About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of COP31 Climate Hub - November 19 from We Don't Have Time, published November 20, 2026. The transcript contains 33,865 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"We are about to cross 1.5 degrees Celsius. The limit nearly every country promised to respect 10 years ago. But there is still some time. It all comes down to the decisions we make next. Live from Antalya, Turkey, the world's biggest climate summit. Cutting emissions, funding the transition,..."
[00:00:01] Speaker 1: We are about to cross 1.5 degrees Celsius. The limit nearly every country promised to respect 10 years ago. But there is still some time. It all comes down to the decisions we make next. Live from Antalya, Turkey, the world's biggest climate summit. Cutting emissions, funding the transition, protecting those already hit. 200 countries are deciding our future. We are taking you inside. Follow our COP31 broadcast on every We Don't Have Time platform.
[00:00:42] Speaker 2: Welcome to the We Don't Have Time Climate Hub here at COP31 in Turkey. I'm Nick Nuttel and this is our final day of broadcasting from here. And what a COP it has been. We will start and end this last day by talking about the conference from very different perspectives.
[00:01:02] Speaker 1: But like every morning we want to mention United for the Future. This is our biggest initiative ever and we're launching it in collaboration with the two rebel moms and scientists from the researchers desk. And this is a great endeavor really. United for the Future calls on people in every country to march for climate action on September 15, 2028. which is the International Day of Democracy. Our goal is 100 million people worldwide to join to get decision makers to act on science and to protect our future.
[00:01:36] Speaker 2: If you have not joined yet, then go to unitedforthefuture2028.org and sign up as one of the first 1,000 founders, a volunteer or an organization or maybe all three. And now let's get this last broadcast underway from our Climate Hub starting with our first session. What is going down at COP31? So we're now going to a session called What's going down at COP31? Some people would say what we would like is something to actually go up, but that's another way of looking at it. I've got some wonderful guests to talk about what is happening here right now with just a few days to go before the end of this conference. Hopefully, it's not going to drag on into the weekend. There's Cosima Cassell, Program Lead at E3G. Great to have you with us. We've got Katharina Safati, Managing Director, Political Strategy and Advocacy at the C40 Cities. And Ingmar Rentschog, the founder of We Don't Have Time and co-initiator of a new initiative called United for the Future, which we may hear a little bit more about. And you've got a badge actually that confirms you are indeed involved in this campaign. That's great. Cosima, you're closely following the negotiations. What can you tell us about it? Where are we right now? And is there any progress?
[00:03:00] Cosima Cassell: Yeah, thanks so much for having me and thanks so much for the question. Yeah, I mean, where are we right now? In this COP, there's three kind of pillars of action here. So there's one, the kind of negotiation space that has been set through the year and a number of agenda items there on finance, just transition, the mitigation work program, adaptation, response measures. There's also a cover decision, which is also a negotiated item, but this was tabled at pre-COP by the presidency and is now in the process of being refined. And then finally, the action agenda, where it's all the kind of wider real world action from, you know, coalitions of parties, but also kind of non-state actors, sub-nationals and others to go through them. And in the first on the negotiations. So we're seeing a lot of divides and a lot of difficulties coming to kind of substantial outcomes there at the moment. But in a lot of rooms, the finance is the biggest issue. And I think particularly in the finance rooms, we haven't seen much movement. We've seen a little bit more movement on topics such as just transition and mitigation on the technical aspects. But finance does come into these rooms and also adaptation as well. And the biggest fight here is also on adaptation finance. There was a goal that was agreed at COP30 to triple adaptation finance. But how to take that forward is the big question, which parties are looking to resolve at this COP. What is the baseline for that? There was no agreement on what that kind of what that tripling is from. So having a pathway forward to to to nail down a baseline will be an important outcome from this COP and we'll be looking for that. The major item, which is actually distracting quite a lot of attention from the other negotiation items, is the cover decision. And this is where a lot of a lot of parties wish lists are now on the table. The presidency released a version on Monday, which has 144 paragraphs, despite saying that they didn't want this to be a Christmas tree of every party's wish. It is currently a Christmas tree, but they're looking to kind of strip it down and yeah, and kind of boil it down to what are the kind of fundamental things that parties can agree. We're expecting another version today. And the question is what stays in there? A lot of the kind of progressive parties, the small island states, Europe and some others are really pushing for strong language on overshoots, defending the science, which has been under attack at this COP. We really important to see how that comes through the finance. Obviously, that is going to be a big issue. What is the forward pathway there? And yeah, and also kind of what how the action agenda is captured in this decision will also be important. We're living in this era of implementation and the second pillar of COPS is rising in relevance. So is this going to be be covered there? And how will the pathway forward on GST2 with the global stocktake? The global stocktake, yeah. Kickoff today is important as well, as well as how the big, big thing which Turkey is focusing on is electrification and how that shows up in the cover decision. And if it's linked to transitioning away from fossil fuels, this will be a big fight and probably difficult to land given current geopolitical dynamics. But there's some things that we will be watching.
[00:06:21] Speaker 2: Right. We'll come back to you on all this because it's absolutely massive what you just tried to get through. And yours was like a marathon decision there to get through. We'll come back and just try and unpick it a little bit. Tell me, Katerina, climate resilience cities are part of the action agenda. So we heard there were three, you might say, streams, the action agenda where real life things are supposed to happen. And this was established by the Turkish presidency, climate resilient cities. This is, I presume, action in terms of building adaptation, building resilience in cities. Yeah. How does that play out at this COP and in the negotiations?
[00:06:58] Speaker 4: Yeah, the action agenda is also in particular thanks to the COP30 presidency, the Brazilian presidency's work, is becoming gradually the new cool kid on the block. There's more attention to it. For the first time, like I've been to several COPs for the first time, media is asking me about the action agenda, which is a signal. So it's definitely getting traction because I guess given the polarization of the world, like the fact that negotiations are stuck, that you don't really understand what's getting in and what's coming out. Actually, the fact of having coalitions of the willing that come together even without full consensus, without all of the national governments agreeing, gives a good sort of push to implementation and action. For example, at C40Cities, we have an initiative that is also picking up, which is the yearly offer of action. So mayors are coming to COP since last year, not saying what they will be doing in 2030, what they will be doing in 2050, but what they have done in the past 12 months and what they will be doing in the next 12 months. Saying year on year action is possible. And if we do it, also others can do it. Last year it was 40 cities coming with their yearly offer of action. This year it's 70, so nearly doubling up. And this is a coalition of the willing pushing for action. Similar coalition of the willing was launched in COP28, the CHAMP coalition, a coalition of national governments coming together saying, we want our NDCs to be more urban, to be more local, to be more implementable. And that made NDCs more fit for purpose for the local level, which also make make them more action oriented. But at a certain point, all of this like action and mobilization needs to flow into the negotiations. So for example, in this cover tree, in this Christmas tree, sorry, cover trees is a good crisis. In the Christmas tree cover decision for the first time, we are seeing very interesting recognition of the work of cities. We're seeing language on the need for direct access of finance to cities. We're seeing language around the need to have good multilevel partnerships between national governments and cities on action. It's a bit the retain hunger games in this moment. So everybody's fighting to have their language stick. And we're hoping to see this type of recognition stick because again, in the real world, in the real economy, mayors are taking action on a regular basis. And it's about time that the COP decisions fully embeds this type of action in view of the global stock take. We're already doing our local stock take. We want it to be part of the global one.
[00:09:47] Speaker 2: Just to say before I come to Ingmar is what appears to be happening in the COP process is that the action agenda is a place where those that want to act can act. And those that don't want to act go somewhere else. Right. In other words, it's like a new sense of it's not consensus, it's action, decision making. Let's move on. Maybe nobody, nobody else comes with us. Oh, no, 25 other countries come with us or 30 other cities come with us. In other words, come with me sort of initiatives. Right. And a bit like the Santa Marta process where the nations that want to get off fossil fuels say, well, not everybody wants to do that, but we want to do it. We're going to go and do it. And then it comes back to the COP. Everyone reports on it. And then they go off and do what they do again and come back again and report on it. It's a different atmosphere, isn't it? To what we used to have.
[00:10:39] Speaker 4: Yeah. In some cases, and you know, we were together in Santa Marta, we saw it. In some cases, the fact that you don't need to negotiate. So you don't have parties on one side negotiating, observers and so civil society and cities advocating to be put in, to be recognized, but actually a common space to discuss the challenges, the opportunities. It's actually useful. But then at a certain point, it needs to be recognized with full consensus if you want to make it part of the political governance of the transition. Okay.
[00:11:12] Speaker 2: Let's come back to this because I like the idea that maybe 150 countries could change the world rather than waiting for the other 40 to join in. But that's another thought. Ingmar, you're doing many things here, but we don't have time has with others and launched a new initiative called United for the Future. What's that about? And why should everyone be interested? Should everyone be interested?
[00:11:35] Speaker 5: I mean, we're running out of time. So things are moving, but it's moving very slowly. And some of those things you mentioned in this Christmas tree have already been decided. For example, there is a big thing going on here, 45% electrification target. Should it be with fossil fuel or not fossil fuel? But what the world seems to have forgot, we already decided to triple renewables and double energy efficiency. And that's the exact same thing. It's a little bit insanity to celebrate and even negotiate something that is already negotiated. It's just another language to it. And I heard both of you were talking about language, but language will not solve the climate crisis. We need action and languages are important way in legal text. Unfortunately, the Paris Agreement needs to also be, you know, followed legally. And we see that in countries like Norway, when the Supreme Court actually have decided that new oil expansion needs to be evaluated for scope 3. Now we're talking, but we need this globally. So what is United for Future all about? It's all about that we want action. We want more action. And we need regulation. And if people are not engaging in this, we are getting less action from legislation. We are getting weaker outcomes from meetings like this. So we need to show that the majority wants more climate action. And there's global studies saying that up to 89% of the people want stronger climate action. The same study also says that most people that want stronger climate action thinks that others don't want it. So we need to make the majority visible for the leaders, but also for us, for ourselves. So United for the Future is getting as many people as possible out in the street. And 15 September 2028, so two years from now, it takes time to mobilize the world's largest climate demonstration. We want at least 100 million people on the street. And we are here to rally support. And people that are advocating for change, for Paris Agreement. We have people like Christiana Figueres, Bill McKibben, scientists like Johan Rockström. They are all in for this. Because if we don't get people engagement, we will not get regulation enough. And the reason we initiated this is not only the fact that we are progressing too slow. We are actually right now going in the wrong direction. This year, and the 12 months period leading up to this meeting, we have seen 45 cancelled or weakened climate policy worldwide. In European Union, in USA, in Canada, in Sweden, in many, many countries all over the world. Because people have left the room and lobbyists are entering it instead. So people need to take back the public space. And I believe that when we do that, that will change things.
[00:15:08] Speaker 2: I mean, social media is good, but showing your face maybe is better. And, I mean, you need both. But you need to see the physical presence of people on the street saying, in a peaceful way, we don't want a violent demonstration, but in a peaceful way coming out and saying, we want this government, you do it. And we mentioned this, or I mentioned this to the COP30 president who had a press conference. I said, what do you think about this campaign? And he paused for a while and he said, no, absolutely. You know, we need to see people out there. Governments know when there are people on the streets. They know that's what they want. He said, it's absolutely clear that this is a, you know, I welcome this campaign. It's something Brazil welcomes. Yeah.
[00:15:46] Speaker 4: And I think the youth, the Gen Z is actually showing it like all over in Serbia. It was students gaining power all over Europe. There is peaceful demonstrations. In India, there's demonstrations in the US. There has been demonstrations. And I think what they're showing for the first time is that the battle for the end of the month has never been so close to the battle for the end of the world. The two are really, really in the fact.
[00:16:15] Speaker 2: The battle for the end of the month being the ability to pay your bills by the end of the month.
[00:16:18] Speaker 4: The ability to pay your bills, the ability to not, to not have to choose between heating your home and putting food on the table is very, is gradually getting closer and closer to the battle for saving the world. Because now like renewables are making energy cheaper. Gas is making bills much higher. Energy efficiency is an issue of energy poverty. Housing and the cost of living is a climate policy. The two are very, very much connected, but not yet in the public debate. And I think the youth demonstrations are really showing this because they're fighting for both. Tell me something.
[00:16:54] Speaker 2: I mean, I know we're sounding like activists. Well, we are activists. I think we're all activists, right? That sometimes that's used as a derisory term. We all care about what happens to our world and we want things to be better. Do you think that in the negotiating rooms that governments, I mean, they're quite polite with each other? But there always comes a moment, I think, when some governments say that's enough. We've had enough, right? We saw that at the end of COP28. And when nations said, no, we need to exit from fossil fuels. Don't play with that language, right? So even governments can be passionate sometimes about what they're doing. Do you find this sometimes?
[00:17:31] Cosima Cassell: Yes, absolutely. I think there's a lot of governments that are really passionate about climate action and also this process. And we want this process to work. Basically, this is the only process that has every party at the table. Every party has a voice. And this is why it's so important. With the Paris Agreement, we've set the direction to 1.5. Yes, we are off track, but we have made huge reductions in emissions and changed that pathway to bring it down to around 2.6 from over 4 before the Paris Agreement in terms of degrees warming. It's not enough. We need to go further. We're living through a very difficult geopolitical moment at the moment. And this is influencing what happens in negotiation rooms. This is influencing what is getting stuck. But we're also entering this era of implementation. And this is why, as we've talked about, the action agenda is becoming so much more elevated and important within the COP space. There's governments and parties who want to do things and are taking things forward and driving this. This is a change that would have needed to have happened, whether or not the geopolitics was favorable or not, because this is now the time to get things done. We're seeing that happening, even if things are difficult.
[00:18:43] Speaker 2: I was in Paris. Maybe you were in Paris. You were probably watching Paris, Ingmar. I mean, there were two temperature targets, weren't there? In fact, I walked through the corridors the other day. I heard a journalist asking a person, was 1.5 just a kind of something people plucked from the stars? You know, I thought I nearly stopped to turn around and say, no, actually, there's a bit of science behind that. But anyway, I just had to get to go somewhere else. But I hadn't got time. No, no, we didn't have time. And but it was interesting because at Paris and during Paris and when Paris ended, it was very clear that it was well below two. And the 1.5 was obviously something that was put there really importantly for the security of the small island states. Right. But then very quickly metamorphosed into 1.5 is the target. And that's overshot now. But did we maybe make a rod for our own backs? You know, in other words, make it harder for us by totally embracing the 1.5 and not just into well below two, because well below two can mean 1.5. Sorry, it's a nuance, but I think politically it's quite important. Ingmar, what do you think?
[00:19:54] Cosima Cassell: Yeah, I'll just jump in on that. I mean, I just say the science is not negotiable. Like at 1.5, we're already seeing impacts, right? Every fraction of degree over 1.5 will mean those impacts are getting worse and intensify. Yes, we will overshoot 1.5. The UNEP overshoot report says that is unavoidable now. But the question now is for how long and how big that overshoot is. And that is what we really need to battle for because, yeah, as I said, every degree, every fraction of a degree matters. And for small island states, just getting back under that by the end of the century is essential for their survival, even though the impacts will continue to...
[00:20:29] Speaker 2: I suppose the question was, did we know that 1.5 was almost impossible when it was put in there in Paris? We knew we had to get below two, and that was always the conversation. And did we, did we, I don't know, did we not make a mistake, but did we realize that that was a really, really, really heavy lift, right? Sorry, I'm just asking that question.
[00:20:56] Speaker 4: 1.5 is the fundamental political goal. Like mayors were, by the way, some of the first constituencies that after the Paris Agreement in 2016 came forward saying we want to develop plans that are consistent with 1.5. Not with well below two, not with the Paris Agreement. And also we have to go back to 1.5. That's what the UNSG told us, you know, in his last COP. It's not just, it's not just about avoiding that overshoot becomes too big, but it's about coming back to 1.5 to avoid the worst consequences and the worst feedback loops. So the, and, and everything is impossible until you do it. And having, you know, having plans that stick to the goal of 1.5, I think is really still very, very much critical because we don't have to lose it as part of our broader political and scientific goal in order for us to come back to it.
[00:21:48] Speaker 5: Yeah. Okay. Claire. I mean, if, if 1.5 is the kind of safe limit by science, what it is, I mean, going beyond that is, is not only having big consequences, it's also a big risk. Because we don't know where those tipping points are actually being triggered. Mm. And if we trigger them, there is no way back. Uh, we, maybe we have triggered some, we don't know. We just need, it's like smoking. We know that we, we, we have a cancer now. And if we continue to smoke, that cancer will kill us. But if we get off it, we, an overshoot, we might survive. Mm. That's where we are. Um, and, uh, I think we should have my, maybe a goal one degree because you're always failing your targets. You need to have targets that you can fail. So if we fail on 1.5 degree, which we have, we will fail on two degrees. If we continue this circus, we need to think very differently. And, uh, Santa Marta is a way of thinking very differently. Uh, but the problem with Santa Marta or the challenge, I will say, uh, is that we need to turn Santa Marta into a binding agreement. Uh, but I think, actually, I think it's time to be a little bit honest here. We, it's important the world meets. Yes. We, we need people and countries that don't agree to meet and discuss things, but the discussion must be based in reality. We should be more focusing on this latest science so people understand what's at stake. And I'm missing that a little bit here at this meeting. We're talking about details and Christmas trees when we should talk about the future of humanity. Uh, I mean, this is a UN, uh, this should be like the Security Council level. Uh, why don't the Security Council have a room here and try to figure out how to make humanity survive? We need to get this discussion back to where it belongs. And that's where I think United for the future can play a role. We, by giving the legacy, legatimate to that discussion, that, that scale. I mean, this is a survival thing. This is not like a small thing happening on the sidelines. It's the, it's our future. It's the center of the future of the world. In our lifetime. Not in our children's lifetime. In my lifetime. I mean, sure, maybe we survive, but it's life about surviving or is it about thriving? Uh, so that's where I see the people needs to raise the voices. Everyone needs to raise the voices.
[00:24:33] Speaker 2: How do the cities respond to what governments do? Because I mean, the cities, you've got a wonderful system in C40, right? People don't meet their targets. Eventually they're kicked out of the club, right? I mean, you know, so here there are certain countries that would be kicked out of the club if they were part of the C40 process, right? But it's the UN. So everybody's allowed in. Um, I know I used to work for the UN for 17 years. Um, so, but what do the, do the cities lobby their own government? Say we need more action. We need better, stronger action from you at the central government. So that it's easy for us as cities to actually meet our targets. And you are actually in most cases meeting your targets, if not exceeding them, right? That's a positive thing we need to remember. Yeah.
