True Crime Vault: House of Cards

[0:01] Welcome back to the 2020 True Crime Ball. [0:04] I still feel the murder in the house. [0:13] We had a 74-year-old woman killed. [0:17] A 35-year-old woman killed. [0:20] Somebody needed to tell their story. [0:23] The blood, a lot of blood all over the mother and the daughter. [0:28] Angel and mom were definitely a package deal. [0:30] Why would you murder two innocent people? [0:32] Two innocent women. [0:33] We have an extremely psychotic, taunting killer who is taking pleasure in the homicide. [0:40] Who is taunting the police and writing this letter. [0:44] About 1230 or so, I got my knife and did the dirty deed. [0:48] What a rush. [0:49] Don't bother checking for prints or DNA. [0:52] I'm wearing a body suit and gloves. [0:54] And then a second letter came in. [0:57] I write to you again. [0:58] I must confess, I have done it for a second time. [1:02] And we had a killer, apparently, who was traveling the country. [1:07] The two letters sent by the killer made it pretty clear. [1:09] He's not only one step ahead of the cops, but the murder spree isn't over. [1:42] It starts on Friday night, the 4th of July weekend in Norfolk, Virginia. [1:47] John Schraft is a rookie officer working a weekend shift. [1:50] It's about 1.30 in the morning, patrolling the East Ocean View area, driving around. [1:58] I was by myself doing normal routine patrols in that area when I got the call from dispatch [2:05] to respond to Fryden Street. [2:09] Okay, is there any serious bleeding? [2:12] Yeah. [2:13] Okay, I need to answer my questions. [2:14] Is there any serious bleeding? [2:16] The victim keeps hanging up. [2:23] The 911 operator keeps calling her back. [2:25] Is anybody there with you? [2:30] Nope. [2:33] It could be anything. [2:39] An accident, burglary, much worse. [2:43] As I'm approaching the steps, I can see that the interior front door is open and the screen [2:54] door is shut. [2:56] And I can also see that there's a light on inside the residence. [3:00] In front of him, there is the faded, sort of beige oriental rug on the floor. [3:06] And there is a lot of red, what he takes to be blood. [3:11] And he sees an older woman on the floor, on the rug, next to a foam that appears to have [3:17] blood on it. [3:18] Immediately drew my weapon, opened up the front door, walked in, asked the elderly female, [3:30] is there anybody else in the residence? [3:33] She said, my daughter is in the bedroom. [3:36] I looked around. [3:37] My main concern was, is there the person that did this, is that person still in the residence? [3:44] Definitely nervous, but your adrenaline takes over for the situation at hand. [3:49] The lady that was apparently called 911, her name was later determined to be Vonda Goyena. [3:58] And she actually was 74 years of age. [4:04] This woman has been stabbed multiple times and her throat has been slit. [4:07] So, when the elderly female said, my daughter is in the bedroom, and I took a couple of steps [4:13] towards the bedroom, walking down the hall. [4:15] He knew what he was going to find, a second victim. [4:24] See that she was clearly deceased, covered in blood, laying naked, face down on the floor. [4:33] She was later identified to be Angelique Goyena. [4:37] She was 35 years old. [4:39] Within the blood-soaked bed, you have this heartbreaking image of her childhood teddy bear, also soaked [4:48] in blood. [4:50] It is an image that is hard to forget. [4:53] They've already checked Angel's room. [4:55] Now, they have to go through every other room in the house, the closets, the kitchen, to make [4:59] sure that the killer is not still inside. [5:02] Detective Walter Whiteside arrives just minutes later. [5:09] Unfortunately, I've been to a lot of homicide scenes. [5:12] It was probably one of the worst. [5:14] That room literally just looked like something out of the movies. [5:17] It didn't even look real. [5:18] Very rarely do you see a scene that gruesome. [5:24] It was very clear that she had more stab wounds than what you could possibly count. [5:31] I think it ended up being over 37, 38 stab wounds. [5:36] There was just no rhyme or reason to why the amount of injuries were inflicted on the victims. [5:42] Still hear Vonda calling out for Angel. [5:48] She kept asking me how Angel was doing. [5:51] And, you know, if she was dead, if she was okay, it hits home. [5:56] It does. [5:56] You try to separate yourself from that. [5:59] But I've got three children. [6:01] So, you know, you do kind of empathize. [6:04] You have to as a human. [6:06] It's horrific. [6:07] And he's starting to realize how many times that she's been stabbed. [6:12] He knows at this point he doesn't have a lot of time. [6:14] As EMTs work, Whiteside steps out to call a homicide detective who tells him what has to happen next. [6:21] He asked me at that time to do a dying declaration. [6:25] So a dying declaration is a legal term. [6:28] Now, normally somebody has the right to confront their accuser in court. [6:32] This is the exception to that. [6:33] The accuser is actually dead. [6:35] So, with their last breath, it's presumed to be the truth. [6:40] A dying declaration can be used in court, but there is one rule. [6:44] The person has to believe that they're going to die when they give you the statement. [6:48] And then, ultimately, they have to die. [6:51] Normal human compassion is to just tell everybody, oh, you're going to be okay. [6:55] Keep fighting. [6:56] We're helping you. [6:59] It's completely counterintuitive to look at someone and tell them, you're going to die. [7:05] Basically, there's no hope. [7:07] You're not going to survive this. [7:10] For them to tell you their last thoughts is, this is who did it to me. [7:16] That's very powerful. [7:18] Walter Lucas, she says. [7:21] Walter Lucas. [7:23] Two women stabbed to death inside this Freedon Street home. [7:32] Tonight, Norfolk police are looking for the person responsible. [7:35] 74-year-old Vonda Goyena died in the hospital yesterday, one day after getting stabbed. [7:41] Her 35-year-old daughter, Angelique Goyena, died early Saturday morning. [7:45] The door frame around the front door had not been forced. [7:49] They fingerprinted all the windows and found no latent fingerprints on any of the exterior [7:54] windows to the house, no signs of some sort of forced entry. [7:58] But nothing is stolen and there is no murder weapon. [8:01] All the DNA and fingerprints belong to Vonda, Angel, her living fiance, David, and other family members. [8:08] The detectives have only one clue to pursue. [8:12] They have to find Walter Lucas. [8:17] As a family, we gathered and tried to find out what would possibly be a motive. [8:23] And we couldn't come up with a thing. [8:26] Why would you murder two innocent people? [8:29] Two innocent women. [8:32] My answering machine from 15 years ago. [8:43] Hey, you know, happy birthday. [8:45] Ready? [8:45] It's Angelique and Mom singing happy birthday to me. [8:49] Happy birthday to you. [8:51] Happy birthday to you. [8:54] Kept it. [8:55] So a month later, they're not on our planet. [8:59] Happy birthday to you. [9:02] I've kept that for 15 years and somehow it's still intact. [9:08] We always call her Angel. [9:16] I mean, it's like if your parents called you, you know, by Angelique, come here. [9:21] You're in trouble, right? [9:22] If you say, Angel, if you come here, then you're not in trouble, you know? [9:27] Angel is the baby of the family. [9:29] She's younger than her three siblings by 16 years. [9:32] And she loves fantasy novels. [9:33] She loves dressing up in Elizabethan style. [9:36] She writes poetry. [9:37] She writes stories. [9:38] And she and her best friend even wrote stories together. [9:41] There was mythology and there was history. [9:45] She wanted to believe in the good of everyone, [9:48] which is something you don't find very often anymore. [9:53] And that's why for her to be gone and stolen away like that, [9:59] it was heart-wrenching. [10:05] This was a woman who loved imagination, loved the magical world. [10:11] We went to a Renaissance fair. [10:13] I think Angel enjoyed just kind of the fun and the carefree nature of it. [10:20] We went to Virginia Beach and on the beach, [10:23] we saw the statue of Neptune. [10:26] Just hung out and just spent time. [10:29] Angel's job may be in a sandwich shop, [10:34] but her heart is clearly in her poetry. [10:38] A heart is judged by the love it gives, [10:40] its thoughts, deeds, and actions. [10:43] First, you must open your heart and take a chance. [10:49] Angel and her mother, Vonda, were very close. [10:53] Angel and mom were definitely a package deal. [10:56] She was the caretaker for her mom, [10:58] who had dementia and heart problems, [11:01] and that was her world. [11:04] Well, it was like my little sister was my mom's keeper. [11:08] They didn't watch TV, they read. [11:10] Angelique would write poetry and photography and art, [11:13] you know, painting and drawing. [11:15] That's what they did. [11:17] My mom was from West Virginia, [11:19] and she was a hoot. [11:21] Oh my gosh, but, you know, [11:23] you couldn't pull the wool over her eyes at all. [11:26] You know, we all tried. [11:29] And she was very creative as well. [11:32] That's probably where Angel got a lot of her creativity. [11:36] Angelique and mom would always go to the store together. [11:39] They would go out to the beach [11:40] to go to, you know, one of the stores for the Wicca. [11:44] They love the Wicca store, both of them. [11:48] Wicca's a pagan spiritual practice. [11:50] Some Wiccans even call themselves witches. [11:53] They see all of the earth and sky and moon, [11:55] all of nature, as a mother goddess. [11:59] Angelique's always been fascinated with the stars. [12:02] It kind of opened her eyes to nature, [12:05] sunsets, leaves. [12:07] There's definitely energy to things. [12:10] It's kind of like the force. [12:11] Be with you kind of