About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Pagbira sa 'Superwitness', bangayan ng kapwa senator-judges sa impeachment trial from DAE News Philippines, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 3,882 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Is he a super-witness, omni-witness? What kind of witness is he's representing defense? He knows the Supreme Court. Who is he? Who is this guy? I'm really very, very curious about the qualification of this gentleman so that he can answer all topics from his handler or defense. Get somebody who can..."
[0:00] Is he a super-witness, omni-witness?
[0:02] What kind of witness is he's representing defense?
[0:05] He knows the Supreme Court.
[0:10] Who is he? Who is this guy?
[0:12] I'm really very, very curious about the qualification of this gentleman
[0:16] so that he can answer all topics from his handler or defense.
[0:23] Get somebody who can really stand up,
[0:26] who can really answer questions from the Senator Judges.
[0:29] Because later it's going to stop,
[0:31] maybe he won't answer it.
[0:33] The woman's justice,
[0:35] the woman's face is broken,
[0:37] because she doesn't need to read all documents,
[0:40] to know about their personalities,
[0:42] because it's simply, simply,
[0:44] that's the point of the law.
[0:46] That's all.
[0:47] I think they are of universal principles,
[0:49] like some accounting principles are also universal.
[0:53] So he can answer that even without seeing the specific documents.
[0:58] Section 2.
[1:05] The President, the Vice President,
[1:07] the members of the Supreme Court,
[1:09] the members of the Constitutional Commissions,
[1:11] and the Ombudsman may be removed from office on impeachment for,
[1:16] and conviction of,
[1:17] culpable violation of the Constitution,
[1:19] treason, bribery,
[1:21] graft and corruption,
[1:23] other high crimes,
[1:25] or betrayal of public trust.
[1:27] All other public officers and employees may be removed from office,
[1:32] as provided by law,
[1:34] but not by impeachment.
[1:35] Sorry, please bear with me,
[1:36] attorney Del Fuente.
[1:38] I just have to go through this portion,
[1:40] because there is a financial investigation conducted in this impeachment.
[1:44] My question is,
[1:45] how will you describe the nature of the list of impeachable officers found in this section,
[1:51] if you can recall from your constitutional law?
[1:53] This is an exclusive list, Your Honor.
[1:57] All right, exclusive.
[1:58] And how will you describe the nature of the grounds of impeachment in terms of seriousness?
[2:05] Well, very serious po ito.
[2:08] On top of the hierarchy sila as to the degree of the offense.
[2:17] All right, thank you.
[2:18] And conviction in impeachment carries,
[2:21] alam naman po natin lahat ito,
[2:23] the penalties of removal from position,
[2:26] and perpetual disqualification to hold public office.
[2:30] Now, how would you describe or characterize these penalties in terms of gravity or seriousness?
[2:36] Well, very serious, Your Honor.
[2:38] Other than removal from office,
[2:43] absolute disqualification from holding further government offices.
[2:47] It leaves a stigma on the official.
[2:52] Okay.
[2:54] We learned from Amit Shikure that the court invited that the provisions of the Constitution,
[3:00] kagaya po nito,
[3:01] must not be read in isolation but in conjunction with each other.
[3:05] So, let me relate the effects of the impeachment with another article under the Constitution,
[3:11] Article 5 on Suffrage.
[3:13] Let me read Section 1.
[3:15] Suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines,
[3:20] not otherwise disqualified by law.
[3:22] For at least 18 years of age,
[3:24] we shall have resided in the Philippines for at least one year in the place.
[3:28] With the permission of Attorney Mark.
[3:32] Yes.
[3:33] What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Rafi Tulfo?
[3:35] Is he a super witness?
[3:36] Omni witness?
[3:37] Ano ba klaseng witness ng pinapresent ng defense?
[3:40] Pati ba naman pati Amit Shikure,
[3:42] papakialaman niya,
[3:43] Supreme Court pakialaman niya,
[3:44] Ombudsman DOJ.
[3:45] Who is he?
[3:46] Who is this guy?
[3:47] I'm really very very curious about the qualification of this gentleman
[3:50] para lahat na lang ng topic kayang-kaya niyang sagutin mula sa kanyang handler
[3:56] or excuse me, sa defense.
[3:58] I don't think he's capable of answering those questions
[4:03] kasi hindi niya teritory yun eh.
[4:05] Mr. Presiding Officer, parang nakakaantok na.
[4:09] Parang hindi ka panipaniwala.
