About this transcript: This is a full AI-generated transcript of EXPLOITATION FOR MONEY: Roblox CONFRONTED over threats to children from Fox Business, published November 18, 2026. The transcript contains 17,291 words with timestamps and was generated using Whisper AI.
"Well, good afternoon. I'd like to welcome everyone to this hearing today, which is entitled Roblox and Online Gaming, Digital Playgrounds Endangering America's Children. This is a hearing of the Senate Judiciary Committee's subcommittee on crime and counterterrorism, which I'm delighted to work on..."
[0:00] Well, good afternoon. I'd like to welcome everyone to this hearing today, which is entitled
[0:04] Roblox and Online Gaming, Digital Playgrounds Endangering America's Children. This is a
[0:09] hearing of the Senate Judiciary Committee's subcommittee on crime and counterterrorism,
[0:13] which I'm delighted to work on with my colleague, Ranking Member Durbin. We're here today to
[0:18] discuss a question that I know from personal experience weighs on the mind of every parent
[0:23] in America, which is, are my children safe online? And the answer is, if your children
[0:28] are on Roblox, and millions of American children are every single day, they are safe not at all.
[0:37] Roblox is one of the most popular gaming platforms in the world, and if your children are on Roblox,
[0:42] they are being exposed in all likelihood to sexual predators, to sexually obscene material,
[0:47] to sexually exploitative content left, right, and center. The company is worth $33 billion.
[0:55] The company's CEO is worth $3.3 billion on his own. And the sad fact of the matter is, is that
[1:04] much of that money and many of those profits have come from exposing children, and I do mean
[1:11] children, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 years old, to sexually obscene material. And the worst part of it is,
[1:19] is that after Roblox does this, and they know what's going on on their platform, after they do it,
[1:23] they force these same child victims into arbitration, which is a fancy way of saying
[1:29] they slam the courthouse door shut in their faces. We're talking about children now. Child
[1:35] victims of sexual exploitation online are denied their day in court by the very company that has
[1:42] exposed them to the content to begin with. Why? For money. It's always the same answer. It's for
[1:49] money. It's for profits. It keeps the profits flowing to this $33 billion company. And we're
[1:55] here today to expose the truth about what is happening on this platform and how it's endangering
[2:01] America's children. But we're also here to call for change. After months of investigation,
[2:06] Senator Durbin and I have introduced legislation that would ban arbitration for child victims of
[2:12] online crimes. We think it is time to do something. And the most important thing Congress can do in the
[2:18] immediate future is allow victims to get their day in court. Roblox and other companies like them
[2:25] don't change their behavior because they think they'll never have to face accountability.
[2:30] They think they'll never have to face a jury. They think they'll never have to look in the eye of the
[2:34] parents, so many of whom are in this audience today. And before I go any further, I just want to take
[2:40] this moment to recognize the dozens and dozens of parents and victims and survivors who are here today.
[2:47] I want to say thank you for being willing to come and take a stand. Thank you for risking the pain
[2:53] that comes with reliving what your children went through. We've got survivors who are here in the
[2:59] audience today. Thank you for being willing to come and to risk your own sense of well-being to be
[3:05] here and to speak out about what happened to you. Thank you for being advocates for the truth. And I want
[3:10] to invite you now, if you're willing, I'd love to invite you to stand and to be honored for the courage
[3:16] that you have shown and for the incredible people that you are. Thank you so much for being here.
[3:22] Thank you so much. Let me just say a word now about Roblox and how it works, and then I'll say a word
[3:37] about our witnesses. As to Roblox, nearly 75 percent of all American children between the ages of 9 and 12
[3:47] play Roblox regularly. Let that sink in. 75 percent of all American children between the ages of 9 and 12.
[3:57] I have to say those numbers are personal to me because that age range is exactly the age range of my older
[4:02] children. 9, 10, 11, 12. This is a massive company with massive reach. Roblox markets itself as the largest
[4:11] dedicated gaming platform for users who are age 13 and under. The company itself estimates that about three quarters of its users
[4:18] are under 18 and fully 35 percent are under 13. And get this, in 2025 alone, Roblox estimated it had 150 million daily active users.
[4:32] 150 million daily active users. It's easy for kids to sign up and get an account. The company does not require any age verification.
[4:43] It doesn't require any parental consent to join, and it allows kids as young as five years old to play.
[4:50] To sign up and start playing games, the only thing you have to enter is a birthday. Any birthday. It doesn't have to be yours and a username.
[4:56] There's no requirement to verify anybody's age. Roblox recently added a few more hoops to jump through to send chat messages,
[5:04] but typing in a birthday is still all that it takes to start playing games. And beneath its veneer as a kid-friendly
[5:11] digital playground, that's what they call themselves, is a much darker reality. A series of 2024 reports highlighted what Bloomberg has called
[5:20] Roblox's pedophile problem. Here's how it works. Predators pose as minors on Roblox to gain the trust of children.
[5:31] They also extort children with Roblox's digital currency called Robux. As a result, countless criminal cases have come out of Roblox.
[5:40] It's absolutely sickening. Here's just a few of the harrowing facts. In March of 2022, a predator named Howard Graham raped and
[5:49] trafficked a 13-year-old girl whom he met on Roblox. In August 2023, a judge sentenced Arnold Castillo to 15 years in prison after he
[6:01] ubered a 15-year-old girl he met on Roblox to his house and sexually assaulted her. In July 2024, a 66-year-old man posing on Roblox as a 13-year-old
[6:15] persuaded a girl age 12 to send him explicit messages. And the danger is more than contact with pedophiles, though that's horrific enough.
[6:25] Children can access games involving graphic violence and sexual content, including going to virtual strip clubs or engaging in
[6:34] sexual role play on the platform. And the company knows about it. The company knows all about it. And they haven't done a thing to make it
[6:43] better. And why is that? That's what I said earlier. It's money. It's M-O-N-E-Y.
[6:48] They're an enormously profitable company with huge revenues and implementing safety measures that would make it harder for
[6:56] predators to contact kids, threatens their user count, and therefore their revenues. And the worst of it is, if you ask me,
[7:05] Roblox is doing everything it can to muzzle the victims, including the ones who are sitting here in the audience today.
[7:11] They force every single user to sign an arbitration contract that prevents any victim from getting into
[7:20] court to sue Roblox or hold them accountable, no matter how horrific the facts may be. You'll see it
[7:29] right there on their first click screen. In fact, they've begun highlighting it because, including some
[7:34] people here in the audience today, more and more victims are trying to go to court to hold Roblox
[7:38] accountable. And in case after case after case, Roblox says, nope, you signed a forced arbitration
[7:44] agreement. Do you know they also cap the reward, the damages, the compensation that a victim can get
[7:50] at a thousand bucks? Can you imagine that? Children who've been raped, who have been sexually exploited,
[7:59] who have been exposed to CSAM material, thousand bucks. Maybe if you're lucky. This is what Roblox is
[8:07] doing today. It's time to put a stop to it. And I want to say a word about our witnesses
[8:11] who are here to help expose and bring to light these facts. You're going to hear today from two
[8:16] brave survivors who are here to share, in some instances, details for the first time, their
[8:22] stories about encountering predators on Roblox when they were children. You'll also hear from an
[8:27] advocate for survivors and for reform who will explain why these websites are such breeding grounds
[8:32] for predators and why Roblox's recent security upgrades, so-called, don't even begin to come in.
[8:39] Finally, you're going to hear from a leading legal scholar today about how Roblox uses
[8:42] forced arbitration to silence victims and keep the money flowing. Now, who you will not hear
[8:47] from today is the CEO of Roblox, David Bozooski. Now, we invited Mr. Bozooski, Senator Durbin
[8:55] and I did, to come and be part of this hearing. We started talking to him and his team back
[8:59] in August. We said, you can come. You'll have the opportunity to answer any question posed to
[9:07] you. We offered to work with them. They stiff-armed us and stiff-armed us and stiff-armed us. Earlier
[9:12] this morning, he sent me a letter in which he complained he just didn't have enough time
[9:15] to decide. Really? We've been working on this for months. And victims who are here
[9:21] in this audience have been suffering for years. He owes the American people answers. But more
[9:27] than that, he owes the men and women in this audience answers. And the fact that he's not
[9:33] here today speaks volumes. He may think he's silent, but in fact, he's testifying. And what
[9:40] he's testifying to is his commitment to money over people, to profits over anything, to
[9:46] exploitation over what is right. And it's time that we took a stand today and said, we'll
[9:51] have no more of it. I look forward to introducing our witnesses in a moment. But first, let me
[9:55] recognize my colleague, Senator Durbin.
[9:57] Thanks, Senator Hawley. Today, we come together to confront some of the most devastating threats
[10:03] to our children. This is an important issue for every American, every father, every mother,
[10:09] every grandfather, every grandmother. We're all in this together. Two years ago, I
[10:14] was chairman of this committee, honored to be. And we started working on legislation
[10:17] to protect children. Finally, we found out very quickly. It was a bipartisan cause.
[10:23] I remember the day that I was going to bring my bill, stop CSAM to the floor, and I
[10:29] didn't have a Republican sponsor. And then there was a tap on my shoulder and a
[10:32] senator from Missouri was standing there who said, I'd like to co-sponsor your bill.
[10:36] It was Senator Hawley. This has been a bipartisan effort from the start. And the
[10:39] should be. It has nothing to do with whether families are Democrat, Republican, Independent,
[10:42] whatever.
[10:43] It's about their kids, many of them innocent kids who are being lured into this
[10:46] terrible situation. What is the stop CSAM act? It's pretty basic.
[10:50] Before I came to Congress, I was a trial lawyer. You wanted to get somebody's attention,
[10:56] serve them with a complaint. Let them know they have to answer in court under oath
[10:59] as to what they've done. It's amazing how that focuses the attention of people.
[11:04] And it also ends up with some real results. When you get the verdicts from
[11:09] the judge, it ends up changing the conduct of the defendant immediately
[11:12] and sometimes forever. As we're facing here, we will examine today at this
[11:17] hearing how predators have used online gaming platform Roblox to exploit kids.
[11:24] Roblox has responded. These tried as respond to these tragedies and what more
[11:28] needs to be done, but not effectively among four witnesses. Today we'll hear
[11:35] from two individuals who've been personally harmed by their experiences.
[11:38] Kids on Roblox schlep and Mr. Doe. Thank you for sharing your stories.
[11:43] And then the car crowd supporting them. We have a number of families who have
[11:47] been through the harm experience with Roblox. Roblox is a massive popular
[11:53] online gaming platform, which is chairman said 138 million daily active users.
[11:58] 138 million by its own estimates. 75% of the kids ages 9 to 12 play Roblox games
[12:03] regularly and the company marketing for the kids.
[12:08] As young as five years old. Not surprisingly child predators have recognized Roblox
[12:22] as a good hunting ground. Roblox has been aware of platform features like virtual
[12:27] Roblox currency that have been abused by predators to facilitate sexual exploitation.
[12:32] They've been too many stories of predators using Roblox to trade child sex abuse
[12:38] material, participate with kids and sexually explicit and violent games, bribe
[12:43] and export extort kids and connect with kids. They later lure into person meetings,
[12:48] person to person meetings. Let me tell you a tragic story. A nine year old boy
[12:52] in Cook County, Illinois, which I'm honored to represent. He was groomed by
[12:57] an adult male predator posing as a child on the platform. The adult cultivated
[13:02] the child's trust and then manipulated him into sharing explicit photographs.