thing. [12:13] Beyond that, they also loved tarot cards, [12:15] reading each other's future and fortunes. [12:18] The tarot cards were, [12:20] I remember them having tarot cards, both of them. [12:22] Tarot cards, palm reading, that kind of stuff. [12:28] They had a love of reading. [12:29] They had a love of tarot cards, [12:32] nature, walks in the park. [12:34] They were really in tune with one another, [12:37] more so as friends, [12:38] beyond that mother and daughter special bond. [12:41] They did everything together. [12:43] They went everywhere together. [12:44] Except for, you know, of course, [12:45] when Angelique would go out on a date. [12:47] Mom couldn't go then. [12:50] Angelique met most of the guys she dated online. [12:54] She wanted to be married. [12:56] And she wanted a family. [12:58] Yes, she did. [12:59] She talked about it. [13:00] I know that's something she definitely wanted. [13:03] And she was hopeful. [13:04] She did tell me she really wanted to have a child. [13:08] And she was concerned that she was too old. [13:13] She was 35. [13:15] She was on the, all over the page with dating. [13:18] One guy, he was really into motorcycles. [13:20] And so she'd be the passenger. [13:23] And this one fellow she dated was a pilot, [13:26] small cop planes, and he let her fly. [13:30] And it seemed to be exciting people that she would date. [13:35] In 2006, Angel decides to put herself out there. [13:39] So she signs up to a dating app. [13:41] And then days after, she meets a man who's a father of two. [13:44] What you can't live without? [13:46] My dreams of finding happiness and love. [13:48] My true love is out there still to be found. [13:50] The last book you read. [13:52] Stories with werewolves, vampires, and other magical creatures. [13:55] My sons are both in scouting, so we like to go camping at things like that. [13:58] I'm good at dream interpretation. [13:59] I live with and take care of my mom. [14:01] You place a strong emphasis on family as well. [14:03] I would love one day to get my poetry published. [14:05] I've dreamed of a knight in shining armor. [14:07] Don't laugh, but I've kept a medallion of gold and silver [14:10] of a knight upon a steed for the day I meet him. [14:13] Angel is discovering so much more about David Hoshaw. [14:19] He is an electrical designer. [14:21] He's a scoutmaster. [14:23] He's seeming more and more to her like he could be the one. [14:29] I remember Angel telling me he seemed sweet. [14:32] She told me he had two boys, and they were a big part of his life. [14:37] I think Angel wanted from David just to kind of be that prince charming, [14:43] that knight in shining armor. [14:46] Angel meets the sons, all great. [14:48] And even meets David's ex-wife, Naomi. [14:50] David was an Eagle Scout, so of course he got the boys into scouting. [14:55] They went camping with the scouts, and they really enjoyed it. [15:00] He was an adoring father. [15:02] When I first met David, my initial thought was, [15:06] he looks cuddly. [15:07] He looks cuddly to me. [15:09] Within a matter of months, they fall in love. [15:12] David proposes, and now he's moved in with her and Vonda. [15:16] And Angel is just off and running, planning a wedding. [15:20] December 18th, 2006. [15:24] David Wayne Hosha Jr. [15:26] David is my fiancé, and this will be the first of many Christmas memories that we will treasure. [15:32] We are planning on being married September 15th, 2007. [15:36] Angel was into the Renaissance, and she was having a special dress made. [15:44] It was very much Angel. [15:46] It was red trim, you know, just kind of fairy tale. [15:49] And her shoes she actually bought from a store and decorated them the way she wanted them, [15:57] you know, artists and all. [15:58] I think my married name will be pretty. [16:01] Angelique Elaine Hosha. [16:04] I wonder if our children will have dark hair like me and blue eyes like David. [16:09] I still have the dress that I purchased to wear as maid of honor. [16:16] Of course, neither of those dresses are ever worn. [16:19] Two months before her wedding, Angel is killed. [16:27] Police don't have much to work with at this point. [16:29] Just a dying declaration with the name Walter Lucas. [16:33] Who is this guy? [16:34] Police need to track him down. [16:37] Turns out Walter isn't hard to find. [16:40] Walter is my ex-husband. [16:42] We were married in our 20s. [16:43] And then, you know, we got divorced. [16:45] But he stayed in touch with the family. [16:47] Everybody loved him. [16:48] Not only does he seem unlikely, the detectives find that on the night of the murder, [16:52] Walter was more than 200 miles away. [16:55] When the detectives told me that Vonda mentioned my name, [16:59] I knew I wasn't the one because, first off, I wasn't there. [17:03] And I knew that she had Alzheimer's. [17:06] I just shrugged it off. [17:09] But he said my DNA was there. [17:11] And I said, well, of course, I was there the week before visiting them. [17:15] But his alibi checks out, so they have to cross Walter Lucas off the list. [17:19] At the time that I was interviewed by the detectives, [17:23] they said they don't have any leads. [17:25] If there is no break-in, the next question police ask is who could get into the house? [17:31] The only people with keys are the two dead women and members of the immediate family. [17:37] Everyone who has a key, family, David the fiancé, all have alibis too. [17:41] The family members confirmed that David Hoshaw is a couple hours away, [17:46] and he's on the Middle Peninsula in Virginia at a Boy Scout week-long camp. [17:54] David is with his 12-year-old son. [17:56] Other parents see him there at 11 o'clock Friday night. [17:59] Now, 6.30 Saturday morning, he's there for camp breakfast. [18:04] And David drives back into Norfolk that afternoon. [18:07] That Saturday was when he had brought my oldest back to me. [18:12] And everything was fine. [18:14] The police track him down, and they tell him that they need him to come down to the station. [18:19] And then I'd gotten the call from the police department saying that my ex-husband was there [18:24] and that he needed a ride. [18:28] The whole time, I'm like, what happened? [18:32] David just said, well, you know, if I was there, I could have saved him. [18:36] I'm like, what do you mean if you were there, you could have saved him? [18:41] You would be dead too. [18:43] And yeah, it was confusing, because we had nobody to go after. [18:46] No evidence. [18:49] Days are passing, and there's no arrest. [18:52] No clues. [18:53] No clear direction. [18:54] They want justice. [18:55] They want answers. [18:57] It takes a little piece of your soul, and it breaks your heart just a little more every [19:01] time you have to tell them that there's no breakthrough in the case. [19:04] But two weeks later, a pretty startling development. [19:07] A single piece of paper changes it all. [19:09] It's a confession. [19:10] You need a homicide victim's family for the first time. [19:22] They don't know you from anybody in the world. [19:24] And you suddenly are handling the most important thing in their life, the case involving the [19:29] death of their mother and their sister. [19:31] The police at this point are just stymied. [19:34] It's been a month since the murders. [19:35] There is no evidence. [19:37] But then a development that most murder investigations never see. [19:40] Letter from the killer, and it's postmarked from Chicago. [19:45] The act of the killing was not enough. [19:50] Essentially, the killer is reliving it and writing this letter. [19:53] So that is highly unusual. [19:55] You don't have a clue, do you? [20:00] I met the pretty biatch at the beach a few days before I killed her. [20:04] She had her mother with her. [20:06] She told me she was getting married in September, but she wanted to have one last fling beforehand. [20:12] It references Angel and her mother going to the beach. [20:15] Now investigators cross-check her diary, where she actually talks about going to the beach [20:20] with her mom. [20:21] Me and mom decided not to waste a good day, and we're ready to be on the beach by 8 a.m. or so. [20:31] After that, I'll play the rest of the day slash night by ear. [20:36] And the dates line up. [20:38] There's also a description about going to the laundry and everything else, and all that was [20:43] consistent with the habits of Angel and her mother. [20:47] How would the writer know all this unless they knew the women, unless they were actually there? [20:53] When it came to going all the way, she told me she was having second thoughts and couldn't [20:59] do it. [21:00] About 12.30 or so, I got my knife and did the dirty deed. [21:05] What a rush. [21:07] I should have gagged her first because she screamed and woke up her mother. [21:10] That's mother M-O-T-H-A. [21:13] The detectives think the use of that kind of slang, biatch, mother, is kind of a clumsy [21:20] way of trying to make them think the writer's black. [21:23] Angel had previously dated white men, African-American men, different types of employment, which is [21:31] one thing that confused the issue. [21:33] The writer clearly knows the victims. [21:37] Don't bother checking for prints or DNA. [21:40] I'm wearing a bodysuit and gloves. [21:42] Clearly it showed a killer that was reveling in what he had done. [21:46] Really was unconcerned with talking about the act itself. [21:50] And then, lo and behold, a second letter is received. [21:56] It's mailed from Gaylord, Michigan, which is a small community in the middle of Michigan. [22:01] This one is so badly spelled, it's hard to read. [22:03] Let me try. [22:05] Detectives, I write to you again. [22:07] I must confess, I have done it for a second time. [22:11] Friday Street was just the beginning for me. [22:13] He's now saying that he's killed someone possibly in the Midwest. [22:18] It gave me such a rush. [22:20] I can't explain. [22:21] I