and state your name and spell your last name for the record you will have three minutes to speak on a subject that is not on today's agenda seeing no one come forward do we have any e-comments no we will move to the next item item 4.1 recommend adoption of resolution 26-21 of the city of clearwater opting out of providing the 80 to 120 missing middle property tax exemption to developments that would otherwise qualify pursuant to the live local act for calendar year 2027.
mr dylan mayu will present this item good morning dylan mayu i'm the housing manager the item before you is a resolution to opt out of the live local act missing middle property tax exemption for calendar year 2027. under state law qualifying rental developments with 71 or more units serving households earning between 80 and 120 so only workforce this doesn't apply to 80 percent and below units of area median income may receive a 75 percent property tax exemption however the law allows local governments to opt out when there is a documented surplus of affordable and available rental housing in between those those amis those area median incomes the most recent shimberg center report identifies a surplus of approximately 6500 units within the tampa st pete clearwater metropolitan statistical area making the city eligible to opt out this year there was a change to the local you you would have had to have that surplus for three years which uh which there has been a surplus per that report for three years for the msa the res this resolution would apply only to the city's portion of property taxes it would not affect exemptions for units serving households under 80 percent um area median income or below the resolution requires a two-thirds vote of council and would be effective for one year beginning january 1st 2027 staff is requesting your recommendation to council with that i'm happy to address any questions so you said this only applies to workforce housing like designated workforce housing this only applies to the units that uh restricted between 80 and 120 percent workforce is kind of the the term used for those units okay i studied the 2025 report and
it's pretty shocking that the zero to 30 ami we have like 60 000 shortage yeah there's and it's a it's
an important distinction um so under 80 percent especially the third zero 30 very low income uh huge deficit with that with that type of housing um and for those families uh above 80 to 120 which have a surplus i think i want to say last year which would have been the report from 2024 it was 4 500 and now we have a around six thousand dollar surplus we've seen a big gain um on workforce housing affordable still
a challenge it would be really nice if they could divide hillsborough pasco and pinellas because they're very different all three pasco has tons of land to build and we don't yeah so it's kind of apples to oranges but we've we've done this before we did this last year right correct are there any
more comments or questions from the board does anyone from the public wish to comment on this item do you have any e-comments hearing no further public comment may i have a motion motion do i have a second second all in favor aye any opposed motion carries 4.2 recommend city council approve the city of clearwater's fiscal year 2025 26 is that correct 25 26 okay consolidated annual performance evaluation report mr dylan mayu will present this item i'm just waiting for the powerpoint to come up oh it is okay um
again dylan may i'm the housing manager today i'll be presenting our consolidated annual performance and evaluation report this is essentially you know this is a this is a beast of report staff takes um a lot of time and uh an effort to put to put this uh this report together and um it gives it's kind of a report card for the the previous year so it's a it's a great way to kind of end the year we can see what we did right what we what we need to work on as we go into the next year um so what is the caper measured it does measure uh so so every five years we put together a consolidated plan out of that every year we put together an annual action plan um in the annual action plan we put together a list of goals you can think of them as like kpis um so we can measure you know how how much progress that we've made against what we uh what we estimated um it also it also demonstrates uh how much of the funding we spent um that we had budgeted some of the some of the funding we budget uh knowing that we're not going to spend it all but we still budget we still have to budget it nonetheless um and it also provides residents and city council with uh with not only our results but also where our priorities were last year and then going into uh the next year so this is a good slide here it's just kind of a macro view of um of what we did some of the more important numbers so we we spent 4.17 million last year between cdbg home and uh and ship dollars um out of that we we created uh five uh units housing units three rental and two owner occupied homes um as you'll see kind of further down the presentation um there are additional units that were created however because we didn't utilize federal funds um they're not counted in a lot of these numbers but we still add them in there to give you guys a better macro view of what's actually going on because remember the caper is just for federal funds so all we're reporting you know in this in this is our federal funding accomplishments however we do in the narrative section of the actual report we do add in um some of the accomplishments that that that we did um utilizing our ship dollars or other local dollars um part of the report does provide some uh demographic data um part of that is i like this this information because it really shows what's needed here in clearwater specifically when compared to the rest of the state we are higher in both cost burden and severely cost burdened households um you can kind of see the numbers there so there's there's absolutely a need for affordable housing and and for the work that we do um this is a a slide that that that spells out our resources and expenditures so for cbg um we had 1.8 million uh almost 1.9 million budgeted we spent 1.19 million of our home dollars we had 5.39 million we spent 1.8 and ship we had 1.33 million which we spent 1.17 and this is a great slide because it really gives you an idea of how our