About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of House Oversight Committee Holds Hearing on ATF’s Out-of-Business Records Retention Practices from NTD, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 13,271 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"We're examining a collection of records most Americans have never heard of. More than 1.4 billion firearm sales records held by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives. When someone buys a gun from a licensed dealer, they fill out a federal form with their name, address, and date..."
[0:23] We're examining a collection of records most Americans have never heard of.
[0:29] More than 1.4 billion firearm sales records held by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives.
[0:38] When someone buys a gun from a licensed dealer, they fill out a federal form with their name, address, and date of birth,
[0:45] along with the gun's make, model, and serial number.
[0:49] When a dealer closes without a successor, federal law requires that those records go to the ATF.
[0:59] The ATF keeps those records indefinitely.
[1:03] In fiscal year 2025, ATF took in roughly 6.8 million new records per month.
[1:13] Federal law forbids the creation of a National Gun Registry.
[1:19] This is to protect Second Amendment rights of all Americans from being infringed by any potential future tyrannical government engaged in firearm confiscation.
[1:33] Federal law thus bars ATF from creating any system to register firearms, gun owners, or gun sales.
[1:42] It bars ATF from consolidating dealer's records.
[1:46] And it bars ATF from electronically searching out-of-business records by name or any other personal identifier.
[1:56] ATF says it follows those rules.
[2:00] It says the records are pulled only to trace guns recovered by police as a result of a crime.
[2:08] And the Government Accountability Office has found that the system does not currently cross the line into a registry.
[2:16] That's the opinion of GAO.
[2:20] But records that in past years were kept as paper and microfilm are now part of a digital database.
[2:27] So ATF's Out-of-Business Records Imaging System, or OBRIS, is an existent digital record, a massive digital record.
[2:40] When out-of-business records are scanned, a buyer's name can be captured as searchable data because it's written on the technology reader.
[2:51] Searching by name is a function that ATF has simply turned off from its tech to remain compliant with federal law.
[3:03] It could just as easily be turned on.
[3:06] Think about that impact.
[3:12] The difference between this database and an illegal national gun registry may come down to a software setting that the ATF itself controls.
[3:24] These records do have some law enforcement value, of course, I'm well aware.
[3:30] Tracing a gun used in a crime to its first retail buyer might give investigators a lead.
[3:38] And out-of-business records were used in nearly half of the crime gun traces ATF handled in 2022 and 2023.
[3:48] I can say from personal experience and observation that the impact on local and state law enforcement crime investigation is almost nonexistent in these records.
[4:03] But nonetheless, a lead in a criminal investigation is not a conviction in a prosecution.
[4:09] And an ATF cannot say whether any given trace has led to a successful prosecution, it just doesn't track that.
[4:17] And the older a gun is, the more likely it has changed hands.
[4:22] That's generally always the case.
[4:25] By the time a gun is recovered on a crime scene, the odds that that gun still belongs to its original owner is very slim.
[4:38] Perhaps this has changed hands even multiple times on the secondary market where no records are kept.
[4:48] That brings us to ATF's recent proposed rulemaking on records retention.
[4:53] There's never been before a cap on how long ATF has allowed to retain out-of-business dealer records.
[5:01] The rule for dealers has swung back and forth through time.
[5:08] Prior to 1985, dealers were required to retain their sales records indefinitely.
[5:14] After 1985, a new ATF rule limited the requirement to 20 years.
[5:21] That 20-year mark generally settled in as acceptable across the board for a dealer to maintain records.
[5:33] This rule was again changed in 2022 under the Biden administration, which again required indefinite retention.
[5:43] This year, ATF proposed a new rule which would limit to either 20 or 30 years the sales records retention for dealers and, for the first time, cap at either 20 or 30 years how long ATF itself is allowed to keep those records.
[6:05] Some see that as a step in the right direction.
[6:09] I'm not necessarily one of those people.
[6:13] Those two clocks, those two 30-year clocks, can stack.
[6:17] A record could sit with a dealer for 30 years, and then if that dealer goes out of business without a successor, could sit with the ATF for another 30 years.
[6:27] That's 60 years on file for law-abiding an American's name, address, and gun purchase data.
[6:34] And what's more significant, perhaps, to continue, is that's 30 Congresses.
[6:41] And we see what can happen with the way the pendulum swings in America from one Congress to the next, the variance of laws.
[6:50] And what we seek today, in today's hearing, is just to objectively put the truth on the table for the American people to consider.
[6:58] We have Second Amendment rights to protect, and we have an obligation to do so.
[7:03] So the question before us is not whether law enforcement should have lawful tools it needs to solve crimes.
[7:10] Of course, we support that, but our observation, based upon accurate historical data for a long time, is that this record retention is precariously close to an illegal federal registry.
[7:28] To an illegal federal registry, and with one push of a button, could become quite a tool of oppression against the American people.
[7:42] Whereas the benefit for law enforcement is almost non-existent.
[7:47] So the question before us is whether a collection this large, reaching back that far, 60 years, is worth the risk to law-abiding an American's privacy,
[7:57] and the risk that a gun registry would erode the Second Amendment's guarantee that the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.
[8:05] With today's hearing, we hope to weigh the principled Second Amendment concerns around ATS record retention practices against federal law enforcement's interest in holding those records for some period of time.
[8:18] We're honored to have expert witnesses with us today to help us examine this important issue, and I'm happy to yield now to Mr. Cesar for his opening remarks.
[8:30] Thank you, Chairman.
[8:33] Earlier this year in my district, a shooter killed three people and injured 15 more.
[8:40] And in 2022, we all remember the Uvalde mass shooting in my home state of Texas that took the lives of 19 precious children and two of their teachers.
[8:53] And of course, so many others have been killed or harmed in individual and mass shootings across my state and across the country.
[9:02] Over 400,000 Americans have been killed by gun violence in the last decade.
[9:08] Over a million people have been shot, including elected officials on both sides of the aisle.
[9:16] America tragically has the highest number of gun deaths amongst high-income nations in the world.
[9:22] And the violence, of course, is not contained at our border.
[9:26] American guns sold perfectly legally from stores in Texas are trafficked across the border to countries like Mexico, increasing instability in those countries,
[9:37] harming our citizens and driving people all across the hemisphere from their homes.
[9:43] This is all unacceptable.
[9:45] We should be spending our committee's time and Congress's time on common sense ways we can reduce gun violence, like stopping teenagers from being able to get semi-automatic weapons, closing background check blue coals, or stopping the flow of guns from Texas stores to foreign drug cartels.
[10:04] But instead of dealing with this horrific problem, this committee is using our last few weeks in Congress to look into this issue of gun store records.
[10:15] Instead of helping to protect all our kids, we know that, unfortunately, this Republican majority has been pushing to loosen the few protections that exist.
[10:24] For example, because of the big ugly bill and actions taken by the Trump administration, now most Americans don't even have to register when they buy a silencer or a short-barreled rifle.
[10:36] I just want kids to come home from school safe.
[10:41] Congress can do real things to address gun violence.
[10:44] Last time the Democrats had control of the House, we tried to move forward the bipartisan Background Checks Act, which would have closed loopholes that allow people to buy a gun without a background check.
[10:55] The Protecting Our Kids Act, which was opposed so often by the Republicans, which would have stopped the sale of semi-automatic weapons to people under 21.
[11:05] And the Federal Extreme Risk Order Protection Act, which would have allowed the court to block someone from getting a gun if they're proven to be at risk of hurting someone.
[11:15] These bills would have saved lives without stopping responsible people from owning a gun.
[11:20] We need to focus on real solutions rather than distractions.
[11:24] And next Congress, the Democrats and the majority will do everything we can on this committee and the Congress to save lives.
[11:32] I yield back.
[11:33] Gentlemen, Yields, without objection, Representatives Cloud of Texas, Representative Clyde of Georgia, Representative Frost of Florida,
[11:48] are waved onto the subcommittee for the purpose of questioning the witnesses at today's subcommittee hearing.
[11:54] I'm pleased to welcome today's witnesses.
[11:57] Let me briefly introduce each and then we'll go through their opening statements.
[12:01] Mr. Aidan Johnston serves as Director of Federal Affairs for the Gun Owners of America, a nonprofit Second Amendment group formed to preserve and defend the rights of gun owners.
[12:12] In addition to his Second Amendment advocacy work, Mr. Johnson authored a lengthy report published in 2022 identifying possible pitfalls of ATF's current out-of-business records retention practices, which is the focus of today's hearing.
[12:31] Mr. Wiley Nelson is a retired ATF Deputy Assistant Director with over three decades of experience with the ATF and in private sector firearms consulting.
[12:44] Currently, Mr. Nelson works as a firearms and explosives regulatory consultant with several pro-Second Amendment groups and maintains robust working professional ties to the ATF.
[12:59] Chris Schiaffullo. Say your name for me. Schiaffullo. Schiaffullo. Schiaffullo. I got it.
[13:11] Chris Schiaffullo is the founder and National Coordinating Council of FFL Guard, providing legal representation to hundreds of federal firearm licensees.
[13:24] He is an expert in the firearms and explosives industry and federal firearms law.
[13:30] Mr. Gregory Jackson is the former deputy director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention during the Biden administration.
[13:39] He currently serves as co-chair of Washington, D.C., Mayor-elect Janice Lewis George's Community Safety Committee and a consultant for Safer Futures, LLC.
