Good evening. We're live. Good evening. Welcome to the City of Delray Beach Advisory Board Agenda, Site, Blind, Review, and Appearance Board for Wednesday, November 18th. I am Annette Gray, your board chair. Can we have a roll call, please? Sure. Brett Talbot is absent. Abby Canton? Here. Sandra Amani? Here. Cynthia Lloyd? Here. Nicholas Coppola? Here. Jose Alvarez? Here. Annette Gray? Here. Are there any additions, deletions, or modifications to tonight's agenda? No changes? Can I have a motion, please? Motion to approve the agenda? Second. I have a first and a second. Can you call roll, please? I'm sorry. Who seconded? Thank you. Abby Canton? Yes. Sandra Amani? Yes. Cynthia Lloyd? Yes. Nicholas Coppola? Yes. Jose Alvarez? Yes. Annette Gray? Yes. I have one set of minutes from October 28th, 2026. Are there any additions, deletions, or modifications to those minutes? No. Seeing none, can I have a motion to approve the minutes? Second. First and a second. Abby? Yes. Nathan? Sandra Amani? Yes. Cynthia Lloyd? Yes. Nicholas Coppola? Yes. Jose Alvarez? Yes. Annette Gray? Yes. All right. Can you swear in the public? Anyone that will be speaking on tonight's agenda, please stand and be sworn in. By the authority vested in me as a notary of the state of Florida, do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth? Would you please see it? Okay. Tonight's meeting will be conducted in accordance with the City of Delray Beach quasi-judicial rules. The applicant, the city, I'm sorry, and the city will be permitted to present their case. The public will be allowed to speak for three minutes each, or a maximum of six minutes if the person represents an organization or group of people who are present but agree not to speak. The city, commission, board, members, staff, and the applicant may be allowed to cross-examine a witness, the city or the applicant will be allowed to offer rebuttal testimony. The decision to approve or deny an application or appeal may not legally be made upon personal views as to whether a project is a good project or not, nor may a decision be based on the numbers of citizens who support or oppose a particular project. The law requires that all decisions must be made on the basis of whether the project meets the requirements of law, the comprehensive plan, and the land development regulations. At this time, I'd like to open public comments for anyone who is in attendance that would like to speak or address the board on anything that is not on tonight's agenda. You'll have three minutes to do so. Okay, seeing none, I'll close public comments, which moves us to agenda item six. There are presentations. None? None. Agenda item 7A. And let's see. Sophia, will you be introducing that item? Good evening, board members. I would like to introduce Sophia Erighi. She's our planner in training, and she's about to graduate from the FAU, Urban and Regional Planning. And she's kind to us today to present on her birthday. So happy birthday, Sophia. And go ahead. Good evening, board. For the record, Sophia Erighi, planner and training. I'd like to enter into the record file number PZ-000945-2026 for a request to amend the master signed program at Delray Town Center, specifically for Unit A-15. And the applicant is here to present. Thank you. If you could state your name and address for the record and start with your presentation. Gina Penny, address is 1077 West Blue Heron Boulevard, West Palm Beach, Florida. We're requesting approval of an amendment to the existing master signed plan for Delray Town Center located at 4801 Linton Boulevard. The proposed amendment will establish supplemental sign criteria specifically for tenant space A-15, currently occupied by PGA Tour Superstore. The intent is to accommodate signage appropriately scaled to this tenant space while maintaining the overall architectural appearance of the development. The aerial identifies the location of tenant space A-15 within Delray Town Center. You can see by the proposed wall sign that we're proposing a sign that's 158.13 square feet. We're requesting an aggregate wall sign area of 160 square feet to accommodate that, just to round it off. And you can see how it fits on the building. It's appealing. The supplemental sign criteria that we're asking for is for individual tier letter heights of 36 inches at a maximum, the combined letter heights at 50 each maximum, the logo height at 70 inches, and aggregate wall sign area at 160. This is a limited amendment to the existing master signed program. It establishes supplemental sign criteria specifically for tenant space A-15, maintains the existing approved criteria for all other tenant spaces, and accommodates signage appropriately scaled to the building's architectural features. And just respectfully requests approval of the proposed master signed program amendment. Again, the request in front of the board today is for the amendment to the master signed program of Delray Town Center, unit A-15. The property is located at the north intersection of South Military Trail and West Linton Boulevard. Unit A-15 is highlighted in purple. It is located within the commercial plaza facing the internal parking area. For some background, SPRAV approved Delray Town Center's master signed program on October 24, 1990, with the following height standards. Two rows of letters measuring 12 inches in height with a 24-inch total maximum height. At the time, Blockbuster Video had a signed approval at 87 inches in height, and Albertsons had a signed approved at 60 inches in height, both going over the 24-inch maximum. SPRAV has approved sign-specific modifications differing from the established MSP in several instances. For example, on November 8, 1997, SPRAV approved First Bank of Florida to have a single-tier sign measuring 18 inches in height. On June 12, 2002, Palm Beach County Bank was approved for two flat wall signs at 50 inches in height. On March 12, 2003, Domino's Pizza was approved for a single-tier sign measuring 24 inches in height. And lastly, on November 9, 2005, Commercial Bank was approved for two flat wall signs, 50 inches in height, single-tier. And as you can see, most sign approvals have differed from the original MSP. And these modifications did not alter the MSP. They are sign-specific. Today, Delray Town Center is proposing amendment specific to tenant space A15. The amendment proposes a maximum tier letter height of 36 inches, a maximum combined lettering height of 50 inches, a logo height of 70 inches maximum, and a wall sign area of 160 square feet max. The purpose of the master sign program is for larger-scale developments to meet the design and aesthetic standards when the normal application of design standards results in an inefficient sign program. The city's LDR does not have specific language, which prevents diversity and creativity of individual signs. And SPRAP has the authority to take action on the MSP. Aesthetic quality must be considered to ensure visual harmony as it relates to its surrounding structures. It is important to consider if the scale size and location are appropriate for the location to ensure a professional appearance. Therefore, the board must consider that the MSP only applies to tenant bay A15, that the amendment will accommodate future tenants, and that the sign is proportionate to the size of the tenant bay, as it is one of the largest in the area. These are your board motions, and that concludes my presentation. Okay, thank you. Are there anyone in the audience that would like to comment on this item? Okay, seeing none of close public comments to the board discussion, are there anyone that