About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Cross-examination of Cong. Chel Diokno to defense witness Atty. Rainer Dela Fuente from UNTV News and Rescue, published November 19, 2026. The transcript contains 7,017 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Good afternoon, Mr. Witness. Good afternoon, Your Honor. You started out in the Anti-Money Laundering Council in July of 2015. July of 2015, Your Honor. Correct. And you were part of the Compliance and Investigation Group only until August of 2017. Is that correct? 2018. Yeah, yes, Your Honor. But..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, Mr. Witness. Good afternoon, Your Honor. You started out in the Anti-Money Laundering Council in July of 2015.
[00:00:11] Jokin: July of 2015, Your Honor. Correct.
[00:00:13] Speaker 1: And you were part of the Compliance and Investigation Group only until August of 2017. Is that correct?
[00:00:23] Jokin: 2018. Yeah, yes, Your Honor. But I'm still part of the Secretariat after August 2017.
[00:00:29] Speaker 1: Well, let's be clear about that. You were only a financial investigator for a period of 24 months. July 2015 up to August 2017. 25 months. Is that correct? Roughly, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. You were only a financial investigator for 25 months at the AMLA. You started in July of 2015 and ended as a financial investigator in August of 2017. Isn't that correct? Yes, Your Honor.
[00:01:04] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:01:04] Speaker 1: In fact, in August of 2017, you were taken out of the Compliance and Investigation Group and reassigned to the Technical Services Staff under the Office of the Executive Director. No longer doing any form of investigation. Isn't that true? The first part of the statement is correct? The answer, my question is very simple. Sir, you're a lawyer, you're a CPA, you can answer it by yes or no. Your defense counsel can ask you to explain later if they want to. The question again, Your Honor. Your Honor, you were only after you were assigned from the or taken out of the Compliance and Investigation Group and transferred to the TSS or Technical Services Staff under the Office of the Executive Director, your work was really more on information campaign awareness, right?
[00:02:01] Speaker 3: Your Honor, before the witness answers, can we just ask for leeway so that the witness will be allowed to answer freely, without interruption?
[00:02:11] Speaker 4: He's on cross-counsel. You can address whatever issues he needs to clarify on redirect. Witness will please answer the question. The answer is yes, but can I explain, Your Honor?
[00:02:23] Speaker 1: Later, if your lawyer wants to ask you to explain.
[00:02:25] Speaker 3: Can he be allowed at this time, Your Honor?
[00:02:27] Speaker 4: Counsel, he already got the Honorable Jokin already got his answer. Again, without prejudice to you asking him to explain and redirect. Yes, Your Honor?
[00:02:37] Speaker ?: Correct.
[00:02:37] Speaker 4: Correct.
[00:02:38] Speaker 1: We will not...
[00:02:39] Speaker ?: We will submit your...
[00:02:39] Speaker 1: Now, the Technical Services Staff under the Office of the Executive Director is a totally different office from the Compliance and Investigation Group, correct? Yes, Your Honor. In fact, the Technical Services Staff serves as staff to the Office of the Executive Director. It has no investigative functions at all. Yes, Your Honor. In other words, your only background or expertise, quote-unquote, claimed expertise as a financial investigator is the 25 months you served as an FI under the Compliance and Investigation Group. Is that correct? May I explain, Your Honor? Yes, Your Honor. You may answer my question. Yes. Perhaps later you may explain if your lawyer wants to ask you. Yes. Yes, Your Honor. Now, you started out... What was your position, sir? BSP ranking? Bank Officer 2. Bank Officer 2. Bank Officer 2. So, that is not a senior management position. Am I correct?
[00:03:39] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor. Yes. That's entry level.
[00:03:42] Speaker 1: Entry level. And based on... And you were never promoted from Bank Officer 2. No, Your Honor. So, your expertise or your claimed expertise as a financial expert in financial investigation under the AMLA involves investigation of money laundering and its predicate crimes. Is that correct?
[00:04:08] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:04:09] Speaker 1: Now, you would agree with me that a financial investigation under the AMLA involves investigation of money laundering and its predicate crimes. Tama po ba yon?
[00:04:20] Jokin: Money laundering, Your Honor, not the predicate crime. Money laundering.
[00:04:24] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you. I stand corrected. So, iba po ang trabaho ng isang financial investigator. Kung ang iniimbestigahan niya ay unexplained wealth, non-declaration ng SAL-N, at participation in business, wala pong kinalaman ang financial investigator ng AMLA doon sa mga bagay na yon, hindi po ba?
[00:04:48] Jokin: Yes po. Yun po kasi ay predicate crime. Iba pong ahensya.