[13:53] We look forward to hearing testimony from all of our witnesses on today's important topic.
[13:59] Pursuant to Committee Rule 9-G, the witnesses will please stand and raise their right hand.
[14:05] Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?
[14:18] So help you God. Let the record show that the witnesses answered in the affirmative. Thank you. You may take a seat.
[14:27] We appreciate you being here today and look forward to your testimony.
[14:31] Let me remind the witnesses that we've read your written statement and it will appear in full in the hearing record.
[14:38] Please limit your oral statement to five minutes. As a reminder, press the button on the microphone in front of you so that it's on and members can hear you.
[14:47] When you begin to speak, the light in front of you will turn green. After four minutes, it'll go yellow.
[14:53] And when the red light comes on, it's time to wrap up.
[14:56] I now recognize Mr. Johnson for his opening remarks.
[14:59] Chairman Higgins, distinguished members of the committee. In 1978, a Republican congressman from Ohio warned about a new federal regulation forcing gun dealers to report records to the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
[15:16] Representative Del Lada warned, quote, this information would feed into a national databank.
[15:22] This is the essence of firearms registration, which this Congress has repeatedly and repeatedly said we do not want for America.
[15:29] It would be simple, he continued, for ATF to later request the names and addresses of all, and I emphasize all, firearm owners, setting up a comprehensive registration system in this country.
[15:41] Congress listened, and that fall, it prohibited ATF from using its funds to consolidate or centralize gun dealer records, a prohibition that is still in effect to this day.
[15:52] That was nearly 50 years ago. Unfortunately, I am here to tell you that ATF has ignored Congress.
[15:59] The national databank Congressman Lada warned about now exists.
[16:03] Right now, in a record center in Martinsburg, West Virginia, the ATF holds more than 1.4 billion records that identify which Americans own which guns.
[16:12] Those records are searchable, and they can be weaponized against law-abiding gun owners for mass gun confiscation.
[16:20] Gun owners of America spent years exposing ATF's registry because it is a direct threat to the right of the people to keep and bear arms.
[16:29] Here's how ATF's registry works. After a firearm is serialized, the manufacturer records which dealer received it.
[16:35] The dealer then records which individual bought it using the information collected on the background check Form 4473.
[16:41] The buyer gives his or her full name, address, date of birth, height, weight, and race.
[16:47] The dealer then records the make, model, and serial number of the gun.
[16:50] What many gun owners do not realize is that when the dealer closes, every single firearm transaction record is sent to ATF.
[16:59] ATF then digitizes these transaction records into a centralized database it calls the Out of Business Record Imaging System.
[17:06] In May of this year, ATF reported that it maintains 1,414,088,513 of these gun and gun owner records.
[17:19] Congress has tried three times to stop ATF from enacting a gun registry, but each time it has failed.
[17:24] Since 1978, Congress barred ATF from consolidating or centralizing these gun and gun owner records.
[17:29] But today, ATF openly brags about its record centralization at the Out of Business Record Center.
[17:35] For decades, it has consolidated records from gun stores to its regional offices and finally into one centralized facility in West Virginia,
[17:43] where it scans them into a single digital database.
[17:46] During the Biden administration, that database grew by 100 million records a year.
[17:52] In 1986, Congress also banned ATF from issuing any new rule that requires gun registration.
[18:00] Yet, the Biden administration finalized a rule forcing dealers to keep Forms 4473 permanently instead of for 20 years.
[18:09] That single change turned every commercial sale since 2002 into a permanent registration record,
[18:15] and that includes every AR-15 sold since the National Assault Weapons Ban expired.
[18:20] And in 1997, Congress also forbade ATF from searching its registration records by name.
[18:26] So instead, ATF built a system with the ability to search and filter by every other important feature of a gun registry,
[18:34] such as make, model, serial number, and weapon type.
[18:37] This is enough functionality to create a list of AR-15s for door-to-door gun confiscation.
[18:42] Today, ATF has not enabled search-by-name functionality, but using technology the federal government already possesses,
[18:49] and an app that I vibe-coded this weekend in an hour, the ability to search by name and address could be switched back on in less than a day.
[18:57] History is clear. Gun registration always leads to gun confiscation.
[19:03] This registry exists so that a future administration can know exactly who has what guns to be confiscated.
[19:10] Last year, Representative Ilhan Omar said the quiet part out loud.
[19:14] She said,
[19:15] It is important to create a gun registry so we know where the guns are and can actually start a buyback program.
[19:21] Unless ATF's billion record registry is dismantled and destroyed in full, it will remain a threat to the Second Amendment.
[19:28] That is why Gun Owners of America is in federal court right now, joined by 17 state attorneys general, fighting to force ATF to comply with this law.
[19:36] This is also why we endorse the No Registry Rights Act, introduced by Congressman Michael Cloud.
[19:42] This is legislation that would require the destruction of this database and permanently bar the creation of another.
[19:48] And GOA is grateful that President Trump has begun to rein in ATF's illegal gun registry.
[19:53] But ATF's current proposal to keep Forms 4473 for up to 60 years is not good enough.
[20:00] I bought my first gun in a commercial sale in 2015, and I shouldn't have to wait until 2075 to know the record has been destroyed.
[20:08] President Trump should order ATF to delete every unlawful registration record that it holds, to stop centralizing records unlawfully, and to cease digitizing any more records immediately.
[20:18] Congress banned federal gun registration more than 40 years ago.
[20:22] It's long past time for ATF to obey that law.
[20:25] I look forward to your questions.
[20:29] We thank the gentleman.
[20:30] I recognize Mr. Nelson for his opening statement.
[20:33] Chairman Higgins, Ranking Member Kassar, committee members, good afternoon.
[20:39] My name is Wally Nelson.
[20:41] I am testifying as a retired ATF Deputy Assistant Director for the Office of Enforcement Programs and Services.
[20:48] In that role, I supervise the tracing center from 1998 until I retired at the end of 2005.
[20:54] As Chairman Higgins said, I am a consultant to the firearms industry for ATF compliance issues.
[20:59] The gun contract required the Secretary of the Treasury to develop regulations, including record-keeping requirements.
[21:06] It included the acquisition and disposition record of firearms.
[21:10] It also included sales to non-licensees, and that's the Form 4473 that we're familiar with.
[21:16] It also required people who went out of business, FFLs who went out of business, to submit their records to ATF within 30 days of doing so.
[21:24] And those records coming in are the genesis of the National Tracing Center.
[21:29] The purpose of ATF record-keeping and the NTC out-of-business records process is to provide information in support of federal, state, and local agencies, law enforcement agencies in their fight against crime and violence.
[21:42] In support of that effort, the NTC traces firearms 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
[21:50] ATF has proposed to change the record retention requirement for dealers from the current permanent regulation to 20 or 30 years.
[21:59] ATF had a 20-year requirement from 1985 to 2022.
[22:06] In 2022, the regulations were changed to make them permanent.
[22:10] ATF's own data that they wrote up in the NPRM for this proposed change indicated that the number of traces coming on records that are over 20 years old has been reduced quite a bit in the last 15 years.
[22:26] I support the 20-year retention period.
[22:29] The old 20-year period we had for 37 years worked very well.
[22:33] I never heard anybody complain on either side of the issue that it needed to be a longer period or a shorter period, so I recommend it be continued.
[22:40] A second ATF proposal calls for the NTC to limit its retention of out-of-business records to 20 or 30 years.
[22:49] Now, ATF has never, to my knowledge, ever proposed to eliminate those records that have come in from dealers.
[22:58] I support this retention at 30 years.
[23:04] This would provide tracing coverage up to 50 years, and about 95% of all traces involved firearms that were sold at retail less than 50 years ago, up to 50 years ago.
[23:16] This would also reduce the number of records stored from the current, what, 1.4-plus billion by several hundred million records.
[23:23] Right now, routine traces take 7 to 10 days to complete on average, and perhaps if ATF could eliminate those records that are over 30 years old, they could have more resources to work on processing the records that come in.
[23:37] Right now, this year, ATF is getting 8 million records a month.
[23:42] Last year it was 6.5 or so.
[23:44] Two years ago it was 4.5.
[23:46] It continues to grow.
[23:47] And so what we have at the tracing center is about 50,000 very large boxes of records waiting to be imaged.
[23:54] And every day the personnel at the tracing center have to go out into those boxes to conduct traces to find the paper record that hasn't been imaged.
[24:04] It's very labor-intensive.
[24:06] The committee is investigating whether ATF has compiled a National Firearms Registry.
[24:11] As has been mentioned, there are statutes that are imposed on ATF in the collection of records.
[24:17] There's the 1979 consolidation that I think was made permanent in 2012.
[24:23] There's the Fire Motors Protection Act, and there are the TRT amendments.
[24:28] I believe ATF is compliant with these restrictions.
[24:32] I base this on my own knowledge of NTC.
[24:34] When I worked there, I certainly was aware of the restrictions.
[24:37] Staff was aware of the restrictions.
[24:39] And since 1996 there have been three GAO audits that have upheld that.
[24:45] And there's also been, in August of this year, an audit by the Department of Justice Inspector General that made the same conclusions that ATF is not violating these restrictions.
[24:55] And I believe that these agencies conduct a thorough review before they make these conclusions.
[25:00] Finally, I want to say that the employees of the National Tracing Center are document-managed professionals.