[4:10] Parang binubola lang tayo nito.
[4:12] Tamo nakangiti nga siya.
[4:13] Kaya smile means yes.
[4:15] Anyway, Mr. Presiding Officer, siguro medyo put him in a short leash.
[4:21] Attorney Mark, along these lines of questions,
[4:27] how many more do you have?
[4:29] I think I get the point and drift of Senator Judge Rafi.
[4:35] He seems to be an expert in all already.
[4:39] But these are basic concepts and interpretations of the law
[4:42] which the court can and will do on its own
[4:45] given that we cannot have taken judicial notice,
[4:48] especially of the constitutional and other legal provisions,
[4:53] especially given that he is not presented nor was he qualified
[4:57] as a constitutional expert but merely expressing his opinion as a lawyer,
[5:02] similar to both parties and those who are lawyers in this impeachment court.
[5:07] So either wind up with this line of questioning
[5:11] or move on to your next point, Attorney Mark.
[5:13] Mr. Presiding Officer, if I may, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[5:17] Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Joe?
[5:19] Mr. Presiding Officer, I wanted to share the sentiment of my seatmate,
[5:25] Senator Rafi Tulfo, because we have been giving a lot of leeway
[5:30] to the respondents' line of questioning.
[5:35] But I was looking at the Sabina issued to the witness, and it says here,
[5:42] the witness, Attorney De La Fuente, will testify on fundamental legal concepts
[5:48] relating to the Anti-Money Laundering Act as amended,
[5:52] identified documents relevant to his testimony and such other relevant matters.
[5:57] The issuance of a sabpena, du sestekum, and ad testificandum is requested directly,
[6:03] directing the witness to appear and give his testimony using his curriculum vitae
[6:11] and other documents relevant to his qualifications and testimony.
[6:15] I'm just wondering, Mr. Presiding Officer, if the witness here will only talk about and be our resource person
[6:32] with regards to what was written in the Sabina.
[6:36] Because if you listen carefully to what we have been hearing,
[6:41] number one, bagamat maaari po siyang magbigay ng expert opinion sa kanyang larangan
[6:50] bilang eksperto sa Anti-Money Laundering,
[6:54] hindi naman siya siguro pwedeng magdeklara na mali o invalid ang findings ng AMLA.
[7:01] At nasa Korte po yung pagpapasya kung gaano kabigat yung ebidensya nga inilalahad po dito.
[7:08] Ikalawag, yung Pangulaw, matagal na diniscuss kanina yung Bank Secrecy Law
[7:16] and malinaw naman po doon sa Section 2 na isang impeachment proceedings ay exemption sa Bank Secrecy.
[7:24] And in the November 5 order of this court, pinayagan po ang AMLA records
[7:31] na may sumiti pursuant doon sa lawful Sabina subject to confidentiality safeguards.
[7:38] At pang huli ginong Pangulo, Mr. Presiding Officer,
[7:41] yung expertise po kasi ng witness sa Anti-Money Laundering,
[7:45] bagamat may iba siguro na hindi mag-agree na siya isang eksperto,
[7:50] ako na ho, I give him the benefit of the doubt,
[7:53] pero ang maaari niya pong ipaliwanag ang AMLA at banking practices,
[7:59] pero na babother po ako, ginong Pangulo, at naaalarma na hindi po siya ang DOJ,
[8:10] hindi po siya ang ombudsman, lalo na hindi po siya ang core party ng korte
[8:16] para magbigay po ng binding legal conclusions o mag-desisyon kung meron nga pong criminal liability.
[8:23] Again, Mr. Presiding Officer, my only question is,
[8:26] dapat ba doon lang po umiikot yung kanyang pagiging isang testigo doon sa inisyo na Sabina?
[8:34] Or ang dahilan po ba kung bakit siya naririto ay para i-refute yung pong sinasabing financial expert ng prosecution?
[8:49] Because if that's the case, I have no problem with that, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[8:53] Your Honor.
[8:54] Attorney Mark, kindly respond to the question, to the query.
[8:57] Noted, Senator Judge Villanueva, kindly respond to the query of the Presiding Officer.
[9:01] Thank you, Your Honor.
[9:03] How long will your questions be along these lines and can you move on?
[9:09] Just a couple of pages worth of questions, Your Honor.
[9:11] Anyway, just to respond also for the guidance of the Senator Judges,
[9:15] part of our offer is for the witness to testify on other relevant matters
[9:21] and we deem that these are all relevant matters.
