My name is Ed Campy. I have the honor and the privilege of being currently the vice chair of the Martin County Board of County Commissioners, so welcome to all of you. I would like to begin by saying what a historic day. Not only are we swearing in our newest county commissioner, we will also be swearing in the longest serving county commissioner in Martin County history. So with that in mind, if you would please stand, we will have the invocation by Pastor Steve Bray. So Steve Bray will join us and ask us to pray. Would you bow your heads? Let's pray this morning. Our Heavenly Father, we come before you today with grateful hearts, recognizing that every good and perfect gift comes from you, including the privilege to live in this incredible community and the freedom to choose our own leaders. Today, as we welcome Commissioner Hurd and Commissioner-elect Collins into a new term of service, we ask for your blessing upon them and upon their work. Thank you for their willingness to serve and to make the personal sacrifice that public service requires. As they begin this new chapter, remind them that the true measure of leadership is not the power we possess, but how faithfully we serve those who are entrusted to our care. Would you grant them the insight on how to address the complex issues that will come before them and give them the grace to work together with their fellow commissioners, even when they might disagree? May they seek understanding before passing judgment and always place the well-being of the community above personal interests and sometimes even political differences. And Father, we want to pray for Martin County today. We are blessed to live in one of the most beautiful parts of this nation, but we also recognize the challenges before us. As our leaders wrestle with the pressures of growth, the protection of our waterways and natural resources, and the responsibility of providing essential services with limited resources, would you grant them wisdom to balance the needs of today with the well-being of generations yet to come? And Lord, we pray especially today that you would protect our families who live in those areas that are prone to flooding. Would you strengthen our schools, bless our businesses, watch over those who serve and protect us? May Martin County continue to be a place where families thrive, opportunities abound, and people of every generation are proud to call home. As these commissioners take up the responsibilities entrusted to them, may they lead with wisdom, serve with humility, and govern with integrity. We now commit these commissioners, their families, and the future of Martin County into your hands. In the name of Jesus Christ, we pray. Amen. Thank you, Pastor. Very much beautifully said. Now, please remain standing for our Pledge of Allegiance, which will be presented by Cheryl Lynn Scrader. I pledge allegiance. Thank you very much. Now, it's my honor to introduce a couple of our other elected officials that are in the room with us this morning. We'd begin with our Sheriff, John Butenseek, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller, Ms. Carolyn Timmon, our Tax Collector, Ruth Petrushefsky, School Board Member, Amy Pritchett, City of Stewart Mayor, Eula Clark, City of Stewart Commissioner, Laura Giobbe, the Town of Jupiter Island Mayor, Anne Scott, and from Sewell's Point, Town Manager, Bob Daniels. If there is anyone that was missed, I apologize. If you would, you can all please be seated. Oh, school board member, Dr. Brian Moriarty in the lobby. Anyone else waving? That seems to be it. Okay, let's get right into it. It's my pleasure and honor to introduce you to Chief Judge Charles Schwab. And yes, the name really is Charles Schwab. Just not that Charles Schwab. I can only tell you to buy low and sell high. Members of the board, distinguished elected officials, family, friends, fellow citizens, the privilege to be with you this morning. You know, they tell us as judges, the less said the better because in my world, it only leads to reversal. So the more you talk, the worse it is. So we'll be simple this morning. Every few years, communities across the country show up to events like this because we've elected folks to go ahead and represent us. An oath of office that's going to be administered in just a moment to both of these folks is a promise made to the public before neighbors, family, friends, fellow commissioners, and to you. That oath is the authority entrusted by the voters will be used faithfully and in service to everyone in the county, not just those who have voted for these particular individuals. As judges, we take the same type of an oath. And I can tell you that it's not just a formality, but it's a commitment, a promise that you make and one that you return to again and again. So today I have the honor of administering that oath to public servants who have answered the call to serve you, the citizens of Martin County. I'll start with bringing up Christopher Dock Collins and all the family that's with them. I think they want you folks. And I think I'm also missing... Who's holding the Bible for you? Good morning. Or other way. Other way. Other way. Happens all the time. And Commissioner-elect, if you would raise your right hand. Yes, sir. I, Christopher J. Collins. I, Christopher J. Collins. Do solemnly swear. Do solemnly swear. That I will support, protect, and defend. I will support, protect, and defend. The Constitution of the United States. The Constitution of the United States. And of the State of Florida. And of the State of Florida. That I am duly qualified to hold office. That I am duly qualified to hold office. Under the Constitution of the State. Under the Constitution of the State. And that I will well and faithfully perform. And that I will well and faithfully perform. The duties of Martin County Commissioner, District 2. The duties of Martin County Commissioner, District 2. On which I am about to enter. On which I'm about to enter. So help me God. So help me God. Congratulations. Thank you, sir. The podium over to no longer Commissioner-elect, but Commissioner Conlin. Forgive me, I had my notes here. You hanging with me, Mav? What are you doing? Today is a very important day, not because of inaugurations, but because of what today represents. Today, control of Martin County returns back to the hands of its residents. Not developers and special interest groups, but it's you who now controls Martin County's future. This election was a clear mandate for slow growth, clean water, and low taxes. You elected two that campaigned on that exactly. And with the help of my fellow commissioners, I intend to deliver that to you. Because you deserve it. You deserve to finally get what you voted for all these years. And why do I say mandate? Because of what we overcame this election. $150,000 of developer donations, relentless TV ads, social media and smear campaign mailers, all directed and distributed by PAC consultants from Tallahassee and Little Martin County. But it didn't work this time. You saw through it. And hopefully it's just the beginning. I did not take their money. So I can exclusively represent you and work every day to earn your vote. I ask you to pray for your elected officials, for staff, for the Martin County Sheriff's Office, Martin County Fire Rescue, for wisdom and grace and the right things to be done as we serve you. I'd like to take this opportunity to publicly recognize my beautiful, lovely wife, Jackie, who truly does not want recognition. And this may be her nightmare, especially that it's on closed caption TV and it's being recorded. Sorry. I don't want to make her pass out. Okay. So we really got a kick out of the election cycle as the other team speculated as to who my high-powered campaign consultants were, you know, that were helping me. Little do they know it's my very talented wife. She is full of wisdom. She is my chief strategist, my content production director, full-time mother, homeschool, full-time homemaker, and amazing wife. So somehow doing that all with grace, I don't know how you do it. But thank you, Jack. You are a gift from God. I'd also like to thank my children who are being so well-behaved. They campaigned. We often discuss policy decisions at the dinner table. You know, often they'll lobby for motions for a vote for what movie we'll be watching at movie night, all with strict Robert's Rules of Order. So truly I can say that it is our entire family who serves you. You know, and often under much pressure, they get the worst of me. So I am thankful for all of you. You are all blessings from God as well, and you are arrows in my quiver. I love you guys. And I will do my absolute best to protect this place for you and for your kiddos when you have them and really for the children of all of our families in Martin County because we live in heaven. This is paradise. We live in the greatest country in the world, in the freest state in the Union, and hands down the best of all 67 counties is Martin County. And it's why we all live here, but it's also why there's incredible pressure to develop it. But we like it and love it just the way it is. Martin County is a refuge. It is a simple life, and it is truly paradise. That said, thank you, Jesus. Thank you, Martin County voters. And now it's time to get to work. Thank you, guys. And if I can call our longest-standing commissioner to take the oath for the 700th time. And, Jeff, do you have the Bible? Yes, sir. Thank you. You all know where to stand. You've done this before. Yes. All right. Yes. And please repeat after me. I, Sarah, heard. I, Sarah, heard. Do solemnly swear. Do solemnly swear. That I will support, protect, and defend. That I will support, protect, and defend. The Constitution of the United States. The Constitution of the United States. And the State of Florida. And the State of Florida. That I am duly qualified to hold office. That I am duly qualified to hold office. Under the Constitution of the State. Under the Constitution of the State. And that I will well and faithfully perform. And that I will well and faithfully perform. The duties of Martin County Commissioner, District 4. The duties of Martin County Commissioner, District 4. On which I am about to enter. On which I am about to enter. Again. Again. So help me God. So help me God. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you. Tom, please turn your attention to the video monitors. Watching another survey line says crazy what they call progress when the oldest thing is the under construction sign. First comes the orange ribbon, then comes the bulldozer, as long as the asphalt is are all gone. Build another high. Can't rebuild what's died. Measure, measure steam. Tom. How will the children measure up? Natural lands are gone. As bins where the light. Trade that for another driveway. Stain. The estuary. Make a sound. Can't rebuild what's died. Kind of place. Get together and take a stain. Preserve it. Now's our. Elections produce opportunities, sometimes innovative ones, like one offered me this summer. Would you like to have an original song for your campaign, Sarah? Well, sure I would. And I got seven, not just one, seven of them. And they're all terrific. If you would like to hear the other six, just tune into my website, sarahheard.com, and you can listen to them there. My friend Jim Hunt was the singer, songwriter, and videographer for these songs. Jim was born and raised in Palm Beach County, but he wisely moved his family to Martin County to Hope Sound 25 years ago. Each song is distinctive, but a thread joins them all. And that thread exhorts us to cherish and to preserve and protect our natural lands and the wildlife that inhabits them. I agree with Jim. This has been one of my policy pillars since 1998. That was when we had conditions that we now call a super El Nino year, which means in part that there's much greater than normal rainfall in the dry months, in the winter months. In 1998, Herbert Hoover Dyke around Lake Okeechobee was leaky. It was very, very high. Regulators were nervous about the dyke breaching, and so nervous water managers discharged zillions of gallons of polluted water into our estuaries. And the estuaries responded. Thousands of dead and lesioned fish floated to the surface of our estuaries. The rivers were on the verge of collapse, and in my opinion, the Board of County Commissioners at that time didn't do enough to stop the discharges and to decrease the damage. At that time, there was a remarkable effort occurring, the largest ecosystem restoration project ever contemplated in the world. And it was passed into law in 2000. It's called the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan, and included in the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan was a component that would go a long way toward restoring the health of our rivers. It was called Indian River Lagoon South. Certainly, getting Indian River Lagoon South approved was going to take tireless energy and advocacy and money and time, but it was worth it. I did that hard work. And in 2007, Indian River Lagoon South was authorized into federal law by Congress. I want to recognize Maggie Herchala and Fowler West for their invaluable efforts to get this legislation passed. Since 2007, billions of state and federal dollars have flowed into Martin County to build the worthy projects contained in Indian River Lagoon South. Tens of thousands of acres of reservoirs, tens of thousands of acres of stormwater treatment areas, uh... are under construction, or have been constructed already. Uh... Water slowly goes into the reservoirs. It's passed slowly into the stormwater treatment areas, where it's treated, cleaned up, before being discharged back into the estuaries. And thanks to our generous voters, thousands of acres of natural lands have been acquired in our western Martin County to improve water quality. All these components are essential, and we are grateful for the marvelous progress. We have made in the last 25 years. Now we reach the final component of Indian River Lagoon South, and it's the most important one, muck removal. Over 100 years of punishing discharges from Lake Okeechobee have deposited over 8 million cubic yards of toxic muck on the floor of the Indian River Lagoon. This estuarine system is the most productive estuary in North America, it's the most productive marine nursery in North America, conditions exist here that don't exist anyplace else in the United States. The, uh, our subtropical climate, the perfect mixture of salty ocean water with fresh river water, the monumental depth or breadth of the Indian River Lagoon, its shallow depth, the gently curving littoral shelves, the shores that are lined with mangroves rather than trapped by concrete seawalls, and finally the crowning glory, the, uh, white sandy bottom. This is a perfect substrate for growing healthy seagrasses. The goal of Everglades restoration is not engineered repairs, it's ecosystem restoration, getting the natural system as close as humanly possible back to historic conditions. Muck removal is a final step, and now the final essential step is attainable. One of the biggest challenges in all dredging projects is finding a suitable spoil site on which to put the muck, and we now have two such suitable sites. One is from the, uh, Florida Inland Navigation District, 125 acres, and the other is right next to it. It's 125 acres that we are, that's being donated to Martin County from Mattamy Homes, the developers of, uh, Newfield Project. We often hear the message that we should leave the earth in better shape than we found it, and most of the time that's an empty platitude. In this case, it is not. We are, we have made remarkable, monumental, game-changing progress in cleaning up our rivers over the last 25 years. We have so many partners to thank. The U.S. Congress, the Army Corps of Engineers, uh, Florida Legislature, South Florida Water Management District, uh, Florida Governors, the Department of Environmental Protection, Florida Inland Navigation District, Mattamy Homes, and our residents, who have voted three times to tax themselves in order to clean up our water. So, it is my sincere pleasure to serve you for four more years. I promise to serve you with honesty, and integrity, and transparency, and accountability, and wisdom, and hopefully a fine sense of humor. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, that's it. Let's congratulate our newest member, Christopher Collins. Let's congratulate, congratulate our longest serving member, and thank all of you, not only for participating this morning, but for participating in the community that we all love. We're going to have a small reception out in the lobby for you to come and enjoy and meet the, uh, newly elected and newly re-elected, uh, sworn in. As we reset the room, we will begin the formal commission meeting at 10 a.m. Thank you so much, and God bless you all. First will be public comment at, uh, 10 o'clock, and at the conclusion of our meeting, we'll have more public comment. There are two additional items this morning. Department four is a discussion of potential funding mechanisms for residential flooding impacts. Department five is a 2026 population technical bulletin. Is there a motion to approve the agenda? Make a motion to approve. Second. I did want to ask if we could take out, um, item five for discussion. Consent five or? Consent five. Sure. There's a motion and a second to approve the agenda, not including the consent agenda. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? That motion passes unanimously. We're going to have a slightly unusual organization this morning. Uh, we're going to, first of all, have an update from Steven Layton. Sure. Good morning, commissioners. Madam Chair, newly elected. Thank you, sir. And staff. I just want to, uh, update you all on, uh, a briefing of what you tasked me with, uh, last week in regards to the flooding in Jensen and, uh, some of the things that the homeowners are, uh, still going through. Um, I've written this down so I don't miss some of them. They couldn't be here. So I'll give you the version that I gave Brian and I give him each night. Since Don, uh, reached out to me last week with the blessing of the commission, several things have ramped up. Others, quite frankly, have not moved as nearly, uh, as quickly as they should. Over the last several days, I've spent considerable time on the ground. Many of you all have as well. With these residents seeing firsthand the devastation inside their home. The exhaustion on their face and the uncertainty about what comes next. Uh, these are hardworking families, as you know, who have experienced anywhere between six inches and three foot of water inside their house. Um, their lives have been turned upside down as we approach Thanksgiving. Many of them are wondering where they are going to go and what they are going to do with their family. There's three key areas that I want to bring to your attention, uh, this morning. Accountability. How did this happen and could it happen again? Uh, the first concern is the one I hear from nearly every homeowner. How did this happen? Could it happen again? Will there be a thorough investigation or a deep dive into the circumstances surrounding this flooding to determine exactly what went wrong? Who was responsible? What steps need to be taken to ensure this never happens again? And more importantly, a line of communication between you all and the other government entities that are pumping in to that area. These residents, uh, obviously deserve answers, not just speculation. They need to understand whether the infrastructure drainage system, operational decisions, and other circumstances contributed to this flooding. Most importantly, they need to, uh, have confidence that we are doing everything possible to prevent another incident. You know, uh, this morning, I think all of us saw what apparently is going to take place in the coming days, uh, with rain as we drove here. So, I can assure you that is on their mind, and many of them are sitting here today and have that frustration. Um, we all believe there needs to be a coordinated review, transparency through this process, and a clear explanation of those findings. I've also had a conversation this morning with the new elected mayor of Port St. Lucy, and he is willing to have that dialogue with your staff and whoever becomes the chair. Recovery. Helping these residents, uh, rebuild. The second area is where, where do we go from here? Approximately 36 homes are impacted. Only three have been completely gutted and cleaned, with damaged drywall and personal belongings removed. Another 14 are partially completed and the remaining homes have little or no progress. And this is a serious concern. These residents are helping one another from sunup to sundown, after work, and when they can. With, uh, many are physically and emotionally exhausted. Some simply do not have the resources, manpower, or knowledge to navigate what comes next. They need more than a list of phone numbers. They need somebody to help walk them through the rebuilding process, which I will get to here shortly. I would encourage the county to establish a clear point of contact who can assist residents with permitting, inspections, rebuilding requirements, and coordination of available resources. The county's decision to waive permitting fees is amazing, associated with the rebuilding effort, and in a very important step moving forward, and we all appreciate that. Number three, the immediate action resources, partnerships, and the road ahead. The third area is a roadmap we have been developing for the coming, in the coming days. We've already seen some meaningful progress. Waste management has stepped up by providing dumpsters. Soon as I called Jeff Sabin, who I believe is here. Uh, he worked with your sanitation crew, who was on the ground all weekend. All of the directors in the sanitation were out there. It wasn't like they were in trucks. They were physically there, helping with the dumpsters and the grapple trucks, removing the items that volunteers put in. Uh, community organizations, volunteers, the churches, the private sector partners have also begun stepping up. Uh, through 25 United, we are working to help coordinate additional manpower, um, as this rain and these other events continue to move forward and as mold continues to build. We need to organize a house-by-house assessment of what remains to be done, what resources are available from the county, the state, and the federal government, and which residents need immediate assistance. We also need to ensure that cleanup and rebuilding are done properly, particularly when it comes to water damage and mold prevention and safety. Roadmap ahead, coordinating with Project Lift. And, uh, I don't know if Bob Zacchio is in the room, but every time that I get tasked with this or as a community is in devastation, he steps up. So, he is committed to 150 to 180 volunteers per day starting in the morning to come and help eradicate what I just went through. Home assessment, identifying which homes have been completed or particularly completed, uh, with significant cleanup. Dupree removal, continuing to coordinate the dumpsters and the grapple trucks. I would ask if we can have dumpsters in each driveway. You know, it's very difficult to clean out a house and walk three driveways down with a little bit of load. You do that ten times, you're exhausted. If there's a dumpster in each driveway, uh, and as that gets filled, your team is already standing by with the grapple trucks to eradicate that dumpster or clean it out. That would be a help, uh, tremendously. Rebuilding, uh, providing residents with a clear guidance on inspections permitting and mold modification and reconstruction. Uh, I asked Don, uh, and for those at home, Don Donaldson, your county administrator, if he could task the building department to have some people come out and just simply educate these homeowners on what they can and can't do and what is a good step moving forward. You know, they have outlets that the water was a foot and a half above them. Does that outlet need to be replaced? I think we have the answer to that, but how about the, the, the toilets? You know, the water was over the toilets. Those are things that if, uh, your building department could send some people out there and just give them some one-on-one care and guidance and a little bit of, of love. You know, we always think of inspectors coming in our house or taking photos. The next thing you know, you get a slip that says you got to shut down. I would ask for a little bit of kindness, a little bit of gentleness with them. Um, I reiterate, they're exhausted, they're tired, and they just need some, some real, some real help. Uh, I also want to recognize the resource center established at Hoke Library. It's an important resource, uh, and we need to ensure that all of these families are connected to that. I don't know how that can happen here, but that is something that continues to come up with. Uh, what I'm asking of you all, the accountability, coordinating, and independent review of what happened. Second, dedicated recovery efforts. Someone within the county needs to help with these families and navigate. You know, I don't know, United Way has been a, uh, a spectacular asset on the ground. They helped with storage, temporary. I also have Armalini, uh, containerization, who they are going to bring a hard container and put it in front of every driveway of, of the ones that want it. But, you know, you can't have a