CivicDunedin, FL › October 23, 2025

CITY COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING - Oct 23, 2025

Dunedin, FL City Commission October 23, 2025 90 minutes
▶ Watch original video Interactive viewer Search Dunedin meetings

Transcript

Commissioner Dugard0:00

I have some hats to give away. You have hats to give away? Seriously? All right. Thank you, Shelby, very much. Okay, since Shelby is passing out the hats and we've gaveled in the meeting but really haven't started, I think we need a let's go Blue Jays. Let's go Blue Jays. Thank you. Let's go Blue Jays. I love this town. It is, it's incredible. It's incredible. All right, well, good evening and welcome to the October 23rd, 2025 commission meeting. I'd like to call this meeting to order. Jen, could you please give the invocation and then followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.

SPEAKER_061:10

Let us begin this meeting by taking a brief moment of silence and reflection. Amen. I pledge allegiance

SPEAKER_041:25

to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Play ball. Play ball.

Commissioner Dugard1:42

The mayor better be watching this meeting. Let me see, absences. Okay, we have some absences up here, if you all didn't notice, that we are missing our mayor tonight as well as Commissioner Sandbergen. And I'll tell you, right after the Blue Jays clinched the championship, they immediately purchased tickets for Toronto. And that's just the flight. There wasn't even tickets to the game. I have heard since then they didn't get tickets. And this is not a taxpayer. She wanted to let you all know it is not a taxpayer expense. It's on her own dime, both the flight and the hotel and the tickets. But both her and Commissioner Sandbergen are representing this week, Dunedin, and cheering on our Blue Jays, who are just absolutely wonderful partners. So I would like a vote on accepting their absences, if I could. Motion to approve. Approved. Whatever. Yes, okay. Okay, all in favor? Aye. Those opposed? Oh, that was close. All right, and that motion passes unanimously. Very good. Michelle, you got that? Yes, sir. Because I'm terrible at taking notes. So, all right, fantastic. We're going to start tonight with some presentations. It is a good evening tonight. Our first one is we are going to sadly but joyfully recognize Principal Glenn, who is principal of Dunedin Highland Middle School, who is leaving us for better grounds. But he needs to be recognized. He's done amazing, amazing work at our middle school. And so, Mr. Glenn, could you please step forward? I like that. And we are going to have Commissioner Dugard say a few comments and read a certification for us.

SPEAKER_113:52

It is with great pleasure that I wish to offer this in recognition of Principal Brandon Glenn. In recognition of being honored as the Pinellas County Schools Principal of the Year 2025, we proudly celebrate your accomplishments, which include leading Dunedin Highland Middle School to achieve an A school grade. Principal Glenn has elevated and empowered excellence in students and staff, transforming the school and fostering a culture of continuous improvement and student connection. The City of Dunedin salutes you. Thank you.

Commissioner Dugard4:33

And if you could hold on just one more moment, sir. I know you're anxious. Dinner's waiting. But we'd all like to say a few comments. And so, Rob, have anything?

SPEAKER_044:52

Principal Glenn, I just want to say, we first met when I came and participated in Teach Across America at your school. And I was just so impressed with the teachers and the staff. And that truly is a reflection on you. And you're what is Pinellas Principal of the Year. You know what? That is such an honor. And I don't know where you're going, but we're going to miss you. You've done a remarkable job. Thank you.

SPEAKER_015:29

Go to the podium. Push the little button. On your phone.

Commissioner Dugard5:32

Thank you, sir. Is he on?

SPEAKER_015:35

Come on. The City of Dunedin has been nothing but great to me and my family. I remember one of my very first meetings with Commissioner, well, Vice Mayor Gao. He was the commissioner at the time. And we had a very in-depth conversation of what he would like to see as far as bringing academic focus back to our community schools. And I made a promise to him that we were going to do that. I am going on to a different role, which will sadly in a different county. But I am excited about that. And I will truly miss Dunedin Highland Middle School and the City of Dunedin. Thanks again for all your support. And it is truly a special community to be a part of. So thank you.

Commissioner Dugard6:18

You know, and that was a wonderful first meeting that we had. Oh, and you do have to step back up because we need pictures. Yeah, we have to. We need pictures. But before that, Brendan, I'm just, he's a falcon. He's a Dunedin High School alumni. And to come back into our community, God, and teach middle school. That is so hard. And to lead a middle school is harder. And you did it with such professionalism, with such grace and passion for the students. And you just saw them just blossom and grow. And it is so often that in the school system, right, it's almost like spinning plates. You get leaders that can really create something in a school and they go, oh, great, well, let's take them to another school and they can do that there. But it's taken that leadership away. I know we'll get more leadership at the middle school. And I know that the ones that are under you have been trained by you and worked with you. So I'm sure they will carry on in that same spirit. But you will be missed. And the students will miss you. The teachers will miss you. Administration will miss you. And the city will miss you. But we do wish you well. It's bittersweet. But thank you for everything you've done for our community. And our Highland Games are in April. So if you want to. Picture time. Okay. Now we're going to recognize our first responders, including public works professionals, on October 28th, National First Responders Day. And I will pass it on to Commissioner Walker.

SPEAKER_048:32

Thank you, Vice Mayor. Can I get all the first responders and public works folks up to the podium?

Commissioner Dugard8:40

That's a good-looking picture there. I think we need a city calendar, Sue, and just the pictures here.

SPEAKER_048:48

Wow. This is such a group. Wow. This is such an incredible group.

Commissioner Dugard9:03

Oh, and law enforcement. Well done. Yes. Very good. They are first responders. Thank you, Sue, very much.

SPEAKER_049:11

That's fantastic. So in recognition of National First Responder Day, whereas first responders, including firefighters, paramedics, police officers, public work professionals, and other emergency personnel, stand in the front lines of our communities, selflessly serving and protecting the citizens of the city of Dunedin in time of crisis. And whereas first responders respond swiftly and courageously to emergencies, often putting their own lives at risk to ensure the safety and well-being of others, whether in natural disasters, accidents, medical emergencies, or public health and safety threats. And in 2003, President George W. Bush issued Presidential Policy Directive 8, PPD 8, and Homeland Security Presidential Directive 5, HSPD 5, officially recognizing public works as first responders. And as of 2019, the U.S. Senate has included language recognizing public works alongside fellow and other first responders. And it is in the public interest for citizens, civic leaders, and children in the city of Dunedin to gain knowledge of and maintain an ongoing interest and understanding of the importance of public works and other first responder efforts in their respective communities. And the city of Dunedin would like to authorize the city of Dunedin Public Works and Utilities and Engineering Departments to use the public works first responder symbol as adopted by American Public Works Association. And to ensure the symbol is displayed wherever appropriate and can raise awareness among all citizens, government officials, and other first responders about the crucial role of public works professionals play in emergency management efforts. Now, therefore, I, Robert James Walker, by virtue of the authority vested in me by the mayor of the city of Dunedin, Florida, and on behalf of the entire city commission, do hereby proclaim October 28, 2025 as National First Responders Day and urge all citizens to join with representative of the American Public Works Association and governmental agencies in paying tribute to all of our first responders to recognize the substantial contributions they make to protecting our national health, safety, and advancing the quality of life for all.

Commissioner Dugard11:57

Would you like to say a few words?

SPEAKER_0812:14

Those behind us stand in front of us in every emergency. They respond. And we really appreciate the recognition for all of them, those who are here and those who aren't here that you don't see. They rock.

SPEAKER_1112:36

I do just want to thank all of the first responders. Obviously, in the last year, we've really seen the value and just how important it is to have quality first responders and teamwork across all the different jobs that we all do in the city. So thank you very much.

SPEAKER_0813:00

I thought Sue's going to get pictures here.

SPEAKER_0913:10

What do you want them? We can do it. Up along there. Squish in. You can do it. Squish in. I'm going to horn in on this one. We need to have a good call.

Commissioner Dugard13:31

We got it. We got it. We got it. That's pretty much anybody. We got to get closer. Closer.

SPEAKER_0913:37

Yes.

SPEAKER_0313:37

Yes. Pretend it's the middle of the EOC, right?

