About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Exposing Green Energy Myths with Engineer Paul Brown from Quillette, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 10,034 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"I think I'll begin here, which is that we have in most of the Western nations and most extremely of all in Australia, perhaps there is this perception that we can fairly easily and quickly shift our energy production from fossil fuels to nuclear and renewables. I don't want to talk about nuclear..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: I think I'll begin here, which is that we have in most of the Western nations and most extremely of all in Australia, perhaps there is this perception that we can fairly easily and quickly shift our energy production from fossil fuels to nuclear and renewables. I don't want to talk about nuclear too much on this particular episode, because I recently had an episode on nuclear power in general, and I'm about to have one on nuclear power in Australia specifically, but there's certainly an assumption that a large part of the energy that we are now getting from fossil fuels, we will be able to, within the near future, in the very short term, obtain from renewable sources and that it's a sensible thing to do to try to subsidise and legislate and basically force people to switch across from fossil fuels to renewables. And I think this is an extremely foolish and unrealistic approach. that you share some of that view. Can you talk a little bit about, let's start from in general, what would make it, what are the fundamental challenges that would make it difficult to switch over?
[00:01:36] Speaker 2: So...
[00:01:37] Speaker 1: So let... Yeah. Go ahead. I mean, maybe start with a specific one like solar, if you'd like.
[00:01:44] Speaker 2: So, in terms of the actual viability of implementing these renewables, I'm not really sure the question is about the... My issue is not necessarily the viability. It's with the fact that all this, the implementations of all this, of all these policies is always prefaced with the idea that it's because of the environment. It's all about environmental concern. And I just think that's absolute nonsense. And I mean, there are lots of other reasons as well that I think that's nonsense, but in terms of environmental concern, you look at solar and the main thing about solar, people don't maybe, people don't really accept or they think people are being arrogant. People like me are being arrogant when we say that there's limits to what these technologies can do. And you look at something like solar and there's just this disconnect. I think that because solar has improved massively in the last few years, that it's going to keep on in that sort of trajectory and you're just, you're soon going to have, it's just going to be able to power everything with small solar panels. But the issue of solar is that the amount of energy from the sun is finite, it's constant and like, it's so constant that the scientific term is the solar constant. And so the amount of energy that you get per, per, you know, the area of the land on earth is constant and it's not a massive amount, it's so, so you're talking I'm not going to go into numbers or anything, and I'm just talking in general terms, 500 watts per square meter. And so you think that a car needs, you know, this is the only numbers I'm going to go into, but a car needs 70,000 watts. So you're talking, what's that, 140 square meters to power a car. There's this idea that somehow you can, you can, you know, get some sort of fancy paint in your car and then your car will be self-driving. And so you've got these limits, you've got this massive area to power a car. And then you have these other limits, like that's only when the sun shines and it's only when there's no clouds. And it's also assuming 100% conversion efficiency from solar into, solar into electricity. In reality, the conversion efficiency is only 20%, the rest is going to be lost by heat. And so, and so the area, the area of solar panels you need is massive, is absolutely gigantic. And that isn't changing because the, you know, it's tied to the amount of energy you get from the sun. So, and that's only one part of the story. When people say that, like people say that solar panels are now the cheapest form of grid electricity, and you see this, it will take you 10 seconds in Google to find, to find claims that it's, that it's 50% of the cost of gas, gas generated electricity. And I just think it's totally dishonest because what they're doing is they're taking the cost of the solar panels and they're taking the amount of energy generated and they're saying, right, that's the, that's the cost of these solar panels, but the supply of the energy you get from solar panels is intermittent and it doesn't synchronize with demand. So you need a place to store that solar energy. So you need a place to store it when you've got excess energy and you need a buffer when you've got too much demand and not enough supply. And so then you need a storage facility. And then there's a cost associated with that. And there's an environmental impact associated with that. And there's like, you know, that's a battery or a hydroelectric facility. And so, so all of a sudden your system's got a bit bigger and more expensive and more, more environmental impact. And then you have to take into account that this, that it's a fundamental law of physics that you cannot convert energy from one form and into another without losses. And so you pump this electricity from your solar panels into this, this, this, this power storage place, and you start using that electricity and you're only getting like 70%, 80% back out. So then you have to overbuild capacity again. So you've started off with 1,000 solar panels. Now you need 1,000 solar panels, plus a storage facility, plus an extra 300 solar panels. And then your solar panels are only producing at the particular rate, at a maximum rate, at say 30% of the time. So you need to overbuild that again. And we're not even taking into account like the finite lifespan of solar or the, you know, the geopolitical concerns, dependence in China, any of these things. It's, it's, it's just, there's a dishonesty in terms of the price. And if you, and sorry, when you take that 50% cost and you implement all these, all these different things, you know, the, the, the overbuilding just to make up for the losses in the storage, the cost is actually two to three times the price of what you're actually stating is. So what's the environmental cost? What are the other costs that people have been dishonest about? And so I guess that's a good starting point for, for what, for what magic, like what my objections to these sorts of things are.
[00:06:26] Speaker 1: Yeah, I noticed with solar as well, that people are subsidized to, to install solar panels on their roofs. And that does work very well for the individual person in Australia, or most of the time. Although even here in Australia, the sun doesn't shine at night.
[00:06:44] Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
[00:06:47] Speaker 1: It is pretty sunny here, but nevertheless, that means that only those people who can afford to own a property, which is a quite small proportion of people here, can afford to also install those solar panels because it's quite a large cost, even though you're being subsidized. Those people are installing the panels being paid by the government to do so. And of course that government money is coming out of other people's tax pay taxes.