container in your driveway after a certain couple days and code enforcement. I would just ask you guys to waive whatever that is in that area so we can get a container. You know, as drywall starts to come in, because I'm trying to work with a national distributor for that. Uh, and, uh, Jetsons is willing to work with every homeowner and, and do things that almost cost. They can buy that refrigerator and put it in that container. Uh, they have nowhere to put these things, especially as this construction process goes along. And so, uh, dumpster in the front yard, a container for them to put their, their belongings or what's left, um, would be significant. And tonight, we have, uh, put together a meeting tonight with just the homeowners, with your team, with Anthony Bona, who is in Tallahassee. Uh, his team, I believe the gentleman, uh, is going to be working for him. And I say that because apparently the speaker has to sign off on their employees and that is being done today or tomorrow. Anthony will be back on the ground here tomorrow to start speaking to them on a state side. I've also, uh, asked him to task the health department to come in and, and help them identify that water that we see in the swells. Is it safe? Is it dirty? I think we all know you all have been there. Uh, the swimming pools is a big issue for each of them. Um, Travis with A and G pool said that he will come and help, uh, establish a, uh, a platform that they can start to clean those pools and, and get the water out of there. But the health department to come in and, and just like we did in Jensen when I was moving the algae, uh, take a sampling of that air quality, go into the homes, do the same thing. And then a little bit of sampling of the water out that is coming up and down the street. I believe that's it. And if you all have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. I'm not going to be here all morning. I'm going back up there. We, we have 13 total affected areas in our congressional district. Um, but, um, that is about it. Thank you. Questions for Mr. Layton. Not a question, just a thank you. Thank you very much. I know when you started this in Hope Heights several years ago, we didn't realize that was going to be sort of like a tutorial for what can come. Um, I think the residents of, I know they appreciate sort of our staff has been very, uh, really remarkable, but to have you and the resources that you just mentioned, very few people would be able to pull it off. So thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Vargas. I wanted to say thank you very much. Also, Mr. Layton. Um, I had a long conversation with our county manager and, um, I have been very, very hopeful that we could start turning the tide on this sooner than later. However, it is a monumental task. And with that said, I did have a conversation last evening with Dr. Steven Hatfield. Who is he? He is a physician and a biomedical researcher. He's focused on infectious diseases, biodefense, and pandemic preparedness. Uh, he was a former chief medical officer with ASPR, which stands for Administration for Strategic Preparedness and Response. And that leads the federal medical public health preparedness and response to pandemics, biological threats, disasters, and other health emergencies. It's part of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. And by that saying, we have new director, John Knox, who will be the department director of FEMA. He will be coming into office November 30th. And he is going to petition personally for President Trump to declare our area a disaster. Uh, also, Dr. Hatfield is reaching out to the Surgeon General of Florida, Dr. Joseph Latipo, uh, to also look here in Martin County and see what has happened, not just here, but also on the other Treasure Coast areas. So we are working behind the scenes feverishly to get national attention for what has happened in Jensen Beach. Thank you. And I would just echo, Brian has had, and I, Brian, uh, your congressman, uh, who I work for, and, uh, you know, some people were like, you know, you're not dressed in a suit and tie. Obviously, you can't be in a suit and tie and be in the middle of what's going on in our, our community. Has had these conversations, not only with the acting FEMA director, uh, but getting that pushed through. So I would encourage all of those people to come. Just, you know, I would encourage them also to understand that these people are hurting and they don't need to come in a suit and tie. You know, or in a doctor's outfit, they need to give them some real answers. And I think that not only here, St. Lucie West tradition, other areas that we have affected. So, uh, I would encourage whoever that is, and I'm happy to meet with them when they, when they can. And my team, uh, the congressional office is on the ground in each of these every day. So if there's any other things that these residents or anybody else is watching that's been affected by it, please reach out. So thank you. Thank you. Is that it? That is it. Wonderful. Thank you. Thanks. I'm going to take up a portion of public comment right now, commissioners, because I want their, I want to, the people who are flooded in Jensen Beach need to get home to continue, uh, fixing their homes. So I'll take the, uh, request to speak form, the forms that I have from Jensen Beach members. I have a big stack of, of, uh, other people who want to speak to us. Do you want to have reorganization before or after public comment? I'd say reorganization after. I think public comment is, uh, important today. So here we go. Uh, the first request to speak form I have is from Lisa French, followed by Alicia Dixon. Hi, I'm Lisa French. I live at 4252 Northeast Cherry Drive. Um, to piggyback on what Steven said with people coming in and give us, you know, where to go and direction. We, you know, you have to remember we don't have the funds, even if you give us direction. Um, I know my neighbors and Steven are going to hit a lot of points. Like, FEMA's still not with us. Um, I'm going to talk about something different because of people that have been on the ground. You've seen us in our tent and our organization. And we know now there's five houses cleaned. My husband's there at 630 today. So I just want to talk about something different because I, my neighbors are going to take the rest. Um, we're tired since we've been able to get back in our neighborhoods. We've been working from the first thing to the end. Um, my husband and I leave at like six, six or 7 PM. We go to the houses, see what's next, see where we're going to send the volunteers. Uh, and keep in mind that our house still needs work and we lost our home and everything. Um, I'm exhausted. I don't want to come to these Tuesday meetings anymore. Uh, I miss my kids. I miss being with them. I miss sitting at the kitchen table and eating dinner with them. Um, I really enjoy our breakfast together. Uh, I want to spend time with my husband on his days off when he has a, a big Kelly week conversation instead of, you know, us directing volunteers on where to go for this disaster. Cause it's, it's been just us and our neighborhood and our community. Um, you know, we all want our, our lives back. We have lawyers calling us saying that we could get $200,000 for each house and to please sign up for them. Um, and you know, it'd be just easy to sue, but for us, we are, we're tired. This has been going on for a long time. We don't want to sue. We just want somebody to step up and help us. Um, we don't want to spend years fighting in court. We all know what's right from wrong. And I feel like we all know something is very wrong here and we just need somebody to step up. Um, so I want to ask each of you something. What if I was your daughter or your sister, would you fight for me? Or would you tell me to, to go ahead and take ship the $25,000 and then get a lawyer right now and leave me hanging? I really hope you all step up and do what's right. Uh, thank you all for who's, you know, coming out and cleaning with us. That's been amazing to see. Um, you know, we, we don't have weeks or months or years to wait for some type of funding as a community. We already have, you know, five houses ready to rebuild. We just need the funding. Um, we're gutting homes. We have our tent. We're doing everything together, but we can't, we can't rebuild two entire neighborhoods on donations and volunteers. Uh, we asked for help before our homes flooded. We asked while the water was rising and we are here two weeks later still asking. You all are bigger than this. You have the resources, connections, and the ability to help us move forward. We have done our part. We've shown up for each other every single day. Now we're asking you to please show up for us. Thank you. Thank you. Alicia Dixon is next, followed by Jacqueline Blake. Good morning, everyone. First, I would like to apologize to Commissioner Vargas. I'm a woman that is trying to live the life that God has destined me to live, to be a servant. And I haven't been resting well because I have a conscience. And the scripture that I'm going to give you is from Proverbs 15 and five. A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger. The people of Jensen Beach are very angry. And my dad always say, it's not what you say, it's how you say it. We have to use a tone that is soothing to the situation that's going on. I know a lot of you have positions, Commissioner 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. But this is a community. When you took an oath, a pledge to be commissioners, it wasn't for District 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5. It was for your communities. When the taxpayer pay their money, they pay it into one community. And it's dispersed out. I feel as though as commissioners, the money that you allocate for certain projects now needs to be reorganized to help the families in need. Washington is showing us they're not stepping up. We're waiting on the president to make a decision with a stroke of a pen that he could have done two weeks ago. He hasn't done it. I'm not mad at him, but I'm looking at the whole totality of the situation. Martin County has the ability to show other communities that we can do it without your help. So let's revamp that vote for the pub for $4.5 million. You guys re-vote that because it didn't just take Ms. Vargas' vote. It took four other people to agree with her. So I can't put the blame on her for getting that money approved. I have to say everyone has a part in that. There are other projects that are coming up that all of you have to vote on. But first and foremost, I want you to vote on the people of your community and how you can help the people of Jensen Beach from Skyline Drive, Highland, and Savannah Road, Tick Ridge, and Mars Hill because they need the help. I'm okay. I have a faith that moves mountains. My house was flooded. They don't even know that. I live in Port St. Lucie. My house was flooded. This petty stuff is petty to me because it's materialistic that can be replaced. But these people's emotions and their livelihood cannot. Please help them. Thank you. Jacqueline Blake is next, followed by Alicia Gibbs. This is not about Jensen Beach, and I'm sorry. You're just speaking to the microphone. The microphone, please. My name is Jacqueline Blake. My address is 3261 Southwest Boblink Way, Palm City. That was a hard act to follow. Just when experts are recommending slowing down AI because they're not even confident enough research has been completed to know where this is leading, this project has been fast-tracked when all others have been vetted, will have been vetted over the next year to study the positives and the negatives of such a large-scale project. This is projected to be very close to South Fork High School, where, coincidentally, my granddaughter attends, and other new development in the area. Martin County has worked tirelessly to make sure our water is a top priority, and this project requires huge amounts of water to cool down the equipment. The humming noise created by such a facility would be a disturbance to students and homes in the area. Local governments have the authority to zone, permit, restrict, or reject data center developments. There has been little public disclosure of this project. Governor DeSantis signed into law the ability to regulate the rapid growth of large-scale data centers. I would respectfully request commissioners just say no to this project and add this proposal to those you are studying in the moratorium after thorough research. Find a better location that is not so close to school or new development, which would hurt their property values. In closing, I did not use AI to write this. Alicia Gibbs is next, followed by Nicholas Berkley. Good morning, commissioners, and congratulations to new elect. Good morning, everybody. My name is Alicia Gibbs. I am a Jensen Beach local. I am here to talk about the Cantor Highway AI data center. I am not here with a motion. I am here with the record. I want the arrangement made clear before I completely start talking about this data center. You guys are all public servants. Our taxes pay your salaries and keep the lights on in this building for you guys to come to work every single day. You guys made a promise under oath to protect and serve the locals in your district, each and every one of you. Now, it belongs to me. It belongs to the people that are sitting behind me, that are fighting every single day against the injustice that you guys bring to the table for us. This AI data center will poison our children's water. They go to school eight hours a day, five days a week, right across the street from this. This is within half a mile. There has been no studies showing infrastructure damage to development. There is also South Fork High School, just like she said. There are new developments being put up in this area, and yesterday I had my feet on the ground witnessing actual living habitat on this proposed 84 acres. Rosea spoonbills feeding in their flock. I also saw great blue herons and other sandhill cranes that are legally labeled endangered species. There is a sandhill crane crossing sign directly posted from the notice of development structure. You can't even read what is proposed to be developed there without trespassing on the property. I think that is unfair because as a citizen, it is our right to stay informed about what is going on in our backyard. You guys, one of you, and I will not name her, but one of you had to recuse herself on the vote on this moratorium because she works with Indian Town's own data center being built, and I absolutely think that's abhorrent. Now, another point that I would like to talk on. I would like to mention Pequa Ohio replaced three of their county commissioners and their mayor based off of the AI data center that was being proposed to be built there. The people spoke up, and I am here to remind you who you work for. You work for me. You work for them. This is our children. This is our wildlife. I say you vote no. There is no chance that this AI data center brings in any revenue for Martin County. Tax exemptions exist for businesses like this, and AI data center is all equipment. They will be paying less than 1% of property tax to this county. That landfall, that all falls on us. These locals that are living next door will have to pick up that residual tax that they will not be paying to this county. Last thing I want to say, there is no dominion without tending, okay? That comes from the book of Genesis. I am a God-fearing citizen, and these people had a right to know what was going on right across from their homes. Thank you. Nicholas Berkeley is next, followed by Elora McPherson. Well, okay. Good morning. I'm not here to talk about data centers or things that take up lots of water, but I am talking about our community, which is under lots of water right now, or at least threatened with that once again. So, I'm here to talk about my neighbors. I live in Jensen Beach. I live at 4180 Northeast Savannah Road. And we've had water on our property for the last two weeks. And I need to talk about our neighbors. These are people who are hurting. These are people who have lost it all, and we need to come together as a community to help these people. So, for my first point here, we're going to talk about these working families that we have. This community is made up of working families. We have teachers. We have landscapers. We have HVAC techs, boat builders, contractors, firemen, the whole nine yards, everybody. These are people who make up the fabric of this community here in Jensen Beach. And they work hard, they pay their taxes, and they've spent years building a life. And now that is under destruction. These people are hurting. I had a neighbor that said, I feel like God is punishing us. Now, that is not okay. These are people who are, they feel lost. They feel just totally without anything. I've been spending days helping them with gutting their homes. We're talking about total and complete gut jobs from floor to ceiling because they sat with water filled with sewage in their home for eight to ten days. This is not okay. We didn't live in a flood zone. It's, I mean, I understand Florida is low. I get it. But where our homes are sitting at, we did not think under any reasonable circumstance that we would need flood insurance. And so most people don't have coverage. The cost of doing these repairs is an unreasonable burden for these citizens to bear. I'm sorry. But it's not just for low and moderate income people, but for any single person. And we stand here today talking about SHIP and what we're going to do to help people. And I'm going to be honest. It needs to help everyone. Because whether you make under a certain amount or a threshold as a family, you should be able to get some sort of help and some sort of assistance. We're talking about hundreds of thousands of dollars in some of these homes. Floor to ceiling drywall. All new appliances. All new bathrooms. Flooring. Everything. It just needs to go. So we need answers for my second point. We need answers and we need drainage solutions. We can't have something right now. I get it. But we can have pumps. We can have all these things that are in place. The county has done an excellent job. Jim has done an excellent job with working with the community on trying to make us feel a little bit at ease. But I'm afraid that, you know, this is not going to work. We've got the ground is saturated. God only knows how high that that water is going to come. If water comes in from the savannas again, we're done. So we need to. So we do need solutions for this upstream and downstream. We need to to call the development. We cannot continue with all of this development. And we need to know what we can do to prevent this from happening again and make these systems work correctly. I mentioned before talking about the weir and other drainage structures that are in place with the savannas. That needs to be fixed and solved. But we have to understand these aren't people that are looking for a handout. These are people who need a chance to recover and get back to where they were in our society, which is already stacked against families. Your time is up. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Laura McPherson is next, followed by Anthony Weisbecker. Hello, Commissioners. How are you? Nice to see you again. Commissioner Collins, congratulations. Excited to have you. Campy, nice to see you. Thank you for visiting our flood neighborhood. We really appreciate it. Heard, nice to see you again. Commissioner Blakes Vargas, my name is Laura McPherson. I am one of the founders of Quit Messing with Jensen. I am here to rally my community. If you don't know me, you're going to know me very well. I rallied the community to fight a development. We won. It was a huge success. Nobody thought that we would win, but we did. Now, with the recent flooding, it's been brought to my attention that nothing was organized. So, me and my counterparts decided to team up and rally our community. We have been down on the grounds, boots on the ground. We've been reaching out to nonprofits, churches, services, companies that can help rebuild. We've been helping clean up. We are having a fundraiser on the 25th. I brought papers that I would like to distribute to you, if that's okay. You can hand the flyer out to everybody. I request and I expect your guys' presence at this fundraiser. Since I'm not seeing much fun being raised, we have people that have been traumatized by this flooding. They're hurting, and they don't feel heard. Only one commissioner has visited this neighborhood. This has all been rallied by us as community members. And I am here for my community, but I am begging you. We need to see more of you guys. We need to see more of you on the ground. You are our advocates. There is only so much that we can do to raise funds. That is what you're here for. You must find money for these people. They have to rebuild everything. They are completely devastated. They're exhausted. I am here to be their voice. We need more help. We need more news coverage. We need more from you guys. More advocating for us. We cannot do this on our own. We trust you. We elect you. Please, please fight for us. Show us how much you care. We need you. These people need you. Me and my friend Ange have been working tirelessly. We've had the worst sickness. My daughter has a high fever. I'm still here. We need your help. Please find funds for these people. Please get more coverage on this. Please start showing up. Eileen, we need more than a PR stunt from you. Get your boots on and get on the ground. I'm Elora. We need help. Let's go. Be strong, everybody. Thank you. Anthony Weisbecker is next, followed by Mary Berner. Break on you. He's strong. Would you please introduce yourself? Well, folks, here we are again. Anthony Weisbecker, 4306 Northeast High Line. That's him. This is the third time. Probably the fourth time we've been flooded to a point. Never to this extreme. I've been talking to the commissioner every time, and I've gotten literally nowhere. You know, our previous commissioner took Ms. Fargus' seat. It was pretty useless to any problems that might have arisen from all this flooding. Last time it rose, we had it within an inch of coming in the house. It was lapping out our front door. We didn't have cars coming down the road in fear of it coming in the house. We were in pretty good shape until, finally, Fort Pierce and St. Lucie County decided to open up their gates and literally destroyed us. And you could watch the water rise. I can't. Sorry. It's very hurtful for him. You know, it's just we've been fighting this for so long, and we've lost everything. I mean, we have 60 years of our life, our kids, everything, great kids. We have nothing left. It's all gone, and we're not young people. We just can't get out there to do it. I've been working daily with our neighbors helping me, cleaning out other people's office. We're just exhausted. We're just tired. And he physically can't do anything. It's just killing him. But thank you. I appreciate it. Whatever you can do, please. The neighbors we do have are instrumental in helping us do what we could because we're both handicapped. And it stinks. It really does. And it's not over. And it don't look like it's going to be over for quite a while because we don't have the funds in order to initiate any fast movement of anybody. You know, we're picking and choosing what's going on. It's such a shame, you know. People just don't know what it's like to work off of Social Security. And I don't know what to tell you guys. Every time I've been here, it's fallen on deaf ears. So I hope it isn't this case. We need lots of funds. I don't mean little funds. $20,000. That's tax money as far as sales tax money for all I concern. We have really got to step up and start handing out some big paychecks in order to try and get the place back together again. And aside from that, what are we going to do to prevent this from happening? Again, it's going to happen again. It's going to follow just like it just has. It's going to go the same route, no doubt. You won't be able to stop Port St. Lucie, it seems like to me. Because they stopped it temporarily. And all of a sudden, it wasn't long enough. But yeah, I got to go. All right. Have a good day, folks. Thank you. Mary Berner is next, followed by Gail Rader. Good morning, Commissioners. My name is Mary Berner. And as I said in the last meeting, I have lived in my home on Highline Drive for 40 years. For 40 years, that home was our security, our sanctuary, the place where we built our lives. Today, it is gutted to the studs. I am speaking not only for my family, but for the more than 30 plus families in our community whose lives have been devastated. We understand that Martin County experienced extraordinary rainfall, but rainfall alone does not answer the questions we have repeatedly asked about water management, pumping decisions, and why our neighborhood remained flooded for so long. At our first community meeting at Barbecue Barron Company, the public works director acknowledged that pumping water into our street contributed to the flooding. He also referenced on a phone call with me and others that drone footage was reportedly showing water being discharged from St. Lucie into the savannas despite warnings against that. However, this was not mentioned once at the last board meeting. We only heard about record rainfall. Where is the investigation? Who authorized these decisions? What