About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Here's the Data I Wanted Congress to Hear about Social Security from Kathryn Anne Edwards, published November 21, 2026. The transcript contains 1,835 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"get ready with me the KEDS economist version I'm going to walk you through all of the documents I had on my person when I went into the senate to testify we won't be putting on makeup or doing our hair we will be talking about social security so first document I had printed out oral remarks that I..."
[0:00] get ready with me the KEDS economist version I'm going to walk you through all of the documents I
[0:04] had on my person when I went into the senate to testify we won't be putting on makeup or doing
[0:08] our hair we will be talking about social security so first document I had printed out oral remarks
[0:14] that I could read and as you can see I made edits basically up until the moment I started speaking
[0:18] including while my co-witnesses were presenting I also had my written testimony which is just a
[0:25] reference document that I submit to the congressional record mainly to source and cite and explain all of
[0:31] the facts and points I make in here I have even have like key point one then I had some prep materials
[0:39] I put it on these nice little half sheets of paper and they're materials to help me with like potential
[0:45] questions right I gave myself a question answered it what what changes have had to the economy what
[0:50] will eliminating the cap do what is social security and how should we think of it who would be hardest
[0:55] hit by a benefit cut what is the maximum a person will pay in 2026 what will scrap the cap due to
[1:00] the finances what has changed since the 1983 reforms of benefits does immigration add to the social
[1:06] security is raising revenue important relative to tax cuts then I had a bunch of like basic facts about
[1:12] social security I think the ones that are the most important solvency over the last 45 years average
[1:18] benefit two thousand dollars average replacement rate forty percent 68 million beneficiaries on social
[1:23] security 37 27 years of surplus in the program life expectancy in 1930 versus 2025 total taxable payroll
[1:33] size of the prime age workforce in the u.s over time whether or not the social security is a ponzi scheme
[1:39] basically just a bunch of like put down and have notes any site or fact I'd like to cite if someone
[1:46] asked me a question I don't do that much member prep but what I did do was each senator the year they
[1:53] were elected to congress what the depletion date was of social security when they were elected to congress
[1:58] if they voted for the tax cut that hurt social security's finances and the one big beautiful bill
[2:03] act and then how important social security is to their state's economy as well as their state's median income
[2:10] and then we had all of my reference materials so I was presenting alongside two economists who had
[2:16] co-written a paper on fiscal effects of government borrowing that social security could get tribute to
[2:21] possibly lead to a fiscal crisis or a debt crisis so I had their paper on hand um AARP the AARP institute
[2:30] has just written a paper on how much social security's tax base has eroded due to changes in the economy so
[2:37] social security's tax base used to represent 41 percent of the economy that's how much was under the cap
[2:43] being earned by Americans that social security drew its tax from that was in 1983 today it's 34 and if
[2:49] it had maintained a 41 percent ratio of the economy we would not be running out of depletion until 20 like
[2:57] 59 we'd have another 25 years from now so workers being hit so hard in the economy over the past 40 years
[3:04] has bruised social security and they wrote a very succinct paper explaining that then I had two papers on
[3:13] the deficit does social security add to the deficit there is an argument for yes and an argument for
[3:19] no the argument for no is really social security gets money from payroll tax contributions and if
[3:27] it has extra payroll tax contributions it puts it inside a trust fund social security's benefits have
[3:32] drawn exclusively from those tax contributions and the trust fund it doesn't use general revenue
[3:38] and it hasn't so it can't really be adding to the shortfall that the government is experiencing now
[3:43] since it's all money that social security itself has raised however some people yes social security
[3:50] as the deficit think that that's just an accounting fiction and it's just government money coming in
[3:54] government money coming out and social security is part of the we don't have enough money coming in
[3:59] versus the money going out I think that that's a really disturbing argument to make because the
[4:06] people who make it are trying to make the forward case like social security doesn't have the money
[4:10] now we need to cut it because it's already too big the trust fund is just an accounting fiction
[4:15] if the trust fund is just an accounting fiction then for roughly 30 years when payroll tax
[4:22] players basically workers were paying into social security congress took their money and spent it and
[4:27] now that those payroll tax contributions are enough the trust fund is an accounting fiction this is like
[4:32] your hand is in the till you treated social security taxpayers like they were putting into a piggy bank