[00:04:52] Speaker 1: Tama po yon. Okay. Now, as a member of the TSS, yung pong technical services staff under the office of the executive director, ang naging trabaho niyo ay capacity building at information awareness campaign. Di po ba? Isa po sa mga trabaho. So, your employers felt that you would be more appropriate to serve AMLA no longer as an financial investigator. Objection, Your Honor. Argumentative. I'm not finished, Your Honor, please. But rather, you would best provide services to AMLA as a member of the TSS.
[00:05:34] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor. The witness will not be competent to answer that question. It's also argumentative.
[00:05:39] Speaker 4: If he knows, if he knows, counsel.
[00:05:42] Jokin: It's not argumentative, but if he knows. It's not argumentative, but if he knows, it's not a member of the TSS.
[00:05:45] Speaker ?: It's not a member of the TSS.
[00:05:45] Jokin: It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS. It's not a member of the TSS.
[00:05:52] Speaker ?: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:05:53] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:06:05] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:06:15] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:06:21] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:06:38] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:06:55] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:06] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:17] Speaker 3: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:20] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:25] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:36] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:52] Speaker ?: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:07:53] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:09] Speaker ?: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:10] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:17] Speaker 3: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:18] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:20] Speaker 3: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:23] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:50] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS.
[00:08:51] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:09:46] Jokin: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:09:50] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:10:06] Speaker 3: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:10:09] Speaker 4: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS.
[00:10:14] Speaker 1: It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. It's not a member of TSS. Ano ngayon ang bigat ng inyong opinion, kung wala naman pala kayong alam, tungkol sa mga ginawa ni Atty.
[00:10:44] Speaker 3: Your Honor. Question is argumentative, Your Honor. And that already, again, calls for a conclusion of fact and law. He said, ano-anong ayon ang bigat or halaga?
[00:10:57] Speaker 4: No, I heard a question. If you know, Atty. Rainer, if you wish to answer and if you know. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:11:03] Jokin: Ang akin lang kung saligan ay ang ating amla, ang ating batas. So, I can answer based on the law. I echo, I mirror what the law says. So, hindi ko daw kailangan... Ako, personally, ayokong basahin yung report because coming here, and wala rin akong access sa report. Coming here, reading that report, I will develop biases. I will be swayed yung report na yon. So, ang akin lang kung sinasandalan dito, ay kung ano ang nasa batas.
[00:11:35] Speaker 1: Now, your knowledge of AMLA operations is limited... Your personal knowledge of AMLA operations is limited to your brief stint as a financial investigator of AMLA. Isn't that correct?
[00:11:49] Jokin: Brief but meaningful. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:11:51] Speaker 1: And as far as any current policies, practices, procedures of AMLA, wala po kayong personal knowledge doon mula nung kayo'y umalis nung 2018.
[00:12:03] Jokin: Internal policies, none. But those that would affect covert persons, yes.
[00:12:10] Speaker 1: Yung kaalaman ninyo about the anti-money laundering concepts, ay na-acquire ninyo after you left. Well, let me reform. What you know about the anti-money laundering concepts is the same as what any other lawyer who reads the law would know. Isn't that right?
[00:12:33] Jokin: Yes, I respect po. Na-develop po ito nung ako'y nasa loob pa at nung ako'y lumabas na. Mas lalo na-develop because aside from getting the insights sa public sector, nakita ko rin ho, I was able to harmonize Mary kung ano ba yung meron sa private sector.
[00:12:49] Speaker 1: Nabasa ko po yung inyong Curriculum Vitae. Tama po ba na wala naman ako nakita doon na meron kayong special knowledge, experience, training, or education in investigating cases of unexplained wealth? Tama po ba yun?
[00:13:05] Jokin: Meron po, Your Honor, I think this was trainings conducted by USAID, anti-corruption. And then meron din ho sa International, ILEA, International Law Enforcement Academy in Thailand. So meron ho siyang financial investigation po, session seven. So I was able to, I was sent by the office to go there and participate, represent the office po namin.
[00:13:31] Speaker 1: But as you mentioned earlier, your work is for the AMLA, involved financial investigation of money laundering. Tama po? Correct, Your Honor. Yes. Now, I noticed as well from your background that you, while you did serve in other agencies, let me go through this one by one. Yung unan yung trabaho ay sa BIR, hindi po ba? Correct po. Earlier on direct, you said you served there at least one year. Is that correct? Yes, Your Honor. Working student po ako na. But it would appear that you were only working there for 11 months. Short of one year. Short of one year? Yeah. Sorry, sorry.
[00:14:18] Speaker ?: Short of one month.
[00:14:18] Jokin: Sorry, sorry. Sorry, Your Honor.