[00:07:16] Speaker 2: Yeah.
[00:07:17] Speaker 1: And it's like an unseen energy costs that people don't realize is part of their, their energy bill because it's not in the little, it's not in the little thing that says this is how much your electricity costs are for this month, but you are actually subsidizing, poorer people are subsidizing wealthier people's solar panels, which is extraordinary, really.
[00:07:41] Speaker 2: I think it's, I think it's mad. And it's the same, it's the same thing here. And in the UK, they'll have energy costs are rising and rising and rising. We now have the highest energy costs. And I think it's the developed world and they don't, this is, this is concurrent with, with pushing all these renewables and installing these renewables and shutting down our existing energy infrastructure. But the two are never correlated. Nobody ever says that, you know, this is caused by, you know, the energy costs are caused by, by the renewables. And to, and to kind of speak to your point about the, the solar panels on the roof, the roofs. It's not, I mean, it sounds like a good idea putting solar panels on a roof. Of course, that's what you'd want to do. But when you put solar panels on a roof, that roof isn't optimized. The angle of that roof isn't, isn't optimized. It is going to get the most energy that it can because the house is built a certain way. It's not the same as, as building these things in the desert where you can just angle them the best direction towards the sun. So to get the same capacity from rooftops, you need a lot more solar panels because, you know, because you're not getting the same energy per solar panel. So then you have to overbuild capacity more, which makes them more expensive, which means that the subsidies are even more, the subsidies are even more inefficient. Those subsidies are better off being spent in energy and solar panels in the desert. But for some reason, it just doesn't, it's one of the, it's another one of these, the aspects of all this that doesn't quite make sense. It doesn't quite, it doesn't, and what it very much doesn't do, it doesn't get people to buy into this idea. What you need these, what they're trying to do, all these countries, the energy is so fundamental and they're wanting to change how energy is generated and how it's consumed, you know, like in the, the way the power is generated and in electric cars and all that. But in order to do that, you need to get people's buy-in and, and by subsidizing some people inefficiently and, and taking those costs from poorer people and being dishonest about all these things, you're not getting people to buy into this. And, and if you truly, if you are truly wanting to optimize for, for environmental impact, then surely you, surely you must realize that you need to get people to buy into this. And, and, but they just don't bother.
[00:09:54] Speaker 1: Hmm. Yeah. I, I feel it's, if it's really such an efficient source of energy, it really is a cheaper and more efficient source of energy than people would opt for that without needing to be subsidized. Why do those industries need to be subsidized? If that is such an efficient way of generating energy, that also makes no sense to me.
[00:10:17] Speaker 2: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I totally agree. And, and, and so you see these claims and you see them all the time of it, the cost structures, solar is so cheap and it's so good. And, and all this sort of thing, if the costs were truly what they were saying, that there was, they were, if, if the costs were such that they truly were cheaper than normal electricity sources, or they truly were better, then you would see natural inflows of, of money and investment into these solar things. You wouldn't need to subsidize them because if you can generate electricity for cheaper, or if you're in the trajectory to generate electricity for cheaper than you can currently generate it for, then you're going to make an awful lot more profit from that electricity generated than you are on existing infrastructure. So, so the money would just not flow naturally and the money would flow out of the oil industry and out of the gas industry, but you're not seeing that. Yeah, it's not, it's not, it's just not happening.
[00:11:04] Speaker 1: Yeah, it's, it's doubly crazy here in Australia because the argument is solar and wind are cheaper than nuclear. We don't really have hydropower except down in Tasmania because we don't have a lot of high rivers flowing down from high mountains here, but solar and wind are supposedly cheaper and more efficient than nuclear and than fossil fuels. And therefore we need to subsidize solar and wind and outlaw nuclear. And that just, that, that, that reeks of a planned economy to me. It doesn't sound like a product that's actually more efficient and profitable and cheaper. If it really were cheaper, you wouldn't need to subsidize and people would, would opt for it. If it kept their energy bills down, they would opt for it, but yeah.
[00:11:59] Speaker 2: Absolutely. I think everything points to this being planned and it sounds maybe going to get into conspiracy theories and things like that. I think absolutely, it just sounds planned. Everything about it's planned and there's, there's an awful lot of people making an awful lot of money. And I think that's what this boils down to.
[00:12:16] Speaker 1: What are the kinds of costs that people don't realize and to what extent do people not realize how dependent we currently are on fossil fuels, which is the one, the first thing we need to know is what are all of the things that fossil fuels are currently doing for us. And I think people are, and I think people are very unaware. They think of energy costs as just being what they see on their energy bill, which is only a small proportion of their living expenses, just their monthly electricity bill. And I think they do not realize just how much civilized life is built upon fossil fuels. Could you, or would you like to say a bit about that?
[00:13:03] Speaker 2: So in terms of that, the fossil fuels, I mean, of course you have fossil fuels in the sense that you're built upon fossil fuels and that if you don't like, if your roads have, if your roads have, fossil fuels are very much demand driven in that if your roads have potholes and you want them fixed, you know, the tar, the bitumen you're using to fill those holes, that's, that's fossil fuels, plastics and you know, everything's plastic these days. That's all fossil fuels. That's all material stuff. But, and I think, I'm not really sure in terms of what we're dependent on fossil fuels for at the moment, like what fossil fuels give us. I don't really want to sound like an advocate for the oil and gas industry. Like I don't think fossil fuels are the critical thing and I do work in, I do do some work now, oil and gas, but I don't think fossil fuels are the critical point. I think maybe what the more important thing is like energy is absolutely fundamental energy as a whole and the fossil fuels are used to generate energy, they're also used to make these other things. So fossil fuels are used to generate energy and these renewables can be used to generate energy. But the thing is, energy costs absolutely underpin everything that we do in that, I don't know, like driving our cars or, or, or even anything, being able to.
