About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of AI Data Centers. KILLERS of the energy transition? from Just Have a Think, published November 15, 2026. The transcript contains 2,645 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Over the last 15 years, the United States has made substantial progress in reducing the carbon emissions from its electricity system, coal-fired power stations have been closing, renewable electricity generation has expanded dramatically, and the overall carbon intensity of the American grid has..."
[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Over the last 15 years, the United States has made substantial progress in reducing the carbon emissions from its electricity system, coal-fired power stations have been closing, renewable electricity generation has expanded dramatically, and the overall carbon intensity of the American grid has fallen. But new analysis from US-based environmental group The Sierra Club suggests that much of that progress could now be undone in just a few years. Why? Well, yeah, you guessed it. It's artificial intelligence. Sierra Club's researchers project that if every one of the enormous number of data centers currently being proposed across the United States was actually built and powered by on-site fossil fuel generators, a projection that is actually highly questionable, but if hypothetically all those data centers were genuinely built, then carbon dioxide emissions from the entire US electricity grid could grow by 42% to reach 2.1 billion tonnes per year by 2030, which is an annual increase of 618 million tonnes compared with 2025 levels. So why is this happening? Is China taking a different approach? And why isn't renewable energy powering the AI revolution? Time to have a bit of a think. Hello, and welcome to Just Have a Think. The Sierra Club's latest calculations were reported by Bloomberg on the 28th of October. According to the organization's principal climate and energy advisor, Jeremy Fisher, proposed power generation for AI data centers could push US electricity emissions back towards levels not seen since about 2010. And there's a stat in here that really stood out. Apparently more than 460 million tons of the projected annual emissions could come from electricity generators that are operating outside the conventional power grid. In other words, instead of waiting for utilities to supply their enormous electricity requirements, some data center developers are literally planning to build their own fossil fuel power stations. Talk about the Wild West. There is an important caveat to the Sierra Club's projections, though, that I should probably lob in right at the start here. Just because a fossil fuel power station has been proposed doesn't mean it'll definitely get built. In fact, the International Energy Agency, or IEA, tells us that of the American gas-powered projects currently being tracked, only around 20% have begun site clearance or construction. So there's a considerable difference between the enormous pipeline of proposed fossil fuel infrastructure and what is likely to materialize, which is why the IEA's central projection is vastly lower than the Sierra Club's number, which is something we'll come to a bit later in the video. Does that mean we should dismiss the Sierra Club's warnings? I think not. Planning for worst-case scenarios is something we humans are extremely bad at, but it's something we need to learn to get much better at as the climate emergency accelerates and exponential tipping points start kicking in. Allow me to give you a little bit of comparative data to put the Sierra Club's projections into some sort of comprehensible perspective. Over here in Blighty, there's considerable ongoing controversy surrounding a proposed new oil field called Rosebank, north of Scotland, up near the Shetland Islands. In October 2025, the project's developer provided an estimate that burning all the crude oil and gas extracted from Rosebank over the field's entire 25-year operating lifetime would generate approximately 209 million tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions. Compare that with the Sierra Club's projection of 618 million tonnes of additional US electricity sector carbon dioxide emissions just in 2030 alone, almost three times the projected lifetime emissions from Rosebank, almost entirely due to data centres. I don't know about you, but I think that's a staggering comparison. So why are companies with seemingly unlimited financial resources turning to natural gas instead of renewables? Well, as far as I can establish, there seem to be three main reasons. Before we look at those, though, I need to ask for your help. Recent videos on this channel have touched on important but very contentious geopolitical issues, and as a result, those videos have been heavily suppressed by the YouTube algorithm, and many viewers have been telling me that they've actually been unsubscribed from the channel without their knowledge. As a one-man band, I do all the research, filming, animating and editing for all these videos, and my independent, non-monetised and non-sponsored content absolutely lives or dies by YouTube's subscriber numbers. Without that support from regular viewers, the algorithm starts to ignore what I do, and ultimately you don't get notified when a new video gets posted. So if you have subscribed in the past, can I ask that you just quickly check that you're still subscribed, and that you've got all notifications switched on, and if you're not yet subscribed, well, you really will be backing me personally if you could click that subscribe button. It's completely free, it gives none of your personal information away, and I absolutely promise you it will