SPEAKER_0913:41

It's a little storm. You've got to get closer.

SPEAKER_0313:44

Come on.

SPEAKER_0213:45

Yes.

SPEAKER_0913:47

Double up.

SPEAKER_0813:48

There you go.

SPEAKER_0313:49

Come on. I'll go up for me. I'm going to be over here.

Speaker13:54

Yeah.

SPEAKER_0313:55

Yeah.

SPEAKER_0813:56

Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker13:57

I'm going to go up right here. Yeah. Perfect.

SPEAKER_0314:02

I'll get you.

Speaker14:04

Okay. Sue.

SPEAKER_0914:06

Which Sue?

SPEAKER_0314:07

Yes. Guys, a little tighter over this side. Come on. Just bring it in just for a couple minutes here. A minute. Not quite a minute. Okay. Ready? Okay. Thank you.

Speaker14:26

Thank you. Thank you.

Commissioner Dugard14:34

And one more presentation. Last but certainly not least, George and Bonnie, can you step forward, please, and be recognized? It's George and Bonnie McPherson, everyone. And they lead Clan McPherson in the U.S. And it is, they're having their annual gathering here. And when clans have an annual gathering, it's actually global. So we will have visitors from all over the world in Dunedin this weekend, all of them Clan McPherson, all of them wearing spectacular tartans like they are displaying now. So it is just going to be spectacular. They had their first gathering in 2019 and they came and visit our city. And it's just an example of what happens when clans get together and one of the reasons why I push so much for tartans and fabric and community because it's such a strength of family when they come here. You see them all over. They have parades down the Pinellas Trail. They engage into the high school pipe band and have them lead the parade down the trail. They take over Pioneer Park for a beautiful picture that's displayed on their website that says City of Dunedin from Pioneer Park on it. So they really embrace who we are as a community. And so it's just fabulous. I'm so proud that they are here. I do have to disclose that I am actually a member of Clan McPherson, but I did not have any involvement on getting them here. But I am nonetheless proud. So it is Clan McPherson Day, so I do have a proclamation. And it's Clan McPherson Days. We're as citizens of Scottish descent have made enduring contributions to our city, our state, and our nation with hard work, faith, and values. And on Clan McPherson Days to be celebrated October 23rd through October 26th, 2025, the spirit and character of a group of these citizens descended from one of Scotland's greatest clans will be celebrated and recognized for their contributions to our culture and way of life. And whereas the City of Dunedin and Scotland have long shared ties of family and friendship with many of these finest customs and ideals, having first grown to maturity on Scotland's soil, the Declaration of Arboreth, the Scottish Declaration of Independence in 1320, embodied the Scottish strong dedication to liberty, and this tradition is brought to the new world by Scots. And whereas the sons and daughters of many Scottish clans were among the first pioneers to settle in London, Florida, and in the City of Dunedin, and their will and determination helped to build our city's character. And whereas many Scottish Americans were great inventors and philanthropists, founding and supporting numerous scientific, educational, and civic institutions, and from the evocative sounds of the bagpipes to the great sport of golf and to the very roots of country music, the Scots have left an indelible mark on our culture. And whereas Al Canning, a lifelong member of the Clan Macpherson Association, was a founding member and one of the early presidents of the Dunedin Scottish American Society, and whereas during the period 23 October 2025 to 26 October 2025, the United States branch of Clan Macpherson Association, which is currently led by Chairman David Macpherson, and it holds an annual gathering and annual meeting in Dunedin. And whereas with the observance of Clan Macpherson Days from October 23 through October 26, the opportunity is afforded to many citizens of Dunedin to celebrate Americans who claim Scottish ancestry, with our city's thanks and appreciation most especially extended to those Scottish Americans Americans that have faithfully served in our nation's armed forces. Now therefore I, Jeff Gow, by the virtue of the authority vested in me by the Mayor of the City of Dunedin, and on behalf of this entire City Commission, hereby recognize October 23 through October 26, 2025 as Clan Macpherson Days in the City of Dunedin, and urge all citizens to observe the day by celebrating the continued friendship between the people of this great Clan of Scotland and the people of Dunedin, and by recognizing the contributions of all Scottish Americans to our city, state, and nation. So thank you.

SPEAKER_0219:43

Good evening. George and I want to thank the City of Dunedin and the Dunedin Council for welcoming us and all of the Clan Macpherson. You have made us feel like we're at home. And to you, Vice Mayor Jeff Gow, who, by the way, is also a Clan member of the Clan Macpherson, we thank you. You have helped us with so much to make this weekend a great success. Thank you again.

SPEAKER_1220:22

I would like to read a message from Jamie Macpherson of Clooney, the 28th Hereditary Chief of the Clan Macpherson. To the Mayor and citizens of Dunedin, Florida, we are truly honored and most touched by this wonderful proclamation of Clan Macpherson Day in the City of Dunedin, Florida. Our links with the United States of America go back a long way, and the contributions that Scots have made is evident across the length and breadth of the country alongside the traditions that are still followed throughout America. So to have this day recognized specifically toward my Clan is a great honor, and in our usual Scottish way, we will raise a glass across the world to the City of Dunedin on Clan Macpherson Day. I'm sorry I cannot be there in person to celebrate this legacy, but I know many Macpherson Clan members will be there in my stead as representatives of the Clan. With all of our best wishes and a salute from Scotland, yours aye. Clooney.

Commissioner Dugard21:26

Thank you. Can I have the proclamation? Would you like that? Do you want me to bring it tomorrow night?

SPEAKER_1221:38

If you and the council members that are present there tomorrow night could read it. Yeah.

Commissioner Dugard21:43

Then we could accept it. So we'll just hold on to it and I'll present to you? Yeah. That would be fantastic. Very good. All right. Clan Macpherson, everyone. And yes, a picture please. Yes, please. Do you need a letter from Jamie for the record? Yes, please. That would be wonderful. If you don't mind.

SPEAKER_0221:57

Thank you so much. Up here. Up here. Yes, yes. Let's see. A little this way so we can. This way. This way. This way.

SPEAKER_0322:09

Perfect. Perfect. Yes. Because I've got the commissioners behind you. Yes. And do you want. Okay. We're going to wait on the proclamation. Okay. There we go. Okay. Perfect. We'll do it this way. Look a little. Turn a little bit. Perfect. Thank you. Thank you so much.

Commissioner Dugard22:39

Thank you. And also as you guys are leading out, you don't need to stand here for this, but I do want to apologize to you all. I know that we had some wonderful events planned and those stinking Blue Jays, they have just blown the whole thing up. So we apologize. We're really sorry about that. Sorry. Well, sorry, not sorry. So, but we'll do, we'll do our, our best to, to get there and engage and do what we do. There we go. There we go. I like that. I like that. But welcome, welcome to Dunedin. Thank you so much. All right. And y'all don't need to stay. If there's anybody here that's hanging out because they were involved in a presentation, you are allowed to leave.

SPEAKER_0923:36

It's quite okay. Unless you work for the city of Dunedin, in which case you must stay.

Commissioner Dugard23:40

You must stay. Something about the night shift, she said. I don't know. Yeah. No kidding. He's off. Uh, citizen input. Is there anyone in the audience that wishes to speak on a topic that is not currently on the agenda? All right. If so, please come forward. You have three minutes. All right. Harry, if you can give your name and address for the record.

