All right, I hereby call this meeting to order. This is the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate for the City of Delray Beach. Cases will be heard in the order in which they appear on the agenda, unless we otherwise note it. When you hear your case called, go ahead and proceed to the podium over here on my left side. The City is going to present its testimony and evidence first. You'll have an opportunity to review any evidence the City has submitted or to ask any questions of any of the City's witnesses, after which time you can present your own testimony and evidence and I will make a decision. This is a quasi-judicial hearing, which means that the formal rules of evidence do not apply here. However, all testimony is taken under oath, under penalty of perjury. With that in mind, if you are thinking about, if you think that you might be testifying or there's a possibility that you might be testifying, please rise and raise your right hand so you can be sworn in. By the authority vested in me, as a notary of the State of Florida, do you swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. Just a quick programming note. While this is a relatively large room, sound does travel really well in here. So if you need to have a conversation with someone or you need to talk to somebody, please do take it outside the room. Second, if you can, please make sure you put your devices either in off or on silence so that they do not interrupt the proceedings. And for the record, I just want to clarify discrepancy in an order issued in October 15, 2026 hearing. That order incorrectly states that today's hearing was reset for lien reduction. In case SM 10-15-26, it's actually purpose was a status update on the property. So correct. Consent agenda? Requesting approval of the consent agenda as written. So approved. Thank you. I guess we have minutes from August 20th and November 5th. So Magistrate Wagner, I didn't know if you wanted, for that issue that you explained, we have to make sure that we discuss when we get to that case as well. Okay, we can. Thank you. We can re-raise it then. Thank you. All right, for the minutes of August 20th and November 5th, those are hereby approved. Thank you. I need to note here that there are two cases that have now come into compliance as of now, which is case number 6, which is code 26-001-237, and case number 8, code 26-001-059. Both cases have come into compliance. Excellent. All right, you can call the first one. Thank you. Case number 1, code 26-001-181. The property owner is Wena Poisson. The property address is 135 Southwest 6th Avenue, and the code officer on the case is Supervisor Joseph Oliva. However, case will be presented by code enforcement officer intern Erin Kesta. I believe there's someone here for the case that's trying to – if you can come up, sir. Proceed. Right to the podium right there. You can proceed. Good afternoon, special magistrate. My name is Erin Kester, code compliance officer intern for the city of Delray Beach. I'm here regarding the property at 135 Southwest 6th Avenue. Code case 1181. This property received a notice of violation October 8th for code 2.4.13B for the unpermitted driveway extensions. The property was given 30 days to comply with violations. A re-inspection was conducted on November 3rd, and the property was still not in compliance. Service was accomplished by certified and regular mail and posted to City Hall on October 5th. In addition, the property was posted on October 2nd, 2026, and an affidavit of posting and mailing and first affidavit of noncompliance is attached to the case. I have not yet been in contact with the owner of the property. As of November 18th, the property has not come into compliance. I have attached six photographs of the property to the case that I would like to introduce into evidence. Okay. Exhibit 1 shows the driveway extensions on either side of the existing driveway there. Exhibit 2 shows the existing driveway to the left of the driveway as well, and the sidewalk that was driven over that sunk in has since been fixed. Exhibit 3 is the posting of the notice of posting. Exhibit 4 is another of the posting. Exhibit 5 is the affidavit of posting and mailing, and Exhibit 6 is the affidavit of noncompliance. The City is asking for an additional 30 days, which would be December 19th, 2026, for them to come into compliance. If they have not come into compliance by then, the City is asking for $100 a day until compliance is achieved. Do I submit those in evidence? I would like to submit these photographs into evidence. Thank you. Sir, can you state your name, please? Yes. My name is Gene Alias. I would like to know if I don't have any permissions to... I'm sorry. Your name was Gene... Alias. A-L-I-E-S. Sir, what's your relation to the owner of the property, Vina? My husband. That's your mother? Her husband. Her husband. Yes. Is that Ms. Poissin? Poissin, yes. We don't actually have anyone here. Does the City have any objection? Because neither one of them is a... Well, she... The property owner is Vina Poissin. Yes. He said that that's her, and he's with her. Oh, he's her husband. Okay. I misunderstood. Go ahead, sir. Yes, I would like to know if I don't have any right to restore my own driveway. I don't think there's a question of right here, sir. It's not permitted. You didn't get a permit, is what they're saying. But before we even get to that, I need to know whether you have any objections to the photographs or documents the City would like to put into evidence. Yeah, I don't know, right? I don't have all those pictures of evidence, but I would like to know what's wrong with me, you know, having fix my own driveway. Hold on one sec. Let me just, for the record, accept those into evidence. And, officer, perhaps you can explain what the issue here is about extending the driveway without a permit. Yes, the driveway extensions were done without a permit being obtained first, so you are in the process of obtaining a permit. A permit was issued, LDEVR-021803-2026. And as of right now, it is in process and waiting for you to upload a owner-builder permit and a survey of the proposed driveway extensions that were created. Yes, so a permit application was submitted. You can't just extend your driveway without authorization from a permit from the City. First of all, the driveway has been there for like 13 years. I don't know if you want to go straight to argument. Currently, we're there. Okay. Yeah. So the City's position is that these pavers were installed, regardless of when, without a permit. As you all are aware, there's no particular statute of limitations regarding code enforcement cases. So I don't recall if the testimony was brought out, but this was, when this was brought to the City's attention by a department, we proceeded with the code enforcement violation. So that's what we're here for today. And we feel that we provided testimony and evidence that the permits were installed, the driveway extension, without proper permits. Under the City Code, you need permits. You need a permit. The permit was, how much is a permit? Well, from my understanding, based on the testimony of the code enforcement officer, the permit has been applied for. The City is just waiting for additional information and documents. And the City has graciously, department, offered 30 more days for you to continue through this process. And if it's not done within 30 days, then the City has for a fine of how much? $100. $100 a day. So we're offering another 30 days for you to continue with the process, or the fine would accrue. Is 30 days enough time for you to finish getting your permit? Is the permit is ready or not? I'm sorry? The permit is ready? The permit is awaiting more documents from you. So after this hearing, if you want to get what the specific department, if you want to call, they've already put it in the comments. If you want to contact them for the specifics, you can. But this isn't the appropriate personnel that will be able to assist you with that documentation. All right. Sir, what I'm going to do is I'm going to give you 60 days. That'll give you some time. You should talk to the department, the building department, and get an understanding of exactly which documents you need. We have the holidays coming up, and so that can take some time. So I'm going to give you some extra time. But you have to stay on top of it. You have to contact the building department and find out what you need to do, and then you have to make efforts to get it done. Do you understand? Go ahead. All right. In case 26001181, I make the following findings of fact and law. I find notices efficient. Find the property in violation of 2.4.13B, the extension of the driveway without a permit. The respondent has 60 days or until 118.27 to bring the property in compliance or a fine of $100 per day you may issue. Thank you for coming up. Thank you. Case number two, code 26001192. The property owner is Jonah E. Frederick, Sr. The property address is 322 Northwest 6th Avenue, and the code officer on the case is Nikanya Kenj-Talton. Good afternoon. My name is Nikanya Kenj-Talton, code compliance officer for the city of Delray Beach. I am here regarding property 322, Northwest 6th Avenue, case number 26001192. This property received a courtesy notice on September 25th, 2026 for property maintenance and no number characters. The property was given five days to comply with the violation. An inspection was conducted on October 1st, 2026, and the property was still not in compliance. A notice of violation was issued on October 7th, 2026. Service was accomplished by a certified regular mail and posted to City Hall on October 8th, 2026. In addition, the property was posted on October 8th, 2026. An affidavit of posting and mailing and first affidavit of noncompliance is attached to the case. I have not been in contact with the owner of the property. As of November 18th, the property has not come into compliance. I have attached 10 photographs of the property to the case that I would like to introduce into evidence. Please proceed. This photo was taken on October 7th. As you can see, the overgrowth and no number characters on the building. More overgrowth. That was taken on September 24th. September 25th, that's when the courtesy was posted to the property. And October 7th, that's when the inspection was conducted. As you can see, the courtesy is still on the door. And you can see the overgrowth. Can you describe the overgrowth in the photos, please? As you can see, the grass has not been cut for quite some time. It has been raining a lot, so it just keeps growing. And that's October 7th. The notice of violation was posted to the property. And as you can see, the grass is still not yet cut. And Exhibit 7 is the affidavit of posting. Exhibit 8, on November 12th, the inspection was conducted. The property still looks the same. Exhibit 9, small photos of the yard with the grass still high. And Exhibit 10 is the affidavit of noncompliance. The city is asking for an additional 15 days, which would be on December 4th, 2026, for them to come into compliance. If not, then the city is asking for $50 a day until compliance is achieved. And then we ask that the exhibits be moved into evidence. Is anyone here on behalf of the respondent, John E. Frederick, Sr.? Seeing no one without objection, the documents and photographs