[13:06] In another case, a 13 year old Iowa teen groomed by a 37 year old who used
[13:13] child's Roblox profile and claimed to be a child. The predators told this team
[13:19] that he was caught in love with him in love with her. I'm sorry and purchased
[13:22] her gifts. Eventually he convinced her to meet him in person near her home.
[13:27] He abducted her from her home and sexually abused her for three days before
[13:32] she managed to escape. These are not unique stories. In 2025 Roblox submitted 65,381
[13:43] reports of suspected child exploitation to Nick Mick, the National Center for Missing
[13:48] and Exploited Children. Each of these reports represents an individual, a family forever
[13:55] impacted by this experience. And when lawsuits have been filed against the company, the
[14:00] response has been an attempt to silence the victims by arguing that these minors
[14:05] agreed to arbitrate all disputes. A five year old making a legal agreement.
[14:10] Get real. Let me put it to you differently. According to Roblox arguments, a kid
[14:15] as young as five could agree to give up their constitutional rights to a trial
[14:19] simply by going to Roblox, creating the username and entering a birth date.
[14:22] That's it. And that's wrong. And while Roblox recently has taken steps, they
[14:29] haven't done enough. And the fact they aren't here today says that they're ashamed
[14:33] of what they're doing, but they're still raking in the money. This committee has a
[14:36] long history of working on a bipartisan basis. We want this to be bipartisan. I
[14:39] have a few weeks left of my service in the United States Senate. I'm thinking each
[14:43] day it's coming to an end, but I wanted to come in the right way. We have pending
[14:47] legislation before the national defense authorization bill, which is pending
[14:50] on the floor, which we can pass in the closing days before the end of
[14:53] December. Protecting children is an important part of it. Let's make it real.
[14:58] Let's make it the law of the land. Let's tell parents across the country. We
[15:01] got the message and we did something on a bipartisan basis. Thank you. Thank
[15:05] you, Senator Durbin. Excuse me. It's the practice of the subcommittee to swear
[15:08] in our witnesses before we did something on a bipartisan basis.
[15:14] Thank you, Senator Durbin. Excuse me. It's the practice of the subcommittee to
[15:17] bear in our witnesses before we begin testimony. So if you would be willing to
[15:22] rise and raise your right hand and answer the following question. You swear the
[15:28] testimony about to give will be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
[15:31] So help you God. All right. Let the record reflect that all of the witnesses
[15:36] answered in the affirmative. Let's just go down now the dais. I want to introduce
[15:40] each of our witnesses and as I do so give you the chance to make an opening
[15:43] statement. We'll start with Mr. Michael Schlepp. Mr. Schlepp is a survivor of
[15:47] childhood grooming and abuse on Roblox. He is now a content creator and a
[15:51] child safety advocate who has dedicated his platform to exposing
[15:55] online predators and raising awareness of child exploitation on Roblox.
[15:59] And I'll just say Mr. Schlepp, I had the opportunity to meet your parents
[16:02] who I think are sitting behind you and are very proud of the man that they
[16:06] raised and rightly so. We're delighted that you're here today. The floor is
[16:09] yours for your opening statement. Chairman Holley, ranking member Durbin and
[16:15] distinguished members of the subcommittee. Thank you for inviting me to testify
[16:18] today. At age eight, I like millions of other American children created my
[16:23] first Roblox account. My parents thought it was a kid friendly educational game.
[16:28] They didn't realize that I would be accessible to strangers across the world.
[16:32] When I was 12, a user invited me to an official Roblox chat room where I met a
[16:39] famous game developer by the name of Kevin Nolan. He began helping me with my own games.
[16:45] As a kid, I didn't realize that Kevin was much older than me. He moved our chats
[16:50] to private spaces, positioning himself as someone I could trust, encouraging me to
[16:55] share my most vulnerable thoughts to him. He asked me to meet in person. I refused.
[17:00] Over time, Kevin's fame grew and Roblox produced an official toy of his avatar.
[17:07] While I was exposed to increasingly disturbing content in our online
[17:11] communications, including BDSM and violent pornography, cartel beheadings
[17:16] and extreme racist ideologies like the Christchurch mass shooting video
[17:20] in 2019. Meanwhile, his toy was sold in stores and featured in commercials
[17:26] all across the country. This is a toy here. When I finally built up the courage
[17:34] to leave Kevin, he publicly leaked my private confessions he had
[17:39] manipulated out of me. The torment culminated in a suicide attempt and
[17:44] a psychiatric hospitalization. I later returned to Roblox hoping to build a
[17:48] safer community through my YouTube channel. Soon, young viewers began
[17:52] messaging me about their own Roblox predators. I realized what happened to me
[17:56] was an isolated incident, but a much larger systemic problem. Then I watched Roblox
[18:05] file a $1.6 million lawsuit to silence a whistleblower by the name of
[18:10] Benjamin Simon. That was my breaking point. Instead of catching predators,
[18:15] Roblox was more concerned with stopping people from pointing out how
[18:19] many predators are on their platform. To expose the problem, I launched a
[18:24] YouTube channel, Schlepp. What I uncovered was unimaginable. Predators,
[18:29] sexting groups, violent and graphic pornography, even child sexual abuse
[18:35] material rings operating and profiting on Roblox through its virtual currency
[18:40] Robux. Partnering with a predator catching group with over 400 convictions
[18:44] across 49 states, I caught six predators within 10 months, resulting in
[18:49] four convictions. One admitted to me personally that he had groomed hundreds
[18:55] of minors on the platform. I received emails saying you got my groomer arrested
[19:00] from children. Where Roblox failed them, I succeeded. Until my videos,
[19:09] Roblox failed to ban these accounts. I begged them for a private reporting line.
[19:14] I mailed physical binders to their headquarters and even offered to sign a
[19:18] contract to help them for free. Instead, I received a cease and desist letter
[19:25] from Roblox, terminating my accounts and threatening to sue me when it back when
[19:33] it backlash sparking the free schlepp movement. They banned users and games
[19:38] protesting. The Louisiana Attorney General and several states sued Roblox
[19:43] citing games I exposed such as Dollhouse Roeplay, a game used by 764, a group the
[19:49] FBI has designated as a terrorist organization. Roblox claims it has
[19:56] changed, but their new age verification system is very easy for child
[20:01] predators to bypass. Kidnappings and murders related to Roblox are still
[20:06] happening despite all of these new features. Roblox funnels their users onto
[20:11] a platform known as Discord, one of the National Center for Online Sexual
[20:16] Exploitation's Dirty Dozens list as a dangerous platform. Roblox claims there's
[20:25] no text-based image sharing on the platform, but it allows you to upload
[20:28] images onto it, which I've seen child sexual abuse material, suicides and
[20:33] cartel mutilations being uploaded onto the so-called children's platform,
[20:38] despite parental controls being enabled. According to their employees,
[20:43] Roblox puts, and I quote, making investors happy above their children's
[20:48] child safety. CEO David Bazzucchi dismissed child predator crisis on the
[20:54] platform as an opportunity to improve safety. Worst of all, law enforcement
[21:00] is not allowed to conduct investigations on their platform. While Roblox
[21:05] banned me, the police have welcomed my help. Just last month, I demonstrated
[21:10] how and where to find predators on Roblox to the Polk County Sheriff's
[21:14] Office in Florida. Roblox must be held accountable publicly. They will not
[21:20] voluntarily act to protect children. Law enforcement, Congress, and state
[21:25] legislators must act. Hundreds of families have filed civil cases, but
[21:30] unsurprisingly, Roblox is trying to force those children whose abuse it
[21:35] facilitated out of court into a secret and rigged forced arbitration system.
[21:41] They must be stopped, and these families must be encountered or
[21:46] empowered to seek accountability in court. Thank you, and I am
[21:51] stand ready to support this committee in stopping online platforms
[21:54] for enabling and profiting off of the abuse of children.
[21:58] Thank you very much, Mr. Schlepp. Next we have Mr. Woody Doe.
[22:01] Mr. Doe is a Marine Corps veteran, a husband, a father of four children,
[22:06] who is speaking out to us today about his experience of child sexual
[22:11] exploitation on Roblox. Mr. Doe, thank you for serving our country,
[22:14] and thank you for being here today. The floor is yours.
[22:16] Thank you, Chairman.
[22:19] Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, and distinguished members of
[22:22] the subcommittee, thank you for giving me the opportunity to share
[22:25] my story today. My name is Woody. I'm a proud United States Marine
[22:28] Corps veteran, a husband, and most importantly, a father to four kids.
[22:32] For six years, I served my country, and I'm also the father of four
[22:37] children under the age of 10. I know what it's like to face difficult
[22:41] situations, but some of the deepest wounds I carry happened long before
[22:45] that. Eleven, that's how old I was when I was groomed and sexually
[22:52] assaulted by a man I met on Roblox. For years, I struggled to understand
[22:56] how something that happened when I was a child could continue to affect
[22:59] so much of my life. It started with the game I loved. Like most of my
[23:03] children, I discovered Roblox and quickly became hooked. Eventually,
[23:08] I joined a group where players could earn Robux, the platform's
[23:11] virtual currency. I logged on one day and was unexpectedly kicked
[23:15] off. Another player reached out to me and offered help to get me
[23:18] back in. He told me his name was Chris. He said he was a kid and he
[23:22] went to a school nearby. I believed him. Chris told me I could rejoin
[23:27] the group if I paid Robux. When I told him I didn't have any, he
[23:31] offered to pay for me if I would send him photos of myself. I
[23:34] remember going into the bathroom to take these photos. Something
[23:38] felt wrong, but I was a kid and I wanted so badly to be part of
[23:41] this community that I just sent him the photos. Afterward, Chris
[23:45] praised me and sent me Robux. But he also said that the other group
[23:48] members had seen the photographs. This gave me a sinking feeling of
[23:52] dread deep in the pit of my stomach. I begged them to delete the
[23:55] photos. I was so afraid that someone from my school or my parents would
[23:58] see them. But Chris demanded more. When I told him no, the group
[24:03] began threatening me. I didn't understand that I was being groomed.
[24:08] I was just a child who believed that he had done something wrong
[24:11] and I was desperate to keep anybody from finding out. Eventually, I
[24:15] reached out to Chris, hoping he would stop threatening me. He told
[24:18] me that he lived in Venus, Texas, not far from my home. One day, while my
[24:23] parents were working late, I had a friend's older brother drop me
[24:26] off at the address that he provided. An older man answered the
[24:29] door. I assumed he was Chris's father and I continued to ask if
[24:33] Chris was home. He invited me inside. When I asked again, he told
[24:37] me that he was Chris. Immediately, I knew something was wrong.
[24:41] Pornography was playing on the television and the man left the
[24:45] room and returned without his pants on. He sat next to me close
[24:48] enough that I could smell his breath. He pulled me toward him and
[24:52] sexually assaulted me. People talk about how sexual assault
[24:59] survivors respond with a flight or fight instinct, but they don't
[25:02] often talk about how so many of us just freeze. I felt like a
[25:05] statue. My chest hurt. I struggled to breathe. I just told him
[25:09] I needed my inhaler. When he stepped away, I left through a side
[25:12] door and inevitably made it home, but I didn't feel safe anymore.