[00:14:20] Speaker 1: One year short of one month with the BIR. Your second job was with Punong Bayan and Aralio. How many months, how many months did you work at Punong Bayan and Aralio? Just for two months, Your Honor. Two months. Yes, Your Honor. And your third job was with the GCG, Governance Commission for GOCCs. How many months did you serve in that office? Two years, Your Honor.
[00:14:44] Jokin: Two years, Your Honor. Before, I think almost, well, few months after two years.
[00:14:51] Speaker 1: My records indicate that you started in April 2012 and ended in January 2014. Would that be accurate? Around that time, yes, Your Honor. So that's not two years. That's 21 months. Roughly, yeah. And your next job was at the Commission on Elections where you served there for 17 months. Yes, Your Honor. January 2014 to June 2015. Yes, Your Honor. And that is the summa total of your qualifications as a financial expert. No, Your Honor. You were peddling before this court.
[00:15:25] Jokin: No, Your Honor. That is my, that is the history of my government and private employment. So, in so far as financial investigation, that would start with AMLC up to, until now, I'm into private practice. It continues up to the present.
[00:15:42] Speaker 1: Now, you said you worked for Punang Bayan and Aralia for two months. So this did not give you any opportunity to learn how to conduct forensic audits, how to conduct compliance and due diligence, and other auditing services that are usually offered by these kinds of firms. Isn't that right?
[00:16:02] Jokin: I was assigned at the tax division. I am a senior tax associate. So the engagements that we handle are on tax assessments, and also due diligence review. Yeah, we did that.
[00:16:17] Speaker 1: So, wala po kayong ginawa o sinagawang forensic audits?
[00:16:21] Jokin: Wala po. Iba pong grupo ang audit. All right.
[00:16:24] Speaker 1: Now, let me move on to, well, first of all, insofar as your work as a financial investigator, ever since you left the Anti-Money Laundering Council, wala na po kayong contact sa mga nasa opisina ng AMLA. Wala po.
[00:16:47] Jokin: After leaving the service 2018, I started my own, well, with a friend po, we started a law office. So I imposed a one-year, wala ko talaga, that's for one year, no AML-related work. Kasi kumbaga delikadesa na rin ho namin. Thank you.
[00:17:13] Speaker 1: You were asked about Section 8-A of Republic Act 9160. May I know, how many times was the Anti-Money Laundering Law amended? Seven times. Now, when was the Section 8-A put in to the Anti-Money Laundering Law?
[00:17:30] Jokin: That's 2021 by virtue of Republic Act 11521.
[00:17:33] Speaker 1: So wala na po kayo sa AMLA noon? Yes, Your Honor. And am I correct in reading that law, that particular section, that there is an exception for the orders of the Court of Competent Jurisdiction?
[00:17:51] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor. That's on paragraph 2.
[00:17:55] Speaker 1: And since the impeachment court is a creation of this Constitution, the impeachment court is a court of competent jurisdiction. Is that not right? Yes, Your Honor. Now, once that exception applies, and now information is subpoenaed by the impeachment court from the Anti-Money Laundering Council, at binigay na po ng Anti-Money Laundering Council yan sa court, that is now within the custody of the court. Is that not right? The last part? That is now -- Once that information is submitted to the court, that information is now in the custody of the court. Correct, Your Honor. And it is the court that then will decide on whether -- what conditions that can be imposed in terms of using that information. Correct?
[00:18:45] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor subject to the same paragraph of Section 8-A. Yes.
[00:18:52] Speaker 1: And in fact, it's not only the impeachment court that issues subpoenas to the AMLA, even the Sandigan Bayan does. Am I correct? Yes, Your Honor. And once the AMLA submits the information to the Sandigan Bayan, that can now be included in the decision of the Sandigan Bayan.
[00:19:10] Jokin: Correct, Your Honor.
[00:19:11] Speaker 1: Yes, Your Honor. That can be mentioned, right? Yes, Your Honor. So, wala na pong espasyo sa confidentiality yan, basta compelled by court order ang information. Di po ba?
[00:19:24] Jokin: Correct, Your Honor. Nakalagay ko kasi doon, merong mga procedures that must be implemented for the protection, handling, and storage of access over such information. Now, this -- I'm sorry.
[00:19:40] Speaker 1: Please continue.
[00:19:41] Jokin: Yung confidentiality na yan, hindi nahuhubad kapag yan ay napunta na sa korte. It travels with the information.
[00:19:50] Speaker 1: I have to -- I wonder about that. Because I've read -- have you ever read any Supreme Court decisions that discuss -- that came from an appeal from the Sandigan Bayan that discuss what was presented by AMLA?
[00:20:07] Jokin: Sorry, Your Honor.
[00:20:08] Speaker 1: Is it not a fact that when -- once the AMLA reports are submitted to the Sandigan Bayan, as you said, they can be incorporated in the decision and therefore accessible to the public? Your Honor. Your Honor.