are admitted into evidence to the city's composite exhibit. The city's concern here, aside from the numbering on the building, is the landscaping? Yes, if you can see Exhibit 9, as of the re-inspection, you can see the tall grass and just lack of lawn maintenance. Do you have any reason to believe that they couldn't get this done within 15 days? Essentially, it just looks like mowing and trimming, essentially. You can't say it out loud. No. You said you have no contact with the respondent. Is there any evidence that anyone is living in this when you visit the property? I'm not sure if anyone is living there. I have not seen any vehicles or anyone in the driveway. And you've seen no evidence of anyone attempting to bring this property into compliance? No. All right. In case 26001192, I make the following findings of fact-in-law. If I notice is sufficient, I find the property in violation of 4.6.16. One specifically, the landscaping is overgrown and not being maintained. And 7.1.5, the numbering on the building. On the building. This bond that has 15 days or until 12-4-26 to bring the property in compliance over a fine of up to $50 per day, M.A. Thank you. Case number three. Code 26001222. The property owners are Shared Future Foundation, Inc. The registered agent is Sarah Selnick. The property address is 205 Southwest 11th Avenue. And the code officer on the case is Naya Rideau. Good afternoon, Special Magistrate. My name is Naya Rideau, Code Compliance Officer for the City of Delray Beach. I'm here regarding the property 205 Southwest 11th Ave, case number code 26001222. The property was issued a notice of violation on October 19th, 2026. Service was accomplished by certified and regular mail sent on October 19th, 2026. And the property was posted to City Hall on October 19th, 2026. An affidavit of mailing and first affidavit of noncompliance is attached to the case. I have not been in contact with the owner. And it was cited for 4.6.1, 4.6.16 subsection I, subsection I, landscape maintenance for overgrowth grass and exposed soil. And 4.6.17 subsection D, subsection II, erosion and sediment control. Also, 4.4.3 subsection I, subsection I, subsection I through 11, construction site maintenance. As of November 18th, 2026, the property has not come into compliance. I have 10 photos I would like to introduce into evidence. Okay. If you can go through the photos and describe. Describe the violations on the photos and the dates the photos were taken. Exhibit 1, October 13th, 2026 is my initial photo. You have to speak into the mic. Oh, sorry. Exhibit 1, October 13th, 2026 is my initial photo of the property showing the erosion. I mean, the property not having any sediment course. Sediment control? Yeah. And a silt fence also needs to be repaired and how the dumpster is overflown. Exhibit 2 shows the dumpster closed up, needs to be dumped. Also, the portable toilet is also not facing towards the property and the loose litter and debris that's on the property. Also, the overgrowth that's growing on the dumpster. Exhibit 3 is the back of the property showing the landscape overgrowth on the fence and on the entire back of the property on October 13th. Exhibit 4 is October 19th showing my posting to the property. Exhibit 5 is my re-inspection on November 5th, 2026. Exhibit 6 is still showing how the property didn't put the course aggregate. Exhibit 6, November 5th, part of my re-inspection shows how the dumpster was still full and the port-a-potty was still not turned inward. Exhibit 7, November 5th shows the landscape, soils exposed. Exhibit 8 is my affidavit of non-compliance. Exhibit 9 is my affidavit of posting and mailing. Okay, at this time, the city would like to introduce the exhibits into evidence. Is anyone here on behalf of the respondent? Seeing no without objection. So admitted, what is compliance in this case? What do they have to do? They have to get course one aggregate for the sediment control and they have to get sawed for the entire property because right now it's just exposed and dumping the trash also. It looks like they dumped the trash, didn't they? No, that was like my first photo. That was October 19th. They did, but it's supposed to be dumped. But they haven't since. Yeah, it's supposed to be dumped every time they finish. So they need sawed, they need the sediment control system, and they need to dump the trash. Yes, and face the port-a-potty inward towards the property. What is the city asking for? Oh, and repair the silt fence. What's your recommendation? The city is asking for an additional 15 days, which will be on December 4th, if not $100 a day. Do you think that's a sufficient amount of time for them to bring this into compliance? Yes. And they do have to re-solid the yard there, right? I think they can do that in a couple of weeks. Yes, they took it up not that long ago. Well, just for clarification, if my memory serves me correct, is this the case where they had already started planting some seeds and it was coming up a little bit? If not, I'm just trying to remember from our review. Proof of them putting seeds, but it looked like the grass was trying to grow through the soil the last time I went by there. But it still just exposed soil since November 5th. So they took up the grass that was there before for the landscape. Yeah, I guess I'm just trying to make sure that I'm giving them a sufficient amount of time to come into compliance there. Well, we defer to your discussion. To my judgment here. Yes. Let me do this slightly bifurcated because the city's concern related to the silt control seems a much more immediate concern. So I'm going to do it like this. In case CE 26001222, I make the following findings of fact in life. I notice sufficient to find the property in violation of listed code sections. As to the 44.3 I1 through 11, the construction site, and 4.6.17 D2, the erosion and sediment control, I order the respondent to bring those into compliance within 15 days or a fine of up to $100 per day may issue. As to 4.6.16 I1, the maintenance standards related to the grass, I'll give the respondent 30 days to do that or by 12, 19, 20, 26 or a fine of $100 per day. Thank you. Case number four, code 26001310. The property owners are Lucci Andrew Jr. and Gail D. Lucci. The property address is 822 Southwest 1st Street. And the code officer on the case is Naya Rideau. Anyone that wasn't sworn in when we first started, now is your chance to get sworn in. If you're going to testify, please raise your right hand and rise. If we can swear her in. You can sit next to Ms. Thompson. I think she's going to be sworn in. Or the chair owner, I know she's not feeling too well. Okay, let's get the swearing in first. Thank you. By the authority vested in me as a notary of the state of Florida, do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. We can proceed. Good afternoon, special magistrate. My name is Naya Rideau, code compliance officer of the city of Derry Beach. I'm here regarding property 822 Southwest 1st Street, case number code 26001310. The property was issued a notice of violation on November 6, 2026. Service was accomplished by mail and certified mail sent on November 9, 2026. In addition, both the property and city hall were posted on November 9. An affidavit of posting and mailing and first affidavit of noncompliance is attached to the case. I have had contact with the property owner. This property was cited for 7.8.3, maintenance of building, for pests, roaches, and appliances. As of November 16, the property has not come into compliance. I have attached 10 photographs of the property to the case that I would like to introduce into evidence. Okay, if you can proceed. Exhibit 1 on November 4, 2026 shows the mice were eating at the wall, which caused the debris on the floor. Exhibit 2 is behind the stove on November 4th. It shows the mice traps and the droppings from the mice and the hole that was behind the stove. Exhibit 3 shows behind the refrigerator on November 4th. It shows mice droppings and also something for the pest that's in that red right there. Exhibit 4 shows a mice on the trap, which was on November 6th, and shows roaches that were on the trap as well. Exhibit 5 on November 6th is when I posted the property. Exhibit 6 is photos from the tenant of a mice that was on the trap as of November 16th. Exhibit 7 is another photo of a mice on the trap with roaches as well on November 16th. Exhibit 8 is photos from the tenant. It shows the wall where it had the mice eating at the wall again, and she put mothballs down, and that was as of November 16th. So these particular photos, you can just go through them, and we can mark them for identification as photographs received from the tenant, and then we have a representative from the tenant who lives in the home that can actually authenticate the photographs. But just for these purposes, you can just scroll through them to say that the staff received them. Okay. Exhibit 9 is my affidavit of posting and mailing. Exhibit 10 is the affidavit of noncompliance. So at this time, let's say we'd like to introduce the 10 exhibits into evidence. Sir, can you tell me your name, please? Andrew Lucci, owner of the property. Mr. Lucci, do you have any objections to the photographs? No objection at all. I have a couple questions for you. Let me just say for the record they're admitted. Oh, thanks. I have a couple questions for you. So we talked a little bit about the rodent infestation, and we've seen the photographs. For this particular violation, there were several conditions on the property that Code Enforcement Department cited them for a lack of maintenance, correct? Yes. We have the rodent infestation, including the mice and rats, correct? Yes. We also have evidence of wall insulation or exposed and damage that needs to be corrected, correct? Yes. Unsealed openings into the walls, behind the stoves? Yes. Right. So there are other maintenance issues aside from the rodents? Yes, and the appliances. And what was the appliance issue? That they were previously in there from the tenant before. So it was like they had roaches and like it was unsanitary. All right. So there are some other unsanitary conditions on the property. Yes. And you've had communications with the property owner and the tenant, correct? Yes, as of yesterday. As of yesterday. And what type of actions have already been taken just for candor to the magistrate? Pest control, as in like foggers and mice traps. Right. And was there some type of pest control agreement or something in there? I believe so. Yeah, I believe so. Do you want to double check your notes, Ms. Thompson? Yes. An email was sent from the property owner to the officer whether there's an agreement for pest control. Thank you. So there's still other outstanding things? Yes. Okay. Nothing further from this witness. Okay. Mr. Luce, do you have any questions for the code officer? No questions. I'd like to make a statement, definitely. Well, we still have another witness. Hang on. I'll let you make your statement. I'm just going to let the city finish presenting the case. We spoke recently. I did let you know that we do now have a service contracting agreement, right? I did also let you know that our maintenance team is going out to the property now that I've been made aware of it every day to check to see if there's any traps or anything to remove them and replace them. And we've been exterminating the place on a regular basis. Had my regular maintenance guy who wasn't. Is that a question? Yeah. Hold on a second. Let's just let the city finish and then you can tell me what you're doing. I'm sorry. I thought you were just confirming your conversations with her. Okay. Yeah. And have we been out since we had a chance to talk to see the property? The last time I went out was November 6th. Okay. All right. So the last time I went out was there because a lot of action. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Okay. All right. Good afternoon, ma'am. Hello. Could you please state your name for the record? I'm Kysiana Bowens. And where do you reside? I don't know the address by heart. Is it the house that we're discussing here today? Yes. And you live there with your mother? Yes. And I'm now showing you what has been previously marked as CDC Exhibit 6 for identification purposes. Do you recognize this? Yes. Was this the condition of the home on November 16th? Yes. So tell us just briefly what's going on with the home. So every day or every other day, there are rodents that are appearing on the traps. As of this morning, they were just appearing on the floor. Um, the roaches are frequent. Um, we can't cook there because obviously, um, we have children at the house. So this is very like unsanitary. We're all trapped in our rooms. We can't utilize our living room or kitchen area because the animals are there. Um, also as of last night, my mother woke me up out of her sleep. Uh, there was one in her bed. So they're in there. They're actively moving around all over. It's very disgusting. Um, my mom is epileptic. So, uh, fear or shock does trigger, um, seizures. Um, so that could have been. I don't want to get into your mom's medical history. So we're just. Okay. So my next question is after, you know, once you observed this, did you report this to the code enforcement department? I believe so. Okay. Now I'm going to go show you exhibit seven. Do you recognize this photograph? Yes. Is that, um, tell us what's in this photograph here. On the trap, it's a, a mice and a centipede and roaches. Okay. Uh, so exhibit eight. This is at the front door, um, to the right of the door. It's the mice are trying to find another route in. So frequently they're digging and it's, the floor is not court, the call. Yes. To the bottom where it's closed. There's a gap in between. So they're digging and it's, they're pushing in the. Okay. And how long have you been specifically dealing with the situation? Uh, since we've been there. So it's, it's been a month, a month. Okay. So I believe these were previously entered, but I just want to make sure they were properly authenticated by the homeowner. All right. Thank you so much for, for coming in. Thank you. The city has no further witnesses. Mr. Lucci. Yes. So what's going on here? Man, first of all, I want to apologize to my tenant in the city. We take these concerns very serious. We've owned apartments in the area for 30 years. Mr. Lucci, can you pull the microphone up? Yes. Yes. I'll definitely speak up. Sorry about that. No worries. I said, we take these concerns very serious. I was recently made aware of myself directly about four days ago. We have 20 apartments in that, in those four block areas. My maintenance man was aware of it. I guess was trying to solve it himself. And then we had a lady in the office who had spoken to our tenant. I actually called our tenant about three days ago and said, hey, I was just made aware of it. I apologized to her, made sure we have an exterminator that went out immediately. I have my maintenance guy going out every day because nobody should live that way. I've offered a full refund on the dollars. The stove and refrigerators, we don't provide when people move in. So the old tenant that left offered to leave them if they wanted them. But we'll have those removed out immediately. And like I said, we'll give a full refund. We have an exterminator going weekly. And I apologize to you for you because no family should have had to deal with it. So you hired a professional exterminator? Yes, we have. What company did you hire? We have a copy of the contract here, Hometown Pest. And they were out and they've seen her. Can you show that to the code officer, please? We actually emailed it to her, but yes, I will. Is that the agreement that she testified to earlier? Okay, yeah, we are aware we haven't. Thank you. We did take those actions. And like I said, we're going out every morning because nobody should see that and deal with it. It is a problem that we're attacking. We're spraying every two days and we're asking if we can send them home so we can bomb in the morning when the kids go to school every two days. We've seen a marked improvement. The poison was laid out. We did see a dead one this morning on the floor, not in the traps. We think between the pest control and our regular maintenance, it's getting there. But like I said, we give a full refund on deposits and any money's paid. Ma'am, have you seen an improvement? To be honest, no. I mean, they're still appearing every day. They're still like this. For instance, this right here has been no improvement made here, specifically on that area. If we sweep at 730 and I come back home around 12, it looks exactly the same, if not worse. And then I can sweep again and then it's still back there again. So, no, but as far as for the pest control did come, like, I believe a day or two ago. Yes, but other than that, they're still moving around. They're still appearing. What's the city asking for here? The city is asking for an additional seven days or $300 a day. And what is compliance here? Like, what is compliance? They have to properly bring the property back into property maintenance. They have to correct the maintenance, all of the issues that were testified today as far as the rodents and the animals and the, I believe they've already voluntarily said they were correct the appliance issue, the maintenance issue, as well as any issues with the walls, the floors. I mean, I would just say it's a lot, but it would be generally bring the property into a clean, sanitary, unrodent-infested manner. I mean, I don't think we invented a word there. Unrodent. Mr. Lucci, the city is asking me to give you seven days to fix this problem. Are you going to be able to do that? The appliance issue, I think, is compliant. We can remove them out. We don't own them. The people there left them, so if that's one, we could definitely have that out. I don't think the appliances are the big issue here. I just want to make sure we just addressed that. That was one that was mentioned. I think the main two issues are the roaches and the rodents. We're actively, I think I'd ask for 30 days because I just don't know if we can get them all out that time. We can do everything we can. Like I said, we're spraying every day, we're bombing, and we're putting traps out every day. As we take a trap out, we've got traps all over the place in the attic everywhere. It's an older building, and we did see. We fixed all the holes, and we saw where they were coming in up through the sewer pipe. So we did see we had a hole in the sewer pipe in the attic. We fixed that, but there's still some probably running around in the area that we're actively getting. If I could get 30 days. What about this wall issue? I mean, it's pretty obvious that they're. . . We went and gone in, and like I said, they were in there. There's no holes in it, but we actually have glue traps behind it to catch them if there's anything that comes in. So if they go over near that area now, they will walk into the trap. So the city objects to 30 days. This is, I mean, if I've ever seen a health safety issue, you know, the tenant came in and talked about her experiences with her family and the children in the household and being secluded to their rooms, you know, in fear of any infestation. I mean, it's raining here. It's just. . . Yeah, it's gross. No, it is. Guys, I agree. I just don't know if we could. . . You give me an answer on how I could fix it soon. I'm not trying to pit it off, even the exterminator when he came in. I said, man, we've got to fix this. I said, Mr. Lucci, this is not something that gets fixed overnight. He said, you're doing the things that you can, but it does take a little time to get them. If I could go in there and I could zap them out, we could pull them out, I would. To treat a family like that, I'm disgusted. Myself and my team fired somebody over it, actually, because that's not how we roll. We roll tons of apartments. How much time do you think you need? Man, I'd love to inspect it again in seven days. I don't mind going out with them because we're attacking it every day. Dan, who's here, that's his job. His job now is to go to that apartment every morning before your kids wake up and get it out. I lived in apartments like that growing up, so I take it personal. But it just takes time to get it. I mean, you guys are cold. Once they're in, how do we get them out? I've been offered to give a full refund. Sir, this is what I'm going to do. I'm going to give you seven days. Okay. And if there is a reason that you couldn't get it done in seven days, you can come back at the fine assessment hearing and try and explain it to me. But I've got to tell you, not a ton of sympathy here, considering what this poor woman has to live with. No, I agree, Your Honor. But at the same time, the reason is, you know, give me a solution and it helps me get it done because I think you're asking me something. I can't show if I can do it. I don't have a solution, but you should make every effort. We are. If you get close, if it takes a couple of, you know, you can come explain it to me. But I'm going to give you the seven, I'm going to give the city the seven days because this has gone on long enough. And it should be noted that he can also, the code enforcement department has been more than responsive to him and communicated through e-mails, through phones. So the staff is working with them as well. So I'm sure our code enforcement officer will do whatever she can to, you know, ensure that. I think we all want to see the roaches and the rats and the mice out of it. We do. All right. Case 26001310, I make the following findings of fact and law. If I notice is efficient, I find the property in violation of 7.8.3, specifically rodents, roaches, and I guess the appliances, which I know you're addressing. And also some maintenance issues regarding the floors and the walls. Maintenance on the floors and the walls. Give the respondents seven days to bring this property into compliance or a fine of up to $300 per day may issue. Good luck to both of you. Thank you. Case number five, code 26001194. The property owner is blank Mike L. Estate. The property address is McClary Street, namely parcel number 12-43-46-28-00-000-3020. The code officer on the case is Randall Strawn. Good afternoon. I'm here regarding case number 26001194 at the property of McClary Street, which is in violation of vegetation and parents, impeding the traffic safety violation. Service was accomplished by a certified mail on October 14, 2026. In addition, both the property and the city hall was posted on October 14, 2026, and that's the day where the posting is attached to the case files. I have not been in contact with the