About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of Fed Chair Warsh delivers remarks at jobs and productivity task force conference from ABC 7 Chicago, published November 16, 2026. The transcript contains 4,657 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"productivity and jobs task force conference hosted by chairman warsh the federal reserve board and the federal reserve bank of san francisco we are just delighted to have you with us for this important conversation i can't imagine perhaps a better week to have this conference in november of 2022..."
[00:00:00] productivity and jobs task force conference hosted by chairman warsh the federal reserve board and
[00:00:05] the federal reserve bank of san francisco we are just delighted to have you with us for this
[00:00:11] important conversation i can't imagine perhaps a better week to have this conference in november
[00:00:18] of 2022 though the world seemed to change open ai released chat gpt and anyone with a phone and
[00:00:26] basic curiosity could see what technologists and financiers had known for a while ai or si has the
[00:00:36] potential to transform now sitting here in the bay area we see that type of change and that type of
[00:00:42] potential every day and it's growing expanding at a rate that's very hard to predict if you thought
[00:00:49] you knew what it could do yesterday you'll be wrong tomorrow now i can say personally this just feels
[00:00:55] different i started at the federal reserve in san francisco in 1996 and witnessed firsthand the
[00:01:01] internet boom and what it meant for people and businesses across the nation this feels faster
[00:01:09] more transformative and less familiar than anything i've seen in my lived experience and probably the
[00:01:16] lived experience of most of you maybe it's like electrification maybe it's like the industrial
[00:01:22] revolution maybe it's much much better the one thing we know for sure is it's definitely different
[00:01:30] so for policy makers these possibilities these promises they're important but they're only part of
[00:01:38] our equation we need to know what will happen not just in the future not in the thing we can all agree
[00:01:44] with will be different but only you know across the timeline throughout the the change throughout the
[00:01:52] transformation we need to know what happens to growth productivity inflation and the labor market
[00:01:59] and this is where insights from the task force and from this conference and the dialogue we have here
[00:02:05] so today we'll hear from technologists academics businesses and other leading thinkers
[00:02:21] talking about what ai could be what it is now and how it's likely to evolve over the coming years
[00:02:29] i personally expect to have a very lively conversation you have the liveliest conversations
[00:02:34] when no one's really sure and everybody is evaluating and investigating together
[00:02:40] so i'd like to get started and here i have literally the distinct pleasure
[00:02:46] and privilege and honor of welcoming kevin warsh chairman of the federal reserve
[00:02:51] we're going to thank you very much for joining us and thank you very much for joining us today
[00:02:59] and thank you very much for joining us and thank you very much for joining us for joining us
[00:03:03] and thank you very much for joining us and thank you very much for joining us for joining us
[00:03:08] and thank you very much for joining us today and thank you very much for joining us today
[00:03:11] and thank you very much for joining us for joining us today and thank you very much for joining us
[00:03:15] thank you very much for joining us today and thank you very much for joining us today
[00:03:18] and thank you very much for joining us today we're going to be here and welcome to the san francisco fed
[00:03:21] uh thank you all very much uh mary thank you for the most kind introduction uh i'm grateful to her
[00:03:38] i'm grateful to the staff at the san francisco fed and the board staff for pulling this off on
[00:03:43] relatively short notice now this is my first visit to a reserve bank as chairman i wouldn't call it a
[00:03:50] snap inspection but i'm certainly impressed by what i've seen in the first couple of hours
[00:03:56] what i really see are high expectations from mary from her colleagues a reform orientation
[00:04:04] a view that we need a forward-looking inquiring spirit because the world is changing every bit
[00:04:10] as fast as mary said at the outlook it's also great to be joined by plenty of my fed colleagues from
[00:04:15] the board and from around the system as you guys know central banking well it's a team
[00:04:20] sport and i'm pleased that you're all here this conference is an expression of the mission we