has an ex parte? Oh, no. Sorry. I presume that meant you wanted to start. Sorry. Yeah, I just had two quick questions. The first is, is this sign equal to the sign that's in the mall, the Target mall on Linton? That's important to know, I think, because that's a corporate logo. I mean, they've actually executed a corporate logo on the store. Is this in the same plaza? Are you talking? No, no, no. It's in where the Target is on Linton. So that's where the store was, and now it's moving locations. So what I'm asking is, is the sign the same, because that's a national corporate logo. So maybe the applicant can answer this? Right, and the area would be the same. And the second thing is... The site is actually smaller than what is in the Target plaza, and there's more than one sign at that location. No, I was going to say that we couldn't hear her. She was, like, started talking when she was sitting, so I was just saying, wait until you get into the microphone. Oh, okay. Do you want me to repeat it? I'm going to hurry. I hurry. Thank you. And then, question, or to be old. To circle back? Yeah, that'd be great. Ms. Imani? Mr. Adler? No problem. No, no comment. No question. Can you pronounce your name? Canva. Canva. Okay. I did have one other question. Was there a reason why you actually didn't show this in relation to the other stores in that area? Because we sort of do have to balance. I mean, I think that was part of the charge when it was read, that, you know, we sort of have to make sure that everything has some cohesiveness. So, I mean, this is great that we see this, but, you know, we don't see the other businesses. Photos for the other businesses. Yeah. I think that's just a small challenge, just, you know, to be fair. There was no, it just wasn't part of the request to be submitted with the application. Good to know. Thank you. But I do have a couple, because we were asking why certain tenants have bigger signs. I have an Aldi, and actually with me. I'd like to see them. Yeah. That'd be great. Thank you so much for that. It's a black and white photo, but it's... That's it. It's thank you for having it. It's like an Aldi. So, once the board reviews the photo, if you want to introduce it as an exhibit for the applicant, you can. Okay. No worries. Thank you so much. Of course. We'll just name that as Exhibit A. Did the applicant introduce her presentation? Yes. So, it will be Exhibit 2, then? Exhibit 2. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you so much for that. No problem. I think it's appropriate for the size of the storefront. All these storefronts... Well, it's a deep space. The storefront is not as big. This is more of a width, and I think it's appropriate. So, are there any other discussions? No, I think you make a good point, and there's a lot of parking, and it's quite far from the street as well, so... Okay. I'd like to entertain a motion. I'll make the motion to move to approval of the amendment of the Master Sign Program, PZ-945-2026, for Delray Town Center, establishing revised wall sign standards for tenants base 815, applicable to current and future tenants, by finding that the request meets the criteria set forth on the development regulations. Second. First and a second. Can you call the roll, please? Yes. Yes. Cynthia Lloyd? Yes. Nicholas Kapova? Yes. Jose Alvarez? Yes. Annette Gray? Yes. Okay. That moves us. Congratulations. Great job. Thank you. That moves us to item 7B, as in void, and that will be introduced by Ms. Susana. Yes. So, to state for the record, my name is Susie Rodriguez. I'm a senior planner. I would like to enter file PZ-701-2026 into the record. This is to establish a master sign program for Mira Delray, and the applicant is here today to present. Is that Mr. Campbell, representative? Good afternoon. I'm Alberto, representing the owner from Fast Science. Basically, this... Do you mind giving your address for the record? Oh. This is 2087 West Atlantic Avenue. Basically, what's going on here, it's a new owner. Excuse me. Did he say his name? I think he said name and address. Yes, he did say his name. Thank you. Yeah, Alberto Reyes from Fast Science in Davie. It's a pleasure to be here. I haven't served. Sorry for that. Basically, the owner is requesting to change the name on the monument. I'm sorry. I would interrupt you again. Like, your address, not the site address. My address as a contractor? That's for the record. Yes, sir. Okay. Yes, sir. We're located at 7080 West State Road 84th in Davie, Florida. Thank you. Thank you, sir. No problem. And, okay, let's proceed with the project. The owner, the new owner wants to change the name for Mayoral Del Rey. And what we found when we applied for the permit, it is just a simple name change. It was a master sign plan approved for the property. So, we came here to get approval of the master sign plan. It's basically following up the same size, same type of signs. Everything remains the same. The only thing that changes the name of the property. But it's the same was approved years ago when they built out the property, but it wasn't a sign plan established on your records. So, we're here to get approval of that. And, of course, the renders you're looking at is with the new name. So, it's kind of two in one. You can click with the clicker. Oh, I see it. So, this is the property. It has two entrances. It's going to be three signs. See it here? Correct. These two locations and one on the south and two is going to be double-sided and one is a single-sided. And we're not changing any kind of structure. We're not changing sizes. Nothing. It keep remaining the same. We're only changing the name. It used to be Aura, the right, and now it's Mira. Pretty simple. I hope it was larger scope, you know. So, this is what we're proposing. The structure is the same. The black box, it'll be the same. Same dimensions. Same thing. Just new letters that says the new name. It's pretty simple. So simple that probably don't have so much to present because it's a pretty simple scope. But I understand that it wasn't approved, a master sign on place for this property. So, these guys say, hey, there's no master sign plan. You know, we've got to introduce it, get approved, and then proceed with the permit. Great. Thank you. You're welcome. So, the site is located on the northwest corner of Atlantic and Congress Avenue. The site was previously MIC Zoning, which is a mixed industrial and commercial zoning, and has been rezoned to SAD Zoning District, which is a special activities district that sets certain standards approved via an ordinance. This site is surrounded by a mix of commercial and industrial use and also some residential uses across the canal. So, a brief background. The site was annexed in 1988 as GC and, well, General Commercial and Light Industrial. Then, in 1990, it was rezoned to the MIC. And then, in 2020, the Ora del Rey overlay was established along with the site plan for 292 units. With the rezoning to SAD, set standards were approved with Ordinance 32-20. The standards do not establish sign-specific standards, and there has been no approval for an MSP for the site. So, Mira del Rey, formerly known as Ora del Rey, is proposing an MSP to establish these sign standards for three monument signs, two along Congress and one along Atlantic Avenue. The MSP standards are as follows. So, it will be for the max height, 4 feet 6 inches, max width, 18 feet 3 inches, max area 70 square feet, and then max setback 14 feet 8 inches. The design criteria is to maintain consistent, cohesive appearance and complement the architectural character and overall design of the