Parsed verbatim from the transcript below — timestamps jump to the moment of the vote.
Tom Markert: present · Judy Mollica: present · Juli Casale: present · Angela Burns: present · Thomas F. Carney, Jr.: present
Good evening, everyone. Welcome to the City of Delray Beach City Commission workshop this Tuesday, November 17th, 2026. If the clerk could please call the roll.
Deputy Vice Mayor Markert.
Here.
Commissioner Mollica. Here. Commissioner Casale. Here. Vice Mayor Burns. Here. Mayor Carney.
Here. Thank you very much. We typically start off with public comment, but we have had a request to have the city attorney make her presentation first before we get into public comment. Is everyone in agreement on that? So, yes. Okay. So, I turn it over to the city attorney.
Thank you, Mayor. Today, my name is Lynn Jelen. I'm the city attorney. Today, I'm joined by Fire Chief Ron Martin. I don't know the new title. Janai Bowens, Director Extraordinaire, Neighborhood Community Education Services. We have Paul Weber, who's our Interim Director of Code Compliance. And we have Rebecca Dossery, who is standing in place of Anthea Giannotis from the Development Services Department. I want to thank all of the team that's here today. We have had countless meetings to go over this to ensure that this presentation addresses all of the concerns coming from the dais as well as the public.
So, let's start.
So, how did we get here? So, I've been with the city since 2016, and I feel like this has been an ongoing conversation.
Can you speak a little louder for some reason? I'm not hearing you well. Is that better?
Thank you. Better? Okay, so, you know, periodically, we've gotten concerns from the dais. I tried to do a search on Legistar, and I could tell that going back to at least 2023, 2024, we had commissioners discussing this on the dais because, inevitably, you're the ones who get the complaints about this. You're the ones who have the concerns from the people, the neighbors who receive the impacts of vacation rentals. We've had resident complaints, and we'll talk about that in a few minutes, and we've had interdepartmental enforcement concerns coming from the code department, development services, your public safety, PD, fire rescue, and legal, because we really have never really had a way to truly enforce the laws that are on the books. So, what is your staff concerned with? You know, one thing we always talk about on the dais is home rule and our ability to do what the commission thinks is best for its residents because you're in the community, and you understand what the community's needs are. You know, unfortunately, Tallahassee has the power to do preemptions, and they have the power to take away whatever home rule powers you have as a city commission, and they have the ability to prohibit certain things and allow limited things. So, we're always looking out for preemptions. I can tell you, Airbnbs have a very strong lobby in Tallahassee, and I think you all know that, and so a lot of the preemptions that we're going to talk about later are coming from those strong lobbyist groups. Your staff is concerned with no available contact information. On the weekends, on the late nights when we're getting calls from neighbors who are complaining about parties and noise and parking, because these are vacation rentals, the property owner is not typically on site, right, because they're renting out their property to tenants. And so, we don't have that ability to call a property owner, discuss the concerns we're receiving from neighbors, and try to find a solution so that we don't keep receiving the same complaint over and over again. We've had concerns about meaningful enforcement. You know, we have a civil citation process that could really alleviate a lot of the impacts, right, the garbage, the parking. Those would be easily enforced through a civil citation. We give you a ticket, and now you're on notice that this isn't okay, and perhaps you're going to, you know, stop the negative behavior. But we can't do that, because when the property owner is not there, we can't give that civil citation. And then we have problems or concerns with residential structures converting to commercial. As you all know, because you deal with our LDRs and the building code, when there's a difference between the construction of a commercial structure and there's different safety requirements that are put into commercial structures versus a residential structure where the idea is one family is living there. When something's commercial, you have to add other safety requirements to ensure that no one's going to basically get hurt, right? So I just wanted to talk about what preemption is, and I know that everyone on this dais knows what it is, but we do have a significant amount of the public that's here, and I do think it's worthy of a conversation. So what is preemption? And I kind of just discussed it. It's when the higher level of government here at Tallahassee reaches down and essentially passes a law that limits or even invalidates the authority of this commission. And when you look at 509.03 subsection 7, that's a very good example of a preemption. This preemption tells you what you can do, meaning that we can require registration, we can have these inspections, but it also tells us that if we pass a law after June 1st, 2011, we can't, that law cannot regulate essentially turnover, right? It says on there that you can't regulate, I just want to get the exact language, frequency or duration of a rental. And that's essentially the turnover, right? So Tallahassee back in 2011, they're probably doing all the things that we're going to talk about that's in that proposed ordinance. And the language that was put into that ordinance, that's called the Savings Clause, that lets us go back to the 2009, because on June 2nd, 2011, the governor approved 509.03.27b, which is that preemption statute that we just talked about, that says that any ordinance passed after June 1st, 2011, cannot regulate frequency or duration. So somebody probably sitting in the seat before me was really smart. So what's a savings clause? A savings clause is language that we put in all of our ordinances that basically saves them, right? It says, listen, if this ordinance becomes unconstitutional, it gets repealed, all the other stuff is still okay. So the stuff that wasn't unconstitutional, you can keep. And so in ordinance number 3-12, there was language put in there that if for some reason this transient residential use became somehow unconstitutional, the language that was in 2909, it reverts back to that. And that's the language that we have here today. So this is the definition of transient residential use that's in the code. You will remember that a few months ago we brought an ordinance to you, basically asking you to clean up the code. Because what was happening was our code of ordinances is basically how we put people on notice about what the requirements of the city are, the city's regulations. And so when the code isn't clear and it's not up to date, people aren't on notice, right? They don't know what the mandates are. So we put this ordinance in place, we put it before you, and all that this did was reaffirm the 2009 ordinance. And it just put that language back in there so that if anybody was coming to Delray Beach and they wanted to have a vacation rental, they could look at the definition of transient residential use and they would know exactly what our requirements are. And so nothing that has happened this year, nothing that's happened up until today, and probably nothing going forward, touches that language. It's always been the language that you see on that screen, which is turnover six times in one year. Now, I'm going to tell you that we have to be mindful of that language. And out of probably every provision in our code of ordinances that has some level of importance, I'm going to tell you that this is probably one of the most important portions of our code. Because this portion of our code is probably the only one that I can think of, that if we change it, if you direct me today and you say, Lynn, we don't want to have turnover regulations, we don't need it, we have good actors in the city, and we don't need a turnover limitation, and I do that, and you approve that ordinance two years, three years, five years down the line, if that preemption language is still in place and we have a problem, there is no going back. So there is nothing that we can do to say, you know what, let's go back to what we had, because it was actually not a bad ordinance. So it's a very heavy ordinance. You know, it's got a lot of impact. And if that's a decision today, that's a decision of this body. But as your lawyer, I just have to tell you that there's no turning back. You know, I always tell people, you know, with our jobs, except probably the fire chief and the police chief, you know, we make mistakes, but they're fixable, right? We can fix our mistakes. We bring a corrective ordinance. We bring something before you that cleans up the error, and you see that a lot. Not the mistakes, but, you know, cleaning up the ordinance and keeping it relevant. That you can't do. So if you make that change, you will never be able to do it unless somehow that preemption language is removed from Florida statute, excuse me. So today, I believe you received an email from Stephanie Elin from the chamber. And what was interesting was she had some data in there. And what the data told us is using the 1350 number from 2024 that Sammy Walthour provided to you and using the data from this software, AirDNA, that generates approximately 53,000 guest bookings a year. If you do the math, that's telling you that our vacation rentals in the city are turning over 39.26 times per year. 39.26 times per year. We just talked about what the ordinance says. The ordinance says six. So I think we know what the issue is, right? And again, if this commission says we don't really have a problem, we don't need the six, we will bring that ordinance for you to adopt. But I think it's pretty clear from what you're hearing from the emails, from the text messages, that really the concern is the turnover and our ability to enforce the turnovers. Because when you look at what the proposed changes, and these are the proposed changes in a nutshell, you don't see turnover on here. And the reason why you don't see turnover on here is because I'm not touching that. That's in the books. We're not changing that. What we're doing is we're