[25:17] I deleted everything connected to roadblocks, including messages
[25:20] that he said he would send to threaten to hurt me and my family
[25:23] if I continued to talk about it or tell anyone. I believed him.
[25:27] So I stayed silent. For years, I carried the shame of what
[25:31] happened. I thought it was my fault. I struggled with feelings of
[25:34] inadequacy that followed me through some of the most important
[25:39] years of my life. These feelings didn't disappear when I got older.
[25:42] They affected my confidence, my relationships, my marriage.
[25:46] I didn't look at people the same. I didn't trust the way I did
[25:50] before. And even in therapy and the support of people that loved me,
[25:53] I struggled to separate the man I am today from that scared little
[25:57] boy I was then. I eventually found the courage to confide in my
[26:00] wife and a Marine Corps Chaplain. For much of my life, I tried to
[26:04] bury what happened and move forward. Then I had children of my own.
[26:08] When they became interested in online gaming, I found myself
[26:11] confronting fears that I had left behind. And then I thought about
[26:17] my parents. They had no idea what was happening to me. They believed
[26:20] I was safe at home playing a game that was made for children.
[26:24] I understand how terrifying it is to know that somebody could be
[26:27] exploiting your child without you ever realizing it. I think about
[26:30] the children experiencing that same fear today. Children who are
[26:33] being threatened into silence. Children who are spend years trying
[26:35] to recover. I know what it feels like because I will always have
[26:38] to live with what happened to me today. I have a lawsuit pending
[26:41] against Roblox for the role that the company played in facilitating
[26:45] my grooming and sexual abuse and for failing to warn parents and
[26:48] children of the dangers. Hundreds of other families have filed
[26:51] similar cases and many of those families are sitting behind me
[26:54] today. I hope our cases will force Roblox to confront the harm
[26:57] children have experienced on its platform and make meaningful
[26:59] changes to protect them. I'm also deeply concerned that Roblox is
[27:03] trying to force many of these cases out of public courtrooms and
[27:06] into secret forced arbitrations. For survivors who have spent many
[27:09] years afraid to speak being heard matters. I am asking Congress to
[27:12] help protect our rights to seek accountability and ensure that
[27:15] children's safety is never treated as less important than a
[27:18] company's profits. I cannot go back and protect the 11 year old
[27:22] boy I once was, but I can speak for him today. And I can do
[27:25] everything in my power to protect the 11 year old boy I once
[27:28] was, but I can speak for him today. And I can do everything in my
[27:31] power to protect the 11 year old boy I once was, but I can speak
[27:34] for him today. And I can do everything in my power to
[27:36] protect the children and help prevent any other children from
[27:39] ever experiencing the same pain. What happened to me only lasted
[27:42] a short time, but that impact has lasted most of my life.
[27:45] Thank you, gentlemen. Thank you very much, Mr. Doe. Next we
[27:48] have Miss Kari James. Miss James is senior legal counsel at the
[27:52] National Center on Sexual Exploitation, where she works to
[27:54] combat sexual exploitation and advocates on behalf of survivors of
[27:57] human trafficking and also child sex abuse. Miss James, we're so
[27:59] glad you're here. The floor is yours. Thank you, sir.
[28:01] Chairman Holtman, I'm going to be here. I'm going to be
[28:04] so glad you're here. The floor is yours. Thank you, sir.
[28:08] Chairman Hawley, ranking member Durbin and members of the
[28:11] subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
[28:16] My name is Kari James, senior legal counsel at the National Center
[28:19] on Sexual Exploitation. Nicosi. We are a national nonprofit dedicated
[28:25] to eradicating all forms of sexual exploitation by exposing the
[28:30] links between them. I am here today because children are being sexually
[28:36] exploited on a platform that is marketed directly to them that is
[28:42] designed to be addictive and that connects them with adults that
[28:48] they otherwise would have never met. That platform is Roblox.
[28:54] Roblox is not simply a video game. It is a billion dollar virtual world
[29:00] made up of millions of individual games where children can communicate,
[29:04] spend money and interact with adult strangers. And this virtual world
[29:09] is enormous. Roblox reports 150 million daily active users, nearly 75%
[29:18] of whom are under the age of 18 years old. Roblox has been used by adult
[29:24] predators to groom children, solicit and exchange child sexual abuse
[29:29] material and lure children into meeting them in person, leading to
[29:34] kidnapping, sexual abuse and murder. Many of these children are between
[29:40] the ages of 10 and 15 years old. The most troubling part is that based
[29:48] on Nicosi's research, these harms occur as a direct result of Roblox's
[29:56] design. This is why in May of 2020, the
[30:00] Nicosi partnered with Fair Play to file an FTC complaint on Roblox's
[30:04] inherently deceptive design practices that incentivize prolonged engagement
[30:21] and the resulting consequences for child safety and sexual exploitation.
[30:29] Now, Roblox has since implemented some age verification and communication
[30:34] safeguards. However, these changes do not undo the harms of the past
[30:42] and they still fall short. Nicosi's adult researchers can still create
[30:51] accounts pretending to be five year olds without parental consent or age
[30:56] verification. We accessed experiences involving dating, romance and violence,
[31:03] freely interacted with strangers, adding them as friends and joining private
[31:09] chats with them. Another issue is that Roblox encourages users to become
[31:16] developers who create games, avatars and items for sale on the platform.
[31:22] And this generates profit for Roblox. But these developers can also create their
[31:30] own chat features, which are not subject to Roblox's new safety settings.
[31:37] This is a critical loophole. Roblox cannot claim to protect children
[31:45] through age verification while allowing developers to build features that
[31:50] bypass those very protections. Roblox has also added parental monitoring, but
[31:57] decreases it significantly as children age. By age 13, parental control is
[32:05] progressively reduced with parents retaining only limited oversight of their
[32:10] child's accounts. Even with parental controls, their responsibility to
[32:18] protect children must begin with the platform itself. A safety system that
[32:26] requires parents to be cyber security experts does not adequately protect
[32:32] children. Parents cannot use safeguards that are confusing or buried in the
[32:38] settings and parental controls cannot be a substitute for platform
[32:43] responsibility. Roblox needs to stop making child safety so complicated.
[32:50] Its safety standards should be clear, transparent and designed to
[32:57] prioritize children's safety over user engagement. For example, Roblox can
[33:04] eliminate chat for minors completely and reserve that feature for adults
[33:12] who have been verified as adults. Child online safety cannot be treated as
[33:20] an optional feature that is added after harm occurs. This is why
[33:27] regulation is necessary. Roblox implemented safety features after
[33:34] extensive harm and intense scrutiny. But these voluntary safety measures can be
[33:43] changed, weakened or removed at any time. Roblox may be a virtual world, but
[33:54] the children are real. The predators are real. The addiction is real. The
[34:01] addiction is real. The exploitation is real and the consequences are real.
[34:08] Children should never have to enter a game marketed to them and wonder
[34:15] whether the person on the other side of the screen is there to play with
[34:18] them or prey on them. We urge this subcommittee to insist upon safety
[34:22] regulations that put the protection of children ahead of engagement and
[34:30] profit. Thank you. Thank you very much, Miss James. And last but
[34:33] certainly not least, Professor Miriam Gillis. Did I get that right,
[34:37] Professor? Good. Professor Gillis is a law professor at Northwestern and
[34:40] one of the foremost experts in the world on forced arbitration and class
[34:45] actions. We're so glad you're with us, Professor. The floor is yours.
[34:49] Thank you, Chairman. Chairman Hawley ranking member Durbin distinguished
[34:52] members of the subcommittee. Thank you for inviting me. It's a privilege
[34:56] to be here and to sit beside these survivors. And thank you for the
[35:00] investigation you opened in August. It gave me hope because you wrote
[35:03] in there that Congress will not look the other way. And I hope that's
[35:06] true. I've been here many times before to testify about how forced
[35:09] arbitration strips consumers and workers of their rights. I never
[35:12] expected to come before this body to talk about its use against
[35:13] nine year olds. But that's where we are. And the question today
[35:18] isn't only what I have to say about the use of the nine year olds.
[35:21] I never expected to come before this body to talk about its use
[35:24] against nine year olds. But that's where we are. And the question
[35:27] today isn't only what I have to say about. I have to say about
[35:30] this. And the question today isn't only what happened to these
[35:34] children online. It's really whether anyone parents, regulators,
[35:38] members of this subcommittee will ever find out.
[35:42] Roughly 180 families have sued Roblox at this point. They're all
[35:48] consolidated in a multi district litigation in the Northern
[35:51] District of California before Judge Seaborg. And most of them are
[35:56] are alleging the things we've heard today about Roblox is designed
[36:00] and how it essentially delivers or enables predators to have
[36:04] contact with children. Roblox is answer to every single one of
[36:08] these cases has been you agreed to arbitrate in secret. What you
[36:13] said, Senator Hawley, they're muzzling these victims right off the
[36:17] bat, right at the beginning of the lawsuit. So consider just one
[36:20] of these children. A girl in Florida started playing Roblox at
[36:23] nine. At 14, a predator found her in a Roblox role playing game,
[36:27] moved her over to discord, and for more than two years coerced her
[36:32] into producing sexually sexual images of herself. Her mother did
[36:37] everything she could. She took the door off the bedroom. She
[36:40] installed cameras. She removed every screen, every device from the
[36:43] home. But the predator kept pulling this kid back in. And here's
[36:46] what Roblox is arguing in federal court about children like her,
[36:50] that she agreed to arbitrate when she signed up at nine. And
[36:53] that's because she and that because she kept returning to the
[36:56] platform, the very place she was being groomed, she can now she
[36:59] can't now disavow the contract. So I just want us to think about
[37:02] what that means. The predators hold on that child is now Roblox's
[37:05] proof of her consent, right? That that's just that's that just can't
[37:08] be right. And this is not a one off. This is the strategy that
[37:12] Roblox and discord have been using to silence these families in
[37:15] case after case after case. Meanwhile, two of their co-defendants,
[37:19] Snap and meta have decided not to pursue arbitration, which tells us
[37:23] that arbitration forcing kids and their families into arbitration is
[37:26] a choice, right? It's a choice. It's a choice. It's a choice. There's
[37:29] a choice. It's a choice. It's a choice. It's a choice. It's not
[37:31] a choice. What does the child's role?
[37:33] forcing kids and their families into arbitration is a choice,
[37:36] right? It's a choice. It's not a necessity.
[37:39] And look what these children supposedly agreed to, 9,000 words
[37:43] into Roblox's terms of use. Everything in the arbitration, that
[37:46] means the hearing, the evidence, any written decision is completely
[37:49] confidential. A private arbitrator, not a judge, decides
[37:52] whether a nine-year-old could decide to arbitrate in the first
[37:55] place. Any claim must be brought within one year when we all
[37:58] know that children often don't want to be in the first place.
[38:01] This is why Congress actually got rid of the statute of limitations
[38:04] for child sexual abuse material.
[38:07] So the whole system, you know, when somebody uses the word rigged,
[38:10] it feels rigged.