SPEAKER_1324:06

This is a little bit of a commercial. Captain Harry, Windstar Sailing Charters, home address 646 Scotland Street. I'm a member of the Marina Advisory Committee. I'm a member of the Causeway Coastal Committee. And I'm speaking here on my own behalf tonight. And I will remind us that, you know, at the meeting this month, we did not say the ferry's open. Oh, we forgot. We did. I meant to bring it up. We didn't say the ferry's open. I'm here to talk about the Marina. Don't throw anything. Okay. I don't know where to start. On some of these committees, as a member, you feel like you're just a little fish not being heard. And I will say that that is not the case on the Marina Advisory Committee, especially now. We are being heard. And there are some of the things we're asking for. It's like, not now. And some of it is, yep, that's in the works. We're well being heard. And that's really what I'm here to say is that the commissioners, the city staff have lived through a roar. I just see this roar. I saw this room full of people. But you've heard what you needed to hear. And that was, we need the Marina open. We need to do what we have to do to get to make that happen. And you've done it. We're open. We have a long way to go. And we have a lot of decisions to make. But you guys have done a great job. The slips are open. The ferry's open. The fence changed. I didn't even think about it. What an amazing thing to change the fence from black to silver. It looks like progress instead of get out, stay out, stay out. Huge, huge perception. And I appreciate how open right now. I drove through there today. There's a crane sitting in the parking lot. We're starting. We're starting to to move forward. And it's because of you guys. Unanimous. Jennifer, excellent job. I got it done in a minute and nine. Thank you. Well, then please continue. Jeff, you particularly look excellent. It is all

SPEAKER_0426:16

about you. I'm going to start weeping here in just a moment. I'm holding back myself because it

SPEAKER_1326:21

really means a lot to me. You know, when you say the Blue Jay thing, that's the ocean for those of us that are addicted to it. And I am. I'm addicted to the ocean. I don't know. You know, that's my ground. That's where I'm grounded. When I when I walked down to the marina after both of the storms, my boat was still there. I was like, OK, I'm grounded. I'm OK. And a lot of people have sports for that. I think sports are a great thing. You asked me to keep going. I think sports are a great thing for Sunday afternoon because I can sit in my recliner and take a nap. And I still look like a man. That's what I'm supposed to do in front of a football game. Thank you. Have a good day. Keep doing what you're doing. We've got a ways to go. Thank you. Thank you, Harry,

Commissioner Dugard27:04

very much. And certainly a lot of that heavy lifting does go to staff. It is the staff. I've got to start over.

SPEAKER_1327:17

It is with the staff. And I can't. I don't want to mention them all. I don't want to leave anybody out. But they're amazing. They are amazing. And it's, yeah, they're the ones that are doing the work. This guy over here, he's working all the time. He's always has a smile. Gives me half the money, not all of it. Thank you, Harry. Thank you, Harry, very, very much.

Commissioner Dugard27:36

Is there anyone else who would like to speak to any topic that is not on the agenda? Hearing none, seeing none. I will bring it back to the commission. All right. We have a consent agenda. So you need to approve the minutes for the October, the August 7th regular meeting and the September second workshop. Item 2B, board and committee appointments, the U.S. Veterans Advisory Committee. And 2C, the contract addendum for Granicus Open Cities website and advanced government cloud packages for gov delivery newsletters. And award, right? Yeah, we're still on consent. And 2D, award the bid 25, 2531 for laboratory services, annual contract to advance environmental laboratories incorporated. And to Eurofins, your environment testing southeast of Altamont Springs. And 2E, wines the blues festival revocable license agreement 2025. Does anyone wish to pull any of those items? Yes, I wish to pull 2A. 2A. Okay. And anything else? All right. Can I get a a motion on 2B through 2E, please? So moved. Second. All right. All in favor? Aye. Oh, thank you very much. Is there anybody who has a comment on any of those agenda items, 2B through 2E, if I ask that correctly? Anybody want to speak on those items? All right. Seeing none, we will bring it back. All right. And I'm sorry. Is there a do I have to redo the motion? And no, is there a vote? All in favor? All right. And that motion passes unanimously. And I think we needed to vote, actually, on that one. Yeah. Yeah. I say I know there's three of us, and two of us either make it, move it, and so it's like, okay. The minutes. Tom, which one you want?

SPEAKER_1129:50

Is there a question or correction or? There is, there does need to be a correction on page 17 of the minutes on 25-17. The current reading of the minutes in the second line, which are my comments, reads, he insisted on more than 50% approval of homeowners because he felt he should have the, they should have the right to say what happens to their homes. That should read 100%, not 50%.

Commissioner Dugard30:15

Okay. And Michelle, do you got that? Fantastic. All right. And was that it? Tom, is there anything else? All right. Rob, any comments, anything since it's open? All right. Do I have a motion on item 2A? So moved. Second. All right. And anyone, ah, see, look at that. I got it. Anybody from the audience have anything to say about 2A? Minutes? Hearing none, seeing none, I'll bring it back. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Those opposed? Ayes have it unanimously. Well done. Action items 3A, resolution 25-26, fiscal year 25. It's a fourth quarter amendment. Jen, if you could please read the resolution 25-26 by Ty Vallone. Resolution 25-26, a resolution of the

SPEAKER_0631:15

city commission of the city of Dunedin, Florida, amending the city's operating and capital budget for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2024 and ending September 30, 2025 and providing for an effective date. That was resolution 25-26, read by title only. Thank you. All right. And, um, I'll ask for a motion

Commissioner Dugard31:36

on this. So moved. Second. And, ah, staff, Les. Good evening. Talk to us about the budget amendment. Good