finding ways to mitigate the impacts of vacation rentals. And it's not the well-behaved ones. It's the ones that become a problem and cause the neighbors to either call your police chief, call code enforcement, or call each of you. And what are we doing? We're designating a responsible party. We're putting in minimum life safety requirements. We're putting a posting requirement. Because if you're going to operate like a hotel, everybody knows that when you're in a hotel room and you look at the back of that door, there's a map that tells you how to evacuate in the event of an emergency. There's a phone in there, and there's information on non-emergency numbers and how you can contact if you need assistance. So if you're going to act like a hotel, then the requirements that we're proposing make you act like it in other ways except your bookings, right? There's a sex offender predator advisement, and we'll talk about why staff thought that was important. Maximum occupancy. Our proposed ordinance says that it's two people per bedroom. If you're going to have a large gathering, it's one and a half times the maximum occupancy. Why? Because we're mitigating the impacts. We don't want the parking complaints. We don't want the loud parties and the noise in these single-family residential neighborhoods. And then the garbage, right? Because inevitably, if someone's having a big house party, there's going to be garbage and the neighbors are going to complain. So let's take a deeper dive. What are the safety standards? Residential Swimming Pool Safety Act. The fence around the pool. You know, we're Florida, right? Almost all these Airbnbs have pools, right? People come down from the northeast to enjoy our weather, enjoy the sunshine, enjoy the pools. So we want to make sure that that fence is there. The Florida Building Code. The Florida Building Code has requirements that, again, go towards those minimum life safety requirements. The fire code, smoke, carbon, monoxide alarms, fire extinguishers. I'm going to venture to guess that most of the well-functioning Airbnbs in our town, vacation rentals, already have these things. This is not something that's onerous, right? But it's something that gives you the assurance that if we're going to have a registration process and we're going to have an inspection process, we're going to make sure that all of this is in there to give the people that rent these places some assurances that there is some level of compliance. The notices. So we're going to require that lessees be advised about the city's parking requirements, the trash requirements, the noise requirements. When does the noise have to be turned down? They're going to have to post a public safety non-emergency phone number. And then we talked about with hotels the map for ingress and egress in the event of an emergency. Almost did it. So the sex offender advisement. I know in some of the emails that you received that was a concern. Why are we requiring this? First of all, it's not for every property. That's number one. There's limitations, and if it's within 1,500 feet of a school, bus stop, daycare center, it's enumerated by Florida statute and our code of ordinances. So it wouldn't apply to everybody. But, you know, I even ask staff, like, why is this necessary? Like, why do we have to put this on there? The reason being is, and most people, I don't use Airbnb, so I don't have this, but when you book an Airbnb, the address is not disclosed. You only get the address when you actually confirm the booking, right? And so it's not like a hotel, because a hotel, you know where the hotel is, you know the exact location. You're not in a single-family residential neighborhood. So staff felt very strongly about it. I know that there were issues about background checks and things like that. If that's a concern, we can tweak that language, right? I don't think we're going to make somebody do a background check that's going to take seven days to get back. But I think this goes back to that statement. You know, people have a right to know who their neighbors are. So I think people have a right to have assurances that, you know, in a neighborhood where a sex offender or a sexual predator wouldn't necessarily be able to live, they shouldn't also be able to rent a vacation rental. We talked about, so more proposed changes to the application. So under the ordinance that we propose, there would be an application process. And the application is going to require, again, that designation of a responsible party, proof of licensure with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, and registration with Department of Revenue. Why? Because they're operating as a business. And so the state has a right to know that they're operating as a business and require them to follow all those requirements through the state of Florida if they're going to act like a business. Because, you know, another issue that's come up, and we've all learned so much, you know, some of these properties, and it's not, it may not be something intentional, but some of these properties have a homestead exemption on them. Right. And so, you know, that becomes an issue for the property appraiser, for the tax collector, because if you're using a property as a vacation rental, and obviously there's nuances to it, but again, you can't have a homestead exemption. And by requiring all these registrations and all these requirements, it gives people the assurances that businesses are operating on the up and up.
Could I ask a question, Mayor?
Yes, go ahead.
I, with the, some of these requirements, though, it would seem, are we assuming liability? If we're saying you have to register a sex offender, and then something happens to a child in a neighborhood because a sex offender goes there, that seems like our oversight did not work, and we are assuming responsibility. Same with the life safety plan and all these things. We're infusing ourselves into these businesses in a way that seems like, I'm not saying I'm against it, but I feel as though if we are creating rules, and then, and we're responsible to enforce them, if something goes wrong, is it on us? Because I don't, I do not want that liability.
So I think with the sex offender, it's just an advisement. So they have to post the advisement on their, on their, on their listing. So no, I don't think that puts the city in any position. And inspection's an inspection. You know, our fire department does inspections all the time. If somebody doesn't pass the inspection, they're given 30 days to comply. So, you know, I, I think that, yes, there's always a concern that the city's inserting itself, but I'll give you an example. If we go out there and we do the inspection, there's the fence around the pool, and it's there. We know it, it's there. If somebody removes that fence, that's not going to make the city liable because they made a decision to remove that fence. That becomes a liability of the property owner. And I think a lot of the things that we're proposing in this, in this ordinance are things that any good business owner would do anyway. So, you know, if you have an investment, you have a property, you want to maintain your property. And, you know, for the, some of the fees that these vacation rentals charge, I'm pretty confident that a lot of these things are being done just in preservation of their investment. So where was I? So inspections requirement, you beat me to it. So it would be Florida Building Code, Fire Code, Life Safety Requirements. Like I just said, there would be a 30-day period to correct violations. And the, the inspection would be included in the registration fee, but if, obviously, if the city has to continue to do inspections, then there would be additional cost for that.
Thank you.
Enforcement is, is really subject to the Code of Ordinances. There are penalties for failure to comply. It would be through the Department of Code Compliance. The city manager would have the ability to deny permits, revoke, or suspend them for failure to comply. The registration would be an annual registration, typically by the 30th of September. I think I said before, all fees would be established by resolution, meaning they would come before the city commission and you would determine what those fees are. They are cost recovery. This is not a revenue-generating operation. The public safety inspection, obviously, there's a fee for that. And there would, a vacation rental can't advertise without a valid permit. The code also would provide that a copy of the permit would have to be posted on the property. So what are some of the concerns that we're hearing? The city is imposing new turnover regulations. I think I beat this one to the ground. It's been there since 2009. We've only reaffirmed those limitations. Annual rentals should be regulated. We agree with you. Unfortunately, Tallahassee has preempted us from doing that, so we can't do that. The city should only require a BTR. And we're going to talk about BTRs a little bit more in just a minute. But really, a business tax receipt doesn't license somebody. It's just proof that you made a payment. So Florida law doesn't authorize us to place conditions on a BTR unless there's a statutory authorization for it. And right now, there isn't for these purposes. So what are the options? Because I don't think we should walk away without at least having a discussion about the options. We can maintain the status quo. I think in Stephanie Immelman's email today, you know, there's not a problem. You know, she's saying what we're doing is working. Well, really, what we're doing is nothing. And that, according to them, that's working, right? So we can just maintain the status quo. We can establish a voluntary compliance through a registry. And we'll talk about that in a minute. We can require a BTR for each rental property. We'll talk about that in a minute. And require a registration inspection. That's the ordinance that we just have discussed, 4126. So option two, voluntary compliance is voluntary. So there's no enforcement mechanism. There's nothing we can do to mandate that people tell us. You know, is it in a business owner's best interest to at least give us that contact information? Sure. You know, if someone's having a huge party at their investment, I think they'd want to know and they'd want the city to be able to contact them and let them know this is what's going on at your property. So I think there's some benefit to that. You know, I think that's better than just the status