[9:24] Considering, Your Honor, my prior question that how important is upholding the rights of the person being financially investigated apply as well.
[9:35] So, just a couple more questions.
[9:37] Again, Your Honor, we ask for leeway considering that.
[9:39] We have been giving…
[9:41] You must acknowledge, Attorney Mark.
[9:43] We have been giving leeway.
[9:44] And we very much appreciate, Your Honor, the leeway that has been given to us.
[9:48] But just to answer the question of the Presiding Officer, there's a couple pages worth of questions, Ron.
[9:55] Just one follow-up question on that.
[9:57] Can I only turn on the mic of Senator Judge Villanueva?
[9:59] Just one follow-up question on that.
[10:01] Did you give the witness a copy of the forensic report?
[10:06] No, Your Honor.
[10:08] No.
[10:09] Because I was wondering, Mr. Presiding Officer, a while ago, if I heard it right from the witness, that he himself did not even get a chance to actually read the forensic report.
[10:22] So, he doesn't have any copy of that.
[10:26] That's accurate, Your Honor.
[10:28] That's why part of our questioning is to confront actual portions of that report and asking him of his general comments there.
[10:36] Yeah, I'm just wondering because if he is to refute the report, then he should have seen the report, should have read the report.
[10:45] So, I'm just wondering. Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[10:47] With all due respect, Your Honor, we just wanted to do it in open court and not prior.
[10:53] We didn't want to have any prior correspondence with the subpoenaed witness.
[10:57] Because that's the thing that I'm going to do later on when we get the chance to ask questions.
[11:02] We will be asking him about the forensic report because we feel that he is the best person to refute the forensic report.
[11:11] Now, if he cannot answer these questions, then for me, it's going to be useless.
[11:16] We are okay with that, Your Honor, with that methodology.
[11:19] It's really up to, we submit to the court's wisdom on how they want to confront this witness later.
[11:24] Okay, thank you. Thank you for that clarification.
[11:26] How the Senator Judges will ask or make interjections and how the Senator Judges in the court will appreciate the testimony of this witness.
[11:34] Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Rafi Tulfo?
[11:36] Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[11:37] Yes, thank you.
[11:38] Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[11:39] Dudugtuan ko lang yung sinabi kanina ni Sen. Lidanueva.
[11:43] Kung i-refute niya ang forensic expert witness, and yet, hindi pala siya nabigyan ng kopya ng mga dokumento present ng expert witness,
[11:56] So, hindi dapat siya pwedeng mag-refute o kumontra, dahil in the first place, wala siyang idea kung ano yung mga nakasaad doon sa sinabi ng testigo, yung forensic expert witness, at pinasenta rito, maliban na lamang sa on the spot, pinagtatanong ng defense.
[12:20] So, dapat, beforehand, he was given a copy of those documents, para mapag-aralan niya, para makapagawa siya ng research, para, in that case, magiging intelligent.
[12:33] He will be well informed, and he can give intelligent assessment doon sa pag-refute sa mga sinabi ng forensic witness.
[12:42] Sa ngayon kasi, wala eh. Wala siyang kaalam-alam, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[12:46] Wala talaga. Zero.
[12:49] Nagtaka nga ako kanina, pati ba naman yung, ano ba ito?
[12:52] G-Wagon. Magwitna siya sa G-Wagon. Ano ba ito? Salesman na rin.
[12:56] I mean, baka mamaya eh.
[13:00] The court reminds the gallery to kindly not react or avoid reacting to statements made by anyone in this chamber.
[13:07] I mean, sorry ah, parang gina-
[13:09] Maybe it's not your fault. I'm not gonna fault you on this.
[13:12] Maybe ang problema sa defense, sobrang bilib sila sa'yo.
[13:16] Pero hindi mo siguro kayang panindigan yung kasobrang kabiliban nila sa'yo.
[13:19] Na kung ano nalang pinapasok at sinusubo sa'yo na hindi mo kayang panindigan, hindi mo kayang sasagot.
[13:24] Nagmumakatuloy ikaw na parang, alam mo na, hindi mo kagagawa niyong kundi kagawa ng defense.
[13:30] Malang salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[13:33] Yes, Julie noted, Senator Judge Rafi. What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Bam?
[13:37] Yeah, on this note, Mr. Presiding Officer, Mr. Witness, any documents provided to you before appearing here?
[13:48] Non-year-old.
[13:50] Non-year-old.
