Parsed verbatim from the transcript below — timestamps jump to the moment of the vote.
Tom Markert: present · Judy Mollica: present · Juli Casale: present · Angela Burns: present · Thomas F. Carney, Jr.: present
Would you like me to make a motion? Motion to deny resolution number 153-26. Second.
Deputy Vice Mayor Margaret: yes · Judy Mollica: yes · Juli Casale: yes · Vice Mayor Barnes: yes · Mayor Kearney: yes
Outcome: Motion to pass.
Do you want me to throw out a motion? Can we have a motion? Second.
Judy Mollica: yes · Juli Casale: yes · Angela Burns: yes · Thomas F. Carney, Jr.: yes · Tom Markert: yes
Outcome: Motion passed.
And then there's a second. Motion to approve ordinance number 45-26. Second.
Thomas F. Carney, Jr.: yes · Tom Markert: yes · Judy Mollica: yes · Juli Casale: yes · Angela Burns: yes
Outcome: Motion passes.
Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. We're calling this meeting to order. Welcome to the regular City Commission meeting of the City of Delray Beach this Tuesday, November 17th. If the clerk could please call the roll.
Deputy Vice Mayor Markert. Here. Commissioner Mollica. Here. Commissioner Cazal. Here. Vice Mayor Burns. Here. Mayor Carney.
Here.
We have a quorum.
Thank you very much. If you could all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. to the flag of the States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for our world. Thank you all. This is the agenda approval. Are there any items to amend, modify, pull? None? Okay. None for me. Okay. Then I need a motion to approve the agenda.
So moved. Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Unanimous. Presentations. Presenting Curtis Wise with an Exemplary Employee Performance Award. And here comes Mr. Metat.
Good evening, Mayor and Commissioners. Sam Metat, Director of Parks and Recreation. And this is Mr. Curtis Wise. It's an honor for me to present Mr. Wise with the Exemplary Employee Award tonight. We heard great things about the work that Mr. Wise does over at the cemetery for Mrs. Burns a couple meetings ago. And I would just like to double down on that a little bit here. Curtis began his career in the city in 2001 as a general maintenance worker. And he advanced to equipment operator in 2016 and was promoted again in 2024 to the cemetery crew leader. Over the years, Curtis has developed an incredible knowledge of our cemetery. He knows the grounds like the back of his hand and is responsible for ensuring that the burial plots are properly prepared and ready for burial. He plays an important role in keeping the cemetery maintained and ensuring that everything is handled with care and respect. Working in a cemetery requires more than physical labor and knowledge of the job. It requires compassion, patience, and an understanding for what families are going through during some of the most difficult times and moments of their lives. Curtis understands this. He treats grieving families with kindness, compassion, and respect. He's a hard worker, a great person to work with, and someone who takes pride in his responsibilities. His 25 years of service reflect his loyalty to the city and his commitment to our community. We appreciate your dedication, Mr. Wise, your dedication, compassion, and the pride you take every day in serving our city. Thank you so very much. Would you like us to come over to the middle? Would you like the picture in the middle? Come on down. Curtis, if you'd like your family to join you, they're more than welcome.
Oh, I've got one thing.
I know the answer, but you're welcome to address the commission if you'd like.
I just like to say I thank everyone for this award. I really do appreciate it.
I like doing that.
It's one of my favorite parts. Recognize somebody who's done something so special for the city. There's no other presentations since now comments and inquiries on agenda and non-agenda items from the public.
Actually, I have one item, Mr. Mayor, before that.
Before the comments and the things?
Yes, as always.
Okay, so it's 4B. Go ahead.
No, no. 5A.
Oh, no, I wasn't moving on from it. I was going to let him talk.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I actually have one item, and it's an effort to provide clarification with respect to questions regarding a private St. Patrick's Day event and the fact that an application actually has been submitted to the city of Derry Beach going back to last week. Nothing prior to that, but actually just last week. And it's interesting because, of course, there's been a number of questions and concerns regarding the prospect of this having been initiated quite some time ago. Not the case. It was actually just one week ago in which an application was formally submitted, and it was done so by the organization Derry Beach Arts Incorporated, which is a 501c6 organization. And interestingly enough, they are the same organization that sponsors and administers the Garlic Festival, recently having come back to the city of Derry Beach, Florida in this regard. However, it's important to underscore that this is a very preliminary step for our respective consideration. Given the formal submission of the application just about a week ago, it still must engage the Special Event Technical Advisory Committee vetting and review process, followed by that of the Development Services Management Group process. Once that's all achieved and the tail is squared away and finalized, it would then be brought before a city commission. This will take us the coming weeks to get to that place. Any outcomes in this regard favorable for review and consideration to come before the city commission will take place in January. So the interest is to advise the city commission in terms of why we are where we are, and this is a 100% private matter for the reasons haven't been communicated quite extensively and well. I've had an opportunity to speak to a few of you all. Actually, since beginning last week while I was actually away, followed by my return this past weekend after being gone a few days, and I thought it was appropriate that we provide this background and clarity because upon my arrival this past weekend, I was able to get my arms around this actual submission, which was, again, just a week ago. So for that reason, I'll offer that background and clarity, and again, 100% private for the reasons noted. Thank you very much.
If I may, I think Mr. Moore is offering clarity because I got so many calls on the parade being canceled. It was an – the Internet was ablaze, and it was never canceled. I mean, and the thing that we're all missing here is commenting and commending Laura Simon, who started working on this in May when we knew there was a question about whether or not we could fund this. She's been working on this since May. It's even in your information letter over a week ago, November 6th information letter, you're talking about how she's working on it. Police and fire. Right. But then you basically answer a phone call from a reporter and say the parade is canceled, which is not actually what happened. The problem is we were transferring funding and hoping someone else would take over the parade. And it just wreaked havoc on our city at a time where we have so much going on with considerations on Amendment 3 and other important things to have people saying we're canceling the parade when we're actually not and losing faith in our city is unfortunate. And it's in your information letter. She's been talking about it since May. I've been talking about it, whether or not there are constraints on funding through police and fire. So, and I got calls from national news media outlets. The mayor, you know, was trying to save the parade while it was actually saved. It's just, it was like three days of running in circles unnecessarily.
Mr. Mayor, if I may please. Please. Thank you. Let's get on with the agenda. Of course. Just to clarify, the city of Delray Beach is not at liberty to proceed with any parade of any kind in this fashion. It's not. So, again, it's 100% private. That's the basis of the clarity. The purpose of my information letter report was to offer context regarding police and fire resources availability. And those are the details that would have to be facilitated. This is not a city of Delray Beach endeavor. This is not a city of Delray Beach event. And that's appropriate in that regard because a number of outside interests express the ability to join us for 2027 in this regard. And clarity was offered that the city of Delray Beach is not having an event at all. Likewise, I welcome the opportunity to engage privately. But it is a 100% private event. It is not a city of Delray Beach event. Just to follow up, to provide additional background and clarity, there is no city of Delray Beach event in this regard. And that is the case legally. And I think everybody understands that. However, this is very preliminary in terms of the review process I just outlined regarding the application and proposal having just been submitted. So, any level of interest going above and beyond the city of Delray Beach underscores the context of the subject matter in and of itself. Nevertheless, there is no city of Delray Beach activity at this juncture. Nor is there a specific event yet planned because this is very preliminary and the actual vetting process for the reasons I've outlined involving CTEC and DSMG must continue in the coming weeks before a final consideration can be made available. Like you all approve any other special events sponsored by private interest, that would be the case in this juncture. And that is all that the city of Delray Beach can make available. Just to be clear. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.
All right. We are now on to public comment. This is the portion of the agenda where the members of the public are welcome to speak to the commission on any agenda item or non-agenda item. Except if it's going to be a quasi-judicial or public hearing, which you'll be separately called. For public comment, please make sure you've signed in. You'll state your name and zip code for the record, and you will each have three minutes to address the commission. This is not a question-and-answer opportunity, and members of the commission will not be responding to inquiries from speakers. Speakers must address the commission as a whole, not any individual. Insults, personal attacks, and disruptions will not be permitted, and you will be asked to leave if you violate these rules. So please come up to the lectern, state your name and zip code for the record, and you will each have three minutes.
Good evening. My name is Chris McGatt, 33483. I, as you know from earlier, I represent Delray Knightley Vacation Rentals. I wanted just to, first of all, thank each one of you for your time today, for the workshop today, the opportunity to be able to have conversation, learn more about what's going on. We really appreciate that. Also, I want to thank you for moving forward with the BTR. In some fashion, it sounds like that's possibly going to be moving forward. I think it's a great step. But allow me to play this out so that we can get clarity around what the unintended consequences might look like as we move forward. First of all, we'll be the first ones in line to fill out that paperwork and properly do what we need to do to properly register in the environment. Once we do that, and understand that AirDNA, which is probably one of the best sources for information on short-term rentals in America, also including Delray Beach, by going through that this morning, it looks to me like there's about 96% or 97% of all of the short-term rentals that are in Delray Beach are in zoned R1, R1A zoning. So we all need to be aware of that. So once I register, give you all my information, then, Lynn, I think your role will need to be to go then enforce the six-day turnover. That's the city ordinance. And at that point, we will need to leave the market. We can't – I can't – I worked hard the past two weeks to look at an economic model that would allow us to operate a business with six turns a year. And I can't figure one out. Maybe someone smarter than I can do that, but I can't figure it out. So we leave the marketplace. And then the question has to be asked, what is left? What happens with that space? How does it work? So I just want you to be thinking about this long-term as it goes through. I want to commend the six people that were courageous enough to stand up and say, I've got a problem. I have parties at my house. I have nakedness, like crazy stories, and I believe every one of them. But it makes me really sad because that's not one of our properties, and I don't think it's many of the properties. I think it's isolated. So my ask to you would be, I don't think you have a turnover problem. I think what you have is an enforcement problem of the rules you already have. You have noise ordinances. You have disturbance ordinances. You have all that in place. We just need to enforce it. And as a short-term rental operator, I need to be there at 11 o'clock at night when you or the police or your court enforcements call me and say, Chris, we've got a problem at one of the houses. I will get in my car. I will drive over. I will solve it. Fortunately, in three years and 400 rentals a year, we've never had that problem before, and I hope we never do. But there's a reason for that. We're very, very aware of who's running our houses, what's going on in the houses. So just know there's a different way of doing this, and I think if we can all work together, we can figure this out, and we can figure out a way to keep Delray Beach special and unique, bringing the right kinds of people into town. Thank you for your time.
Thank you very much.
Did you leave this here?
Mr. McGott?
I think it's mine, but it's lovely.
Oh, that's been there all evening?
Is it chocolate or something? I lost a pound. Can you eat it? Lost a pound.
Can you eat it? Mayor's recipe. I'll figure it out. Ready? Yes, Mr. Rose. Okay.
Daniel Rose, 33444. Now that Amendment 3 passed, I watched the last commission meeting, and I was horrified to hear about the amount of outstanding accruing fines or code enforcement. So it's both residential and commercial. So I did some research and some digging, and the problem is, unlike other municipalities, unfortunately we right now don't have an ordinance or mechanism other than to foreclose to get enforcement and get these fines paid and encourage compliance. So I did some homework, and there's a solution that other municipalities have enacted. In fact, Fort Lauderdale just did effective October 1st. If you're not in compliance with code and or have large fines accruing, you don't get a certificate of use or a landlord permit or BTR or whatever name you use for those functions. So, in other words, you have a landlord or a business owner who continues to operate a building in noncompliance with code enforcement. Their certificate of use is suspended until they get into compliance, which would be either making the property compliant and paying those fines. And, of course, getting, you know, a majority of the time there's fine forgiveness or, you know, you can go once you're in compliance, usually a special magistrate will allow you to reduce your fines. So it's not a witch hunt. So, example, a commercial landlord, let's say, has no roof and has $50,000 in fines, and there's still blue tarp everywhere on Atlantic Avenue somewhere. The certificate of use can be suspended until he gets into compliance. What do you have to do? Fix his roof, get into compliance, and he can negotiate his liens like they usually do, and he can be back in business. So we can collect some of that $8 million or whatever the number was. So this will eliminate the bad actors. You know, some operators are like, hey, I only have a $250-a-day fine, but I've got eight people living in a house, so I'll pay it. It eliminates loopholes. So you have to go to Florida Statute 162, Section 162, that authorizes us to enact such a legislation or ordinance in this town. Just so, as I said, the city of Fort Lauderdale just implemented the same plan effective October 1st. So everyone in Fort Lauderdale is now getting their properties in compliance and negotiating and paying fines. So that's a piece of lost revenue that's not accruing. It's being collected. Miami-Dade's had one for years, and that surprised me. It's Section 2.207 in their code that allows them to do the same thing. The city of Weston explicitly has an outline of rules under their Ordinance 16468, which allows them to revoke or suspend a certificate if a holder refuses code enforcement inspection access and lies about things to get application. Like, I'm only opening up a bar, but it turns out to be a 24-hour speakeasy. So if one who looks like every municipality except for us has one, so now would be the time while we're looking at getting revenues and people into compliance. It's a win-win for tenants, commercial and residential, because you have landlords that don't care. They're going to let those fines add up. They're never selling the property. They don't need to refinance it. They'll just continue renting. There's protection there for tenants and the rules. So I'm encouraging you to really have an honest discussion about this, and it would allow us to bring some of these rogue landlords into compliance by allowing them to fix their properties. We're not looking to foreclose at that point. We're just looking to collect and be in compliance. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Welcome back.