[00:04:26] all have at the fed one fed fit for purpose focused on the future i also want to thank the task force
[00:04:34] leaders that are here mark andreessen chad jones asha sharma for leading this task force
[00:04:41] you're giving the scare system resources your time and your commitment it's a service to the fed and
[00:04:47] our nation and i am eternally grateful the task force is one of the five i've convened as chairman
[00:04:54] these groups are a way of broadening our thinking of inviting robust discussions that take us far
[00:05:00] deeper far more involved than fleeting data points or daily market moves our task forces are an intellectual
[00:05:09] investment to help better equip us for the next policy conjuncture and beyond we need to get this right
[00:05:17] the common attribute of those leaders i mentioned asha mark chad the reason i asked them to lead
[00:05:23] is not just their exceptional insight and experience it's their battlefield bravery in the world of ideas
[00:05:30] their intellect their willingness to think hard and at least as important think anew
[00:05:36] they need to help us think about what might happen next they're the ones who asked me to open up the
[00:05:42] task force discussions to all of you to broaden the discussion among academics businesses leaders of
[00:05:48] all sorts because none of us have a monopoly on the truth as for me i feel particularly engaged to be
[00:05:56] back here in california i arrived here in this part of the world in 1988 as a stanford undergrad i remember
[00:06:04] sitting in green library over thanksgiving didn't go back home i did a little bit of extra work my
[00:06:09] freshman year reading and wrestling with the great works from a canon that i had scarcely known existed
[00:06:16] that was in my own little way an initiation to the world of ideas it was a special time to be in the bay
[00:06:22] area neither boom nor bust a quieter period between tech surges and today just as then i'm keen to listen and
[00:06:32] learn from the greatest minds and the people that are thinking anew about this new era
[00:06:38] the current era may be the most transformational period in my adult lifetime marked by the arrival
[00:06:45] of this new general purpose technology si it's an entirely new force in economic life and society
[00:06:52] and it demands our special attention even a few years ago the idea that we could find in our pockets
[00:07:00] instant access to genius level intelligence on almost any subject would have seemed far-fetched
[00:07:07] today with the advances of si it is happening the marginal cost of satisfying limitless curiosity
[00:07:16] on questions large and small is falling fast perhaps even trending towards zero
[00:07:24] a subject that financial markets are trying to figure out every day so now we're going to turn to the
[00:07:30] wonkier part of the discussion but frankly the more consequential in the tradition of endogenous growth
[00:07:36] theory and economics ideas are the ultimate resource if living standards are to advance conditions must be
[00:07:44] favorable to the generation of new ideas it should be no surprise then that the united states is leading
[00:07:53] societies that bring forth the best ideas well they tend to prosper the most the implications for economic
[00:08:00] policy can hardly be overstated while an idea can be costly to discover it's free to use and because
[00:08:09] an idea is non-rival that is one person's use does nothing to diminish that of anyone else its value grows with
[00:08:18] the number of people who use it the nobel laureate paul romer among others including my friend chad has
[00:08:25] shown that a doubling of ideas and other key inputs can more than double output the keyword there is more
[00:08:32] allowing increasing returns to scale even so in the u.s over the last several decades breakthrough ideas
[00:08:42] had been harder to find you'll recall at conferences like this this is when there'd be discussions about
[00:08:48] secular stagnation by some efforts research efforts have increased more than 20 times since the 1930s
[00:08:56] yet nick bloom another friend who's here chad jones and other co-authors have pointed out that research
[00:09:02] productivity has fallen by an even larger amount the result productivity growth has fluctuated
[00:09:10] and while in recent quarters it has been reasonably strong it hasn't yet broken out definitively structurally
[00:09:18] reliably to the upside at least not yet long-run growth i should note is also a function of the rate
[00:09:26] of increase in the number of people producing these ideas setting them in motion the conventional view
[00:09:33] holds that as population growth slows there may be fewer new ideas to drive prosperity the increasing