[13:51] Non-year-old.
[13:52] So, none of the AMLA records that we subpoenaed were shown to you?
[13:56] Non-year-old.
[13:57] Yung mga bank statements, insurance, placements, GIS na mga kumpanya, were any of this shown to you?
[14:10] None, Your Honor.
[14:11] None.
[14:12] Okay.
[14:14] So, I take it the defense is asking you about the report in terms of concepts.
[14:19] And on the basis, Your Honor, of actual portions because it's a 50-page report, Your Honor.
[14:24] So, we just wanted to focus on several portions of that report by confronting him in open court of those portions and then asking him about concepts.
[14:34] Okay. So, it's really concepts and general ideas about AMLA and financial investigations.
[14:42] Okay. Kasi, Mr. Witness, and again, hindi mo naman ito kasalanan, but many times, we have witnesses here.
[14:49] Pag tinatanong na namin, ang sagot sa amin, di ho namin alam.
[14:52] So, gusto namin ng mga witness na pwede kaming saguting diretsyo talaga.
[14:59] Because we just wanna find out the truth. We want to know your opinion.
[15:04] Yes, sir.
[15:05] But on specific matters also. So, anyway, you're here. And later on, may cross. Later on, magdatanong kami.
[15:12] Pero ang ayaw namin marinig is yung sunod-sunod na hindi ko po alam, hindi ko po nabasa, hindi ko po...
[15:17] Diba? Kasi, ang nangyayari, parang wala rin tayong narating na totoong opinion o totoong pananaw dito sa mga bagay-bagay.
[15:27] Thank you. Thank you, Mr. President.
[15:28] What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Irwin? The remarks of the Honorable Aquino are Julie noted.
[15:33] Mr. President Officer, a quick manifestation lamang po.
[15:38] Kung wala pong nakita ng mga dokumento itong testigo po na ito,
[15:42] And lahat po na sinasabi niya kanina pa, kanina pang umaga, ba aabuti na tayo ng alas 6 ng gabi.
[15:50] And lahat po ito ay theoretical and cannot be rebutted, documented as documented financial intelligence, Mr. President Officer.
[16:00] Kahit na nanggaling pa siya dyan sa AMLOC, etc., na yung kanyang expertise.
[16:07] Kung hindi naman niya po nakita pala ay mga dokumento, STRs, CTRs.
[16:11] What good is it?
[16:13] Para anong titistigo niya, e puro ito theory sa kanyang paningin, sa kanyang paniniwala.
[16:21] I think the defense.
[16:23] I know that you can do better than that.
[16:25] Siguro these coming days, get a witness who can really stand up.
[16:31] I'm just telling you now to prepare.
[16:37] Get somebody who can really stand up, who can really answer questions from the senator judges.
[16:43] Because mamaya ito, papawisan ito, baka hindi na makasagot ito.
[16:47] I mean, medyo mahina po, I'm sorry ha, mahina po yung the witnesses that you're presenting here these past few days.
[16:54] I cannot dictate that, but I'm just saying that's my opinion there.
[16:58] Get somebody who can really, ika nga na professional, who can rebut yung mga sanasabi ng prosecution, makakasagot po.
[17:08] Maraming salamat po.
[17:09] We respect the opinion.
[17:10] We know the manifestations of the senator judge.
[17:12] Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Ruiz Santavaris?
[17:15] If I may, Mr. Presiding Officer, just a quick follow-up question to the questions raised right now by the colleague Senator Judges.
[17:27] If I may.
[17:29] Yes.
[17:30] Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[17:31] You may proceed.
[17:32] Dr. Correct.
[17:33] Atorенный de la Fuente,
[17:34] karanasabi niyo na lamang po ngayon, na hindi niyo po nabasa ang forensic report na earlier inihain sa korting ito ni attorney Cabrera.
[17:45] Correct, Your Honor.
[17:46] If you review gak that theoro罪 rights.
[17:48] But at least, nabasa niyo po ba?
[17:49] Nasi mataban na mo ang scan, natingnan niyo po ba yung mga iba't ibang records na sinupinas, sinumite, na perpreslands,
[17:59] It was the case of Attorney Cabrera in his forensic report.
[18:06] Your Honor, indeed, this is confidential. I don't have authority to look into those documents.
[18:12] So, with all due respect, for now, you don't have a solid position.
[18:23] The quality, the truth, or a solid basis, even in the general principles of the forensic report of Attorney Cabrera.