[00:14:27] Speaker 1: The food we eat, which is grown with, with pesticides, with fertilizers, which are produced using energy.
[00:14:35] Speaker 2: Yeah, and like, you imagine, you imagine if we didn't have these, this, this way to harness this external energy and we didn't have, um, like diesel to put in the tractors, we didn't have tractors, anything like that. We would all still be out there plowing fields and fields like by hand or by, you know, animal. And because we do have that energy, it means that less resources can be, will be consumed by, to do particular things that we need to do, which means we have more time spent to spend on other things. So by not spending time plowing the fields and getting tractors to do that and, you know, machines to do all other things that they do, then you can do things like invent medicines or, or, or, you know, I mean, talk about, talk about things, you know, spend more time talking about things or, or writing, reading newspapers or, or all that sort of stuff. So it's absolutely crucial. It's absolutely fundamental. And we, and the other thing is because it underpins everything, then low, low or not necessarily the lowest energy costs, but comparable energy costs with our competitors are necessary because without comparable energy costs. And because it underpins everything, then it has an influence on their final product price, whatever that product be. I mean, if we're making chemicals, then, you know, it's obviously going to be a bigger component of the cost, but you're not making, even if you're providing services, there's, there's still a cost, a cost component of whatever the final service is that is related to energy, because it's almost like a tax all across the supply chain from, you know, if you're a, I don't know, if you're like a journalist, fair enough, your energy cost isn't going to be a big cost of your, of your thing, but all the, all the materials you supply all down that supply chain that got to you at the point are, are accounted for in, in your cost of living. So, so those costs need to be comparable with your competitors in order to make your economy competitive, in order to make people buy your goods, in order for you to give you the money so you can buy goods elsewhere, buy what you need.
[00:16:34] Speaker 1: Yeah, I also, I, I find it, I mean, I agree that we need to reduce dependence on fossil fuels, we need to transition to new forms of energy, eventually, and hopefully to, to very efficient, more efficient forms of energy, more productive forms of energy, just as we transitioned from. Yeah. From. In the agricultural revolution. Yeah. To being able to harness more energy from, from the sun, ultimately from plants and from animals through agriculture. And then later when we discovered fossil fuels, we're able to use the bodies of our dead ancestors to, to access more compact energy. We need to keep going forward rather than backward to more reliable and more compact and more efficient sources. But in the meantime, I mean, I do think climate change is a concern and I think reducing emissions is a concern, but there seems to be a very parochial attitude to what that involves. So for example, Australia is responsible for about 2% of climate change causing emissions worldwide. We're pretty small producer directly of emissions, but we're massive importer of coal and gas and uranium to other countries, especially China, where they're being burnt, where the Chinese are burning the fossil fuels. So it seems to me to be a very strange calculation or attitude to say that, well, we've reduced our emissions right down by just sending the things to be burnt and create emissions elsewhere. I agree.
[00:18:29] Speaker ?: I think it's strange.
[00:18:30] Speaker 2: I mean, I'd, I'd never, I'd never considered the idea that, you know, Australia would send the oil or the coal to be burnt in China. Like of course they do to the massive mining industry, but it's mad. Like you need to, coal mining is like, coal is like the dirtiest form of fuel. That's not debatable. That's one of these things and to send it overseas and have it burnt and then buy the equipment and say, it's just absolute madness.
[00:19:02] Speaker 1: What can you say to that? Yeah. And I mean, to China where they've got no regulations basically covering it.
[00:19:08] Speaker 2: And zero. They just don't care.
[00:19:10] Speaker 1: They just don't care. Can you talk a little bit more in technical terms about the intermittency, the costs of relying on an energy source that is intermittent, like wind and solar and the constraints of energy storage through batteries.
[00:19:33] Speaker 2: So, so in terms of the, the energy storage, the constraints of energy storage through batteries. Again, going back to these, this idea of these limits, people, I don't think people, well, this is, this. Do you mean in terms of energy storage through batteries in terms of electric vehicles or in terms of like the weight limitations in electric vehicles? Or do you mean in terms of.
[00:19:54] Speaker 1: Let's start with electric vehicles. So you've, you've talked about hybrid cars as an example of working with physical constraints rather than against them. Yeah. And the fact that many governments are going, moving actually away from hybrid cars, want to go to completely electrified vehicles. And I think the UK has said they want to have, they want to abolish combustion, internal combustion engine cars by some specific date. So can you talk more technically about why that's a bad idea? I hope I'm framing my questions. Okay. Cause I don't have any science background. So I'm trying to frame them as best I can.
[00:20:34] Speaker 2: Absolutely. I'm trying to answer as best I can. Cause that, you know, obviously it's a big problem.
[00:20:38] Speaker 1: So feel free to, to just rephrase if, if what I've said doesn't make sense.