development. So, overall, an approval of an MSP may include automatic granting of waivers and or adjustments to the provisions provided that the intent of the sign code is maintained and the character of the community and neighborhood is not diminished. So, SPRAB has the authority to take actions for MSP. That criteria is as follows. So, it shall not be garish. It must be appropriate size, scale, and design, and have a professional appearance. So, as a reference of the adjacent standards, residential is limited to one freestanding sign per lot with a max square feet of 20 square feet and then minimum 10 feet setback. Commercial is limited to one freestanding sign per frontage, 160 square feet max, the calculations based off of property frontage, and then a minimum setback of 10 feet. The board should consider if the proposed MSP is harmonious with the characteristics of the development and is in good taste with the surrounding area. Bless you. Note, this approval is for the MSP standards and the specific signs are still subject to the sign permit process. In the future, these signs could be modified through the sign permit process if compliant with the MSP and does not need to return for board review unless the applicant is requesting for an amendment to the MSP. For example, when the commercial lot is constructed and they want to sign. So, this SAD does include a commercial component to the north. This is your board motions and this concludes my presentation. Okay, thank you. I'd like to open public comments for this agenda item. If there's anyone in the audience that would like to speak to this project, public comments is now open. Seeing none, I'll close public comments to the board. Before discussion, are there any ex parte communication that needs to be discussed? I'm just familiar with the sign. Okay. Excellent. Would you like to lead us off? So, thank you for the presentation. I guess my main question here is we're establishing a sign program, so the criteria seems very specific. Like, you know, 18 foot 3, 70.9. Is there a reason why we're so specific? Or could the wording be more generalized to allow future signage? That's my question. So, staff did bring this up to the applicant if they would like to do more vague numbers so it can free up for future signs. The applicant wanted to proceed in this manner. As this was an existing sign, they're not changing anything in the dimension, so they just wanted to continue with the same type of signs that have been seen in the past for this development. So, it has been brought up, but the request was to remain like this. And does that same specificity apply to that commercial site? No. So, when that commercial sign comes in, currently, right now, I believe they're in the process of trying to do some pre-applications to build something there. When the process comes that they're actually requesting for signs, the MSP will have to return to approve any of those signs for that commercial business, and it would be an amendment to this MSP. Okay. But there's no wording currently for that. Okay. All right. No other questions. Mr. Clifford. Do you have a picture of the aura, by any chance, that we can compare the two? The existing sign, possible. And while we're doing it, is it the applicant, while we're doing that, the applicant stated that the letters are the same size as the aura sign. Is that correct? Ma'am, can you come to the microphone? Please give your name and address for the record, once you're here. Excuse me, will you swear to me? If you can. No, but I can. Okay. He's already vested in me as a notary of the state of Florida. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony are back to give the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. My name is Maria-Alesia Borges, and my address is 340 Southeast 3rd Street, Miami, Florida, 33131. So we're keeping the same size of what you see as the black panel, which holds the letters. That's what was already there on the monument, and we are respecting that size and not modifying it at all. And we are removing those, like, the old aura letters that were there. And based on the scale of that black box, we put the new logo, and that's how we got the size inside that space. So that's, like, why we are respecting what was already there originally from the previous name. So are the letters the same size as the aura? I think... Or the black background, obviously, because that's a... No, the black background stays the same. But the size of the letters? No, I don't... Like, based on my memory, they're not the same size. Actually, aura used to take more space on the black backer panel. Great. Yeah, that's what I would like... Yeah. I feel... I think it's important that we all see what we're replacing and compare the two. And for my reason, it's from an aesthetic perspective, because I think that doesn't compare to that. Okay. So I'd like to say that the record can hear, but it can't see. So I know it appears that Mr. Alvarez was passing around his iPad. If you can just turn it around, display it to everyone so that all the members see the sign. Thank you. Thank you. And that's why I asked specifically with the same size. So I see a stark contrast from this to the existing one. Yeah. From the existing one. But let me finish. Am I concerned with your proposal for the Master Sign Program? It limits it limits you even further. Okay. I believe the size of the sign comprises from the black background and the letters. The letters are within that black background, which covers the whole area of the monument that we're doing. That's the whole sign. So the new logo, of course, is completely different to what it used to be like, and we had to apply the size of those new letters into that space proportionally without modifying the way that the logo was designed, because we have to respect the brand of what they created with that new name. That's why we even tried, like, putting Myra or Mira, like, bigger and the Del Rey on the side so it could take over more space. But that was not up to the new branding that was created for the new name of the property. Okay. Well, you say logo. I mean, there's no specific logo there per se. So are you saying that your brand more so? Or is that because, like, or, again, I look at the picture of the Aura, there's an actual logo there. Correct. And it seems to fill up more of that whole space that you're saying is the same size. For the obvious reasons, I don't think you could reduce the size of that. It's a concrete structure. Exactly. You know, I'll say that's really my concern to compare really what the quality of that Aura sign is. I'm okay with a change. It almost seems like something was more there, and is that the letters of sign seems very, very... So I just want to also clarify, the Master Sign program is not in specific up to the Mira Del Rey or the Aura Del Rey. It's just the square footage. So the square footage is the black dimensional that they have. I just quickly did the math, which is the 70.9, which is that black panel. So that is what they're asking for in the sign area. It's not specific to the Aura Del Rey or to the Mira Del Rey because in future applications, if they want to change it to a different name and they're still meeting all the criteria of the MSP, it will just go to the sign permit process and it will just continue with whatever, with the changes like that. But it's the black portion of the sign area that is in the... So what you're saying is the lettering could actually, there's no requirement. My understanding is there's a requirement on the size of the lettering as well. So in this one, the MSP