[18:34] Your Honor, as flash on the screen, I echo what the law says.
[18:41] Based on the law, I would like to answer whether it is lawful or not.
[18:49] That's what I'm doing now.
[18:52] So, lastly, follow-up sa ngayon, ah, Atty. Dele Fuente.
[18:55] Kasunod ng mga prinsipyo ngayon, na kung bibigyan nyo po ng benefit of the doubt si Atty. Cabrera noon,
[19:03] na nagsisikap siyang sumunod din sa mga batayang prinsipyo ng inyong profeson,
[19:09] dahil kayo po ay peer, kayo po ay kolig kay Atty. Cabrera.
[19:14] Masasabi nyo po ba na may misrepresentation kay Atty. Cabrera na tawagin siyang supposed expert sa field ninyo?
[19:25] I have high respects pa rin po kay Atty. Cabrera.
[19:28] Nire-respeto ho natin siya.
[19:30] His professional and personal opinions po ay nire-respeto ho natin siya.
[19:35] But pagdating ko sa batas, again, ah, we have to abide kung ano yung tama ba,
[19:40] nasa tamang proseso po ba, ang kanyang methodologies po ba ay taba.
[19:46] So, ang ginagawa ko lang ho, binabangga ang kanyang ginawa doon sa kung ano ang meron sa batas.
[19:52] So, ito po ba ay mag-a-align. Yun ho ang aking role dito.
[19:57] Kaya nga sabi ko, I don't need to, ito ho sa sarili ko, no, to read the full report even before going here.
[20:04] Because kahit ho, i-flash ho yan ngayon pa lang, makikita nyo na po eh.
[20:08] Align po ba ito sa mga provisions ng AMLA or hindi?
[20:11] Sa huli po, at least, salamat naman sa pinahayag nyong pagrespeto bilang peer ninyo kay Atty. Cabrera.
[20:18] And I'm willing to guess kung itinanong namin sa kanya noon, sasabihin din niya sa kahit sinong colleague.
[20:24] So, at the very least po, in closing dito sa interjection ko,
[20:28] dahil tinanggap po ng Korte na isa sa mga expert witnesses sa trial na ito si Atty. Cabrera.
[20:35] At the very least, nire-respeto nyo po ba yung ganyang pagtanggap ng Korte
[20:40] ka Atty. Cabrera bilang isa sa mga expert witnesses sa trial na ito?
[20:44] Yes, Your Honor.
[20:45] Maraming salamat po, Terny De La Fuente.
[20:47] Salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[20:49] Senator Judge Amy, what is your pleasure, ma'am?
[20:52] Yes, maraming salamat sa ating presiding judge.
[20:55] At nakikinig po ako sa aking mga kasamahan dito sa Senado.
[20:59] Subalit, ipapaalala ko lang sa lahat na si Lady Justice o yung babaeng justisya ay bulag nakatakip ang mata.
[21:08] Kasi hindi kinakailangan nabasahin ang bawat dokumento alamin ang mga personalidad dahil pantay-pantay ang timbang sa batas. Yun lang po.
[21:21] Senator Judge Camille, what is your pleasure, ma'am?
[21:26] Yes, hello. Good afternoon po. Just a quick manifestation. I think we've been listening to this witness and I have to say that while he probably hasn't seen the documents that were given by the AMLC, I distinctly remember even the supposed expert witness ng prosecution, si Atty. Cabrera.
[21:53] Meron po siyang mga figures dun sa kanyang report of the alleged unexplained wealth.
[22:02] That was based on, and it was in the forensic report, that was based on research on the internet.
[22:10] There were also certain facts that he put that also he had very little or no basis for saying.
[22:19] And I think we respected that and accepted that. So personally, I would like to hear the thoughts and opinions of our witness, especially regarding theories.
[22:37] Because I think while some of his answers to the questions that are being asked by both the defense and the prosecution is of his expert opinion, I think they are of universal principles, like some accounting principles are also universal.
[22:56] So he can answer that even without seeing the specific documents.
[23:02] And I think we listened to the expert witness, to the forensic witness, the financial forensic witness of the prosecution.
[23:13] I think we should also give due time to the expert witness of the defense.
[23:20] That's all.
[23:21] That's all.
[23:22] Chair notes.
[23:24] I thought I was going to go to the kantin.
[23:29] Yes.
[23:30] Mr. President, just one quick manifestation, Mr. President.