SPEAKER_1031:50

evening, ah, Vice Mayor. Commissioners, Les Tyler, the finance director. I'm here with Gene, our budget manager. This is resolution, ah, 25-26. Do we need to read the resolution first, or? We already did. Yeah, we already did. Yeah. This is resolution 25-26. This is, ah, fourth amendment for the fiscal year 25 budget. Florida statute 166241 provides for a municipality to amend its budget at any time during the fiscal year or within 60 days after the fiscal year. Our fiscal year is September 30th each year. The proposed amendments are on pages 2 through 7 in the staffing report and listed in attachment B. The total impact on fund balance is shown on page 2 of the staffing report for each fund impacted. The total impact on all funds is $629,000. I would like to briefly go over the key amendments, ah, in the different funds, starting with the general fund. The general fund, ah, the first item is an increase in expenditures of $18,740 in the fleet replacement ISF account. And that's for outfitting, ah, lighting and, ah, and striping for the, ah, the fire department vehicle 116, which is a 2024 F-150, ah, full-wheel drive crew, ah, super crew cab. That item was below the, ah, delegate authority threshold. And it's a decrease to fund balance in the general fund. The next item in the general fund is an increase, ah, in the expenditures budget of $33,265. And that's for the streets portion of the, ah, LAC consulting, ah, related to the implementation for the public works improvements and operations. The total cost of that, ah, was $166,322. And the general fund's portion is $33,265. This results in a decrease to fund balance in the general fund. And this amendment, ah, this particular amendment for LAC consulting is in five different funds. I won't go over all of them today, but, ah, the total amount is $33,265 in each of the funds. And this is the general funds portion. And again, I want to mention LAC was to implement efficiency studies, ah, for the public works department. And that item was presented to commission on May 22nd, 2025, approval of an agreement and purchase order with LAC consulting for, to implement the efficiency recommendations that they provided to the city prior. Uh, the next fund is the stadium fund. This is an item of a decrease in insurance expense in our, ah, of $123,800 in our stadium fund. And, ah, this was, we, we out, we budgeted our 25 property insurance and we later received information after the budget was completed last year that had, ah, it was a, ah, a report from Gearing Group, our consultant that has a list of assets with premiums by location. And, ah, ah, some of the premiums changed quite a bit with that updated information. Ah, and one of the larger changes was in the stadium fund. So, ah, what we're doing here is we're sort of truing up to what those premiums, ah, should have been for 2025. The total costs aren't changing at all, but we are transferring from some, from some funds to another. The stadium fund is, is have, actually having a decrease, ah, in cost of $120,800. And that report, ah, reflects that. Some of the changes in other funds were very minor. Ah, this fund had one of the largest changes and there's one other fund that we'll go over later that had a pretty large change. But this results in an increase in fund balance in the stadium fund. And we did discuss this in the 26 budget process. We, we talked about this, ah, in the, ah, August 6th, 2025 workshop. We mentioned that we, we're going to have a, ah, a revision to the 25 estimates. And we talked about 26 estimates as well. And we're just trying to true up better information. Normally those reports, when they come out later, they're very, very close to what we had budgeted. But in 2025, there was quite a difference. So we wanted to true it up. Ah, that's the only stadium fund adjustment. And the next is the ARPA fund. We had one, ah, adjustment in the ARPA fund, and that was $180,000 increase in expense for the purchase, ah, for the fire department of an, ah, of a fire truck that was, ah, that was purchased. Ah, it was, it was taken to commission on September 18th. Ah, it was a 20, 2011 E1 surplus, ah, fire engine that we purchased from, ah, Palm Harbor Fire. The purchase of the vehicle was $150,000, but we had accessories, ah, that we needed to add to that for $30,000. So this is $180,000 increase and a, and a decrease to fund balance in the ARPA fund. The next is the CRA fund. We had a, a reclass of $173,000 of an expenditure budget for Skinner Boulevard improvement project from, ah, improvements other than buildings to other contractual services. This is really just an accounting adjustment to make sure we get it in the proper account. And this is, ah, a transfer to, to ensure that. And this item was presented to the city commission on August 7th. Ah, it was, ah, award bid 25-2515 for Skinner Boulevard electrical improvements for $172,000. The next fund is the water sewer fund. And there's a few adjustments in this fund. The first of which is a transfer of $150,000 from the wastewater process equipment, R and R project repair, repair and reclass project to the water wastewater treatment plant emergency generator building rehab project. Ah, the projects budgeted in 26th, but staff determined it was necessary to start working for design in 2025. So we, we made that transfer of $150,000. Ah, it was just a transfer. So there's no change in fund balance with that item. Ah, the, this item was presented to commission on August 7th, ah, as part of approval of a GEC service authorization to Tetra Tech in the amount of $149,694. The next item in the water wastewater fund is a reclass of $117,200 from the wastewater process equipment, R and R project maintenance account to the machinery and equipment account for the purchase of an eight inch bypass pump. This transfer is to ensure the expenses in the correct GL account for the purchase of that item. Ah, there was no change in that position. As a result of that, it was just a transfer. And that item was presented to the city commission on July 17th, ah, commission approval and ratification of the FDEP consent order and authorization to purchase a trailer mounted wastewater bypass pump for $117,000. The next item in water sewer fund is a transfer of $350,000 from the Virginia street water main replacement project to the utilities relocation on Curlew project. Ah, additional design work was, was necessary due to the F, FDOT changes on the project. And there's no change in net position on that. That was just a transfer. The Virginia street project had extra funding and it was transferred to cover the Curlew project. And that was presented to city commission on September 18th, 2025, ah, which is a service authorization with, ah, Chin Moore and associates CMA for additional engineering design work of $314,000. Ah, the next item in water sewer is, ah, another insurance. I wanted to mention this, another insurance adjustment. This is the same as the one I mentioned in the stadium fund. Ah, the, when we trued up the, ah, property insurance allocations, ah, the water sewer fund is having an additional expense of $112,200. So they, ah, the stadium fund and the water sewer fund had the largest adjustments. And, ah, in the water sewer fund, it's an increase in expense. And that is decreasing the, ah, net position of the water sewer fund. And I mentioned again, we discussed that some on the, on the August 6th workshop number two for the 26 budget discussions. Ah, next is the marina fund. We have one adjustment there. We have an increase in capital expense budget of $249,660. And that was for the purchase and installation of electrical pedestals at the marina. Ah, that resulted in a net, in a decrease in net position in the marina fund. However, we are expecting that to be, ah, reimbursed by FEMA. We're expecting that this item to be reimbursed, ah, by 75% FEMA and, and 12.5% state. Ah, that's our expectation. And this item was presented to the city commission on May 8th. Ah, and that was approval of RFQ 2505 for the purchase of marina shore power pedestals for the marine electrical equipment, ah, any amount of $210,000. And also included an award, ah, of the installation of the pedestals with fuel electric for $38,960. And next is the golf fund. We have, ah, one adjustment there. We had an increase in the facility's custodial costs. Our internal service fund expense of $15,075, ah, for custodial services at the Dundee golf club. Ah, this was, this was not included in the original 25 budget. We realized that and, and, ah, posted it later. And that resulted in a decrease in net position in the golf fund of $15,000. And that was below the delegated authority amount of, of 25,000. Next is the fleet fund. Ah, fleet fund only adjustment was, ah, fleet fund had a, ah, an increase in the revenue in the fleet fund of $18,740 for the outfitting of the fire department vehicle that I mentioned earlier in the general fund. Vehicle 116 was replaced and, and this $18,000 is, ah, moving revenue into that fund as well as the extra expense to pay for the outfitting. So that has no net impact on fund balance in the fleet fund. And next is the facility maintenance fund. The, this is an increase in the revenue budget, ah, and the expense budget for the facility maintenance fund, the ISF fund to $15,075. And that's the offset to the custodial services at the golf club. And that's just recognizing revenue and also the expense side of the facility fund. And that's got, has no net, no, no increase or decrease in net position. That concludes, that concludes the, ah, the amendments. I would like to point out that, ah, included in the packet in, in the last page and attachment C, we always, we always show the Indian available fund balances. We, we, we show, we show the impact of these, ah, amendments, ah, on the fund balances of these funds that we went over today. And, ah, it shows the beginning fund balance and then the estimated fund balance at the end of 2025. Ah, we're still working through our 2025 numbers. We closed our year end and we've got lots of year end accruals and different things we're doing, but we, ah, but we have our, the estimates, ah, in the report today and all funds, ah, meet or exceed the reserve target levels with the exception of a few that I'll briefly go over. Ah, and these are really not surprises. These were, these estimates were also included in our 26 budget, ah, estimates, but I wanted to mention them. The water sewer fund is, ah, slightly below target. The target is 25% and we're at about 24.4%. So it's just slightly under the target in the water sewer utility fund. The stormwater fund is below the target of 25%. Ah, that fund is, that's fund still building up reserves, ah, you know, with the rate study we implemented in 25 with, with, with some of the rate adjustments. And, ah, that began in 25 and that it'll take a little bit of time to build those reserves up. And we discussed that some as well during the 26 budget process. And, and the other one is the golf operations fund. The golf operations fund is projected to have, ah, you know, a fund balance reserve right now of about 3% in 2025. That is below our target for sure. You know, we, ah, this was our first year of operation. We had our, ah, we had the storm, we had different events that happened. Ah, and, ah, we, we're still working through the numbers as I mentioned. But, ah, our, our, we're, we are anticipating our 26 revenues to, to be better the next year as far as, ah, you know, ah, green fee revenues and, and also, ah, you know, ah, membership revenues as well. But we are, we are watching the golf operations fund very closely. It's a new fund, as you know. It's, it's, it's a new fund and a new operation that we're, we've got really not even a full year under our belt really. We really, we really, we really, the course opened, ah, we're supposed to open November 1st. It didn't, it opened even after that because of the storm. So, ah, so we, ah, we're a, a little under where we projected. But we're, ah, we're, we do have positive estimates for 26 that will be, start building those reserves to where we start getting that to that 25% and then more than that moving forward. That includes our, our general comments. I'd be happy to answer any questions. And we'll start with Commissioner Walker.

SPEAKER_0444:54

Thank you, Vice Mayor. I just really have one. I, I, when I looked at this, I, I go back and I just refresh in terms of the decisions were made and how they were doing it. But I, really, this is more esoteric. Um, how are we doing on our FEMA reimbursements?