[38:13] And we should be concerned, right? Why is secrecy such a problem here?
[38:17] Because every parent needs to know what Roblox is not doing to
[38:20] protect their child, what they've decided to do, right?
[38:23] Why is secrecy such a problem here? Because every parent needs
[38:26] to know what Roblox is not doing to protect their child,
[38:30] what they've decided not to do to protect the children.
[38:34] In court, these answers come out in public, right?
[38:37] In arbitration, they get locked into one child's file and the next
[38:42] family doesn't know anything about what happened to that previous
[38:45] child. Concealing misconduct only leads to more misconduct.
[38:49] Every lawyer knows this. Every parent knows this.
[38:52] Some will say that Congress fixed this problem in 2022 when it ended
[38:57] forced arbitration for sexual assault claims.
[39:00] This is a landmark law led by the late Senator Graham with strong
[39:04] support from ranking member Durbin, Senator Blumenthal, and others
[39:07] on this subcommittee. But Roblox is already exploiting that law's
[39:12] gaps. Roblox argues that that law covers only a completed physical
[39:17] assault. So a child coerced over a webcam into producing abuse material
[39:22] like the Florida girl may be left out.
[39:25] It also argues that the law only reaches the predator or an employer,
[39:29] not the platform that delivered the child to him.
[39:32] The cruel irony is that the children at the center of today's hearing,
[39:37] victims of online exploitation and see Sam are the ones most likely to
[39:40] fall through the cracks. So what should Congress do? Pass the fair act,
[39:45] pass the bill that Senators Holly and Durbin have proposed any
[39:50] legislation that gives families back the right to choose a courtroom.
[39:55] Chairman Holly, you said it in your introductory remarks. It's time
[39:58] to allow the victims to have their day in court. You and Senator Blumenthal
[40:01] applied that principle to trafficking victims in your bill for ending
[40:05] forced arbitration of human trafficking claims. Children exploited on
[40:08] roadblocks deserve exactly the same thing. In my view, to be
[40:14] effective, that legislation must reach the platforms, no matter
[40:17] what form the harm takes, has to leave the question of eligibility
[40:20] to judges, not to arbitrators, and has to reach children that are
[40:24] already harmed, not just future children. We have to protect people
[40:27] who've already been harmed by this platform.
[40:30] The, uh, Stop CSAM Act, which again, you, you both have, uh,
[40:35] have co-sponsored would give victims the right to sue the platforms.
[40:38] And I applaud that effort. But let's be honest, Congress can pass
[40:41] laws, but if they just get shunted into private arbitration,
[40:44] they're doing no good in the world.
[40:47] So, you know, right to sue that ends in secret arbitration is,
[40:50] is a right in name only.
[40:53] So I urge you to do more. Where and whether to bring a case
[40:56] for a child's injuries should be the family's choice, not the
[40:59] platforms. And only Congress can give that choice back. I urge you
[41:02] to do so. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks to all of our
[41:05] witnesses. We're going to start now some rounds of questioning
[41:07] seven minute rounds, and I will begin. And I'm going to start
[41:10] with you, Mr. Doe, if I could. And I just want to start by
[41:12] thanking you again for being willing to be here and to share
[41:15] your story. Thanks for your service to our country and thank you
[41:18] for the service to your family that you're now rendering as a
[41:20] husband and father. Let me just ask you, you were 11 years old.
[41:23] You said when you first started playing on Roblox and when you
[41:26] were exploited. Is that right? Yes, Mr. Senator. And when you
[41:29] got onto Roblox, did you think it was a safe platform? And do
[41:32] you have any reason to think it wouldn't be? There were no
[41:36] indications that this would have been something dangerous for my
[41:39] young mind to get on to. I was in fact very excited to because
[41:42] I was very into Lego. And as you can see, they're pretty close
[41:45] together. My parents have probably spent thousands of years
[41:47] to get on to. I was very excited to because I was very into Lego
[41:50] and as you can see, they're pretty close together. My parents have
[41:52] probably spent thousands of dollars on them. I'm sure he's a
[41:56] father yourself. You're very in tune with Lego. But yes, I was
[41:59] very into the game. It seemed just like a virtual playground like
[42:02] it was to to code to come up with my own little worlds. And so I
[42:06] was so involved in it. That's what's a big hook. So was it was
[42:12] easy to spend time on the platform. It was very engaging. You had
[42:17] no reason as a kid to think that you were in any danger. Would you
[42:20] say that Roblox looked out for your safety?
[42:22] Absolutely not. How did that you you alluded to this a little
[42:27] bit. I just want to if you're willing, give you a chance to say
[42:30] something more about it. How did the abuse that you experience as
[42:33] a very young boy affect you years down the line?
[42:38] It came in multiple ways. If I'm being honest, there was years
[42:45] of feeling inadequacy like I tied into a little bit on my my
[42:49] introduction, but it stemmed far deeper than that. I ended up going
[42:54] to I work out very consistently and I swapped. There was no interest
[42:59] in doing any physical sports or whatever. I was a little gamer kid.
[43:02] This quickly transitioned into me working out and trying to just
[43:06] reimagine what kind of man I was going to be. I ended up following
[43:10] along with my father's footsteps. I was trying to emulate men that I
[43:13] thought were successful and powerful because me myself and my formula
[43:17] of years just I had no more identity. I felt vulnerable. I felt abused.
[43:22] And so with that that stemmed all the way up until my military career
[43:26] where I missed out on my second daughter's actual birthday because
[43:31] I had been volunteering deployment attachment, everything I could possibly
[43:36] embellish myself into to distract myself from the damages that had
[43:41] happened to me as a child. That long lasting effects.
[43:46] Well, I just got a pause there and say to the CEO of Roblox who isn't
[43:51] with us today. Is it really worth it? I mean, is the money really worth that?
[43:55] What you did to this man or this incredible guy who's in front of us now
[43:59] who's who's turned his life around and is an incredible advocate, father,
[44:03] husband, but no amount of money justifies what you went through.
[44:07] Mr. Doe, no amount of profit could justify that and no amount of profit
[44:12] can justify closing the courtroom door on you or hundreds, thousands.
[44:17] Who knows how many of other victims who deserve their day in court,
[44:21] who are getting exactly the same treatment you're getting right now
[44:24] from this company? Let me just ask you this. What's your view of Roblox now?
[44:27] I see them as lazy. If I'm being honest, they have so much money
[44:33] to dump into their safety programs and protecting children and they've
[44:36] just refused. The fact that this thing has happened to me over 15 years
[44:40] ago and I'm still hearing of cases happening very similar to myself.
[44:44] It just goes to show that they haven't put really any effort into
[44:47] keeping our kids safe. Do you think they've solved their safety
[44:50] problems? No, sir. Absolutely not. Mr. Schlepp, if I could just ask you,
[44:54] I want to thank you for being here as well and thank you for telling your story.
[44:57] Thank you for the tremendous work you're doing to try and rescue victims
[45:00] and to try to give voice to survivors.
[45:03] Based on your experience catching predators on Roblox,
[45:07] does Roblox ensure that predators can't contact children on their platform?
[45:12] I can tell you as someone who created decoy accounts, it was unbelievably easy
[45:18] for child predators to reach out. You know, I was able to find games
[45:23] where child predators would message you on Roblox within seconds.
[45:28] They allowed games based off of the now defunct platform Omegle,
[45:34] which was sued out of existence for child exploitation to rack up tens of
[45:38] millions of visits on the platform. And Roblox's chief safety officer,
[45:43] Matt Kaufman, had actually played these games according to his Roblox profile.
[45:47] And these games weren't removed until a major public outcry happened.
[45:52] And it goes to show that Roblox is very aware of some of these hubs
[45:56] and hotspots on the platform, but weren't taking action.
[45:59] So this goes far beyond just, you know, allowing them to exist.
[46:03] It's knowing this is a very important point that you just made.
[46:06] So Roblox, it's not just that they think, well, you know,
[46:09] maybe there's a problem out there.
[46:11] They know that specifically there are multiple problems on their platform.
[46:14] They know that sexual predators are using their platform.
[46:17] They know that sexual predators are abusing people like Mr. Doe
[46:20] when he was a child and they're not doing anything about it.
[46:23] Is if I got that right? That is correct.
[46:25] I mean, a month or I think it was about two months before I got my cease and
[46:29] desist letter, Roblox invited a guy who made sex games into an official
[46:33] partnered event for Roblox.
[46:35] And it became such an ordeal that developers boycotted the company
[46:39] and pulled their games from this event over it.
[46:41] Let me just give you a statistic.
[46:43] 61% of parents nationwide.
[46:46] I think we've got a poster to this effect.
[46:47] There it is.
[46:48] 61% of patients nation, of parents nationwide believe that their children
[46:52] are safe from predators on Roblox.
[46:55] Let me just ask you.
[46:56] You've got a chance now to tell parents like me across the country.
[47:01] What do parents need to understand about the truth of this platform?
[47:05] See, I don't think it's just understanding.
[47:08] I think they actually need to see it.
[47:10] I've seen videos of child safety advocates going into classrooms
[47:13] and asking kids, have you seen inappropriate content on the platform?
[47:17] And half of the classroom raises their hand.
[47:19] This isn't just a problem affecting a few kids.
[47:23] This is a problem affecting a vast majority of children.
[47:27] If you ask a regular Roblox user if they've stumbled across inappropriate content
[47:31] on the platform, I'd be willing to bet that they're going to tell you,
[47:34] yes, they have.
[47:35] And, you know, it'll range from seeing inappropriate avatars to being preyed on.
[47:40] Let me just ask you this.
[47:42] When you started exposing just how common predation is on the Roblox platform
[47:48] and how common contact with predators is with children,
[47:51] how did Roblox respond again?
[47:53] Did they thank you?
[47:54] Did they say thank you for bringing this to our attention?
[47:56] Did they work with you?
[47:57] And what was their response?
[47:58] Roblox's response was to send me a legal threat.
[48:01] And mind you, I had made it publicly clear.
[48:03] I had written emails to them saying that I would be willing to have meetings.
[48:08] I want a private line.
[48:09] I want to communicate with you guys.
[48:10] You know, I think that we could do some really good work.
[48:13] And Roblox, they said that I was causing more of a danger to their users
[48:18] than the predators that I caught, which are now convicted.
[48:22] One was just recently sentenced to five years in prison.
[48:25] And, you know, the thing is, too, after all that came out,
[48:29] Roblox actually went as far as to compare me to child predators
[48:32] for running decoy accounts on their platform.
[48:35] Just unbelievable.
[48:38] Let me just finish with this.
[48:40] The CEO of Roblox said this is poster number six, guys.
[48:44] If you're not comfortable, then don't let your kids be on Roblox.
[48:49] And, you know, maybe that is actually a really good piece of advice.
[48:54] I think it's not exactly as he meant it.
[48:56] But, you know, I mean, if you're not comfortable,
[48:59] don't let your kids be on Roblox.
[49:00] But the truth is, as you were just saying, Mr. Schlepp,
[49:02] and as you've testified, Mr. Doe,
[49:04] Roblox lies to parents all the time about how their platform is safe.
[49:07] They tell parents it's safe.
[49:09] They tell parents that there's these safety features.
[49:11] And then when there's a problem with kids, parents in the room,
[49:14] you know this is true, then they turn around and they blame you.