[25:08] They've set up their whole system with these restrictions in mind, and they comply with them, and they process hundreds of thousands of traces coming in from law enforcement agencies every day, one gun at a time.
[25:21] Thank you.
[25:22] Thank you.
[25:25] We thank the gentleman.
[25:26] I recognize Mr. Shufalo for his opening remarks.
[25:29] Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Kazar, and distinguished members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
[25:38] My name is Christopher Shufalo.
[25:40] I am an attorney at law, and for nearly three decades I've devoted my career exclusively to representing FFLs, Federal Firearms Licensees.
[25:52] From dealers, to manufacturers, to almost every type of federally licensed firearms business in between.
[26:00] I'm the founder and National Coordinating Council of FFL Guard, a nationwide, attorney-led, legal services and compliance solutions program that helps FFLs navigate the complex quagmire of firearms laws and regulations.
[26:16] And our philosophy at FFL Guard is one that FFLs truly embrace.
[26:22] Because we don't ask them to just meet the minimum requirements of law, we ask them to do more, voluntarily.
[26:29] And they do.
[26:32] At FFL Guard, we call that doing law plus.
[26:34] And since today's hearing concerns ATF's retention of out-of-business firearms records, I'm here to offer a perspective sometimes missing from that discussion.
[26:44] The perspective of the FFL.
[26:47] Those business people who first keep all the records in question.
[26:51] These are the people with the initial record-keeping responsibilities.
[26:55] These are the folks that I know best.
[26:58] And believe it or not, FFLs are people too.
[27:03] These guys usually aren't massive conglomerates.
[27:06] Instead, they're small business owners, employers, parents, even our neighbors.
[27:13] They sponsor Little League teams.
[27:15] They support local charities.
[27:17] And they keep Main Street USA alive across this country.
[27:20] At the same time, they're responsible for creating and maintaining the very records that make lawful firearm sales and tracing possible.
[27:30] The very records we're here to discuss today.
[27:32] When an FFL permanently closes its business, federal law requires the FFL's records to be surrendered to ATF.
[27:41] Congress expressly authorized that surrender in the GCA.
[27:46] But also limited certain post-1986 record transfer and recording requirements via the Firearms Owners Protection Act.
[27:56] The authority for ATF to receive these surrendered records does not, by itself, resolve every question about what happens next.
[28:05] Is there really authority to reproduce, digitize, or otherwise process them?
[28:10] Congress is entitled to ask what authority governs ATF's reproduction of surrendered records?
[28:17] What analysis supports destroying originals after conversion?
[28:22] And what limits should apply to long-term retention by the government?
[28:26] I want to clearly recognize that under current Director Robert Sakata, ATF has undertaken meaningful reforms and greater engagement with the firearms industry,
[28:36] including a willingness to revisit clunky or superfluous regulatory approaches that Director Sakata didn't ask for, but he certainly inherited.
[28:47] The pending notice of proposed rulemaking on record retention is a perfect example.
[28:52] The proposed rule would replace indefinite record retention with defined limits, limits that were already addressed 40 years ago,
[28:59] and that this industry already successfully navigated from 1985 to 2022 using a 20-year records retention window.
[29:07] Most importantly, the proposed records retention rule would set corresponding limits on how long ATF can retain those records at the NTC,
[29:18] the National Tracing Center, before they're destroyed.
[29:21] That, at least, makes sure that a de facto registry couldn't exist, like federal law requires, even without getting into the issue of digitization or searchability of records.
[29:34] But this requires Congress to make sure the ATF is also properly funded to deliver on this meaningful reform.
[29:42] Why is all this important?
[29:44] Because FFLs are the ones who first shoulder decades of storage and security costs.
[29:48] Finite retention periods tied to demonstrated investigative value would reduce unnecessary burdens and provide clear expectations for everyone.
[29:58] Everyone would be on the same page.
[30:00] When an FFL's records are ultimately surrendered, responsibility for their custody, preservation, management, and lawful disposition rests with the government,
[30:11] so accountability must work both ways.
[30:13] For decades, Congress has asked what ATF needs from FFLs.
[30:17] Maybe it's time Congress asked what FFLs need from ATF, particularly when it comes to consistency and fairness,
[30:24] overseeing and managing the very records originated at an FFL's place of business now and after that FFL has gone.
[30:33] I'm happy to answer your questions today, and I appreciate your invitation to be here.
[30:38] We thank the gentleman, and I recognize Mr. Jackson for his opening remarks.
[30:44] All right. Thank you, Chairman, ranking member, and members of the committee for inviting me to testify on this important topic.
[30:50] I'm Greg Jackson, a D.C. resident, a survivor of gun violence, and the former deputy director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention,
[30:57] where we coordinated federal resources, implemented life-saving policies, and coordinated with both state and local leaders to reach a nationwide reduction in violent crime by 14.3% and reduce homicides by 41% in three years.
[31:11] I've spent the last decade of my life working to address gun violence and have seen the damage of this crisis firsthand when I was shot in 2013
[31:18] and spent six months learning to walk again in recovery.
[31:21] Nearly a million people have been shot or killed since my tragedy,
[31:25] and whether it's the eight small children killed in Louisiana this year or the 35 people shot at a homecoming game in Georgia,
[31:32] gun violence continues to shatter communities as the leading cause of death for youth, pregnant women, black men under the age of 44,
[31:39] and now the leading cause of newly disabled Americans.
[31:44] The encouraging news is that we know what works, proactive violence prevention and keeping guns out of the hands of those in crisis.
[31:50] In the two years before the Trump administration, major cities took action and saw historic reductions in gun violence,
[31:56] and today the United States is continuing to witness historic low levels of violent crime and the lowest murder rate reported in U.S. history.
[32:04] This is a direct result of increased federal, state, and local investment in violence prevention, law enforcement resources,
[32:11] and holding the gun industry accountable for this profit-driven public health crisis.
[32:15] A major federal resource that has helped solve millions of crimes is our ability to trace firearms used in crimes.
[32:21] The out-of-business records being discussed today are a crucial tool for tracing crime guns,
[32:27] because while businesses may close, the guns are still being used in crimes.
[32:31] In fact, more than half of all crime gun traces requests submitted to the ATF National Tracing Center from 2000 to 2023 were from these out-of-business records,
[32:41] a large portion of which were tied directly to violent crimes.
[32:45] That totals more than 4.6 million crime gun traces requests fulfilled using these records.
[32:51] ATF itself reported prosecuting an average of 8,310 cases per year involving firearms more than 20 years old,
[33:00] and totaling nearly half a million traces since 2014 of these older firearm purchases.
[33:06] In the recent years, we've seen several high-profile shootings utilize these records to solve heinous crimes,
[33:13] including the 2025 murder of Charlie Kirk, the 2024 assassination attempt on Donald Trump,
[33:19] the 2023 California Lunar New Year mass shooting, the 2022 Highland Park Parade mass shooting,
[33:24] the 2022 Brooklyn Subway mass shooting, just to name a few.
[33:28] And among those five examples, a total of 20 deaths and 70 folks were injured.
[33:34] Today, you will hear other witnesses that this record center is illegal,
[33:39] that infringes on the Second Amendment, that should be destroyed altogether.
[33:42] But the current Trump-appointed ATF director has set himself on the record that ATF does not have an illegal firearm registry,
[33:49] and that ATF mains firearm transaction records in accordance with federal requirements enacted by Congress.
[33:55] Furthermore, a recent DOJ Office of Inspector General report concluded that nothing came to our attention
[34:01] that caused us to believe the ATF was not in compliance with the laws or regulations.
[34:05] Since executive action in 2022 to keep records held permanently, we've only seen tracing requests increase,
[34:12] which shows how the demand of this data has grown from law enforcement.
[34:16] In fact, over the past decade, trace requests have grown almost 40 percent.
[34:21] This hearing is not about protecting the rights of Americans.
[34:23] It is simply another radical attempt by a gun industry lobbyist and the Republican Party
[34:28] to dismantle measures designed to keep our communities safe from violent crime.
[34:32] The Trump administration already shut down the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention,
[34:38] defunded law enforcement significantly, including the ATF,
[34:41] cut over $1 billion in mental health resources,
[34:44] terminated $812 million in funding violence prevention,
[34:47] defunded gun violence research,
[34:49] dismantled important regulations like the zero tolerance policy for gun dealers,
[34:53] and now is even aiming to strip our local state law enforcement of important tools to solve crimes.
[34:59] With that said, I want to reinforce three things.
[35:01] First, crime gun tracing is amongst ATF's most critical functions
[35:05] and serves as an important tool to law enforcement.
[35:08] This is an action that will push ATF away from its mission,
[35:11] that will make it more difficult for folks to solve crimes,
[35:14] and the out-of-business records center is not an illegal national gun registry.
[35:19] Any community, any family, any person that feels threatened by crime is one too many,
[35:24] and the statistics tell us that we've made progress,
[35:27] but as I opened in my testimony, statistics don't tell us the whole story.
[35:30] All Americans deserve to feel safe and to know that law enforcement has the tools necessary
[35:35] to bring justice to those committing crimes, and that should be our number one priority.
[35:40] Allowing the Trump administration to continue to roll back critical public safety initiatives
[35:45] and dismantle tools for law enforcement will only worsen crime, not make us safer.
[35:50] Thank you for your time.
[35:51] We thank the gentleman. I now recognize myself for five minutes for questioning.