SPEAKER_1045:11

Uh, FEMA, our, it's a process. We, we're, we work, are working diligently with Tetra Tech. Uh, FEMA's, FEMA's slowed down a lot with, with the federal shutdown. Uh, you know, that's impacted, uh, that's impacted the admin support that deal with our stuff for sure. Uh, but aside from that, that's not been that long. We are, we, we've, uh, we've been working with, uh, FEMA. We've got, uh, a lot of our, a lot of our marina projects are almost through FEMA. I mean, the review process, uh, that doesn't mean they haven't approved them yet, but, but through the the review process, uh, our debris removal, we, we still have about 3.2 million of debris removal that we expect from FEMA. We, we expect, expect that to be obligated. The, that 3.2 million dollar amount, uh, within the next 60 days and have that funding in our, uh, we should receive the funding by December, we hope, uh, for that piece. Uh, so we're working, we're working through it with them, but, but it is, uh, it is a process. There's a lot, there's a lot of, uh, moving parts, uh, the, the, the larger, the larger assets, uh, are the marina, obviously, you know, some of the larger ones and, and the pure, the pure two that's in the general fund, not the marina fund, but, uh, but we are, and we work and the state's been a good partner. You know, the state is involved in the whole review process with this, and we've got a really good representative from the state. Uh, one of the challenges that we have, and I think all cities have this, FEMA changes, changes their representatives on a regular basis, and, you know, we've, since the storm, these two storms, Helene and Milton, we're on our fourth rep now, and, and that, that, that doesn't, that doesn't help communication as far as, uh, where, where we at, you know, because, uh, but, but, but we're working through it. We have, uh, weekly meetings, uh, with Tetra Tech, uh, and we also have every two week meetings with, with FEMA. Uh, I do think that by March, we, we should have, uh, we should have the, uh, the east, the, the east wall at the marina, and doc A, A and V, uh, know where FEMA's at with those two, and hopefully have their approval, hopefully obligation, and obligation means that FEMA's approved it, and then it goes to the state, and then two or three months later, hopefully the state approves it, and then, then the funding

SPEAKER_0447:36

becomes available. I appreciate that. And then, in terms of the reporting of this, and just kind of the, the tracking of the progress, does that typically happen during these weekly meetings, or is that kind of where we get our information? Does the state, I guess the other part, is, is the state facilitating this discussion, or is it Tetra Tech, or how does that work?

SPEAKER_1048:00

The, the, the, the meetings with FEMA are, are with my, with myself, uh, Tetra Tech, and our county manager, uh, Tanya Duffy, uh, uh, those are the weekly meetings. The, the ones with FEMA include that same group, and then it also includes a state rep, uh, plus, plus a couple of FEMA reps. So, those are good because, uh, when we have those, there's, there's, uh, individuals at a higher level from FEMA, which helps, helps them make decisions quicker, which, we, we, we found those meetings, to have those every, every two or three weeks, has been helpful because it, it, it clears up questions that our first line of contact, uh, you know, we're, we're working with, and kind of moving things along a little, a little better. Yeah, I appreciate that. Thank you.

SPEAKER_1148:46

Mr. Degard. Thank you, Vice Mayor. Um, I was noticing inside the general fund, we have an increased expenditure by 18, 740 for fleet replacement. We also have a line item later on for fleet. Help me understand what we're doing here. Are they both fleet? What, what, one's in a restricted fund and one's not? Help me understand why we have two fleet adjustments in two separate areas, one in general and one in fleet. Go ahead. Yeah, sure. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_0049:21

All right. Commissioner, what happens is, um, the way that it works when we have an ISF fund, the, um, department. So like in this case, the fire department will book an expense, will post an expense. So in the thousands at 18,000 and then there's an offsetting entry in the fleet fund. So the expense is coming to the general fund because it was something that should have been paid throughout the fleet replacement plan. They realized when they bought the vehicle, they needed a little extra to do this striping. So fire is bearing the expense. So that's why it's in the general fund. And then the way, the mechanism for it to work in the fleet fund is to show it come in as revenue and then have the expense go out to the vendor for purchasing the needed items or services. So they're, they, they basically offset each other with, um, fleet in this instance, not bearing, not bearing any expense. It's, it's just being passed through them. So there's no, there's no change

SPEAKER_1150:27

in fund balance and fleet. Okay. Now we only have $52,000 in general fund adjustments. That's what we saw on the first segment. Is that correct? 52? 52,000. 005. Yeah. Right. That's correct. Yeah. Okay. Now all of these others are separate enterprise funds or separate funds. Are they cat, should be, shouldn't there be a subcategory within those? Because some of those seem to be fully standing enterprise funds and others seem to be integrated inside the budget. Just want to be sure I understand what I'm looking at when I see the summary. Yeah. Well, they're all, they're all

SPEAKER_1051:00

separate funds. And as an example, stadium fund is a, is a special revenue fund. We call it in the governmental accounting. ARPA is a special revenue fund. Solid waste is an enterprise fund. Yep. Water waste, water's enterprise, marine and stormwater enterprise, Gulf enterprise, and then the fleet and facilities are internal service funds. So they are, they're all, they're all

SPEAKER_1151:19

our separate standalone funds. The only reason I say that is because we're kind of co-mingling all of those. Some are enterprise funds, some are special funds. It just strikes me that we might want to have subcategories within that. Enterprise funds being one category and then special funds being another, just so we get a little bit more focus on that. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Commissioner Dugard51:40

Thank you. You know, I, I really don't have anything other than the, the golf fund. And it is where it is, is that because I write, they started late. We've had some storms. So it's kind of been, and it was the first year. So you've got a whole lot going on there. A lot of best guessing and things of that nature of where we think we'll end up. But is, is, was this more revenue short or increase in expenses because of the storm or really is it a combination of, of both? I, I think it's a

SPEAKER_1052:22

combination of both. Yeah. I think that the revenues are, are, are some, are less than, uh, projected in, uh, in, in budgeted in 25. Uh, you know, the storm was part of it, but then also, uh, the revenue estimates from out, from outside play, uh, for quite a few months were less than budgeted, uh, you know, during the year in 25. Uh, so I'd say a combination of both. Yeah. All right. And,

Commissioner Dugard52:51

uh, we have individually talked about all these items throughout the year. So this isn't the first time we've really seen them. So anybody at home that's thinking that we're not really giving it the focus we deserve, we have seen all this before. And so, um, with that, if there's no other questions, I will ask for a motion. Oh, thank you. We can, we can do that. Uh, is there anybody from the audience who would like to speak on this topic? Seeing none, hearing none. I will bring it back. Thank you, Michelle. All right. Do I have a motion? So moved. Second. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. Very good. All right. Did we? Then, all right. The legal people said we did, we did. So all in favor? Aye. Oh, wait. Oh, I'm sorry. Voice vote. I'm sorry. And no final comments, I'm assuming. No, there can't be. At some point, the training wheels will come off. I know.

SPEAKER_0353:53

Okay. Okay. Commissioner Walker. Aye. Commissioner Dugard. Aye. And vice mayor. Aye.

Commissioner Dugard54:01

Aye. And, and the motion passes. Well done. Look at us go. It's blue jay fever. You got, you got to know it's blue jay fever. It is blue jay fever. Now I'm trying to figure out where I am. Okay. That was item, uh, 3a. So now we'll go on to 3b. Uh, so Jen, could you please read

SPEAKER_0654:22

resolution 2531 by title only? Yes. Resolution 25-31, a resolution of the city of Dunedin, Florida, relating to the state revolving fund loan program, making findings, amending resolution number 21-25, approving the form and authorizing execution of the third amendment to the loan agreement, establishing pledge revenues, designating authorized representatives, providing assurances, providing for conflict, severability, and an effective date. That was resolution 25-31,

Commissioner Dugard54:52

read by title only. You know, I see certainly where the mayor gets addicted to that read by title only, and it's not over until you hear that. Um, I can ask for a motion. So moved. Second.