[00:25:11] Speaker 4: Three out of four cities in C40 are reducing per capita emissions faster than their national governments. Um, we have a collective commitment to halve fossil fuel used by 2030. It's not a small task. Um, we are reviewing all the climate action plans of cities through a, through a lens and a framework that is consistent with the UNSG initiative on fossil fuel phase out. So our climate action plans are gradually becoming fossil fuel exit roadmaps. Um, uh, we are, have a commitment to have climate budgets for all cities by 2030, which means all bits of the government of the cities, um, have to look at their financials and their budget from a climate perspective, not just a financial one. Uh, we have pretty, pretty high standards. And as you said, if cities don't meet them, the steering committee decides that they have to, they have to become inactive, get a little bit more support. And if they still don't meet them, then they're, they're kicked off. They're kicked off.
[00:26:10] Speaker 2: Another kind of exit strategy as opposed to exiting fossil fuels.
[00:26:13] Speaker 4: Yeah. An equitable transition away from, from C40.
[00:26:16] Speaker 2: An equitable transition away from C40. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:26:22] Speaker 4: Yeah. Yeah. But, but, but because exactly what you were saying, because that is the type of ambition and action we need. I would say I have a little bit more of, um, of, um, uh, positive view, I guess, of cops. I don't think cops are the game. I think cops are the scoreboards. Like the action happens elsewhere. And then here you come to see where you are, right? Like how many, how many goals you have scored, uh, how many, uh, self goals you have auto, auto scored. Um, and you give signals, you know, to the, to the market, to the world on, on, on, on, on, what are the trends or what is happening or you really need to focus on. But we shouldn't consider cop for now, at least, uh, with this polarized world and with, with this conflict being the actual game. The actual game happens in the streets of our cities, happens through local governments, happens through businesses, happens, happens all the time. Uh, what we need national governments is to, is to conceive everything that is going on in the real economy as allies and not counterparts. Um, we're not here, you know, to ask for more money and ask for more recognition. We're here to help, to help delivery, to help implementation, to help convening workers, communities. Um, that's, that's, I think that's a little bit what cop is about.
[00:27:35] Speaker 2: Ingmar, do you want to create a quick thing? Then we go over here straight to Cosimo.
[00:27:39] Speaker 5: I think cities is very interesting. Uh, and if we go to the history where I came from, Sweden, we actually have a pact between cities that was more powerful than countries. we call the Hansa City Pact, uh, where cities were coming together, forming an alliance legally. Uh, it was like a European Union for cities. Uh, and I think that, uh, maybe we need a legal, that C40, not just as a club for voluntarily climate action, that it actually become, some kind of legal pact or something. But I want to say something else. Um, and that's, I think it's very important that we meet. But I see a big risk with the, the COP meetings right now. Because when I talk to people outside the climate movement, uh, the space or climate, they, they are laughing at us. They see this as insanity. They see that a hundred thousand people are going somewhere negotiating something. they never are able to negotiate that scale, just details. And they are like, the world are meeting and failing every single year. That is only framing a failure. So I think we need to get other expectation and outcomes from these meetings. Like here you have, how many citizens see 40, for example? Is it 40? No, no. No, it's a hundred. It's exactly. Why it's named 40? It was 40 from the beginning. Another story. Another story.
[00:29:09] Speaker 2: Anyway. I think Bloomberg was 40 years old. No, maybe it was the England, uh, London man. Okay. Off topic.
[00:29:15] Speaker 5: But my point here, there's a lot of, uh, hopeful stories with real action, uh, with alliances forming from those meetings outside this meeting and coming here back to report. I want that to take more central stage. People need to know that hundred cities are actually doing it. What we need to do, what countries are not doing beyond, uh, that's fantastic. That is the stories we need to get out of here and spend more time on. And that's why I want people on the street to push 2,000 cities, 10,000 cities. I think it's possible.
[00:29:52] Speaker 2: Cosima, sorry. We've been ignoring you and I didn't mean to. Sorry.
[00:29:56] Cosima Cassell: Yeah, no worries at all. Um, but yeah, I mean, I completely agree. I think we're, as I said, we're at this period where cops are in transition. The negotiations aren't the sole story anymore. There is this whole action agenda and it's becoming, you know, I think last year the Brazilians did an amazing job of having this, the structure under the six axes, which is also linked to the, what as negotiated outcome was the global stock take, um, from, um, uh, from 2023. And this, this structure, um, is now kind of, you know, in a, in a period of transition. And we're seeing, um, you know, like the yearbook from the action agenda that was published at the beginning of COP, it will be updated and republished, uh, this, this, maybe today, or when, when the, I think tomorrow, the, the, the final closing plenary of the action agenda is. And watch, watch out for that, because that will be a moment where a lot of the work, a lot of the, uh, announcements that have come out from this real world action, this, this, these last two weeks, these last two weeks and all the work that's culminated over the course of the year will be shown. There's just been agreement released yesterday between the heads of the different climate weeks, um, saying how they're going to align the climate weeks with the action agenda, six axes to build the story of this is the progress that's happening under the six axes, not just at COP, but through the year. And then COP is the moment to kind of take stock and, and, and, um, and see what's happening. And, you know, yesterday was a big day for the action agenda. There was a lot of countries signing up to the electrification pledge. I think we're over 60 countries are now signed up to that pledge. Um, a number of countries released their own, uh, transitioning away from fossil fuels roadmaps. There's a lot of energy happening here. Um, and I think the media is also kind of in a transition from focusing just on the negotiations, because that's been historically what's the focus has been. But we have negotiated the Paris rule book. Um, there's still stuff to negotiate and we still need further action. And we're not on target and we need to have those conversations, but there needs to be more focus also on all the stuff that's already happening, because we've set those conditions in place. Um, and the economics is going in.
[00:31:51] Speaker 2: I mean, I, I mean, you know, there was one announcement last week, which was, um, a deal between Turkey and China. Was it 15 or 16 billion on investment in renewable energy in Turkey? I mean, it kind of just disappeared in two seconds, but it's there, right? And it's hard to capture all this. I see yesterday somebody offered, somebody, some countries gave 20 million to the, the, um, the cool coalition of UNEP for the cooling agenda, right? 20, 20 million. It's not a lot, but it's, it's, it's, there are a lot of these little purses of money flying around right now for certain things that people think are important. So trying to capture it all is, is the nightmare. But I think we've got a new, slightly different perspective of the cop from this conversation. Uh, in mind, maybe this is something cause, uh, our, we're going to have a discussion later today with some people about what is the future of the cops. And I think you've helped maybe just think about this for us as well. That's so thank you very much indeed. Um, you don't have an enviable job because you're following the negotiations. Do you think you're going home Friday night or do you think you might be staying a little bit longer?
[00:32:52] Cosima Cassell: I suspect I might still be here on Saturday. Okay.
[00:32:55] Speaker 2: Best of luck then. Okay. Thank you very much indeed, everybody. So welcome to, we don't have times climate hub here at cop 31 in Antalya in Turkey. I'm Nick Nuttall and I'm one of the co-presenters of we don't have time. Our next session is called future proofing connectivity. Decarbonizing mobile networks for a cleaner climate resilient future. Now we know mobile networks underpin our daily lives, but, uh, and they also are part of cutting emissions and they're doing a really good job, but they also have to be reliable through storms and floods and heat waves and all the other impacts that are coming actually from climate change. How do we keep people connected in these difficult times? Joining me is Steven Moore. Hello, Steven. Hi. Hi. Good. Head of climate action at GSMA. And Steven will set the scene and then lead our panel discussion with voices from Vodafone, Cisco and the carbon trust in the UK. Steven, please take us through the industry's progress towards net zero first and the growing physical risks to mobile networks. Steven Moore: Thank you very much, Nick.
[00:34:14] Speaker 6: Um, yeah, it's fantastic to be here at cop to talk about the progress of the industry. We have an ambition to be net zero by 2050. So that's in line with limiting global heating to 1.5 degrees. And there's a lot of progress that's happening across the industry towards this goal. So we have more than 80 mobile network operators all around the world that have committed to reduce their emissions in line with this net zero by 2050 target. Um, and we're already starting to see progress in that direction. So we've had a reduction of around 13% of carbon emissions since 2020. Um, we're not quite on track to where we need to be by 2030, but we are seeing some positive acceleration in that direction. Um, one of the highlights that we've seen is the, uh, quite significant uptake in renewable electricity. So electricity, we use quite a lot of to power all the networks that support the connectivity that you and I use every day and everyone around the world. Um, and we have seen that, uh, the latest figures we have around a quarter of the electricity that we're using globally is renewable. Uh, that's in addition to renewables that are already on the grid. So, um, there's lots as well that we're seeing around energy efficiency to improve the energy efficiency of networks. We're starting to see new technologies as well, like AI being deployed to support that. Um, on the flip side of it, we are an infrastructure business as well. So we're also subject to the changing climate and more extreme weather events. Um, we're already seeing that there's quite significant damage that's happening to networks, uh, to mobile masks, for example, every single year. Um, and we just did a piece of research looking at what is likely to happen by mid-century in terms of the increases in extreme weather. On networks and the results were quite, uh, striking. So we expect to see an almost doubling of impacts of extreme weather. Uh, that's an 80% increase. Um, this will take annual damage potentially up to about $3 billion per year. So really significant figure. Um, and this will be primarily from, uh, more extreme storms. So higher wind speeds affecting things like mobile masts and then also from flooding. So that's from, uh, rivers and also from coastal flooding as well. Um, so, uh, we're seeing in response to this, a lot of resilience measures being put in place as well by network operators. So how can we harden networks? How can we strengthen them? Uh, anticipating these more extreme effects from, um, from the climate changes we expect to see.
[00:37:05] Speaker 2: And how, how can we put pressure on governments to actually meet their promises under the Paris climate agreement to keep us, uh, well, now we've overshot 1.5, but keep us well below two degrees and get back to 1.5. Yeah, absolutely. Okay, good. I'm going to hand the show over to you, uh, Steven. Uh, thanks very much indeed. And, um, yeah, best of luck. I'll be back later. Yeah.
[00:37:28] Speaker 6: Thanks so much, Nick. So it's great to be here to be joined by our panelists from Vodafone from Cisco and from the Carbon Trust. And I'd like to start by coming to you, Andrea. So your group environment lead at Vodafone, and I'd love to understand from Vodafone's point of view, you have networks across Europe, the Middle East, across Africa. Um, I was talking there before about extreme weather impacting networks. What are you seeing from Vodafone's point of view? How is that perhaps already impacting networks across different countries? Thanks, Steven.
[00:38:04] Speaker 7: So yeah, I think, um, we're already starting to see the impacts of climate change across our networks. So for example, um, we're seeing more floods, um, across Europe, more storms. Um, in our African business, we see repeated cyclones. Um, for example, um, now in Mozambique, they're experiencing quite severe cyclones, um, every year. Um, and, uh, that is affecting our customers and our ability to, um, uh, keep the network running because I think connectivity is absolutely a lifeline. Um, for people in those kinds of disaster situations when you want to make sure that your loved ones are safe. Um, and you need to contact, um, uh, the authorities for support. Um, so I think super important that we, um, continue to build resilience into our network infrastructure. Um, and one of the ways that we're doing that is thinking about, um, our dependency and our interactions with the energy, um, the energy network. So our base stations often rely on electricity grids, um, and sometimes they can also be affected, um, by these climate related events. So we've been looking at how we can identify particularly critical sites, for example, in Europe, um, and put in additional, um, battery backup at those sites. So that, um, they are increasingly more resilient, um, when the power grid goes down. Um, so I think, um, yeah, like I, that many, many different measures that we can take, um, uh, to help with both prediction, preparation, uh, response and recovery, um, in these types of climate related events.
[00:39:36] Speaker 6: Fantastic. Thanks so much, Andrea. Um, really good to hear that Vodafone is approaching this, uh, as a, as a system problem, a systemic problem, uh, not just within your own infrastructure, but obviously how that's impacted by other parts of the infrastructure like energy. Uh, and then I perhaps come to, to Colin next, um, to Colin, your chief sustainability officer at Cisco. You're obviously, Cisco's obviously a really key part of the infrastructure that sits behind a lot of this. Uh, that acts, um, to connect the connectivity. Um, so I'd really love to understand picking up on this issue of risk, particularly in your supply chain. So what are you seeing around physical and transition risk to your supply chain? And maybe also how are you responding in terms of the technology that Cisco can provide to support reducing emissions and then also support resilience? Quite a big question.
[00:40:31] Speaker 8: Yeah, you're right. It is a big question. So we sit in the middle of the supply chain. So we have a lot of manufacturers and suppliers on one side, and then we have a lot of customers like the telecom industry on, on the other side. And within that, as you said, we're looking at those dual challenges. How do you reduce emissions? And then how do you make sure things are resilient? So with our manufacturers and suppliers, um, we'll look at how we can do reduction in emissions through getting more recycled content, getting clean energy into the manufacturing locations. And then we'll also look at the risk, both the physical risk and also the transition risks. So with the physical risks, we look at acute problems like, uh, weather flooding or, uh, large, you know, wind or things like that. As Andre's already mentioned. And then we'll also look at chronic things like changes in temperature. So extreme heat or drought. And we'll look at that across our, our suppliers and manufacturers. And then we document that, uh, every couple of years. And we, we look at what we can do to mitigate that. And then as we go out to customers, we look at the customers and what challenges they have. And we try to work out, uh, how do we help them to build more resilient systems? So on the one hand with our manufacturers and suppliers, we're working at the individual box level. How do we reduce the footprint of one box? We know that for our, our customers, they're using lots and lots of boxes. So how do we get those to work more effectively as a whole in a system? How do we get the measurements out of that? How do we build the right levels of redundancy into that? And sometimes how do we make that industrial type of equipment that can survive again? The, the heat, the wind and the environmental challenges they have within their own networks.
[00:42:17] Speaker 6: Yeah. Thanks very much, Colin. Um, picking up on that point on, I guess, how do you build this resilience into the technology that you deploy and maybe coming back to you, Andrea, uh, just to pick up on that and, and build on the points that you were making before. So it'd be really good to understand how Vodafone is making your networks more resilient. But then also I know that you have very, uh, strong ambitions about reducing your own emissions and reaching net zero actually faster than the 2050 target that we have for the industry. So could you talk a little bit about that?
[00:42:50] Speaker 7: Yeah. When it comes to both decarbonizing the network and also building in resilience, we have to plan for both. So at Vodafone, as you said, we've got a net zero target by, um, 2040. Um, we're looking to decarbonize both our network infrastructure, um, and also our supply chain working together with suppliers, um, like Cisco. Um, and, um, in order to do that, um, we are looking at energy efficiency. So, um, uh, that includes 65% more, um, uh, efficiency in terms of the data that we are able to transfer. So for each unit of data, um, we use about 65% less energy than we did in 2020. Um, we're also matching 100% of the grid electricity that we use with renewable sources, something that, um, as you said, there's been great progress on across the industry, um, over recent years. Um, and I think that's, that's where we really started to see those emissions coming down. Um, 85% reduction in our scope one and two emissions since 2020 for our own operations, um, which is really great to see. But I think the next challenge for us will be how do we decouple the growth in emissions, um, from the growth and expansion of our networks, which is absolutely critical for, um, digital inclusion and bringing the internet to more people. Um, and when we're doing that, we also need to, to build our networks with resilience in mind for a change in climate. Again, by looking at, um, backing up, uh, batteries and making sure that we've got enough redundancy, um, but making sure that the structures that our equipment sits on is, are strong enough to withstand climate related events. Fantastic.
[00:44:24] Speaker 6: Yeah. Thank you. That sounds like quite a comprehensive set of measures, uh, challenges, and also changes that are happening across, um, Vodafone. And I understand that a lot of these measures being brought together under climate transition plans that companies are developing like Vodafone, like Cisco. And I wanted to bring in Antoinette, uh, now. So Antoinette is, uh, a specialist consultant at the Carbon Trust, uh, as part of their ICT practice, uh, Antoinette, um, thinking about climate transition plans, thinking about the work that the Carbon Trust has been doing to support companies, um, with building the business case for some of the measures that Antoinette, um, sorry, that Andrea and, uh, um, Colin were just talking about. Um, could you tell us, how do you, where do you start when you're starting to develop the business case in this space and what should companies focus on? Thanks, Steven.
[00:45:16] Speaker 9: Um, so we definitely see seeing companies moving from strategy to implementation, which is a strong focus at the moment. So building a strong business case is really key to do that and to move to the implementation. And the other thing as well is there are various priorities within companies for, for capital and for other resources as well. So your business case really needs to be robust and strong. Yeah. So on the mitigation side, um, there are many carbon reduction measures that already do have a good business case behind it. And definitely we would encourage, um, companies out there to really start with those that will result in a net saving overall, but then also supporting to reduce your emissions. And, but then also together with that, there are also many carbon reduction measures that will also help companies to put controls in place against transition risks and really help to support business resilience against disruptions and future changes as well. So by not only highlighting the financial side of it, and also not only highlighting the carbon reduction side of it, it's really also important to also demonstrate how it can help the business business to become more resilient, how it can reduce risk. Um, and we have been doing a lot of work on, uh, on that. Um, and, uh, we've also collaborated with the GSMI earlier this year, where we've developed a bit of a guidance and a handbook. It really includes quite a lot of details in terms of how businesses can do that. Thank you so much, Antoinette.
[00:46:54] Speaker 6: Yeah, it was fantastic to collaborate with you and the carbon trust on, uh, on building that guidance. And I wanted to, um, think now about how we go about delivering some of the changes that we see and what we should prioritize. Um, and Colin, maybe I could come to you first here because there are, um, technologies that we can put in place. There are policies that we can get from governments. There's financing, sustainable financing. There's innovation that we can deploy. Um, what, from your point of view in Cisco, what are you prioritizing? What are you really focusing on to help deliver these cleaner, more resilient networks?
[00:47:36] Speaker 8: I think one of the key things has come out already from this conversation is that, that partnership, that deep collaboration. Uh, so from the Cisco side, we can bring expertise in our technology, but what we really need from the telecom side is the expertise in the problem we're trying to solve. Uh, that means a really deep collaboration. So you get away from just having PowerPoints to actually getting the practical implementation, understanding what, what, how it works in the field, what the skills are to support it. If there's any policy changes that are needed, how do you actually make something that's, that solves a real problem can solve in a way that is scalable, affordable, that can actually have some proven results coming out of it.
[00:48:19] Speaker 6: Fantastic.
[00:48:20] Speaker ?: Thank you.