property owner at this time. The property was cited for vegetation in Paris with traffic safety. On October 7, 2026, I myself observed overgrown vegetation of scrutin' traffic along the street. Wilder violation of 100.01, subsection B. As of November 18, 2026, the property has not come to compliance. I have six photographs I would like to introduce as evidence. Exhibit 1 depicts overgrown vegetation into the street, which was taken on October 7, 2026. Exhibit 2 depicts the same thing. You have cars also along the street with the overgrown vegetation. This was taken on October 6, October 7, 2026. Exhibit 3 depicts, which was taken on October 7, 2026. Also, the overgrown vegetation and seeding on the street. Exhibit 4 is the posting of the property that was taken on October 6, 10, 2026. And this is the affidavit of the posting of the property. Exhibit 5. Exhibit 6 is the noncompliance photo, which was taken on November 12, 2026. And this is the affidavit of the noncompliance photo, Exhibit 7. Is anyone here on behalf of the respondent? Seeing no one without objection, I'll admit that in evidence. Okay. What is your recommendation? Recommendation is 30 days for compliance by December 19, 2026. If not, $50 a day to file for noncompliance. I'm sorry, help me understand. So this is a street? Yes. Is this like a parcel that runs the length of the street? Is that it? Do we have the picture? Can I see this? Do we have the picture above the? We wish we had the property appraiser. If we can pull it up just to show you, just to, do you want to take it or do you want me to take it? You can just explain. Okay, I can explain. So basically what, this is a good photograph here. This is fine. So in Exhibit 1, you see where the cars are in the strawberry, and then you see the left side. So kind of like center down the street, half of its city, half of its private property. The private property half is closer, you know, on the side with the strawberry here on the right side of the photograph. So it's, you know, so we're bringing it on a maintenance for that. As you can see, it's really overgrown, even though it's a private property. You know, homeowners still have the, you know, they're still supposed to maintain their property with overgrowth and such. So the property on my right-hand side, which is where the cars are parked, is sort of in the bush. You can see they're like in the bushes. Yeah, they're, yes. Yes, I mean, this is a better angle. What is clear to me is that clearly has not been maintained. So that part's easy. Right. I'm just trying to understand, is that a parcel that runs down the side? Yes, the property line comes all the way to the middle street. Joe is going to show you exactly where the property line is. Can we just flip it so, oh, it doesn't flip. You have that automatic. Yeah, no, I know, but it's easier, like, if you see it, like, how it looks there. But you can go ahead. Yeah. Can you describe what you're showing him, Joe, for the record? Yes. Yes. So as you see where the property line is, it goes, like, halfway in the street. So they basically own that part of the street. That's a large parcel. That's the owner? Yes. Yeah, if I shrink it, they own the water and every other part of the water and everything. So this is basically a vacant lot that's just not being maintained. Yes. Correct. All right. It was simpler than I thought. Yeah, that's why I was trying to bring you back to, uh, they have to maintain the property. And you, uh, I'm sorry, obviously you said you had no contact with the owner? No contact as it hits. And I'm judging by your pictures that it doesn't look like they've made any... Are people really parking their cars right in the middle of the road? I don't know. I mean, in these conditions with the wind, that's just not safe. Okay. I don't know. I digress. Um, I think you've established your case. You want to give them 30 days or $50 a day? Uh, yes. Okay. Case 26001194, I make the following findings of fact. Unlawed. If I notice is sufficient around the property, it is very much in violation of 100.01B. The vegetation is impairing traffic safety. I give the respondent 30 days to come to compliance or a fine of up to $50 per day measure. Thank you. As previously stated, case number six has come into compliance as of the time of this hearing. So we're moving on to noncompliance cases, which is going to put us at case number seven. Case number seven, code 26000658. The property owner is Fankel Exontas. The property address is 3320 Boulevard Chatelain. The code officer on the case is Chantel Jean Baptiste. Good afternoon. Code compliance officer Jean Baptiste for the city of Derry Beach. I'm here regarding property 3320 Boulevard Chatelain. Do we need, do they need an interpreter? Yes. I don't recall if the interpreter has been sworn in. No, not at all. No, not at all. Okay. Can you swear him in as a witness and as an interpreter? Absolutely. And then we'll have to restart the case so we can ensure that they understand. Absolutely. Test, test, test. Officer Rubinson DeJaden, do you swear or affirm that you will translate a fair and accurate interpretation? Yes, I do. By the authority vested in me? Okay. Par autorité de Madame Gluck. As a notary of the state of Florida? As a notary of the state of Florida, do you swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Thank you. He said yes. Thank you. Thank you. If you can restart, you got to translate what I'm saying. If you could restart the case, please, miss. Thank you. Case number seven. Dossier numéro 7. Code 26. Dossier numéro 26. 0-0-0. 0-0-0. 6-5-8. 6-5-8. The property owner is Fenkel Exantos. property address 3320 Boulevard Chatelaine. The code officer on the case is Chantel Jean-Baptiste. The officer who will present the dossier is Chantel Jean-Baptiste. Good afternoon, Magistrate. Good afternoon, Magistrate. I'm code enforcement, I'm code compliance officer Jean-Baptiste Chantel. Non, pas moi, c'est officier et compliance Jean-Baptiste Chantel. Property 3320 Boulevard Chatelaine. Numéro 4-3-3-20 Boulevard Chatelaine. Originally found in violation. Alors, qu'est-ce que ça lui-même t'est en violation? On May 21st, 2026. Notre date, uh, May qui t'est 21, 2026. For an unpermitted structure. Alors, pour, uh, alors, pour, uh, permis que, uh, qu'elle a une impacte va. Given 30 days to come into compliance. Alors, y'a t'est bon 30 jours pour t'es capable de finir ou pour t'es capable de corriger le problème non. For a $100 a day fine. Ou bien y'a charge ou 100 dollars par jour. A magistrate order. Alors, y'a t'est bon y'un ordre. Inspect it was conducted. Alors, y'a t'est fait inspection. Which confirmed that the property remained out of compliance. Ça veut dire que pour t'es, uh, comme si, corrigé le problème non. Compliance. Alors, y'a t'es pas non, euh, pas de corriger le problème non. On septembre 3rd, 2026. 3 septembre 2026. Hearing case came back to Special Magistrate. Alors, même tout si ça a venu, uh, encore jeudi à l'heure. Where the magistrate ordered to stay. Alors, pour. Sorry. Go ahead. Special Magistrate, where the magistrate ordered to stay $100 daily fine. Alors, y'a t'es demandé pour, uh, sali, ben t'es qu'à bretter 100 dollars par jour. For 30 days. Pour 30 jours. Or October 3rd, 2026. Ou bien, 3 octobre 2026. The hearing was reset for October 15th. Alors, y'a t'es, uh, uh, uh, uh, here we now, encore jeudi à pour 15 octobre 2026. With the provision that a $100 daily fine would resume, uh, within 30 days. Alors, pour t'es comme si 100 dollars par jour, pour t'es comme vous résume pour dossier à. If compliance was not met. Alors, si que ou pas quoi, j'ai pas ou l'amner. On October 15th, 2026. 15 octobre 2026. The hearing was scheduled. Alors, y'a t'es comme si m'était l'accord pour aujourd'hui à. This was postponed and rescheduled for today's agenda, November 19th, 2026. Alors, y'a t'es une bonne extension pour t'es capable de venir, jeudi à, uh, dans, uh, côte là, jeudi à la. I have four photographs to present to Special Magistrate. Alors, y'a quatre photos que je pourrais présenter jeudi à la, dans Special Magistrate. And I would like to introduce these four photos as evidence. M'a introduit les photos à y'o comme évidence. I will show the original photos first. Alors, y'a montrou photos qui t'es là avant y'o. Of the unpermitted structure. A que, en fait, y'a pas t'prends permis pour ça que y'a montrôla. Exhibit 1. Ça, c'est numéro 1, hein. On October 7th, 2026. Non, y'a quitté Octobre 7th, 2026. Posted a non-compliance hearing notice to property. Alors, y'a t'es pas pire ça, y'a Kayaoua, ou que, alors, parce que y'a pas t'es corrigé le problème, non? Exhibit 2. Alors, exhibit numéro 2. Is the affidavit of posting on October 7th, 2026. Ça, c'est l'affidavit que y'a t'implié, d'amnale, alors, madame ou bien officier Chantal Humaineté Météli. Non, dat, qui t'es 7th, octobre, 2026. Exhibit 3. Alors, numéro 3, du. Is where I re-inspected the property on November 12th, 2026. L'it est inspecté, Kayaoua, encore, et non, dat, qui t'es 12 novembre, 2026. And check the permits. Alors, checker permis encore. Exhibit 4. Ça, numéro 4, là. Is non-compliant. Alors, ça avait dit qu'il faut corriger le problème, là. As of today, November 19th, 2026. Jeudi à l'arbre au 2026, là. The property remains out of compliance. Alors, et Kayaoua, les mêmes ne toujours pas corriger le problème, là. Total fines occurre, là. Alors, l'immédiat du total, puis que vous venez ou louer, si t'il y a, 8,900 dollars, 8,900 dollars. Alors, si t'il y a aujourd'hui, elle a suggéré, Pour capable, comme si elle, pour capable de charger 8,900 dollars. And continue the $100 daily fine. Alors, pour continuer 100 dollars par jour. Pour jusqu'à ce que ou corriger le problème, là. Does the city have anything further? L'immédiat ce que l'immédiat le bayer ou quoi l'appdi? Yes, the total is 8,900. Alors, avocat là, la m'a de Komeko, l'immédiat, c'est 8,900 dollars. Ok, aujourd'hui. It's your turn to tell me what you think I should know. Qui so oublé dit avec moi? Depuis un premier jour, moi t'ai vini là, na yurinan. Moi t'ai pren yon un contracteur. Ok, if we could pause, since we're doing verbatim translation, he said a lot, so can you tell us what he said? Oui, oui. Oui, oui. Oui, oui. Depuis l'immédiat, là. Since my last hearing, m't'ai pren yon contracteur. I hired a general contractor. Tout sa li di m'fè m'fèl. He told me what needs to be done. Bon, se yo men ki ken be, et sa, se sa tu fèl. Et sa pa kou rezoud. He said that that has nothing to do with him, but he tried his very best. Et l'emande yo yo di m'konsa, et tout bagay yo nan siti ya, et papi yo nan siti ya ya previze yo. He said that all the paperwork that he submitted, it's in the review of the Virgin Department. Et yo di m'bi se tann pou m'pou m'wet tann m'bagye an yem kaffè. I advise me to just wait. Magistrate, they have applied for permits, however, on November 12, 2026. Slow down. Yeah, you gotta let him translate. Yeah, l'exiliou m'em noté appliqué, et pou, et, not that ke li so de batalera, novembre 26, alors, novembre 2026, là. The note stated they were, the permit department requested for them to resubmit documents. They have to resubmit for everything. That's what I read. So they have to contact the Berlin Department if they want specifics. Correct. At this stage, there's not much for me to do here other than to lean the property and continue. Once