[35:56] We had an existing timeframe that was accepted across the country,
[36:03] pretty much by Democrats and Republicans, by gun dealers, small and large,
[36:09] and that was a 20-year retention of records from the original sale.
[36:15] And for a small gun dealer, it was quite a burden, but by and large,
[36:22] it was a tremendous effort to comply with that, like a real good-faith effort from the gun dealers of the nation,
[36:31] large and small, because they knew, number one, their license depended upon it,
[36:35] and also it was a workable agreement.
[36:41] So that 20-year retention of records is what a reasonable man, like I consider myself to be,
[36:54] we support that the original sale of a firearm in America be retained by the original dealer for 20 years.
[37:03] And if he goes out of business with no successor, no business purchasing his sale business,
[37:09] with no interruption in business, if he has no successor,
[37:13] then it's reasonable for ATF to retain those records for the remainder of that 20 years,
[37:19] however long that is. But 20 years is long enough.
[37:22] And the existence of these records, it's not good, sir, that Mr. Jackson, respectfully to your statement,
[37:34] your position, it's not that these records are currently being used in an oppressive manner,
[37:44] it's that the records could be used in an oppressive manner,
[37:48] which was the original intention of the law banning such a federal registry.
[37:55] And to say that it doesn't exist as a registry because someone hasn't pushed the button
[38:01] allowing it to be searchable by name is currently searchable by address.
[38:07] But to say that it's really not a registry because we're not using it as a registry is sort of intellectually unsound,
[38:18] in my humble opinion.
[38:22] And conservatives support an executive authority, we believe the executive has the authority,
[38:30] to destroy all of these ATF records that exist beyond the 20-year window of the original sale of the firearm.
[38:38] And we support strict enforcement of that 20-year retention of records, but nothing beyond that.
[38:47] The centralization of these records is dangerous.
[38:53] Mr. Nelson, you stated that there were 50,000 boxes waiting to be processed,
[39:01] and it's the first time I've heard that number.
[39:04] Where did you – how do you know that?
[39:06] Have you observed those boxes?
[39:09] Turn your mic on, sir.
[39:11] I did not observe the records, Chairman.
[39:14] I got that from information I received.
[39:17] I've been reading, preparing for this.
[39:19] It's gone up.
[39:20] It was 28,000.
[39:21] It was 38,000.
[39:22] Now it's about 50,000.
[39:23] Is that, to your knowledge, accurate, Mr. Johnson?
[39:25] About 50,000 boxes?
[39:27] It's in the ballpark, yeah.
[39:28] That sounds right.
[39:29] So these records are continuously coming into ATF.
[39:32] There's a hell of a lot of manpower and energy being invested to add to the already existent
[39:39] 1.4 billion digital records that we have on file.
[39:45] And is it true, Mr. Nelson, Mr. Johnson, Mr. Shifullo?
[39:52] Is it – I got your name right – is it true that with a very easy IT adjustment,
[39:58] this record compilation will be searchable by name?
[40:03] Is that true, Mr. Johnson?
[40:05] Yes, this weekend I wrote a program using AI.
[40:08] Is that true, Mr. Nelson?
[40:12] It could be.
[40:13] I don't know.
[40:14] I'm not a computer expert.
[40:16] Mr. Shifullo?
[40:18] The GPT gave me directions on how to get here today, Mr. Chairman.
[40:22] So I think anything's possible.
[40:23] Mr. Jackson, are you aware of the IT – and I'll let you close out my five minutes,
[40:30] Mr. Jackson, because I respect you being here and I appreciate you being here.
[40:34] In your – in your awareness of this list, this compilation of data, which I say is precariously close to being an illegal federal registry,
[40:47] are you aware of the existence of this one firewall that stops it from being searchable by name?
[40:54] Yes, I'm aware of that firewall.
[40:56] And as you mentioned, you know, we're talking about hypotheticals.
[41:00] But destroying those records means we will destroy the records that are responsible for 15% of the traces.
[41:06] That's over 500,000 –
[41:08] If the gentleman will yield for comment, my time has expired.
[41:12] But the demand for data – that was your quote – let me say, as a law enforcement professional, a demand for data is not a requirement from a criminal investigation.
[41:26] You're checking the box.
[41:28] Very few of those traces lead to actual advancing of the criminal investigation.
[41:33] My time has expired and I yield to the ranking member for the opening question.
[41:39] Thank you, Chairman.
[41:40] For folks watching at home, we're talking about gun tracing.
[41:45] And on March 1st, this issue – this year – became very personal for people in my district in Austin, Texas,
[41:54] when a gunman opened fire into a crowded area on West 6th Street, injuring 15 people and killing three innocent people.
[42:03] The FBI determined that the rifle and the handgun that were used were purchased back in 2017, about ten years ago.
[42:13] Law enforcement needs to be able to reconstruct a gun's history years or even decades after the purchase.
[42:20] And that's what gun tracing is all about.
[42:23] And out-of-business records make gun tracing work.
[42:26] And that's why law enforcement and the ATF stress the importance of these out-of-business records.
[42:33] We are discussing in part today whether those out-of-business records should be destroyed after 20 years or not.
[42:40] The Chairman – and I may have disagreements on a variety of issues – but Chairman did mention at least protecting those records for, at minimum, those 20 years.
[42:53] And I would yield time to the Chairman or to others on the committee to see whether we have agreement at least on those 20 years.
[42:58] Because this Congress, HR 563, was filed by one of the Republican members of this committee, which would destroy all of those out-of-business records.
[43:10] And have no out-of-business records going to the ATF.
[43:15] That would be very concerning to me because that would make it much more difficult for law enforcement to track down how guns got into the hands of people who've killed folks or criminal organizations.
[43:28] And so I yield time back to you, Chairman, or to others who might answer the question of, do we at least have agreement that we should have those out-of-business records?
[43:37] I may be – and I'm open here, you know, to seeing if I misunderstand HR 563, which would end the out-of-business records and therefore hamper this important gun tracing.
[43:49] The Chairman will yield for a response.
[43:52] Yes, sir.
[43:53] I'm happy to discuss this further with you.
[43:55] When we have time, we can sit down.
[43:58] What we support is the agreement that worked for decades in our country – retention of records for 20 years – by the original licensed dealer.
[44:10] And if the dealer goes out of business with no successor, I think you'll find great acceptance from the conservative spectrum.
[44:19] That it's reasonable to retain those records in some manner by the federal government for up to the total of the 20 years.
[44:26] Thank you, Chairman.
[44:28] And then, to me, that's important clarification given that HR 563 from the good gentleman here on the committee, as it reads here, would remove the requirement that FFLs that go out of business deliver those firearm transaction records.
[44:47] And furthermore, that bill that I understand you are a co-sponsor of, Chairman, as is your right, would require the ATF to destroy all of those out-of-business records.
[44:57] And in my view, that is important work on this subcommittee if, in fact, we can at least agree that destroying all of those out-of-business records would be dangerous and that we shouldn't do it.
[45:09] And at least, then, we are debating this 20-year period.
[45:13] So, Chairman, I appreciate your statement on that and I hope, then, that we can agree to not destroy all of those out-of-business records.
[45:21] I just have a question for Mr. Jackson.
[45:24] Can you tell us about the ATF analysis of this rule of destroying business records after 20 years?
[45:32] After 20 years?
[45:33] It seems that there was once an attempt to get rid of all of this.
[45:35] Yeah.
[45:36] Now, maybe we're having a conversation.
[45:37] Maybe that's not a great idea.
[45:39] I hope that we don't go down that path.
[45:42] But talk to us about why it's important to maintain these records after 20 years.
[45:46] I think destroying these records is extremely dangerous.
[45:49] As I shared before, that makes up 15% of the traces that have happened.
[45:53] In fact, 531,520 crime guns were recovered and traced back from records after that 20-year period.
[46:03] That is a very significant amount of crime guns.
[46:06] And what is also dangerous about this is that it creates, really, the evolution of untraceable guns.
[46:11] We know, with the murder of Charlie Kirk, that shooter intentionally got a gun that was older
[46:16] because he thought it would be harder to trace.
[46:18] And so we could potentially create a new evolution of untraceable firearms that encourages criminals
[46:24] to go back and use older firearms to avoid being traced and apprehended.
[46:28] And I think that's a very dangerous direction to go just because of the hypothetical concern
[46:34] about how these records could be utilized.
[46:37] Thank you, Mr. Jackson.
[46:39] I yield back, Chairman.
[46:40] The gentleman yields.
[46:42] Mr. Biggs is recognized for questioning.
[46:44] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[46:45] Thank you to the witnesses for being here.
[46:48] Our founders understood that an armed citizenry is essential to preserving a free nation.
[46:53] That's why they enshrined the Second Amendment in the Constitution, protecting the right to keep
[46:57] and bear arms as a safeguard against foreign threats, government tyranny, and the erosion of liberty.
[47:02] But today we have something that I think we're not addressing fully and directly head-on,
[47:10] and that is whether what is being compiled as a registry.
[47:15] I think it's clever and euphemistic to say, well, this is a database, not a registry.
[47:21] But what is a registry actually?
[47:24] And before I get there, I'll just remind you that the reason that FISA, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act,
[47:32] is so dangerous is because it is a database that is searchable and abused.
[47:44] And so we, on this committee, have been fighting to restrain that government surveillance ever since I came to Congress
[47:53] and have been unsuccessful.