[00:48:20] Speaker 6: I think we can all get behind getting off PowerPoint, moving more towards the implementation. Uh, Andrea coming to you and maybe picking up on that same question. What are you, um, looking at prioritizing or focusing on from Vodafone's point of view to help kind of accelerate these positive changes? Yeah.
[00:48:38] Speaker 7: So for us, I think it's really about trying to build in resilience to the network, um, really listening to communities and understanding what they need, um, in the moments when, um, when it really matters to have connection. Um, uh, I think, uh, preparedness is one aspect of it. So making sure that, um, resilience is part of our business as usual when we're planning the network. Um, but then when that disaster strikes, um, uh, looking at how are we working together with governments to get messages out, um, to communities. Um, for example, we've collaborated, um, with the government in Germany, um, on, uh, establishing that initial cell broadcast system that helped, um, provide messages to people ahead of the, uh, Valley floods, um, back in 2021. And now cell broadcast is, um, much more widespread across Europe. Um, but we could still do more across some of our other markets. For example, in Africa, how can we, um, feed into early warning systems there, um, working together, um, with government and, and really strengthening that infrastructure. So I think, yeah, early warning systems, working resilience into network infrastructure, both big priorities for us. Um, and then, um, on the philanthropic side, we're also supporting in response to floods. Um, so for example, in Albania, we've been running simulations together with our Vodafone Foundation team, looking at instant network and how we can bring back emergency connectivity, um, and rehearse that ahead of time with the government, with local partners and local NGOs, so that we're prepared when that disaster happens.
[00:50:12] Speaker 6: Fantastic. Yeah. It's all about preparedness, isn't it? Um, for the, some events that we expect, but there are many that we don't expect as well. Uh, and you mentioned that early warning systems, um, which is also so crucial. And, uh, you know, we know that there's ambition for everyone to be covered by an early warning system, every country, but I think we're only about halfway there in terms of countries. There's still quite a bit further to go. Uh, thanks very much, Andrea. Coming to you, Antoinette, uh, really with this same question from your point of view, um, from where you sit as a consultant working with many of these companies across the sector, what do you see maybe as being important for them to prioritize or for you to prioritize from carbon trust point of view?
[00:50:58] Speaker 9: Yeah. So I think, um, definitely agree with what Andrea said. Um, when disaster happens, when you see, have storms flooding, um, it not only impacts the infrastructure of the telcos as well, but also the communities around it as well. And during that time, they need to rely on connectivity in that time to be able to deploy their disaster management. So really important to be able to have more resilient networks, really working close to local authorities, national disaster management organizations. But then also from a national perspective as well, um, seeing telco communication really as critical infrastructure and also working towards developing national strategies or policies and frameworks that really guide how the country will use telecommunications before, during and after disasters and during emergencies as well.
[00:51:56] Speaker ?: Yeah.
[00:51:57] Speaker 6: Thank you, Antoinette, um, especially for bringing up that point around, um, having, um, uh, telco networks recognized as critical national infrastructure. Uh, I think that's also something that maybe is, uh, more recently happening because we have become increasingly reliant on connectivity, but that's also happened in fairly recent history. Um, so, uh, having it, uh, be recognized to sit alongside, you know, energy, which we know as well being so important and the interconnectivity between the two of them, uh, recognized as well as so important. I wanted to finish up our session just by asking, um, because we're here at COP 31 in Antalya, in Turkey. Um, and I know that you've all been taking part in lots of different sessions, speaking at different sessions, listening to other stakeholders at different sessions. So what I'd love to understand, maybe Colin coming to you first is what do you hope we take away from, uh, COP 31? And I guess, particularly looking towards 2030, which is rapidly approaching, what do you want to see us take away from COP 31 and maybe achieve by 2030?
[00:53:05] Speaker 8: I think what we've seen is these are very, very big, complicated system problems. Uh, even just in this, this short conversation we've had, it goes right away from the way we manufacture equipment, right the way through to the way it's used. And true to the impact of energy grids that it runs on. So they're very large, complicated infrastructure systems. What's happening of course now, as we're getting huge amounts of data out from all of that. At huge amounts of data, it's now possible using things like responsible AI to start to process it, to look at potential risks, to look, to start to do more modeling around climate impact and so forth. So there's a lot of things that have been talked at COP, which sound like they have great potential, but we know we need to, to work carefully towards those things. There's a lot of new skills we need to develop in the industry, both again, within our side, as we're manufacturing equipment within the customer side, as they're using it. And also with the policymakers, as they're deciding what they, what they get behind and how it gets implemented locally, uh, through different, different governments. So we know there's, there's a lot of potential out there, but there's a lot of things we need to get through. As you say, with 2030 coming up very quickly. Yeah.
[00:54:20] Speaker 6: Thank you very much. Picking up the same question to you, Andrea, um, what would you like to see coming out of COP31 and particularly on this, uh, you know, we're rushing towards 2030 and by then.
[00:54:31] Speaker 7: I think a similar point, really, um, uh, collaboration and just thinking much more holistically about the systems problem that we face. Um, so for example, we need joined up spatial planning on energy, digital connectivity, AI data centers. There's a huge pressure now on, um, the energy transition. There's been a lot of discussion here at COP31 about electrification. Um, so, but that all of that depends on technology and it depends on connectivity. Um, so I think, yeah, thinking together, um, with other partners and collaborating on how we design the right system for the problem. Um, is one of the key things that I will, that I will take away and maybe just one further one, um, which relates specifically to this conversation. Is that we also apply that joined up thinking and that collaboration when we are looking at the problems related to climate change, adaptation and resilience. Um, thinking not just about, um, infrastructure, but also about the communities that this is really affecting and working with them, really listening to them to understand what they need as well. Yeah.
[00:55:35] Speaker 6: Thank you so much. Thank you for bringing in as well, the community aspect of it. Cause you talk there about the kind of, um, better spatial planning that we need. And obviously these, um, technologies that we're deploying, they exist in spaces where communities also exist. So how do we coexist in a more harmonious way? How do we achieve a more just transition as we're going through this energy transition? How do we take a broader set of stakeholders views on board, uh, as we sort of decarbonize, uh, and also have to tackle some of the challenges that we're seeing around the deployment of kind of new technologies like AI data centers. Um, great. Thank you so much, Andrea coming to you, uh, Antoinette with the same question. Then, um, thinking about from your point of view, what you would love to see come out of COP 31, uh, what would be on your wish list? Uh, and where would you like to see us, uh, be by 2030?
[00:56:31] Speaker 9: So my wish list coming out of COP 21, um, as you have mentioned, we've already progressed quite a lot in terms of reducing our carbon emissions, which is great, but there are still many other novel, novel technologies out there that can really do with some more development. So from my perspective, um, it would be great to see further R and D, um, so that those technologies can improve so that it can improve the costs. Um, also more on the, the policy and collaboration side as well to then move from pilots to be able to scale these innovative solutions that we so dearly need, um, by 2030, 2040 and out to 2050.
[00:57:16] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Antoinette. Yes, exactly. I think we definitely need to, uh, to scale them and to move, uh, beyond the ambition, uh, that we've got much more into the implementation. I think we've touched upon that already with some of the fantastic examples that we've talked about, uh, on this panel. Um, we know actually that many. Many, all of the technologies that we need to solve the climate crisis, uh, do exist already. They're just not necessarily being, uh, evenly distributed and deployed, uh, where we need them. So the quicker that we can do that, uh, the better. And it's great to see, um, the progressive actions that we're seeing taken by companies like Vodafone, like Cisco, uh, in terms of decarbonizing while also at the same time realizing that we, um, are facing climate disruption. Um, and we have to make ourselves, we're locked into a certain level of disruption over the coming years. We hope to minimize that, but we do need to reduce those impacts to become more resilient, um, as well. So I think I'll definitely take away, uh, those points that you've all made today, um, that there is so much that's going on. Um, maybe a lot of it is perhaps more behind the scenes and it's not talked about so much because we know that, uh, the biggest stories are where there's perhaps not been progress. Um, and they, those create the headlines, but we also know that just from this discussion as well. And what we hear about a cop that there's lots of other fantastic progress going on. Uh, and we're already starting to see that trickle through, I think into the economy in terms of some of those reductions. Um, but we just need to push to take this further to get where we need to be. Uh, thank you so much. Thank you, Andrea from Vodafone, Colin from Cisco and Antoinette from the Carbon Trust. Um, and back to you, um, Nick. So good job.
[00:59:13] Speaker 2: Um, before we close, uh, one brief final reflection maybe, uh, from the panel. Uh, Steven, what was the most important message you want our audience to take away? Um, yeah. Do you want to come on with that one? Yeah. I think the most important message was what we touched upon right at the end.
[00:59:32] Speaker 6: And that is actually what is already happening that maybe we just don't see. Uh, and I think we talked about a lot of the fantastic things actually that really progressive companies like Vodafone, like Cisco are doing already. And the ways in which, uh, um, organizations like the Carbon Trust are helping them. Um, so that's, I think the thing that I'd like the audience to take away that there's perhaps a lot more going on than we necessarily always hear about.
[01:00:01] Speaker 2: I think that's a very good point. Uh, the, the government seems to be locking their horns again, like a herd of cows on, on things to do with not the real world in some cases, right? I mean, yes, they need to unlock the finance with the poorer countries. That's absolutely critical. But the action agenda, which really got fired up from Brazil is now moving forward. And governments, uh, uh, are saying, yeah, we're going to do the Santa Marta process. That's one way of exiting fossil fuels. The cities are acting. They're even exceeding their targets and the business sector, right, is stepping up as well. So in fact, it can be done in the real world. And yes, you can lock horns at the cops in terms of consensus, but maybe there's a new kind of cop emerging. I think that's probably the key, key message. Um, I want to say thank you, Andrea, um, Antoinette, is it? Colin and Steven for setting the scene and leading the discussion. And thank you to everyone watching. Uh, we don't have time TV and the climate hub here at cop 31. Cheers.
[01:01:00] Speaker 10: Hey everyone, Jad Daly here, president of terra formation. And we're excited to bring you another episode of the under story, uh, our podcast with, we don't have time, uh, live here, uh, from cop 31. So I'm going to fly solo for one more episode. My cohost Shata is still on her maternity leave. Uh, a great reason to be off the podcast for sure. Um, so I'll be flying solo, uh, here today, uh, and delving a little bit deeper into the issues that we care about most here on the podcast, which is really how do we get nature-based solutions right? maximize their impact for climate change, for biodiversity, and for people. And one of the most important things that's happened in this field in recent months and years is the release of a new report from the UN Environment Program. And I'm going to get the title exactly right. It is Limiting Overshoot, Navigating Exceedance of 1.5 Degrees Celsius, and Pathways to Return. And so, we're really excited. I have a great guest today, Mireille Atala. Did I get that right? From the UN Environment Program. And she was one of the coordinators of pulling this report together. And so, we're really excited to have you on the understory today to ground people in this report, and what they should draw from it, how it's intended to be used, and kind of as a guidance for policymakers and practitioners alike. And in particular, really delve in today to where nature-based solutions factor into the findings of this report, but also the strategies that it outlines for, in particular, getting back to 1.5 degrees C, after we have stabilized and capped carbon emissions and greenhouse gas emissions. So, once essentially we've stopped increasing and we start on the decline pathway, what's the role of nature-based solutions in doing that? And so, my first thing, though, I wanted to do just quickly, in case any of our listeners aren't familiar, tell people about the UN Environment Program and kind of, you know, the role of the program and how it's organized, you know, kind of, where are you located around the world and how does it fit into what people should know about the UN
[01:03:23] Speaker 11: and the role of the UN Environment Program? Right. Thank you very much and pleasure for me to be here. So, the UN Environment Program, as the name says, is essentially the entity within the United Nations that is responsible for our mandate is essentially to keep the global environment under review. And one of our main functions is similar to what we've done with this report, to raise the alarm, raise the flags, sometimes red, sometimes white, on what is going on in the environment very broadly, what is going on on climate, on nature, on biodiversity, on pollution, on chemicals, and so on and so forth. Beyond that, we do act on the flags that we raise as well, either via our UN Environment Assembly, which brings together all the member states in a similar fashion to what is happening here, but on a much broader agenda and very often times at the forefront issues of climate change, of environment. So, for example, things like the Climate Change Convention or the Biodiversity Convention or some of the pollution-related conventions were born out of discussion in the UN Environment Assembly, or what preceded it was the governing council of the UN Environment Programme. And then we deploy support. We support countries and member states to access finance, to think about their policies, to implement projects with the purpose, essentially, of creating the change that needs to happen in policy, in finance, in practices, in mindsets, so that those challenges that we identify on the environment front, very broadly, essentially become addressed at the action level, at the policy level. - Yeah. - And right now, for instance, for the past two years, I think, we also have been incubating, if I can put it this way, a treaty on plastics, addressing plastic pollution, and that has come out of the before-last UN
[01:05:44] Speaker 10: Environment Assembly. - So, I love that you're in the action role. You know, you're both keeping a pulse on how we're doing on, you know, critical aspects of environmental protection, but then also playing this equally critical role of saying, now that we know how we're doing, what are the actions that we need to take to stay on the right trajectory for protecting our environment. And so, tell us about this overshoot report. A little funny story. At New York City Climate Week, I started every event where I was speaking by asking, for a show of hands in the room, how many people have actually read the report? It's about 130 pages, and I said, I actually did read it, because I realized everyone was referring to it, and I wasn't clear that many people had read it. So, I actually pulled it out, I read it. It's very easy by read, by the way. It's really well organized. You did a great job of making it very readable. But what I was struck actually, fewer people had read it than I expected. And so, I want to make sure that we really get, that help folks understand what are they missing in here, and how is this information meant to, as you said, spur action. So, can you start by saying, where did this report come from? Was it sort of a part of some ritualized check, or was it in response to some of the alarming new information about passing 1.5 degrees C? Where did the report come from, and who is it aimed at?
[01:06:58] Speaker 11: All right. So, where did the report come from? From our mandate. We have a mandate, as you said, to take the pulse of where we stand on different environment issues, including climate change. You probably know that every year we produce the emissions gap report and the adaptation gap report, that are year-on-year assessments or, yeah, analysis of where we stand, both on the emission trajectory and also on the adaptation trajectory, from planning to implementation to finance. Now, in a way you're right, because in 2024 and 2025 were reported as the hottest years. And we were, there were reports also in the media that we had gone beyond 1.5. And then there was a lot of speculation and discourse, in media in particular, that we had the Paris Agreement is breached, and the Paris Agreement is dead, so on and so forth. And so, we thought there's distinctions between science and public knowledge that are not necessarily always very clear. One of those distinctions is that the Paris Agreement has set a long-term goal of maintaining global warming as close as possible to 1.5 and as low as possible below 2 degrees. But that's a long-term goal. When you breach, you know, it's like when you take an average, this year you, let's say you produce five kilograms, say you're an apple producer, you produce five kilograms this year, 10 next year, three the year after, your average is the sum of those three divided by the number of years, right? So, it doesn't necessarily mean that you've failed if you have produced three kilograms in the third year. So, that was the first thing for us, was to see, okay, we have an annual average that has gone beyond 1.5 in two consecutive years. Where do we stand on
[01:09:12] Speaker 10: the trajectory? So, like you're putting those annual ones in context. Yes, exactly. We're putting, we're,
[01:09:17] Speaker 11: but also we're, we're, we were also checking. So, how far are we from the global? Right. From that long-term goal? Right. And what does it mean for that long-term goal? Right, right. So, the first thing that the report establishes is that we currently stand at 1.37 degrees Celsius of global warming, multi-decadal in comparison to pre-industrial levels, and that we have been warming at roughly 0.25 degrees per decade. Now, if you may, if you do the math, it does mean that we will be exceeding 1.5 as a global multi-decadal average in the next few years. Yeah. So, that's the first thing is that those annual breaches actually do, or those annual exceedances do give us an indication and do support a trend that we will be exceeding 1.5 as a multi-decadal average. However, given that the, the Paris Agreement has a long-term goal. Right. By end of the century. Game's not over yet. Right. Game's not over yet. There you go. We can come back. So, what we need, so what we triggered with that report is that, you know, the mindset had always been, um, pegged against an increase of temperatures that we need to curb at or around 1.5. Right. So, you've got an increase and a new plateau. Right. Now, as we go above 1.5, as we exceed 1.5, that mindset needs to change. We are going to have to bring temperatures back to 1.5. Yeah. We have to decline more, right? We have to decline. Yes. Exactly. So, that's number two. That's the second thing that the report brings to the fore. Now, something that the general public, including policy makers and including, you know, even the climate of the, of the future, of the future community, there's a need clarification on is that there is a distinction. So, if you're in the business world, you overshoot your KPIs, your key performance indicators, you probably get a bonus. Right. Right. In the climate space. Not this time. No, you don't get a bonus. We don't get a bonus for exceeding 1.5. Yeah. Um, the other thing is that when we talk about overshoot the world, the word, unfortunately, um, in the science space, so we talk about overshoot pathways, and there's a very, there's an important distinction to make here is that you exceed a point, you exceed the threshold. Yeah. But here on an overshoot pathway, we're talking about the whole thing. We're talking about the exceedance phase. Right. While we're still on an increase. Yeah. We're talking about the peak. Yeah. Which is where we stop that increase. Right. We're talking about the decline. Yeah. And the stabilization phase. Yeah. So all of that. Yeah. Constitutes overshoot pathway. Yeah. Going beyond 1.5 is just exceedance. Yeah. Because we don't know at
[01:12:25] Speaker 10: what level we would pick. So can I, I want to direct you. And then for our audience in the understory, um, I mean, these are folks who are committed to the climate challenge writ large. And so we, I think it's fair to say, uh, certainly at terra formation, and I think across the forest climate community, people are part of the whole solution, but particularly focused on how to forest do their part. And so what I'd love to focus on is that the pathways that the report talks about to decline back to 1.5 degrees C, because it has some really important guidance and findings in there. Um, and, and one of the things, and I'll even read from exact from the report, it says total global afforestation and reforestation currently achieve about 2.2 gigatons of removals per year, citing a 2026 data from Smith at all. That's really exciting because we've had, uh, I think, unfortunately those of us working on reforestation as a, as a climate action pathway have endured some attacks and some questions. It can, can reforestation in all of its forms that I'm including in that agroforestry, afforestation, all forms of, of adding more trees and tree cover on our planet. You know, is that really going to help, uh, on, on climate change? And this says it's helping a lot, by the way, to put 2.2 gigatons in context. That's more than double global emissions from the airline industry. Think about that for a second. Think about how much energy and concern there is about that. We're doing more than double emissions from airlines with afforestation and reforestation right now. And the report goes on to say current model estimates suggests that sustainable afforestation and reforestation could remove about 5.6 gigatons per year by 2050, with limited potential for future expansion. So that's about 150% increase over this already massive climate change solution. Now, to be clear later in the report, it makes abundantly clear that trees can't do this alone. Afforestation and reforestation is not a replacement for the urgent need to reduce warming and greenhouse gas emissions as quickly as possible. Um, as part of this overall strategy that you described, it also says trees are going to need help, um, from other forms of carbon dioxide removal, um, that are not yet close to that same level, but, but we want to catch up. Um, so it, it doesn't certainly say it's just about reforestation in all of its forms, but it certainly says this is a central must-have pathway to get back to 1.5 degrees C. So, so talk to me about, you know, how, how you see that and how the UNEP team sees that and, and what we should all take away from this report in terms of what it says to the reforestation
[01:14:53] Speaker 11: community about our responsibility to be part of this. Right. So I think you've got it in numbers over there, but I think there's, uh, to the nature community, there's a number of options and pathways and messages and takeaways. I think the first one is not to discredit nature. Um, because in, in many, in many cases, whether it's standing forests or reforestation, afforestation, there are, there are setbacks and there have been, and we know, and now we know how to correct them. Yep. I think that one of the key messages is learn and move on rather than discredit the whole sector. That's exactly right. Because it's, because it's made mistakes in the past, or, you know, we went too fast or, uh, whatever. Yeah. So I think the first message is that, um, you know, forests are one of the largest carbon sinks, not stocks. I mean, not just stocks, because if we talk about stocks, then we get into
[01:15:59] Speaker 10: peatlands. That's exactly right. Yeah. So flows. Sources of active carbon removal from the atmosphere.