is outlining a height for the overall freestanding structure, a width for the overall freestanding structure, the maximum area for the sign area, which is just that black area, and then the minimum setback for the freestanding. Right. Nothing for lettering. This one is not specific into lettering. All right. That's all the questions I have. Thank you. Mr. Adams? I mean, I agree with your comments, but given what we're evaluating, right, as part of the master sign program, you know, it's pretty much remaining in the same scale. So, you know, in that sense, I have no comments or applications to it. I'm going to mirror what he just said, no pun intended. Since aesthetics are not on the table, it seems to satisfy what is put in front of us to decide. I have no other. I actually don't mirror. I personally think aesthetically it's easier to read and it's very clean, and I actually prefer it rather than the logo. I think when you drive past it, it's going to actually, you'll be able to really see the name. So that's just a personal, for me, I think it's fine. But since our charge is literally just dimensions. I actually have a couple of questions for staff. So we are, in essence, approving for this project placement, right? So we're saying, what's the distance between the two? We're saying if we approve this, allowed for future development, not just this one. Yes, no. It's in general. The future is similar within this? This site. Yeah. So the MSP is specific to this site. Okay. Do you mind? Go ahead. Are we approving also the total number? Yes. Okay. All right. So another project that's designated as MSP comes in. They will have their own site plan, signage plan. And so what we're approving tonight is specific to this site. So when an application, like a permit, sign permit comes in, we base it off of the location. So we'll look if it requires just our regular 467 requirements or if there's an MSP for that site. So when a future sign permit will come for this, we'll look at this MSP that was approved with these standards of the three signs, the location, the minimum area, so-and-so. And that is what we'll base our review on for this site. So can we create a scenario? Because I understand the hardship on the client. They're taking over an existing, let's say, platform to work with. Do we have a process where we can grandfather something in and then make a decision about future MSP signage? Just let me also give you more information about this. The zoning district is a SED, special activity district. Usually with a SED like this, they can write their own code. So usually what do they do is they write their own sign regulations within the SED. Now specifically for this SED, they did not write it. So when we went to the sign code to see what they are allowed to do, there is no, in the sign code does not specifically mention SED as a zoning district with specific requirement. This is why, another reason, that they are establishing the master sign program from scratch. They do not have a master sign program. That's the first time you are establishing now. Now, another question, usually, usually the other zoning district, that's not general, but mostly they will have one sign per frontage, for example. But this one, because it's a master sign program, you are allowed, you can, it's within your preview, to approve two signs, freestanding signs. The one, the two are along Congress. So the code, if it's a GC, for example, I'm just giving an example, GC zoning district, you can have one pair frontage along the road. But the master sign program allows you to approve more. So even at the Aura, the one that they did, it could be subject to code enforcement. They have never had a master sign program established. You are establishing it for the first time, with whatever you approve. Right. So that's my concern, because I am questioning the necessity for two signs on that frontage. Do we know the distance between those two? Applicant, would you like to? I would also just like to mention, too, before they come up, that if there's any amendments to this, so if a new development comes in and they want to change the signs completely, do something different that don't meet these standards, they have to come back for an amendment. So it's not that this closes the door. If, in general, any applicant wants to do something different than what's approved here, they would have to come in for an amendment. Okay. I'm here to just add more information. The way it's designed, there's two ways to design an entrance sign. If you have a middle aisle, you can put one sign, but it's going to be double-sided, which is considered double the area. And it will probably answer your question. You usually see on the aisle, you see one sign with two signs facing the street, so people coming from north or people coming from south. The other way to do it is when you don't have a middle aisle, you put two signs on the side. So drivers here, they're looking at that sign. Driver for there, they're looking at that sign. It's kind of just the purpose of the type of sign. Okay. So I hope that answered a little bit. I understand you're going to say why it's two signs. It's because they're single-sided, and you have two options to put two or one in the middle. So the purpose is for drivers to see. They don't have to angle 90 degrees. They only go 45 degrees to take a turn to the property. That's the answer. Thank you for the clarification. And it helps to know that they're single-sided. I was thinking they're actually double-sided, which would consider me. When I start a presentation, I made a mistake. So I'm not crazy. Okay, great. Thank you. See, it is one, it's two singles and one double. See, we listened to you. Sorry for that. All right, great. I mean, just, my concern is the implications of it being so specific. Because we're establishing something brand new today that's going to last forever on this property unless it gets amended. We're establishing location, type of sign, dimensions, with no room for anybody else to possibly change without an amendment. That's my only concern. Like, it seems too restrictive. I'll just note, too, these are all maximums. So someone can do something less than this. So the maximum height, or I'm sorry, the maximum area is 70 square feet. Someone can come in and do 60 square feet. So they're still able to amend it. These are just your maximums that are allowed. So I can take it in that way of just what's the maximum to take on this type of project for this MSP. Okay. And I think I understand your question. And those are specific because they are actually tailored to the exact product that they want to prove. So they didn't, like, know what will happen in the future. So they didn't want to come and approve a higher one while they actually have some structure over there with this specific size. So it's specific because the scope of work is specific for them. Thoughts or comments? I'll entertain a motion. I'll go ahead. So let me just pull that up. Move approval of the Master Sign Program PZ-701-2026 for Mira Del Rey establishing standards to accommodate three monument entrance signs located on West Atlantic Avenue and Congress Avenue by finding that the request meets the criteria set forth in the land development regulations. I'll second. I'll second. I have a first and a second. Nicole, roll please. Abit Campin. Yes. Sandra Armani. Yes. Cynthia Lloyd. Yes. Nicholas Capola. Yes. Jose Alvarez. Yes. Annette Gray. No. Congratulations. Majority passes. Okay. That leads us to gender item 7C as in Charlie and let's see. Are you presenting this one? Yes. Okay. So good evening