[47:55] But there's been loads of abuses there.
[47:57] So let's find out here.
[47:59] Do we actually have a registry?
[48:03] I mean, Mr. Johnston, you talked about this database as a database.
[48:09] They're accumulating information, putting it into a database, right?
[48:12] That's correct.
[48:13] And they're putting it in, and the purpose, the very purpose of that database is to make it searchable.
[48:21] Is that not true?
[48:23] It's to know who owns what gun so it can be traced.
[48:26] Right.
[48:27] So that doesn't work if it's not searchable, right?
[48:30] That's correct.
[48:31] And everyone who has testified here today has said this database is searchable.
[48:41] What makes it a registry?
[48:42] Is it a registry if it's searchable by address only?
[48:46] Is it a registry if it's searchable by make, model, and serial number?
[48:51] And all four of those things are where it's currently searchable.
[48:55] Is that not true, Mr. Nelson?
[48:57] That's correct, and that's all you need to say confiscate AR-15s by weapon type.
[49:03] Mr. Nelson?
[49:04] I don't know that that's true.
[49:05] My understanding is that they have a, it's a flat TIF file, and it goes into a file of all the images of the records for that FFL.
[49:13] And when they get a trace, they have to go through them one at a time to find the particular firearm.
[49:17] So you're saying it's not searchable?
[49:18] I don't believe so, sir.
[49:20] You just described a way to search it.
[49:22] Well, they're just going through the reels of the record, the individual photos or optical scans to find the firearm they're looking for.
[49:30] So, right, so what they're doing, they're looking, another word for that would be searching to find the information they want.
[49:40] That makes it a searchable database.
[49:43] Mr. Chiafalo?
[49:44] Thank you for the question, Mr. Biggs.
[49:47] I always struggle with the threshold issue, which is whether documents are supposed to be digitized to begin with.
[49:54] Whether they're searchable today or not, you can get five different stories from five different people.
[50:01] There are reports.
[50:02] There are those that say you can't.
[50:04] There are those that say you can.
[50:06] But I think could it be done in the future is very frightening.
[50:11] But if you never even get there, which is these records really maybe never should have been digitized to begin with,
[50:17] pursuant to the law, then it's a whole different equation.
[50:22] So, now, future, yeah, maybe.
[50:25] But I don't know that you should even get to that point.
[50:28] So, Mr. Jackson, I'm going to ask you this question because I think I'm interested in your response.
[50:32] Not whether you think it should or shouldn't be.
[50:37] I mean, I'm going to go with what Mr. Chiafalo just said.
[50:41] Should these records be digitized?
[50:45] I mean, let me rephrase it.
[50:48] Is there legal authority to digitize these records, in your opinion?
[50:54] You know, I will say, right now, the last two terms of the Trump administration, we've seen more records digitized than any other time in history.
[51:03] Yeah, but you guys, everybody on my other side of the aisle thinks almost nothing he's done has been legal.
[51:08] So, the fact that he was digitizing, the question is, is there legal authority to do that?
[51:14] Mr. Chiafalo says he doesn't think so.
[51:16] Do you have some kind of case or some kind of statute that's been passed by Congress?
[51:25] Yeah, I mean, I think the Inspector General report says that nothing they've done has compromised or been out of compliance with law regulations.
[51:33] They did not.
[51:34] I have to stand with that ruling.
[51:36] Okay, but they didn't go in and say, pursuant to this statute, they can digitize records, right?
[51:42] They did not say that in the Inspector General report.
[51:44] So, I guess what I'm saying is, Mr. Chairman, if we're going to talk registry and what you can look and what you're going to preserve,
[51:51] maybe we need to define what registry is and maybe we need to define things like digitize,
[51:57] whether something can be digitized or not before we get into the deeper question or the finer question that you're addressing today.
[52:05] Thank you. May I put some UCs in, sir?
[52:08] Yes, sir.
[52:11] Thank you.
[52:12] This one is titled, ATF forgot to comply with policy.
[52:16] This one exclusive.
[52:17] Feds hold 1.4 billion gun records on Americans.
[52:20] Without objection.
[52:21] Gun Rights Group's ATF report accuses agency of making illegal gun registry.
[52:25] Without objection.
[52:26] Just one more step, Australia's new weapon laws.
[52:28] Without objection.
[52:29] Canada, where gun registration equals confiscation.
[52:32] Without objection.
[52:33] Why DC remains one of the nation's most dangerous cities.
[52:36] Without objection.
[52:37] And ATF struggles to prove that its priority is stopping gun crime, not furthering a gun control agenda.
[52:42] All records entered without objection.
[52:44] Mr. Bell is recognized for five minutes for questioning.
[52:47] Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[52:48] Before coming to Congress, I served as a St. Louis County prosecutor.
[52:52] And in my 20 plus years, 25 years of practicing and six as DA.
[53:00] One thing I can say with absolute certainty in my years in this field is that I've never seen a case get stronger because evidence was destroyed.
[53:11] Ever.
[53:12] So, when my friend, the chairman says that the help that this information gives to law enforcement is almost non-existent.
[53:29] I have to do a logic test.
[53:31] Almost non-existent equals existent.
[53:35] And the numbers that Mr. Jackson pointed to bear that out.
[53:41] And so, Mr. Johnson, my question for you is, ATF Director Sakata has stated under oath that trace data is a critical investigative tool.
[53:51] Just very quickly.
[53:52] Do you agree that it's a critical investigative tool?
[53:56] Law enforcement uses trace data.
[53:58] That's correct.
[53:59] Okay.
[54:00] So, my next question is, when I was DA, we had an officer that was killed responding to a call about a fraudulent check.
[54:12] He was 40 years old.
[54:13] He had spent 17 years with the St. Louis Police Force before joining the North County Cooperative.
[54:20] He was survived by two children, his fiancee and his parents.
[54:25] My question for anyone is, do any of you want to limit the tools, the investigative tools, that we have to solve this crime?
[54:38] Yes, we need to eliminate this registry.
[54:41] I'm sorry.
[54:42] If you believe that we should limit the tools to solve the crime for an officer who was killed, please raise your hand.
[54:49] We have to stop this registry.
[54:52] Okay.
[54:53] That's fine.
[54:54] I responded to a scene where a toddler had been killed.
[54:59] And what I saw was a little crib with a hole in it that went right through it, because by the time that we got there, they had already taken the deceased toddler.
[55:12] Does anyone believe we should limit the investigative tools in order to solve that crime?
[55:17] That's a tragic situation, but it is-
[55:22] So you do.
[55:23] Okay, thank you.
[55:24] Do you know if the trace was essential for solving that crime?
[55:25] I was very clear with my time.
[55:26] I just wanted you to raise your hand if you want us to limit the tools.
[55:30] Okay.
[55:31] There was a six-year-old that was killed in St. Louis County in 2020.
[55:46] If this evidence would help lead to those killers, is there anyone who would not want us to use this information?
[55:55] I don't believe that we need a gun registry, and I don't know that keeping a gun registry-
[56:00] I didn't ask that question.
[56:01] If you're not going to answer my question, I would appreciate it if you respect that.
[56:05] I don't believe in the registry.
[56:06] I would appreciate it if you respected my time and didn't respond.
[56:08] Either answer my question or don't respond.
[56:10] Very simple.
[56:11] Now, Republicans in Missouri passed legislation to ban local law enforcement from being able to work with federal authorities on gun cases.
[56:28] That ban was ended because of the Missouri Supreme Court, not through Republicans on the state level or on the federal level.
[56:41] So, on one hand, we hear about supporting law enforcement and law and order and public safety, but what we continue to see is the eroding of the investigative tools needed to make us safer.
[56:59] So, we don't want local and federal authorities working on federal gun cases.
[57:05] Now, we want to eliminate critical investigative tools to solve these cases.
[57:11] So, ultimately, I got to ask, who are we protecting here?
[57:17] Because, are we protecting the murderers and killers?
[57:24] Are we protecting the victims and that notion that we all are supposed to care about justice?
[57:30] What we find is that folks who are involved in these kind of crimes, they don't stop.
[57:37] And if we don't get them off the street, they're going to continue creating more victims.
[57:44] And so, while you want to protect a particular lobby, I want to protect regular folks, regular citizens, and I could care less what letter is in front of their name.
[57:56] And I think we need to really start reevaluating what we're here to do.
[58:03] We do.
[58:08] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[58:10] Gentlemen, Dills.
[58:11] Mr. Cloud is recognized for five minutes for questions.
[58:13] Thank you, Chairman.
[58:14] And I appreciate you holding this hearing.
[58:17] It's been a long time coming.
[58:19] We started this investigation a while ago, found out that with GOA that the federal government
[58:25] had accumulated 54, I think, million gun records in the course of a year.
[58:30] That seemed like a lot.
[58:31] So, we investigated a little more, found out there at the time there was almost a billion gun records.
[58:37] Since then, it's grown to about 1.4 billion.
[58:42] One of the ways we got there was in between this period and that was the Biden administration,
[58:48] which took the 20-year limit and extended it forever.
[58:53] Then placed a zero-tolerance policy on FFLs and began to intimidate them to force them out
[58:58] their business so that they could collect the gun records, it would seem, to grow the database.
[59:09] And then we're told that this is not a searchable database or it's not a registry.
[59:14] It's definitely a searchable database.