will never forget me first. [22:24] The Goyanas. [22:25] So now they're checking the Midwest for unexplained homicides. [22:28] A killer could be roaming from state to state. [22:31] He could easily have come through Norfolk. [22:33] Norfolk, Virginia, has one of the highest per capita murder rates in the United States. [22:40] You have large ports. [22:41] You have international airports. [22:43] You're kind of the hub for 95 and 85 areas where people are traveling north and south a lot. [22:49] We have an extremely psychotic, taunting killer who is taking pleasure in the homicide, [22:55] who is taunting the police, who writes in a vernacular words that are more commonly used [23:02] by an African American or someone else other than somebody in the family. [23:07] Both letters and envelopes were forensically checked. [23:11] No DNA on either of them. [23:13] Taunting the police is not a smart move. [23:16] It tends to make them even more determined. [23:18] The case is about to add another detective and the most bizarre twist yet. [23:24] The man comes into the station, says he knows who did it, [23:27] hands them a ceremonial knife, and tells them he's a vampire. [23:32] There's no immediately available forensic evidence, [23:50] meaning that there's no suspect fingerprints. [23:54] We have no DNA at the scene. [23:56] The clear investigators won't be able to rely on forensics to identify the killer. [24:02] No physical evidence, no sign of forced entry. [24:05] But that in itself gives them two important clues. [24:09] First, these murders were likely planned. [24:11] Second, only someone Angel and Vonda know. [24:15] His friend? [24:16] Maybe a romantic partner. [24:18] We have this fiancée, and they're set to get married in September. [24:24] We aren't aware of any motive for him to want to do harm to his fiancée. [24:29] And furthermore, he's out of the area. [24:32] This is a dead end for them. [24:34] And at this point, the rest of the family and the friends have been ruled out. [24:39] Prosecutor Phil Evans needs a confidant, [24:42] someone that he knows will get the job done. [24:44] So he turns to a man that he's worked with many times in the past. [24:49] Let's get Rick Malvin on this case. [24:51] We'll work it together. [24:55] Phil and I have worked a lot of cases together. [24:58] I won't say it's like brothers, but it's pretty close. [25:02] Rick was the best of the best. [25:05] He was someone who could translate the crime scene, [25:09] but he also understood what it really means to develop evidence for the courtroom. [25:14] I went to the house with Detective Malvin. [25:20] We walked through it. [25:23] We could still feel the murder in the house. [25:28] I knew that this case was going to be difficult. [25:32] But deep down, I felt that this was a solvable case. [25:35] It may have taken time, but it was going to be a solvable case. [25:39] They approached this from the standpoint of, [25:42] we're going to start at ground zero. [25:44] We weren't at the crime scene. [25:45] We're going to go back and go through everything [25:47] so that we are comfortable nothing was missed. [25:52] Nobody is perfect when they commit a murder. [25:54] I may overlook something, but there is no such thing as the perfect murder. [26:01] At this point, Evans and Malvin are worried about something else. [26:04] The killer made it pretty clear he's not only one step ahead of the cops, [26:08] but the murder spree isn't over. [26:10] Anyone working that case should have taken that letter personally, and I did. [26:15] Then a second letter came in taunting. [26:19] I must confess, I have done it a second time. [26:23] I was going to do everything I possibly could to find that person. [26:27] The cops up here are a lot smarter than you use. [26:31] It really puts an increased energy on Detective Malvin, [26:36] and certainly I felt it. [26:37] We had a victim's family here who was just gutted. [26:41] They lost their mother and sister, [26:42] and we had a killer, apparently, who was traveling the country. [26:47] At the very least, if he wasn't killing other people, [26:50] he was perversely enjoying having killed the Goyunas. [26:55] You don't just look at suspects in a murder case. [26:59] You also look at the victims. [27:01] By 2008, Detective Malvin and his partner are digging deeper into Angel's past, [27:05] and they find the ties to Wicca. [27:07] Remember, Angel and her mom were interested and hung out at this Wiccan bookstore. [27:14] Angelique's relationship with Wicca was more interest, [27:19] and I think that kind of trickled down to mom as well, [27:21] because mom got interested in that. [27:24] Wicca became popular in America back in the 50s. [27:27] You know, you can think of lunar rituals and secular worship. [27:31] It is not black magic and Satanism. [27:34] It's more defined as nature's religion, [27:37] where Earth is a source of spiritual power. [27:41] Angel had become associated with a group [27:46] that loosely operated out of a bookstore called the Mystic Moon. [27:51] Wiccan rituals often involve a special set of mystical tools, [27:55] commonly including a wand, a pentacle, a chalice, [27:58] and a large knife called an athene, used only for symbolic purposes. [28:04] To the police, that opened a Pandora's box of, [28:08] well, who did she meet there? [28:11] January 2, 2008, there's a call to the Norfolk Police Department. [28:17] There's a man that wants to talk to you on the Goyuna case. [28:20] He considered himself a vampire. [28:28] We met with him. [28:31] We invited him down to the office. [28:33] And he said he was part of that community [28:36] where there were some people who were involved in vampirism. [28:41] He also disturbingly implied to the detectives [28:46] that he may know something about Angel's murder. [28:53] He produced a knife that he said [28:55] that was used by someone else to commit the murders. [28:59] So now the detectives had a knife in their possession. [29:02] The case is taking a pretty bizarre turn. [29:04] More than six months after Angel and Vonda were stabbed to death, [29:07] Detective Malvin is sitting across from a self-described vampire, [29:11] someone who claims to draw pleasure from ingesting blood, [29:14] and someone who turns over an athene knife [29:16] he says is the murder weapon. [29:18] The knife was submitted to the lab. [29:23] The DNA, blood trace, [29:26] and the knife could not have made the injuries on the bodies. [29:30] And so once we talked to him [29:33] and knew that he was not close to the family, [29:37] I didn't have a problem eliminating him. [29:39] It's another costly detour, squandering time and resources. [29:44] So Evans and Malvin take a harder look at someone [29:47] who seemed to have an airtight alibi, [29:49] Angel's fiancé, David Hoshaw. [29:52] He came to take his sons to a Boy Scout camp. [29:57] He had been away from his fiancé for a while. [30:02] He certainly could have left a Boy Scout camp. [30:05] He could get to the house without being noticed. [30:08] We looked into David Hoshaw's background. [30:14] The more we looked, [30:14] the more disturbing information came. [30:17] He becomes stronger, not by evidence of this crime, [30:21] but by information about his behavior in the back. [30:30] We had a 74-year-old woman killed. [30:34] A 35-year-old woman killed. [30:37] Somebody needed to tell her story. [30:41] That's it. [30:53] The house looks so different. [30:56] Everything's changed. [30:57] Everything's new. [30:59] And that's a good thing. [31:01] Detective Rick Malvin is a veteran homicide detective [31:04] with 15 years under his belt. [31:06] But this case is different. [31:08] Malvin begins an investigation that will span two years, [31:11] four states and a couple thousand miles. [31:15] I got here during the early morning hours. [31:19] The initial investigators were here on scene when I arrived. [31:24] Rick Malvin was one of our senior homicide detectives. [31:27] He was definitely one of the go-to guys. [31:29] He had a very good reputation. [31:35] Detective Malvin was just very focused, [31:38] and it was like the bulldog sense about him [31:41] that he's going to get something done. [31:43] You know, he's going to do something. [31:44] When I go to work on homicide, [31:50] when I roll out, I pray. [31:54] And that's for my mother. [31:56] I pray that I don't get tunnel vision [31:59] and let me see through the lies. [32:02] Fishing through all the lies, [32:03] Detective Rick Malvin and his partner, [32:06] they've been following dozens of leads. [32:08] All of them are dead ends. [32:10] The only real solid clue that they have at this point [32:12] are these two letters. [32:14] But who wrote those letters? [32:16] And was it truly the killer? [32:17] I can't remember a case where the police department [32:21] ever received legitimate letters like this [32:25] in connection with a real homicide. [32:27] Can you? [32:27] No. [32:28] We explored the possibility of it being a serial killer. [32:32] Letters were taken to the FBI lab, [32:34] and they determined that it wasn't a serial killer. [32:37] So that narrowed down our search, [32:43] and David Halshaw looked more like a suspect to me. [32:48] There's no reason to write a letter like that [32:52] other than to try to throw the police off. [32:55] Obviously, whoever wrote it [32:57] put Norfolk in strange handwriting [33:00] that's not the same as the return address. [33:03] Part of trying to look at everything [33:06] is each person of interest, [33:09] we want to know everything we can about them. [33:12] My way of doing my job [33:14] and Rick Malvin's way of doing his job [33:16] is we're going to get every detail we know. [33:17] We're talking about this guy, David Halshaw. [33:20] Who is he? [33:20] For Angel, David Halshaw is the man [33:25] she wants to grow old with. [33:27] But in the month before they exchange wedding vows, [33:30] it's clear she is