impact did they have on our homes? And when will residents receive documented answers? Has a substantial damage assessment been done yet on any of our homes? If not, when will this happen? Are our homes even safe to go back into? Our homes sat in flood water and raw sewage for nearly two weeks. We received no meaningful warning. Struggled to obtain emergency assistance and watched our belongings and decades of memories deteriorate. Church volunteers have now helped tear apart our homes. We are grateful for their extraordinary generosity. But volunteers should not have to fill the gaps left by a disaster response. And homeowners should not be left wondering how they will afford to rebuild. Why is one of the wealthiest counties in the state relying on churches and volunteer organizations? However, thank you, Ed Campi, who personally helped clean out my house and promised me we wouldn't be forgotten. You showed your character and what it means to be a leader. I sadly can't say the same for you, Mrs. Vargas. Couldn't you at least hand out waters? Anything? Have you even been to our street yet? At the last meeting, we were told there was no emergency fund available to assist us. Yet we also heard discussion of this approximately $5.2 million allocated toward rebuilding a beachfront cafe. I recognize that funding may have restrictions, but I ask this board, have you explored whether any of those funds can legally be redirected, reallocated, or replaced with another funding source? Ma'am, your time is up. I'll speak for my husband now, who couldn't be here. Because if millions of dollars can be found to rebuild a public amenity, surely every possible avenue should be explored to help families rebuild their home. Even insurance does not erase losses. It comes with deductibles, exclusions, limits, and expenses we may never recover. Why should the financial burden fall entirely on residents when serious questions remain about government water management decisions and excessive development contribute to the destruction of our community? We are not asking for charity. We want accountability, transparency, and meaningful financial assistance for each household affected. Today, I ask this board for three commitments. An independent review of the flooding and pumping decisions. A written explanation of available funding options from this county, not an 800 number, to an organization that you have to be low income qualified. And including those funding options from this county and a specific timeline for some action. Please do not send us away with another promise to look into it again. Our homes have been torn apart. Our finances are uncertain. Our lives are on hold. We cannot afford to wait indefinitely for answers. We did not make the decisions that directed this water to our street when we were all asleep. We should not be left alone to pay for their consequences. Gail Rader is next, followed by Maureen Keelian. Commissioners, and congratulations to the new commissioners. My name is Gail Rader. I live at 2091 Northwest Golden Oak Trail in Jensen Beach. I've been there for five years now. I've had a second home for many, many years, 27 years to be exact, in Martin County. And we moved down five years ago. So that you know my background, I'm an adult nurse practitioner. I'm a certified Red Cross shelter manager. And I still do Office of Emergency Management work for my hometown back in Hunterdon County, New Jersey. So I'm well aware of the situation that's gone on here. I'd like to share one very personal story. Five years ago, when I moved down, my daughter decided to come. She rented a house on the corner of Carroll Street and Sherry, which was flooded this past two weeks. And my granddaughter came down and her dog got out. I want you to know that those people in that community that are currently flooded spend day and night with us looking for a dog. It took two weeks. They didn't stop, and they found the dog. I want you to know that as soon as the flood started, our church, Trinity United Methodist Church in Jensen Beach, located on Savannah Boulevard, jumped in. We offered these people cooling center, electric. We started bringing water and food. I am now, and I brought my phone. There are seven of us, and you just heard several of these gals speak. They are heroines. We put together a text group. Every day, day and night, our text goes off. What supplies do we need? How many sandwiches to feed people? Steve got up, and he gave a very nice presentation, and now we're going to have between 150 and 180 volunteers to feed. I'll be bringing 30 lunches tomorrow. We are bringing juice and drinks. We've brought the Weisbackers who spoke. We brought them bubble wrap and containers. There's so much need, and as late as last night, my phone was going off, and today as I came here and I'm going back to my church, Holly Creek had supplies they were worried about now additional flooding, and we're bringing that there because we don't want the supplies to get flooded. There is so much need. I am begging you, please, please, these people have lost everything. They don't have flood insurance. They're just nice people. They're wonderful people with kind hearts. You have to help them financially. They don't have flood insurance, and come on. We all have house insurance, and we all know what that means if you don't have flood insurance. I'm begging you, please, please help these wonderful people. It's the holiday. Reach into your hearts. Our church is willing. We got together. We're willing to be a point of distribution. I'll finish in one second, and I gave Ms. Vargas my card as well. Anything that we can do because this is going to happen again. Something else is going to happen, and our community is all of us, and we need to help each other, and thank you so much. I appreciate everything you've done, and please, please, we need help. Thank you. Maureen Killian is next, followed by Kyla Shea. Good morning. My name is Maureen Killian. I'm a District 1 constituent and a resident that was, like, flooded in Holly Creek also. You've heard from the residents here, the flooded families, including mine. The crisis revealed that Martin County was not prepared. When homes flooded, Martin County had no temporary shelter to open and no year-round shelter to send anyone to. After spending a few hours myself on Highline Drive and well over 10 hours in my own community, it is very apparent that for house people, we're lacking too. With more heavy rain on the way, residents received a phone and a text flood alerts this week. That was a real step forward. I appreciate that personally. Thank you for listening. But the alert tells people to get to safety. Where does that go? Where do you go? Is not having a shelter now a legal liability? House Bill 1365 has been lost since 2024. Banned sleeping in public. Two years later, Martin County still has no designated site and no funded shelter. The need is growing. 77 homes flooded and 24 were destroyed. Martin County's homeless count is rising. Tent City Helpers has been here. Yaya Purvita, Sephra, and others have asked eight times, now nine, since January 2025. The budget shows the choice. The reactive budget versus proactive budget. Public safety and the sheriff get $256 million. Human services and housing, $147,000 to deal with just this now? This year's budget is not a hand up, it's a hand down. This is not an oversight. They're decisions made with full knowledge of the need. Stable housing is prevention. Without it, mental health and addiction crisis ends up in our jail and in our ERs instead of recovery. Our flooded families who had homes just got a glimpse of what our unhoused neighbors live with every day. A county with nowhere to send them and a budget with nothing set aside for their most basic needs. Please, we ask the board to set aside funds for emergency and year-round shelter. Designate a temporary site that meets House Bill 1365. Put it on the agenda. Adopt a disaster sheltering plan so that the next storm does not catch us unprepared again. And I'm still waiting on the report on how many unhoused people were reached during the storm and how many were arrested or trespassed. Michael Jackson sang a song. If you want to make the world a better place, take a look at yourself and make that change. Commissioners, look at this budget and make that change. Thank you. Kyla Shea is next, followed by Roman P., who will pronounce your name properly when you... Okay. Good morning, Commissioners. Good morning. My name is Kyla Shea. It's been a while since I decided to visit you all. I'm the president of Trailside Homeowners Association. We're south of Bridge Road, west of Pratt Whitney. I'm going to start out by saying everyone keeps saying we had an unbelievable amount of rain. I've lived at Trailside for 20 years. We had 29 inches of rain in this last event. The largest we've ever had in one event was 37 inches, and we handled that. Our pastures were wet for two, three days. It was fine. We're not fine. We're left without any meaningful assistance. We flooded that our lots, our roads were underwater. The houses were out of the water. Buildings, cattles. I waded through waist-deep water to pick calves out of fields. There was no place to put them. We put them on driveways. We put them with cattle panels around houses, trying to keep them out of swimming pools that had overflowed. Our fields remain underwater. The pastures have been or will be destroyed. The grass cannot sit under two weeks of water. Some of these lots were three to four feet deep, and they remain that deep. Our canals have drained a little bit, but not enough. Our land, this is our agricultural operations, livelihoods, and our property values are suffering. Every additional day, this water remains creates more damage and makes recovery more difficult. We believe that this flooding is directly related to the uncontrolled vehicles on Palmar property that are damaging their drainage utility easement. It is also related to the SERP, the Save Our Rivers Loxahatchee River Project. I have documentation of three additional weirs that have been added as Palmar's water is supposed to drain to our east. The first of them is three feet height. The second is at a six-foot height. We haven't figured out. So when you're going to hold six more feet of water, you're making an artificial reservoir that cannot drain. These are fixed concrete structures. The project's engineering is wrong. The calculations are wrong. Water level assumptions, water management decisions must be independently reviewed. Our community deserves some answers. We want permanent protective dikes to keep Palmar's water off of us. Palmar's engineer told me, well, our drainage utility easements aren't to keep Palmar's water in. They're to keep your water out. We've gotten their water twice in breaches into our community. It's time to fix it, and we expect you all to stand with us. Thank you. Roman Peay is next, followed by Ann Vanderstiel. Good morning, and congratulations to all the news. My name is Roman Truputnevich, and I live at 1901 Southwest Trailside Run, Stewart, Florida 34997. This is to the Martin County Board of County Commissioners, County Administrators, all county staff, and Martin County Sheriff's Office. We are demanding immediate cessation of all vehicle access to Palmar region. Continued vehicle traffic has damaged and compromised the elevated drainage berm, contributing to the Palmar's ability to contain its waters and placing trailside HOA surrounding farms, neighbors, homes, risk of flooding, and property damage. The Palmar Water Control District has apparently addressed multiple canal breaches by grading approximately the upper six to eight inches of the drainage easement material back into the breached area. This raises serious questions about the adequate and long-term stability of this repair. Lowering an already inadequate drainage easement is not an acceptable solution. Trailside HOA remains at risk of another breach and additional flooding. We cannot wait for another failure before action is taken. We have repeatedly been told that these entering the area have property rights. Well, let me make something perfectly clear. Guess what? So do we. We do have rights. Our homes, land, pastures, and protected from flooding matter. Two, recreational access cannot take priority over neighboring property rights and critical drainage infrastructure. We are demanding five immediate action. One, stop all vehicle access to Palmar area. These legally entitled to enter can walk, bicycle, or ride a horse. Install barricades and access controls to prevent further damage from vehicles. Involve the Martin County Sheriff's Office in enforcing applicable access restrictions. Require independent engineering assessment of the canal breaches, repairs, and drainage berms. The Palmar engineer reportedly maintains the berms are intended to keep surrounding properties water out of Palmar, not contain Palmar's water. Yet neighboring properties are experiencing the consequences of drainage failure. We demand independent explanation and assessment. Bring Martin County, Palmar Water Commission District, South Florida Water District, together to establish a permanent solution protecting trails and surrounding property. We expect our county officials to stop passing responsibility around and stop protecting the people they present. This is not about denying property rights. It's about preventing another drainage failure and protecting our community. We demand immediate action, not another investigation after damage occurs. Stop the vehicle access, protect the drainage easement, protect trail sites, and protect our community. Thank you. Thank you. Ann Vander Steele is next, followed by Risa Olcott. Good morning, and thank you for being here, and congratulations, Commissioner Collins. Thank you. The people here are speaking today very loudly and very clearly and very plainly, and it's just so refreshing, and I want to congratulate them. They're doing a fabulous job. You know, hearing stories about cows underwater and people having to wade in into an area that took 30-some inches before of rain and drained just fine and are taking still a significant amount but less and aren't speaks volumes to me about what we're doing with our land and how we're allocating it. We're not allocating it because stormwater runoff is a real thing, and, you know, we have a problem with beef in this country. Apparently, we're importing cows from Argentina because we don't have enough, and Florida being the beef capital really over Texas shouldn't be ignored. We need to preserve that. So the slow-growth aspect of what I love about Martin County, and when I fly over it with my son, who's a pilot, and we go north, we are so pristine here. And if you go south, you see just how valuable our real estate is. And by maintaining this slow growth, we can also increase our property values, which is also good for everybody here. But we need to remember that power is in with the people. And last time I was here, we talked about, you know, you guys passed the moratorium, and we're very appreciative of that. We really respect that you're going to do that and do the studies and look at what's going on. But we do have a data center that is snuck in prior to the moratorium, and I believe it was Commissioner Vargas who asked, can we move to get a ban? Do we need a full year to study this? Can we get a ban, and can we not also do real studies on this data center in Martin County and off Cantor Highway across from schools? The noise pollution, the potential devastation to your real estate values, and the fact that we really can't afford to have more stormwater runoff issues and more degradation of our environment. Can we not look at conservation easements for some of these other areas? This is what I think is critical and made Martin County so incredibly valuable, is that we have these potential assets available to us to deploy to protect the environment, give the owners of these properties some recourse in their real estate, and also let them continue to use the property as such, but again protect us from the fact that if we go ahead and design these data centers and increase the stormwater runoff, we're also going to contribute to the problems that you hear today from the people who are suffering. My heart goes out to every single person that's here that's been impacted by this. My community saw a lot of high water. It didn't get to our homes, but it did almost get to some on the other side of my neighborhood out in Cobblestone and Stewart West. So I understand the threat, and it's concerning, and we're looking at more rain today. So I appreciate your listening, and I really hope that we can all work together to at least certainly help the people that have been impacted here, but also to prevent more data center development. Thank you. Risa Olcott is next, followed by Tammy Amerson. Hi. Thank you, everyone, for your time. Just want to be a quick voice again to be against the data centers. I really don't want to see any of that here. Don't have anything written, but I think everyone talks about all this research. What are the benefits? Okay, if we don't know the benefits yet, we know the negatives. We know about these cows, these poor baby calves being born, stillborn, or dead. So why are we even entertaining this idea? We have lived hundreds of years without AI and AI data centers. I know not everyone is for it. I don't understand why anyone is for it. So please, and again, I'm just going to make this quick because you obviously have a lot on your plates to deal with in our community. My neighborhood luckily did not, I did not get flooded personally. I'm up high, but my neighborhood was flooded completely in. We could not leave. We could not come and go. I live out right by the data center where they want to propose it. So, again, just want to be a voice to say you've got a lot of work to do. We appreciate the work you're doing. Please, let's keep going forward. Thank you so much. Thank you. Tammy Emerson is next, followed by John Dial. Hi, Commissioners. Congratulations. Sarah Hurd, Christopher Collins. My name is Tammy Emerson, and I also want to speak to really looking at trying to cull the development. I strongly oppose bringing a data center to Martin County. Our water, land, and peace should not be sacrificed for a facility that primarily benefits a corporation. I'm greatly concerned about constant noise and pollution from cooling equipment, backup generators, as well as the risk that heavy water use and construction runoff could threaten local water quality and disrupt our already heavily burdened ecosystems. While AI can offer powerful tools, the physical environment remains the foundation for all life and well-being. Technology cannot replace the intrinsic beauty, biodiversity, and life support systems that healthy ecosystems provide. The destruction of human intelligence, creativity, and viability is under attack by artificial intelligence and the individuals who are forcing their expansion on us. There are over 5,000 data centers in the U.S., significantly outnumbering any other country. We don't need another data center. We need clean water, restful sleep, and a healthy planet. And this is no longer about one project in our community. This is about setting a precedent for how and when industrial-scale data infrastructure is developed across Florida and the U.S. We must have responsible, evidence-based growth that protects our water, our communities, and our future way of life. The development of AI cannot come at the expense of the natural world. This is your time to stand with the local community and say no to all data centers, including the one proposed on 96th Street and Canter Highway. Not only could this proposed data center be a strain to resources and utilities, homes close to these massive facilities can face downward pressure on values due to industrial aesthetics, continuous generator hum, high noise levels, and heavy truck traffic. We have quite a few established developments in close proximity to that site, including schools that could potentially face a decrease in their property values, among other dire consequences that come with living in close proximity. Let Martin County be an example for the state and the country. This is your opportunity to make the right decision and choose the people and the land you represent over any amount of money or anything else you could have been offered. We will see the change and say no to data centers in Martin County and Florida. Thank you. Thank you. John Dial is next, followed by Luke Walker and Tyler Walker. Okay. Luke Walker and Tyler Walker, followed by Roxanne Howard. Good morning and congratulations on the newly elected. My son lives at 4265 High Line and his home was completely destroyed. It's gutted right now. Right now, the community is suffering pretty heavily. The morning was started with a beautiful prayer. And when we're sworn into office, you put your hands on the Bible. The Bible teaches to help those that are in need. There are definitely people in need now. There's no question about that. So what I would suggest is getting the funds to them. There's 25 homes that I know that are completely destroyed. If you did $160,000 to each one of those homes, that's only $4 million. God has blessed this county with plenty of money. $4 million would mean nothing in the long run to this county, but it would change the lives of those people in a way that you would not believe. For Tyler, he's blessed to own a business with me. We would not want any of that money. Put that money towards the rest of the people who need it. But please help the community. And remember, when we're sworn in, we put the hand on the Bible and the Bible teaches to help those in need. Thank you. Thank you. Roxanne Howard is next, followed by Jennifer Hettier. Wow. I haven't been up here in a long time. Hi. My name is Roxanne Howard. I am from Hobe Sound, Florida. My family has been in Martin County, Hobe Sound, since 1947. So I'm very aware of what's going on around us, and I'm very upset for these people in Jensen. I am shocked, but I'm not shocked because we've been fighting to preserve land. We've been fighting forever, Sarah knows. So I'm not here to discuss for those people, but I do want to point out that there's no pub needed. I'm not sure where this pub is. Is it at the Stewart Beach? Whatever. There's a very nice one right across the street at the Elliott Museum. So scrap it, halt it, my taxes need to go to help those people, period, end of story. I also propose an immediate halt to all construction. I know that's crazy, but this is stupid, what we're dealing with. So our counties, I'm here to talk about the data center as well. So our county's official motto is what? Enjoy our good nature. That isn't just a slogan. It's our economic engine. It's our quality of life, and it's the reason families and businesses choose to be here. As data center proposals look at our area, I'm asking this board to adopt common sense zoning standards before approving any permits. So I highly recommend to set a precedence because the biggest reason people are arguing with me on social media for data centers is to compete for the well-being against China. Even AI, and I guess I do use AI, says that the USA is well beyond China. So that's not an argument. AI says it's mainly big corporation. So, but in case the argument comes to push or shove, we do not have to choose, hold on, between modern technology and protecting our community. The technology already exists to build smaller, ultra-efficient, Earth-friendly data centers that still deliver massive computing power, and we should require developers to use it. Specifically, I urge you to establish three clear standards for any data center. I don't want any data centers, but if you do, if the push comes to shove and you're worried about getting sued, first mandatory closed-loop cooling. Closed-loop cooling, outdated centers evaporate millions of gallons of local drinking water every day. Modern liquid-cooled systems recycle the same water endlessly with near-zero waste requiring closed-loop systems protects our local water supply while keeping servers running efficiently. Are you kidding me? All right, the next thing would be strict noise limits and buffer zones for schools, and that's a thing. Third-grid cleaning energy accountability, that's a thing. That's a possibility, and keeping them small preserves the land. That's it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Jennifer Kadir is next, followed by Terry Kogel. Good morning, and thank you for having me, and congratulations on your new position. Thank you, Deborah. I'm here as a Martin County resident and a mother and a healthcare professional. I'm going to speak very fast. I'm deeply concerned about the proposed AI data centers for both our healthcare and our community's healthcare. We do not have the resources to handle what will come if you guys push this data center through. We already know that there's nearly a million-square-foot industrial facility with enormous electrical demands, cooling equipment issues, and backup generators that might produce harmful emissions. And we don't have to guess about the potential consequences. We can learn from the communities that have already had data centers. In Northern Virginia, researchers have modeled increased respiratory and cardiovascular illnesses associated with emissions from data center generators. A separate study of a facility using natural gas turbines projected additional