[59:16] And they'll say, oh, well, we're not scanning the name.
[59:18] I've gone and I've actually watched them scan the documents in.
[59:21] They scan the names and it's a patch that they basically place in the software to keep the
[59:25] name from kind of being withheld.
[59:28] But that seemed like it could very easily be solved.
[59:31] Mr. Johnston, can you speak to how easily this would be to change that paradigm?
[59:37] So, it would be very easy to change this into a digital,
[59:40] into a completely searchable database by name and by address.
[59:44] Mr. Johnston, like it's been said already, these are kept in like TIFF files, a type of image with no data.
[59:50] And it's accompanied by metadata.
[59:52] And all ATF would have to do is re-scan the images using optical character recognition
[59:57] in order to get all of the data that's written on each page.
[1:00:00] Mr. Johnston, well, and now in the world of AI, that's...
[1:00:05] Mr. Johnston, right, I wrote a little piece of software this weekend.
[1:00:08] Mr. Johnston, ATF could convert them all in about an afternoon using federal government technology.
[1:00:12] Mr. Johnston, yeah.
[1:00:13] Now, we all support law enforcement.
[1:00:15] We want them to have the tools to do what they need to do.
[1:00:17] And over the course of the last few years, we've sent several letters to the ATF.
[1:00:20] As a matter of fact, we got one back from the DOJ 17 minutes before this hearing started.
[1:00:25] But they all basically say the same thing, that a trace does not establish who currently owns the firearm.
[1:00:33] It goes on to say it cannot reliably report how many traces ultimately contribute to prosecutions or convictions.
[1:00:39] And so the justification for traces seems to be the fact that we have traces.
[1:00:44] We have all these searches that happen, but we're not able to tell whether or not they help lead to convictions or to prosecutions.
[1:00:51] And many times they're after the fact.
[1:00:53] Now, we try to dig into this because we want to make sure that we're able to have the tools for law enforcement to do legitimate work.
[1:01:00] But what we see is that's not the case.
[1:01:02] As a matter of fact, in the Biden administration, what they'll tell you is these traces are always used for criminal investigations.
[1:01:08] But we know that isn't always the case.
[1:01:11] My colleague, Mr. Clyde, is an FFL.
[1:01:14] He had a business where he had a trace on a firearm that never was sold and never had left the warehouse yet.
[1:01:20] And so that's not always the case.
[1:01:23] And again, during the Biden administration, we saw the knock and talk cases where the ATF was showing up people's doorsteps were serial numbers because apparently their address was attached to it and asking to see serial numbers.
[1:01:36] And I will point out without a warrant, putting pressure on our fellow citizens and our law abiding citizens.
[1:01:44] And again, putting pressure on FFLs and pushing them out of business.
[1:01:49] Mr. Shufalo, hopefully I got that right.
[1:01:52] Shufalo, yep.
[1:01:54] Could you speak to what was going on in relation to the FFLs and some of the, I guess, bad activity we've seen where how this database can be used nefariously?
[1:02:09] I feel like I'm in a crazy place because everything pre we're here for out of business records is what I understood.
[1:02:18] And everything that I've heard so far, at least from Mr. Bellow, I hope to talk to was presupposing that every out of business record was evidence to a crime.
[1:02:27] And I don't think that's the case.
[1:02:30] And I don't also think anyone thinks that 20 years is unreasonable at length to hold records, whether you're being traced, whether it's being traced or not.
[1:02:40] So, you know, what nefarious things can be done with a registry speaks to itself.
[1:02:46] You could you could lead the confiscation like Mr. Johnston says it could be used in various bad ways.
[1:02:56] Well, and it was just said that this was a hypothetical, but it was only like three years ago where we saw this actually happening,
[1:03:02] where the ATF was abusing these records to go after FFLs, to go after law abiding citizens, to do no warrant knocks on doors and to threaten people.
[1:03:11] And so this is what's concerning to me.
[1:03:13] And yes, we want to keep people safe.
[1:03:15] But as I remind everybody up here all the time, yeah, we want to keep people safe.
[1:03:19] But our first priority in this role is to keep people free.
[1:03:22] And I think I'm out of time.
[1:03:23] So I'll yield back, Mr. Chairman.
[1:03:25] The gentleman yields.
[1:03:29] Ms. Ansari is recognized for five minutes for question.
[1:03:32] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[1:03:33] I'm really glad to see that we're having a hearing for the first time since the spring.
[1:03:38] For six months, this Republican led committee has had no discussion on the out of control Homeland Security agents,
[1:03:45] including ICE and Border Patrol, arresting and murdering innocent people as part of Trump's mass deportation sweep.
[1:03:51] We've had no hearings with officials at the Department of Justice targeting Democrats and perceived political enemies of the president.
[1:03:57] Like a fascist police state.
[1:04:00] And in fact, we've never had a hearing on any of it at all.
[1:04:03] It is absurd.
[1:04:04] And grateful that Democrats will soon have the gavel as we will be thoroughly investigating the rampant criminality, corruption and cruelty happening under Donald Trump's watch.
[1:04:15] When we did have our last hearing with the ATF back in May, I asked Director Sakata very simple, straightforward questions about why ATF is diverting agents away from their normal duties of disrupting gun violence and drug trafficking to instead fulfilling Donald Trump's mass deportation agenda.
[1:04:34] At the time, Director Sakata told me, quote, we have no one reassigned to Title eight immigration enforcement.
[1:04:42] But that was completely false.
[1:04:45] After Trump took office, 80 percent of the ATF workforce has been ordered to take on immigration related duties.
[1:04:52] Just months before coming before our hearing with him, Director Sakata told the Senate Judiciary Committee that since the beginning of the Trump presidency, quote, 75 to 100 agents per day had been assigned to the Title eight immigration enforcement.
[1:05:06] Mr. Jackson, you served as the deputy director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention.
[1:05:12] What are the public safety consequences of diverting ATF agents from typical duties like preventing drug trafficking to President Trump's anti-immigrant mass deportation agenda?
[1:05:22] Yeah, I think the impact is devastating.
[1:05:27] We have to recognize that ATF is one of the smallest federal law enforcement agencies we have with only 2,400 agents responsible for managing and overseeing over 128,000 FFLs.
[1:05:38] And I think previously someone else in the dais talked about what happened during the Biden administration when we deployed this limited workforce to focus on keeping guns off out of our communities.
[1:05:48] We saw homicide clearance rates increased from 52 percent to 69 percent.
[1:05:53] We saw assault clearance rates go from 37 percent to 47 percent.
[1:05:58] We saw historic three years of historic drops in homicides and gun violence across the country.
[1:06:03] And we did that by focusing on upstream accountability, shutting down 240, violating FFLs, prosecuting over 600 gun traffickers.
[1:06:12] But many of that work has been stalled.
[1:06:14] And I live in Southeast D.C.
[1:06:15] I see ATF patrolling underprivileged and under-resourced neighborhoods as opposed to working upstream to keep guns from pouring into our streets.
[1:06:23] And I think that's a real tragedy and a real threat to our safety.
[1:06:27] Yeah, I could not agree more what the Trump administration is doing instead of keeping our country safe from gun traffickers and violent crime enterprises is using these ATF agents to find and arrest immigrants,
[1:06:40] including grandmothers, parents, sons and daughters, people who have no criminal convictions whatsoever.
[1:06:46] And then after he flat out lied to me about ATF's operations, I wrote to Director Sakata to demand clarity on his testimony.
[1:06:54] And in response, he refused to share the policy decisions that led to ATF agents being reassigned because he deemed them to be, quote, sensitive information.
[1:07:05] Sensitivity alone does not authorize anyone to withhold information and documents from Congress, particularly the policy directives that I outlined,
[1:07:15] which are a matter of national importance and informed public policy debate.
[1:07:19] Mr. Jackson, another question for you.
[1:07:21] Do you think that the public deserves to know under what statutory authority the ATF is reassigning agents to immigration enforcement?
[1:07:29] And who at the ATF approved each category of immigration related deployment, which again, Sakata refused to disclose in his reply letter to me?
[1:07:38] Absolutely.
[1:07:39] So what's clear is this under Trump, ATF is shirking its fundamental public safety responsibilities to aid President Trump.
[1:07:48] And I'll add Stephen Miller, now the White House chief of staff's extremist political agenda, all while lying about it and evading accountability.
[1:07:57] I believe Director Sakata perjured himself before the subcommittee and direct questioning.
[1:08:02] He should take responsibility and resign.
[1:08:05] I'm not holding my breath.
[1:08:06] But with Democrats in the majority, I promise we will be getting these answers and we will be putting American security and well-being first above all else.
[1:08:15] I yield back.
[1:08:16] Gentle lady yields.
[1:08:18] Mr. Clyde is recognized for questioning for five minutes.
[1:08:21] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[1:08:24] I appreciate you holding this very important hearing.
[1:08:28] And I thank the witnesses for being here today.
[1:08:32] As we well know, each time a dealer sells a firearm, they fill out a form 4473 with the buyer's name, home address and date of birth next to the firearms make, model and serial number.
[1:08:44] When a dealer closes with no successor, federal law requires them to send those records to ATF within 30 days.
[1:08:50] The ATF now images those records in its out-of-business records imaging system known as OBRIS.
[1:08:57] It has been reported that ATF now has more than 1.4 billion records and that the agency's own proposed rule says that it takes in more than 6.8 million every month.