[49:16] They say, well, it's your fault.
[49:18] You should have done it.
[49:20] You should have known.
[49:21] You should have been there.
[49:22] We're doing our part.
[49:23] It's really your fault.
[49:24] When the truth is just the reverse,
[49:25] you're doing your part and they're making the money.
[49:27] You're doing your part and they're exploiting your kids.
[49:30] And it's time to put a stop to it. Senator German.
[49:32] Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
[49:34] Uh, Professor Gillis.
[49:36] Help me understand the argument from Roblox for a minute.
[49:40] When it comes to forced arbitration.
[49:43] Mm hmm.
[49:44] Is it my understanding that they're arguing that the user, the child,
[49:46] in this case, can consent to forced arbitration?
[49:49] Yes.
[49:50] Well, I'm trying to remember that contracts. Of course, they took a
[49:51] long time ago.
[49:52] If I do remember it properly, if a child showed up in an auto
[49:56] dealership and signed up to buy a car for $25,000.
[50:02] That would be avoidable contract, wouldn't it?
[50:04] Yes, it would.
[50:05] Why?
[50:06] Well, because under the common law, we do not believe the children
[50:09] can consent to those sorts of purchases.
[50:12] And so that's how I remember too. Yeah. So why is this an exception
[50:15] that a child can consent under Roblox?
[50:16] To activity which is potentially so dangerous.
[50:31] Well, so there are a couple of things here. Senator First Roblox
[50:34] and discord argue that under their delegation clauses, which are part
[50:37] of their arbitration, which is the possibility of our obligation
[50:38] that under their delegation clauses, which are part of their
[50:41] arbitration provision, only an arbitrator can decide whether
[50:45] a child's disaffirmance is valid. So that's not for a court to
[50:48] decide. It's for an arbitrator to decide. So that's a problem right
[50:52] there, right? Because it's not void. It's voidable.
[50:56] It's voidable. But first, you have to go to arbitration to
[50:59] find out. Right. And then we don't know what happens there because
[51:02] arbitration is secret. And then the second argument, which I think
[51:05] is even more devastating, is they argue that a child's
[51:09] continued use of a platform defeats disaffirmance. So if you're
[51:14] arguing that your child, you know, couldn't actually, you know,
[51:19] agree to arbitration, well, why is your kid still playing
[51:22] Roblox? That's their argument. And at least two courts have
[51:26] actually accepted that argument. The Seventh Circuit, in a recent
[51:29] case, KFC, has actually held that the child there, an 11-year-old
[51:34] had the ability to consent and did consent to arbitration.
[51:39] This is hard to imagine that anybody, any court, any judge can
[51:44] sit and see a nine or 10-year-old and say they have the capacity
[51:48] to consent to conduct an activity which is potentially so dangerous.
[51:53] Yes. But I think one of the things we have to remember is that
[51:57] courts in this country for the past decade, because of the Supreme
[52:00] Court's interpretation of the Federal Arbitration Act, have treated
[52:03] arbitration provisions differently than other contracts, right?
[52:08] They get special care, these arbitration provisions. They're
[52:12] treated differently. Because they're self-dealing by the
[52:15] corporations. Yeah. They're basically setting up a scenario where
[52:19] they always win it. As long as they can keep it secret, you don't
[52:22] know what's happening. As long as the courts are given a nod of
[52:25] approval, this will continue. Yep. I'd like to ask Mr. Doe or Mr. Schlepp to
[52:28] talk to me about Discord, which pops up in a lot of descriptions here of
[52:34] exploitation. Mr. Schlepp? Discord is really one of the worst platforms
[52:38] I've seen when it's come to child exploitation. And it's something that I
[52:42] specifically have been really trying my best to showcase and expose.
[52:47] When parents ask me, you know, what apps should I never let my children on,
[52:57] Discord is usually one of the first ones I mention. Discord has released
[53:03] some information related to, in the UK, of moderation statistics on what
[53:10] they've taken action on. And it's been shown that there have been accounts that
[53:14] have been flagged for child safety related issues that they've left on
[53:19] the platform even after being flagged. It is very shocking to see the
[53:24] lack of moderation on the platform specifically. And, you know, in
[53:29] general, Discord is a very unsafe platform for children.
[53:33] Mr. Doe, your story is nothing short of amazing. What you've been
[53:38] through, your life's journey, Marine Corps, your own family, and the
[53:45] courage to come here today. I'm a fan. Mr. Doe, you really are saving
[53:49] lives by this testimony. I believe that some people watching this are
[53:52] going to change their attitude toward this dangerous situation. So I know
[53:56] you've been through a lot and you'll go through a lot. But hats off to
[53:59] you, buddy. Serving our country and your family as well as you do today.
[54:02] I want to thank you personally for that. Thank you, Mr. Senator.
[54:06] This James. You must see this in the organization you work for coming
[54:09] at you on regular basis. Thousands of complaints and such. It's
[54:13] in my opening statement, talked about 65,000 complaints during the
[54:16] course of a calendar year. What are we talking about in terms of
[54:19] the volume of victims across the United States?
[54:23] So yes, NCMEC has received over 65,000 reports, I believe, in
[54:26] 2024 and then it doubled in 2025 from the last year.
[54:30] So yes, NCMEC has received over 65,000 reports, I believe, in
[54:33] 2024 and then it doubled in 2025.
[54:36] From Roblox because of the amount of child sexual abuse material
[54:39] that was being passed around Roblox.
[54:42] But it's more than that. That's just what's being reported.
[54:45] One element I want to raise before I close, and that is, it
[54:48] strikes me that there are a couple things. Professor Gillis first.
[54:53] It isn't just a child signing a contract for a car.
[54:56] It's signing a contract for a car with no brakes. That, to me, ought
[54:59] to be taken into consideration. It can be taken into consideration.
[55:02] It can be taken into consideration. It can be taken into consideration.
[55:05] As well when we consider the danger. And the second thing that I
[55:09] observe is what in the hell are we thinking as a nation that we let
[55:14] our kids and grandkids be lured into this kind of a horrible situation
[55:20] and dream up legal theories to justify it. What is wrong with us?
[55:25] And the answer is nothing's wrong with us and the richest people in
[55:27] the world who are exploiting these kids need to be held accountable.
[55:31] It's up to us. Put the party aside.
[55:34] In the Senate and do the right thing for the people and families
[55:37] of this country. I think Senator Hawley, who are as different as
[55:40] He and I are as different as night and day on some issues.
[55:43] Really see this the same way. I hope we can get something done
[55:46] before the end of the year. There is no excuse why another child
[55:49] is exploited. We hold twiddle our thumbs and think of some reason
[55:53] why we can't get around to it. We have a bill before us on the
[55:56] floor of the CSAM. We have a bill before us on the floor of the
[55:58] CSAM. We have a bill before us on the floor of the CSAM.
[56:00] It's in the defense authorization bill and it's time to pass it.
[56:03] Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Senator Blackburn.
[56:05] Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our witnesses for being
[56:08] here today. I met earlier today with parents that had lost their
[56:12] children online. And of course, Senator Blumenthal and I've worked
[56:15] for years on the kids online safety act, but I know we have some
[56:18] of the kids online safety act, but I know we have some of the
[56:20] things that we can't get around to it.
[56:22] We have a bill before us on the floor of the CSAM's bill.
[56:25] We've worked for years on the kids online safety act, but I know
[56:31] we have so many in the audience today. Um, and if you are a victim
[56:38] of some of this online abuse, or if you have a loved one that is
[56:45] a victim or lost their life, I want you to just stand right now.
[56:50] Thank you all. Thanks. Um, thanks for being here and I thank you
[57:07] for caring enough. You all may be seated, but I thank you for caring
[57:12] enough to come to share your story and to help others and Mr Doe.
[57:19] You're serving the country in a different way and we thank you. Um,
[57:26] I do have a couple of questions I wanted to get to with you all. Um,
[57:31] Mr. Slep, I think your response on how you see roadblocks today is lazy.
[57:38] I see them as evil and I what they're doing. And here's the thing.
[57:45] In 2024, we had the then CEO of discord before us for a hearing.
[57:50] He could not answer or justify any of their actions, which was really
[57:55] quite astounding to me. I have teenage grandsons and to me, the
[58:00] fact that he could not provide, um, a proper explanation, I thought
[58:03] was just astounding. But I'm not sure that he could not provide a
[58:08] proper explanation. I thought was just astounding. But I'm not sure
[58:14] just astounding. But I see what they're doing by using our children
[58:19] in the virtual space as the product and the moneymaker and what they're
[58:25] being exposed to for these companies to benefit financially. I see that
[58:32] is as being evil. And I think one of the things that we have learned
[58:38] through the years that we have worked on this issue, which is six years
[58:42] now trying to get some of these bills passed and big tech has fought us
[58:47] every single step of the way, every step of the way. But what we have
[58:54] learned is that these tech companies are incapable of regulating themselves.
[59:03] They're incapable. They are so greedy and so given to a profit that they
[59:13] refuse to regulate themselves. Now that should astound us. They have
[59:18] no safety standards. Every industrial sector in this country has safety
[59:24] standards, except the virtual space and the companies that function in
[59:28] that virtual space. If you buy a car, there are safety standards. If you go
[59:33] buy a toaster oven, there are safety standards. But the social media platforms
[59:39] have zero zero safety standards. They think that if you are using their
[59:43] product, you owe them. Here's the problem. They are not owed our
[59:48] children's lives and what they are doing is profoundly evil. It is so
[1:00:08] disgusting. Miss James. I want to come to you. Kids online safety act. We've
[1:00:15] mentioned that we're up to 77 sponsors in the Senate. We passed it out last year. 91 to 3
[1:00:20] broadly bipartisan. Our friends in the house are trying to come around to
[1:00:25] supporting this. We're nudging them. And we've talked to you and Professor
[1:00:31] Gillis have talked a little bit about seeking recourse for people that have been
[1:00:36] abused virtually. We've talked a little bit about seeking recourse.
[1:00:40] Seeking recourse for people that have been abused virtually. Talk about the
[1:00:46] importance of getting a law on the books that holds tech companies
[1:00:52] responsible. Talk about the importance of that for a moment. Yes, Senator. So
[1:00:58] the first thing I want to say is there has to be a consequence, right? Because
[1:01:02] Roblox has has scratched the surface and done the bare minimum to say that they're
[1:01:08] protecting children. But that's because the world is watching right now. But
[1:01:12] what happens when the world isn't watching? Right? And we know what's going to
[1:01:15] happen because for the past 10 years they did nothing, nothing because there was no
[1:01:21] consequence. And so without regulation, without a law, whether it's stop CSAM or
[1:01:29] COSA. How do we know that they're not just going to backtrack and get rid of
[1:01:34] all of these bare minimum changes that they have made? That's why we need to pass some
[1:01:39] legislation. Well, I completely agree with you on that. The problem is they
[1:01:46] feel like they're operating in secret because there's only one person looking
[1:01:52] at the screen and most often it is a child who is absolutely so frightened.
[1:01:57] And Mr. Doe laid that out very, very well. And we're grateful for that.