[00:09:41] challenge of generating breakthrough ideas combined with slower population growth helps explain why many in the
[00:09:48] economics profession especially in the post-crisis environment return to the old theme from the 1930s of secular
[00:09:55] stagnation so the question for all of us the one that i want to explore with our colleagues today
[00:10:02] is does superintelligence dramatically change this picture well there's certainly some indications that it does
[00:10:11] SI might be somewhat different from general purpose technologies the kind that mary referenced in the outset the internal combustion
[00:10:18] is an engine or electricity or the transistor those inventions made for decades a follow-on innovation
[00:10:24] so i don't mean to dismiss them but they did not themselves automate the creation of new ideas
[00:10:31] what might set SI apart as an economic influence is that it could supercharge idea generation
[00:10:40] it appears to be changing the method and at least as important the speed of innovation
[00:10:46] if idea generation broadens growth could be sustained at a level substantially higher than the long run
[00:10:53] average but for all of that however let me make one essential point humans should not be underestimated
[00:11:01] there is no replacing the minds and hands of men and women machines that can amass or even exceed human
[00:11:08] knowledge well they're still machines they do not take the place of human judgment morality dignity or responsibility
[00:11:18] humans are the designers and the builders and humans must be the deciders so for our country in this era
[00:11:27] consider how much is on the line consider the reason why five and a half months ago we put this task force in the front of the line
[00:11:35] in this nation i remember bob mendel another nobel recipient saying years ago that the most important
[00:11:41] fact of the 20th century was the rise of the united states as a superpower for us today that's more than a fact of history
[00:11:50] it's our charge to keep and so we must ask can you be a superpower without super intelligence
[00:11:57] and we're certainly not here to make predictions we can't know the future and as you've heard from me
[00:12:11] before in other settings we ought not to pretend otherwise our job is to prepare for whatever comes next
[00:12:18] that means contingency planning a subject that i will return to in other task forces contingency planning
[00:12:26] becomes only more important when the world is changing at this fast speed so our aim today is a
[00:12:33] humble one to ask the right questions as policy makers we have to be mindful that great opportunities
[00:12:42] rarely come risk-free and the risks in this case if overlooked can be highly disruptive and economically
[00:12:51] quite costly si empire empowers all including bad actors so we're thinking especially of critical
[00:13:01] infrastructures and their vulnerabilities and of course i think of economic policy in this new era of si
[00:13:10] at the at the fed our role is neither as advocates or opponents our responsibility is to recognize
[00:13:19] that the widespread adoption of this technology will have a very significant effect on the economy
[00:13:26] with hugely important implications for our day jobs on monetary policy so let me say a few words
[00:13:32] about some of the big questions they're mostly about magnitude scope and timing of this development
[00:13:39] first will this new technology deliver a rise in total factor productivity will the democratization of
[00:13:48] specialized knowledge significantly raise standards of living when will this surge start if it hasn't
[00:13:55] already and when will it taper will it happen sooner or faster here in the u.s than in other countries
[00:14:03] and will adversaries race to deploy si in whatever its form happens to be intending to do harm to our economy
[00:14:12] these answers will matter greatly and that is why we're thinking about them today in a sober serious way
[00:14:20] and i expect more clarity with the passage of time still we've got a job to do in monetary policy so it's worth
[00:14:28] considering the range of economic outcomes we could see over the next several years depending on how si
[00:14:34] progresses board staff has begun to evaluate various contingencies there's that word again applying
[00:14:41] stylized model-based frameworks to generate scenarios they're illustrative scenarios they're not forecast
[00:14:47] they're not predictions moreover many other outcomes probably including the one that will actually happen
[00:14:53] could be drawn consider them a starting point for the very useful discussions we've got lined up today
[00:15:00] first at one end si leads to an increase in productivity and economic gains that are shared broadly