Happy to be here. Alexandra Zetlawi, 33445. I'm here really to talk about the overdevelopment that is happening in Delray Beach. When I drive down these streets, when I walk down the sidewalk, all I see is land for lease, luxury condos coming soon, and I see acres of land being decimated. I see wildlife being killed. I see trees being ripped out from their roots, and it feels like we've all been sold out to developers, and the message feels clear that I am not welcomed here, that people who've lived here for decades, businesses that have helped shape the city have shut down because of private equity money, and that those of us on the west side of 95 are not wanted by the priorities of the developers. It feels as though you see dollar signs when you look at the constituents that have voted you in, and I wonder if any of you have looked at us as people who deserve an affordable city with climate-based science baked into its leadership. It's frustrating that we haven't seen more people first governing when I know that it can be done, and I have seen it happen through other states and other cities, and I know that the people on this administration care about their constituents as well, and I would like to see that have a further reach than it does right now. I will say it is ironic that this council is the same one who would have a leave the world better than you found it message when we had the meeting earlier, when it feels like we are not leaving the world in a better place. Believe it or not, I do love this city. I got married here. I want to have children here. I want to have a family here, but it feels like I won't really be able to do that for so many reasons. For so many reasons, I fell in love with this city. As a final point, I received a newsletter for both the Delray Gazette and the Delray Gazette. I don't really know how I got subscribed to either, and it feels as though the Delray Gazette is constantly attacking Commissioner Casal, and I find that, quite frankly, to be dangerous. It creates a lot of AI garbage of her and single-handedly blames her for issues that the newsletter disagrees with, and I hope that the city and her peers would support her in doing what they can to stop this, or at least putting out a message. It does not feel like a unifying city whenever I get this newsletter I didn't even subscribe for. Thank you so much.
Thank you very much.
Good evening. Dan Edwards, Delray resident. I'm just here to speak on behalf of Item 7C, which is the Marine Way District, Seawall Roadway Utility and Drainage Improvements. I hope, obviously, for a positive outcome on that this evening. I met with our neighbors, Jeannie to the north, AJ, and Adam to the south, and obviously, we all know about the flooding. Subject to approval, I would like to be able to discuss the timeline, and three neighbors to the south are also wondering the same thing as far as when we start with remodels of our homes, and obviously, I think the first key would be to have the seawall done. And then, along with that, if they're bidding out anything, half a dozen projects that I'm doing from Hillsboro Mile to Highland Beach to Boca and Delray, I use Alpha Marine. They're two former Navy divers. They're Army Corps of Engineers approved, and I don't know, along with that process, if they're going to be bidding those things out, but I could be involved in that process if they wanted to be or not be involved. That's it. Thank you guys so much.
Thank you very much.
Mr. Mayor, Commissioners, my name is Gary Leopolis. Address is 1021 Northwest Fifth Avenue. First, I want to say, Mr. Mayor, thank you. I got my birthday card. It was very sweet of you. You guys still have time. It's still this month. Anyways, I am here for— You're so young, I didn't need many stamps. I'm here also for 7C, which is the contract you guys are going to be looking at tonight, and I am hoping that you're going to support it, too. So we do a lot of work in our historic Marina District. This is on the National Register, and I've always said that I kind of complain that it takes so much to get a project approved, and yet we have so many issues with the flooding. I like saying this because our city attorney is here. Here's Exhibit A. I only have one exhibit. Anyways, for the record, yes. This is 160 Marine Way. This is my client's property. It's important because what happens is we sent these photos right in front of her house. This was on April 23rd, okay? There was no full moon. There was no king tide, okay? She can't even get into her yard and stuff. Now, what the city has done right now is across the street there is a three-quarter horse-powered pump that's in a five-gallon Home Depot bucket that's trying to pump this out. On that day, the actual tide and the intercoaster was very low, and yet you'll still see there's all water in front of her house. My point is I know when it comes to king tides, full moon, all that kind of stuff, all bets are off, but I encourage you, please look at this. We've got several projects now. We're looking at lifting houses in the Marina District. So they're doing their part. I'm hoping now the city can return the favor and do theirs. Last time we renovated anything down there, I believe, was in 2002. So I'm hoping you guys will give that strong consideration and approve it tonight. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, sir.
Good evening. Apologize. I only have six copies.
Did you give a name and zip code?
Pamela Williams, 33444. Tonight, I would like to say, you know, with the passage of the Homestead Exemption Amendment, we can anticipate that certain services and or activities may need to be reduced or discontinued. As a resident, we depend on our city commission and city staff to work together, exercise good judgment, and continue to be responsible stewards of our tax dollars. With that in mind, I would like to bring an important matter to the city commission's attention involving administrative oversight within the sanitation division. Under the supervision of the sanitation administrator, the city was required to reimburse the CRA approximately $249,737. Please refer to my cover page. The CRA and the city share the responsibility for the annual salaries of two litter prevention employees. The understanding is that these employees are assigned to work services specifically in the northwest-southwest neighborhoods. However, upon my research, it appears that for several years, these two employees completed work performed outside of the northwest-southwest neighborhoods. These documents were subsequently reviewed and approved by the sanitation administrator before being submitted to the CRA for payment of their portion. I encourage you to take a look at the financial breakdown included in my report. The figures reflect a reimbursement in the amount of $62,000 for fiscal year 22, a reimbursement needed in the amount of $66,000 for fiscal year 23. $70,000 had to be reimbursed to the CRA for fiscal year 24. And thank goodness someone caught it, not city staff, to where we only had a reimbursement of $7,000. Now, I bring this before the commission, not simply to point out a problem, but to encourage greater attention to fiduciary responsibility and accountability throughout our city government. Making sure employees' reports, timesheets, and invoices are carefully reviewed before approval is just as important as the actual work being done in the field. At the end of the day, I believe we all want the same thing, a city that operates efficiently, responsibly, and with the best interest of the resident's money. After all, these are our tax dollars, and we all have responsibility to make sure they are being properly managed. Thank you for your time and efforts, and please do take a look at the report.
Thank you very much.
Good evening, Mayor, Commissioners Yvonne Odom, 33445. I'm here to compliment some city staff because I received the water bill that was doubled last month, and I was like, wait a minute, how can this happen because I'm on draft, you know, bank draft. So I immediately called my friend in the water department, Terrence, and I said, Terrence, what's going on? So he explained to me about the new system you had, and I'm in zone three. And the reason I'm bringing this up, because if somebody else is like me and not aware of that, so he explained that we went to a new system, and I'm in zone three. Even though it's a double bill, they have to bill me before they can charge me. So he's like, you know, there's a whole lot of people ahead of me. So I said, I'm going to call the city manager because I think this should be explained. And sure enough, I did, and I want to public apologize. I did not know you were on vacation, but he returned my call, and I was shocked when he told me he was there. But he also explained, and he must be there. You know you're going to pass the buck. He told the head of the department, Hussein, he called to explain how this happened. And then Jackie called, and so my point was because I just encouraged him. I'm a proactive person. I like to be proactive. And if I was shocked that I had a double bill, I'm sure somebody else was. And they explained it to me about the billing without fussing. And, of course, I reminded them. I said, now, you know this election year, you're going to get a bunch of calls fussing and everything. So explain to the people how this has happened so you don't get all the wrath for somebody who actually don't sign and try to get clarity. So I want to publicly thank you and Hussein and Jackie and Terrence who took the time to let me know that I wasn't going crazy, that my water bill really was not double, even though it said it on the piece of paper that I had to pay double. So thank you very much for your due diligence and getting back to me.
Thank you very much.
Good evening, everybody. My name is Marcelo Rosano. I'm here for the Ordinance 4126. And I want to personally thank you, everybody, for... Your zip code, please, for the record. Oh, I'm sorry, 33444. I want to thank you, everybody, for listening to us in previous meetings and giving us a chance to work for the city. I'm the owner of Rosano's Pizzas, and I also want to be the voice for all the food trucks owners. We thank you, and we want to see what else we can bring to this community. So thank you so much for listening to us and giving us a fair chance to keep working. Thank you. Thank you very much, sir.
Good evening, everyone. Laura Simon, the DDA 33483. A couple of things I just wanted to... First, I wanted to just bring up... We had a meeting, I guess, back in August with the commission and our downtown businesses to listen to a few issues that they're facing. And one is pedestrian signage. And our downtown is a very pedestrian, walkable downtown, and our retailers and our businesses have been using sandwich board signs or A-frame signs or pedestal signs that are currently restricted in our code. But these are transactional and beneficial to their business. And I recently had a great meeting with city staff, Amy and Anthea, and discussed it and would like to work on bringing a pilot program forward that is only for the downtown. And it could be jointly coordinated with the DDA and the city, which would allow for attractive A-frame and small upright signage that would be in selected areas, creating a sidewalk that would be free of clearance, but would really work and add to the ambiance and the character of our downtown. We have other cities in the state that we're working with or looking into. So I wanted to share something, but I wanted to bring that forward because I'd love to have that supported. And also just wanted to support also the, on 9B, the, is that a, it's a first reading, but should I wait till then? Or is the West Atlantic parking? So our board did support that to continue and extend that for a longer term. And also just as we look at 7D on the Old School Square, the plan would love to suggest that we as, you as an organization and our board, the DDA, get together for a workshop, discuss that. As we said we would back in January when we met to come forward with the feasibility study to then talk next steps. So, but those are my suggestions and I just appreciate your time. Thank you. And happy Thanksgiving.
Thank you very much. Are there any other members of the public wishing to address the commission? Seeing none, public comment is closed. We now have the consent, we need the motion to approve the consent agenda.
Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Consent agenda is approved. We now are going on to item 7A of the regular agenda, which is a resolution 166-26, if the city attorney would kindly read the resolution to the record.
A resolution of the city commissioner of the city of Delray Beach, Florida, amending its budget for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2026, by providing for supplemental appropriations in the amounts identified in Exhibit A, repealing all resolutions and consistent herewith, providing an effective date and for other purposes.
Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Ms. Alamov.
Good evening. Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, Commissioner, City Manager, City Attorney, and City Clerk. Before you is resolution 160-26, proposing amendments to the fiscal year 2026-27 adopted budget. This amendment includes two main adjustments. The first recognizes approximately, sorry, got the wrong one, I have to restart. Before you is resolution 166-26, proposing amendments to the fiscal year 2026-27 adopted budget. It consists of two adjustments within the neighborhood services fund, totaling $377,027.98. The first adjustment is $160,000 to increase Urban Development Action Grant, or UDAC, funding to continue providing financial assistance to eligible nonprofit organizations in support of the city's public service grant program. The second adjustment is $217,027.98 to accommodate the personnel and equipment costs associated with two workforce housing specialist positions. These positions will assist in the administration of the city's growing workforce housing portfolio. Both adjustments will be funded through the appropriation of prior year fund balance within the neighborhood services fund. Staff recommends approval of Resolution 166-26, and I'm happy to answer any questions.
Great. Thank you very much. Are there any questions for Ms. Alamond?
I do. I have a question. Okay. I guess it's actually more, I have this on my list for Mr. Moore. I don't remember us talking about hiring two more people for that department. Is that what we're doing?
In relationship to our public services grant program, so it's not a direct impact to the general fund, and there was a discussion about it.
It doesn't impact the general fund, the salaries? No, not at all.
Not at all. The neighborhood services fund.
It's going to be funding from its own. Correct.
As part of our entitlement community designation in that regard, so because there aren't any impacts to the general fund, we humbly recommend approval. And given our requirements to administer the federal funds to that effect, that's what is being made available.
Thank you.
You're welcome.
Any other questions? Then I need a motion.
So moved. Second. Motion to approve.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? It is adopted unanimously. Great. So item 7B, which is going to be amendment number one to the RFQ. We don't need to read this into the record, okay? Missy Barletto, would you like to come up and explain to us 7B and tell us what we're going to be doing?
Good evening, Mayor and Commissioners. Missy Barletto, Public Works Director. And I am delighted to explain to you what we're going to do. Initially, I would like to introduce two of the members from Kiewit Corporation, which is the company that we're asking to enter into Phase 2 of this contract with. In the back row over here, we have Russell Dingman, who's the principal, and Joe Pescatori. If you guys would like to come up to the podium in case they have any questions of you, in the interest of a very long agenda, I've made very short presentations. So if you have any questions, this would be a great time to ask all of us. So initially, what I want to talk about is the contract duration, the full construction project, the beginning would be in December of 2026, ending in July of 2030. So initially, when we brought this project forward to commission, we talked about a five-year duration. One of the ways that we have managed to lower the expense of this project is to shorten that duration. From five years to about three-and-a-half years.
Wow. Thank you.
So the project highlights in the Northwest Neighborhood Project include utilities, rehabilitation, replacement upgrades to water, sanitary sewer, and drainage systems throughout the entire neighborhood. Roadway and streetscape improvements. We'll be resurfacing or reconstructing about eight-and-a-half miles of roadway, including sidewalks and decorative pedestrian-level lighting. There are two miles of new permeable concrete alleyways that will be a part of this project. Traffic calming, as we did, we've done significant public outreach in the Northwest community, talking to the people there. Their biggest concern by far was with traffic calming, and their request was to have additional speed humps and stop signs, and to make sure that all of the safety features in the neighborhood would be addressed. This does that. And in addition, we'll be doing, obviously, beautification and installation of landscape nodes. And another thing that was very important to them, eight upgraded and new decorative sub-neighborhood signs. So within what we call the Northwest neighborhood overall, there are eight communities, and each of those communities will get a sense of place with a new neighborhood sign. So when we entered into the contract with Kiewit initially, phase one of the contract is to develop a guaranteed maximum price. So they take a look at all of the design plans, and they ask questions, they look for conflicts, they look for abilities to minimize the conflicts and the cost of the project to become more efficient. They send every element of the project out for bid leveling. So before we bring these guaranteed maximum price opportunities to commission to vote on, the project has already been bid, and the bids have been what they call leveled, which means that all of the bids are looked at. And because individual contractors may not bid every item of a bid offering, they level those bids to make them even so that everybody is playing on an even keel. And then they look at the most responsive bid that is at the lowest price. So in this particular project, they started at a $128.5 million request. Following those alternatives and looking at all of the value engineering and bid leveling, we got down to $119.9 million. And following final adjustments to that in negotiations, we stand at $112.9 million for this neighborhood project. So here's how those numbers break down. In direct construction cost is $81,751,601. That is very close to what our initial engineering estimate was. On top of that, though, there are general conditions costs, a fixed fee of 9%, which you've seen in the last project of this time we brought forward. It was greater than that. And the plan total cost of the work, the actual work, is $107,078,876. On top of that, we have contingency of 3% on the owner's side and contingency, the owner being the city of Delray Beach. We own the project and contingency on the construction manager's side of 3%. Those contingency funds are there to address any unforeseen conditions that we might run into and to make sure that there's coverage for those. At the end of the project, if we do not use these contingency funds, they will revert back to the city. So the total estimated GMP with the contingency is $112,973,126. I goof that up every single time. So of that amount, Kiewit Corporation actually was also awarded the Complete Neighborhood Project for Tropic Isle Neighborhood. And there are some additional savings that the city can realize once the GMP for Tropic Isle Neighborhood has been negotiated. And if the commission approves to move forward with phase two of that contract, then there will be an additional reduction in the GMP for this project of right around $3.25 million. That actually covers duplicate staffing. Did I say that right?