again board members. I'd like to present item 7C parks at the Ray level one site plan application PZ-000457-2026 and the applicant is here to present. Mr. Covelli, your name and address for the record please. Good evening. Mike Covelli, 1209 South Swinton Avenue. What you have before you is a level one site plan for the parks of Del Rey to add some gates within the community. The property is located south of Old Germantown Road and west of South Connors Avenue and this is a little bit of a narrative what it is. There's four main access points. There's going to be five gates because one of the areas is a roundabout and has two driveways that go off of it. There's one gate that's going to require some modification of landscaping, curbing, and I'll detail that for you. These gates will remain open from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., which is the peak hour so you don't have to worry about cars backing up because they can't get through the gate. And it's closed at night. These gates are basically what they call soft gates. They don't have a clicker. They don't have a keypad. They don't have an access code. When you pull up to the gate, it opens automatically. The purpose of these gates is to provide security. We've had some instances in the area where one involving a firearm, luckily no one was hurt. And the idea of the gates is that when people pull up to the gate, they have to slow down so that they can be videotaped, license plate readers, all those things, document people coming in and out of the property. It isn't for the purpose of keeping people out like some gated communities are. It's basically open to the public, but it creates a little bit of a sense of security in terms of people that shouldn't be there know that they are being monitored in terms of when they go in and go out. And so if something occurs, they can look at the records of that time frame and kind of figure out who was in and out. So that's really the purpose of the gates. They are located within the infrastructure part of the site plan, which is along the roadways. They meet the site visibility triangle items. We're not blocking off any pedestrian ways. And since they automatically open, you don't need a knocks box or a siren activation for security vehicles to enter. This is part of an SAD. This is the phasing plan that is part of that SAD. And the area in yellow was phase one that was the first thing built in the project, which is all of the infrastructures and roads. And that's the location where the gates are going to be. Phase two in green has already been completed. Phase three and four under construction. I think they're about to go for one of their first TCOs. There's a commercial building at the northeast corner of 70,000 square foot office space. And the other two parcels are somewhat in process for something at this point. This is really what the gates look like. We've chosen a model of gate that has a very slim design so that it's a very small foundation. It is not intrusive. We don't have to disrupt utilities, landscaping, irrigation, all those things to put these in the current position. And here's the locations. At the southeast corner of the site, there is an entrance off of Congress Avenue. This is a picture of the roadway. This is an older picture because most of the construction is actually done right now. But with the rain, I really didn't feel like going out and getting soaked with it to take a picture. So bear with me. But the square boxes show the approximate location of where those gates are going to be. This is off of Congress Avenue, which is under Palm Beach County jurisdiction. Palm Beach County requires any gates have to be 150 feet back from the street. These are 170 and 160-some feet, so we're well in compliance with that standard. So this meets all the standards in terms of these kinds of gates. The next entrance is off of Congress Avenue also, which is the main east-west corridor that goes back to the residential and services the sites to the north and south of the road. On the left, the image shows the location of the gates in relationship to the roadway in Congress Avenue. Again, we are in excess of the 150 feet. We're at 183 feet. And the picture shows the approximate location of where those gates will be. This section of road has been constructed with a previous plan in mind in terms of the driveway locations. You can see one on the left and back behind on the left. You can see another driveway locations. Whenever any site planning happens with those vacant parcels on the north or south of this, these gates may move. They might have to move back. They might have to go away. They might – we don't know. But for right now in the current situation, we want to maintain these gates as part of this program for monitoring people in and out. The next gate is at the – let me see if I can get the – there we go. It works. This gate requires two parking spaces to be removed, and I wanted to show it because right in this area, we're going to relocate those parking spaces, and I'll show you the detail here. This is where the gate is going to go, and you can see there's a black car on the right and a white car on the left. That's where the two parking spaces are going to be removed, and landscape nodes are going to be put in. Here it is in plan view, the two yellow spaces with the red squares are the spaces that will be relocated and turned into landscape nodes. A tree will be placed in the landscape node on the west side and on the east side, the bottom of the thing. That is going to be a tree that's relocated from the area where we're going to create the other spaces. This is the area south of there where the spaces are going to be created. The two trees on the left or the right remain, and the one tree that's kind of just a green circle is the one that will be relocated. So with this, we comply with the 100-foot setback, which is the city's requirement because old Germantown Road is a city street, and we're relocating parking so there's no loss of parking, but we're gaining one tree. So that would be that one. And then the final entrance is located at the west end on Old Germantown Road, and this shows you the location very similar to the other one with the exception of this is only 77 feet in primarily because this is a townhouse project, and we can't move those driveways like we did with the parking spaces. So with 77 feet, the code permits us to ask for reduction from the city engineer. We did that along with the queuing analysis. The city engineer approved the reduction from 100 feet to 77 feet, and Palm Beach County offered a no objection. This is an excerpt from the gate queuing, which basically says you need to have queuing for at least two vehicles or 50 feet. With 77 feet, we have more than enough. And again, to reiterate, during peak hour, the gates are open, so this isn't an issue. At 6 o'clock, the gate closes, and again, you pull up to it, and it opens. So there's really a very short period of time. So 50 feet is more than enough to not have any cars back out into the street. In terms of findings, this is a Level 1 site plan finding, and as per LDR Section 2.4.10, there are no findings required for a Level 1 site plan. So I've shown you that it complies with the standards that are applicable, and I'd appreciate it if you would approve this. Thank you. Thank you so much. Good evening again, board members. So this is Parks at Del Rey, 1690 to 2350 South, Congress Avenue, Level 1 site plan application. And the property size is approximately 48 acres. It's a special activity district with the land use of Congress