premature deaths and millions of dollars in annual healthcare-related damages. These are modeled risks, and they deserve serious attention. Chandler, Arizona. Residents have reported persistent industrial humming from data centers and cooling equipment, raising concerns about sleep disruption and quality of life. In the Dalles of Oregon, Google data centers approximately use 1.26 million gallons of water per day in 2024, accounting for roughly 30% of the city's national average or daily average of their water demands. We don't know what daily water demands this center is going to put on our town, and that's drinking water for our children. This proposed Burton County facility would require up to 130 megawatts of electricity. We need to know exactly how much water it will consume, what emissions it could produce, and how its operations may be affecting the surrounding neighborhoods, their property values, and the two schools that are very close to it. For more than seven years, I've cared for our nation's veterans through the Department of Veterans Affairs. I've spent years treating people living with preventable illnesses that our government knew about before they passed harmful exposure risks. Those decisions whose risks were known should have been recognized long before the consequences became apparent. I've sat across from thousands of patients whose lives were forever changed by illnesses that might have been prevented. I've seen what happens when we address these consequences of decisions instead of preventing the harm in the first place. Today, I own my own medical practice that serves Martin County. My patients are my neighbors. My families, these families I see at the grocery stores, their parents raising children alongside of mine. The people who make this community a home. I don't want to spend the next chapter of my career treating preventable illnesses in my own neighborhood because we failed to take the environmental health risks seriously enough when we had the opportunity. As a health care professional, I understand and I've spent my entire career understanding how the environment affects our health care. I just want to say one more thing about Jensen. I'm deeply disturbed that things haven't been happening. You guys need to do whatever you need to do on the political front, but I know each and every one of you belong to a church and you guys should start organizing local missions and sending people out to those neighborhoods and support that church. Thank you. Harry Kogel is next followed by Christine Berge. Good morning, Commissioners, and I would like to especially welcome our new commissioner. Thank you. Mr. Collins. I also would like to thank Commissioner Campy for taking the time and interest in attending our NAC meetings in District 4. It said the commissioner for District 4 has only attended approximately three meetings in two years. However, that commissioner will always be present when the press is invited. Okay. Over the last two commissioner meetings, October 27th, November 10th, and actually this one also, it was a full house only because it was for the data center and Jensen Beach flooding discussions. After some I had spoke to had to leave work and make other arrangements to be able to attend. They are unable to do so on a monthly basis. The Board of County Commissioners had held meetings regarding various development issues and projects within Martin County in the 9 a.m. Thereby making it impossible for the majority of working class taxpayers to attend the public board meetings. Perhaps that is the plan. Having open meetings at 9 a.m. limits information, communication, and education to the public. It limits the public's input to the Board. If the Board truly wants the public to be informed and educated on development issues and projects within the county, the Board should change the time to the open meetings from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. And such is done by the City of Stewart Commissioners. Numerous emails have been sent to you in the past to no avail. The Board ignores its legal duty to the public to inform them of all facts pertaining to the county's proposed development projects. The legal obligation and your sworn duty is for the health, safety, and welfare of the residents of Martin County. And that has been passed over to accommodate the developers and the greed of the Board. Thank you. Christine Berge is next, followed by Denise White. Good morning, Commissioners, and welcome. Thank you. Christine Berge. I'm Christine Berge. I live south. Is it south? I always have problems, even though I studied geography a bit. I live less than three miles away from where this proposed data center is going to go. Why the application was accepted without research, I don't know. The question now is what is going to be done about it? Because I do not agree with building this data center. According to environmentalhealthnews.org, is it safe to live near a data center? EMF radiation risks explained. It's not. And this is a large-scale data center. There's not enough research. There's not enough regulation. It doesn't exist. We're talking about living in an ecosystem. And I love Martin County. We have an estuary. It's been polluted. What would happen, say, we're in an industrial revolution? No one denies that. What happened if we were more responsible back in the day? So there wasn't pollution. So there wasn't death. I don't want to be the dead fish in the river because research wasn't done, because it was negligent to not have enough data or to have enough common sense to realize. And I'm going to let you guys all read this. That if something's happening in a small scale, what's really going on in a larger scale? Microcosm, macrocosm. This is a worldwide issue. We're a microcosm in Stewart, Florida. Do we really want, are we going to be the canary in the coal mine before too much damage is done? Thank you. Thank you. Denise White is next, followed by Tom Whittington. Sorry, I'm real short. Okay. My name is Denise White. My family's been in Martin County since 1983. I moved here 16 years ago when I retired from state government in Austin, Texas. I appreciate the environmental aspect of the Martin County lifestyle. I live where the Arundel Data Center is proposed to go in. I mean, I live in River Marina. And the next, okay, as you're going down Southwest 96, right, there's a right turn right before the Arundel Bridge. That's where I live. I live. And so yesterday I called Commissioner Hurd's office and I talked to Sarah Fillion and she was very professional and helpful and gave me the location of the data center. told me that basically it's out of your hands, that now it's with growth management. So I talked to Brian Elam in growth management. He helped me locate the site. So I went out and saw exactly where this proposed data center is going to go in. And I was talking to my friend Dana. She Google mapped it. Where the data center is going to go is 1,000 feet from the entrance to Crystal Lake Elementary. Now, I've researched and Alicia Gibbs that spoke earlier, I went on her Facebook page and she had a PBS video about data centers, mainly in Texas. So what an Abilene called Starlight. Well, they got the permission to put the data center in. And then what they did, it's a really big data center too. You know, there's power issues and water issues with data centers. Well, what they did is they brought in gas turbines on tractor trailers to provide their own power. So I don't know what would prohibit this data center from doing the same thing. Yeah, I think gas turbines, that sounds like it makes a lot of noise to me. What we've already heard is my friend Dana lives in Legacy Cove, which is between Cove and Salerno. But anyway, she's supposed to hear the noise at her place. So can you imagine what it's like at my house or Crystal Lake or St. Lucie Falls that's a 55 plus community? Is that for me? Okay. Thank you. You get my drift. People over profits. These data centers are intended to make a lot of money. Take care of the people. Tom Whittington is next, followed by John Wexler. I don't see Mr. Whittington. Is John Wexler still here? Followed by Jackie Thurlow-Lippish. Good morning, Madam Chair, members of the board. My name is John Wexler. Last week, my home and property in the Trailside community was flooded. Luckily, the water never got to my house, and I feel terrible hearing about what happened in Jensen Beach and other communities in Martin County. But we had a lot of water. My wife was terrified, asked me to take her and evacuate the area. There was water several feet high in my fields. My calves were swimming behind their mothers as they were led to higher ground. There were alligators swimming across our roads, which had several feet of water on them for several days. This is unacceptable. There are many elderly people in our community that need to have access to medical care and receive prescriptions by mail, none of which was available during this period of high water. And the effect on our livestock and agriculture was substantial. I understand this was due to the water in the Palmer area breaching its berms, and you've heard about this before. It's happened before. They flooded our canals, and they filled our community with several feet of water. And after it stopped raining, it continued to flow from the south to the north across our road for three days before it finally stopped. I also understand that you have a plan to improve the drainage capability of this area, but as yet, you have not begun implementation. Last week, I sent a large check to Martin County for my annual real estate taxes. Forty other families in Trailside will be doing the same if they haven't already. I noted on the real estate tax invoice that you send every year that the value of our properties goes up every year. If our property floods in heavy rains, it's not worth more. It's worth less. I respectfully ask that you utilize some of these tax dollars to implement your water management plan and fix the continuing issues at Palmer Trailside. Thank you. Thank you. Jackie Thurlow-Lippish is next, followed by Joe Flanagan. Good morning, commissioners and staff. Congratulations, Mr. Collins, and congratulations, Sarah, for being here to continue to give us all of your wisdom. And thank you all to the rest of you for everything you're doing. It looks like you're going to be hitting the ground running. I'm here today to say congratulations, but I'm also here today because I'm a longstanding resident of this community, and one of my very dear friends is Miss Alicia Dixon. She spoke earlier today. She's from the historically black community of Tick Ridge, which is also affected by this flood. Savannah Road, Highline Drive, Sherry, and some of the other roads in there. And she called me right away and asked me if I would check it out. So we have. And I drove around in the golf cart. And, of course, you know, you can go. It's just how many times can you say break my heart here? And I want to thank Commissioner Vargas for her video that she did when I couldn't get any other information. And it was pouring cats and dogs. And that was very helpful. Thank you, Commissioner. So I'm not on any board anymore, but I have some historical education. So if you're looking at a map, and I'm sure that you all know this, but I think we really need to look at this. So St. Lucie County, of course, parts of it run down into the savannas. And I believe that St. Lucie County has a permit from the South Florida Water Management District to discharge legally a certain amount of water into the savannas. Then that water ends up some of it. And there's neighborhoods, and there's canals, and it's insane that they ever built there, but they did. And so did we. And a lot of it runs into the Blackwell Reservoir, okay? You need to check out. I'm asking you to check out the Blackwell Reservoir. This reservoir is west of, what is it, Greenway Parkway, the newer one they put in. And it is huge, and it's beautiful. The animals love it. It is, from what I understand, and my brother helped me out with this, Todd Thurlow. It is owned by the city of Port St. Lucie, even though it's in Martin County. I want you to check that out, okay? I could be wrong. So the water runs into that reservoir, and then it comes through some culvert thing in the northern area into the savannas. And so, of course, in that recent flood, we had it. You know, Port St. Lucie is legally discharging into Blackwell Reservoir. The water's flowing under the road. I'm surprised the road didn't break apart. The water's coming down from the heavens like it's Noah's Ark. And then whatever happened, maybe, you know, the reservoirs that are in that High Line area got too high at the bottom, so they couldn't do what they're supposed to do to go out of Warner Creek, which has become like a tube for all of Port St. Lucie, all of Jensen Beach. We need to look at Warner Creek Watershed. Maybe something's going to have to happen, like we're going to have to buy out some homes, I'm sorry, somewhere. I mean, what's happening now is not going to stop. This is an El Nino event that we're in through April. It's going to come and go. And, but please check out the Water Management District and Drew Bartlett and all of our good people. I'm sure they are busy, but they should be here. And this should be, I hate when I say it should. It would be very nice if we would all coordinate together what we can do about this issue. But I think that Blackwell Reservoir, if it is owned by the city of Port St. Lucie, that's insane. And if I'm wrong, I'm sorry. But check it out and all that stuff needs to be coordinated. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Joe Flanagan is next. I yield my time. Followed by Kathy Reff. Reffmeyer. And Ms. Reffmeyer will be followed by Kathleen McGann. Good morning. My name is Kathy Reffmeyer. I am going to preface my speaking with the fact that I am currently recovering from a craniotomy in my frontal lobe that affects my ability to speak. It does not affect my ability to be passionate about what I'm speaking about. But I will stumble and pause and fail to articulate what I want to say, but here goes. Yes, you are. What I am going to say can be used in the defense of the people that have been affected by stormwater runoff and the data centers. The fundamental duty of our representatives are to represent us, the people. One vote. One vote. Not Tallahassee. Not developers. Not big corporations. The fundamental duty is to represent the people that live in this county. We feel that we're being left out of those conversations and everybody else's best interests are being considered except the people that live here. We have to drive here. We have to drive here. We have to pay taxes here. We raise our families here. This affects our quality of life. Every one of the decisions that you guys, as a commissioner, are responsible to please, please, please protect our interests. And I'm one of those people that have come from the North, but I came here 16 years ago, and I've seen so much development. And it really scares me. And I have used my voice, even though it's not well anymore. But I appreciate having the opportunity to use it, and I appreciate everybody that is standing up for our community and what we believe. So you are elected to serve us, so please serve our best interests. Thank you. Thank you. Kathleen McGann is next, followed by Sandra Casey. I learned a lot, but I will say this. Okay. My name is Kathy McGann. Oops. My name is Kathy McGann. I moved to Palm City in 1990. I'm a retired Martin County middle school teacher of 25 years. And I believe that people must be present and voice their opinions and objections to their representatives so they will protect us, their community. I came here today with many questions. They're written here about where is this place going to be? I'm talking about the data center. Is it near Crystal Lake? Is it near South Fork? I didn't know. I didn't know any neighborhoods that would be impacted. The people are not being informed. So I came here today, and I have learned much about the location, the environmental impact of this data center. My questions have been answered by former speakers. So I'm really grateful that I came. I believe the board must be open to informing all of us. The public must be informed. I don't know if you have already committed to something that has to be studied. But if that's the case, because I would say no right away because it sounds like a disaster. But if we have to have at least a moratorium, study the data center. Make it open to all the people. All impacts of its development should be publicly available to us, the residents. And my fervent wish is that the building of this data center will ultimately be denied, please. And I think that's based on the detriment to our community. All the kids, all the people, all of us who love Martin County, and I'm so grateful to be here. I'm from Long Island, and it's great. We love it here. So I've been here, what, since 1990. So please listen. Thank you. Thank you. Sandra Casey is next, followed by Iran Acevedo. Morning. I think we're still there. Thank you for hearing everyone this morning. My name is Sandra Casey. I live at 835 Southwest Bromelia Terrace in the Florida Club, which is .8 miles from the proposed data center, along with 525 other homes and families who, just by word of mouth, have all talked to me because in my past I've been assistant principal at South Fork High School, assistant principal at Pinewood Elementary, 40 years in education, and currently serve on the state board of directors for the Florida Realtors Association, and practice real estate in Martin County. So we were, I initially heard about data centers at the Florida Realtors State Convention in August in Orlando, where it was announced by our legislative team that we are to be cautious and aware and keep our ears open for the possibilities of a data center in any of our counties that may be applied for since they're a growing thing. And how the impact on each and every homeowner, because of the negative impacts, which we were informed by council, was the vibrations caused from the plant, the drain on the utilities in the community, the loss of wildlife. Because of the noise, it's a 24-7 operation. I don't know how many of what level of understanding everybody has so far on it, but I would urge you to research it thoroughly. But if it's everyone's for the environment in Martin County. That's why I left Michigan and came here 30-some years ago. So let's preserve it and diligently look at this process. I know that the application came in, I don't know, days before your moratorium, which was a wise move, and I applaud that. But it now seems that it has administrative approval to go through the process. And if that's the case, I don't know at what point if it comes down to a final vote or if it's like other building permits and it administratively gets authorized. But I would hope that, with your wisdom, you'll find a way to prohibit that from being so close to Crystal Lake Elementary and the schools. It's hard enough to keep kids focused, I'm sure. As parents and visiting schools, you know how difficult that is. So, please, I urge you to be responsible in looking at every aspect and forcibly doing everything you can in your power to deny and stop the data center from being built in Martin County, seeing as we have enough other issues. Thank you. I have been a teacher in high school. I know about the attention here. Iran Acevedo is next, followed by Yamila Escalona. Good morning, Commissioners, and good morning to the elected Commissioners. My name is Joey Acevedo, and I represent Amalgamated Transit Union, the employees at Marty County. And I stand before you here with some of my members, and we do want to thank you for everything that you have done since the crash of the system. And, you know, we really appreciate everything you've done, and we want to thank you for that. And on the second note that we understand that as Marty comes back in different phases, we do have employees that are still out of work as, you know, everything comes back and the service comes back to full service. We're asking before you to see if there's any funds that you guys may be able to allocate to help the employees as the holidays come up and we try to help bridge the gap. We do still have a lot of employees still out of work as we navigate with trying to get SRA to make sure they make the employees whole. That's going to take some time, so we stand here before you and ask if there's anything that you guys could possibly do. I know there was some funds done, and we do thank you for that. So I know you've got your hands full. Our hearts go out to, you know, the members and the people that were impacted by the storm. I know you have a tough job, but if there's anything that you can do for us, please reach out to us. And we just want to make sure that the employees have the needs to bridge the gap between the holidays. Thank you. Thank you. Yamila Escalona is next, followed by Laura Giobi. I'm not going to yell at you guys today, so don't worry. My name is Yamila Royan Escalona. I direct Yaya Por Vida. The morning, or this morning, I submitted my written comment by email because water was already rising in my neighborhood again. And as I speak, I came anyway. And I'll tell you why, because today more and more of my neighbors to the south are walking into this chamber, standing up, speaking out, and refusing to be quiet. That is what it took or what it looks like when a community decides it will not be ignored anymore. I will not repeat my written comment. I will give you the part that you need to hear out loud instead. First, credit, because we give it the same way that we give accountability to. Mobile showers went out. Vice Chair Chiampi is championing the Dignity Bus, the model already working in Vero. The only member of this board who has ever acknowledged us. The only one who came out to flooded neighborhoods and got his hands dirty. One out of five. Oh, but I saw you got dirty for real, for real. We noticed. It can be done from that dais. The question is whether the four of you are truly willing. I'll give you some time, Christopher. Thank you. Maybe next time. Good. Now the water came back. The first flood was a surprise. This one was forecasted days out. You guys knew. So here's what the public needs to sit with. A county that can predict a flood and text thousands of residents that got to safety, which we got that today. Great. But now we have no published place where people can go. The alerts say seek shelter. But where does a person without a home go? Where does a family whose house took water two weeks ago go tonight? Through Thursday. And one commissioner just said we must wait for FEMA until November 30th. Wait. The water's in our streets already today. The forecast runs through Thursday. And the answer from this dais is wait 13 more days for permission from Washington. 