Yeah.
He's mumbling over here, so I hear my conscience.
So, yeah, so just kind of explain that a little bit more is, you know, the size of this job, you know, it's a large job. It's a $100-plus million job. And the Tropic Isle job is going to be similar. It's going to be in that $100 million range, too. But with them being in close proximity, we can utilize staff that would typically be on a single job between the two jobs. So, once we do that, we can do a deductive change order of this job to split that cost into half and overall manage the two jobs together to provide that additional savings opportunity, too.
Great. Thank you. Thank you very much. Yep.
And that is the end of our very short presentation this evening. And we welcome questions.
Thank you very much. To the commission. Commissioner Casale, any questions?
No, we briefly discussed this at our CRA meeting, so we're kind of – we knew what we were expecting. And thank you. I like the idea of the $3 million savings. That's a great thing. And thank you very much. We look forward to getting started.
Commissioner Malika.
Thank you. I just wanted to point out for the public that those funds are CRA funds, correct? CRA is doing the Northwest Project. Is that correct?
The project will be funded through a revenue bond.
Understood.
That will come to the city, and then the CRA is committed to making the debt service payments on that bond to pay the funds back. Thank you.
And one other question. With the Tropic Isle Project, I had a resident saying that we really should wait until we can put streetlights up. Or, no, I'm sorry, bring the wires underground. There's no plan to do that. Is that accurate?
We don't have the plans? There is no plan to do that. That project is not on the table tonight, but I can tell you that there's no plan to do that. Commission has voted many times in the past not to fund undergrounding of electrical lines. And the storm secure program that is a part of Florida Power and Light that is undergrounding power lines all around the city right now does not have a plan to go to that neighborhood in the foreseeable future.
Thank you.
I would just add one thing to that, too, is I would highly recommend to do that secondary with the amount of underground work that we're going to be doing out there. If you put underground utilities, yeah, another hazard out there for me when I'm working, that would be something you would do on a follow-on basis because we're opening up that whole area. There's so many utilities we're going to be dealing with in the ground. And the last thing we want is one more hazard in the ground when we're doing that project. Thank you.
We can't deport it anyway, but just saying. Thank you. Commissioner Burns?
I don't have a question. I just wanted to say thank you for all the work that you've done on this. Thank you as well. The community is very excited about this project finally getting on the road. So thank you.
Commissioner Marker?
Yeah, I'm excited about this. I think it's great. The one thing I would throw out to the residents, just because you hear your utilities are going to be buried, be careful when you hear that. I can tell you in Lake Ida, where I live, there have been so many complaints. We buried all of our utilities, all of our FPL utilities. However, we didn't bury Comcast or AT&T. So we still have poles. We still have wires. There's just a little bit less of them. So it's a little bit of a – we get a lot of feedback in Lake Ida on that, that that was a shame that we couldn't convince AT&T and Comcast to join the party, but we couldn't.
So even though the electricity is out, you can't watch cable. Wow. There you go. Yeah, I guess. I think this – look, I'm very happy we're approving this tonight, as well as some other stuff. It will improve the – I mean, this project will improve the neighborhoods, which will increase the property values, which will pay for itself over the years. And I think it's a great thing that we're doing. So I need a motion. I have a question. Oh, yes, miss.
I'm sorry. What utilities are being underground? I thought you said that there were no utilities.
They are not. But he said what happened in Lake Ida. Yeah.
Okay. Yeah. Thank you. So the question was about Tropic Isle neighborhood, not about Northwest neighborhood. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I'm ready.
Anyway, do I need a motion to approve?
Motion to approve.
Amendment number one.
Amendment number one. Do I need to go through the RFQ? No, that's fine. Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? It is approved unanimously. Okay. And there's an approval of Amendment number one to agreement RFQ 2005 with Mankind. This is the Marine Way.
Thank you, guys. Thanks, sir.
I'm giving to the – I was asked by one of the residents of Marine Way who took some pictures, who had planned to be here today, but it was delayed, couldn't make it. So this – in your packet, there's pictures that was taken, I'm gathering, the last couple days. But anyway, you'll just see the pictures here just for your – that she wanted them presented to you. So do you have some idea?
This presentation I have a short video to show as well. Okay. So the second guaranteed maximum price amendment that we're entering – that we're asking for approval for this evening is for the historic Marine Way seawall roadway and drainage improvements project. So the project highlights for this particular project are 600 feet of new seawall along Marine Way north of southeast 1st Street, drainage system upgrades, including the city's first stormwater pump station that is west of the intracoastal waterway that will serve a good portion of the historic marina district. There's 1,200 feet of new drainage pipe associated with that. There are water and sewer system upgrades with 450 feet of new water main and 600 feet of new sanitary sewer pipe. Roadway and streetscape improvements with 1,300 feet of new pavement. Streetscape enhancements to include new landscaping, decorative hardscape elements, and lighting that will complement the historic character of the neighborhood. The landscape plan that we chose for North Marine Way was actually based on a photograph from 1926 that was provided to the city by the Historical Society. So one of the things that is different with this project, oh, I just realized I forgot to introduce my guys. So with me tonight I have Anthony Mancini, who is the principal with Mancon Corporation, and his counsel, Neil Shiller. So one of the things that Anthony is passionate about is artificial intelligence, and he has already developed the project website for the Delray Marine Way project. And there are a few elements of this that I would like to show you tonight because it's quite impressive. So the first is a one-minute video that is about the project that for all the people that didn't get to see the pictures that just went into your folders, they will get to see a little bit more about the project.
King tides, sea level rise, and erosion are wearing down historic Marine Way as water from the intracoastal floods the street. The city of Delray Beach is investing about $55 million in Marine Way, beginning with a new, higher seawall. Near Southeast First Street, a new underground stormwater pump station with a backup generator is planned from July 2027 to September 2029. The street is rebuilt as a brick paver roadway, with grass-paved parking and new drainage below. The result, a more resilient Marine Way, better protected from tidal flooding. All dates are proposed and may change. For updates, visit delraymarineway.com.
So that is the initial. And then there's a second tutorial that tells how to navigate the site. So, I'm going to show that it's one minute also.
Welcome to the Historic Marine Way Project website from the city of Delray Beach and Mankan. Here's a one-minute tour. Start with the project assistant, the first tab. Type a question or tap a suggestion. Answers come only from the project information published on this site. The map tab shows the planned work on an aerial view. Find your address, then turn on each part of the work to see what is planned near you. The project tab explains what is being built. A new seawall, a stormwater pump station, drainage, water and sewer lines, and a rebuilt street. The schedule tab shows each part of the work by phase. Tap a phase to see what happens, where, and what it means for you. This schedule is proposed and pending approval by the city of Delray Beach. Questions has short answers about driveways, parking, water service, noise, and more. To reach the project team, call or WhatsApp 561-595-5593 or use the contact page. In an emergency, call 911. Thank you for your patience while we build a safer marine way.
So that is the future of things to come for project websites, and I think that is a great enhancement for this project. The project schedule feeds into this public outreach document so that as the schedule changes, the answers that people get from the project website also will change.
Great. Great idea. Thank you. Is that concluding your...
Hang on. Now we're to the important part. Now we're to the part where you need to vote. So the starting offer, as we like to talk about it, for this project from Mankind was $58.8 million to complete the project. Following the valuation of alternatives, value engineering, and bid leveling, that project value went down to $56.5 million. And following our final adjustments, the price for the guaranteed maximum price that we're asking you to vote on this evening is $55 million even. So the way that that breaks down is $34.5 million in direct costs, $2.23 million in insurance and bonds. The construction manager's fee is 12% on this project. There are some differences in risk on this project as opposed to the complete neighborhood project. There are other general conditions that are not subject to the CMR fee. And then contingencies, the construction manager's contingency on this project is 5% because they have absorbed more of the risk on this project than some of the other projects that we've moved forward with. What they do not spend out of contingency on this project, they will retain as part of their fee. And the owner's contingency is about $780,000, which brings us to the total guaranteed maximum price of $55 million. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions.
Great. Thank you very much. Who would like to go first? Commissioner Casale.
Start. Thank you. That was a great presentation. I like that website Mr. Edwards was asking, could we see a scheduled timeline? And I think if you hop on that website, you'll be able to see it. And I imagine as it goes along, the changes will be updated. Missy, thank you for explaining that contingency because we just saw 3%. So seeing 5% was a little eye-opening. I know we discussed that this project costs more than anticipated. In 2022, staff thought this would be a $20 million project. And we had a lot of time that went into addressing residents' issues with respect to mangroves and a whole host of other meetings that dragged this out substantially. And now here we are, and it's $55 million. But I think my only question to you is, if you look at the agenda sheet, we've got $22.975 million from the Stormwater Utility Fund, and we've got $2 million from the Water and Sewer Fund. So where are we getting the additional $30 million anticipated?
Because this is a lot of money. As we've discussed, the improvements to the stormwater system are going to be, that are coming forward not just for Marine Way but also for the Tropic Isle neighborhood, again, as that comes forward, will be done through a stormwater revenue bond. Right. And then our stormwater utility assessments will pay that debt service back over a period of time. Right. Thank you.
Yes. Commissioner Burns.
Yes. No questions. I just want to say, again, thank you. This is another project, a long time coming, and congratulations to the residents for finally getting this project done. I'm ready for approval.
I'm very much in favor of this also. Just a curiosity question. How much taller will the seawall be?
The seawall will match the seawall at the city marina. Okay. It's about 4.2 NAVD, I believe is what it is. It's plenty tall enough to take care of our needs up to from between 15 and 20 years into the future, but it's also been engineered so that we can put an additional 18-inch cap on top of it without having to rebuild the seawall.
That's great. Thank you. Commissioner Malika.
Thank you very much, Missy. Can we get this fabulous website on our city website so people can easily find it for their updates?
As soon as we have signed contracts and everything is ready to go, yes, it will be on the city's website.
Thank you.
Well, I don't think the people are going to miss the boating that they're having on Marine Way. I know. So I need a motion to approve.
So moved. Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Contracts approved.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
We are now on item 7D, right? We are. Which is a presentation of the final report for the market study, et cetera, for Old School Square. Mr. Orris, you are making the presentation? Oh, Miss Barletta. Oh, I'm sorry.
So I'm going to make the presentation and then I'm going to hand it over to Mr. Orris as we pass this project from public works facilities realm into city manager realm, depending on the decisions you make toward the end of the presentation. So this will be in your packet for the commission meeting tonight. Was the final Microsoft Word version of the final feasibility report for the Old School Square needs assessment. And I'm going to run through the highlights of that for you. So in March of 2026, Web Management Services, which is a national expert in this area, was hired to do the phase one of the feasibility study, which was to examine the current campus for how it could possibly be used in its highest and best use. And to look at the community needs and what the market has already got available and what needs might be there to be plugged. Phase two of that, which you may or may not choose to go forward with, is affirming a vision for the Old School Square campus and commencement of business planning. Actually developing a business plan. In September, the Duncan Webb from Web Management actually came to commission and made a presentation. It was not greatly received. And we anticipated that the reaction would be that you already know these things. And we know you already know these things. We all already know these things. But it was good to have that reiterated to the commission that this is the position we're in. This is what we're dealing with. And I do think that in spite of the controversy that has surrounded the campus, there is a relatively cohesive vision for where the community thinks the campus should go. So in the Old School Square campus governing organization, I am hitting just the highlights of the larger report. The study suggests that there should be one organization with overall responsibility for the campus in order to coordinate campus-wide events and pursue a unified missions and vision for the campus. So those campus components that we have available on the Old School Square campus are varied. They require very different skills and resources. And therefore, the study suggests that the various campus components will have different operators. So one overarching organization with the potential for different operators for each of the individual components of the campus. On the Creative Arts School, the suggestion was to consider a new location for the ceramics program. It's very, very popular. And they felt that there could be a better use of that and more participation in a larger space. Grow programs for both youth and visitors. Build partnerships with the education sector and with the Arts Garage to provide for additional educational opportunities. Recommend change in oversight and management of the school unless the city you choose to operate the overall campus internally. For the Cornell Museum, the overall was that it's a very well-run facility for local, regional, and national exhibitions. They recommended change in oversight and management of the museum unless the DDA is chosen to govern the campus. The Field House. Maintain the charm and character as an attractive venue for meetings and events while addressing the acoustics, technical systems, and catering support areas. So for the Field House, the primary recommendation was to improve the facility. For the amphitheater and grounds, improve the ability to manage access for paid events and invest to create a more welcoming, passive park when events are not taking place, the downtown living room kind of vision. So build a team that can work with promoter partners and support the growth and development of outdoor events. And the team needs to work across multiple venues, especially the Field House and amphitheater. Did I freeze you out when I turned it down? It was hot when the room was full of people. So for the Crest Theater, consider presenting more touring, live arts, and entertainment, and make the venue attractive and available for a range of non-profit and commercial rentals, opportunity to create access for education and programs to support larger campus-wide events and festivals. And the Crest Theater is seen as the most challenging venue to operate and sustain. The report suggests combining the operations with the Field House and the amphitheater or soliciting management proposals from other venues or venue managers. So some of the recommendations that were included in the report that are already in progress. We're making drainage improvements to the grounds that are currently under review and solutions are in the process of being designed. The concession stand restrooms are being renovated. They'll be completed in fiscal year 27 through the parks government obligation bond issuance. We looked at one of the regular problems are the arcade roll-up doors. They're ugly. They look like garage doors. So we have spent some time working on redesigning those to where they will, instead of rolling up, they will open and close out. And they are designed to look like wrought iron gates more so than a roll-up door. So there will be some, for privacy for events and that sort of thing, there will be some screening elements that will need to be included with that. In addition, we're looking at improving the lighting along Swinton Avenue on the front side where there are certain safety issues because the lighting is not bright enough. We're putting new chandeliers inside the arcade and some additional lighting on the outside. The design of that has been funded by the CRA and the cost of implementation will come in a future capital improvement program budget. So the Crest Theater also is under design. We brought this to commission several months ago, looking at doing significant improvements to the back of house, to the dressing rooms and backstage areas, improvements to the loading dock, adding Americans with Disabilities Act, access to both the backstage area and to the front of the house by including a new chair lift. That would be part of it, putting in a catwalk that can access new lighting, improving the acoustics in the theater and taking what is now three sound booths inside the theater and making it a single sound booth and being able to include additional seating. So all of the seats inside the theater will be new, but the end caps to keep the historical perspective, the end caps will be kept. And then that design effort is underway now and will go on for about another year. And then in fiscal year 28, capital improvement budget will be coming back forward for an ask for construction dollars for the Crest Theater, which will be in the neighborhood of $8.2 million today. So really why we're here tonight is to give you an opportunity to move forward with with the discussions that you've asked to have several different times about how what next steps you're ready to take for the campus and how how staff can help you move forward with that. So some, I just put some thoughts down on this slide. If you like them, great. If you have something different in mind, that's also great. We have no preconceived notion.