[01:16:06] Speaker 11: Yeah, exactly. And so first message is that forests that are connected by diverse and healthy are extremely critical in terms of that, um, carbon in terms of the carbon flows. So drawdowns. Yeah. And are extremely important in terms of resilience. Yeah. Because they play a role beyond the carbon stocks and flows. That's an easy way to measure that, you know, to attribute value and to measure. Yeah. It's easy to measure. But beyond that, there's the water cycle, soil retention. Yeah. Species maintenance. Yeah. Uh, maintaining the web of life. Yeah. That become increasingly important as we get into that exceedance phase. Yeah. And the higher the peak. So the higher that overshoot, the more and more important it is to maintain that very connected web of life. Yeah. You did
[01:17:05] Speaker 10: such a good job of being integrative in the way this report is done. Uh, it really weaves together all those different things that you were talking about, which we sometimes separate in the forest community. We talk about each benefit of forests and, and kind of why we do it as a separate strategy. And what you did in here was show that the right forestry actions give us all those things simultaneously, the right things done in the right places, give us all those things. I thought that
[01:17:26] Speaker 11: was a really exciting part of what you did with the report. Well, and I think that this connects to one of the questions that you had about the mitigation adaptation going hand in hand. Yes. Yes. Because, you know, we've kind of conceptually separated things that are connected in nature or in action. Right. Maybe a quick example that I can give you, and I will bring it back to forests. Yeah. Is we used to say that forests are the lungs of the world. Right. Forests are the air conditioning of the world. That's exactly right.
[01:17:52] Speaker 10: It's the new one that I want to give you here. Exactly.
[01:17:54] Speaker 11: And, and not only in natural systems, but also in urban ecosystems as well. Yes. Thank you. Absolutely. Nature based solutions, 10% of green spaces in reduces or buffers temperatures, temperature extremes. Yeah. By up to 9%. Yes. In Colombia has managed to reduce, you know, changes in temperatures and increases in urban warming. Yes. Of up to four degrees. That's massive. And as you talk about in the report,
[01:18:24] Speaker 10: I was so excited to use urban forests as an example of combined mitigation adaptation in the report. Because as you noted in there, it's, it's that cooling benefit is a health benefit. It's also reduces energy use for air conditioning, which is a major source of greenhouse gases. So it's that double play for mitigation and adaptation all together with one action with urban forests. I thought it was, I was excited to see you use that example in the report.
[01:18:46] Speaker 11: Very much so. And so that disconnect between mitigation and adaptation. Yeah. Between forests for carbon versus for biodiversity versus for resilience. Yeah. We need to break that. 100%. We can no longer, uh, we need every, every action to deliver on multiple fronts. Exactly. And the more we fragment things conceptually and theoretically, the more we make it difficult actually. Yeah. So I think that there is a plea. Yeah. To, to shed, um, a little bit of that single focus, you know, kind of tunnel vision that we, that we've kind of gone into. Yeah. Now we need
[01:19:30] Speaker 10: to open it up. Boy, you get a permanent place on the understory podcast. Cause what you just said is one of the deepest held beliefs that we have that we're, we've talked about this a few times on other episodes that we're hurting ourselves by fragmenting. I won't repeat what you said, cause you said it so beautifully, but when we divide, uh, you know, our, our strategies and, uh, you know, and our, our, as you said, conceptual frameworks, we're making this work much harder on ourselves in so many different ways. We fragment our stakeholders, fragment finance. Uh, we don't even sometimes see how the same action could be done in a way that combines those multiple benefits. So it's just very exciting
[01:20:00] Speaker 11: to hear you articulate that. Double counting. We put a bigger strain on countries, on stakeholders for reporting. We spend too much time doing the same thing, but pitching it in a different way. Yeah. We don't have time for that. Yeah. We're in the, we don't have time.
[01:20:16] Speaker 10: Well, and don't you think that the, the, the reality that we just had a biodiversity cop, right? And it's, and in which we were talking about many of the same interventions like reforestation, which is a really powerful way to deal with the global biodiversity prices. And then we're having a climate chop. We're talking about, uh, you know, climate change is a solution for climate mitigation and adaptation. Fortunately out there in the world, I think those two things are coming together. But to your point, the more that we can integrate how policymakers think about it, how financial instruments are created to reward activities on the ground that do all these things together, human health, job creation, all these different things that we can achieve with an intervention like reforestation, we're so much better off. So let me ask you a related question, which is you talk about in the report, the fact that it's both a matter of strategy. It's also a matter of execution. So reforestation's a particularly great example, right? When we replant climate stress forests, if we don't adjust for the climate stresses, the forests are just going to die again, right? And so the science and the deep science behind how we create climate resilient reforestation designs, for example, is one of those elements of integrating mitigation adaptation all the way down to literally how we deliver these solutions. How do you think about that challenge in terms of execution of these strategies?
[01:21:27] Speaker 11: So, I mean, it's one of the areas in which this is the most challenging because in, in, so the way I see it and what we are saying in the report is that essentially we're going to start to see species shifts in altitude and in latitude. We're going to see species mismatches, for example, between the migratory season versus the availability of praise, for example. And then we're going to see changes in in global systems. Yeah. Particularly triggered by changes in the hydrological system, water system. Yeah. So the way I like to describe it to make it easier to comprehend is through what we call climate analogues. Now, a climate analog is essentially telling you, let's say, we are, where are we? We are in Turkey. It's the Mediterranean. Right. So essentially, you know, there's a lot of Mediterranean type ecosystems around the world in Australia and South Africa, around the Mediterranean, California, so on and so forth. So essentially to give the example, rather than saying your agroecological zone is going to shift or your climatic zone is going to shift to have x percent more or less precipitation, x percent or x degrees higher temperature or changes in temperature and so on. What we say is to give you a comparator. Yeah. The Mediterranean is going to become like the savannah. Right. Exactly. And you're trying to... And then you know exactly, you project yourself and you know exactly what are the kind of species, what are the kind of trees, what are the kind of systems that you are going to have to work
[01:23:12] Speaker 10: with or the system boundaries that you work against. Right. Even genetic differences within them, right?
[01:23:15] Speaker 11: Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And so, but the challenge for reforestation, afforestation and restoration more broadly, because this is one of the critical points of the report, is that monospecific, unhealthy and fragmented systems have a higher risk of tipping than those that are connected and bi-diverse. That's right. And so even as we go into afforestation, reforestation, restoration and so forth, we need to start thinking about the species assemblages. Yes. So have more than one species in your restoration effort that can retain soil, that can withstand certain temperatures, that can serve as a food for pollinators, have multiple species of pollinators. Because if one is very sensitive to temperature changes, another one might survive. Yeah. And so you want to think about functionality as opposed to about single species. And that is a massive change. And I think it works to our advantage because then it takes us beyond the rapid growth tree species that have been criticized, monospecific reforestation or afforestation that have been criticized and it takes us toward more holistic approaches. And for what it's
[01:24:33] Speaker 10: worth, you know, I did actually go and look at the study, the 2019 Lewis study that was cited in there, looking at what's in terms of the commitments that are out there, what percentage of them are focused on biodiverse forest systems and which ones aren't. And I think the field has evolved a lot in just that seven years. And so I suspect that that same analysis done today would find a much higher percentage. You know, including on working forest lands, huge credit to many of the working forest producers, BTG Paxual is a great example that's really, I think, been very innovative in continuing to give us the forest products that we need, but doing it with more biodiverse forestry systems. And so I feel like as a field, people are really hearing that message that you're saying, and we're making a lot of progress and sort of the terraformation, we've been very focused on this whole, how do we inform really hyperbiodiverse planting reforestation strategies? So really aligned with, with the goal that you laid out. Okay, we're going to just a few seconds left. So here's your final question is, I'm going to give you the mic, pretend you're on the main stage at, you know, some major cop gathering here, you get to tell the, all the assembled leaders, one thing, what's one thing they should take away from this report? What's an exhortation that you can give us from this amazing report? Action. Now, no time.
[01:25:44] Speaker 11: No talking. Get to work. Immediately. That would be my core message. And across all fronts. It's not just about nature. It's about fossil fuels, electrification, energy efficiency. We need all in. A hundred percent. What we do now determines how, how, how high we peak. Yeah. Well, listen,
[01:26:03] Speaker 10: thanks for making the time. We know you had to run over here for another meeting. Thank you so much for what you and your colleagues have done. I'm going to keep asking the question in every room that I'm in. Has everyone read this report? I did it again this week here, because we need to get everyone to read this report, take this call to action and take exactly the kind of integrative science-based approach that you've advocated. So thanks for being on the show. We appreciate it. Thank you very much.
[01:26:32] Speaker 1: We are nearing the end of our broadcasts and engagement here at COP31 in Turkey. The final outcome will come Friday or perhaps into the weekend, according to some of our sources. And we, along with the, probably most of the people of the world, hold our breath as to what this United Nations process, based on consensus of all nations, will actually achieve this time. But while we hold, or maybe, maybe more accurately, not hold our breaths, what do we do going forward to get our world on track, to meet the spiraling challenge of a world out of climate control? To talk about this, we have great people at the studio, as always. We have Ingmar Renshoek, CEO and founder of We Don't Have Time. And you, he co-founded We Don't Have Time 10 years ago. And he's a platform CEO and also chair of W, the new social media company, been built in Europe with a new standard of integrity. And we have, on the other side here, Nick Natal, my co-host, that you'll probably all have met over the years. And, but, but you also might know that he was a spokesperson for the Paris Agreement. And Nick has covered as a journalist, or a United Nations director, all the cops since the first cop. Almost all the cops. Almost all them. So next to Nick is Louisa Neubauer. Great to have you, Louisa. You are a climate justice activist, Fridays for Future Germany. And then we have our, one of our favorite guests here, Zebra Burman. You are a founder of the Fossil Fuel Treaty. And it's great to have you with us again. So let's start with Ingmar. I think it would be fair to say, Ingmar, that you, that you have, you've had, have had your fair share of, of, of cops and their inability to deliver what is needed. So please share your perspective on this. Yes. And I mean, I found that
[01:28:30] Speaker 5: We Don't Have Time 10 years ago. And we're still not, I mean, the temperature is rising. We are passing 1.5 degree officially, according to UN itself. And emissions are still going up. Maybe slowing down, maybe flattening out, but it's not shrinking, not near enough what we need. And here we are negotiating small, small details when we're still focusing on do something completely different. I mean, the Paris Agreement, we need to realize this. We have failed. The Paris Agreement will not deliver the solution we need. I mean, it was good when it came into place. But 10 years later, we are passing the 1.5 degree. We have no plan in the Paris Agreement to stay under two degrees. And emissions are still going up. And we are kind of celebrating small progress that we already have achieved. We just frame it differently. This cup, it's a big debate how we're going to make the 35% electricity target. If it's going to be only with clean energy or not. But the world seems to have forgotten. We have already agreed on triple clean energy and double energy efficiency. That's the exact same thing. I mean, come on. We need to think totally different.
[01:30:05] Speaker 1: Thank you, Ingmar. So, Nick, please share your thoughts about this.
[01:30:08] Speaker 2: Yeah, I take a slightly different view to Ingmar. I don't think the COP process is a failure. I think some of the governments who are in the COP process are a failure. I mean, you know, it took a long time. It's absolutely true. Far longer than it should have done to actually get a universal treaty of all nations acting under their own kind of responsibilities, in a sense, to actually deal with the climate process. But it did happen in Paris. And there was every opportunity that this could be built upon. Now, only part of the new infrastructure has been built upon. And some of that, indeed, was already happening before Paris. It made Paris possible. In other words, renewable energy. I mean, if the renewable energy had not been sort of roaring ahead pre-Paris, Paris would never have happened. And it's continued to roar ahead. That's indisputable. And I think the COP process that had a role in that because governments were cleanly aware that regulations were coming on energy at some shape or form. And that inspired the development of renewable energy much faster than it was. And there were leaders like Germany and others who actually took that forward, right? So that's a win, I think, for the COP process. And it's a win post-Paris. But I suppose I also agree with Ingmar that if you're sitting at home right now watching the news, and if you're actually waiting for the outcome of this COP, you're going to be very disappointed because the media are not reporting on the right thing. And I'll come back to later.
[01:31:30] Speaker 1: Thank you, Nick. So, Zebra, what are your thoughts here? I mean, you are the founder of the fossil fuel treaty. You've had many press conferences here. You'll have another one soon. And also you're involved in the Santa Marta process. And both of these things are sort of processes parallel to the UNFCCC processes. What are your thoughts on the failure or the benefits or the downfalls of this process, the COP process?
[01:31:55] Speaker 12: Look, in some ways, I agree with both of you. We would be in a much worse situation if we hadn't had these COP processes and if we didn't have the Paris Agreement. And I think we need to understand that. We're not where we need to be, but we would be in a worse situation. We don't want to throw out the baby with the bathwater, as they say. We need more than one tool in our toolbox. And I think what we know is that the 30 years of the COP process has failed to address the cause of climate change: oil, gas, and coal. And that's because the fossil fuel industry and fossil fuel interests have had such a powerful role in trying to make that issue invisible, literally the words invisible here. And the progress that has been made is a debate over whether to include the words "fossil fuels" in the text, which we finally got in Dubai. It's debated again here. But there's no plan to phase out fossil fuels. And I think what is really exciting is that now we're starting to have multiple processes. And that's important. There's actually no other issue within the UN system that doesn't have multiple agreements and multiple treaties to address one issue. So now we have the Paris Agreement. We have emissions targets. We have a goal of 1.5. We have some important initiatives that are being discussed here, like the just transition mechanism. But I think what's really exciting is for the first time in history, we have almost 60 countries who gathered in Santa Marta last year, not to talk about whether to phase out fossil fuels, but to talk about how and to plan on that. And that coalition is growing with the next conference, diplomatic conference hosted by Tuvalu in Ireland in 2027. And we have a growing block of countries that is designing a fossil fuel treaty at the table. Over 25 countries, more will be announced today by the countries. And those countries are developing new legal global governance frameworks to cooperate to phase out fossil fuels and to stop the expansion. And that's the critical piece here. We've never been able at COP to talk about the expansion of fossil fuels. So even countries that are producing roadmaps on fossil fuel phase out at COP, which is great, finally, we have countries talking about fossil fuel phase out. Several of those countries are talking about increasing fossil fuel expansion. You can't phase something out by building more of it. And that is why it's so exciting that we now have multiple diplomatic tracks. That doesn't mean we throw at COP, that doesn't mean we don't need the Paris Agreement, but it does mean we do need the Santa Marta process and a fossil fuel treaty to complement those
[01:34:45] Speaker 1: initiatives. Thank you, Zebra. So, Luisa, please, Nick, hand the Luisa our microphone. So, what is your
[01:34:52] Speaker 13: stand on this? I'm curious. Yeah. I mean, what are we talking about, right? This is the most complicated thing that humanity has ever done, frankly. It was much easier to get into the climate crisis than getting out of it. It's a ridiculous, absurd endeavour that we are embarking on, right? And we have not even, you know, altogether decided that we're doing it. You know, the majority of the world population has, and the majority of almost every government, but a lot of industries are, you know, they're moving in the other direction. So, obviously, there's not going to be that one route that is going to do that. And there's not going to be that one tool or this one mechanism. And I find the same people who are so disappointed that the kind of climate youth movement hasn't solved all our problems magically are the people who are now saying, oh, but that process is, you know, is not the one and that government is not that one or that leader is not the one. Yes, surprise, that's not the one. There's just a trillion moments and ways that we try to go. It's a non-linear road. It's a quite the opposite. It's a very bumpy road. It's going uphill. And I think instead of setting our hopes on this one solution or that one person, one government or one party or even that one COP, I think it's more about setting hopes and the diversity of approaches and then making sure we are strategic about it. We look at what is working out and we kind of throw out what's not working out. And we are being honest to ourselves about the aesthetics of things that the new momentum and climate will look differently than we might expect it. And we might, you know, we shall open our eyes so we actually don't oversee it just because we expected something different or we wanted something different. So I find it's a good, it's a good moment to re-evaluate for every organization, for every party, for every movement, for every individual, what am I doing? What am I bringing on the table? Can I join something that is, you know, promising? Can I leave something that has failed? What is my commitment that I give to the universe and to this wonderful planet and its people?
[01:36:54] Speaker 1: Thank you, Louisa. So, Ingmar and Nick, reflections on what Zebra and Louisa just said. You go ahead, Ingmar.