[00:15:07] across labor and the owners of capital in that event real gdp grows persistently above its long-term
[00:15:15] average and the u.s stays close to full employment other outcomes however could be less positive
[00:15:23] an si-driven expansion could bring substantial labor market disruption as some jobs are displaced rather
[00:15:30] than complemented by technology gdp growth would still rise above its long-term average in this
[00:15:36] contingency but widespread automation combined with labor market frictions could push the jobless rate
[00:15:43] above levels consistent with full employment let me reference a third or si could disappoint after
[00:15:52] significant capital investment stock market gains expected returns could turn down equity valuations could
[00:15:59] fall leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment in time the economy
[00:16:06] would recover but without the productivity gains i stress that while i'm not here to offer predictions
[00:16:12] i'm not exactly impartial about american leadership in a time so filled with both challenge and possibility
[00:16:22] i'll end where i began thinking back to my first visits out to this part of the world
[00:16:26] to my days at the hoover institution and to a collaboration with my fine mentor and colleague john
[00:16:33] kogan as we wrote some years ago without the knowledge that si might be upon us but i must say as optimists
[00:16:41] and believers in the u.s and i'll quote a paper that he and i wrote together if we meet the challenges
[00:16:48] before us we said america has a bright future with strong durable economic growth abundant economic
[00:16:56] opportunities vibrant and secure communities and a healthy environment future generations will inherit
[00:17:04] a dynamic economy capable of delivering technological advances that will extend lives and promote human
[00:17:10] flourishing that's the goal that's the ultimate scenario that's what all of us here hope to see
[00:17:18] i can just end with a final note it is a privilege privilege of a lifetime to be a policymaker
[00:17:24] here at a time of such consequence and it's the most encouraging sign to be joined by some of the most
[00:17:31] serious sober responsible thinkers great men and women who are willing to join the fed even as an aside
[00:17:39] to try to put put our si goals on the right path thank you all very much let me turn now to our first
[00:17:46] panel and i'll ask my panelists to join me up here on stage thank you
[00:18:01] so let's uh turn to this first panel it's an honor to be joined by these three gentlemen i've known them
[00:18:21] all for decades um let me do let me introduce this like we would a proper beautiful old russian novel
[00:18:29] introduce the characters and then we'll see where the plot goes um um i have the wrong one in front
[00:18:35] of me hold on a sec that's the wrong characters i was going to introduce so this panel is called at
[00:18:40] the frontier um the idea here is to ask questions from people that are users of the technology who are
[00:18:49] some of the most innovative thinkers that i know we didn't call these guys here because they're at the
[00:18:54] labs and they're designing this great stuff we called them here because we wanted to know what's really
[00:19:00] happening inside of companies that they happen to run technology companies might be an accident of
[00:19:07] history is that because these technology companies themselves are more innovative are willing to cast
[00:19:12] aside how they've done business or is it just three guys that happen to work down the street
[00:19:17] um let me do the brief introductions nikesh is immediately to my left he's the chairman and ceo
[00:19:22] of palo alto networks which he's led since 2018 before that he was the president at softbank where i
[00:19:29] came to know him and even before that he was at google where he was the chief business officer
[00:19:35] next to him patrick collison i've known him and his brother since they came to these shores as
[00:19:40] young men from overseas poor immigrants and they've done pretty well in the united states
[00:19:46] millions of businesses used stripe the business that they started and founded to accept payments and
[00:19:51] payouts and manage other complex online enterprises max levchin who's at the end has been a friend also
[00:19:58] for i don't know 20 years he also came to the united states and is one of the smartest people that i know
[00:20:07] he's the founder and ceo of a firm the co-founder and chairman of other companies and he created an
[00:20:14] innovation lab called hvf which stands for hard valuable and fun i don't know if i was supposed to
[00:20:19] disclose that max was the chief technology officer at paypal back when we were all much younger than this