Would you like me to start?
Are we finished?
Yeah.
Okay. Yes. Thank you. No, I was waiting to see another page. Fine. Commissioner Gissel.
Yeah, thank you so much. I think at this point, I think our expectations, as we stated at the last meeting of the report, we didn't quite get what we were expecting. But the place is operational now. We do need a funding mechanism, like in order to collect funds, donations, that is. But when we did the joint workshop, we spent three hours with the DDA in a joint workshop trying to figure out how to move forward. We concluded that, and I'm reading the minutes. We're talking about getting the feasibility study. And then we agreed that the city and the DDA would move forward with another joint workshop to address what we were going to do. I think at this point, I think we should have another workshop with the DDA and talk about how we're moving forward. We could continue to operate the campus as we are right now, but we have to obviously fund it. And we still have to look to fund all of these items that need to be funded. We don't really have a business plan because that study was supposed to provide us with that. So now do we want to continue on with another phase of that study? I don't know that we want to put more money into that. I don't know that we could develop an RFP at this point in time because the whole section of that is not completed. So you're looking at an RFP that in a year and a half, two years, you might be looking to change completely because then you have another component of the whole operation. I'd like to just ask my colleagues, why don't we just, we do so many workshops all the time, do another DDA workshop, and discuss this with our partners who are currently running it and sort of have a good sense of what's going on, and then look to figure out how we're moving forward into the future. That would be my recommendation.
One of the reasons I was waiting is because I thought you said you were turning it over to Mr. Orris. Do you have something to say after this then? I was trying to see if you were finished. That's my point.
The idea, of course, is that Missy handled the study and would handle any facility upgrades, those physical things, but then it gets turned over basically to the city manager's office to figure out how to move forward the components that you have expressed that you want. So I'm here to make sure I hear everything you have to say so we can move that forward.
Because when I was gone, we had, there was a discussion about the formation of a task force, right?
I was waiting for me. Oh, you're waiting for me.
I'm sorry. Go ahead. Commissioner Burton, Vice Mayor Murray.
Oh, I mean, you know, if you want to do your comments now, but I was waiting for that.
No, no, go ahead.
Because that's what we talked about. I mean, we've workshopped it. We've talked about it for years. And we haven't gotten, this is where we are. So I say that we go ahead and create this task force. And maybe some of our residents with experience can come up and give us these alternatives. I mean, obviously, we need two heads. And that'll be like many heads are better than one. Because we've done this. I mean, to have another workshop, I'm not opposed to that. But let's get some outside, some of our community involved in this and do the task force. So that's what I'll be. Commissioner Mollinger.
Thank you. I'm in agreement with the task force. The entire campus was community-led and community-built. And I'm even thinking about the $8 million reno. I mean, I even feel like that could somehow come from the community. But first, we have to go out to the community and talk to them and ask for their input. There's a lot of people with a lot of interest in making this great again and community run or business run, whatever it is. But let the task force suss that out. And we can all select people for the task force. I know a lot of people that would put their hands up with some criteria, that they've got some entertainment background, I guess, that they've been involved in this kind of thing. And I wouldn't limit it to just Delray Beach citizens, either. I would open it up.
Okay. Mr. Marker.
Yep. First of all, thanks for the work. I think we should also do another workshop with the DDA. I think we're at a point where we can take all the information that we have and get it to a next level. I do think we are approaching a point where we're going to need to appoint a board or a group of people to take this to the next level. I absolutely do not think we should be naming members who are friends or anything else to this committee. I think we should do a skills-based assessment. We should look at resumes to make sure we're getting the skills that we need on this task force because I think it's super minded. It's always nice when the siren goes off. Does that mean I'm right?
You're lightning. That's what it means.
I think this task force, I think they need to be very open-minded people, and I think we need to make sure they're capable of compiling a thorough review and options for us to consider. I'm glad we're here. I know there was some discontent with the last presentation that was made, but I would say it did level set the universe for all of us because everybody wasn't in the same place, and I think it did do that for us. But I think for the next phase, I think one more meeting with the DDA makes sense, and then I think we need to form a task force. But before we do that, we have to sit down and determine the skills we need on that task force so we get the right people and the right minds on that task force.
Thank you. Are you finished? I am, sir. I am actually of the opinion that we ought to form the task force sooner rather than later. We've been dancing around this campus, and there's great work being done there now, but we talked about doing other kinds of stuff too. I mean, I thought the task force was a great idea when it was first presented by the vice mayor, and you've only confirmed it now. I understand. I don't even think we know how to sit down and talk with the DDA about what we wanted to have without the task force telling us. So I think, well, I think that's going to be a useful exercise. I still think we should be trying to figure out how we want our task force done, and I would be of the view that we should, at the next meeting, we should come back with, I don't care, two people apiece. But I agree with Commissioner Marker, because I would like to be on the task force, somebody who has actually some understanding, a skill set of understanding entertainment venues, understanding art venues, understanding, you know.
Money-making.
Fundraising would not be irrelevant. So, you know, understanding how to raise, you know, things. So that would be my view. So I don't know, I mean, if you two are in the task force thing now, and I'm in the task force thing now, I think that's where we, that's the next move we should go. But I, so is that where we're at? That's where you are, and that's where you are, and that's where I am. So the question would be, do we want to try to appoint somebody, how many people we want on the task force?
So what you're saying is we're not going to go forward with the meeting with the DDA?
Not yet. No, no, I think I want to get the task force together, try to help us figure out what, because I don't even know, I'm going to sit down. I'm not going to even know what we're talking about. Oh, it's okay.
I get you.
So, you know, I want to get there. I just want to get it done, because it's been languishing for a while. Yeah, it has. You know, my fault, too. Everyone's fault, but, you know. So how many people do we think we should have on the task force? Should we each appoint two people? Is that a number?
Again, I don't think we should appoint. I think we have to have, we need to spend a little bit of time understanding what are the skill sets that we want. And then I think we should ask, you know, we should ask people to nominate themselves to be on that task force. And then I think we should match those, sorry, this is my corporate side coming out, match those resumes with the skills that we think will make the task force successful. Then I think we're on a good path.
That's fine, and I think the DDA can help us with figuring out what's the kind of people we want to have, so put together something where people can apply. Because they've got, you know, obviously direct experience with the operation of the campus. Yeah. And try to move forward that way. So, I guess, am I saying that direction is being given to the city manager to put together, you know, with the assistance of our partners here, put together some kind of application where people can apply for, serve on this task force?
Do we make a criteria for that application? We have to do that. We have to do that.
I think we're looking for feedback. One moment.
You said with the assistance of our partners, and that's kind of the whole point of getting together with them. Why don't we include them in the discussion of the task force?
There's other partners, too. Mr. Mayor?
They're operating it. Okay. I mean, why don't we have a quick, why don't we have a workshop? Ms. Burns said it's a good idea. Mr. Markert said it, and I'm saying it. I think we want to get the captain. That would be three. Quick workshop with our partners at the DDA to discuss the task force, if I may. Could I get a consensus on that?
I want to do the task force now. I don't think there's a need to do this.
We can wait one month. It's not going to make a difference. These are our partners operating it.
We have city manager and staff working with the criteria for the task force.
I think we have to come up with the criteria.
May I offer a recommendation, ladies and gentlemen?
We need to come up with the criteria.
So, given the interest to proceed with the task force and ultimately some type of workshop engagement with the DDA partnership, I would like to make this an agenda item for the December 15th meeting, your meeting calendar for December 8th and December 15th.
Thank you.
Excuse me, for the month of December, our December 8th and December 15th, we are preparing an agenda for December 8th. It's fairly robust. December 15th will be a cogent opportunity for a dialogue to this effect in which we would present an application format as well as other considerations to help advance the process.
Is that going to be a joint workshop? I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Judy. That will be a joint workshop with our partners.
What I'm proposing at first.
This is the commission doing something.
If I may, ladies and gentlemen. This would be a regular meeting agenda item in which we would talk about what the application criteria would be, present that in that regard, and you take the coming weeks to actually appoint individuals. And from there, you can have your workshop meeting in concert with the application process.
I would ask my colleagues, can we meet with our partner for a workshop before we create the task force?
For what?
Because I would like their input. They've been running that whole facility for years.
But we're talking about getting their input as we put together the thing.
I'd like to have a joint meeting. Can we just get a consensus? You're a no. Ms. Burns, would you consider a half-hour, 45-minute joint meeting to entertain your colleague, me, to discuss with our partners? You know, they understand what is currently going on, Judy. You have people that understand that, and I know that. I need input from our partners.
That would be possible if there's an interest in that regard. So if I may, ladies and gentlemen, just to summarize.
Mr. Barker, are you a third? I am. Thank you very much. There's three for consensus. Mr. Moore.
If I may, thank you. So we're looking at a workshop meeting to take place Tuesday, December 15th, for this specific purpose. I'm anticipating 4 o'clock to 5 o'clock. That's more than enough time to get everybody squared away in that regard. So in advance to that, Mr. Horace, you and I will meet with DDA leadership so that we can prepare accordingly, as well as to present an actual application format to be discussed during the regular meeting as well, so that you can proceed from there. The specific item, regular meeting agenda, an application format, what that looks like so you can begin your vetting process based on what you are to discuss during a workshop meeting session.
Wouldn't you want to put it on the following agenda because you're going to have a workshop discussion. You don't know what's going to happen on the agenda.
The scope of the workshop with the DDA will be for them to help us decide what type of people we want on the task force. The criteria, right? That would help us develop the criteria. Correct. Understood. Okay. We can do that the same day. Correct.
So the agenda item, regular, just to be additionally clear, is simply an application format, what that looks like. The recruiting tool will be, and you all can incorporate your thoughts as communicated during a workshop meeting prior, and we go from there. But actual appointment of task force members will likewise not occur for a few weeks later.
No, no, that's understood. That's understood. That will be enabled when we meet at the regular meeting to discuss that issue.
So workshop December 15th, 4 o'clock for this purpose, as suggested, as well as a workshop meeting.
Well, my purpose was really more of a broader discussion, frankly, but I'll take what I can get.
Okay. So you've got your direction. You've heard the direction. And so we are item 7D we're finished with. We're now moving to item 7A. I'm going to actually – 7E, 7F, and 7G are all quasi – what?
And one of the eights. 8B, I think it is. And one of the eights? 8B, yep.
Eight what? B as in boy.
B as in boy.
Oh, 8B and 8B, of course, yep, are quasi-judicial hearings. So I'm going to read the quasi-judicial rules. These hearings, which is 7 – whatever I said. I lost control of my – 7E, 7F, 7G, and 8B.
B, B as in boy.
Are going to be held in accordance with the quasi-judicial rules. The applicant in the city shall be allowed 15 minutes each to present their case. The public shall be allowed to speak for three minutes each or a maximum of six minutes if the person represents an organization or a group of people who are present but agree not to speak. The city commission, staff, and applicant may be allowed to cross-examine a witness. The city or the applicant will be allowed to offer rebuttal testimony. The decision to approve or deny an application or appeal may not be legally made upon personal views as to whether a project is a good project or not, nor may a decision be based on the numbers of citizens who support or oppose a particular project. The law requires that all decisions must be made on the basis of whether the project meets the requirements of law, the comprehensive plan, and the land development regulations. Any people wishing to speak on these four items, please stand and be sworn by the clerk.
As a notary of the state of Florida, do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do.
If you could please enter the first project, the 7E project file, into the record.
Sure. Amy Alvarez, Development Services. The first item has two file numbers, PZ 8003-2026, is that correct? Yes. 803. I'm sorry. And then the second one is PZ 804-2026.
Great.
Caption.
I'm sorry?
Did you want me to read the caption?
Well, I'm going to see whether or not we have any exparta communications. So are there any exparta communications on this?
Just what's on the server.
Commissioner Byrne.
This is the FAR waiver. The address is 219. We are on 7E. Oh, you have a different agenda.
Mr. Markert? No. Commissioner Mulligan? None. None for me either. Oh, I spoke to staff. That's not important.