13 days through a second flood through Thanksgiving. For maybe a gymnasium at least to open today. Commissioner. You do not need FEMA's blessing to open a school. Neighboring counties didn't wait. Churches didn't wait. Mutual aid organizations. Mine included are pre-positioning supplies right now. Arriving this week without waiting for anyone's permission. FEMA reimburses counties that act. It does not resurrect the people who quote unquote drowned while you waited. Hold on, Dawn. This time again. I'm asking one more time for you to give me some clemency. It does not resurrect the people who drowned while you waited. Waiting is a choice. And my neighbors standing in this room today are telling you what they think of that choice. Because some of them are calling for the resignation of District 1 Commissioner. When a community asks you to choose differently. And you ask wait till the 30th. That is what enough looks like. Seven days ago, I asked the question on the record. Amendments 3 impact on human services. The flood outreach count. The arrest count. The water is coming back. The answers have not. And while we wait, the water sits in our streets. Land approved before you. The data center moratorium is moving forward through the gap. While the neighborhoods that fought for that moratorium are going to sit under water. You passed a moratorium with a hole in it. And the hole is being widened today. A moratorium with a hole in it that doesn't protect us. One commissioner really walked through that door. And y'all all passed through it. Except for Christopher. Thank you. Thank you. I look forward to disappointing you. Laura Giobi is next. Followed by Mike Edwards. Good morning, commissioners. Congratulations, Commissioner Collins. Hey. And congratulations, Commissioner Hurd. First, I want to say that I've had an opportunity over the last five days to meet Lisa French and Laura McPherson. And I think they have done so much in their community. I'm calling on the public airways, the stations, the reporters. Because the news cycle is 24 hours. And the 24 hours is over. I'm asking them to do a daily piece. Doesn't have to be long. But keep this alive so that the rest of the community knows that there are people who are in need. People who could use donations. People could use help. I want to commend all of the individuals who have come out to volunteer, do the hard, you know, boots on the ground work. And I have to tell you, I've had a flooding in my own home up north four times. No one knows what it's like to watch your photographs you can't replace and furniture and books and whatnot just destroyed. And you have to throw them in the garbage. So I feel for these people. Again, we can only help them now. But what I'm asking this commission, and you have seven very intelligent people sitting up there with the power. You have the power, okay? I'm asking you, because this is just not this incident. It's the data center. It's the overdevelopment. Take the 30,000-foot view the next time you look at a large project. How does it affect your neighbors to the north, to the south, to the east? Those are the things that are important to look at, not that individual project. They're not built in silos. They affect everything around them. And today we're having that effect. And it will continue until this body with the power has the ability to say, no, you can't build that to maximum density. No, we don't want data centers. Start looking at those things, because the next time we have an El Nino, and it's going to happen. Mother Nature is who she is. We need to be prepared. We can help where we can, but let's try and not make it a future issue. You guys all have the power. Other commissions in Florida, other commissions in other states have said no. They are looking at development. They're looking at it in a new way. You all have a legacy, and I'm sure you don't want it to be. Those are the individuals who let Martin County lose its Martin County, special Martin County, who we are. It's the Martin County way. Don't let that be your legacy. Let it be your legacy that you have saved it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Mike Edwards is next, and Mr. Edwards is the last request to speak form I have. If you would like to address us, please fill out a request to speak form and get it to one of our bailiffs. Good morning. Good morning. I first wanted to mention I feel for the people that are the flood victims, and I'm hoping that you can find some funds to help these people out. The reason I'm here, though, is to speak about the data center, the proposed data center. First, this is not a small data center. This is a hyperscale, 950,000-square-foot, four-building proposal, and it's a half a mile from schools and homes. I live in Florida Club. It's very close to the Florida Club. The noise that it generates or will generate, based on my research, is 40 to 50 decibels of a continuous hum within a half mile, and 80 to 100 decibels with occasional generator load tests. And the 40 to 50 decibels of continuous hum is 24-7, even when you're trying to sleep. The emissions data centers use massive amounts of power and typically have backup generators, which typically use fossil fuels, and those release pollutants such as fine particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide that are directly linked to heart and lung disease and premature death. This is a facility that is going to be a half a mile from an elementary school and homes downstream of those pollutants. When you have noise and emissions concerns, this will affect local property values of our neighborhoods close by, including our houses and the Florida Club. And I have a question for each commissioner. When you look at the noise, emissions, and drop in property values, would you want a hyperscale data center within a half mile to two miles of your neighborhood? No, no. So if you feel it's necessary to have a data center at all in this area, why not somewhere else where it will affect neighborhoods and schools? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I have one more request to speak for him, and that's from Richard. Please pronounce your last name properly. Minikino. Minikino. Hi. Good morning. My name is Rick Minikino. I live at 2523 Southwest Riviera Road in Stewart in River Forest. The South – the gateway project that we have started – oh, that's great. It's 30 seconds now. Yeah. Sorry. The South Florida gateway project was supposed to be for light industrial. My question is, how does the data center with its consumption of electricity qualify as light industrial? Also, the square footage at 900,000 square feet along with the truck center that is just adjacent to it. Both of those properties require a tremendous amount of runoff. That runoff eventually ends up into the canal. The canal, now being overburdened, needs to be drained out into the estuary. So it all kind of runs downhill unless it backs up in the neighborhoods. I understand the need for AI data centers to some degree, but I think they should be – there should be a larger, major industrial area that these would fit into that is closer to the power grid. Information that leaves data centers leads through fiber optics. So it doesn't matter how close it is to a city or a neighborhood. It travels through fiber optics at the speed of light. So it can be further away and still serve communities. So I would like to see – I understand that Tallahassee is pushing for this. But we still have some grip, some say over our own communities. And some of that say is how it meets the local criteria for noise and for other runoff and for other items that we could still use to stop this or downsize it or break it into pieces. Originally, I believe that land was owned by Coulter Homes and then it was bought out. And if you follow the money back as to where it's being funded, and we've all heard in the news recently about how AI is being funded, I would be very – I wouldn't be surprised if this falls into that category as well. Also, with the improvements in AI, this data center could be obsolete within the next half dozen years. They're looking at putting this in space if they can figure out how to dissipate the heat in space without the convection. So this data center, you may end up with a 900,000-square-foot building in 10 years with no one in it. So I appreciate your time. Thank you for allowing me to speak. Would anyone else like to address us? I don't see any, so let's get back to our agenda. Let's do the reorganization of the Board of County Commissioners with the first thing being the election of a chair and a vice chair. Commissioner Camps. I move that Commissioner Campy be our chair in the coming year, and I want to thank Commissioner Hurd for an awesome job as chair in the last two years. Zero seconds. The protocol of vice chair to chair, we did extend our chair's year, her service an additional year. I know it's not customary when we have a life yield. Commissioner Collins. So personally, I know we're in the middle of a motion. I would like us to continue in the organizational structure that we are currently in with Commissioner Hurd at the helm and Commissioner Campy as vice chair. Personally, that's what I would like to see going forward. Okay. No knock on you. I get it. Yes, sir. I get it. That would be unprecedented. I think two is the max. I will weirdly second the motion that I would become the chair. Okay. I have a comment. There's a motion and a second to appoint Commissioner Campy chair. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? That motion passes. Opposed. Wait. No, I think they changed their minds. So that was for? That was for vice chair to stay. Everybody in their seats. To stay? No. So the original motion was for Campy to become chair. You're the only one that had a second. Okay. All right. So all those in favor of Commissioner Campy becoming chair signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Opposed. That motion passes three to two with commissioners Collins and Vargas dissenting. You want to do a vice chair? Sure. And then we will take a break. I'd make a motion that Commissioner Camps having served two years now have the opportunity to become vice chair. Second. Commissioner Camps, do you have a comment? No, I'm good. No, I'm good. There's a motion and a second to appoint Commissioner Capps to be vice chair. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? That motion passes unanimously. I meant to say aye myself. We are going to take a 10 minute break and we'll return to the rest of our reorganizational duties. The county commissioners meeting. This morning we had our inauguration where we swore in our newest commissioner Christopher Collins and we welcomed back our longest serving commissioner, Commissioner Hurd. So congratulations to the both of you. We will begin our actual meeting now with a discussion of the consent agenda. We did have a request from Commissioner Collins to pull, was it consent? You want to do reorg first? Oh, I guess. We're going to do reorg next? Yes, we can do that. That's fine. Donna, if you can pull it up, please. We're ready for two. Yes. Number two, approve the use of the prior chairman signature plate for check signing purposes until the new signature plate arrives. I'd entertain a motion for that. So moved. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Adopt a resolution designating who may sign documents on behalf of the board. Can everybody sign documents? I was going to say in the past we've made it everyone. I move that everyone signs documents. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Districts two and four commissioners make district appointments to the LPA agency and board of zoning adjustment and adopt the resolutions. Before we do that, I'd also like to say that in district five, I will be having a change in my appointee for the local planning agency as well. So we'll start with you. Commissioner Collins, do you have your appointees yet or do you need more time? I'll be submitting that before next meeting. Okay. Yes, sir. And I am reappointing Jim Moyer to the LPA and I will get back with you at the Boza appointment. Okay. And then I will do the same thing. Commissioner Capps? I'm good. Oh. Commissioner Vargas, are your appointees staying as they are? Yes, they are. Thank you. So with that being said, I'd entertain a motion for. Do you want to change yours? I am going to appoint John McAuliffe to the LPA. So moved. All those appointments. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed, that motion carries unanimously. Appointments to boards and councils which require commissioner membership. The board is asked to appoint a chair to the value adjustment board of the. Oh. I'm sorry. That's okay. I'm using your version. Well, I was just going to the big chart. Can you scroll back? Just so I can. Let's so people know. Make appointments to the commission membership. We did that. Value adjustment board of two appointed commissioners. Administration staff will notify the liaison for each board and council. So, currently the chair of the value adjustment board is Commissioner Hurd. Yep. Would you like to continue? And as Commissioner Vargas, are you the vice chair or a member of that board? For which one? The value adjustment board. I'll continue on that board. Okay. You want to be the vice chair or the chair? I can be the chair. That's fine. Okay. And then we had Commissioner Hetherington was on that. Commissioner Collins, would you like to join the value adjustment board? Yes, I'm happy to serve as an alternate. Thank you. And Commissioner Capps, are you okay serving, continuing as an alternate? Sure. So I would entertain a motion for that one. So moved. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed, that motion carries unanimously. We're just going to start down the list now. Okay. Access 67 initiative with George Stokas as the staff member. It's me. I'm more than happy to continue if someone else would like to have a shot at it. It's part of the Florida Association of Counties. It requires very little dedicated time to that specific one. I don't mind keeping it. If we are staying the same, I think we can, do you want a motion for each of these? Not necessarily. Yeah, we can bundle some. So until someone says otherwise, we'll just keep reading down. Affordable Housing Advisory Committee is currently Commissioner Vargas. I will stay on that. Okay. Airport Noise Advisory Committee is Commissioner Hurd. I'll stay. The Arts Council was Commissioner Hetherington and myself. I'd like to continue. We need a new member. I'm happy to serve. Terrific. And just to make it easy, I'm happy with all of the appointments that she had, actually. We'll just see if anybody else wanted to have one of them. Yes. But I appreciate that. Currently, our representative on the Business Development Board is Commissioner Capps. Are you interested in keeping it? And is anyone interested in being part of that? I'm fine keeping it. Terrific. The Canvassing Board will switch. I don't know if we appoint members to the Canvassing Board in a non-election year. But obviously, it won't. Commissioner Vargas and I served on it in this last election cycle. I don't know if we need to fill those positions for 20. You never know. We could. You never know special. That's true. That's true. Why don't we switch? Yeah, that's fine. Okay. Commissioner Vargas will be the member of the, well, it's normally the chair or the substitute, so you would be the member of the Canvassing Board and I would be the alternate. Children's Services Council is Commissioner Hurd with Commissioner Hetherington as the alternate. Yes. Happy to keep it. It's an interesting year, I think it would be. Yes. Do you take her as the alternate? Yes. Okay. Donna, you're getting all of this. I know you are. The Circuit 19 Juvenile Justice Board, formerly known as the Juvenile Justice Council. It's Michelle Miller who represents us. I don't think anyone's looking to knock Miss Miller out of that spot. Seeing none. Continuing Florida Aviation Systems Planning Process Steering Committee is Andrew McBean, our Airport Director. I think we could leave him in place. County Coalition for Responsible Management of Lake Okeechobee, St. Lucie, and Caloosahatchee Estuaries in the Lake Worth Lagoon. Sarah Hurd was the member with Commissioner Hetherington as the alternate. Yes. Okay. Drug and Alcohol Abuse Awareness Committee is handled by Michelle Miller, Human Services Director. Indian River Lagoon Council was Commissioner Hurd as the member with Commissioner Hetherington as the alternate. Yes. Yep. Okay. Internal Audit Planning and Priority Committee is Commissioner Capps. I don't mind staying on it. I don't see anybody looking to steal that one away from you. The Law Library Committee is Commissioner Hurd as the member with Commissioner Campy as the alternate. That's okay. We're perfectly fine. Loxahatchee River Management Coordinating Council is Commissioner Capps. I would like to stay on that one since that's in District 3. I was going to say that's in your neck of the woods. The Metropolitan Planning Organization is all of us so Commissioner Hetherington will be replaced by Commissioner Collins. The Palmar Water Control District Board of Supervisors is Commissioner Hurd with Commissioner Capps as the alternate. Yes. That one we don't allow anyone to ever get off. It's just like a neck. Yes. Public Safety Coordinating Council is the chair or its designee. It's currently Commissioner Capps and I was the alternate. I'm fine staying on it unless you would prefer to be on it. No, I'm fine to be the alternate. Okay. Small County Coalition has been Commissioner Vargas with Commissioner Hetherington as the alternate. Yep. Leave it alone and Commissioner Collins, you will take that alternate position? Yes. Forgive me. Yes. Tourist Development Council was Commissioner Hetherington. Yes. Would you like to be the member of the Tourist Development Council? Yes, sir. Everyone okay with that? Yep. Perfect. Mr. Collins. Treasure Coast Community Action Agency Advisory Board is our Library Director Jennifer Salas. Treasure Coast Council of Local Governments is Commissioner Capps with Commissioner Vargas and Commissioner Campy as alternates. I will tell you that is, especially for newer commissioners, that's an excellent opportunity to meet your colleagues throughout the area at all levels of the municipalities. I used to serve on it with Jackie Therla-Lippish. I would like to be an alternate on that. Okay. Not as a primary. Not as the primary? No. Okay. So you are keeping your position then as alternate? I'll keep it as alternate. Okay. Commissioner Capps? I'm fine with staying on it unless somebody else wants it. Commissioner Collins, would you like to have an alternate can attend that meeting, correct? Or can you only have, oh, that's true, you can't, obviously. You can only have one at a time. I don't mind keeping it. When do they meet? Once a month. What day of the week? It's also on Zoom, too. You can Zoom in. Thursday. 10 in the morning. Yeah, in Fort Pierce. On a Thursday? In Fort Pierce. Yeah, I believe it's Thursday. Or Fridays. I can serve as a Friday. First Wednesday of each month is what information they gave me. First Wednesday of each month. They've switched. They've had it on Fridays, too. Okay. We can leave it as is. We'll leave it as is. Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council is Commissioner Vargas and Commissioner Capps, with Commissioner Hetherington and Campy as alternates. I'd be an alternate. Okay. And I will switch with you and become one of the members. I haven't done that in quite a while. So we'll have Commissioner Capps, are you okay staying on it? Sure. We'd have Commissioner. Happy to be an alternate. Okay, perfect. We'd have Commissioner Capps and Campy as the members with Commissioner Vargas and Collins as the alternates. The Treasure Coast Workforce Consortium has been Commissioner Hetherington, Commissioner Collins. We're filling your plate up. Trico Board is the Vice Chair. I've been doing that with Commissioner, with Commissioner, with Mr. Donaldson, and then our staff handles that. It's primarily just reviewing cases that will be solved and settled with staff. I don't mind keeping it. It's not a tremendous amount of work. So I'll keep it unless someone else is interested in having it. I might be interested in being on the Trico Board this term. Very well. Then Commissioner Vargas will be our representative on the Board. And then the Value Adjustment Board, we just discussed that, correct? We're good to go. Is there any others? Question. Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council. We have Commissioner Vargas is an alternate. Commissioner Capps is the member. Commissioner Collins is the... Alternate, and I'm the other member. Alternate. Okay. Okay. Is there a second page? Well, that's the whole list. That's it. We'd entertain a blanket motion for all of those changes that we've made. So moved. Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Collins, seconded by... Seconded and third by Commissioner Capps and Hetherington. All those in favor? Yeah. What's going on? Aye. Seconded by Commissioner Capps. You're missing. Already he's missing. No, I did that because it was sort of simultaneous, but... You said Hetherington. Yeah. Oh, did I? Yeah. You already miss her. I could tell. I was already in my head talking like how clever the second and the third was. I left the other part out. I want to take back my vote. Hey, Nick. Come on. Wow. That was fair. Talk about like a real, you know. Oh, yeah. Unbelievable. You're the chair. Yeah. Razor. Dancing on the head of a pin. Uh-huh. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Now we're going to discuss meetings that we will continue here in the chambers. We have January 5th and the 26th, February 2nd and 16th, March 2nd and 16th, April 6th and the 20th, which we, the 20th, we will be our capital improvement plan workshop after the meeting. May 4th and 18th, June 8th and 29th. The June 15th is a joint meeting, which all of us, because Commissioner Collins was the mayor of Stewart, he understands the joint meetings. We don't have to explain that to him. That's at the Blake. July 12th and 13th is the budget. Traditionally, we only end up using the 12th, but we allot for both. And then July 27th, August 10th and the 24th, September 14th is our meeting. And then we also have our first budget public hearing at 5.05. The 28th is our meeting, and then the final public hearing for the budget at 5.05. October 12th and the 26th, another joint meeting on October 5th. And then November 2nd and the 16th, which, believe it or not, on the 16th we'll be doing this a year from now, and December 7th and the 14th. Any changes, issues, Commissioner Hurd? I have an addition, and that is that I am adamant that we have workshops, budget workshops. I don't know if we need to add a day or if we can just add a workshop. Do you have to designate workshop meetings as workshops, or could we do them on the same date as the regular meetings? We can do them on the same day. I think if we have a busy meeting, it wouldn't be bad to at least have a tentative schedule for an extra day each month. And then we can always provide advance notice and advertise it properly so that we can advertise a, certainly if we can accomplish the workshop on the same day. But if we have meetings that are really busy, it would be nice to have whether it's the date in between each one of these as the Tuesday in between, or some sort of generic schedule that we could have for the, at least until July. Yeah, I'd like to have at least one, well, one meeting each month until we hit July. May I make a suggestion? Most of our meetings don't barely last past lunch. So that would be the first. And then also, if we were going to do them, how about at, similar to we did the budget at 5.05, if you're going to do a workshop and it's about budgets and Amendment 3, I think the residents, maybe one or two, if you're rotating, could be in the evening of a Tuesday meeting, similar to how we do the budget, so that folks that can't participate during the day would have an opportunity to come as a suggestion. I think having them on the same Tuesdays instead of, because as soon as you start picking other days, five people will have to then go back and look. There's FAC meetings, there's NACO meetings, there's other travels that we've already sort of hashed through, so you'd just be asking Donna to create a thing. These days have basically been vetted already, so I think, yes, you're welcome. I think most days, it's very rare. Last Tuesday was a very rare day where we had such a long meeting. Most of the time, we're out of here by 2 o'clock in the afternoon. Yeah. That was a, so, and a workshop is lighter, you know. That's just a suggestion. I don't expect they'll be light, but they'll be, um. I don't think the topic will be light, but it's not the same thing as having a full agenda. Yes. It's one, so can we ask staff to look into that? Agreed. Commissioner Hurd? Sure. Okay. Does that need to be a motion, or is that a head nod for you? No, that's, we'll report back, and we can do both. We can plan to have it at 5, but also look at your schedules in case we need one in the middle of the month. Okay. Starting in January or December? Yes. Okay. Yes. Okay, so I'm entertained. I have a request to speak. Is this about the calendar, sir? Okay. Please come forward. We have Mr. Gary Erler. You are recognized, sir. Thank you. My name is Gary Erler. I'm a resident of Martin County, Port Salerno. Congratulations. Thanks. Congratulations on your re-election. Last meeting, Commissioner Hurd did make the point that she wanted more budget workshops, and I agree. I only request that we have those after 5. We're more of the public. We are. You just said it. I just want to reiterate it. That's about all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions or comments about the calendar? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. So moved. Second. Second. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Then we have the 2027 Board approved holidays. They're listed there. They are the traditional ones. And then we have other holidays and occasions of note listed for planning purposes only. You're welcome to add to the list. Okay. You're welcome to add to the list. Donna, when's your birthday? We can add. Seeing none, I would entertain a motion to accept those dates for 2027. So moved. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed? Aye. Okay. Adopt the rules of procedure. Noting the changes administrative staff and county attorney are recommending for the rules of procedure. Page six, a change dramatic to serious under physical presence of commissioners. Are we going to talk about these? Yes. The implications of this or what? Mr. Donaldson, do you want to elaborate on page six or Ms. Elder? Excuse me. I think it was just to clarify the definition. An immediate family member, spouse, parent, child is undergoing dramatic, I guess was as serious as an easier term to define than dramatic. Serious medical treatment. Move approval of that. Yeah. Thank you. You want to do them, we'll bundle them? Yeah. So we can go back to your list. Yeah, the other one was. Page 16, added language to requests and presentations. So that was added by the county attorney's office just to clarify that the board requests presentations and not the member of the public can request a specific, it was just unclear, so we just did it to clarify. Okay. Last one. The last one is about no comment during Article 10 appeals. There was some, it was unclear whether there was public comment or we have a very specific procedure for Article 10 appeals and there is no public comment, so we just wrote that so members of the public know and that's really so you don't prejudice the person who is appealing because you never know what's, if someone's for or against them. So that was also a clarification. Is that a local clarification or is that a state clarification? That's our local clarification because there was some confusion in one of our board meetings and a member of the public expressed concern, so I just wanted to clarify it in our procedure so everybody understands what the process is. Okay. Move approval of all three changes. Second. We have a motion for the changes as presented, seconded also. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed, the motion carries unanimously. Commissioner Hurd? Yeah, and one thing for Commissioner Collins that may be different from your time on the City Commission is a motion for reconsideration. If you vote with the majority, you can make a motion for reconsideration on that same date or at the next meeting as long as it's not 30 days beyond it. So that's how you can, the only way that you can reconsider your vote. How would that work with a new commissioner that didn't actually vote on that motion? You wouldn't get to? I don't think you'd be allowed to. You weren't a commissioner at the time. I was curious. That'll only happen to you today. Yeah. Okay. We're just, that's it? Yes. See, that was relatively harmless. Thank you. Our next agenda item is departmental number four. Just, just, sorry Commissioner Campy for clarification. It can be made by a member who was absent from the vote. So potentially a prior commissioner would have been absent from the vote. So if there's anything we want to rehash from the last meeting. Yeah. Well he was absent but he wasn't sworn in. No, I know. So that's just, I just wanted to clarify. There were a few that were. That's right. Three twos. I'm ready. At the pleasure of the majority of the board. Let's do the consent agenda before we move on. Mr. Gordon you say right there. Commissioner Collins. Yes. You wanted to pull. I wanted to discuss item five. From the consent agenda. Yes. Fiber optic dark fiber license use agreement. Do you want me to launch into my thoughts or. We'll just have Ms. Sinclair sit down so that she can hear you. Hello. Hi. Erica Sinclair, Chief Information Officer and welcome. Thank you. Commissioner Collins. This is Russell Norvell. He is our telecommunications manager and is oversees the fiber among many other roles and responsibilities. Perfect. Okay. So my questions in looking at this. I'm not an IT person but I had somebody that I really respect approach me about this and some of the concerns were one if this could create a lack for us in the future to hand over and lease some of this dark fiber these two strands could there be potentially in the future not enough capacity for the county and have we really looked at that in detail what our need will be especially in light of this automatically renewing in five years. So within that you know timeframe 10 years might we need that capacity to where we wouldn't want to have an automatic renewal. Well this actually what the agreement is is for them to have two strands so basically they have their own individual roadway as you would say for whatever their needs are. We haven't experienced any issues with capacity since 2012 for them. If they need more than they work with us and we add the lanes that they are the sites that they need to the to the contract. But if you're if you're talking about growth with them beyond that technical. And us you know. Yeah. But it those are specific to them. So they have what they need growth for the county as a whole is what I think maybe you're talking about. Need of the county right to use utilize that bandwidth. Right. I'm not an IT person. Right. So we have we have over 200 miles that handle all of our county buildings today when there's a need or growth and that would be another financial investment that would be made based on the county's decisions. And you beat me to it is if we did need more capacity. My instinct is it would be very expensive to create that. So if we have we plan for how much capacity we will need. So that we're not having to build the infrastructure to the construction ultimately. I think the good question is, you know, when we installed the the the fiber years ago, there were a lot of additional dark fibers that were included in there for future use, as I recall. And so and and the technology is increased. So you can actually cram more information down the tubes we have. So as I recall, there are a number of additional fibers that are being used ourselves. And and so there is plenty of capacity for ourselves and the handful of other folks that are sharing the same tubes. Is that correct? Am I still correct in that? Correct. And we've done the long term anticipation of what we will need. Yes. I think we have a lot. So the the most expensive thing in fiber is actually putting in the tubes. Right. And then you they pulled more fiber than we needed through those tubes. And so most of them are not being used. We have plenty of capacity for our future that we have. Yes. So second concern was the rate. So I was curious how we determined what market rate was at forty five dollars a mile, because this individual I was talking with that's an I.T. person said in looking into it, it would be something like seventy five to two hundred dollars per mile based on that tier two to three market. So my question would be, you know, when you project that out for one hundred and forty three miles, that could be double or triple. You know, you're now taking in. I think the numbers I'd written down seventeen thousand versus sixty five hundred. How are we determining market rate so that this is in light of Amendment three and all of our leases and making sure we're recouping every dollar we can and that this is not a sweetheart deal for Cleveland and it's fair for taxpayers? I can say that this agreement we've been looking over it for a couple of years with them and at the time the studies that we've done and through that, you know, I'm not sure who you're talking to, but we did our analysis and research and that was a going rate for us at that time. At this time, though, since we're renewing, would that reflect the current market rate? I think from our evaluation. Have we done an analysis on that? Yes, we did. Currently? As in today? No. I have to be honest. But it's based on the previous contract? No. It's based on when we started this contract with Cleveland Clinic. Which was in 2012? No, just a few years ago. Okay. We started working on the contract. Got it. Okay. And I'm sorry. This is Caroline Moogler, the assistant county attorney. This is also, we're not trying to make a profit on this either because we're not in the profit making business. So with the charges to Cleveland Clinic, we are covering our own expenses because, you know, when you're trying to make a profit, we're trying to cover taxpayer dollars. So we wanted to make this reasonable because it's a mutual benefit to the county and Cleveland Clinic. The benefit to the county is the money? The benefit to the county would be, it enhances our ability to maintain and repair fiber throughout the county. And when we are in partnership with Cleveland Clinic as well, it's benefiting the community. And we're assisting the hospital in maintaining their operational expenses and delivering community services. So it's the money to be able to operate and maintain the line is the benefit to the county? Yes. I agree with you. Just curious as to if we're making that full market rate benefit to the county. Thank you. Those were all my questions, really. Okay. Just wanted to take a little deeper dive. Perfect. Move approval of the consent agenda in its entirety. Second. Thank you. We have a motion by Commissioner Hurd, seconded by Commissioner Capps. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Thank you very much. We'll take up Departmental Number 4, Discussion of Potential Funding Mechanisms for Residential Flooding Impacts. My name's Jim Gordon. I'm the Public Works Director. With me, I have Sally Waite, our Emergency Services Director. Before I get into the agenda item, I just want to give you a brief update of where we're at and also our preparations for the rain event later this week. So I know that most, if not all, of the board has been through the neighborhood in Highline, but here's just some photos of what we have going on down there right now. We've got a number of roll-offs as well as three clamshell trucks. So Public Works staff, along with Emergency Management and Solid Waste, are working to remove this material. We opted to self-perform this activity. We think our own employees can do a better job than a contractor to remove this material in a timely manner. And we're doing an excellent job. Yep. Really, like, full in, all hands on deck, doing an excellent job. So we're working seven days a week, and that's our commitment is we're going to continue to do that until we get everything cleaned up. As you can see also in the bottom left-hand photo, there's also pump hoses. So what we're seeing is we got all the water out of the homes at the end of last week, but the groundwater table is still bleeding up to the surface, so we have to re-pump that water as it comes up to the surface. So we have people working 24 hours a day pumping that material down. We also have, this is a follow-up on the berm failures. I know several residents from Trailside were here today, so the red dots on the image are where failures occurred. The red dot that's on the blue polygon, that's the Palmar failure that they brought up today. So Palmar did do a repair. It's a temporary repair, and they used wet dirt because everything out there is soaking wet. So it's definitely a temporary repair that needs to be reworked, and the elevation of that repair needs to be looked at. We are in communications with the district engineer as well. Now on the red polygon is the Elise Jay property that the county purchased recently. So that berm failure leads, it doesn't go into Trailside. It goes into the Hope St. Lucie Conservation District Irrigation Canal. And Hope St. Lucie reached out to us last week, and they're making the repair to that one. So that should be resolved. The two in the bottom right-hand side, those are in the Cypress Creek natural area, and we're working with FEMA on the repair for those. So Sally's going to give the recovery update. Great. Sally Wade, Emergency Management Director, for the record. At this time, we still have no federal declaration. We are still activated to a level two in our Emergency Operations Center. Last week, we did conduct a joint preliminary damage assessment with the Florida Division of Emergency Management, FEMA, and Small Business for individual assistance and public assistance. We do continue to operate the multi-agency resource center at the Hope Library Monday to Saturday from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. And just over the weekend, where I did see most of you, a volunteer reception center was operated on Saturday and Sunday at the Jensen Beach Community Church, where we did have transportation there from the school district, and we were transporting volunteers to and from impacted areas. So now just transitioning to what are we doing today to prepare for the rain event that we might have later this week. I mean, certainly we're going to get rain. I mean, last night, but there's a potential for up to 12 plus inches of rain. So what we're doing is pumping down the system. So the photo on the left and the right are both in the same location, just at different times. So the one on the left was just after the rain event two weeks ago. The one on the right is this morning. So we're pumping down those ponds and getting storage so that we have some flexibility if we do get a big rain event. So this is Lake Pitchford, which is on the south end of Jensen Beach right behind the CVS on Jensen Beach Boulevard. And Highline Pond is the same way. We're pumping that one down much further than we normally would to provide that storage. And we're doing that all in conjunction with the Water Management District. So that's what we're seeing. We've also deployed a number of pumps. We now have almost 10 pumps out moving water in different locations just preparing for that storm. Typically, we would not be able to pump on private property, but because we're in a state of emergency and we've got water kind of stuck. When the savanna is overtopped into Tick Ridge, there's water stuck on those private properties. And if we don't get that water out, it wouldn't take much rain to discharge again into the Highline neighborhood. So we're moving that water as quickly as we can. Great. As Jim said, we are actively monitoring a weather system affecting our area this week. Martin County could receive three to six inches of rain with localized higher amounts of eight to 12 inches starting this afternoon until Friday. The Emergency Operations Center will be staffed today at 2 p.m. until the incident is over. The Community Information Center is open for residents to call for information from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. And residents can call 772-287-1652 for information. Yesterday, we sent out an alert Martin notification urging residents to be prepared and to stay informed with us. We are coordinating with the National Weather Service, the Florida Division of Emergency Management, and local and regional partners on this event. We have fire rescue services standing by. We have two high water rescue trucks that will be staffed and available throughout the event. Our fire rescue crews have been out reconning areas prior to the rain event, and the entire department is out actively now and has been since yesterday. We do also have sandbag operations happening at Howell Patiokee Park that started today at noon and will continue to 6 p.m. And then tomorrow from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. And we're giving out 25 sandbags per person that comes up. Can I ask a question? Yes. Is that the only location at Howell Patiokee? Is there any way to put one up in Jensen somewhere? So that's the only location because it requires some equipment to make it happen. We can put a ton of sandbags out with what we have going out there. We can produce a pallet of sandbags in five minutes. We are delivering sandbags to Highline. Okay. So that neighborhood is... So they don't have to go and fill their own, so you're bringing sandbags. They don't have to go to Howell Patiokee again. Yeah, absolutely. So they're getting their own sandbags, but as far as residents in other parts of the county that might want it, that's the location we're going to do it. Okay. Anything else? No. The funding portion? The funding part is the next part. So I just wanted to give you the update in advance. Excuse me one second. I'll wait until I finish with the presentation. Push it back. Hit the light again one more time, please. Commissioner, just hit your light again. Thank you. So Donna, if you could put on the agenda item, please. So transitioning over to the agenda item. So at the November 10th meeting, the board directed staff to return with potential funding mechanisms to assist residents whose homes experience prolonged flooding as a result of the November non-named storm. So this item provides an opportunity to the board to discuss available options and provide directions to staff. So if I could have Michelle Miller, our health and human services manager come up. So in general, the request was to look at the Port St. Lucie program to see what they're doing to provide services to their residents who were affected. And we researched that program. Our ship program offers $20,000 to homeowners. And the Port St. Lucie program goes through the same exact ship program and they offer 25. So that's the difference between the two. But Michelle can speak a little more about that. Right. Good afternoon, commissioners. Michelle Miller, human services director for the record. So, yes, we did some research into the Port St. Lucie program and their program is using the same funds that we use. So these are our ship funds, state housing initiatives program, which is funded by the Sadowski funds, funds that we received from the state. So we have asked the state for permission to increase to meet their award of $25,000, which they agreed, and ours will continue as a grant. So if that is acceptable to you all, then we will bring back our local housing assistance plan for you all to approve that amendment, which they have tentatively approved pending your final approval. But that will have to come on another agenda. We will bring the whole plan before you. But that would increase the amount from $20,000 to $25,000 as a grant fund. And Port St. Lucie is requiring a lien. So we are not requiring the lien for that amount. Up to $25,000? Up to $25,000. So that's different than what we heard? Yep. Good. And then additionally, what could happen after that, so that's a one-time assistance award for someone who's qualified. If someone needed more than that, they could apply for another strategy that we have in that local assistance plan, which is our rehab strategy. And that plan goes up to $75,000. So if you are approved for one, you would be approved for both. And if you wanted that assistance, you could get the $25,000 in a grant, and then you could get the $75,000 in a lien amount. That lien amount reduces one-tenth each year for 10 years. And if you live there for 10 years, then it's totally forgiven. So that already is available for anyone that wants to apply for it. So the only difference today to bring before you is that we would be increasing that amount from $20,000 to $25,000 in that grant assistance. Two quick questions for you. One, how quickly could people get the money? And two, can you explain the qualifications? Sure. So just for context, we've already had 15 people apply since we were here last week talking about it. We have had one person already approved. So it's a very quick approval process. And then for the grant funds, that money can be distributed immediately. It just depends on what it's needed for. So if it's for rental assistance, we just get the name of the landlord. We send the money directly to the landlord. If it's something like supplies that someone needs to muck out their house or clean out their house, then when we get their receipts and we verify what it was for, then that money would be distributed directly to the person. So there's some things that we just have to verify once we get their application. Primarily is their income because it's an income eligible program. So if the person meets the income qualifications, then the application process from there is pretty quick. We just need a proof of income, which could be a pay stub. It could be your tax returns, one or the other. What are the dollar amounts? So the dollar amounts are per the – and these are HUD amounts. So we don't come up with these amounts. They come from HUD, goes to the state, comes to us. So in Martin County, our average median income, according to HUD, is $102,000. So for one person to qualify, they couldn't make more than $86,040. For a family of four, so that could be two parents, two children, it could go up to $122,880. And then it goes up depending on how many people are in your household. So if there are two working people in your household, then both of those people would have to supply their income eligibility. But if it's two parents and, say, two children, three children, then we just get the income for the two parents and then documentation of the children, birth certificates, things like that. Commissioner Vargas, do you want to speak now? Yeah. I wanted to ask a question because I lived through Hurricane Andrew, and it was a different time. And I know you administered the program very carefully because these are tax dollars. But you verify receipts. I understand that. So if somebody wants to rebuild and they do qualify, because you have to qualify for this. This is not just given, a check written, and that's it. It has to be at the Florida Building Code. This must be contractors that are insured. And also they have, you know, passed what they need to to be a bona fide contractor. We're allowing trailers to be put on the property, which is different than what we normally do. We're also allowing if there's going to be changes in so far as the interior movement of walls will go ahead after the fact. They do have to get building permits for this. But again, we'll have our folks in that department working with these folks if they decide this is the route they want to do. Normally, the county responsibility ends at the right of way. But your department is going above and beyond for this. We have no charge for the debris removal. We've done that also. And we're not penalizing if this extended period of time, because normally, you know, contractors, they may, as we've seen recently, they may take more time to build or build out. But they have to be licensed and insured. And this has to keep moving forward. This is not a stop and start. You know, we have our folks out in Trailside, too, that have big problems there, too. They have a breach. And they are running agricultural businesses in addition to living out there. So we have to also be mindful of them, too. Martin County has spent money on this particular disaster. So I will say thank you very much to Jim Gorton. I could not have done it without him. And I wanted to meet with the people. I got right in front of it. It was a few days later after this episode happened. Nobody could move faster than what we did. And it was a very emotional meeting. But we were there to listen and try and find the answers. We don't have all of them right now. No, we do not have nobody on this board, whether you're working down at the site or not working or, you know, trying to get information out, as I've been doing. But it has to be correct information because social media takes on a life of its own. And this is happening. And some people were, you know, how can I say this? They're not really thinking that maybe we're working as fast as we can. I did, through contacts, am reaching out to FEMA to try and light a fire and get this going. We know what it would be like. I've lived through hurricanes. My sister's home exploded in Hurricane Andrew. It did. There was nothing there. There was lumber. So I've seen that. And that's a close family member. She still had a mortgage on the property. She still had to pay the bank. So, unfortunately, it was not a good situation after that. So I understand that. But having said that, we have to be very mindful. And I appreciate your department, Ms. Miller, in administering these funds. I've also looked into the fact of the State Rainy Day Fund. This is one of our amendments. This past election where it could be for emergency might be another option. But I'm talking about federal money. We're talking about state money, which is what you are referring to right now. And so having said that, I did get some figures from our county manager yesterday. It's about $3 million estimated damage, you know, to homes. $14 million king tithes. We just replenished the beaches. We've had the king tithes that have washed that away again. So we have to go find more money for that federal level, of which I'm taking the lead on that to do. We have staff, overtime supplies, everything considered for a natural disaster. That's at least half a million dollars today. And it keeps mounting every day. Our roads have to be repaved, you know, have to be reworked again. That's at least a million dollars, if not more. Something's, you know, brewing right now. The other thing that was brought to my attention is that, and Mr. Gordon can speak more to this, is about the study to the Savannahs to see if it's updated to real-world conditions. And make sure that, you know, the stats and the water level all combined, you know, for storm stats. So I'd like you to address that also because, again, I did say this at the last meeting, this will happen again. And if it does, if homes are being rebuilt, they have to be elevated. This happens throughout the county. I've seen flooding in other parts. I've seen it in Palm City because I was very interested to see where else we were affected. So it's not just near the beach area, not just near the St. Lucie, not just these waterways that are in this area here. As I said, we cannot forget our neighbors at Trailside at all. And I think that several people spoke very well towards this today. So we have work to do. I'm rolling up my sleeves in the background, in the background. And I want everybody to hear my voice here. I am committed to my district, but I can't do everything. I'm trying to focus to see how we can help them, these folks that have been hurt, bring their lives back to Tormalicy as quickly as we can. But the wheels of government, as I say, don't move as fast as we want. We have many, and I have the list here, of nonprofits. And some of these folks were in the room this morning, and they've done an exemplary job. And that is there for you also. We have the nonprofits. We have the churches. We have other organizations. We also have the library, which is open six days a week, that you can tap into those resources. So the help is there. Again, I've never seen so much help except when I was in Hurricane Andrew. And that devastated South Florida entirely. So could you please explain about the study? Sure. So there's really two asks for this agenda item. The first one is to request that the board approve increasing the ship grant amount from $20,000 to $25,000. And the secondary request is we have a funded CIP sheet in this year's budget, and it's called the Stormwater Master Plan. There's about $900,000 on that sheet. The request is that