[1:02:03] Let me come to Mr. Schlepp and Mr. Doe. I've many times said these platforms are
[1:02:13] playgrounds for for predators, for them to prey on our children, predators,
[1:02:20] pedophiles, perpetrators, groomers. They love these things. They can operate. They
[1:02:26] they think behind a screen. Um, I brought meta child safety whistleblowers before privacy
[1:02:37] technology in the law, which is the subcommittee I chair here at judiciary so
[1:02:44] that they could, um, expose what happens to children and immersive virtual platforms and
[1:02:54] how experiencing this trauma virtually is closely akin. It has the same effect as if this was happening
[1:03:06] to them in real time in the real world. And it was frightening to listen to that testimony. Now,
[1:03:18] uh, each of you were children when you experience this abuse and, uh, you both talked a little bit about
[1:03:27] this, but go back to how this changed you as a child and then how it altered your relationship with people and
[1:03:40] you each touched on it briefly. I want you just to have a little bit more explanation on that. Mr.
[1:03:47] Slep first. Um, it, it's definitely been the most devastating factor of my life. Um,
[1:03:54] it's something that I still go to therapy over. It's affected relationships. It's affected, uh,
[1:04:00] how I can trust people. Um, you know, and, and, and there's just a part of me that was stolen and robbed.
[1:04:09] Um, and it is something, you know, I never got my own personal justice for, you know, uh, my abuser was never,
[1:04:17] uh, uh, you know, criminally held. And, uh, you know, I, it, it's something that, that really has,
[1:04:24] that really has hurt me. But what helped me was being able to actually give victims their own form of
[1:04:30] justice, that being finding child predators and getting them arrested and convicted and in some cases sent to prison.
[1:04:38] Yeah. Mr Doug for myself personally trying to delineate that 11 year old boy from the United States Marine that I
[1:04:48] had become did not come without consequence. Um, in my marriage, there were some difficulties. I had self-worth
[1:04:56] issues and of course that never ends well. So there were issues with addiction. There were issues in me feeling good
[1:05:02] enough, honestly, to spend time with my own children. Because if I couldn't protect myself, how would I feel
[1:05:07] like I'd be able to protect them?
[1:05:09] Thank you for that. Mr Chairman. Thank you for letting me go over. I appreciate that.
[1:05:16] Thank you. Senator Blumenthal.
[1:05:20] Thank you, Mr Chairman. Thank you for having this hearing and for your leadership in this
[1:05:28] area. I've been very proud to work with you and Senator Blackburn on bipartisan measures to
[1:05:34] address the harms that have been so strikingly and eloquently outlined today and by numerous of
[1:05:44] the parents who are here today, parents and loved ones who have endured the unimaginable grief and
[1:05:53] pain and the survivors who courageously step forward here and in support of the Kids Online Safety Act
[1:06:04] and other measures to hold big tech accountable. As you know, children across the country have been
[1:06:12] victims of these harms, sexual exploitation, assault involving online platforms and video games.
[1:06:19] Roblox alone has been sued more than 100 times for abuse, exploitation and deaths by suicide of children
[1:06:29] groomed by adult Roblox users. Those lawsuits attest to the
[1:06:37] the passion and energy of parents who also have the courage to go to court and relive the pain that has been
[1:06:50] caused to them. And yet when these children and their parents sued to recover for these unspeakable
[1:06:57] harms, they often encounter obstacles that Roblox and other online platforms erect, forcing them into arbitration.
[1:07:10] These forced arbitration agreements take those cases out of court and limit the ability for children and
[1:07:18] parents to recover. We know that arbitration has a place in our judicial system, but it is way overused and
[1:07:30] exploited as a means to impose unfair burdens on people who have been harmed, not only in this area, but others. But in this area, it's
[1:07:41] especially appalling because these online platforms have themselves facilitated the abuse of children and
[1:07:48] then try to escape legal responsibility.
[1:07:53] That's why a number of us here have sponsored legislation.
[1:07:59] Senator Britt, Senator Booker and I have introduced a bill to end forced arbitration in cases involving harms to minors.
[1:08:07] In online platforms, video games streaming services and AI systems are bet bill known as the ending forced
[1:08:18] arbitration of children online act will hold these platforms accountable for the harms that they have caused.
[1:08:26] This legislation complements other measures that have been introduced by my colleagues, Senator Hawley and Durbin.
[1:08:36] We have a common objective, and it is essentially to open the courthouse doors, as Senator Hawley said in his opening
[1:08:43] statement to make sure that people have what is guaranteed them under the Constitution. A day in court more than a day of fair hearing.
[1:08:53] A fair hearing in court by a jury. If they so choose by a judge was an article three appointee and can fairly
[1:09:05] adjudicate their causes of action. So, uh, I know I may be repeating what you already heard. I apologize, but it can't be said
[1:09:16] often enough. It cannot be repeated too frequently that the victims and survivors of big techs.
[1:09:28] Reprehensible arms should have justice. Uh, Professor Giles. Can you explain to me how forced arbitration impacts?
[1:09:41] Practically speaking the ability of litigants, parents, survivors, victims to achieve justice and why arbitration
[1:09:55] with somebody making decisions appointed by probably one side is going to produce a one sided result.
[1:10:06] I think I've asked you a kind of leading question as we say. Yeah, but, um, but I'll be brief. Um, so first of all, I think
[1:10:14] that the most important problem here is the secrecy, right? In court, you get a public record. Um, changes happen because of a public record.
[1:10:23] I've been hearing about Roblox's most recent changes. Um, the age verification, some of the changes they've made.
[1:10:29] I think we've got to look at the timing of some of these changes. It is very much because of AG lawsuits because of the investigation
[1:10:35] that this subcommittee launched, right? Accountability, daylight, sunlight, it tends to make people, um, change their bad behavior.
[1:10:43] So the first thing about arbitration is the secrecy. Um, the second thing is the isolation.
[1:10:48] As I listened to the, to the victims and survivors, um, I, I'm struck, you know, these kids are all harmed
[1:10:55] by the same exact design choices that Roblox has made. Uh, but arbitration forces each family to go it alone
[1:11:02] and to not know what the other family that went before them learned in their arbitration.
[1:11:07] If of course these arbitrations are happening in public court, this is, I mean, this is one of the great things
[1:11:12] about our litigation system. Um, it, it allows for open access and it allows for knowledge.
[1:11:18] Um, so I, I, I think there are lots of reasons, um, to, to, that we should not want arbitration in this space.
[1:11:25] Um, because I think it, it really deters access to justice and on the, the sort of repeat players problem.
[1:11:31] I mean, this has been well documented in the literature empirically, um, in the employment setting, for example,
[1:11:37] when employees go into arbitration against their employer, employees are one shotters, employers are repeat players.
[1:11:44] If you, if you sort of game this out, employees lose more and more, um, as, as the game goes on than employers do.
[1:11:52] And that's because employers are paying the, the fees of these arbitrators.
[1:11:56] They are the repeat players. They write the rules. They are there continually.
[1:12:01] So we should expect the same to happen in any arbitration.
[1:12:04] And I'll just say one last thing. Um, Roblox has changed its arbitration provider
[1:12:10] from the triple A and jams, which are viewed as very respectable arbitration providers to fed arb,
[1:12:17] which is a new kid on the block, uh, far less reputable, um, and known for playing ball with defendants.
[1:12:24] Um, and so I think all that tells us is that if you can write your own rules, you can choose your own forum.
[1:12:30] You're going to write the rules to benefit you and choose the forum that's best for your side.
[1:12:35] And often when, um, a minor on Roblox or an employee or anyone else who encounters forced arbitration signs a so-called agreement, a checkbox,
[1:12:50] they often have no idea what they're agreeing to do. Is that correct?
[1:12:55] I mean, we all do it, right? If you want the next version of iTunes and there's a pop-up box that says, you know, click here, um, so that you can get that thing
[1:13:03] that's on the other side of the pop-up box, we all click on it.
[1:13:06] And even lawyers, even those of us who, you know, spend our lives researching this issue, we don't really read those 11,000 words.
[1:13:14] There are 11,000 words in the Roblox, uh, terms and conditions, many of them quite sophisticated, like multi-syllable words.
[1:13:21] My kids were smart. They couldn't have figured out those words, right?
[1:13:24] So no, we don't read that stuff. And that's what they're banking on.
[1:13:28] Senator, if I may, uh, I just wanted to showcase this. This here is the Roblox terms of use.
[1:13:35] You can see how thick this is. Um, I mean, it's something like, you know, pretty, pretty huge.
[1:13:41] And Roblox has a single paragraph in this about child safety.
[1:13:45] Meanwhile, they have, I believe, 16 pages related to arbitration, uh, within it.
[1:13:50] Um, Roblox itself, uh, uh, very much, uh, they're doing everything in their power to make sure that these victims don't get access to justice.
[1:13:56] And, uh, no teenagers going to read through 16 pages.
[1:13:59] No, not even teenagers. They're saying eight year olds.
[1:14:02] Roblox is legally in court seeing eight year olds.
[1:14:05] Read this, read this entire piece of paper right here.
[1:14:09] That's ridiculous.
[1:14:10] And when there is forced arbitration for that eight year old or 13 year old or anyone else,
[1:14:16] there are virtually no rights of real appeal, correct?
[1:14:21] Yeah.
[1:14:22] Let me ask you, uh, and I apologize if I can use just a little bit more time.
[1:14:28] Thank you.
[1:14:29] Uh, I'm happy to yield to the center from Alabama.
[1:14:32] Thank you. Uh, cause I want to ask a question about kids online safety act, uh, which would set a federal duty of care to prevent this kind of sexual abuse and other harms.
[1:14:52] It would require safe defaults mandate parental tools obligate Roblox to respond to user complaints instead of ignoring them Roblox has fought the kids online safety act and
[1:15:05] I think the testimony today shows very graphically and dramatically why it has fought Cosa because it knows it would be held to a standard of care.
[1:15:19] It's not a novel idea. We have standards of care throughout our legal system.
[1:15:28] And from the testimony today, it sounds to me like Roblox would fail every one of the standards that are included requirements that are included
[1:15:42] in that standard of care. They would literally be in a world of hurt unless they change their business model and it's a business model exploiting kids is their business model.
[1:15:53] Do you agree that we need to pass? And I know again, I'm probably repeating some of what's been asked, but let me ask all of you would Cosa make a difference here.
[1:16:06] Absolutely. Yes.
[1:16:09] Yes. Thank you, Professor. Others? Yes, I believe it would. Mr. Senator.
[1:16:16] I'm not entirely sure about all the details related to Cosa, but you know, I personally believe if it holds Roblox to where they're able to moderate their platform better because that's the crux of the problem.
[1:16:29] The moderation is truly abysmal on the platform and that that is something Roblox really needs to do better at.
[1:16:36] Thank you all. Again, my appreciation to every one of you for being here today and many others in our audience.
[1:16:45] Do not doubt that you are making a difference.
[1:16:48] Senator. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I just want to echo what Senator Blumenthal said. Number one, thank you for being here.
[1:16:55] Thank you for telling your story. What a powerful moment when Senator Blackburn asked victims and survivors and loved ones to stand. It shows you what you're
[1:17:07] It shows you what you're up against and it shows you that this knows no bounds. And I want to thank the members that are here today.