having serious doubts. [33:33] I haven't heard from David [33:34] except before work this morning. [33:36] He says he misses me, [33:38] and I hope he does because I miss him. [33:40] Halshaw has a job doing electrical work [33:42] for a Virginia company with U.S. Navy contracts. [33:45] Detectives learn he tells Angel [33:47] he's been placed on a project in the Midwest. [33:50] Most of the time, he'll be living up there [33:52] and commuting back to Norfolk. [33:54] But you've got to ask, [33:55] is that really why he's gone? [33:58] Angel's diary entries in the last weeks of her life, [34:01] she was frustrated on one level [34:03] because he didn't seem to be engaged [34:07] and he didn't seem to be his normal demeanor towards her. [34:10] It just makes you feel ignored [34:12] when you get only less than five minutes on a call [34:15] when you need way more to feel loved and appreciated. [34:19] He worked for a naval contractor. [34:21] He was supposedly building a ship. [34:23] But why are you building a ship in Wisconsin or Michigan? [34:27] How is it? [34:28] It didn't make sense. [34:31] You would think it would be built in Norfolk, [34:33] not the Midwest, Great Lakes. [34:36] I've been filled with all sorts of doubts and worries, [34:41] but I think the part of me is slowly learning to trust David [34:44] and that he is not like the guys in my past [34:47] that betrayed and hurt me. [34:48] I hope this means my capacity to love is increasing as well. [34:52] There were definitely red flags [34:54] that David possibly was cheating [34:56] or hiding something from Angel [35:00] just when she couldn't get a hold of him [35:02] and he's not where he's supposed to be. [35:05] When the forensic investigators were going through the house, [35:11] one of the things that was of interest was a computer. [35:16] We got the search warrant for the computer [35:19] and once we got it to Forensic, [35:22] that's when we found out when he changed that password. [35:26] The forensic analysis of the computer [35:28] revealed that on June 24, 2007, [35:33] David Hoshaw, as the administrator for the computer, [35:37] changed the password to For Amanda. [35:39] Amanda, if David's marrying Angel in two months, [35:43] who is Amanda? [35:45] Amanda came into the picture [35:47] when we realized David Hoshaw [35:50] had changed the password on the computer. [35:53] It's early 2007. [35:55] Angel is buzzing, planning for this wedding. [35:58] Turns out, David Hoshaw, [36:00] he actually goes back to the dating websites [36:03] and he ends up connecting with [36:06] and starts to date another woman. [36:12] So while he's traveling for business [36:15] to stay up there to work, [36:19] he was actually cultivating another relationship [36:21] in that area to Amanda, [36:24] to another woman. [36:26] All the while, [36:27] Angel is preparing for a wedding in September. [36:33] Angel was very trusting, [36:34] but when someone hasn't necessarily [36:36] given you initially a reason to doubt them, [36:40] why should you? [36:42] That password unlocks more than a computer. [36:45] It also opens an exhaustive search. [36:48] Detectives start digging into everything [36:49] David Hoshaw said he was doing [36:51] before, during, and after the killings, [36:53] starting with his airtight alibi. [36:56] Was he really in Boy Scout camp [36:58] the night of the murders? [37:00] We knew he was roughly 80 miles away [37:03] at 11 p.m. at night [37:05] and he was there at 6 in the morning. [37:07] That is not physically impossible [37:09] to drive to Norfolk two hours, [37:12] commit a brutal homicide, [37:13] and drive back, [37:14] but it's unlikely behavior. [37:16] Detective Melvin knows [37:18] that the whole case is riding on the letters. [37:20] Prove who sent them, [37:21] and they have their killer. [37:26] When you're looking at individuals [37:28] capable of committing a homicide, [37:30] David Hoshaw does not jump off the pages. [37:34] He doesn't look like [37:35] he's going to be a threat to anybody, [37:36] but sometimes people that present that way [37:39] are actually the most dangerous. [37:42] Turns out, David Hoshaw [37:44] was more dangerous than anyone imagined. [37:48] It's like a whole nightmare. [37:51] I never thought in a million years [37:52] I would be him. [37:54] He came down the hall [37:56] and grabbed my throat [37:58] and started strangling me. [38:00] I just felt something just smack [38:02] across the back of my head, [38:04] and I just blacked out. [38:06] In the residence, [38:15] I was, you know, [38:16] slightly in shock of what I saw. [38:18] Two people are no longer with us [38:20] who should be [38:21] who were good people. [38:23] What would possibly be a motive? [38:26] The murder somehow be tied [38:28] to Angel's interest in the occult. [38:31] Remember, Angel and her mom [38:32] were interested. [38:33] Whoever did this [38:34] must be some kind of monster. [38:36] Extremely psychotic, taunting killer. [38:39] We got two letters [38:40] that we have the killer [38:41] taking credit [38:42] for the double homicide. [38:45] I skipped town pretty quick. [38:47] I move around a lot, [38:48] so good luck catching me. [38:52] But if you ever confronted him [38:54] about anything, [38:56] the switch would just flip in his brain. [38:58] I just felt something [38:59] just smack across the back of my head, [39:01] and I just blacked out. [39:04] It was just like [39:05] I was throwing in an alligator pit, [39:08] and I needed to fight my way out of it. [39:10] I think truly [39:11] there was something [39:12] more sinister going on. [39:13] Thank you, Jim. [39:16] Thank you, Mom. [39:17] We've had several homicides [39:27] in the city of Norfolk, [39:29] multiple deaths. [39:31] This case was unusual [39:32] in the sense that [39:33] it was a mother and daughter. [39:35] Angel and Vondegoyana [39:38] were killed so brutally [39:39] right in their home. [39:41] How could there be [39:42] no evidence to go on? [39:43] There was no signs [39:44] of 4th century. [39:45] There was no DNA [39:46] or fingerprints. [39:47] The police investigation [39:48] of everyone Angel knew, [39:50] including people [39:50] from the Wicca Bookstore, [39:52] has led nowhere. [39:53] And the self-proclaimed vampire [39:55] who went to the police, [39:56] it was a false lead. [39:57] Angel was humble. [39:59] She was kind. [40:00] She was writing [40:01] how excited she was [40:02] to get married. [40:03] I was trying to catch a killer. [40:05] I was going to do everything [40:05] I possibly could [40:06] to find that person. [40:11] Where do they go from here? [40:13] Angel's best friend [40:14] thinks she knows. [40:16] It was David. [40:17] Just had a feeling. [40:21] Remember, [40:22] early in their investigation, [40:24] police reached out [40:24] to Angel's fiance, [40:25] David Hoshaw, [40:26] at the time, [40:28] he seemed to have [40:29] a credible alibi. [40:30] David talks to police [40:32] and tells them [40:32] he was about 80 miles away [40:34] on a Boy Scout trip. [40:36] But it was some [40:36] of what David said [40:37] during this interview [40:38] that piqued their interest. [40:40] What was interesting was [40:41] he never asked them, [40:43] why do you need [40:44] to talk to me? [40:45] If you got called [40:46] by the homicide squad, [40:47] your first question is, [40:48] what is this about? [40:49] When he was talking [40:51] to the detectives, [40:53] he'd tell them, [40:54] check my E-ZPass. [40:57] Well, you can leave [40:57] the E-ZPass [40:58] at the Boy Scout camp. [41:00] When a person [41:01] is being interviewed [41:01] in a murder investigation [41:02] and they're providing you [41:04] a lot of information, [41:05] it means they're totally innocent [41:06] or they're somehow involved [41:08] and they've gone [41:08] to a lot of trouble [41:09] to make it look like [41:10] they're totally innocent. [41:12] David Hoshaw [41:13] became like an onion [41:14] in the case. [41:15] The more you peeled him back, [41:16] the more strange information [41:18] came out. [41:20] A disturbing picture [41:21] of Hoshaw's past [41:22] begins to emerge. [41:24] We knew that there were [41:25] at least six women [41:26] that David Hoshaw [41:27] was involved in [41:29] and we investigated [41:31] all six of them. [41:33] David Hoshaw [41:34] had been married [41:35] three times prior [41:36] to becoming engaged [41:38] to Angel. [41:39] I am Naomi Hoshaw. [41:40] I was David's first wife. [41:43] We were 16 [41:44] and we met at Busch Gardens [41:46] when we worked there. [41:48] It's all the fun [41:49] and splendor [41:49] of old Europe, [41:51] but a lot closer. [41:52] At first, [41:53] neither one of us [41:54] liked each other. [41:55] You know, [41:56] I looked at him like, [41:57] oh, he's too preppy [41:58] and his uniform's [42:00] on too perfect, you know. [42:01] I gave him [42:02] a little bit of attention [42:03] and he gave it back [42:04] a million fold. [42:06] I felt special. [42:07] Of course, [42:08] when he asked me [42:08] to marry him, [42:09] I definitely said yes [42:10] because that's what I wanted. [42:12] He then joined [42:16] the United States Air Force [42:17] and was transferred [42:18] out to Spokane, [42:20] Washington area. [42:22] And the good times [42:23] were good, [42:24] but what I remember [42:25] are more of [42:26] the bad times. [42:29] He would be very [42:30] lovey-dovey [42:31] when he wanted to be, [42:33] but if you ever [42:34] confronted him [42:34] about anything, [42:36] a switch would just [42:37] flip in his brain. [42:41] I found out [42:41] I was pregnant [42:42] and he was like, [42:43] no, you're not pregnant, [42:44] you're not pregnant. [42:45] And I was. [42:47] I was on bed rest [42:48] at the very end [42:49] and I got up [42:51] because I wanted [42:51] something to drink. [42:53] He came down the hall [42:56] and grabbed my throat [42:58] and started strangling me. [43:02] And my oldest