[01:37:02] Speaker 5: It's spot on. It's so many people complaining what others do, but they don't do anything themselves. Or they're like, oh, the youth will solve it. Or the COP will solve it. And the observation is right. It's many times the same people. They love someone else to solve this. And when they're not solving it, they are blaming them for not solving it for them. So we need to get everyone that understand and have a little insight about the severe of the climate crisis. And those people complaining, they have some insights, otherwise they will not say anything at all. And this is the part I'm really missing at those climate meetings. We need people to realize the severeness. I mean, we have Al Gore sometimes doing a great keynote or Johan Rockström doing a keynote at the plenary. But besides that, it's not really what we're talking about here. It's like everyone knows it. Yes, you know it, but it's a thing to get this latest science updated. And this is a missed opportunity. We have, I don't know how many journalists, five, ten thousand at this meeting. It's maybe the most journalists in one place in the world are here. They should, you know, at least the first week of COP cable out the updated science. It doesn't look good at all. And you have hundreds of negative news sharing that. And the second week, what the hell to do about it? And I don't feel the first thing. I don't feel the second thing. And I certainly believe in one thing. We need everything. This is very complicated. It's not one solution that we fix it. But it's important that we don't waste time on the process that is not taking us nowhere near where we need to go. And I've been a big fan of the Paris Agreement, defending it. But I think we need to realize that we need to evolve the Paris Agreement. It can't be those 144 details that we're spending two weeks on moving back and forth. It needs to be, I mean, we're failing it. COP existed before the Paris Agreement. We had Copenhagen. I think we need a new Copenhagen moment to realize that we need to reset this and think differently and throw out what's not working and focus on what's working. And some part of the Paris Agreement is working very good. Keep that. But the ones that are not working, do something else.
[01:39:39] Speaker 2: Nick, then separate. So I think we're partially solving the problem, right? So we can't say we're not solving the problem. We're partially solving the problem. But the bit we're not solving is really important that we solve it rather quickly, right? But I think the COP process, I think what people are missing is that the COP process is changing. It's changing before our very eyes here. And some people don't see it. Some people don't even recognize it or want to recognize it. And some people are living in the past. The action agenda that the Brazilians forged last year in Belém is actually alive and well and kicking. There are people actually doing things, not negotiating things, but doing things. And they're telling other people about what they're doing. The cities, I mentioned those before. I mean, the cities are meeting. Many, many cities are meeting their targets and over-exceeding their targets. Many sub-national governments in provinces or states are doing things which go beyond what even, you know, governments are doing. And businesses too, although they're being a bit quiet about what they're doing, there are some businesses really powering ahead. The others have to come along too. So in other words, within that action agenda, you've also, in a sense, got some countries under your treaty and also on the wider exiting and fossil fuels movement saying, we've had enough, right, of this consensus-based structure, which is something from way back when the UN was set up. We've had enough too. We're going to go on our own. I mean, if you look at the Amazon, right, it's not going to be saved at this COP. The Amazon is going to be saved by Brazil, Colombia, and all the countries around it and the people around it, the businesses and the scientists, they're going to solve that problem, not here at COPS, right? So why even bother trying to make it an issue? Do you know what I'm trying to say? I mean, there's a chance for people just to go ahead and do
[01:41:25] Speaker 1: things without waiting for consensus. Okay, Zebra, and then we need, I'm going to want you to move to another, we're going to move to another slightly different topic on this. Zebra, what are your
[01:41:34] Speaker 12: thoughts? I don't think that countries need to wait for consensus. I think we're going to need multiple plurilateral and multilateral agreements in order to move forward. And we're also going to need national regulations and domestic action. I don't think that the, while there's increased ambition and some great initiatives here at COP, I don't think we're seeing a fundamental change of the COP structure. We are not seeing those action agenda issues being negotiated in any agreements. For example, even with the just transition mechanism, which I think is the one of the big signs of hope that came out of the BLEM COP. What do we have agreement to so far here at COP? A website. Well, we're not going to give countries the support that they need, especially to address the increasing extreme weather and experiences like Nepal has experienced with the devastating landslides with a website. We actually need frameworks and we need agreements. But I think the Copenhagen moment has happened. I think the Copenhagen moment that is going to shift international diplomacy and climate politics forever is Santa Marta. The fact that 60 countries actually were talking about fossil fuel phase out that actually are starting to collaborate on different initiatives like a fossil fuel treaty is absolutely critical. And the world has changed enough that they can do it now. And I think I want to make three quick points there. One, renewables are now cheaper than fossil fuels. That was not true in the past, you know, 30 years of COPs. It is now possible to develop solutions at scale, even for transportation. And that's really exciting. Two, this is no longer just as if that wasn't enough, a climate issue. This is also now fossil fuel phase out is also now an issue of national security and energy security. And we saw that as a result of the bottlenecks in the Strait of Hormuz. And now people are realizing that the fossil fuel system has actually made them more vulnerable and that now they can move to renewable energy systems. And I think the third issue is that we are now seeing the fossil fuel industry being held to account in a way that they have never been in the past. And I think their power is weakening. They have held these cops hostage on ambition and especially on fossil fuel phase out for 30 years and they've captured many of our governments. And I think that that is just starting to change. People are realizing that it's not okay that nine oil and gas companies in the last four months made $95 billion in profit while families are suffering with higher gas prices and now wanting to get out from under the fossil fuel industry and not support their increased expansion and their obscene profits. But even the electrification conversation here at COP, people haven't been talking about displacing fossil fuels. They've just been talking about increasing renewables. And the atmosphere doesn't care how many solar panels we build. Ultimately, the atmosphere cares how many fossil fuel projects we don't. And that's why Santa Marta and the fossil fuel treaty are truly exciting as I think new Copenhagen type breakthroughs. Thank you. We need to move to
[01:44:59] Speaker 1: the next topic. I'm going to talk about the power of the people because I want to make sure we touch upon this because during the COP here, we relaunched the international campaign or initiative called United for the Future. And let's talk a bit about power of the people here that could put pressure on this. We all have this impatience, right, to get things done. And we saw what happened in Brazil, a massive immobilization between the first and second elections. So Luisa, if you will hand Luisa the microphone, please. Could the critical mass of people in the streets, I mean, you were part of Fridays for Future Germany, could this really change the climate action of nations? What are your thoughts here? Because we try to get 100 million people on the streets on Democracy Day, September 15th. Okay, that's a number. So again, when it comes to
[01:45:47] Speaker 13: people power, to mobilizations, to activism, to movements, I do find there's a bit of a... I'm not sure if... How do I say it? So I, what I observe is, everyone agrees that the youth climate mobilizations that we kick-started in 2019 with like millions of people on the streets around the world, that they have changed the conversational climate, that they brought a new era of climate energy. They brought a new era of policies. We had court rulings. We won. We, me and others, sued the German government. We changed elections. We were able to, um, organize capacity towards processes like Santa Marta, like the fossil fuel treaty, like so many other things that kind of erupted. So I think there's broad agreement that this, um, this had a catalyzing effect on everything that's going on. That it's not this single solution to everything, nothing is, but there is that we need to see these movements and we need to see activists. Though the moment that this is kind of like abbing down a little right now, which is the nature of momentum, momentum, momentum per definition doesn't last forever. So I'm sorry to everyone who's disappointed that the momentum isn't there. If you want momentum, you have to deal with the absence of momentum at some times, but, um, it's, it's really physics. Um, but the moment that it's not quite everywhere, I find there's a bit of a denial about the role of momentum and of activists. And I see not just outside, but also inside the climate space. I see an idea that activism is something that you have to afford. That's not the thing to fund right now. Um, we see spaces like COP, where I would say activism isn't, you know, quite welcomed. I would see panels where people would say, yes, you can join, but not as an activist. You know, that's a bit too much for us right now. We see governmental repressions against, um, movements, even in places like Germany that would pride itself to be like an, you know, a liberal country. So I find, yes. And we see this incredible, like legal repressions against, uh, movements and activists of all sorts. So I, I do think there's a bit of a double standard going on and a hypocrisy when it comes to the role of movements that you can't on the one side, appreciate everything and acknowledge the historical achievements, even in the younger past. And at the same time, basically do quite a few things to limit those possibilities for the future. And as the momentum is not here and we desperately need new momentum. I wonder what is the investment right now that institution parties, organization individuals take to bring activism forward, to become activists, to leave that comfort zone and to stop, you know, hoping on someone from the outside saving us. This is exactly what we're
[01:48:23] Speaker 1: trying to do with the United for the Future. We want to get all aboard organizations. I mean, people, unions, cities, and also of course, um, corporations to get this happening. And maybe just to add one thing,
[01:48:35] Speaker 13: because I find there's a big debate going on right now about the role of peaceful protests and can it, you know, deliver. And I do find it's quite a task right now to be deliberate about these things. It is not the protest on the street that is changing the game. It's every single conversation leading up to that protest. Absolutely. It is every piece of coverage that we see. It is every person that would never join that protest, but sees or hears from the protest that, you know, changes his mind and that suddenly sees people out there. It is not that someone holding up a sign will change the game, but it's millions of very ordinary people to decide to do one thing, and that might be one of them, that will change things. So I find it's a real task right now to look closely and to understand how change works and not to fall for the easy answers for the populism kind of weaving through this question of social change and to be, I would say, open and open-hearted when it comes to all the different kind of protests and activism and movements that we need to see that ideally, you know, comes together and unites at some point where there is no hierarchy between a protest that makes sense and a protest that doesn't make sense. Great. Thank you, Louise. And we're
[01:49:45] Speaker 1: counting on you, of course, to be part of this because we need that kind of energy and we need also your
[01:49:52] Speaker 2: experience. So, Nick? I was just going to say, I think it's the very recognition that that is very important and that it is not happening at any scale right now. I mean, these people are from Stockholm and, of course, they had a protest there before the elections. A lot of people showed their face. That's one of the inspirations. But I remember, Louise, in Berlin not that many years ago where there was a "We are the many" came out on the streets of Berlin. And that was climate activists, but it was also trades unions and it was Ryanair pilots upset about their pay. It was many different people. And, of course, this is a systems change that we need. And so I think we hope that by choosing Democracy Day, we won't just get people angry about the climate out there. We'll get people angry about a lot of the systems that are not working for society and humanity right now. So, yeah.
[01:50:40] Speaker 13: I do think the biggest challenge, however, is to make sure we don't talk about the problems, but about the solutions. It's just really hard to recognize a problem in its full scale if you can't even see on the horizon the limbs of an answer that will be big enough to counter that. So, yeah.
[01:50:57] Speaker 1: It's wonderful, Louise. It seems like you've read all our background and our concept note, which you haven't. But it's exactly this. Well, touche, absolutely. I mean, we're trying to source everything we can that has been working, obviously, and also building on maybe not so much protesting against anything, Nick, but more like protecting. And the narrative that we're choosing is really act on science and protect what we love. And this is going to be all-including, not all-inclusive, because we're not going to serve drinks, but we've got to have, including everybody. All-inclusive sounds like a package holiday, doesn't it? We have to make sure it's not one of those
[01:51:33] Speaker 12: either. But I just want to say something kind of tangible about what all-inclusive means. It means showing up. It means calling your elected official. It means marching in the streets. It means dusting off those placards if you haven't done it for a while. It means everyone can do something. Exactly. And I think what's important to remember is we wouldn't have countries right now at the table for a fossil fuel treaty if it wasn't for literally thousands of people showing up and signing the petitions and marching in the streets. And I think that's true of a lot of the ambition we see, especially at a national level. History is made by those who show up. So we need to show up. We need to do everything we can to show our elected officials that they have the political space that
[01:52:19] Speaker 2: they need to do the right thing. And so the question is, is the cop dead? And should it be buried? I think the answer is probably no, but it needs to... Yeah. No. But it... Well, we try to set that as a possible concept.
[01:52:33] Speaker 1: One of the ideas with this campaign initiatives could revive it.
[01:52:36] Speaker 2: And I think we also need to show what's happening, the solutions. You have an idea for that, Ingmar. And I also think that when you actually start talking to people here, there are things that just go whizzing by the radar, which you like, oh, the Chinese are going to invest 15 billion in renewables in Turkey. Oh, that's not a bad thing, right? You know, the UK is spending this amount of money on cooling in in developing countries to try and help. And you start noticing adding some of those up as well. They're not marginal, they're important, but they get lost in the whole chaos of the final document. You know, and maybe what the journalists need to do is focus less on this consensus at the end, and more on what actually was delivered at this COP in terms of other initiatives. Good advice from a journalist. Let's balance it out a bit, yeah.
[01:53:21] Speaker 1: Good advice. I mean, you've been a journalist forever, just like I've been, so great advice. So let's end with a call to action on how to get more climate action based on what you have seen fail or work here at COP. Louisa, would you like to start, please? Just brief.
[01:53:36] Speaker 13: Just very briefly, I find one of the greatest challenges of our time might be the cynicism kind of arising from every broken promise, from every failed conference, from every great idea that, you know, didn't make it. And I guess it's crucial to remember that the cynics have, you know, slept through the greatest wonders of our times, right? They could never see them. And it's those who showed up who made good stuff happen. So I find much rather than, you know, setting our minds on this one single thing that might solve everything, which I, as I said, don't think exists. It's a good moment in time to adjust ourselves in this and tackle our inner cynics. And then go out, join something, organize with someone, show up somewhere and the rest were sort of tough. Beautiful. Nick?
[01:54:33] Speaker 2: Well, actually, I would just totally agree with Louisa. And I also would say that we have to be mindful that we think we've persuaded one, two, three, four people here that they should be active. But then some of those people die and new people come and some of them go and do other jobs, like environment ministers, and they forget what they were doing before, because they're now dealing with housing or something, that we need to remember there's a turnover of people in the world. And we need to keep active informing anybody we come across about why they need to act on this issue.
[01:55:03] Speaker 1: It's the Sisyphus work. Yeah, it is indeed. We just have to keep pushing and pushing. Yeah.
[01:55:08] Speaker 12: I think it's really critical for people to try and keep it simple. We can get lost in all of these details, you know, and that can alienate people. And so I think it's important for us to be really clear. We have to stop expanding the problem, oil, gas and coal. We have to call on our elected officials to build a cleaner and safer world. And that means renewable energy and electrification and to protect what we love, our existing natural and primary and old growth forests. And we also have to keep talking about the problems. We do. We have to paint a future, a picture of a future that people can get excited about that is absolutely possible. But we have a tremendous capacity to normalize what's happening today. And it shouldn't be normal. It's not okay that, you know, that 35,000 people died from extreme heat in Europe this summer alone, that one person is dying every minute due to lethal heat, that it's costing $16 million an hour now for the world to deal with extreme weather. None of this is okay. The wildfires sweeping the planet are not okay. And we can't allow ourselves just to get used to it and just to adapt to it. So talk about it and then get out in the streets, call on your elected officials to do what's necessary to protect what we love. Thank you, Sephra. And one final sentence from
[01:56:40] Speaker 1: Ingmar that I know you need to run, Louisa. Yes, you need to run. Yeah, well, just do you want to say
[01:56:45] Speaker 5: something to finish us off? I maybe talk too long, so run first. Thanks for joining us. Thank you so much,
[01:56:52] Speaker 1: Louisa. And keep up the good work. See you. Bye. All right. That was really good. I would like to say
[01:56:58] Speaker 5: something. Yeah, go ahead. I just wanted not to steal her time. So, I mean, three things. We need, there's 89% of the world population supporting stronger climate action, according to global studies. There are some other studies saying 80%, but it's a majority. It's a big, big majority. The problem. Those in that majority, most of them thinks they are a minority. They don't think others think the same. In the same studies. So that's a fact. And thirdly, this majority are starting to think that we are not solving it and that someone else is going to do it. And here's the thing. No one is going to solve this crisis for us. It takes all of us in that 89% majority. All of us. And I think it's time to do three things to achieve that. One, we need people here and watching this and the ones not watching this to realize what's at stake and the timetable. We're not talking about your grandchildren. We're talking about. It's happening. It's happening right now. People are dying. And we're talking about a risk that billions of people will die because of this during our lifetime. People don't get that. But if we only say that, we get synonyms. We get like, but when give up, why should I engage? I can use my time by doing something, play golf or something. So we also need to get people very, very angry about that we have the solutions. And there is some powerful interest out there trying to stop the solutions and not only continue digging oil, but literally stop the solutions. One example. United States have paid billions of dollar to stop expanding clean energy this year. They're paying companies to not build wind power to instead build fossil fuel power. They're paying them money to stop the solution. This should get you mad as hell. So we should be mad about that we're stopping the solution because we have all the solution. But lastly, and I think this is the most important thing. We can't give this to saying that someone else are going to solve it. It's not the youth. It's not people like us or Cibora or people here. We're not going to fix this for you. It takes everyone. We need people voting on conservative right parties to join. We need left people to join. We need people that never votes to join. We need people in rich countries, in poor countries, global south, global north, global west, on the moon, on the space station to join. We need old people, young people. We need everyone to join. And the easy part, it only takes one thing to show up. And we have set a date, 15 September, 2028. That's two years from now. Many here are saying, are you crazy? You're an organization called We Don't Have Time. And you set a date two years from now. And I like, oops, they have a point. But the thing is, Louisa actually sold it to us. By talking about this, we're doing the action. I mean, the day on the street is just a world record. People will talk about a world record before, during and after. But the important thing, show up. Don't get cynical. We can solve this. It will not be solved here. It will be solved by all of us. And we can do it. That's my message. Well, thank you so much, Ingmar. Thank you, Nick.
[02:01:37] Speaker 1: And a special thanks to Zebra Bergman for coming to our studio again. And, well, you know what to do. Show up. And also, of course, go to the web page, unitedforthefuture2028.org. And do your show up there. And also in other spaces. There is lots of stuff that can be done. And we need all hands on deck. Indeed. Thank you.
[02:01:59] Speaker 2: Thanks. We are nearing the end of our climate hub here from COP31. But don't go anywhere. Because we have a roundtable with some great and some great interviews lined up for you to watch. We have, for example, the energy efficiency roundtable. An interview with Matthias Frumier from Sweden. An interview with Andrea McCormick and Stephen Moore from GSMA. That's the big mobile network. And we also caught up with Kelsey Billsback from the Methane and Health Initiative lead, PSC Healthy Energy. And got to do an interview, by the way, with Ugo Bigheri, who is a regional representative for Europe's Global Alliance for Banking on Values. So thank you all for watching.
[02:02:44] Speaker 1: And don't forget to go to the unitedforthefuture2028.org and support and become one of the first 1,000 founders. It's only a three year per month commitment, really. And you can also support the initiative by becoming a volunteer and/or sign your organization up and get more information about how to organize this demonstration in your community. Let's act on science and protect our future. And to play out our broadcast from here, let's show a film about Africa on the role youth have played in climate action and how we really see them shifting from raising awareness to building solutions. It's from Crux. It's a new all-female production company. And the film is called Not Done Yet. And that's really, really true.