[00:20:26] Speaker 3: Your Honor. Your Honor, the -- this won't be competent to answer without the good counsel confronting him with the documents.
[00:20:36] Speaker 4: If he knows, Your Honor. If he knows of a case. He was presented as a AMLA expert. So -- Correct me if I'm wrong, Your Honor.
[00:20:43] Jokin: Can the decision cite portions of the report? Is that a question?
[00:20:50] Speaker 1: You're familiar with the cases of Ligot among others. And you will confirm that in the decision of the Supreme Court, mention there was made of what was presented by the anti-money laundering council. If not in the Ligot case, in similar cases of unexplained wealth. Okay. Yes, Your Honor. So in that respect, ay hindi na po confidential yung galing sa AMLA. Kasi mismo ang Supreme Court na naglabas ng mga nilalaman ng AMLA documents.
[00:21:23] Jokin: If my memory serves me right, Your Honor, these are findings already. Process information. What is prohibited is the raw data, intelligence report data, which is subject to verification.
[00:21:38] Speaker 1: So now you're making these finer distinctions that you did not make earlier. Ang sinasabi po ninyo ngayon, yung raw data lang po ang confidential. Including the investigation report, Your Honor.
[00:21:50] Jokin: Not just the raw data. Which is a derivative.
[00:21:52] Speaker 1: But yung investigation report nga po ay sinasight mismo ng Supreme Court. So paano siya magiging confidential? And ganon. Objection, Your Honor.
[00:22:00] Speaker 3: Counselors already arguing with the witness, Your Honor. Anyway, the witness already gave his answer, Your Honor.
[00:22:06] Speaker 4: Move on to your next point, Ernie Cel.
[00:22:09] Speaker 1: Now, earlier on your direct examination, you testified that you -- there's no such thing as sensitivity analysis. Sa batas. Sa batas. Wala po. Ngayon, kayo po ay certified public accountant, hindi po ba?
[00:22:27] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:22:28] Speaker 1: So, am I correct in saying that that concept of sensitivity analysis is recognized in the field of accountancy? Yes, Your Honor. So, nagagamit po yan ng mga accountants sa kanilang pag-i-investiga, hindi po ba? Yes, Your Honor. And there's nothing wrong with a forensic expert applying a sensitivity analysis test in his or her examination. Would that be correct?
[00:22:56] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:22:57] Speaker 1: Now, in connection with that sensitivity analysis, meron din kayong kanina nabanggit na piercing the corporate veil can only be done by the court. Did I get you right?
[00:23:12] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor. I base it on my limited knowledge of our revised corporation code.
[00:23:19] Speaker 1: Limited knowledge of the revised corporation code. Ibig niya bang sabihin na sa pag-analyze ng isang accountant o di kaya financial investigator, hindi niya pwedeng tingnan kung sino ang totoong may-ari ng isang kumpanya?
[00:23:38] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor. Misleading and already assumed the fact that that's not been established, Your Honor.
[00:23:44] Speaker 1: It's not misleading, Your Honor. It's based on the testimony of the witness given the evidence.
[00:23:48] Speaker 3: Misleading, Your Honor, because that's not even the concept that is contemplated by the piercing, the veil of corporate fiction doctrine, Your Honor.
[00:23:58] Speaker 4: Actually, court would like to hear the witness answer. Court has his own questions with respect to his theory in that regard at the proper time. If you know Attorney Rayner, can you repeat the question, Your Honor?
[00:24:11] Speaker 1: Let me just rephrase it. Kanina po, sinabi ninyo na ang korte lang ang pwedeng mag-pierce ng corporate veil. Ang tanong ko po, ibig niyo bang sabihin na hindi maaring i-apply yung doctrine na yan ng isang CPA o forensic investigator?
[00:24:35] Jokin: Sa kanya hong analysis, maaari.
[00:24:38] Speaker 1: So wala naman po palang pagkakamali ang ginawa ng forensic experts sa impeachment court na ito sa pag-apply ng piercing the corporate veil sa kaso nito.
[00:24:50] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor, that's already misleading. Considering Your Honor that the good counsel already added its own interpretation to what the forensic analyst allegedly did.
[00:25:03] Speaker 4: No, um, um, uh, Attorney Mark, the witness answered that it is possible, it can't be used. Um, witness may answer. It came from its own answer.
[00:25:12] Jokin: The question again, Your Honor, uh, kung tama ba? Uh, yes, Your Honor, tama naman, uh, maaari niyang gawin yun.
[00:25:19] Speaker 1: At ano po ni yung pangalawang tanong? Kung ginawang pagkakamali si Atty. Cabrera nung in-apply po niya yung doctrine ng piercing the corporate veil sa kanyang analysis sa kaso nito.