son, [43:04] he was just screaming [43:05] and screaming [43:05] and screaming [43:06] and he just wouldn't stop. [43:09] Finally, David let go [43:11] and I went [43:13] and picked up my oldest son [43:15] and calmed him down. [43:17] I was terrified [43:18] and I didn't know [43:20] what was going to happen next. [43:21] And then there were [43:25] some letters [43:26] that I found. [43:28] To my one true love. [43:30] During his first marriage, [43:31] David also started [43:32] to groom an unlawfully [43:34] touch a 12-year-old [43:35] friend of the family. [43:37] I went in there [43:37] in hopes to be alone with you. [43:39] Your mom would not have known. [43:41] I didn't know [43:42] what was going on. [43:43] I was naive. [43:45] You're in your 20s [43:46] and this person [43:47] is still in elementary school. [43:50] Love forever, David. [43:52] You knew she was 12. [43:55] That's the part [43:56] that I could never [43:57] wrap my head around. [44:02] Naomi had complained [44:04] to the United States Air Force [44:05] about domestic abuse. [44:07] The 12-year-old girl [44:08] and her parents [44:09] cooperated with [44:09] the United States Air Force. [44:12] He pled guilty [44:12] to both indecent acts [44:14] and assault [44:15] on the 12-year-old. [44:17] The United States Air Force [44:18] chose not to criminally [44:20] prosecute him [44:21] in a court-martial, [44:23] which could have [44:23] sent him to prison, [44:25] and administratively [44:26] discharged him [44:27] from the Air Force [44:28] with an other-than-honorable [44:30] discharge. [44:31] I filed for the divorce [44:33] and he never fought me. [44:35] After his discharge [44:39] from the military, [44:40] David follows his ex-wife Naomi [44:42] back to Virginia [44:43] to stay close to his kids [44:44] where he begins [44:45] online dating. [44:47] One of the women [44:48] that we talked to [44:50] indicated he said [44:51] all the right things [44:52] and he wined and dined them. [44:54] After Naomi, [44:56] he got involved [44:56] with his eventual [44:58] second wife, [44:59] who he was married to [45:00] for a short time. [45:01] And then there was me. [45:02] My name is Allison Ashcroft. [45:06] I am David's third wife. [45:09] I met David in 2001 [45:11] through an online dating website. [45:15] He showered a lot of attention [45:17] on me and that was not [45:18] something that I was used to. [45:20] At that time, [45:21] I was severely overweight. [45:24] And so that there was [45:25] this person who found me [45:27] attractive despite that [45:28] was just mind-blowing to me. [45:30] And I thought, you know, [45:32] I might want to hang on [45:33] to this one. [45:34] We were concerned [45:35] what we learned from Naomi [45:36] and the domestic assault. [45:38] We were trying to see [45:38] if there's a continuity [45:39] of violence with Hoshaw. [45:42] I had an injury [45:44] at David's hands. [45:46] I was having migraines [45:47] and dizziness. [45:49] David had asked [45:50] if there was anything [45:51] he could do to help. [45:52] And we had a massage roller. [45:54] So he started rolling [45:55] this thing back and forth [45:56] across my neck. [45:58] He started moving [45:59] a little faster [45:59] and he was lifting [46:01] the roller up off my neck. [46:02] And then eventually [46:04] I just felt something [46:05] just smack across [46:06] the back of my head. [46:07] And I just blacked out. [46:13] When I came to, [46:14] he was standing [46:15] on the side of the bed [46:16] looking down at me [46:18] saying, [46:18] do you think we need [46:19] to go to the hospital? [46:23] Hoshaw came up [46:24] with some story [46:25] that did not include [46:27] any acknowledgement [46:27] he had something [46:28] to do with it. [46:29] I don't think anything [46:30] was really said [46:31] other than he may have [46:32] said he was sorry [46:33] and that the roller [46:35] just slipped out of his hands. [46:37] Now I realize, you know, [46:38] I was young and naive then [46:40] that I think truly [46:41] there was something [46:42] more sinister going on. [46:44] It left that nagging [46:45] seed of doubt [46:46] in her mind. [46:48] In 2005, [46:50] he said, [46:51] this marriage [46:51] isn't working out. [46:52] I said, [46:52] I can't do this anymore. [46:54] I'll pack my stuff up [46:55] in the morning [46:55] and I'll be gone [46:58] and we can get a divorce. [47:01] I think [47:02] if I had tried [47:04] to work things out [47:05] with him, [47:05] if I had stayed, [47:08] I might not be [47:09] sitting here right now. [47:10] As detectives [47:13] dig into all [47:14] of David Hoshaw's [47:15] past relationships, [47:17] they learn that [47:17] his trail of lies [47:19] and deceptions [47:19] only continues to grow. [47:22] Very soon, [47:23] he would move on [47:23] to a relationship [47:24] with Angel. [47:25] And that's when [47:26] he got ugly. [47:28] Now that the authorities [47:36] have learned [47:37] about David Hoshaw's [47:38] disturbing past, [47:39] the question becomes, [47:41] what exactly happened [47:42] between David [47:43] and Angel? [47:44] When Angelique [47:46] Goyana meets [47:46] her true love online, [47:48] there's a lot [47:48] he isn't telling her. [47:49] like he's been married [47:51] three times. [47:54] I have a huge heart [47:55] of gold that I want [47:56] to share with my partner. [47:57] What he projected [47:58] was all the type [47:59] of things Angelique [48:00] Goyana would want [48:02] to hear or see [48:03] in a dating profile. [48:04] I was happy [48:05] that my sister [48:06] found someone, [48:07] but when I met him, [48:09] I didn't really care [48:10] for him. [48:11] There was something [48:11] about him I didn't like. [48:12] You know, [48:13] this force and energy, [48:14] it wasn't good, [48:16] but Angelique liked him, [48:18] so I'm going to [48:18] like him too. [48:20] Within a few months, [48:20] David Hoshaw [48:21] is moving in [48:22] with Angel [48:22] and Vonda. [48:24] When we found [48:25] that out, [48:26] we were up in arms [48:27] about that. [48:28] And he's a bum. [48:29] He's going to live [48:29] in my mom's house [48:30] for nothing? [48:32] No, we didn't like that. [48:33] But my mom [48:34] wasn't here to stay. [48:36] Angel was hoping [48:37] that they would [48:37] live there with her mom [48:39] and continue [48:40] to take care of her. [48:42] Angel's diary entries, [48:43] they start to change. [48:45] It's not all hearts [48:46] and flowers anymore. [48:47] Why is he so secretive [48:51] about his money? [48:52] I know marriage [48:54] is a matter of trust, [48:55] but David is weird [48:56] with money. [48:57] There was concern [48:57] that David was not [48:59] the person he originally [49:01] appeared to be. [49:02] Angelique would tell me [49:03] out of the clear blue [49:04] that he'd have a look [49:06] on his face [49:06] like he was disgusted [49:08] with her, [49:09] and that would really [49:10] bother her. [49:11] David was wanting her [49:13] to put Vonda [49:14] in a managed care facility [49:16] and Angel was [49:17] vehemently against that. [49:20] He's been grumpy [49:21] and moody. [49:23] Tonight he was even [49:24] arguing with mom. [49:26] I stood up for her, [49:26] of course, [49:27] but it put me [49:28] in a strange place [49:29] between mom, [49:30] who I love, [49:31] and David, [49:32] who I love. [49:34] David didn't seem [49:35] to have jumped in [49:36] on getting the wedding [49:37] preparations together. [49:39] He did nothing. [49:40] He proposed [49:41] and that was it. [49:42] She's bugging [49:43] Hoshaw, [49:44] who do you want [49:44] to invite? [49:45] And he kept saying, [49:46] yeah, yeah, [49:46] I'll get them to you. [49:48] And David Hoshaw [49:49] is going back and forth [49:50] to Michigan. [49:53] He wasn't around [49:54] and I thought [49:55] that's strange [49:56] for somebody [49:57] who wanted to get married. [50:00] It said in a [50:01] condescending tone of voice, [50:03] don't question me [50:04] where I am. [50:06] Doesn't seem like [50:07] he was feeling [50:08] warm fuzzies for me, [50:09] now does it? [50:09] Angelique called me [50:14] and she was really upset [50:16] and said that [50:17] she'd had a bad dream. [50:19] That she dreamed [50:20] he was kissing [50:21] someone else [50:22] and I tried to console her. [50:25] You're getting cold feet [50:26] or something like that. [50:27] Now I kind of, [50:28] looking back at him, [50:29] like, oh my gosh. [50:31] In spite of all [50:32] the red flags, [50:33] even the day [50:34] before she is killed, [50:36] Angel is still [50:36] looking forward [50:37] to the wedding. [50:38] Friday, [50:39] 77 days and counting. [50:41] After work today, [50:43] as I always do, [50:44] I check my voicemail [50:45] and guess who [50:46] finally called? [50:48] David. [50:49] He'll be home [50:50] sometime tomorrow [50:51] and for that [50:51] I am very glad. [50:54] That is written [50:55] just hours [50:56] before she dies. [50:59] Initially, [50:59] the family is going [51:00] to the house [51:01] and they're going [51:02] through personal belongings. [51:04] We gathered [51:05] and tried to [51:06] find out [51:06] what would possibly [51:08] be a motive. [51:09] There were forensic [51:10] investigators still [51:11] working on the house, [51:12] trying to make sure [51:13] they didn't miss [51:14] some forensic evidence. [51:15] There was nothing, [51:16] nothing important [51:17] to anybody. [51:18] We didn't think [51:19] it was going [51:19] to be solved. [51:21] A couple times, [51:22] Hoshaw showed up there, [51:23] which they thought [51:23] was strange. [51:25] He was allowed [51:26] access to the house. [51:28] He should not [51:29] have been allowed [51:29] in the house. [51:30] I think he got [51:31] anything he wanted [51:32] that could destroy [51:34] the case. [51:35] And maybe he did. [51:36] I just noticed, [51:37] why isn't he grieving? [51:39] He doesn't even [51:39] appear to be shocked. [51:40] At the viewing [51:43] at the funeral home, [51:44] entire family shows up. [51:45] Who doesn't show up? [51:46] David Hoshaw. [51:48] Angel's sisters [51:49] and her brother [51:50] are like, [51:51] there's something up [51:51] with David Hoshaw. [51:54] Not only is David Hoshaw [51:55] a no-show [51:56] at his fiancee's funeral, [51:57] he makes another [51:58] stunning move. [51:59] He packs up, [52:00] leaves Norfolk, [52:01] and moves to Michigan [52:02] to be with a new girlfriend. [52:05] Remember, [52:06] as police were [52:07] investigating Hoshaw, [52:08] they discovered [52:09] that shortly before [52:09] the murder, [52:10] he changed his [52:11] computer password [52:12] to For Amanda. [52:18] Marky? [52:21] Tell me your first name [52:22] and how you were [52:23] connected to this case. [52:24] Amanda and I was [52:24] engaged to David Hoshaw. [52:27] At Amanda's request, [52:28] we are not using [52:28] her last name [52:29] and have altered [52:30] her appearance. [52:32] He told me that [52:33] his ex, Angelique, [52:36] was murdered. [52:37] He was distraught. [52:38] He was confused. [52:40] He went to the [52:40] police department [52:41] and they're questioning him. [52:44] And I asked him, [52:45] I said, [52:45] did you do it? [52:46] And he said, [52:47] no. [52:48] He said he was cleared. [52:50] So I, you know, [52:50] I believed him. [52:52] When I found out [52:53] that he had another woman, [52:55] I went, [52:55] oh my gosh, [52:56] Angelique's dream. [52:57] It's like she was right. [53:00] I set up a meeting [53:01] with the victim's family [53:02] and they were adamant [53:04] that they knew [53:05] it was David Hoshaw. [53:06] We all thought [53:07] it was him. [53:08] We had to get him [53:09] charged for fear [53:10] that he would do [53:10] something else. [53:21] David Hoshaw is now [53:22] living with his girlfriend, [53:24] Amanda. [53:24] And while police [53:25] consider him a prime suspect, [53:27] there's no physical evidence [53:28] linking him to the murders. [53:30] The detectives in this case [53:33] may feel like David Hoshaw [53:34] is the killer, [53:35] but they can't yet prove it. [53:36] And hunches don't count [53:38] in a courtroom. [53:39] We have circumstances. [53:40] We have behavior [53:41] that is strange, [53:42] but we have to demonstrate [53:44] there is no other person [53:46] that could have committed [53:47] the homicide. [53:50] We looked at everything [53:51] that David Hoshaw did [53:54] before the homicide [53:55] and after the homicide. [54:02] We got two letters [54:03] that we have a killer [54:05] taking credit [54:06] for the double homicide. [54:07] Yep. [54:08] But we needed evidence [54:09] that showed that Hoshaw [54:11] was the only person [54:11] that could have mailed [54:12] the letters. [54:16] This is the envelope [54:17] of the first letter [54:19] that was mailed [54:20] on July 23rd [54:21] from Curtis Collins [54:23] Processing Station [54:25] in Chicago. [54:27] But you were able [54:28] to nail it down [54:29] to one specific [54:30] distribution center [54:33] that would have applied [54:33] that postmark. [54:36] We had to try [54:37] to find something [54:38] that would put him [54:39] around Chicago. [54:41] So we had to try [54:43] to rebuild [54:43] David Hoshaw's activities. [54:47] If they can connect [54:48] the dots of cell phone [54:49] records and credit card [54:50] receipts, they can use [54:52] the paper drill [54:53] that Hoshaw left [54:54] and trap him. [54:55] We started following [54:56] the cell phone records [54:58] of David Hoshaw. [54:59] There was a cell call [55:01] that bounced off [55:02] a tower within a few [55:04] miles of where this [55:05] letter would have had [55:06] to have been mailed. [55:08] That was really key [55:09] that we were able [55:10] to put him between [55:11] 2.1 and 12.6 miles [55:14] from that post office. [55:16] So evidence places [55:18] David in Chicago [55:19] near the post office [55:20] on the same day [55:21] the first letter [55:22] was mailed. [55:23] Can they connect them [55:23] to the second letter? [55:25] But this one was mailed [55:26] nowhere near Chicago. [55:28] August 15th. [55:29] That letter is dropped [55:30] in the mailbox [55:31] in Gaylord, Michigan, [55:32] which is a small community [55:34] in the middle of Michigan, [55:35] middle of nowhere. [55:37] David Hoshaw's credit card [55:38] purchases opened a window [55:41] because his purchase history [55:43] was literally a road map. [55:46] We knew that David Hoshaw [55:49] took his new girlfriend Amanda [55:52] on a little celebratory road trip. [55:56] Tell me about that. [55:59] Why did you take that trip? [56:01] We went on a trip [56:02] because I had a doctor's appointment [56:04] and we started off [56:06] in our town [56:07] and we stopped [56:07] at all these little [56:08] different places. [56:10] There were hotels. [56:12] There was the zoo, [56:14] IHOP, [56:16] movie theaters. [56:17] We followed all of them. [56:18] Yeah, he's showing Amanda [56:23] the good time. [56:24] You know, [56:25] he's trying to impress her. [56:26] August 13th and 14th, [56:28] he was consistently [56:29] making purchases [56:30] moving southward [56:32] on the interstate [56:33] to the point [56:34] where he would go [56:35] through Gaylord [56:35] on August 15th. [56:39] Within a few-hour time frame, [56:40] he made purchases [56:41] north of Gaylord [56:42] and then south of Gaylord. [56:44] There's a single highway [56:45] running through it. [56:47] What are the odds [56:48] it's going to be somebody else [56:49] who mailed that letter? [56:50] So never saw him [56:53] stepping away [56:54] to go to the post office [56:55] or mail anything? [56:57] No. [56:58] Nothing unusual. [56:59] I mean, [57:00] I'm usually the one [57:00] that's gone, [57:02] you know, [57:02] stepping out somewhere. [57:04] Now they've got [57:04] a string of receipts [57:06] and cell phone records [57:07] that all connect David [57:08] to the letters. [57:09] The problem with that is [57:10] that doesn't go into court [57:11] and prove anything. [57:13] Could the answer be witnesses? [57:15] It is always [57:16] a lot more powerful [57:17] when you have an eyewitness. [57:18] That carries a lot more weight [57:20] in front of a jury. [57:23] So Detective Malvin [57:23] and his partner [57:24] go on a road trip [57:25] talking to store owners [57:27] and vendors [57:27] and trying to get them [57:29] to come into court. [57:30] We ended up with [57:31] 23 to 25 different people [57:33] subpoenaed in this case. [57:34] They present their case [57:35] to the grand jury [57:36] and get an indictment [57:37] and an arrest warrant [57:38] for David Hosha. [57:47] David Hosha had set up [57:48] a separate life. [57:49] He was moving on. [57:50] We knew Amanda [57:51] had now changed her life [57:53] to live with David Hosha [57:54] and take him into her home. [57:57] David and Amanda [57:58] have a child [57:58] and Amanda's due [57:59] with their second. [58:00] But things seem [58:01] to be headed downhill. [58:03] David's changed. [58:04] He was acting weird. [58:07] I'd find him [58:07] in random places. [58:09] I'm like, [58:10] what are you doing? [58:11] Why are you sitting here? [58:13] He never had an answer. [58:15] We wanted David Hosha [58:17] not to be prepared [58:18] for what was happening [58:19] and we wanted [58:20] to create an impact [58:22] upon Amanda. [58:23] So 2009, [58:26] you're pregnant [58:26] with your second child [58:27] and you hear [58:29] a knock on the door. [58:30] I didn't get [58:31] no knock on the door. [58:32] So tell me [58:33] about what happened. [58:34] It was 4 a.m. [58:37] And they rush in. [58:42] One officer pushes me [58:44] to the side. [58:45] I'm asking [58:46] what's going on. [58:47] So they're running in [58:48] and just grabbing David [58:49] and telling you. [58:50] Yeah, they threw him [58:51] on the ground. [58:52] I have a baby [58:53] in the other room. [58:54] I'm just asking [58:55] what's going on. [58:56] Well, he's under arrest. [58:59] David Hosha stepped out. [59:00] He was handcuffed [59:01] and escorted out [59:02] of the house. [59:05] And he finally told me [59:06] that he murdered [59:07] two people, [59:08] his ex. [59:09] But really, [59:10] to find out [59:10] he was his fiancée. [59:12] It wasn't his ex-fiancée. [59:13] It was just his fiancée. [59:16] What did you say? [59:17] I was stunned [59:17] because I thought [59:19] he was cleared. [59:20] He was transported [59:23] to a state police barracks. [59:27] That was the first chance [59:29] that Detective Malvin [59:30] had to talk to [59:32] David Hosha. [59:33] You ever been advised [59:34] you to write before? [59:35] Yes, I have. [59:35] I didn't even get time [59:37] to even process anything. [59:39] I just... [59:39] It's like I was thrown [59:40] in an alligator pit [59:42] and I needed to fight [59:43] my way out of it. [59:45] Amanda has no idea [59:47] that she's about [59:48] to break the case. [59:49] Did you do? [59:53] Did you? [59:56] I didn't have a confession [1:00:06] from David Hosha. [1:00:07] I had all this other evidence. [1:00:08] The only way he could [1:00:09] say something [1:00:09] is if tactically [1:00:11] and psychologically [1:00:11] we got under his skin. [1:00:13] Do you understand [1:00:14] the statement you made [1:00:15] maybe you just got [1:00:16] an issue of court [1:00:16] and a lot of words [1:00:17] that's no secret issue? [1:00:19] Yes, sir. [1:00:19] We're here [1:00:20] to talk to you [1:00:21] about the deaths [1:00:23] of Angelique [1:00:23] and Bonk. [1:00:24] When we walked [1:00:26] into that interview room [1:00:28] I expected [1:00:29] to get a confession. [1:00:30] I was so pumped. [1:00:32] Do you recall [1:00:34] mail of a letter [1:00:35] from Northropshire Park? [1:00:40] I don't know what you said [1:00:41] left. [1:00:46] That's an envelope. [1:00:46] The