quo. But it's the status quo plus one, and the plus one is this voluntary registration. The registry would be maintained by the Department of Code Compliance. Keep looking at Paul because I can't say it. The business tax receipt option. So that's option three. So up until 2006, business tax receipts were known as local occupational license tax. And the legislature felt that that's really, it's a little confusing because it kind of implies that we're licensing an occupation, meaning that you're almost like vouching for the professional experience and expertise of a business, which you're not. So they changed it to a business tax receipt. And really, all that it is, it's proof of payment of your tax for the privilege of doing business in the city of Delray Beach. So it's essentially a piece of paper. It's a revenue-producing tax, and it's not a qualification for licensure. And again, it can't be revoked or conditioned without a statutory authority given to us by the legislature. You can't, oh, sorry, you can't condition it unless the legislature has authorized it, essentially. So if I wanted to say, we will issue you a BTR if you show us that you comply with e-verify, I can't do that because the legislature hasn't said that that's a condition of a BTR. So what would the process look like if we did these BTRs? So there would be an online application. We can amend the application to have the responsible party designation, name, contact information, phone, email address. Typically, when you get a BTR for a business, there's a facility inspection. I would say we wouldn't do that because typically facility inspections aren't for residences. So that would not be part of the process. We, for BTRs, we do require SunBiz documentation, which would require you to almost, like, establish yourself as a business legally. And the fee would be $190.30. So next steps. What are we looking for today? We're looking for direction. Before any implementation for whatever you decide to do, there will always be training and education. I can seek a legal opinion. I think the mayor and I talked about this. Essentially, I can get a legal opinion to determine what that times means, six times in one year. You know, is time one day, one week, one month? Can we define that even? So I can get that opinion to, again, give people more clarity and kind of, you know, make the definition a little bit more practical and realistic. I think that's what the goal would be. And anything that we do would not be done before October of 2027, if at all. So I just want to say this. The four people that are sitting here, the five people sitting up here, all the people that are under these people, every single one of us has one goal. And that goal is to leave this place better than when we got here. I've heard all of you say it. Your actions show me that. And I – maybe not you, Mayor. Just kidding. Only because you made a face. So – but I just want to be clear because I think what you have here, this is the democratic process in action, right? It's the people who care, who want to be part of the process, and who want to be heard. And that's a great thing, right? Like, we want that. You deserve that because you guys are making the heavy decisions here, getting paid the big bucks to make those decisions. And at the end of the day, there's always consequences to every single thing that we do here. Sometimes people are happy. Sometimes they're not. Sometimes we make national news. Sometimes we don't. So at the end of the day, I don't think anybody should walk out of this room, you know, thinking that they're being attacked, thinking that something is going to – nothing is going to happen today. I can tell you that much. This is a workshop. For those who aren't familiar with the process, we don't vote today. We get direction. And really, the direction could be today, don't do anything. It seems to be working. But why don't you go get that legal opinion? Because maybe there's something that we can do to try to give people more clarity. But, you know, I did some email searches because I was trying to locate, you know, more specific information. And I just, you know, Commissioner Burns, you know, the teacher up here, you're always looking – you know, she's always checking on me, right, to make sure the homework's done, right? Did you do your homework? Is the assignment ready to go? And I just feel terrible that somehow this became, like, your pet project. It wasn't. And I can tell you that the people sitting here, your subject matter experts, this is what we came forward with because we thought it would make this place a little bit better for everybody, for that balance, for the residents and the businesses. And so I want to thank the team. I thank the commission. And if you have any questions, I'm here.
I thank you very much. I'm going to ask – this is going to be time for everyone to get up and start speaking at the lectern here. You will give your name and zip code for the record. You'll each have – I think we're running really short on time. So with respect, I'd like to move the time to two minutes per person so that more people have the opportunity to speak. And if you're going to be saying the same thing as somebody just said before you, I will accept ditto and let you put that into your remarks because, you know, we're going to – I'd like to give everyone a chance to speak. With that in mind, Mr. Snyder, please come to the – give your name and zip code for the record, and you'll have two minutes.
All right. Greg Snyder, 33445. Mr. Mayor, Commissioner, it's Mr. Moore, Attorney Dillon. I'm probably going to say the opposite of most of these people. I'm speaking as president of the Lakeview Neighborhood Association, Civic Association. I just did a quick check online. I found at least three Airbnbs in my R1 neighborhood. We don't – I like this. We don't need those people in our neighborhood. As she said, you want to know who your neighbors are. Those people aren't our neighbors. They're transients. And we live in an established neighborhood where we know our neighbors, and we're really not interested in transients. Having said that, I think that six times in 12 months is reasonable, but my question is how do you enforce it? Howard, you'd say – you put up on the screen code enforcement. Okay, code doesn't work at night, so – and who's going to go over there and count the number of times that you go through it? The other problem is we have one in particular that advertises that it's a good house for loud parties. Next door to a family with children who can't sleep. And she has had the police over there that people say, okay, fine, we'll quiet down. The police leave, and they turn it back on. The last time, they called the police on her for trespassing. This – and so how do you enforce that? I like the proposed ordinance, but there's got to be a way to enforce it. Thank you very much.
Thank you. How are you all doing? Robert Slakas, 33483. Thank you all for trying to tackle this, and I appreciate you all sitting in, you know, the shoes of the people that, you know, we're like you. We live in a community, and Delray is our family, right? So, I don't know where the limitation would be on what commercial business I could run inside my residential neighborhood to make a profit. And basically, we're here today because there's unhosted short-term rentals. It's changed in the character, the safety, affordability of a residential neighborhood. The residential zone exists to support stable communities where neighbors know and look out for one another, not to operate as a commercial hotel district. In our neighborhood, investor-owned Airbnbs, you know, they bring a constant rotation of transient guests. It's led to ongoing late-night noise, some trash left on the streets, severe parking, sometimes congestion, emergency vehicle exits. Out-of-town owners face zero accountability, and I don't know any of us that would like somebody running a commercial business in their neighborhood. So, then the neighbors have to rely on overburdened police and code enforcement. So, summing it all up, obviously, we urge the city to protect the neighborhoods by banning non-owner-occupied short-term rentals, enforcing strict neighborhood caps, and revoking licenses after repeat offenders, and put long-term residents first. And thank you all for being. Thank you very much.
If I can just submit this to the record there, that'd be great. Good afternoon, Mayor Carney, Commissioners. I'm Chris McGatt, 414 Southeast 4th Avenue. My wife and I own Delray Nightly Vacation Rentals. We opened in 2023, and today we own and also manage just under 20 homes. All of them are licensed with the state, licensed with the county, and we carry a city-issued VTR license for our business. Before we invested, we asked the city where it stood. For three years, code enforcement and the planning department provided us the same exact answer. The city deferred to the state on licensing and was not enforcing the six-night turnover limit. Because of that, we invested heavily in Delray. Today, we host about 400 guest bookings a year in safe, clean, no-party, no-smoking luxury homes. We have great neighbor relations, and we've never been cited by the city. We support city oversight, annual safety inspections, and we think extending the business, the VTR, is actually a really great idea. And I expect that the city will do something like that soon, and I hope that's the case. But there is the elephant in the room, Ms. Gellin, as you said, and that is the annual six-cap turnover. It was passed in 2009. The city modified it in 2012, reinstated it, reinstituted it in 2026. But the question really is, what problem does the cap solve? A guest who stays two months and brings the same daily traffic as eight families who may stay for one week each. The city police calls the city referenced in its November 2nd presentation deck that shows 39 noise or disturbance complaints over the past five years. That's about eight a year against roughly, I think I saw, 50,000 guest days per year. Bad operators cause problems, but the number doesn't make the big difference. I'm going to have to come and ask. I'm trying to get everybody to speak. Oh, I'm sorry. That was three minutes. Yeah, two minutes.
No, I started off by telling everybody it was going to be two.
I'll just submit this, and you can catch the list.
We'll have that as part of the record. Thank you so much. Next, please. I'm sorry it was strictly enforced, but there is a long line. Oh, yeah. Okay.