SPEAKER_0955:09

You do have no choice. If I want out of here. All righty. And we have, what, Nan, Alex, Les,

SPEAKER_0755:19

whoever. There we go. Uh, good evening, mayor, uh, or vice mayor, commission, and staff. Uh, Alex Gonzalez, project engineer. And I'm here today to present the, uh, recommendation of, uh, commission approval of resolution 25-31, authorize, authorize, authorizing the execution of a long day. Yeah. Revise amendment number three for a one year time extension and $295,000 increase for technical services during construction to the loan agreement, WW5202C1 by the city of Dunedin to finance the construction of various wastewater projects and repealing resolution 25-20. Uh, in short, uh, we have an agreement with the FTP and their state revolving fund SRF. Uh, the city was granted a clean water SRF loan in 2021 for various wastewater projects, which includes the, uh, recently awarded wastewater treatment plant electrical upgrade project. Uh, the, uh, the SRF program, uh, operates on a yearly cycle, uh, which is why the city submits a, uh, a maximum one year extension, uh, in any funding requests. We won't get a chance to do it one time a year, every August. Uh, so these requests are evaluated every August by the governing board, uh, which seems that we come here at least once a year asking for an amendment, uh, to the commission for a time extension. So this past July in 2025, the commission considered resolution 25-20 to authorize, uh, authorize, I don't know what that word is bugging me today. Authorize. I have, that word is bugging me today. Um, uh, for the, for the amendment number three for a one year time extension. Uh, but when we submitted the resolution to the state, uh, we also had a loan increase, uh, sort of in limbo. And when we gave them the time extension, uh, they, uh, sent it back to us saying just do both at once. So here we are coming back to the commission with a time extension for one year and a loan increase amount. Um, so as such, uh, the staff hereby recommends the commission to adopt resolution 25-31, uh, that's in my head, uh, approving the execution amendment number three to FDEP SRF loan agreement, uh, for a one year time extension and a 295,000 loan increase for technical services and construction for a reimbursable amount up to, uh, 23,495,152 for the ongoing construction of various wastewater projects as presented today.

SPEAKER_0458:01

All right. And are there any questions for staff? Uh, no, I don't really have any questions. I would

SPEAKER_1158:07

just to comment. One question. Can you remind me the interest rate on this loan? Yes, I can.

SPEAKER_0858:18

Go for it, Nan. I clarified this to make sure because I knew somebody was going to ask this. So, okay, he's got it right here. So the original loan amount of 15,000, of $15,550,000, let me see if I can read this. $15,550,400 had a zero interest rate. The first amendment, uh, had an increase of $7,649,000, $752. Um, and that was at 0.4%. Uh, the second amendment was a time change only. And then this third amendment on the $295,000 is at 2.04%. The interest rate I think is relative to the time that the money is allocated to the project. So back initially when we did the original loan, the interest rate was zero. So on about 15.6 million, it's zero percent. On, um, about 7.6 million, it's 0.4%. And then on this $295,000, it's 2.04%.

SPEAKER_1159:32

One more question. Uh, what is the drawdown on this loan? I presume it's a loan that we draw, we don't get the whole thing at once. We draw down as we expense. Is that correct? Correct. We, we send in

SPEAKER_0859:42

reimbursement and we, we get reimbursed as the project is being built. And we have, we have gotten the first reimbursement. Yeah. Because the, it's been a number of projects. The very largest part of this, the, the $16 million electrical upgrades is just getting underway. And, um, as, as we get invoice from the contractor, we can invoice the state and then they'll reimburse us. Darn shame.

SPEAKER_111:00:08

We can't just draw it all down. We could make money off this at that interest rate. That's not

Commissioner Dugard1:00:12

how it works. Very good. That's all I have. Um, vice mayor. Thank you. All right. And I really don't have any questions on this. Ask and answered, um, comments. Yeah. I just want to say, and this really

SPEAKER_041:00:25

probably is for the general public, just education on this. Um, the, uh, this, the revolving, revolving fund here basically is analogous to a revolving line of credit for corporate enterprises. And, uh, it's, um, it's basically free money. And with that said, uh, it really is, the program itself is awesome only because of the fact that it allows us to do so much more. And it really ties to improving and sustaining and debilitize overall our infrastructure. So anyway, I just want to put that out there for just general understanding. Thank you.

SPEAKER_111:01:14

Thank you, vice mayor. Um, it's important to note here that, uh, a lot of this improvement is natural to the facility and just needed, but there's some things that we're doing beyond just simply replacement. And we're doing some things, uh, with this $23 million that will improve the quality of the water that goes into the sound. If any does, and we're going to, by 2035, we're supposed to have nothing going in there, but fresh water as I understand it. That's a challenge for every community in this state that is dealing with the issue. Uh, I know we, we pulled on this bone pretty hard back when we were seeing the wastewater rates and the water rates. Um, it's important for our citizens to know that this is a vast improvement over a very good system to start with. So compliments to the team.

Commissioner Dugard1:02:07

I appreciate it. Thank you, vice mayor. And I absolutely concur with all that. So thank you, Commissioner Dugard, very much. Uh, and I will actually open it up to, um, comments. Anybody in the audience? Yeah. Hearing none, seeing none, we will bring it back. Very good. And may I have a roll call vote?

SPEAKER_031:02:29

Yes. Commissioner Dugard. Aye. Commissioner Walker. Aye.

Commissioner Dugard1:02:33

And vice mayor. Aye. And that motion passes unanimously. Uh, you guys aren't showing me any grace this late evening. Thanks. Uh, uh, uh, item three C is a starred item, a proposed agenda for the November four workshop. Can I have a motion on that? So moved. Second. Very good. All righty. And a, uh, a voice vote. Right. Ryan, am I asking for a voice vote now? Oh, to put it on? Yeah. To put it on the agenda for a start item. That makes sense. I'm sorry. Yeah. I need a voice vote. There's three of us. Aye. Aye. Very good. Motion passes. So now it's on the agenda. Uh, let me see. Uh, so are there any additions, questions? Seen it? Are we all good with the agenda? So moved. Second. All right. And, uh,

SPEAKER_111:03:42

a voice vote on that, on it now. Aye. Aye. Aye. I'm waiting on Rob. Seniority. When I was waiting on the

Commissioner Dugard1:03:54

clarity. You're doing this. You're killing me. Are we good? Are you good? Oh, God. Man. I need to phone a friend or something. Oh my goodness. This is this. I'm, I'm, you guys are having a great time. I'm going up in flames. I'm glad to hear that you're having a good

SPEAKER_041:04:21

time. You can phone a friend, but I'm sitting right here. Well, it, it is nice to know I have one.

Commissioner Dugard1:04:31

Very good. All right. So now, uh, we're on to informational items. No, we're not. Oh, 3D. Yeah. Kill me now. Okay. The proposed agenda for the November 6th commission meeting. Are there any changes, additions, deletions? All right. I need a motion to approve. So moved. Second. All right. And, uh, voice vote all in favor. Aye. Those opposed. Ayes have it. Now, informational items. Right. Are we good there? Right. We're all following along on the agenda. Okay. We are at the informational portion of the show. All right. The commission discussion and, and, and just general comments. Nothing about the way the meeting was led though, please. Optional. I'll follow you anywhere. Oh my God. Off a cliff we go. Um, any, any comments from anybody?

SPEAKER_041:05:34

Yeah. Yeah. I just want to say, uh, uh, um, Dunedin History Museum is doing their spook easy tonight at Andrew's Chapel. And, uh, I'm going to head over there right after this. And, uh, uh, y'all are welcome to join me. Um, and, uh, that's, uh, that's, uh, that's all I got.

Commissioner Dugard1:06:00

Very good. Thank you. Again, I might take you up on that. Commissioner Degard.

SPEAKER_111:06:07

Thank you, Vice Mayor. Um, a couple things. Um, I have been informed that, um, our mayor and, uh, Commissioner Sandberg have been watching and they're making comments and laughing. I do, but they are, they are on board. They are safely in Toronto and Stephen says it's cold. Just we get weather report. So, um, that's just bring us up to that. Um, I hate to put a cloud over what has been a really delightful meeting. Thank you for that, Vice Mayor. Um, but we've had in the last 72 hours, two accidents in our community involving e-bikes. Um, one over on Wilson on the Pinellas Trail, uh, and one on New York and Maine. It would be wrong of us not to bring out to our citizenry the dangers of this new mode of transportation. It is unfortunately true that what usually happens when new modes of transportation are introduced into a system is that they, it's the wild west for a period of time until there's casualties. I don't want there to be any more casualties. It's, by the way, there was a third accident down in St. Petersburg during that same 72 hours also involving an e-bike. Um, we're, we're playing with fire here. The laws of physics aren't forgiving. They just are. And you try to stop something going even at just 20 miles an hour. And the math is horrible, particularly if you don't have a helmet on or any other safety features. This is something we have to address in a future meeting more than we have so far. And with that, I, like I said, I hated to put a cloud over what was, has been a wonderful meeting. Very collegial and, uh, dealing with some important issues, but all in a positive way. But this issue is before us. Thank you, Mayor. Vice Mayor. Thank you. Thank you. And, you know, Tom,

Commissioner Dugard1:08:28

I certainly can't disagree with, with, with any of that. And a lot of it might go, and I don't know about a lot, but some of it goes to the actual classification of e-bikes, which is, uh, governed by the state. And so this might be something that we can, uh, maybe get help on with our, our lobbyists and maybe getting us in front of and just, we need to start having these conversations about that

SPEAKER_041:08:56

classification and what that means. I think, yeah, I think that's exactly the right thing. And I really do think we may even want to put that on our legislative priorities for this upcoming session.