[00:25:32] Jokin: Sa kanyang professional, uh, uh, report. No, wala naman po. Walang nagbabawal sa kanyang nagamitin.
[00:25:39] Speaker 1: Earlier, you said that, uh, you have, quote unquote, limited knowledge of constitutional law. Uh, kayo na mismo po nag-amin yan, di po ba?
[00:25:49] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor, I was subpoenaed for AML matters.
[00:25:53] Speaker 1: So your opinions about what is found in the Constitution are really, don't really have much, um, um, Paano po kami makakapaniwala sa sinasabi ninyo sa mga nabanggit ninyong constitutional law opinions? Kung mismo kayo nagsabi na, limited po ang inyong kaalaman tungkol sa saligan batas. So, um, you said that, um, um, you were asked about legitimate income, and you answered, uh, to the effect that, um, uh, legitimate income would include income derived from the, from one, uh, business.
[00:26:54] Speaker 5: Uh, like, uh, official. Presley. Presley. The Constitution from receiving any. Uh, what they receive from their.
[00:27:14] Jokin: to decide whether they would consider this as legitimate or illegitimate, given the facts surrounding the case.
[00:27:32] Speaker 1: But you would agree with me that under Section 13, Article 7 of the Constitution, the Vice President is not allowed to receive any emoluments other than her salary as Vice President. You would agree with that legal statement?
[00:27:48] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor. Again, already calls for a conclusion of law. And that's precisely the question that the court needs to resolve in this impeachment case.
[00:28:00] Speaker 4: I think the Honorable Chell is quoting the constitutional provision itself. Would that be correct? Yes, Your Honor.
[00:28:05] Speaker 3: But he's asking already for an interpretation of such provision, Your Honor, that favors their position, Your Honor.
[00:28:12] Speaker 4: You also did that, Attorney Mark, but the witness simply answered, he defers to the court. He may do so again now. We will submit, Your Honor. Yes. Attorney Rainer, if you know.
[00:28:23] Jokin: If it is what is written in the Constitution, yes, Your Honor.
[00:28:27] Speaker 1: So, would your answer now change about what is legitimate income, considering that for the Vice President, income from a profession is not allowed while the Vice President is sitting as such?
[00:28:41] Jokin: Again, I leave it to the discretion of the Honorable Court, Your Honor.
[00:28:47] Speaker 1: One question, earlier, you were shown snippets of the report of Attorney Cabrera. You have already testified that you didn't read the whole report. Wouldn't you agree that context means a lot in terms of evaluating the veracity of a financial
[00:29:07] Speaker 3: report? Yes. The question is vague, Your Honor. Context means a lot. What does that mean?
[00:29:12] Speaker 4: I think the witness is intelligent enough to be able to understand the question. Witness may answer if you know.
[00:29:21] Jokin: As much as I want to read, Your Honor, I have no access over this information. I only do, I did my research, reading the news, watching some of the audio clips, and that's it.
[00:29:37] Speaker 1: Yes, Your Honor. Let's turn this around. Let's say that I were going to evaluate your investigation report. Do you submit an investigation report to the Anti-Money Laundering Council? Yes, Your Honor. But when I was looking to evaluate your report, I don't want to read the report. I just saw a few portions of that. Don't you think that would be unfair to you?
[00:30:02] Speaker 3: It's a speculative question, Your Honor.
[00:30:05] Speaker 4: I think the witnesses are already arguing. Allow me, counsels. Attorney Rainer, ang pinupunto lamang naman po ni Honorable Jokno, importante ang konteksto. Ibig sabihin yung kabuang report para maunawaan yung parte nito at yung mga konklusyon nito. Sang-ayon po ba kayo sa statement na yun na mahalaga ang konteksto at medyo may pagkukulang kapag hindi nyo nakita yung kabuang report sa pagbibigay ng komentaryo kaugnay sa parte o bahagi lamang ng report?
[00:30:36] Jokin: Correct, Your Honor. Pero ang pagbabahagi ho ng aking opinion sa report ay base lamang ibabanggahos kung ano maang provided ng batas. So I am not countering his or her conclusions na nando sa report. Tinitignan lang ho natin kung ito ay naaayon sa batas. Tama ba ang naging proseso? So, yun lang ho. As to the acceptability or not, again, we respect the professional, personal opinion of the forensic accountant who did that. But it should have been done within the bounds of law. Yun lang ho ang aking role. I do not question. Nasa sa ating impeachment court na ho yun kung kanila bang tatanggapin o hindi.
[00:31:16] Speaker 1: That's the witness's answer, Honorable Chell. You cannot cite any specific action done by attorney Cabrera that violates the law.