[23:33] Number one, let me again put on record that we have been listening attentively to the respondents' line of questioning,
[23:43] despite the fact that it's beyond the issuance of the subpena and the boundaries set forth by the court in as much as the process is concerned.
[23:57] We have no problems with that, Mr. President.
[23:59] In fact, I wanted to palawigin nga, Mr. President, Mr. President, yung ginagawa ng depensa kung siya ay isang forensic expert, kung siya ay magre-refute ng forensic report.
[24:14] Gusto ko pong gawin yun, Mr. President.
[24:16] I'm more than willing to listen.
[24:18] In fact, kayo na po nagsabi, Mr. President, at inamin na po ng defense lawyer na nagbibigay tayo ng leeway sa kanila.
[24:27] And we have been, we should be continuously giving leeway to be able to understand clearly.
[24:34] But ang hindi po kasi maganda kung unlimited yung magiging scope ng pagiging testigo ng isang witness.
[24:48] And again, we respect the witness. We feel that he is indeed an expert sa issue ng money laundering activities.
[24:58] And again, Mr. President, we're willing to listen to him as long as nandun pa rin sa tamang jurisdiction.
[25:07] Yung nga pong aking masidhing pagnanais ay matanong po siya mamaya dun sa forensic report para nang sa ganoon, makita po natin yung kabilang side, yung kabilang face noong pong nangyaring pagtistigo, noong pong forensic expert ng prosecution.
[25:27] Now, if he is not the forensic expert ng defense, I am more than willing to listen in the coming days kung meron pong forensic expert ang defense to refute yung mga binanggit naman ni Attorney Cabrera.
[25:39] Maraming salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you.
[25:41] Yes, I'm Senator Judge Raffi. Kindly turn on the mic of Senator Judge Raffi.
[25:47] Kasi, kanina pa tayo rito at parang nagiging super witness na siya, ikaw nga sabi kanina.
[25:52] Now, very simple question lang dito kay Mr. Witness.
[25:56] Kanina, if you remember, I asked you kung ikaw ba ay nakapagkumpleto na ng isang kaso while you were in unblock, you said yes?
[26:05] Yes.
[26:06] You sure? You're under oath?
[26:07] Yes, sir.
[26:08] Okay, and ano yung kasong yun?
[26:09] Ah, hindi ko po siya, dahil that's part of the confidentiality. Ah, hindi ko po masasabi.
[26:15] What if I would present to you an evidence later on, na wala kang naikumpleto ang kaso at wala ka pang naifile na kaso whatsoever while you were in unblock?
[26:23] What if I can present an evidence?
[26:24] Personally, Your Honor, it's the agency who files, hindi ako yung personally naifile.
[26:28] Kasi sabi mo kanina nung tinanong kita, kanina-kanina pa, na ikaw pa ay nakapag-investigat, nakapagbuo na ng isang kaso.
[26:33] What if I can show you proof later on, na wala talaga, so pwede ka makontempt?
[26:38] Ah, as far as I can remember, Your Honor, I signed the…
[26:42] You signed?
[26:43] Yeah.
[26:44] Then, pwede ma-refute yan later on.
[26:46] So, doong pangalan, Mr. Presiding Officer eh, eh, nagkakaproblema na eh, sinasabi niya na meron na siyang naubuo na kaso, hanggang sa naifile, when in fact, ang pagkakaalam ko, wala, wala pa talaga.
[26:59] And he's just claiming it, and like I said, later on, pwede kong kukuha ng ebidensya na wala pa siyang naubuo kaso, at baka makontemplan to.
[27:07] Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[27:09] We note the manifestations made by all of the senator judges.
[27:19] However, the court cannot dictate nor impinge upon how either party will present their evidence in chief, much less dictate their strategy in choosing their respective witnesses.
[27:31] I urge our colleagues to exercise more leeway and patience with the presentation being made by the counsel for the respondent.
[27:45] Senator Aimee is correct.
[27:47] Habang sinisimbolo ng babaeng sumisimbolo sa ustisya na nakatakip ang mata niya, hindi po nakatakip yung kanyang mga tenga.
[27:54] Ibig sabihin, huwag tayong magbasa base sa panlabas na kanyuan, makinig at pakinggan din natin kung anong sinasabi, hindi lamang ng mga testigo, pero gayon din, nang magkabilang panig.
[28:06] I ask for the indulgence of our colleagues and ask Attorney Mark II to take note of the manifestations made and be sensitive to them to a certain extent in continuing with this direct examination with this witness.