you get the property in compliance, there is a procedure you can use to reduce the fine. But at this stage, I need to continue the fine until the property comes into compliance. For the record, in code 26000658, code 26000658, I lean the property $8,900. Which I'll continue at $100 a day. Until the property comes into compliance. Please let the city know as soon as you come into compliance. And you can discuss with the code officer what you need to do further. Thank you. Mr. Wagner, the next three cases, 9, 10 and 11, all involve the property located at 302 Northeast, I'm sorry, involve the property owned by 302 North East 6th Avenue, LLC. See if we can call them all up. Okay. Who's the code enforcement officer on the case? So just a little background before the code enforcement officer reads where we are right now. Okay. We have three cases. Two were irreversible cases where there's a one-time fine of $3,500 on each case. The third case is a regular noncompliance case where the fines have accrued to a certain amount as of today. Just for background, I'll have him read the cases and where we are and what the compliance dates were, and then if there's any argument, then we can proceed from there. Good afternoon, Magistrate. Joseph Oliva, Code Compliance Supervisor for the City of Delphary Beach. This property, 302 Northeast 6th Avenue, case number 2025-004685, was originally found in violation on July 23rd, 2025, for not having an updated safety plan, restriping of the parking area, and paving of the driveway. They were given 30 days to have a permit issued for the marking and signage, 30 days to have a permit issued for the apron, and 60 days to submit a life safety plan and new zoning certificate of use, or pay a daily fine of $250 for not compliance. So, specifically, you're referring to the order dated September 17th, 2026, nonproton, July 23rd, 2025, which lists out, and I believe it's in the back up, which lists out all of the requirements. Yes. Thank you. September 3rd, 2026, the case came to Special Magistrate regarding appellate mandate and continuance was granted to allow both parties to submit a proposed order containing written findings of fact and conclusion of law. September 17th, the case came to Special Magistrate where an amended Special Magistrate order on remand finding violation was ordered. And that's the order we just discussed, correct? Yes. As of November 19th, 2026, there is an accrued fine in the amount of $113,000. The city suggests to lien the property in the amount of $113,000 and continue a $250,000 daily fine. And just to be clear, that amount is calculated from the original date prior to the appeal that they were supposed to come into compliance, correct? Yes. Thank you. Okay, next case. Before we leave, is the city's testimony that the property is not in compliance as of today? Yes. And it's out of compliance with all the requirements if you just want to read them straight down, everything that they're out of compliance with? The respondent is in violation of Section 2.4.6C, 4.6.9D8, and 6.1.4D2 of the city's land development regulations, and the violation is continual and ongoing. As to the violation of the LDR Section 4.6.9D8, respondent must obtain and require permits within 30 days of the hearing date, which was August 23rd, 2025. As to the violation of the LDR Section 6.1.4D2, the respondent must obtain the required permit within 30 days of the hearing date, which was August 23rd, 2025. As to the violation of 1DR Section 2.4.6C, the respondent must submit a life safety plan and zoning certificate of use application within 60 days of the hearing date, which is October 22nd, 2025. If the respondent fails to meet either deadline, $250 daily fine will be assessed for each day that the violation continues to exist. Thank you. So that $250 is calculated. That's how you got to that $13,000. $13,000. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Okay. So this is address 302 Northeast 6th Avenue. It's IR254908. Originally found in violation on June 18, 2025 for not obtaining an event permit, given a one-time fine in the amount of $3,500. September 3rd, 2026, the case came to a special magistrate regarding appellate mandated and continuance was granted to allow both parties to submit a proposed order containing written findings of fact and conclusions of law. September 17, 2026, the case came to a special magistrate where an amended special magistrate order on remand finding violation was ordered. As of November 19, 2026, the fine of $3,500 has not been paid. The city suggests lien the property in the amount of $3,500. And then we have 302 Northeast 6th Avenue, IR code 25-000010, originally found in violation on July 23, 2025 for not obtaining an event permit, given a one-time fine in the amount of $3,500. On September 3rd, the case came to a special magistrate regarding appellate mandate and continuance was granted to allow both parties to submit a proposed order containing written findings of fact and conclusions of law. On September 17, the case came to a special magistrate where an amended special magistrate order on remand finding violation was ordered. As of November 5th, 2026, a fine of $3,500 has not been paid. The city suggests to lien the property in the amount of $3,500. Thank you. Anything further from the city? Not at this time. Sir, can you tell me your name, please? Rodney Mayo. Sir, in your position with 302 Northeast 6th Avenue, LLC? The president of the corporation. The floor is yours. First, I would like to request a continuance for the next available hearing date to retain an attorney and to give counsel time to review the city's evidence and prepare my responses. I'm asking that the merits of the case be determined, be deferred. Please rule on my request on the record. Counsel? One moment. Let me just see when this was noticed. The city noticed this and served this on October 22, 2026. So that's almost nearly a month. This is the first time the city is hearing that Mr. Mayo is requesting additional time to have his attorney review. So we would object to any continuance. We did request through Assistant City Manager Ortiz, because that's who we were told to contact with, and we've been in constant communication via text with him, and we told him the same. My appellate attorney, who is still working on the appeal, says they do not have the time to go through all this, because this is very in-depth, detailed, and it goes outside of the appeal, which they are still working on answering the city's response to the appeal. So they are recommending another attorney. They have three names for me that I need to contact, but this is, we're going back three years of e-mails, three years of evidence. I have here 27 pages of documents to read into the record. This is a long, very detailed. I don't understand a lot of it, so I'm doing the best I can, but I do feel I need counsel. When did you make this request to the Assistant City Manager? Oh, jeez, probably three different times. When did you initially make this request? When we first got the notice, immediately. Do you have any documentation? Text messages from Dave Weir, who has been in contact with Jeff Ortiz. He works for me. He's the one that was actually assigned and told to be the liaison. I don't know if you remember, but in a commission meeting, the commission said that appointed Jeff Ortiz as my specific liaison for everything that deals with subculture. And I've gone to submit paperwork at the city and were turned away and say that everything has to go through Jeff Ortiz. So he's been our contact. I can have him send me all the text messages. At some point, he stopped responding about two weeks ago. So I'm just trying to figure out the necessity for the attorney because the appeal has been finalized. The city complied with the appellate mandate and executed this order on September 17th. And if there is any opportunity to appeal that order, that would have been within 30 days based on 162 and we're in November. We're welcome to reviewing and having any text messages, but the city objects to an additional time. When is our next code meeting, Linda? December 3rd. Mr. Mayor, what I'm willing to do is I'm willing to reset this to December 3rd and give you a chance to get an attorney. But what I'm not willing to do is I'm not going to stay anything that's pending. No, I understand. It's going to continue. I know. All right. Yeah. I'll reset these for December 3rd. Thank you. Thank you. And just for clarification, these are reset for a lean and continue hearing on the one case where the fines have... Lean and continue on nine and lean certification hearings on 10 and 11. Thank you. Thank you. Case number 12, code 26-000805. The property owners are Greg C. and Marcia L. Miller. The property address is 850 Bondway. And the code officer on the case is Chantel Jean-Baptiste. Good afternoon, special magistrate, code compliance officer Jean-Baptiste. Property 850 Bondway originally filed in violation on August 20, 2026 for a true removal without a permit and a fence placed in city right away. Given 60 days to come into compliance or $100 daily fine, property was re-inspected on November 4th, 2026, and the property was still out of compliance with landscape, obtained a landscape permit. And the fence was removed out of the city right away. The owner is here asking for 60 days extension to comply. Sir, can you tell me your name, please? Keith Kern, represent Mr. and Mrs. Miller. I was in here before on this. The fence issue has been fully resolved. Correct. That's in compliance. Okay, so the remaining issue is there were two trees removed by Delray Garden Center, without my client's consent, I might add, that are located in the alleyway. There's been a lot of mistakes made here. The landscape plan that was presented to the city, the city reviewers, Delray Garden Center, all depicted the original landscape plan as the 10-foot alleyway where these trees are located as being an easement. It is not. It's city-owned property. Two mango trees were removed in the alleyway. We, my clients, have applied for the tree removal permit to comply with this. The permit, my understanding, has been rejected because we need to do tree mitigation. But that alleyway is not our property. My client's position is that the landscape on their property now complies with the shade tree requirements. There's Royal Poinciana, Sapodillas, Strangler Fig, et cetera, that there's less than 7,000 square feet, 7,500 square feet there. And I think we're in compliance. We're willing to do whatever is necessary. My question that I sent to Mr. Glover and Ms. Warren and a whole bunch of others was, do you want us on this tree mitigation to put trees back in the alleyway? I think trees back in the alley would be a violation of the city's ordinances that say alleyways need to be accessible and trees that block that are a public nuisance. We're happy to put trees back in the alleyway. I don't think there's room for trees at the home. So there's been a lot of mistakes made here, not intentionally, but nobody realized that that alleyway was not my client's. The landscape plan was approved. Fences in the past, I think 2022, were approved in the alleyway. We have since removed them. So we want to comply. I had requested a meeting so we can sit down and discuss this. Mr. Glover made mention of some kind of a tree fund. My