41:08] kasi we don't have a lot of time eh [41:09] so dito [41:10] sinabi ni ano [41:11] ni Luisro na [41:12] best interest daw [41:14] kasi [41:14] for the best interest [41:16] of everyone [41:17] so napatanong si Alan Peter [41:18] Kayatano [41:19] ano ba daw yung best interest [41:21] I wanna show you this part [41:22] kasi [41:23] I want you to tell me [41:24] kung ako lang ba to [41:25] o kung [41:26] hindi nagme make sense [41:27] yung sagot [41:28] ni Alan Peter Kayatano [41:29] so [41:30] I'll share this with you guys [41:32] and I want you to decide [41:33] kung tingin nyo ba [41:34] ako lang [41:34] ang hindi nakaintindi [41:36] o kayo din hindi nyo naintindihan [41:37] yung sinasabi ni Alan Peter Kayatano [41:39] panorin natin daw [41:39] Just to clarify [41:43] Madam [41:44] with your permission [41:44] Mr. President [41:45] and Mr. President [41:46] when you say [41:47] it's the best interest of all [41:48] can you clarify that [41:49] are you talking about time? [41:51] That is one [41:51] your honor [41:52] including the [41:53] resources of the government [41:54] and even the attention [41:55] of the [41:56] honorable senator judges [41:58] considering the equally [41:59] important legislative matters [42:00] which are pending [42:01] before the senate [42:02] not to mention [42:02] your honor [42:03] the upcoming budget [42:04] hearing for 2027 [42:05] isay-sayin natin yun [42:06] first of all time [42:07] there is no limit [42:09] in the constitution [42:10] we can finish this in January [42:11] we can finish this in February [42:12] we can take a break tomorrow [42:14] and focus on the budget [42:15] it is our choice [42:16] kung ako masusunod [42:17] unahin natin yung budget [42:19] may super El Niño [42:20] hindi patapos yung flood control investigation [42:22] ang daming na tiwangwang [42:24] na flood control [42:25] hindi nagspend ang gobyerno [42:27] we're in an economic crisis [42:28] not only because of our own doing [42:29] but the whole world [42:30] I mean [42:31] all of us here [42:31] all of us here [42:32] legislators [42:32] share all this concern [42:34] marami na nagsasabi na [42:35] itong impeachment [42:36] ay para sa mga politisyan [42:37] we know that's not true [42:38] we know it's an accountability [42:39] mechanism [42:40] but we do know [42:41] that the budget [42:42] next to divine intervention [42:43] and prayer [42:43] is the most important [42:44] but I heard today [42:45] we might even change [42:47] our schedule na naman [42:48] para mauna yung impeachment [42:49] so first of all [42:50] time [42:50] it's in the best interest [42:52] of everyone [42:52] that there's fairness [42:53] and we take our time [42:55] there's no time limit [42:56] who is saying [42:57] that we have to finish this [42:57] by November [42:59] I want it finished [43:00] but between finishing it [43:02] tapos may unfairness [43:03] and finishing it [43:05] na unahin to kaso sa budget [43:06] Mr. Presiding Officer [43:08] and Mr. Senate President [43:09] you know [43:09] I'd like to put on record [43:10] I'm very uncomfortable [43:11] with that [43:12] I think it will be a disservice [43:13] to the Filipino people [43:14] number two [43:15] government resources [43:15] it was the choice [43:17] of the prosecution [43:17] you could have started [43:19] with the Ilgapin wealth [43:21] and stopped there [43:21] but you chose to spend [43:23] 38 days [43:23] so kung baga sasuntukan [43:25] sinuntok nyo na yung defense [43:26] then sasabihin nyo [43:27] to save time [43:28] wag na kayong gumante [43:29] and then sasabihin [43:31] yung platform [43:32] ang gagamitin [43:32] so this is my second question [43:34] can the court issue [43:35] subpoenas [43:35] for their witnesses [43:37] to