Can I read the caption?
I'm sorry?
Can I read the caption?
Yes, would you please read the resolution into the record?
Resolution number 153-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Delray Beach, Florida, approving a waiver to Section 443-F2B of the Land Development Regulations to allow floor area ratio 0.41, and approving a waiver to Section F2C of the Land Development Regulations to allow an upper floor area of 102% of the first floor for the property located at 219 Northwest 12th Street, as more particularly described herein, providing it for an effective date and further purposes.
Thank you very much. To the applicant. You go first. Yes. Okay.
My name is Howard Gale, 33435. No, I need your address to the record. This is quasi-traditional. I need your address. The whole address? 630 East Wilbright Road, apartment 612, Boynton Beach. Thank you. Okay, so I am a GC in the area, and one of my clients has requested these two waivers. I want to start off on the next slide where we started and what we're asking. The existing home was built in 2015, and in Lake Ida region, we have a floor to upper floor to lower floor ratio of 75%, which is the standard. The home was built in 2015 to 97.9%, which is outside of the standard already. And in 2024, the city had permitted a remodel that had taken it up to 111% instead of the existing 98%. So it was a big bump up to add to the second floor. Our revision after zoning came back to us and said we couldn't do that, and they had closed the permit within less than a year on us. So we tried to do a revision to really simplify everything, and that's when they came back to us and said that we were out of conformity and we had to try and get the house into conformity. So we came up with a smaller design, and that's why we're here today, to try to get that passed. Yeah. So the house is here on 12th Street. It's on a corner. So the biggest problem with this house is that it has two frontages, two 25-foot setbacks off the west side and the south side. The other two sides, we have 10 feet. The one on the north side is already at 10 feet. On the west side, I'm sorry, the east side is at 15. So our proposal is to go to the property line on that side of the street. This is how we got here. This is the permitting plan submitted at 23. City permitted the plans in 24. We came along, and the homeowners wanted to change the contractor. So we did that. We did a revision on the plans, and that's when zoning changed, made us come in for the waivers. So to this point, the original plans were already permitted. They had spent a lot of money just to get it to that point, and now we were told that we couldn't even do that. So we tried to come up with an easier plan. The house exceeded the home already at 75. We're requesting 102% instead of the 111. That was already permitted and then taken away. And the FAR would be at 4.1 instead of an additional 4.1. Here is what the house was permitted to be. So this was their original remodel, which really doesn't, I think, live up to the standards or aesthetically pleasing to the neighborhood compared to what the house is now. This is, again, the permitted design around the house. It didn't fit the neighborhood. It was the designer that had designed that house. The owners were not happy with that. So when we came in, we took the original house. The one on the left is what they had proposed and the city permitted. The one on the right is what we are looking for to do. Now, to compare that with what they have is not much of a change on the aesthetics. So we're keeping with the aesthetics of the existing house that was built in 2015, and we're adding a five feet to the right side of the house and adding an office and playroom on the second floor. And that's what took us up out of the numbers here. So we have a floor-to-area ratio. The code requirement is 35%. The existing is right around 35%. The one that was permitted by the city went to 46%. We brought it down to 41% by just adding 686 square feet to it. Because of the 25-foot setback, we had to go to the side yard on the first floor a little bit, and then we added some to the second floor. The upper floor ratio, 75% max is what the code require is. The existing, which was built out of conformity already, is 97.9. The permitted by the city went to 111%. We brought that down to 102%. Same thing here, showing you the square footage and the numbers of what we did. And I just wanted to mention that there were two other properties that the FAR, they came in to get a waiver, and they had already been permitted, but they were over the FAR, and the city had approved their increase. One was 0.42. The other was 0.44. We're at 0.41.
I'm sorry, Mayor. Just a reminder that each waiver stands on its own. So I don't know what those circumstances were that justified those waivers, but I would ask you not to consider that because of the legal requirements of a waiver.
Thank you. And that's the resolutions. And then these are the two homes again in the summary. So that is what we're asking for. We're asking the two waivers. The one would be a 0.41 instead of a 0.35. And the other one is a second-floor-to-first-floor ratio, which goes from 97.9 to 102.
Great. Thank you very much. Thank you.
If I can just add something. Oh, sure. Homeowner. Okay. So I just wanted to give you these sheets. I have a...
I need your name and address for the record. Yeah.
Daniela McLeod, 219 Northwest 12th Street. Okay. 3-4-4-4. Yeah, that's fine. So I have some neighbors that had written letters in support of us, and I know that my dear neighbor right here, he's on the other side. We only have two houses budding up to us. One neighbor to the left of us, if you're facing our home, has sent a letter in support. And I know my dear neighbor Sandy is not in support, but I wanted to reassure him and his wife that there wouldn't be an impact to their pool area or their home as he... He told me that it would be. I took pictures from outside of our loft. The loft is just going to extend somewhat a little bit, but these are from my highest windows in my loft, and I just wanted you to see what it looks like, if I could just pass them out. Yeah, and these are the letters of approval from three other neighbors sent me letters to boarding. And you could see from the upper level, this is what you see. We can't even see the neighbor's house, and any build would not affect his view in any way. We wouldn't be able to see, and there's no privacy issue with us looking over the pool or near the bedrooms, because we can't see. And I just want to reiterate, one of the letters is from the neighbor that is abutting my house, and she actually will see the changes. She... It's... She doesn't... We don't have enough foliage between us, and she's in support of this. So the scope of the renovation isn't the legal standard here. Every other dimension of the project, the setbacks, the height, lot coverage, we're in compliance. In fact, we made ourselves more compliance on one of those standards. And the revised design is much smaller than what the city already permitted. There's two narrow, specific waivers. There's not... It's not an oversized project. As you can see, we're not building at all over our garage. The other thing I want to mention is that there are two standards in Lake Ida. One of the standards is for people who live on the lake. The other standard is for people who don't live on the lake. If you go by the standards of the people who live in the lake, we're over by 1% on our 100% upper floor than lower floor. Fairness, you know, it wasn't fair that we went through an eight-month process and paid well over $90,000. We had change orders and everything because the city went through the process with us. They let us go. They permitted us. So now we're at a point where it's been since September 2023. We just want to get something done at this point. And I want to say thank you because these two ladies here have been helping us along the way. It was really, I mean, it was a problem for them as well because they were handed this. I know the gentleman who did permit us or who was responsible for the majority of the work is no longer with the city. But, you know, as a citizen, walking through the process, doing everything we needed to do, and then get denied after that. We did incur over $90,000 a piece. And we're still waiting on $100,000 from our builder who we fired.
Thank you very much. Thank you for your time. Yeah, okay. To the city staff.
Okay. Once again, Amy Alvarez, Development Services. I have with me Madison Lemmer. She's our Development Services, I'm sorry, our Development Permit Manager in the Development Services Department. So, again, this is resolution number 15326 for a few waiver requests to the Lake Ida Overlay District requirements at 219 Northwest 12th Street. Which button? Which button? Okay. So, just an aerial overview of the subject property with the existing structure. Again, these two waivers are to exceed the maximum allowed floor area ratio in the Lake Ida Overlay District. And then there's also for multi-story buildings, of course, a 75% maximum. And so, the request is to, I'm sorry, I did not complete that sentence, a 75% maximum for the second floor. That's a percentage of the first floor. And so, that's their second request. So, just to give some background, in 2008, that's when the Lake Ida Overlay regulations came in, were adopted. It was a request by the Lake Ida Neighborhood. They had a task force, and that was part of the Lake Ida Neighborhood Property Owners Association. The purpose was compatibility. We had a lot of mansionization going on in the city. And so, it was really intended to combat those issues of incompatibility and reduce the size and bulk of new homes that were impacting the historic character of the neighborhood. So, in 2012, you may know the property that is in question was originally part of a larger single property, essentially. So, in 2012, that property was replatted into five parcels. In 2013, there was a permit. Again, Lake Ida was adopted in 2008. However, we did issue a permit in November of 2013 for the existing residents. In 2014, however, the lots were reconfigured from five lots to seven lots. And so, that's what you see on the screen, and that's the current configuration. And then you can see the current aerial. And then, in July 2015, that 2013 permit was completed. So, the current owners, they purchased the property in 2019. They did submit a new permit for additions and renovations. The permit was issued. However, it was closed by the request of the contract of record at that time. No work had commenced. Later on, it looks like just a week later, there was a new permit submitted. And that was when staff reviewed it. And it was disapproved because we were applying the Lake Ida overlay development standards that are in our LDR since 2008. So, again, the existing home that was permitted in 2013, their current FAR is compliant. It's 0.33, where 0.35 is the maximum. But their current second floor is 97.9% of their first floor, where there's a 75% maximum. Not quite sure how that happened, but it is an existing nonconformity that did not receive relief at that time. So, the regulations that are in place, lot coverage, floor area ratio, and the 75% limitation for upper floors, all of those regulations work together to help mitigate impacts from mass and scale of new construction in the neighborhood. So, again, the request, there's a maximum floor area ratio of 0.35. The proposal is for 0.41. You can see in the, hopefully, in the yellow portions of the plan on the screen. Those are the areas that are being added and that contribute towards the floor area ratio, which is essentially 869 square feet of additional floor area. So, this is just, again, comparing new, the proposed versus the existing and going through the square footage. For the second floor area, again, they're currently nonconforming, and the proposal would increase that nonconformity to 102% if approved. Of course, it would validate it at 102%, but also incorporate the validation of the 97.9% that exists. So, this is just an existing elevation. And then just to see the comparison between the two and where the additions are, you can see they are enclosing an existing open-air porch. So, there's really not much bulk added there, and it is only 50 square feet. And then, again, their proposed plan. So, you do have findings with these waivers that the request shall not adversely affect the neighboring area. B and C don't apply. And then you would look at D and consider whether it's the granting of a special privilege. So, you know, the standards in Lake Ida are there to reinforce the character that was desired and makes the neighborhood desirable. Lake Ida and the Barrier Island are the only neighborhoods that have size limitations through FAR. And as I mentioned, they were incorporated to address McMansionization and larger new construction that was happening at the time that those regulations were adopted. And if, I have no idea what my last sentence means, but, oh, to maintain compliance, I'm sorry, to maintain compliance, they would just be able to have a 247-square-foot addition. So, again, the requested action is to increase the floor area ratio from 0.41 to 0.35, I'm sorry, to 0.41 from 3.5, which is the maximum that's allowed, and then to increase the upper floor ratio to 102% of the first floor, where 75 is the maximum allowed. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Are there any members of the public wishing to address the commission on this agenda item? Please come to the lectern, give your name and address for the record. You will each have three minutes.
Yes. Good evening, everybody. Sandy Zeller. I live at 209 Northwest 12th Street, Gilroy Beach, directly to the east of this house. My house is a one-story house directly to the east of this house. The addition that they are proposing will essentially impact our house adversely. They're moving the garage over by about four feet into the open space on that side of the garage, and they're building that addition and a porch that will overhang the property on that side. On our side of the property, on the western side of the property, we have three bedrooms, and in between the bedrooms, there's a swimming pool and a deck area. That's what will be impacted by that. Our privacy will be impacted. Our natural air will be impacted. Our light will be impacted. Our privacy will be impacted. They mentioned that in 2024 they got permitted approvals for something larger than this. Well, I don't know about that. I mean, we live here full-time. We've lived here over 11 years. We never got notice of that. I don't think there was a hearing on that. I don't know how that happened, but whatever happened happened. Those aren't the plans that we're confronted with here. What we're confronted with here is a situation where this street from Swinton all the way down to Northwest 3rd Avenue, there are a total of 19 houses. Of those 19 houses, 16 of them are one-story houses. There are no other houses as large as this house. Our properties were all built by, Seaside built it by Tom Ladani at once. He built the, I call it the horseshoe, and they were all built at the same time. And we bought that directly from him. He happened to have been my neighbor at the house where we lived previous to buying this house, my next-door neighbor. In any event, they're asking for the floor-area ratio increase, and they're asking for a significant increase, with the second floor being bigger than the first floor. That's really somewhat unheard of. It's contrary, of course, to the LBRs. When I was on the PNC board and we had orientation, one of the first things they told us is that on any of these hearings, there has to be sufficient, credible evidence to prove this. Well, there's been none of that evidence to prove the four criteria that Ms. Rodriguez just talked about. So let me just say, in closing, that one of the previous hearings, the commissioner said that responsible development means more than what can be squeezed into an individual lot. It means considering how each project fits within the surrounding community, and this request does not fit within the street or the surrounding area. I know there was received a few letters from our neighbors. I have another neighbor here that is here to testify about the history as well. So I thank you very much, Mr. Zilber. I thank you for your time. I object to the ordinance. I object to the resolutions, and I ask that they be denied.
Thank you, Mr. Zilber. Are there any other members of the public wishing to speak? Seeing one, name and address for the record, please.
Susan Edwards, 33 Northwest 12th Street. I very much oppose this. I opposed it when they were developing this whole section, however many years ago that was. Very fortunate that we have gained some very nice neighbors. 33 Northwest 12th Street, I live in an original Lake Ida cottage, and I'm very respectful of all of my neighbors that have original cottages, and we do not want to see any more development like this happen on our street. And I would like to give the rest of my time over to my dear neighbor because I fear for his privacy as well as what's going to come of the homes that are around my house that are single one-story original cottages. I do not want to have something like that develop next to me, and I fear that if this happens now, then it's going to be continued to happen to the other homes that potentially could be demolished and rebuilt.
I'm not sure you can give. She cannot. You can't give my time to him. This is in Congress. Okay.
Well, I just want to say that all of us that are in original homes are very much against it.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
Are there any other comments from the auditor? Nope. Seeing none, public comment is closed. Rebuttal. Do you have any – is there any rebuttal that the applicant has with staff or what the staff has with the applicant?
You need to go to the microphone.
You need to go to the microphone. I'm sorry, ma'am.