clients would probably contribute to that instead of in lieu of putting trees. We'll put trees in, but there's really no room on our property. Do you really want them on the city's property in an alleyway underneath power lines? FPNIL, I'm sure, has an easement there, and they do not allow trees to be placed. So we just need a little bit of guidance. So I would dispute that this has been a lot of mistakes, especially, I mean, that characterizing this situation is that I would more so characterize it as the property owner not liking it. or being willing to do what the city is asking of them to do. And I believe Mr. David Glover is here to testify to what has been proposed, Mr. Glover. And, you know, Mr. Curtis. So, yeah, my name is David Glover. I'm the CEO of the state planner for the city. Yeah, I would object to the characterization that the attorney is presenting here now. I would also say that it has not been a due process with the attorney for it. They did submit a true permit, which I made comments for, I believe, over two months ago, that he's not interested in the next step. It was straight to the attorney. When we were asking for a pre-mitigation plan, all of this is a documentation on the survey that shows that it's interesting on the property owner. We need that documentation to do a mitigation. Mr. Glover, if you can, I don't know if your microphone is on. I didn't want to. Can you hear me now? Yes. To do a tree mitigation review to see what the compliance total would be. Also, in email exchanges, yes, I have relayed to the attorneys that we do have two processes where the trees could be mitigated on the property or that mitigation could be paid into the tree trust fund. What the attorney is failing to mention is that they have an approved landscape plan. And in that approved landscape plan, these trees were identified as two mango trees. And the purpose of those two trees was to remain, regardless of the location of these two trees, a permit is required. On the landscape plan, it does depict that as a 15-foot easement. Well, if I understand correctly, the respondent is saying that he applied for a tree permit, but it was denied. He applied for a tree permit after the fact of the code violation of the trees being removed. Yeah, I understand that. But we're at the point where we're trying to get to a resolution here. So what's he supposed to do here? He can address the comments onto the applied permit by applying tree mitigation or into the tree trust fund. But we haven't gotten to the point of discussion of which way we would go because no one has addressed any of the comments on the permit submitted. So that's what they have to do, address the comments, or there is some discussion about the tree trust fund. There was never a process. So why didn't you address the comments on the permit? That's pretty standard. I submitted a very detailed letter asking for a meeting to discuss the comments because honestly, and Mr. Glover, you were taking my comments incorrectly. I didn't say anybody in here made a mistake. But clearly, when plans that were approved contain property that my clients don't even own, that's a mistake. I don't know what my clients thought they owned it. The landscape planner thought they owned it. The city approved the entire plan. So that, in my opinion, was a mistake. Nothing intentional by anybody. So everyone misunderstood the property lines. And in addition, Delray Garden Center submitted a statement back here in October saying that they have contacted canopy landscape architects to produce the tree disposition and mitigation plan. And I guess they haven't submitted that yet. They're not being very responsive because they know that I'm going to be going after them for cutting down the trees without anybody's permission, including my clients. So all we want to know is where should we put the trees? I wanted to have a meeting just to discuss that. And if Mr. Glover says here's a good place to put the trees because – If I understand the city's position, correct me if I'm wrong, the city is suggesting the meeting isn't right because you haven't finished the permit. Is that essentially it? Yeah, but we also addressed – me personally, I addressed each comment that was made into that letter received from their attorney on point, direct directions of which way they could proceed. And all we – I was responding back with was, thank you. Also, too, if you look in their whole entire permit sheet, you can see where their approved site plan does deplete this as an alleyway. What their attorney is mentioning is a landscape plan, but that's not the survey for the property. But not to get in all the weeds, regardless of the location of the trees, you need a permit to work – you need a permit to remove the trees, regardless of the location. If it's in an alleyway, an easement, or on private property, you need a permit. And that's the simple fact of where we're at now. And they don't have a permit because they haven't responded to the comments? No. They removed the trees without a permit. There was an issue of code violation. No, no, no. The question is they haven't responded to the comments. No. So what are you asking me for, sir? Additional time so that we can – I think we have addressed the comments. It's – we're wanting to know where can we put the trees to replace the two that were cut down. I don't think you want them in the alleyway. Do you? I very rarely get involved with where one should put a tree. Right. Like I said, we have two – there's two options. And the code is very clear. If the property cannot attain or custom all the trees that are required, they can pay into the tree trust line. But that is done through the permanent process and review. But I would need the tree disposition plan to get the sizes of the existing trees so, therefore, I could do my calculations of what the cost would be to go on. Okay, I think I'm getting it now. So the city has stopped because you don't have the disposition plan. Correct. And I believe the compliance state has already passed on this. Yes. It was October – I'm sorry, May 31, 2026. So I'm not sure if they're asking for – to extend that or – I'm not sure. Yes, I filed an extension request. Okay. And like I said, Delray Gardens Center is apparently – and they're not being very responsive to me – they're the original persons that did the – entity that did the landscaping. They are supposedly submitting what Mr. Glover is asking for. I'm guessing they haven't. How long have you been waiting for them to do this? They submitted this letter to the city on October 16th saying they need at least 12 business days. A letter from what? Delray Gardens? Sent to the city. Yes. Yeah, I have no knowledge of that. Okay. So you're asking me for more time? Correct. We will comply. We just know – we need to know how to comply. Again, I – the characterization that the – that city staff has not told them how to comply or replied to any comments. No, they haven't. Like – Mr. Glover sent a very detailed letter, and I appreciate that. But I then responded with a question of do you want us – do you really want us to plant trees in your alleyway? Well, that's all – I thought I made it clear on that letter because I put it in very big, bold letters. You can plant on your private property or pay into the tree trust fund. Those are the only two options. And then we keep getting back with the same comments of saying, well, do you want them in the alleyway? We don't feel like it was approved, correct. It's just always the same response back. It's never – What is the cost of the – to pay into the tree trust fund? I would – we would have to go through the permit process and do the review of the trees. Okay. So it's never been comments through the building portal or the building permit process. It's always been a response back to, you know, back and forth opinions of which way to go. So – Thank you. And then I would ask if the special magistrate entertains any type of additional time for compliance that the outstanding fines remain that have been already accruing. I'll tell you what. I'll stay the fines as of today, and I'll give you 30 days to figure it out. Okay. In case 2600805, I'm going to stay the additional fines for 30 days, pending resolution, and we'll reset this for – do we have a second meeting in December? December 17th. All right. We'll set this for December 17th. Wait. Will you be here? You will? You will be here on December 17th? Okay. I just wanted to make sure that the code enforcement officer was here. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Case number 13, code 26-000629. The property owners are 222 Ocean North, LLC. The registered agent is Blaine C. Dickinson. And the code officer on the case is Supervisor Latoya Thompson. This is a reduction of lien or fine request. Good afternoon. Special Magistrate Code Compliance Supervisor Latoya Thompson, originally found in violation – this case was originally found in violation on May 7th, 2026 for demolition construction site being used for storage of materials. Given 24 days to come into compliance for $100 daily fine, property was re-inspected on June 1st, 2026. Property still was out of compliance. Property came into compliance on July 21st, 2026. There is an accrued fine in an amount of $5,000. The owner is asking for a reduction of fine. Can you tell me your name, please? Sean McAllister. What is your relation to the property? I guess an authorized agent, something along those lines. Are you an attorney or a real estate agent? No, I work for the firm. What is your position? Director of Development. Thank you. You're authorized to be here on behalf of the property owner? Yes. Do you have any objections? No. So tell me what you're asking for and why I should grant it to you, sir. Sure. Yeah, we're just asking for, obviously, the reduction of the fine that was issued. It took a little bit to get into compliance, so the lot was demolished, and then it was subsequently split into two separate parcels. And one parcel, or two separate parcels, both were applied for building permits, one each. And at the time we were staging for construction, the permits had not been issued yet. One permit has since been issued. Another permit is still in process. But, obviously, the site has been brought into compliance, as mentioned. But we were, you know, gearing up to start construction on the permits that were one has subsequently been issued. So we're asking for reduction of the fine that was issued for the storage of materials on the demolished site. What kind of reduction are you asking me for? Preferably full reduction. What's the city's position on this request? The city suggests 25% of the $5,000, which would be $1,250 to be paid within 30 days. Got to tell you, that's probably better than I would have done. Sure. I'll reduce the fine to $1,250 payable within 30 days. Thank you. Thank you. Case number 14, code 26-000685. The property owner is Delray Place, LLC. The registered agent is Joe Carosella. The property address is 1801 South Federal Highway. And the code officer on the case is Supervisor LaToya Thompson. Good afternoon, Special Magistrate, Code Compliance, Supervisor LaToya Thompson. This case was originally filed in violation on June 18, 2026 of Section 24.10, Subsection A.1, Site Plan Application, and 4.4.25, Subsection H.1, Special Activities District, related