attend their Facebook live [43:39] or press cons [43:39] with all due respect [43:41] your honor [43:41] that was in response [43:42] to the statement [43:43] of the defense [43:43] that the evidence [43:44] of the prosecution [43:45] have been seen [43:46] by the public [43:46] yes ma'am [43:47] I understand [43:48] but that's the problem [43:49] you put all of your witness [43:51] here in court [43:52] in a formal process [43:54] before the Filipino people [43:55] and this is an impeachable officer [43:57] there are only a few [43:59] impeachable officers [44:00] in our constitution [44:01] and this is not [44:02] purely a judicial process [44:03] as we all know [44:04] it's a political process also [44:05] meaning [44:05] it's not enough dito [44:07] na ma-convict [44:07] or ma-acquit [44:08] yung reputation [44:09] ng tao [44:09] yung certainty [44:10] ng tao [44:11] na siya'y guilty [44:12] o hindi [44:12] so for example [44:13] so that's my other question [44:14] assuming we don't give the defense [44:17] the opportunity to present [44:18] dun sa tatlong articles [44:19] or dun sa dalawa nag-present na [44:21] is the prosecution [44:22] willing [44:22] that we acquit her [44:24] on those two articles [44:25] will we categorize [44:28] the dismissal [44:29] as an acquittal [44:29] we believe your honor [44:30] that by the withdrawal [44:31] of the three articles [44:33] by the prosecution [44:34] it means that this will no longer [44:35] be part of the impeachment trial [44:37] and therefore [44:38] they are no longer [44:38] proper subject matter [44:39] of the verdict [44:40] to be rendered [44:41] by the honorable impeachment [44:42] so we see the problem [44:43] that was created [44:44] no problem with the corona precedent [44:46] and with the article [44:46] that you have not [44:47] that you will not pursue [44:49] because you did not present [44:50] evidence in this court [44:51] every day [44:52] using government resources [44:53] getting people's attention [44:54] but for the two articles [44:56] that you have already [44:57] done your best [44:58] and a lot of people [45:00] agree with you [45:00] a lot of people [45:01] disagree with you [45:01] but to say [45:02] sandali lang [45:02] winidraw namin [45:03] o matuwa na kayong [45:05] defense [45:06] wala na yan [45:06] is that the kind of democracy [45:10] the kind of legal system [45:11] the kind of justice [45:12] that we want to give [45:13] the Filipino people [45:14] can you imagine the president [45:15] so kung galit ako sa COA [45:17] and I have barkada [45:19] one third of congress [45:20] and I tell them [45:21] don't worry [45:22] ipresent lang natin [45:23] yung evidence [45:24] and then at the last minute [45:25] i-withdraw na lang [45:26] wag na lang tayo [45:26] mag formal [45:27] offer [45:28] and then [45:29] sa media na lang [45:30] or whatever [45:31] sinira na natin yung isang tao [45:32] we already use government [45:34] so I don't know [45:34] many of the senator judges here [45:36] I'm not at liberty [45:37] to mention them [45:37] but tama din naman sila [45:38] if you withdraw everything [45:39] then wala din naman choice [45:41] ang defense [45:42] if they withdraw all four [45:43] then we have to stop [45:45] this impeachment [45:45] wala tayong pag-uusapan [45:46] but the reality is [45:48] when you withdraw [45:48] one or more [45:50] but leave one [45:51] all the accusations [45:53] still stand there [45:54] especially the evidence [45:56] that you've already [45:56] already filed [45:58] so I do not know [45:59] exactly how the [46:00] presiding officer [46:00] is going to rule [46:01] but may I put on record [46:02] the following things [46:03] number one [46:03] we have to finish [46:04] this impeachment