Good afternoon, Mayor Carney and commissioners. Thank you for hearing me out. My name is Francis Vogler. 33407 is my zip code. I own a luxury vacation rental property here in Delray Beach. It's professionally managed. It's licensed by the state. We do not allow parties. Additionally, I'm proud to say that we actually get along with our neighbors. They know us. They know what we do, and that has not posed any challenges for us personally. Additionally, I am, again, mentioning the fact that the tourist development tax, business taxes, and property taxes that we pay on this one home are close to $100,000 a year. I'm here to support extending the business tax receipt program to vacation rentals. Totally agree with it. It does provide the city contact information, as you mentioned, for every owner and manager and the chance to expect every home. That's a part of it. But let's play this out for a second. Say you extend the BTR and enforce the six turnover cap, which is the elephant in the room. I'll keep repeating that. With ordinance 2909 still in place and the annual six cap turnover, now every one of the over 1,300 Delray nightly owners faces a choice. Register and ultimately get shut down, or don't register and operate until you get caught. Quality owners and managers, you spoke to this earlier, likely won't break the rules, but they can't survive on six days a year, so they will exit. What does that mean? What's left are the under-the-radar operators and the city that has to hire investigators and purchase software to count turnovers. You lose the good operators and keep the bad ones. That's the opposite of what I think everybody wants in the room. There's a better way, and I think it's a simple way, barring legal counsel. When a vacation rental receives its BTR, it also receives a waiver from the six turnover cap. Leave the cap on the books. Don't necessarily eliminate it, but just tie the exemption to the BTR. Three good things happen. First, every owner has a real incentive to register quickly and promptly. That way, they'll be, again, registered and also receive that exemption. Second, you complete the registration of everyone in the market, one of the major slides that you spoke to earlier, and that's been a huge challenge in Delray. Third, you get leverage. If an operator breaks your rules, and we're all for the rules and guidelines that you're setting forth, you revoke the BTR, and the cap applies again. Good operators are protected. Thank you, sir. Yep, thank you. I can leave you that, too, please.
Hi, Tommy Sedita, 33444. Just as far as the burden of regulation, that's what I have in mind. And, you know, it's been stated as far as counsel has stated the numbers of the data shows, 200 complaints in the last five-plus years, and also her belief that most people tend to be operating under goodwill. And I think the data does support that. I've been in the city for 13 years. I've been operating for quite some time. Anecdotally, you know, we don't hear a lot of issues, you know, part of the community. You know, we hear when these things occur. I'm not part of code enforcement, so I'm not privy to that information. So, obviously, you know, I'm sure that's been discussed. But what I would ask is, you know, with these rules or what's proposed, and I'm not against the rules. I operate in other cities that have these rules, and I think having rules is a positive thing. But has it been considered what some of these rules, the burden they would bring to actually to the city and the limited resources that there are, and do they make sense for the amount of complaints that we are seeing as a community? You know, you mentioned the education and the compliance and so forth. You know, do those actually line up to the problem that exists today? That's it. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Hi, Mayor Carney and Commissioners. I'm Lindsay Bennett, 33445, and I'm a realtor with Coal Banker Realty here in Delray. Last year, I sold nearly 70 homes in this amazing city, and I want to tell you about one of my secret weapons, vacation rentals. And here's how it works. Someone in Chicago or New York or even Toronto falls in love with Delray Online. Before they make the biggest purchase of their lives, they want to live here for a week or a month. They want to walk to the beach. They want to grab coffee on Atlantic Avenue. They want to find their favorite restaurant here in town. They want to figure out if this is really the place for them. So I send them to a professionally run vacation rental, and then they come back and they buy. When I make that referral, my name's on it. So yes, I'm all in on registration and annual safety inspections. I want every home I send someone to to be safe, clean, and run by people who know what they're doing. And I know it works because I live it. Curtis, my husband and business partner, and I own a vacation rental in Boynton Beach. Boynton registers and inspects every rental with no caps on stays, and our experience has been really positive. It's simple, it's fair, and it works. But the six-day cap in Delray is where I raise my hand. I've learned that the city hasn't enforced it in years, so why now? What problem is staff trying to solve that registration and inspections won't take care of? That rule was written in 2009 for what I believe is a very different Delray. Picture my buyer from Chicago. With a six-day cap, that home she wanted to try out probably isn't available. So maybe she tries Palm Beach instead, and she buys there. I also work with investors who want to own and operate great short-term rentals here. They hire local cleaners, landscapers, and contractors, and their guests fill our restaurants and shops every single night of the week. So here's my ask. Keep the registration and the safety inspections. Let the six-day cap stay in 2009. And let's make Delray the city that shows everyone else how to do vacation rentals here. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Good afternoon, Mayor Carney and Commissioners. My name is Jayden McClintock. I actually represent the Realtors Association with 94,000 members across the Tri-County of South Florida. We're the largest association in the world. I will actually leave a lot of what was just said as the points I was going to make to the benefit of people coming, staying here, learning about the city, becoming part of the community, and staying. That was brilliant as far as an active member of the community and a realtor on all sides of that argument. One thing I want to enforce, and it goes to a lot of the points that were brought up by the legal counsel, is you guys had 154,000 calls for service between the police department and other sources in 2021. You've had 200 police and code enforcements in the last five years come up on vacation rentals. That's staggering even on a one-year, right? But that was in one year, 154,000 and only 200 calls over five years. To me, that's almost nothing. If you looked at one year, 4% or less of the 1,349 vacation rentals had anything. Well, I would venture to guess probably 10 of those actually got most of the calls because they were bad actors, right? Not each one of those got one call, even if it was 4% of them with 50 calls that year. So my thing is, when you look at this, the numbers don't show that there's a massive problem. There's a few bad actors, and the bad actors should be dealt with. There should be sensible enforcement on these things. I'll leave with, I had a vacation rental in Boynton Beach. I had a different experience. It cost me over $2,500 to put a safety light for an egress light in that rental unit between permitting and having somebody professionally put it in for a $25 right. So I'll leave with, it has to be sensible enforcement of these things. While these may be commercial units, because they're being rented at a higher volume than an annual, they are not commercial businesses in practice. So be sensible with regulation. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Thank you for your time, Mayor Carney and commissioners. My name is Alan Russell. I'm reading a letter from Rich.
Your zip code, please, sir.
Army? Your zip code. Oh, 33441.
Thank you.
Okay, Rich Gascon, a Delray Beach resident who's out of state today. He sent it to each of you on November 15th and asked that it be part of the record. My request is simple. Please hold any reading of ordinance 48-26 until the data behind it has been verified. The staff presentation for November 2nd cited over 200 police and code enforcement complaints related to a vacation rentals since 2021. That figure has been the main public justification for this ordinance. So I looked into it first, the city cannot produce the complaints behind it. A public records request asked for them. On November 12th, the city replied that it has no separate file for vacation rentals. That matches what code enforcement wrote in January 2025 without a vacation rental ordinance. It does not track properties as rentals. If the city can't identify vacation rental complaints, it isn't clear how the over 200 figure was produced. Second, the police call list that has circulated has 192 calls over five years and no code enforcement records. Nothing on it identifies a vacation rental. Only 39 of those calls are noise and disturbance, neighbors, or fake calls. The rest are alarms, service calls, civil matters, and fraud. At least nine can't be tied to any property, and the calls are spread across about 157 addresses, with no more than four at any one address in five years. So even taken at face value, the conduct this ordinance targets comes down to 39 calls in five years, about eight a year.
Thank you. Thank you very much, sir. Thank you.
Stephanie Immelman, Derry Beach Chamber of Commerce. Our advocacy committee looked into this issue and asked me to read a statement today, which I've sent to all of you, so I'm going to truncate it somewhat. First of all, we do support some regulation on the vacation rentals, such as registering via the BTR process. That way you'd have the owner contact information, and it will generate income for the city, probably about a quarter of a million a year. And we also believe that safety regulations are also fair. We just want you to think about the unattended consequences for our local economy and the tourism industry if we bring it down too much. So City Attorney Jelen mentioned that we have 1,350 short-term rental properties annually. That's 53,000 bookings a year with 3.8 guests a night. That's 200,000 visitors, mostly to our downtown, that dine at our restaurants, shop at our businesses. They visit our attractions, and they support a lot of the small businesses in Derry Beach. Just think of the impact. If you had 3,000 less visitors a day, I worry that they'd take their dollars to other neighboring communities. The short-term rental income provides an important financial resource for many Derry Beach homeowners, and also if we enforce the six visitors per year, that would really have a financial impact to these businesses, but also to our local economy. The data suggests that the overwhelming majority of the short-term rentals occur without incident. There were 48 complaints last year, over 53,000 bookings, so that's a rate of approximately 0.09%. And many of the short-term rentals are booked through established platforms, such as Airbnb and VRBO, that have screening and verification process, and some of the owners also do their own screening and background checks. We recognize that the city has a responsibility to protect neighborhood quality of life, address legitimate complaints, and ensure that the properties are reasonably operated, and we completely support those goals. We would just advocate and encourage the city to carefully evaluate the data and consider the unintended economic consequences, and work collaboratively with the homeowners of businesses and the stakeholders. Thank you very much. Thank you.