[00:20:42] Speaker 2: No, no, no, absolutely. So in terms of electric vehicles, you know, my inclusion of the, the, the hybrids in that article is an example of what you could do. It's really just an example of what you could do. Like there are ways to optimize these policies that, that would result in reduced environmental costs, but they're just not done. Like they're just ignored. And so the, the, these bands, the blanket bands and internal combustion engines, they don't care about hydrids and hybrids or their distinction or what their, what their benefits are. And in terms of the limits on electric vehicles. So basically the, the, my big, the, the big issue, the biggest issue of electric vehicles is their weight and the amount of, the amount that batteries can store. And the amount of energy that battery can store because the energy is how dictates how far that, that car can go. And then obviously all sorts of environmental costs associated with, with having things that are heavy and taking a lot of materials to build them. be their energy intensive things to build, but in terms of the weight and the limitations of batteries, there's this maybe not an, I think they may be not quite aware that there's only so much you can do with regards to batteries. And then there's only so much you can cut down that weight and, and it's never going to catch up to fossil, to, to not necessarily fossil fuels, but liquid or chemical fuels in cars. And then, and the reason, do you want me to go into just quickly? Yeah, please do. Go into a bit of, yeah. Okay. So the reason, the reason, okay. I'll try and explain in terms of the limits behind the batteries, why they are not going to, why they are not going to catch up with fossil fuels is in order to understand the limits behind something. Or, or in order to understand even that there are limits, like to, to just see that there's only so much you can do. And I think you have to understand a bit about how the, what the mechanism is by which that thing works. And with, with batteries, first off, when you're designing the battery, you would look at the periodic table of the elements, right. And the elements are, are the big, is a big, the elements are the fundamental, fundamental building blocks to the things that you can use to, to build things or things you can work with. And the thing that differentiates, different, the thing, and examples of elements are like helium and hydrogen, uranium, carbon. And the thing that differentiates, differentiates the elements is the primarily their weight. So, hydrogen and helium will have, will be, are very light, use them in hot air balloons. And then, you know, lead and gold are heavy. And the reason that the alchemists use, try to turn lead into gold is because they couldn't be broken, they couldn't break down either into anything further. So they thought there was something similar between them, but also there were very similar weights. So it's the weight that is absolutely fundamental to the, to differentiate these elements. And another characteristic of these, of these atoms, these elements, is that they may or may not have any number of electrons and like too many electrons or too few electrons. And so they may, they may have either too many or too few, or they may have just perfect number of electrons in this table. And it doesn't matter what electrons are for, for purposes, but if you connect an atom with too many electrons to an, an element of too many electrons to an element of too few electrons, then those too many will flow to the few, too few. You collect, you connect them through a wire. And that flow is obviously electricity. And what you've made is a battery. And when they balance out, that's your battery discharged. So you've heard of lithium batteries and that's what you use in phones and cars, and it kind of enables electric cars to work. But the, the reason lithium is the, is the third lightest element. There's about a hundred elements, a hundred and something elements in the periodic table. And it's already the third lightest element. And it's the first element that you, that you can use with any, that has any free electrons. So hydrogen and helium are lighter, but they don't have any electrons. So you can't use them for batteries. So you have to use lithium and then, or sorry, you don't have to use lithium. So you use lithium. It's the lightest one. And it only has one electron free per, per, per atom. But there are elements which have two electrons, three or three, you know, more electrons free, but there's always going to be a weight penalty with those. So, so maybe you'll choose like a different element, but that will have three times the amount of, of, of electrons free, but it might be five times the weight. So by choosing lithium, you're already optimizing for weight. So there's, so there's only, and like, I'm not saying that you're not going to improve battery technology. You are, you're going to improve lifespan. The amount of, the amount of time it takes to discharge it, all these things. But, but the energy you can get per weight is tied to atomic structure. And it's just not something you can, it's not something you can engineer, engineer away. So, so there is only so much you can do. And there's almost, and, and you mentioned as well, and sorry, to compare that with fossil fuels or chemical fuels, the way in which the energy is stored is absolutely different. With, with, in batteries it's stored, it's just the shuffling of these electrons. With fossil fuels it's stored in chemical bonds and you have to burn those in an engine. You, you know, you burn them and you, and they, um, and it, and it's an awful lot more energy that's released. You know, there are big massive chains of atoms, gently linked atoms, you burn them and it's an awful lot more energy. Usually it's just fundamentally different. And there's a gap there and the gap is not going to change. I don't know if that explained anything or cleared anything up. Yeah.
[00:26:17] Speaker 1: Yeah, that was great.
[00:26:18] Speaker 2: In terms of the limits, but your question was about the constraints on the, on like storage and things like that.
[00:26:27] Speaker 1: Hmm. Yeah. You also talked a lot in, in your article for Quillette about the environmental impacts of renewables, which is something people don't, which is something people don't take into consideration. Could you talk a bit about that? What environmental impacts people are maybe missing?