process [46:05] with the basic element [46:07] of fairness [46:07] of really justice [46:09] kahit anong mangyari dito [46:11] acquit or [46:11] convict [46:13] may matutuwa [46:14] may magagalit [46:15] but history will judge us [46:17] whether or not [46:18] yung elementary [46:19] fairness and due process [46:21] number two [46:21] priorities are priorities [46:23] priority dapat yung budget [46:24] kung masasabay natin [46:27] bakit hindi [46:27] in the last few months [46:28] pinagsabay natin [46:29] session, budget, impeachment [46:31] but if we're gonna stop [46:32] just for the sake [46:32] na matapos tayong [46:33] November [46:34] we're gonna suffer [46:35] the budget is not [46:36] just passing it [46:37] then third [46:38] Mr. President [46:40] honorable members [46:42] of the prosecution [46:42] whatever the judgment [46:43] it has to be acceptable [46:44] by the Filipino people [46:45] and just because [46:46] there's no food [46:46] just because [46:47] there's no [46:48] people power [46:49] and just because [46:50] you know the rating [46:51] some of us [46:52] are doing well [46:52] some of you [46:53] are doing well [46:53] just because [46:54] last month [46:56] these guys are doing well [46:57] that doesn't mean [46:57] na tama yung tinatanim natin [47:00] sa mga kabataan ngayon [47:01] just like you [47:03] even during the [47:05] Duterte administration [47:06] the Aquino administration [47:07] we have to do [47:07] what has to be done [47:08] and we are in the moment [47:09] and there are certain things [47:10] that we all believe [47:11] has to be done [47:12] but then [47:13] 10 years later [47:13] we look back [47:14] so like the corona [47:15] impeachment [47:15] I'm gonna pause it [47:18] right here guys [47:18] medyo na [47:19] nauumay na ako [47:20] kay Alan Peter [47:20] kasi pasensya na [47:21] so I'll just go over [47:22] yung mga points [47:23] na binanggit niya dito [47:24] sabi niya [47:24] in the interest of time daw [47:26] sabi niya [47:27] na best interest in time [47:29] sabi niya [47:29] I agree [47:30] na dapat talaga [47:31] na may oras daw [47:33] pero at the same time [47:34] pag tinignan mo [47:35] sinasabi niya na [47:36] importante yung budget [47:38] e kaya nga [47:39] sinasabi ni Luis Tro [47:40] at ng buong prosecution [47:42] dinadrop na nga nila yung dalawa [47:43] para nga mapabilis no [47:45] para nga maasikaso [47:46] yung budget [47:47] para maasikaso [47:49] yung mga ibang legislation [47:50] kasi ang daming legislation [47:51] kailangan gawin [47:52] ang Senado [47:53] imagine mo [47:54] kung umabot po ito [47:55] sa susunod na taon [47:57] at umabot ito [47:58] ng kalahating taon [47:59] dahil sa [48:00] pagpepresentaan [48:02] ng mga iba't ibang [48:02] mga witnesses [48:04] tapos lumalabas [48:05] wala din naman [48:06] di ba [48:06] so nakikita ko [48:08] yung punto [48:08] na huwag na itong patagalin [48:10] pero yung sasabihin niya [48:13] na ano [48:13] well yung sinabi nga niya [48:15] pag sinabi bang [48:17] hindi na itutuloy [48:18] parang sinasabi mo [48:19] na ako it si Senado Duterte [48:20] hindi [48:20] hindi naman necessarily [48:22] kasi ibig sabihin lang nun [48:23] ay [48:24] tingin nila [48:25] malakas na nga yung isa [48:26] and that's all they need [48:27] kasi they got the result [48:29] they wanted [48:29] yun lang yun [48:30] but for me [48:31] I would love [48:33] siguro on a matter of principle [48:35] gusto ko talaga makita si Sarah Duterte [48:38] na ma-convict [48:40] sa grave threat [48:41] gusto ko ma-convict siya [48:43] sa confidential fund misuse [48:45] gusto ko ma-convict siya [48:47] sa kanyang [48:48] undeclared [48:50] wealth [48:51] yung mga billion [48:52] na undeclared [48:53] gusto ko makita yung