Mayor, they also have the right to cross-examine.
Oh, yeah, and you have a right to cross-examine. So if you wish to cross-examine any of the witnesses or cross-examine.
No, I would just like the commission to look at the pictures because that is actually what the house looks like next to me where Alan lives, which is, you know, fine. It's lovely. I understand he can come here and he has every right to sit here and, you know, say how he feels about it. That's wonderful. I'm just asking you, because this was a city deal from the beginning. We were permitted. And, Alan, it's in the record. You can find that permit online. I didn't think that. I thought that was too big. I didn't like the way it was designed. We went through the process of redoing it. And it just so happened that when I did fire my contractor, the contractor just asked for him to be taken off of the permit. He didn't ask for the permit to be closed. I have paperwork on that. But I know that the city knew that it was falsely permitted when they started seeing the dimensions. And we knew, and that's why we have dumbed it down a lot. We knew after the fact. I mean, we're not familiar with the LDRs. We hired an architect who probably should have also looked it all up. He didn't. But he also walked through this process with the city for eight months, and there were many eyes in the city on the job, and nobody came back and said anything. And like I said, in May of 2024, we received a permit for it. We did strip up. We stripped our landscaping. We had a lot of things already done and ready to go. I have a tub sitting in my garage. And we paid a lot of money. We're not asking for much. If you look at the grand scheme of things, you've already allowed the 4.2 and 4.4 with homes that have similar situations where they've been permitted already. The build was up, and then somebody said something about that being out of range. So we're asking for a 4.41, and they've been approved for 42 and 44. Like I said, the lake has a 4.0. So you can, you know.
I'm looking for a cross-exam, not really a new presentation.
Okay, so I just, yes. So I just wanted to say, and if you look at the pictures, you'll see how it will not impact the house next door.
Thank you. She did a great job. She's my wife, so I'm not going to say that.
Okay. To the city, any follow-up, any cross-exam?
Just to clarify, obviously, this is between the existing structure and what is proposed. That original permit was closed out and is completely separate.
Okay. To the...
I just have a question, because it kind of all went fast, and I usually study it a lot beforehand, but I didn't. So the permit was for that one with things jutting out all over the place? That was permitted. Is that accurate?
I have not looked at those elevations from that permit that was approved. But they're saying yes. But that's their testimony, yes.
And so when we went back to a design similar to the house that's already existing, that's the new permit that they're trying to get? Got it. That's the permit that's under review. Thank you.
I'm sorry. We can't have that.
Okay. All right. Commissioner Marker. Have you finished, Commissioner Mulligan? Yes, yes. Commissioner Marker.
Yeah, I appreciate the presentation and everything. This neighborhood's been pretty clear in the past few years that they don't want McMansions built here, and there have been some that have been built, and the neighbors have hated it. So I wish that you could have brought this in line with the specs that are approved in Lake Ida, because the neighbors don't want big stuff right now, and I understand it. I mean, most of the things, as the young lady said, are cottages, and there's a certain charm and look and feel there. And I just wish that your revised plans had taken that into consideration.
Mayor, may I?
Please do.
Amy, can you put the slide up that shows the findings that we have to make today? I just want to make sure that we're directing our comments towards the findings. And I think staff was clear that it's really, well, all you're really looking at right now is, does it adversely affect the neighboring area, and does it result in the grant of a special privilege? So those are the two criteria that I think the comments should focus on.
Okay. Thank you very much. Commissioner Burns?
Yes. I, well, I think it does affect the neighboring area because it is outside of the overlay requirements and the LDRs. I'm inclined to honor the neighborhood wishes for the overlay that was established. Whenever it was established, it was established for a reason. And so neighborhoods who establish their criteria, I think that, you know, anything that's coming in there should be within those guidelines. And so that's where I am with this.
Okay. You finished?
Yes. Commissioner Casale?
What was it?
There was a slide that said to maintain compliance.
Oh, the 247 square feet that would be allowed.
I think it's up a little.
I went through. Thank you.
You finished with that?
That was my question. I just wanted to read that slide.
Okay. I feel differently about when it's being added on than if they were starting from scratch. At the same time, I am concerned with the larger house. I mean, that neighborhood has really tried to keep itself in it with a certain type of identity. They worked very, very hard to put these guidelines together. And as much as I love the design that you're doing, I still think that these guidelines were put there for a reason. And I'm not prepared to deviate it because I don't think, I think that the neighborhood is saying it adversely affects them. I do think it's a special privilege. I understand you say there were others out there, and I can't consider those. But I do think, you know, because we've looked at others and say the same kind of things. I'm very consistent in my comments. So I'm going to have to tell you that on this one, I'm not going to be able to support it. And I hope you come back with something else because I know your house. I mean, I know, Emily, your next-door neighbor. I've seen your house a lot of times. But that's just the way I think this is going to go.
Would you like me to make a motion?
Please do.
Motion to deny resolution number 153-26.
Second. Please call the roll.
Deputy Vice Mayor Margaret.
Yes.
Commissioner Mulligan. Yes. Commissioner Cassell. Yes. Vice Mayor Barnes. Yes. Mayor Kearney. Yes. Motion to pass.
Sorry, 7F. Okay, we're going to go to 7F.
I'm going to let you take over here for a few minutes.
Vice Mayor, do you want me to read the resolution?
No, you're just – I'm going to – I'll tell you what. We're now going on item number 7F. This is a quasi-judicial hearing. If you could please enter the file into the record.
Sure. The file for this next item is PZ772-2026.
Thank you very much. Are there any ex-parte communications on this? No. No. Okay, none. If the city attorney could please read in the –
Resolution number 170-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Delver Beach, Florida, approving a waiver to Section 478A1A of the land development regulations to allow a side street setback of 7 feet 6 inches for the property located at 260 Northwest 8th Avenue. It is more particularly described herein, providing an effective date and for other purposes.
That was a very good introduction. Can I start?
Sure.
Commission, my name is Gary Leopolis. For the record, I am the Vice President of the Community Land Trust. With me tonight is also our CEO, Severin Dobson. We also have our contractor, William Hatcher of Hatcher Construction. I did want to ask a question. So we do have item 7F and 7G. They're virtually the same, so I'm not sure how you want me to do it because it would be just a repeat.
Do you want me to read the caption for the next one? Yes. And then we can consider it. It is Resolution number 169-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Delver Beach, Florida, approving a waiver to Section 478A1A of the land development regulations to allow a side street setback of 7 feet 6 inches for the property located at 259 Northwest 9th Avenue. It is more particularly described herein, providing an effective date and further purposes. And just for the record, were there any ex-parte communications for this item? No. No. No. Perfect. Thank you.
Okay. We're very excited to be here tonight. This has kind of been a longer process than we were thinking when we first got involved with this. But the goal is hopefully we're going to get two more workforce homes in our community. So as far as the site goes, right up here you see you have 260 Northwest 8th Avenue. Basically we are just south of the parking lot for the Spady Elementary School. These lots were awarded to us back in March of 25 from the CRA. It was an RFP. We responded to it. We got it. We developed the drawings for these. We submitted. And I believe actually the project that you might have approved for your capital improvement project tonight was actually something that changed our whole design or at least approach. And that's why we're here tonight. It was the improvement of the infrastructure and everything else like that that changed these sites. So that's why we are here requesting these waivers. So basically that's stating it right there. You know, you had the RFP. You had the infrastructure that the city was doing. And now after we've submitted for permit, we are coming back and looking at this. We're hoping that you guys, when you look at what we're proposing, it actually is still a great opportunity for the community. I don't believe it's going to affect any of the negative areas around it. I think it's actually going to reinforce everything. So as it was stated, what we're requesting. So you're dealing with workforce housing. When you're dealing with lots between 40 and 50 feet, the side street setback is 10 feet. We are requesting 7 foot 6 with these. There are the two lots that we're talking about. So you're talking 2 foot 6 relief. This is showing one of the lots right here. So what you have is you do have an alley on the east. This one's on the west side. We are going to be dedicating 2 feet to increase the alley. So when the alley is done for both lots, you're going to have 20 feet in between them. And we're also going to be doing corner clips. This is basically showing the area. Now, again, we're in basically, in theory, hopefully most of the time, no speed zone. I mean, when you're across the street from a parking lot, one of the things that you do want to do is, when you have vacant lots, is build homes there. These are obviously undersized lots. One of the other criteria that you're dealing with when you're dealing with workforce housing is the minimum lot size is 4,000. Even after our dedications, we will actually still be over that. We're going to be at 5,067 square feet. So you do see the corner clip right here. You have a 20 by 20. You have our setback that we're requesting along the street, which is 7 foot 6. On the south side, when you're doing workforce housing, 5 feet is allowed. And you're seeing on the west side there the 2 foot dedication. When we talk about the corner clips and everything, we talk about safety. We're talking about sight lines. We still will comply with all the sight lines, which will actually still be a safe situation when these houses are constructed. One of the things about these homes are they are, the other criteria is you can't be over 26 feet. We are actually at 20 feet when you're dealing with the homes that we're proposing. All the rooms inside are relatively modest. You're dealing with bedrooms that are 11 foot 8. You're dealing with the so-called main level living areas that are at 13 feet each of them. So you're not dealing with a lot of areas that I can start shaving it. So we're hoping that you would understand that we're also trying to give the quality of a good home to a good family. Again, that's just a quick breakdown of what we're talking about with regards to the request tonight. And then your findings. We believe that the proposed building placement maintains the streetscape and the neighborhood character. One of the things is, let me see if I can go back to it to show, I guess not. Amy, I need you. You know that. One of the things I was going to say is that the homes that we're placing, okay, the front of it's going to be 47 feet off of the front property line. The back will be 45 feet. So what you're finding out is that we've got plenty of open space around these homes, which we think is going to definitely help the neighborhood and the character. When we start talking about, no, that wasn't it, but that was a good one too. Okay, she'll not significantly diminish the provisions of the public facilities. That definitely will not happen with these homes. We're going to have, again, all the site visibility lines clear for safety reasons as far as does not result in the granting of a special privilege. And the same waiver would be granted under similar circumstances under other properties for other applicants or owners. We believe that would be the case for any other kind of fair housing lot that we're dealing with. Thank you very much. That concludes my presentation. Be happy to answer any questions should you have anything.
Thank you very much, Mr. Leop.
I'm sorry, was he doing both? You did both? What? That's your presentation for both? Yeah. Perfect. Yeah.
So we're doing, we're going, we have to read the other file into the record. She did. Oh, you did while I was gone. Very good. I appreciate that.
Do you have ex parte for the second one, Mayor? I'm sorry? Did you have any ex parte for the second one? Communications? No, no ex parte. We didn't hear that.
Using those big words, ex parte. Ms. Alvarez.
Just a question. Am I able to just make one presentation as well?
Yeah.
Of course. Okay. Just to be sure. All right. Resolution number 170-26. It's the waiver for 260 Northwest 8th Avenue for the side street setback. Let's see. We can fly through it. I was going to say, do you need a presentation on this? Because I can't imagine it's very different than the others. I am more than happy to not make a presentation. Do you have any cross-examination? No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
I'm getting there.
Let me just see if there's anything in here that we do want to point out. Just that it retains the original 1925 configuration. You can see here what the difference would be, whether they provide the 10-foot side street setback that's allowed only for workforce housing. Otherwise, it's 15 feet. That's standard for non-workforce housing. And they want to reduce it to 7 1⁄2 feet. I'm sorry, I didn't mean to say the community land trust would like to reduce it to 7 1⁄2 feet. You're only allowed to do that if you meet certain criteria. They went over that. Thank you very much. And so you're allowed to grant waivers, as we know. Here's your criteria, your findings, and some explanations on it. It's in your backup. And all right, you can consider. Thank you very much. Thank you, City.
This is a public hearing. If there are any members of the public wishing to speak on this item, please come to the lectern, give your name and address for the record, and you shall have three minutes. Seeing none, public comment is closed. Is there any cross-examination or rebuttal?
No.
Do you want me to throw out a motion? Are you ready? Can we have a motion? I'm going to need two motions. Resolution 170-26. Second.
I'll call the roll, please.
Commissioner Mollica. Yes. Commissioner Casale. Yes. Vice Mayor Burns. Yes. Mayor Carney. Yes. Deputy Vice Mayor Markert. Yes. Motion passed.
Motion to approve resolution number 169-26. Second.
Pull the roll. Commissioner Casale. Yes. Vice Mayor Burns. Yes. Mayor Carney. Yes. Deputy Vice Mayor Markert. Yes. Commissioner Mollica. Yes.
Motion passed. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you very much. Have a great night. Great presentation. Thank you.
Resolution number 165-26, a resolution of the City Commission of the City of Delivery Beach, Florida, providing for the partial abandonment of a utility easement located at 1400 South Federal Highway, totaling approximately 280 square feet, as more particularly described herein, providing for an effective date and for other purposes.
Does anybody need to hear a presentation here?
No.
No. Can I get a motion to approve?
Motion to approve resolution number 165-26. Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Fine. Done. Great presentation. Thank you. You're the lawyer, right? So you're going to have to do a thing and you guys do the meeting. Good deal. That was right to the point. Next item? We're now on item 8A.
Mayor, can we do 8A and 8B together?
Can 8A and 8B together. We are going to do 8A and 8B together. But one is a quasar judicial.
8B.
Right? So I'm not going to read the quasar rules again. We'll just wait to see if anybody's going to do it. So 8A and 8B together. So who would go first?
I guess it's privately initiated. So where's Mr. Costello? Okay, there he is here. Mr. Costello? Don't be scared.
You're on.