[1:09:09] These numbers should greatly concern all of us.
[1:09:12] The retention limits for records have varied over the years.
[1:09:15] Originally, records were kept permanently.
[1:09:19] Then in 1985, the requirement was changed to keeping them for 20 years, and that has worked out quite well for both the industry and ATF.
[1:09:27] This changed again, in my opinion, in violation of the Fire Moiner's Protection Act to a permanent retention under a 2022 rule.
[1:09:35] For the ATF itself, there has never been any limit.
[1:09:38] The ATF's new rule would again revoke the permanent time limit and cap both dealers and the ATF to either 20 or 30 years for a combined amount of 60 years.
[1:09:48] On August the 4th, I led 28 of my House Republican colleagues in sending the ATF a letter as a comment on its proposed rule, firearms records retention periods.
[1:09:59] Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to enter this record or this letter into the record.
[1:10:04] Without objection.
[1:10:05] Thank you.
[1:10:06] Our congressional letter argues for a shorter period, but maintains the bigger problem is the digital archive itself and the recording of out-of-business records that creates the digital archive.
[1:10:18] The Gun Control Act tells dealers to deliver their records to the ATF.
[1:10:22] It said nothing about ATF scanning or digitizing the records.
[1:10:26] In fact, Congress has already spoken out on this matter through the Firearm Owners Protection Act, which bars, and I quote,
[1:10:32] any system of registration of firearm owners or firearm transactions or dispositions.
[1:10:38] It also prohibits the recording of out-of-business records.
[1:10:43] And now I would like to just read you that, that section of the current law, which says,
[1:10:48] no rule or regulation prescribed after the date of the enactment of the Firearm Owners Protection Act
[1:10:53] may require that records required to be maintained under this chapter or any portion of the contents of such records,
[1:11:00] that would be the 4473s, be recorded at or transferred to a facility owned, managed, or controlled by the United States or any state or political subdivision thereof,
[1:11:10] nor that any system of registration of firearm owners, firearms, or firearm transactions or dispositions be established.
[1:11:18] So it prohibits two things. It prohibits, one, the recording of the records.
[1:11:23] And number two, the creation of a system of registration of firearms.
[1:11:29] That is the Firearm Owners Protection Act. That is the law. That's today's law.
[1:11:34] So, question for each of you, or Mr. Johnson, for you first.
[1:11:41] Am I reading this wrong, but does that not seem like there's a prohibition on recording of records?
[1:11:48] There is a prohibition, and President Biden directly violated it with a new rule.
[1:11:52] Mr. Shufalo.
[1:11:53] It definitely would seem that way. Yeah, absolutely.
[1:11:57] All right. Thank you.
[1:11:58] Furthermore, a permanent appropriations rider, and I'm an appropriator,
[1:12:02] prohibits the ATF from spending money on, quote,
[1:12:05] consolidating or centralizing dealers' records within the Department of Justice.
[1:12:09] Read together, these two provisions explicitly block the ATF from digitizing records at all,
[1:12:15] no matter how long the agency keeps them.
[1:12:18] And I'll read that writer.
[1:12:19] It says, provided that no funds appropriated herein or hereafter, that makes it permanent,
[1:12:25] shall be available for salaries or administrative expenses in connection with consolidating
[1:12:30] or centralizing within the Department of Justice the records or any portion thereof
[1:12:34] of acquisition and disposition of firearms maintained by federal firearms licensees.
[1:12:39] That would be the 4473 record.
[1:12:41] Yet the ATF's proposal on the length of records kept does not address either law.
[1:12:48] So, Mr. Nelson, before the ATF began imaging records, it traced firearms through paper, correct?
[1:12:57] That's correct.
[1:12:58] Okay.
[1:12:59] Could ATF complete an out-of-business trace then?
[1:13:01] Yes.
[1:13:02] Okay.
[1:13:03] Thank you.
[1:13:05] So, digital records are not necessary for completed traces.
[1:13:09] Is that correct?
[1:13:10] That's correct.
[1:13:11] All right.
[1:13:12] Thank you.
[1:13:13] And I believe, let's see.
[1:13:16] Also, I would like to ask unanimous consent for Section 580 of the Fiscal Year 27 CGS Appropriations Bill,
[1:13:24] H.R. 8845, to be entered into the record.
[1:13:27] And that is the current appropriations rider that prohibits the ATF from recording records.
[1:13:34] Without objection.
[1:13:35] Thank you.
[1:13:36] I see my time has expired.
[1:13:38] The gentleman's time has expired.
[1:13:40] Ms. Simon is recognized for five minutes for questioning.
[1:13:44] Thank you so much, Chairman.
[1:13:46] Mr. Jackson, in the beginning of your remarks, you said a number of things that should catch
[1:13:56] the attention of everyone watching.
[1:13:59] Gun violence, you said, is one of the most significant public health crisis in the United States.
[1:14:05] You also talked about gun violence being the leading cause of death among pregnant women,
[1:14:13] pregnant women in this country.
[1:14:17] You talked about gun violence being the leading cause of new disability among Americans.
[1:14:26] I could ask you a number of questions, Mr. Jackson, but, you know, it's difficult to move past those statements.
[1:14:38] You talk about freedom.
[1:14:43] How free are we if we're not safe?
[1:14:45] How safe are we if we're not free?
[1:14:50] You know, I'm also excited that we actually are having a conversation.
[1:14:55] As my colleague said, we have not sat down as a committee in a formal hearing space in quite some time.
[1:15:02] What has been said by my colleagues and members of the panel, I hope it's ringing true for everyone.
[1:15:11] I'm from Oakland, California, Mr. Jackson.
[1:15:13] And in my career working with young people, I've buried many young people, many young people.
[1:15:21] And I've watched children who were never able to grow old being lowered into the ground.
[1:15:29] And if the ATF wants to destroy the records and we want to have a silly conversation around trashing information.
[1:15:42] I think about the 50,000 traces that go dark according to their own records.
[1:15:51] Those are real people's lives.
[1:15:54] Mr. Jackson, you served in the White House under the last administration.
[1:16:02] And I've heard you speak at length about what it took the heavy lifting working with faith leaders all over the country.
[1:16:12] Many of them facilitating many of those funerals who knew and know and understand the deep impacts when law enforcement government community aren't working together to keep us all safe.
[1:16:26] I wanted to give you an opportunity in the two minutes that I have left because you've only had a few minutes to speak to talk about what would be happening if the office of violence prevention gun violence prevention was still moving forward.
[1:16:48] What were your hopes for that institution within the White House?
[1:16:54] Yeah, well, a major focus of our office was preventing violence in all its forms.
[1:17:02] And I'll never forget, you know, in Philadelphia, we met with parents who had lost their loved ones to violence.
[1:17:08] And I met a mother in tears because her son was shot and killed by a ghost gun.
[1:17:12] We went to Las Vegas and sat down with the local law enforcement district and said, what is the most important thing that the federal government can offer you to help you be more effective?
[1:17:20] And they said we need help tracing crime guns.
[1:17:23] And a lot of the work that we did was directly connected to the conversation today.
[1:17:27] We talked about how these records are important, that these older guns are not an issue.
[1:17:32] But since 2017, we've seen 92,000 ghost guns recovered by the ATF.
[1:17:38] And if we actually destroyed these records, we would have created an additional 531,000 untraceable guns.
[1:17:45] So we this a movement like this would create a flood of untrace firearms that will lead to more carnage and more losses across the country.
[1:17:54] And so a major part of our office's job was to work with agencies to ensure they see the blind spots, that they have the resources they need that were improving and strengthening coordination.
[1:18:05] But also that we're clarifying and identifying new ways to address violence.
[1:18:10] And we move forward 54 executive actions, help fully implement the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, which had many strong Republican led measures in that bill.
[1:18:19] But ultimately, it led to drastic and historic results.
[1:18:23] And so what is challenging about now, as opposed to thinking about how we can double down and build on it, build on the success of the ATF, build on it.
[1:18:30] We are actually at a time where the budget is being threatened to be reduced by, I believe, 26 percent.
[1:18:36] Again, the actual tools that they have for local and state law enforcement are now being discussed about being destroyed, literally destroyed.
[1:18:43] And we're moving backwards from a proven bipartisan strategy that has saved countless lives to date.
[1:18:49] Well, my time is up, but I really want to thank you.
[1:18:51] And I think I speak for many of us.
[1:18:55] We're so honored that you are still in the work, in the mud, in the communities, saving lives.
[1:19:00] Thank you so much for your service, sir.
[1:19:02] Thank you.
[1:19:03] I'll yield back.
[1:19:04] The gentlelady yields.
[1:19:05] Mr. Jack is recognized for five minutes.
[1:19:07] Mr. Chairman, thank you for convening this hearing.
[1:19:09] I would like to yield my time to the strongest defender of the Second Amendment with whom I've ever served, my colleague from Georgia's 9th Congressional District, Mr. Clyde.
[1:19:20] Thank you.
[1:19:23] Thank you, Mr. Jack.
[1:19:24] I appreciate your yielding the time.
[1:19:27] Let me continue on with my questioning here.
[1:19:30] So, to Mr. Shafullo, so what I read with regard to the Appropriation and the Firearm Owners Protection Act, the permanent appropriations rider, with those two combined, do you believe those two would prohibit the ATF from digitizing out of business records?