[00:26:47] Speaker 2: Yeah. So, I mean, look at, look at that battery example. These, these batteries are, they're heavy. There's a lot of materials involved. The refining of them takes a lot of energy. There's an environmental impact associated with batteries. And you will need batteries to, when you have renewables, it's intermittent, it's, it's unsynchronized supply and demand. You are going to need some, you are going to need batteries. You're going to need a lot of batteries. That's one environmental cost. In terms of the coal, we mentioned that you're burning and you're importing from Australia and you're burning. But in terms of the environmental impact. So there's all this focus on, on like CO2 emissions and global warming using our, sorry, climate change using, using that methods. But these renewable energies, they don't, they don't create energy. They harvest it from the environment. And, and you can't take energy from a system without affecting that system. So like you can't take energy from the climate without affecting the climate. So if they're without changing the climate. And, and so that's like an immediate and obvious, obvious kind of high level one. Then you take the solar panels and first off you're, you're absorbing as much sunlight as possible. So, so that, that sunlight was previously reflected into space and now you're just absorbing it. And like the, the wind is caused by differential heating of different parts of the land. So, you know, you think of a coastal area and a sunny day, it would be calm in the morning and then calm. And then the wind will pick up and then it will, you know, die down. And that's because the land is heating up different from the water. The same with these things. You're going to get these, these localized weather patterns. And then that's just one aspect of it. That's, that's a change in weather patterns, which is exactly what we're trying to mitigate against with, with the CO2 arguments. And then you're also covering, you know, due to the limits of the sun's, the sun's energy I mentioned earlier. This is vast amounts of, of land you're covering. And underneath you're absorbing all this light. So underneath those solar panels, nothing is growing. And like fair enough in the desert, that might be okay, but elsewhere it's not. There is an environmental impact. And then there's like the material costs in, in terms of these things taken, they're massive amounts of, of these things you need to make. And you've mentioned the coal costs. They have, do you have the batteries, which is a massive amounts of batteries or, or, or energy or storage requirements. There's the overbuilding of capacity. And then there's the finite lifespans. Because at the end of these, these things, there's currently, as far as I'm aware, I could be wrong on this, but as far as I'm aware, there is not really any viable way to rejuvenate solar panels. So their lifespan is extended beyond their, I think it's like 15 year lifespan. So after that 15 years, these are, this is electric waste. You need to scrap them. You need to, you need to get rid of that somehow. And then, and just buy totally new things. And that cost of recycling is significant and at least, and it's, sorry, environmental cost of recycling. And they need to buy, they need to get more again. And I don't think any of these costs are taken into, I mean, some of them are in a very high level, but the, but the whole thing is not taken into account in any sort of debts. I don't think, I'm quite certain that's not.
[00:29:51] Speaker 1: I mean, another thing that I was thinking of, I don't, I don't know how true this is, but we're often using renewables in tandem with gas. So that when the renewables are scarce, you switch over to the gas system to keep the grid running. And I imagine if you have a gas plan, even if you can turn the supply on and off, you nevertheless, you're going to charge as if, as if the supply was on all the time. It's like, I used to be a dance teacher. And if you book your dance lesson with me, but you don't show up, I'm still going to charge you because I'm still there in the studio. Having booked the space, having kind of, you know, that's not time that I can productively use otherwise. And so I imagine that's also increasing our gas costs that we have this unpredictable system.
[00:30:48] Speaker 2: I hadn't thought about that exact angle, like, but absolutely. And to kind of speak to that point, there's all this talk about green energy and green steel. Basically what they use is excess solar. Maybe it's not particularly green steel I'm talking about, but there's all these, there's all these investments in a particular industry. I can't quite remember which one is, and it's a similar sort of thing. It's kind of like the opposite mechanism where when you've got excess renewable power, you are going to use that power to generate hydrogen, which is very inefficient. And then you're going to use that hydrogen to produce steel and same thing. Like when that, when those steel plants or windows, whatever the plants are, are sitting idle. And when, when guys are turning up to work and there's no work because you don't have the hydrogen, you know, you don't have the gas because there hasn't been any excess. Then you still have to pay, like you say, for the, for the energy energy, this infrastructure is massively expensive. You need to pay for that. And you need to finance that infrastructure, whether it is producing or whether it is not. And so I imagine speaking to your point is like the cost of electricity from your gas plant. When you're only using it intermittently, it needs to be born by, sorry, the fact that you're using less electricity from your, less energy from your gas plant means that the cost of that electricity has to be higher to pay for the, you know, to pay for the gas. So absolutely the costs are going to rise.
[00:32:17] Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. You've still got to pay the guys when they come in in the morning to work, et cetera, even if, you know, you don't need gas today because it's sunny or whatever it might be. There are so many hidden costs to just unreliability and intermittency like that. Absolutely.
[00:32:36] Speaker 2: And I think that's the same with, with the entire, um, my issue of this, all this infrastructure or all this kind of pushing of the, of the renewables and the electric cars. And the electric cars and the batteries and stuff. If there was one or two things that were wrong about it that I thought, oh, that's kind of flawed. And you can kind of see what they're doing there. You think, okay, fair enough. Like that makes sense that, you know, that they'll be worked out. They'll be weaned out in the, in the process, but it's not like there's one or two things that there's just one thing after another, after another, after another, across, across everywhere you look at it. It's just, it just doesn't make sense. It's in particular for an environmental perspective. It just doesn't make sense.
[00:33:14] Speaker 1: I mean, one thing, one problem for me, or one fundamental problem is that this is not being, um, pushed by technology and innovation, but by governmental fiat and political decisions. It's not that I think that we could never have efficient and reliable renewables. Maybe we could in the future because it's, it's impossible to predict how we will, how we will solve certain problems, problems that used to seem completely intractable to human beings. Humanity has, humanity has, has solved. There are many, many such examples. So perhaps through innovation, we will eventually solve these problems, but that will need to happen on the timetable dictated by scientific innovation, by discovery, rather than we've got a switch within 10 years or within 20 years, because this government decree has come in. That seems like the, a completely wrong way round to me.
[00:34:18] Speaker 2: I agree. I agree a hundred percent. And I think there's, there's an awful lot of strange things about this. For example, we're buying all this equipment, like we're buying massive amounts of this renewable energy equipment from China. And we're acknowledging like you look as slightest bit below the surface and you see that these, these solar panels are not really doing that much for the environment or the batteries are not right now are not really doing much for the environment. And people say technological process, progress, that will, that will, that will change. Then you take into account, like the whole point in this is about the climate change urgency and the stuff we're buying right now, that's going to be in place for next 15 years. That's not going to, that itself is not going to change. So why are we not putting the money into, into re into, you know, the domestic research and development of solutions rather than just brand, just sending that money overseas for, for suboptimal solutions and entrenching the Chinese interests. And then, and then you look to, you look at, I mean, there's all this, just the exact same, like labeling of this whole thing, the energy transition. This doesn't look like any sort of energy transition, any successful energy transition in history. Like it's quite different in that every other energy transition happened. Like you say, naturally it happened because there were massive incentives for everyone to adopt the, the new energy forms. And this is just not that, this is just different. This is just forced. And it's, and like you say, it's government fear and almost the, there's almost, maybe not the suppression of debate, but there's a definite skewing of, of, of the, of the narrative very much in favor of a very single position. And there's a tone down, the turning down of the volume of any sort of, not even dissent, but any sort of, oh, maybe we should think of this type, type, I don't know, it's not an objection, but whatever that is.