conviction [48:55] kasi yun ang tingin kong [48:56] prinsipyong tama [48:57] pero naiintindihan ko [48:59] kung saan nanggagaling [49:00] yung prosecution [49:00] I don't agree with them [49:02] but I see where they're coming from [49:04] okay [49:04] so ngayon [49:05] pag-usapan natin [49:06] ano ba [49:07] yung mga pros and cons [49:10] of [49:11] this [49:12] decision [49:12] na ginawa [49:14] ng ano [49:15] ng [49:15] prosecution [49:17] tingnan natin yung mga pros and cons [49:19] na ito ha [49:19] so unang-una [49:20] okay [49:21] pag-usapan natin [49:22] ano yung advantage [49:23] sa prosecution [49:24] for doing this [49:25] and then after na ito [49:26] pag-uusapan naman natin [49:28] kung ano [49:28] yung mga [49:29] problema [49:30] sa ginawa nilang to [49:32] okay [49:32] and by the way [49:33] interesting talaga para sa akin [49:35] na [49:35] Bam Aquino [49:36] asked [49:36] attorney Sheila [49:37] gusto mo bang [49:39] maibalik tong charges [49:40] na hindi nga siya makasagot [49:41] medyo na [49:42] natawa ko nun [49:43] nung binato sa kanya [49:44] yung tanong na yun [49:45] so [49:46] obviously [49:48] ang advantage ngayon dito [49:50] ng defense [49:51] ay binigyan ni [49:53] Jesus Cudero sila [49:54] ng pagkakataon [49:55] na [49:56] pwede sila magsalitana [49:57] in public [49:58] kumbaga tinanggal yung [49:59] subjudice rule [50:00] subjudice [50:02] subjudice rule [50:04] na section [50:05] rule 18 [50:06] kung saan dapat [50:08] pinagbabawal magsalita [50:09] yung [50:10] lahat ng parties [50:11] sa impeachment [50:12] tungkol sa issue [50:14] ng impeachment [50:14] pero ngayon sinabi niya [50:15] nire-relax na niya [50:16] yung rules [50:17] at yung defense [50:18] pwede humarap sa media [50:19] at kahit na anong [50:20] plataporma [50:21] para magsalita [50:22] tungkol sa article 1 [50:24] article 3 [50:25] and article 4 [50:26] okay [50:27] article 1 [50:28] article 3 [50:29] and article 4 [50:29] okay [50:30] anything they want to talk about [50:32] they want to present [50:34] their evidence [50:34] to the public [50:35] that way [50:35] they can [50:36] so this is actually [50:37] an advantage [50:38] para sa defense [50:39] bakit [50:40] kasi [50:41] pag [50:41] sila ay magpe-presenta [50:43] ng kanilang ebidensya [50:44] in a public forum [50:45] through a press con [50:47] for the general public [50:48] walang kukontra [50:50] walang magko-cross-examine [50:51] walang magko-object [50:53] eh di [50:54] ang bilis yung presentasyon [50:55] walang [50:56] kayang [50:57] mag [50:58] mag-question [51:00] sa ebidensya [51:00] na pe-presentahin nila [51:02] sa publiko [51:03] so in terms of [51:04] public opinion [51:05] kung meron talaga silang [51:06] matibay na ebidensya [51:07] para patunayan [51:08] na hindi nag-grave threat [51:09] si Sarah Duterte [51:10] na hindi niya [51:11] ginilustay [51:12] yung confidential funds [51:14] ito ang pagkakataon nila [51:15] na gawin to [51:16] na walang objection [51:17] kahit kanino [51:18] na walang makakapagtigil [51:20] sa kanya [51:21] walang kukontra [51:21] sa mga ebidensya [51:22] yung papakita nila [51:23] o sa naratibo [51:24] gusto nila ipalabas [51:25] so [51:26] walang katatak [51:28] walang [51:28] kinatatakutan [51:30] ang mga magsasalita [51:32] tungkol dito [51:33] hindi mo nga mako-question [51:35] yung kredibilidad [51:35] ng mga ihaharap nila [51:37] ngayong mga witnesses [51:37] pag ginawa nila yan [51:39] sa press con [51:39] tulad nung mga [51:41] 18 Malayataboy [51:42] parang ganun yung gagawin nila [51:44] hindi mo na mako-cross-examine [51:46] so it's actually [51:47] advantageous [51:48] for the defense [51:49] na tinanggal na nga [51:51] yung [51:51] Article 1, 3, and 4 [51:53] kasi ngayon [51:55] siguradong