[4:38] and now congress is balking on paying them back so i can understand the argument of like yeah social
[4:43] security adds the deficit it makes sense because it's simple but for the perspective of like what
[4:48] these taxes were intended for and how they were told they were being treated congress saying social
[4:53] security adds to the deficit is congress saying we stole your payroll tax contributions for other things
[4:58] and now we just really don't want to pay you back so i was prepared to talk about that part other
[5:04] things i was prepared to talk about sources of our current kind of deficit we have the third fourth
[5:10] largest deficit in u.s history outside of world war ii the great recession and the pandemic it's right now
[5:16] and obviously whoever member of congress is speaking to me it's the other party's fault but i did have
[5:21] a table of every tax cut that has been passed since 2001 its name its short name and then how much it added
[5:28] to the deficit in the year that it was passed versus put that number in real terms and how much it adds
[5:34] now so you can see it's two-sided because there's been about 14 and it takes you know roughly one to
[5:40] 1.25 trillion dollars off of annual revenue has been tax cuts this century and they have gone so
[5:47] overwhelmingly to the top one percent something i was able to cite in the testimony that the largest
[5:51] decrease in effective tax rates over the past 25 years have been felt amongst the top one percent
[5:56] they had a three point drop in their effective tax rate so that was what i was prepared to talk about
[6:02] then i thought there were some things that could come up in questions that i wanted to have like
[6:05] big documents on hand one member of the committee who exclusively refers to a certain part of the
[6:13] population as illegals because he doesn't think that he's going to end up in a classroom in 40 years
[6:18] as horrified high schoolers look at how he talks about people he is part of this like what's causing
[6:24] the government's issue is fraud like it is undocumented immigrants who are stealing our
[6:30] public services and that's why they're out of money and not because of like c table of massive number
[6:36] of tax cuts so i had a report a piping hot fret off fresh off the press report from the government
[6:43] accountability office finding that there is rampant rampant fraud almost 300 billion dollars a year
[6:50] in tax fraud people who don't pay their taxes and they get away with the irs being underfunded and
[6:55] so fraud was your primary motivation and all you wanted to do to fix the government you would make
[7:00] rich people pay their taxes the other argument that i made is that you know fixing social security
[7:07] in a closed system means either you raise revenue or you you cut benefits that's really your only options
[7:13] however if you were thinking outside the box and thinking of you know see just how much the u.s worker
[7:20] is no longer paying in because of how low their wages are relative to historical periods and how
[7:25] much workers take home of the economy if you were to do things like invest in universal child care you
[7:31] would have higher labor force participation and so i was ready to cite the new the first new mexico
[7:37] child care study to talk about labor force participation and how much how many more workers we would have
[7:44] in the economy if we had child care for what it's worth the u.s has a really low work rate amongst
[7:50] prime age earners compared to our english-speaking peers so our prime age work rate is around 83 percent
[7:57] in canada the uk ireland australia and new zealand it's around 87. four points of additional labor force
[8:05] participation in the u.s just to put us on par with our english-speaking peers we would have five million more
[8:11] people working which would do enormous wonders for social security's bottom line and so i was trying
[8:15] to make the case to congress you need to invest in workers because it's a payroll finance program like
[8:21] let's let's attack the problem at its source people don't work enough and they don't make enough that'll
[8:25] help social security not everyone agrees that workers have really done so poorly in the u.s economy
[8:31] and so i have this really big paper that talks about every perspective in workers participation in
[8:36] their labor share and kind of what you need to know and so i was ready to talk about like you want
[8:40] to throw a little elasticity at me ready i didn't really get to talk about any of those things because
[8:46] this is the most important document i carried on my person as i walked in the committee room given to
[8:51] me by the democratic staff right beforehand the transcript of ron johnson on fox business here is
[8:57] his exact quote it's not your money it's being spent the minute it comes through the door and your
[9:06] benefits will be paid for by your children grandchildren and money borrowed from the
[9:10] public again that is a scam it is grotesque at this point there is no way to fix social security
[9:18] it is a ponzi scheme you can't fix it you just shut it down and hope you can recover some money
[9:24] now the difference between a government sanctioned ponzi scheme is that you can force investors to keep
[9:28] putting money in and that's what we'll have to do just remember the most successful public program
[9:36] in u.s history that has high 90 approval ratings from the u.s is according to the chair of the senate
[9:42] budget committee grotesque