[02:03:30] Speaker 14: Right. So enjoy and be inspired. This is CBB reporting live at Dandora Dam site. We are currently standing on the many heaps of waste. We have officially trashed the world. Climate is changing. The droughts are droughting. Floods are flooding. The boats are ready. Soon enough, we'll struggle to get enough water to drink. Young people of the world are scared. But do not worry. The leaders of the world are working perfectly to just save the planet. For now, the authorities advise that you use your tote bags to do your groceries. But the best thing to do is you sit down, relax, and wait. Bullshit. This is Dandora. This is where I come from. They call it a dumb site. A place for all that is unwanted. But nothing really gets away. It just ends up somewhere else. Besides somebody else and other somebody else's feet. And then you watch the people who are supposed to solve it. The people I don't have all the answers. And summits, statements, strategies, multilateral institutions, and formalities had targets for tomorrow. They say we'll replace the targets they missed yesterday. Ask the experts. Ask the leaders. Ask the market, dear readers. And the man behind lecterns that appease. Please, please, please, please, please. If it is not too much trouble, stop selling our future by the barrel. So we asked. So we asked. We asked politely. We asked with posters, with petitions, with millions of bodies marching through the cities whose windows reflected us but whose walls never listened. The future, always the future, never the room, never the table, never the hand on the lever. Old enough for the consequence. Too young for the conference. And slowly we stopped asking. Not because the fire stopped, but because we stopped believing anyone was coming with water. This is where their narrative ends. The one where we beg. The one where we beg. The one where we stand at the edge of somebody else's story and ask to be written in. Fuck that. This is our story. Our camera. Our road. This is our spotlight. On young people who saw seats in a dump site. Not waiting on anyone to save the world. This is our film. And we are not done yet.
[02:06:31] Speaker 15: Coming out of the energy efficiency movement, I take away that there is a common understanding of a call for action. And it's clearly about collaboration and partnerships. And it's clearly about making sure that we have business cases that looks through the complete value end to end. So that's what I bring with me. And my call for action is really to continue to work with partnerships and connect even beyond what I managed to do today. That's my call for action.
[02:07:01] Speaker 16: So we just come out from the round table discussion. And what I really appreciate is that it's a consideration of the Montreal framework we did with the CEO round table back in June with the IEA conference on energy efficiency. And that's where we have policy makers, financial institutions, and the industries together. And my call for action here is that let's bundle up. Let's have industrial companies where we can make the business case bigger, more attractive, and then we can also come in with financial institutions, financing these packages, and then even policy makers, and make these industries moving in a better way with, for example, heat pump legislations.
[02:07:48] Speaker 17: The good news is the technology exists. And the discussion that we had today was about connecting the dots between public, private companies, industries, and then the finance. And I think everyone on the table has a solution on how to drive energy efficiency progress. And electrification is an opportunity to walk together in the same direction. When it comes to the call to action, it's about connecting the dots. It's about implementing and implementing and implementing the solutions on the technology side, on the financial side, and maintaining the stable policy environment moving forward.
[02:08:36] Speaker 18: So, Bob Henkel, President and CEO of Metris Energy, Metris is a developer and financer of large-scale sustainable energy upgrade projects. We finance and implement projects through our energy-as-a-service solution. And my main takeaway from the roundtable was the need to really have a broad-based business case for energy upgrades that go well beyond energy savings and get into the operational, financial, and sustainability benefits of projects. For example, a lot of the projects that we finance and implement involve cooling and heating system upgrades, and those benefits carry beyond energy savings and include health and safety, indoor air quality and temperature improvements that can increase productivity of workers and health and safety for everyone that's within the buildings. And in terms of a call to action, especially being here at Cobb, is to work more in terms of public-private partnerships where the investments we make are in communities, and there's ways to combine our energy-as-a-service solution with tax-exempt financing through local government authorities that can really amplify the benefits of all the projects we do.
[02:09:46] Speaker 19: My big takeaway is that we need to treat energy efficiency just like we treat the power generation. It's one part of the solution of getting more power in the system. At the same time, we need to understand that energy efficiency is a part of electrification. Because now, with the smart demand response, it can also be part of really how to make sure that we maximize the electricity systems. Finally, my takeaway is that data is becoming an increasing part of both for companies and for financial institutions to really be able to create those financial products that are so important to get scale in this. And the call to action from my side is really to start where we are today, look at the products we have. We have, for example, heating as a service, we have energy efficiency loans, and see how can we bring that forward to slightly more innovative areas. And we need to get that together and bring that to Ireland to really show that this is possible.
[02:11:00] Speaker 20: I think it was a great discussion we had just on energy efficiency. It gives a lot of hope for a policymaker because I could see the industry representatives were very much in favor of keeping energy efficiency high up on the agenda, making sure it's a part of electrification, which is now a high topic. So it has to be done smartly, the electrification, energy efficiency first, then you electrify and then go further. I think that's one important point which came up here. The second point was that there was an understanding that we need data, we need examples about the benefits of energy efficiency in terms of faster permitting, in terms of lower investment costs per unit compared to building new generations. Capacities or grids, which is all part of the transition. So there is a competitive advantage and we need to talk about that more. We need to the evidence to show that so that people understand why we think about this. And the other, a third point maybe is the multifaceted aspect of the benefits of energy efficiency. So we talk about cost benefit analysis. Those are often too narrowly looking at the costs and certainly the benefits. It's not only about climate. It is very much about resilience to crisis. It is resilience against fossil fuel price hikes. This is what energy efficiency gives you. It gives you the possibility to rely more on homegrown electricity, energy. And these are important aspects of that. And certainly one very important point, competitiveness, particularly in a place like Europe where we have high cost of labour. So we have to be efficient. We will need to be leaders on that. So many good reasons to invest in energy efficiency and keep that high up on the agenda. When we talk about electrification, when we talk about renewable energy, they are all together. They must be together. Thank you.
[02:13:12] Speaker 21: So just coming out, I've been moderating the round table where we brought together industry, finance institutions and policy makers to sit around the same table. It might take away from this session is a partnership is a new leadership. We need to collaborate. We need to sit around the same table to unlock the barriers. And we had really honest, thorough discussions of how to move the needle for investments. What I also learned is that we need to talk and tell the positive story. There are so much benefits to energy efficiency. It is a business case. You will save money, but it's also about keeping a good temperature in the house. It's about reducing the energy consumption in the industry. So you don't, you don't so exposed to the volatile energy prices. And it's also about the city itself. It might be a little bit more expensive to invest when we electrify and work with energy efficiency. But in the long term, we will be more beneficial from this, this investments. So energy efficiency, it is really the neighbor for electrification. The solutions are there. Money is there. It's now time to unlock and really implement the solutions at scale.
[02:14:31] Speaker 1: The final day of the negotiations here at COP31 is the 20th. But they might go on beyond that. We know that. I mean, history tells us this. So with us here in the studio to talk about the negotiations and also in general about his experiences from the COP is Matthias Frumeri. You're climate ambassador and head of delegations to the UNFCCC in Sweden, which is also where We Don't Have Time is founded and based. So we're delighted to have you as always, Matthias. Thank you. So Matthias, how many COPs have you attended?
[02:15:10] Speaker 22: This is my eighth.
[02:15:11] Speaker 1: Your eighth. Well, that's quite a number. What would you say sets this COP apart from other COPs you have attended?
[02:15:18] Speaker 22: I think maybe the key thing which sets this COP apart is the dual presidency for both Turkey and Australia, which has also sort of given a bit of a new dynamic to the whole COP where we're seeing this increased focus on the action agenda, which from a switch perspective, I think is really great because, you know, in the action agenda, that's where we see all the solutions, all the new initiatives coming across and highlighting results. We're already seeing across countries and regions when it comes to climate action. So I'm really glad that we're seeing this increased focus on the action agenda and also maybe how we can capture those outcomes or the results in the outcomes of the COP itself.
[02:15:56] Speaker 1: Not all of our viewers might be familiar with what the action agenda is. So can you briefly describe it?
[02:16:03] Speaker 22: Sure. So the action agenda is sort of, it's a track which is parallel to the negotiations. It was initiated a couple of years back where there was this idea of bringing in what we call non-state actors. So actors, which are not governments like local and regional governments, civil society actors, academia, business actors to provide them, give them a space within the UNFCCC to be part of the process. So not negotiating, but looking into various sectors or initiatives or presenting new research and allowing for various types of alliances or coalitions to come to be close to the process. And what we hope then is sort of that this kind of energy which we see in the action agenda will also translate into the negotiations proper.
[02:16:48] Speaker 1: Would you say it is? Well, in a way it is.
[02:16:50] Speaker 22: I mean, it's not being maybe reflected to the extent we would see, want to see in the texts themselves. But maybe that's what we can see a bit of a breakthrough here at COP31 where we're at least, you know, from a Swedish new perspective, encouraging the two COP presidencies to make that shown in the outcomes of COP31. You know, in the hopefully the cover decision as we're negotiating right now or maybe in some, you know, how they when they summarize COP31 that they will say this is what we've seen in the action agenda and this is going to help us to accelerate the transition in countries globally.
[02:17:25] Speaker 1: You sound quite hopeful and energized, Matthias. There's a lot of criticism against the COP. I mean, this is the 31st COP and emissions are still rising. What do you say to the people that are critical of the COP process?
[02:17:39] Speaker 22: Well, firstly maybe that if we wouldn't have had the COP process, if we wouldn't have had the Paris Agreement, the emissions would have been rising even quicker and even faster or even more than they are now. When we entered into the Paris Agreement in 2015, we were set on a trajectory for a four degree warming. We are now sort of at a two, two and a half degree warming. It's still far too high, but it's much better than we were in 2015. So I think that was, you know, credit to the Paris Agreement and of all parties working together to actually deliver on implementing the Paris Agreement. At the same time, we're seeing now with the reports coming out, for example, from UNEP on the emissions gap report, but also the overshoot report, that the urgency of action is even more present today than it ever has been. And that is really what we want to see as the framing also for this COP meeting. You know, we have this term called overshoot, where we will be temporarily going beyond the 1.5 degree target that we set or the limit that we set in the Paris Agreement. So we may need to make overshoot as short and shallow as possible.
[02:18:44] Speaker 1: And that is not a walk in the park.
[02:18:45] Speaker 22: That is not a walk in the park, but we know the solutions are there. So, you know, our message consistently at every COP, you know, whenever we enter into various kinds of conversations, we know the solutions are there. It is for policymakers to put in place the regulatory environments, you know, the rules and regulations that create demand for those kinds of solutions so countries can accelerate in deploying them across industry, transport, food systems, waste management and so forth.
[02:19:12] Speaker 1: So, Mattias, would you say that the sense of urgency really is there in the negotiations and how are they going?
[02:19:20] Speaker 22: Well, maybe not as much as they should be in the negotiation rooms, because I think also, you know, one reflection which we've done over the past couple of years is that as the transition accelerates and it does, you know, we're seeing also resistance, increased resistance from those who are maybe more or heavily dependent on primarily fossil fuel exports. So, you know, the quicker we will that we are accelerating, the stronger we will also be seeing that kind of resistance. So that also at least, you know, leads me to the conclusion that we need to have that kind of collaboration, you know, across countries with everyone. How can we work together? How can we strengthen that kind of collaboration in order for us all to be on that pathway to a net zero future? I mean, all countries are doing their part in this, but I think, you know, we need to recognize that for some which have a heavy dependency on fossil fuel exports, it is a more difficult pathway for them. So, you know, my approach would be, you know, strengthen collaboration with them as well to ensure that we can be diversifying their economies, you know, working together to diversify their economies also in this kind of, in the new kind of economy that we're building and that we need to build.
[02:20:33] Speaker 1: So, Matthias, what would be your major hope for breakthrough or an outcome of this COP?
[02:20:40] Speaker 22: What we're looking for is that very strong signal to markets that the transition is accelerating and that we as governments are saying, you know, we're going to be putting these policies in place to create demand for the solutions, but also that we can strengthen this kind of collaborative spirit at the COP meetings themselves. You know, for countries to come together to share experience, share solutions and see, you know, how can we strengthen that kind of collaboration in order to accelerate action on the ground nationally?
[02:21:07] Speaker 1: Well, the blockers, I mean, we have all seen those veto hands. I mean, some countries that just never take them down. How do we, how do we address this? I mean, we have the Santa Marta process. We have the treaty, the fossil fuel treaty process. We have other agendas sort of parallel to also the COP presidency roadmap agenda. So what can you say about the parallel processes and their importance here?
[02:21:29] Speaker 22: Well, I think they're becoming increasingly important because that is where also we can be highlighting these kind of positive results. I mean, we had just now, for example, Netherlands was hosting the energy transition conversation where the Swedish minister was participating as well, you know, countries coming out, speaking about the usefulness of roadmaps and how you can be working together to strengthen your economies while transitioning away from fossil fuels. So we also launched yesterday, the third iteration of something we call the leadership group for industry transition together with India, where we focus primarily on decarbonization of steel and cement, you know, and hopefully then expanding that kind of partnership. Ethiopia is also a member of lead it. So Ethiopia's next, next, next host, you know, they will also be engaged in this work. And just as another example, we're engaged in something we call the global carbon pricing challenge, which we currently chair, where we're encouraging more countries to be putting in place carbon pricing mechanisms in order also as a tool to be accelerating decarbonization of our industries.
[02:22:28] Speaker 1: So, Matthias, for those watching this and might sit in other corners of the world, say this is just meaningless. The outcome is blah, blah, blah, and nothing is really moving. Do I interpret you correctly that you say that there are so many processes happening that we might not be aware of that are really positive signals here?
[02:22:47] Speaker 22: Yeah, I would, I mean, hopefully everyone is aware, but for those who are not aware, you know, say many are just shrugging and saying this is just not a trade show. I think definitely, you know, we, I mean, I am fully aware of the kind of criticism that has been directed towards COP meetings and the large number of participants that come here. I mean, and obviously we can see there is probably ways to structure the COP meetings differently. And I mean, also from the negotiations perspective to make it even more focused on implementation. But I think the, the, the, the beauty of the COP meetings, if I may express it that way, is this enormous energy we're seeing, you know, so many different types of actors coming together and sharing these kinds of results and want to be part of this. You know, want to be collaborating, strengthening collaboration, you know, across actors, across sectors, across countries. And so if we wouldn't have this, you know, I would hope we need to, we would need to create it probably because it is really, you know, the key point during the course of the year when all of these actors are coming together to highlight the work that we've been doing, you know, setting us all on that pathway to accelerate decarbonisation.
[02:23:51] Speaker 1: So thank you, Mattias. And you were representing Sweden here and at the COP 31 as you had many previous COPs and, but this will be your last COP in this role because you've announced that you're stepping, stepping down. So what is your main takeaway from your many years here and in this role? I mean, and also maybe you have a special unexpected memory to share or reflection.
[02:24:16] Speaker 22: There are, there are so many memories and I think, you know, personally, I've been so privileged to have this role for this many, a number of years. I mean, I probably should have ended, you know, a number of, if I would have stuck to, you know, the regular rotation scheme.
[02:24:30] Speaker 1: I think many would have disagreed with that.
[02:24:32] Speaker 22: Oh, well, I mean, I think it's, it's been really privileged to be part of this and to be able to represent Sweden in a way where, you know, there's, we have such a fantastic story to share, you know, both in terms of, you know, how we address. The transition within our countries, all the various solutions that, you know, our companies can provide the engagement from our civil society actors. And how we sort of, you know, how are we structuring our economy and our society in driving the transition towards the end zero? Obviously all actors can do more, including Sweden. But I think just being part of this and being able to share that with the global partners as, you know, this is one way of doing it. Obviously others have other ways to do it, but just being part of that conversation, I think. And what, what we hopefully have been contributing with, I think over the past couple of years is also sort of to inject that opportunity perspective into the conversation here. You know, when we started out shaping our key messages on urgency and opportunity a couple of years ago, we didn't see many actors actually having that kind of approach, but now we're seeing, I think more and more actors. I mean, the urgency is obviously there, but opportunity, I think has been something which more and more actors are speaking about, you know, how the transition brings new jobs and growth, strengthens competitiveness, builds resilience in our economies. And hopefully, you know, if we've been able to contribute with that over the past couple of years, I mean, I would see that as we have done something hopefully good.
[02:26:00] Speaker 1: Well, thank you so much, Matthias. And I'm wearing a pin here today. I know you've seen it. It's called United for the Future. And you mentioned NGOs, and I mean, you mentioned also parts of society, but just try to unite a lot of people from different, all the parts, you know, corporations, companies, churches, soccer teams, to really, to really act on science. And so off camera later on, I'm going to give you a pin. And thank you for your fantastic work. I mean, we have had you on our shows many times and you've been very devoted to your work here. So thank you from the We Don't Have Time team.
[02:26:36] Speaker 22: Thank you so much.
[02:26:37] Speaker 1: Thank you.
[02:26:44] Speaker 6: Hi, I'm Stephen Moore, Head of Climate Action at the GSMA, the Industry Association for Mobile Network Operators all around the world. And I'm here at COP31 and I'm joined by Andrea. Andrea, you are the Environment Lead at Vodafone. And I wanted, you've been at COP31. You've seen a lot of different sessions. You've taken part in a lot of different sessions, both speaking and also listening as well. And I'd really love to understand what are your reflections from what you've taken part in the conversations? What are you going to be taking away? Yeah, thanks, Stephen.
[02:27:21] Speaker 7: I think, first of all, this is my first time at COP and it's quite overwhelming. I mean, like the size of COP, it's absolutely staggering. But I've been really pleasantly surprised to hear the level of conversations that have been going on, both from an intellectual perspective, like real experts in their field talking about how they're going to help address the climate crisis, both in the blue zone and in the green zone as well. I've seen civil society here really raising their voices about the urgency of the issue, reminding us in business and at the policy level that we really need to take action now. So I think that that experience has been amazing to be here for and a real reminder for us as a business that the time to act is now and that the problem solving that we need to do needs to happen urgently. So, yes, I think that's probably one of the things that I will take away with me is that feeling that we need to really push for action immediately and really keep up momentum on the plans that we've got in place and the plans that we're trying to push ambition on, continuing to push ambition on.
[02:28:29] Speaker 6: Yeah, thank you so much because we've seen a lot of ambition at previous COPs and we've also seen at the same time, there's a feeling that the implementation is perhaps or definitely not happening as quickly as we need it to. And we've also seen this parallel process being started in Santa Marta in a response to the slow pace of change here in the COP process. So what are you going to be taking away in terms of how do we move from ambition to implementation? What are the positive things perhaps that you've heard at COP or that you know are already going on?