hindi na [51:56] mako-convict si Sarah Duterte [51:57] kasi wala na [51:58] number one [51:59] so advantage yun [51:59] number two [52:01] pwede pa rin sila [52:01] mag [52:02] pwede nilang [52:03] palitan ng naratibo [52:04] ngayon sa publiko [52:05] by doing [52:07] their own press con [52:08] and walang [52:09] makakapag-contrast [52:10] sa pagpapakita nila [52:11] na ebidensya [52:12] so [52:13] natanggal na yung [52:14] possibility for conviction [52:15] at [52:16] nagkaroon sila ng [52:17] pagkakataon [52:17] na ayusin yung imahe [52:19] ni Sarah Duterte [52:20] sa mata ng publiko [52:21] so advantage [52:22] para sa kanila [52:23] pero ang problema [52:25] ang problema [52:27] and thing good [52:28] na-consider din ito [52:29] ng prosecution [52:30] may gag order [52:32] on Article 4 [52:34] which is grave threat [52:35] ang kampo [52:36] ni Sarah Duterte [52:37] kasi humaharap siya ngayon [52:38] sa isang criminal complaint [52:39] for grave threat [52:40] so anong pwede mangyari [52:43] well [52:44] mukhang [52:45] baka lalabas na rin [52:47] yung mga kaso [52:47] laban kay Sarah Duterte [52:49] para sa [52:50] salien [52:51] sa undeclared [52:52] at saka yung kanyang [52:54] hidden wealth [52:54] alright [52:55] or ill-gotten wealth [52:57] at saka lalabas na rin dito [52:59] siguro [53:00] yung [53:00] kaso niya [53:02] para dun sa [53:03] natanggap niyang pera [53:04] galing sa China [53:05] yung pagiging [53:07] trader niya sa Pilipinas [53:07] so posible na may mga [53:08] lalabas ng kaso [53:09] at pag lumbas sa mga kaso [53:11] gag order na rin yan [53:12] hindi niya siya [53:12] makapagsalita [53:13] so [53:14] yan yung pros [53:16] at yan yung cons [53:17] sa defense [53:18] ang con naman nila [53:19] ang isang [53:20] mahirapan sila ngayon dito [53:21] kasi [53:22] parang [53:23] pwede nila kasing [53:25] pahabain itong [53:26] impeachment [53:27] para mabore nga [53:28] ang mga tao [53:28] at wala na makikinig [53:29] at [53:30] tuloy yung ligaya [53:31] para kay Sarah Duterte [53:32] kasi po [53:33] kung alam po nyo [53:34] sa mga criminal cases [53:35] yan ang ginagawa po [53:36] ng mga corrupt [53:37] patatagalin nila yung kaso [53:39] as long as possible [53:40] remember [53:40] yung mga kaso [53:41] ni Enrile [53:42] yung mga ganun [53:43] pinatagal nila yun [53:44] ng ilan dekada [53:45] na umabot sa punto [53:47] na namatay na si Enrile [53:48] actually excuse me [53:49] bago nga siya namatay [53:50] umabot sa punto [53:51] na sobrang tanda na niya [53:52] na sinabi na ng korte [53:54] na i-dismiss na ito [53:56] dahil sobrang tanda na daw [53:57] ni Enrile [53:58] sobrang tagal na daw [54:00] sobrang tagal na daw [54:00] ng kaso [54:00] na corrupted na [54:02] yung ebidensya [54:03] parang ganun yung ruling [54:04] so parang ganun [54:07] ang strategy talaga [54:08] ng mga corrupt [54:09] okay [54:10] na pinatatagal nila yung kaso [54:12] sunod naman [54:13] ang problema ng defense [54:16] wala daw silang [54:18] supina power dito [54:19] para mag [54:19] magdala ng hostile witness [54:21] para pwede nilang [54:22] questionin [54:23] pero at the same time [54:24] remember [54:24] in the [54:26] presentation [54:27] of [54:28] the [54:29] prosecution [54:31] they had the opportunity [54:32] para [54:33] banatan [54:35] lahat ng mga [54:36] witnesses [54:37] na hinarap [54:38] ng prosecution [54:38] at sinubukan nilang [54:40] gawin yun [54:41] at hindi nila [54:42] nabasag [54:43] yung galing [54:44] ng mga witnesses [54:45] na ito [54:45] napakatalino talaga [54:46] ng mga witness [54:47] at kasi [54:49] kung nasa side ka [54:50] ng katotohanan talaga [54:51] wala ka talagang [54:52] katatakutan [54:53] sinabi ko na yun [54:53] sa inyo [54:54] okay [54:55] so ngayon [54:56] yan