funding works so um home dollars you may ask well how can we only spend was that maybe 40 percent or a little bit less than 40 percent um of of what was made available home dollars are are unique in that you can stack those dollars up over multiple years so we may get around 400 000 a year and where cdbg we have to spend the majority of the funding that we get in a year within a couple of years home dollars we get to save up over seven years we have to spend the allocation within seven so we don't expect to actually i mean it'd be great to expend those dollars all out in one year but really that that's kind of our our piggy bank that that we utilize for larger projects that require millions of dollars worth of subsidy um with both home and cbg and there's more in the presentation about this but they were both affected our ability to fund projects services improvements to public facilities was affected by the government shutdown last year we usually get we just got our agreement with hud a few months or a few weeks ago rather and last year i want to say we got it in late january so we actually didn't get to get started um until february i think maybe even going into march with some of our our projects and services so that kind of hurt some of our our funding ability um so part of that consolidated plan that five-year plan that overarching strategy um you know we have seven categories program administration housing homelessness non-homeless special needs community development economic development and then emergency and disaster and that that last one there is really only utilized um if we have a natural disaster or something to effect we have strategies in our plan to utilize ship dollars for that so this gives a a breakout of our accomplishments when with regard to housing um so new rental units we we met our goal and again bear in mind this is this is a scorecard specifically for federal funds so the next slide will actually show um a little bit more in depth as far as what we did for housing including our ship dollars but for new rental units uh we our goal three out of three new homeowner units two out of two um we completed seven out of nine uh down payment assistance loans or homeowner assistance um and then with uh rental assistance rapid rehousing so this is our tiber program tenant-based rental assistance we exceeded our goal of 65 we hit 95 units with rental rehab units and homeowner rehabilitation units we did not utilize any federal funds for um for those activities however um with ship dollars we completed uh 11 owner occupied rehabs so that puts us at i put it in here i think 220 percent of our goal and uh purchase assistance loans an additional 10 to that seven so it puts i think 17 total um at 189 of our goal um we also did uh a roof over at community service foundation that supported seven units rental units um so we hit seven percent 700 of our goal with uh rental rehab um so we completed two single-family homes this year the actual the one that's that's pictured here um was a uh no funding was utilized uh however the city did donate the the property so this will be it's kind of a unique project we're getting it at 80 to 120 it's hard to get 80 to 120 percent ami single-family homes um but this one will be restricted 80 120 for 15 years done by a new developer um like i said he utilized his own funding um we just donated the land um clearware gardens you know we've we've seen this one pop up for multiple years now we can only count the accomplishment once uh the actual uh final user is is in place um which which occurred this year so uh with this with this property we we supported three units utilizing home dollars those federal dollars and then three units uh with the ship dollars and of course the this was a litek deal so they needed our funding for this project to go forward they needed our support for this project to go forward um so out of from the macro view we actually got 81 units there this is is another unique one uh when um chuck and i had initially gone through the uh the inventory i want to say in 2023 we looked at this lot and we thought it's impossible it's not possible to build anything here it's it's an odd shape it's it's really it's not deep enough um we had one of our partners csf came in um they they wanted to do something unique they used steel insulated panels or sips to build this home i think a couple of police officers actually you know rose the home in a few days using those uh those materials but this went to a homeless veteran and their family um and so this is a cool again not part of the report because it's it's not we didn't utilize any federal funds but i think important to share homeless service and services and facilities so we got hit pretty hard as far as the the shutdown we weren't able to start funding um those services and facilities projects and as a result they were they started utilizing other funds prior to ours and worked to finish out those funds first so some of our services were well below the goal they also utilized a lot less cash as you can see from that cv that that funding um to allocation slide we just didn't utilize as much cvg because we started uh maybe three to four months later than usual um but some of the things we did finish so uh hep they uh we redid the uh renovated the kitchen and dining hall it was really tired in there before and now they have a nice clean space for for their community kitchen um willa carson we um the office space there along with a bathroom and their flooring was redone and then lift which is a neurodivergent school um received a new playground that actually looks really good so now it was not as easy i think a lot of the parts had to come from overseas and it just took a lot of time to piece that one together but that one is finally finished uh and this is a good example of of why we're behind so projects uh public facilities that are still underway essentially every project from uh 24 25 i'm sorry 25 26 um none of those closed so we're still underway um some of those have been finished since we closed out the year so um directions for living their stairwell and doors i think it was like 120 something doors pretty big project um that's completed and um i know we made some headway on some other ones there and we're still waiting on a few things but uh the generator for maddie williams is backlogged for i