we move $200,000 from that sheet to our Savannah's hydraulic modeling sheet so that we can do two things. The first one is model the storm event that we just had. We need to update, get some of the development that's occurred to our north, put into that model first, and then model that storm, see where the weaknesses were. And then secondarily is look at some solutions to reduce the risk. So that's the ask is to move money from the existing Stormwater Master Plan that's funded in this budget year to the other existing sheet, which is the Savannah's hydrologic model. Exactly. I just want to read something else here, please. Some of the organizations, and if I'm missing a few, it's because they're coming forward now. Agency for Persons with Disabilities, Baptist Disaster Relief, Catholic Charities, Department of Business and Professional Regulation. I met these folks. I met these folks. Department of Children and Families, Department of Health, Martin County, and we talked about that this morning. I have folks that are very concerned about the health of our residents, and I'm addressing that also. And that to me is paramount, because that can last the rest of a lifetime. Family Promise, Florida Rural Legal, Habitat for Humanity, Martin County Emergency Management Agency, Martin County Human Services, Red Cross, Salvation Army, United Way of Martin County stepped in, and able to also offer housing. But again, you have to be able to apply for this, and it would be a very short-term type of a rental housing. Department of Veterans Affairs. And again, this may be a partial list. It may absolutely be a partial list. But again, everybody is locked arms. We're moving forward as quickly as we can. There is no magic wand to make this happen from one day to the next. And I would appreciate if those could see through this right now and see that our hearts are in this. This board and myself as your district commissioner could happen to any district. And there is in Trailside another commissioner there. They don't feel that maybe that commissioner is doing enough. So I've heard. But that's not a reason to say, well, nobody's doing anything. We're doing everything that we can to help the folks. I was concentrating on the federal funds because FEMA has stepped in the past. We've had a lot of changes, not just here, but also at the national level. And so far as funds flowing, this is where we are right now. I wish it were different at this moment. So I appreciate everything that everybody is doing. I truly do. And I've met and I've spoke with these folks that are there six days a week. And they'll come out. They'll come out also to meet with the residents. Okay? We all have to be in this together. All of us. Those affected and those that are here. Thank you, ma'am. Commissioner Collins. Jim, thank you for working really hard. I'm sure a lot of people have been telling you that, but I wanted you to hear it from me, just observationally, sort of from the outside in the last couple of weeks. You're the man. That said, with what you are recommending in that second part, that sounds to me like an investigation, sort of what the public has been asking for. My question would be, would that include, would the scope of that include beyond, you mentioned development, but also how the water was managed into the savannas and if that was done properly, you know, and how, and if there's blame to our neighbors to the north. So we will want to model the flood event and all of the inputs into the system at that time. So, yeah, we would be looking at everything that came into the system and the timing of that. The one weakness we have in the savannas is it's really a blind spot. There's no gauges out there to capture that data. That's another piece we're working on right now is we're putting gauges in Martin County in the savannah so that we can see the water levels. Are they going up or down? But yes, part of the study will look at exactly the conditions that happened that caused the flooding because we have to do that to be able to look at ways to mitigate that. Because if not, and if we needed to increase the scope of what you're studying, I would love to do that. My biggest concern is people are gutting their houses right now, and once it's mitigated, they're going to start throwing drywall up again. And if we have another event, you know, so anything we can do short-term as well. I know you're drawing down water in those ponds. You guys are doing a great job, but those are my concerns. Anything we can study to make sure this doesn't ever happen again, basically. Commissioner, we'll make sure that that's included in the scope. And if there's any amendment due to the investigative nature to determine the man-made influence on this, we'll let you know and ask for that increase if needed. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Hurd. Yeah, this morning one of our speakers said that there is a reservoir called the Blackwell Reservoir that's in Martin County, but that she alleged is owned by Port St. Lucie. You know anything about that? Yeah, that's accurate. So it's just west of Green River Parkway on the north side of the name of Martin County. Are they allowed to discharge into the Blackwell Reservoir because they own it? So the Blackwell Reservoir is operated by three pumps, so they pump the neighborhood that's immediately north in Port St. Lucie into the Blackwell Reservoir. And then once the water's in the reservoir, it's an impoundment, so there's berms around it, and it drains by gravity. So once the water's pumped in from the community to the north, it drains by gravity along Green River Parkway, and it runs north along Green River Parkway. There's five or six weirs that discharge at the same elevation into the savannas, and so once the water's in the reservoir, it has to discharge. There's no way to stop the water from discharging. So if you look at it today, the reservoir has very little water in it because they haven't pumped for several weeks. Okay. Also, there's been a lot of talk about a new regulation schedule for the savannas, and I'm all completely in support of that. We've seen what being at the bottom of the system is like in the St. Lucie Estuary and Indian River Lagoon. You know, the top of Lake Okeechobee is unregulated for inflows, and the outflows also are not regulated enough so that there is damage caused being at the end of the system. So, yeah, it's very important to get a regulation schedule. This is such a big system, and we need to manage it as a whole, not have four different entities having permits that don't relate to one another. Mr. Layton this morning asked for dumpsters in every driveway. Is that possible? So we'll continue the dialogue with him. We have a meeting with him this evening. So they're also asking for containers to put in the driveways to put personal effects in. So I don't think there's enough real estate in the driveway to do both of those. So we're going to work with the neighbors to make what makes the most sense. Can we get more roll-offs? Yes. We have seven roll-offs there now. We can put more roll-offs in there, but we don't want to put them in locations that impact their ability to do other things they want to do. So it may be a decision for each homeowner. It might be an individual decision, and we'll work with them to accommodate. And also, I noticed this morning when I was driving to work that there's the beginning of tidal flooding this morning. So we're going to have really big king tides. When are the really high king tides supposed to start? So the worst of it will be next week, but because we have wind-driven waves again. So we have wind that's pushing water back in, so we're already seeing some elevated water levels. So the challenge with that is coastal flooding. But in addition to coastal flooding, it reduces the efficiency of our drainage networks because when you're at a high tide, they're just not draining as quickly as they normally would. So the two things together aren't great getting a lot of rain on top of a high tide like this. But, yes, we are seeing that, and it's going to get gradually worse over the next week. Thanks. Commissioner Capps. Let me begin by expressing my heartfelt compassion on all the victims in Jensen Beach. I was there on Sunday afternoon to help clean out a house, and I wanted to clarify something to begin with. A couple of the public speakers were under the mistaken notion that only one commissioner had responded to the tragedy in Jensen Beach. And I know, Commissioner Vargas, you've done an awful lot, and I appreciate all that you've done. Thank you. And, but I was there Sunday afternoon and helped clean out a house, and I know that Commissioner Campy was there, I believe, on Saturday, doing the same thing. And Commissioner Hurd, from what I understand, has been to Jensen Beach as well to see all the damage. Yeah. But one thing I think I'll never forget, the house we were helping to clean out, there was this dirty brown water line on the outside of the house that was perfectly straight all the way around the house. And then when you walked into the house that was being gutted, that same dirty water line was on the doors. And it was about two and a half feet of dirty brown stain. And as my heart just went out to these folks that own this home, it was, it's just tragic. Can you imagine the horror of two and a half feet of water in your house? It's just awful. Had a couple of questions. Maybe this was, there's a lot of information coming at us. Maybe this was already addressed. What about building permit fees and building inspection fees? Have we looked into whether we can waive those whenever the people start building, rebuilding their homes? Yes, Commissioner. There are some fees we can waive certainly for this natural disaster. And under that declaration, we can, and we have done so already, waived a number of, you know, obviously no demolition permit was necessary, things like that. And we'll continue to work with the residents on that. I know another thing they have done in the past at the building department after hurricanes, is they allow people to go ahead and do emergency work and not have to wait on permit processing. Like people go ahead and do their roofs and then pull the permit after the fact. And I wonder if we could show flexibility there as well. We will be working on those hours. Yes, sir. You know, especially in those areas that are hard hit, you know. And that's the idea of working with the licensed contractors on there. Those homeowners that want to do owner builder, we'll need to talk to them more specifically on how we make sure it's inspected and help them. I think that's part of the discussion we'll have with them tonight is kind of outlining those things. But absolutely, we would expect that there are, during the rebuilding process, there is unforeseen conditions. And we will remain flexible with them to ensure that all of their rebuilding and improvements are permitted properly. Great. Ms. Miller, I have a question for you about the $25,000 grant. And that would not be a lien, right? That's a grant. Correct. And then you mentioned the possibility of $75,000 in rehab funds. Darn. But what my concern is, is the SHIP fund has a limit. It does. And it's about a million dollars a year. That's what we get. Is that right? It has been historically. Currently, we have about $900,000 in funds available for this event. And the state has assured us that additional funds will be coming in the future to assist. Well, my concern is, you know, there will be a run on that $900,000 in a week, you know, or less. And, you know, that's probably going to help about five or six people, you know. And we're going to run out of money real fast. I mean, what are these assurances or these overtures from the state that somehow money is going to reappear into SHIP? So they collect disaster funds for events such as this, and then they distribute them to the counties as needed. We're not sure of the amount yet, but we do know that we will get some disaster relief funds from the state. Right. The initial thought was that assuming that didn't happen, it seems to me like we have to find a way to do more than $25,000 as a grant and $75,000 as rehab with a running out of money after $900,000. We've got to do something more than that, in my judgment. What cap sit at $900,000? Forgive me. That's what we currently have available for assistance. It's only so much per year that you get in SHIP funds from the state because these are state funds for this kind of thing. But the other thing that's interesting about the SHIP program, that generally funds a lot of other things, too, throughout the course of the year, rent assistance for people and just rehab outside of a flood disaster, you know, for those. So whatever, if we deplete SHIP, we won't have any of those funds going to those other things. And I'm probably okay with that under the circumstances, but I want us all to know that that is what would happen. You know, when the SHIP money is gone, it's gone for the year. Right. And, you know, it seems to me like this is so urgent that I'd probably be okay with that. But the question remains, is this enough? I mean, I think there are 77 flooded homes. Is that right, Mr. Gordon? Or 66. Sixty-six. Sixty-six. Okay. Sixty-six flooded homes. And then many folks have talked about how 25 of them are destroyed. Do you feel that's accurate? So FEMA reviewed all of the flooded homes with the state and county representatives. We reviewed them all. They didn't classify any of the homes as destroyed on their list. We are going to follow up and have a little dialogue with them about their rankings of the homes because, you know, we thought a little bit different than them. But according to FEMA and the state, who both did their own analysis, they didn't consider any of the homes destroyed. Well, destroyed would mean that you would have to tear it down. I mean, some of them are gutted to the studs, but they're not destroyed. So I guess it's just a matter of definition. Correct. Exactly. Yeah, and we need to be careful with that in terms of art because we're talking about private property and the rules that apply to those. So in our code, substantially damaged is an important factor in terms of the Florida Building Code and what you're required to do once you're determined you're substantially damaged. You also have the property owners have a right to dispute your claim. And so in terms of damage assessments, driving by and estimating the damage for purposes of getting a natural declaration is different from application of the building code and determining what's substantially damaged and your requirements under that to meet the building code for rebuild. And so I think significant damage is what we're talking about. We know. But I don't want us to assign anybody the designation that they were substantially damaged without us and the private property owner having the ability to either agree or go through a dispute on that because there are legal implications of that. So let's just leave it as, yes, there is a FEMA requirement that we felt that the actual dollar amount figure that they claimed was worthy of a national disaster. We disputed that thinking the number was higher. But that has no relationship to whether they could be rebuilt or whether we considered them substantially damaged. Correct. Correct. Commissioner Vargas. Okay. As I said, I had a very long conversation with our county manager yesterday, and there's only a finite amount of money. It's not endless stream. My understanding is those homeowners that were lacking money have the option to go to the SBA for a loan to rebuild. Is that correct, Mr. Donaldson? SBA loans are only available to damaged properties if we get a declaration. Or a declaration. So at this point in time, they are not available. But if they are, that is a valuable tool should it become available. Okay. That is federal declaration? Yes. That is why I'm pushing to get a federal declaration. That is why I'm pushing to get a federal declaration. This is behind the scenes work. It may not happen, but I'm giving it every effort that I can and pulling contacts, folks that are in Washington. I am not in Washington. None of us are in Washington. But this, to me, is something that is critical at this juncture, if we're successful. And it's a big if we're successful. So I just want to make a mention of that, too. There is another recourse if we can get that declared. So we're working on it. Thank you. Two quick things. One, the money that we've been discussing, you have to qualify for. Yes. So anyone that is above that threshold won't be eligible to get any of this money. But just because you're, you know, thousands, let's say, over the threshold doesn't mean that you're not financially struggling as well. So let's keep that in mind. And secondly, I do have the opportunity. I was granted the opportunity this evening to meet with Cameron Hamilton, the FEMA director, and the Deputy Secretary of HUD, Andrew Hughes. I will be meeting with them later today here in Florida. Commissioner Capps. I'm concerned about a fast run on the ship funds by just a few people and basically leaving everybody else out in the cold. I have a thought. I got on my feet here. My thought would be to limit ship funds only to the $25,000 so that everybody gets a piece of the pie, and then that we pull money from somewhere else. But perhaps we set up an emergency fund from other sources for, like, say, a million dollars that we could have additional funding, to stress it even further. Because, you know, what's 66 times 25,000? Like, if everybody got that, you know, we're going to run out of money real fast. Nobody's going to – there's going to be a bunch of people that don't get anything. If we just pass this as proposed. So why not do kind of a level one thing where we're going to do the 25 for people and see how far that goes. And then maybe we could go ahead and set up another emergency fund for, like, a million dollars right now from other sources. That could be kind of an overflow so that everybody gets at least that. You know, we're going to run out. How far is that going to go? Yeah. Let's figure that out real quick. 25,000 times 66,000. What else is calculating? How much? We don't even have enough money to give everybody 25,000. Right. So one thing we could do perhaps is come back at the next meeting, let you know how many people have applied, give you an update of where we're at with that funding. Yes. And that might give you the ability to make a more informed decision on whether we're – because people might not qualify. So that's – I mean, we're 700,000 short, just like if everybody got 25, you know, we're $700,000 short right now just for that. Forget the rehab, 75 additional for rehab. We won't have those resources. So can we – in the short run, can we say we're not going to do the 75 rehab yet? We're going to do that like at a phase two maybe or at a later time. You know, we're going to – we need to spread it out initially. So, Commissioners, you're talking in a very broad sense. And, you know, when you get into giving people money, the question is not only income qualifications but, you know, did they have insurance or other means? And how are you going to qualify these or are these just simply a grant that if you were flooded you get 25,000? So that's a – becomes a complicated question on what kind of program are you asking us to do? And then the type of funds that the county would use – the state funds have all the rules already in the program established. So that's what makes it easy for us to implement. Because as soon as you add these other components into it, then you – we need – we would need clear direction from you all. Or what are the rules of engagement if we're going to use county funds on how to distribute grants? Yeah, just as a finish up, maybe we could do the 25 initially and see how long it lasts. And then we could do a reevaluation at that point. Thank you, Commissioner. My concern is, though, that if we allow people to jump into the 75 extra early, we're probably going to run out before the next meeting, but – Thank you. Commissioner Hurd. Yeah, I'm okay with limiting the first round to 25,000 for those who qualify and see how we fare. But as far as giving away tax dollars, I think Stephanie Murley is over there having a heart attack, and I would be in her shoes also. We can't just give away county money as much as we feel sympathy or empathy or compassion for these people. We need to be aware that we have an approved budget and that those dollars are – have been appropriated for specific items. And that's how they are to be spent, not appropriate – reappropriated in order to solve a shortfall that we have right now. Thank you. I think we also have to be careful about what we say up here, completely understand the urgency of the comments. But the news media is here, and we don't want to send misinformation to the residents that live there that, hey, we heard we're getting 25 or 75 or everyone's getting 25. I'm leery of how many people would qualify for those dollar amounts. I think a lot of people will be making even if it's just a little bit more. Ms. Miller, you know that number is locked, and if you're $4,000 above it, you're not getting it. So we'd want to be careful with that. You're having a meeting this evening. We have additional things. Is there anything else that we need to discuss? The board want to tell our staff or staff want to tell the board so we can move on? The only other thing was we have got the United Way here, and I'd like to bring up Carol just to give you an update on what they're doing. Fantastic. Commissioner Capps will speak while Ms. – Yeah. It's just a comment for future meetings. For those victims who are flooding, that would be really disappointed that we're only doing the 25 at this point. I think we could probably agree that this will be an or could be an ongoing discussion at future meetings, and at any given point we could consider some modification to the assistance we might be offering. But as an initial level one distribution, we probably ought to limit it to the 25 to make sure we can have some widespread use of those funds and that a few people don't get all the dollars. I would agree, and also I think that the opportunities for the county staff to participate without writing checks, as Commissioner Hurd said, with relief on permits, relief on demolition, relief on – just if you were doing a construction project and you were going to load dumpster after dumpster and bring it to the landfill, that's also expensive. So all of those things that we can do within the realm of what we're able is a step in the right direction. And then the FEMA designation will try real hard to get that as well. Miss, welcome. Thanks for everything you're doing again. Well, I'm a behind-the-scenes kind of person too, so being up here has been kind of interesting for me. So Carol Howard Dietz with United Way of Martin County, for the record. Welcome to our new people and re-elected. Just wanted to share with you some good things that have happened, and then I'll get into the funding piece. So I have a team member that has reached out to every person that has been affected by this event. She has either spoken to and or created a spreadsheet of what people need in the affected area. If she hasn't spoken to them, she has left message after message, and if she hasn't spoken to them, she's calling them back. So I do have a person working on that. We've also had a donor come forward and offer two condos at no cost for seven months for people to live in. One of them is going to a veteran and his wife. We are getting it fully furnished from House of Hope because they lost everything. We have one more. They have to be 55 and older. It's in Jensen Beach. So, again, you have to go through Martin County Health and Human Services, go through their process. Because if they don't qualify for the SHIP funding, that's when I'm working with the Community Foundation and other funders to see if we can put a pot of money together for those that are above the income level. Because we know some, maybe a lot of them, will be above the income level. We've also worked on hotel rooms. If there's anyone still staying in their home and it's not safe, we will get you in a hotel room for at least two weeks, and then we're still looking for temporary long-term housing. We've also provided storage units for individuals in our community. All you have to do is call. No questions asked as long as you're in an address that we know is in the affected area. We will get you a storage unit for at least two months. I'm sorry, at least six months. And then we'll go forward from that. We have been working with the Baptist Disaster Relief Organization and Christ Fellowship. They have been out there from day one working and trying to assess and working on homes. We are also working with others behind the scenes, American Red Cross, Salvation Army. We can assist with filling up food pantries and also clothing for people who have lost all of those items. We have organizations that are already willing and able to do that. I also heard earlier that people are worried about the holidays. We have a holiday project. There is no family in Martin County, whether they work for transit and or this disaster. If they have children, they just have to call our office and we will make sure that they have the holiday that they deserve. We can alleviate that kind of burden on them. But we're here to help behind the scenes working. So know that I may not be physically helping at sites, but I'm better. My resources are better collecting people in the community and working that way. So we should have heard from you first. Yeah, sorry. I just heard it all. I was in the back listening going, oh, but there's so much that has happened that people don't know. You just have to call our office and what we can do, we will do for you. Let us have the phone number, please. 