About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Noam Chomsky for Age of Economics - Full interview from Age of Economics, published November 17, 2026. The transcript contains 10,021 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"There's the period of so-called regimented capitalism, Second World War up until mid-70s, roughly. No financial crises, banks tightly controlled, no tax havens, no shell companies, all illegal. Treasury Department enforced the law. Then there's the period of neoliberalism, a reaction to regimented..."
[00:00:00] Milton Friedman: There's the period of so-called regimented capitalism, Second World War up until mid-70s, roughly. No financial crises, banks tightly controlled, no tax havens, no shell companies, all illegal. Treasury Department enforced the law. Then there's the period of neoliberalism, a reaction to regimented capitalism, late 70s to the present. It's a crucial part of the neoliberal programs. Milton Friedman, the economics guru, announced in a famous article, 1981. The sole responsibility of the management of a corporation is self-enrichment. Anything else violates fundamental principles. So, transfer decisions to the hands of private, unaccountable enterprises whose sole responsibility is self-enrichment. It doesn't take a genius to figure out what's going to happen. The present form of capitalism says, let's destroy the environment in which humans can survive. Clearly suicidal. We'd have a much better world if we were not driven by the needs of private profit and private consumption. And we were concerned with the common good.
[00:01:34] Speaker ?: we were concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good.
[00:01:49] Milton Friedman: We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good.
[00:02:01] Speaker ?: We're concerned with the common good.
[00:02:02] Milton Friedman: We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. We're concerned with the common good. Why should we, for example, sow aerosols in the atmosphere to reflect sun's rays? But if you take a look at these suggestions there, at least the serious ones, are accompanied by saying there's a lot we don't understand. At most, we should try this on a very small scale. So if anything goes wrong, we can reverse it. Not just let's throw them all over the atmosphere and see what happens. You don't read that except from cranks. On the other hand, take a look at the way economists deal with the economy. So, for example, take a major change like the onset of neoliberalism 40 years ago. Well, there were some proposals, you know, some ideas, Milton Friedman, others. Well, let's just execute them and change the whole global economy. It's like hitting a complex system with a sledgehammer. We have some ideas about how it ought to work. So let's try it everywhere. Well, we can look at how it worked. Or shock therapy in the Eastern European countries. We have a theory about three markets. So let's force it down. Let's impose it on them without taking a look at the nature of the societies. Well, we know what happened there. Millions of deaths in Russia. Economy collapsed. Oligarchs from the old Communist Party buy up the whole system. You get Putin. It looks nice on paper, but when you try massive changes in a complex system, you have to be cautious. You can't just come forward and say, we've proven that, you know, recessions are impossible because we have the tools to deal with it. The markets are efficient, forget everything else. Okay. You can't do that in a complex world. And in the natural sciences, there's a lot more caution. I think those are aspects of the kind of humility that I think is badly needed in many sectors of the profession. I think this relates to just what I said. Economic science is, in fact, if you take a look at the actual economic science, overwhelmingly, it's the study of markets. How can markets work in pure forms? Okay. It's pretty much, that's what it is, is nuances. But that's the core of the study. As I said before, you can learn things that way. You can learn about how a certain abstract model should function without interferences. And from that, you can extract principles, conclusions, you know, things the way, how things might happen. Arrow theorem, other things. Economic engineering is saying, what do we do in the complex systems of the world? That involves many other factors besides the abstract model. You can learn from the abstract model. There are principles that you can think about how you might apply. But you have to do it in a way which deals with the complexities of the realities of human existence, society, political formations, and so on, which have a dramatic effect on how the economy works. I mean, just in gross terms, take a look at the post-World War II economy. Roughly, take the United States as a model. I mean, other countries have variations. So there's basically two periods. There's the period of so-called regimented capitalism, Second World War, up until mid 70s, roughly. Then there's the period of neoliberalism, a reaction to regimented capitalism, late 70s to the present. They were radically different. Period of regimented capitalism had the highest growth rate in American history, egalitarian growth. Lower quintile actually did a little better than the upper quintile. Banks were banks, not financial institutions. The bank was a place where you put your money. If you had something extra, they lent it to a guy who wanted to buy a car and so on. No financial crises. Banks tightly controlled. No tax havens. No shell companies. All illegal. Treasury Department enforced the law. A lot more to say, but that was basically the first period. Wages tracked productivity. Minimal wages tracked productivity. Starting in the late 70s, it all changes. The relation between wages and productivity is dissolved. Productivity increases not as fast as before. The growth increases not as fast as before. Wages flatten. Minimum wage flattens. It means it actually reduces. You consider inflation. Today, if that curve had been extrapolated, minimum wage would probably be about $20 to $25, something like that an hour. It's about a third that at the moment. The growth increased, but into very few pockets. So, for example, when Reagan came in, the top, just take a look at the very top, top 0.1% of the population, they had about 10% of the wealth. Now it's double, 20% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:11:38] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:11:38] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:11:46] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:11:46] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:14:01] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:14:02] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:14:08] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:14:09] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. It's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:18:24] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:18:25] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:18:27] Speaker ?: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth.