Avenue mixed use, CMU. Adjacent zonings are RM, north and west. East is MROC, and south is RM. The existing uses multi-family residential developments with remaining parcels that I will come to it in a minute, subject to previously approved entitlement in the SAD. So the location of the gates, the applicant did a very good job, like he explained it well, so I won't repeat what was said. But this is an aerial view, and as you can see, like the north-west side corner of the site, along Congress, is already developed with an office building. And the development is happening, and the development is happening here, and the phase two is happening. And we currently have two applications. One went to the planning and zoning board. It's not relevant to, like, I mean, like your motion today or your decision today is not depending on any of the applications, but it's part of the context. One is rezoning to the entire SAD for some specific requirement. I think the staff report touched based on this, and the other one is we do have a site plan application pertaining to the two, C1 and C2, as I am pointing to the screen, two parcels here. We currently have an ongoing active site plan application for this, so this is why, like, you are seeing the gate now, the gates now, because it's also related to the overall development and what's happening. So the request is for five automatic gates, and I'm glad that the applicant made it very clear that the gates are not really a restriction. Like, it's just, like, as you pull towards the gate, the gate will open automatically, so it's not kind of, like, requires a pass or any sort of restriction. And this is the SAD. We have parcels C1 and C2 right now with us in current planning for a site plan for 108 townhouses are happening here. The gate will be, one of the gates will be here in the middle of that. So it's just kind of, like, happening concurrently with that. The background, this was rezoned in 2018, and SPRAP approved the Class 2 site plan modification 2019, 2020, Class 4, and 2022, SPRAP approved the Class 5 and the 2022 Class 4 site plan modification for more units to come. The gates are shown again here on the screen, and the two gates to the lower corner here. Those are two counts, and then one, and then one on each corner. And it's going to, like, the applicant mentioned the timing and no restriction. This is a level 1 site plan application. So per the code 2410, a level 1 site plan application is eligible for an administrative approval. Staff can go ahead and approve this. And also, for the code, so the director can elevate a level 1 site plan application to the board decision. And because it's associated with more development that is happening, and it's also associated with an existing development, it was elevated to your decision just to examine the entire situation and just make a decision about that. So a level 1 site plan application does not require findings in the code. So when the code says that, that means there is no concurrency requirement, as you can see in a residential development, like we have water, we have drainage. So there is no specific findings that we need to arrive at. It's just the request and the LDR requirement that are pertaining to the request. One of it is actually the stacking distance. So it needs to meet, all the gates need to meet stacking distance of 100, except for whenever Congress, the Congress Ave is a county road, so they require more, which is met. Along German town road, one of the gates are not meeting the 100, but also the code allows the city engineer to grant a waiver. So that's an administrative approval of a less dimension based on whatever justification provided by the applicant, documentation saying why it is required to be less. They did this, and the city engineer granted the approval for a less dimension, 77 fee. So it's not really in front of you today to decide on it, like less or more. The city engineer already granted this based on the information the applicant provided it to. Those are the gates. I'm not going to repeat it, but you can actually ask me to come back to it. The two gates along Congress, the one in the middle, and one along Germantown, and the other one on Long Germantown, which is, this is the one that has 77 fee, and the city engineer already granted. The operations, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., automatic open, no keys or access. Palm Beach County Traffic Division provided no objection. Fire, this went to the technical advisory committee, and fire building all the other agencies, internal partners, reviewed it and declared it, no comments, no pending comments. Associated with it, some parking relocation meets the parking requirement, and the landscape requirement are also met, no restrictions. So, consistency with the approved SAD, we looked at it in the context of the governing ordinances, number 3018-18, and as amended ordinance, 61-20. No changes to the street layout or connections or internal road networks, and no changes to existing development entitlements. The board consideration could be around, are the proposed gates compatible with the SAD ordinance, and with the gates provide a sense of disconnection between the development and the street networks, and here are the board motions for the city. And thank you. Thank you for that. I'll open and close public comments. I appreciate it. Are there any ex-parte communication that needs to be discussed? I'm just familiar with the property. Okay, great. Thank you. Who would like to lead off the discussion? Okay. So, I guess my main concern here is it's hard for me to, like, I understand the distances, stacking, it's all technical information. I understand all of that. It's just we're affecting another development that hasn't been developed yet. So, it's hard to know the implications of this onto that, I guess, without that information. I mean, just to clarify, I think you're talking about parcels C1 and C2 within the same SAD, correct? Yes, exactly. And under the same ownership. Okay. So, you know, and I think if we're going to talk about that, it's fair to bring the board up to what the latest motions were on that, if you would. PZB, you mean? So, although it's not relevant to your decision, but, like, part of the background, if, like, two days ago on Monday, like, the 13th floor, the owner, like, the developer of the entire development proposed a rezoning. And I think the rezoning was recommended for denial to the city commission. So, this is going to city commission in December, and they recommended denial. That is irrelevant to this, but it's part of the background. We do have, again, like, a site plan for the parcels, the two parcels, that are coming to, going to a board perhaps next month. We're still intact, like, the Technical Advisory Committee reviews. So, my question is, could we approve the other ones and this one leave as amended depending on that decision? Would that be an option because we don't know how this is going to affect that development? In other words, if we approve this now and then they come back and now this location is going to hinder something, now they have to come back in front of SPRAB again and modify that? That's true. And you are – actually, the board can approve – can make an amendment to the approvals. That's your approval as amended, for example, except for or as amended to. That's within your review. Hold on. Let him finish. Are those all your questions? Yeah, I guess – yeah, that's fine for now. Are they rushed? You're okay? Yeah, it's okay. I'm fine. That's my main item. Actually, I just want to tag on to it just