[00:31:25] Jokin: Based on the circumstances, again, it's up to the impeachment court.
[00:31:34] Speaker 1: Sir, my question is very simple. Meron pa ba kayong may papakita na mismong paglabag ng batas dun sa report ni attorney Cabrera?
[00:31:46] Speaker 3: Your Honor, again, the witness was not able to peruse the actual report, Your Honor.
[00:31:51] Speaker 4: No. As to the portion shown to you, Attorney Rainer. As to the portion shown to you, you testified, you made observations earlier, you expressed your opinion earlier. The question of attorney, the Honorable Chell, is quite clear. On the portion shown to you and methodology used as described by the counsel when he was asking you questions, were any laws, did attorney Cabrera in his methodology and our presentation violate any laws? In your opinion.
[00:32:21] Jokin: The section 8 of RA 9160 as amended. On confidentiality. On confidentiality. To a private individual.
[00:32:33] Speaker 4: Ito yung pagbibigay ng prosecution o ng komite sa kanya ng kopya para pag-aralan, suriin at pagbasihan ng report. That's the violation.
[00:32:41] Jokin: Yung po. Pero ito ay, again, depende na ho sa aggrieved party if he or she will pursue that case. So again, nandun na po tayo nakadepende.
[00:32:50] Speaker 1: And that is the only legal provision that you can cite. Nothing else.
[00:32:57] Jokin: That's the only legal provision on confidentiality, Your Honor. Section 8-A, in relation to that, we have the penal provision on Section 14-D.
[00:33:09] Speaker 1: Yes, so those two related provisions. Yes, Your Honor. Now, considering that the impeachment court itself has allowed the presentation of the Anti-Money Laundering Council records, and also allowed the testimony of attorney Cabrera, is it your opinion that that provision is still being violated by the impeachment court? Objection, Your Honor.
[00:33:33] Speaker 3: Question is misleading. What the witness answered was that it was a violation of 8-A because the AMLC documents or materials were provided by the prosecution to a third party. Now, the counsel is implying, Your Honor, that the court authorized such disclosure, but the court will never admit, Your Honor, that it issued any order authorizing the release of those AMLC documents to attorney Cabrera. No.
[00:34:04] Speaker 4: Chair confirms that, and I believe the prosecution admitted that they gave a copy to attorney Cabrera much, much earlier, based on the documents received by the Committee on Justice, by virtue of a subpoena issued by the Committee on Justice. Move along, counsel.
[00:34:19] Speaker 1: Thank you, Your Honor. earlier you questioned the reports, or according to you, use of official receipts from Jollibee Corporation. Those are considered as official receipts from the branches involved, right? Yes, sir. So in other words, those are -- those documents have evidentiary weight. In fact, if a corporation issues a receipt and states that it is their corporation that is issuing the receipt, that is in the nature of an admission by the corporation, is it not?
[00:35:04] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor, it's already calls for conclusions of facts and law, and the witness
[00:35:08] Speaker 1: will not be able to testify on those. Your Honor, the witness is a lawyer and a CPA,
[00:35:13] Speaker 3: I believe if he knows, he can provide an answer. Yeah, but it was not covered in his testimony.
[00:35:18] Speaker 1: I am entitled to question him on this point. We're giving him enough leeway,
[00:35:21] Speaker 4: counsel. Witness may answer, if he knows, on the receipts. Ano po li yung specific question, Your Honor?
[00:35:28] Speaker 1: Yung pong mga official receipt na ini-issue ng isang kumpanya, ay mayroong pong evidentiary weight yun, di ba?
[00:35:37] Jokin: It's not the best evidence obtainable po, no? There are better evidences po, no? Sa ating official certified true copies.
[00:35:47] Speaker 1: Well, thank you for that. That really wasn't my question. My question is very simple. When a company issues an official receipt and states that it was that company that issued the receipt, mapigat po na evidentia yun, hindi po ba?
[00:36:03] Speaker 3: Objection, as an answer, Your Honor, the witness already distinguished Your Honor. The evidentiary weight of such document vis-a-vis other official documents.
[00:36:13] Speaker 4: Move on, counsel. We get the point. Thank you, Your Honor.
[00:36:20] Speaker 1: I just have a few more questions on cross-examination, but if I may be given just a minute or two to confer with my colleagues, there may be other points that I will raise. If I may, Your Honor.
[00:36:32] Speaker 4: Without calling a recess, you may do so, counsel. We will entertain some interjections then from one or two. Senator Judge Soto, former Senate President, is recognized. You may proceed with your interjections, sir. You have two minutes.
[00:37:10] Speaker 6: I actually have one or two questions. Only, Mr. presiding officer. Thank you. Mr. witness, attorney de la Puente, when did you author that AML handbook?