[00:18:36] Milton Friedman: Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. Now it's about 10% of the wealth. The drug companies weren't interested. It's not their business. Milton Friedman explained to them that their role is to enrich themselves. Okay. That's not economics. It's called economics. It's politics. The result is they're not going to spend money on some catastrophe that might happen in 10 years. Or maybe you'll get a vaccine that people will use once and you won't make that much money for it. You want to make money tomorrow on things that sell. It's also a question of choice of things to look at. Like, you know, to work on malaria because millions of people are dying from it are poorer than they have any money to pay. So you do other things. It applies in the rich countries as well. You know, all kinds of things you can get in different sort of ways of getting rid of wrinkles, but not of fundamental diseases. Because you get rid of them once you've done. All of this is an extraordinary, not just an extraordinary distortion of the economic system, but having enormous human consequences. And this is a very live question right now. Because right now, scientists, once again, are predicting that if, when we finally emerge from the current crisis, there's other ones coming, which will very likely be worse. We've been lucky so far. Every one of the coronaviruses has either been highly contagious and not very lethal, like Ebola, or not very lethal and highly contagious, like COVID-19. Who's to say the next one won't be both? It's known how to prepare for it. Drug companies are not going to pick it up. It's not their business. The government can't pick it up because of the neoliberal doctrine. Government is the problem. An enormous government labs, great resources. The government does most of the basic work anyway on development of vaccines and drugs, but then hands it over to private companies because government is the problem. So we have a socio-political system, which is setting the stage for further disasters and economic science can tell you that it wouldn't work like this in a free market. They can tell you that, but that doesn't help economic engineering. We have to make decisions and they're being made every day. A couple of days ago, the United States government pulled out of the COVAX consortium. 170 countries or so working on trying to integrate efforts to create a vaccine, which would, of course, if with cooperation, there's much more chance of achieving a successful result. The most powerful country in the world pulls out and impedes that. It also, not very effectively, but at least to some extent, the COVAX consortium is looking at distributional problems. How do we ensure that if there is a vaccine, it'll go to the people who need it? Like poor people in Africa won't be just monopolized by the rich countries. They're at least looking at that. The US says, no, not our business. We're going to do it ourselves. We want to. We'll monopolize it because we're just the master of the world. Well, it's not a joke. It has big effects. Things like that are happening all the time. And to just, you know, do economic engineering without thinking of all these things, that gives you very dangerous results. We've seen plenty of it. We're seeing it right now. So that's not a critique of economic science. It's a call for some understanding and humility. The kind of humility you see normally in the physical sciences. And pre-Trump, you used to see it in the EPA, you know, the Environmental Protection Agency, or in the FDA, which insists on careful testing before you throw things into the public. Now a lot of that is being dismantled, just with the goal of increasing profit for private power, for the very rich and the private sector. Those are the circumstances of the world. Well, I mean, there are some economists who've tried to study the environmental crisis. The most famous is William Nordhaus, who has economic models in which he draws a conclusion about what's the most important. About what's the most economically efficient way to deal with the environmental catastrophe. His conclusion is, we should aim to live at a level of three degrees centigrade rise over pre-industrial levels. That's probably cataclysmic. I mean, the effects of that on the environment are extraordinary. I mean, we're seeing little tiny bits of it now, not, you know, one degree centigrade approximately. But nobody can guess what it's going to be like in three degrees, but it might be horrendous. It might pass tipping points in Arctic ice melting, could raise sea levels in 10 feet, all kinds of imponderables. Here's a perfect case of total lack of humility. I say my economic model says the most efficient thing is three degrees centigrade. So let's aim for that. How much is taken account of there? What effect does that have on the people of Bangladesh with a coastal plain, which will be flooded? I mean, a couple hundred million refugees, where do they go? What does that do to Asia? Okay. What does it do to Asia when the dwindling water supplies in South Asia, which already leave hundreds of millions without potable water? What happens when the glaciers continue to melt? When the river flow declines, when Pakistan and India to nuclear armed countries are facing water shortages and are struggling over the same water sources. How do you put that into your calculation into your economic model? I mean, you just can't. It's not the kind of factor that can fit into an economic model. And I can magnify this all over the world. You know, large parts of the world that are now inhabited are going to be virtually uninhabitable if