to make sure I understand. So, we're talking about the one that's 77, correct? Yeah, the one in the middle. Yeah. Just that one. Yeah. So, you're – Because there's an empty – those two blank areas, there's nothing there, but there's going to be something there. It's been recommended for denial, apparently, for rezoning. But that already meets the criteria, right? Yeah. It does, but we are – it does, but we're approving an internal – like it says here, like some sort of circulation pattern that may happen or may not happen. It's just – it's hard to approve something that may not happen without seeing what's there, right? There's nothing there. But the issue is, if we approve this and now it has to be modified, we now have to do an amendment to what we approved, or we can just leave that off and they can come back in the future with that one thing with the other project. I guess my – I'm sorry. I just want to finish why I was asking the question. Because my concern is, is that if it's a security issue, that is off Congress. So, even now, I would imagine if they've had issues. So, I just wanted – just throwing that out there, but please go ahead. If they wanted to remove the gates, they don't need to come back to the board, right? They can just remove them. Yeah. They don't – Oh, okay. Yeah. If I may, these are private roads. The standards we have to meet are where the gate is minimum, which – but it also has a requirement that Palm Beach County is going to weigh in on where your first driveway is. Most likely, it's going to be behind the gates because it's farther than that 150 feet. So, you know, in – and I don't know – I haven't seen the site plan because I'm not working on that. But I – early, early on, I saw a plan that had the driveways on the very west end of that road into that. But that's irrelevant at this point, so let's not get into that. Yeah. Let me just chime in. But remember, this is a level one site plan. It should have been an administrative approval. So, in terms of modifying the gates, that should be an administrative approval once we're past this board. So, that's part of my question, so thank you, Mr. Carvel. Yes. Do you have any questions? I was actually going to ask that, so. So, to be clear, they can – if this was approved today, he had stated in the future, they may move the gates if needed, but they would come in front of the board or they could just – as long as they're within their property. It could be either way, like any – okay, in general, level one site plan application, in general, is eligible for an administrative approval. And any site plan, level one site plan application, also could be elevated to the board. Depending on the request, if staff are comfortable, like, just with your direction, approve it, they will just proceed. So, it can actually proceed administrative, that's true. And it can also come back to you, depending on the type of the request and the level. We have elevated level one site plan applications many times to the board, and we have made administrative decisions also regarding different ones. So, it depends on the request. So, I'd like to pose a question a different way. I respect your expertise, your decision-making. What was it about this that made you elevate it to the board and abdicate the administrative process? I want to understand what you understand. So, I think what specifically about this is the SED entirely is right now at the city arena for rezoning. There are lots of, like, the request of the rezoning also to amend the SED is also related to the two parcels that are vacant, narrowing down roads and stuff like that. But part of this also about the SED approved the development without gates. So, we already approved this, and it's written. So, nothing in the SED is mentioning gates, yes or no. So, the SED is silent when it comes to gates. But we already, like, the city approved it like that. Now, we are adding gates. So, it is fair that the board weigh in and decide that it is good or bad, or actually will it hinder anything or add restrictions to the traffic. I think the applicant also explained more about, you know, like, doesn't require access and so on and so. But it is related to the overall development and how is it approved and what is currently happening with the city. Additional information also. So, if staff approve the level one site plan application, it does not go to the appealable report of the city commission. But if the board approve a level one site application, it goes to the appealable report of the city commission. So, also, the city commission can weigh on your decision whether you approve it, approve as amended, or denied. So, that's also additional to that. That helps. Did you have a question or a comment? I mean, you know, part of me thinks that, you know, whether it affects the other two parcels or not, you know, it's the same ownership. So, that kind of, to me, is, you know, if it hinders their traffic, they're kind of hindering themselves in the future and they'll just have to deal with it then. Right? So, that part of me is kind of, you know, by the time that those two parcels get developed, we're probably looking at another, you know, at least two years, right? You know, two, three years. So, I would opt on giving the current residents the ability to have added security, you know, whether it be even just, you know, for the time being until the rest is resolved. And I'm sure at that time, you know, 13th floor, they're a smart developer. You know, I've seen the work that they do. But I'm sure at that time, they would assess the location of the gates, if it's going to be an issue or not. So, I guess long term, I don't, you know, I don't see an issue, given that if it's a hindrance, they would only be hindering themselves. So, you know, I guess that's where I go. I concur in terms of the hardship that's being self-imposed. I think it might be a little bit premature, but I can understand why, because there are two existing developments that is almost completed, right? And so, if they have to circle back three years from now and address it, they would have provided some sense of security for the existing parts, depending on how long the other two takes. That's not my primary concern. My primary concern is that everybody, including the engineer, has looked at this from a technical standpoint. That area in the mornings, school traffic and everything, already is congested. I have a concern about the 77 feet, that is my primary concern, and the two-car allowance. So, it's 50, gives another 25. I am not altogether comfortable with that exception, and that's where my concern lies. The internal circular, proposed hardship, same owner, timing, put it in now, go back, rip it out later, you know. The other component is that everybody is taking for granted that there will be no issues with the 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. just being open. Being done for security reasons, security issues are happening day and night, and this is designed to tort security to slow down and identify coming and goings. The 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. doesn't really make a whole lot of sense to me. It doesn't have to, but the 77-foot exception does give me a pause. Would you like to address that? Sure. I'll address it. And where I am, I think it meets all the requirements. I mean, Congress, you meet the requirements of the county. The fact that you're letting traffic go in and out, it's just monitoring. So, there's not going to be, correct me if I'm wrong, there's not going to be that delay where folks are calling and saying, hey, you