My name is Ian Rodier, 33483. I listen to the realtors, and I listen to the property owners, but they weren't woken up at 1.40 a.m. this past Saturday. They weren't woken up at 4 o'clock in the morning. They don't have people going over and over and over. They don't have people going over 6 times. How about 25, 30 times? And when you live in Tropic Isle, you live on a canal. So these people are in your backyard. They're running around naked. They're drinking. They're smoking pot. They're jumping off the pylons into the water. I pay $70,000 a year in property tax, and this is what I get? No, it's not fair. And there are zoning ordinances that this is a residential neighborhood. If it's a residential neighborhood, why are we running commercial businesses? We should enforce the zoning, that this is zoned for residential, and it's not zoned for commercial. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Curtis Bennett, 33445. And we were up at 1.40 with our two-year-old last name. So I grew up in Connecticut, so New York City was the big city next door. It's also the biggest real-world test of a popular idea that limiting short-term rentals makes housing more affordable. So here's what happened. In September 2023, New York began enforcing Local Law 18, which effectively banned most stays under 30 days. Airbnb listings dropped more than 90%, from about $38,500 to roughly $3,000. The promise was more apartments and lower rents. Two years later, the Wall Street Journal reported rents at all-time highs and a vacancy rate next to nothing. Manhattan's median rent had a record $4,700 a month. Researchers at the University of South Australia studied New York and found that restrictions neither significantly increased long-term housing nor reduced rents. What did change? Hotel prices. The average New York hotel room rose to $283 a night. Visitors paid more, and their spending moved away from neighborhoods. Meanwhile, the cap has real costs here. Guests, buyers, investors read uncertainty as risk, and they take their business elsewhere. That's less spending in our restaurants, shops, gyms, and grocery stores. So I'd ask two things. Adopt registration and inspections, because they target the operators who actually cause problems. And before you enforce a cap, show us the problem that it solves and the data that says it will work. New York already ran the experiment. We don't need to run it again. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Hi. I'm Ilver Musikaif, 33444. I'm a VP of data science and from NBCUniversal. Sorry. I'm a vice president of data science and analytics from NBCUniversal. I hear a conversation here mostly around the six times cap and the economical effect of that. And I hear that the numbers are flying back and forth. People bring in like one number or another number. And as a professional, I have one recommendation for the committee. If you're going to make a decision about six times cap, please hire a professional team that would look primary impacts, secondary impacts, the Cascadian impacts. It is a big decision. It is hundreds of millions of dollars on the stake. And you need to hire the professional team. I can tell you that Delray Beach is a unique town. If you compare that with any other town, this is a booming vibro, you know, really great town. And I would compliment basically that to the committee that you were able to create this environment. You were able to create this town. Please don't break it because if you make a wrong decision, then it could basically have cascading effect and it may be negatively impacted. So please, if you're going to make a decision of six times cap, hire the professional team how basically to prepare the data and prepare the analysis and make it based on the professional decisions.
Thank you very much, sir.
Hi, Commission. My name is Jeff Wichwright, 237 C Crest Lane, 33444. I'm here about ordinance 4826, obviously. I support annual registration and life safety inspections. I want my home to be held to those standards. I want every operator to be held to them. I support removing bad actors. Responsible owners are the ones who are hurt most when a few properties give the industry a bad name. I'm asking you to remove the six-day annual limit. A cap on stays can't tell a well-run home from a bad one. A badly run house can cause trouble in just a few stays while a well-run home is penalized simply for being used. Registration, inspections, enforcement go after the real problems. Just a quick comment on the 200 number. I don't think that that is accurate and it's biased against short-term rental owners. I've filed a complaint on residents while I've been in my home. So I'm included in that number against actual residents. So I think you guys should keep that in mind. I chose Delray Beach with my family and we love it here. This was my full-time residence before I had to relocate after COVID back to New York for work. I've invested materially into the neighborhood. This is not a speculative investment. My family and I still spend two to three months a year here. In the off-season in particular, that means we're spending in Delray when many visitors are gone. We help sustain local businesses year-round, not just in peak season. I run our home through a professionally managed local company and keep it to the standard I want for my own family. As everybody else has commented on, the ripple effect goes well beyond my home. Every state generates tourist and sales tax for the city and county. It also supports the people who keep the homes running. Cleaners, landscapers, pool, maintenance crews, handymen, local property managers. I have invested in contractors, trade peoples, and suppliers and keep those dollars funding in repairs and upkeep. I ask you to think about who this really helps. A six-cap stay really only benefits the large hotel chains. Families want to stay in a hotel or in a home and they'll be going to different communities.
Thank you very much.
Hi, my name is Chris Hertrick. I'm a resident of Delray Beach, also Tropical Isle, 33483. Since 2021, I've bought 28 properties representing over 100 rental units within our city limits. Only four of these are short-term rentals. I also build new homes and currently have two projects underway. I care deeply about Delray Beach both as a resident and as someone who continues to invest in this community. I agree that property owners should be reachable, responsible, and accountable when their properties negatively affect their neighbors. So I'm just going to go over two points here because most people have covered my others. One of my biggest concerns is the potential impact this ordinance could have on property values throughout Delray Beach. When someone purchases real estate, they make a significant investment. Part of that investment is their right to use their property within the law. Every additional restriction can reduce an owner's flexibility, limit future opportunities, and potentially make a property less attractive to buyers. When you limit what people can do with their property, you risk reducing buyer demand and putting downward pressure on property values. And that concern extends beyond short-term rental owners. Changes in buyers' demand could affect other homeowners as well. Florida voters have now approved Amendment 3, expanding homestead property tax exemptions. Delray Beach's financial projections have indicated potential annual property tax revenue losses of approximately $7 million to $13 million over the next several years. Meanwhile, rental properties, investment properties, second homes, and commercial properties will not receive these expanded homestead exemptions. These properties will continue to be an important source of our tax revenue for the city. So I have to ask, at a time when Delray Beach is facing substantial reductions in property tax revenue, why would we want to discourage the very investors and property owners who continue contributing significantly to our tax base? These are people purchasing properties, improving neighborhoods, building homes, maintaining a rental housing, creating jobs, and paying property taxes without... I'll go there. Thank you.
Thank you very much, sir.
Hi, good evening. Despite the fact that I look like I'm wearing my pajamas, I live in Delray Beach, 33483. My name is Andy Kotze. I work for... I'm a realtor. I do mostly high-end luxury real estate. I work for a brokerage that is housed in Delray Beach. My broker lives in my neighborhood, so we are all not part-time, full-time. I guess the biggest problem I have from what I'm hearing, with all due respect, I mean, the Board of Realtors is here, you know, whoever's representing real estate. I live in the neighborhood, and I live the drama on a weekly basis. I have... I sold the house across the street from me a couple of years ago, and the buyer told me that he was so excited to live in this neighborhood and bring his 60-foot boat and be my neighbor, and we were going to have dinner together, and then four weeks later, it was a 1031 exchange that turned into tenants, and a lot of them, three, four times a week. So the problem is, from what I'm hearing, is the people that have spoken before me, minus a couple, are talking about the money, the investment that they're making. They're the ones that are running these businesses that have these investment homes, whatnot. But for me, I'm the one that lives across the street, and I'm a realtor, so I feel like I'm neutral. I see all sides. It's a problem for me. I don't like seeing 12, 15 cars across the street from me. I pay six figures in property taxes every year. I'm happy to promote real estate and, you know, moving all of our properties in Delray Beach. I love Delray, but I'm not really interested in people that have investment homes that need to make money. I would love to see this six times a year because, like I said, I'm six times every two weeks, sometimes every week. It's cars in and out, in and out. It's bringing a lot of overrun traffic down my street. It's a problem. And so, again, you know, I'm a realtor. I represent the city. I love Delray, but I'm not interested in all these people that only care about their pocket. I live there, and I want what's safest and what's best for my community. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Good evening. It's good to see you. Ken Edwards, 3137 Cardinal Drive. And I'm going to change everything that I was going to say. I'll say ditto to a lot of the resident comments that I have heard. The rentals in my neighborhood have changed the whole complexion of the neighborhood. I've heard multiple long-term residents tell me what's happening in the neighborhood looks just like what happened with the rehab homes. It took decades for that to be worked out. There's a place for rehab to occur. I have a heart for people. I have a heart for businesses. I bought my home in a residential neighborhood. I know what the zoning is. I have provided information on more than 10 times, and it is two or three times a week that things are changing over. Some of the things that you see in front of these houses, you can't call the police right at that time. This is not the place for high-turnover-rate rentals to occur, not in a residential neighborhood. That's what the zoning regulations are for. Business in business places and certain kind of business in a residential area, I have no problem with six times a year. But a short-term is bringing people into the neighborhood where they're not going to be treated well by the neighbors. They're not going to enjoy their time there because they're really not welcome. They don't understand that when they come. It is important to look at this six times a year. I have no problem with, but it is destroying the nature of the neighborhood. I live in Tropic Palms, and it is an up-and-coming area of the city. I would like to see it continue to be that way. Thank you. Thank you very much, sir.