[00:36:08] Speaker ?: Yeah.
[00:36:09] Speaker 1: And once it gets into the political realm, it's going to get simplified anyway, because these are technically complex issues and economically complex issues. And we're talking about a global issue with massive ramifications. So of course, people in the public are expecting to hear from political spokespeople on this issue. And therefore they are the messages that they're getting are in Australia. They're just so wrong. I find it kind of comical. So for example, our, our prime minister says that the sun and wind are basically free. A solar and wind energy are basically free because the sun doesn't send you an energy bill, which I just found such a bizarrely, such a bizarre, either misunderstanding or failure to understand the issue, which is not necessarily, you know, entire. I'm not putting that entirely on him. Yeah. It's just that there should be the advice that's being given. He clearly doesn't have any scientific background. Okay. He doesn't understand what's going on, but the advice that he is receiving from people who do understand should be, should make more sense. Should enable him to make statements that are just a bit less nonsensical. I totally agree.
[00:37:32] Speaker 2: And like, I, I'd never heard of that thing before that, like, obviously it's ridiculous, but it's a similar thing in the UK. Like, like the shutting down the, I mean, again, I'm not an advocate for, for oil and gas. I don't really, I just don't really care, but, um, they're shutting down domestic oil production in order to import it from overseas. And they're shutting it down domestically because, because like there's the carbon cost and they're importing from places like Kazakhstan and Qatar. And, and you think like, and, and, and they're fully acknowledging that there's like, we are going to need 15 billion barrels of oil, even if this energy transition goes ahead, full steam, like in the next 10 years. And, and so these, these, these, these sorts of insane policies, policy decisions, they seem to, they very much seem to be international and they all seem to be at the same pace and all that sort of stuff. And you mentioned there about the advice that they're giving. And that's something that I think, I mean, you, you listen to this madness from, from, from an awful lot of places. And you can't help, but think that, that people can't be that, that these people are getting advice and surely people are giving them advice. Like, you know, making the explanation such that they can, they can articulate them, like to, to, to, to, to, even if they don't understand the decision, they can articulate them to make people buy into these things. And then you have to question like, who are their advisors, are maybe their advisors, do maybe their advisors have vested interests in promoting certain, promoting certain angles? And is it maybe, and I suspect, I don't know anything about it, but I suspect that is a major part in this, that these, that these, these, these politicians and the, you know, the policymakers, I'm not calling them stupid. They're absolutely not stupid. They're at the top of their game and, and the, the political specialist and, and by being, by becoming a specialist in something, there's an opportunity cost. And their opportunity cost is that they maybe don't understand technical argument, arguments fine, because they need to know about an awful lot of issues, right? It's not just energy, but. Yeah. So, so they, so they're dependent on these advisors and they, and they lack the, they lack the, the technical context, even to judge if what they're, what they're hearing from their advisors is reasonable or not. And so they just take it from the advisors. They, they just, I don't know, they, they, what I think has happened is that I think they find that they, if they really don't know about a subject, they find an advisor with the high, with the most institutional credibility. And they just listen to what they say and they just do what they say and, and it just so happens that those institutions are going to be among the bigger institutions, the most successful institutions. And they are very much going to have interests that differ with the interests of the electorate. It is really what I think that's comes down to. Yeah.
[00:40:31] Speaker 1: I, I've kind of come to believe that too. And I'm not usually a believer in, uh, corruption at governmental levels, certainly not in the West. And, but in this case, the arguments make so little sense that I think there must be, there must be vested interests there. Are you talked a little bit in your article also about the kinds of financial incentives that people can have to invest in renewables. Can you talk a little bit more about how that, how that works?
[00:41:02] Speaker 2: So I think the biggest, I think the main driver for all this stuff, right? And, and, and again, I am, I am like you, I don't think of government corruption. And I don't think it's corruption. I think it's just markets doing what markets do. And it's just kind of, you know, it's just one of these, one of these things that we're, our systems are vulnerable to. But yeah, that's a good way of putting it. Yeah. Like there's nothing criminal here. I don't think. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:41:29] Speaker 1: Yeah.
[00:41:30] Speaker 2: Yeah. In terms of the, in what the main driver to all of this is, I am, I think absolutely is the ESG industry. And, and like, that sounds like we're getting, you know, people say ESG and it's a, it's like conspiracy theory, like tinfoil hat sort of stuff. But it's a real thing.
[00:41:46] Speaker 1: Tell people what ESG stands for. Okay.