can get in. So, to your point, it's slowing down in order to monitor the plates. Where I find, I was originally forced, but when I found out that they actually own those two lots, we're not inconveniencing anybody. To your point, that's why with the traffic slowing, I don't think it's going to slow that much because there's no restriction at the gate. The gate is going to slow folks as they come in and just go up. That's why I asked, there's no calls or anything for the gate to go up. So, I'm okay with it. Yes. Do you know, just because it might help the conversation, do you know how long it takes for someone to drive up the gate to open? And it might be in here, and I'm sorry, but it's just for ease. The gate goes up. Oh, and one question to go with that. What's your backup if there's a technical failure? Oh, the gates can manually be open. So, there's management on site at all times, so there's no issue with it in here. I just think it's an important question because some places have gates, and it's a challenge. Give me, we'll get there. Oops. This is from the traffic study where they did the service rate, and they're saying that the gates, as it is, the way it is, can handle 190 vehicles an hour. So, when they look at the number of volume coming in and out, they're saying it's 70 vehicles per hour. So, you know, that's a little over, or that's a little less than one minute a vehicle. It doesn't take that long for the gate to open. It's about a 10-second cycle where, as you pull up, the gate opens. You go through. The gate closes. It's very quick. So, these are, like, I guess worst case, but the way it cycles, it should be very quick. And part of the peak hour gates being open was a comment from Palm Beach County in terms of the concerns of Congress Avenue because of the traffic situation on Congress Avenue. So, it was an assurance that we wouldn't add to any traffic situations over than what's currently there by having those gates closed, even though the cycle is very fast. But, again, when you go through even open gates, you instinctively slow down a little bit. And so, the goal is to slow traffic down for recording of that vehicle. So, it's kind of a balancing act between all the different agencies in terms of, you know, they want to ensure your same concerns. They want to ensure that there's not an issue with traffic backing onto the street. And so, that's where the 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. gates open came. And since it is a matter of just trying to slow vehicles down, it will serve the purpose whether the gates are up or down. So, that's the way they're trying to do that. One more question. If, for some reason in the future, because the wording here says gate arms, let's say they want to do swinging gates. No, they can't. Would you ever have to come back? Okay. They have to be arms that open perfectly straight because of fire vehicles and emergency vehicles. They have to be able to quickly go up so they can clear with nothing impeding the area. We had a lot of conversation about that. So, this is the only option that will open? Yes. Okay. Just making sure. Thanks for asking that. I was wondering if in the future there is a possibility for them to convert to something more stringent in security. Someone even brought up the fact that there's some gates that are hinged in the middle, and when they open, part of it hangs out. And we can't even do that. So, this is the option. Okay. Got it. Okay. Those are my questions, thoughts, and comments. Are there any additional before we move to a vote? Madam Chair, I'd like to make a motion. Yes, I'll entertain. Okay. Move approval of the level Site 1 Plan PZ000457-2026 for the installation of five automatic vehicular gate arms at four access areas within parks at Del Rey, including associated site improvements, by finding that the request meets the criteria set forth in the land development regulations and the approved SAD. Second. I have a first and a second. Can you call a roll, please? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you very much. You're welcome. Have a great night. Stay dry on the way home. All right. Agenda item eight, reports and comments, staff. No reports or comments, just remind us that the December meeting is the second Wednesday. So far, we don't have December 9th. So far, we don't have anything scheduled, around the beginning of the month, but you will be notified that like normally where the same time that we post the agenda, like a week ahead. So we know like December 2nd, that there will be a meeting or no January meeting, business as usual, 4th Wednesday, January 27th, 2027. Wow. And February 24th, 2027. That's also the 4th Wednesday, which is business as usual. And thank you, board attorney. Thank you. Thank you. Madam attorney. I don't have any comments. Good. Board members. Good. I actually had one question. I'm sorry. So the meeting is not going to be on the 18th because December. It's usually earlier in December. I know. Yeah. No. It's usually the 4th Wednesday. Right. So it went back two weeks. That's why I'm asking. Yes. And if you remember, like every year, like around September, we hand the board, like the entire year schedule. And we also fill it in in the city, like board calendars. So you can also check it online. No, no, no. I understand that. So this one is going to be December 9th. Right. That I know. I was asking why it was pushed back two weeks. Because of, like the holidays. My question is, let me clarify it. Is there something else on the 18th? That's what I was asking. Well, usually there is, like, I don't really know there is a city commission, like around 14, and there is a planning and zoning board. But this specific Wednesday, you know, I think towards the 18th, lots of city staff and, you know, applicants and also, like, officials, they would like to take an extended holiday. And you guys all know why I was asking. Because I've missed one meeting, and I take this very seriously. And I am leaving that day, the 9th. Because it's so early. How dare you? I know. But I have a grandchild. And I take her as seriously as I take you. No, but so that's why I was asking the question. Because if there was a desire to try to see if anyone could, you know, if we did have anything. I mean, you know, sometimes meetings are canceled. So I was more concerned. I was just trying to be diligent about attendance. So please know that that was all. Not to be selfish, but just because I take it seriously. I understand. But traditionally, don't we have two dates on hold? Well, traditionally, like, I think, like, before my time, even, like, the board used to meet twice a month. Right. Two times. I remember that. Maybe. So moving it or changing dates is. That's okay. I was just, that's all. Okay. Thank you so much for allowing me that grade. No worries. I would like to echo something that was mentioned by one of my fellow board members, which is, and you do a very good job when it's a new project coming in and showing pictures of the surrounding and other properties. I think tonight would have been a great example of seeing the previous sign for ourselves to help with the visual. We're not. No, Lance. They are good. But it does help. It was a very helpful point. So if you can, if it is all possible. We took, we already noted this without the board mentioning it, so we noted. Just so you know, it's appreciated by us. Yeah. Thank you. Any additional comments? All right. Happy Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving. Meeting adjourned. Thank you. Have a great holiday. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.