Hi, Joy Howell, 33444. And if my comments sound a little disjointed, it's because I don't want to repeat too much. But what I will say is going to sound maybe just like some of the things you've heard, which is I sort of feel like most of this registration ordinance that's been proposed is a bit of a solution in search of a problem. Now, we've heard some very real problems here. And we, as responsible vacation rental owners, we want to make sure that people have a high quality of life. I just wonder if we couldn't all put our heads together and try to come up with something that's workable because I don't want these guys awakened at night either. We moved here 12 years ago. We sank our life savings into buying some old, run-down, railroad car-looking properties. I mean, these two old duplexes, some of our first. Anyway, we had a tree root growing out of the bathroom wall. We had hypodermic needles out front. We spent every penny we had making them better and making them into really nice quality luxury rentals. And I think our neighbors are happy with what we're doing, and that should be the goal of everyone, and I think it is. We support, we have annual and short-term, we support enforcing existing laws. If anybody's making a problem, noise, whatever, we want to know about it, we would support a BTR so that you could call us any time of the day. We have cleaning crews. We have, you know, maintenance people. We have pool people. We have, we support a lot of people economically in this town, and we're proud to do that. And I hope we can continue that. We're senior citizens, and we're supplementing our income. So all I would ask is equal enforcement of provisions. I've heard that there's some issues with applying it to certain sectors. I think you've got to address that somehow. If sexual predators are really a problem at Delray Beach, then the hotels ought to be checking for sexual predators when people check in, et cetera.
Thank you. Thank you very much.
Good evening. Christina Morrison, 33483. So I've listened to everybody. I've talked to some of you commissioners, and I've talked to the city attorney. I've sent you memos. This is what you have to do. First of all, our city attorney addressed these small short-term rentals as businesses. They should be paying the business tax that the rest of us pay. I have a small boutique real estate firm. There's only three of us, but I have a business license. If short-term rentals are a business, they should have a business license or whatever you call it these days. If short-term rentals are a business, then limiting them to six customers a year is kind of weird. Would you limit a boutique owner's business to six visitors a year or six buyers a year? I don't think so. So treat it like a business. The BTR is the perfect solution to finding out the details of a rental. Anybody should – you need to have the contact information for people that own the properties in our city. That only makes sense, and a business BTR would do that. In addition to an inspection fee, if you have to inspect the property once a year, which I would highly recommend if you're giving somebody the right to stay in a place, you should inspect it once a year, charge an inspection fee in addition to the business rental tax. Short-term rentals don't belong in a single-family neighborhood. They really don't. It's a business. It doesn't belong in an R1AA neighborhood. No way. So unless the owner lives in the property that they're going to rent, like they have a cottage in the back or something that they rent out, that's fine. They're on the site. They can monitor their tenants. But if they're not living there, they shouldn't be able to rent a short-term rental in an R1AA neighborhood. Are you crazy? That only decreases property values. If people have bought homes here to rent them out short-term in an R1AA neighborhood, sell them. Residences are at an all-time high in Delray Beach. They'll make a lot of money. Those are my answers.
Thank you very much.
Kimberly Chase, good evening, Mayor, Commissioners. I've lived and worked in Delray 33444 for 15 years, and for 25 years I've owned a home one block north in the Delray Beach border. Though technically in Boynton Beach, our 911 calls route through Delray dispatch first, meaning border short-term rentals directly impact your city. Whole home rentals in non-HOA neighborhoods cannot be confused with condos. Vacationers book whole home homes to invite friends for four years over 80 guest groups plus unmonitored animals rotated next door with golf carts and day and night pool parties 25 feet from my private space and master bedroom. Those open invite gatherings kept me out of my own pool for four years. Because codes did not require pool privatization or perimeter fencing, allowing 14-foot hedges to overgrow, I felt forced to isolate inside, abandon my home work base, and relocate my pool operations elsewhere. I pay residential taxes faithfully, yet local enforcement offers no relief except for clear drug or criminal behavior. Even after short-term rental laws took effect on October 1, 2023, systemic gaps failed residents. No live ad tracking. Nobody audited licenses against live ads, which still allow street parking in 2026. By September 2024, only 25 of 250 local rentals held local licensure. Inspections were missing, and non-compliant properties kept operating despite residential pleas. Weak penalties and health hazard risks. After two years of reporting on licensed rentals, unidentified vehicles, overgrown hedges, and garbage bins left out all week causing rodent issues, code enforcement issued warnings and liens instead of citations. Lanes are just a cost of doing business while rentals continue. Flood?
Thank you very much, ma'am.
Thank you.
Are there any other members of the public wishing to... No. Okay, we got one. Good.
Hi.
Name and zip code for the record.
Oh, sure. Alexandra Zetlawi, 33445. I'm speaking in front of you to ask you how much my life is worth. It's a question worth asking because you've clearly thought about how much we're all worth and made decisions. They've allowed developers to gut and pillage what can never truly be called the village by the sea again. When I look at the city, I see degradation in bold. I see myself drowning in streets that don't have appropriate drainage, and historic flooding has made that clearer and clearer. I see myself choking on pollution of what these developers are promising, the additional cars they'll bring, the death of thousands of wildlives in nature that keep these things in check. I see myself having heat strokes because our bus stops are in the bushes, the dirt knocked sideways, have no proper shade or overhead or even benches. And in New York, they're piloting greenhouse bus roofs and looking into more nature-based architecture to combat damages that have been done from years of overselling, not carrying, and rising heat and flooding threats. So I know that this sort of care in people-first governance can be done by our city officials. It is also very curious how hard the city is working to highlight their efforts to save the St. Patrick's Day Parade, which is great, but the Pride Parade has been paid dust. As another point, I do receive newsletters. The comment's supposed to be about the agenda item.
Yeah, because we're only talking about the vacation rentals here.
Sorry, I thought it said...
We're still...
That is all my... Thank you all so much. I came in late.
No, you're early.
I'm early. Even better. Wait, you guys will get a repeat.
All right, thank you. Okay, thank you. Thank you very much. Then I realized what she was here for. Okay, yeah. I didn't know what she was here for until I... In two seconds. Yes, sir. You're here for vacation rentals, right? Yes.
Just checking. Hi, my name is Lars Heldra. I live in Delray. 33483 is my zip code. I actually run a vacation rental business. Most of our properties are not in Delray. They're in Fort Lauderdale. Deerfield Beach, Lauderdale-by-the-Sea, Pompano. All cities, by the way, that have a vacation rental ordinance. And I'm all for rules and what have you. But I know a little bit about this business since I run a company. And I can tell you that it's not really the frequency that makes the problem. It's the duration. And I don't know if Delray can do anything about the duration because of what you spoke about the preemption. But if you had, say, a minimum of seven days, that would take away a lot of the problems. Because when you do have a problem, we really don't have a lot of problems because we screen people and whatnot. But I'm not going to say that there's never, ever been a problem because I've been doing this since 2008. But when there is a problem, it's usually like a two-night rental. And it's usually someone local that's coming up from Miami or someplace like that and are inviting all of their friends for a big party. The people that are coming for seven days, a family, usually with kids, and those are really the people we want because vacation rentals are really for families. They're for people that want to be in a house, not having to go out to restaurants at night that aren't even family-friendly or kid-friendly. They want a pool, they want a barbecue grill, and they just want to be left alone. And those people do not cause problems. So if there was a way in which you could do something about the duration and say it has to be a minimum of seven nights, that would work just fine for anyone who runs a vacation rental business because those are really the people that we want. And that's all I wanted to say.