on the course that's described. What's the number that you associate with that, that you plug into your economic model? These are imponderables. And if you're all rational about this, you'll apply the famous precautionary principle. Like when I take a fire insurance on my house, which I do. I could pretend to be an economist and say, okay, let's calculate the risk to my house is going on fire. And the amount of money I lose in fire insurance and how much I could invest it for in a nice fund and make money and go to the theater more often and so on. It's a totally meaningless calculation. I want fire insurance in my house, even if it's not economically appropriate. And we are talking about the whole world. We want an insurance policy on the world. We don't want to face the 10% possibility that everything will just be destroyed. We don't face that. It doesn't matter what the economic model says. There are other criteria involved. And here again, a touch of humility and common sense. And the attitudes of the natural sciences would be very salutary. Very salutary, I think. It's the same question across the professional domains. Should international relations scholars be held accountable for the fact that they publish books saying that America's mission is to install democracy over the world? Should they let's take the leading figure of, I mean, should they be held accountable to the consequences of that has consequences policy makers say our duty is to install democracy. So let's invade Iraq and destroy the country and set the Middle East to flames as our mission is to install democracy. Should they be held accountable to that? Well, not in the courts. In public opinion, yes. I think I've been writing to the extent of boredom for the last 60 years on responsibility of intellectuals. All of them. And if you look over history, their role is not pretty. Way back to classical Greece. Overwhelmingly, they've been what are sometimes called stenographers for power. Actually, Henry Kissinger, a master of the art, put it very well. He said the duty of the intellectual advisor to government is to articulate the preferences of the powerful. To find ways of articulating it properly. So that means if Richard Nixon gives him, and maybe in some half drunken stupor, Richard Nixon hands him something says bomb Cambodia every possible way. Then as a stenographer for power. He puts that precisely. He sends to the air force the words. Virtually quoting massive bombing campaign in Cambodia. Anything that flies against anything that moves. In a single simple English that says genocide is he did articulate the preferences of the powerful. Is he responsible for that? Well, not in, not the way laws are set up. Public opinion, he should be. And that's just, that happens to be an extreme example. But it's not all that unusual. Economists, the same. If they decide to hit the economy with a sledgehammer. Because of what some model says. Yes, they should be held accountable. The terms of political discourse and commentary are pretty loose and vague. And that's true of capitalism, socialism, democracy. Actually, I don't think these terms can have, terms get precise definitions within the framework of explanatory theories. Outside those theories, they never have precise definitions. So what's motion? What's energy? What's mass? What's velocity? These terms didn't have precise definitions until physics had reached the level of explanatory depth. By 17th, 18th century, they were getting precise definitions, which were, incidentally, were not the general usage. Of course, the sciences very quickly depart from ordinary usage. If a physicist is studying, say, work, he doesn't look up unemployment statistics. It's a very specific, narrow, precise definition. Well, the social and political sciences haven't reached that point. They don't have far reaching explanatory theories, except in pretty arcane domains, which are pretty remote from human life. So the answer to the question, what is capitalism is just kind of more or less. I mean, to the extent that a society relies on markets, to the extent that it relies on competition, on wage labor, on a boss worker relationship, to that extent, it's more capitalist. To the extent that it moves in other directions, it's less capitalist. So just in the United States, maybe out at the extreme of capitalist societies. The regimented capitalism of the first post-war era was a different capitalism from the capitalist of the neoliberal era. And you look at the Nordic societies, a different form of capitalism. Take a look at the family dictatorships of the Gulf, a different form of capitalism. Okay. So I don't think we can define it. There are elements of, first of all, we have no capitalist societies and nothing approximating what a capitalist society is supposed to be. What we actually have is many varieties of state capitalism. That included the old Soviet Union, included Maoist China, includes the Gulf dictatorships, includes the United States. Just different varieties of a mix of state intervention and reliance on the private sector and all kinds of intimate interactions. That's true of almost everything we use. Take what we're doing now. We're using computers, internet, satellites, microelectronics and so on. Where did that come from? It came during the period of regimented capitalism, mostly from the state. Either direct state funding or state grants to private institutions. Didn't really go onto the market for about 20, 25 years. The first usable personal computer was 1977. After about 30 years of extensive research and development and innovation risk, mostly in the public sector. Internet was the