Commissioner Dugard1:09:08

Right. I know it's late, but, but crises can move things. Well, you know, but the great thing,

SPEAKER_041:09:15

well, you know, there's nothing great about it, but the thing is we're, we're heading right into legislative days. Now's the time to be shaping that agenda. And, you know, I think we've, we've got an opportunity here and we need to, we need to strike. Absolutely. So, um, just if I, if I can,

SPEAKER_091:09:35

uh, get additional direction. Um, so I, and the sheriff was here and he did his presentation on e-bikes and what's permitted on the trail and what's not permitted in, in, um, all the different categories. The city commission then is looking to, uh, include in our legislative agenda, uh, the classification of e-bikes on the trail specifically. Um, what, you know, so yeah, yeah, there are multiple issues

SPEAKER_111:10:11

here facing us, the county and the state from a city standpoint. Um, we have to be responsible for safety on our streets and we have to look at what ordinances we can pass to determine greater safety measures that can be employed to keep e-bikes safer. By the way, I believe they should actually be on streets instead of on trails or, or other because they're motorized. Uh, and that gets back to the state issue. We have to get that definition of what is a motorized vehicle reviewed because something that can go 25, 20, 30 miles an hour is a motorized vehicle. That's not self-propelled. So that's one of them. The other issue is with our county because they actually have jurisdiction over the trail. This trail is a county piece of property. And so I think that we ought to make an inquiry with the county and the commissioners there on, uh, what local authority. I've been toying with the idea and I'm going to throw it out there. It's premature. It's not been worked up in any way of having a walk only zone, uh, in our downtown for the trail that we have no bikes of any type in that area. Everyone must walk. It's just too congested. Um, otherwise it's just not safe, but that's just my view on the matter. So I think there's, you're right. There's, there's five different ways to look at this and, uh, we have to parse those out and figure out what the best approach is on

SPEAKER_041:11:46

each other. So, uh, um, thank you. Sorry. Yeah. So what I, I, I think where we start here is we just, we need to take a look at what currently are the defined, um, classifications and then take a look at what makes the most sense in the allowance or the prohibition of any sort of category from the, you know, the trail or for any of the bike lanes or anything of that nature. Um, and I, an example to this is, is that, you know, not all electric bikes are the same. You've got the pedal assist and then you've got the ones that can are fully powered almost to the point of like a mini bike or a motorcycle. And, um, those to me are the, they're, you know, the most dangerous ones because basically, you know, you, it's, I see people going 30 miles an hour down the trail and it's those, it's those particular bikes that are doing that. So I, I think, I think to start, we need to do some research. We need to understand collectively what the classifications are and what would make sense in terms of how we, we structure our advocacy for, you know, better and improved laws and ordinances.

SPEAKER_111:13:17

It is clear to me that there are various uses of the trail. If you get away from the classification of vehicles that are on the trail and into what it's being used for, people are using it to get to work on their e-bike. I get that. They don't have to stop and they are not stopping at the stop signs. That's how one of the accidents occurred over here by, um, uh, on the trail. American Legion. Yeah. By American Legion. Um, the vehicle that was hit, the truck had stopped and was moving forward. The e-bike wasn't going to stop. He didn't think he was supposed to. He thought he could pass through because in the casual way stop signs are dealt with on bicycles, a lot of times cars will give them the right of way, even though they are not, they haven't even stopped. So, you've got a, you've got a culture of how that trail is being used that is setting up a circumstance that can be devastating when an e-bike doesn't stop and this was a prime example of that. That being said, if we could have, if we, and the reason I'm leaning toward this walk-only space which the county would have to join us in, if we had that, that transportation modality would not be as advantageous. The e-bikes would move to the streets because they have to walk in that area. That's why I'm suggesting this. It forces the e-bikes to skid off and it means they won't be zooming through stop signs and it may save a life or two. They'll be angry at us, but a lot of people are angry at us from time to time. I think it's for their safety that we need to consider something

Commissioner Dugard1:15:07

like that. And that's where I'm, that's where I'm going. And, um, you know, I can't disagree with a lot of the comments that are here tonight, but I, I also want to acknowledge that it's not the e-bike, it's the rider. And, and so we need to work on the classifications, but we also need to, you know, I, I grew up in a, in a time where I don't know where you learned it, whether it was from television or from school or probably from everywhere, but everybody knew hand signals on how to ride a bike. And you certainly heard common phrases of driving cars was a privilege, not a right. And you don't hear that anymore. And we become so car centric today that driving is no longer a privilege. It's, I have to get to work. It's a right. I need to get there. And so people treat it like it's a right and not a privilege. And I think there's enough blame to go around. Um, but you hear a lot on, on social media, uh, blaming e-bikes for all the ills in the world. And, and so we, we do need to at least stress the classification, but also come up with some sort of educational program. I think the city needs to do that. I think the schools need to do that and just come back to this, this is how you use transportation in, in the real world. Um, I also saw a lot of comments on social media today, uh, certainly around the, the, the tragedies that have unfolded in the last hours and that there was a distinction. And I don't know this to be true. So I would ask Jennifer, Jennifer, she can look into it, that there were, their comments were in clear water, bikes do not have to stop at the intersections and other cities done even they do. And maybe that's not all intersections at clear water, but unless it's a major intersection, you don't. So Jennifer, can you look, look into that? Sure. Because I have also had conversations with residents over their frustration that bikes don't stop at the stop signs. And so I asked them, would it be okay if they just had the right of way and were able to go through? And their response was yes. And I was kind of taken back by that. I think it's a matter of people just want to know what the rules are and that everybody's playing by the rules. And it's because right, we do live in an area now when you come up to those intersections, does the bike stop or not stop? Do they get waved through by the driver on the road? So there's a lot of uncomfortableness in the intersections now and, and maybe addressing some of those issues. I'm not necessarily suggesting that, hey, we just take those away, but at least let's see what other cities are doing. You know, reach out to Forb, Canunless, or the county, City of Clearwater, whoever be in that jurisdiction. And maybe not just Clearwater, but some of these coastal cities, you know, on the west coast of the trail. You know, we don't need to look at countryside and that area, but at least on the, on the sound portion, that, that might help give us some guidance on, on what we might be able to do. I know Sue said that we have some old reels and, and shorts that we did and she's trying to bring those back to life and that's wonderful. Okay. Um, but that would be just great because yeah, it's been, it's very sad