[00:20:27] and before at least some of us had got mixed up in public policy and he was the chairman of yelp not bad
[00:20:33] not bad for someone new to our shores so those are the three people i want to sort of probe on a few
[00:20:39] areas of questions one is adoption what's really happening and i want to try to understand if what's
[00:20:46] happening is so special and different in their companies what about the rest what about the other 450
[00:20:53] companies in the s p the other 2 000 companies in the russell 2000 because i want to know whether this is
[00:20:59] just a technology that's at the frontier and going to stay there is going to find its way more broadly
[00:21:05] when i start at the end max with you um tell us about how your business is different how you're using
[00:21:12] this new technology and exactly what you think that means not just for your business but for the broader
[00:21:18] economy sure thank you can everyone hear me uh thank you chairman for inviting me to participate
[00:21:28] um so a firm is a lender fairly sizable one and uh everything we do is done by machines so our
[00:21:36] underwriting models are entirely ml super intelligence based etc etc and so we've been an early adopter
[00:21:44] of the earliest models we've been using them primarily to increase our engineering productivity
[00:21:51] which for scale is about five times more productive so the cost per feature is one-fifth or what you
[00:21:58] know what it was we expect it to be one-tenth so these are pretty pretty extraordinary gains
[00:22:04] it's a great story that's what everybody will tell you so this is none of it is new so to contextualize
[00:22:08] what that means as a lender our job is to sort risk so people come in they ask to borrow money because
[00:22:14] they're trying to buy something we need to pick the ones that are most likely to pay us back on time
[00:22:19] every time versus the ones that don't and it's all done by machines but humans are the ones deciding
[00:22:26] what makes an interesting predictor so the fancy term is feature the kind of colloquial term is a signal
[00:22:31] as you try to decide what what might be a great signal that predicts your ability to repay
[00:22:37] the ideas greatly outstrip the available time to train and the engineers to put those things
[00:22:42] into motion so there's lots and lots of really good ideas that end up on a cutting room floor
[00:22:46] so what does this efficiency or this productivity gain really do for us we're able to pick up a
[00:22:51] tremendous number of these ideas off the floor and put them into production so
[00:22:56] so in a kind of a almost too meta a story we used llms to design our most recent model which in
[00:23:05] itself is actually built on top of a transformer model so not exactly an llm but a token representation
[00:23:10] of repayment events that allowed us to do almost twice as well as the next non-llm model would have
[00:23:18] done so we ran the two side by side and we saw an 80 increase over the baseline
[00:23:22] which again for context translates to about two more billion dollars per year of loans for us
[00:23:26] and so this is a direct consequence of just being able to free up engineering talent all human zero
[00:23:34] layoffs due to ai at a firm um and just deploy them for what you might think of mass customization
[00:23:42] which i think is what's going to happen you know the maybe maybe i'm too pollyannish but as a techno
[00:23:47] utopian i i'm prone to uh to to love our machine overlords what i think will happen is uh we will
[00:23:55] see more and more of these long tail ideas that no one would ever have the time or the productivity or
[00:24:01] the staff to lift off the floor come to four and some of them will fail but that's what we're supposed
[00:24:07] to see but we get to find out if the thing that you need and only you which is now can be produced at
[00:24:13] a much lower cost is going to be vitally created and you might in fact find that there is the
[00:24:19] intersection between supply and demand that that makes it work so patrick let me let me turn to you
[00:24:24] i presume you're going to also tell us a story that stripe is at this frontier and you're making great
[00:24:31] progress we want to hear about that we want to hear also from you about how long will the delay be
[00:24:38] between those at the frontier and the rest what do you think is holding down what's the bottleneck
[00:24:43] when will the rest see it and what happens if they don't um well again great to be here when you
[00:24:50] said it's like a russian novel or or something i thought it was because we're all you know unhappy
[00:24:53] in our own ways as uh ceos but um but um so yeah like max we've seen a very significant uh acceleration