[1:19:50] The legal reading of it would seem as such, yeah.
[1:19:55] Not that, you know, listen, I'm just a country lawyer from New Jersey.
[1:19:58] You know what I mean?
[1:19:59] Like, I'm not some, you know.
[1:20:01] But at the end of the day, the reading of it would be that, yes.
[1:20:05] And at the end of the day, I mean, I've known you for a long time.
[1:20:10] Yes.
[1:20:11] I know you're a federal firearms licensee.
[1:20:13] And I think that there are solutions or there are things out there with the records to help tracing that could be achieved.
[1:20:21] I don't know that retaining records that are 50 years old and having somebody manage them or digitize them or do this with them or that with them is good money spent.
[1:20:32] I don't know that the juice is worth that squeeze.
[1:20:34] You could have more cops.
[1:20:35] You could have more, you know, initiatives.
[1:20:39] You could have a lot more.
[1:20:40] I don't know that people need to be hanging over boxes and 50,000 boxes of records that may not have quite the effect that we've heard they have.
[1:20:51] Mr. Johnson, what do you say?
[1:20:53] With those two, the Fire Motors Protection Act and the Permanent Appropriations Rider combined, do you think that would be a prohibition on ATF from digitizing out of business records?
[1:21:03] I think that the registry is illegal for and violates both of those requirements from Congress.
[1:21:09] But I do think that in general Congress has failed to rein in ATF and that more legislation ought to be passed if the current administration won't enforce the law as we currently have.
[1:21:20] Mr. Nelson, do you know, granted you haven't been in ATF for a number of years, but do you know the cost of retaining those records?
[1:21:29] Those old records that are 20, 30, 40, 50 years old?
[1:21:33] I do not.
[1:21:37] Okay.
[1:21:38] All right.
[1:21:39] My understanding is it's somewhere around $10 million a year that it actually costs to do that.
[1:21:44] Now, notably, the ATF liens on a 2016 GAO review that found that OBRIS is compliant because records were not searchable by name.
[1:21:54] But what it doesn't mention is the recording prohibition.
[1:21:59] When I read Section 106, which was an amendment to Section 926 of Title 18 of the United States Code, it had two prohibitions there.
[1:22:09] It had no such rule or regulation prescribed after the enactment of the Fire and Monish Protection Act may require that records maintained, which is the 4473, be recorded or transferred to any facility or at any facility managed or controlled by the United States.
[1:22:25] So that's prohibition number one.
[1:22:27] And the second prohibition was that any system of registration of firearms, firearm owners or firearm transactions or dispositions, be established.
[1:22:35] So, Mr. Shafullo, the ATF defends OBRIS by pointing to the GAO, the 2016 GAO report.
[1:22:45] Are you familiar with that report, sir?
[1:22:46] I am.
[1:22:47] All right.
[1:22:48] Do you see any problems with that report?
[1:22:50] And if so, what problems?
[1:22:52] First and foremost, it's from 2016.
[1:22:55] Okay.
[1:22:56] So I don't even think I had a cell phone in 2016.
[1:22:59] So we need some updating there.
[1:23:02] Second of all, I don't know that Congress is bound by a report.
[1:23:06] It's not presidential in any way, shape or form.
[1:23:09] You're correct.
[1:23:10] It's not law.
[1:23:11] Okay.
[1:23:12] So who relied on it then has a lot to do with politics, has a lot to do with a lot of different things.
[1:23:19] I don't know that I would personally rely on that today.
[1:23:23] But like I said, that's just me.
[1:23:25] Mr. Johnson, the ATF defends OBRIS by pointing to this 2016 GAO report.
[1:23:32] Do you see any problems with this report?
[1:23:34] That report found ATF to be in violation of the consolidation and centralization in two separate databases.
[1:23:43] I believe there is a third specific violation limited to the confines of that report that was ongoing from 2004 and was covered up by the Biden administration in 2022.
[1:23:54] On the larger scale, I do think that the report is wrong in its interpretation of the various searchability, consolidation and registration prohibitions.
[1:24:03] This is a registry in violation of those laws.
[1:24:06] Thank you.
[1:24:08] The question for the ATF isn't only how long it keeps these records, but it's whether Congress has ever allowed a digital archive of them in the first place.
[1:24:16] We cannot forget that gun registration inevitably leads to gun confiscation.
[1:24:20] Therefore, we must fight for the ATF to immediately remove its illegal gun registry and ensure that such records are never digitized again.
[1:24:28] And I will continue to do that in my ongoing efforts to protect and restore America's Second Amendment freedoms.
[1:24:34] And I yield back to Mr. Jack.
[1:24:36] And I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
[1:24:37] I thank the gentleman.
[1:24:39] And in closing, we've exhausted our questions up here.
[1:24:44] I believe the ranking member, we don't have any more Democrat questions, neither Republican.
[1:24:49] So I'd like to thank our witnesses once again for your testimony today.
[1:24:53] And I yield to the ranking member for closing remarks.
[1:24:57] Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[1:24:59] Just to summarize, this is the subcommittee on federal law enforcement.
[1:25:05] We're supposed to be working on keeping people safe while protecting their rights here at the federal level.
[1:25:11] We haven't met in months.
[1:25:13] We've gotten back together here.
[1:25:15] And what it seemed like so much of the Republican questioning was about was eliminating what is known as out-of-business records,
[1:25:24] basically eliminating a key law enforcement tool for gun traces.
[1:25:29] These tools are used hundreds of times a day to track down evidence in cases of violent crime.
[1:25:39] And I asked earlier about HR 563, authored by my colleague from Texas, Mr. Cloud,
[1:25:46] which would eliminate this key tool that the ATF uses.
[1:25:53] And it seems like from Mr. Clyde's questions, others' questions, that there's this continued goal
[1:25:58] to eliminate a tool being used hundreds of times a day to help us get the evidence we need to solve violent crime.
[1:26:08] I'm grateful that my friend Chairman Higgins seemed to indicate actually that we shouldn't eliminate the entire database.
[1:26:15] And I hope then that the Chairman would rescind his support for this bill that would eliminate this critical law enforcement tool.
[1:26:25] We should be using this committee and these hearings to make sure that we solve instances of violent gun crime,
[1:26:33] not take away one of the tools that law enforcement needs and has to make sure that lawful gun owners can remain responsible,
[1:26:42] but that we also hold those responsible who commit violent crime with their guns. I yield back.
[1:26:49] Ranking Member Yields. I recognize myself for closing remarks.
[1:26:54] To Americans watching and to those present in the room, it's important that we recognize that we seek balance in the truthful reveal of the intersection between federal law enforcement and the American people.
[1:27:15] Yeah, that's the federal law enforcement subcommittee of the oversight committee is a very powerful subcommittee within a very powerful committee.
[1:27:23] And we have we have a solemn duty to explore where oppression may be born within the federal government.
[1:27:38] upon the individual rights, liberties and freedoms of the American people.
[1:27:46] And the and exploring this topic today was looking through a very important window of that intersection,
[1:27:55] because the Second Amendment is an inalienable right and the federal law long standing prohibits the establishment of a registry of legally owned firearms.
[1:28:11] This is fact. It's also fact that this that the seizure of weapons and the components of light weaponry was the decisive catalyst that led to the armed conflict of the American Revolution.
[1:28:33] We it was asked earlier, who are we protecting?
[1:28:40] We are protecting. We are protecting the entire Republic, the very foundation upon which our Republic stands when we defend individual rights, liberties and freedoms and constitutional protections.
[1:28:54] And to guard against those individual rights, liberties and constitutional protections.
[1:29:01] We must explore where the federal government is encroaching upon the citizenry's daily life.
[1:29:12] And we must identify potential threat, especially in a massive form.
[1:29:19] So, yes, the gentleman, the ranking member has brought up a couple of times that that I support the discussion of a 20 year retention of records.
[1:29:31] Yes, but that doesn't include the digitization of records that are turned over by licensed firearms dealers.
[1:29:39] Firearms dealers and the tracing of data, respectful of Mr. Jackson's testimony, tracing of data happened a long time before we had computers.
[1:29:53] We we we have an obligation to seek balance between our constitutional rights and effective law enforcement, always with the pursuit of justice within the parameters of our criminal justice system and always with an eye towards our individual rights, liberties and freedoms as American citizens.
[1:30:22] I thank all of our witnesses for being here today with that and without objection.
[1:30:29] All members have five legislative days within which to submit materials and additional written questions for the witnesses, which will be forwarded to the witnesses.
[1:30:39] If there is no further business without objection, the subcommittee stands adjourned.
[1:30:44] From my name of John and John Anhek Dharma, I'm at John Anhek Leahy we believe that Revelation has reached our page and will be part of that in the nuestra head of John Anhek representa level.
[1:30:45] In your name of John Vfakorgtiburg.
[1:30:46] 已经 es Kristin canvas migrations
[1:30:47] andencial bodies cigarettes
[1:30:48] every city from nearbyzn
[1:30:49] order of John Anhek
[1:30:50] 111
[1:30:51] to John Anhek
[1:30:51] 121
[1:30:52] the "'Now-O' kolom Z 남は
[1:30:53] 2-4
[1:30:53] and 1
[1:30:55] to John Anhek
[1:30:56] 111
[1:30:57] plus 2
[1:30:59] 1
[1:31:09] 2
[1:31:10] 5
[1:31:11] 7