to the proposed modification of the existing AT&T building. Compliance was established in two phases. Phase 1, Submission of a Sufficient Application. The applicant was required to submit a sufficient application by the compliance date of June 8, 2026. This phase was subsequently achieved, although the application was submitted after the established compliance deadline. Phase 2, Approval of a Complete Site Modification Plan. The applicant is required to obtain a Complete Site Modification Plan within 180 days of the hearing date. Establish a final compliance deadline of December 16, 2026. Today's hearing, the purpose of today's hearing is to receive an update from the applicant regarding the progress made towards complying Phase 2, and to determine whether the applicant remains on track to achieve full compliance by December 16, 2026. Thank you. Ma'am, can you state your name, please? Yes, Christina Belenke, and I'm here representing the property owner. You're an attorney, ma'am? I am. And who do you have with you? Rebecca. Hi, my name is Rebecca Dossery. I'm with Development Services, and I was processing the applications submitted by the applicant. Excellent. So that would be a lot of city. My apologies. So tell me what's going on. Sure. So we've actually been working very closely with Rebecca and Development Services staff on these applications. The applications essentially require two separate applications, an SAD amendment, which is equivalent to a rezoning application. It requires public hearings before the Planning and Zoning Board and City Commission. That application was heard before the Planning and Zoning Board on September 28th of this year. Subsequently, it was discovered there was a notice issue with the public hearing notices. So we've been working with staff. We have to reissue notices and re-hear the item. So we are working collectively towards the December 14th Planning and Zoning Board meeting for that item. And then we anticipate City Commission meetings in January and February. The site plan application is processed separately. It's been submitted, reviewed. I think it's currently under review by staff right now. They'll issue comments. We'll respond. I think they're very minor in nature. But that cannot be approved until the rezoning is approved by the City Commission. So best case scenario, I think we're looking towards the end of February, early March. Yes, so we've met with code enforcement staff and development services staff about this issue. And the City's position is that the reason why the property owner has not come into compliance with that second phase of the order is really a respondent's issue. It's not on the City. So the notice issue that was brought up is they issued the wrong notices, right? So the City's position is that the compliance date is still December 16th. I'm not sure where we will be on December 14th with the Planning and Zoning hearing. Maybe we can readdress it at a code enforcement hearing after that. But just to extend out the deadline at this point, I understand foresight, but I think that we still want to kind of keep the foot on the gas on this and not extend it out and have more issues later. And respectfully, I mean, we wanted the notice to be correct. We thought it was correct. We discovered that after the fact. There's nothing about this process where we would have wanted to go back to a second Planning and Zoning Board meeting. Unfortunately, the only way to cure a notice defect is to re-hear the item. So that is the position we're in. It requires a second hearing to assess a lien at this point. I'm not going to change any of the underlying orders, and we'll just reconvene probably in the next year and see where you're at. And if the City wants to make an argument that I should assess a fine on you, I'll hear it. If you think that that's not appropriate, I'll hear it then too. But I don't know that there's anything that I need to do here. So taking no action? Yeah. Just get it done as soon as you can. And if the City wants to hold you responsible for not getting it done in a timely fashion, you can explain it to me. Just as a point of clarification, I believe the order from the last meeting did assess fines as of December 16th? It gives the potential for me to assess fines, but it would require a fine assessment hearing. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to take no action at this time. Just to be clear, Magistrate, there will be no new orders today. No, no orders, no action. Thank you so much. Case number 15, Code 26-000534. The property owner is MDG Banyan Delray Partners, LLC. The registered agent is Cogency Global, Inc. And the code officer on the case is Reggie Williams. This is a request for a reduction of fine or lien. Yeah, so if you recall, Mr. Wagner, we were here on about, I believe, October 1st. We've already heard testimony. Mr. Michaels stated his position. The city stated their position. And the real issue was that you wanted us to look into is whether you even had the authority to reduce the current $9,000 fine that had already been paid by Mr. Michael. So you asked us both to look into it. I have my position and Mr., you know, I'm sure Mr. Michael will have his position on it. So I don't know if you want me to just proceed. Yep, go ahead. Okay. So we respectfully oppose any further reduction of the fine on this case. In the city's opinion, you previously exercised your discretion under Chapter 162 and reduced the fine to $9,000. If you remember, there was a different amount of fine. There was a lot going on on this property. The wall was left and you accounted for that and said, I think the fair and reasonable thing to do would just be to assess the fine for a specific period of time for that specific violation because the others had been cured before a certain date, right? So you've already reduced it and considered all those things, reduced it to $9,000, taking that into consideration of the compliance of specifically for that portion of the case. That reduction was memorialized in your order, specifying a payment deadline. The respondent, as he testified at the last hearing, paid that, reduced the amount before any particular deadline. I don't know if there was, I don't recall, I believe there was some issue and he didn't want it to affect his financing or something like that. So he can further clarify that in the order. What I've done since the last hearing, I reviewed Chapter 162, any relevant case law, any relevant Florida attorney general opinions addressing the authority of a special magistrate or a code enforcement board to reduce fines after the fines have already been paid in satisfaction. So I was able to find attorney general opinions that address the limitations or the authority once a fine has been reduced or recorded as a lien. In that sense, it was, you can't do anything about it. It's a lien. You know, your jurisdiction is gone after that point. But, however, I was not able to identify any particular case law, any precedents, or any opinions directly addressing the reopening of a case of a fully satisfied fine for the purposes of what would happen in this case, issue a refund for the city. So in some, what Mr. It seemed to me we're even one step past the lien. Right. I mean, the case is done, right? So what I was going to say, you know, what 162 does authorize is a fine reduction if fines have been accrued, if it hasn't been paid, and things like that before it gets paid and it's not satisfied. You know, the city's position is that there's no longer, you can no longer reduce a fine as the fine has already been paid. There's no specific authorization in 162 to do it. Rather, the respondent is effectively, in this sense, requesting a refund of public funds collected under a final order that has been already satisfied. So, absent any demonstrated legal basis from Mr. Michael for reopening that would go above and beyond what your authority is in Chapter 162, the city respectfully requests that the respondent's request for a further reduction be denied. And, honestly, if you would consider it, the cities would state that you've already done it, you've already considered it, and we would object to it as well in that sense. All right, Mr. Michael, the floor is yours. I'll want to just introduce this into the record, if it's okay. You have to show it to the city attorney first. Yeah, I've got one for each. Did you ask to read it, Mr. Michael, before you present it? Go ahead. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm Steve Michael. I'm here on behalf of MDG Banyan, owner of the Docks Building, and thank you for taking the time to research your question last month. I'd like to answer directly from me. You asked whether you can return a fine payment. Respectfully, I believe you can. The statute lets you reduce a fine imposed with no exception for a fine that has been paid. That power really ends only when a fine is ordered and recorded as a lien. No lien was recorded here. So this is a reduction of a daily fine, not a lien reduction. Once you reduce it, the city is holding money that it really isn't owed. The payment was voluntary. I'm sorry. The payment was not voluntary. The city told me in writing that my reduction request would be heard at the next available hearing. At that hearing, it asked for full payment while a lien would have defaulted my construction loan. That's why I did not want a lien. I paid under protest, relying on that written promise from the city. The city's approved plans put an opening exactly where the vehicle had struck the wall that's in question. We filed a repair permit the day after your April 20th order. And the city's own code officer had testified that we always address concerns immediately. We've been very good about that. Florida statute says an enforcement board may reduce a fine imposed pursuant to this section. Section 162.03 gives the special magistrate the same authority. Nothing in the statute exempts a fine that has been paid. The Florida Attorney General has concluded that this power has no time limit and that it ends at one point, really one point only, when the fine order is recorded and it becomes a lien. No lien was ever recorded here. That's exactly why I paid this, to keep a lien from being put on my property. The city's own code enforcement manual draws the same line. Section 2 gives the board discretion to reduce liens and accrued fines based on a totality of circumstances. When you reduce a fine already paid, returning the balance follows from the order. If you view the refund as an act of maybe the city manager or the commission, then I would ask you to ask them to refund the fine. I expect the city to argue that the daily fine could have been $1,000 that you set at $200 and that I have already received my reduction, as they have. Respectfully, that is not correct for four reasons. First, the statute treats these two separate steps. Section 162.09 governs determining the amount of the fine when it is imposed. Section 162.09 also is a separate power to reduce a fine imposed. $200 a day is the fine that was imposed. $1,000 was actually never imposed. So nothing was reduced from it. Setting a rate below the maximum is not a reduction. It's just a fine. Second, when the rate was set, the wall had not yet been repaired. The reduction step exists to weigh what happens afterwards. The city's