think they said 300 days i mean you know what are you gonna do um special needs this one uh obviously is an outlier um you know we served the sub-recipient served 226 uh persons our goal was 48 this was a new program um so the only real explanation is they just underestimated the the need for for the service so we hit about 470 of that goal um again community development uh this is where you'll see the the public uh facilities it's low because we didn't close any of our our deals from last year we're still backlogged on those so uh next year's caper will look really good but unfortunately that uh government shutdown really pushed us back um other public services so this is this is non-low income um we didn't have any any we didn't fund any public services that that uh support any non-low income um so we didn't hit any of our goal there and then we do we do budget a small amount i think it's around 60 000 65 000 for uh demolition this is for demolition of of something that would be considered slum and blight um i want to say maybe we have an application in for those funds but we haven't that hasn't closed yet so um so we did not uh demolish any buildings last year um same kind of issue with economic development due to starting late um our partners really only utilize about a little less than half of their uh allocation um they still did serve about 20 businesses out of the 33 which was the goal they they served an additional 17 however they did not uh qualify income wise for the funding so they were at 37 businesses in clearwater but 20 were funded by our cbg dollars facade improvement program this one's been a tough one to get off the ground we've been working on it for years uh at this point we've had multiple consultants our legal team has helped us through a lot of it last year we completed the program we feel confident that that it's going to be a strong program however we still have to put together the agreements and figure out the the legal on all of those we um we do have that in after running the program we we figure out that our first application that's been the pipeline for a while now unfortunately will not qualify due location um so we have two other applications that we're working through i think one is almost approved and we should be breaking ground here in the next few uh the next month or so a couple weeks or a month um this is a good graph here it shows where the dollars were actually invested um so citywide obviously that that's the biggest uh piece there but we actually this is i think this is unique we actually we actually invested more in lake bellevue this year than north greenwood um or last year when i say this year i'm in 25 26 last year and then downtown gateway uh took the smallest share um so kind of what i've been going over you know federal timing that was that pushed us back um also market pressures it's been more challenging to get deals to pencil out interest rates insurance um interest rates if i could say that over and over again it's just hard to get people to qualify and then also uh construction costs and everything else frank's shaking his head because he knows it's it's it's tough um but we still did i think we still did really well considering so um yeah and then capacity and everything else i mean we're we're uh we're going as fast as we can one thing i'm really proud of is um you know in our most recent audit we had zero findings um which as you all know up there this is an extremely complex business there's a million moving parts so to have no findings no concerns nothing it's it's quite the accomplishment team deserves all the recognition there um and then some other numbers that i thought were really interesting 66 000 home labor hours um so that's how many hours um were utilized in our projects um and of that 28 000 section 3 worker hours so our priorities for next year we are going to um we are making a headway on our on our public facilities so we're going to plan to close all of those projects none of those should be outstanding next year um from 25 26. um affordable housing so we have a 24 unit uh townhome project between habitat for humanity and tampa neighborhood housing services we are funding that entire deal like all those units will count so we'll have a pretty robust caper next year um but that should close we're hoping for next by the 15th of next month um we're on track for that we're obviously going to continue our home buyer assistance um and rehab programs our rehab program was shut down for or pause not shut down for several i want to say six months of last year mainly because you know the the ship allocations were coming in slower ship allocations come from uh dock stamps so with less transactions in the state less dock stamps that means the money flows a little bit slower um but we are reopened we are processing applications out of quite the pipeline i think we have six or seven in there now um the facade program you know one thing we are we are going to institute is a timeline some deadlines for the application um that will help things kind of flow through a little bit more efficiently um you know if we don't receive the documentation that we need within an appropriate timeline then we'll move to the next application um one thing that that we realized was you know i think we're going to look at projects specifically the public services maybe four to six months in and reevaluate you know does this need to be amended as far as goals are they spending the money um you know as efficiently as they assumed when they when they first made their um their application for the funding um and then of course we'll continue to monitor and uh keep up with compliance so next steps today you'll be recommending uh you'll provide a recommendation to council public comment for the the report is open until november 29th this report is public um is uh is publicly available on our website also it's available at our office um or we can also email it over by request um and then on december 3rd we'll be taking this to council um as a public hearing for final approval and that i believe is due uh by the end of the year we're hoping to get it in a couple weeks early you don't like to wait in the year to submit it so with that that's our that's our report card for the year um i'm happy to address any questions i'll just say well done good job and i'll say uh dylan i