772-283-4800 and ask for Share because she is the one that's really collecting all of that information. We've been sharing it with the county. They know. We've been doing work orders to make sure that homes that need the assistance and want the assistance because that's the other piece. Some people have just gone and done it themselves, and they're like, don't call me again. Yeah. Please don't do that to Share. I'm just saying. She is just somebody that's working and trying to help, so. That's fantastic. Thank you. With that, I think that's a great way to end this particular comment. Oh, I apologize. Commissioner Capps, you get the last word. Mr. Gorton, there were a couple of people from Trailside here this morning and had a few questions about the breach of the berms that caused all of the problems there. Mainly flooded roads and flooded pastures where livestock were having to be crowded up on driveways and in little, small, high areas of land. And that was also very heart-wrenching and awful to hear about. There was talk about two berms that breached. One was in Palmar and one was on our recently acquired Elise J property. And first of all, the first question I have is who owns the land that those two berms sit on? And whose technical responsibility is it to fix those berms? Is it our responsibility or is it someone else's responsibility? So in Palmar, it's the Palmar Water Control District has to repair that berm. And then on the Elise J, it's actually the berm that protects the irrigation canal for Hope St. Lucie. The berm is shared between our recently acquired property and theirs. So I would say that one could be a shared repair. They're going to make the initial repair. The county is going to come in and design a water control structure to properly discharge during high water events. So as far as the property that it sits on, it sits on, it straddles our property and the Hope St. Lucie Water Control District. But they're going to do the temporary repair. And I think they've already put some material in there. Okay. And any thoughts about the timing of that work? To do a design, so we have to design the water control structure. You can't overdrain a wetland and that's what that property is, is a giant beautiful wetland. So we have to do some analysis up front for that. We already have a consultant working on the wetland hydrology on that property. And then once we have that elevation set, then we'll get an engineer under contract to do the water control structure design. I would say that would occur in the next, the two contracts would be within six months. Okay. And then I believe the president of the Homeowners Association, Ms. Kyla Shea, was a speaker this morning. And I think she mentioned that something could be done on one of the berms to like shave off some of the dirt on the top of it. And she was concerned about that, that why would we be lowering the height of the berm? That doesn't sound like a good solution. Wouldn't it be like building it up even higher than what it was originally, but somehow some of the dirt got shaved off the top of it? Yeah, so they wanted to do a temporary repair to stop the water from discharging. So they took water off the top of the, or soil off the top of the berm to fill in the area that washed out. I think that's a temporary measure. In fact, the repair they made was with wet soil, so that's a temporary repair as well. But we are in discussions with their engineer for the water control district. Do the berms need to be built higher than they have been in the past, do you think? I don't know that they need to be higher. They need to be sound. And the tricky part about natural areas is that the idea, you know, there's not a lot of infrastructure out there to deal with these high water events. And that's why you see berm breaches. And that figure I showed you had four different berm breaches in the same vicinity. And that's because there's water impounded on those properties without, you know, we're not trying to overdrain them. It's more like natural Florida in those areas. And, but as far as a lease J itself goes, we are going to put a work because that particular property has had problems in the past. And we don't want to continue to see that going forward. Okay. Now the other ones are not really county, so. Have the waters receded quite a bit in trail side at this point? They're still impacted. And then, you know, I'm hopeful that we don't, the forecast for the rain is more of a coastal event. So I'm hopeful they aren't as impacted as other parts of the county because they still have a lot of recovery in their drainage system. They just have one way to get it out and it's got to go all the way up to Hal Patioke Park. So if you know where they're at, their water eventually discharges into the South Fork of the St. Lucie River. And that's a long way to run. And that's why it's so slow getting out. Yeah, the word that I got was that at the entrance to trail side where the gate is there, you know, the water was like three feet, three or four feet deep there. So do you know how widespread their road flooding was during the event? Like, was most of the road covered up? Yeah, I think the road is, other than that entrance, was definitely the deepest spot. The road was flooded periodically through the event and then, but it was accessible other than that low spot coming into the community. And how many days were they basically trapped in their homes? They, I don't know that they were trapped in their homes, but they were, you know, very limited on what they could do. Most of them have higher water, higher level vehicles, pickup trucks, and so they could get through that three feet of water. But it's been since the event two weeks ago and they're still not fully recovered. Yeah, I was quite heartened by one of the public speakers when he said that many people have prescriptions delivered to their homes. And that wasn't happening during that period of time. That's something I'd never thought about before. But our hearts go out to them, too. And we'll be watching closely to see how quickly we can get these repairs done. Thank you. Yes, sir. Thank you very much, Mr. Gordon. We will move on. Appreciate it. Do you need action from us? Yeah, we did need a motion for two things. Was the approval to amend the ship program to $25,000 and it would be a grant program without the lien. And the second item was to authorize the movement of funds in the CIP sheet for resiliency to the Savannah CIP sheet in the amount of. $200,000 from the stormwater master plan to the Savannah's. Are there motions or warnings? Yes. I'll move approval of those two items. Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Kapp, seconded by Commissioner Collins. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed, the motion carries unanimously. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next agenda item, Departmental No. 1 Office of Management and Budget items which require board approval. Ms. Stephanie Murley, you are recognized. Good afternoon. Stephanie Murley, Director of the Office of Management and Budget here to present two items on OMB today. Our first item is a permission to accept the State of Florida Department of Transportation Public Transportation Grant Agreement for the Public Transit Block Grant Program. Our Public Works Department is requesting the acceptance of $441,256 in funding for FY27. These funds provide operating assistance for the Martin County Public Bus Service or MARTI in the urbanized area as well as Americans with Disabilities Act Complementary Services. There is a local county match of $441,256 which is currently budgeted in our FY27 transit operating budget. And the second item is amendment to the Coral Garden Septic to Sewer Project CIP Sheet. The Board approved the Coral Garden Sewer CIP Sheet back in FY21. At the time of the construction bid, the cost was estimated at approximately $16.8 million in funding. As the construction is progressing, there have been items that have been encountered resulting in the need for additional funding. So the Utilities and Solid Waste Department is requesting an amendment to the CIP in the amount of $1.2 million on existing funds that are available within the Septic to Sewer overall county budget. And it requires a budget transfer and amendment to the CIP Sheet in order to get this project continued. And that's all I have today. Thank you. Commissioner Capps. I'll move approval of those, but I also have a comment. Administrator Donaldson and I talked about an issue going forward about grants with Amendment 3 coming on and how many of the grants that we seek require rather large local shares or contributions and matches. Like on this item number one, the grant is for $441,000 and the local match is $441,000. Well, with Amendment 3 coming on, our resources are going to be radically reduced to be able to really do much with these grants. So the thought was floated that perhaps we should petition our state legislators at the upcoming meeting in December to push them to reduce the matching requirements for grants going forward. But that could be like the least that the state could do for us considering the depth of these cuts. And I would tend to think local governments would be speaking out about that all around the state and pushing the state to at least reduce the matching requirements to, you know, 5% or 10% instead of 25%, you know, 30%, 40%, 50%. It seems like a really reasonable thing to request at the legislative, what do they call it, the legislative update. Yes. We have our, the local delegation has a meeting in December to take requests from all communities on their priorities. And that could be a priority to ask the state to lower the local's match requirement. Right. So I understand at that meeting the chair speaks and the county administrator speaks at that meeting. And maybe you guys could be our advocates for that issue. Absolutely. Commissioner Hurd. Yeah. And number two, the amendment to the Coral Garden Septic to Sewer Project. So what's being unfunded with the additional 1.22 million that's being given to Coral Gardens? Keep it on that side of the river. Yeah. For the record, Jeremy Covey, Deputy Director, Utilities and Solid Waste. With the additional 1.2 million, that would fully fund the project. Currently, we have in the weightings of right around 900,000 of additional asphalt and road base that we have yet to bill for because of underestimation by the engineer of record. On the quantities, an additional $100,000 in additional concrete and right around $200,000 in additional asphalt for moving pits from the swales to the roadway. Okay. I understand that. But we're robbing Peter to pay Paul. So what are we removing this funding? What project are we removing this funding from? The additional $600,000 from the FPL franchise fees are currently budgeted to the Septic to Sewer overall program, and they do not have an actual line item to go to. So this will move it from the actual program to the project. What about the rest? And the rest of it was from utility funds, correct? Correct. CFC and a current grant. Those funds were earmarked already? Earmarked for some other projects, I'm asking. Currently, they're earmarked just to the actual program itself, the Septic to Sewer program. The FPL franchise fee, isn't it? Correct. Yes, it's just allocated to the general Septic to Sewer program. So you're delaying projects at the back end? I'm asking what projects are being delayed, and I'm not getting an answer. None of the – this was money that was going to be saved for the next project in line, so it does not affect Rocky Point or Old Palm City, but it would delay the next project in line after those. I don't – possibly. Yeah, the funds were intended to be used for the projects needed at that time. Like, currently, Port Salerno is out there. In order to meet that $12,000 cap, if we need to buy down those funds, those funds could be used for that. And then Old Palm City from there, and then Rocky Point from there. Okay, thanks. We have a motion. We don't have a second yet. Second. Thank you. We have a motion by Commissioner Kapp, seconded by Commissioner Collins. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Thank you. Thank you. Our next agenda item is departmental number three, adopt a resolution approving and accepting the acquisition of 20 acres on Southeast Bridge Road from the Conservation Fund as recommended by the Environmental Lands Oversight Committee and approved by the Board of County Commissioners. Ms. Segura, you are recognized. Good afternoon. Carla Segura, Real Property Manager. This request is for the adoption of a resolution approving and accepting the acquisition of two contiguous parcels totaling approximately 20 acres from the Conservation Fund. The acquisition was recommended by the Environmental Lands Oversight Committee in September 2025 for the restoration of Kitchen Creek and potential link between Jonathan Dickinson and the Atlantic Ridge State Park. The acquisition was subsequently approved by the Board of County Commissioners on October 21st, 2025. The two parcels are adjacent to county-owned property off of Bridge Road. The Conservation Fund purchased the property in 2023 for $900,000. Staff obtained two independent appraisals which established an average appraised value of $2,375,000. Staff negotiated a purchase contract in the amount of $1,250,000 which is substantially below the appraised value. This represents a physically responsible acquisition and an effective use of voter-approved referendum funds designated for protecting environmental lands. All title work has been reviewed and there's no encumbrances on the property. Pursuit to Section 139.31 and 139.32 General Ordinances of Martin County Code, staff recommends that the Board adopt a resolution approving the acquisition of the two parcels totaling approximately 20 acres and authorize the chair to execute the vacant land contract in the amount of $1,250,000 and authorize the county administrator or designee to execute any documents necessary to complete the transaction. If there's any questions. Thank you very much. Commissioner Capps. Yes, this is in Hope Sound, so familiar territory. I want to begin this by thanking a couple of people and an entity for their roles in the acquisition of this parcel and I'd love for Mr. John Mayle to maybe highlight anything that I'm missing, but this all started with a couple of old friends of mine in Hope Sound. Julian and Esteline Rogers, who are old friends, and I didn't ask them for permission to recognize their names, but they're familiar enough friends to where Julian and I will laugh about this later. I'm confident that I'll get by with it and he won't be distressed about it. But they're wonderful people. They're very environmentally conscious. They bought the land initially and sold it to the conservation fund as sort of an intermediary for, as I remember, no profit to themselves or very little profit. And they could, as we can see here, they could have made a nice little bundle for themselves, but they didn't. And they're wonderful people, but they left a lot of money on the table because they wanted to see the land put into conservation. And if anybody knows Julian Rogers, a lot of people know him around town. He's kind of like a native vegetation advocate. Yes, he is. He's extremely disturbed about exotic vegetation around the county, as we all should be. But he's quite a guy, and I want to recognize them as my dear friends and community partners. And then they sold it to the conservation fund. And then, as we can see, the conservation fund left a bunch of money on the table, too, by selling it back to us at a massive discount off of its fair market value. So we appreciate the folks at the conservation fund as well. And, John, did I miss anything? Do you have anything to add to that? For the record, John Mayall, Environmental Resource Administrator. The only thing I would add is that he was warned you would do this to him. Oh, good. And didn't protest. This would be one of three properties where Mr. Rogers and his wife have made that investment for the purpose of making sure it's eventually available to the public. Right. Beautiful. Thank you. I noticed that this was ranked last on our ELOC list. And I also note that the present owner is the conservation fund, which doesn't make it sound like it's extremely vulnerable. So why is the conservation fund, whose purpose is conservation, selling us this property? Why is this vulnerable? Because I don't think it is. So I would agree it's no longer vulnerable under ownership of the conservation fund, but their organization doesn't exist to own land necessarily. So they can move out faster. In fact, this acquisition was really in play as part of the Loxalusi project, even before we had funds available to acquire it. So they were kind of taking a risk that eventually it would someday go to the county. There are instances where it's challenging for county government to be the lead on an acquisition and groups like the conservation fund can help us get something protected before it becomes something else and then just hold it until we're able to put together the partnerships or the funding to finish the acquisition. The conservation fund, I'm not familiar with this entity, are they committed to only purchasing lands in Martin County? They're a national organization. But we have really good representation for them here locally and a lot of support for that organization locally. We have a motion by Commissioner Capps. Second. Now we have a second by Commissioner Collins. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? That motion carries unanimously. Thank you so much. Our last agenda item of the day, Department No. 5, Population Technical Bulletin, presented by Ms. Samantha Lovelady. Ms. Lovelady, what do you figure how long is this item going to take? Not long. It's up to you. Fantastic. I can do an aggressive move approval if you want. You can do that. No. Give us a taste. All right. All right. All right. Thank you, though. I appreciate that. Yes. Good afternoon, Commissioner. To my record, Samantha Lovelady with the Growth Management Department. This is an annual update. Into the microphone, please. This is an annual update to the Population Technical Bulletin. The Florida Statutes Chapter 163 requires local government comprehensive plans to be based on permanent and seasonal population estimates and projections. Various elements of the Comp Plan, such as future land use, housing, and capital improvements, are all directly based on population data. Policy 4.1 of Chapter 4 of the Comp Plan requires the county to produce a Population Technical Bulletin. It is based primarily on U.S. Census data and data provided by the University of Florida Bureau of Business and Economic and Business Research, also known as BEBER, for the State of Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research, also known as EDR, for population estimates and projections. are used to generate population data for the county, the municipalities, and for the unincorporated area. The data is then used for planning purposes, such as projecting the future needs for housing and public facilities. So here we have the permanent – actually, I wanted to show you this first. Sorry, this mouse is – I wanted to show you the historical population growth for the county. You can see the 2025 estimates are 0.87% increase over the 2024 estimates. Here you have the permanent population for the municipalities in the unincorporated area. And here you have your peak population. And the peak population is the maximum number of people at the height of the tour season, which includes snowbirds and hotel guests. The weighted average is used for level of service calculations, which is used for the capital improvements plan. It's the average between permanent and peak population with the assumption that five months out of the year are peak and seven months out of the year are permanent. And then we have the planning areas. This is a map of the planning areas for you to look at. This does not – this covers the whole county, not just the municipalities. So your totals on these are the same as the previous tables. The peak totals are the same. They're just separated out between North River Shores, North County, Hutchinson Island, Stewart Urban, Palm City, Port Salerno, Mid County, South County, Indiantown West. And then you also have your peak hotel population. With that, I'll recommend approval. Excellent. Commissioner Capps. Mr. Doolin, maybe for people who don't follow all this stuff all the time, you can tell us why it's important that we have this updated population technical bulletin and why we monitor it, why it's important to the county. Yes, of course. Clyde Doolin, for the record, comprehensive planning administrator. These numbers go into, as Ms. Lovelady said, our capital improvements planning. They go into our long-range planning for county services and for – they're a requirement by our comprehensive plan for our long-range planning. And we use them in any number of ways through our – in our planning process. Thank you. Thank you so much. We have a – we have a recommendation for approval. Move approval. Thank you. Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Hurd, seconded by Commissioner Collins. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed? Motion carries unanimously. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. It brings us to the end of our agenda. We'll take Commissioner comments. I have a – I have a solid 20-minute – Fantastic. – breakdown of all the things I want to say. I look forward to hearing it. No, no. In my card. I have no comment. Thank you. I'm set. Thank you. Commissioner Capps. Congratulations once again – Thank you, sir. – to our new commissioner and our longest-serving Martin County Commissioner for her re-election. I look forward to serving with you both – Excellent. – in the coming days. And – and – – and – wish you the very best in your service. I know you'll enjoy – Say that one more time? I said I wish you the very best. I wish me the best. Okay. Commissioner Vargas. Yes. Welcome, Commissioner Collins, to this die. And you bring a wealth of information, and we will all learn something from you. Wow. Impressive. And, Commissioner Hurd, thank you so much for staying with us again. Again, you have a huge slant on the environment and everything that Martin County has been and will be with the – with your strong hand and your deep knowledge of what makes Martin County so special for us. I would like us to consider evening meetings, especially as we touched on the budget. This is critical. We are coming into a new era. I've been talking about this since early 25, and we need to be able to look at our numbers and our services, and we need to comb through and do what is necessary. We are the stewards of our taxpayers' dollars, and they expect from us, as you heard today and previous days, that we be fiscally sound and responsible. So I appreciate both of you being here. Thank you. That's it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Just in terms of business, I just wanted to confirm that Commissioner Capps mentioned advocating maybe one of our legislative priorities of the state, increasing their contribution. If you're all agreeable with that, we'll add it to it. And should the Chair want to include that in his comments with the local delegation, we will. And then the last thing I'll say is, you know, we will have a lot of lengthy discussions about budgeting because it is compartmentalized in the sense that each taxing authority has its own essentially voting requirements and how that money is spent. And just to remind you that the general fund is just one of those taxing authorities and our fire MSTU is another one and stormwater and parks. And so each one of those will have similar discussions. But one statistic I know that borrowed from one of the managers from a larger county had looked at the amount of reduction, you know, in our budget. You know, there is the value of your property values, and there's the rate that you charge. And leaving the rate alone, if we leave it the way it was last year, it's a 12 percent reduction. And during the Great Recession, we reduced our ad valorem by 12 percent over five years. And we will have to do, if we leave the millage alone, we will do that in one year and have to do it again the second year. But just it is the magnitude of what we are doing with it is significant, and the choices that you all have to make are monumental. So we will be here with you every step of the way, and that's why the number of discussions we have beginning in January and some preliminary conversations even before that will take us six months to go through that. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Our next meeting will be on Tuesday, December 1st. And with that, I wish everyone a very healthy and happy Thanksgiving. My name is Jimmy Ch半g because I am Irrigation of Trustee Ang địa. I hope you are watching everybody PewDiePie. Thank you. Thanks. Happy Thanksgiving.