[1:17:14] Chairman Holley, ranking member Durbin, Senator Blumenthal, Senator Blackburn. All of these men and women have been champions for the voiceless, have made sure that parents and children are protected.
[1:17:31] The things we're talking about today are absolutely common sense, right? There is no way an eight year old hold that up again. An eight year old could read those terms.
[1:17:45] Yep. And then sign away their right to a moment in court effectively silencing themselves dealing with the trauma that they endured online and then the trauma of not being able to use their voice and tell their story.
[1:18:01] And as a result of that, more and more children become victims. And at what point is this body not going to stand up and do the right thing? Dear gosh, if we can't stand together for these kids, what can we do? I am hopeful that we will all stand with Senator Blumenthal and Senator Blackburn and get the kids online safety act. Get that passed before the end of this Congress. We cannot allow big tech to continue to put their profits ahead of people.
[1:18:32] A head of precious children stealing innocence and in the most just damning circumstances stealing lives. So thank you for telling your story. Thank you for being advocates. Thank you for digging in.
[1:18:47] I was so honored to stand next to Senator Blumenthal and introduce yesterday the ending forced arbitration of Children Online Act. The time to pass. This is now. This bill would invalidate
[1:19:05] invalidate the pre dispute arbitration agreements and cases in which a minor has suffered harm on a platform, including physical injury, mental or psychological harm, a violation of privacy or a misuse of personal data platforms covered by this bill of Senator Blumenthal's and mine include social media platforms and gaming platforms like roadblocks. I believe arbitration does have a place and our duty
[1:19:36] judicial system. I believe that platforms like judicial system, but I do not believe that platforms like roadblocks should be able to use arbitration as a shield against accountability for the harms they have caused to minors, allowing them to become repeat offenders over and over and over again.
[1:19:51] Professor Gillis. You said it earlier, but you said they become good at this. While the victim is one and done. They learned the system. They know the players. They know what to say. They know how to pressure. They know how to get the results. Tell us a little bit about both the secrecy. You mentioned they changed arbitrators. Tell parents right now. We're going to clip this and put this out. Tell them what they need to know. What
[1:20:23] What is this company knowingly doing over and over and over again to these innocent kids?
[1:20:28] Well, first of all, they are completely aware that they're the design choices they've made are basically delivering these children to predators and they're doing nothing about it.
[1:20:38] And when families and victims sue them trying to get changed, trying to get some reform, they force those cases into secret arbitration. Let's be clear.
[1:20:50] Arbitration has has a place in the system. Both Senators Britt and Blumenthal mentioned this. The place for it is after a dispute has arisen. If a family or victim would like to go into arbitration, we should let them do that.
[1:21:04] Right. That's a choice you can make once you can assess the situation completely. And there might be good reasons for that. But forcing a child as as a precondition to playing a game, which we've heard is a game that they want to play, forcing them to sign away rights they don't even understand.
[1:21:19] That's that's not fair. That's not that's not real. And to the extent these arbitrations are happening and I have to be clear, Senator, arbitration is secret and confidential. So I don't know if arbitrations are happening right now.
[1:21:31] But let's assume that some families have actually taken Roblox up on its offer to arbitrate the claim. So there are a few things. First of all, you have to go to FedArb, which is chosen by Roblox before you can file an arbitration.
[1:21:45] You have to make a demand. It has to be 60 days before you file and there has there's a there's a period of pre dispute mediation, which I think is the time that Roblox takes to try to convince you not to actually bring a claim against them.
[1:22:00] So maybe they try to settle with you, make you go away in some way. And then you're in a secret arbitration and there's limited discovery. The statute of limitations, as Senator Holly noted, is one year from the time of the incident, which many times the child may not have even have has not even told a trusted adult about that.
[1:22:19] Exactly. So lots of these cases are going to be DOA before they can even be brought. And that's really what Roblox is counting on. Right. Because if this were to be brought, these cases were to be brought in court. First of all, they could be brought openly.
[1:22:33] Family members would hear about these claims. And if they had claims, they could join these claims so they could be consolidated. There would be discovery into what Roblox knew when it knew it, what it was doing to solve the problem. We would know all of these things.
[1:22:46] Now this is all happening in secret. And I think children are going to continue to be abused and harmed unless this body does something, because let's be clear, the Supreme Court has said that it will it's going to enforce arbitration clauses as written unless this body tells it otherwise.
[1:23:07] Well, surely we can all agree that an eight year old shouldn't be able to sign away their rights and their ability.
[1:23:13] You said, Mr. Schlapp, knowingly, you said, roadblocks knows exactly what they're doing. We just heard delivering predators to children.
[1:23:25] Yes. In fact, Roblox bragged to investors in a shareholder announcement that they were decreasing their spending on moderation while their player base was exploding. What context does that even make sense for Roblox to decrease their moderation while their users are going up?
[1:23:44] Hindenburg found that Roblox has one of the lowest moderator to user ratios than any other social media website, not to mention Roblox is outsourcing their moderators to Southeast Asia, where they don't even understand grooming vernacular.
[1:24:00] And in some of these employees who've been interviewed have said that they would never let their children on Roblox.
[1:24:06] Don't get me wrong. Roblox is a concept is is fundamentally a beautiful idea. It is something that I think could work. I think it is something that that is truly could be beneficial there. There's stuff like programming, all this other stuff. But the current leadership at the company has truly shown that they are putting profits ahead of safety. And that's not true.
[1:24:18] And that's not me giving my opinion. That is their own employees saying that. Well, I think you said it in that big pack. There's one one paragraph on child safety and the rest of it is about protecting themselves.
[1:24:24] Yeah. So here actually is the community standards for Roblox. So this is like what you can and can't do on the platform. Very thin. You see that. And then this is their terms of use legal contract, which you agree to by hitting I agree.
[1:24:36] And they're saying eight year olds are binded to this eight year olds that have committed suicide. So we we heard Senator Holly earlier, Chairman Holly say parents if you're if you're if you're if you're for a child, you're not going to school.
[1:24:57] So we heard Senator Holly earlier.
[1:25:02] Hawley earlier, Chairman Hawley say parents if you're if you're if you're for watching this this is this is what you need to know. I think to your point the concept is something that parents believe is going to be good for their child to learn and to grow and to build and have no idea that the platform has is allowing this to occur and knowingly turning a blind eye to it. I am out of time but just one more question Mr. Chairman if you don't mind.
[1:25:31] I'd like for each of you look what is the one thing you feel like this body needs to know or could do that would make a difference in what we're seeing on kids online safety in general. I think it is absolutely reprehensible and feckless that Congress has done nothing. The most the most vulnerable and our most precious asset is the next generation and we continue to kick the can down the road instead of do the right thing. So very quickly.
[1:26:01] Since I am out of time and I'm so grateful for each of you being here, but just what's what's the one kind of thing that you feel like this body needs to know as we're looking at what we do towards the end of the year.
[1:26:10] There are some wonderful bills. You and Senator Blumenthal have a bill. Senators Holly and Durbin have a bill past one of these bills and just get rid of forced arbitration. You will be amazed by how quickly the company will change its behavior once it is sued in public court.
[1:26:26] I agree with my colleague here that there needs to be a consequence and the consequence is being held liable and how we can make that happen is through passing legislation, whether it's stop CCM COSA, the forced arbitration act. Something has to be done. That's also why they're not here. Right. There's no consequence. Nothing's going to happen. Absolutely. Mr. Doe. Um, oh, sorry. I completely agree there. They're protecting themselves from their investors through this forced arbitration. All
[1:26:57] I think that every laundry is hidden. The minute that goes out the window, they're really going to feel the repercussions of their actions. All I can ask is please get on those bills.
[1:27:04] Thank you. Yeah, I fundamentally believe that Roblox needs better moderation and they really should improve. Like you were saying, you know, kids or parents are putting their kids on this because the concept itself is a beautiful concept.
[1:27:16] Um, and I think honestly, Roblox, uh, if they're doing what they're promising can, can be something great, but they're not doing that. And some of this stuff that they've released like age estimation and all this other stuff is clearly not working. And, uh, at the end of the day, they're over reliance on stuff like AI moderation when they should be doing stuff in house here in the United States is something that I really think Roblox needs to do more of.
[1:27:39] Thank you for everyone for being here. And, um, gentlemen, let's work together and get this done. Thank you, Senator Britt. Let me just ask the panel if I could a few more questions and I want to come to you, Ms. James. Um, you said earlier that I just want to focus our attention on the decisions that Roblox has made here. You said earlier that what we're seeing with the predation online is a direct result of Roblox's design. Could you just elaborate on that? I think this is an
[1:28:11] important point. I think parents need to know this. And I think it's important to pierce through the lies that Roblox is telling. They say we're just a neutral platform. We're just we're bystanders of bad people happen onto our platform. You know, oops, not our fault. You're saying no, actually it's written into their design. Tell us about that. That's right. So Roblox knows that that predators are using its platform. In fact, they talk about it in their SEC report just from last quarter. They know that this is happening and they can do something.
[1:28:41] about it. They can do continuous age checks. They won't. They can close the developer chat loophole. They won't. And the reason that they won't. And they openly say this in their annual report. They just think nobody's reading it because it's in fine print, except for me. Um, did they need the developers to make money and the developers can be children, but most of them are adults. They also say that they need children knowing that they're under 13 predominantly because without children,
[1:29:12] they don't make money. They don't make money. The problem is if developers are able to create experiences within the game that are not subject to the safety settings and Roblox knows that children are going to use that, then how can they say that they care about children? That's how we know that they have intentionally made a choice to design their platform to make money, not to protect children.
[1:29:36] And shouldn't they be liable for those choices if they've made them intentionally and knowingly? Absolutely. Yeah. Um, let me ask you this. The safety changes that Roblox has has said it's recently implemented. You know, they've, they've gotten religion now and all of a sudden they say we're for, we're for safety. In fact, I just can't resist. I think we have a poster of the CEO saying this. Uh, he has said that Roblox is, and I quote him now, the safest place for anyone on the internet. Yeah, that's it.
[1:30:07] Right. Uh, he also has said that Roblox considers the prevalence of predators on its site, not necessarily, not necessarily just as a problem, but as an opportunity as well. I'm sure it is an opportunity for the predators.
[1:30:19] Let's come back to this idea, though, that that Roblox is the safest place for anyone on the internet. They have these new safety features. Why are these not adequate in this change?
[1:30:26] So, and I guess I'll, I'll touch. There's three things that are the safety features that they're saying that they have created that have remedied the problems of the past. One of them is this age estimation and we should highlight estimation because it's not completely accurate and Roblox knows that. Are they doing anything about it? No.
[1:30:44] It's a selfie. Someone can take a selfie and that is the age estimation. They can misclassify you into the wrong age group, which allows you to interact with people that you should not be interacting with.
[1:30:56] Predators can buy age verified accounts. They can buy logins to use a child's account. They can use their own children. They can use somebody else's children to bypass the account because you only have to do it one time.
[1:31:10] You take your selfie one time and you have complete access to all of the children that are on Roblox. The solution to that is continuous age checks. Roblox knows that they've talked about it, but they won't do it because predators wouldn't use their website anymore.
[1:31:26] The next thing is closing the loophole in the developer chat. They say that they have remedied that loophole by turning on the parental controls. The problem, and this is what parents in this country need to know, is that they're extremely deceptive with that.