[02:29:08] Speaker 7: Yeah, I think there are a couple of really positive messages that I've noticed. So there's been a huge amount of discussion here in Turkey about electrification. And I think that's an agenda that everybody can get behind. The business case for electrification is really clear. Renewable, clean power through electricity is something that will decarbonise industry, will decarbonise homes and transport and heat. So I think that's a really strong story. And there's some really fantastic progress that's happened with the deployment of solar, increasing wind power as well. So I think those are all really positive signs. And it feels like both government, policymakers, business, industry have all really lent in to that discussion, a huge amount of progress on that one. I've also seen progress elsewhere. And it's been a real privilege actually to hear some of the discussions going around, going on in many of the pavilions here in the Blue Zone. One of the fantastic stories that I've heard is around forests. So the coming of age of jurisdictional REDD+ and the TFFF framework, which is helping to mobilise finance for standing forests. So we've been talking about a lot of these issues for many years, but we're seeing them come to fruition in implementation right now. And I think actually that has been driven by an ambitious policy process in the past. I know that there are now, I guess, an evolution of the policy making process, as you mentioned, looking at coalitions of the willing through things like Santa Marta, rather than necessarily keeping everything within the framework of COP. However, what that has led to is, I guess, an evolution of what we need to do on implementation and action. And we're starting to see those that can push forward absolutely go ahead and do that with implementation. So that's really pleasing to see.
[02:31:08] Speaker 6: Excellent. Yeah, thank you. It's good to hear these positive signs, actually, of things that are going on at COP. And we know there's this big push for electrification. So we're really hoping to see something positive come out of that. And I think that will continue to build. And then obviously, like you say, forests as well, so important and so much progress that we need to make there in terms of protection. Restoration as well is so important. And I guess from from your point of view at Vodafone, Vodafone has a number of very progressive measures, targets looking to be net zero by 2040, which is 10 years ahead of our ambition for the whole industry. I know you're doing a lot around network resilience as well in the face of a changing climate. What will you take away for your work back at Vodafone? What will you take from visiting COP, hearing about all these experts and what's going on?
[02:32:03] Speaker 7: I think the key thing that I'll take away is holistic systems planning. So we talked about it a little bit earlier, like absolutely the need for better joined up spatial planning of the energy system, AI data centers, digital networks, connectivity. These are all one in the same thing. And we need to stop seeing those planning systems in silos, stop talking about them in silo and really come together with others across different sectors who are aiming to achieve essentially a low carbon economy, which is more electrified, more digital, smarter, driven more by intelligence and using technology in the right way to be able to solve some of the big sustainability challenges that we have. So, yeah, that's one of the really key takeaways for me. I think maybe on a more personal note, like what's been really refreshing for me as a sustainability professional is reconnecting with some of the voices that we hear from indigenous peoples, from communities who see that progress needs to be needs to be made. They want action to happen right now. But their warning is don't replace one system which is unjust with another system that has the potential to be unjust as well. So I think we really need to look at the warning signs around the social impacts of the transition. Think about just transition, how we design for communities, design for positive benefits for those who might be underrepresented in the types of conversations that we are typically part of back home in the UK or elsewhere in business forums around the world.
[02:33:43] Speaker 6: Yeah, fantastic. It's so important that this energy transition that we're going through, net zero transition, is a just transition and also that we seek to learn from communities that already live in harmony with nature and have so much that we can learn from them, like indigenous communities, as you mentioned there as well. You talked a bit about the systems change that we need to see happen. So I wanted to also ask you maybe as a final question, what you will be taking back then about what broader changes that we need to see and how kind of Vodafone your role sits in with that and how you engage with others to achieve that.
[02:34:23] Speaker 7: I think, yeah, we can't do this alone, I think is a really key point that we've always known, like individual companies need to work together with their value chains, with their supply chain partners, with governments. And that message, I think, is clearer than it has ever been, because the types of change that we need to see are in very complex systems. And we need to move multiple things around that system to make all of the puzzle pieces fall into place. So collaboration and thinking about how we align our expectations and our ambition with other parts of the system, with government and with the people that we are working with in value chains, I think is a really key and important point.
[02:35:07] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Andrea. It's so great to hear all of the positive things that you're going to be taking away from your very first COP and hopefully not your last COP. Thank you so much for joining us.
[02:35:16] Speaker 7: Thank you so much, Stephen. Thank you.
[02:35:21] Speaker 2: So we have another wonderful guest with us here. It's Kelsey Billsback. And you're the Methane and Health Initiative lead at PSE Healthy Energy. So very nice to meet you.
[02:35:34] Speaker 23: Nice to meet you too. Yeah.
[02:35:36] Speaker 2: It's your first COP, I understand?
[02:35:37] Speaker 23: Yes.
[02:35:38] Speaker 2: Do you have an experience today getting in here or was it quite challenging? Yeah.
[02:35:44] Speaker 23: It took a while to get here on the bus and the lines are a bit long yesterday, but we've made it.
[02:35:51] Cosima Cassell: Yeah.
[02:35:52] Speaker 23: Excited for great conversations. Yeah. Okay.
[02:35:56] Speaker 2: So we're very interested in methane. We've been doing a lot of shows on methane and we will do a lot of shows here on methane too. And most people are very interested in mapping methane for seeing leaks coming safe from the oil and gas industry. So they can then send an alert to a government and say, you've got a lot of methane coming out of these pipes. Why didn't you fix it? Right? For the saving of the climate. Mm-hmm. But you're mapping methane in a different way. It's for health reasons. So tell us a little bit about what this work involves. Yeah.
[02:36:30] Speaker 23: So as you mentioned, I'm our methane and health initiative lead. And so we're a nonprofit science policy research institute made up of about 40 scientists, engineers, public health professionals. And we've been studying oil and gas and air quality and health for about 10 years now. And so through this work, we've gone all over the U.S. and in certain parts of the world, and we've studied what gas is made out of. So we've taken direct gas composition samples. We've scraped regulatory documents and compiled all this information together. And what we found is that basically every gas sample that we've looked at contains at least one hazardous air pollutant. So 99% of samples have harmful compounds and 97% of samples contain benzene, which is a known human carcinogen. And so we pulled all this information together. And that has allowed us to create a comprehensive gas composition database and really understand gas composition across the oil and gas supply chain. And so using this database, we've built what we call the methane risk map. And so this takes carbon mappers, satellite, methane detections, information about emissions and the location of the event. And then we come up with a best estimate of the hazardous air pollutants that are coming out alongside those methane super emitters. And then we use a regulatory grade dispersion model to model those events and look at the number of people and number of sensitive facilities, things like childcare centers and daycares that are within that health risk area. And what we found is pretty interesting. We've modeled about 2,000 oil and gas methane super emitters in the U.S. And we found that about 98% of them pose health risks. So they exceed guidelines for concentrations of benzene and other pollutants. And so those communities living near super emitters could be potentially at risk. Yeah.
[02:38:49] Speaker 2: Okay. And there's other, you mentioned obviously the benzene, known carcinogen. The others would be things like volatile organic compounds like, I don't know, toluene or xylene. Okay. And black carbon at all in this mix from?
[02:39:06] Speaker 23: We don't look at black carbon yet. So in our map we have, yeah, some VOCs that are, we quantify them or call them hazardous air pollutants in the U.S. because they have known health impacts, but we're looking into expanding to other pollutants. Right now we're focused on venting, but flaring is another big source of black carbon and other air pollutants, things like PM 2.5. And so, yeah, we're really interested in mapping those as well. Right, right.
[02:39:41] Speaker 2: So where's the information going then? Are you sending it to local authorities, to cities? Do you send it back to the industry that's causing the methane to leak in the first place? What's happening?
[02:39:54] Speaker 23: So our map is publicly available and we publish events that are published by Carbon Mapper. We analyze them on a regular basis and continue adding new events to our tool. And we make those available to lots of different potential users. We use regulatory grade data and regulatory grade dispersion modeling so that the data can be used. So it's defensible, scientifically defensible, can be used by policymakers. Our methods are peer reviewed as well. We also have built this visualization, which allows people to look at different factors in the community. Whether people have in that community have underlying health conditions and things like that. So we make that information available to community members who might be concerned. But yeah, we put it on the public data portal. It's science backed information, defensible methods, and anyone can see that and use that information.
[02:41:03] Speaker 2: So, I mean, people can make legal challenges based on this information in defense of the communities involved, I suppose. Cities can make choices about what they want their neighbor, which might be an oil and gas installation should do. And obviously the oil and gas industry itself can look at these and say we will plug the leak so that doesn't happen. Do you ever see any successful change in behavior by either the emitters or the recipients of this data in terms of health threats to their communities?
[02:41:35] Speaker 23: It's interesting you ask that. So, one of the most impactful cases on our tool happened in Carlsbad, New Mexico, in February of 2025. And we estimated that there was about 37,000 people exposed to benzene levels that could have been harmful for their health. And there are about 44 sensitive facilities, things like childcare centers and schools that were in the health risk area. And when we published that map, it was picked up by an investigative journalist at Hunter Brook Media. And that investigation launched a regulatory investigation into the event. So, yeah, our model is to make that information publicly available so people can use it.
[02:42:25] Speaker 2: Anybody, so you mentioned the United States, you mentioned other parts of the world, but it's generally most of your work is in the USA. Do you think this is clearly a global model of raising awareness of potentially hazardous health threats from methane, from oil and gas installations, maybe even from waste tips and things like that? Are there any plans to take it globally or, I mean, where would you go from here on that? I suppose you'd have to talk to other governments and there'd be funding implications and lots of things. But it seems like something everybody should have, right?
[02:43:05] Speaker 23: Yeah, we're very interested in bringing this outside of the US. Just to mention some work we recently published earlier this year. It was a study on the level of benzene and consumer grade natural gas in places like the UK, Italy and the Netherlands. And we very interestingly found that the level of benzene was about 60 times higher in that consumer grade natural gas compared to what we saw in the US. So we really see a lot of variability place to place, which will have implications for bringing the map to other places. We've modeled a handful of events. The framework is able to be brought to other places. So it's really a matter of working with folks on the ground to bring in the data.
[02:44:00] Speaker 2: Good, Kelsey. Well, we are actually going to have a broadcast we do this week, which kind of touches a little bit on this, on this new information that's coming from, yes, from the UK, for example, in terms of a global campaign, like the global CookSave Alliance, which are trying to make people aware of the amount of health hazardous substances and methane in cooking at home on gas. And so I think the border of this discussion is expanding very fast at the moment. And so your work has obviously contributed to that. And so thank you very much for being with us. Thank you. So I'm pleased to be joined by Dexter Galvin. He's the senior vice president and climate ambassador at EcoVardis. Dexter, great to see you. And just tell us a little bit first, what is EcoVardis so that people that maybe don't know will know? Absolutely.
[02:45:05] Speaker 24: So we're the global sustainability ratings organization. We provide sustainability ratings for over 175,000 companies around the world. We also collect vast amounts of carbon data in the process. So we have emissions data from about 65,000 companies reporting into our platform as well.
[02:45:28] Speaker 2: Amazing. OK, you've done a report together with the consultancy Kearney. And this report's called better carbon data means faster scope three progress. What's that all about?
[02:45:44] Speaker 24: So there's a big challenge in the global sustainability space, which is how do we actually drive action? You know, it's a big, big topic in COP at the moment. How are we actually moving the needle? How are we driving change? Well, our contention is that the supply chain is the greatest lever to drive change. So the average company has 27 times their emissions actually beneath the surface in the supply chain. So vast majority of the company's impact is actually in the supply chain. So our contention is that companies should be taking more action to drive the change that we need to see and using the supply chain to do that. Right.
[02:46:26] Speaker 2: And when we talk supply chains is for ordinary people. Well, for the tech, the techie, the techie people, the nerds that scope three, isn't it? Emissions. And for ordinary people, it's like, okay, yeah, right. So I've got an electric car. It was built in, I don't know, France or somewhere, maybe even in Britain. But actually, it wasn't all actually coming from there because most of the parts are coming from all around the world. And then they assemble it somewhere else in another country. So it's all those parts and contributions to the making of that car from outside where it's actually put together. That's right.
[02:47:01] Speaker 24: So a lot of organizations have effectively outsourced their emissions to their supply chain. So when you think about the average consumer, they will be thinking about their purchases and the carbon involved in those purchases. But often it's not the brand name on the product that's producing those. It's actually happening upstream in their supply chain. And that's what scope three is all about. So traditionally, scope one is your direct operations. Scope two are the emissions associated with your energy consumption. And scope three used to be just everything else. But actually, the main category of scope three is purchased goods and services, which is your upstream emissions, where your suppliers are producing things.
[02:47:47] Speaker 2: Yeah, thanks very much for clearing that up. We have a very eclectic audience here. They all care about climate change and they want to understand what's happening in the world. So that's a really good explanation of how that works. So it was 56,000 companies in this report. Can you tell us first what scope three emissions are? Well, we've done that. And you also said why they're important. But the main results, let's really get to the nitty gritty here. So report reveals that companies relying on low reliability data. So companies relying on low reliability data may be underestimating their emissions from their supply chains, their scope three footprint, by 2.7 times. That's quite a lot of missed emissions, if I can put it that way, by those companies. Yeah.
[02:48:37] Speaker 24: That's right. Yeah. So traditionally, a lot of organizations will go out to their supply chain. As I said, 27 times the average company's emissions are actually in their supply chain. So a lot of organizations know that that's where their impact is. So traditionally, what they'll use is modeled data to come up with an idea of where their emissions are, what their scope three emissions look like. So they'll use basically spend based estimates to work out their scope three emissions. But that isn't very useful because a lot of that data is out of date and inaccurate. And it causes misdirected effort in the supply chain. So you can have organizations lulled into a false sense of security based on incorrect data. And actually, what we found in this report is that those companies with better data can see more of the emissions in their supply chain. It's not that they have more emissions in their supply chain. It's that they've got visibility over that blind spot. And that's really important because you can't manage what you don't measure. And if you can't see what's happening in your supply chain, you're going to be lulled into a false sense of security. And of course, as we know, in the supply chain, emissions stands for increased energy risk, increased climate risk across the board. So it's not just about accounting for your emissions. It's also about driving emissions reductions and managing risk and resilience in your supply chain. Because if you don't manage these issues properly in your supply chain, they come back and bite you in increased energy costs and increased frequency and severity of extreme weather events, which hit the supply chain and mean that you're ultimately pushing up the costs for consumers. Right.
[02:50:32] Speaker 2: And if you can get it right with the supply chain, then they're going to have lower emissions. There's going to be a lower carbon footprint. There's a lower chance of these many, many companies that are providing these parts and whatever it is to you actually being damaged by extreme weather events because you're part of a global effort to reduce climate emissions. And also they save money, presumably, especially when you have crazy things going on with oil and gas prices. So, yeah, there's a lot of benefits to be had from managing this down with good data. How do you get the data, though? How do you get the good data rather than the sort of, I wouldn't say cooked up data, that's the wrong phrase, but rather than the kind of estimated emissions?
[02:51:15] Speaker 24: So it's all about engaging the supply chain. So you've got to ask the question of suppliers. You know, the interesting thing is asking the question of your suppliers, actually engaging with your suppliers makes you six times more likely to meet your science based targets. So you have reduction goals. You're far more likely to actually meet those reduction goals if you're asking your suppliers the question and having the conversation. Why is that important? Well, if you're just using model data or estimates, your suppliers don't know that you care about this thing. They're not going to prioritize for a lot of suppliers. One, 2% of their operational spend is on energy and they're not prioritizing it. But if their biggest customer that spends 100 million quid with them is asking them to reduce their emissions, they're going to do it.
[02:52:05] Speaker 2: Absolutely. And I suppose obviously these supply chains are all around the world. They could be in countries with very different points in their economic development and different points in how, you know, maybe enthusiastic they are in terms of cutting emissions overall as nations. But within that supply chain from somewhere else in the world, there are companies that will be doing things like this because they're being asked to do it. And they can contribute perhaps to that nation's overall sense of how do you actually deal with climate change problems. I'm thinking of how they become almost ambassadors within, say, developing countries that actually you can manage down your emissions through good data and you can do your bit for climate action within your country and for the world.
[02:52:48] Speaker 24: That's right. I mean, it's strange to say it, but it could be the procurement professionals that save the world, right? These guys that are normally traditionally all about saving costs and managing quality are actually contributing to creating a global baseline where their suppliers in all different regions who maybe are on the less good end of climate action, let's say, different parts of the world that are actually still massively increasing their emissions. Well, if their big customers are telling them they need to reduce their emissions, then that creates this global baseline and helps all organizations improve their energy efficiency, start reducing emissions, deploying renewables. And so it has an incredible effect on global emissions and I think it's one of the secret weapons in our arsenal to solve climate change.
[02:53:50] Speaker 2: And maybe looking forward, how are you going to use this to advance, you know, this agenda? Where do you go from here with this, Dexter?
[02:54:02] Speaker 24: So I think more companies are going to take action on their supply chain. I think what companies are going to take away from this is that they have a big blind spot in their supply chain. They need to start talking to their suppliers, they need to start engaging with their suppliers and getting data back from their suppliers. In the research, only 4% of those 58,000 companies that we surveyed were actually getting primary data from their suppliers. So that's a real weak point across the system. So more and more companies need to take action and start talking to their suppliers. So I think companies will hear that. But I also think, you know, renewables are now in the money massively. The COP is all about electrification at the moment. I think procurement professionals are hearing that. So there's this huge opportunity to push renewables out across global corporate supply chains as well. So I think companies will be buoyed into action as a result of this data and this report.
[02:55:09] Speaker 2: And can Ecovaldis help maybe working with people like Kearney to actually communicate maybe to these 56,000 companies about, hey, guys and girls, you have to wake up a bit here on your data collection for your supply chain emissions?
[02:55:26] Speaker 24: Absolutely. I mean, so companies should leverage existing frameworks to engage their supply chains. It's really important not to reinvent the wheel. If you start asking random questions of your suppliers, your suppliers will be inundated with slightly different questions for essentially the same information. So it's really important to consolidate those asks into one ask so the supplier isn't over boarded with millions of different requests for essentially the same information. And that's where Ecovaldis can come in as one of those standardized frameworks for actually engaging the supply chain.
[02:56:06] Speaker 2: Good, Dexter. Well, it sounds really interesting. And anything that reduces emissions is important in a world that's overshooting its promises to stay within safety limits. So we really need to work even harder. And anything we've missed here in this report? Anything last words you want to say?