not result in any spam emails from me. So, massive thank you if you can. Right, now then, what are those three main reasons I just mentioned then? Well, the first is speed. A modern hyperscale data centre can require hundreds of megawatts of electricity. Some proposed facilities demand more than a gigawatt of power, which is roughly comparable to the output of a large conventional power station. Connecting something that big to the national grid typically involves years of waiting for transmission lines, substations, and other infrastructure to become available. Tech bros aren't known for their patience and wisdom, though, are they? So if you're Elon, or Zuck, or Sam Altman, or Jeff Bezos, or Google, or Microsoft, and you've got a national president saying, Drill, baby, drill, then you can simply flick the psychopath switch to on, ignore the environmental and climate consequences, and justify building out new gas-fired generators directly alongside your data centres by reminding everyone that you have a fiduciary responsibility to provide the best return on investment for your shareholders, which means building data centres fast and screw the longer-term consequences, or externalities, as economists like to call them. Those tech leaders will no doubt also try to point to reliability to help justify their actions. Data centres do, of course, need electricity 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. And while wind and solar are increasingly the cheapest sources of new electricity generation, we all know they don't produce electricity continuously and predictably. Batteries can do that, though, can't they? So combining renewables with batteries plus geographically distributed generation and other sources of firm, low-carbon electricity could provide the reliable power that data centres require. Oh, well, yeah, say the tech bros, but assembling that infrastructure at such enormous scale would require stuff like planning and coordination and regulations, which is, you know, a bunch of effort and, like, a real drag, man. Gas turbines are a quick fix that can produce electricity whenever it's required, provided fossil fuel supplies are available, which, of course, is something the current US administration appears very keen to ensure. The third apparent justification is commercial competition. All the big tech companies are engaged in an extraordinary race to develop ever more powerful artificial intelligence systems. God knows we hear enough about that on the news, don't we? Delaying a data centre, even by a few months, could mean losing customers, market share, and potentially billions of dollars in revenue. So from the perspective of a tech company's CEO, securing electricity quickly has become more important than minimising long-term emissions, despite the fact that many of those same technology companies have publicly committed to ambitious climate targets. Some of them even claim to match 100% of their annual electricity consumption with renewable energy purchases. But buying enough renewable electricity over the course of a year is not the same as actually operating on carbon-free electricity every hour of every day. A data centre could be drawing heavily on gas-spied electricity at night while using renewable energy certificates to balance its annual accounts. Classic economic book cooking. Now, of course, it's not just the USA that are going big on data centres, is it? We're doing our best to get involved here in Europe and over there in the People's Republic of China, just like everything else they do over there, data centres are expanding at breathtaking speed. And according to the International Energy Agency's 2025 Energy and AI Report, something like 70% of the electricity physically consumed by Chinese data centres is being generated by coal, which is an absolute f***ing disaster. But, Xi Jinping's government has put in place a programme called East Data West Computing, which aims to move suitable computing workloads away from densely populated eastern provinces towards western regions where there are already abundant wind and solar resources. The idea is that rather than transmitting enormous quantities of electricity across the country to power data centres, why not locate those data centres close to where renewable electricity is being generated? By the way, that's actually a point that's also been made here in the UK by Greg Jackson, founder and CEO of this country's largest electricity supplier, Octopus Energy. He argues that an initiative like that could significantly reduce the number of times we have to pay Scottish wind farms to switch off, otherwise known as curtailment, which is something that costs the UK taxpayer about £3 billion in 2026. But that's a whole other video in its own right. In November 2026, Inside Climate News reported on a new AI data centre campus developed by Chinese renewable energy company Envision Energy in Ulangkab, Inner Mongolia. The facility began operating in August and uses renewable electricity supplied directly to the site. Envision says its integrated electricity system combines renewable generation, batteries and advanced power electronics. The company is planning a much larger campus, potentially reaching 3 gigawatts of computing capacity by 2028, with more than 80% of its electricity coming directly from clean energy. So instead of treating renewable energy as an obstacle to rapid AI development, China is increasingly attempting to make abundant renewable electricity a competitive advantage. That doesn't make them any kind of paragon of virtue though, of course. The IEA still projects that Chinese data centres will continue consuming substantial amounts of coal generated electricity through to 2030. The encouraging