[00:41:49] Speaker 2: So ESG is environmental and social governance. And basically, do you want to get a couple of, a minute or two minutes and I'll, and I'll explain what I think the mechanism is. Sure. And people can see whether I'm, you know, if, if what I'm saying is, is, is non, they can judge for themselves. So basically how it works is, is 10, 15 years ago, these big financial players, they, they, they started this ESG industry. So they gave the, ultimately they give points to companies and a score to companies based on how well the client, they comply with these environmental or social governance criteria. And so on the social side of things, the criteria are things like, like the ethnic diversity of, of the people in your advertising. And the, and the environmental side of things is, it's like the amount of, of electric cars you use in your fleet or, or your, how much you advocate for, for, for climate issues and environmental issues and your website and your, and your doc and your literature. And then your, and then your advertising. And so the, and, and like the reason that you want more points is because it's very lucrative. The, this, this industry is massive. It's like 30, 30 trillion dollars. Like it's a third of the entire stock stock market. More points mean more of that fund is allocated to your company. They buy more shares. Your share price increases. That's it. Like your share price increases and it can, it cascades all down, all down industry. So like if you're a big company, your suppliers or your clients will be smaller companies. But since your suppliers and your clients affect what your ESG rating is, you're going to give them quick, you're going to go check, you're going to give them checklists. You're going to say, you know, if you're a bank, if you're, you're a big bank, you're not, you're going to, it's going to be better for your ESG score to, to have more ESG compliant companies who are your customers. So you're going to give them better rates. So you're going to give them better rates for loans. If you're a big, you know, if you're a small company and you're supplying goods to a big company, you're going to get these checklists because the supplier rating affects the ESG rating of the, of the big company. And they're like, they're an easy sell. Like if you're a, if you're a, say you're a teacher's pension fund or a nurse's pension fund. It doesn't look good if you're investing in, um, like arms companies or, or, or I don't know, like tobacco companies, whatever, oil companies. So, so you put your money into these, these funds and it's sorted for you. But this year is like, it skews the, what I think the issue is, it skews the narrative, um, in the sense that one of the most effective things is in like the media and the media and companies reliant on advertising for their income. And so part, a large part of the ESG score is, is dependent on the context in which your advertising appears. So you're not going to advertise in, in media or publications that, that they will affect your score. So these publications that previously, that previously, um, that previously needed to get as many users or viewers or readers as possible, they now don't really care so much about the readers. Now what they care, and they need as many readers as possible because the more readers means the more demand for your, the more people are seeing the advertisements, which means more you can sell your advertisements for. Instead of doing that, the demand for the advertising comes from, from, from the, from the ESG rating. And so they'll do everything they can to maximize their, they're not going to publish anything that, that counter contradicts their, you know, that, that affects their ESG rating. And that's why all these media companies are saying, the mass media, they're saying the same thing. And so, and so the result is like, and you've got all these, like the public narrative is absolutely skewed towards these policies for the only reason that these policies are favored by this ESG industry, or sorry, these ESG ratings agencies. And the ESG ratings agencies, the ones that score these companies are owned by the big companies themselves. So they just, so it's just absolutely self-reinforcing. It's, it provides not only the, the one-sided narrative, um, but it also provides the financial incentives in the, in the, you know, we do this in order to get a bigger ESG. We buy this electricity because then we can get, we can show to our supplier that we're getting that, we're getting a higher ESG score and therefore our share price or, or the supplier is going to be more likely to use us or this customer is going to be more likely to use us as a supplier. So that was maybe a bit long winded, but that's what I think is absolutely driving all this. Absolutely.
[00:46:26] Speaker 1: I'm going to read a really short paragraph from your essay, because I think this describes what I mean when I talk about corruption, I guess. I don't mean government ministers taking kickbacks or something like that. That's, that's not going to happen in Australia. I'm pretty confident about that, but it's more about the skewed incentives. And the corruption is, is more in industry rather than in politics, but it has knock on effects everywhere. As you said, here's your description. Imagine you're managing a massive investment fund. Traditional industries, oil, automotive, manufacturing are stable, but provide only small returns, 8% annually. If you are lucky, then you notice something interesting. There are a host of green technology companies. They're not yet profitable. Maybe they're making electric cars that cost too much or solar panels that can't compete with coal. But unlike traditional companies whose success is unpredictable, these companies' success depends almost entirely on government policy. You can invest heavily in these companies while their stocks are cheap, then use your financial influence to push for policies that would make their products mandatory. This is not even that expensive. All it will take is a few strategic political donations, funding for friendly research institutes, aggressive PR campaigns about climate urgency. Maybe you can start a few environmental investment funds and write some stern letters to other companies about their carbon footprints. And suddenly magic happens. Governments start mandating electric vehicles. They ban gas heating in new homes. They require utilities to buy renewable energy. They create carbon credit markets out of thin air. They give people tax credits for buying your company's products. That's companies, plural, products. Now, those unprofitable companies you invested in are sitting on government mandated markets. Their stock prices soar. You point to these returns to attract more investor money, which gives you even more influence to push for more favorable policies. Traditional companies, seeing the writing on the wall, start investing in green technology too, often by buying from or partnering with your companies. Better yet, you've created a politically bulletproof position. Anyone who questions these policies can be dismissed as a climate denier. The environmental movement provides grassroots support. Yeah, so that kind of mechanism is what I mean by a cropton, a system full of skewed incentives. The reason that I'm focusing so much on how dependent we are on fossil fuels currently is not because I think fossil fuels are a good solution going forward. It's that I wish people would realize how fundamental the dependence is and therefore what kinds of unwanted impacts are going to come from just tinkering around the edges and thinking that this will help things and solve things. That we need to have systems that we need to have systems that will actually replace the things that fossil fuels are doing for us. And that's going to be even more the case as the third world is developing and people's lifestyles are improving in the third world, which is something we also want. And all of that kind of development and new technology and improvement in human flourishing comes from having reliable and good energy systems. And we had one in fossil fuels, which is no longer, you know, no longer the greatest system because of the impacts on climate and on environmental degradation. And also because fossil fuels are becoming more expensive and difficult to extract. but it won't be solved by putting a few solar panels on a roof. In fact, that's just going in the wrong in the wrong direction. Nuclear is the most promising thing we have at the moment. And meantime, we should be developing new things, but we can't just say, oh, those things will be ready in 10 years or in 20 years when we can't even see a pathway to how they will be ready as yet.