own manual accepts reduction requests only after compliance, which I had to do. Third, the city did not take this position in June. When I asked for a reduction, the then director of code enforcement, Director Pryor, did not say that I had already received one. She said my request would be heard at the next available hearing in an email. And your October 26 order set today is a fine reduction hearing. Fourth, $1,000 a day is a statutory limit. Available only by a special ordinance under Section 162.09. It's not a starting point. Choosing a lower rate applied the statutory factors to the facts at the time. I think it was the severity of the case. It did not decide the reduction request the city told me to file. The city has never cited any statute or ordinance or rule saying the payment closes a case. I asked for one in writing. I never received anything. On June 16th, I wrote the city that the knee wall repair and final inspections were complete and asked for a fine reduction. Thirty minutes later, Director Jerry Pryor, who headed the code enforcement, replied, Mrs. Kent will schedule you for the next available magistrate hearing. It cannot be for tomorrow's hearing. That afternoon, Mrs. Kent sent me a form and told me to fill it out. Once it was received, she would replace me as a request for the next available agenda. The city's manual also bars approving a request submitted within seven days. That's why we couldn't do it. At the next day's hearing, which was my last hearing, the city asked for full payment and opposed time for a mitigation hearing, which I asked for. I explained on the record that a recorded lien would default our construction loan of approximately $20 million. I paid $9,600 under protest, relying on the city's written promise. In August, the city told me the payment had closed and the case could not be refunded. The Florida case law does not allow that result. Our courts hold that the government is stopped when it makes a representation of fact. A person relies on it and the person is harmed by it. This is what happened. Florida courts also told that a payment made to avoid a cloud on title of real property is not voluntary. The city cannot direct someone into a procedure that then uses compliance to deny him that procedure. I'm not asking you to revisit the finding of the violation. I'm asking you to weigh the statutory factors, gravity, correction action, and prior violations. The gravity is that a woman drove off of Atlantic Avenue and hit our knee wall. It wasn't our – we didn't cause any of the damage. The property was already in permitting with the city of Delray and shows – and it was part of the overall project. The city required a repair to a section of the wall that the approved plans had removed. Mrs. Hoyland, on October 15th, emailed – says that the wall – when she sent me an email – wall was going to be restored and not demolished. But the wall she circled, which is part of the – what I gave you, the wall that she circled is the wrong wall. It's not the wall that was in question with the code enforcement action. I asked her in writing to correct the record, but I have not gotten a response. Corrective action, we filled the – we filed the repair permit application the day after our April 2nd order. The city logged it in on April 24th. In May, on May 21st, testimony that we filed – that we filed our permit application the day before that hearing was not accurate. By June 16th, the repairer had passed the final inspection. The only item cited was a certificate of occupancy, which we don't need for a knee wall repair. Prior violations. We have none on this property. We've had a very good relationship with code enforcement. And at prior hearings, under oath, a code officer testified to that. That is the city's testimony, not mine. I ask you just to weigh it in our clean history and totality of circumstances. Compliance was achieved. Keeping $9,600 really serves no compliance purpose. So I'm asking really for four things. First, find the authority under 162.09 that the payment did not – that the payment did not remove it. Second, reduce the fine to zero, or the city's documented cost, and direct the balance to be returned to us. Third, the alternative, grant a 90% reduction, if you think that's the correct amount, in my pending request, in returning $8,600 approximately. And fourth, find the payment that was made under protest in reliance on the June 16th representations by the city that we have no prior violations and a record of addressing every city concerned always. Thank you. I just have a quick rebuttal. So I just want to start off by saying the representation that the city made promises about what would happen or what would occur if Mr. Michaels brought this back before the special magistrate. There was no written promises to make any refunds, no written promises to reopen the case after it was closed, after the fine was paid. The only promise that was made to Mr. Michaels was for the ability to be heard in due process, which is what we're here for today, right? So the city is giving him the opportunity to be heard, giving him the opportunity to bring forth any legal authority or any authority that would allow this to happen. Mr. Michaels talked about 162, and while he's saying that there's nothing in there that doesn't prohibit you for doing it, there's nothing in there that authorizes a special magistrate to explicitly reduce a fine after the case has already been closed and paid. So our position is that there is no authority for the special magistrate to reopen the case, reduce a fine, and mandate a city to refund from public funds money based off an updated order. And just frankly, there's no more fine. There's no more issue. And while Mr. Michaels does correctly state that Chapter 16202, Section 2C, provides an enforcement board, you know, specifically in this case, a special magistrate may reduce fine imposed pursuant to this order. That's while they're pending and ongoing and continual. That is not while it has already been fined. Mr. Michaels has effectively waived that at this point by paying the fine in this case. So, you know, I don't even think we need to get to the gravity and the, you know, the considerations that are taken into consideration under Chapter 162 when fines are actually imposed. But, so we would just object to that. And again, even if the magistrate wants to consider all of that, we would just say that based on this circumstance, I mean, it wasn't just that, you know, that time period where Mr. Michaels said that he filed the permit. We have to go back to the initial beginning of the case when the notice was issued back in January 2026 and nothing had been done and staff continued to give Mr. Michaels continuances throughout that time period until the actual code enforcement board, I'm sorry, special magistrated hearing was occurred. So, I just fall back on my initial position. There's no jurisdiction here. There's nothing specifically in Chapter 162 that authorizes Mr. Wagner to reduce a fine after a case has been effectively closed and paid. Mr. Michaels, I'll give you the last one. Sure. First, I am not expecting, I didn't expect what the reduction would be, but I was told in writing in an email, which I unfortunately didn't bring with me, but I do have, that I would have my opportunity to go to a lien reduction hearing. And that was what I relied on the day before the hearing and paid the fine. And you didn't give me the opportunity, the time, to go to a mitigation hearing because you demanded the money that day. So, there was, I did rely on that. And it was written emails from your director of code enforcement. And state statute, as far as the fact that, you know, it doesn't say that you don't have the authority, it's not clear whether, you know, you do or do you do not have the authority. It doesn't have anything in the statute that says that you don't have the authority. And really, state law says if it's vague, it really doesn't go to the city's, it doesn't go back to the city in the city's favor. It goes to the applicant or the person who is being affected. And I would object to that characterization of Chapter 162. It's all right. I'll let him finish. So, that's, yeah, that's my answer, sorry. Yeah, I mean, it's not a question of whether it goes to you or the city. It's a question of a, I think you're misunderstanding Chapter 162 and special magistrates in general, which is I'm not a judge. I'm not a constitutional officer. I have specific authority delegated to me through state statutes and through the code of the city of Delray Beach. That is the limits of my power or what they give me, not what I can apply that might exist. All of which is to say I've been in the code compliance legal side, oh, goodness, since the 1990s. And while I admire both the conviction you bring and also the conviction that you bring to your argument, I have never in the entire time that I've been in this business seen anyone attempt to do what you're attempting here, which is attempting to get a magistrate to return a fine that's paid. And part of the problem with it is I would have to essentially issue an order to the city of Delray Beach ordering them to take funds, because they're funds that are in their possession now, and pay them out, which is a legislative function. I am not prepared to issue such an order. I do not see the authority of myself to be able to do that. If you think that the city did you wrong, there are legal remedies to such things. But I do not have the authority. And one of the reasons that I sort of postponed this is because I said you find something that I didn't find that says that I have the right to do something like this, I'll listen to it. But unless there's an express grant of authority to a magistrate to order a municipality to spend money, goodness, think about the implications of what that might well be. Well, I'm not asking you to order them to spend money. They already have it, so it's become public funds the moment you spend it. But it's not their money because they didn't acquire that. You may not think so. You may not think so. As far as my argument. It is in their treasury. So at this point, I would be ordering them to spend money. I do not see my authority going that far. I am a special magistrate. I'm not a judge. But if you did order a reduction without imposing an order to make them pay the fine back, that would in essence mean that they have the ability and the obligation to pay that difference back. But there's another implication here too, which is if I have the authority to do this, then basically any case that's ever been before code enforcement that has been finalized, concluded, and paid, somebody could come back and go return my money. But law says it's only finalized when there's a lien. It's final. Yeah. This is past the lien. This is paid. And in fairness, I mean, we're really being fair here. The only reason there isn't a lien is because the city was trying to accommodate the fact that you didn't want to have a lien on your property for lots of reasons. But regardless, that doesn't ultimately matter. I do not see any authority for me to reopen this case and reduce the lien. So your request is denied. But I appreciate the attempt. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Seeing no further business before us. We are adjourned. Thank you. Thank you.