Well, let me read the captions. 8A is Ordinance 4426, an ordinance of the City Commission of the City of Derry Beach, Florida, adopting a small-scale land use map amendment, redesignating a parcel of land, measuring approximately 0.24 acres, located at 116 Southwest 5th Avenue, as more particularly described herein, from commercial core to medium density, 5 to 12 DU per acre, pursuant to the provisions of the Community Planning Act, Florida Statute Section 163.3187, providing a complex clause and a severability clause, providing an effective date and further purposes, Ordinance No. 45-26, an ordinance of the City Commission of the City of Derry Beach, Florida, rezoning a parcel of land, measuring approximately 0.24 acres, located at 116 Southwest 5th Avenue, as more particularly described herein, from Central Business CBD District to Medium Density Residential RM District, amending the City of Derry Beach zoning map, July 6, 2021, and further amending Figure 4413B2, West Atlantic Neighborhood Sub-District, regulating plan. In Section 4413, Central Business CBD District, for the Land Development Regulations, providing a conflict clause and a severability clause, providing an effective date and further purposes. These are both second reading. The second one is quasi-judicial.
Great. Because the second one is quasi-judicial, have there been any ex-parte communications on the item written 8B?
Mr. Costello called me twice, but I was in meetings all day, so we did not speak. So partial ex-parte, I suppose.
Mr. Costello called me for any questions or clarifications. I had none.
Mr. Costello called me, and I did take your call. So go ahead. I spoke with Mr. Costello as well.
I ignored his call.
There you go.
You're not under oath.
You can be honest. Mr. Costello, you were sworn, right? I was sworn before you. Yes, sir. Right.
Yes. Mayor, Commissioner, Jeff Costello, JC Planning Solutions, 91 Delray Lake Stride, Delray Beach, Florida, 33444. Here this evening, on behalf of the applicants on this land use map amendment and rezoning of this parcel of land on the edge of the CBD adjacent to the southwest neighborhood, here are some photos of the property. There was a single-family home. You could see the foundation fairly many years ago, and these are some of the adjacent properties. Yeah, in 81, the structure was demolished. There's been a number of redevelopment plans adopted in that area, and most recently the property was rezoned, land use map amendment rezoning in 2005, and that really extended the CBD south of First Street. It normally did not. And so here we are today with a proposal. The existing land use designation is commercial core, zoning is CBD, proposal is medium-density residential, and proposed RM. The proposal is to build a duplex for these gentlemen on the property. It's about a quarter of an acre. With it, you know, in the future, once we get into permitting, we'll be dedicating five feet of right-of-way for Fifth Avenue and a two-foot right-of-way dedication for the alley. It's currently vacant, and this is part of the We Are Home workforce housing program. Just another exhibit showing where the property is located adjacent to the southwest neighborhood. Required findings can be made with regard to future land use map consistency, and this is the preferred zoning for the MD land use destination allows single-family, duplex, multi-family concurrency. Positive findings can be made, as well as consistency with the comprehensive plan. The required findings associated with the amendment to a land use map can be made. This is the zoning facilitates small-scale residential development. This consists of the goals, objectives, and policies of comprehensive plan, the set transformation plan, and really all other related plans. Development will meet all of the concurrency standards and is compatible to surrounding area. There are a number of comp plan policies that are applicable, just highlighting a few. The staff report is very detailed, and so I'm going to move a little bit quicker here to the time. But as you can see, the positive findings can be made. This really works in promoting homeownership in the southwest neighborhood. And again, just to recap some of the plans, very great analysis in the staff report related to all those. You know, since the rezoning occurred in 2005, there really hasn't been a lot of activity in this portion of the block. You know, and sometimes circumstances change where, you know what, you know, maybe it's time to look at it a little bit different. This is a family that's owned this property for many years and who now wouldn't want to build a home duplex on the property. This positive findings can be made for the standards for rezoning actions, existing development pattern, and typical lot size to support the RM as the most restrictive residential zoning district applicable to the site. And the land use and RM zoning will result in land uses that are generally compatible with the adjacent properties. Just, I'm not going to go into detail of the land development regulations. Of course, this is a lower of intensity and density allowed from the CBD to the RM. And this is in the overlay district, which allows up to 24 units. However, the desire is just a duplex. Positive findings can be made with regard to rezoning findings. There has been a change in circumstances and requested zoning is a similar intensity of the allowed under the land use map and is more appropriate based on particular circumstances to the site and neighborhood. And so, therefore, we respectfully request approval. Thank you very much, Mr. Gossela.
To the city.
And my mic was not on for any of that. That's fine.
That's right. We heard Columbia University. That was it. Yes. That scared me. I figured.
She's been a great addition to our team. So, I'm not sure, you know, given prior items tonight, how quick you want me to go through this. I don't know that I have much more. You can go quickly. To add, other than Mr. Costello's presentation, just that there is also an LDR amendment associated with this, and that's just for the regulating plan in the West Atlantic neighborhood sub-district, to remove this from the CBD.
We've had a great – I think we've all looked at the staff right. Awesome. This is a public hearing. Yes. If there are any members of the public wishing to speak on this item, please come to the lectern, give your name and address for the record. You will each have three minutes. You don't need to speak, but –
You don't need to. Hello to everyone. David Haynes, 48 Southwest 7th Avenue. I just wanted to say that, again, the property has been in our family for over 40 years, and we finally decided to put something on the land. Me and my brother, we both have been born and raised in this city, two blocks away from where we're trying to build now. Also, we both work in this city, me as a mail carrier and him as a barber, so we still serve the community also. And also, with you all help, the CRA and the workforce housing, we would like to see these come to fruition so that we are able to build on the property. Great.
Thank you.
Thank you very much. Thank you. Is there any rebuttal or any cross-examination? Oh, do you want other? Okay.
Just one other quick one. Hi. Allie Levin. I'm the executive director of the Delray Beach CDC. And just to reiterate what they were both saying, so we are – once this is – we're hoping that it is approved, we are ready to go. We have a builder already lined up for the duplex. They've already been fully approved for their mortgages and their loans. They've already been fully approved for the workforce housing program of Palm Beach County. And with that program, they'll also be receiving subsidies of up to $65,000 to add into the home. So we're hoping this works. This family has owned the property for decades, and we're very excited to actually build two new homes on it. Thank you. Great.
Thank you very much. Are there any other members of the public wishing to speak? Is there any cross-examination between the applicant and the city or any of the witnesses? Seeing none, that's opposed to the commission.
Yes. Motion to approve ordinance. Oh, do you want me to do it, or do you want to talk? Sure, you can do it.
I was just going to say hi to David. I haven't seen you in good years.
I don't know you, but hello to.
Yeah. Motion to approve ordinance number 44-26.
Second. All in. Is she second? On a roll? Is she second? I'm sorry.
Vice Mayor Burns. Yes. Mayor Carney. Yes. Deputy Vice Mayor Markert. Yes. Commissioner Mollica. Yes. Commissioner Cassell. Yes.
Motion passes. Great. And then there's a second. Motion to approve ordinance number 45-26. Second.
Call the roll.
Mayor Carney. Yes. Deputy Vice Mayor Markert. Yes. Commissioner Mollica. Yes. Commissioner Cassell. Yes. Vice Mayor Burns. Yes. Motion passes.
Congratulations. That's exciting. Oh, great. Congratulations. Can I ask something about this item? Yes. Okay. So this item, I mean, well, the act that we just made, for instance, can we extend this? Because this, like, leaves pockets of inconsistencies in this neighborhood and in this book.
I actually talked to Amy about it earlier today. We'll look into it when Anthea gets back. And if there's a possibility to do something city-initiated, we'll bring it back before you to make that record.
Okay. This is one of those ones that you really, you know.
Yeah. Because there's some other vacant properties, and I'm sure. It doesn't finish the line. Okay. Right. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you both. Congratulations. Good night. You too, Allie. Bye. Thank you. Ordinance.
Are you leaving that for us, Mrs. Odom? I think someone else left it. Oh, okay. Good. We can steal that. That's good. Yeah. Okay. All right. On item number 9A, Ordinance number 41-26.
An ordinance of the City Commission of the City of Delvary Beach, Florida, amending the Code of Ordinances of the City of Delvary Beach by amending Chapter 120, Operation Sale of Food for Mobile Food Trucks by revising and clarifying regulations related to the operation of mobile food trucks, authorizing mobile food trucks in the Central Business CBD District as defined herein, establishing a limited duration pilot program for the operation of mobile food trucks in certain zoning districts, providing a conflict clause, providing a severability clause, authority to codify, and providing an effective date. I know we don't do a presentation, but I did want to ask a question. This ordinance came as a result of a workshop that we had. I think you heard from the gentleman earlier today. And there was something in the workshop that was discussed, but we didn't put it in the ordinance. And I just, if you want it in there, I can put it in for second reading. It was the limitation on the actual number of food trucks on a certain parcel.
I found one other thing, too.
Oh, thank you.
Sure. So I... Let's do one at a time, then. Is that something we want...
Well, why... In other words, there are some where you have three different food trucks, a dessert truck, a lasagna, and I don't know that we... Why... What would be the upside to that? Yeah, what would be the number?
If it's fish and parking...
So I think when it was discussed, commission... I mean, I don't know if you want 10. I guess, you know, if a site is large enough, you could have 10, right? So a lot of the times, I think the sites will constrict themselves naturally because you can't park in certain areas. But I think at the workshop, I think Commissioner Mollica said two?
I said two, and the mayor said three. But I am in agreement that we have to have a number or we could end up with a food truck city if a lot is big enough.
Right.
So I would totally be on board with three.
But they only allow to park for 30 minutes. No.
No, no, no.
No, no, no. That's what we're changing. No, this changes it. It increases the hours that they can operate. It increases the locations. But like Commissioner Mollica said, if you have a site big enough, you could have 10 of them there. And I don't know if that was the intent.
Well, they've got to be able to park it. So, I mean, they're usually in these lots and these stores.
I would say we don't have to really limit it that much because you're right. I mean, if it's a small parcel like the one on Federal, you can only fit two or three there max.
Three, yeah. Right?
I mean, where...
Is there something that we could amend later on? Always. Oh, sure. It doesn't work. Leave it alone.
Right.
So just leave it as is? Because right now there's no limitation. Yeah, leave it. Right, just leave it. And then you had a second thing that you...
Yeah, I had a concern because this was crossed out. Mobile food truck vendors are prohibited from selling and distributing alcoholic beverages. Is that what we want?
I actually think that's a state law. Huh? Where is it? Did Amy leave? There was something. Did we... Where are you? I'm sorry.
I am on page four at the top, number six. That was struck down.
Oh, it was in there, so...
I mean, I'm okay to drink at these food trucks, but I don't think it's a good idea. What do you guys think?
Well, what, if they're selling beer or wine? Does that matter? I mean, they're going to have to have some sort of a license. They have a license.
Yeah. If he was here, for example, he's got that pizza truck. Right. Does he sell wine? I mean... I don't know, but he should.
If he's selling pizza, he should sell wine and beer. No, I'm just saying, like, it maximizes their ability to, you know, make money and... And they would have a license.
I think part of the issue is the open container issue. Like, you know, when we have special events... Because they'd be drinking in a parking lot? Because you're drinking outside. You're not in a brick and mortar. I don't know.
I think if we can find a way to craft the ordinance so that it wouldn't violate... I mean, I understand the open container, but if they're on site and within proximity of the truck and they're sitting down, you know, they're not walking up the street, that's a different scenario than if there is.
Well, an open container violation is illegal, so, I mean, if you take the beer from there and then walk, you could do that at any bar downtown if you so chose, right? So, I don't think it's really...
I mean, it's definitely a violation, so... Right. Let's be clear. Okay, so you want me to put that back in? No, I'm saying it, but it's a violation.
No, I think they're saying keep it crossed out. I'm saying... Oh, no, I thought that...
No, we're saying to add the ability to do it, but we've got to figure out how to do not file it.
So, right now, there is the ability to... I'm going to un-strike through it.
Well, you know, you could... I mean, maybe you can't handle the can of beer, but they can handle the can of beer, but they can handle the can of beer, but they can handle the can of beer.
We're given a privilege against it. Yeah, they're given it in a glass. That's a good point.
That's a good point. Right, exactly. You put it into a glass. You don't have to put your hand on the can of the bottle.
I mean, let me just... No, we can't do that. No, no, no. They do do that.
That gets around to the rule.
I think it's just leave it. If you're walking down the street with an open container, you're violating it.
So, you don't want it. It's not an open container. I'm just telling you. That's the way they get around it.
Can I... Oh, my goodness. Okay, so the proposed ordinance says, basically, it takes that language out. It's currently in the code. It's going to take it out. So, everyone wants it in. We're going to allow them to. So, I'm going to... Sell if they have a license.
But it's got to be related to and pertinent to their having the food at the truck.
I'll put language. They don't understand. Currently, it is omitted for allowing alcohol. Right. If you ask her to un-omit it, then it won't allow alcohol.
We're keeping it in. We want alcohol or not. Yes. Got it. Okay, I have my direction.
But it's got to be in proximity to the, you know... Yeah, I'm going to craft it.
I'll craft it. So... They know. Okay. Right. That can't sell like a package store.
Right. I mean, we know that. Right, right. Yeah. Okay.
It's a given. Okay, so I will make those changes, and then no limitations on the number. And we'll see how it goes. Okay, that's...
Yeah, I need a motion. So, do we have a motion to approve the Ordinance 41-26?
So moved. Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Good. Okay, 9B. 43-26.
In ordinance of the City Commission of the City of Devery Beach, Florida, amending the land development regulations of the City of Devery Beach Code of Ordinances, Chapter 4, Zoning Regulations, Article 4.4, Base Zoning District, Section 4413, Central Business, CBD District, Subsection I, CBD Parking Standards, Subsection 2, Minimum Number of Off-Street Parking Spaces, to extend the parking exemption for changes in commercial use within existing commercial buildings and associated outdoor areas within the West Atlantic Neighborhood Sub-District of the Central Business District through December 31, 2031, and expand the geographic area of availability for the exemption, providing confidence cause of severability, close authority to codify, providing an effective date, and for other purposes, first reading, there's no presentation.
Okay.
Is this a public hearing?
Is this a public hearing? No, no. It's a first reading. We're not going to have a public hearing. There's no documenting presentation. So, motion to approve for this number 43-26.