[1:31:42] Because the parental controls Roblox says that while we've now made it where parents can go in and turn off their child's ability to chat. But what they don't tell the parent when they hit off is that it does not turn off the developer created chats. It only turns off the Roblox native chats.
[1:32:01] And does Roblox disclose which experiences are developer created and which ones are Roblox created? No, they don't. So there's no way for a child to know or for a parent to know for that matter, if their child is entering an experience, entering an experience that they're going to have full access to other adults and predators are going to have access to them.
[1:32:25] And then the last change that they claim to have made, which they have not made is the addictive nature of Roblox. They say, well, we've put these screen time controls in place.
[1:32:35] Well, it's easy to say that. But what they haven't done is taken away these time based rewards, the scarcity marketing tactics, the visible inventories, which is using Roblox and the virtual items that we know children want.
[1:32:51] That's what keeps children coming back. There is things flashing on the screen constantly when children are playing to keep them coming back for more. Don't log off yet because you won't get this reward if you log off.
[1:33:03] Come back in five minutes and this reward will be cheaper. They could take that away, but they won't because then the children won't play Roblox anymore.
[1:33:12] And then they won't make money. I mean, at the end of the day, here's what I want parents to understand and the public, the general public to understand, which is that when Roblox says that they've implemented these safety features, they're lying to you. Essentially, it's all smoke and mirrors.
[1:33:25] It's games. It's window dressing because they want their revenue stream to continue and their revenue stream depends on kids who are my children's age.
[1:33:33] My youngest is five. My oldest just turned 14. My kids age young kids. Their their revenue depends. Their whole business model depends on those kind of kids being on that platform all the time, which means it depends on lying to us parents about it and making sure we really can't control anything that goes on in the platform.
[1:33:49] Professor Gillis. I just want to ask you, you made a point that I think is so important, which is that it is. It is. Yes, vital to give individuals rights of action to get into court.
[1:34:01] And I believe in that 100 percent. And Senator Dermott talked about our bill, the Stop CSAM Act, which creates a private right of action. That's just a fancy way of saying it.
[1:34:08] A right to get into court. But your point was, if that then terminates an arbitrate forced arbitration, it doesn't do any good.
[1:34:15] So we need to go a step further, which is what we're talking about today and ban forced arbitration for these victims on this platform and other platforms.
[1:34:24] Could you just underscore again why it's so important that these cases happen in public that they go into a real courtroom that that where there's a jury right that that jury right is accessible. Tell us again why this is so vital.
[1:34:37] The short answer, Senator, is the courts produce a public record and arbitration is designed to do the exact opposite. Right. It's designed, as you said, to muzzle to make everything as secret as possible.
[1:34:51] And public accountability produces reform. Right. We've seen a time to time with with Roblox with also, you know, other companies that have been held responsible under the EFAA. For example, we see reform whenever companies are sort of forced to justify defend themselves in court.
[1:35:08] So I think the answer is really simple here. And given that we're talking about children, it feels like this is an even easier case than the EFAA was a few years ago.
[1:35:18] Let me ask you this. I think we have a poster of this effect, the cap on on all damages.
[1:35:23] I mentioned this in my opening statement in terms and conditions that Mr. Schlepp held up.
[1:35:28] One of the terms and conditions is this. It's a limitation of liability. And it says when you click that little box, you agree to that forced arbitration, no matter what your age is.
[1:35:37] And you also agree that any suit, any claim, any damages against Roblox or its affiliated parties for all claims will be limited to a thousand dollars total.
[1:35:47] Can I just ask you, Professor Gillis, do you think that Roblox, let's say they actually do lose an arbitration?
[1:35:52] We'd never know. But let's say that they wonder wonders actually losing arbitration to have to pay a thousand bucks.
[1:35:58] They are currently worth 33 billion. The founder and CEO alone is worth 3.3 billion.
[1:36:05] Is a thousand bucks going to change anybody's behavior in your professional opinion?
[1:36:10] Absolutely not. And quite frankly, this provision as well as that one year such limitations would not be enforceable in court.
[1:36:17] Right. So they know this. They know that arbitrators are bound to to to to follow the terms of the arbitration agreement as drafted.
[1:36:26] But as you know, well, no judge is going to listen to a thousand dollars in a contract.
[1:36:31] We don't get to write contracts in this country that simply tell a court what to do. Right. And that's what they're trying to do here.
[1:36:38] You know, they're also trying to avoid moral accountability. And I'll end with this. And Senator Blumenthal may have some additional questions.
[1:36:44] What they're really trying to do is they're trying to avoid the moral responsibility for what they're doing on their platform.
[1:36:49] And they don't want any moral limits enforced on them. They want to say we'll exploit your kids and take everything we can from it.
[1:36:55] You will. We will strip mine your family and there won't be a thing you can do about it. And you know what?
[1:36:59] What we've said as a country over and over and over again is we believe in markets and we believe in competition.
[1:37:04] But there are moral limits that we as a country impose on businesses and everybody else.
[1:37:10] And one of them is that you can't exploit children. We don't allow child labor in this country.
[1:37:15] We don't allow exploitation of workers in this country.
[1:37:17] And the idea that we would allow this company to sexually exploit children or expose them to such in order to make money is just fundamentally un-American.
[1:37:27] It's not who we are. And they know that. And they're trying to get around our system of justice.
[1:37:33] And what I'm saying today is, and what I hear everybody on this dais saying is, it's time to put a stop to that.
[1:37:39] It's time to get back to some basic principles of right and wrong and make the company follow them like everybody else in America does.
[1:37:46] If we do that, our children would be a lot safer. Senator Blumenthal.
[1:37:50] Thanks, Senator Hawley. I couldn't agree more with Senator Hawley. I think everybody in the room probably does, unless we have representatives here of Roblox.
[1:38:00] And perhaps other people in which case you're welcome at the podium if that's you.
[1:38:06] And even if they come to the podium and we've seen it before, big tech comes to the podium. Oh, well, we're in favor of regulation, just not that regulation.
[1:38:18] Or we're in favor of regulation. And then they stop the legislation behind closed doors, as they did with COSA last session, when we passed it here by a margin of 91 to 3.
[1:38:35] In the United States Senate, that's pretty overwhelmingly bipartisan. And then there was no vote in the House. So we need to mobilize not just here, but after this day to move forward with this legislation on forced arbitration and other measures.
[1:38:54] $1,000 limitation not only would be unacceptable to a court, but no lawyer would take a case when the result is limited to $1,000. You just won't get a lawyer to take your case.
[1:39:11] And I'm not being critical of the legal profession, but the lawyers who do it aren't taking those cases for the money. They're trying to vindicate the rights of their clients.
[1:39:22] Very importantly, Ms. James repeatedly has used the word design. These cases are about product design. I don't know whether Senator Blackburn made this point.
[1:39:39] But if you buy a toaster and it blows up on your kitchen shelf and hurts you, you have a potential legal action for that defect in the product. If your car runs off the road because the steering doesn't work.
[1:40:01] You have a potential cause of action. And absolutely right that private attorneys general both Senator Hawley and I have been state attorneys general.
[1:40:12] But very often private attorneys general simply by enforcing cases against defective product design can change the product. It's happened in automobiles. It's happened in aviation to an extent.
[1:40:18] It hopefully will happen on tobacco. Um, and now we're potentially going to see it if we give people these rights of action.
[1:40:42] Uh, but I want to come back to really, um, the human stories here because I can talk forever here at this dais and it will have far less impact than the stories that you've told Mr. Doe and Mr. Schlepp.
[1:41:08] And I was especially moved by, uh, the story that you told Woody Doe, uh, because I left here and went to a ceremony marking the 251st birthday of the United States Marine Corps. Happy birthday Marine and saw the strong straight back well disciplined skilled courageous Marines in that ceremony.
[1:41:44] In that ceremony. I was part of the ceremony since I was just in full disclosure, the oldest Marine. So I got the first piece of cake.
[1:41:57] Uh, but it reminded me of your story and how you thought this abuse was your fault, your fault that you were to blame until you talked to that chaplain and you were able to begin to overcome some of the painful, harmful outcomes of that experience, which was not your
[1:42:28] fault. And so, uh, I want to thank you for sharing that experience because there are probably thousands, maybe millions of other children, adolescents, young men and women, maybe older men and women who still think it was their fault.
[1:42:51] And what we need to do is elevate your story and have them talk to a chaplain or to a counselor or to someone who can make them realize that not only is it not your fault, but you are a survivor and a victim and
[1:43:14] your courage and stepping forward will help us pass this bill. So thank you to you both, uh, and others who are here in the audience and who will be in other audiences.
[1:43:26] Uh, around the country over these years. And you are the reason that we will pass the end of force arbitration kids online safety ending the immunity under Section 230 for big tech.
[1:43:44] Other kinds of reforms that are absolutely necessary. We're going to keep fighting. Thank you for your service.
[1:43:49] Thank you, Mr. Senator. Happy birthday.
[1:43:53] Hurrah.
[1:43:57] I just want to say in conclusion, thank you to our witnesses for being here. Uh, thank you to the parents and the survivors that are here.
[1:44:05] I got to talk with a number of you beforehand and I know that some of you are holding pictures and we've asked you to stand.
[1:44:10] But if you want to hold up your pictures of your of your beautiful children and loved ones, we'd love to see them. And I just want to say as they do that, yeah, they're all over the room.
[1:44:19] I just want to say as you do that, that I just know that the the children, the beautiful pictures you're holding here, their their sacrifice, the pain that you've gone through will not be in vain. As Senator Blumenthal just said, it's because of you that progress will be made.
[1:44:38] And I think ultimately justice will be had for thousands and thousands of other people who have suffered. So I want to say thank you for your courage. Thank you for your boldness.
[1:44:46] I know it's not easy to be here. Probably not very fun, but you're the ones who are going to make the difference. They don't care what we say. What you say and your stories cannot be denied because it's the truth and what your children have gone through is the truth.
[1:44:58] And however long it takes us, we will get justice for your children and for thousands of others like them. I want to say to Roblox, you chose not to come here today, but you know what you're doing is wrong.
[1:45:14] And we call on you today to admit your wrongdoing and to stop it. You can change your behavior and you should. You should implement real safety regulations and restrictions like we've talked about today.
[1:45:25] But you should also voluntarily enforce arbitration. I just say to the CEO of Roblox, if you truly believe that your platform is the safest place on the Internet for anybody.
[1:45:35] Prove it. End forced arbitration. You can announce it right now. Do it today. Today announced that you will allow any victim who has been harmed on your platform to have their day in court because you have nothing to hide.
[1:45:47] I challenge you to do it. And in the meantime, I will not rest until this body marks up and passes a bill ending forced arbitration for victims of sexual exploitation and other exploitation online.
[1:46:01] Thank you all for being here. Thank you, Professor. Thank you, Miss James. Thank you, Mr. Doe and Mr. Schlepp. Thank you to our audience.
[1:46:08] I think I'm supposed to read some magic words here now, guys, about how long the record will be open. Here we go.
[1:46:13] The record for this hearing will remain open for one week until Tuesday, November 24th at 5 p.m.
[1:46:19] for the submission of statements and questions for the record. And with that, this hearing is adjourned.