want to congratulate you and your staff number one for zero findings that's always uh plus that means that uh compliance is being done the way it should be and um and and governance and oversight is being done the way it should be um also for the impact that you've had despite the um the delayed start through no fault of your own uh for me when i see a a slow year or low numbers in one year i know to expect higher numbers the following year you know there's generally reasons for that there's you know a lot that goes into pre-development before a project actually comes out of the ground um you know project is pregnant for nine months before it it delivers kind of thing um so just want to say kudos to you and your team and then um we've noticed that our organization an uptick in calls from people that are um in default with their uh mortgage and and in foreclosure and i just wonder if um if you're
seeing any of that uh on your end or your staff you know i've heard that um and i i believe we've i believe we we have a um i'm not sure if it's a program through a local church or someone else we don't have any any kind of um like mortgage assistance program put together yet but something something we could look at um i know there's there's a local non-profit that that assists with that kind of thing i think a couple of months worth of mortgage payments um but yeah if you ever have anyone
obviously send them over to us and we'll do our best are there any more comments or questions from the board does anyone from the public wish to comment on this item are there any e-comments hearing no further public comment may i have a motion motion second all in favor aye any opposed motion carries thank you mr mayhew do you have anything additional to report nothing further no do any board members
have any final words before we adjourn i do i just have an announcement to make uh dylan mentioned the lake bellevue townhome project and tomorrow morning at 9 a.m at 1454 south mok we will be having a groundbreaking event of the lake bellevue townhome project which is a 24 unit mixed income affordable housing development it's a joint development project between habitat for humanity gulfside as well as tampa bay neighborhood housing services 12 of those units will be reserved for families below 80 percent ami and the other 12 will be for for workforce housing or families between 81 and 120 percent ami that project or that development is a product of the work we do here on ahack and they have it's also a product of the collaboration between the city and the county bringing funding together and two affordable housing developers also coming together to meet all of us collectively to meet the needs of clearwater residents if you're able to make it tomorrow morning at nine please come out and support the project and i look forward to seeing
you there this concludes our business for the day our next nahab meeting is scheduled for january 12th 2027 says 26 on here thank you everyone this meeting is adjourned good morning today's meeting of the affordable housing advisory committee the city of clearwater is called to order on this day november 17th 2026 welcome everyone agendas of today's meeting are at the entrance to the meeting room on a chair somewhere back there please remember to turn off your cell phones to ensure a complete record of the committee's actions we ask that each individual wishing to speak clearly state your name and spell your last name for the clerk we ask that you limit your comments to three minutes at this time i would like to ask the board members to introduce themselves and state the fields you represent starting from my right
that would be me good morning clearwater council member mike manino michelle chenault community
development board good morning sharisa dody affordable housing frank cornier development and
construction of affordable housing christine bond low-income residents sean austin citizen representative and i'm robin field the board chair and i represent uh affordable lending as it uh as it relates to affordable housing i can never remember that this is the fourth and final meeting of this committee for 2026 i thought we had a great discussion at our last meeting i know we have a lot to discuss today so let's get right to the agenda our first order of business is to approve the minutes of the committee's meetings on october 13th 2026 may i have a motion to approve so moved is there a second all in favor all right any opposed minutes are approved the main item on today's agenda is to continue our
discussion led by connor baird of way trim mr baird the floor is yours thank you is this on okay um good good morning uh welcome to our final um meeting and our first in the new chamber so uh just as important as the first um again my name is connor baird with way trim working with the city to update the local housing incentive strategy for 2026 um so i'll go over our schedule again um we are currently at our november 17th um 2026 meeting um and where we will um look to approve the updated lhis report that we have updated in our past meetings our next meeting will be well not our next meeting but after this meeting um the lhis will go to city council um after that it will be submitted to the florida housing finance corporation and that meeting will be on december 3rd our meeting schedule a recap of our meetings um again this is our fourth and final meeting um we had meetings on august 11th september 8th october 13th and finally today november 17th um to recap our value principles and vision um and i'll go over these just so that we have them into the record one last time our affordable housing values are a supports a dynamic and competitive economy b improves social well-being and builds sense of community c aspires to have housing that fits the city's residents and b everyone deserves a safe affordable home and there was no updates to any of these values we continue the affordable housing principles are one affordable over the long term two diverse supply that provides for a mix of income levels and the diverse needs of residents three designed to be sustainable energy and cost efficient to minimize physical barriers to accessibility four an aesthetic character with the surrounding neighborhood five strategically located and pedestrian oriented with access to mass transit open spaces educational institutions and