Thank you very much.
You got it.
I'm assuming now that public comment on this matter is now finished. So I am going to close public comment. Well, we're after five, so, I mean, we need to have some kind of a discussion here. So, Ms. Malika, would you like to start us off?
So I am a vacation rental user when I'm going on vacation with my family because we're six, and I've always enjoyed them. And I understand, and I also have one across the street from me, by the way, but I've never had any difficulty. In fact, I sold, I'm in real estate, I sold one of them a place in Delray because they loved it so much here. But I would be in favor. I think it's very important for us to know who to get in contact with. So I would be in favor of the business tax receipt for each rental property with criteria of contact information to have for them. I'm not in favor of necessary annual inspection. I don't know if that comes with the BTR. It does not? Okay. So that is what I would be in favor of.
Okay. Mr. Markert, are you finished? I'm sorry.
Well, I just want to point out, because a lot of people said ban short-terms rental, we can't. We're not allowed. No, we're not allowed to do that. By the state of Florida. Anyways, go ahead, please. No, sir. Okay. No.
Sorry. I, like most people in this room, have used vacation rentals, and we've had really good results with them, and we've always tried to be extremely respectful. I heard a lot of things today. I took a lot of notes. And some of the things that registered with me, I do like the idea of an annual registration, and I do believe there should be a business tax receipt going forward. I do like the idea of an annual safety inspection. I think, you know, I think, like I think Lynn said, I don't think you're going to turn up much, because I think most of the owners are going to be responsible. But I do think making sure that there are fire extinguishers where we need them and making sure there's information. If there is a problem on the front door where you can call, if you call 911, you've got the address just in case you're not familiar with it. So I'm all on that. I like what one of the gentlemen said, that we ought to be thinking about hiring a professional to evaluate the rentals. I think there were a lot of really good ideas that came out today, and I think that might be a good idea. I like what the gentlemen said a few minutes ago about minimum seven days, because I do think that will get you families. So I very much like that. I would like to find out more about what our neighboring cities are doing. I think that that's important that we understand that, because we don't want to put ourselves at a disadvantage to any of our sister cities. And lastly, I don't know quite how we accomplish this, but it would be great if there was a way that when people are coming in to rent a home in Delray Beach, that we can provide them with a little bit of education, you know, about making sure there's not garbage in the yard and making sure you're being respectful. And I think education can go a long way. So those are my comments, Mayor.
Thank you very much.
Commissioner Burns.
Yes. My interest has always been to ensure that the city can identify and reach responsive property owners, these absentee owners that have properties all over the city and we can't find them. So I'm all for registration. I don't think, you know, I heard from the six, out of all the emails I received, 30, 40, 50, six people here today spoke against the vacation rentals. And I hear your concerns. And as someone said, we can't not have them. We can't regulate against them. However, I just, I don't think we have a massive problem. I think that, you know, we just have to, we don't, I don't want, I don't want to create a problem. I don't want to try to fix a problem by creating more problems. So if, if a registration and safety, you know, I'm, I'm concerned about safety and also knowing who the, the owners are so that we can contact someone in case of an emergency or in case of issues. So that's, that's where I'm at.
Sorry, what about the BTR?
The BTR, I'm, I'm for. That's, that's, that's, I think, I've got that down. I think that's what you meant by registration.
Could we pull up that slide with the four options, status quo, BTR, voluntary compliance, and then there was one other you had on there, if you don't mind.
We ordered.
Okay, so there's so much, there's so much to this topic and we needed way more time on this to have a thoughtful discussion because I think it involves a great deal more than what's really being discussed. If I would be absolutely appalled if I lived next to a house and I had to be woken up in the middle of the night every single night by parties and with no recourse. It's, it's your quality of life is completely diminished and one of the things we pride ourselves on in this city is the quality of life. Yet, we have an influx of residents who have created a business in this city and we want to support them. So here we are and how do we do that? And this is extremely complicated. I think the gentleman had a brilliant idea about the waiver. If people are voluntary, you, yes, that, yes. If that's something we could do, I, I like that idea and not because we're changing the ordinance because we can't change, you're saying it's not possible to allow a conditional waiver.
I'm happy to look into it, but when you look at the preemption statute, it's very clear that you can't have any ordinance that regulates frequency or duration. So if you're waiving something, I think that's an ordinance that's essentially addressing the variation.
So we're having, keeping it in our ordinance because we were, we, we grandfathered it in, but we're not enforcing it. We're not really capable of enforcing it and we're holding it there because we may require it if something could change in the future.
I don't think it's fair to say that we're not capable of enforcing it. I think enforcing it is challenging, but I can tell you that I've seen where it's been recently enforced within the last, you know, if you look at code, it's been enforced. It's a challenge. Right. Because you have to rely on somebody's representations when they come before the board and what they tell the magistrate. So it's not easy, but.
Right. The BTR is a way to create a database to have contact information, but it's not going to pay for itself. There's no cost recovery. It's just additional work and.
The BTR is just a business tax receipt. Right. It's $190.
There's administrative costs to us, but other than that, there's nothing back. So we do that. We get a name of someone we can call if we have a problem. But the gentleman, one of the gentlemen pointed out that in the scheme of things with the large number of turnover that we understand to be happening, there's a small amount of calls. And because when I heard 200 calls, I said, that's a lot. I don't like it. And I guarantee you there are people that are not complaining. I've gone out to homes where people said, we've complained so many times, it's pointless. We're not going to bother getting up in our pajamas, call at 1 a.m., sit and wait a half hour for someone to show up, and then figure out a solution. But what I really wonder is, if you're getting in this list in 2026, you've got three complaints on the same night at the same house, 3138 Lakeview, three times, right one after the other, and then basically it's a noise, noise, and then a civil matter. Why can't the police just – because if we're going to continue on with this, we need to ensure that our residents are having a good quality of life. Why can't the police – Connecticut, it was like breach of peace, here it's disorderly conduct. Go in and cite people. So at a minimum, if we say we don't want to destroy these businesses that these people have going on, but we need to protect the quality of life of the resident that lives there. There has to be a way to try and figure out as – and I don't think we're making a decision on this today. I don't even know if we're making a decision in the next year. But as this is happening, we need to figure out how to preserve and protect the quality of life of our residents, because I would not be happy living next to a party house. And, you know, the gentleman spoke. I think there's HOA rules that you can sometimes lean on if you're in an HOA or residential neighborhood. We need to figure out a solution, because code doesn't go out at night, right? So if you call the police, why is someone having to call three times in a row and something not happening that resolves that issue? And should it be that we do more, even if that's not the owner of the house, it's some group of people partying, to, you know, do some enforcement? And then I was just going to say, I'm not – I don't – I'm concerned about that sex offender registry part, just because I'm concerned about the liability aspect. Excuse me, that's spam. And I do think if people are saying we want to voluntarily register and we want to have someone come in and look, we do – we are going to – I was at the fire department today. It's going to require an upfront outlay of money to get us to the point where we can get into the homes and do the review of whether they have the extinguishers and all that. Not saying it's a bad thing, the fire department is very much in favor of it, but understanding at the initial outlay there's going to be funds that will need to be expended. And the last thing I was going to say is it does concern me when people say that people are operating these in residential areas where they're not properly zoned for commercial. And I think we need to really have some thoughtful discussion about how we're moving forward with this, because there's a lot involved in this, and it's a lot more than – it's a lot of decision-making on our part. So I guess maybe we start with the voluntary compliance and then look to, you know, phase in the other parts and figure out how we can make this work in our city. And then if we think we can't, then we need to do something.
Thank you. While I'm hearing – I think – well, I'm not sure what that last comment is, but I think we generally agree that the concept of the BTR is a good idea, because you will know if there's going to be a problem where you pick up the phone, you call the cops, and they'll note – and when you call the cops in a complaint, the owner of that BTR will be informed, and we will probably have to build in some mechanism. If you have multiple violations, you know, your ability to operate will be pulled, and I think that that's fair for the – I mean, you know, neighbors.