[00:37:29] Jokin: July of 2025, Your Honor. It was published, but initial works po dito yung nagsimula na 2024.
[00:37:38] Speaker 6: You worked with the AMLC from 2015 to 2018 only, correct? Yes, Your Honor. Where were you in January 2021?
[00:37:54] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:37:55] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:37:57] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:37:58] Jokin: Yes. We amended the law in January 2021.
[00:38:00] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:38:01] Jokin: Thank you. Honorable Chell, are you ready? Senator Judge Luxon, what is your pleasure, sir? Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes. We amended the law in January 2021. Thank you.
[00:38:10] Speaker 6: Honorable Chell, are you ready? Senator Judge Luxon, what is your pleasure, sir? Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:38:18] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor.
[00:38:19] Speaker 4: Yes, Your Honor. Thank you. Honorable Chell, are you ready? Senator Judge Luxon, what is your pleasure, sir? Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:38:27] Speaker ?: Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor.
[00:38:31] Speaker 4: Yes, Your Honor. Not yet. Senator Judge Luxon, what is your pleasure, sir? Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:37] Speaker 7: Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:38] Speaker ?: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:38] Speaker 7: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:42] Speaker ?: Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:42] Speaker 7: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:45] Speaker ?: Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:45] Speaker 7: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you, Mr. President.
[00:38:50] Speaker ?: I had actually interjected on the issue involving the claim of the same defense council about weaponizing
[00:38:50] Speaker 7: AMLC, the AMLAC, for political persecution and harassment. When then Executive Director Benaventura was our witness. Since Attorney Bill Luan brought it up again, pinapulawd ko na po yung TSN para mas accurate. I remember. Yeah. And ang tanong ko po sa witness, familiar pa kayo sa history or provenance ng Section 16 ng AMLA? Nang AMLA? Nang AMLA. Kung saan ang galing yung Section 16? Attorney Rainer, can I respond? Not that familiar, Your Honor. But I'll tell you, no?
[00:39:29] Jokin: Historically.
[00:39:30] Speaker 7: Yeah. Ang nag-introduce niyan, Senator Soto. Soto Amendment. Actually, yung kasama niya nag-introduce dito, patay na rin pareho. Si late Joker Arroyo, Senator Arroyo, and Senator Ople. As well as Senator Angara. Siya na lang po ang naiiwan. Well, I can say na, following yung interjection ni Senators Soto and Ople, pwede na natin i-matededuce natin na yung present provision of Section 16 on prohibitions against political harassment of the money laundering law, including the AMLAP, no? On the prohibition against political persecution and harassment was really for the protection not only of trade and commerce, but also of a candidate sa eleksyon. Diyan po nagsimula yan. So, general lang yung paragraph one. Actually, yung two yung specific. Yun nga, in-introduce ni Sen. Soto at the time. Kaya nasama yung trade and commerce kasi yun yung mga contributors eh. Baka maharas. So, hindi pwedeng interpret na in a general sense like an impeachment trial na i-apply yung political persecution. Kasi po ako noong 2001, hanggang 2000, when I ended my term, ano, in 2013, subject po ako ng political persecution. Money laundering din. Sinasabi nung nating administration ay stashed, ano, sa mga foreign banks, hundreds of millions of US dollars. Yun ang political persecution. Hindi ko ginamit yung prohibition kasi hindi applicable. Kasi nga, applicability ng Section 16, papunta lamang doon sa election period para huwag maharas yung kandidato. I would just like to reiterate that, ano, kasi laging nabibring up yung political harassment sa ka-persecution dito sa impeachment trial. Hindi po yung intent and purpose of that provision. Yun yun lamang po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
[00:41:47] Speaker 4: Thank you, Senator Judge Lacson. Honorable Chell. You may proceed with your cross and wind up.
[00:41:54] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you, Your Honor. Earlier, Mr. Witness, good afternoon. You testified that you felt that two weeks was medyo mahirap para magpagsagawa ng isang financial investigation. Tama po ba yun? Challenging po yan.
[00:42:13] Jokin: Mahirap po.
[00:42:15] Speaker 1: But that is on the assumption that the person involved only had two weeks. Yes, Your Honor. The person has several months to begin their examination and as records came in, continued to examine the documents. Mulaan pong iso ang two weeks. Tama po ba? Yes, Your Honor. Thank you.
[00:42:36] Speaker ?: Thank you. Thank you.
[00:42:36] Speaker 1: Thank you. Now, let me just wind up. I just want to summarize several points that you have mentioned. You're not saying to this court that the records submitted by AMLA are inaccurate or untruthful. Wala naman kayong sinasabing ganun? Wala po, Your Honor. You're not saying that the records submitted by the BIR, SEC, and other government agencies are tampered or fabricated. Hindi mo rin sinasabi yun? None, Your Honor. Hindi nyo rin sinasabi na hindi totoo yung mga bank records na sinabmit ng mga banko sa hukumang ito?