employment or workforce training opportunities and finally number six incentivize to promote incorporation of affordable housing into all housing developments and again these were all continued with no updates and finally the affordable housing vision reads as the city of clearwater will incentivize the development of a diverse supply of housing that is safe accessible affordable sustainable and energy and cost efficient that blends into the aesthetic character of all the city's neighborhoods proximate to public amenities and employment opportunities which promotes an inclusive community community and the diverse needs of residents and finally there were no updates to this as well so our strategies that we went over um over our past couple meetings uh there were 11 florida mandated uh florida mandated by florida statute um incentive areas and then um five additional a hack initiated incentive incentive areas um that were continued um some of our discussion in our last meetings identified some incentives and barriers um that we wanted in the 2026 update number one was a lack of affordable housing supply which was seen as a barrier number two land use and zoning regulations minimum lot sizes and mdr corner lots was also seen as a barrier three properties delayed in lhitc which are also seen as a barrier real estate taxes and insurance costs for home ownership renter cost burden fees and utility costs lack of subsidized housing for low income seniors and then finally one incentive uh was the adus and missing middle housing and the um update to our recommendations that uh we went through over our past couple meetings um to recap uh there were again 11 incentive areas five incentive areas by the um affordable house advisory committee 34 total recommendations two incentive areas with no recommendation um many are many of them were implemented or in progress and then our 2026 changes uh we continued 32 of those recommendations and modified two recommendations which was recommendation 6.2 and 10.5 and we'll go over those here recommendation 6.2 was our first modified recommendation related to parking reductions and and that is to continue to tie reductions of off street parking requirements to proximity and access to alternative modes of transportation including transit sidewalks sidewalks trails or other options for affordable housing developments and special needs populations and we included uh that final little uh bit of the sentence there second our second and final um modification was uh to recommendation 10.5 relating to inventory of public lands where we removed the reference to partnership with the green print 2.0 timeline and those were the only two modifications that we had to the 34 recommendations um and so now i will hand it over to you all um to discuss and vote on the lh is report but you have to give me power back when you're done so that's another update does anyone on the board have any questions or comments
pretty quiet yeah does anyone from the public wish to speak to this item if so please step to the podium you will have three minutes to speak do we have three minutes to speak do we have any e-comments i will now close the public
comment period mr bear you are back i will turn it back over to you uh to vote on approving the lh is
report for the 2026. move to approve the lh is recommendation report second all in favor hi any opposed thank you very much
good i was worried i'm sure you were um all right thank you um for uh your participation and uh the vote our next steps as i mentioned earlier uh the next step will be uh taking the um approved lh is report to city council on december 3rd 2026 um that will be at 6 p.m um in the new council chambers here at clearwater city hall at 200 south myrtle avenue if you have any questions uh you can contact dylan and he will um forward any to me that needs to be to me and respond to any of your comments and that is the end of our our meeting today so thank you very much to all of you for um working with us and and
getting this done thank you for all the work that you and your company do we appreciate you absolutely okay uh citizens to be heard regarding items not on today's agenda is there anyone here to speak to items not on today's agenda if so please step to the podium and state your name and spell your last name for the record you will have three minutes to speak on a subject that is not on today's agenda seeing no one come forward do we have any e-comments i will now close the public comment period and i'd like to ask if there are any final comments from committee members uh i just have an announcement i may
have made this announcement at a previous meeting but tomorrow morning at 9 a.m i invite you to join me for a groundbreaking event at 1454 south mlk here in the city of clearwater it is the groundbreaking of lake bellevue townhomes a 24 unit mixed income affordable housing development it's a joint project between habitat for humanity gulfside and tampa bay neighborhood housing services 12 of those units will be for families below 80 percent ami the other 12 will be for families between 81 and 120 percent ami this project this development is a product of the work that we do on this committee as well as the nahab committee it's also a product of municipalities coming together to fund affordable housing development projects so both the city of clearwater and pinellas county have funding into this development and it's also a product of two affordable housing developers collaborating together to meet the needs of clearwater residents so if you are able to please join me tomorrow morning look forward to seeing you at 9 a.m 1454 south mlk lake bellevue townhome groundbreaking
thank you thank you lastly i'd like to ask dylan mayu if he has anything additional to report to this
committee um i just want to say thank you all i know this is time consuming and it's not the easiest thing to get to on a tuesday morning and sometimes they're two three hours long so i really appreciate it this plan really does uh make an impact to the community and drives and directs our our strategies and funding so thank you so much i appreciate it and i would like to thank all my fellow board members
the staff and the public for their input in this process i'm excited to see clearwater progress its affordable housing inventory over the next year this meeting is adjourned thank you