[00:25:02] um and and it's been changing quarter by quarter where you know 12 months ago uh maybe the you know
[00:25:07] the narrow work of engineers was being somewhat accelerated in code production whereas today at
[00:25:12] stripe and i'm sure at both palatal networks and at affirm it's more about these longer horizon loops
[00:25:17] where the agents are identifying tasks autonomously themselves they're going and actually implementing
[00:25:22] the feature or fixing the bug or whatever end to end uh and deploying it to production with uh with
[00:25:27] substantially reduced human i mean human oversight nonetheless but reduced significantly reduced
[00:25:31] human oversight as compared to say six months ago in terms of what that means for stripe the
[00:25:35] organization um i mean it's interesting there's always kind of this question you know to what extent ai is
[00:25:40] kind of a a substitute versus a complement at least in the near term uh we're seeing substantially reduced
[00:25:47] hiring for our gna functions as compared to some you know prior counterfactual um uh and uh you know gna as
[00:25:54] a share of our revenue is definitely diminishing quickly but for engineering that is kind of r d you
[00:25:59] know our kind of product production uh and for sales uh thus far we are seeing acceleration because you
[00:26:07] know effectively the as max said the cost of future production is diminishing so you know in the face of
[00:26:11] that there's a sale on for feature production and in the you know in the face of the sale we want to buy much
[00:26:17] more uh than we uh than we did previously uh and similarly on you know our sellers are much more
[00:26:22] productive than they were previously and so therefore on an you know the roi math is quite straightforward
[00:26:28] it's mathematically arithmetically makes sense to hire to hire more of them in terms of we're seeing
[00:26:32] across the economy generally um you know i remember early in stripes history um the ceo of a very large
[00:26:40] mega cap uh company came to visit um and you know we were all we were using all these new sas collaboration
[00:26:47] tools and everyone in the company could see what was going on and all the things and you know he was
[00:26:51] shocked i mean the stripe was a 30 person company at this at this juncture he was shocked that we were
[00:26:56] um that we were you know that we would operate this way and you know where is the governance and the sock
[00:27:01] too and you know all the kind of enterprise considerations uh that uh that you know were that looms large for
[00:27:06] him and um and i'm now sensing some of this same disparity and kind of mental model impedance mismatch between
[00:27:16] incumbent organizations and new companies uh where large companies uh and uh i i put stripe to some
[00:27:23] extent on the incumbent side of this we have all the same questions uh that uh that you have in terms
[00:27:29] of well where is the human supervision and where's the governance and what's the certification and the
[00:27:34] compliance and you know all the things that a sort of prudentially oriented uh infrastructure company
[00:27:39] uh i think uh is is wise to consider um new startups are new startups and they're happy you know we would
[00:27:49] not autonomously plug the agents into uh sort of just you know feature development loops and you know
[00:27:56] dust off our hands and walk away and say hey you guys do whatever you want to do
[00:28:00] the new startups are happy to do this um and the 2026 cohort of companies started on stripe is mass of
[00:28:09] new companies is massively outperforming uh any prior year's cohort by you know a dramatic magnitude
[00:28:17] the number of new businesses being launched on stripe every week is up approximately twofold year over
[00:28:23] year yeah we've we've had more than one decade long time series here you know stripe has been in
[00:28:28] operation for around 15 years and so a 2x year over year increase increase is not something with
[00:28:34] historical precedent even for example during the pandemic and so i guess i'm reminded of you
[00:28:38] know there's the the um many people here in the room can correct me is the paul david 1990 paper
[00:28:43] i think about how with uh electricity by and large the benefits accrued to new firms rather than
[00:28:50] existing incumbent firms uh adapting and um you know obviously existing firms are trying to adapt and
[00:28:56] you know there's certain you know ai is incredibly salient for ceos across the industry but i will say
[00:29:00] that new firms that we observe and whose business performance we directly see on stripe um are um
[00:29:07] are proceeding at an unprecedented pace uh and