[00:43:19] Jokin: None, Your Honor.
[00:43:20] Speaker 1: Hindi nyo rin sinasabi, aside from yung mga nabanggit nyo mga snippets ng report ni Attorney Cabrera, na meron pang ibang mga questionable parts ng report niya dahil hindi mo naman nabasa yung kabuuan.
[00:43:34] Jokin: Kung ano lang po yung napakita sa akin, Your Honor.
[00:43:37] Speaker 1: Hindi nyo rin sinasabi na, in fact, kanina pinupurin nyo yung qualifications ni Attorney Cabrera bilang forensic expert. So you're not questioning his qualifications.
[00:43:48] Jokin: I still respect him as a fellow professional.
[00:43:52] Speaker 1: Now question, kasi baka po magka, hindi tayo, hindi kayo maintindihan o hindi malinaw sa publiko. Kayo po ba, sinasabi ba ninyo na pag walang money laundering, wala rin unexplained wealth? But ano po, pag walang money laundering? Pag walang money laundering, walang unexplained wealth?
[00:44:12] Jokin: Baliktad po, money laundering is a derivative offense. So, it has to depend on, wala kong ilo-launder kung walang krim yung nangyari.
[00:44:21] Speaker 1: So, kahit na wala kayong mahanap na ebidensya ng money laundering, pero mapatunayan yung requirements ng unexplained wealth sa ilalim ng Republic Act 3019, section 8, ay pwede pa rin po magka-finding ng unexplained wealth.
[00:44:38] Jokin: Doon po kasi magsisimulang umikot ang gulong.
[00:44:42] Speaker 1: So, tama po yung sinabi ko.
[00:44:45] Jokin: Ano po yung sinabi niyo para, for clarity?
[00:44:48] Speaker 1: Even if there is no case or finding of money laundering, a case for unexplained wealth can still prosper if the evidence is there to prove unexplained wealth. Yes, Your Honor. Thank you. Ngayon, Nakausap niyo si Defense Council bago po kayo na upo dito? Unfortunately, hindi po. So, hindi po niyan na ipaliwanag sa inyo kung ano talaga yung nasa loob ng Article 2, ng Articles of Impeachment? Hindi po, Your Honor. At hindi niyo rin nabasa bago ngayon yung laman.
[00:45:32] Jokin: Sa balita po, nabasa po yung laman.
[00:45:35] Speaker 1: I'm sorry, hindi ko.
[00:45:36] Jokin: Sa balita po, Your Honor. Ah, sa balita.
[00:45:38] Speaker 1: Pero yung mismo dokumento na Article 2, you have not read. Not. Now, that may perhaps be the difficulty in your testimony. Kasi po, ang batayan ng Article 2, kung babasahin po ninyo yung laman, ay hindi naman po Republic Act 9160.
[00:46:03] Speaker 3: Objection, Your Honor. Sorry to interrupt. I have no question yet. I understand that. But, Your Honor, good counsel already used the terms difficulty. So, in other words, again, Your Honor, with all due respect, it's not the prosecution's function to interpret or give probative value to the testimony of the witness. It is the function of the court. He can just ask questions, Your Honor, to test his credibility.
[00:46:31] Speaker 4: I haven't heard a question yet, Attorney Mark. Kindly restate your question, Honorable Chell. I don't believe you've asked the question yet.
[00:46:42] Speaker 1: Not yet, Your Honor. Since you did not get to read Article 2 of the Articles of Impeachment, you do not know that this article is based on Republic Act 3019. You confirm that?
[00:46:57] Jokin: Yes, Your Honor. Based on the news, Your Honor, and the research that I did before coming in here, yes, I know that it's based on that Republic Act.
[00:47:06] Speaker 1: So, you confirm that this article on unexplained wealth is based, one of the laws is Republic Act 3019, Anti-Graphic and Corrupt Practices Law. Yes, Your Honor. You confirm that? Yes, Your Honor. You confirm as well that that law is in relation to the provisions of Republic Act 1379 on civil forfeiture. Yes, Your Honor. You also confirm that Article 2 is based on Republic Act 6713, your code of conduct of public officials and employees. Yes, Your Honor. And most especially, you confirm that the allegations of unexplained wealth, amassing of wealth manifestly disproportional to the lawful income of the respondent, the allegations of participation in business that is prohibited by law, as well as the non-declaration of Salem. These are all based on the constitution of our country. Yes. Thank you. No more questions, Your Honor. No more questions, Your Honor.
[00:48:20] Speaker ?: Thank you.