Can we do that? No, and that's kind of the issue. For the BTR, it's just proof that you paid a tax. That's why we wanted to couple it with either the registration or the inspections, because then you can have some element of a requirement of –
Well, the registration – okay, so I think we're all – because you also want to create some kind of – make sure that they have minimum life safety things, like they have a fire extinguisher and they've got a map. Right. So that's not really – That would be the inspection part. I don't – and so you could do that because I really – I mean, this is a big segment of our economy. We have a lot of people coming in and rent, and we – and the reality is most of them are probably operating well. Sure. So I think it's unfortunate we can't do a waiver. It's kind of an all-or-none thing, so –
I'm going to look into it. My gut tells me no because it is a regulation, right? It's a law. It's an ordinance. It's a regulation. We can look into it. In every area of the city?
If we can find a way to pull the licenses if they don't act correctly, then that's –
Well, that's why the permit – that's why we were doing the permit, because a permit you can pull. You can suspend it. You can revoke it. You can do whatever.
Yeah, but the rest of the elements of it were so bloody onerous to everybody.
Look, we can have another workshop, and we can tailor what it is that you like about the registration, but the registration – the turnover was separate and apart from the registration. Right. The registration is just this list of – No, I understood that. I understood that.
The registration, I don't – you know, that's going to – and the suggestion that we should actually have a meaningful study – I mean, I know we all hate having studies, but what the financial impact is of that, it would be interesting to know, because I do agree with the one person who got up there to speak, because I've used –
How could you know that, though? You'd have to know how many times they go to restaurants and all. I think that's well beyond what we need to know. It's either we're just going to continue it on.
I'd like to finish my remarks, if I could. I don't want to – I also don't want to – I agree with the advice, Mayor Burns, that I don't want to create a problem where there's not a problem, because right now – because I sat on the commission in 2012 when we adopted it. I'm the only one up here, maybe the only one in this room. No, there are some in the room that did it. But when we adopted that provision, it was a deal with a very different problem. We had sober homes. We were trying to deal with sober homes. Let's be honest. This whole thing with the numbers and the caps had to do with preventing – because insurance companies were being able to – their average stay for their tenant would be 90 days, and so we didn't want them to be able to rent, you know, because we could put – essentially trying to arrest the sober homes we have in the city. Thankfully, we don't have that problem now. It's kind of a problem in reverse now. We've got these high-end people bringing in high-end people to come in and spend money in all our restaurants, and those are not – those would certainly have not have been who we were talking about back in 2012 and or 2009. They were not. So we have a genuine issue here where this has turned into its own business. I do agree with the one realtor that said, you know, people come in and they rent the house for a week or a month and then stay to see if they like it, and then they move down here. That happens, I think, a lot more than people think. I mean, I think it really happens a lot. So I don't really want to discourage that either. So, I mean, as Commissioner Casale said, you know, this is a business that I really don't want to – that brings in a lot of revenues here. So I don't know where we are. I mean, we clearly have to talk about some type of registration, whether it's a business tax receipt or not. I don't know what the other options that we have.
The BTR can be separate from the registration. We can do baby steps and start with the BTR with the responsible party designation and just start with that.
Yeah, let's see how it works. In my view, let's see how it works with the BTR. And then – because at least it's going to give the neighbors the opportunity to pick up the phone and call and say, you know, there's something terrible going on in this house because they'll know who to call because the police will have access to who the people are, correct?
Well, we have to work on that part of it, but ideally, yes.
Theoretically, within our scope of things, an address with a BTR, the code enforcers should be able to access and call.
That's not going to come before you. So if the direction today is to start that process, we can start initiating that process. It's going to be a while.
We have to – we have to –
No, I don't think we need to. I think there's – we can use, like, a generic classification, and we can just amend the application. It's all online. I wouldn't do it, like, until October 1st. You know, it will go with the normal routing of BTRs. But I'm just saying that doesn't require an ordinance change. Like, if you give direction to us today, we can start working on that. Mr. Moore will update you on the process, but that can be done sooner.
But we should be able, through a BTR system, to at least find out some who are abusing it, correct?
No.
Why?
Because the BTR is literally just an application with your name, your tax ID number, your address, the responsible party, and that's it.
If it's operating as a business and I find out that, you know, I call that address and they're having loud parties at night, I won't be able to find out with a BTR who that person is?
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
I mean, ideally, there was – There will be the opportunity for someone to pick up the phone and say, look, this house is out of control. They're running naked in my backyard and swinging on trees and jumping in the – you know, I mean, yes?
Yes.
But just a question on that.
Who would do that? Is that the police code? The neighbor would pick up the phone and –
We would have to have a mechanism for – it's probably going to boil down to police. Because, like you said, code doesn't work those late hours, and this is all happening in the late hours. It would have to be police. We'll have to find a way to integrate both systems so that police can have access to that information, and then they can address it by contacting the property owner.
And I'd like to – I mean, whether the BTR price is the right price or whether there should be a separate category, I don't know. I don't know that. I do – I think all of our BTR prices, by the way, need to – we haven't changed those since – 2018. Yeah, since – yeah. I mean, it's been almost 10 years. We haven't changed any of those. So those we clearly have to look at, generally speaking.
That's complicated, but if you direct us today, we can start the BTR process.
Well, that would be my – Is there a consensus? I'm going to do this in baby steps. I want to see if this can at least address some of that. I don't think this is going to be the last time we have this conversation. I just don't think it's going to be the last time we have this conversation.
So there's consensus for the BTR with the responsible party designation. That's it.
Yes.
I think we all – we've all agreed on that. Yes? Yes. I'm just trying to get where we all agree on. That one thing, okay. So there's three of you for that.
Okay.
All right. So that's – is that what we agreed to? That's how we're going to start this process?
Yes. I mean, I think – but so explain – the BTR could potentially give you some information from – for your registry. What additional information would the registry look to acquire?
Well, the registry is what's going to trigger the inspections, the safety issues. Okay. That's what the registry is going to do.
Isn't there a zoning certificate of use that goes to the BTR and could not – and require a –
We had that discussion. The zoning certificate of use really just looks at zoning, and so – and that would – right. I mean, I don't think we need to go that far. I think the BTR in our discussions was sufficient.
Well, then, if we're all in agreement, that's your – that's the direction for tonight. Perfect. And, Mr. Boyd, did you want to weigh in? Yes, I do. And that is simply – I'm trying to dabble us.
Of course. That is simply a commitment to offer an update in the coming weeks in terms of how the BTR registration process for vacation rentals will be structured. Perfect. I will offer a written update to you all in the coming weeks. Okay. As I work with the respective departments, given the direction having been offered this evening.
Thank you. Commissioner Casale, you had one more thing?
Yeah.
I'd just like to ask if we could also get a consensus, Mr. Moore, to just discuss with our police that we know – I think the police, because they're all on the same route on a regular basis, know which homes are vacation rentals that are giving us problems and which maybe aren't. And we need to figure out a way, as we traverse this, to, again, just make sure the quality of our life. If we have a persistent offender, we need to know that and we need to figure out how to address that as we're trying to take these small steps towards figuring out how we're dealing with this.
Code enforcement doesn't lose its right. If you have someone that keeps doing – go in there and – They're not up at night.
We can always – we can always regulate the impacts. Noise, garbage, parking.
Because the noise should be a factor in a neighborhood. That's correct. There's noise, inappropriate behavior, naked and drunkenness. I mean, all this stuff.
So, Commissioner Casale, I'm already way ahead of you. I made a commitment to work with leadership of the Delray Beach Police Department accordingly with the support of residents making calls, bringing matters to their attention that may have not been offered to date. Nevertheless, so be it.
Thank you.
I appreciate that.
This is like a Ginzu knife commercial. Wait, there's more.
Go ahead. Wait, but wait. There's more. I just want to point out that it's not always vacation rentals. I have a neighbor that constantly gets the police called. I don't call them because I can't hear them, but my neighbor does. And it's constant. So, it's not just vacation rentals.
We're going to deal with those other people at another meeting. And I dance too. Unless there's anything else, we're going to reconvene at 545 for the regular meeting. Thank you all for coming tonight. Thank you all for your input. And we are adjourned.