news though, is that the technologies required to operate much cleaner data centres already exist. Wind, solar, hydroelectricity, geothermal energy, nuclear power and batteries can all contribute depending on local circumstances. But the TEPROS can't be allowed to simply buy an annual renewable energy certificate to assuage their guilt. They'll need to demonstrate that their facilities are genuinely supplied by low carbon electricity when they're operating. And that's not looking likely in the good old US of A any time soon. Efficiency is an important criteria here too. Data centres don't just need electricity for computing, they also need it for cooling, power conversion and other supporting equipment. Liquid cooling systems can transfer heat away from powerful processes more efficiently than conventional air cooling in suitable applications. And better thermal management can reduce the electricity consumed by supporting infrastructure. Virtually all the electricity consumed by computing equipment ultimately becomes heat. And in certain locations that heat can be recovered and using district heating networks or industrial processes potentially displacing fossil fuel heating. And theoretically, at least according to the IEA, data centres could actually help balance electricity systems by shifting suitable workloads to periods when renewable generation is abundant. In other words, some non-time critical computing tasks could run when the sun is shining or the wind is blowing with batteries providing short-term flexibility. And then of course there's the efficiency of the dreaded artificial intelligence itself. Better processes, smaller models and new software can all dramatically reduce the energy required for individual tasks. Which all sounds lovely, doesn't it? But I can just hear some of you shouting the phrase "Jevons paradox" at the screen right now. And you know, yeah, fair point. If you're not familiar with the concept, it essentially describes a situation where making a technology more efficient can actually increase its overall consumption of energy or resources, rather than reducing it, because greater efficiency makes the technology cheaper to use, which encourages people to use more of it. So although each individual task consumes less energy, the total energy consumed can end up increasing. As AI becomes cheaper and more accessible, assuming the whole thing doesn't collapse like a spontaneously deflated bubble of course, then demand could increase so rapidly that overall electricity consumption would outstrip any efficiency gains. Under the IEA's central projection, data centre demand more than doubles to approximately 945 terawatt hours by 2030, which is more electricity than the whole of Japan currently consumes in an entire year. And by 2035, the IEA reckons that number will have grown to about 1200 terawatt hours. Now, you know me folks, I do try to be straight with you about the colossal climate and environment risks our modern civilisation is bringing to bear on itself. But to be absolutely fair, I think we do have to ask ourselves whether data centres are likely to become the predominant cause of those risks. And in all honesty, the answer to that question appears to be probably not. Despite the Sierra Club's projection of an additional 618 million tonnes of CO2 emissions just in the USA by 2030, the International Energy Agency has annual carbon dioxide emissions associated with data centres across the entire planet, rising from around 180 million tonnes to 300 million tonnes by 2035. Still a big number, but well below the Sierra Club's worst case scenario and actually less than 1.5% of global energy sector emissions. Even so though, every new gas or coal-fired power station built to support a data centre is creating infrastructure that could continue producing emissions for decades. And that's just one more way that those jolly clever folks in the fossil fuel industry have found to perpetuate their highly profitable enterprises for as long as it's humanly possible. I mean, they really must have thought all their Christmases had come at once when a climate denier became US president at exactly the same time that artificial intelligence suddenly started to explode. There's a whole separate debate to be had about AI, of course. It undoubtedly has the potential to deliver enormous advances in science and medicine and engineering and energy system management and it could itself help develop better materials, facilitate grid efficiencies and accelerate the clean energy transition. Or, you know, it could wipe out humanity. And if the price of developing increasingly intelligent machines is to make our planetary life support systems progressively less stable, then maybe we need to think a bit more carefully about what intelligence actually means. But like I say, that's probably a conversation for another time. Anyway, I'm sure you have your views on data centre and greenhouse emissions. So as always, feel free to leave your thoughts in the comments section below. That's it for this week though. If you found this video useful and informative and you feel you'd like to support me to make more content like this, then the most effective way you can do that is by visiting patreon.com/justhaveathink, where for less than the price of a coffee each month, you can chat directly with me and other like-minded folks, get early access to all my videos and take part in monthly polls to shape the future direction of the channel's content. You can also support me absolutely for free by hitting the like and subscribe button right here on YouTube. Most important of all though, thanks very much for watching. Have a great week and remember to just have a think. See you next week.