ang mga [54:57] side ng defense [54:58] sa side naman [54:59] ng prosecution [55:00] ang [55:01] tingin kong [55:02] problema [55:04] ang pros neto [55:05] ang pros neto [55:06] ay yung oras [55:07] ang advantage [55:09] neto yung oras [55:09] kasi ngayon [55:10] mapapabilis na [55:10] baka makuha na nga natin [55:12] yung conviction [55:13] na kailangan [55:13] para tapos na to [55:15] at move on na tayo [55:16] sa mga ibang bagay [55:17] flood control [55:18] yung mga iba pang [55:19] kailangan makulong [55:20] di ba kailangan [55:21] mapapag-usapan na naman [55:22] nato [55:22] yung budget [55:23] yung anti-dainasy law [55:25] marami tayong [55:26] pwede pang pag-usapan [55:27] at mapapag-usapan [55:28] na matututukan [55:29] pag matapos na to [55:30] number one [55:31] number two [55:31] isa pang pwede nilang [55:33] advantage dito [55:35] ay yun na nga [55:37] na throw off nila [55:38] yung timing [55:39] ng defense [55:40] at dahil dito [55:41] nagsascramble ngayon [55:42] yung defense [55:43] number three naman [55:45] ngayon [55:46] wala ng pagkakataon [55:48] na mag [55:49] explain ang defense [55:51] para depends [55:51] sa sarili nila [55:52] I mean if we're talking [55:53] strategies and advantages [55:54] kung yun lang [55:56] ang pag-uusapan [55:57] naman natin [55:57] ano naman [56:00] yung mga cons [56:01] neto [56:01] yung mga negative [56:03] sa ginawa nila [56:04] sinabi ko na nga [56:05] na yung negative [56:06] ay yung perception [56:07] yung public opinion [56:08] na baka [56:09] may mga iba sa atin [56:10] iisipin natin [56:11] na parang [56:11] sinasabi ba [56:13] ng prosecution [56:13] na mahina yung kaso [56:15] kaya nila dinadrop [56:16] na wala naman silang [56:17] matibay na ebidensya [56:19] number two [56:20] pwedeng gamitin [56:21] itong naratibo [56:22] ng kampo ni Duterte [56:24] para lumakas pa siya [56:26] okay [56:26] tapos isa pa [56:28] ay [56:29] ngayon na nadrop na [56:31] wala ng pagkakataon [56:33] na [56:34] ibalik [56:34] itong kasong to [56:36] kay Sara Duterte [56:37] in terms of impeachment [56:38] hindi na pwede [56:39] sinabi na ni [56:40] ni [56:40] presiding judge [56:42] Alan Peter Cayetano [56:43] na once dinadrop to [56:45] wala na kayong [56:46] pagkakataon [56:47] for the entire [56:47] 20th Congress [56:48] para ibalik ito [56:50] or subukan i-impeach [56:51] on the same charge [56:52] wala na yun [56:53] may finality na yun [56:55] and last but not least [56:57] ang isa pang ano dito [56:59] parang pwedeng [57:00] masama sa kanila [57:01] is [57:02] bakit pa nyo sinayin [57:03] yung oras ng [57:03] mga senator judges [57:05] kung idadrop lang nyo din [57:06] pero at the same time [57:08] we have to look at [57:09] what the prosecution [57:10] did in good faith [57:12] na ginagawa lang [57:13] talaga nila ito [57:14] after looking at everything [57:15] na [57:15] teka lang [57:16] ay matiba yung kaso [57:17] natin sasahalin [57:18] Article 2 [57:20] sobrang tibay [57:20] huwag na natin [57:22] nanuhin yung iba [57:22] huwag natin [57:23] abalahin yung mga [57:23] senator judges [57:24] natin [57:24] kasi ang dami na nga [57:25] na kailangan tignan [57:26] para ito [57:27] isa na lang [57:27] titignan nila [57:28] para tanong [57:28] isang simple [57:29] tanong [57:29] mali ba yung ginawa [57:31] ni Sara Duterte [57:32] sa kanyang [57:32] under declaration [57:33] ng kanyang salien [57:34] mali ba yun [57:37] o hindi [57:37] mali ba [57:38] na meron siyang [57:39] hidden wealth [57:40] ill-gotten wealth [57:42] mali ba yun [57:44] o hindi [57:44] mali ba [57:45] at betrayal [57:47] of public trust [57:47] ba yan [57:48] na nakikita natin [57:50] na may conflict [57:50] of interest siya [57:53] partnership sa mga kumpanya [57:54] na may ginagawang [57:56] negosyo [57:57] kasama ng [57:58] mga city governments [57:59] yun yun ang mga tanong [58:01] ganun lang kasimple [58:01] so yun yung pros and cons [58:03] ito [58:04] for both [58:05] and it's going to be [58:06] interesting [58:07] kung ano ang [58:08] strategy ng dalawa [58:09] anong gagawin nila [58:11] ngayon [58:12] para sa akin [58:15] at the end of the day [58:16] I would have [58:17] had a different strategy [58:20] I would have preferred [58:22] to see kung anong [58:22] kayang gawin ng [58:23] defense [58:24] para [58:25] patunayan [58:26] na hindi totoo [58:28] yung grave threat [58:29] yung [58:30] paglustay [58:33] ng confidential funds [58:34] at yung [58:34] under declaration [58:35] na salin [58:36] pero yung sa salin [58:37] makikita pa naman natin yun [58:38] I'm actually curious [58:39] to see that [58:40] but at the end of the day [58:41] I'll give the [58:43] prosecution [58:44] the right [58:46] na para gawin [58:47] itong decision na to [58:48] it's not up to us [58:49] but [58:50] for me [58:51] yan ang ano [58:51] yan ang tingin kong [58:52] sana ginawa nila [58:54] and I would have loved [58:55] to have heard [58:56] ano ba yung sasabihin [58:57] ng defense [58:58] tungkol dito [58:58] sa issue na to [58:59] alright [58:59] ngayon sa mga viewers [59:01] natin [59:01] naintindihan ko [59:03] huwag nyo nang pansinin [59:04] ng mga DDS [59:05] sa ganyan [59:05] na talagang pananalita nila [59:08] wala nang bago yan [59:10] tayo nakakaintindi [59:12] na lang [59:12] ang umintindi [59:14] sa pinagdadaanan nila [59:15] good vibes [59:18] tanungin mo [59:19] sa pamilya [59:19] ni Inday [59:20] sa Inday [59:20] baka sila [59:21] ang may trillion [59:22] at may triangle [59:23] mafia [59:24] salamat [59:27] sa mga [59:27] super stickers [59:28] na pinadala nyo [59:29] ngayong araw [59:30] na to [59:30] na appreciate ko yan [59:31] at sa mga viewers [59:32] natin [59:33] salamat sa inyo lahat [59:34] starting tomorrow [59:36] pag-uusapan na natin [59:38] siguro yung budget [59:38] kasi wala ng impeachment [59:39] bukas [59:40] so we're gonna be [59:41] talking about the budget [59:42] titignan natin [59:42] kung tama ba [59:43] yung ginawa ng kongreso [59:44] sa pag-approve nila [59:45] sa ating national budget [59:46] at titignan natin [59:48] yung mga issue [59:48] na hinaharap [59:49] ditong budget na to [59:50] na kailangan ngayon [59:51] tignan ng ating senado [59:52] at pag-usapan din natin [59:54] yung mga ibat-ibang issues pa [59:55] para sa impeachment watch [59:57] babalik tayo [59:58] on November 9 [1:00:00] at dito [1:00:03] makikita na naman natin [1:00:04] makikita natin [1:00:04] at magkakaroon ng pagkakataon [1:00:07] ng defense [1:00:07] para patunayan [1:00:08] na inosente [1:00:10] ang kanilang kliyente [1:00:11] na si Sarah Duterte [1:00:12] kayo ano singin nyo [1:00:13] agree ba kayo [1:00:14] sa ginawa ng prosecution [1:00:15] o hindi [1:00:16] sulat yung lahat [1:00:17] ang comments [1:00:18] sa comment section [1:00:18] at ikalat natin [1:00:20] itong video na to [1:00:21] para mas marami [1:00:21] sa mga kababayan natin [1:00:22] na makakita [1:00:23] ng mga videos [1:00:23] sa tulad na to [1:00:24] para mamulat [1:00:25] ang kanilang mga mata [1:00:26] at sa mga viewers natin [1:00:28] alam ko marami sa inyo [1:00:29] ay hindi pa subscribers [1:00:30] please lang [1:00:31] consider nyo [1:00:31] clicking the subscribe button [1:00:32] para lalo pong kumalat [1:00:34] at lumaki pa yung bosses natin [1:00:35] salamat sa inyo lahat [1:00:36] ito po si Christian [1:00:37] salamat sa lahat [1:00:38] ang mga donations [1:00:39] magkita tayo muli [1:00:40] sa akin susunod na video [1:00:41] nyo [1:00:42] thank you so much for [1:00:54] thank you so much for