[02:56:24] Speaker 24: No, I think it's the scale of the problem in the supply chain. And it's not just counting emissions. It's also about building resilience, increasing resilience in terms of energy, increase price increases and extreme weather events, which are really hitting the supply chains of big corporations all around the world. And all of this is increasing prices for the consumers. So it's not just about saving the planet, it's also about building meaningful resilience into the global business system.
[02:57:00] Speaker 2: Good. Dexter, thanks very much indeed for being on We Don't Have Time. Thank you, Dick.
[02:57:11] Speaker 25: Often in spring, the competition were behind me and I have this vacation to enjoy. And even though I've been skiing a lot during the preseason and competition season, all I wanted to do is put on my skis again, because the feeling when you effortlessly can glide across the landscape and be so close to nature is something. It's hard to describe. The snow is still cold, but the sun is warming your face. And hopefully you have a bunch of friends with you and something I want to share with my children and some of my strongest core memories and when I have been most alive. I got the question from the international ski and snowboard federation to join them to talk about the future for white winters. Will it be possible to ski and do sport in the future as well? And it was a no brainer to say yes, because this is a topic that means a lot for me during my career, but it's a lot, even more after, even more after, and definitely after becoming a mother of two boys, it becomes so clear that I hope that future generation also will experience snow and winter as I have been able to do through my life. I've grew up 700 kilometers from where I now live. I thought that the sun may be the place where we have long winter as well. But in the end of my career, we don't went on snow between World Cup races in November and December. We had to put out our roller skis or search for artificial snow. And that is something that I'm really worried about. That the one who can afford to travel to the snow or the one who are able to produce snow is the one who will ski in the future. Not the easy way we had. When I grew up, it was just outside my doorstep. I'm very glad to be part of an initiative called Food for White Winters, because I think it's important that role models from the sport shows the way for others. So the concept is to show that we with our food choices can help protect the winters. So this was an initiative from Nordic Sustainability Arena. And earlier this year, we had it going live on the World Cup in Nora. So the athletes, the volunteers and some of the guests were served locally, sustainable, environmental friendly food, and show that it's both delicious, nutritious, and it can provide enough energy for athletes to perform on their top. Because when it comes to nutrition during my career, I have never compromised that it will fuel me with enough and right energy to have the top performance. Food and nutrition has been something very important for me during my career. It's when we meet and recover. And food choices we make several times a day, all the year round. So we can just put the spot on that. If you just are more conscious about your choices, you can help protect, for example, the winter and the climate. So that this is guaranteed from athletes as well. I hope that sustainable choices can be the normal choice in the future and not the exceptional ones.
[03:01:45] Speaker 2: So that's it.
[03:01:46] Speaker 25: That's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one.
[03:01:49] Speaker ?: Yeah, it's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one.
[03:01:53] Speaker 2: Yeah, that's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one.
[03:01:56] Speaker ?: Yeah.
[03:01:56] Speaker 2: That's a good one. That's a good one.
[03:01:58] Speaker ?: Yeah.
[03:01:58] Speaker 2: That's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one. Yeah. That's a good one. That's a good one. That's a good one.
[03:02:06] Speaker 26: So we're part of the Global Renewables Hub, where we partner with the Global Renewables Alliance with six industry associations tied to renewable energy, storage, and green hydrogen. And we're also with IRENA. So we're bringing data and facts and people and partnerships to promote the policies that we need to implement. I really like the energy that's here because it's about action plans. And that's what we're really trying to show is energy storage is in every conversation. Every country wants to have electrification and some type of community benefit. And we're trying to translate what that looks like for them.
[03:02:36] Speaker 2: Do you find that, obviously, countries at different parts of their development find this topic either familiar or not familiar in terms of long duration energy storage? That sometimes it's a brand new topic for them? It is. And they're like, wow. Yeah. Or it's like, no, I can't talk about this. It's too complex. Or others go, yeah, we really get it, but we need to step up our game. I mean, it must be very… It's all of the above. Yeah, right. Yes.
[03:03:01] Speaker 26: But there's common themes about the need for energy storage. But what does that look like for you? And when a lot of people are talking about flexibility, because we can talk about all this great new renewable energy coming online or into your communities. But if you want to have that work around the clock, you need energy stores. And then we talk about what policies make that happen and what financing. So we tie the money, we tie the people, we tie the projects together so that it actually looks like a real project.
[03:03:27] Speaker 2: So, I mean, the world once had fossil fuels, then it moved to renewable energy. Then we're all very happy. And then we suddenly found that actually, in some cases, we were making too much energy. Right. And we had to do something with it. What do we do? Oh, well, in that time we wasted it, right? It never went anywhere. Stranded assets. Stranded assets, yeah. And that made renewable less competitive with the fossil fuels. Now we're getting a bit better. But what's happened first was what? Batteries. Tell us about batteries. And then tell us now where you come in.
[03:03:58] Speaker 26: So it's great that we've had batteries, short duration batteries, lithium ion that are not only in cars, but now in homes and communities around the world. That scale has really helped the transition speak to what other types of energy storage are available. And so we're working with the rocks, the salts, the bricks. We're working with pumped hydro, big and small, all sizes, to really show that we have a tool that can make wind and solar work around the clock for days, weeks, months and years. And this works for industry. It works for buildings, for urban centers, agriculture. Every community can use energy storage to address whatever constraint they have. So this is why we're excited to see the important role for energy storage play.
[03:04:36] Speaker 2: So it's not theoretical. It's not hypothetical. Are there any other words? It's proven. It's deployed. Yeah. So it is being deployed. Yeah. So Australia, I know, is doing stuff with, I think it caves or caverns. Compressed air storage. Compressed air storage. Yes.
[03:04:53] Speaker 26: And vanadium flow batteries. They have a bunch of those. There we go. The United Kingdom has done an amazing job of over 160 gigawatt hours of required procurement for long duration storage. Thermal energy storage is already deployed at over 47 gigawatt hours. We're no longer talking megawatts. We're talking gigawatts, which will get us closer to the big goal of terawatt hours. Right. And all these numbers just mean that we're deploying more and more energy storage to meet the need, the growing need.
[03:05:16] Speaker 2: So, clearly it's not enough yet. Not enough yet. It needs to scale much further and much faster. Exactly. So this would be the message, one of the messages you're bringing to COP31 as you go to meetings and discussions and things like that. Yes. What do some of the poorer countries say? Do they say, well, who is going to finance this for us? Exactly. Do you have answers or would you just say the multilateral development banks are this way?
[03:05:44] Speaker 26: They do help out tremendously, but the public-private partnerships are key. Industry wants to be deployed around the world. They want to have those partnerships. They want to have customers. But they also need the incentives and market structures. And so we're working with different policy makers from countries, whether it's in Africa, East Asia, India, Latin America. We're really trying to showcase the leadership that's there to highlight the policies. So you have that regulatory certainty to bring in the money. And we can do creative deals. Like we can see the sharing of utilities that might have a very restrictive debt equity ratio. We're trying to translate this into different types of creative financing to really empower local communities to own, operate, sell, invest in energy storage. It's a long-term investment. It's been working around the world. And now we want to show that every community can value from it as well.
[03:06:31] Speaker 2: What do you make of the electrification story here? There's some tension between the phrase clean and another phrase, which I don't know what it is. Well, maybe not clean. But where do you oscillate on this topic?
[03:06:46] Speaker 26: I think it's a lot about interpretation education. Because some people, like some of us are, what does flexibility mean? What does energy storage mean? So I think it's more relative to clean, renewable energy. Can you make it work around the clock? And electrification is so important to the Global Renewables Alliance. Because this is how you bring the renewable energy target, the storage and grids target, to actually have the incentive to say, like, this is what you need to do for all industries and communities to reach the goals of decarbonization. So it does really help you get there. And I think it's really about the end goal. And I think some of the verbiage is important because it's how you interpret it. But at the same time, we have a shared in vision to have renewable energy work 24/7 around the clock, around the world.
[03:07:27] Speaker 2: So we have renewables. We have a fully functioning, flexible grid. Infrastructure. They can handle all the interconnections and things like that. And if we have short-term or short-duration energy storage and long-term energy storage, then we have the full train set.
[03:07:43] Speaker 26: You have the ecosystem that is actually really healthy when you have all the pieces working together. Yeah, okay. I like that train set.
[03:07:49] Speaker 2: Train set. Everyone get on board. We could have said Lego, but it's probably a brand that we're not allowed to mention. There are other forms of playthings for children and not just Lego. Let me state that.
[03:07:58] Speaker 26: Like wood tools, magnet tiles. There's lots of things. Exactly.
[03:08:01] Speaker 2: And the fairy animals as well we were talking about. Oh, yes, yes. Now we're getting distracted from the health. But, Julia, lovely to hear about what you're doing. Thank you. It's really important. The energy transition won't happen without it. Exactly. Not fully, anyway. Right. And we'll always be hanging on to fossil fuels, which we don't need to do if we get these kinds of systems in place. Yeah.
[03:08:21] Speaker 26: It's all about the partnerships and people behind it. That we can make this happen. That's why we're all here. We're energized because we're full of passion to make a difference.
[03:08:27] Speaker 2: Yes, yes. We've been going to COP for a long time, so we're long COP duration people, right? Yes, we are. Okay. Keep that charge going. Exactly. Exactly. Good. Well, lovely to see you and thanks so much for being with us. Thank you.
[03:08:39] Speaker 26: We don't have time. Yes, I loved it.
[03:08:41] Speaker ?: Thank you so much.
[03:08:42] Speaker 2: So we're back with another wonderful interview with another wonderful person from COP31. We're happy to welcome Ugo Bigeri, Regional Representative for Europe, Global Alliance for Banking on Values. Great to have you here, Ugo. Thank you very much. Hello, everybody. Thank you. You are right at this moment preparing for a side event, I understand, here at COP31, which is focused on banking on nature. What are you going to be talking about?
[03:09:14] Speaker 27: Yeah, we think that there is a big need of adaptation, climate adaptation, and so finance for climate adaptation. But this should be driven at the local level and nature-based solution is the best way to really have a real impact. And very often the people that live locally, they know or they can imagine what is needed for the change, for it to be adapted. And so we sometimes don't need very big infrastructure, but simply hearing from the people. And that's the most important thing, find a way to finance the adaptation measures or practice.
[03:09:53] Speaker 2: Yeah, you're absolutely right. I mean, adaptation and resilience is still somewhat the poor relation versus, say, renewable energy generating electricity, this sort of thing. But it's absolutely crucial right now in a world where we're overshooting the top safety limit of the Paris Agreement, the 1.5 degrees centigrade. We need to get more resilient and adapt more, yes?
[03:10:15] Speaker 27: Yeah, that's definitely true. We, as a bank in the Global Alliance for Banking on Values, there are all banks starting to try to finance for good. And so the idea was mitigation. We don't have to create climate change. And so most of the banks, all these banks, they don't finance oil or they finance a renewable and so on and so forth. But it's clear we have to also to adapt. And it's quite crucial because adaptation is connected with climate justice, with the protection of vulnerable people and also with the future of the area that will be most affected by climate change. So we have to move in this direction. And so we look a little bit around the world what we can do.
[03:10:59] Speaker 2: Okay. When you think about, you know, banking on nature and creating resilience that way, do you, can you imagine what kind of projects might be supported by your network of banks?
[03:11:15] Speaker 27: Yeah, we have, we have worked on research looking for, for what the bank are actually doing so they can do more, of course. And, well, we have several examples for all continents. And the main problem is that generally the adaptation is long term issues in regards of all communities. So not just private company. And so there are multiple, multiple actors who benefit from adaptation, but let's say in a very strict, no one who had to pay or want to pay in the short period. And so we have different, different example. One is, is, is from UK, three, three of those UK in a community finance the adaptation to, in order to reduce the risk of fluid floods. That's mean, yeah, taking care of wetlands, taking care of, of how you drain the water and so on and so forth. And has been financed by a blended finance project means that the government put some guarantees or some money. The local government, they put some money, the, the utilities, the local company, all they contribute to repay the loan that was used for readapt. So it was, of course, very complex to put all these actors together, but, but it's worth because it's the only way you can, you can really take care of such a long term issues. Or you can have a very stride and simple or apparently simple Centenary Bank in Uganda. They, they normally do micro credit loans for, for agriculture. And so they develop a tool say, okay, we cannot continue as the business as usual, because there will be some change. So they discuss with, with their borrower and they say, what, what, which kind of finance more you need to do what for adapt to climate change. And so they have a tool and they went now when they, this borrower alone, if there is also a part dedicated to adaptation, they also manage to offer better condition. So it's, it's, it could be very different, but the problem is to think in advance about, about adaptation. Because if we use business as usual, well, maybe they obtain the opposite effect. No, absolutely.
[03:13:32] Speaker 2: I suppose in the example with the UK, you had government guarantees, very important. You had a local authority or taking, or managing the loan and maybe the local community helped pay back part of the loan. Was that the idea? Yeah. Okay.
[03:13:50] Speaker 27: So everyone was in it together. Everyone has to pay a little bit back. Yeah. Yeah. Somebody more, somebody has to pay more, but the guarantee helps a lot.
[03:13:57] Speaker 2: Yeah, of course. Absolutely brilliant. Yeah. And how is that going to be, what you said was that you'd surveyed your members to see what they were doing. Is that right? Yes. And what happens then from there? Do you, do you engage with them and say, well, you could do more or how is it, you know, where do you get take, take this report in a sense? Yeah.
[03:14:19] Speaker 27: I think, I think it's fundamental to understand the place where you work. We are, we are, I think it's very easy and it's important to, to imagine that we try to imagine global solution, but then adaptation is not just global. It's something very local and the local people or the local ecosystem sometimes speaks to you about what, what is better to do. If you have to do drainage, if you have to do foresty, if you have to do, doesn't matter what, a lot of potential, potential solutions. So if a local bank is rooted in a community, it should have a dialogue with the community. And I don't know, for instance, one city in Canada, they, they talk with the first nation people and they, which are client and they look to help general them as a client. And so they, they make focus group and they discovered that they were very much interested in, in housing and how to adapt their, their house to the climate change. So they, they start to develop a loan in that, in that direction. If, if you don't make this effort, you can have, um, um, adverse, uh, effect because if you are not rooted in a community and, and the, the start to be a stress in the ecosystem because of the climate change. Well, the first response of traditional finance is, Oh, I stopped giving credit. Let's see what happened. So you have a credit crunch. And so climate change will create new, not bankable people. And we have to avoid this, but to avoid this, you have to, you have to really think long term. And it's also, it's not just because it's just, but if you lose client, because they are not, they become unbankable, you stop doing profit in that, in that region. So it's also, I mean, reasonable from the finance point of view to take care of long term issues connected with adaptation.
[03:16:13] Speaker 2: So, you know, we'd have time is a bit of a fan of the global Alliance for banking on values. And, uh, we, we love what you're doing because we also love people that, you know, are serious about taking action on climate change within their capacities. And, um, and I think I I've said before on this show that most, a lot of ordinary people out there who have bank accounts don't realize that within their country, there's a good chance, or there's a good chance that there will be a bank that actually is part of the global Alliance banking on values. How do they, how do they find out, you know, basically if they have a bank like that in their country or their neighborhood?
[03:16:54] Speaker 27: Well, uh, um, let's say first a good, a positive news, not all the banks who do good are in global Alliance. So there are a lot of banks who do good, but, but deciding when a bank could do good is, is a work. So you have to do really inside because there is a lot of greenwashing around. So Global Alliance for sure has bank that for, in all their portfolio, in all their activity, they try to do positive social and environmental impact. So in this sense is a guarantee. And, and I, and I suggest to look always of the whole portfolio, not just to one single, uh, project. Uh, we have a website is gabv.org and you can find the 45 members. So there are 21, 22 in Europe and, uh, another, uh, six, uh, 50 around the world. And so, yes, there are a lot, almost in any country or in many country, there is a bank who take care of us about the environment and, and, and, and, uh, social issues. And you're right. We don't think what our money do. So we may be an environmental activist and put our money in a mainstream bank who is financing actually oil extraction. We know that the financial system is still financing a lot the, uh, fossil fuels. So our mark, our money, our saving in the night, they work against our, what we do during the day. So, well, maybe it's better to be a little bit more coherent.
[03:18:23] Speaker 2: No, that's, that's a good point that you raised that because people basically need to do some work before they just automatically put their money in the bank that the, maybe their parents opened a bank account for them in a certain bank when they were teenagers, when they went to university. And they've been banking that with ever since. And they've never really looked around and seen what's available. Yeah. Very cool indeed. And, um, so, um, you are releasing, um, a white paper on this subject, uh, today, tomorrow. Um, can you tell us more about that? And, uh, yeah, finally, where our viewers can find the, the, the full report themselves if they want to know more. It's probably the same website. Yeah.
[03:19:02] Speaker 27: Same, same website to gabv.org. Yeah. And, um, well, the, the white paper is, is, is, is, has been created starting from a collaboration with the university of Florence and, uh, and also a PhD student in the university of Oxford. And they, they, they start to work, uh, on the, on these issues and they ask GBV if they were interested to work. And, uh, and in fact, was a good collaboration because so we have, we have the, the general view, overview of the, of the, what is adaptation and why adaptation is important. Also for the one who think that we have to stop climate change because, because we cannot stop what is already happened. So there will be a need of, uh, of adaptation and, um, and, uh, and so looking also what we, you can do practically at the local level. So not just at the, at the global living level, changing the rules, but at the local level. And this is important because, uh, for the very few and fast explained example I've done, it's clear that you have really to change the way you do finance. Because if we apply finance as it is to climate adaptation, we will not obtain good results. So it's something that everybody, even the savers, but, but the local authorities and the, the utilities, the, the government, and also the company who live in a, in an ecosystem. They have to understand because very often the solution could be a little bit complicated, but not impossible. And we have to measure to measure the, the, the not, not in billions. Also if billions are, we need a lot of billions. We need UNEP says we need three, 300 billion, uh, dollar a year for adaptation, but it's not just billion is also the, the real economy, the impact. So even if we have, don't have perfect measurement, we have to try to measure what we are doing. Got you. All right.
[03:21:00] Speaker 2: Um, that's really good. Ugo. Uh, we've run out of time. The show is called. We don't have time. Uh, but that's normally about, we don't have time to muck around with climate change. We need to do things. You guys are doing something really valuable and, uh, we know that adaptation is not going to be solved by your network of banks, but you are a contributor to, uh, uh, getting that, uh, moving. And I think that's, uh, that's really brilliant. So congratulations for your work and thanks for being on. We don't have time TV. Thank you very much.