person [1:00:51] that mailed that letter [1:00:53] for credit for the deaths [1:00:56] of Angelique [1:00:57] and Bonk. [1:00:59] Okay. [1:01:00] I think he was unnerved [1:01:03] but trying not to show it [1:01:04] and he's sort of like [1:01:06] processing the situation [1:01:08] talking in a normal [1:01:09] turn of the voice. [1:01:10] You were playing [1:01:11] 2.1 miles [1:01:12] of the post office [1:01:14] that processed that life. [1:01:16] Okay. [1:01:18] You think [1:01:18] it was not a coincidence? [1:01:20] But like I said [1:01:21] I don't remember [1:01:22] being in there [1:01:23] on July 23rd. [1:01:24] Okay. [1:01:25] But what? [1:01:26] That would be [1:01:26] one hell of a coincidence. [1:01:27] One hell of a coincidence. [1:01:28] I wanted David [1:01:30] to know [1:01:31] that we knew [1:01:33] almost better than him [1:01:34] what he had done [1:01:36] after the homicide. [1:01:37] Let me give you [1:01:39] a little history [1:01:40] on your trip. [1:01:41] You stayed at the [1:01:41] comfort end [1:01:42] room 333. [1:01:45] You had an IHOP [1:01:46] you had a potato pancake breakfast [1:01:47] a plum cake meal. [1:01:49] There is a psychological [1:01:50] tactical game [1:01:52] that goes on [1:01:53] in the room. [1:01:54] And it's hard. [1:01:54] I know [1:01:55] it's hard talking [1:01:56] about it the first time [1:01:57] but I guarantee you [1:01:58] once you get it [1:01:59] off your chest [1:02:00] you're going to feel [1:02:01] a lot better. [1:02:03] I know your heart [1:02:03] is burning right now man. [1:02:07] It got to a point [1:02:08] where I told him [1:02:10] that he wasn't going home. [1:02:12] That he was going [1:02:12] coming back to Norfolk [1:02:13] to stand trial [1:02:14] for killing Angelique [1:02:15] and Vonda. [1:02:17] And then he broke my heart. [1:02:21] I need to speak [1:02:21] to an attorney. [1:02:22] I need to speak [1:02:24] to an attorney. [1:02:25] Okay. [1:02:27] He said [1:02:28] I need to talk [1:02:29] to an attorney. [1:02:30] He knocked me down. [1:02:32] I didn't get anything [1:02:32] from him. [1:02:33] He lowered it up [1:02:34] and I knew [1:02:37] he wanted to talk [1:02:37] to Amanda [1:02:38] and Amanda [1:02:39] had asked [1:02:40] to talk to him. [1:02:40] I asked [1:02:42] if I could speak [1:02:43] with David [1:02:44] and find out [1:02:44] what's going on. [1:02:46] They told me [1:02:47] we'll get him ready. [1:02:48] So I waited. [1:02:51] I want to let Amanda [1:02:52] go. [1:02:52] You want to see her? [1:02:54] It was one of those [1:02:58] things where sometimes [1:02:59] like it's the drop [1:03:00] of water [1:03:00] in a still pool. [1:03:02] You allow the drop [1:03:03] to fall [1:03:03] and then it will [1:03:04] take its own course. [1:03:05] Did you do it? [1:03:26] Excuse me mom. [1:03:27] Did you? [1:03:31] I love you. [1:03:31] I love my heart. [1:03:33] Did you hurt these people? [1:03:37] We have kids. [1:03:38] I know we do. [1:03:39] I've asked [1:03:41] for an attorney. [1:03:41] I don't want to say [1:03:42] anything else [1:03:43] in front of a police [1:03:44] office. [1:03:45] So what did [1:03:46] detectives say to you [1:03:48] about talking to David [1:03:49] during the interrogation? [1:03:50] That I would have [1:03:51] a private conversation [1:03:52] in a room [1:03:54] and I could talk to him [1:03:56] and it would be [1:03:56] just me and him. [1:03:58] Let me do you guys [1:03:59] just one. [1:04:00] Thank you. [1:04:05] Detective Malbin [1:04:05] advised David [1:04:07] Hoshaw [1:04:07] of his legal rights. [1:04:08] This was in an interview [1:04:10] room in which [1:04:11] there was a camera [1:04:12] that was discreetly placed. [1:04:14] So did you know [1:04:15] it was going to be recorded? [1:04:16] No. [1:04:17] I never knew that. [1:04:18] Maybe I just [1:04:18] I need [1:04:19] I'm just [1:04:20] not the smartest [1:04:21] cookie in a bunch [1:04:22] but I thought [1:04:24] it was just [1:04:24] a private room. [1:04:25] He had a right [1:04:26] to remain solid. [1:04:27] He didn't have [1:04:28] to talk to Amanda [1:04:28] especially about the case. [1:04:30] He didn't have [1:04:30] to answer her. [1:04:37] I got creeped. [1:04:44] I'm so sorry. [1:04:45] Looking at you [1:04:47] on the interrogation tape [1:04:48] it's almost as if [1:04:50] you seem like [1:04:51] you're in physical pain. [1:04:53] I was sick to know [1:04:54] that my baby's daddy [1:04:55] did this. [1:04:56] I mean come on. [1:04:58] I was distraught. [1:04:59] I thought maybe [1:05:00] I was [1:05:02] having a nightmare. [1:05:05] I don't know [1:05:05] if I could have [1:05:06] me again. [1:05:07] I didn't [1:05:15] I didn't go down there [1:05:17] with that in my mind. [1:05:20] I went down there [1:05:21] to try and break up [1:05:22] and things got me. [1:05:23] I was so confused. [1:05:25] It doesn't make sense to me. [1:05:27] Why were you there [1:05:27] at that time? [1:05:28] If you were going to [1:05:30] break up with her [1:05:30] why didn't you do it [1:05:32] during the day? [1:05:35] Amanda started going off. [1:05:38] She picked up the letter. [1:05:40] They have this letter. [1:05:42] I was trying to [1:05:44] get him off my dad. [1:05:48] He eventually told her [1:05:49] he mailed a letter [1:05:50] to get us off the tail. [1:05:52] So at that point [1:05:54] I knew I had [1:05:55] the right person. [1:05:56] He took ownership [1:05:57] of being the writer [1:05:58] of the letters [1:05:59] in this exchange [1:06:00] with Amanda [1:06:01] and he said that [1:06:03] yeah I mailed them [1:06:04] to get them off [1:06:05] my tracks. [1:06:06] I never understood [1:06:07] how he had time [1:06:09] to write these letters. [1:06:11] So he must have [1:06:12] wrote them before [1:06:13] and had them [1:06:14] ready to go. [1:06:16] If he had never [1:06:17] mailed the letters [1:06:18] there's a very good chance [1:06:20] the evidence [1:06:20] would never have developed [1:06:21] to charge him. [1:06:23] Did you admit [1:06:24] to me? [1:06:26] I think you're pretty much. [1:06:29] Said enough to Amanda [1:06:35] to strengthen my case. [1:06:39] I couldn't wait [1:06:40] to come out [1:06:40] and call Phil. [1:06:43] It was [1:06:43] a great feeling. [1:06:45] He acknowledged [1:06:46] that he went [1:06:47] to the house [1:06:48] to break up [1:06:49] with her [1:06:49] but then things [1:06:50] got out of hand. [1:06:52] He admits [1:06:53] to her [1:06:54] sending the letters. [1:06:56] A confession [1:06:57] really is [1:06:58] a mission [1:07:00] of certain facts. [1:07:03] She just [1:07:04] pregnant at the time [1:07:10] and I just [1:07:13] found out [1:07:13] that my man [1:07:14] is guilty [1:07:15] of killing [1:07:16] two [1:07:17] not one [1:07:18] but two people. [1:07:19] All I could think of [1:07:29] is why I wanted [1:07:30] to get up [1:07:30] and slap him. [1:07:33] His smirky face [1:07:34] but I didn't [1:07:37] because [1:07:37] it wasn't worth it. [1:07:52] He lies. [1:08:01] All he does [1:08:02] is lie. [1:08:04] I feel [1:08:04] there's more truth [1:08:05] to the story [1:08:06] and I figure [1:08:07] the only way [1:08:08] I could get the truth [1:08:09] is through the courts. [1:08:11] The man accused [1:08:14] of killing [1:08:15] a Norfolk woman [1:08:16] and her mother [1:08:16] now faces [1:08:17] a capital murder [1:08:18] charge. [1:08:18] In Norfolk [1:08:19] yesterday [1:08:19] a grand jury [1:08:20] indicted [1:08:20] David Wayne [1:08:21] Hosham. [1:08:22] The problem [1:08:24] with the case [1:08:24] is the first [1:08:25] thing a defense [1:08:26] attorney is going [1:08:26] to do [1:08:26] is stand up [1:08:27] in court [1:08:27] and say [1:08:27] you do not [1:08:28] have one piece [1:08:28] of evidence [1:08:29] that demonstrates [1:08:30] my client [1:08:31] committed the crime. [1:08:33] We want people [1:08:48] to be held [1:08:49] accountable [1:08:50] for their actions. [1:08:52] Two people [1:08:52] are no longer [1:08:53] with us [1:08:54] who should be. [1:08:55] His past [1:08:55] is horrific. [1:08:56] He preys [1:08:57] on those [1:08:58] that are insecure [1:08:58] and maybe [1:09:00] people he perceives [1:09:01] as being weak. [1:09:02] He was a predator. [1:09:08] David Hosham [1:09:09] in jail [1:09:10] is waiting [1:09:11] for his murder [1:09:11] trial to start. [1:09:12] The prosecution [1:09:13] seems to feel [1:09:14] pretty good about this. [1:09:15] They have a very [1:09:16] unsympathetic guy [1:09:17] to put in front [1:09:17] of this jury. [1:09:19] It was clear [1:09:20] he went to great [1:09:21] ends to try [1:09:22] to cover his tracks [1:09:23] and we knew [1:09:25] that his taunting [1:09:26] in the letters, [1:09:27] the boasting [1:09:28] would not play well [1:09:29] to a jury. [1:09:30] But District Attorney [1:09:31] Evans has a problem. [1:09:32] The sort of evidence [1:09:34] he's going to give [1:09:34] to those 12 people. [1:09:36] Nobody said [1:09:37] he did it. [1:09:38] Nobody said [1:09:38] he confessed to me [1:09:39] he did it. [1:09:39] Nobody forensically [1:09:40] said it was his [1:09:41] thumbprint. [1:09:41] It was his DNA. [1:09:43] To be blunt, [1:09:44] what we did [1:09:44] was we built up [1:09:45] a case of [1:09:46] circumstantial evidence [1:09:47] layering one [1:09:49] piece of evidence, [1:09:51] information, [1:09:51] on top of another. [1:09:53] This is not [1:09:54] where a prosecutor [1:09:54] wants to be. [1:09:55] Juries like to have [1:09:56] that smoking gun, [1:09:57] that forensic proof, [1:09:59] but that's not [1:09:59] the hand that he's [1:10:00] been dealt. [1:10:01] At the same time, [1:10:02] the defense is doing [1:10:03] their job trying [1:10:04] to exclude evidence [1:10:05] the prosecutor does [1:10:06] have, like Angel's [1:10:07] diary entries. [1:10:09] David said in a [1:10:10] condescending tone [1:10:11] of voice, [1:10:12] question me where I am. [1:10:16] They want to throw [1:10:16] out the interrogation [1:10:17] video. [1:10:19] I got a creep. [1:10:22] But it doesn't work. [1:10:23] The judge admits it all. [1:10:24] The diary, [1:10:25] the interrogation, [1:10:26] the jury's going to [1:10:27] see all of it. [1:10:28] The case was set [1:10:32] to be tried for a month. [1:10:34] We had about 140 [1:10:35] witnesses subpoenaed. [1:10:36] We were ready to go. [1:10:37] We literally had [1:10:39] travel arrangements [1:10:40] for, I think, [1:10:42] half of the vendors [1:10:43] in Michigan. [1:10:44] Shop owners, [1:10:45] clerks at hotels. [1:10:47] I don't think anybody [1:10:48] could have got food [1:10:49] up and down the [1:10:50] interstate in the [1:10:50] middle of Michigan [1:10:51] because they were all [1:10:52] coming to Norfolk, [1:10:52] Virginia for trial. [1:10:53] We produced a mannequin [1:11:02] and we asked the [1:11:03] medical examiner [1:11:04] to use knitting needles [1:11:07] and we intended [1:11:08] to use this at trial [1:11:09] to demonstrate [1:11:11] all of the wounds. [1:11:13] It not only shows [1:11:14] just the incredible [1:11:15] sheer number [1:11:16] of stab wounds [1:11:17] in this area, [1:11:18] but it does clearly [1:11:19] show that Angel [1:11:20] sustained defensive wounds. [1:11:23] A demonstration like that [1:11:24] is so effective [1:11:25] with the jury. [1:11:26] It shows the level [1:11:27] of violence [1:11:28] of what they call [1:11:29] overkill. [1:11:30] We have waited [1:11:36] three years [1:11:37] to hear David Hoshaw [1:11:38] on the stand [1:11:39] to see all the proof. [1:11:42] A lot of emotion. [1:11:45] You, [1:11:46] you want that justice. [1:11:48] The death penalty [1:11:48] is on the table [1:11:50] and facing all of that, [1:11:53] Hoshaw surprises them all. [1:11:56] David Hoshaw pleaded guilty [1:11:57] to capital murder [1:11:58] and first degree murder. [1:11:59] He was originally scheduled [1:12:01] for a jury trial next week. [1:12:03] A guilty plea. [1:12:05] No trial. [1:12:05] And suddenly, [1:12:06] it's over. [1:12:08] Detective Rick Malbon [1:12:09] is excited. [1:12:10] He finally got his guy. [1:12:11] He pled guilty. [1:12:12] He's getting ready [1:12:13] to call Amanda [1:12:14] and deliver [1:12:15] what he thinks [1:12:16] is great news. [1:12:17] But he was not [1:12:18] expecting this reaction. [1:12:20] I was shocked. [1:12:22] I couldn't even handle it. [1:12:25] I said things to Rick [1:12:26] that maybe I shouldn't have said, [1:12:28] but he deserved [1:12:29] to go to trial. [1:12:30] He deserved [1:12:30] to have the whole laundry, [1:12:32] all the truth out, [1:12:34] to set her family free, [1:12:37] to give her, [1:12:38] that family, [1:12:39] the truth about everything. [1:12:42] Accepting a plea agreement [1:12:43] for two life sentences, [1:12:45] first degree murder, [1:12:46] David had to stand before [1:12:48] the Guayanas, [1:12:49] the victim's loved ones, [1:12:51] and he had to admit [1:12:52] to killing Angel and Vonda. [1:12:54] He made a very long, [1:12:56] very bizarre statement. [1:12:58] He then went on [1:12:59] to lecture every participant [1:13:02] in the court process. [1:13:04] I want to say shame on you, [1:13:06] Detective Malbon, [1:13:07] for his actions. [1:13:08] The Lord God Almighty [1:13:09] does not like people [1:13:11] to be full of pride [1:13:12] of themselves. [1:13:13] I pray that you lose [1:13:14] that pride [1:13:14] before it's too late. [1:13:18] Every word that came out [1:13:19] of David's mouth in court [1:13:21] just made me angry. [1:13:23] just to see him, [1:13:25] to see words coming [1:13:26] from his mouth. [1:13:28] Today, for the sake [1:13:29] of my family, [1:13:30] I'm pleading guilty [1:13:31] to this horrific crime. [1:13:33] I'm putting their needs [1:13:34] and their desires [1:13:35] ahead of my own. [1:13:37] He said he pleaded guilty [1:13:38] for his family. [1:13:41] Uh, no. [1:13:42] Well, do you think [1:13:43] that was for you [1:13:43] and your children? [1:13:44] I think he lied. [1:13:46] He didn't take this deal [1:13:47] for his family [1:13:47] because he knew [1:13:48] I wanted him [1:13:50] to go to trial. [1:13:51] He murdered him. [1:13:51] He doesn't do it [1:13:52] to live. [1:13:53] I'm sorry. [1:13:56] It might be harsh, [1:13:57] but it's the truth. [1:14:00] Two life sentences, [1:14:01] I think it's what he got. [1:14:03] He is ineligible [1:14:04] for parole. [1:14:06] He's gonna rock [1:14:08] their jail. [1:14:10] Would you forgive somebody [1:14:11] that killed your mom [1:14:12] and sister? [1:14:13] I won't. [1:14:16] The family's most [1:14:17] basic question [1:14:18] is never answered [1:14:19] in court, [1:14:20] and that is, [1:14:20] why did he do it? [1:14:22] So, this is really [1:14:23] the first time [1:14:24] you're talking [1:14:24] about Vonda [1:14:25] and Angelique. [1:14:26] Well, I don't know [1:14:28] what I'm talking about. [1:14:29] And he does talk [1:14:30] about it [1:14:31] in a prison interview. [1:14:32] After all these years, [1:14:38] I still think about her. [1:14:40] I have a tattoo [1:14:43] of two butterflies. [1:14:44] It's just a reminder. [1:14:47] It's always there. [1:14:49] It's something [1:14:51] I can see every day [1:14:53] and know that she's there, [1:14:57] even if she's not. [1:15:00] Remember, [1:15:00] to avoid the death penalty, [1:15:02] David Hoshaw [1:15:02] had to admit [1:15:03] that he killed [1:15:04] Vonda and Angel, [1:15:05] but he didn't have [1:15:06] to say why, [1:15:07] and he hasn't [1:15:07] until now. [1:15:10] David Hoshaw [1:15:11] agreed to interview [1:15:12] with me over the phone [1:15:13] since he is in [1:15:14] a high-security [1:15:15] prison facility. [1:15:16] David tells me [1:15:18] that night [1:15:18] he went [1:15:19] to Angel's house [1:15:20] to simply [1:15:21] break up with her [1:15:22] at one in the morning. [1:15:25] How were you thinking [1:15:26] the night [1:15:27] would have played out? [1:15:39] David claims [1:15:40] that when he told Angel [1:15:41] it was over, [1:15:42] there were tears [1:15:43] and raised voices. [1:15:45] You have [1:16:04] one minute [1:16:05] remaining. [1:16:07] And his second victim, [1:16:08] he says [1:16:09] Vonda tried to stop him. [1:16:11] I thought, [1:16:25] wow, [1:16:26] you know, [1:16:27] I always got so lucky. [1:16:28] He made himself [1:16:30] out to be [1:16:31] a guy [1:16:31] that was [1:16:32] a terrific man. [1:16:33] He was a [1:16:34] boy scout engineer. [1:16:36] I mean, [1:16:36] he takes care [1:16:37] of his sons. [1:16:38] I mean, [1:16:38] he's there for them [1:16:39] when they need it. [1:16:40] In a way, [1:16:42] David Hoshaw [1:16:42] left two kinds [1:16:43] of victims, [1:16:44] the ones he killed [1:16:45] and the ones [1:16:46] he left behind. [1:16:48] There are a lot [1:16:49] of times [1:16:50] when I think, [1:16:52] it should have been me. [1:16:54] It should have been me [1:16:55] and it wasn't. [1:16:58] Why? [1:16:59] That monster. [1:17:00] I was married [1:17:02] to that monster. [1:17:04] The ripple effect [1:17:05] of grief [1:17:06] that families experience [1:17:08] and loved ones experience [1:17:09] in cases like this, [1:17:11] it goes through generations. [1:17:12] He lied [1:17:13] and he, [1:17:14] you know, [1:17:14] about him being [1:17:15] in a relationship [1:17:16] with Angelique. [1:17:17] So he like [1:17:18] got me [1:17:19] into the circle [1:17:19] and then he got [1:17:21] rid of her, [1:17:23] murdered her [1:17:23] because [1:17:24] basically of me. [1:17:26] I'm feeling [1:17:27] horrible [1:17:27] for them. [1:17:29] I hate, [1:17:29] you know, [1:17:30] I'm not hating him. [1:17:33] It's like a lot of hate. [1:17:35] So what do you do with it? [1:17:37] The coroner noted [1:17:40] something in their report. [1:17:42] The only thing [1:17:42] Angel Guyana [1:17:43] was wearing [1:17:44] when she died [1:17:44] was a medallion. [1:17:48] I have dreamed [1:17:48] of a knight [1:17:49] in shining armor. [1:17:51] Don't laugh, [1:17:52] but I've kept [1:17:53] a medallion [1:17:53] of gold and silver [1:17:54] of a knight [1:17:55] upon a steed [1:17:56] for the day [1:17:56] I meet him. [1:17:59] I had an old mentor [1:18:01] who told me, [1:18:02] you can always see [1:18:03] the soul [1:18:04] of your victim [1:18:04] reflected in the eyes [1:18:06] of those who love them. [1:18:08] And on the fourth [1:18:09] of July, [1:18:10] it's kind of hard [1:18:12] day to remember, [1:18:13] you know, [1:18:14] because that's the weekend [1:18:16] this all happened. [1:18:17] Her brother remembers [1:18:18] a moment [1:18:19] long after the murders [1:18:20] when he went [1:18:21] by the house. [1:18:23] This kid was laughing, [1:18:24] but I saw my sister, [1:18:26] my mom and my sister [1:18:27] standing there [1:18:27] looking at me. [1:18:29] And they were there [1:18:30] and they were smiling [1:18:31] and I looked back [1:18:33] and they were gone. [1:18:34] But I know, [1:18:35] I saw them. [1:18:36] I'll remember that. [1:18:38] I think I am at peace. [1:18:40] I know I am at peace. [1:18:41] It's taken me years [1:18:43] to get to this place. [1:18:45] I just think [1:18:47] of them very fondly. [1:18:48] My mom's incredible [1:18:49] sense of humor [1:18:50] and Angel, [1:18:54] just gosh. [1:18:57] Angelique was a gift [1:18:59] to our family. [1:19:02] What are you left with [1:19:03] when someone dies? [1:19:06] Photographs, [1:19:06] memories, [1:19:08] before the Guyanas, [1:19:09] Angel's poems. [1:19:13] The night with its endless [1:19:14] realm of possibilities. [1:19:16] What could last forever? [1:19:18] Stars, [1:19:20] scattered diamonds [1:19:20] of the night. [1:19:21] The stars watch [1:19:23] and somewhat guide [1:19:24] choices and outcomes. [1:19:27] But in the end, [1:19:29] the stars watch us. [1:19:33] That's my girl. [1:19:35] That's my girl. [1:19:38] Find all new broadcast episodes [1:19:45] of 2020 Friday nights [1:19:47] at 9 on ABC.