SPEAKER_091:18:43

events and, and the community is very upset about it. So just, if I may, Vice Mayor, just a couple of things. Um, so we are submitting a grant, uh, to Forb Pinellas, which is our metropolitan planning organization, uh, for assistance to design, um, uh, the area right on main street, the business area, the trail in the, uh, entire county, um, and to, to separate pedestrians and bicyclists in that, in that part of the trail. And it would be, um, from Scotland all the way to Skinner. So that's something that would, that we have, uh, in the Petri dish, if you will, and that, that we're working on. Um, and then the other part is we met, um, uh, we had a production meeting, um, in regards to, um, uh, well, we were really at that point talking about the watch parties, but anyway, we were talking about the trail as well. And, uh, one of the things that we're looking to do is to put up, uh, some form of a barricade system, um, on the trail during special, the larger special events where we have road closures in downtown, like Halloween happenings, the, the, um, art, uh, arts and, um, craft shows, old fashioned Christmas. When you, you do have, um, uh, and, and a woman came up to talk to us about that, uh, I think last month, uh, you have folks that don't even know they're on the trail, pedestrians that don't even know they're on the trail and the bikes are still bombing through. And there's a lot of anger involved in both parties. Um, get out of my way and, and you're too close and that type of thing. So in that case, during those larger events, they would have to get off and walk their bikes through that area. So, um, those are two things that we're working on. I hear you. I want to sit down and talk to staff a little bit, um, about how we, we couch this, this, this legislation, if you will, to make it something that is meaningful and that our representatives in Tallahassee can help us with. And of course it had to be the, we need the county on board. It would have to be the entire trail. Um, you know, and interestingly enough, one of the things that, that, that I noticed when you look at the usership on the, on the trail, that Clearwater is, is in the city of Clearwater is where it's used the least, you know? So, uh, and I, I'm not exactly sure why that is. Maybe it's just larger, you know, or longer there. I don't know. But anyway, we'll, we'll look into all of these things, uh, and bring back some ideas for all of you. I did talk to Sheriff Galtieri. Um, he called when the young man was hit, that was Monday, I think. So he called Tuesday, uh, evening and he said that the sheriff's office is starting to do some PSAs, public service announcements, um, regarding bicycle safety, trail safety, uh, wear your helmet, you know, that type of a thing. Um, because he, that was certainly on his radar, our two events here so close together in Dunedin. So he's, he, um, he said they're, they're going to concentrate it in Dunedin as well, because again, it's the most used part of the trail. So thank you. Thank you very much. All right.

Commissioner Dugard1:21:42

Is there anything else from the commission? Okay. I do have one more item and that is actually left over from the last commission meetings. Uh, and I had requested, um, from the research I did, there was $5,000 remaining balance in aid organization and to, uh, offer it to the Dunedin County Middle School had asked for the band program to help them in their, um, kilt refurbishment within the Scottish arts program. And the mayor had asked us to move it to tonight, uh, to ask the city manager if she couldn't confirm the balance and just do some research on maybe what else has been spent and things of that nature so you all felt comfortable. Um, we did not break sunshine with the mayor, but I, at least because she was going to Toronto, asked her if we could continue the conversation or she wanted it moved. And she was comfortable with us continuing the conversation tonight, but I have no idea how she would have voted or what she would have said.

SPEAKER_111:22:45

One question. Do we anticipate this being ongoing or is this a one year? Is this a ongoing or a one year issue? The, the way I'll answer that

Commissioner Dugard1:23:04

is within the framework of aid to organizations. It is certainly not uncommon for the same organizations to come back to the well every year and ask for money for something, but I can't answer that

SPEAKER_041:23:17

directly. I have no idea. Well, in this case, we're currently, what we're doing is, is we've got what we think is $5,000 left over and looking at how we want to spend that remaining $5,000. Correct. Yeah. So I don't, yeah, I don't know if you can call it recurring at this point, but, um,

Commissioner Dugard1:23:40

yeah, that was my understanding. And this is, I, I want to say the first time the middle school band has asked for it. I, anything, and it's been a number of years, I think, if they had.

SPEAKER_111:23:52

We're talking about fiscal year 25 or 26. I'm just, I want to make sure I know what box we're in. Uh, fiscal year 20, 26. 26. It started October 1. Got it. Okay. That's a long time. If anything else comes up for us to have zero balance, just as a thought. Yes. Right. Yes, it is. Okay. Any

SPEAKER_091:24:11

recommendations from staff? Um, so the, we do have the, the balance remaining, um, $5,000. It's there and it's available. Uh, so the, as far as, as the mayor's request to look at, um, I wasn't quite clear exactly what that request was beyond what, what we're spending aid funding on for aid organizations, the ones that we've awarded. So there are cultural partners. There's, there's our civic partners. Our civic partners are, are the museum, uh, and the DFAC. And then, and their cultural partners are, um, the, the, the bands, the SAS, the SAF, and so on and so forth. And so, um, we, uh, have not spent, um, that I recall had a, a similar request in, in a couple of years. And I, I, if anything emergent were to come up that the city commission would like to award, um, I, I think the aid organization can, can accomplish it through that, through that budget. Um, we did, the last time we spent aid organization funding that I recall was to buy the, uh, covers for the drums for the pipe band. Right. Uh, and that was, uh, it's six years ago. So it's not unusual, um, for this type of request. And, and, um, and it has been awarded before.

SPEAKER_041:25:29

So moved. Second. No, I think it's a great idea. I, I really do. I, I think it, this is in keeping with the, you know, who we are and what we do. And, you know, this to me is, it's a no brainer.

Commissioner Dugard1:25:57

Well, and thank you, gentlemen. And, and just to remind you, I'm, you know, that this, this booster organization is actually who we're donating it to, we're giving the money to for the band program, are very strategic in how they spend their money and how they're approaching this. They just don't want kilts. They've analyzed and they're broken down to get in section. So they, they will be looking to get new kilts next year as well, just because they're eating the elephant one bite at a time, as they should. And as they see that they can raise money, they will get new kilts, which is the way they do. So they are doing it the smart way. And so that's why I really do support

SPEAKER_111:26:33

what they're doing. Just in comment before we vote on the motion. You've already voted on it.

SPEAKER_061:26:40

I thought I just made it. No, there is a motion. Oh, the motion is second. We still need public

SPEAKER_111:26:44

comment and a vote. Oh, thank you for the public comment. We're not, we haven't made the, we haven't voted. No, you haven't. No, I got excited. So I'm going to say this. Sure. I'm glad we're doing this. I'm excited about doing this, but this, on a continuing basis, we'll have to compete against what our whole spectrum of needs are going to be in the future, which we don't have any idea about.

Commissioner Dugard1:27:07

Right. And agree. Right. Absolutely. Yeah. I think that's, I'm sorry. I think that's always

SPEAKER_091:27:11

a given and implied. Right. And we typically, every year, set aside funding for this type of a situation. And it just hasn't been used in the past.

Commissioner Dugard1:27:21

I think the last time I remember it being used this quickly was actually my first year. Mm-hmm. I think that was the drum covers. Uh, no. No? No, it wasn't. Okay. I can't remember what it was. It still hurts. Oh, I don't know what it was. Uh, yeah. Uh, is there any public comment on this? And I guess through all that rambling, what we're doing is we have an aid organization, um, where we offer, we have a pool of funds that we offer to some of our nonprofits. And the Dunnean Middle School Band Booster Program has asked us, uh, for assistance in helping them purchase, uh, new kilts for, for the band kids. And, uh, so that's what the, that's what this discussion was about. So if anybody has anything, hearing none, seeing none, I will bring it back to the commission. Is this a voice vote? Okay. It's a voice vote. All in favor? Aye. Those opposed? And the ayes have it. Thank you all gentlemen very much. Very good. And with that, uh, anything

SPEAKER_031:28:23

from the city clerk? Any updates? Just a shout out to the Citizens Academy students on their upcoming graduation. Yes, sir. That will be on Tuesday, October 28th. That's right. And just to

Commissioner Dugard1:28:34

acknowledge, we are missing Mark Ocean tonight. Just, it must be graduation time. He's got his credits.

SPEAKER_091:28:40

Very good. Uh, city manager. Yes. Uh, I'm going to be missing their graduation. I'll be out of town, but I did join them yesterday or Tuesday to say goodbye and thank them for their. Good for you. Thank you for doing that. Yeah. Very good. Very good. Um, attached to your, uh, city manager's update, we have a grant procurement tracking form, and this is, we're submitting to the Department of Environmental Protection for a living shoreline design, uh, for River Park design grant in amount of $30,000. We'll let you know if we get it. That's exciting. That is exciting. Yeah.

Commissioner Dugard1:29:13

Very good. I like those other things. City attorney? I'm sorry, city manager, you done? I'm good. Okay. No report? Nothing. No report. She's so good at that. Wow. Goodness. Good news,

SPEAKER_111:29:27

good news and then no news. That's quick. Always. He is going to be so missed. My goodness. Uh,

Commissioner Dugard1:29:41

well, with all that said and done, we're adjourned. Yay.