Do I have a second?
Second.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Okay. Comments and inquiries by non-agenda items, Mr. City Manager.
I yield at this time.
Good. City Attorney.
Two things really quick. Happy Thanksgiving to all of you. Yes. And the other thing, for the record, I think that everyone sitting up here is here to make this place a little bit better than the way they got here. So, that's for you, Mayor. I liked that in the slide.
Thank you.
Oh, that wasn't working. Okay. Are you finished? Yes, sir. Excuse me. Have you concluded your remarks? Yes, sir. Okay. Commissioner Malika.
Okay. Thank you to the fire department for sharing the new cold cut response unit. Somebody said they call it a cobra. It's cold. Yeah, it's very cool. I watched that happen. And that's specifically to put out e-cars. You know, when the batteries catch on fire. So, I'm grateful that they have that. Congratulations to our IT department for being top ranked in digital cities for the fourth year in a row. And as Laura Simon mentioned today about, we heard this actually at the business round table as well, a number of businesses speaking about being allowed some visible signage. Like, there was a candle shop on Atlantic Avenue, and you can see their sign if you stand in the middle of Atlantic Avenue and look up. But if you're walking along the street, you don't know it's there. And they're only allowed so much in the window. So, I think that we should take Ms. Simon's recommendation and have a pilot program for retail pedestrian signage in the DDA district. Anthea's department could work with the DDA on a particular selection of styles at a particular size of signage. And I'm seeking consensus for a retail pedestrian sign pilot program for one year.
To the commission, have we got consensus for that? Sure. Yes. I agree. Yep. So, you've got consensus. Excellent. Good.
That'll have to come before you for approval.
And one last thing, and that is that the people at the Mayor's Education Roundtable, the table that I was at was to speak about the education board resurgence, but they had an appetite for education task force. And when we discussed it at a workshop or at commission, we talked about that going into the chamber as a task force, but when the people that were interested in it contacted me, they said that wasn't what they had in mind, that they wanted the task force to be with the city specifically because they have, their goal would be to update the education element of the comprehensive plan, and they would need a lot of data set from the staff. So, and they wanted a specific time limit of one year, so I wanted to, I don't know what the steps are to make that a city task force.
We can just draft something.
Okay. That's all I got.
Do we, is it, is it going to be the same people that were at your table? Yeah. Is that how everybody envisions it? Yeah.
Okay. Yeah. Okay. So. Except me, not me. And then Ms. Burns wanted to be on it. Ms. Burns wanted what? You're going to be on that education task force. Yes. Okay.
Okay. Okay. So, we'll bring it back to you.
Thank you.
Commissioner Casale.
Thanks. So, I just, back to the workshop, which was really interesting and challenging. We did not have enough time, I didn't feel, to address all the things. But there was this, I pulled this out of my tax bill, this, the mailer, you know, you get, which tells you how much you have to pay in tax. And in it, it reads, what every property owner should know, if you offer accommodations for short-term rental, six months or less, you're required to collect a tourism development tax, which is 6% of the total taxable rental receipts. And then it says you need to establish an online tourism development tax account, and you need to obtain a county local business or BTR or short-term rental with each property. But, I mean, maybe we could just get a list from the county, Mr. Moore, so we can cross-reference when people are coming in voluntarily that we're getting all of the people and maybe those who aren't voluntarily, we figure out a way.
We'll do.
I mean, we'll ask my colleagues.
You can even go on Airbnb and look some homes up.
Right, but I don't want to sit there and do that.
No, I like the idea.
I mean, if they have a running list with names and addresses and we can just get it, create an Excel database and check off when we get, we'll know if we're covering the people. And so we can work more towards the goal of, you know, trying to figure out how to deal with the people. As the city attorney aptly pointed out, so many of our regulations are created just to deal with the people who aren't doing the right thing. And it always feels unfortunate because you have the whole community coming out because of maybe a couple of bad actors. But we do, that's our job. So figuring out how to work with this the best way we can is what we need to do. So next thing, SB 1134, we know the parade situation is what it is. We know the parade situation is what it is. I had asked Mr. Orris if there's any other events that are in question. He did not believe that there are, but I think could we look into that and see whatever, what lists of events we're having that may fall into that category so that we can discuss those. And also my concern was, if that goes into effect in January, how does that affect the way we structured our nonprofit funding for the current fiscal year? We had talked about, or the last time I talked about it, is the money was going to them sort of after a period of time. Will some of these nonprofits not qualify after January for funding from us because of some of the programming they're doing. And if that's the case, Mr. Moore, I think we should distribute the funding that we guaranteed them in December for the year with the Clawback Clause city attorney in case they don't, if we have issues. But we get them the money in December so that they have it before this goes into play. And then we figure out where we're going in the next fiscal year. Because we did promise them that in the current fiscal year, and I don't want to have people expecting to receive financing and then not get it because of this new legislation. So are you all in favor of that?
Yeah, I was going to mention that too.
Okay. So distributing before January and including some kind of clawback. And lastly, when are we going to discuss publicly Amendment 3 and the ramifications to the taxpayers?
So my update information letter report this Friday will include a state legislative report. So that will take place in January. So we're working closely with Matt Forrest. We anticipate the presentation during the January 19th meeting to talk about the implementation details and what that means for Delray Beach. So we're working closely with state lobbyists Matt Forrest, ballot partners, to help us in that engagement as part of that overall. I wasn't meeting him.
I'm talking us. What additional revenues are we looking at? What additional cuts are we looking at? Because he's looking at it from a very different perspective. I'm talking about what is our municipality doing, not what is the state doing. We know what the state is doing. Palm Beach County, if you click on the website, there is a, when you go under your property taxes, there is a page on every taxpayers that tells you what we're going to lose next year, and it's about $13 million. Correct.
For the city of Delray Beach.
So I think we need to be letting the residents know that we are thinking about this and addressing it because it's going to require something from us. And, you know, we don't want it to be drastic, and we need to start planning now. I read the report that we got, and frankly, I have concerns about that report. It doesn't provide us any really new information. Those recommendations are not. I mean, some of them are so obvious that they probably didn't need to be incorporated into the report. Beyond that, there's nothing very useful. And then there's a second part of that report that you provided us that talks about how we can go to the state and ask them to implement new taxing abilities for us. Well, the state that just took tax money away from us is not going to give us the opportunity to add new taxes. So I just think we need to be doing this in the public. Look, the residents deserve to know that we are addressing this and what we're thinking about this and how this is going to impact them. I don't know how people budget years out in their life of what their plans are, vacations and all kinds of things. People need to understand if there's going to be consequences to this, what they may be, and that we're working on it.
Early New Year.
Well, January 1, we'll have the numbers, too. That's correct.
So once we get that information to prepare for 27-28, that would be an appropriate time to have that particular dialogue. I mentioned Matt Forrest a bit because we are targeting January 19th. So either January 19th, January 26th, City Commission meeting, we'll have this exercise as it specifically relates to Derry Beach. So they're distinct in many regards. However, there is a relationship between the two. But to answer the question, that's when we'll engage with the Commission publicly.
Thank you. Thank you. May I do one more thing? I want to thank our police department, our fire department, Ocean Rescue, all of the city, and Mr. Moore, you. I had a child, a young lady shadowing me today, and the city was remarkably accommodating to her, and she had a lovely day. Thank you all.
Yes, ma'am. Commissioner Byrne.
I want to thank everybody. Everybody's great. Me, too. That was so sincere.
Can you call us off by name?
Yes, everybody's great. And you mentioned that. No, listen, I love my city. I think that the city is great. Everybody does a great job. So, you know, we make mistakes every once in a while, but we get up. We fall down, but we get up. And also, Commissioner Molliker mentioned the National 26 Digital Cities Survey Award. So congratulations on that. And just, you know, just everybody, everybody does a great job, and I'm just very happy. And happy Thanksgiving.
Commissioner Molliker.
I'll be in.
That's a hard act to follow. I just have kind of two quick things. First of all, Mr. Moore, I want to thank you for the conversation that we had earlier today. I would, and this concerned the relocation of our city auditor's workspace. The only thing I would ask in the future, which we talked about, is that things that involve the direct reports of the commission and the mayor, it would be great if we could be consulted ahead of time about those moves. I am still concerned about the relocation that's planned. I would ask that you think about reconsidering it. I do, however, know your options are extraordinarily limited. But as I did a little bit of homework this afternoon on it, I am concerned with bringing her back into a very public area because she is our watchdog. And there is something to be said about privacy, and you can try to go off-site in Delray, but it's pretty hard to even go off-site in Delray to any place where you might go. So I don't know what the options are.
Could we ask Mr. Moore, why would we relocate one of our upper-level, highest-level staffer out of her office to give the office to the state rep? That just doesn't make sense. That's her office. It's her space.
Sure.
Why don't you put the state rep up near you?
Ladies and gentlemen, there was a request being made to that effect, number one. Number two, there had been past precedent in that regard. And frankly, my interest is to treat everybody well, to provide appropriate resources, appropriate spacing. The practice of allocating office and workspace environments is a rather minute and rudimentary function of daily operations. So, frankly, I was operating from that vantage point. No disrespect to anybody. I do what I can to talk and listen and strike a balance in that regard. However, this request was hit. We experienced this request based on previous precedent of state and federal elected officials having had a presence in that regard. That's the genesis in that regard.
What was the precedent? We had somebody in here who we had trouble getting rid of, I heard, because they didn't pay their rent. Right. That was the precedent, yeah. Yeah. I mean, if we're going to talk about precedent, that was the problem.
All right. Well, in one instance, I understand that's the case. And any considerations to this effect would involve a monthly obligation in that regard to be discussed at the potential next meeting. So, what I will do is consider all thoughts and points of view, and I'll do what I can to go from there. Yes, sir. Yes, ma'am.
I just think moving her out of her space for somebody who is not a city employee. There's other spaces. I'm not saying don't provide them space, but put them up near your office. I mean, taking her space away from her, I don't understand why we would take a city employee's, upper-level employee's space away from them. Thank you. That's my point.
Okay.
One more.
It's not her space.
Anyway, well, how does it not?
I'm good. I'm good. I'm good. I just have one more comment. It has to do with St. Patrick's Day. Like all of us up here, we were bombarded with calls and letters and all sorts of things, and I just want the city to know that it was absolutely our interpretation that the city could not execute a St. Patrick's Day parade. That was the data that we were given. That was the interpretation. And so we ended up canceling the city's plans. We absolutely did this only to comply with the law. There was no other reason that we did this, and if Governor DeSantis is listening, I would love the opportunity to meet with you or have a phone conversation with you to just let you know that's from the heart for me. And just to say, you know, the 6'7 guy who played basketball forever, I live by one mantra, one team, one dream. And we don't want to be off sides with the state at all. That's not who we are. It's not who we want to be. And there was lots of bad information that got out there over the past couple of days, and I would really love the opportunity to talk to the governor about it. I'll drive up there tomorrow if need be because, again, one team, one dream.
I think your phone's ringing. I wish.
That's her. She's calling to yell at me. And that's it, Mayor. Thank you, sir.
I've got a couple of things, and I'm going to make it real quick. I received a letter from someone who had a parking permit, resident parking permit. Her license plate, she rented a car, and the license plate changed or whatever it was. And she called the city to say, look, can I transfer over the thing to the new? And the city said, we don't have the ability to do that. So I'm just putting it out there so someone to look into this, because I told her I would look into it. Because if you bought the resident parking permit and your car is in the shop and you are renting a car, there's no mechanism.
We said okay.
Through the app, is she parking with the app?
I don't know.
The resident parking permit for the garage.
The resident parking permit for the garage.
Not everyone uses the app. I'm just saying, I would like to be able to get back to her. Somebody get back to me so I can get back to her what the mechanism is, because we certainly need a mechanism if someone's going to rent a car and their car is in the shop to be able to still enjoy the benefits of being a resident parking permit if they pay for it. Secondly, I want to congratulate the city on the Veterans Day event. I think it went very, very well. It was cool. And there were some very nice speeches. The Jim Bassett speech I thought was great. And I thought everyone did a great part. The last thing is I want to, I hate to quote, I'm not, but Dan Rose brought up a very good point here, and I don't know what the rule is, but what are our rules if there is a code violation? Okay, someone's got, oh, it's a fine, does this, and then they, do we pull their certificate of use? Do what do we, I mean, there really should be a way to compel people, unless they're in an appeal process, we shouldn't just be allowing them to keep the fines going on and on and on.
We have a workshop going up.
We got, so, I mean, I just, I think you made a very good point.
Just really quickly, though, we have a zoning certificate of use that when you start a business in the city, you have to get your zoning, your ZCU, and then after that, you can get your BTR. Mr. Mayo was cited for violation of his ZCU. No, no, but, well, we know what Mr. Rose is talking about, so we have that process in place. We don't do an annual ZCU. That we don't do.
No, but if you have a certificate, if you are operating a business in this town, and you've got, they've leveled a fine against you for whatever reason, forget Mayo, forget any of these. I'm talking about a legal principle here. So you, I'm operating a business, I get a certificate of use. Code enforcement comes in and says, you know, you're not doing this. We're going to fine you $5,000. Two months later, I got to apply for another certificate of use or something such as that, or BTR. Why do we renew it if there's an outstanding fine?
So we can look into an annual process for the ZCU, but remember, the BTR is, you just paid your tax to do business. No, I understand. So the BTR, we can't touch. I can't.
I'm just looking for a way for us to put some teeth into our code of force and action. We can look into the ZCU. Yes.
But we asked for this, so do we know presentation?
I'm just, these are all calls that I got this week, so I'm just, I'm just, and Rose brought it up today, sorry.
Mr. Mayor, I have one other item, if I may, please.
I'm sorry, you're commissioned, you were number, you were number A. No. This is fine. Yes.
And that is best wishes for a happy and safe Thanksgiving holiday.
All right. If there's no other business coming before the commission, we are adjourned.