same. It didn't get privatized till the 90s. It was being developed and actually in the lab where I was working in the 1950s. And that's across the board. The same with pharmaceuticals, the same with just about every aspect of the economy. It's a mixture of public, private mixture in various ways and different ways. What is the right way to deal with it? Well, we could debate that. My own feeling for what it's worth is essentially the position of the Republican Party under Abraham Lincoln. I think they had it about right. That wage labor is different from slavery only in that it's temporary. Until a person can become a free man or woman again. That was also the view of industrial workers in the late 19th century. They wanted to free themselves from the tyranny of a boss worker relationship, which is an assault on human dignity and the Republican rights of free citizens. The rich labor press going into this in detail. Major labor organizations like the Knights of Labor were based on the principle that, in their words, those who work in the mill should own the factory girls, so-called young women from the farms who were working in the textile mills, running their own quite lively, interesting press, took the same view. Now, the first populist movement, the real populist movement, not what's called populism today, radical farmers in Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, wanted to take control of their own lives and enterprises away from the Northeastern bankers, who lent the money, charged huge interest around the markets. They wanted to do it themselves. They'd have their own banks, their own marketing and so on, run democratically by participants. They started to link up with the Knights of Labor, the most radical democratic popular movement in American history. It was crushed by force, but I think they had the right idea. We have to adapt it to new circumstances. Well, that's one point of view. Let me take other points again. Its current form, it's suicidal. Definitely, clearly suicidal. The present form of capitalism says, let's destroy the environment in which humans can survive. Heading right in that direction. Just take a look at the extrapolate from what's been happening. It's exactly what you get. It's true that Trump is carrying it to an extreme. He's saying, let's race the disaster. Okay. Others are saying, let's try to mitigate it. But in its current form, it's heading for disaster. Now, can there be modifications within the framework of established capitalist institutions that will reverse this course? Yes, there can be. That's basically what the Green New Deal is about. As it's developed by the most careful practitioners. People like my colleague and co-author, Robert Pollan, economist at the University of Massachusetts. Detailed, careful analysis of how we could meet the UN goals. Having cutting in half emissions by 2030, net zero emissions by 2050. We could do it within easily within the expenditures. A fraction of the expenditures that are even used to prop up the economy by the Treasury outflows during the pandemic. Far less than during World War Two. And Jeffrey Sachs, another fine economist, has used slightly different models, comes out with about the same conclusions. Here, incidentally, is very significant work that economists can do using their tools and their knowledge and taking account of real world conditions. And I think they and some others show quite convincingly that without a fundamental change in existing institutions, we have the means within a few decades to put a stop to the suicidal tendencies of capitalism. And we can't take care of what's already been done and that's done and it's going to last in the destruction of the environment that has already taken place extends into the future. No matter what we do, stop fossil fuels tomorrow, still going to continue. We can't stop it. We can't stop it. These processes are underway. Well, we can constrain them. We can control them, have a good chance of creating not only a livable world, but a much better one. We have a much better one world if we were not driven by the needs of private profit and private consumption. And we were concerned with the common good. Very straightforward ways. We'd all be better off if we had high quality mass transportation than if we were sitting in traffic jams for a couple hours a day to try to get to work. But the system has been set up. So it's got to be the latter, not the former. Government is the problem. Can't do that. We see it. These are decisions that are made constantly. We're not talking outer space. We're talking about decisions that are made every day. They can be oriented towards the common good. They can be oriented towards private profit and private consumption. Those are not consistent notions. So more of one or more of the other. But these are very direct decisions. And I should say that the careful studies of people like Paul Paul and Jeff Sachs are showing what economists could do at their best. And using the tools that have been developed, not only for practical purposes, but for purposes that are essential for human survival. Can't be better than that. The Green New Deal quite consciously keeps within the framework. I mean, I'm talking about the careful proposals for a Green New Deal. There's all kind of proposals around. But ones like, say, Paul and Sachs keep explicitly within the framework of capitalist institutions. I don't think the architects of this system necessarily believe that those are the best institutions. In fact, I know that they don't. But if you look at timescales, the timescale necessary to overcome the urgent crisis that you're facing