[00:51:06] Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly. I mean, yeah, and going back to like the stated urgency and climate change, like that's the words of the people promoting these policies and not, you know, like not necessarily me, but these solutions, they're not going to do anything. They're not going to do anything, you know, like, as the other moment, they're not going to do anything to combat climate change. I just think the whole thing is a bit of a con, I think it's a bit of a con.
[00:51:40] Speaker 1: Yeah, I tend to agree. Paul, is there anything we haven't covered that you think it would be important to cover or any other topics that we haven't discussed or things you wished I'd asked you?
[00:51:51] Speaker 2: No, no, no, the only thing I would say is like the China dependence. I think that's massive. I think that's absolutely gigantic. I think nobody's discussing it. The idea that we're buying this from China, it means we're going to be dependent on buying all that stuff from China. It's not like buying washing machines. This is energy costs. We buy it from China and we buy it from China because it's cheap and therefore we become dependent on them for our energy costs. And like, you know, we talk about the financial angles, but I think there's also an angle there. I'm not quite sure how they integrate, but I don't think you'd have to look very far to find some sort of Chinese involvement. You know, we're getting into more conspiracy theories here, but I really don't think you'd have to look far to see some Chinese involvement in like investing in Western environmental organisations. I'm not saying that's the main driver, but I think that is an element to all of this, all of this. And then, I don't know, it'll just be interesting how it all plays out. I mean, I'm quite confident that it is not, it's, it's, and despite the mandates for electric vehicles for 2035 that are getting pulled forward to 2030, I'm quite confident, I would put, I'm not a gambler, but I would put money on it, that that is not going to happen. That it's going to push back and push back and push back because there's just too much of this. It just does not make sense.
[00:53:14] Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the example of Germany is a, it should be a real, it should be a cautionary tale for us that they transition to renewables or greater reliance on renewables while closing down their nuclear power plants. So the worst possible situation, exactly what Australia also wants to do. And as a result, their emissions have gone up massively. Yeah. Their emissions are now like five times the emissions that France has. And they're also, they've also been relying on importing Russian gas and oil, a country with whom we are at war. That is just insane. That's insane.
[00:53:54] Speaker 2: That's insane.
[00:53:55] Speaker 1: That's insane. That's the last person we want to be dependent on.
[00:53:59] Speaker 2: Well, and then the second last person's China. Yeah. The nuclear thing you're talking about, that is a strange one in terms of climate change. Nuclear, like I'm on the, I'm definitely on the fence. I'm not one of these people who say, oh yeah, nuclear, nuclear, nuclear, like everything should be nuclear. I really don't. It has its downside. It needs to be like thought of, it needs to be, there's places where it's appropriate. There's times when it's not appropriate. But, you know, obviously the issue of nuclear is the potential for catastrophe. But given that this climate change stuff, it's, you know, there's a very low chance of, of catastrophe, catastrophe with nuclear. But there's a, you know, the government are telling us that there's a certain chance of catastrophe with global warming or climate change. Therefore, why are they shutting down nuclear everywhere? They shut down in Germany. They shut, they've just pulled 20 million or 20 billion, sorry, or 10 billion, some, an awful lot of money in the UK. Because from, from research or making these nuclear, you mentioned that they're wanting to pull it in, in Australia. That doesn't make sense.
[00:55:06] Speaker 1: Yeah. Well, in Australia, nuclear is not, is illegal. And in fact, weirdly, we have nuclear waste, but we don't have, so we actually have nuclear waste storage in Australia, but we don't have any nuclear energy. Apart from, we have, apart from a research reactor, there's one nuclear reactor in Australia, the research reactor here in Sydney at Lucas Heights. But this is going to be a subject of a, of a different podcast episode soon. Oh yeah, sorry. Yeah, of course. Yeah, no worries. It is clear. It's, to me, it's the obvious solution, at least for, for now. To me, it's the best solution we have for now. And new developments will also be coming in nuclear in the future, hopefully. So first thorium salt reactors, and then hopefully later at some stage fusion. But there is this kind of desperate rush to get rid of our dependence on fossil fuels without having thought out how we're going to replace this. Seems crazy to me.
[00:56:12] Speaker 2: Absolutely. I a hundred percent agree. It's the, the whole thing is just strange.
[00:56:17] Speaker 1: Paul, thank you so much for coming on this podcast and for having this somewhat frustrating conversation with me and for expressing things so very clearly. I would recommend everybody goes to read the article, which is probably a lot clearer in its technical, in the technical aspects than some parts of this conversation. And that's because I don't have the scientific background to necessarily ask the most pinpointed questions, but you are a fantastic writer, incredibly clear and methodical. So, um, I highly recommend people read the article and, uh, meanwhile, thanks so much for being here.
[00:57:00] Speaker 2: You know, thanks, and thanks for having me. And, and apologies if, if, if, during this, this podcast, I got a bit too technical or carried away in various things. I do find it difficult to communicate these things. No, no, no, it was great. It was great. But no, thanks.
[00:57:13] Speaker 1: No, it was great. It's just, there's even more in the article, which I think is, is good. Um, yeah, no, you're fantastic. Thank you so much.
[00:57:20] Speaker 2: No, no, thanks again. Thanks, Iona.