is far shorter than the timescale necessary to change institutions. It doesn't mean one or the other. You can be working in the background to create the consciousness, the elements of the future society within the present one. But we have an urgent need. Actually, an even more urgent need. We have to get rid of the malignancy in the White House. If that's not done, all of this is moot. All of it. Because we'll be driving the disaster. But assuming that that cancer can be excised in November, which is by no means certain. Then the next urgent task, it's actually two, is to deal decisively with the economic, with the environmental crisis. We have the tools to do this. Get rid of nuclear weapons, which are an immense threat. Get prepared for the next pandemic, which we can do. Reverse the deterioration of democracy. And then beyond that, look into the nature of institutions. I mentioned the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln. Basically, he was taking the stand of classical liberalism. One which actually goes back to classical Greece and Rome, Cicero and others. The idea that one person should be dependent on the orders of another is intolerable. Except in extreme conditions. Like a three-year-old child is dependent on the decisions of the parent. But for society to be organized on the principle that you spend almost all your waking hours under the rules of a tyrant with total control over you. Way beyond what Stalin dreamed of. Stalin didn't say you can take a bathroom break at three o'clock. Or you have to wear these clothes and go from this spot to another spot in the Amazon warehouse or whatever. The idea that most of your waking hours are spent that way, I think is intolerable. And that can be overcome. It can be overcome pretty much the way the Knights of Labour were talking about it. Those who work in the mills should own them. Enterprises should be in the hands of participants, workers, community. We can have much more rich democratic systems without systems of what are in my view totally illegitimate authority. Okay. It's not unfeasible. In fact, you could even call it capitalism if you want. Call it whatever you like. But it's a very different system. And I think those moves in that direction are appropriate, necessary over the longer term. Meanwhile, we have immediate crises that must be overcome or else none of these discussions mean anything.
[00:48:48] Speaker 2: Okay. I mean, I'm adding now a question for myself, by myself. I'm not reading big optimism out of what you are saying. Obviously, the problems are extremely urgent, extremely big. My question is, seeing the human condition, is it something like comfortable or is it incompetence? Is it stupidity or is something mean working on it?
[00:49:26] Milton Friedman: It's not stupidity. I mean, Milton Friedman was a very intelligent person. I'm not competent to judge, but competent economist. He was a very good economist. He was a very good economist. It was not stupidity when he said the role of the private sector is solely self-enrichment. That's ideology, not stupidity. I mean, I happen to think it's a stupid conclusion, but he wasn't making it on the basis of stupidity or incompetence. The case of Bolsonaro, let me not judge, but I think it's, we might notice the fact that the three countries that are pretty much in the lead in moving towards autocracy and destruction of democracy also happened to be in the lead in number of deaths and cases of the virus. The United States, India, Brazil. The next one in line is Russia. Also not exactly a model of democracy. Is this an accident? Well, you can decide. I don't think so. I think that's inherent in autocratic control and demonization and ignoring science because we're smarter than that. We're better than anyone else. We just run the typical in Brazil. Typical here, dramatic. Same in India. Killing the intellectual sectors. I think these things are related, but I don't think they're stupidity. The answer to specific power needs and in some cases, personal needs, but mostly fundamental power. I think Trump would not remain in office if he did not understand that his prime duty is to enrich the very rich and the private sector. He can talk all he likes to white collar workers, the working blue collar workers, about how much he loves them. But at the same time, he's stabbing them in the back. Every legislative proposal, whether it's a tax scam for the rich or cutting back safety and health regulations, is stabbing working people and the lower middle class in the back. Same with Bolsonaro, same with Modi. Kind of an interesting phenomenon. They keep popularity, but it's a different matter. Dictators and demagogues often do, not because they're helping people. But these, these are very, I think you're raising very serious issues. I mean, and in the, in many different countries, they have different roots, different characteristics and so on. But there are some common features. I think one common feature is the neoliberal assault of the last 40 years. It's had different effects in different places, but similar ones. And it has led to this atmosphere of anger, contempt for institutions. I meant to search for some leader, maximal leader who save us from all of this. And blame somebody. So in India, you can blame the Muslims. In the United States, you can blame the immigrants, the world health organization. Yes, ma'am. You can blame the Kurdish immigrants, whatever it is. But blame somebody, not the sources that are responsible. That's the nation, nature of demagogic leadership. Not for the first time in history. Plenty of examples. plenty of examples.
[00:54:06] Speaker ?: .